E\,]DEHOD.LHODQ
ZZZZ\FKRZDQLHIL]\F]QHSO
3LODWHVMHVWGODND*GHJR
2SUDFRZDQLHPJU,]DEHOD.LHODQ
Ä7HUD]MX* ZLHP± QLHPRJ VL P\OLü&Dá\NUDM
FDá\ZLDWSRZLQLHQZ\NRQ\ZDüPRMHüZLF]HQLD
:WHG\OXG]LHEG V]F]OLZVL´
-RVHSK3LODWHV
0HWRGD3LODWHVDSRZVWDáDZODWDFKGZXG]LHVW\FK;;ZLHNXDQD]ZDMHMSRFKRG]LRG
QD]ZLVNDMHMWZyUF\-RVHSKD3LODWHVD8URG]RQ\Z1LHPF]HFKZURNXZG]LHFLVWZLH
E\á VFKRURZDQ\P FKáRSFHP &KRURZDá QD DVWP NU]\ZLF L JRUF]N UHXPDW\F]Q 7H
FKRURE\ L VáDED NRQG\FMD VSUDZLá\ *H ]DF]á SRV]XNLZDü PHWRG\ NWyUD SRPRJáDE\ PX
]ZDOF]\ü MHJR GROHJOLZRFL : XSUDZLDQLX VSRUWX ZLG]LDá VSRVyE QD ]EXGRZDQLH W*\]Q\
IL]\F]QHM =DLQWHUHVRZDá VL JLPQDVW\N 8SUDZLDá QDUFLDUVWZR ERNV L DWOHW\N
=DLQWU\JRZDáDJRIL]MRQRPLDOXG]NLHJRRUJDQL]PXD]ZáDV]F]DXNáDGPLQLRZ\6WXGLRZDá
PHWRG\'DOHNLHJR:VFKRGXWDNLHMDNMRJDGODWHJRZáDQLHQLHNWyUHSR]\FMHZSLODWHVLHV WDN
EDUG]R SRGREQH GR MRJL FKRü ]DVDGD MHVW MHGQDN WURV]N LQQD :RMQD SRPLG]\ $QJOL L
1LHPFDPL NWyUD Z\EXFKáD Z URNX SU]HUZDáD MHJR NDULHU =DPNQLW\ Z RER]LH
MHQLHFNLP -RVHSK Z\P\ODá üZLF]HQLD GOD XWU]\PDQLD VLHELH L VZRLFK ZVSyáZL(QLyZ Z
GREUHMNRQG\FML
: URNX JG\ HSLGHPLD JU\S\ ]DELáD Z $QJOLL W\VLFH RVyE üZLF]HQLD 3LODWHVD
SRPRJá\ XFKURQLü RVDG]RQ\FK Z RER]LH QDMEOL*V]\FK -RVHSKD 3R ]DNRF]HQLX ZRMQ\ L
XZROQLHQLXZUyFLáGR1LHPLHF7DPSRW\PFRVL Z\GDU]\áRZRER]LHSUDFRZDáQDGVZRM
PHWRG MHV]F]H]DFLHNOHM=DF]áXF]\üWDQFHU]\3RNUyWNLPF]DVLHVWDáVL DXWRU\WHWHPZLFK
URGRZLVNX:URNXRWU]\PDáUR]ND] DE\]DMáVL WUHQRZDQLHPQLHPLHFNLHMDUPLL7R
QLH VSRGREDáR VL 3LODWHVRZL L E\áR SRZRGHP QDW\FKPLDVWRZHJR Z\MD]GX GR 6WDQyZ
=MHGQRF]RQ\FK5D]HP]SLHOJQLDUNNWyUDSy(QLHM]RVWDáDMHJR*RQSRVWDQRZLOLZVSyOQLH
RWZRU]\ü]DNáDGJLPQDVW\F]Q\:\NV]WDáFLáZLHOXQDMOHSV]\FKWUHQHUyZNWyU]\]RVWDZLOLSR
VRELHZLHG]HQDWHPDWMHJRUHZROXF\MQHMPHWRG\LQDSU]HVWU]HQLODWGRVWRVRZDOLPHWRG GR
G]LVLHMV]\FKQDV]\FKSRWU]HE
']LVLDM 3LODWHV MHVW FRUD] EDUG]LHM SRSXODUQ\ , FKRFLD* SRF]WNRZR üZLF]HQLD WH
VáX*\á\ NRQWX]MRZDQ\P WDQFHU]RP L VSRUWRZFRP E\ PRJOL ]DFKRZDü NRQG\FM L V]\EFLHM
SRZUyFLüGRDNW\ZQ\FKWUHQLQJyZG]LVLDMMHVWMHGQD]QDMEH]SLHF]QLHMV]\FKIRUPUXFKRZ\FK
EGF\FK Z RIHUFLH ILWQHVVNOXEyZ 3RF]WNXMFH L UHGQLR]DDZDQVRZDQH RVRE\ üZLF] QD
UR]áR*RQHM QD SRGáRG]H PDFLH PDWEDVHG 3LODWHV GOD ]DDZDQVRZDQ\FK SU]H]QDF]RQH V
üZLF]HQLD Z\NRQ\ZDQH QDVSU]FLHHTXLSPHQWEDVHG3LODWHV3RGF]DVWUHQLQJXWUZDMFHJR
PDNV\PDOQLH JRG]LQ\ Z\NRQXMH VL üZLF]HQLD Z\EUDQH ] ]HVWDZX SRQDG SLFLXVHW
üZLF]HNWyUHZFKRG] ZVNáDGWHMPHWRG\,FKLORüLUy*QRURGQRüVSUDZLD*HüZLF]F\QLH
PRJ VL QXG]Lü
0HWRGD 3LODWHVD PD ]D ]DGDQLH VWZRU]HQLH UyZQRZDJL Z FLHOH -HVW WR SRáF]HQLH
WUHQLQJXXP\VáXLFLDáDGOD]DSHZQLHQLDSUDZLGáRZHMV\OZHWNLûZLF]HQLDZ\NRQ\ZDQHSU]\
G(ZLNDFK áDJRGQHM PX]\NL SRZRGXM RGSU*HQLH L áDJRG] VNXWNL VWUHVX *áyZQ ]DOHW
PHWRG\3LODWHVDMHVWHIHNW\ZQRü5R]FLJDQLHVSLQDQLHLUR]OX(QLDQLH]DUyZQRGX*\FKMDNL
PDá\FK JUXS PLQLRZ\FK SRZRGXMH LFK Z]PRFQLHQLH L XHODVW\F]QLHQLH 6\OZHWND VWDMH VL
VPXNáDDFKyGVSU*\VW\
-DNRüüZLF]H MHVWEDUG]RZD*QD0HWRGD3LODWHVDZ\PDJDVNXSLHQLDLNRQFHQWUDFML
5XFK\ V SRZROQH EDUG]R GRNáDGQH L R QLHZLHONLP ]DVLJX ûZLF]F\ PXV] UyZQLH*
NRQWURORZDüSU]HSRQ LSRGF]DVRGG\FKDQLDZ\NRU]\VW\ZDü*HEUDLNODWN SLHUVLRZ
E\,]DEHOD.LHODQ
ZZZZ\FKRZDQLHIL]\F]QHSO
ûZLF]HQLD3LODWHVDPR*HZ\NRQ\ZDüND*G\%UDNSRGVNRNyZLJZDáWRZQ\FKUXFKyZ
SRZRGXMH*HMHVWWREDUG]RGREUDPHWRGDGODRVyE]FKRUREDPLVWDZyZEyODPLNUJRVáXSD
QDGZDJ LGODRVyEEH]NRQG\FMLIL]\F]QHM
*áyZQHNRU]\FLMDNLHGDMHQDPPHWRGD3LODWHVDWR
SRSUDZDHODVW\F]QRFLLUHODNVDFMDFDáHJRFLDáD
]ZLNV]HQLH VLá\ PLQL Z V]F]HJyOQRFL PLQL EU]XFKD GROQHM F]FL SOHFyZ
ELRGHU LSRODGNyZ
Z\GáX*HQLHLZ\VPXNOHQLHPLQL
SRSUDZDNRQWUROLPLQLSOHFyZRUD]NRF]\Q
Z\VPXNOHQLHV\OZHWNLLVSDOHQLHWNDQNLWáXV]F]RZHM
SRSUDZDVWDELOQRFLNUJRVáXSD
]ZLNV]HQLHZLDGRPRFLVZRMHJRFLDáD
SUDZLGáRZHRGG\FKDQLH
SRSUDZDNRRUG\QDFMLUXFKRZ LUyZQRZDJL
UR]OX(QLHQLHUDPLRQNDUNXLJyUQHMF]FLSOHFyZ
XHODVW\F]QLHQLHNUJRVáXSDVWDZyZEDUNRZ\FKLELRGURZ\FK
]DSRELHJDQLHNRQWX]MRPLUHKDELOLWDFMDXUD]yZMX* QDE\W\FK
-DNND*G\WUHQLQJPHWRGDWDPDUyZQLH* VZRMH]DVDG\,FKSU]HVWU]HJDQLHSU]\VSLHV]\
ZSá\ZüZLF]H QDV\OZHWN2WRRQH]áRW\FKUHJXá3LODWHVD
]DZV]H]DF]\QDMRGUR]JU]HZNL
QLHVSLHV]VL,PZROQLHMüZLF]\V]W\POHSLHM
üZLF]]JRGQLH]U\WPHPVZHJRRGGHFKX
ZNáDGDMFDá\Z\VLáHNZZ\GHFK
SU]\Z\GHFKXZFLJDMSSHNNXNUJRVáXSRZL
NRQWUROXMVZRM SRVWDZ
NRQFHQWUXMVL QDW\PFRLMDNURELV]
VLá PLQL EU]XFKD UR]ZLMDM SRZROL MH*HOL XZ\SXNODM VL RQH SRGF]DV üZLF]HQLD
]UyESU]HUZ
UXFK UDPLRQ ]DF]\QDM RG PLQL QDMV]HUV]\FK JU]ELHWX L F]ZRURERF]Q\FK
DQLHRGVDP\FKUDPLRQ
ZD*QDMHVWMDNRüDQLHLORü6WRVXMVL GRSRGDQHMOLF]E\SRZWDU]DQ\FKüZLF]H
üZLF]HQLD3LODWHVDZ\NRQXMUHJXODUQLHQDMOHSLHMFRG]LHQQLH
W\ONRG]LNLZ\WUZDáRFLX]\VNDV]áDGQ L]JUDEQ V\OZHWN
$RWRSU]\NáDG\NLONXüZLF]H ]DF]HUSQLW\FK]PHWRG\3LODWHVD
ûZLF]HQLHQU± W]ZÄVHWND´
&HO üZLF]HQLD Z]PDFQLD PP EU]XFKD UR]JU]HZD FLDáR SU]HG LQQ\PL üZLF]HQLDPL GRGDMH
HQHUJLL
3: OH*HQLHW\áHPQRJLXQLHVLRQHGRSLRQXVWRS\UR]OX(QLRQH:HUVMDáDWZLHMV]DQRJLXJLWH
Z VWDZDFK NRODQRZ\FK SRG NDWHP SURVW\P UDPLRQD Z]GáX* WXáRZLD XQLHVLRQH NLONDQDFLH
FHQW\PHWUyZ QDG SRGáRJ GáRQLH VNLHURZDQH ZQWU]HP GR GRáX JáRZD V]\MD L áRSDWNL
XQLHVLRQHSLOQXME\PLQLHV]\LLNDUNXQLHE\á\QDSLWHDWXáyZLQRJLE\á\ZEH]UXFKX
58&+ XQLH QLH]QDF]QLH UFH Z NLHUXQNX XG L RSXü MH QLH GRW\NDMF SRGáR*D RGG\FKDM
ZROQR OLF]F GR &Dá\ F]DV NRQWUROXM UXFK :\PLHQLDMF ND*GD NROHMQD OLF]E SRGQR Z
F]DVLHZ\GHFKXUFHE\QDVWSQLHSRGF]DVZGHFKXMHRSXFLü=UyEüZLF]H UNELRUF
RGGHFKyZ$E\URELüSRVWS\ZPLDU MDNF]XMHP\VL VLOQLHMVLPR*HP\RSXV]F]DüQRJL
ZNLHUXQNXSRGáR*D
E\,]DEHOD.LHODQ
ZZZZ\FKRZDQLHIL]\F]QHSO
ûZLF]HQLHQU± ÄSURVWRZDQLHQyJ´
&HO üZLF]HQLD Z]PDFQLD PP EU]XFKD SOHFyZ L PLHGQLF\ VWDELOL]XMH PP GROQHM F]FL
WXáRZLD
3: OH*HQLH W\áHP SUDZD QRJD Z\SURVWRZDQD XQLHVLRQD QDG SRGáRJ OHZD QRJD
]JLWDZNRODQLHLZVWDZLHELRGURZ\PSRGNWHPá\GNDUyZQROHJOHGRSRGáRJLJáRZD
V]\MDLUDPLRQDXQLHVLRQHQDGSRGáRJGáRQLHWU]\PDM SRGXG]LHOHZHMQRJL
58&+ XWU]\PXMF FLDáR Z WHM SR]\FML Z\NRQDM ZGHFK QDSLQDMF GROQ F]ü PP
SRODGNRZ\FK ZHZQWU]QHM L W\OQHM F]FL XGD ]UyE Z\GHFK Z\SURVWXM OHZ QRJ
UyZQRF]HQLH ]JLQDMF SUDZ .RQWUROXM UXFK QDMQL*V]\PL L QDMJáEV]\PL SDUWLDPL PP
EU]XFKD3RZWyU]UD]\
ûZLF]HQLHQU± ÄSá\ZDQLH´
&HO üZLF]HQLD Z]PDFQLD PP EU]XFKD SOHFyZ PLHGQLF\ REUF]\ EDUNRZHM XáDWZLD
VWDELOL]DFM FLDáD
3: OH*HQLH SU]RGHP SURVWH UDPLRQD Z\FLJQLWH Z SU]yG VWRS\ RSDUWH JU]ELHWRZR R
SRGáRJ LUR]VWDZLRQHQDV]HURNRüFP
58&+ FLJQLM áRSDWNL Z\SURVWXM SOHF\ L Z\FLJQLM V]\M ZH( ZGHFK D QDVWSQLH URELF
Z\GHFKQDSQLMPPEU]XFKDMDNE\ZFLJDMFMHGRURGNDWDNE\JyUQDF]üWXáRZLDVWDáDVL
QLHUXFKRPD8QLH UDPLRQDJáRZV]\M LNODWN SLHUVLRZ RUD]QRJLQDZ\VRNRüRNFP
QDG SRGáRJ 5DPLRQDPL L QRJDPL Z\NRQXM QR*\FH SRGQRV]F MHGQRF]HQLH SU]HFLZOHJá
QRJ LUN ]DND*G\PUD]HPQLHFRZ\*HMURGNRZDF]üFLDáDMHVWZEH]UXFKX8QRV]F
NRF]\Q\NRQFHQWUXMVL QDLFKZ\GáX*DQLX3U]\ND*G\PZGHFKXUD]\SRGQR LRSXV]F]DM
NRF]\Q\RUD]UD]\SU]\ND*G\PZ\GHFKX.LHG\]URELV]]DOHFDQDOLF]E SRZWyU]HSU]H]
FKZLO XWU]\PDM FLDáR ] XQLHVLRQ\PL NRF]\QDPL :\NRQDM ZGHFK LZ\G\FKDMFSRZLHWU]H
RSXüJyUQ F]üFLDáDSRWHPQRJL3RZWyU]üZLF]HQLHUD]\1D]DNRF]HQLHREUyüVL QD
SOHF\LSU]\FLJQLMNRODQDGRNODWNLSLHUVLRZHMUR]FLJDMFQDGZ\U*RQHPPSOHFyZ
ûZLF]HQLHQU± ÄPRVW]XQRV]HQLHPSURVWHMQRJL´
&HOüZLF]HQLDZ]PDFQLDPPGROQHMF]FLSOHFyZLREUF]\ELRGURZHM
3: OH*HQLHW\áHPQRJLXJLWHZNRODQDFKVWRS\RSDUWHQDSRGáRG]HWDNE\]QDMGRZDá\VL
SRQL*HMOLQLLNRODQUDPLRQDZ]GáX* WXáRZLDELRGUDXQLHVLRQHGRJyU\WDNE\UD]HP]EDUNDPL
LNRODQDPLWZRU]\á\MHGQ OLQL
58&+URELFZ\GHFKQDSQLMPPEU]XFKDLZ\SURVWXMMHGQ QRJ SRGNWHPSU]HGVRE
3RGF]DVZ\SURVWXQRJLXWU]\PXMELRGUD UyZQROHJOHGRSRGáRJL=UyEZGHFKLZUyüGRSR]\FML
Z\MFLRZHM3RZWyU]üZLF]HQLH± UD]\QDND*G QRJ
ûZLF]HQLHQU± ÄXQRV]HQLHSU]HFLZQHMQRJLLUNLZNONXSRGSDUW\P´
&HO üZLF]HQLD Z]PDFQLD PP SOHFyZ REUF]\ ELRGURZHM L EDUNRZHM VWDELOL]XMH L UR]FLJD
NUJRVáXS
3: NONSRGSDUW\PPEU]XFKDV QDSLWH
58&+ ]UyE Z\GHFK LXQLH SU]HFLZQ UN LQRJ GRJyU\WDNE\NUJRVáXSE\áSURVW\L
Z\GáX*RQ\URELFZGHFKZUyüGRSR]\FMLZ\MFLRZHM=PLH UN LQRJ üZLF]F LSRZWyU]
FDáHüZLF]HQLHUD]\3DPLWDMRSLHUVLRZ\PWRU]HRGG\FKDQLD
0HWRGD 3LODWHVD MHVW LGHDOQ\P VSRVREHP QD XGRVNRQDOHQLH ZáDVQHJR FLDáD OXE
RG]\VNDQLH SHáQHM VSUDZQRFL UXFKRZHM :DUWR VSUyERZDü L SR*HJQDü UD] QD ]DZV]H
XSRUF]\ZH GROHJOLZRFL ]ZL]DQH ] QLHSUDZLGáRZ SRVWDZ -HGQDN VXNFHV MHVW
JZDUDQWRZDQ\W\ONRZWHG\JG\WUHQLQJZ\NRQ\ZDQ\MHVWUHJXODUQLHSU]\QDMPQLHMUD]\
ZW\JRGQLX
E\,]DEHOD.LHODQ
ZZZZ\FKRZDQLHIL]\F]QHSO
0RLP ]GDQLHP ZDUWR Z\NRU]\VWDü üZLF]HQLD 3LODWHVD SRGF]DV ]DMü Z\FKRZDQLD
IL]\F]QHJR 0RJ RQH VWDQRZLü RVREQ MHGQRVWN OHNF\MQ OXE E\ü HOHPHQWHP ]DMü ]
DHURELNX 7HJR W\SX ]DMFLD FLHV] VL SRSXODUQRFL Z JUXSDFK *HVNLFK NODV V]NRá\
JLPQD]MDOQHM L SRGDQJLPQD]MDOQHM :LHP ] GRZLDGF]HQLD *H PáRG]LH* LQWHUHVXMH VL
QRZLQNDPL ] ]DNUHVX NXOWXU\ IL]\F]QHM L FKWQLH SRGHMPXMH QRZH IRUP\ DNW\ZQRFL
UXFKRZHM 3LODWHV VWDMH VL EDUG]R PRGQ\ SU]\QRVL ZLHOH NRU]\FL QLH Z\PDJD VSHFMDOQHM
NRQG\FMLLQDSUDZG PR*HüZLF]\üJRND*G\
/LWHUDWXUD
Ä3LODWHVGODND*GHJR´'HQLV$XVWLQ
Ä3LODWHVNV]WDáWRZDQLHáDGQHMV\OZHWNL´$QQD6HOE\$ODQ+HUPDQ
,QVW\WXW3LODWHVD± KWWSZZZSLODWHVSO