Ä85$1,$²3RVW S\$VWURQRPLL´
XUDQLDSWDHGXSOVFLHQFHKWPO
.2602/2*,$ ±
3RGVWDZ\2JyOQHM7HRULL:]JO GQRFL
32'67$:<2*Ï/1(-7(25,,:=*/ '12&,
6IRUPXáRZDQD Z U SU]H] $ (LQVWHLQD 6]F]HJyOQD 7HRULD :]JO GQRFL 67: Z\Uy*QLD
SHZQ NODV XNáDGyZ RGQLHVLHQLD ² XNáDG\ LQHUFMDOQH =JRGQLH ] ]DVDG Z]JO GQRFL ZV]\VWNLH
LQHUFMDOQHXNáDG\RGQLHVLHQLD,82VUyZQRSUDZQHDSRGVWDZRZHUyZQDQLDIL]\NLVQLH]PLHQQLF]H
Z]JO GHPWUDQVIRUPDFML]MHGQHJRXNáDGXLQHUFMDOQHJRGRGUXJLHJR²F]\OLZ]JO GHPWUDQVIRUPDFML
/RUHQW]D3U]\MPXMHVL WXWDN*HJOREDOQRüND*GHJRXNáDGXLQHUFMDOQHJR²W]Q*HXNáDGWDNLPR*H
E\ü ]DGDQ\ Z FDáHM F]DVRSU]HVWU]HQL :LHP\ *H SUDNW\F]QLH WUXGQR MHVW ZSURZDG]Lü WDNL JOREDOQLH
LQHUFMDOQ\ XNáDG RGQLHVLHQLD =LHPLD Z\NRQXMH UXFK REURWRZ\ ZRNyá VZHM RVL RUD] UXFK RELHJRZ\
ZRNyá6áRFDZL F]ZL]DQ\]QL XNáDG QLH E G]LH VSHáQLDá Z\PDJDQHJR NU\WHULXP 6áRFH WDN*H
Z\NRQXMHUXFKRELHJRZ\ZRNyáURGND*DODNW\NLWD]DUXFKRELHJRZ\ZRNyáURGNDPDV\ORNDOQHM
JURPDG\ JDODNW\N 3UDNW\F]QLH PR*QD ZL F Z\]QDF]\ü Ä]EXGRZDü´ XNáDG RGQLHVLHQLD NWyU\ ]
OHSV]\POXEJRUV]\PSU]\EOL*HQLHPE G]LHVSHáQLDáNU\WHULDXNáDGXLQHUFMDOQHJR²E G]LHXNáDGHP
ORNDOQLHLQHUFMDOQ\P1DMEOL*V]\LGHDáXPyJáE\E\üXNáDGRGQLHVLHQLD]ZL]DQ\]HUHGQLPUR]NáDGHP
PDV ZH ZV]HFKZLHFLH W]Z ÄVXEVWUDWHP´ DOER XNáDG Z NWyU\P NRVPRORJLF]QH SURPLHQLRZDQLH
UHOLNWRZHMHVWL]RWURSRZH
6]F]HJyOQDWHRULDZ]JO GQRFLQLH]DZLHUDáDZVRELHVSRVREXRSLVXJUDZLWDFML(LQVWHLQG*\áZL F
GRWDNLHJRRSLVX]MDZLVNIL]\F]Q\FKZNWyU\PZV]\VWNLHXNáDG\RGQLHVLHQLDE\á\E\UyZQRSUDZQH
RUD]ZNWyU\PPLHFLáE\VL WDN*HRSLVJUDZLWDFML
-DN ZLDGRPR Z QLHLQHUFMDOQ\FK XNáDGDFK RGQLHVLHQLD 182 SRMDZLDM VL W]Z VLá\
EH]ZáDGQRFLRZH VLáD RGURGNRZD F]\ VLáD &RULROLVD = LFK SRZRGX UyZQDQLD PHFKDQLNL
QHZWRQRZVNLHMQLHVQLH]PLHQQLF]HSU]\SU]HMFLX]MHGQHJRGRGUXJLHJRXNáDGXQLHLQHUFMDOQHJR1D
ZVW SLHQDOH*DáRZL FSU]HDQDOL]RZDüSUREOHPZ]JO GQRFLSU]\VSLHV]HQLD67:SRXF]DQDV*HQLH
LVWQLHMH DEVROXWQD SU GNRü ² R SU GNRFL PR*QD PyZLü MHG\QLH Z]JO GHP MDNLHJR XNáDGX
RGQLHVLHQLD$MDNMHVW]SU]\VSLHV]HQLHP"'ODF]HJRZXNáDGDFK QLHLQHUFMDOQ\FK RGF]XZDQH V VLá\
EH]ZáDGQRFLRZHLZ]JO GHPF]HJRGDQ\XNáDGQLHLQHUFMDOQ\MHVWSU]\VSLHV]DQ\"&Dá\WHQNRPSOHNV
S\WD²]ZDQ\SUREOHPHP0DFKD²QXUWRZDáWDN*H(LQVWHLQD
5R]ZD*P\QDVW SXMF\SU]\NáDG]ZLUXMF\PZLDGUHPQDSHáQLRQ\PZRG:LDGRPR*HZWDNLP
ZLUXMF\P ZLDGU]H SRZLHU]FKQLD ZRG\ VWDQLH VL ZNO VáD QD VNXWHN G]LDáDQLD VLá\ RGURGNRZHM $
Z]JO GHPF]HJR²Z]JO GHPMDNLHJRXNáDGXRGQLHVLHQLDZLUXMHWRZLDGUR"2GSRZLHG(0DFKDEU]PL
²Z]JO GHPUHGQLHJRUR]NáDGXPDVUHV]W\ZV]HFKZLDWD0R*QDZL F]DS\WDü²F]\JG\E\]DPLDVW
ZLDGUHP NU FLü ZRNyá QLHJR ÄUHV]W ZV]HFKZLDWD´ WR WH* PHQLVN ZRG\ Z ZLDGU]H ]URELáE\ VL
ZNO Vá\"(LQVWHLQLGF]DP\O(UQVWD0DFKDSRVWXOXMHJG\*WUXGQRWR]ZHU\ILNRZDüHPSLU\F]QLH
RGSRZLHG(WZLHUG]F7DNZL FMHJR]GDQLHPUXFK\SU]\VSLHV]RQHSRVW SRZHOXEREURWRZHPDM
VHQV ZáDQLH Z]JO GHP UR]NáDGX LQQ\FK PDV ZH ZV]HFKZLHFLH *G\E\ ZL F Z FDáHM SU]HVWU]HQL
ZV]HFKZLDWD LVWQLDáD W\ONR MHGQD F]VWND WR QLH PR*QD E\ PyZLü R MHM UXFKX DQL F]\ MHVW RQ
MHGQRVWDMQ\ DQL F]\ MHVW SU]\VSLHV]RQ\ 7R REHFQRü LQQ\FK PDV ZH ZV]HFKZLHFLH SRZRGXMH *H
PR*QD RGUy*QLDü XNáDG\ LQHUFMDOQH RG QLHLQHUFMDOQ\FK SRSU]H] Z\VW SRZDQLH Z W\FK RVWDWQLFK VLá
EH]ZáDGQRFLRZ\FK %\áR WR EDUG]R QRZDWRUVNLH VSRMU]HQLH 'RW\FKF]DV Z NODV\F]Q\P XM FLX
PHFKDQLNL]ZL]HNSRPL G]\UXFKHPMDNLHMF]VWNLDLVWQLHQLHPLQQ\FKPDVZHZV]HFKZLHFLHE\á
FDáNRZLFLH LJQRURZDQ\ 7HUD] W\ONR JG\ SUDFXMHP\ Z V]F]HJyOQ\FK XNáDGDFK ² LQHUFMDOQ\FK
XNáDGDFKRGQLHVLHQLD²PR*HP\LJQRURZDüUHV]W ZLDWDZRJyOQ\PSU]\SDGNX]DQLH7\PZáDQLH
Ä85$1,$²3RVW S\$VWURQRPLL´
XUDQLDSWDHGXSOVFLHQFHKWPO
.2602/2*,$ ±
3RGVWDZ\2JyOQHM7HRULL:]JO GQRFL
Uy*QL VL ,82 RG 182 8RJyOQLHQLH RSLVX SUDZ IL]\NL QD XNáDG\ QLHLQHUFMDOQH Z\PDJDáR WDN*H
XRJyOQLHQLDSRGVWDZRZHM]DVDG\Z]JO GQRFLGRQDVW SXMFHJRVIRUPXáRZDQLD
ZV]\VWNLH XNáDG\ RGQLHVLHQLD V UyZQRSUDZQH D SRGVWDZRZH UyZQDQLD IL]\NL V
QLH]PLHQQLF]HZ]JO GHPWUDQVIRUPDFML]MHGQHJRXNáDGXGRGUXJLHJR
-HVWWRSLHUZV]\SRVWXODW2JyOQHM7HRULL:]JO GQRFL²W]ZSRVWXODWRJyOQHMNRZDULDQWQRFL
:PDWHPDW\FHRGGDZQDE\á\MX*]QDQHWDNLHRELHNW\PDWHPDW\F]QHNWyUHGREU]HWUDQVIRUPXMVL
RG MHGQ\FK ZVSyáU] GQ\FK GR GUXJLFK D ]EXGRZDQH ] QLFK UyZQDQLD ]DFKRZXM SU]\ WDNLFK
WUDQVIRUPDFMDFK VZRM SRVWDü 6 WR W]Z WHQVRU\ D UyZQDQLD ] QLFK ]EXGRZDQH WR UyZQDQLD
WHQVRURZH 7DN ZL F Z 27: SRGVWDZRZH ZLHONRFL IL]\F]QH PXV] E\ü WHQVRUDPL D ]DSLV
SRGVWDZRZ\FKUyZQDPXVLWH*PLHüSRVWDüWHQVRURZ
3U]\MU]\MP\ VL GDOHM VLáRP EH]ZáDGQRFLRZ\P SRZVWDMF\P Z 182 0DM RQH WH VLá\ W
ZáDVQRü *H ZV]\VWNLP FLDáRP ² EH] Z]JO GX QD LFK PDV ² QDGDM MHGQDNRZH SU]\VSLHV]HQLH
UyZQH FR GR ZDUWRFL SU]\VSLHV]HQLX 182 =DXZD*P\ *H LGHQW\F]Q ZáDVQRü PDM VLá\
JUDZLWDF\MQH:LHP\*HQSSU]\VSLHV]HQLH]LHPVNLH ,
g
MHVWMHGQDNRZHGODZV]\VWNLFKFLDáQD=LHPL
7RVSRVWU]H*HQLHSR]ZROLáR(LQVWHLQRZLVIRUPXáRZDüGUXJLSRVWXODW27:²]DVDG UyZQRZD*QRFL
%U]PLRQD
QLHLQHUFMDOQ\ XNáDG RGQLHVLHQLD R SU]\VSLHV]HQLX ' '
a
E GF\ SR]D SROHP
JUDZLWDF\MQ\PMHVWORNDOQLHUyZQRZD*Q\QLHRGUy*QLDOQ\XNáDGRZLLQHUFMDOQHPXZ
SROXJUDZLWDF\MQ\PRSU]\VSLHV]HQLX
.
g
a
=
,QDF]HM PyZLF ² ÄV]WXF]QD JUDZLWDFMD´ SRZVWDMFD Z 182 MHVW ORNDOQLH QLHRGUy*QLDOQD RG
JUDZLWDFMLÄSUDZG]LZHM´SRZVWDMFHMZRNyáPDV,OXVWUXMHWRSRQL*V]\U\VXQHN
D
E
F
8N¥DGLQHUFMDOQ\
SU]\VS
D
0!
J!
8N¥DGQLH
LQHUFMDOQ\
D!
8N¥DGZSROX
JUDZLWDF\MQ\P
SURPLHÆ
ÐZLHWOQ\
SURVW\
SURPLHÆ
ÐZLHWOQ\
]DNU]\ZLRQ\
5\V
0DP\ WX WU]\ V\WXDFMH : F] FL D REVHUZDWRU ]QDMGXMH VL Z UDNLHFLH NRVPLF]QHM NWyUD MHVW
XNáDGHPLQHUFMDOQ\PVLOQLNLRGU]XWRZHQLHSUDFXML]QDMGXMHVL ]GDODRGZV]HONLFKPDVE GF\FK
(UyGáHPJUDZLWDFML2GF]XZDRQVWDQQLHZD*NRFLDSU]HODWXMF\ SURPLH ZLHWOQ\ ELHJQLH SR OLQLL
SURVWHM2EVHUZDWRUVWZLHUG]DZL F*HZW\PSU]\SDGNXJHRPHWULDZMHJRRWRF]HQLXMHVWHXNOLGHVRZD
Ä85$1,$²3RVW S\$VWURQRPLL´
XUDQLDSWDHGXSOVFLHQFHKWPO
.2602/2*,$ ±
3RGVWDZ\2JyOQHM7HRULL:]JO GQRFL
:V\WXDFMLEZáF]RQRVLOQLNLRGU]XWRZHUDNLHWDOHFL]SU]\VSLHV]HQLHPREVHUZDWRURGF]XZDZQLHM
SU]\VSLHV]HQLHNXSRGáRG]HDMHGQRF]HQLH]DXZD*\*HSURPLHZLHWOQ\SU]HELHJDMF\ZSRSU]HN
UDNLHW\ XOHJQLH XJL FLX NX GRáRZL 6WZLHUG]L ZL F *H JG\ ]DF]á RGF]XZDü SU]\FLJDQLH WR
MHGQRF]HQLHJHRPHWULDZMHJRRWRF]HQLXVWDáDVL QLHHXNOLGHVRZDJG\*QDMNUyWV]DGURJDSRPL G]\
NRFDPL SURPLHQLD ZLHWOQHJR QLH MHVW MX* HXNOLGHVRZ OLQL SURVW 1D PRF\ SRVWXODWX
UyZQRZD*QRFL LGHQW\F]Q\ HIHNW SRZLQLHQ Z\VWSLü JG\ UDNLHWD VWDQLH QD MDNLHM SODQHFLH R
SU]\VSLHV]HQLXJUDZLWDF\MQ\P
.
g
a
=
3URPLHZLHWOQ\ZSROXJUDZLWDF\MQ\PSRZLQLHQWDN*HXOHJDü
XJL FLXU\VF
1DOH*\ WX MHGQDN Z\UD(QLH SRGNUHOLü ORNDOQRü RSLVDQHM SRZ\*HM UyZQRZD*QRFL 6SyMU]P\ QD
SRQL*V]\U\VXQHN3ROHZHMVWURQLHPDP\XNáDGRGQLHVLHQLDQSSRMD]GNRVPLF]Q\SRUXV]DMF\VL
GDOHNR RG ZV]HONLFK PDV UXFKHP SU]\VSLHV]RQ\P SUDFXM VLOQLNL UDNLHWRZH ]H VWDá\P
SU]\VSLHV]HQLHP ' '.
a
2EVHUZDWRU ZHZQWU] E G]LH RGF]XZDá V]WXF]QH FL*HQLH NX SRGáRG]H ]D
XSXV]F]RQH GZLH NXONL E G VSDGDá\ SR OLQLDFK UyZQROHJá\FK GR VLHELH ] SU]\VSLHV]HQLHP .
a
3R
SUDZHM VWURQLH PDP\ WHQ VDP XNáDG SRVDGRZLRQ\ QD PDV\ZQ\P RELHNFLH NXOLVW\P PDMF\P QD
SRZLHU]FKQL SU]\VSLHV]HQLH JUDZLWDF\MQH
.
g
a
=
7X WDN*H REVHUZDWRU ZHZQWU] SRMD]GX E G]LH
RGF]XZDáSU]\FLJDQLHNXSRGáRG]H-HGQDNMHOLUR]PLDU\SRMD]GXLPDV\ZQHJRRELHNWXVSRGREQH
MDNQDU\VXQNXWRV\WXDFMHSROHZHMLSRSUDZHMVWURQLHU\VXQNXE GUR]Uy*QLDOQH3RMDZLVL HIHNW
]EOL*DQLD VL VSDGDMF\FK NXOHN GR VLHELH D WDN*H ]PLDQD VLá\ FL *NRFL ] Z\VRNRFL F]\OL ]
RGOHJáRFL RG URGND -HG\QLH ORNDOQLH Z EDUG]R PDá\P REV]DU]H F]DVRSU]HVWU]HQL RELH V\WXDFMH
E GSUDNW\F]QLHQLHRGUy*QLDOQH7DNMHVWQSZVNDOLODERUDWRU\MQHMJG]LH]GREU\PSU]\EOL*HQLHP
PR*HP\ ]LHPVNLH SROH JUDZLWDF\MQH WUDNWRZDü MDNR SROH MHGQRURGQH L JG\ Z SU]\EOL*HQLX PR*HP\
]DQLHGEDüZV]HONLHUXFK\REURWRZHLRELHJRZH=LHPL
SU]\VSLHV]HQLH
J
5\V
8 SRGVWDZ RSLV\ZDQHM SRZ\*HM UyZQRZD*QRFL OH*\ MHV]F]H MHGHQ ZD*Q\ IDNW ² SRWZLHUG]DQ\
ZLHORNURWQLH GRZLDGF]DOQLH ² PLDQRZLFLH UyZQRZD*QRü F]\ ZU F] UyZQRü W]Z PDV\
EH]ZáDGQHMRUD]PDV\JUDZLWDF\MQHM:LHP\]GUXJLHM]DVDG\G\QDPLNL1HZWRQD*HDE\]PLHQLüUXFK
MDNLHJRFLDáDQDOH*\]DG]LDáDüQDQLHVLá=DSLVXMHP\WR]QDQ\PZ]RUHP
)
&
M A
0DVDFLDáD
)
M
Ä85$1,$²3RVW S\$VWURQRPLL´
XUDQLDSWDHGXSOVFLHQFHKWPO
.2602/2*,$ ±
3RGVWDZ\2JyOQHM7HRULL:]JO GQRFL
W]Z PDVD EH]ZáDGQD MHVW ZáDQLH LORFLRZ PLDU MHJR EH]ZáDGQRFL :LHP\ ERZLHP WDN*H ]
FRG]LHQQHJR GRZLDGF]HQLD *H SU]\ WHM VDPHM ZDUWRFL G]LDáDMFHM VLá\ FLDáD R Uy*Q\FK PDVDFK
GR]QDMUy*Q\FKSU]\VSLHV]H=GUXJLHMVWURQ\MX*RGF]DVyZGRZLDGF]H*DOLOHXV]DZLDGRPR*H
QS Z ]LHPVNLP SROX JUDZLWDF\MQ\P ZV]\VWNLH FLDáD VSDGDM ] MHGQDNRZ\P SU]\VSLHV]HQLHP
SRPLMDMFRSyUSRZLHWU]DLSU]\VSDGNX]Z\VRNRFLPDá\FKZSRUyZQDQLX]SURPLHQLHP]LHPVNLP
6LáDJUDZLWDFML
G
G
&
M G
MHVWZL FUy*QDGODUy*Q\FKFLDáVWDáH]DMHVWSU]\VSLHV]HQLHJUDZLWDF\MQH
3RMDZLDMFDVL WXZLHONRü
G
M
WRW]ZPDVDJUDZLWDF\MQDFLDáD-HOLZL FHIHNW\JUDZLWDF\MQHPDM
E\üORNDOQLHQLHUR]Uy*QLDOQHRGHIHNWyZ]ZL]DQ\FK]SU]\VSLHV]RQ\PUXFKHPXNáDGXSRUXV]DMFHJR
VL SRGZSá\ZHPMDNLHMLQQHMVLá\
&
WRPXVL]DFKRG]LüUyZQRü
G
)
M
M
,W ZáDQLHUyZQRü
SRWZLHUG]Lá\PLQGRZLDGF]HQLD(|WY|VD'LFNLHJRLLQ
5R]ZD*P\WHUD]ZNRQWHNFLHRSLVDQHMZ\*HMUyZQRZD*QRFLVá\QQHGRZLDGF]HQLH(LQVWHLQD]H
VSDGDMF VZRERGQLH ZLQG Z MHGQRURGQ\P SROX JUDZLWDF\MQ\P 6SDGDMFD ZLQGD MHVW XNáDGHP
QLHLQHUFMDOQ\P MHGQDN QLH MHVW WR XNáDG ² WDN MDN WR IRUPXáRZDOLP\ Z\*HM ² ] GDOD RG SyO
JUDZLWDF\MQ\FK D ZU F] SU]HFLZQLH ² ]QDMGXMH VL RQ Z SROX R ZDUWRFL SU]\VSLHV]HQLD
JUDZLWDF\MQHJR G L]WDNLPSU]\VSLHV]HQLHPVSDGDZLQGD6SDGHNVZRERGQ\ÄNRPSHQVXMH´QLHMDNR
FKRü W\ONR ORNDOQLH HIHNW\ ]ZL]DQH ] LVWQLHQLHP SROD JUDZLWDF\MQHJR 2EVHUZDWRU ]DPNQL W\ Z
WDNLHM ZLQG]LH E G]LH ZL F SU]HNRQDQ\ ZV]\VWNLH MHJR GRZLDGF]HQLD E G QD WR ZVND]\ZDá\ *H
]QDMGXMH VL Z LQHUFMDOQ\P XNáDG]LH RGQLHVLHQLD )L]\ND Z MHJR VZRERGQLH VSDGDMF\P XNáDG]LH
RGQLHVLHQLDE G]LHIL]\NV]F]HJyOQHMWHRULLZ]JO GQRFL6ZRERGQ\VSDGHNZSROXJUDZLWDF\MQ\P
] SU]\VSLHV]HQLHP
G
MHVW ZL F ORNDOQLH UyZQRZD*Q\ VZRERGQHPX MHGQRVWDMQHPX
LQHUFMDOQHPXUXFKRZL]GDODRGSyOJUDZLWDF\MQ\FK7RWDN*HMHVW]DVDGDUyZQRZD*QRFLW\ONR
LQQ\PLVáRZDPLZ\UD*RQD
3RZUyüP\ UD] MHV]F]H GR U\VXQNX :\QLNDáR ] QLHJR *H VWRMF Z SROX JUDZLWDF\MQ\P
SRZLQQLP\ ]DREVHUZRZDü HIHNW\ ZLDGF]FH R QLHHXNOLGHVRZRFL F]DVRSU]HVWU]HQL ZRNyá QDV QS
XJL FLH WUDMHNWRULL SURPLHQLD ZLHWOQHJR 'RZLDGF]HQLH SRWZLHUG]LáR Z SHáQL VáXV]QRü WHJR
SU]HZLG\ZDQLD=QDQ\MHVWFKRüE\HIHNWXJL FLDSURPLHQLZLHWOQ\FKJZLD]GZSROXJUDZLWDF\MQ\P
6áRFDREVHUZRZDQ\SRGF]DV]DüPLHQLD:W\PZL FVHQVLH27:VSURZDG]LáDSROHJUDZLWDF\MQH
GR QLHHXNOLGHVRZRFL F]DVRSU]HVWU]HQL ,QQ\PL VáRZ\ ² UR]NáDG PDV\ HQHUJLL Z
F]DVRSU]HVWU]HQLGHWHUPLQXMHMHMJHRPHWUL WD]DRNUHODUXFKPDVZF]DVRSU]HVWU]HQL:D*QH
MHVWWXWDMWRZ]DMHPQHÄVSU] *HQLH´SRPL G]\UR]NáDGHPPDV\±HQHUJLLDJHRPHWUL-HGQRZSá\ZD
QDGUXJLHLRGZURWQLH7RMHVWLVWRWQDUy*QLFDSRPL G]\SRGHMFLHP27:DNODV\F]Q\PSRGHMFLHP
QHZWRQRZVNLP:IL]\FHQHZWRQRZVNLHMDEVROXWQDSU]HVWU]HE\áDMDNE\VFHQQDNWyUHMUR]JU\ZDá\
VL ]MDZLVNDIL]\F]QH:SU]HVWU]HQLSRUXV]Dá\VL FLDáDG]LDáDüPRJá\Uy*QHVLá\OHF]VDPDSU]HVWU]H
ZW\PVSHNWDNOXF]\QQLHQLHXF]HVWQLF]\áD-HMXG]LDáE\áELHUQ\RQDW\ONRE\áDOHF]QLFVL ]QLQLH
G]LDáR
:27:VDPDF]DVRSU]HVWU]HXF]HVWQLF]\ZW\PFRVL ZQLHMG]LHMH-HMJHRPHWULD]PLHQLDVL
ZUD]]]DFKRG]F\PL]GDU]HQLDPLWR]DZSá\ZD]ZURWQLHQDSU]HELHJ]GDU]H0DMFWRQDXZDG]H
PR*QDVL VSRG]LHZDü*HSRGVWDZRZHUyZQDQLDSRODJUDZLWDF\MQHJRZ27:E GGRüXZLNáDQHL
PRFQRQLHOLQLRZH,WDNWH*MHVWIDNW\F]QLH
: WHRULL Z]JO GQRFL SRGVWDZRZ\P RELHNWHP PDWHPDW\F]Q\P FKDUDNWHU\]XMF\P JHRPHWU\F]QH
ZáDVQRFL F]DVRSU]HVWU]HQL MHVW W]Z LQWHUZDá F]DVRSU]HVWU]HQQ\ RSLVXMF\ Uy*QLF]NRZ RGOHJáRü
SRPL G]\GZRPDSXQNWDPL]GDU]HQLDPLZF]DVRSU]HVWU]HQL:67:JG]LHRERZL]XMHJHRPHWULD
SVHXGRHXNOLGHVRZDLZHZVSyáU] GQ\FKNDUWH]MDVNLFKPDRQ]QDQSURVWSRVWDü
Ä85$1,$²3RVW S\$VWURQRPLL´
XUDQLDSWDHGXSOVFLHQFHKWPO
.2602/2*,$ ±
3RGVWDZ\2JyOQHM7HRULL:]JO GQRFL
DS
DX
DX
DX
DX
JG]LH
X
CT
2JyOQLHMLQWHUZDáPR*QD]DSLVDüZSRVWDFLVXP\
I
J
IJ
I J
DS
G DX DX
'ODZ]RUXZVSyáF]\QQLNL
IJ
G
XNáDGDMVL ZPDFLHU]
IJ
G
¯
¡
°
¡
°
¡
°
¡
°
¡
°
¡
°
¡
°
¢
±
*G\F]DVRSU]HVWU]HMHVWHXNOLGHVRZDOHF]Z\ELHU]HP\ZQLHMZVSyáU] GQHNU]\ZROLQLRZHQS
VIHU\F]QHWRPDFLHU]ZVSyáF]\QQLNyZ
IJ
G
PR*HPLHüEDUG]LHM]áR*RQHZ\UD]\QDSU]HNWQHMMHGQDN
]DZV]HGDVL MSU]HWUDQVIRUPRZDüGRSRVWDFLZUDFDMFGRZVSyáU] GQ\FKNDUWH]MDVNLFK
*G\ F]DVRSU]HVWU]H VWDMH VL QLHHXNOLGHVRZD WR PDFLHU] ; =
IJ
G
E G]LH ]DZLHUDáD QD RJyá MDNLH
]áR*RQHZ\UD*HQLDUyZQLH*SR]DGLDJRQDOQHE GFHIXQNFMDPLZVSyáU] GQ\FKF]DVRSU]HVWU]HQQ\FKL
QLH GD VL MHM GRSURZDG]Lü GR SRVWDFL *DGQ WUDQVIRUPDFM 7DN ZL F ZVSyáF]\QQLNL
IJ
G
]ZDQH
WHQVRUHP PHWU\F]Q\P ]DZLHUDM SRGVWDZRZ LQIRUPDFM R ZáDVQRFLDFK JHRPHWU\F]Q\FK
F]DVRSU]HVWU]HQL:áDVQRFLWHQDPRF\]DVDG\UyZQRZD*QRFL]DOH*RGUR]NáDGXPDV\HQHUJLL
,ORFLRZRRSLVXMWRZáDQLHHLQVWHLQRZVNLHUyZQDQLDSRODNWyUHV\PEROLF]QLH]DSLVXMHVL
ÅÅÅÅÅÅÅÅ
IJ
IJ
'
4
I J
L
/HZDVWURQDW\FKUyZQD
IJ
'
WRGRüVNRPSOLNRZDQHIXQNFMHVNáDGRZ\FK
IJ
G
RUD]LFKSLHUZV]\FK
L GUXJLFK SRFKRGQ\FK 3UDZD VWURQD ]D
IJ
4
WR ZLHONRFL RSLVXMFH UR]NáDG PDV HQHUJLL L S GX
E GF\FK(UyGáHPJUDZLWDFML/HZDLSUDZDVWURQDW\FKUyZQDPXV]E\üRF]\ZLFLHWHQVRUDPLQD
PRF\SRVWXODWXRJyOQHMNRZDULDQWQRFL7DNZL FUR]ZL]\ZDQLHSUREOHPyZZ27:VSURZDG]DVL
GR WHJR *H ]DGDMHP\ MDNL UR]NáDG PDV\ Z SU]HVWU]HQL SUDZ VWURQ XNáDGX UyZQD (LQVWHLQD L
SRV]XNXMHP\ SROD JUDZLWDF\MQHJR ² F]\OL JHRPHWULL F]DVRSU]HVWU]HQL VNáDGRZ\FK
IJ
G
E GFHM
VNXWNLHPWHJRUR]NáDGXPDV3RQLHZD*PDFLHU]; =
IJ
G
q
MHVWV\PHWU\F]QD
IJ
JI
G
G
PDP\ZL F
QLH]DOH*Q\FKVNáDGRZ\FK5yZQDQLD(LQVWHLQDWRZQDMRJyOQLHMV]\PSU]\SDGNXXNáDGUyZQD
Uy*QLF]NRZ\FKF]VWNRZ\FKGUXJLHJRU] GXNWyU\UR]ZL]\ZDüWU]HED]HZ]JO GXQDQLHZLDGRPH
VNáDGQLNL
IJ
G
-HVWWREDUG]RVNRPSOLNRZDQ\XNáDGUyZQDZL FMHJRDQDOLW\F]QHUR]ZL]DQLDXGDáR
VL ]QDOH(ü MHG\QLH GOD NLONX QDMSURVWV]\FK V\WXDFML -HGQ ] QLFK MHVW RSLV VWDW\F]QHJR SROD
JUDZLWDF\MQHJRZRNyáPDV\NXOLVWHMW]ZUR]ZL]DQLH6FKZDU]VFKLOGD:W\PSU]\SDGNX]HZ]JO GX
QDV\PHWUL VIHU\F]QSUREOHPXLVWRWQDMHVWW\ONR]DOH*QRüJHRPHWULLRGZVSyáU] GQHMUDGLDOQHM
R
]D ] FDáHJR XNáDGX UyZQD LVWRWQH SR]RVWDM W\ONR GZD ] QLFK 5R]ZL]DQLH WR SU]HZLGXMH PLQ
LVWQLHQLHF]DUQ\FKG]LXU]REDF]'RGDWHNSRQL*HM
'UXJLPSU]\SDGNLHPUR]ZL]DQ\PDQDOLW\F]QLHMHVWV\WXDFMDJG\FDáDSU]HVWU]HMHVWMHGQRURGQLH
Z\SHáQLRQDPDWHULRUyZQHMJ VWRFL
S
7XUyZQLH*]HZ]JO GXQDGX*SURVWRW ]DJDGQLHQLDLVWRWQH
SR]RVWDM GZD UyZQDQLD ] FDáHJR XNáDGX 6 WR SRGVWDZRZH UyZQDQLD NRVPRORJLF]QH RSLVXMFH
JHRPHWUL F]DVRSU]HVWU]HQLZV]HFKZLDWDLMHMHZROXFM ZF]DVLH
Ä85$1,$²3RVW S\$VWURQRPLL´
XUDQLDSWDHGXSOVFLHQFHKWPO
.2602/2*,$ ±
3RGVWDZ\2JyOQHM7HRULL:]JO GQRFL
'2'$7(.&]DUQHG]LXU\
2ELHNW\Z\WZDU]DMFHZRNyáVLHELHWDNVLOQHSROHJUDZLWDF\MQH*HQDZHWZLDWáRQLHMHVWZVWDQLH
RGOHFLHü ] LFK SRZLHU]FKQL UR]ZD*Dá MX* Z URNX IUDQFXVNL PDWHPDW\N L DVWURQRP /DSODFH
%D]XMFQDQHZWRQRZVNLHMWHRULLJUDZLWDFMLLNRUSXVNXODUQHMWHRULLZLDWáDPyJáRQSURVWRSROLF]\ü
ZDUXQHNMDNLPXVLVSHáQLDüRELHNWRPDVLH- LSURPLHQLX
2
SU]\NWyU\PW]ZSU GNRüXFLHF]NL
))
6
UyZQDVL SU GNRFLZLDWáD
C
=HV]NROQHJRZ]RUX
))
'-
6
2
áDWZRRWU]\PDüSU]\UyZQXMF
))
6
C
JUDQLF]Q\SURPLH
G
2
2
RELHNWXRPDVLH
-
G
'-
2
C
/DSODFH QLH X*\ZDá MHV]F]H QD]Z\ F]DUQH G]LXU\ QLH ZLHG]LDá WH* QLF R JUDQLF]QHM SU GNRFL
ZLDWáD NWyU ZSURZDG]LáD Sy(QLHM 7HRULD :]JO GQRFL 'RSLHUR UyZQDQLD 2JyOQHM 7HRULL
:]JO GQRFL27:GDá\]DGRZDODMF\RSLVZáDVQRFLSRODJUDZLWDF\MQHJRZRNyáPDV\NXOLVWHM2SLV
WHQZSU]\SDGNXVáDE\FKSyOJUDZLWDF\MQ\FKGDMHUH]XOWDW\]EOL*RQHGRSU]HZLG\ZDQ\FKSU]H]WHRUL
1HZWRQD,VWRWQHUy*QLFHSRMDZLDMVL GODVLOQ\FKSyOJUDZLWDF\MQ\FK
-DNMX*ZVSRPLQDQRZUR]G]LDOHRSRGVWDZDFK27:²SRGVWDZRZLQIRUPDFM RJHRPHWU\F]Q\FK
ZáDVQRFLDFKF]DVRSU]HVWU]HQL]DZLHUDLQWHUZDáF]DVRSU]HVWU]HQQ\DZV]F]HJyOQRFLZVSyáF]\QQLNL
IJ
G
WZRU]FH W]Z WHQVRU PHWU\F]Q\ L Z\OLF]DQH ] UR]ZL]D UyZQD (LQVWHLQD 3ROH NXOLVWR
V\PHWU\F]QHMHVWMHGQ\P]QLHOLF]Q\FKSU]\SDGNyZGODNWyU\FKUyZQDQLDWHXGDáRVL ZPLDU SURVWR
UR]ZL]DüW]ZUR]ZL]DQLH6FKZDU]VFKLOGD=HZ]JO GXQDNXOLVWV\PHWUL SUREOHPXZDUWRSU]HMü
RGZVSyáU] GQ\FKNDUWH]MDVNLFK
X Y Z
X X X
GRZVSyáU] GQ\FKVIHU\F]Q\FK
R R K
ZHGáXJ
]QDQ\FKIRUPXá
SIN SIN
SIN COS
COS
X
R
X
R
X
R
R
K
R
K
R
3URVWH Uy*QLF]NRZDQLH SR]ZDOD SU]HSLVDü HXNOLGHVRZ\ LQWHUZDá SU]HVWU]HQQ\ Z W\FK
ZVSyáU] GQ\FK
SIN
¸
DL
DX
DX
DX
DR
R D
R
D
R
R
K
]DLQWHUZDáF]DVRSU]HVWU]HQQ\
SIN
¸
DS
C DT
DR
R D
R
D
R
R
K
D
6NáDGRZHWHQVRUD
IJ
G
VZL FZSU]\SDGNXHXNOLGHVRZ\PQDVW SXMFH
ÅÅÅ
ÅÅÅ
ÅÅÅ
SIN
G
G
G
R
G
R
R
3U]\ NXOLVWHM V\PHWULL SROD JUDZLWDF\MQHJR MHG\QH ]PLDQ\ MHJR QDW *HQLD Z M ]\NX 27: V WR
]PLDQ\JHRPHWULL]DFKRG]]RGOHJáRFL
R
QLHPD]D]PLDQZNLHUXQNDFKNWRZ\FK2]QDF]DWR*H
ZUD]]XZ]JO GQLHQLHPSRODJUDZLWDF\MQHJRZQDV]\PLQWHUZDOHD]PLHQLVL Z\UD]
G
VWRMF\
SU]\
DR
RUD]HZHQWXDOQLHZ\UD]
G
VWRMF\SU]\
C DT
2WU]\PDQ\SU]H]6FKZDU]VFKLOGDUH]XOWDW²
UR]ZL]DQLDUyZQD(LQVWHLQDGODSXVWHMSU]HVWU]HQLZRNyáVWDW\F]QHMQLHURWXMFHMPDV\ - ²
GDáLQWHUZDáF]DVRSU]HVWU]HQQ\ZSRVWDFL
Ä85$1,$²3RVW S\$VWURQRPLL´
XUDQLDSWDHGXSOVFLHQFHKWPO
.2602/2*,$ ±
3RGVWDZ\2JyOQHM7HRULL:]JO GQRFL
SIN
¬
¸
®
G
G
2
DR
DS
C DT
R D
D
2
R
R
R
R
K
JG]LH
G
2
'- C
²W]ZSURPLHJUDZLWDF\MQ\²MHVWLGHQW\F]Q\]HZ]RUHP
:LG]LP\ZL F*HLQWHUZDáPDSHZQRVREOLZRüQDRGOHJáRFL
G
R
2
²MHVWWRW]ZKRU\]RQW
JUDZLWDF\MQ\6FKZDU]VFKLOGD3RQL*HMWHMZLHONRFL]DZRG]LRSLVSU]\SRPRF\LQWHUZDáX2EV]DU
GOD
G
R
2
MHVW ZQ WU]HP F]DUQHM G]LXU\ $ ZL F JG\ FDá PDV - VFLQLHP\ GR UR]PLDUyZ
b
G
R
2
WRXWZRU]\P\F]DUQG]LXU 3U]\NáDGRZRGOD=LHPL
G
2
FPGOD6áRFD
G
2
NP
3RUyZQXMFZLHONRFL
G
]IRUPXáDLZLG]LP\*HXSá\ZF]DVXZSROXJUDZLWDF\MQ\PDU
MHVWZROQLHMV]\QL*EH]SROD JUDZLWDF\MQHJR Z F]DVRSU]HVWU]HQL HXNOLGHVRZHM
DT
=ZL]HN MHVW WX
QDVW SXMF\
¬
®
G
2
D
DT
R
U
1D VDPHM SRZLHU]FKQL
G
R
2
VSRZROQLHQLH WR VWDMH VL QLHVNRF]RQH 2]QDF]D WR *H RGOHJá\
REVHUZDWRU]QDMGXMF\VL ]GDODRGSRODJUDZLWDF\MQHJRLSRUyZQXMF\VZRMHRGVW S\F]DVRZH
DT
]
LPSXOVDPL DU ]HJDUD ]EOL*DMFHJR VL GR ÄSRZLHU]FKQL´ F]DUQHM G]LXU\ Z NRFX VWZLHUG]L MDNE\
Ä]DWU]\PDQLHVL ´F]DVXWHJR]HJDUDQDSRZLHU]FKQL
G
R
2
7DN*HVDPSURFHVVSDGDQLDQDF]DUQG]LXU E G]LHVL RGOHJáHPXREVHUZDWRURZLZ\GDZDáFRUD]
ZROQLHMV]\ZU F]DV\PSWRW\F]Q\LQLHVNRF]HQLHGáXJRWUZDá\1DWRPLDVWREVHUZDWRUZVSyáVSDGDMF\
]W\P]HJDUHPGROHFLGRSRZLHU]FKQLKRU\]RQWXJUDZLWDF\MQHJRSRVNRF]RQ\PF]DVLHZáDVQ\P U L
ZSDGQLHQLHRGZUDFDOQLHGRF]DUQHMG]LXU\=DRGOHJá\REVHUZDWRUÄGRZLHVL ´RW\PRGELHU]HRVWDWQL
V\JQDáJLQFHJR]HJDUDSRQLHVNRF]HQLHGáXJLPF]DVLH T
&]DVRSU]HVWU]H ZRNyá F]DUQHM G]LXU\ PD ZLHOH RVREOLZ\FK ZáDVQRFL -HGQ ] QLFK MHVW W]Z
NRáRZDRUELWDIRWRQX2ND]XMHVL *HZRGOHJáRFL
G
R
2
IRWRQZ\SXV]F]RQ\VW\F]QLHGRRNU JX
ZRNyá F]DUQHM G]LXU\ E G]LH M RELHJDá SR W\P RNU JX GOD RUELW R SURPLHQLX
G
R
2
IRWRQ
ZSDGQLHMX*GRF]DUQHMG]LXU\3RQLHZD*MDNZLHP\ZLDWáRELHJQLH]DZV]HSRGURG]HQDMNUyWV]HM
ZLG]LP\ZL F*HJHRPHWULDF]DVRSU]HVWU]HQLZRNyáF]DUQHMG]LXU\MHVWWDND*HQDMNUyWV]GURJQLH
MHVWHXNOLGHVRZDSURVWDOHF]OLQLDNU]\ZD²ZV]F]HJyOQRFLQSRNUJ
1DMSUDZGRSRGREQLHM EDUG]R PDV\ZQH JZLD]G\ R PDVDFK SRQDG G]LHVL FLRNURWQLH ZL NV]\FK RG
PDV\ 6áRFD NRF] VZ HZROXFM ]DSDGDMF VL GR F]DUQ\FK G]LXU $VWURQRPRZLH ]QDM NLOND
SU]\SDGNyZ REVHUZDF\MQ\FK PRFQR SRGHMU]DQ\FK R LVWQLHQLH WDNLFK ZáDQLH RELHNWyZ 5yZQLH* Z
MGUDFKJDODNW\NRUD]NZD]DUyZVSRG]LHZDQH V W]Z VXSHUPDV\ZQH F]DUQH G]LXU\ R PDVDFK U] GX
GR
PDV6áRFD
SURI-HU]\6LNRUVNL
,QVW\WXW)L]\NL7HRUHW\F]QHML$VWURIL]\NL
8QLZHUV\WHW*GDVNL
HPDLOIL]MNV#LIWLDXQLYJGDSO