1

AC@;6E@7C6663@@<

5($/,=$d®2

7+(+,6725<2)(1*/$1'

-DQH$XVWHQ

+(15<WKHWK

+HQU\WKHWKDVFHQGHGWKHWKURQHRI(QJODQGPXFKWRKLVRZQ

VDWLVIDFWLRQLQWKH\HDUDIWHUKDYLQJSUHYDLOHGRQKLV

FRXVLQDQGSUHGHFHVVRU5LFKDUGWKHQGWRUHVLJQLWWRKLPDQG

WRUHWLUHIRUWKHUHVWRIKLVOLIHWR3RPIUHW&DVWOHZKHUHKH

KDSSHQHGWREHPXUGHUHG,WLVWREHVXSSRVHGWKDW+HQU\ZDV

PDUULHGVLQFHKHKDGFHUWDLQO\IRXUVRQVEXWLWLVQRWLQP\

SRZHUWRLQIRUPWKH5HDGHUZKRZDVKLVZLIH%HWKLVDVLWPD\

KHGLGQRWOLYHIRUHYHUEXWIDOOLQJLOOKLVVRQWKH3ULQFHRI

:DOHVFDPHDQGWRRNDZD\WKHFURZQZKHUHXSRQWKH.LQJPDGHD

ORQJVSHHFKIRUZKLFK,PXVWUHIHUWKH5HDGHUWR6KDNHVSHDUV

3OD\VDQGWKH3ULQFHPDGHDVWLOOORQJHU7KLQJVEHLQJWKXV

VHWWOHGEHWZHHQWKHPWKH.LQJGLHGDQGZDVVXFFHHGHGE\KLVVRQ

+HQU\ZKRKDGSUHYLRXVO\EHDW6LU:LOOLDP*DVFRLJQH

+(15<WKHWK

7KLV3ULQFHDIWHUKHVXFFHHGHGWRWKHWKURQHJUHZTXLWHUHIRUPHG

DQGDPLDEOHIRUVDNLQJDOOKLVGLVVLSDWHGFRPSDQLRQVDQGQHYHU

WKUDVKLQJ6LU:LOOLDPDJDLQ'XULQJKLVUHLJQ/RUG&REKDPZDV

2

EXUQWDOLYHEXW,IRUJHWZKDWIRU+LV0DMHVW\WKHQWXUQHGKLV

WKRXJKWVWR)UDQFHZKHUHKHZHQWDQGIRXJKWWKHIDPRXV%DWWOHRI

$JLQFRXUW+HDIWHUZDUGVPDUULHGWKH.LQJVGDXJKWHU&DWKHULQH

DYHU\DJUHDEOHZRPDQE\6KDNHVSHDUVDFFRXQW,QVSLWHRIDOO

WKLVKRZHYHUKHGLHGDQGZDVVXFFHHGHGE\KLVVRQ+HQU\

+(15<WKHWK

,FDQQRWVD\PXFKIRUWKLV0RQDUFKVVHQVH1RUZRXOG,LI,

FRXOGIRUKHZDVD/DQFDVWULDQ,VXSSRVH\RXNQRZDOODERXW

WKH:DUVEHWZHHQKLPDQGWKH'XNHRI<RUNZKRZDVRIWKHULJKW

VLGHLI\RXGRQRW\RXKDGEHWWHUUHDGVRPHRWKHU+LVWRU\IRU

,VKDOOQRWEHYHU\GLIIXVHLQWKLVPHDQLQJE\LWRQO\WRYHQW

P\VSOHHQ$*$,167DQGVKHZP\+DWUHG72DOOWKRVHSHRSOHZKRVH

SDUWLHVRUSULQFLSOHVGRQRWVXLWZLWKPLQHDQGQRWWRJLYH

LQIRUPDWLRQ7KLV.LQJPDUULHG0DUJDUHWRI$QMRXD:RPDQZKRVH

GLVWUHVVHVDQGPLVIRUWXQHVZHUHVRJUHDWDVDOPRVWWRPDNHPHZKR

KDWHKHUSLW\KHU,WZDVLQWKLVUHLJQWKDW-RDQRI$UFOLYHG

DQGPDGHVXFKD52:DPRQJWKH(QJOLVK7KH\VKRXOGQRWKDYH

EXUQWKHUEXWWKH\GLG7KHUHZHUHVHYHUDO%DWWOHVEHWZHHQWKH

<RUNLVWVDQG/DQFDVWULDQVLQZKLFKWKHIRUPHUDVWKH\RXJKW

XVXDOO\FRQTXHUHG$WOHQJWKWKH\ZHUHHQWLUHO\RYHUFRPH7KH

.LQJZDVPXUGHUHG7KH4XHHQZDVVHQWKRPHDQG(GZDUGWKHWK

DVFHQGHGWKH7KURQH

(':$5'WKHWK

7KLV0RQDUFKZDVIDPRXVRQO\IRUKLV%HDXW\DQGKLV&RXUDJHRI

ZKLFKWKH3LFWXUHZHKDYHKHUHJLYHQRIKLPDQGKLVXQGDXQWHG

%HKDYLRXULQPDUU\LQJRQH:RPDQZKLOHKHZDVHQJDJHGWRDQRWKHU

DUHVXIILFLHQWSURRIV+LV:LIHZDV(OL]DEHWK:RRGYLOOHD:LGRZ

ZKRSRRU:RPDQZDVDIWHUZDUGVFRQILQHGLQD&RQYHQWE\WKDW

0RQVWHURI,QLTXLW\DQG$YDULFH+HQU\WKHWK2QHRI(GZDUGV

0LVWUHVVHVZDV-DQH6KRUHZKRKDVKDGDSOD\ZULWWHQDERXWKHU

EXWLWLVDWUDJHG\DQGWKHUHIRUHQRWZRUWKUHDGLQJ+DYLQJ

SHUIRUPHGDOOWKHVHQREOHDFWLRQVKLV0DMHVW\GLHGDQGZDV

VXFFHHGHGE\KLVVRQ

(':$5'WKHWK

7KLVXQIRUWXQDWH3ULQFHOLYHGVROLWWOHDZKLOHWKDWQRERG\KDG

3

KLPWRGUDZKLVSLFWXUH+HZDVPXUGHUHGE\KLV8QFOHV

&RQWULYDQFHZKRVHQDPHZDV5LFKDUGWKHUG

5,&+$5'WKHUG

7KH&KDUDFWHURIWKLV3ULQFHKDVEHHQLQJHQHUDOYHU\VHYHUHO\

WUHDWHGE\+LVWRULDQVEXWDVKHZDVD<25.,DPUDWKHULQFOLQHG

WRVXSSRVHKLPDYHU\UHVSHFWDEOH0DQ,WKDVLQGHHGEHHQ

FRQILGHQWO\DVVHUWHGWKDWKHNLOOHGKLVWZR1HSKHZVDQGKLV:LIH

EXWLWKDVDOVREHHQGHFODUHGWKDWKHGLGQRWNLOOKLVWZR

1HSKHZVZKLFK,DPLQFOLQHGWREHOHLYHWUXHDQGLIWKLVLVWKH

FDVHLWPD\DOVREHDIILUPHGWKDWKHGLGQRWNLOOKLV:LIHIRU

LI3HUNLQ:DUEHFNZDVUHDOO\WKH'XNHRI<RUNZK\PLJKWQRW

/DPEHUW6LPQHOEHWKH:LGRZRI5LFKDUG:KHWKHULQQRFHQWRU

JXLOW\KHGLGQRWUHLJQORQJLQSHDFHIRU+HQU\7XGRU(RI

5LFKPRQGDVJUHDWDYLOODLQDVHYHUOLYHGPDGHDJUHDWIXVV

DERXWJHWWLQJWKH&URZQDQGKDYLQJNLOOHGWKH.LQJDWWKHEDWWOH

RI%RVZRUWKKHVXFFHHGHGWRLW

+(15<WKHWK

7KLV0RQDUFKVRRQDIWHUKLVDFFHVVLRQPDUULHGWKH3ULQFHVV

(OL]DEHWKRI<RUNE\ZKLFKDOOLDQFHKHSODLQO\SURYHGWKDWKH

WKRXJKWKLVRZQULJKWLQIHULRUWRKHUVWKRKHSUHWHQGHGWRWKH

FRQWUDU\%\WKLV0DUULDJHKHKDGWZRVRQVDQGWZRGDXJKWHUV

WKHHOGHURIZKLFK'DXJKWHUVZDVPDUULHGWRWKH.LQJRI6FRWODQG

DQGKDGWKHKDSSLQHVVRIEHLQJJUDQGPRWKHUWRRQHRIWKHILUVW

&KDUDFWHUVLQWKH:RUOG%XWRI+(5,VKDOOKDYHRFFDVLRQWR

VSHDNPRUHDWODUJHLQIXWXUH7KH\RXQJHVW0DU\PDUULHGILUVW

WKH.LQJRI)UDQFHDQGVHFRQGO\WKH'RI6XIIRONE\ZKRPVKH

KDGRQHGDXJKWHUDIWHUZDUGVWKH0RWKHURI/DG\-DQH*UH\ZKR

WKRLQIHULRUWRKHUORYHO\&RXVLQWKH4XHHQRI6FRWVZDV\HWDQ

DPLDEOH\RXQJZRPDQDQGIDPRXVIRUUHDGLQJ*UHHNZKLOHRWKHU

SHRSOHZHUHKXQWLQJ,WZDVLQWKHUHLJQRI+HQU\WKHWKWKDW

3HUNLQ:DUEHFNDQG/DPEHUW6LPQHOEHIRUHPHQWLRQHGPDGHWKHLU

DSSHDUDQFHWKHIRUPHURIZKRPZDVVHWLQWKHVWRFNVWRRN

VKHOWHULQ%HDXOLHX$EEH\DQGZDVEHKHDGHGZLWKWKH(DUORI

:DUZLFNDQGWKHODWWHUZDVWDNHQLQWRWKH.LQJVNLWFKHQ+LV

0DMHVW\GLHGDQGZDVVXFFHHGHGE\KLVVRQ+HQU\ZKRVHRQO\PHULW

ZDVKLVQRWEHLQJTXLWHVREDGDVKLVGDXJKWHU(OL]DEHWK

4

+(15<WKHWK

,WZRXOGEHDQDIIURQWWRP\5HDGHUVZHUH,WRVXSSRVHWKDWWKH\

ZHUHQRWDVZHOODFTXDLQWHGZLWKWKHSDUWLFXODUVRIWKLV.LQJV

UHLJQDV,DPP\VHOI,WZLOOWKHUHIRUHEHVDYLQJ7+(0WKHWDVN

RIUHDGLQJDJDLQZKDWWKH\KDYHUHDGEHIRUHDQG0<6(/)WKH

WURXEOHRIZULWLQJZKDW,GRQRWSHUIHFWO\UHFROOHFWE\JLYLQJ

RQO\DVOLJKWVNHWFKRIWKHSULQFLSDO(YHQWVZKLFKPDUNHGKLV

UHLJQ$PRQJWKHVHPD\EHUDQNHG&DUGLQDO:ROVH\VWHOOLQJWKH

IDWKHU$EERWWRI/HLFHVWHU$EEH\WKDWKHZDVFRPHWROD\KLV

ERQHVDPRQJWKHPWKHUHIRUPDWLRQLQ5HOLJLRQDQGWKH.LQJV

ULGLQJWKURXJKWKHVWUHHWVRI/RQGRQZLWK$QQD%XOOHQ,WLV

KRZHYHUEXW-XVWLFHDQGP\'XW\WRGHFODUHWKDWWKLVDPLDEOH

:RPDQZDVHQWLUHO\LQQRFHQWRIWKH&ULPHVZLWKZKLFKVKHZDV

DFFXVHGDQGRIZKLFKKHU%HDXW\KHU(OHJDQFHDQGKHU

6SULJKWOLQHVVZHUHVXIILFLHQWSURRIVQRWWRPHQWLRQKHUVROHPQ

3URWHVWDWLRQVRI,QQRFHQFHWKHZHDNQHVVRIWKH&KDUJHVDJDLQVW

KHUDQGWKH.LQJV&KDUDFWHUDOORIZKLFKDGGVRPH

FRQILUPDWLRQWKRSHUKDSVEXWVOLJKWRQHVZKHQLQFRPSDULVRQ

ZLWKWKRVHEHIRUHDOOHGJHGLQKHUIDYRXU7KR,GRQRWSURIHVV

JLYLQJPDQ\GDWHV\HWDV,WKLQNLWSURSHUWRJLYHVRPHDQG

VKDOORIFRXUVHPDNHFKRLFHRIWKRVHZKLFKLWLVPRVWQHFHVVDU\

IRUWKH5HDGHUWRNQRZ,WKLQNLWULJKWWRLQIRUPKLPWKDWKHU

OHWWHUWRWKH.LQJZDVGDWHGRQWKHWKRI0D\7KH&ULPHVDQG

&UXHOWLHVRIWKLV3ULQFHZHUHWRRQXPHURXVWREHPHQWLRQHGDV

WKLVKLVWRU\,WUXVWKDVIXOO\VKRZQDQGQRWKLQJFDQEHVDLGLQ

KLVYLQGLFDWLRQEXWWKDWKLVDEROLVKLQJ5HOLJLRXV+RXVHVDQG

OHDYLQJWKHPWRWKHUXLQRXVGHSUHGDWLRQVRIWLPHKDVEHHQRI

LQILQLWHXVHWRWKHODQGVFDSHRI(QJODQGLQJHQHUDOZKLFK

SUREDEO\ZDVDSULQFLSDOPRWLYHIRUKLVGRLQJLWVLQFHRWKHUZLVH

ZK\VKRXOGD0DQZKRZDVRIQR5HOLJLRQKLPVHOIEHDWVRPXFK

WURXEOHWRDEROLVKRQHZKLFKKDGIRUDJHVEHHQHVWDEOLVKHGLQWKH

.LQJGRP+LV0DMHVW\VWK:LIHZDVWKH'XNHRI1RUIRONV1HLFH

ZKRWKRXQLYHUVDOO\DFTXLWWHGRIWKHFULPHVIRUZKLFKVKHZDV

EHKHDGHGKDVEHHQE\PDQ\SHRSOHVXSSRVHGWRKDYHOHGDQ

DEDQGRQHGOLIHEHIRUHKHU0DUULDJHRIWKLVKRZHYHU,KDYHPDQ\

GRXEWVVLQFHVKHZDVDUHODWLRQRIWKDWQREOH'XNHRI1RUIRON

ZKRZDVVRZDUPLQWKH4XHHQRI6FRWODQGVFDXVHDQGZKRDWODVW

IHOODYLFWLPWRLW7KH.LQJVODVWZLIHFRQWULYHGWRVXUYLYH

KLPEXWZLWKGLIILFXOW\HIIHFWHGLW+HZDVVXFFHHGHGE\KLV

RQO\VRQ(GZDUG

(':$5'WKHWK

5

$VWKLVSULQFHZDVRQO\QLQH\HDUVROGDWWKHWLPHRIKLV

)DWKHUVGHDWKKHZDVFRQVLGHUHGE\PDQ\SHRSOHDVWRR\RXQJWR

JRYHUQDQGWKHODWH.LQJKDSSHQLQJWREHRIWKHVDPHRSLQLRQ

KLVPRWKHUV%URWKHUWKH'XNHRI6RPHUVHWZDVFKRVHQ3URWHFWRURI

WKHUHDOPGXULQJKLVPLQRULW\7KLV0DQZDVRQWKHZKROHRID

YHU\DPLDEOH&KDUDFWHUDQGLVVRPHZKDWRIDIDYRXULWHZLWKPH

WKR,ZRXOGE\QRPHDQVSUHWHQGWRDIILUPWKDWKHZDVHTXDOWR

WKRVHILUVWRI0HQ5REHUW(DUORI(VVH['HODPHUHRU*LOSLQ+H

ZDVEHKHDGHGRIZKLFKKHPLJKWZLWKUHDVRQKDYHEHHQSURXGKDG

KHNQRZQWKDWVXFKZDVWKHGHDWKRI0DU\4XHHQRI6FRWODQGEXW

DVLWZDVLPSRVVLEOHWKDWKHVKRXOGEHFRQVFLRXVRIZKDWKDG

QHYHUKDSSHQHGLWGRHVQRWDSSHDUWKDWKHIHOWSDUWLFXODUO\

GHOLJKWHGZLWKWKHPDQQHURILW$IWHUKLVGHFHDVHWKH'XNHRI

1RUWKXPEHUODQGKDGWKHFDUHRIWKH.LQJDQGWKH.LQJGRPDQG

SHUIRUPHGKLVWUXVWRIERWKVRZHOOWKDWWKH.LQJGLHGDQGWKH

.LQJGRPZDVOHIWWRKLVGDXJKWHULQODZWKH/DG\-DQH*UH\ZKR

KDVEHHQDOUHDG\PHQWLRQHGDVUHDGLQJ*UHHN:KHWKHUVKHUHDOO\

XQGHUVWRRGWKDWODQJXDJHRUZKHWKHUVXFKDVWXG\SURFHHGHGRQO\

IURPDQH[FHVVRIYDQLW\IRUZKLFK,EHOHLYHVKHZDVDOZD\V

UDWKHUUHPDUNDEOHLVXQFHUWDLQ:KDWHYHUPLJKWEHWKHFDXVH

VKHSUHVHUYHGWKHVDPHDSSHDUDQFHRINQRZOHGJHDQGFRQWHPSWRI

ZKDWZDVJHQHUDOO\HVWHHPHGSOHDVXUHGXULQJWKHZKROHRIKHU

OLIHIRUVKHGHFODUHGKHUVHOIGLVSOHDVHGZLWKEHLQJDSSRLQWHG

4XHHQDQGZKLOHFRQGXFWLQJWRWKHVFDIIROGVKHZURWHDVHQWHQFH

LQ/DWLQDQGDQRWKHULQ*UHHNRQVHHLQJWKHGHDG%RG\RIKHU

+XVEDQGDFFLGHQWDOO\SDVVLQJWKDWZD\

0$5<

7KLVZRPDQKDGWKHJRRGOXFNRIEHLQJDGYDQFHGWRWKHWKURQHRI

(QJODQGLQVSLWHRIWKHVXSHULRUSUHWHQVLRQV0HULWDQG%HDXW\

RIKHU&RXVLQV0DU\4XHHQRI6FRWODQGDQG-DQH*UH\1RUFDQ,

SLW\WKH.LQJGRPIRUWKHPLVIRUWXQHVWKH\H[SHULHQFHGGXULQJKHU

5HLJQVLQFHWKH\IXOO\GHVHUYHGWKHPIRUKDYLQJDOORZHGKHUWR

VXFFHHGKHU%URWKHUZKLFKZDVDGRXEOHSHLFHRIIROO\VLQFH

WKH\PLJKWKDYHIRUHVHHQWKDWDVVKHGLHGZLWKRXWFKLOGUHQVKH

ZRXOGEHVXFFHHGHGE\WKDWGLVJUDFHWRKXPDQLW\WKDWSHVWRI

VRFLHW\(OL]DEHWK0DQ\ZHUHWKHSHRSOHZKRIHOOPDUW\UVWRWKH

SURWHVWDQW5HOLJLRQGXULQJKHUUHLJQ,VXSSRVHQRWIHZHUWKDQD

GR]HQ6KHPDUULHG3KLOLS.LQJRI6SDLQZKRLQKHUVLVWHUV

UHLJQZDVIDPRXVIRUEXLOGLQJ$UPDGDV6KHGLHGZLWKRXWLVVXH

DQGWKHQWKHGUHDGIXOPRPHQWFDPHLQZKLFKWKHGHVWUR\HURIDOO

6

FRPIRUWWKHGHFHLWIXO%HWUD\HURIWUXVWUHSRVHGLQKHUDQGWKH

0XUGHUHVVRIKHU&RXVLQVXFFHHGHGWRWKH7KURQH

(/,=$%(7+

,WZDVWKHSHFXOLDUPLVIRUWXQHRIWKLV:RPDQWRKDYHEDG

0LQLVWHUV6LQFHZLFNHGDVVKHKHUVHOIZDVVKHFRXOGQRWKDYH

FRPPLWWHGVXFKH[WHQVLYHPLVFKHLIKDGQRWWKHVHYLOHDQG

DEDQGRQHG0HQFRQQLYHGDWDQGHQFRXUDJHGKHULQKHU&ULPHV,

NQRZWKDWLWKDVE\PDQ\SHRSOHEHHQDVVHUWHGDQGEHOHLYHGWKDW

/RUG%XUOHLJK6LU)UDQFLV:DOVLQJKDPDQGWKHUHVWRIWKRVHZKR

ILOOHGWKHFKHLIRIILFHVRI6WDWHZHUHGHVHUYLQJH[SHULHQFHG

DQGDEOH0LQLVWHUV%XWRKKRZEOLQGHGVXFKZULWHUVDQGVXFK

5HDGHUVPXVWEHWRWUXH0HULWWR0HULWGHVSLVHGQHJOHFWHGDQG

GHIDPHGLIWKH\FDQSHUVLVWLQVXFKRSLQLRQVZKHQWKH\UHIOHFW

WKDWWKHVHPHQWKHVHERDVWHGPHQZHUHVXFKVFDQGDOVWRWKHLU

&RXQWU\DQGWKHLUVH[DVWRDOORZDQGDVVLVWWKHLU4XHHQLQ

FRQILQLQJIRUWKHVSDFHRIQLQHWHHQ\HDUVD:20$1ZKRLIWKH

FODLPVRI5HODWLRQVKLSDQG0HULWZHUHRIQRDYDLO\HWDVD4XHHQ

DQGDVRQHZKRFRQGHVFHQGHGWRSODFHFRQILGHQFHLQKHUKDGHYHU\

UHDVRQWRH[SHFWDVVLVWDQFHDQGSURWHFWLRQDQGDWOHQJWKLQ

DOORZLQJ(OL]DEHWKWREULQJWKLVDPLDEOH:RPDQWRDQXQWLPHO\

XQPHULWHGDQGVFDQGDORXV'HDWK&DQDQ\RQHLIKHUHIOHFWVEXW

IRUDPRPHQWRQWKLVEORWWKLVHYHUODVWLQJEORWXSRQWKHLU

XQGHUVWDQGLQJDQGWKHLU&KDUDFWHUDOORZDQ\SUDLVHWR/RUG

%XUOHLJKRU6LU)UDQFLV:DOVLQJKDP"2KZKDWPXVWWKLV

EHZLWFKLQJ3ULQFHVVZKRVHRQO\IUHLQGZDVWKHQWKH'XNHRI

1RUIRONDQGZKRVHRQO\RQHVQRZ0U:KLWDNHU0UV/HIUR\0UV

.QLJKWDQGP\VHOIZKRZDVDEDQGRQHGE\KHUVRQFRQILQHGE\KHU

&RXVLQDEXVHGUHSURDFKHGDQGYLOLILHGE\DOOZKDWPXVWQRWKHU

PRVWQREOHPLQGKDYHVXIIHUHGZKHQLQIRUPHGWKDW(OL]DEHWKKDG

JLYHQRUGHUVIRUKHU'HDWK<HWVKHERUHLWZLWKDPRVWXQVKDNHQ

IRUWLWXGHILUPLQKHUPLQGFRQVWDQWLQKHU5HOLJLRQDQG

SUHSDUHGKHUVHOIWRPHHWWKHFUXHOIDWHWRZKLFKVKHZDVGRRPHG

ZLWKDPDJQDQLPLW\WKDWZRXOGDORQHSURFHHGIURPFRQVFLRXV

,QQRFHQFH$QG\HWFRXOG\RX5HDGHUKDYHEHOHLYHGLWSRVVLEOH

WKDWVRPHKDUGHQHGDQG]HDORXV3URWHVWDQWVKDYHHYHQDEXVHGKHU

IRUWKDWVWHDGIDVWQHVVLQWKH&DWKROLF5HOLJLRQZKLFKUHIOHFWHG

RQKHUVRPXFKFUHGLW"%XWWKLVLVDVWULNLQJSURRIRI7+(,5

QDUURZVRXOVDQGSUHMXGLFHG-XGJHPHQWVZKRDFFXVHKHU6KHZDV

H[HFXWHGLQWKH*UHDW+DOODW)RUWKHULQJD\&DVWOHVDFUHG3ODFH

RQ:HGQHVGD\WKHWKRI)HEUXDU\WRWKHHYHUODVWLQJ

5HSURDFKRI(OL]DEHWKKHU0LQLVWHUVDQGRI(QJODQGLQJHQHUDO

7

,WPD\QRWEHXQQHFHVVDU\EHIRUH,HQWLUHO\FRQFOXGHP\DFFRXQW

RIWKLVLOOIDWHG4XHHQWRREVHUYHWKDWVKHKDGEHHQDFFXVHGRI

VHYHUDOFULPHVGXULQJWKHWLPHRIKHUUHLJQLQJLQ6FRWODQGRI

ZKLFK,QRZPRVWVHULRXVO\GRDVVXUHP\5HDGHUWKDWVKHZDV

HQWLUHO\LQQRFHQWKDYLQJQHYHUEHHQJXLOW\RIDQ\WKLQJPRUHWKDQ

,PSUXGHQFLHVLQWRZKLFKVKHZDVEHWUD\HGE\WKHRSHQQHVVRIKHU

+HDUWKHU<RXWKDQGKHU(GXFDWLRQ+DYLQJ,WUXVWE\WKLV

DVVXUDQFHHQWLUHO\GRQHDZD\HYHU\6XVSLFLRQDQGHYHU\GRXEW

ZKLFKPLJKWKDYHDULVHQLQWKH5HDGHUVPLQGIURPZKDWRWKHU

+LVWRULDQVKDYHZULWWHQRIKHU,VKDOOSURFHHGWRPHQWLRQWKH

UHPDLQLQJ(YHQWVWKDWPDUNHG(OL]DEHWKVUHLJQ,WZDVDERXW

WKLVWLPHWKDW6LU)UDQFLV'UDNHWKHILUVW(QJOLVK1DYLJDWRUZKR

VDLOHGURXQGWKH:RUOGOLYHGWREHWKHRUQDPHQWRIKLV&RXQWU\

DQGKLVSURIHVVLRQ<HWJUHDWDVKHZDVDQGMXVWO\FHOHEUDWHG

DVDVDLORU,FDQQRWKHOSIRUHVHHLQJWKDWKHZLOOEHHTXDOOHGLQ

WKLVRUWKHQH[W&HQWXU\E\RQHZKRWKRQRZEXW\RXQJDOUHDG\

SURPLVHVWRDQVZHUDOOWKHDUGHQWDQGVDQJXLQHH[SHFWDWLRQVRI

KLV5HODWLRQVDQG)UHLQGVDPRQJVWZKRP,PD\FODVVWKHDPLDEOH

/DG\WRZKRPWKLVZRUNLVGHGLFDWHGDQGP\QROHVVDPLDEOHVHOI

7KRXJKRIDGLIIHUHQWSURIHVVLRQDQGVKLQLQJLQDGLIIHUHQW

VSKHUHRI/LIH\HWHTXDOO\FRQVSLFXRXVLQWKH&KDUDFWHURIDQ

(DUODV'UDNHZDVLQWKDWRID6DLORUZDV5REHUW'HYHUHX[/RUG

(VVH[7KLVXQIRUWXQDWH\RXQJ0DQZDVQRWXQOLNHLQFKDUDFWHUWR

WKDWHTXDOO\XQIRUWXQDWHRQH)5('(5,&'(/$0(5(7KHVLPLOHPD\

EHFDUULHGVWLOOIDUWKHUDQG(OL]DEHWKWKHWRUPHQWRI(VVH[PD\

EHFRPSDUHGWRWKH(PPHOLQHRI'HODPHUH,WZRXOGEHHQGOHVVWR

UHFRXQWWKHPLVIRUWXQHVRIWKLVQREOHDQGJDOODQW(DUO,WLV

VXIILFLHQWWRVD\WKDWKHZDVEHKHDGHGRQWKHWKRI)HEDIWHU

KDYLQJEHHQ/RUG/LHXWHQDQWRI,UHODQGDIWHUKDYLQJFODSSHGKLV

KDQGRQKLVVZRUGDQGDIWHUSHUIRUPLQJPDQ\RWKHUVHUYLFHVWR

KLV&RXQWU\(OL]DEHWKGLGQRWORQJVXUYLYHKLVORVVDQGGLHG

VRPLVHUDEOHWKDWZHUHLWQRWDQLQMXU\WRWKHPHPRU\RI0DU\,

VKRXOGSLW\KHU

-$0(6WKHVW

7KRXJKWKLV.LQJKDGVRPHIDXOWVDPRQJZKLFKDQGDVWKHPRVW

SULQFLSDOZDVKLVDOORZLQJKLV0RWKHUVGHDWK\HWFRQVLGHUHGRQ

WKHZKROH,FDQQRWKHOSOLNLQJKLP+HPDUULHG$QQHRI'HQPDUN

DQGKDGVHYHUDO&KLOGUHQIRUWXQDWHO\IRUKLPKLVHOGHVWVRQ

3ULQFH+HQU\GLHGEHIRUHKLVIDWKHURUKHPLJKWKDYHH[SHULHQFHG

WKHHYLOVZKLFKEHIHOOKLVXQIRUWXQDWH%URWKHU

8

$V,DPP\VHOISDUWLDOWRWKHURPDQFDWKROLFUHOLJLRQLWLVZLWK

LQILQLWHUHJUHWWKDW,DPREOLJHGWREODPHWKH%HKDYLRXURIDQ\

0HPEHURILW\HW7UXWKEHLQJ,WKLQNYHU\H[FXVDEOHLQDQ

+LVWRULDQ,DPQHFHVVLWDWHGWRVD\WKDWLQWKLVUHLJQWKHURPDQ

&DWKROLFVRI(QJODQGGLGQRWEHKDYHOLNH*HQWOHPHQWRWKH

SURWHVWDQWV7KHLU%HKDYLRXULQGHHGWRWKH5R\DO)DPLO\DQGERWK

+RXVHVRI3DUOLDPHQWPLJKWMXVWO\EHFRQVLGHUHGE\WKHPDVYHU\

XQFLYLODQGHYHQ6LU+HQU\3HUF\WKRFHUWDLQO\WKHEHVWEUHG

PDQRIWKHSDUW\KDGQRQHRIWKDWJHQHUDOSROLWHQHVVZKLFKLVVR

XQLYHUVDOO\SOHDVLQJDVKLVDWWHQWLRQVZHUHHQWLUHO\FRQILQHGWR

/RUG0RXQWHDJOH

6LU:DOWHU5DOHLJKIORXULVKHGLQWKLVDQGWKHSUHFHHGLQJUHLJQ

DQGLVE\PDQ\SHRSOHKHOGLQJUHDWYHQHUDWLRQDQGUHVSHFW%XW

DVKHZDVDQHQHP\RIWKHQREOH(VVH[,KDYHQRWKLQJWRVD\LQ

SUDLVHRIKLPDQGPXVWUHIHUDOOWKRVHZKRPD\ZLVKWREH

DFTXDLQWHGZLWKWKHSDUWLFXODUVRIKLVOLIHWR0U6KHULGDQV

SOD\RIWKH&ULWLFZKHUHWKH\ZLOOILQGPDQ\LQWHUHVWLQJ

DQHFGRWHVDVZHOORIKLPDVRIKLVIULHQG6LU&KULVWRSKHU

+DWWRQ+LV0DMHVW\ZDVRIWKDWDPLDEOHGLVSRVLWLRQZKLFK

LQFOLQHVWR)UHLQGVKLSDQGLQVXFKSRLQWVZDVSRVVHVVHGRID

NHHQHUSHQHWUDWLRQLQGLVFRYHULQJ0HULWWKDQPDQ\RWKHUSHRSOH

,RQFHKHDUGDQH[FHOOHQW6KDUDGHRQD&DUSHWRIZKLFKWKH

VXEMHFW,DPQRZRQUHPLQGVPHDQGDV,WKLQNLWPD\DIIRUGP\

5HDGHUVVRPHDPXVHPHQWWR),1',7287,VKDOOKHUHWDNHWKH

OLEHUW\RISUHVHQWLQJLWWRWKHP

6+$5$'(

0\ILUVWLVZKDWP\VHFRQGZDVWR.LQJ-DPHVWKHVWDQG\RX

WUHDGRQP\ZKROH

7KHSULQFLSDOIDYRXULWHVRIKLV0DMHVW\ZHUH&DUZKRZDV

DIWHUZDUGVFUHDWHG(DUORI6RPHUVHWDQGZKRVHQDPHSHUKDSVPD\

KDYHVRPHVKDUHLQWKHDERYHPHQWLRQHG6KDUDGHDQG*HRUJH

9LOOLHUVDIWHUZDUGV'XNHRI%XFNLQJKDP2QKLV0DMHVW\VGHDWK

KHZDVVXFFHHGHGE\KLVVRQ&KDUOHV

&+$5/(6WKHVW

7KLVDPLDEOH0RQDUFKVHHPVERUQWRKDYHVXIIHUHGPLVIRUWXQHV

HTXDOWRWKRVHRIKLVORYHO\*UDQGPRWKHUPLVIRUWXQHVZKLFKKH

FRXOGQRWGHVHUYHVLQFHKHZDVKHUGHVFHQGDQW1HYHUFHUWDLQO\

9

ZHUHWKHUHEHIRUHVRPDQ\GHWHVWDEOH&KDUDFWHUVDWRQHWLPHLQ

(QJODQGDVLQWKLV3HULRGRILWV+LVWRU\QHYHUZHUHDPLDEOHPHQ

VRVFDUFH7KHQXPEHURIWKHPWKURXJKRXWWKHZKROH.LQJGRP

DPRXQWLQJRQO\WR),9(EHVLGHVWKHLQKDELWDQWVRI2[IRUGZKR

ZHUHDOZD\VOR\DOWRWKHLU.LQJDQGIDLWKIXOWRKLVLQWHUHVWV

7KHQDPHVRIWKLVQREOHILYHZKRQHYHUIRUJRWWKHGXW\RIWKH

VXEMHFWRUVZHUYHGIURPWKHLUDWWDFKPHQWWRKLV0DMHVW\ZHUHDV

IROORZV7KH.LQJKLPVHOIHYHUVWHGIDVWLQKLVRZQVXSSRUW

$UFKELVKRS/DXG(DUORI6WUDIIRUG9LVFRXQW)DXONODQGDQG'XNH

RI2UPRQGZKRZHUHVFDUFHO\OHVVVWUHQXRXVRU]HDORXVLQWKH

FDXVH:KLOHWKH9,//,$16RIWKHWLPHZRXOGPDNHWRRORQJDOLVW

WREHZULWWHQRUUHDG,VKDOOWKHUHIRUHFRQWHQWP\VHOIZLWK

PHQWLRQLQJWKHOHDGHUVRIWKH*DQJ&URPZHOO)DLUID[+DPSGHQ

DQG3\PPD\EHFRQVLGHUHGDVWKHRULJLQDO&DXVHUVRIDOOWKH

GLVWXUEDQFHV'LVWUHVVHVDQG&LYLO:DUVLQZKLFK(QJODQGIRU

PDQ\\HDUVZDVHPEURLOHG,QWKLVUHLJQDVZHOODVLQWKDWRI

(OL]DEHWK,DPREOLJHGLQVSLWHRIP\DWWDFKPHQWWRWKH6FRWFK

WRFRQVLGHUWKHPDVHTXDOO\JXLOW\ZLWKWKHJHQHUDOLW\RIWKH

(QJOLVKVLQFHWKH\GDUHGWRWKLQNGLIIHUHQWO\IURPWKHLU

6RYHUHLJQWRIRUJHWWKH$GRUDWLRQZKLFKDV678$576LWZDVWKHLU

'XW\WRSD\WKHPWRUHEHODJDLQVWGHWKURQHDQGLPSULVRQWKH

XQIRUWXQDWH0DU\WRRSSRVHWRGHFHLYHDQGWRVHOOWKHQROHVV

XQIRUWXQDWH&KDUOHV7KH(YHQWVRIWKLV0RQDUFKVUHLJQDUHWRR

QXPHURXVIRUP\SHQDQGLQGHHGWKHUHFLWDORIDQ\(YHQWVH[FHSW

ZKDW,PDNHP\VHOILVXQLQWHUHVWLQJWRPHP\SULQFLSDOUHDVRQ

IRUXQGHUWDNLQJWKH+LVWRU\RI(QJODQGEHLQJWR3URYHWKH

LQQRFHQFHRIWKH4XHHQRI6FRWODQGZKLFK,IODWWHUP\VHOIZLWK

KDYLQJHIIHFWXDOO\GRQHDQGWRDEXVH(OL]DEHWKWKR,DPUDWKHU

IHDUIXORIKDYLQJIDOOHQVKRUWLQWKHODWWHUSDUWRIP\VFKHPH

$VWKHUHIRUHLWLVQRWP\LQWHQWLRQWRJLYHDQ\SDUWLFXODU

DFFRXQWRIWKHGLVWUHVVHVLQWRZKLFKWKLV.LQJZDVLQYROYHG

WKURXJKWKHPLVFRQGXFWDQG&UXHOW\RIKLV3DUOLDPHQW,VKDOO

VDWLVI\P\VHOIZLWKYLQGLFDWLQJKLPIURPWKH5HSURDFKRI

$UELWUDU\DQGW\UDQQLFDO*RYHUQPHQWZLWKZKLFKKHKDVRIWHQEHHQ

FKDUJHG7KLV,IHHOLVQRWGLIILFXOWWREHGRQHIRUZLWKRQH

DUJXPHQW,DPFHUWDLQRIVDWLVI\LQJHYHU\VHQVLEOHDQGZHOO

GLVSRVHGSHUVRQZKRVHRSLQLRQVKDYHEHHQSURSHUO\JXLGHGE\D

JRRG(GXFDWLRQDQGWKLV$UJXPHQWLVWKDWKHZDVD678$57

)LQLV

6DWXUGD\1RYWK

&RS\ULJKW‹YLUWXDOERRNVFRPEU

7RGRVRVGLUHLWRVUHVHUYDGRVD(GLWRUD9LUWXDO%RRNV2QOLQH00(GLWRUHV/WGD

10

eSURLELGDDUHSURGXomRGRFRQWH~GRGHVWDSiJLQDHPTXDOTXHUPHLRGHFRPXQLFDomR

HOHWU{QLFRRXLPSUHVVRVHPDXWRUL]DomRHVFULWDGD(GLWRUD