$UNXV]HHJ]DPLQDF\MQH,,,
32=,2032'67$:2:<
:5=(6,(
- =<.32/6.,
2 . 5 * 2 : $
. 2 0 , 6 - $
(*=$0,1$&<-1$
Z . 5 $ . 2 : , (
3UyEQ\HJ]DPLQPDWXUDOQ\]M ]\NDSROVNLHJR
0RGHORGSRZLHG]LLVFKHPDWRFHQLDQLDDUNXV]\HJ]DPLQDF\MQ\FK
=$6$'<35=<=1$:$1,$381.7Ï:
$5.86=,
=GDM F\PR HX]\VNDüPDNV\PDOQLHSXQNWyZNWyUHSU]\]QDMHP\ZHGáXJQDVW SXM F\FK
]DVDG
5R]ZLQL FLHWHPDWX
2FHQLDQLHUR]ZLQL FLDWHPDWXUR]SRF]\QDP\RGXZD QHMOHNWXU\NU\WHULyZ
5R]ZLQL FLH WHPDWX RFHQLDP\ OHG] F UHDOL]DFM SRV]F]HJyOQ\FK NU\WHULyZ 1D OHZ\P
PDUJLQHVLHSUDF\]DSLVXMHP\VSHáQLRQHNU\WHULXPSRVáXJXM FVL MHJRQXPHUHPQSD
ELWSZSU]\SDGNXWHPDWXRUD]$D$H>SU]H]$UR]XPLHP\DQDOL] IUDJPHQWX@
==D>SU]H]=UR]XPLHP\]ZL ]HN]LGH XWZRUX@ZSU]\SDGNXWHPDWX
$E\ X]\VNDü PDNV\PDOQ OLF]E SXQNWyZ ]GDM F\ PXVL VSHáQLü VSR UyG
Z\PLHQLRQ\FK NU\WHULyZ QLH PXVL ]UHDOL]RZDü ND GHJR NU\WHULXP QLH PR H X]\VNDü
ZL FHMQL SXQNWyZQDZHWJG\]D]QDF]\P\VSHáQLHQLHZL FHMQL NU\WHULyZ
=D ND GH VSHáQLRQH NU\WHULXP SU]\]QDMHP\ SXQNW\ RERZL ]XMH VNDOD QLH ZROQR
SU]\]QDüF] VWNRZHJRSXQNWX
1DOH \SDPL WDü HPRGHOQLHQDU]XFDSRU] GNXZ\SRZLHG]L]GDM FHJR
2F]HNXMHP\Z\SRZLHG]H RWUH FLV\QRQLPLF]QHMQLHLGHQW\F]QHMGRSRGDQHMZPRGHOX
=GDM F\QLHPXVLF\WRZDüPLPR HZPRGHOX]QDMGXM VL F\WDW\
.RPSR]\FMDLVW\O
2FHQLDP\QDSRGVWDZLHNU\WHULyZQDOXEOXESXQNW1LH PR HP\SU]\]QDüLQQHM
OLF]E\SXQNWyZQL ZVND]DQH
%á G\VW\OLVW\F]QHSRSHáQLRQHSU]H]]GDM FHJR]D]QDF]DP\QDSUDZ\PPDUJLQHVLHSUDF\
%á GyZQLHOLF]\P\
- ]\N
2FHQLDP\QDSRGVWDZLHNU\WHULyZQDOXEOXEOXEOXESXQNW\1LHPR HP\
SU]\]QDüLQQHMOLF]E\SXQNWyZQL ZVND]DQH
%á G\M ]\NRZHSRSHáQLRQHSU]H]]GDM FHJR]D]QDF]DP\QDSUDZ\PPDUJLQHVLHSUDF\
%á GyZQLHOLF]\P\
6]F]HJyOQHZDORU\SUDF\
3XQNW\]DV]F]HJyOQHZDORU\SU]\]QDMHP\ZWHG\JG\ZSUDF\RGQDMGXMHP\VWZLHUG]HQLD
LZQLRVNL]JRGQH]LGH WHPDWXDQLH]DZDUWHZPRGHOXRFHQLDQLDOXEJG\]DGDQLHSRVLDGD
V]F]HJyOQHZDORU\VW\OLVW\F]QHLNRPSR]\F\MQHQSHVHLVW\F]QH
3XQNW\]DV]F]HJyOQHZDORU\SU]\]QDMHP\ZWHG\JG\>SRWUDILP\MHXPRW\ZRZDü
3U]\]QDMHP\SRSXQNW\]DZDORUQLHZROQRSU]\]QDZDüDQLSXQNWyZ
*G\QLHRGQDMGXMHP\Z]GDQLXV]F]HJyOQ\FKZDORUyZ]GDM F\QLHX]\VNXMHSXQNWyZ
=DUyZQR ]D UR]ZLQL FLH WHPDWX MDN L ]D NRPSR]\FM VW\O L M ]\N ]GDM F\ PR H RWU]\PDü
SXQNWyZ
3UyEQ\HJ]DPLQPDWXUDOQ\]M ]\NDSROVNLHJR
0RGHORGSRZLHG]LLVFKHPDWRFHQLDQLDDUNXV]\HJ]DPLQDF\MQ\FK
7HPDW
=DSUH]HQWXMUHQHVDQVRZ NRQFHSFM %RJDL ZLDWDRGZRáXM FVL GR]QDQ\FK
&LSLH QL-DQD.RFKDQRZVNLHJRLGRNRQXM FLQWHUSUHWDFML+\PQX&]HJRFKFHV]RGQDV
3DQLH
, 52=:,1, &,( 7(0$78 PR QD SU]\]QDü PDNV\PDOQLH SXQNWyZ ]D
VSHáQLHQLH NU\WHULXP SU]\]QDMHP\ SXQNW\ ]D MHJR QLHVSHáQLHQLH SXQNWyZ QLH
SU]\]QDMHP\SXQNWyZF] VWNRZ\FK
5HQHVDQV±RNUH OHQLHFHFKNXOWXURZ\FKHSRNLZNRQWHN FLH]DJDGQLHQLD
5HQHVDQVRZDILOR]RILD
D QHRSODWRQL]P SRá F]HQLH LGHL 3ODWRQD ] ILOR]RIL FKU]H FLMD VN LGHD
PLáR FL Z UHODFML %yJ ± F]áRZLHN ,VWRWD 1DMZ\ V]D F]\OL %yJ LQQH
RNUH OHQLD%RJDZ ZLHWOHWHMILOR]RILLWR:LHONL'HPLXUJ:LHONL$UFKLWHNW
ZLDWD±VWZRU]\á ZLDW]PLáR FLGRF]áRZLHNDZ\VWDUF]\ZVND]DüMHGHQ
HOHPHQW
SNW
E ZLDW L SU]\URGD V NRQVWUXNFMDPL LGHDOQ\PL KDUPRQLMQ\PL XU] G]RQ\PL
]UR]P\VáHPZWDNLVSRVyEDE\ZV]\VWNRZQLFKPLDáRVZyMFHOLPLHMVFH
SNW
F QDWXUDOQ\ XVWDORQ\ SU]H] %RJD ± 6WZyUF SRU] GHN L áDG Z SU]\URG]LH
SRZLQLHQLVWQLHüZND G\PF]áRZLHNX
SNW
G %yJ REGDU]D F]áRZLHND ZáDG] Q DG ZLDWHP D MHG\Q\P ]DGDQLHP URG]DMX
OXG]NLHJRMHVWP GUHJRVSRGDURZDQLHQD]LHPLWDNDE\SU]\QRVLáDRQDSORQ
ZWHQZáD QLHVSRVyEF]áRZLHNRGGDMHF]H ü%RJX
SNW
5HQHVDQVRZDHVWHW\NDNODV\F\]PX
D Z]RURZDQLH VL QD V]WXFH DQW\F]QHM JUHFNLHM L U]\PVNLHM NWyUD QDMOHSLHM
RGGDZDáDKDUPRQL QDWXU\
SNW
E FL OHRNUH ORQ\NDQRQSL NQDSL NQRMHVWMHG\QHLRELHNW\ZQHPDZ\QLNDü
]SURVWRW\DQLH]]DZLáR FL
SNW
F QD ODGRZQLFWZRQDWXU\±PLPHVLV
SNW
G KDUPRQLDáDGUyZQRZDJDVWDW\F]QR üSURVWRWDLSU]HMU]\VWR üNRQVWUXNFML
SHUVSHNW\ZDOLQHDUQDSURSRUFMRQDOQR üW]ZERVNLHSURSRUFMHUR]ZL ]DQLD
RSDUWHQDJHRPHWULLZ\VWDUF]\ZVND]DüMHGHQHOHPHQW
SNW
H UHQHVDQVRZHWRSRV\LPRW\Z\QSWRSRVJHQH]\MVNLWRSRVUDMVNLHJRRJURGX
PRW\ZDUNDG\MVNLPRW\ZSDQNDOLLPRW\ZDUW\VWRZVNLZ\VWDUF]\ZVND]Dü
MHGHQHOHPHQW
SNW
.RQFHSFMD ZLDWDL%RJDZSLH QLDFK-DQD.RFKDQRZVNLHJR
ZLDW
D MHVWKDUPRQLMQ\LSL NQ\MHVWRGELFLHPERVNLHMGRVNRQDáR FLLGREURFLU] G]L
VL WH SUDZDPL PRUDOQ\PL NWyUH ZVSLHUDM L XJUXQWRZXM RSW\PLVW\F]Q\
ZLDWRSRJO G
SNW
E áDG L QDWXUDOQ\ SRU] GHN ZLDWD VWDQRZL JZDUDQFM Z ZLHFLH VSUDZ
OXG]NLFK QLHQDUXV]DOQR FL L QLH]PLHQQR FL UD] XVWDQRZLRQHJR SRU] GNX
PRUDOQHJRLVSRáHF]QHJR3LH ,,Ä6HUFHUR FLH´3LH ,;Ä1LHSRU]XFDM
QDG]LHMH´
SNW
F PLW\F]QD$UNDGLDÄ3LH ZL WRMD VNDR6REyWFH´
SNW
3UyEQ\HJ]DPLQPDWXUDOQ\]M ]\NDSROVNLHJR
0RGHORGSRZLHG]LLVFKHPDWRFHQLDQLDDUNXV]\HJ]DPLQDF\MQ\FK
%yJ
D 7ZyUFD$UW\VWD:LHONL%XGRZQLF]\$UFKLWHNW ZLDWD
SNW
E WUZD ZLHF]QLH L MHVW ZV]HFKREHFQ\ WZRU]\ SU]HGPLRW\ L SUDZD GDMH
F]áRZLHNRZL \FLHLZáDG] QDG ZLDWHPEXG]L]DFKZ\WLSRG]LZ
SNW
F RWDF]DF]áRZLHNDRSLHN 3LH ;,9
SNW
G Z\Z\ V]\áF]áRZLHNDSRQDGLQQHVWZRU]HQLDGDM FPXUR]XPLPRZ 3LH
;,;
SNW
H WDMHPQLF]\QLH]EDGDQHV -HJRZ\URNLPR HZSá\ZDüQLF]\P)RUWXQDQD
]PLHQQR üOXG]NLHJRORVX3LH ,;3LH ;,9
SNW
$QDOL]DLLQWHUSUHWDFMD+\PQX&]HJRFKFHV]RGQDV3DQLH
$QDOL]DWHNVWXZLHUV]D
D Z\RGU EQLHQLHSRGPLRWXOLU\F]QHJRLDGUHVDWDZ\SRZLHG]LSRHW\FNLHM
SNW
E UR]SR]QDQLH QDZL ]D GRWUDG\FMLSVDOPLF]QHMS\WDQLDZNWyU\FKSRMDZLD
VL MD±Z\]QDZFDLW\±%yJ
SNW
F Z\V]F]HJyOQLHQLH FHFK JDWXQNRZ\FK XWZRUX PRQRORJLF]QR ü ]ZURW\
DSRVWURILF]QHDGUHVDWEyJOXEKHURVRELHNWNXOWXF]FLZLDU\PRGOLWHZQ\
FKDUDNWHU SRGQLRVá\ Z\VRNL WRQ Z\SRZLHG]L PHORG\MQR ü Z\QLNDM FD ]H
VZRLVWHM NRQVWUXNFML ZHUV\ILNDF\MQHM EXGRZD VWURILF]QD R VWDá\P XNáDG]LH
ZHUVyZ Z\UD]LVWD U\WPL]DFMD SDUDOHOL]P\ VNáDGQLRZH L OHNV\NDOQH
XPR OLZLDM FHMLQWHUSUHWDFM PX]\F]Q Z\VWDUF]\ZVND]DüGZDHOHPHQW\
SNW
G RNUH OHQLHW\SXOLU\NL]DOLF]HQLHXWZRUXGROLU\NLDSHOXLQZRNDF\MQHM
SNW
H ZVND]DQLH URGNyZ DUW\VW\F]QHJR Z\UD]X Z\VWDUF]\ ZVND]Dü GZD
HOHPHQW\
SNW
,QWHUSUHWDFMDZLHUV]D
D SRGPLRW OLU\F]Q\ ]ZUDFD VL GR %RJD Z\VáDZLDM F *R Z LPLHQLX FDáHM
]ELRURZR FL±GHNODUDFMDZLDU\PLáR FLLSU]\ZL ]DQLD
SNW
E %yJ MHVW VWZyUF L SDQHP NRVPRVX ± Z WU]HFLHM L F]ZDUWHM ]ZURWFH SRHWD
RSLVXMHDNWWZRU]HQLD ZLDWD]QDQ\].VL JL5RG]DMXPRW\ZJHQH]\MVNL
SNW
F ZLDWXF]\QLá%yJQLHXVWDQQLHRZRFXM F\PRJURGHPREUD]UDMVNLHJRRJURGX
VSU]HG JU]HFKX SLHUZRURGQHJR Z NWyU\P ZV]\VWNR \MH L UR]PQD D VL
]ZURWNLSL WDLV]yVWD±WRSRV(GHQX
SNW
G ] ZROL %RJD ZLDW ]RVWDá XSRU] GNRZDQ\ L SDQXMH Z QLP QLHVND RQD
JU]HFKHPKDUPRQLDJUSDQNDOyVNDJDWKRV ZV]HFK±GREU\LSL NQ\
SNW
H %yJ MHVW JZDUDQWHP áDGX XVWDQRZLRQHJR QD SRF] WNX MHVW ZV]HFKREHFQ\
SU]H]VZRM GREURü
SNW
I %yJ ± $UW\VWD QLH W\ONR VWZRU]\á ZLDW DOH UyZQLH XF]\QLá JR SL NQ\P
=SLHUZRWQHM L EH]áDGQHM PDWHULL FKDRVX ZJ 3ODWRQD %yJ XNV]WDáWRZDá
G]LHáRSL NQHDSU]H]WRGRVNRQDáH
SNW
:QLRVNL
+\PQ VNLHURZDQ\ GR %RJD MDNR KXPDQLVW\F]QD SRFKZDáD SL NQD ZLDWD
SRG]L NRZDQLH]DG]LHáRVWZRU]HQLD ZLDWDLF]áRZLHND%yJNLHUXMHVSUDZDPL
ZLDWD L REGDU]D F]áRZLHND GREURG]LHMVWZDPL NWyU\P QLH PDV] PLDU\ V RQ H
ZLHF]QH MDN XNáDG QDWXU\ ]D SR UHGQLFWZHP NWyUHM F] ü ÄKRMQ\FK GDUyZ´
ER \FK VSá\ZD QD F]áRZLHND ZLDUD Z LVWQLHQLH ERVNLHM RSDWU]QR FL NWyUD
NRQVW\WXXMH L XWZLHUG]D áDG NRVPRVX L áDG ]LHPVNLHJR ZLDWD Z\VWDUF]\
ZVND]DüMHGHQHOHPHQW
SNW
3UyEQ\HJ]DPLQPDWXUDOQ\]M ]\NDSROVNLHJR
0RGHORGSRZLHG]LLVFKHPDWRFHQLDQLDDUNXV]\HJ]DPLQDF\MQ\FK
+\PQ .RFKDQRZVNLHJR PR QD X]QDü]D PDQLIHVW UHQHVDQVRZHJR RSW\PL]PX
SRQLHZD KDUPRQLD L SL NQR ZLDWD V RGELFLHP ERVNLHM GRVNRQDáR FL
XVWDQRZLRQ\ SU]H] %RJD SRU] GHN VWZRU]HQLD SRWZLHUG]D ZDUWR ü F]áRZLHND
LSU]\QRVL PX V]F] FLH SRGPLRW OLU\F]Q\ Z\UD D SU]HNRQDQLH H ÄGREURü
ERVNDQLJG\QLHXVWDQLH´SRGPLRWOLU\F]Q\ZLHU]\ZPR OLZR FLSR]QDZF]H
F]áRZLHND UR]XPHP PR QD SU]HQLNQ ü L RJDUQ ü SUDZD QDGDQH SU]H] %RJD
QDWXU]HZ\VWDUF]\ZVND]DüMHGHQHOHPHQW
SNW
8:$*$PRGHOQLHQDU]XFDSRU] GNXZ\SRZLHG]L]GDM FHJR
,, .2032=<&-$PDNV\PDOQLHSXQNWyZQLHSU]\]QDMHP\SXQNWyZ
F] VWNRZ\FK
- SRGSRU] GNRZDQD ]DP\VáRZL LQWHUSUHWDF\MQHPX IXQNFMRQDOQHPX ZREHF
WHPDWX VSyMQD ZHZQ WU]QLH SU]HMU]\VWD L ORJLF]QD SHáQD NRQVHNZHQFMD
ZXNáDG]LHJUDILF]Q\P
SNW
- XSRU] GNRZDQD ZHGáXJ SU]\M WHJR NU\WHULXP VSyMQD JUDILF]QH
Z\RGU EQLHQLHJáyZQ\FKF] FL
SNW
- ZVND]XM FDQDSRGM FLHSUyE\SRU] GNRZDQLDP\ OLQDRJyáVSyMQD
SNW
,,, 67</ PDNV\PDOQLH SXQNWyZ QLH SU]\]QDMHP\ SXQNWyZ
F] VWNRZ\FK
- MDVQ\ \Z\VZRERGQ\]JRGQ\]]DVWRVRZDQ IRUP Z\SRZLHG]L
XUR]PDLFRQDOHNV\ND
SNW
- ]JRGQ\ ] ]DVWRVRZDQ IRUP Z\SRZLHG]L QD RJyá MDVQ\ Z\VWDUF]DM FD
OHNV\ND
SNW
- QDRJyáNRPXQLNDW\ZQ\GRSXV]F]DOQHVFKHPDW\M ]\NRZH
SNW
,9 - =<. PDNV\PDOQLH SXQNWyZ QLH SU]\]QDMHP\ SXQNWyZ
F] VWNRZ\FK
- SRSUDZQD XUR]PDLFRQD VNáDGQLD L IUD]HRORJLD ]JRGQD ] QRUP IOHNVMD
LRUWRJUDILDU]DGNRSRMDZLDM FHVL Eá G\LQWHUSXQNF\MQH
SNW
- SRSUDZQD XUR]PDLFRQD VNáDGQLD L IUD]HRORJLD ]JRGQD ] QRUP IOHNVMD
VSRUDG\F]QLHSRMDZLDM FHVL Eá G\RUWRJUDILF]QHLLQWHUSXQNF\MQH
SNW
- Z ZL NV]R FL SRSUDZQD VNáDGQLD L IUD]HRORJLD ]JRGQD ] QRUP IOHNVMD
QLHOLF]QH XVWHUNL OHNV\NDOQH RUD] QLHOLF]QH Eá G\ RUWRJUDILF]QH
LLQWHUSXQNF\MQH
SNW
- Z\SRZLHG NRPXQLNDW\ZQDPLPR HVFKHPDW\F]QDVNáDGQLDVWRVXQNRZR
QLHOLF]QH Eá G\ IOHNV\MQH OHNV\NDOQH L IUD]HRORJLF]QH RUD] Eá G\
RUWRJUDILF]QHLLQWHUSXQNF\MQH
SNW
- VFKHPDW\F]QDVNáDGQLDOLF]QHEá G\VNáDGQLRZHIOHNV\MQHLOHNV\NDOQHRUD]
RUWRJUDILF]QH L LQWHUSXQNF\MQH SU]\ ]DFKRZDQLX NRPXQLNDW\ZQR FL
Z\SRZLHG]L
SNW
9 6=&=(*Ï/1(:$/25<35$&<SXQNWyZ
3UyEQ\HJ]DPLQPDWXUDOQ\]M ]\NDSROVNLHJR
0RGHORGSRZLHG]LLVFKHPDWRFHQLDQLDDUNXV]\HJ]DPLQDF\MQ\FK
7HPDW
: NRQWHN FLH ]Dá F]RQHJR IUDJPHQWX Ä/XG]L EH]GRPQ\FK´ 6WHIDQD
HURPVNLHJRLFDáHMSRZLH FLUR]ZD QDF]\PSROHJDLVWRWDÄEH]GRPQR FL´ZSU]\SDGNX
-XG\PDLLQQ\FKERKDWHUyZXWZRUX
, 52=:,1, &,( 7(0$78 PR QD SU]\]QDü PDNV\PDOQLH SXQNWyZ ]D
VSHáQLHQLH NU\WHULXP SU]\]QDMHP\ SXQNW\ ]D MHJR QLHVSHáQLHQLH SXQNWyZ QLH
SU]\]QDMHP\SXQNWyZF] VWNRZ\FK
$QDOL]DLLQWHUSUHWDFMDIUDJPHQWX
%RKDWHURZLHVFHQ\
D 7RPDV]-XG\P±OHNDU]LGHDOLVWDNWyUHJRFHOHPMHVWVáX EDQDMXER V]\P
SNW
E -RDVLD3RGERUVND±]DNRFKDQDZ-XG\PLHVSUDJQLRQDPLáR FLLURG]LQQHJRGRPX SNW
3RVW SRZDQLHERKDWHUD
D RGU]XFHQLH PLáR FL -RDVL QD U]HF] VáX E\ VSRáHF]QHM Ä1LH PRJ PLHü >@
RQ\DQLMHGQHMU]HF]\NWyU E\PSU]\FLVQ áGRVHUFD]PLáR FL >@´
SNW
E LPSHUDW\ZPRUDOQ\-XG\PDSRGM üZDON ]H]áHPLZ\U]HFVL V]F] FLD
RVRELVWHJRÄ0XV] Z\U]HFVL V]F] FLD0XV] E\üVDPMHGHQ´
SNW
F SUREOHP RGSRZLHG]LDOQR FL OHNDU]D SU]HG VSRáHF]H VWZHP ÄMD MHVWHP ]D WR
ZV]\VWNRRGSRZLHG]LDOQ\´Ä-H HOLWHJRQLH]UREL MDOHNDU]WRNWy WRXF]\QL"´
SNW
G RERZL ]HN VSáDW\ GáXJX ]DFL JQL WHJR ZREHF ZáDVQHM NODV\ VSRáHF]QHM
Ä2WU]\PDáHPZV]\VWNRFRSRWU]HED0XV] WRRGGDüFRPZ]L á7HQGáXJ
SU]HNO W\´
SNW
Ä%H]GRPQR ü´-XG\PDVHQVGRVáRZQ\LPHWDIRU\F]Q\
D QLHPR QR üSU]\VWDQLDQD]áR ZLDWD
SNW
E Z\U]HF]HQLHVL XURNyZ \FLDURG]LQQHJR
SNW
F QLHPR QR üSU]\VWDQLDQD]áR ZLDWD
SNW
&HFK\-XG\PD
SNW
D ]EXQWRZDQ\SU]HFLZ]áX ZLDWD
E EH]NRPSURPLVRZ\
SNW
F ZHZQ WU]QLHUR]GDUW\ERKDWHUWUDJLF]Q\
SNW
G ZUD OLZ\QDNU]\ZG OXG]N
SNW
H VDPRWQ\ERMRZQLNSR ZL FDM F\VL GODRJyáX
SNW
I SRVWDZDDOWUXLVW\F]QD
SNW
=ZL ]HNIUDJPHQWX]LGH XWZRUX
:\MD QLHQLHWHUPLQXÄEH]GRPQR ü´]RGZRáDQLHPGRW\WXáXSRZLH FL
SNW
-XG\P MDNR V\QWH]D ERKDWHUD URPDQW\F]QHJR QLH]JRGD QD U]HF]\ZLVWR ü
LSR]\W\ZLVW\F]QHJRNXOWQDXNLLSUDF\±ÄURPDQW\F]Q\RUJDQLF]QLN´
SNW
-XG\P QLJG\ QLH PLDá SUDZG]LZHJR GRPX Z SU]HFLZLH VWZLH GR -RDVL L QLH
UR]XPLHFRWUDFL
SNW
-XG\P MHVW ÄEH]GRPQ\´ Z VHQVLH URGRZLVNRZ\P QLH F]XMH VL GREU]H DQL
ZNU JXSUROHWDULDWXNRQWDNW\]EUDWHPDQLZNU JXLQWHOLJHQFML URGRZLVNR
OHNDU]\DQLVIHUZ\ V]\FK
SNW
Ä%H]GRPQR ü´LQQ\FKERKDWHUyZSRZLH FL
D -RDVLD 3RGERUVND Z\NRU]HQLRQD ] ZáDVQHM NODV\ VSUDJQLRQD GRPX
URG]LQQHJRRGWU FRQDSU]H]-XG\PDVND]DQDQDGDOV] WXáDF]N SRFXG]\FK
GRPDFK
SNW
E :LNWRU -XG\P ]H Z]JO GX QD VRFMDOLVW\F]QH SRJO G\ ]PXV]RQ\ GR
RSXV]F]HQLDNUDMX
SNW
3UyEQ\HJ]DPLQPDWXUDOQ\]M ]\NDSROVNLHJR
0RGHORGSRZLHG]LLVFKHPDWRFHQLDQLDDUNXV]\HJ]DPLQDF\MQ\FK
F :DFáDZ 3RGERUVNL G]LDáDF] UHZROXF\MQ\ L QLHSRGOHJáR FLRZ\ ]HVáDQ\ QD
6\ELUWDPXPLHUD
SNW
G /HV/HV]F]\NRZVNL XFLHNDM F\ ] 3ROVNL SU]HG UHSUHVMDPL SR XSDGNX
SRZVWDQLDVW\F]QLRZHJR
SNW
H .RU]HFNL GHNDGHQW ZUD OLZ\ QD NU]\ZG OXG]N EH] PLHMVFD Z \FLX
SRSHáQLDVDPREyMVWZR
SNW
I SUROHWDULDWPLHMVNLZLHMVNL±EH]GRPQR üMDNRVWUDV]QHZDUXQNL \FLDÄWXOXG]LH
ZWU]\G]LHVW\PURNX \FLDXPLHUDM ERMX V VWDUFDPL']LHFLLFK±WRLGLRFL´
SNW
%H]GRPQR ü WR GOD HURPVNLHJR SUREOHP VSRáHF]Q\ ± SRZLH ü XND]XMH
SUREOHP\ZVSRVyEUHDOQ\MHGQDNSURSR]\FMDUR]ZL ]DQLDMHVWXWRSLMQD
SNW
,QWHUSUHWDFMDW\WXáXSRZLH FL
SNW
:QLRVHN Ä%H]GRPQR ü´ ERKDWHUyZ SRZLH FL HURPVNLHJR PD ]QDF]HQLH
PHWDIRU\F]QH ZV]\VWNLFK LFK á F]\ QLH]JRGD QD ]DVWDQ\ ZLDW GODWHJR
RGU]XFDM \FLRZ VWDELOL]DFM QDU]HF]ZDONL]H]áHP ZLDWD
SNW
:QLRVHN&]áRZLHNEH]GRPQ\ZND G\P]SRGDQ\FK]QDF]H MHVWQLHV]F] OLZ\ SNW
8:$*$PRGHOQLHQDU]XFDSRU] GNXZ\SRZLHG]L]GDM FHJR
,, .2032=<&-$PDNV\PDOQLHSXQNWyZQLHSU]\]QDMHP\SXQNWyZ
F] VWNRZ\FK
- SRGSRU] GNRZDQD ]DP\VáRZL LQWHUSUHWDF\MQHPX IXQNFMRQDOQHPX ZREHF
WHPDWX VSyMQD ZHZQ WU]QLH SU]HMU]\VWD L ORJLF]QD SHáQD NRQVHNZHQFMD
ZXNáDG]LHJUDILF]Q\P
SNW
- XSRU] GNRZDQD ZHGáXJ SU]\M WHJR NU\WHULXP VSyMQD JUDILF]QH
Z\RGU EQLHQLHJáyZQ\FKF] FL
SNW
- ZVND]XM FDQDSRGM FLHSUyE\SRU] GNRZDQLDP\ OLQDRJyáVSyMQD
SNW
,,, 67</ PDNV\PDOQLH SXQNWyZ QLH SU]\]QDMHP\ SXQNWyZ
F] VWNRZ\FK
- MDVQ\ \Z\VZRERGQ\]JRGQ\]]DVWRVRZDQ IRUP Z\SRZLHG]LXUR]PDLFRQD
OHNV\ND
SNW
- ]JRGQ\]]DVWRVRZDQ IRUP Z\SRZLHG]LQDRJyáMDVQ\Z\VWDUF]DM FDOHNV\ND
SNW
- QDRJyáNRPXQLNDW\ZQ\GRSXV]F]DOQHVFKHPDW\M ]\NRZH
SNW
,9 - =<. PDNV\PDOQLH SXQNWyZ QLH SU]\]QDMHP\ SXQNWyZ
F] VWNRZ\FK
- SRSUDZQD XUR]PDLFRQD VNáDGQLD L IUD]HRORJLD ]JRGQD ] QRUP IOHNVMD
LRUWRJUDILDU]DGNRSRMDZLDM FHVL Eá G\LQWHUSXQNF\MQH
SNW
- SRSUDZQD XUR]PDLFRQD VNáDGQLD L IUD]HRORJLD ]JRGQD ] QRUP IOHNVMD
VSRUDG\F]QLHSRMDZLDM FHVL Eá G\RUWRJUDILF]QHLLQWHUSXQNF\MQH
SNW
- ZZL NV]R FLSRSUDZQDVNáDGQLDLIUD]HRORJLD]JRGQD]QRUP IOHNVMDQLHOLF]QH
XVWHUNLOHNV\NDOQHRUD]QLHOLF]QHEá G\RUWRJUDILF]QHLLQWHUSXQNF\MQH
SNW
- Z\SRZLHG NRPXQLNDW\ZQDPLPR HVFKHPDW\F]QDVNáDGQLDVWRVXQNRZR
QLHOLF]QH Eá G\ IOHNV\MQH OHNV\NDOQH L IUD]HRORJLF]QH RUD] Eá G\
RUWRJUDILF]QHLLQWHUSXQNF\MQH
SNW
- VFKHPDW\F]QD VNáDGQLD OLF]QH Eá G\ VNáDGQLRZH IOHNV\MQH L OHNV\NDOQH RUD]
RUWRJUDILF]QHLLQWHUSXQNF\MQHSU]\]DFKRZDQLXNRPXQLNDW\ZQR FLZ\SRZLHG]L
SNW
9 6=&=(*Ï/1(:$/25<35$&<SXQNWyZ
3UyEQ\HJ]DPLQPDWXUDOQ\]M ]\NDSROVNLHJR
0RGHORGSRZLHG]LLVFKHPDWRFHQLDQLDDUNXV]\HJ]DPLQDF\MQ\FK
$5.86=,,
.LHUXMHP\VL Z\W\F]Q\PL]DZDUW\PLZNU\WHULDFKRFHQLDQLDSRV]F]HJyOQ\FK]DGD =GDM F\
PR HRWU]\PDüPDNV\PDOQLHSXQNWyZ
1DRFHQ QLHZSá\ZDM Eá G\M ]\NRZHSRSHáQLRQHSU]H]]GDM FHJR
=DGDQLDVSUDZG]DM FHUR]XPLHQLHF]\WDQHJRWHNVWX ZLDWL]D ZLDW\
0RGHO]DZLHUDSU]HZLG\ZDQHRGSRZLHG]L2GSRZLHG]LXF]QLDPRJ SU]\ELHUDüUy Q IRUP
M ]\NRZRVW\OLVW\F]Q DOHLFKVHQVPXVLE\üV\QRQLPLF]Q\ZREHFPRGHOX2FHQLDM FSUDF
XF]QLDQDOH \VWRVRZDüSXQNWDFM ]DZDUW ZPRGHOX
8ZDJD1LHQDOH \SU]\]QDZDüSRáyZHNSXQNWyZ=DEUDNRGSRZLHG]LOXERGSRZLHG]L
Eá GQHQLHSU]\]QDMHVL SXQNWyZ
=DGDQLH
SXQNWDFMD±
6SRG]LHZDP\ VL GZyFK PR OLZ\FK RGSRZLHG]L $OER XF]H RGSRZLH H ZVSRPQLHQLH
ILOR]RID KLV]SD VNLHJR MHVW DQHJGRW NWyUD PD ]D ]DGDQLH XDWUDNF\MQLü ZVW S GR WHNVWX
SR ZL FRQHJR PLHUFL DOER H DXWRU SU]\ZRáDá WR ZVSRPQLHQLH E\ ]ZUyFLü XZDJ Q D
ZVSyOQR üGR ZLDGF]HQLDMDNLPMHVWUR]P\ ODQLHOXG]LQDGZáDVQ PLHUFL
3U]\]QDMHP\GZDSXQNW\]DRGSRZLHG SRSUDZQ PHU\WRU\F]QLHLVIRUPXáRZDQ ZMHGQ\P
SRSUDZQLH]EXGRZDQ\P]GDQLX-H HOLRGSRZLHG SU]HNUDF]DGáXJR üMHGQHJR]GDQLDOXEMHVW
WR]GDQLH]EXGRZDQHQLHSRSUDZQLHSU]\]QDMHP\MHGHQSXQNW
=DGDQLH
SXQNWDFMD±
6WZLHUG]HQLHÄ2F]\ZLVWR ü PLHUFLF]\QL]QDVLVWRW\P\ O FH´VXJHUXMH HW\ONRF]áRZLHN
NWyU\X ZLDGRPLVRELHIDNWZáDVQHM PLHUWHOQR FLMHVWGXFKRZRGRMU]Dá\
3U]\]QDMHP\GZDSXQNW\]DRGSRZLHG SRSUDZQ PHU\WRU\F]QLHLVIRUPXáRZDQ ZMHGQ\P
SRSUDZQLH]EXGRZDQ\P]GDQLX-H HOLRGSRZLHG SU]HNUDF]DGáXJR üMHGQHJR]GDQLDOXEMHVW
WR]GDQLH]EXGRZDQHQLHSRSUDZQLHSU]\]QDMHP\MHGHQSXQNW
=DGDQLH
SXQNWDFMD±
:VSyOQ\P WHPDWHP WU]HFK DUF\G]LHá OLWHUDWXU\ HXURSHMVNLHM MHVW G HQLH GR UR]ZL ]DQLD
]DJDGNL PLHUFLWHJRFRQDVW SXMHSRQLHM
3U]\]QDMHP\GZDSXQNW\]DRGSRZLHG SRSUDZQ PHU\WRU\F]QLHLVIRUPXáRZDQ ZMHGQ\P
SRSUDZQLH]EXGRZDQ\P]GDQLX-H HOLRGSRZLHG SU]HNUDF]DGáXJR üMHGQHJR]GDQLDOXEMHVW
WR]GDQLH]EXGRZDQHQLHSRSUDZQLHSU]\]QDMHP\MHGHQSXQNW
=DGDQLH
SXQNWDFMD±
&HOHP SU]\ZRáDQLD PLWX R 'HPHWHU L 3HUVHIRQLH MHVW FK ü SRGNUH OHQLD IDNWX H MX
ZP\ OHQLXPLW\F]Q\PZD QHPLHMVFH]DMPRZDáDUHIOHNVMDRRGUDG]DQLXVL \FLDSR PLHUFL
3U]\]QDMHP\GZDSXQNW\]DRGSRZLHG SRSUDZQ PHU\WRU\F]QLHLVIRUPXáRZDQ ZMHGQ\P
SRSUDZQLH]EXGRZDQ\P]GDQLX-H HOLRGSRZLHG SU]HNUDF]DGáXJR üMHGQHJR]GDQLDOXEMHVW
WR]GDQLH]EXGRZDQHQLHSRSUDZQLHSU]\]QDMHP\MHGHQSXQNW
3UyEQ\HJ]DPLQPDWXUDOQ\]M ]\NDSROVNLHJR
0RGHORGSRZLHG]LLVFKHPDWRFHQLDQLDDUNXV]\HJ]DPLQDF\MQ\FK
=DGDQLH
SXQNWDFMD±
3UDZLGáRZDMHVWRGSRZLHG E
1LHSU]\]QDMHP\SXQNWyZF] VWNRZ\FK
=DGDQLH
SXQNWDFMD±
&KRG]LRRNUH OHQLDÄNRVPLF]QDNDWDVWURID´±ÄV\WXDFMDZROQR FL´
1LHSU]\]QDMHP\SXQNWyZF] VWNRZ\FK
=DGDQLH
SXQNWDFMD±
*QRVW\F\ ]RVWDOL QD]ZDQL ÄJUR Q\PL NRQNXUHQWDPL PáRGHJR FKU]H FLMD VWZD´ SRQLHZD
RGU]XFLOLJáyZQHLGHHFKU]H FLMD VNLHF]áRZLHF]H VWZR&KU\VWXVDZDUWR ü-HJR PLHUFLQD
NU]\ XL]PDUWZ\FKZVWDQLH
3U]\]QDMHP\GZDSXQNW\]DRGSRZLHG SRSUDZQ PHU\WRU\F]QLHLVIRUPXáRZDQ ZMHGQ\P
SRSUDZQLH]EXGRZDQ\P]GDQLX-H HOLRGSRZLHG SU]HNUDF]DGáXJR üMHGQHJR]GDQLDOXEMHVW
WR]GDQLH]EXGRZDQHQLHSRSUDZQLHSU]\]QDMHP\MHGHQSXQNW
=DGDQLH
SXQNWDFMD±
3UDZLGáRZDMHVWRGSRZLHG F
=DGDQLH
SXQNWDFMD±
3U]\NáDG\ ]PDUWZ\FKZVWDQLH ERJD QLH PLHUWHOQR FL ± $WWLVD RGUDG]DQLH VL ] SRSLRáyZ
)HQLNVD]PDUWZ\FKZVWDQLH'LRQL]RVDLZ\SURZDG]HQLH]SLHNáD$ULDGQ\
3U]\]QDMHP\GZDSXQNW\]DSRGDQLHWU]HFKSU]\NáDGyZ-H HOLXF]H SRGDGZD±SU]\]QDMHP\
MHGHQSXQNW=DSRGDQLHMHGQHJRSU]\NáDGXQLHSU]\]QDMHP\SXQNWyZ
=DGDQLH
SXQNWDFMD±
Ä%á NDQLH VL PL G]\ VMHVW D WUZRJ ´ R]QDF]D H ERLP\ VL PLHUFL D MHGQRF]H QLH P\ O
RQLHM SUyEXMHP\ ]DJáXV]\ü FKRüE\ SRSU]H] XFLHF]N Z QLHU]HF]\ZLVWR ü WHOHZL]\MQ\FK
UHNODP
3U]\]QDMHP\GZDSXQNW\]DRGSRZLHG SRSUDZQ PHU\WRU\F]QLHLVIRUPXáRZDQ ZMHGQ\P
SRSUDZQLH]EXGRZDQ\P]GDQLX-H HOLRGSRZLHG SU]HNUDF]DGáXJR üMHGQHJR]GDQLDOXEMHVW
WR]GDQLH]EXGRZDQHQLHSRSUDZQLHSU]\]QDMHP\MHGHQSXQNW
=DGDQLH
SXQNWDFMD±
3DPL WDM H LP V]\EFLHM X ZLDGRPLP\ VRELH IDNW ZáDVQHM PLHUWHOQR FL W\P P GU]HM
LGRMU]DOHM E G]LHP\ PRJOL SDWU]Hü QD QDV]H \FLH 1LH OHNFHZD IDNWX H ÄE\ü´ MHVW
ZD QLHMV]HQL ÄPLHü´
3U]\]QDMHP\WU]\SXQNW\]DRGSRZLHG SRSUDZQ PHU\WRU\F]QLHVIRUPXáRZDQ ZGZyFKOXE
WU]HFKSRSUDZQLH]EXGRZDQ\FK]GDQLDFKZ\QLNDM F ]FDáHJRWHNVWX]X \FLHPLPSUHV\ZQHM
IXQNFMLM ]\ND-H HOL]GDQLD]EXGRZDQHV SRSUDZQLHDOHRGSRZLHG ]RVWDáDVIRUPXáRZDQD
W\ONR QD SRGVWDZLH RVWDWQLHJR DNDSLWX SU]\]QDMHP\ GZD SXQNW\ -H HOL Z\PyJ IRUPDOQHM
SRSUDZQR FLQLH]RVWDáVSHáQLRQ\SU]\]QDMHP\MHGHQSXQNW
3UyEQ\HJ]DPLQPDWXUDOQ\]M ]\NDSROVNLHJR
0RGHORGSRZLHG]LLVFKHPDWRFHQLDQLDDUNXV]\HJ]DPLQDF\MQ\FK
=DGDQLH
SXQNWDFMD±
&KRG]LRRNUH OHQLHÄSR PLHUWQHSU]HVWU]HQLH´
=DGDQLH
SXQNWDFMD±
3UDZLGáRZDMHVWRGSRZLHG D
=DGDQLH
SXQNWDFMD±
8]QDMHP\GZLHPR OLZR FLSRGDQLHVáRZDÄGODWHJR´OXEÄP GUR ü´=GDM F\SRGDMHW\ONR
MHGQRVáRZR:LQQ\PZ\SDGNXX]QDMHP\SLHUZV]\]SRGDQ\FKSU]\NáDGyZ
1LHSU]\]QDMHP\SXQNWyZF] VWNRZ\FK
=DGDQLH
SXQNWDFMD±
$XWRUZFL JDF]\WHOQLNDZWRNVZRLFKUR]ZD D SRSU]H]NRQVHNZHQWQHX \ZDQLHZFDá\PWHN FLH
F]DVRZQLNyZL]DLPNyZZRVOPQQSÄVND]XMHP\´Ä]DJáXV]DP\´ÄQDV´ÄP\´LWG
3U]\]QDMHP\ WU]\ SXQNW\ ]D RGSRZLHG SRSUDZQ PHU\WRU\F]QLH VIRUPXáRZDQ Z MHGQ\P
SRSUDZQLH ]EXGRZDQ\P ]GDQLX ]DZLHUDM F SU]\QDMPQLHM GZD SU]\NáDG\ ] WHNVWX -H HOL
RGSRZLHG SU]HNUDF]D GáXJR ü MHGQHJR ]GDQLD OXE MHVW WR ]GDQLH ]EXGRZDQH QLHSRSUDZQLH
SU]\]QDMHP\ GZD SXQNW\ -H HOL Z RGSRZLHG]L ]DEUDNQLH SU]\NáDGyZ SU]\]QDMHP\ GZD
SXQNW\
=DGDQLH
SXQNWDFMD±
3UDZLGáRZDMHVWRGSRZLHG E