6FHQDULXV]]DM ü*RG]LQD]Z\FKRZDZFGODNODV\9
6]NRá\3RGVWDZRZHM
7HPDWÄ1LHQLH]UREL WHJR´±MDNE\üDVHUW\ZQ\P"
&HOJáyZQ\5R]SR]QDZDQLH]DFKRZDDVHUW\ZQ\FK
&HOHRSHUDF\MQHXF]H
]QDSRM FLHÄDVHUW\ZQRü´
]QDURG]DMH]DFKRZDDVHUW\ZQHDJUHV\ZQHXOHJáH
UR]XPLHSRWU]HE DVHUW\ZQHJR]DFKRZDQLDVL
SRWUDIL]DSDQRZDüQDGHPRFMDPL
SRWUDILXV]DQRZDüJRGQRüGUXJLHJRF]áRZLHND
0HWRG\IRUP\SV\FKRGUDPDEXU]DPy]JyZüZLF]HQLRZDLQG\ZLGXDOQDJUXSRZD
URGNLG\GDNW\F]QHNUyWNLHVFHQNLNU]\*yZND]HVWDZ\]DFKRZD
SW3RVWDZDDVHUW\ZQDELHUQDLDJUHV\ZQD´üZLF]HQLD
XáDWZLDMFHSU]HND]\ZDQLHZ\SRZLHG]L]SR]\FMLÄ-D´
SV\FKR]DEDZDSW=DFKRZDQLD´
7RN]DM ü
1DXF]\FLHOSRGDMHWHPDW]DM ü
8F]QLRZLHVLHG]FZNU JXZ\NRQXMüZLF]HQLHGRSRZLDGDMQLHGRNRF]RQH]GDQLH
-DNRF]áRZLHNPDPSUDZR
2GSRZLHG]LXF]QLyZ
-DNRF]áRZLHNPDPSUDZRE\üWUDNWRZDQ\]V]DFXQNLHPLJRGQR FL
SURWHVWRZDüSU]HFLZNRQLHVSUDZLHGOLZHMNU\W\FH
SU]HFLZVWDZLDüVL QLHXF]FLZHPXWUDNWRZDQLX
Z\UD*DüZáDVQHVG\LRSLQLH
VáXFKDüJáRVXZáDVQHJRVXPLHQLDQLHFXG]\FKUDG
SURVLüRSRPRFRVRE\SRVLDGDMFHZL NV]H
XPLHM WQRFLLGRZLDGF]HQLD
F]DVHPRGSRZLDGDüÄQLH´MHOLNWRQDPDZLD
GR]áHJR
SRSHáQLDüEá G\
RGF]XZDüLZ\UD*DüUDGRüVPXWHN*DO
1DVW SQLHQDXF]\FLHOZLHV]DQDWDEOLF\NU]\*yZN NWyUXF]QLRZLHZVSyOQLH
UR]ZL]XM
:]yUGRVNRQDáRFL3RF]XFLHZLDGRPRüZáDVQHMZDUWRFL
&]DVHPQLHMDVQD0DPDWDWDLMD
0\OLW\ONRRVRELHVDPROXE:LHG]DQDE\WDSRSU]H]QDXN
1LJG\QLH]DZLHG]LHLGRZLDGF]HQLH
3U]\MDFLHOZSRGUy*\,QDF]HM]DGRZROHQLH
.á ELVL ZJáRZLH
1DMZD*QLHMV]DLVWRWDQD]LHPLWR
,
'
(
$
à
6
<
7
8
$
&
-
$
(
*
2
,
6
7
$
3
5
=
<
-
$
&
,
(
/
7
2
:
$
5
=
<
6
=
0
<
/
,
&
=
à
2
:
,
(
.
*
2
'
1
2
û
5
2
'
=
,
1
$
0
'
5
2
û
5
$
'
2
û
3RUR]ZL]DQLXNU]\*yZNLQDXF]\FLHOZ\MDQLDSRM FLHDVHUW\ZQRFLL]DFKRZD
DVHUW\ZQ\FK
$VHUW\ZQRüWRVSHF\ILF]QHXPLHM WQRFL]DFKRZDQLDVL ZUy*Q\FK
V\WXDFMDFK
=DFKRZDQLHDVHUW\ZQHWREH]SRUHGQLHVWDQRZF]HZ\UD*HQLHZREHFGUXJLHM
RVRE\ZáDVQ\FKXF]XüZáDVQHJR]GDQLDLRSLQLLSU]\MHGQRF]HVQ\PSRV]DQRZDQLX
MHMSUDZ
=DFKRZXMFVL DVHUW\ZQLHUHVSHNWXMHP\SUDZDVZRMHLLQQ\FK
3U]\]QDMHP\VRELHVDPLSUDZDNWyUHQDPSU]HFLH*SU]\VáXJXMMDNRF]áRZLHNRZL
QSV]DFXQHNSUDZRGRZáDVQHJR]GDQLDRSLQLLQDGDQ\WHPDWLWG
3UDZDPyZLRW\P*HZND*GHMV\WXDFMLF]áRZLHNPDE\üWDNWUDNWRZDQ\
DE\QLHQDUXV]DQRMHJRJRGQRFL
8F]QLRZLHG]LHOVL QDWU]\]HVSRá\.D*G\]HVSyáRWU]\PDQDNDUWFHVFHQN
NWyURGHJUDSV\FKRGUDPD3R]DNRF]HQLXüZLF]HQLDXF]QLRZLHZ\SRZLHG]VL
(ODMHVWRV]F] GQDPD]DZV]HSU]\VRELHNLHV]RQNRZHNWyUHGRVWDMHRGURG]LFyZ
=DZV]HSR*\F]DSLHQLG]HRGQLHMNROH*DQNDWZLHUG]F*HRGGDQDGUXJLG]LH
1LJG\MHGQDNQLHRGGDMHQDZHWRW\PQLHZVSRPLQDJG\*ZLH*H(ODMHVWQLHPLDáD
LQLHXSRPQLVL RSLHQLG]HFKRüQD]ELHUDáRVL LFKMX*GX*R-DNZLGDüNROH*DQND
SR*\F]DáDRG(OLSLHQLG]HNLONDNURWQLHDOHQLJG\QLHRGGDZDáD
7HUD]]QRZXSU]\V]áDLSURVL(O RQRZSR*\F]N
3RFR]QRZXSU]\V]áDSRSLHQLG]H"S\WD]GHQHUZRZDQD(OD
7\NáDPF]XFKRRGGDMQDMSLHUZWHNWyUHSR *\F]\áDZF]HQLHM±
PyZLSRGQLHVLRQ\PJáRVHP(OD
-HVWH]áDQLHGREUDHJRLVW\F]QDQLHXF]FLZD ±NU]\F]\
]GHQHUZRZDQD(OD.ROH*DQNDSUyEXMHVL Z\WáXPDF]\ü
DOH(ODZFDOHMHMQLHEVáXFKD
-RODRELHFDáDSR*\F]\üLSU]\QLHüGRV]NRá\NROH*DQFHFLHNDZNVL*N DOH
]DSRPQLDáDMHM]DEUDü]GRPX.ROH*DQNDEDUG]RVL QDQLREUD]LáD
.LHG\-RODVSRWNDáDNROH*DQN ]DF] áDMSU]HSUDV]DüLWáXPDF]\üVL PyZLF
RVRELHMHVWHPQLH]GDUDQLHXGDF]QLFDEH]QDG]LHMQD-HOLW\ONR]HFKFHV]WR
SROHNFMDFKZVLG ZWUDPZDMLSU]\ZLR] &LW NVL*N
.ODVDMXWURZ\ELHUDVL QDZDJDU\:V]\VF\V]DFKZ\FHQLW\PSRP\VáHPRSUyF]
.DVL
-DPDPLQQH]GDQLHQDWHQWHPDW±PyZL.DVLDJáRQR
LRGZD*QLH
8ZD*DP*HQDV]DNODVDSRJRUV]\VRELHMX*LWDN]áV\WXDFM
XQDXF]\FLHOL-DP\O *HQDV]DZ\FKRZDZF]\QLE G]LHVL
RQDVPDUWZLüSU]HFLH*PR*HQDPVL FRSU]\GDU]\ü
-DNP\OLFLH"
-DXZD*DP*HQDOH*\SRUR]PDZLDü]Z\FKRZDZF]\QL
L]DSURVLüMQDZVSyOQHZ\MFLHNODVRZH
-HOLZ\SyMG]LHQDZDJDU\WREH]HPQLHMD]GDQLDQLH]PLHQL
3R]DNRF]HQLXüZLF]HXF]QLRZLHSRGDOLZQLRVHN
:SLHUZV]HMVFHQFH(ODQLHSR]ZROLáDGRMüGRJáRVXNROH*DQFHREUD]LáDM
NU]\F]DáDQLHSRWUDILáDVSRNRMQLHRGPyZLüSRZLHG]LHüÄQLH´]DFKRZDáDVL ZU F]
DJUHV\ZQLH
:GUXJLHMVFHQFH-RODSU]HVDGQLHSU]HSUDV]DáDNROH*DQN ZU F]XSRNDU]DáDVL
E\áDEDUG]RXOHJáD
6FHQNDWU]HFLDSU]HGVWDZLD.DVL RGZD*QSUDZGRPyZQLRWZDUW']LHZF]\QD
QLHREUD]LáDQLNRJRPLPRL*VWDQRZF]RZ\UD]LáDVZRMH]GDQLH
8F]QLRZLHVáXV]QLH]DXZD*\OL*HND*GH]W\FK]DFKRZDXF]QLyZE\áRLQQH
1DXF]\FLHONDSRGDMH*HPR*QDZ\Uy*QLüWU]\URG]DMH]DFKRZDWM
$JUHV\ZQH$VHUW\ZQH8OHJáH
=DFKRZDQLDDJUHV\ZQHGRFKRG]LGRRWZDUWHJRNRQIOLNWXQDVLSDUWQHU]\
F]XMVL ]DJUR*HQLNRQWUROXMHP\FXG]H]DFKRZDQLDZ\W\NDMFLPEá G\
DVLHELHVWDZLDP\QDSRGLXPSU]HVWDMHP\E\üOXELDQLSU]H]LQQ\FK
=DFKRZDQLDDVHUW\ZQHVSU]\MDMGREU\PNRQWDNWRPVSRáHF]Q\P
-HVWHP\RWZDUFLLEH]SRUHGQLZZ\UD*DQLXXF]XüWRWH*F]DVHPWUDFLP\
V\PSDWL QLHNWyU\FKNROHJyZ7DNDSRVWDZDQLHREUD*DQLNRJRSR]ZDOD
QDPSRZLHG]LHüÄQLH´ZUy*Q\FKV\WXDFMDFK8F]HNWyU\SRWUDILVWDQRZF]R
LVSRNRMQLHRGPyZLüMHVWZPLDU EH]SLHF]Q\QLHZSDGDQLHV]\ENRZ]áH
URGRZLVNRE G]LHPLDáZáDVQH]GDQLHNWyUHSRWUDILREURQLü
=DFKRZDQLDXOHJáHELHUQHURELP\FRZEUHZZáDVQHPX]GDQLX
XOHJDMFLQQ\PWUDFLP\SRF]XFLHZáDVQHMZDUWRFLEORNXMHP\VLOQHHPRFMH
NWyUHSURZDG]GRQHUZLFFKRUyESV\FKRVRPDW\F]Q\FK
8F]QLRZLHSRG]LHOHQLQDWU]\JUXS\RWU]\PXM]HVWDZ\SU]\NáDGyZUy*Q\FK
]DFKRZDSW3RVWDZDDVHUW\ZQDELHUQDLDJUHV\ZQD´UR]SR]QDMMHLXG]LHODM
RGSRZLHG]L
3RVWDZDDVHUW\ZQDXOHJáDELHUQDLDJUHV\ZQD´
8PLHPVSRQWDQLF]QLHFLHV]\üVL ]NRPSOHPHQWyZLREGDU]DüQLPLLQQ\FK
%RM VL NRPSOHPHQWyZLQLHSRWUDIL QLPLREGDU]DüLQQ\FK
&LHV] VL ]NRPSOHPHQWyZFKRüU]DGNRQLPLMHVWHPREGDU]DQDQLHGEDP
RNRPSOHPHQWRZDQLHLQQ\FK
&]DVHP]JDG]DPVL ]NU\W\NQDWHPDWPRMHJRSRVW SRZDQLDF]DVHPQLH
1LJG\QLH]JDG]DPVL ]NU\W\NQDWHPDWPRMHJRSRVW SRZDQLD
=DZV]H]JDG]DPVL QD]NU\W\NFRGRPRMHJRSRVW SRZDQLD
5REL VL ]á\LDWDNXM NLHG\NWRPDLQQH]GDQLHQDGDQ\WHPDWQL*MD
1LHG\VNXWXM MHOLNWRPDLQQH]GDQLHQDGDQ\WHPDWQL*MD
3URZDG] G\VNXVM MHOLNWRPDLQQH]GDQLHQDWHQVDPWHPDW
3RVWDZDDVHUW\ZQDXOHJáDELHUQDLDJUHV\ZQD´
=DZV]HV]DQXM SU]HGHZV]\VWNLPVLHELH
6]DQXM LQQ\FKWDNVDPRMDNVLHELH
:RJyOHQLHV]DQXM VL ERQLHPDPSRZRGX
1LHREUD*DPOXG]LERQLJG\QLHPyZL ZSURVWFRPLVL ZQLFKQLHSRGRED
1LHREUD*DPOXG]LDOH]DZV]HPyZL LPZSURVWMDNVL F]XM ]W\PFRPLVL
XQLFKQLHSRGRED
2EUD*DPOXG]LL]DZV]HPyZL ZSURVWFRPLVL XQLFKQLHSRGRED
%RM VL *HNROH*DQNLSU]HVWDQPQLHOXELüMHOLE G PLDáDLQQH]GDQLH
QLH]JRG] VL ]QLPL
1LHREDZLDPVL *HPQLHNROH*DQNLQLHE GOXELüMHOLE G PLDáDRGPLHQQH
]GDQLHQLH]JRG] VL ]QLPL
1LFPQLHQLHREFKRG]LF]\NROH*DQNLSU]HVWDQPQLHOXELüMHOLE G PLDáD
RGPLHQQH]GDQLH
3RVWDZDDVHUW\ZQDXOHJáDELHUQDLDJUHV\ZQD´
-HVWHPSHZQDVZRMHMZDUWRFLLQLHREDZLDPVL RND]\ZDüWHJR
-HVWHPQLHSHZQDVLHELHVZRLFKPR*OLZRFLWRWH*F] VWRXOHJDPLQQ\P
-HVWHPGXPQDZ\QLRVáDLOXEL U]G]LüDE\PQLHLQQLVáXFKDOL
=DZV]HX*\ZDPNU]\NXMDNRVSRVREX]PXV]DQLDPRLFKNROHJyZGRZ\NRQDQLD
WDNLHJR]DGDQLDMDNLHPQLHRGSRZLDGD
:\NRQXM WDNLH]DGDQLDMDNLHFKFPRLNROHG]\FKRFLD*QLH]DZV]HPDPQD
WRRFKRW
:\UD*DPVZRMH]GDQLHLRSLQL QDWHPDW]DGDNWyUHZ\NRQXM ]NROHJDPL
.LHG\FRZ\NRQXM GREU]HJáRQRLRWZDUFLHVL ]WHJRFLHV]
3RND]XM LQQ\P*HVáDELHMZ\NRQDOLW SUDF LVJRUVLRGHPQLH
:LHP*HGREU]HZ\NRQDáDPWR]DGDQLHDOHVWDUDPVL REQL*DüZáDVQH]DVáXJL
WZLHUG]F*HWRSU]\SDGHNW\ONRXGDáRVL
:QDVW SQ\PüZLF]HQLXXF]QLRZLHE GXF]\üVL SU]HND]\ZDQLDZ\SRZLHG]L
W\SXÄ-D´VáX*FHDVHUW\ZQ\P]DFKRZDQLRP2WU]\PDMQDNDUWNDFKSU]\NáDG\
Uy*Q\FKV\WXDFMLLE GXNáDGDüRGSRZLHG(]SR]\FMLÄ-D´
6<78$&-$
:<32:,(''Ä-$´
3U]\MDFLyáND]NWyUF] VWRZVSyáSUDFXMHV]
MHVWZZ\MWNRZR]á\PKXPRU]HPLOF]\
LZ\UD(QLHFL XQLND
:\SRZLHG]LXF]QLyZ
-HVWPLVPXWQR*HQLHSUDFXMHV]G]LVLDM]H
PQLQLHUR]PDZLDP\WDNPLáRMDN
]DZV]H
.ROH*DQND$QLRELHFDáD*HSU]\MG]LHMHM
SRPyFZOHNFMDFKL]DZLRGáD$QLDQLH
ZLHFRRW\PP\OHü
$QLDUR]PDZLD]NROH*DQNPyZLF
0\ODáDP*HSU]\MG]LHV]GRPQLH
0DUWZLáDPVL R&LHELHP\ODáDP*HFR
VL VWDáR
.ROHJDFKFHSR*\F]\üSLHQLG]H
DMHV]F]HQLHRGGDá&LW\FKNWyUHSR*\F]\á
ZF]HQLHM
-DQLHSR*\F] &LSLHQL G]\SRQLHZD*QLH
RGGDáHPLSRSU]HGQLFK
7áXPDF]\V]NROH*DQFHEDUG]RZD*QH
]DGDQLH=ERNXVWRLNROHJDNWyU\FLJOH
&LSU]HU\ZDJG\PyZLV]
-DSU]HSUDV]DPDOHFKFLDáDE\PVNRF]\ü
VZRMZ\SRZLHG(QDWHPDWUR]ZL]DQLD
EDUG]RZD*QHJR]DGDQLD
%DVLD]DSODQRZDáD*HVS G]LQLHG]LHO
ZGRPX]PDP']ZRQLNROH*DQND
NWyUD]DSUDV]DMQDQLHG]LHO GRVLHELH
%DVLDRGSRZLDGD-DWH*PDPRFKRW
]7REVL VSRWNDüDOHQLHG]LHO
]DSODQRZDáDPVS G]LüZGRPX
&K WQLHVL VSRWNDP]7REZSU]\V]á\P
W\JRGQLXFR7\QDWR"
.ROH*DQNDRVNDU*DPQLH*HQLHU]XFDáDP
FHOQLHGRNRV]DLGODWHJRQDV]DGUX*\QD
SU]HJUDáD
-DP\O *HJUDáDPG]LVLDMQDMOHSLHMMDN
W\ONRSRWUDILáDP
1DXF]\FLHOSRGVXPRZXMH]DM FLDRDVHUW\ZQRFL
.D*G\]XF]QLyZZGRPXZ\NRQDüZLF]HQLHSV\FKR]DEDZ SW=DFKRZDQLD´
3V\FKR]DEDZDSW=DFKRZDQLD´
'RNRQDMDQDOL]\VZRLFK]DFKRZD ZSLVXMFRGSRZLHG(WDNQLH
7RüZLF]HQLHZ\NRQXMHV]GODVLHELH
&] VWRXOHJDPLQQ\P
%\ZDPEDUG]RDJUHV\ZQ\
1LHXPLHPXSRPLQDüVL RVZRMH
1LHSRWUDIL SURVLüRSRPRF
&] VWRSURV] SU]\MDFLyáURG]LQ RSRPRF
1LHXPLHPFKZDOLüLQQ\FK
-HOLNWRPQLHFKZDOLF]XMHVL RQLHPLHORQ\QLHZLHP
FRPDPSRZLHG]LHü
1LHZLHPMDN]DFKRZDüVL NLHG\NWRPQLHNU\W\NXMH
1LHXPLHPEURQLüVZRMHJR]GDQLD
.U]\NLHPLJUR(EZ\PXV]DPVSHáQLHQLHPRLFKSUy E
1LHOXEL OXG]LNWyU]\PDMLQQH]GDQLHQL*MD
2GF]XZDPO NLWUHP NLHG\PXV] Z\VWSLüSXEOLF]QLH
1LHSRWUDIL E\üFDáNLHPV]F]HU\
-HOLNWRPQLHQLHVáXV]QLHSRV G]DRFRQLHSURWHVWXM
0DPMDVQRZ\W\F]RQHFHOH *\FLRZH
3RWUDIL SU]\]QDüVL GREá GXLSU]HSURVLü
:NODVLHPRLNROHG]\LNROH *DQNLOXELPQLHWDNLPMDNLP
MHVWHP
=GDM VRELHVSUDZ *HMHVWHPNLPZDUWRFLRZ\P
&]XMH*HZQDV]HMV]NROHPRJ ZSHáQLE\üVRE
&]DVWUZDQLD]DM üJRG]LQ\
=DM FLDRSUDFRZDáD-DGZLJD6]HZF]\N
6]NRáD3RGVWDZRZDà\VLQ\
=DáF]QLNGR]DM ü*RG]LQD]Z\FKRZDZFGODNODV\9
$WPRVIHUDZQDV]HMNODVLH
3U]HF]\WDMSRGDQHQL*HM]GDQLDRSLVXMFHUy*QH]DFKRZDQLDXF]QLyZZNODVLH
1DVW SQLH]DVWDQyZVL NWyUH]QLFKFKDUDNWHU\]XM7ZRMNODV
3RVáXJXMFVL SRGDQ\PLRNUHOHQLDPL]D]QDF]]QDNLHPÄ´SOXVZRGSRZLHGQLFK
UXEU\NDFK7ZRMRFHQ FKDUDNWHU\VW\F]Q\FKFHFKQDV]HMNODV\
/S
=DFKRZDQLDXF]QLyZ
1DRJyá
]JDG]DP
VL
&] FLR
ZR
]JDG]DP
VL
5DF]HM
QLH
]JDG]DP
VL
=XSHáQLH
QLH
]JDG]DP
VL
1DV]DNODVDMHVW]JUDQ\P
]HVSRáHP
:QDV]HMNODVLHZV]\VF\
VNROH*HVF\
:QDV]HMNODVLHSDQXMH
VROLGDUQRüZVSUDZDFK
V]NROQ\FK
:QDV]HMNODVLHXF]QLRZLH
G]LHOVL QDJUXSNL
:QDV]HMNODVLHSDQXMH]D]GURü
]SRZRGXZ\QLNyZZQDXFH
:QDV]HMNODVLHND*G\P\OL
SU]HGHZV]\VWNLPRVRELH
:QDV]HMNODVLHFK WQLH
SRPDJDP\VRELHZ]DMHPQLH
:QDV]HMNODVLHXPLHP\
GRFKRG]LüGRSRUR]XPLHQLD
:QDV]HMNODVLHVRVRE\NWyUH
QDU]XFDMLQQ\PZáDVQH]GDQLH
:QDV]HMNODVLHF] VWRGRFKRG]L
GRNáyWQLLQLHSRUR]XPLH
8F]QLRZLHQDV]HMNODV\FK WQL
VGRQDE\ZDQLDXPLHM WQRFL
*
\FLDZJUXSLH
:QDV]HMNODVLH6DPRU]G
NODVRZ\NLHUXMH]HVSRáHP
XF]QLyZZNODVLHLUR]ZL]XMH
NRQIOLNW\
1DV]DNODVDNLHUXMHVL ZVZ\P
SRVW SRZDQLXQRUPDPLNWyUH
ZVSyOQLH]Z\FKRZDZF
XVWDQRZLáD
0DWHULDáGRDQNLHW\Z\NRU]\VWDQR]Ä3RUDGQLNGODZ\FKRZDZF\NODV\´F] ü,,,
0DULD%R*HQD.VL *\N:20&] VWRFKRZDU