ZLDGRPRüLG\QDPLF]QHPRGHOHG]LDáDQLDPy]JX

:áRG]LVáDZ'XFK

.DWHGUD0HWRG.RPSXWHURZ\FK8QLZHUV\WHW0LNRáDMD.RSHUQLND

XO*UXG]LG]ND7RUX

http://www.phys.uni.torun.pl/~duch

Streszczenie

ZLDGRPRü ]ZL]DQD MHVW ] XZDJ SDPL FL URERF] L SHUFHSFM 6WUXPLH ZLDGRPRFL

]DZLHUDW\ONRWHHOHPHQW\NWyUHSRMDZLDMVL ZSDPL FLURERF]HMNeurofizjologiczne kore-

ODW\ZUD*HZLDGRP\FKPRJREHMPRZDüSURFHV\V\QFKURQL]DFMLRVF\ODFMLHz odpowie-

G]LDOQH]DVFDODQLHZUD*Hthe binding problem). Przedstawiono alternatywne teorie rozwi-

]DQLD OXE XQLNQL FLD SUREOHPX VFDODQLD ZUD*H 6]F]HJyOQLH RELHFXMFH PRJ E\ü NRUHODW\

RSDUWH QD SRPLDUDFK ZVSyáF]\QQLNyZ ]áR*RQRFL DNW\ZQRFL QHXURQRZHM ]DSURSRQRZDQH
przez Tonioni i

(GHOPDQD2PyZLRQRWHRULHÄEEOLDNW\ZQRFL´LDGDSWDF\MQHJRUH]RQDQVX

Z\MDQLDMFH ZLHOH DVSHNWyZ ]ZL]DQ\FK ] IHQRPHQRORJL ZUD*H ZLDGRP\FK 3U]HGVWa-

ZLRQRDUJXPHQW\]DX]QDQLHPZLDGRPRFL]DSURFHVG\VNU\PLQDFMLQLHV\PEROLF]Q\FKUe-

SUH]HQWDFMLSRMDZLDMF\FKVL ZSDPL FLURERF]HMRQLHZLHONLHMSRMHPQRFL7HUHSUH]HQWDFMH

WZRU]VWDQ\UH]RQDQVRZH]UHSUH]HQWDFMDPLSU]HFKRZ\ZDQ\PLZSDPL FLGáXJRWUZDáHM-HVW

WRSURFHVNWyUHJRQLHGDVL V\PXORZDü]DSRPRFF\IURZHJRNRPSXWera.

Abstract

Consciousness is connected with attention, working memory and perception. The stream of
consciousness contains only those elements that are present in the working memory. Neuro-
physiological correlates of conscious states are sought in form of synchronization processes
based on 40 Hz oscillations needed to solve the binding problem. Alternative theories to solve
or avoid the binding problem are presented. Correlates based on neural complexity index re-
cently introduced by Tonioni and Edelman are especially promising. Theories of “activity
bubbles” and of adaptive resonance explain many aspects of the conscious’ experience phe-
nomenology. Arguments supporting the idea that consciousness is a process of discrimination
of continuous, non-symbolic representations appearing in small-capacity working memory are
presented. These representations create resonant states with long-term memory traces, a proc-
ess that cannot be captured by digital computer simulations.

6áRZDNOXF]RZHZLDGRPRüXNáDG\G\QDPLF]QH
Keywords: consciousness, dynamical systems, binding,

1 Wprowadzenie

%DGDQLDQDGZLDGRPRFLREM WHE\á\SU]HGGáXJLF]DVURG]DMHPWDEX3UREOHPQDWXU\ZLa-

GRPRFLG\VNXWRZDQ\E\áJáyZQLHSU]H]ILOR]RIyZVSHNXOXMF\FKQDWHPDWXP\VáXZFDáNo-
witym oderwaniu od

QHXURELRORJLL:\MWNLHPMHVWWXVWZRU]RQ\SU]H]3DWU\FM Churchland

nurt „neurofilozofii” [3]

 NU\W\F]Q\ ZREHF IXQNFMRQDOL]PX D Z V]F]HJyOQRFL DUJXPHQWyZ

GRW\F]F\FK QLH]DOH*QRFL VWDQyZ SV\FKRORJLF]Q\FK RG VWDQyZ Py]JX 1LHVWHW\ QLHZLHOX

2

ILOR]RIyZXP\VáXSRV]áRZW\PNLHUXQNXLZWHMG]LHG]LQLHSDQXMHQDGDOGX*HSRPLHV]DQLH=

MHGQHM VWURQ\ QLHNWyU]\ ILOR]RIRZLH SURSRQXM RGU]XFHQLH ZV]HONLFK SRUHGQLFK SR]LRPyZ

RSLVX WZLHUG]F *H LVWQLHM W\ONR VWDQ\ QHXURIL]MRORJLF]QH L ZLDGRPRü [15] NU\W\NXMF

EDGDQLHSURFHVyZSU]HWZDU]DQLDLQIRUPDFMLSU]H]Py]J-HVWWRZ\MWNRZRGHVWUXNW\ZQHSo-

GHMFLHJG\*QLHPR*QDVNRQVWUXRZDüVHQVRZQ\FKPRGHOLXP\VáXEH]ZSURZDG]HQLDFDáHJR

V]HUHJXSR]LRPyZSRUHGQLFK±IDNW\QHXURELRORJLF]QHPXV]E\üSRGVWDZDOHEH]PRGHOL

WHRUHW\F]Q\FKLV\PXODFMLNRPSXWHURZ\FKSR]ZDODMF\FKQDVWDZLDQLHLWHVWRZDQLHKLSRWH]

GRW\F]F\FK IXQNFMRQRZDQLD Py]JX SR]RVWDQLHP\ QD SR]LRPLH EHKDZLRU\]PX = GUXJLHM

VWURQ\G\VNXVMHGRW\F]FHXP\VáXVS\FKDQHVQDPDQRZFHSU]H]ILOR]RIXMF\FKPDWHPDWy-

NyZDUJXPHQWXMF\FK±ZRGHUZDQLX]DUyZQRRGSV\FKRORJLLNRJQLW\ZQHMMDNLRGneuro-

ELRORJLL±]DLVWQLHQLHPWDMHPQ\FKZáDVQRFLXP\VáXNWyU\FK]UR]XPLHQLHZ\PDJDüE G]LH
rewizji fundamentalnych teorii fizycznych [14].

1LHVWHW\WDNLHEH]SáRGQHG\VNXVMHILOR]RILF]QHRGZUDFDMXZDJ RGFLJáHJRSRVW SXZUo-

]XPLHQLX]ZL]NyZSRPL G]\VWDQDPLPy]JXDVWDQDPLXP\VáXSRVW SXNWyU\GRNRQXMHVL

G]L NL PRGHORP G\QDPLF]Q\P W\SX VLHFL QHXURQRZ\FK William James i inni twórcy psy-

FKRORJLLZ;,;ZLHNX]DMPRZDOLVL SU]HGHZV]\VWNLPZLDGRPRFL-X*ZURNXDo-
nald

+HEE Z VZRMHM NVL*FH ÄOrganization of Behavior´ ]DSURSRQRZDá Z\MDQLHQLH ZLHOX

]MDZLVN SV\FKRORJLF]Q\FK ]ZL]DQ\FK ] SHUFHSFM XF]HQLHP VL  SDPL FL L ]DEXU]HQLDPL

DIHNW\ZQ\PLZRSDUFLXRSURFHV\]DFKRG]FHZVLHFLDFKQHXURQyZ:HZVW SLHGRVZRMHM

NVL*NL+HEEXWR*VDPLDáWHSURFHV\]H]MDZLVNDPLSV\FKLF]Q\PLQLHSRVXQáVL MHGQDN*HGR

SUyE\]UR]XPLHQLDZLDGRPRFL3V\FKRORJLDNRJQLW\ZQDSRPLPRRGU]XFHQLDRJUDQLF]RQHM

SHUVSHNW\Z\EHKDZLRU\]PXVWURQLáDRG]DJDGQLH]ZL]DQ\FK]HZLDGRPRFLERMFVL LFK
pozornie „nienaukowego” charakteru. Dopiero w ostatniej dekadzie XX wieku badania nad

ZLDGRPRFLZNURF]\á\GRJáyZQHJRQXUWXQDXNL3U]\F]\QLáDVL GRWHJRVHULDNRQIHUHQFML
organizowanych od 1996 przez University of Arizona w Tucson, oraz powstanie szeregu
specjalistycznych pism, takich jak Consciousness and Cognition (Academic Press) oraz Jour-
nal of Consciousness Studies (Imprint Academic

 :D*Q URO  RGHJUDá UyZQLH* DUW\NXá )

Cricka i C. Kocha [4]

IRUPXáXMF\SUREOHPZLDGRPRFLZ]URNRZHM]SXQNWXZLG]HQLDneu-

URELRORJLLRUD]SRSXODUQDNVL*ND)Cricka [5].

2

3UREOHP\]ZL]DQH]GHILQLFMZLDGRPRFL

7UXGQRMHVWMHGQR]QDF]QLH]GHILQLRZDüZLDGRPRüVáRZRWRX*\ZDQHMHVWERZLHPZZLHOX

Uy*Q\FK ]QDF]HQLDFK L NRQWHNVWDFK MDNLHJR ZL F Z\MDQLHQLD PR*QD VL  VSRG]LHZDü" &]\

ZLDGRPRüGDVL VSURZDG]LüGRXZDJLSDPL FLURERF]HMOXESHUFHSFML"&]XFLHZLG]HQLH

F]\ Vá\V]HQLH V ZLDGRP\PL ZUD*HQLDPL Z\QLNDMF\PL ]H ]ZUyFHQLD XZDJL QD F]\QQRFL

GRW\NDQLDSDWU]HQLDLVáXFKDQLD:M ]\NXSV\FKRORJLLSRWRF]QHMF]\QLP\ZL FUR]Uy*QLHQLH

SRPL G]\ G]LDáDQLHP XZDJL DNW\ZQHJR SURFHVX SR]ZDODMFHJR QD Z\EyU ERG(FyZ RUD]

VDP\PSURFHVHPGRZLDGF]DQLDW\FKERG(FyZMDNRZUD*H8ZDJDZ\ELHUDNWyUH]LVWQLHM-

F\FKZPy]JXSREXG]HE G]LHP\ZLDGRPLHGRZLDGF]DüOXESR]ZDODDNW\ZQLHSRV]XNi-

ZDüQRZ\FKZUD*H QS SU]H] NRQWURO  UXFKX JDáHN RF]Q\FK SRG ZSá\ZHP ERG(FyZ DNu-

VW\F]Q\FK&KRFLD*SRM FLDSV\FKRORJLLSRWRF]QHMPRJVL RND]Dü]XSHáQLHQLHDGHNZDWQH[3]

QLH QDOH*\ LFK RGU]XFDü SRFKRSQLH :\MDQLHQLD ]JRGQH ] SRWRF]Q\P VSRVREHP X*\ZDQLD

SRM ü GRW\F]F\FK ZLDGRPRFL E G VL  QDP Z\GDZDü EDUG]LHM QDWXUDOQH QL* Z\MDQLHQLD

DEVWUDNF\MQH1LHVWHW\Z\MDQLHQLDWDNLHQLHVXQLZHUVDOQHERZUy*Q\FKM ]\NDFKSRM FLH

ZLDGRPRFLLPHWDIRU\GRW\F]FHXP\VáXIXQNFMRQXMZRGPLHQQ\VSRVyESRUUR]Uy*QLHQLH

SRPL G]\consciousness i awarenessZM ]\NXDQJLHOVNLP:V]\VWNLHZ\MDQLHQLDSRWRF]QH

3

RGZRáXMVL ZMDZQ\OXEXNU\W\VSRVyEGRhomunculusaD ZL FRVWDWHF]QLHQLHGDG]VL

]DDNFHSWRZDü.WRNLHUXMHXZDJ"3UREOHPWHQQLHSRMDZLDVL MHOLG]LDáDQLHPy]JXRSLVu-

MHP\]DSRPRFXNáDGyZG\QDPLF]Q\FKSRUSRQi*HM

0QLHMMDVQHMHVWUR]Uy*QLHQLHSRPL G]\SDPL FLURERF]working memoryDZLDGRPRFL
Baddeley [1]

 XZD*D *H ZLDGRPRü G]LDáD SU]H] SDPL ü URERF] VWDQRZLF MHM DNW\ZQ\

HOHPHQWNRQLHF]Q\GRNRRUG\QDFMLLQIRUPDFML]Uy*Q\FK(UyGHá]DUyZQRSDPL FLHSL]RG\Fz-

QHM]GDU]HSU]HV]á\FKMDNLELH*FHMSHUFHSFML:W\PXM FLXVDPDSDPL üURERF]DMHVWW\ONR

]ELRUHP ÄRELHNWyZ XP\VáX´ UHSUH]HQWDFML LNRQRJUDILF]Q\FK SHUFHSWyZ P\OL D ZLDGo-

PRüMHVWDNW\ZQ\PSURFHVHPGRNRQXMF\PVNRMDU]HUHIOHNVMLLZROLFMRQDOQHMRFHQ\SRMa-

ZLDMF\FKVL PR*OLZRFLBaars [2]UR]ZLQáSRGREQHLGHHZUDPDFKWHRULLJOREDOQHMSU]e-
strzeni roboczej (Global Workspace

SUyEXMFZSHZQ\PVWRSQLXSRZL]DüM]neurofizjo-

ORJL : MHJR UR]XPLHQLX XZDJD VWZDU]D GRVW S GR ZLDGRPRFL ]DZLHUDMFHM RSUyF] per-

FHSWyZ ]ZL]DQ\FK ] G]LDáDQLHP ]P\VáyZ UyZQLH* LQWHQFMH SUDJQLHQLD ]QDF]HQLD DEVWUDk-

F\MQ\FKSRM üLLQQH HOHPHQW\ZLDGRPRüMHVWQDWRPLDVWSURFHVHPQDGU] GQ\PNRQLHFz-

Q\PE\SRZLDGRPLüZV]\VWNLHVWUXNWXU\Py]JXRSRMDZLDMF\PVL SUREOHPLHL]HEUDüF]Vt-

NRZHZ\QLNLRGZ\VSHFMDOL]RZDQ\FKQLHZLDGRP\FKSURFHVRUyZ]GROQ\FKGRUR]ZL]DQLD

IUDJPHQWyZ WHJR SUREOHPX =DZDUWRü VWUXPLHQLD ZLDGRPRFL SU]H*\ZDQH ZUD*HQLD MHVW

WR*VDPD]WUHFLSDPL FLURERF]HM7HLSRGREQHSRGHMFLDSV\FKRORJLF]QHXVLáXMFHVNRn-

NUHW\]RZDü SRM FLD M ]\ND SRWRF]QHJR Z\GDM VL  DWUDNF\MQH SR]ZDODMF VWZRU]\ü SRPRVW

SRPL G]\G\QDPLF]Q\PLPRGHODPLSURFHVyZ]DFKRG]F\FKZPy]JXDWUHFLXPyVáX

ZLDGRPRüZL*HVL ]VXEWHOQ\PLS\WDQLDPLGODF]HJRZRJyOHPDP\ZUD*HQLDZLDGRPH"

:UD*HQLDPDMMDNRFL]ZDQHZILOR]RILLXP\VáXqualiaNWyUHQLHGDMVL RSLVDü]DSRPRF

EDUG]LHMSRGVWDZRZ\FKSRM ü&]\LVWQLHQLXW\FKMDNRFLPR*QDSU]\SLVDüMDNIXQNFM "&]\

PRJRQHSRZVWDüZHOHNWURQLF]Q\FKV\PXODWRUDFKPy]JXOXESURJUDPDFKZ\NRQ\ZDQ\FK

SU]H]NRPSXWHU\"-DNLHMHVWHZROXF\MQH]QDF]HQLHZUD*H"&]\ZLDGRPRüUHIOHNV\MQQa-

OH*\X]QDü]DLQQ\URG]DMZLDGRPRFLQL*ZLDGRPRüSLHUZRWQ"3RZV]HFKQLHXZD*DVL 

*HVWRS\WDQLDQDNWyUHQLHPR*QD]QDOH(üRGSRZLHG]L0R*QDMHGQDN]QDOH(üDUJXPHQW\

SRND]XMFH*HV\VWHPV]WXF]Q\NWyUHJRG]LDáDQLHZ]RURZDQHMHVWQDPRGXODUQ\FKVLHFLDFK
neu

URQRZ\FKPy]JXPXVLWZLHUG]Lü*HRGF]XZDZUD*HQLD[9].

1DMEDUG]LHMNRQNUHWQHZ\GDMVL SUyE\V]XNDQLDQHXURIL]MRORJLF]Q\FKNRUHODWyZRGUy*QLDM-

F\FK VWDQ ZLDGRP\ RG QLHZLDGRPHJR 0R*QD ]QDOH(ü ZLHOH NRQWUDVWXMF\FK ]H VRE SDU

]MDZLVN XP\VáRZ\FK ] NWyU\FK MHGQR NRMDU]RQH MHVW ]H ZLDGRP\P G]LDáDQLHP D GUXJLH ]

QLHZLDGRP\P'RW\F]\WRUy*Q\FKURG]DMyZSDPL FLSDPL üNUyWNRWUZDáD±SDPL üGáXJo-

WHUPLQRZDHSL]RG\F]QD±VHPDQW\F]QDGHNODUDW\ZQD±SURFHGXUDOQDZLDGRPHXF]HQLHVL

LSDPL ü±XF]HQLHVL LSDPL üXWDMRQDimplict learning, implicit memory.RQWURO LZQLo-

VNRZDQLHZLDGRPHSU]HFLZVWDZLüPR*QDNRQWUROLLDXWRPDW\F]QHPXG]LDáDQLXOXEWH*EDr-

G]LHM RJyOQLH SURFHV\ Z\PDJDMFH XP\VáRZHJR Z\VLáNX SURFHVRP Z\NRQ\ZDQ\P VSRQWa-

QLF]QLHOXEEH]Z\VLáNXZLDGRPDSHUFHSFMDNRQWUDVWXMH]QLHZLDGRPUHFHSFMERG(FyZD

PHFKDQL]P\XZDJLZ\Uy*QLDMERG(FH QRZH ]QDF]FH VLOQH OXE ]QDMGXMFH VL  Z FHQWUXP

XZDJL VS\FKDMF GR QLHZLDGRPHM UHFHSFML ERG(FH SRZWDU]DMFH VL  QLHLVWRWQH VáDEH OXE

]QDMGXMFHVL QDSHU\IHULDFKXZDJL6WDQMDZ\LPDU]HVHQQ\FKSU]HFLZVWDZLüPR*QDVWa-

QRZLVQXJá ERNLHJROXENRPLH(NVSHU\PHQW\PRJSRND]DüUy*QLFHSRPL G]\VWDQDPLPó-

]JXZF]DVLHZLDGRPHJRG]LDáDQLDLG]LDáDQLDQLHZLDGRPHJR

4

3

1HXURIL]MRORJLF]QHNRUHODW\ZLDGRPRFL

.RQWUDVW\SRPL G]\F]\QQRFLDPLLVWDQDPLZLDGRP\PLDQLHZLDGRP\PLPR*QDEDGDüZ

WHVWDFKSV\FKRORJLF]Q\FK-HGQDN*HSU]H]GáXJLF]DVWUXGQRE\áR]QDOH(üneurofizjologiczne

NRUHODW\ ZUD*H ZLDGRP\FK 0HWRG\ REUD]RZDQLD Py]JX SR]ZROLá\ FR SUDZGD GRVWU]HF

REV]DU\]DDQJD*RZDQHZSU]HWZDU]DQLHLQIRUPDFMLMHGQDN*HVDPRSREXG]HQLHSáDWyZF]Ráo-

Z\FKZF]DVLHUR]ZL]DQLD]DGDGRW\F]F\FKSODQRZDQLDQLHMHVWSUHF\]\MQLHVNRUHORZDQH]

ZUD*HQLDPL ZLDGRP\PL 5R]G]LHOF]Rü F]DVRZD I05, OXE 3(7 QLH MHVW Z\VWDUF]DMFD GR

]DREVHUZRZDQLDWDNLFKNRUHODFML3DPL üNUyWNRWUZDáDMHVWEH]ZWSLHQLD]ZL]DQD]ELRHOHk-

WU\F]Q\PL V]\ENR]PLHQQ\PL SREXG]HQLDPL SU]HMDZLDMF\PL VL  Z F]\QQRFL ((* NRU\
Crick i Koch [4]

]DVWDQDZLDOLVL QDGproblemem scalania (the binding problemDNW\ZQRFL

Uy*Q\FKF] FLXNáDGXZ]URNRZHJR[21]ZSURFHVLHZLG]HQLD6FDODQLHDNW\ZQRFLNRQLHFz-

QH GR SRZVWDQLD ZUD*HQLD SU]HFKRZ\ZDQHJR Z SDPL FL URERF]HM Z\PDJD V\QFKURQL]DFML

Z\áDGRZD QHXURQyZ :LHOX EDGDF]\ ZVXQ áR KLSRWH]  R LVWRWQHM UROL RVF\ODFML R F] VWo-

FLDFK U] GX  Hz w tym procesie. Singer [16] SLV]H Ä0R*OLZH *H W\ONR WH SREXG]HQLD

SU]HNUDF]DMSUyJZLDGRPRFLNWyUHVGRVWDWHF]QLH]RUJDQL]RZDQHLNRKHUHQWQH´6\QFKUo-

QL]DFMD SRZLQQD GRW\F]\ü QLH W\ONR LQWUDNRUW\NDOQ\FK SREXG]H OHF] UyZQLH* REHMPRZDü
struktury limbiczne oraz twór siatkowaty.

3RPLPR OLF]Q\FK HNVSHU\PHQWyZ ] XG]LDáHP OXG]L L ]ZLHU]W SRWZLHUG]DMF\FK LVWQLHQLH

]ZL]NX SRPL G]\ ZUD*HQLDPL ZLDGRP\PL L V\QFKURQL]DFM QHXURQyZ  SRU SU]HJOG Z
Temporal Binding, numer specjalny Consciousness and Cognition Vol. 8, No. 2, czerwiec
1999) hipoteza 40

+]MHVWZGDOV]\PFLJXNRQWURZHUV\MQD3U]HGHZV]\VWNLPQLHMHVWZFDOH

MDVQHF]\VDPSUREOHPVFDOHQLDZUD*HZ\PDJDUR]ZL]DQLDDOERZLHPQLHNWyU]\ILOR]RIRZLH

SRGZD*DMSU]HNRQDQLHRNRQLHF]QRFLWUDNWRZDQLD ZUD*HZLDGRP\FKZFDáRFLRZ\VSo-

VyE-HOLXGDáRE\VL Z\ND]Dü*HMHGQRüZLDGRPRFLMHVWSHZQHJRURG]DMXLOX]MLQDOH*\

UDF]HMPyZLüRVWUXPLHQLXZUD*HLQWHUSUHWRZDQ\FKMDNR FDáRüSUREOHPVFDODQLDRND]DáE\

VL SR]RUQ\Zeki i Bartels [21]SU]\FK\ODMVL GRSRUHGQLHJRSRJOGXZNWyU\PPRGXODUQD

EXGRZDPy]JXSR]ZDODQDSRZVWDZDQLHV\QFKURQLF]Q\FKVWDQyZ ZHZQWU]PRGXáyZOHF]

QLHZREU ELHFDáHJRPy]JX%\áE\WRZL F]ELyUÄPLNURZLDGRPRFL´]DPLDVWÄWHDWUXZLa-

GRPRFL´[2]3RGREQWHRUL JáRVL$Damasio [6]JUXS\QHXURQyZZ]QDMGXMF\FKVL  Z

Uy*Q\FK REV]DUDFK Py]JX ± ÄVWUHIDFK NRQZHUJHQFML´ F]\OL REV]DUDFK wielomodalnych, od-

ELHUDMF\FKLZ\V\áDMF\FKV\JQDá\GRZLHOXUHMRQyZPy]JX±PRJSREXG]DüREV]DU\F]u-

FLRZHLREV]DU\RGSRZLHG]LDOQH]DHNVSUHVM HPRFMLUHNRQVWUXXMFVWDQ\Py]JXSRGREQHGR

W\FKNWyUHZ\ZRáDQH]RVWDá\SU]H]SLHUZRWQHERG(FH:WHMWHRULLVFDODQLHZUD*HQLHZ\Pa-

JDV\QFKURQLF]Q\FKRVF\ODFMLFKRFLD*SRZLQQ\LVWQLHüNRUHODFMHF]DVRZHSRPL G]\DNW\ZQo-

FLUy*Q\FKREV]DUyZZLGRF]QHQDREUazach fMRI i PET.

: QLHNWyU\FK EDGDQLDFK QLH ]DREVHUZRZDQR LVWQLHQLD NRUHODFML SRPL G]\ V\QFKURQL]DFM
oscylacji 40

+]DZUD*HQLDPLZLDGRP\PLFRPR*HZLDGF]\üRVáXV]QRFLZVSRPQLDQ\FK

WXWHRULLDOWHUQDW\ZQ\FK6\WXDFMDMHVW]DSHZQHEDUG]LHMVNRPSOLNRZDQDQL*SRF]WNRZR]a-

NáDGDQR Newman i Grace [11] ]DVWDQDZLDM VL  QDG PHFKDQL]PHP LQWHJUDFML L ILOWURZDQLD

Uy*Q\FK SHUFHSWyZ VFDORQ\FK ]D SRPRF V\QFKURQL]DFML UR]SURV]RQ\FK JUXS QHXURQyZ Z

SDPL FLURERF]HM$QDOL]XMFHNVSHU\PHQWDOQHGDQHGRFKRG]RQLGRZQLRVNX*H]DV\QFKUo-

QL]DFM  SURFHVyZ ]DFKRG]F\FK QD QDMZ\*V]\FK SL WUDFK SU]HWZDU]DQLD Z REV]DU]H dolno-
skroniowym (IT) i

SU]HGF]RáRZ\P WZRU]F\FK VWUXPLH ZLDGRPRFL RGSRZLHG]LDOQH V

procesy selekcji (gating

 GRNRQ\ZDQH SU]H] RURGNL XNáDGX OLPELF]QHJR EU]XV]Q F] ü

SU*NRZLDD]ZáDV]F]DMGURSyáOH*FHLMGURVLDWNRZDWHZ]JyU]Dnucleus reticularis thal-
ami

 157 -HVW WR UR]ZLQLHFLH ]DSURSRQRZDQHJR ZF]HQLHM ÄUR]V]HU]RQHJR siatkowo-

5

wzgórzowego schematu aktywacji” (Extended Reticulo-Thalamic Activation System,

(57$6 Z REU ELH NWyUHJR SRZVWDZDü PLDá\ SREXG]HQLD RGSRZLHG]LDOQH ]D ZLDGRPRü

V]F]HJyá\neuroanatomiczQHRSLVDQHVZSUDFDFK[11],[17],[19],[20]).

William James

VG]Lá*HZLDGRPRüMHVWZ\QLNLHPG]LDáDQLDFDáHJRPy]JXJG\*QLHZLHOH

XV]NRG]HPy]JXSURZDG]LGRMHMFDáNRZLWHMXWUDW\:EDGDQLDFKZ\NRU]\VWXMF\FKU\ZDOi-

]DFM  REXRF]Q binocular rivalry X PDáS Z\ND]DQR EUDN NRUHODFML SRPL G]\ ZUD*HQLDPL

ZLDGRP\PLDDNW\ZQRFLZL NV]RFLQHXURQyZQL*V]\FKSL WHUNRU\Z]URNRZHM99

07ZF]DVLHJG\DNW\ZQRüQHXURQyZZZ\*V]\FKSL WUDFK,7676MHVW]QLPLVNo-

UHORZDQD3RGREQHZ\QLNLRWU]\PDQR]DSRPRFPHWRGmagnetoencefalograficznych (MEG)

XOXG]L:\GDMHVL U]HF]RF]\ZLVW*HDNW\ZQRüW\ONRW\FKREV]DUyZPy]JXZNWyU\FK

LVWQLHMVWDELOQHniezmiennicze reprezentacje SHUFHSWyZPR*HZ\ND]\ZDüNRUHODFMH]ZLa-

GRP\PLRGF]XFLDPL2NRSU]HPLHV]F]DMFVL UXFKDPLVDNNDG\F]Q\PLZ\V\áD]VLDWNyZNLGR

QL*V]\FKSL WHUXNáDGXZ]URNRZHJRV\JQDá\]E\WFKDRW\F]QHE\PRJá\RQHEH]SRUHGQLRE\ü

XZLDGDPLDQH2EV]DU\NRU\]ZL]DQH]HV]ODNLHPJU]ELHWRZ\PXNáDGX Z]URNRZHJR G]La-

áDMZ]QDF]QHMPLHU]HQLH]DOH*QLHRGZLDGRPRFLSR]ZDODMFQDSU]\NáDGQDV]\ENDXWo-

PDW\F]Q UHDNFM  QD Z\NU\ZDQLH UXFKX 3REXG]HQLD V]ODNX EU]XV]QHJR SURZDG]FHJR GR

SáDWyZVNURQLRZ\FKSURZDG]EH]SRUHGQLRGRZUD*HZ]URNowych.

:LHOH LQQ\FK SURFHVyZ DXWRPDW\F]Q\FK SREXG]D F] FL XNáDGX Z]URNRZHJR L VáXFKRZHJR

ZSá\ZDMFMHG\QLHZSRUHGQLVSRVyEQDWUHüZUD*HZLDGRP\FK2F]\ZLFLHZV]\VWNLH

REV]DU\Py]JXV]HVREVSU] *RQHLZGáX*V]\PRNUHVLHF]DVXPRJQDVLHELHRGG]LDá\ZDü

DOH QLH ZV]\VWNLH PRJ WR ]URELü Z NUyWNLP RNLHQNX F]DVRZ\P SRWU]HEQ\P QD SRZVWDQLH

ZLDGRPHJRZUD*HQLDU] GXXáDPNyZVHNXQG7\ONRQDMZD*QLHMV]HLQIRUPDFMHGDMEH]So-

UHGQLZNáDGGRSDPL FLURERF]HMVFDODMFHMVWDQW\FKREV]DUyZPy]JXNWyUHZLVWRWQ\VSo-

VyEZSá\ZDMQDNRQWURO ]DFKRZDQLD+DELWXDFMDSRZRGXMH]DQLNDQLHVNRUHORZDQHM]GDQ\P

ERG(FHPDNW\ZQRFLSR]DREV]DUDPLVHQVRU\F]Q\PL'áXJRWUZDáDSDPL üHSL]RG\F]QD]DSi-

VXMHSU]HGHZV]\VWNLPVWDQSDPL FLURERF]HMSR]ZDODMFJRRGWZRU]\üZSy(QLHMV]\PRNUe-

VLHLXPR*OLZLDMFX*\WHF]QHVNRMDU]HQLD-HGQ]IXQNFMLZLDGRPRFLMHVWZL FURO  ILOWUD

SR]ZDODMFHJR]DSDPL WDü]PRU]DNRPELQDFMLGRFLHUDMF\FKGRPy]JXV\JQDáyZW\ONRQDj-

ZD*QLHMV]H

&KRFLD* QLH PD VHQVX PyZLü R ÄQHXURQDFK ZLDGRPRFL´ QLH ZV]\VWNLH REV]DU\ Py]JX Z

MHGQDNRZ\P VWRSQLX PDM EH]SRUHGQL ZSá\Z QD WUHü SDPL FL URERF]HM D ZL F QD WUHü

ZLDGRPRFL7DMHPQLFD ZLDGRPRFL ] SHZQRFL Z\GDZDáD E\ VL  PQLHMV]D JG\E\ XGDáR

VL ]QDOH(üWDNLHFHFK\ZPR*OLZ\FKGR]DREVHUZRZDQLDV\JQDáDFKDNW\ZQRFLPy]JXNWyUH

MHGQR]QDF]QLH NRUHOXM VL  ] VXELHNW\ZQ\PL ZUD*HQLDPL =QDF]Q\ SRVW S Z W\P NLHUXQNX
stanowi praca Tononi i Edelmana [19]

SRGNUHODMFDGZLHVSU]HF]QH]HVREFHFK\ZLDGo-

PHMDNW\ZQRFLVFDOHQLDUy*Q\FKDVSHNWyZGRZLDGF]DQ\FKZUD*HLMHGQRF]HVQHJRGX*HJR

]Uy*QLFRZDQLDSR]ZDODMFHJRQDV]\ENLH]PLDQ\SU]H*\ZDQ\FK]áR*RQ\FKHSL]RGyZ6Fa-

OHQLHDNW\ZQRFLJUXSQHXURQyZPR*QD]PLHU]\üZSURZDG]DMFPLDU IXQNFMRQDOQHJRVNu-

SLHQLD DNW\ZQRFL F

A

 RSDUW QD LQIRUPDFML Z]DMHPQHM : RNUHORQ\P RNLHQNX F]DVRZ\P

JUXSDIXQNFMRQDOQDSRZLQQDFKDUDNWHU\]RZDüVL ZL NV]\PLQGHNVHPF

A

dla elementów na-

OH*F\FKGRWHMJUXS\QL*GODSR]RVWDá\FKHOHPHQWyZ

Niech X oznacza zbiór elementów neuronowych (np. minikolumn); wybierzmy z niego j-ty
podzbiór X

j

k

o k elementach (z k

HOHPHQWyZXWZRU]\üPR*QDZLHOHNRPELQDFMLL]EDGDMP\QD

LOHDNW\ZQRüWHJRSRG]ELRUX]DOH*\RGSR]RVWDá\FKQHXURQyZX

−

X

j

k

:SURZDG]DMFPLDU

LORFLLQIRUPDFMLHQWURSLL]ELRUXH(X)PR*QDRNUHOLüLQIRUPDFM Z]DMHPQH

I

(X

j

k

;X

−

X

j

k

)=

6

H(X

j

k

)+ H(X

−

X

j

k

)

−

H(X)

NWyUDUyZQDMHVWVXPLHLORFLLQIRUPDFML]DZDUWHMZSRG]ELRU]HX

j

k

i

MHJRGRSHáQLHQLXX

−

X

j

k

PLQXVLORüLQIRUPDFMLZFDá\P]ELRU]HX=DPLDU LQIRUPDFMLZ\Qi-

NDMFHM]LQWHJUDFMLSRG]ELRUXX

j

k

PR*HP\SU]\MüUy*QLF PL G]\VXPLQIRUPDFMLZV]\Vt-

NLFK HOHPHQWyZ SRG]ELRUX WUDNWRZDQ\FK MDNR QLH]DOH*QH F]\OL I(X

j

k

)=

Σ

i

H(x

i

∈

X

j

k

)

−

H(X

j

k

).

Iloraz F

A

(X

j

k

)= I(X

j

k

)/H

I

(X

j

k

;X

−

X

j

k

)

RNUHODPLDU VNXSLHQLDDNW\ZQRFLDMHJRPDNV\PDOL]a-

FMDSR]ZDODWDNGREUDüSRG]ELyUHOHPHQWyZE\LQIRUPDFMDZHZQ WU]QDE\áDMDNQDMZL NV]D

SU]\ QDMPQLHMV]HM LQIRUPDFML Z]DMHPQHM .ROHMQ\ NURN WR ZSURZDG]HQLH PLDU\ ]áR*RQRFL

RNUHODMFHM]GROQRüV\VWHPXGRSU]\MPRZDQLDVWDQyZNWyUH]MHJRZáDVQHJRSXQNWXZi-

G]HQLDVLVWRWQLHUy*QH-HOLX]QDü*HV\VWHPPR*HREVHUZRZDüVDPVLHELHWRG]LHOFJRQD
X

j

k

i X

−

X

j

k

PR*HP\]PLHU]\üLQIRUPDFM Z]DMHPQH

I

(X

j

k

;X

−

X

j

k

)

NWyUDMHVWGX*DMHOLREy-

GZLH F] FL PDM GX*D SRMHPQRü LQIRUPDF\MQ Z VWRVXQNX GR FDáHJR ]ELRUX  Tonioni i
Edelman [19]

 SURSRQXM SU]\Mü MDNR PLDU  ]áR*RQRFL neuronalnej zbioru C

N

(X)

VXP  SR

wszystkich k

HOHPHQWRZ\FKSRG]ELRUDFKXUHGQLRQSRPR*OLZ\FKSRG]ELRUDFKF]\OL

C

N

(X) =

Σ

k

<

H

I

(X

j

k

;X

−

X

j

k

)

>

j

'X*D]áR*RQRüR]QDF]DZVSyáLVWQLHQLHVSHFMDOL]DFMLIXQNFMRQDOQHMHOHPHQWyZQDOH*F\FKGR

DNW\ZQ\FKVNXSLHSU]\MPXMF\FKOLF]QHZ]DMHPQLHRGVLHELH]DOH*QHVWDQ\=DVWRVRZDQLH

WHMPLDU\GRV\PXORZDQ\FKVLHFL]áR*RQ\FK]W\VL F\QHXURQyZGDMHQDMEDUG]LHMLQWHUHVXMFH

]DFKRZDQLDVLHFLLGX*HZVSyáF]\QQLNLC

N

(X)

GODÄQDWXUDOQHM´WRSRJUDILLSRáF]HDQLHZLHl-

NLHGODLQQ\FKWRSRJUDILL* VWHSU]\SDGNRZHSRáF]HQLDGDMhipersynchroniczne pobudzenia

RQLHZLHONLP]Uy*QLFRZDQLXDU]DGNLHSRáF]HQLDGDMFKDRW\F]QH]Uy*QLFRZDQHDOHQLH]a-

OH*QHRGVLHELHSREXG]HQLDDZL FL]áR*RQRüneuronalna jest niewielka. Tonioni i Edelman
[19]

 PDM QDG]LHM  *H ]DVWRVRZDQLH WDNLFK PLDU LQIRUPDF\MQ\FK SRPR*H Z LGHQW\ILNDFML

VWUXNWXUPy]JXELRUF\FKZLVWRWQ\VSRVyEXG]LDáZJHQHUDFMLVWDQyZZLDGRP\FK

4

7HRUHW\F]QHPRGHOHZLDGRPRFL

John

7D\ORUSRVWDZLáVRELHEDUG]RDPELWQH]DGDQLHZ\MDQLHQLDZRSDUFLXRPRGHOHQHXUo-

QRZHZáDVQRFLFKDUDNWHU\]XMF\FKSU]H*\FLDZLDGRPH[17],[18]. QualiaPRQDG\F]QHZáa-

VQRFLZUD*HQLHUHGXNRZDOQHGRZáDVQRFLSURVWV]\FK]QDQHW\ONR]LQWURVSHNFML3UREOe-

PHPMHVWWXRF]\ZLFLHXVWDOHQLHIHQRPHQRORJLLZUD*HJG\*QDLZQHWZLHUG]HQLH*HSU]H*y-

FLD ]QDQH V EH]SRUHGQLR D QLH LQWHUSUHWRZDQH Z ZLHWOH ZáDVQHM WHRULL XP\VáX QLH MHVW

SUDZG]LZH 3DWU]\P\ QD ZLDW SU]H] VZRMH ZUD*HQLD D QLH ÄGRZLDGF]DP\ ZUD*H´ 6u-

ELHNW\ZQDWUHüGRZLDGF]HQLDZHZQ WU]QHJRMDZLVL QDPZLQW\PQ\EH]SRUHGQLVSRVyE

QLHPR*HP\VL RGHUZDüVSRMU]HüQDWUHüXP\VáX]]HZQWU]WDNE\]REDF]\üMDNLHPHFKa-

QL]P\ VWRM ]D VFHQ ÄWHDWUX ZLDGRPRFL´ 0RQDG\F]QRü ZUD*H QLHPR*OLZRü LFK Ge-

NRPSR]\FMLSRZRGXMH*HWUXGQRMHVWMHRGQLHüGRVWDQXQHXURQyZJG\*QLHZLDGRPRMDNLH

HIHNW\ PDM SRZRGRZDü WH VWDQ\ 1D SR]LRPLH QHXURQRZ\P PR*HP\ PyZLü R IXQNFMDFK

RGSRZLDGDMF\FK SU]HWZDU]DQLX LQIRUPDFML DOH WX QLH FKRG]L R SU]HWZDU]DQLH LQIRUPDFML

:UD*HQLDPDMVZyMZ\PLDUF]DVRZ\VREHFQHWUZDMPDMRNUHVlatencji (powstanie wra-

*HQLD Z\PDJD NLONXVHW PLOLVHNXQG L QLHVSRVWU]H*HQLH SU]HFKRG] Z LQQH 7UZDQLH PR*H

REHMPRZDüNLONDVHNXQGZNWyU\FKQDVW SXMHLQWHJUDFMDZUD*HQSSRWU]HEQDGR]UR]XPLe-

QLD VHQVX ]GDQLD :L NV]Rü VWDQyZ SV\FKLF]Q\FK MHVW LQWHQFMRQDOQD ZVND]XMH QD FR Z

ZLHFLH,QQHDVSHNW\WRWHQGHQFMDGRSRVWU]HJDQLDFDáRFLJHVWDOWUR]Uy*QLHQLHZUD*HFHn-

WUDOQ\FKLSHU\IHU\MQ\FK'RZLDGF]HQLDZLDGRPHSU]\SLV\ZDQHVLRGQRV]RQHGRFHQWUXP

ÄMD´DOHMHVWWRZáDVQRüZLDGRPRFLUHIOHNV\MQHMNWyUHMPRJQLHSRVLDGDü]ZLHU] WD

:áDVQRFLSU]H*\üZLDGRP\FKPRJXOHFUDG\NDOQHM ]PLDQLH Z SU]\SDGNX XV]NRG]H OXE

FKRUyEPy]JX$QDOL]XMFWHZáDVQRFLTaylor [17]Z\SURZDG]D]QLFKGRüRF]\ZLVWHNU\We-

7

ULDMDNLHSRZLQQ\VSHáQLDüPRGHOHQHXURQRZH1SÄSDWU]HQLHSU]H]ZUD*HQLD´]ZL]DQHMHVW

]HIHNW\ZQRFLG]LDáDQLDV\VWHPXáF]FHJRPRGXá\GRVWDUF]DMFHGDQH]ZL]DQH]ZUD*e-

QLDPLGRPRGXáyZQDZ\*V]\FKSL WUDFKZW\PPRGXáyZRGSRZLHG]LDOQ\FK]DUHSUH]HQWDFM

SHUVSHNW\Z\HJRFHQWU\F]QHM1DVW SQLHUR]ZD*DSU]HVWU]HQQHF]DVRZHLHPHUJHQWQHZáDVQo-

FLNRQLHF]QHGRSRZVWDQLDSU]H*\üZHZQ WU]Q\FKSRGDMFURG]DMHVLHFLQHXURQRZ\FKMDNLH

PRJUHDOL]RZDüWHJRW\SXIXQNFMH:áDVQRFLSU]HVWU]HQQHOXERJyOQLHMWRSRJUDILF]QH]Ue-

DOL]RZDüMHVWQDMáDWZLHM]DSRPRFVDPRRUJDQL]XMF\FKVL PDSQHXURQyZ:áDVQRFLWHPSo-

UDOQH]ZL]DQH]WUZDQLHPODWHQFMLSU]HMFLDPLSRPL G]\ZUD*HQLDPL]UHDOL]RZDüPR*QD

]DSRPRFORNDOQ\FKUHNXUHQF\MQ\FKVLHFLNRQNXUXMF\FK]HVREQHXURQyZ]RGSRZLHGQL

G\QDPLNZNWyU\FKSU]HMFLDPL G]\VWDQDPLDWUDNWRURZ\PLVGRVWDWHF]QLHV]\ENLHZSo-

UyZQDQLX ] F]DVHP SU]HE\ZDQLD Z SRV]F]HJyOQ\FK VWDQDFK 1DMFLHNDZV]H V ZáDVQRFL

HPHUJHQWQH ± WX DXWRU SURSRQXMH ÄEEOH DNW\ZQRFL´ RGSRZLDGDMFH ZUD*HQLRP SRZVWDM-

F\PQDQDMZ\*V]\PSR]LRPLHKLHUDUFKLLPRGXáyZV\VWHPX7DNLHEEOHWZRU]VL ZPRGe-

ODFKWUDNWXMF\FKWNDQN QHXURQRZMDNRFLJáGZXZ\PLDURZZDUVWZ 6WR]ORNDOL]RZa-

QHSREXG]HQLDWUZDMFHSU]H]MDNLVNRF]RQ\F]DVQDZHWSR]QLNQL FLXV\JQDáyZNWyUHMH

Z\ZRáDá\

W sieciach

DWUDNWRURZ\FKSREXG]HQLDQHXURQyZV]\ENRSURZDG]GRPHWDVWDELOQ\FKVWDQyZ

NWyUH]DFLHUDMODG\VZRMHJRSRFKRG]HQLDJG\*VWDNLHVDPHQLH]DOH*QLHRGSRF]WNRZHJR

SXQNWXZ\MFLDZREU ELHEDVHQXDWUDNFML&LJZLDGRP\FKZUD*HSRMDZLDVL NROHMQREH]

PR*OLZRFLSU]HOHG]HQLDVNGVL RQHELRU7D\ORUVG]L[18]*HNOXF]RZURO ZNRQWUo-

ORZDQLXNRQNXUHQFMLSRPL G]\Uy*Q\PLIUDJPHQWDPLUHSUH]HQWDFMLVNáDGDMF\PLVL QDFDáo-

FLRZH ZUD*HQLD SHáQL MGUR VLDWNRZDWH 157 WUyMZDUVWZRZD VLHü KDPXMF\FK QHXURQyZ

]QDMGXMF\FKVL ZF] FLEU]XV]QHMZ]JyU]D157PDREXVWURQQHSRáF]HQLD]HZV]\VWNLPL

REV]DUDPLNRU\RUD]SR]RVWDá\PLF] FLDPLZ]JyU]D6\PXODFMHNRPSXWHURZHSRND]Dá\*H

LVWRWQLHSU]HMFLDSRPL G]\VWDQDPLDWUDNWRURZ\PLZXNáDG]LH157NRUDZ]JyU]HPDMRd-

SRZLHGQLHZáDVQRFL-HOLGRGDüGRWHJRPRGHONRU\ZSRVWDFLFLJáHJRSRODneuronalnego
(Continuum Neural Field Theory

&1)7ZNWyU\PSRZVWDMEEOHDNW\ZQRFLáF]FORNDl-

QHPRGXá\&1)7ZZDUVWZ\PR*QD]DREVHUZRZDüV]HUHJZáDVQRFLNWyUH]JRGQHV]NUy-

WHULDPLGODV\VWHPXUHDOL]XMFHJRZLDGRPHSU]H*\FLD%EOHZNROHMQ\FKZDUVWZDFKPRJ

VL VWDZDüFRUD]GáX*V]H]DFLHUDMFV]F]HJyá\VWUXNWXU\QDQL*V]\FKSR]LRPDFK3REXG]HQLH

NUyWNLPLPSXOVHPZ]URNRZ\PPR*HZ\ZRáDüDNW\ZQRüZREV]DU]H9RFKDUDNWHU\VW\Fz-

Q\PF]DVLH*\FLDU] GXPVZ\GáX*DMFVL ZZ\*V]\FKSL WUDFK XNáDGX Z]URNRZHJR

ZLHORNURWQLH0R*HWRE\ü(UyGáHP]áXG]HZ]URNRZ\FKQSUXFKXSR]RUQHJR%EOHDNW\w-

QRFLPRJVL SU]HVXZDüSRGZSá\ZHPQRZ\FKERG(FyZDUXFKW\FKEEOLPR*HVL SU]H]

MDNLF]DVXWU]\P\ZDüMX*SRXVWDQLXERG(FyZ-HG\QLHWDDNW\ZQRüNWyUDWUZDGRVWDWHF]QLH

GáXJRPR*HVWDüVL (UyGáHPZLaGRP\FKZUD*H

7DNLH WHRULH ]EOL*DM QDV GR V]F]HJyáRZ\FK PRGHOL G\QDPLNL Py]JX R ZáDVQRFLDFK NWyUH

PR*QDFLOHSRZL]Dü]ZáDVQRFLDPLSU]H*\ZDQ\FKVWDQyZSV\FKLF]Q\FK3R]RVWDMHMHGQDN

ZLHOHS\WD$NW\ZQRüNWyU\FKREV]DUyZPy]JXRGSRZLDGDEH]SRUHGQLR]DWUHüZLDGo-

PRFL"7D\ORUSURSRQXMHWXLQIRUPDFMDSU\ZDWQDJáyZQLHERF]QHF] FLSáDWyZFLHPLHQLo-
wych. Propozycja ta wymaga eksperymentalnego zbadania, np. przez zrobienie mapy czasów

*\FLDEEOLDNW\ZQRFLZUy*Q\FKF] FLDFKNRU\]DSRPRF0(*OXE((*3URJUDPEDGa-

QLDF]DVyZDNW\ZQRFLPR*QDUHDOL]RZDü]DUyZQRGODERG(FyZSRGSURJRZ\FKMDNLXZLa-

GDPLDQ\FK 6SHF\ILF]QD WUHü ZUD*H WDNLFK MDN GRZLDGF]DQLH F]HUZLHQL ]DFKRG]FHJR

VáRFDOXEVPDNXF]HNRODG\MHVWZ\QLNLHPZ]DMHPQ\FKUHODFMLSRZVWDMF\FKVWDQyZLVWa-

QyZ ]DSDPL WDQ\FK ']L NL W\P UHODFMRP SRZVWDM VNRMDU]HQLD L LQWHUSUHWDFMH Taylor nie

WZLHUG]L*HMHJRWHRULDEEOLSU]HNUDF]DSU]HSDüSRPL G]\SV\FKLNDIL]MRORJLQLHRGSo-

8

ZLDGDERZLHPQDIXQGDPHQWDOQHS\WDQLHÄGODF]HJRZUD*HQLDVZRJyOHRGF]XZDQH´XZD*D

MHGQDN*HMHVWWRSLHUZV]\U]XWRNDQDGUXJVWURQ WHMSU]HSDFLexplanatory gap).

Dla Stephena

*URVVEHUJD SUREOHP ZLDGRPRFL MHVW F] FL RJyOQLHMV]HM WHRULL ]ZL]DQHM ]

XF]HQLHPVL LXZDJ[11]3RGVWDZRZDKLSRWH]DEU]PLZV]\VWNLHVWDQ\ZLDGRPHVVWDQa-

PL UH]RQDQVRZ\PL = WHJR SRZRGX ZLHOH SURFHVyZ Z Py]JX Z\NRU]\VWXMF\FK XF]HQLH

NRQNXUHQF\MQHOXESRUyZQ\ZDQLH]SURWRW\SDPLWRSURFHV\QLHZLDGRPH5R]ZLMDQDSU]H]
Grossberga przez ostatnie 30 lat teoria adaptacyjnego rezonansu (Adaptive Resonance Theory,

$57]QDMGXMHOLF]QLH]DVWRVRZDQLDZ\MDQLDMFQSLOX]MHZ]URNRZHDNXVW\F]QHWZRU]HQLH

NDWHJRULLF]\LQWHJUDFM ZUD*HZRNLHQNDFKF]DVRZ\FK1SVá\V]F]GDQLH„It was found
that the ...eel is on the ...” (

VWZLHUG]RQR*Heel jest na ...), gdzie ]DVWSLRQHMHVWV]XPHP

ZLDGRPHZUD*HQLH]ZL]DQH]QLHSHáQ\PVáRZHPHHO]PLHQLDVL SRGZSá\ZHPQDGFKo-

G]FHJRSy(QLHMVáRZDNRFRZHJR6á\V]\P\]GDQLD„peel is on the orange” (skórka jest na

SRPDUDF]\, „wheel is on the wagon” NRáRMHVWQDZR]LH, „heel is on the shoe” (obcas jest
na bucie) lub „meal is on the table”

SRVLáHNMHVWQDVWROH:UD*HQLDQLHSRZVWDMZL FEH]So-

UHGQLRQDSRGVWDZLHV\JQDáyZ ]P\VáRZ\FK OHF] V Z\QLNLHP RGZRá\ZDQLD VL  GR MX* LVt-

QLHMFHM ZLHG]\ SU]HFKRZ\ZDQHM Z SDPL FL GáXJRWUZDáHM : FLJX VHNXQG\ SREXG]DQH V

UHSUH]HQWDFMH W\FK SRM ü NWyUH QD SRGVWDZLH NRQWHNVWX PRJ QDGDü SHáQLHMV] LQWHUSUHWDFM

UHSUH]HQWDFMRPZSDPL FLURERF]HMSRF]\P]DZDUWRüSaPL FLURERF]HMXOHJD]PLDQLH

0R*QDQDWHQSURFHVVSRMU]HüMDNQDGRSDVRZDQLHGRFKRG]FHMLQIRUPDFMLGR]JyU\XVWDOo-

Q\FKRF]HNLZDG]L NLZLHG]\]GRE\WHMQDSRGVWDZLHZF]HQLHMV]\FKGRZLDGF]H']L NL

RF]HNLZDQLRP]V]XPXZ\ELHUDQHVRGSRZLHGQLHIRUPDQW\MHVWWRNRQNOX]MDHNVSHU\PHn-

WyZSV\FKRIL]\F]Q\FK7HQZ]DMHPQ\ZSá\ZRF]HNLZDLLVWQLHMFHMZGDQ\PPRPHQFLHZ

SDPL FLURERF]HMLQWHUSUHWDFMLZ\WZDU]DVWDQUH]RQDQVRZ\SU]HGáX*DMF\LQDVLODMF\SREu-

G]HQLDáF]F\ZW\PSU]\SDGNXIRQHW\N ]VHPDQW\N]GDQLD

$57VWZRU]RQRSRWRE\ UR]ZL]DüSUREOHPVWDELOQRFLSODVW\F]QRFLZQDE\ZDQLXQRZHM

ZLHG]\ 6WDELOQRü MHVW NRQLHF]QD E\ QLH ]DSRPQLHü X*\WHF]Q\FK LQIRUPDFML VSU]HF]Q\FK ]

QRZRQDSá\ZDMF\PLSODVW\F]QRüNRQLHF]QDMHVWE\QDXF]\üVL QRZ\FKLQIRUPDFML0RGHOH

$57VWDUDMVL GREXGRZDüQRZZLHG] ZNRQWHNFLHMX*]QDQHMWZRU]FVWDQ\UH]RQDQVo-

ZH6WDELOQRüXF]HQLDLPSOLNXMHMHJRLQWHQFMRQDOQRüDOERZLHPMHVWRQRRSDUWHQDRF]HNi-

ZDQLDFKZREHFZLDWDGRVWDUF]DMFHJRV\VWHPRZLGDQ\FK2F]HNLZDQLDVUyZQLH*SRGVWDZ

PHFKDQL]PXXZDJLVNXSLDQLDVL V\VWHPXQDÄLQWHUHVXMF\FK´JRGDQ\FK3REXG]HQLHUH]o-

QDQVRZ\FKVWDQyZQDZHWMHOLQLHE G]LHQDW\OHVLOQHE\SRMDZLüVL ZSDPL FLURERF]HM

PR*HXWRURZDüGURJ GRSy(QLHMV]HJRZ\ERUXRF]HNLZDQ\FKRGSRZLHG]Lpriming). Procesy

UH]RQDQVRZH ]DFKRG] Z XNáDG]LH Z]URNRZ\P QD Uy*Q\FK SR]LRPDFK áF]QLH ] XNáDGHP

RULHQWDFMLJDáHNRF]Q\FKZXNáDG]LHVáXFKRZ\PSUDZGRSRGREQLHVUyZQLH*SRGVWDZSUo-
cesów czuciowych, procesów warunkowania klasycznego i interakcji kognitywno-

DIHNW\ZQ\FK0R*QDMHQD]ZDüÄGRSDVRZDQLHPSREXG]DMF\P´SRGF]DVJG\SURFHV\PRWo-

U\F]QHMDNLSURFHV\]ZL]DQH]XVWDODQLHPSRáR*HQLDZSU]HVWU]HQLZ]URNRZ\V]ODNJU]ELe-

WRZ\VNRPSOHPHQWDUQ\PLSURFHVDPLGRSDVRZDQLDKDPXMFHJR.RPSHWHQFMHPRWRU\F]QHL

PDS\ SU]HVWU]HQQH PRJ E\ü GRVNRQDORQH Z FLJá\ VSRVyE QLH PD WX QLHEH]SLHF]HVWZD

]QLV]F]HQLDVWDELOQRFL3RQLHZD*QLHPDWXVWDQyZUH]RQDQVRZ\FKSDPL üSURFHGXUDOQDQLH

SURZDG]LGRZUD*HZLDGRP\FK:SU]\SDGNXDPQH]MLQDVW SF]HMSDPL üSURFHGXUDOQDQLH

MHVW]DEXU]RQDQDE\ZDQHVQRZHXPLHM WQRFLDOHQLHPR*QDVRELHSU]\SRPQLHü]ZL]DQ\FK

]W\PZUD*H=DEXU]HQLDUR]SR]QDZDQLDRELHNWyZLQLH]GROQRüGRQDXF]HQLDVL UR]SR]Qa-

ZDQLDQRZ\FKRELHNWyZQLHR]QDF]DEUDNX]GROQRFLGRXF]HQLDVL QRZ\FKVSRVREyZPDQi-

SXODFMLW\PLRELHNWDPLDOHWHXPLHM WQRFLQLHV]ZL]aQH]ZLDGRP\PLZUD*HQLDPL

9

5 Modele dynamiczne i neurofizjologia

'ODF]HJR VWDQ\ Py]JX PLDá\E\ SURZDG]Lü GR SRZVWDQLD ZLDGRPRFL" 'RW\FKF]DV UR]Zi-

QL WHWHRULHFKRFLD*SRWUDILF] FLRZRRGSRZLHG]LHüQDS\WDQLDÄNWyUHVWDQ\ Py]JXPRJ

E\üZLDGRPH´QLHSUyEXMRGSRZLHG]LHüEH]SRUHGQLRQDWRS\WDQLH)LOR]RIRZLH]DMPXMF\

VL XP\VáHPZ\REUD*DMVRELH*HPRJLVWQLHü]RPELLVWRW\]DFKRZXMFHVL WDNMDNOXG]LH

DOHQLF]HJRZLDGRPLHQLHRGF]XZDMFH[2]3U]\WDF]DVL WXSU]\NáDGOHSRW\NRURZHMblind-
sight

ZNWyUHMV]F]WNRZHZLG]HQLHSR]RVWDMHSRPLPREUDNXZUD*HZ]URNRZ\FK'ODF]HJR

WRFDáHSU]HWZDU]DQLHLQIRUPDFMLSU]H]Py]JQLH]DFKRG]LZFLHPQRFLEH]ZUD*H"

5R]ZD*P\W\SRZH]DGDQLHSU]HGMDNLPVWRLVVDNQSV]F]XURG*\ZLDMF\VL Uy*QRURGQ\P

SRNDUPHP6PDNSR*\ZLHQLDQLHMHVWZLHONRFLG\VNUHWQQLHPR*QDJRRSLVDüV\PEROLFz-

QLHD]ELyUSREXG]HF]RSNyZVPDNRZ\FKQLHMHVWLQZDULDQWQZLHONRFLNWyUDPR*HVWDü

VL EH]SRUHGQLRZLDGRP\PZUD*HQLHP6]F]XUPXVLSRUyZQDüQRZ\VPDN]]DSDPL WDQy-

PLVPDNDPLE\RNUHOLüF]\MHVWWRSR*\ZLHQLHEH]SLHF]QH5HSUH]HQWDFMDZUD*HQLDVPDNX

PXVLZL F]RVWDüUR]HVáDQDGRZV]\VWNLFKREV]DUyZPy]JXNWyUH]DZLHUDüPRJLVWRWQHLn-

IRUPDFMH 0XVL ZL F E\ü XWU]\PDQD Z SDPL FL URERF]HM GRVWDWHF]QLH GáXJR E\ SREXG]Lü

ZLHOH REV]DUyZ Py]JX L E\ QDVWSLá\ SURFHV\ VNRMDU]HQLRZH LQWHUIHUHQFMD UHSUH]HQWDFML

0DP\ZL FGRF]\QLHQLD]FLJáQLHZHUEDOQDNWXDOL]DFMUHSUH]HQWDFMLZUD*HVPDNRZ\FK

Z SDPL FL URERF]HM SRZVWDZDQLHP VWDQyZ UH]RQDQVRZ\FK &LJáD DNWXDOL]DFMD NRQLHF]QD

MHVW ]H Z]JO GX QD V]\ENL ]DQLN LQIRUPDFML Z SDPL FL URERF]HM L MHM QLHZLHON SRMHPQRü

-HOLQLHSRMDZLVL *DGQHQHJDW\ZQHVNRMDU]HQLDV]F]XU]DF]QLHMHüZSU]HFLZQ\PSU]y-

SDGNXNROHMQ\PVWDQHPMHJRPy]JXE G]LHSREXG]HQLHRURGNyZVWUDFKXOXEZVWU WXLSRU]u-

FHQLHMHG]HQLD1DMZD*QLHMV]\PSURFHVHPMHVWZL FG\VNU\PLQDFMDUHSUH]HQWDFMLZUD*HVPa-

NRZ\FKRGNWyUHM]DOH*\]DFKRZDQLH-DNWRZ\JOGD]SXQNWXZLG]HQLDPy]JXV]F]XUD"

6]F]XUZLHMDNSRVWSLüDMHJRZLHG]DPDFKDUDNWHUZUD*HZ\QLNDMF\FK]G]LDáDQLDPHFKa-

QL]PyZSR]QDZF]\FK *G\E\MHJRPy]JSRVLDGDá]GROQRüZHUEDOQHJRNRPHQWRZDQLD VWa-

QyZSDPL FLURERF]HMWDNMDNSRVLDGDMPy]JOXG]NL]SHZQRFLVWZLHUG]LáE\*HRGF]XZD

VPDN ZLG]L SU]HGPLRW\ L PD ] W\P VNRMDU]RQH ZUD*HQLD JG\* UHSUH]HQWDFMH ZUD*H V Ii-

]\F]Q\PLVWDQDPLMHJRSDPL FLURERF]HM.D*G\PRGHOPy]JXG]LDáDMF\QDSRGREQHM]DVa-

G]LHMHOLE G]LHGRVWDWHF]QLH]áR*RQ\E\PyFNRPHQWRZDüSRMDZLHQLHVL WDNLFKUHSUH]HQWa-

FML ZUD*H PXVL WZLHUG]Lü *H MHVW ZLDGRP\ VZRLFK ZUD*H :áDVQRFL W\FK ZUD*H E G

PLDá\FHFK\SRGREQHGRRSLVDQ\FKSU]H]Taylora [18]. Modele mózgu autonomicznego zwie-

U] FLDPXV]]DZLHUDüMDNUHSUH]HQWDFM VLHELHRGJUDQLF]DMFÄMD´RGÄQLHMD´SRZDODMF

RGUy*QLüÄVLHELH´RGUHV]W\ZLDWD1DV]HSRF]XFLHWR*VDPRFL]ZL]DQHMHVWVLOQLH]proprio-

FHSFM D UR]ZyM Py]JX ]ZL]DQ\ E\á SU]HGH ZV]\VWNLP ] NRQLHF]QRFL SRZVWDQLD Ze-

ZQ WU]QHJRPRGHOXFLDáDZFHOXSU]HZLG\ZDQLDZ\QLNyZUXFKXNRF]\Q:V\VWHPLHSRMDZL

VL  ZL F SHUVSHNW\ZD ÄPRMH ZUD*HQLD´ Z\QLNDMFD ] XWU]\P\ZDQLD VL  VWDQyZ UH]RQDQVo-

Z\FKLPR*OLZRFLNRPHQWRZDQLDVWDQXSDPL FLURERF]HM

ZLDGRPRüZW\PXM FLXQLHMHVWZL FQLF]\PLQQ\PMDNSURFHVHPG\VNU\PLQDFMLFLJá\FK

UHSUH]HQWDFMLVWDQyZSDPL FLURERF]HMVWDQyZWZRU]F\FKÄSU]HVWU]HZHZQ WU]Q´GODVu-

ELHNW\ZQRFL :V]HONLH ]DEXU]HQLD ZLDGRPRFL PXV] E\ü ]ZL]DQH ] XSROHG]HQLDPL

IXQNFML NRJQLW\ZQ\FK L RGZURWQLH ]DEXU]HQLD WZRU]HQLD QDWXUDOQ\FK UHSUH]HQWDFML PXV]

SRJDUV]DüRGSRZLHGQLHNRPSHWHQFMHSR]QDZF]HOHSRWDNRURZDZ\QLNDMFD]XV]NRG]HQLD

NRU\ Z]URNRZHM SURZDG]L GR XSROHG]HQLD IXQNFML Z]URNRZ\FK SRPLPR GRVW SQRFL Ln-

10

formacji z nerwu wzrokowego w wielu strukturach mózgu. Informacja ta ma jednak odmien-

Q\ZNáDGGRG\QDPLNLPy]JXRGSRZLHG]LDOQHM]DSDPL üURERF]QL*]Z\NáHZUD*HQLDZ]Uo-

NRZH '\VNU\PLQDFMD QRZ\FK VWDQyZ QLH SURZDG]L GR ZUD*H QDWXU\ Z]URNRZHM FKRFLD*

]ZL]DQDMHVW]OLF]Q\PLWUXGQ\PLGRRNUHOHQLDZUD*HQLDPL±LQWHUSUHWDFMLW\FKZUD*HWU]e-

ED VL  SRZROL QDXF]\ü DOH SR]LRP NRPSHWHQFML Z]URNRZHM QLJG\ QLH E G]LH ]E\W Z\VRNL

JG\* GR SUHF\]\MQHM DQDOL]\ V\JQDáyZ ] QHUZX Z]URNRZHJR EUDNXMH Z\VSHFMDOL]RZDQ\FK

VWUXNWXU7DNLHUR]XPLHQLHSU]\F]\QSRMDZLDQLDVL ZUD*HZLDGRP\FKSURZDG]LGRZLHOX

ZQLRVNyZ L SU]HZLG\ZD HNVSHU\PHQWDOQ\FK GRW\F]F\FK IHQRPHQRORJLL ZUD*H 'XFK Z
przygotowaniu).

: MDNL VSRVyE PR*QD PRGHORZDü WDN VNRPSOLNRZDQH ]DJDGQLHQLD" -HGHQ ] SRP\VáyZ [8]

SROHJDQDSUyELH]GHILQLRZDQLDVHULLSU]\EOL*HRGSR]LRPXPROHNXODUQHJRSU]H]SRMHG\n-

F]HQHXURQ\JUXSQHXURQyZVLHFLQHXURQRZ\FK]UHNXUHQFMD*GRVNUDMQHJRXSURV]F]HQLD

RSLVX Z SRVWDFL SUREDELOLVW\F]Q\FK OXE GHWHUPLQLVW\F]Q\FK UHJXá ]DFKRZDQLD 1D ND*G\P

SR]LRPLHPR*OLZHMHVWEDGDQLHLQQ\FKIRUP]DFKRZDQLDLLQQ\FK]MDZLVN3U]HMFLDGRRSLVX

G]LDáDQLDXP\VáXQDSR]LRPLHSV\FKRORJLF]Q\PPR*QDGRNRQDüZSURZDG]DMFPRGHOSDPL -

FLURERF]HMRSDUW\RSRSXODUQHZSV\FKRORJLLSU]HVWU]HQLHSV\FKRORJLF]QH6WUXPLHZLDGo-

PRFLPR*QDZyZF]DVPRGHORZDüMDNR]GDU]HQLDZSU]HVWU]HQLDFKSV\FKRORJLF]Q\FK±FKo-

FLD*VRQHFLHQLHPQHXURG\QDPLNLWRWUDNWRZDüMHPR*QDMDNRQLH]DOH*Q\emergentny po-

]LRPVWDQRZLF\SRPRVWSRPL G]\neurofizjoORJLDSV\FKRORJL

6 Dyskusja

3U]HGVWDZLRQ\WXNUyWNLSU]HJOGSUREOHPyZLWHRULL]ZL]DQ\FK]HZLDGRPRFLSRND]XMH

*HMHVWHP\QDGREUHMGURG]HLSRWUDILP\]DGDZDüFRUD]EDUG]LHMSUHF\]\MQHS\WDQLDQDNWyUH

RGSRZLHG]LGDMHNVSHU\PHQW\LV\PXODFMHNRPSXWHURZH3RPLPRRJURPQHM]áR*RQRFLPó-

]JXV\PXODFMHNRPSXWHURZHPRJXFKZ\FLüQLHNWyUHPHFKDQL]P\SU]\F]\QRZHSR]ZDODMF

QLHW\ONRQDRGWZRU]HQLHIXQNFMLVWUXNWXUPy]JXOHF]UyZQLH*]UR]XPLHü]ZL]NLSRPL G]\
specyficznymi uszkodzeniami neuroanatomicznymi, zmianami neuropatologicznymi i wyni-

NDMF\PLVWGV\PSWRPDPL6]F]HJyáRZHPRGHOHRSDUWHQDneurofizjologicznie poprawnych,

LPSXOVXMF\FKQHXURQDFKZ\ND]XMMDNRFLRZH]DFKRZDQLDNWyUHPR*QDRGWZRU]\üZPo-
delach uproszczonych [10],[13]

0RGHOHNRPSXWHURZHPRJZLVWRWQ\VSRVyESU]\F]\QLüVL

GR]UR]XPLHQLD]DEXU]HSDPL FLVSRVREyZX*\ZDQLDLUR]XPLHQLDPRZ\]DEXU]HQHXUo-

ORJLF]Q\FKLFKRUyESV\FKLF]Q\FK&] VWRMHVWWRUR]XPLHQLHMDNRFLRZHPHWDIRU\F]QHSo-

VáXJXMFHVL OX(Q\PLDQDORJLDPLDOHLWRVWDQRZLVSRU\SRVW S

&]\PUy*QLVL PRGHONRPSXWHURZ\G]LDáDQLDPy]JXRGVZRMHJRELRORJLF]QHJRSLHUZRZ]o-

UX":UD*HQLDP\OLSHUFHSW\LLQQHRELHNW\XP\VáXVIL]\F]Q\PLVWDQDPLELRHOHNWU\F]Q\FK

SREXG]H LVWQLHMF\FK Z RNUHORQ\P PRPHQFLH F]DVX 3DPL ü URERF]D ]DZLHUD Z VRELH

ZNáDGRGSURFHVyZSHU\IHU\MQ\FKLQWHUIHUHQFM UH]RQDQV]SRGREQ\PLVWDQDPLSU]H*\Za-

Q\PLZSU]HV]áRFL3RVWU]HJDQLHOXESU]\SRPLQDQLHMHVWDNWXDOL]DFMSRWHQFMDOQLHGRVW SQ\FK

VWDQyZ Py]JX Z XORWQHM IRUPLH ELRHOHNWU\F]Q\FK SREXG]H : NRPSXWHU]H UHSUH]HQWDFMH

V\PEROLF]QH V DNWXDOL]RZDQH SU]H] SU]HV\áDQLH LFK GR UHMHVWUyZ SURFHVRUD MHGQDN*H V WR

UHSUH]HQWDFMHPDUWZHJG\*ELQDUQHVWDQ\UHMHVWUyZQLH]DZLHUDMZVRELH*DGQHJRERJDFWZD

DVRFMDFML'\QDPLF]Q\FKSURFHVyZWZRU]F\FKÄXEUDQH´UHSUH]HQWDFMHSRZVWDMFHZSDPL FL

URERF]HMQLHGDVL V\PXORZDü]DSRPRFF\IURZHJRNRPSXWHUD:UD*HQLDZLDGRPHVU]e-

F]\ZLVWHJG\*VUHDOQ\PLVWDQDPLIL]\F]Q\PLDQLHW\ONRVWDQDPLSU]HWZDU]DQLDLnformacji.

11

6\PXODFMH XP\VáX PHWRGDPL V]WXF]QHM LQWHOLJHQFML QLH GRSURZDG] ZL F GR ZLDGRP\FK

NRPSXWHUyZDOHQLHR]QDF]DWR*HLVWQLHMMDNLHRJUDQLF]HQLD]ZL]DQH]HVSUDZQRFLDu-

WRPDW\]DFMLSURFHVyZP\OHQLD:EUHZSRZV]HFKQHPXPQLHPDQLXQLHPDGRZRGyZQDWR

*H ZLDGRPRü MHVW DNW\ZQLH ]DDQJD*RZDQD Z UR]ZL]\ZDQLH SUREOHPyZ [21]. Przegrana
Kasparowa z systemem komputerowym Deep Blue

ZURNXSRND]XMH*HPDV]\QDNWyUHM

V]\ENRüSU]HWZDU]DQLDLQIRUPDFMLMDNLSRMHPQRüSDPL FLQLHSU]HNUDF]DSURPLODPR*OLZo-

FLOXG]NLHJRPy]JXPR*HZGREU]HRNUHORQHMG]LHG]LQLHZ\PDJDMFHMVSUDZQRFLLQWHOHk-

WXDOQHMRVLJQüOHSV]HUH]XOWDW\RGF]áRZLHND'RURNX,%0]DPLHU]D]EXGRZDüNRm-
puter Blue Gene

RPR*OLZRFLDFKSRUyZQ\ZDOQ\FK]OXG]NLPPy]JLHP.RPSHWHQFMHV\VWe-

PyZHNVSHUWRZ\FKUHDOL]RZDQ\FKQDWDNLFKNRPSXWHUDFKPRJ]QDF]QLHSU]HNURF]\üOXG]NLH

PR*OLZRFL=WHFKQLF]QHJRSXQNWXZLG]HQLDQLHPDZL FSRWU]HE\EXGRZ\ZLDGRP\FKPa-

V]\Q.RQVWUXNFMDWDNLFKPDV]\QPXVLDáDE\]DZLHUDüMDNRNOXF]RZ\HOHPHQWDQDORJRZSa-

PL ü URERF] ]GROQ GR SU]HFKRZ\ZDQLD UHSUH]HQWDFML LQWHUIHUXMF\FK ] UHSUH]HQWDFMDPL

SU]HFKRZ\ZDQ\PLZSDPL FLGáXJoWUZDáHM

Literatura

[1]

Baddeley A.D, Consciousness and working memory. Consciousness and Cognition 1
(1992) 3-6

[2]

Baars B.J (1996) In the theater of consciousness: the workspace of the mind. (Oxford
University Press, London)

[3]

Churchland P.S, Neurophilosophy. Toward a unified science of the mind/brain. MIT
Press, Bradford Book, 1986 (7-me wydanie 1993)

[4]

Crick F, Koch C, Towards a neurobiological theory of consciousness. Seminars in the
Neurosciences 2 (1990) 263-275

[5]

Crick F, The Astonishing hypothesis. The scientific search for the soul. Charles Scrib-
ner's sons, New York, 1994 (

WáXPDF]HQLH=GXPLHZDMFDKLSRWH]D, 3UyV]\VNLLS-ka,

Warszawa 1997)

[6]

Damasio A. R. (1990). Synchronous activation in multiple cortical regions: A mecha-
nism for recall. Seminars in Neurosciences 2, 287–296.

[7]

Dennett, D.C. (1991) Consciousness explained. Boston: Little, Brown.

[8]

Duch W. (1997): Platonic model of mind as an approximation to neurodynamics. W:
Brain-like computing and intelligent information systems, red. S-i. Amari, N. Kasabov
(Springer, Singapore), rozdz. 20, str. 491-512

[9]

Duch W, Consciouss mind as a limit of brain-like computing. Minds and Machines (wy-

VáDQH

[10]

Duch W (2000)

6LHFL QHXURQRZH Z PRGHORZDQLX ]DEXU]H neuropsychologicznych i

chorób psychicznych. W: Biocybernetyka 2000, Tom 6: Sieci neuronowe (red. W.
Duch, J. Korbicz, L. Rutkowski i R. Tadeusiewicz), rozdz. II.18

[11]

Grossberg S. (1999) The Link between Brain Learning, Attention, and Consciousness.
Consciousness and Cognition 8, 1–44

[12]

Newman J, Grace A.A. (1999) Binding across Time: The Selective Gating of Frontal
and Hippocampal Systems Modulating Working Memory and Attentional States. Con-
sciousness and Cognition 8, 196-212

12

[13]

Parks R.W, Levine D.S, Long D, red. (1998): Fundamentals of Neural Network Mod-
eling. (MIT Press, Cambridge, MA)

[14]

Penrose R.

1RZ\XP\VáFHVDU]D. (Oxford University Press 1994)

[15]

Searle J.R.,

8P\VáQDQRZRRGNU\W\. PIW, Warszawa 1999.

[16]

Singer, W. (1994) The organization of sensory motor representations in the neocortex:
A hypothesis based on temporal coding. W: Umilta C, Moscovitch M. (eds.), Attention
and performance XV: Conscious and nonconscious information processing, str. 77–107.
Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

[17]

Taylor J.G. (1998) Cortical Activity and the Explanatory Gap. Consciousness and Cog-
nition 7, 109-148

[18]

Taylor J.G. (1999) The race for consciousness. MIT Press, Cambridge, MA

[19]

Tononi G, Edelman G. (1998) Consciousness and complexity. Science 282, 1846-1851

[20]

Treisman, A. (1996) The binding problem. Current Opinion in Neurobiology 6, 171–
178

[21]

Wróbel A. (1997)

:SRV]XNLZDQLXLQWHJUDF\MQ\FKPHFKDQL]PyZG]LDáDQLDPy]JX W:

Mózgi i zachowanie, PWN Warszawa (red. T. Górska, A. Grabowska, J. Zagordzka)

[22]

Velmans M. (1991) Is human information processing conscious?, Brain and Behavioral
Science 14, 651-726.

[23]

Zeki S., Bartels A. (1999) Toward a Theory of Visual Consciousness. Consciousness
and Cognition 8, 225-259