.2602/2*,$ ±
3LHUZRWQDQXNOHRV\QWH]D%%1
3,(5:271$18./(26<17(=$
%%1
3RG NRQLHF HU\ OHSWRQRZHM SU]\
Å+
4
b
RN Å-E6 Z UyZQRZDG]H ]QDMGXM VL
QDVW SXMFHUHNFMHRGG]LDá\ZDVáDE\FK
ÅÅÅÅÅÅ
E
E
P
N
E
N
P
E
O
O
j
j
:UyZQRZDG]HVWRVXQHNLORFLQHXWURQyZLSURWRQyZ
< >
N
P
RNUHORQ\MHVWSUDZHP%ROW]PDQQD
Å-E6
N
P
M
M
K4
N
P
N
E
P
M
M
M
¯
¡ °
¡ °
¢ ±
%
:PLDU HNVSDQVMLWHPSHUDWXUDVSDGDDZUD]]QLPDOHMH
< >
N
P
RGRN QDSRF]HU\OHSWRQRZHM
GRRN SRGMHMNRQLHF
3U]\WHPSHUDWXUDFKRNÅ-E6UyZQRZDJDZ\*HMZ\PLHQLRQ\FKUHDNFMLVWRSQLRZR]DáDPXMHVL
D EDUG]LHM SUDZGRSRGREQ\ VWDMH VL QLHRGZUDFDOQ\ UR]SDG EHWD
E
N
P
E
O
l
: RNROLF\ WHM
WHPSHUDWXU\PRJMX*XWU]\PDüVL SURGXNW\SLHUZV]HMUHDNFMLQXNOHRV\QWH]\
$
N
P
H
l
7HPSRWHMUHDNFML]DOH*\RG
DWHPSHUDWXU\F] VWRWOLZRüLHQHUJLD]GHU]H
EVWRVXQNX
< >
N
P
FNRQFHQWUDFMLVDP\FKEDULRQyZF]\OLRGZLHONRFL
B
N
N
H
I
1HXWURQPDZL FZW\FKZDUXQNDFKGZLHPR*OLZRFL
UHDNFMD]SURWRQHPLV\QWH]DGHXWHUX
VSRQWDQLF]Q\UR]SDGEHWD
3U]H] SLHUZV]H VHNXQG\ SU]\E\ZD QDP GHXWHUX *G\ MHJR LORü Z]JO
GHP ZRGRUX RVLJQLH
< >
$
(
x
SUDZGRSRGREQH VWDM VL UHDNFMH V\QWH]\ QXNOLGyZ WUyMF]VWNRZ\FK ² WU\WX
4
RUD]
L]RWRSXKHOX
(E
$
4
l
N
H
$
(E
l
P
H
1D VNXWHN W\FK UHDNFML XE\ZD GHXWHUX L MHJR REILWRü VWDELOL]XMH VL VWRSQLRZR QD SR]LRPLH RN
< >
$
(
x
¸
*G\ Z]JO GQD NRQFHQWUDFMD
(E
RVLJQLH WH* RN
(E
(
¯ x
¢
±
WR ]DF]\QD ]DFKRG]Lü NROHMQD
UHDNFMD
(E
Å (E
Å (E
P
l
7R ZáDQLH Z SLHUZV]\FK NLONX PLQXWDFK QXNOHVRV\QWH]\ SRZVWDáD ]DVDGQLF]D LORü KHOX ZH
ZV]HFKZLHFLH
3RQLHZD* QLH PD VWDELOQ\FK QXNOLGyZ R PDVDFK DWRPRZ\FK L ZL F KHO MHVW JáyZQ\P SR
ZRGRU]HSLHUZLDVWNLHPNWyU\SR]RVWDMHSRWHMHSRFH3HZQDQLHZLHONDMHJRF] ü]G*\MHV]F]HZHMü
ZUHDNFMH
(E
4
Å ,I
H
l
.2602/2*,$ ±
3LHUZRWQDQXNOHRV\QWH]D%%1
(E
(E
Å "E
H
l
(ZHQWXDOQD UHDNFMD
(E
(E
Å "E
H
l
GDMH FDáNRZLFLH QLHWUZDá\ L]RWRS EHU\OX PDMF\
RNUHVSRáRZLF]QHJRUR]SDGXRN V
'ODNROHMQ\FKUHDNFMLMDNQSF\NO
(E
Å #
H
l
MHVWMX*Ä]D]LPQR´3U]H]WHNLONDVHWVHNXQG
WUZDQLDQXNOHRV\QWH]\:V]HFKZLDWUR]V]HU]DMFVL RVW\JáGR
Å+
4
LMHJRJ VWRüWH*]QDF]QLH
VSDGáD3RGDOV]\FKNLONXW\VLFDFKVHNXQGUDGLRDNW\ZQ\WU\WVWRSQLRZRUR]SDGDVL QD
(E
]D
"E
SU]H]Z\FKZ\WHOHNWURQXSU]HNV]WDáFDVL Z
,I
3LHUZRWQD QXNOHRV\QWH]D QD W\P VL NRF]\ 1D UHV]W SLHUZLDVWNyZ WU]HED SRF]HNDü D*
Z\SURGXNXMMHJZLD]G\-HGQDN]DVDGQLF]DREILWRüKHOXZH:V]HFKZLHFLHZLORFL
(E
(
¯ x
¢
±
XVWDOLáDVL ZyZF]DV3y(QLHMV]DHZROXFMDJZLD]GMX*MHMUDG\NDOQLHQLH]PLHQLáD
5\V$ 3U]HELHJSLHUZRWQHMQXNOHRV\QWH]\ZF]DVLHSLHUZV]\FKNLONXQDVWXPLQXW
.U]\ZHXND]XMVWRSQLRZ\Z]URVWOXEVSDGHNREILWRFLSRV]F]HJyOQ\FK
QXNOLGyZRUD]QHXWURQyZ
N
3UREOHPREILWRFLKHOXLLQQ\FKOHNNLFKSLHUZLDVWNyZ
-DNMX*VWZLHUG]LOLP\SRZ\*HMSLHUZRWQDQXNOHRV\QWH]D%%1GRSURZDG]LáDGRSRZVWDQLDNLONX
QDMO*HMV]\FKQXNOLGyZ²GHXWHUX
(E
(E
,I
3U]\WRF]P\WXUD]MHV]F]HSRGVWDZRZHUHDNFMHWHM
QXNOHRV\QWH]\
$
$
4
$
(E
(E
(E
(E
(E
4
,I
(E
(E
"E
N
P
N
P
P
H
H
H
H
H
l
l
l
l
l
l
.2602/2*,$ ±
3LHUZRWQDQXNOHRV\QWH]D%%1
3URFHV\WHWUZDMSU]H]SLHUZV]HNLONDVHWVHNXQGHZROXFML:V]HFKZLDWDLXVWDMJG\WHPSHUDWXUD
VSDGQLH SRQL*HM
. .RFRZD REILWRü SRZVWDá\FK SLHUZLDVWNyZ ]DOH*\ ]DVDGQLF]R RG GZyFK
F]\QQLNyZ
DWHPSDHNVSDQVML²DZL FLRGWHPSDÄVW\JQL FLD´:V]HFKZLDWD
EJ VWRFLPDWHULLEDULRQRZHM
B
S
²DZ]DVDG]LHRGZLHONRFL
B
N
N
H
I
:LHONRüWDQLH]PLHQLDVL ZWUDNFLHGDOV]HMHNVSDQVMLLPR*HE\üREHFQLHGREU\PPLHUQLNLHPGR
REVHUZDF\MQHJRWHVWRZDQLDVNXWNyZSLHUZRWQHMQXNOHRV\QWH]\,OXVWUXMHWRSRQL*V]\U\VXQHN%
5\V% 7HRUHW\F]QH NRFRZH UR]SRZV]HFKQLHQLH OHNNLFK SLHUZLDVWNyZ LORü DWRPyZ
Z]JO GHPZRGRUXSRSLHUZRWQHMQXNOHRV\QWH]LHZ]DOH*QRFLRGREHFQHMJ VWRFL
PDWHULL EDULRQRZHM
B
S
GROQD VNDOD OXE RG ZDUWRFL SDUDPHWUX
B
N
N
H
I
JyUQDVNDOD
:HZQ WU]Q\ QLH]DNUHVNRZDQ\ SDV RGSRZLDGD VNUDMQHPX SU]HG]LDáRZL QLHSHZQRFL
ZLHONRFL
B
S
GRSXV]F]DOQHPX SU]H] GDQH REVHUZDF\MQH :LGDü *H QDMEDUG]LHM
F]Xá\PZVND(QLNLHPMHVWREILWRüGHXWHUXDQDVW SQLH
(E
L
,I
-DNZLGDü]WHJRZ\NUHVXREILWRü]Z\NáHJRKHOX
(E
VWRVXQNRZRVáDER]DOH*\RGJ VWRFL
B
S
L
Z\QRVL
(E
(
¯ x
u
¢
±
OLF]FQDLORüDWRPyZOXEWH*RN
ZVHQVLHSURFHQWRZHM
LORFLPDV\-HVWWRQDW\OHGX*DREILWRü*HSy(QLHMV]DHZROXFMDJZLD]GQLH]ZL
NV]\áDMX* MHM Z
]QDF]F\ VSRVyE 2EVHUZDF\MQH Z\]QDF]HQLD REILWRFL KHOX ]ZáDV]F]D Z QDMVWDUV]\FK JZLD]GDFK
]QDNRPLFLH PLHV]F] VL
Z SRZ\*V]\P SU]HG]LDOH -HVW WR ZL
F GRü PRFQ\ DUJXPHQW QD NRU]\ü
NRQFHSFMLSLHUZRWQHMQXNOHRV\QWH]\
2EVHUZRZDQD REILWRü
(E
VWDáD VL WH* GRGDWNRZR ZVND(QLNLHP WHVWXMF\P NZDUNRZR±
OHSWRQRZ\PRGHOEXGRZ\PDWHULL²DNRQNUHWQLHM²ZVND(QLNLHPLORFLW]ZJHQHUDFMLNZDUNyZL
.2602/2*,$ ±
3LHUZRWQDQXNOHRV\QWH]D%%1
OHSWRQyZ-DNWRMX*ZVSRPLQDQRZUR]G]LDOHÄ(UDOHSWRQRZD´SU]\MPXMHVL REHFQLHLVWQLHQLHWU]HFK
JHQHUDFMLW\FKHOHPHQWDUQ\FKVNáDGQLNyZ
ÅÅ
ÅÅ
E
E
N
U
N
U
O
O
O
¬
¬
¬
®
®
®
-HGQRF]HQLHWHPSRHNVSDQVMLLVW\JQL FLD:V]HFKZLDWDQDW\PHWDSLHRSLV\ZDáRUyZQDQLH
4 T
T
G 4
¸
JG]LH F]\QQLN G ]DOH*\ ZáDQLH RG LORFL URG]DMyZ F]VWHN Z W\P SU]\SDGNX JáyZQLH RG LORFL
URG]DMyZQHXWULQ7HPSRVW\JQL FLD:V]HFKZLDWDU]XWXMH]NROHLQDWHPSRUHDNFMLQXNOHRV\QWH]\D
ZL FQDNRFRZREILWRüOHNNLFKSLHUZLDVWNyZ²ZW\PWDN*H
(E
.ROHMQ\U\VXQHNLOXVWUXMHQDP
NRFRZSURFHQWRZREILWRü
(E
Z]DOH*QRFLRGLORFLJHQHUDFMLOHSWRQyZ
.
:
]J
O¾GQD
RE
ILW
RÐ
±KH
OX
U
U>>
JFPA@
A
A
1
1
1
1
5\V& 7HRUHW\F]QD REILWRü KHOX MDNR SURFHQW PDV\ Z ]DOH*QRFL RG ZDUWRFL
SDUDPHWUXI SU]\UR*Q\FKLORFLDFK
.
W\SyZOHSWRQyZLNZDUNyZ
-DNZLGDü]SRZ\*V]HJRU\VXQNXX]QDZDQDREHFQLHLORü
.
SURZDG]LGRFDáNLHPGREU\FKL
]JRGQ\FK ] REVHUZDFMDPL SU]HZLG\ZD REILWRFL KHOX *G\E\ EDGDQLD Z ]DNUHVLH F]VWHN
HOHPHQWDUQ\FK ZVND]Dá\ QD NRQLHF]QRü ZSURZDG]HQLD MHV]F]H MHGQHM ² F]ZDUWHM ² JHQHUDFML
NZDUNRZROHSWRQRZHMWR]SHZQ\PWUXGHPGDáRE\VL WRMHV]F]HSRJRG]Lü]REVHUZRZDQREILWRFL
KHOX -HGQDN GDOV]H JHQHUDFMH QLH PLHV]F] VL MX* Z GRW\FKF]DVRZ\P VFKHPDFLH SLHUZRWQHM
QXNOHRV\QWH]\ 3U]\MPXMH VL ZL F REHFQLH *H ]QDP\ MX* FK\ED ZV]\VWNLH F]\OL WU]\ JHQHUDFMH
NZDUNyZ L OHSWRQyZ 7DN ZL F EDGDQLD QDG NRVPLF]Q REILWRFL KHOX SU]\GDá\ VL GRGDWNRZR GR
WHVWRZDQLDWHRULL]FDáNLHPLQQHMVSHFMDOQRFL²]WHRULLHOHPHQWDUQHMEXGRZ\PDWHULL8]QDQRWR]D
GX*\VXNFHVZWZRU]HQLXMHGQROLWHJRREUD]XEXGRZ\:V]HFKZLDWD²]DUyZQRZVNDOLPDNURMDNL
PLNUR
3U]HGVWDZLRQDQDU\VXQNX%NRFRZDWHRUHW\F]QDREILWRüLQQ\FKOHNNLFKSLHUZLDVWNyZUyZQLH*
SRGGDQD E\áD WHVWRP REVHUZDF\MQ\P 2EILWRü GHXWHUX Z VHQVLH LORFL DWRPyZ Z]JO GHP
QRUPDOQHJRZRGRUX²
< >
$
(
²RWU]\P\ZDQD]REVHUZDFMLPLHFLVL ZJUDQLFDFK
¸
u
¸
.2602/2*,$ ±
3LHUZRWQDQXNOHRV\QWH]D%%1
1LHMHVWWRQDMSUDZGRSRGREQLHMSLHUZRWQDREILWRüWHJRL]RWRSXJG\*MDNZLDGRPR]WHRULLHZROXFML
JZLD]G GHXWHU MHVW F] FLRZR QLV]F]RQ\ Z LFK ZQ WU]DFK Z SURFHVLH SU]HPLDQ\ ZRGRUX Z KHO
3U]\MPXMH VL ZL F *H SLHUZRWQD REILWRü GHXWHUX E\áD QLHFR Z\*V]D RG REHFQLH REVHUZRZDQHM L
Z\QRVLáDRN
:\]QDF]HQLHSLHUZRWQHMREILWRFL
,I
L
(E
MHVWMHV]F]HPQLHMSHZQHOHF]REVHUZDFMHSR]ZDODM
QDLFKRNUHOHQLHSU]\QDMPQLHMFRGRU] GXZLHONRFL3U]\MPXMHVL ZL FQDWHMSRGVWDZLH*HREILWRFL
WHZ\QRV]RGSRZLHGQLR
,I
(E
ÅÅÅÅORAZÅÅÅÅ
(
(
¯
¯
x
u
x
¡
°
¡
°
¡
°
¡
°
¢
±
¢
±
%LRUFSRGXZDJ Z\]QDF]RQHREILWRFLZV]\VWNLFKF]WHUHFKOHNNLFKQXNOLGyZGHXWHUX
(E
(E
L
,I
PR*QD]U\VXQNXRGF]\WDü*HRGSRZLDGDMFDW\PREILWRFLRPZDUWRü
I
x
u
FR RGSRZLDGD REHFQHM J VWRFL PDWHULL EDULRQRZHM
B
S
x
u
GCM
-HVW WR ZDUWRü
NLONDNURWQLH PQLHMV]D RG W]Z J VWRFL NU\W\F]QHM SU]\ NWyUHM JHRPHWULD :V]HFKZLDWD VWDMH VL
HXNOLGHVRZD 3U]\ WDNLHM J VWRFL REHFQH WHPSR HNVSDQVML :V]HFKZLDWD PXVLDáRE\ E\ü ]QDF]QLH
ZL NV]H QL* ZVND]XM QD WR GDQH REVHUZDF\MQH 3RZVWDMH ZL F SUREOHP W]Z EUDNXMFHM FLHPQHM
PDWHULLRNWyU\PE\áDPRZDZUR]G]LDOHÄ(UDOHSWRQRZD´
SURI-HU]\6LNRUVNL
,QVW\WXW)L]\NL7HRUHW\F]QHML$VWURIL]\NL
8QLZHUV\WHW*GDVNL
HPDLOIL]MNV#LIWLDXQLYJGDSO