MR.RIGHT
J.S.COOPER
Contents
Mr.Right
J.S.Cooper
NewStandaloneBookfromNewYorkTimesBestsellingAuthorJ.S.Cooper.
Somenightsaremeanttoremainasecret.Somenightsaremeanttobeforfun.Somenightsare
meanttolastjustonenight.Itwasneversupposedtohappen.But,wecouldn’tstopourselves.
Onenightbecametoomany.HewastheonemanIwasn’tsupposedtowant.TheonemanIwasn’t
supposedtohave.TheonemanthatcouldneverpossiblybemyMr.Right.Howeverhe’stheoneman
Ican’tgetoutofmymind.He’stheonemanthat’sgoingtochangeeverything.
Onlyhehasasecretthat’sbiggerthaneverythingelse.Hehasasecretthatcouldruineverything.
Thisbookisaworkoffiction.Anyresemblancetoactualpersons,livingordead,oractualeventsis
entirelycoincidental.Names,characters,businesses,organizations,places,events,andincidentsare
theproductoftheauthor ’simaginationorareusedfictitiously.
Copyright©2016byJ.S.Cooper
EditingbyLoreleiLogsdon
ProofreadingbyProofingstyle
ThisbookisdedicatedtoallthewomenthatarelookingfortheirMr.Right’s.Nevergiveuphopethat
heisoutthere.
A C K N O W L E D G M E N T S
Mr.Rightisabookthatwaswrittenfrommyheart.Iwouldliketothankthefollowingpeopleforall
oftheirhelpasIwrotethisbook.ThanksgoouttoKatrinaJaekley,TanyaKaySkaggs,StacyHahn,
LaciKeenzel,ChantealJustice,PamSnell,CiliciaWhite,BarbaraGoodwin,KristinaHammock,
KathyShreve,AshleyHedden,KristineRoller,Jean,ReganBrown,KarenGonzalez,CarrieRenteria,
ElizabethHe,theSFWritersintheir20’sand30’smeet-upgroup,andGod.
T
P R O L O G U E
herearetenthingsyoushouldknowaboutme:
I’
M
NOT
A
BAD
GUY
.
IwasattractedtoherthemomentIsawher.
Ilovetoteaseher.
IknewIwasplayingwithfire.
Iknewshedidn’tknowthetruth.
Ididn’tcare.
Apartofmewasexcitedbythedanger.
Iknewthesexwouldbeamazing.
Ididn’twanttobeherMr.Right.
Ikneweverythingwouldendinfireworks.
I
HAVE
A
SECRET
.Abigsecret.Abiggersecretthansheinitiallythinks.It’ssobigthatIthinkI’mgoing
tohavetotakebackthefirstthingyouknowaboutme.TheI’mnotabadguycomment.I’mnotso
surethat’strue.MaybeI’malittlebad.OrmaybeI’malotbad.MaybeIjustdon’tknowanymore.
There’sapartofmethatwishesIcouldchangeeverything.Iknowshelovesmebecauseshethinks
I’mperfect.IknowIloveherbecauseIknowshe’simperfect.I’mjustnotsurewhat’sgoingto
happenwhenshefindsoutthetruth.I’mnotsurewhat’sgoingtohappenwhensherealizesexactly
howtwistedthisallreallyis.
P
I N T R O D U C T I O N
ARTI
J
C H A P T E R 1
ess
H
OT
DAMN
,there’sawarmbodypressingintomefrombehind.And—whoa—Ithinkthatwhoever ’s
behindmeisveryhappyI’mawake,ifthehardnesspushingintomybuttisanyindication.Shit,my
eyesareblinkingrapidlyasIthinkbacktothepreviousnight.Toomanycocktails.Andthenthose
glassesofwine.Andthetwobeers.WhatwasIthinking?Oh,shit.Ifrozeasmymindimmediately
rememberedhimslidingintome,deepandhard.Icanpicturehisintenseeyes,hisloudgrowlsas
he’dslammedintome.Oh,fuck,whathadIdone?
“M
ORNING
,Jess,”hewhisperedintomyearashishandslidaroundtograbmybreast.“Readyfor
roundtwo?”HepinchedmynippleandImoanedandclosedmyeyes.Iwasahorribleperson.I
couldn’tbelieveIwashereinbedwithhim.Icouldn’tbelievewe’dhadsex.Shit,Icouldn’tbelieve
weweregoingtohavesexagain.Iwasabad,badgirlforhavingsleptwithhim.Butfuckit,whatwas
thepointofresistingroundtwowhentherehadalreadybeenaroundone?I’dpayformysinslater.
Whatwasdonewasdone.We’dalreadycrossedthelineofnoreturn.
I
NEED
tostartatthebeginning.I’mnotabadperson.ThoughI’mnotagoodpersoneither,obviously.
Imean,lookwhoIsleptwith?I’mnotgoingtotellyouyet.Idon’twantyoutojudgemeandthink
I’mhorrible.I’mnothorrible.Really?I’mprettynice.Imean,IthinkI’mevenprettycool,ina“I
sleptwithsomeoneIshouldn’thaveandkindofregretit”way.I’vegotmostofmyshittogether.I’m
agoodfriend.I’mahardworker.Itryandhelppoorpeople.Thatshouldn’tallbeinvalidatedbecause
Ididonebadthing,right?Soyeah,sueme,IsleptwithsomeoneIshouldn’thave.Butreally,how
couldIsayno?He’shot,sexy,oversixfoot,chiseledchest,sexydimples,lushdarkhairandhehas
handsthatseemtoknowmybodybetterthanIdo.Butsorry,I’mgettingdistracted.IsaidI’dstartat
thebeginning.SoIwill.Maybeyou’llunderstandhowharditwasformetosaynoonceyou
understandthesituationIwasin.Imeandamn,I’mnotsuremanywomenwouldhavebeenableto
resist.Howdoyousaynotothesexiestmanalive?ButlikeIsaid,I’llstartatthebeginning.
MynameisJess.JustJessiswhatmyfriendscallme.I’mnotsurewhy.It’snotlikeitsays
anythingaboutme.Well,nothingexciting.IguessitdoessaythatI’mjustaregulareasy-goinggirl,
becausethatiswhatIam.Idon’thaveawholeheapofthrills.I’mnotdrama-filled.Idon’thookup
withdifferentguyseverynightoftheweek.NotthatI’vehadtheopportunity,tobehonest.Who
knowsifIwouldhaveifdifferenthottieswerethrowingthemselvesatmeeverynightoftheweek.
I’mtwenty-three.Ijustgraduatedfromcollegelastyear.Iworkasasecretaryatalargeaccounting
firm.Yes,thejobisboring.Andno,mybossisnothot.Ilivewithmybestfriend,Alyssa,inadumpy
apartmentinSanFrancisco.Andno,I’mnotexaggerating.Itisdumpy,butIloveit.NotasmuchasI
wouldlovelivinginNewYorkCity,butagirlcan’thaveeverything.IlovemylifeeventhoughI’m
notsuperrichandIdon’thavethejobofmydreams.Ihavemyinsecuritieslikeeveryoneelse,butI
thinkI’mprettylevelheaded.AtleastIwasuntilIgotintothiscrazymess.
Thisstorystartslikemostcrazystoriesstart:atabarwithtwocrazygirls,lookingforafunnight
outandsomeattention.Don’tgetdistractedthough,thisisthebeginning,notthemiddleanddefinitely
nottheend.Bearwithme,you’reabouttogoonacrazy-assridethatyouandIwillneverforget.
Pictureit:SanFrancisco,March,2016.AlyssaandIaresittingaroundinthelivingroomwhen
shehasthebest—andwhenIsaybest,Imeankindoftheworst—ideaever.Andonlyworstbecauseit
endedupwithmefeelinglikethestarofsometitillatingLifetimemovie.
“Let’sgotoacluborabar,areallyniceoneandjustletloose,”Alyssasaidthatnight,hereyes
eagerandwatchingmecarefully.
“Wecan’taffordtogotoareallynicebarorclub,”Iresponded,becauseI’mthepracticaloneand
Iknewthatneitherofushadmuchmoneyinthebank.
“Wecan’taffordtogotoabadbar,either,ifwe’rebeinghonest.”Icontinuedthinkingaboutour
limitedfundsandtriednottocringe.
“Yes,wecan.”Alyssarolledhereyes.“Ihaveacreditcard,youhaveacreditcard.”Alyssahadthe
mentalitythatitdidn’tmatterhowyougotthemoney;ifitwasavailable,itwasabletobespent.Iwas
honestlyquitesurprisedthatshe’dnevertakenajobasanescortorsomething.Though,Isuppose
that’sanunfairstatementtomake.She’snoteasy,justaspendthrift.
“Alyssa,Ihavetwohundredandsixtydollarsinthebank.Youhaveeighty.Wecannotaffordtogo
anywhere.”Ishookmyheadather.
“Ihavetwograndonmycreditcard.Thanks,CapitalOne.”ShegrinnedatmeandIcouldn’tstop
myselffromlaughing,evenasIshookmyhead.
“Dude,wecannotgoout.WeshouldjustwatchNetflixandeatRamen.Youmighthavetwogrand
inavailablecredit,butyou’llstillhavetopayitback.”
“Idon’twannaeatanymoreRamen.”Shegroaned.“And,sorry,Idon’twanttowatchmore
GilmoreGirls.Iwanttogoout.Iwanttomeethotguys.Iwantastrangeguytokissme,feelmeup,
makemefeellikeI’msomehotyoungthing,livinginthecity,livingmylife.AndIhavethirtydays
topayitback.We’lljusttryanddosomeovertimeorsomething.”
“Youareayounghotthing,livinginthecity,livingyourlife.”Igrinnedatherandtriednotto
laughatthepitifullookonherface.“AndIknowplentyofstrangeguysintheTenderlointhatwould
bewillingtokissyou.”
“Yeah,homelessdudeswithbadbreath.Mintybreathisamusthave.”Shegrinnedandthenwinked
atme.“Andtheabilitytotakemeoutforafancydinner,soIdon’thavetoeatRameneverynight.
AndsoIdon’thavetorunupmycreditcardbill.IneedthesortofguyI’dmeetatahotclub.Notona
hotstreetcorner.”
“Hey,whataboutme?”Ipouted.“Idon’twanttoeatRameneverynighteither.”
“I’llbringleftoversforyou,don’tworryaboutit.I’llhookyouup.”Shegiggled.
“Wow,I’msolucky.”Iwinkedather.“Iguess,then,wemustgoouttonight.Let’smaxoutour
creditcardssoyoucanstartbringinghomethoselobsterandsteakmeals.”IshookmyheadasI
spoke,butshecouldtellfrommyvoicethatIhadalreadyrelented.Imean,Iknewitwasabadideato
gooutandusemycreditcardtofundthefun,butifIsaidnotoeverybadideaAlyssaorIhadever
had,thenI’dbesomesortofsaint.Andasaint,I’mnot.Asyou’reabouttofindout.
“Soundslikeaplantome.Whereshallwego?”
“Youtellme,RichieRich’sfuturewife.”Irolledmyeyes.
“Yougotthatright.I’dbeTrump’swifeifitmeantI’dbelivinginthelapofluxury.”Shegrinned.
“LetmehavealookonYelpandseewhat’shot.”
“Yelp?”Iraisedaneyebrowather.“Anyclubsworthgoingintodebtforarenotgoingtobelisted
onYelp.”Icouldfeelmystomachchurning.“Andreally,you’dwanttobeMr.Comb-over ’sfourth
wife?”
“Notreally.I’drathermarryLeonardoDiCaprio.”ShelickedherlipsandIjustshookmyheadat
her.“Alsopraytell,Jess,howarewegoingtofindagreatexclusiveclubwithoutYelp?’Alyssa
lookedatmepointedly.“DoyouhavesomeinsiderknowledgeIdon’tknowabout?”
“Ohyeah,Ihavesomuchinsiderknowledge,it’snotevenfunny.Alltheclubswantmethere
everynighttodanceonthetablesandbringinallthehandsomemen.”Ipulledmyphoneoutofmy
pocket.“Letmeseewhichclubswantmetheretonight.”
“Youcanbringsomehandsomemenbackhere,ifyouwant.”Alyssalaughed.“Afteryoupimp
yourselfoutatthegentlemanbars.”
“Iwant,youwant,buttheydon’twant.”Ilaughed.“Theyneverwant.EvenwhenIpimpmyself
out.”
“Theywant,butthey’rejusttooscaredtotalktoyou.”Alyssalaughedagain.“Theyknowyou’re
tooexpensiveforthem.Menareweaklingsinside.”
“Hmm,Idon’tknowaboutthat?”Imadeaface.“IthinkIcouldbegivingitawayforfreeandstill
getturneddown.”Alyssajustrolledhereyesatmeinresponse.WebothknewthatifIgaveitaway
forfree,I’dhaveplentyoftakers.
“WanttobuynewoutfitsatMacy’sandgetfreemakeoversinthecosmeticsdepartment?”She
grinnedatmeencouragingly.“Wecankeepthetagsonthedressesandreturnthemtomorrowornext
weekorsomething.”
“That’sawful.Youknowthat,right?We’dessentiallybestealing.”
“Yousaytomato,Isaytomaahto,tomato,tomaahto,”AlyssasangandIrolledmyeyes.
“Fine,butonlybecauseIhadashittyweekatworkandwebothneedsomefun.”Itoldyou,it
doesn’ttakemelongtogodownthewrongroad.Notsureifthatmakesmegoodorbad.Orjust
somewherein-betweenlikemosthumanbeings.Thoughmosthumanbeingswouldn’thavedonewhat
Idid.
“Andwe’rebothpooranddeservetowearcutedresses.Poorgirlsneednicethingstoo.”Alyssa
startedsinginganddancingaroundtheroomandIfoundmyselfsmilingathercontagious
enthusiasm.
“Oh,God,wesuck.”Igroanedandcollapsedontothedumpysecondhanddenimcouchthatwe’d
pickedupatasecond-handstoreforfiftydollars.
“Butatleastwe’renotdoingitforcash.”Shefelldownonthecouchnexttome,giggling.
“Doingwhatforcash?”
“Sucking.”Shewinkedatmeandwebothburstoutlaughing.Andthatwashowitbegan.So
innocently.Well,notexactlyinnocently,butyouknowwhatImean.Itwasn’tevenmyideatogotothe
club,soreallyIcan’tbeblamedforeverythingthathappenedbecauseIwenttotheclubthatnight.I’m
notabadgirl.Well,Ididn’tusedtobe.NowIdon’tknowifIcanreallyclaimthatanymore.The
innocentgirlIwasthatnightisnolongerthegirlIam.Idothingsnowthatwouldmakeyoureyes
popopen,thingsthatwouldmakeyougasp,thingsyouwouldn’tevenbelieve.ThingsIwouldn’ttell
myparentsabout.I’mevenashamedtotalkaboutitwithAlyssasometimes,butIcan’tnottalktoher
aboutit.IfIdidn’thaveher,Iwouldn’thaveanyone.Andtrustme,thesituationI’min,it’snota
situationthatIcanjustnottalkaboutwithanyone.Forone,it’stoojuicyandtoocrazy.Andasmuch
asIhatemyselfforwhatI’mdoing,Ialsocan’tstop.
W
E
GOT
intotheritzyclubquiteeasilythatnight.Welookedhot,butthat’swhatfreshmakeoversat
Macy’sandtightshortdresseswilldoforyouwhenyou’reyoungandwillingtowearanything,
whichwewere.IwaswearingashorttightblackLycrapiecethatmademelookasthoughIwason
themake,whichIkindawas,thoughnotreally.Iwasoneofthosegirlsthatlikedtheattention,but
wasn’tlookingtohookup.I’mnotaone-nightstandkindofgirl.Idon’twantaguygropingmeor
rubbinguponme,ortryingtotakemehome.I’mmoreofaromantic.Iwantaguytolookatmeasif
I’mhotstuffand,yeah,hiseyescantellmehewantstosleepwithme,butIwanthimtohavemore
restraint.Ifeellikeaguywithrestraintisaguythatisseeingyouaslong-termpotential.Idon’tknow
ifthat’srightornot,butit’sjustthewaythatIfeel.Imean,itcouldalsomeanthattheguyisgayor
thathe’sjustnotintome.That’showAlyssainterpretsthefactthataguydoesn’twanttosleepwith
herrightaway.Shesaysthatifaguyisintoyou,whetherornothewantsyouformorethanone
night,hewantstosleepwithyou.Ithinkthatdoesn’tmeanhehastoactuponit,butthat’swherewe
differ.
Notthateitheroneofusjudgedtheotherone,andthatwaswhatreallymattered.Alyssahadhad
moreone-nightstandsthanIcouldcountonbothhands,andyetitworkedforherbecauseshenever
gotemotionallyattachedandneverfeltusedthenextmorning.I’dhadsexwithoneguyaftergoing
onaboutfivedateswithhimandwhenhenevercalledmeback,I’dbeendevastated,cryingintomy
pillow,wonderingwhatwaswrongwithme,feelingused,abusedandcheap.SometimesIthinkI’m
tooemotional,tooinvestedinwhatsexmeansinarelationship.SometimesIthinkIshouldbelike
Alyssa,butthenIalwayssecond-guessmyself.ThoughIsupposeeverythingchangedthatnight.That
wasthenightthatImetPierce.Pierce,Pierce,Pierce.Heturnedmyworldupsidedownandput
everythinginitonedge.NothinghasbeenthesamesinceImetPierce.
Electrifying—that’sthewordIwouldusetodescribethefirsttimemyeyesmetPierce’s.Hehada
smolderinglookabouthim.Hehadoneofthosehardfacesthatgrewhandsomewhenhesmiled,and
—oh,boy—whenhesmiled,hewasmagnetic.Almostboyish.Though,Iguessit’shardtolookhard
andboyish.ButifyousawPierce,you’dunderstandwhatImean.Nooneintheclubcouldtaketheir
eyesoffofhim,eveniftheywantedto.Hehadjet-blackhair,straight,silky—thekindofhairyou
wishedyouhad,andwantedtoplaywith.Hiseyeswereskyblue,andwarm,directandinteresting
whenhegazedatyou.HiseyesseemedtobesearchingintoyoursoulwhenhegazedatyouandI
almosthadthefeelingthathecouldreadmymindwhenhelookedatme,thoughIknewthatwas
impossible.Becauseifhe’dreadmymind,thingswouldhavebeenalotlesscomplicatedandI
wouldn’thavegottenmyselfintothismess.
IwaswithAlyssastandingattheedgeofthedancefloorwhenImethimforthefirsttime.Atfirst
IthoughthewaslookingatherandIwasgiddywithexcitementforher.Imean,thegoalhadbeenfor
oneofustomeetaniceguy,and,well,Alyssawantedrichaswellandhelookedasifhehadmoney,
ifhisexpensivesuitwasanythingtogoby.Ihonestlywouldn’thavebeenupsetifhe’dtriedtopickup
Alyssaandnotme.Maybethatwouldhavebeenthebestthingthatcouldhavehappened.Butlifenever
goesasitshould.
“Don’tlooknow,butthere’sahotguycheckingyououtatteno’clock,”IwhisperedtoAlyssaas
subtlyaspossible,whichwasverynon-subtle,asI’mthesortofpersonwhodoesn’tdosubtlewell,at
all.I’malwaystooloudandalwayslookatthepersonI’msupposedtobeignoringorpretendingI
don’tsee.Well,that’sthewayIusedtobe.I’mplentysubtlenow.
“Teno’clockp.m.ora.m.?”Alyssaaskedmeeagerly,herfacelightingup.
“Areyoukidding?”Iaskedher,myjawdroppingasitsometimesdidwhenAlyssamadeoneof
hermoreridiculouscomments.NeitherAlyssanorIwerethesmartestgirlsintown,butshe
sometimessurprisedmewithhowdumbsomeofherquestionswere.
“Kiddingaboutwhat?”Shefrowned.“I’maskingyouaquestion.”
“Tena.m.ortenp.m.?”Ilookedatheragain,waitingfortheballtodropinherhead.
“Thatwasthequestion,”shesaidandrolledhereyesatmeandIjustshookmyheadather.
“Alyssa,praytellwhat’sthedifferencebetweentena.m.andtenp.m.ontheclock?”Iraisedan
eyebrowather.
“Thedifference?”Shepaused,lookedmeintheeyesforafewsecondsandthengiggled.“Oh
yeah,oops.”
“Yeah,haha.Idiot,”Isaidlovinglyandlaughedwithher.“Nowcheckouttheguyatteno’clock
p.m.andtellmeifyouthinkhe’scute.Actually,youdon’tneedtotellmeifyouthinkhe’scute.I
alreadyknowthatyou’llthinkhe’scute,sojusttellmeifyou’regoingtogohomewithhimtonight.”
“Jess,whatsortofgirldoyouthinkIam?”Shegiggledassheturnedtolookattheguy.Iwatched
ashereyeswidenedandshestartedplayingwithherhair.ThatwasatelltalesignthatAlyssawasinto
aguy.Shealwaysplayedwithherhairwhenshewastryingtoflirtwithsomeone.IgrinnedasI
watchedherbattinghereyelidsandwonderedifIshouldgohomesoshewouldn’tfeelconflicted
aboutleavingwiththeguy.“Jess,Idon’tknowwhatsortofvisionyouhave,butMr.McHottieisnot
checkingmeout,”shesaidfinallyasshelookedbackatme.
“What?Isawhimstaringoverhere.”Ifrowned.WasIcompletelyoutofit?
“He’scheckingyouout.”Shelookedoveratmeandwinked.“AsmuchasIwouldlovetosnag
himformyself,he’stotallyintoyou.”
“Youthinkso?”Ilookedoveragainandstaredrightathim.Itoldyou,Ihavenogame.ThistimeI
lookedathimforatleastaminute,andAlyssawasright.Hewastotallycheckingmeout.Normally,I
wouldhavelookedawaybecauseI’mactuallyquiteshy,buttherewassomethingabouthisgazethat
haltedmefromlookingaway.Itoldyouitwaselectrifying,andmagnetizingandcrazyallatthesame
time.Andhedidn’tstoplookingatmeeither.I’veneverhadthatbefore—thatmomentwhenyou
shareamomentwithsomeoneyoudon’treallyknowandfeellost.Ifeltlikeweweretheonlytwo
peopleinthebarinthatmoment.EvenAlyssa,whoIknewwasstandingthere,suddenlyfellaway
frommyperipheralvision.Itfeltlikesomespecialmoviemoment,onlyitwasreallyhappening.And
tome.Andthenhestartedwalkingtowardsme,whilestillmakingeyecontact.AndIthoughtIwas
goingtolosemymind.Myheartstartedracing,myfingersstartedtrembling,mystomachwasin
knotsandthethoughtsinmybrainwereracingatahundredmilesaminute.Eachsecondandstepthat
hetookonlyseemedtoincreasemyanxietyandawarenessofhim.
“Oh,myGod,Jess,”Alyssasaidloudly.“McHottieiswalkingtowardsus.Oh,myGod.”
“Iknow,”Isaid,snappingoutofmyreverie.“WhatshouldIdo?”Itriednottosquealbecause
that’stotallyuncool,butI’mnotsureIwasabletoholditback.
“Justbecool.We’recool.Actcool.Ignorehimandplayhardtoget.”
“Okay.”Inodded.“Hardtoget.That’swhatI’lldo.”Ilookedatherandthensnuckapeekbackat
McHottieandhewasstillwalkingtowardsmeandwasonlyafewyardsaway.IthoughtIwasgoing
tofaint.IlookedbackatAlyssaandtriedtothinkofsomethingtosay.“Saysomething,”Iwhispered
atherurgently.“Idon’twanthimtojustshowupandwe’restandinghere,justsittingandnotsaying
anything.”
“WhatshouldIsay?”sheasked,obviouslytryingtothinkhard.
“Idon’tknow.Anything.Askmeaboutworkoranythingyouwant.”
“Ithoughtyoudidn’twanttotalkaboutworkrightnow?”Shemadeaface.“Ithoughtyousaid
yesterdaythatyourbosswasgettingonyournervesandyouwereworriedthatyoumightgetlaidoff
soon.”
“Ididn’tsaythatImightgetlaidoffsoon.Isaidthattheremightbelayoffssoonbecausemyboss
isajackasswhodoesn’tliketodoherworkandshe’salwaystryingto…”MyvoicetrailedoffasI
felthispresencebehindme.Hehadn’tsaidanythingyet,butIknewhewasthere.Iknewthathewas
rightbehindmebecausemyentirebodyfeltlikeitwasonfire.
“Hello,canIbuyyouladiesadrink?”adeep,smooth,sexyvoicesaidfrombehindme.How
coulditbepossiblethatthisguywasevenmoreperfectthanjusthislooks?Itdidn’tseemright.How
couldhelookandsoundsexy?Ofcourse,atthatpoint,Ihadnothingtocomparehimto.Ididn’tknow
thathewasjustthebeginningofthesexytrain.
“Yes,thanks,”AlyssasaideagerlyinresponsetoMcHottie,andIwantedtogroan.Thatwasnot
playingitcool.Iturnedaroundtolookathimandmyjawdroppedonceagainatthenextwordsout
ofhismouth.
“Youguyswantablowjob?”hesaidwithawickedgrinandmyfaceflushed.Hadhemeanttoask
usifwewantedtogivehimablowjob?Whatapervert!
“We’rewomen.”Igavehimalookandhiseyessparkledashelookeddownatmychest.
“Ifigured.”Hewinkedashelookedbackupatmyfaceandintomyeyes.
“Sowedon’tneedblowjobs,”Icontinued,givinghimalook.Yes,Iwasbeingabitch,yes,Iwas
stilltryingtoflirtandyes,IreallyhadnoideawhatIwasdoing.
“That’sthenameoftheshot.”Hegrinned.“Ifiguredyouguyswouldenjoythem.”
“Why?”Iaskedhimcuriously.Thiswasnotacome-onlineI’deverheardbefore.
“Becauseyoulooklikeyouenjoysweetandcreamythings.”Hewinkedagainandmyjaw
dropped.Hewasnotgoingthere,washe?
“Wedo.”Alyssagiggledwhilepokingmeinthesiderealquick,tryingtotellmetostopbeingso
bitchyandtostartbeingalittlenicertoMcHottie.She’smybestfriend,sheknowsmyflirtingis
slightlyoffandthatIcanbeabitpricklywhenitcomestoguys,evenguysthatIlike.Butman,didI
reallywanttoflirtwithamanwhowasalludingtothefactthatIlikedsweetandcreamythings?
“Soshotsallaround,then?”HelookedatAlyssaforasecondandthenbackatme.“Orwouldyou
prefersomethingelse?”
“No,ablowjobisfine,”Irespondedwithasmallsmile.“Justaslongasyouaren’texpectingone
inreturn.”
“Areyousayingthatyou’renotwillingtogivemeablowjob?”Hestaredintomyeyesintently
andIcouldn’ttellifhewasbeingseriousornot.
“That’sexactlywhatI’msaying.”Inoddedandgavehimasmallsmile.“I’mnotthatkindofgirl.”
“Really?”HiseyesglitteredasifI’djustgivenhimsomesortofchallenge.“Iguesswecansee.”
“Seewhat?”Itiltedmyheadandgavehimahalf-smile.
“IfIcanmakeyouthatkindofgirl.”Hewinkedyetagainandthenlaughed,hiseyescrinklingas
hisfacetransformed.HelookedoveratAlyssaagainandsmiled.“So,sixshots?”
“Ifyouwant.”Sheshrugged,thesmilefixedonherface.Shewasgettingbored.Alyssahadcome
tofindherownman.Shedidn’twanttowastehertimeflirtingandstandingaroundwithamanwho
washereflirtingwithme;especiallyasthatwasn’tthepurposeoftheevening.Ifithadbeen“findJess
amannight”thenshewouldhavebeenmorethanhappytospendherhourswithme,makingsureI
hookedupwiththebestmanpossible.Maybewe’dgofrombartobarandgetfreedrinksandflirtthe
nightaway,dancingandmovingaroundlikebutterflies,skittishandpretty,drawingattentionto
ourselves,butalwaysflyingawayatthelastmoment.However,thiswasn’tgetJessamannight,this
wasafun,possiblenightofdebaucheryforoneofus,andtheonewhowasmostlikelytogetdown
anddirtywastheonewhohadn’tfoundaguytotalktoasyet.
“Soyou’regoingtogiveyourselfablowjob?”Iaskedtheguywithasmallsmile,tryingtoget
myflirtgamebackontrack.
“IwishIcould,thoughIdon’tknowhowgoodIwouldbe.Iprefertoreceivefromsomeonewho
knowswhatthey’redoing.”
“Okay,we’redefinitelynottalkingaboutthedrinksnow,”Isaid,slightlysurprisedthathewas
driftingfromthejokealready.Hewashotandsexy,butthefactthathewastalkingaboutactual
blowjobsrightawaywasabitoff-putting.
“Wereweever?”HewinkedatmeagainandIstartedtowonderifhehadaneyetwitch.ThenIfelt
hishandonmyshoulder.
“Yeah,Iwastalkingaboutthedrinksthewholetime,”Isaid,thoughI’mnotsurethatwas
technicallytrue,butwhocared,right?Hewasoutofmyleague,Iwasactinglikeanidiot,andIalso
didn’tevenknowhowIfeltaboutthewholesituation.Hewassuperhotandsexy,buttherewas
somethingabouthimthathadthepotentialtobeprettydouche-likeandIwasn’treallyinto
douchebags.I’dratherbesinglethandateadouchebag.Orevenflirtwithadouchebag.Ifhis
approachwastotalkaboutblowjobs,thenIknewthatwemightnotbeamatchmadeinheaven,but
youknowhowitiswhenyou’reattractedtosomeoneandreallylikethem,allsenseofrational
thoughtgoesoutthewindow.EventhoughIhadbellsinmyheadtellingmethatperhapsthisguy
wasn’tgoingtobeMr.PrinceCharming,Iwasstillengagingwithhim.That’swhathappenswhen
you’rearoundasuper-hotguy,allyoucanthinkaboutarehisgleamingeyes,hissilkyhairandhis
hardbody.AndI’mnotevenagirlwhodoestheone-nightstandthing.Butman,thatnight,I’mnot
surewhatitwas;Iwasreadyforachange.
“Yougirlswanttocometothebarwithmetograbthedrinks?”heasked,thoughhewaslooking
directlyatme.
“IactuallythinkI’mgoingtogoanddance,”Alyssasaidwithasmallwinkatme.“Iwanttoletmy
freakflagflytonight.”
“Butdon’tyouwantablowjob?”Iaskedher,givingheralookthatwasessentiallyaskinghernot
togoanywhere.
“Nah,Ithinkyouguyscanhandletheblowjobs,”shesaidandwiththatsheflouncedontothe
dancefloorwithoutevenglancingbackatmetoseeifIwaspissed.ShealreadyknewthatIwasgoing
tobepissed,ofthatIwassure.
“Seemslikeyourfriendwasboredofyourcompanytonight.”Mr.Hottieleanedinclosertome
andsmiled,hishandonthesmallofmyback.NormallyIhatesuchanintimatemovefromamanI
don’tknowsoquickly,butasyoualreadyknowthisnightwasnotliketheothers.Notatall.
“Yeah,ormaybeshewasboredofyou,”Isnappedbackathimandgavehimalittlewinktoshow
thatIwasteasing.ItoldyouthatI’mnotalwaysthesmoothestwhenitcomestoflirting.
“Perhaps.”HishandslidfartherandIfelthimgivingmyassaslighttap.Yes,hetappedmyass.I
nearlyjumped.Inearlypulledawayfromhim.Inearlypushedhimaway,butIdidn’t.Ididn’tbecause
ithadbeenanicesensualtouchandmaybeithadjustbeentoolong,butIkindofdidn’tmindit.Ikind
oflikedit.Ikindofthoughtaboutwhatelsehemighttrytodo.WhatelseImightlethimdo.Istarted
tothinkabouthowfarhewouldtrytogoandatwhatpointwouldItellhimtostop.“Unlikely,
though.”
“Whyunlikely?”
“Mostwomendon’tgetboredofmethisquickly.”Heleaneddownsothathislipswerecloseto
mine.“Mostwomendon’tgetboredofmeever.”
“Shouldn’tthatbe,mostwomendon’teverboreofme?”Isaidsweetly,andhelaughed.
“You’vegotasmartmouth.Ilikethat.”
“That’snottheonlythingyoulike,isit?”Iraisedaneyebrowathim.
“What?Yourmouth?”Hegrinneddownatme.“Whywouldyouthinkthat?”
“Whydoyouthink?”Iaskedhimwithaflirtatiousglance.Ireallywassteppingupmygame.
“BecauseItoldyouIwanttofeelyousuckingmycock,”hesaidsimplyandmyeyeswidenedas
mybodystiffenedinshock.Ihadnotjustimaginedthosewordscomingfromhismouth.Icouldn’t
believewhathe’djustsaid.Icouldn’tbelievethatIwashere,stillstanding,staringathim,engagingin
thisconversation.WasIabsolutelycrazy?Iwasnotthesortofgirlwhojustallowedaguytotellme
suchthings.Ithoughtitwasscandalous.Absolutelyscandalous,butyouwouldn’thavethoughtso
basedonmyresponsethatnight.I’mnotevensurewhereitcamefrom.
“You’dbetterbeabletomakemecomewithyourmouthforatleasttenminutesbeforeexpecting
anysortofmouthactionfromme,”Irespondedwithasmallsmile,shockingbothmyselfandhim
withmywords.MyheartwasthuddingasIcrossedintouncharteredterritory.Wherehadthisbad,
naughtysideofmecomefrom?Ididn’tevenknow.IhavetoadmitIwaskindofproudofmyself.I’d
neverbeenadirtygirl,butsomehowthisguywasbringingitoutinme.Alyssawouldhavebeen
absolutelyshockedifshehadheardwhatI’dsaid.
“WhatifItoldyoufifteenminutes?”Hislipspressedagainstminethen.“Fifteenminutesofpure
unadulteratedcoming,rightonmymouth.”Hebitdownonmylowerlipandsuckeditforasecond,
shockingmewithhisboldness.“Howwouldyoulikethat?”hesaidashepulledaway,andIwasn’t
sureifhewastalkingabouthisinvasionofmymouthorhisfifteenminutescomment.Eitherway,I
wasfeelingbuzzed,warmandtinglyinside.I’dneverhadafeelingofanticipationjustfromwords
before,butIsupposeI’vejustnotbeenwiththerightguys.
“I’mstillwaitingonmydrink,”Isaidwithasmallsmile,tryingtoseeifIcouldshiftthemood
backslightly.Ididn’twanttoendupsleepingwiththisguyrighthereonthedancefloor.Imean,Iwas
downforchangingstuffup,butnotthatmuch.Ididn’twanttogofromnuntoslutintwopointfour
seconds.Iwasn’treadytogetitonandhaveawholeclubwitnessingmyentranceintodebauchery.
“Stillwantablowjoborwouldyouprefersomethingelse?”
“It’suptoyou,”Isaidwithashrug,reallyhavingnoideawhatIwassayingordoing,butjust
knowingthatIwasenjoyingbeinginPierce’scompany.Hewasanintoxicatingpresence.I’dnever
beenaroundsomeonelikehimbefore,someonewhocompletelymademelosemyselfinthe
moment.It’saweirdfeelingtobethatattractedtosomeoneatfirstsight.Andit’snotthesamethingas
fallinginloveatfirstsight.Itwasn’tthatsortofheart-stopping,“oh,myGod,Ithinkhe’stheone”
moment.Iknow,becauseI’vefeltthosebefore.Obviously,theydidn’tturnouttobetrue,becauseI’ve
stillnotfoundtheone,butI’vehadthosemomentswheretheearthhasstoodstillandmystomachhas
flippedandmyhearthasthuddedwiththebeatofathousanddrumsandI’vethoughttomyselfthat
thisistheone,thisisthemoment,thisisthetime:I’vemettheoneforme.That’snotwhatIfeltwith
Pierce.WithPierce,Ifeltsomethingalotmoreprimal.WithPierce,Ifeltastirringinmybellyanda
wetnessinmypantiesthatmademefeelthingsI’dnotfeltoutsideofabedroombeforeandespecially
notwithastranger.Andespeciallyhavingnotevenbeentouched.Ididn’tevenknowthatyoucouldbe
soturnedonbysomeonejustfromwords.Imean,Iknewpeoplehadphonesexandallthatjazz,butI
thoughttheturn-onwasfromtheself-play,asopposedtotheactualwords.NotthatI’deverdonethat.
Iusedtobeaprude.Notthatyou’dknowthatrightnow.
“Well,ifit’suptome,IknowwhatIwanttodo.”
“Whatyouwanttodo?”Ifrowned.“Don’tyoumeanwhatdrinkyouwanttobuyme?”
“I’llbuyyouallthedrinksinSanFrancisco,ifyou’lldowhatIwantyouto.”
“I’msureyouwould.”Igavehimaquestioninglook.“Whatisityouwantmetodo?”
“Doyoureallywanttoknow?”Hislipsturnedupatthesideandhiseyesdarkenedasheglanced
atme.
“Iwouldn’thaveaskedifIdidn’twanttoknow,”Isaid,myvoicetremblingslightly.Ihadnoclue
whatIwasdoing.Thiswasunfamiliarterritory,butIthinkthat’swhatmadeitsoexciting.Ialmost
wonderedifI’dbeendruggedorsomething,butPiercehadn’tgottenmeadrinkyet,soitwouldhave
hadtohavebeensomesortofimmaculatedruggingandIwasn’tquitesurethatwaspossible.Okay,
let’sbereal.Iknewitwasn’tpossible.ButIfeltlikesomethinginmehadchangedalmost
instantaneouslyuponlookingatPierceandIwishIknewexactlywhatitwasthatmadeeverything
changeasitdid.Thatwasthenight,themoment,whereeverythinginmylifestartedtogocrazy.Istill
lookbacknowandIcan’texplainexactlywhathappened.Whatwasthecatalyst?Whatmademe
decidetoindulgePierceandhisfantasies?Whatmademewanttoshareinhisfantasies?Ihadnoidea,
andIstilldon’t,butthatwasthemomentthatIbecameawomanIdidn’trecognize.Awomanwhowas
goingtoembracetheworldandhersexualityinallitsglorywithoutfeelingsuperguiltyaboutit.
“Iwantyoutocomehomewithmetonight,”hesaidsoftly.“AndIwanttotakeyouona
rollercoasterrideofpleasurethatyou’veneverexperiencedbefore.”
“HowdoyouknowI’veneverexperienceditbefore?”
“Icantellbythelookonyourfacethatyou’veneverhadamantakeyoutotheheightsIcantake
youto,”hesaidnonchalantly.“Icanalsotellthatyou’renotthesortofgirlwhomeetsguysinbars
andhooksup,soyou’reprobablystrugglingwithhowtorespondtomerightnow.”
“IfyouthinkI’mnotthatkindofgirl,thenwhywouldyouevenapproachmewithsuchathing?”I
askedhimhesitantly,feelingslightlygiddyandunsure.
“BecauseIlikeachallengeandIlikebeingateacher.”
“Ateacher?”
“Yes,ateacher.TherearemanythingsIcanteachyou.”
“I’mnotevengoingtoaskyouwhat.”
“That’swhyIlikeyou.”Hesmirked.“Yourmindprobablycan’teventhinkuphalfofthethingsI
wanttoteachyou.”
“Oh?”
“Oh,yes.”Helaughed.“I’mbeingtooforwardandperverseandI’msorry.Youjustmakeme
excited.”
“Imakeyouexcited?”
“Inmorethanoneway.”Henodded.“AssoonasIsawyouacrosstheroom,IknewIhadtotalkto
youandwehadtomeet.”
“IthoughtyouwerelookingatAlyssa,”Iadmittedwithasmallsmile.
“AtfirstIwas.”Henodded.“Butthen,well,myeyessawyouandthatwasthat.”
“Thatwaswhat?”Iaskedhimcuriously.
“ThatwaswhenIknewthatIcouldn’tcarelessabouther.Iwantedtotalktoyou.Iwantedtokiss
you.Iwantedtotouchyou.”
“Okay.”Ifeltslightlydisappointedbyhiswords.Imean,Iknewitwasasexthing,buthecould
haveatleasttriedtoromanticizeit.
“IknewIwantedtogettoknowyoubetter.Findoutwhatmakesyoutick,inandoutofthe
bedroom.”
“Really?”Iscoffedathim.“YouwanttoknowwhatI’mlikeoutsideofthebedroom?”
“Itmightnotseemlikeit,basedonourcurrentconversation,butIaminterestedingettingto
knowallofyou.Inbecomingfamiliarwitheveryaspectofyourbeing.IhopeI’mnotsoundingtoo
intense,butIfeltwehadsomesortofconnection-attractionassoonasIsawyou.”
“Idon’tknowwhattosay.”Igavehimashysmile.Thisdidn’tseemlikereallifeinanyway.In
fact,apartofmewonderedifIwasdreamingthisallup.Itallfelttoosurrealandtotallynota
situationthatIwouldeverbein.
“Saythatyoufeelthesameway.Tellmethatyouwanttogettoknowmeaswell.”
“Ifeellikegettingtoknowyoucouldcauseproblemsforme.”
“Whatsortofproblems?”
“Idon’tknowwhatsort.IfIknew,Iwouldmostlikelyhaveleftbynow.”
“Leftandgonewhere?”
“Idon’tknow.”Ishrugged.“TothedancefloorwithAlyssa.”
“Wecangoontothedancefloorbyourselves.IcandotoyouallthethingsIwanttodotoyou.”
“Yeah,butwhatifallthethingsyouwanttodotomearen’tthethingsIwantyoutodotome?”
“Iguesswecanjustwaitandsee,right?”HesmiledatmelasciviouslyandIwonderedwhathe
wasthinking.WhatsortofgirldidhethinkIwas?Imean,hehadtoknowthatIwasn’tthatkindof
girl,right?ButthenIalmostslappedmyself.WhyonearthwouldhethinkIwasn’tthatsortofgirl?
Heknewnothingaboutme.ExceptforthefactthatIwasengaginginthisridiculousconversationwith
himandlettinghimthinkthatwemightactuallydosomethingtonight.
“Idon’tknow.”Ibitdownonmylowerlip,nervesallofasuddenhittingme.Thiswasn’tthe
situationIwantedtobein.Allofasudden,Ifeltveryself-consciousandunsureofwhatIwasdoing
inthissituation.Thiswasn’tme,andnomatterhowgoodlookinghewas,Ididn’twanttobeinthis
situation.“Actually,IthinkI’llpassonthedrink.”Igavehimasmallsmile.“IthinkIneedtogoand
seeifAlyssaisokay.”Ilookedintohiseyesandhisfacelookeddisappointed.“Itwasnicemeeting
you,though.”
“You’renotseriouslyleavingmeherebymyself,areyou?”Hefrownedatme.“Ididn’tmeanto
offendyou.”
“Youdidn’toffendme,”Isaidwithasmallshrug.“IjustcameoutonagirlsnightandIthinkI
shouldn’tabandonmyfriendanymoretoday.”
“Sheleftyou,youdidn’tleaveher,”hesaid.“I’msureshe’sokay.”
“Ijustfeelbad,though.”Ilookedathimwithashyglance,wonderingwhyhewasmakingthisso
difficult.Itwaskindofflatteringthatthishottiewantedtospendmoretimewithme,butslightly
disconcertingthathewasseemingsoupset.Whatdidhereallycare?
“Feelbadforleavingme?”Hegavemeateasingsmile.“AfterIgrewtheballsandthecourageto
comeandtalktoyou?Nowyou’regoingtoleavemeandmakemefeeldejected?”
“I’msureyou’renotgoingtofeeldejected,”Isaidwithasmallsmile.“Thereareplentyofother
womenheretonightwhowouldbehappytotalktoyou.”
“ButIdon’twanttotalktothem.”Healmostwhined.
“Buttheywanttotalktoyou.”Igrinnedathim.“I’msurehalfthewomeninherewanttotalkto
you.”
“Onlyhalf?”Helaughed.“Thoseoddsaren’tgood.EspeciallyafterIcameuptotheonegirlI
wantedtotalktoandIthoughtthingsweregoingwell,butthenshedecidedtoditchme.”
“Ididn’tditchyouyet,”Isaidwithalaugh.“I’mstillheretalkingtoyou.”
“Somycharmisstillworkingalittlebit.”Hegrinned.“Ijustneedtogetyoutostaytalkingtome
allnightandthenmyeveningwillbemade.”
“Haha,Isayyou’vegotplentyofcharm.Idoubtthat’saproblemthatyouhave.”
“Perhapsnot.”Helaughed.“However,ifyouditchme,thenyou’llhavemequestioningmyself
andeverythingIthoughtIknew.”
“Everythingyouthoughtyouknewaboutwhat?”
“EverythingIthoughtIknewaboutyouwhenIfirstglancedatyou.”
“Whatdidyouthinkyouknew?”Iaskedhimcuriously.
“IthoughtIknewthatyouwerespecial.ThatyouwereagirlthatIwantedtogettoknow.That
perhapsweweredestinedtomeettonight.”
“You’rejoking,right?”Istartedlaughingandhelookedatmewithawrysmile.
“Toomuch?”
“Waytoomuch.”Inodded,stillgiggling.“Imeanit’sanicethoughtandall,butit’swaytoomuch.
Romanticandperfectforarom-commoviestarringKateHudsonorsomething,butforthissituation,
notquite.”Ilaughedsomemore.“Notafteryouofferedmeablowjobshotandbasicallysolicitedme
forsex.”
“Ididn’tsolicityouforsex.”Helaughed.“IjustletyouknowthatIwouldn’tbeopposedtosome
funtimeswithyou,ifyousowished.”
“Uhhuh.”Inodded.“Sure,sure.”
“That’snotallI’minterestedin,though,”hesaidseriously,hisexpressionchanging.“Ihopeyou
don’tthinkI’mthatsortofguy.”
“Ihopeyoudon’tthinkI’mthatsortofgirl.”
“Iknowyou’renotthatsortofgirl.”Helaughed.“We’dbeinthebackalleybynow,ifyouwere.”
“Excuseme?”Iaskedhim,notreallyunderstandingwhathewassaying.Well,Ihadanidea,butI
wantedhimtoexplainhimself.
“We’dbesomewhereenjoyingeachother ’sbodiesrightnowalready,ifyouwerethesortofgirl
whowasupforaquickfling.”
“Isee.”Ipursedmylips.
“Butyou’renotthatkindofgirlandI’mokaywiththat.”Hegrinnedatme.“Actually,Ikindof
likethefactthatyou’renotthatkindofgirl.”
“Butyouwouldn’thavemindedifIwasthatkindofgirl,though,right?”
“Noguywouldmindthat.”Helaughed.“Andanyguywhosayshewouldmindisnotthekindof
guyyouwanttobewithbecausethatsortofguywouldbealiar.”
“Isee.Soyou’resayingthatbasicallyeveryguyisaslutormalewhore.”
“I’msayingthatnoguyturnsdownsex.It’sthewayoftheland.Thelawofnature.”Heshrugged.
“Ifit’sonoffer,mostguysaregoingtotakeit.”Helookedmeintheeyes.“Someofus,though,some
ofushavemorediscernment.Someofuspreferqualityoverquantity.Andwedon’tneedthegirlwho
isreadyandwillingrightaway.”
“I’mthequality?”Iraisedaneyebrowathim,wonderingifhewasjustsayingallofthissoI
wouldn’twalkaway.Whichwasastupidthoughtbecauseitwasobviousthatwaswhyhewassaying
everythinghewassaying.Hewouldn’tdoafull-circleinconversationoutoffun.Hediditbecause
I’dthreatenedtoleave.Iwasprobablyachallengetohimnow.Iknewthatguyslovedachase.And
nowthatI’dsaidIwasgoingtogoandfindAlyssaandditchhim,Iwassomethingtobeconquered.
“Oh,yeah,you’rethequality.”Heleanedcloseandbrushedapieceofhairawayfrommyeyes.
“You’retheonlygirlI’velookedatformorethantensecondstonight.You’reashiningstarinthis
roomofbrightlights.You’retheNorthernLights.You’rethesonginmyheartcallingmeover.
You’rethenervesinmystomachthatarehopingthatI’mnotbeingtoocheesy.Iwanttospendthe
nightwithyou,doingwhateveryouwanttodo.Ijustwanttobewithyou.IjustfeellikeIjustneedto
bearoundyou.Idon’tknowifthatmakessense.Idon’tknowifI’mcomingontoostrong.”
“No.”Ishookmyhead,feelinglikeIwantedtoswoon.Iwasn’treallysurewhatwasgoingon,but
Iknewthatwhateveritwas,itwasn’tgoingtoendnow,becauseIwantedtogettoknowPiercebetter
aswell.Theonlyproblemwas,mygettingtoknowPiercewasnotreallyaboutgettingtoknow
Pierce.MymeetingwithPiercewasallaboutmyjourneytoEvan.
J
C H A P T E R 2
ess
T
HE
FIRST
TIME
ImetEvanwasonaSundayafternoon.Iknow,Iknow,you’rewonderingwhothehell
EvanisandwhathappenedtoPierce?Trustme,I’mgoingtotellyou.Eventually.Thisisa
complicatedstory.Idon’twantyoutojudgeme.Atleast,notwithoutknowingthefullstory.Youhave
toknowthefullstory.
Now,backtoEvan.Iknow,Iknow,youwanttohearaboutPierceandwhathappenedwhenweleft
theclub,butIcan’tnottalkaboutEvanfirst.Evanisthereasonforallthetrouble.WhoknewwhenI
metPiercethatnightthattherewasgoingtobeanEvaninthepicture?Notme.Notatall,butman,
Evanisthemanofallmen.Hotdamn,EvanEvanEvan.ThefirsttimeIsawhim,Ithoughtmypanties
weregoingtofalloff.Andtheynearlydid.I’dgoneovertomeetPierceathisapartmentforanearly
dinnerandwhenI’dranghisintercom,he’dbuzzedmeinandletmeknowthathewasn’tactually
homeyet.HesaidthatIcouldgoupandthatthefrontdoorwouldbeopen.He’dsaidtojustletmyself
inandwaitforhim.Hehadn’tsaidanythingabouttherebeinganothermanintheapartment.He
hadn’tsaidhe’dhadcompany.Hehadn’tsaidanyofthosethings.Soyoucanimaginemysurprise
whenIwalkedinandIrealizedthatIwasn’talone.Andbynotalone,ImeanIwasaccompaniedbyan
extremelyattractiveman.
HewasstandinginthekitchenatPierce’sapartmentandhewaswearingapairoffadedbluejeans
andawhiteT-shirt.HisbackwastomeandIcheckedouthisassinthewaythatwomencheckoutthe
bodiesofmentheyfindphysicallyattractive.ItmighthavebeenalittlecreepybecauseIdidn’tsay
anythingforagoodminuteorsoasIstoodthereadmiringhimandthenheturnedaroundandgave
meahugegrin.
“Enjoyingtheview?”hesaidwithasmallnodandatwinkleinhisdeepgreeneyes.Myface
flushedasIstaredathim,wonderinghowI’dnevermethimbeforeandhowhe’dknownthatIwas
there.Ifhe’dheardmecomingthroughthefrontdoor,whyhadn’thedonethepolitethingandcome
outtogreetme?IshouldhaveknownfromthatmomentthatEvanwassomethingdifferent.Hedidn’t
evenhavetheinitialpolitenessthatmostpeoplehave.MaybethatwaswhyIwassodrawntohim.
ThoughIthinkIwoulduseanyexcusenow.
Evanstaredatmelikehewaschallengingmetosaysomethingsnarkyinresponsetohisview
comment.Imean,whatsortofmanaskedyouthatwhenhefirstmetyou?Howcockycouldoneman
be?IhavetoadmitthatoneofthefirstthoughtsinmymindasIstaredathimwastowonderifhewas
single,thoughthatwasmoreforAlyssa’ssakethanitwasformine.Imean,I’mnotgreedy.Ididn’t
needtwohotmenfightingoverme.NotthatIhadanyhotmenfightingoverme,butyouknowwhatI
mean.Anditwasn’tasifIwantedEvan.Notatall.NotwhenIwasinthebeginningstagesofdating
Pierce.Iknow,Iknow,youwanttoknowmore.I’llgettoPierce,thoughhe’snotasimportant.Not
anymore.
“Whatview?”Iasked,feigningconfusionasIglancedathim,tryingnottostareathimtoohard.
Hewasabsolutelygorgeous,inoneofthoseoldHollywoodways:debonairanddashing.Strikingly
handsome.Hedidn’thavethatbaby-boyedgethatPiercehadabouthimbuthewasequallyasalluring.
Letmebehonest,hewasevenmorealluring.MaybethatwaswhyPiercehadn’tintroducedusyet.
Maybeheonlywantedmetomeethisunattractivefriends.NotthatI’dreallymetanyofhisfriends.It
wasreallytoosoonforthat.ButifIhadmetmore,IhadafeelingEvanwouldn’thavebeenoneofthe
firstonestobeintroduced.Heseemedlikethesortofguywhocouldn’tbetrusted.Imean,ifAlyssa
hadn’tbeenwithmeonthenightthatI’dmetPierce,I’mnotsurethatIwouldhaveintroducedthem—
andwewerebestfriends.Anditwasn’tbecauseIdidn’ttrusther,ItrustedAlyssaimplicitly.Iknew
withoutadoubtthatshewouldneverdoanythingshadywithanyonethatIwasdating.ButwhatifI’d
onlygoneononeortwodateswiththeguybeforetheymetandwhatiftheyclickedandweremore
attractedtoeachotherthanheandIwere?Wouldthatbefairtotrytostopthem,justbecauseI’dmet
theguyfirst?Also,IknewthatAlyssawashot.Inallfairness,shewasprobablyalothotterthanme.
Shehadalookthateveryguyseemedtogofor.Shewaspetite,blonde,bigboobsandditzy.Tobe
honest,thatwaswhyI’dautomaticallyassumedthatPiercehadbeenstaringatherthenightwe’dmet.
Guysnormallywentforherfirst.NotthatI’dminded,butitwassomethingIalwayshadinthebackof
mymind.
WhichwaswhyIwascuriousifthatwaswhyIhadn’tmetEvanyet.MaybePierceknewthatEvan
wasoneofthoseguyswhocouldmostlikelygetanygirland,well,PierceandIhadonlyjustrecently
met.AndIwasn’tevenreallysurewhatwasgoingonorwhatIwantedtobegoingon.
Istoppedmyselffromcontinuingmythoughts.Iwasn’tsurewhyIwasgettingcaughtupthinking
aboutsomeguyI’djustmet.Iwasactingcrazy.I’donlyknownPierceforoneweek,soitwasn’tasif
I’dexpectedtohavemethiswholefamilyandallhisfriendsbynow.IfIwasbeinghonestwith
myself,Ihadn’treallymetanyoneinhislife,saveforsomeonewhomayormaynothavebeenaco-
workerorex-loveratthecoffeeshopbyaccidentoneday.Iwasstillconfusedbyhisexplanationfor
howhe’dknownher.He’dmumbledsomethingandshe’dlookedathimwithslantedflirtyeyesanda
partofmehadwonderedexactlywhatthestorywas,butIcouldn’task.Thatwouldhavebeenwaytoo
crazy.Icouldn’tbenoseyandslightlyjealouswhenwe’dbarelymet.
“Y
OU
WERE
CHECKING
ME
OUT
,right?”Evangrinnedagain.“Fromthebackandnowfromthefront.”
“I’mnotcheckingyouout.”Ifrownedathim.“WhywouldIbecheckingyouout?”
“Idon’tknow,whywereyoucheckingmeout?”Heraisedhiseyebrowsatme.
“Iwasn’tcheckingyouout.”Iglaredathim.Thisguywascockyandabittoodirectforme.
Couldn’thepretendthathehadn’trealizedthatI’dbeencheckinghimout?Wasn’tthatwhatmost
politemendid?Thoughheobviouslywasn’tpolite.Healsolookedlikehewasafewyearsolderthan
Pierce,soIwonderedifhewasabadinfluence.MaybethatwaswhyPiercehadstartedgetting
annoyingalready.Maybehewaslisteningtothisassholeonhowtobeanarrogantprickandbe
annoyingtogirlsveryquickly.Iimmediatelyfeltguiltyatmythoughts,butPierce’spick-upatthe
clubhadbeenslightlyoffatsomepointsandhis“game”wasalittlebittooconfidentandself-
assured.Itwasannoying.
IfrownedtomyselfatmythoughtsasIstaredatEvan.Ineededtostopbeingsonegative.Pierce
wasn’tthatannoying.Iwasjustabitch,awhinybitch.Imean,itwasn’thisfaultthathe’dtakenmeto
EthiopianrestaurantsonbothofourdateswhenI’dtoldhimexplicitlythatIdidn’tlikeEthiopian
food.Imean,hewasn’texpectedtoremembereverythingaboutme.He’djustmetme.And,well,it
hadn’tbeensobad.Ihadn’tdied.Andhehadapologizedbothtimes.Evenifhisapologyhadseemed
kindaweak.Maybeitwassomesortofdoucheymovethathe’dlearnedfromEvan.Thatwouldmake
sensetome.ThisguylookedlikeadouchebagwithacapitalD.
“Sure,okay.”Evanwinkedandwalkedtowardsme.“Youcanfeelthemifyouwant,”hesaidashe
stoppedinfrontofme.
“Feelwhat?”Isaid,gazingupathim.Hehadstoppedandwasstandingwaytooclosetome.I
knewhewastryingtomakemeuncomfortablesoIdidn’tstepbackfromhim.ThoughIreallywanted
to.Mybodywasstartingtofeelhotjustbeingthisclosetohim.IwasscaredthatIwasgoingto
explodeintoaballoffire.
“Mymuscles.”Heflexedhisarm.“Icanseeyou’vebeencheckingthemout.”
“Iwasn’tcheckingoutyourmuscles.”Ishookmyhead,thoughmyeyesdidfalltohisarmsthen.I
watchedasheflexedthemagainandIwatchedashisbicepswentup.Boy,hewasmuscular.He
definitelyhadadifferentphysiquethanPierce.HewasalotmorebuiltandInormallydidn’tlikeguys
whoweresupermuscular,butthisguywasonthecuspofperfect.Hehadaridiculouslyhardandbuilt
body,buthe’dstillbegoodtocuddleinbed.ThoughIwasn’tsurewhyIwasthinkingaboutcuddling
withhiminbedorspooning.Oh,shit,whywasIthinkingofspooning?Oh,shit,myeyeswerenow
movingdownwards.Oh,whyohwhyweremyeyesmovingtohiscrotcharea?Iwascheckingtosee
ifhehadabulgeand,ifhedid,howbigitwas.Onceagainmymindwenttothespooning.What
woulditfeellikeifhewerebehindme,pressingintome,hisstrongarmswrappedaroundmybody?
Oh,God,I’mhorrible.Ishouldn’tbehavingthesethoughtsaboutPierce’sfriend.Ishouldn’tbe
havingthesethoughtsaboutanyone.I’magoodgirl.MaybeifIrepeatedthattomyselfenoughtimes
thenthatwouldbetrueagain.Itoldyouthatsomethingchangedthatnightatthebar.I’mnotsure
what,butallofasuddenmymindhadgonecrazy.AllofasuddenIwaslikesomesortofpervert,
thinkingabouthotmen,hotbodies,touching,one-nightstands,allthosethingsthatgoodgirlsdon’t
thinkabout.Atleastgoodgirlslikeme,thoughIsupposeI’mnotreallyagoodgirl.Notanymore.
Well,technicallyIstillam.Ihadn’tsleptwithPierce.Yeah,we’ddonestuff,butstuffdidn’tmeanI
wasaslut.Stuffjustmeantstuff.Everyonedidstuff.Though,Isupposeeveryonedidn’tmeetoneguy
oneweekandthenstartfantasizingaboutthatguy’sfriendtheminutetheymetthem.Eveniftheguy
wasashotasEvan.
“Pennyforthem?”Theguylookedatmeandhiseyeslookedall-knowing,likeheknewexactly
whatsortofpervertwasstandinginfrontofhim.
“Pennyforwhat?”Isaid,feelingflustered.WherethehellwasPierce?Andwhowasthisguywho
wasflirtingwithmesodangerously,makingmewanttobothhithimandkisshimatthesametime?
“Youknow.”HewinkedatmeandmyfaceflushedasIresistedtheurgetohithim.
“Ihavenoideawhatyou’retalkingabout,”Isaidinmymosthaughtytone.DidheknowthatI
thoughthislipswereluscious?Aslusciousashisasswas?
“Youhavenoideaaboutwhat?”Hetiltedhisheadandlookedatmyfacewithasexysmile.His
eyesfelltomychestandstayedthereforatleastthirtyseconds.
“Excuseme,”Isaidfinally,myfacehot.Icouldn’tbelievethathewasblatantlystaringatmy
chest.Whatsortofassholewashe?
“Excuseyouwhat?”
“Canyoustopstaringatmychest?That’ssorude.”
“I’mrude?”Helaughed,adeepchucklethatreverberatedthroughthewholeroomasheglanced
atmewithanamazedlook.
“Youdon’tthinkso?”Istaredbackathimwithnarrowedeyes,myheartracing.Shit,buthewas
sexy.
“Idon’tthinkI’mrude.Atleast,notifyoudon’tthinkyouwererude.”
“HowwasIrude?”
“Youwerestaringatmyass.”Heshrugged.“Iwasstaringatyourchest.”
“Soyouadmitit.Ha!”
“Itwouldbehardtodeny,right?Thosebeautiesarerightthere.”Hewinkedatmeagainandshock
ranthroughmybodyathiswords.Icouldn’tbelievewhatIwashearing.
“Oh,myGod,didyoujustsaythat?”Myjawdroppedopen.“Idon’tbelieveyou.”Ishookmy
head.“You’reabsolutelydisgusting.”
“Really?”Helookedperplexed.“I’mdisgustingbecauseIadmittedtoenjoyingstaringatyour
chest?Orforcallingthembeauties?WouldyouratherI’dhavesaidthattheywereugly?”
“I’dratheryou’dhavesaidnothing.”Iglaredathim.“I’mherewaitingonPierce.”
“Iknowhim.”Henodded.“Verywell.”Hesmirked.
“How?”Iquestionedhim,wantingtoknowexactlyhowtheywereconnected.Iwasn’tsurewhy.
“Ifhewantedyoutoknow,Ithinkyou’dknow.”HelickedhislipsandIwatchedthetipofhispink
tongueasitglidedbackandforth,myheartracingfast.Iwasn’tsurewhythisguyaffectedmeso
much,butIjustcouldn’tstopmyselffromfeelingattractedtohim.
“Whatever.”Ilookedawayfromhim,feelingfrustrated.“I’mgoingtogoandwaitintheliving
room.”
“Asyouwish.”Heshrugged,hisexpressionshowingthathedidn’tcareifIlefthimornot.
Iturnedaroundquickly,feelingflusteredonceagain,notreallysurewhyIwaslettingthisman
affectmeasmuchashewas.Whatwashisproblem?Whatwasmyproblem?WasIreallylettingmy
briefattractiontohimmakemethink/feelsomethingforhimthatIshouldn’tbe?Whatwasmy
problem?
“I’mEvan,bytheway.”Hesaidhisnamesilkily,sexily,andIfeltsomethinginmystomach
rumblingashestoodbehindme.Waytooclose.
“Jess,”Isaidandgavehimaquicklook.“I’mJess.”
“Nicetomeetyou,Jess,”hesaid.ThistimehismouthwasclosertomyearandIcouldfeela
thrillofexcitementrunthroughmeasIfelthiswarmbreathagainstmyskin.Ishouldhaveknownin
thatmomentthatEvanwasdanger.IshouldhaveknownthatIwasplayingwithfirebyjustspeaking
tohim.Justbeingaroundhimwasn’tgoodformybody.There’ssomethingaboutmenwith
confidence.Somethingaboutmenwhohavecharisma.There’ssomethingaboutoldermen.They
don’tplaygamesandtheyaren’thesitant.Theygoafterwhattheywantandsometimestheydon’tcare
whatorwhoisintheway.CertainlyEvandidn’t.Hedidn’tcareatall.Andultimately,Ididn’tcare
either.Ididn’tcarethatIwasjumpinghead-firstoffofagiantcliff.Ididn’trealizeitthatnight.I
mean,yeah,IknewI’dfoundhimattractive,buttherearealotofattractivemenintheworld.Iknew
hewasobnoxious,buttherearealotofobnoxiousmenintheworld.IknewIwantedhimandthat
there—thatthereshouldhavetoldmewhatIneededtoknow,butsometimeswe’redumb.Sometimes
wedon’tlistentoourownvoices.Ididn’tlistentomyinnervoiceandthat’showIendedupinthe
mosttantalizingscenarioofmylife.AndwhenIsaytantalizing,Imeaninthemostscandaloussense
oftheword.
J
C H A P T E R 3
ess
P
IERCE
O
LIVER
.He’sthekindofguythateverygirlwantstobewith.Charmingdoesn’tevenbeginto
describehim.But,Imean,youknowthat,fromourfirstmeetingatthebar.Hehascharmand
confidenceand,well,lotsofothergoodqualities.Andhe’scut.Hischestislikeaworkofart.Six-
packalert.Hothothot.MaybenotashotasEvan,butmoreclassicallyhandsome.Notthatthat
matters,anyways.Iwasn’tevensurewhyIwascomparingPiercetoEvan.Evanwasnothingtome.
HewasjustanarrogantprickfriendofPierce’sthatIdidn’tevenreallyknow.Backtothesix-pack.
Pierce’ssix-pack,notEvan’s.Honestly,I’veneverdatedaguywithasix-packbefore.Notthatwe’re
dating.We’regoingonourfirst“official”datetomorrownight.I’mexcited,ofcourseIam.I’mjust
hopingthatwewon’thavemoreEthiopianfood.Imean,ifhetakesmeoutforEthiopianagainthen
therewillnotbeanotherdate.Therewillbenomakingout.Therewillbenogroping.Nodry-
humping.Nosecretwhispersandtugs.Nochanceofpossiblenookyforeitherofus.Which,ifI’m
honest,I’msurprisedhehasn’tbeenpressingalittleharderfor.Iwasn’tevenreallysurePierce
wouldcallafterourfirstcoupleofmeetupsafterthenightwemetattheclub.We’dmadeoutabitand
Iknewhewantedmore,butI’mjustnotthatkindofgirl.Iwouldn’tmindbeingthatkindofgirl,but
forsomereasonIjustcan’tdocasualsex.AtleastnotwithPierce.It’sallthoseyearsofSunday
school.Andmymomtellingmethatgoodgirlsdon’thavesexonthefirstdate.Icouldn’tcareless
aboutbeingagoodgirl,butpicturingmymom’ssternfacestillmakesmepanic.IthoughtI’dblown
itwithPierce,honestly.Imean,thewaywe’dbeengoingonattheclub,I’msurehe’dthoughtI’dbea
surething.I’deventhoughtIwasgoingtobeasurethingthatnightandI’mnotthatsortofgirl.Ithad
reallysurprisedmethathewantedtoseemeagain,especiallyasI’dthoughtthatheonlywantedsex
and,well,hehadn’tgottenthatfromme.Butturnsoutnosexdidn’tmeannomoredates.
IthinkI’machallengetohim.Menlovechallenges.Especiallyfromgirlswhoseemlikethey
mightbeasurething,asIhadintheclub.I’manenigmatohim,Ithink.I’dlefttheclubwithhim
quiteeasilythatfirstnight;I’devensurprisedmyselfathoweagerI’dbeenaswe’dfumbledoutthe
doorswhilekissing.I’dhadafewdrinksandwe’ddancedtoacoupleofsongsandI’dletmyselfget
carriedaway.He’dpulledmeintothealleynexttotheclubandI’dlethimpressmebackupagainst
thecoldbrickwallandstartkissingmyneck.Hislipshadbeenwarmashe’dsuckedonmyskinand
hishandshadrunupanddownmybodyinahaphazardway.Tobehonest,I’dbeensurprisedbyhis
lackoffinesse.Hehadn’treallyexcitedmeinthatcarnallyexplicitwayI’dexpected.Hisfingershad
runovermybreastsandI’dalmostbeennonchalant.Imean,yeahitwashot,butnotashotasI’d
thoughtitwouldbe.Nothotlikeinthosemovies.Orpornos.NotthatIwantedtobeinaporno,but
youknowwhatImean.Iwasexpectingheatfactormultipliedbytwenty.Whenyou’reinthekindof
situationwhereyouareleavingaclubwithahotman,youshouldn’tbethinkingaboutwhatsortof
pantiesyouhaveonandifthebouncersmightpossiblycatchyouintheactandcallthepolice.When
you’reinthattypeofsituation,allyoushouldbethinkingaboutishowmuchyouwanttobetakenand
howyoucan’twaittogetyourlegsupandwrappedaroundhiswaistsohecanfuckyouashardas
possible.Ican’tsaythatIwasthinkingthatandthatisprobablywhyhewasn’tabletosealthedeal.
Instead,we’dleftthealleyandwenttogetsomecheappizzaandIendedupgoingbackwithhimto
hisapartment,wherewewatchedsomecrappymovieonNetflixwhileIlethimrunhishandsupand
downmythighsbeforeIfellasleeponhischest,myhandrestingonhissemi-hardnessbeforeIfell
offintooblivion.Soyeah,Iwassurprisedthathe’daskedmeoutagain.Iwasalsosurprisedthathe
seemedtobesotakenwithmesoquickly.Ididn’tthinkthatwashowthesethingsnormallywent.
Guysashotashimgenerallydidn’twastetimewithgirlslikemewhodidn’tevenreallyknowwhat
wewanted.Butthat’salwayshowlifegoes,right?Wealwaysgettheguyswedon’treallycareabout
thatmuch,andtheoneswereallywantcan’tevenbebotheredwithus.Atleastthat’showmylife
alwaysgoes.JustforonceIwantedtobeinasituationwhereIfeltalittlebitofexcitementforand
fromaguyIreally,reallywantedtobewith.
PiercearrivedhomeabouttwentyminutesafterI’dleftEvaninthekitchenbyhimself.Ihaveno
ideawhatEvanhadbeendoinginthekitchenduringthattime,butIknowthathedidn’tcomeoutto
thelivingroomtocheckonme.
“Hey,you,”Piercesaidasheenteredtheapartmentandgavemeahugesmile.“SorryI’mlate.”
“That’sokay.”Isatonhiscouchawkwardly,wonderingifIshouldstandupandifitwas
appropriatetotryandhugandkisshim,asifIhadn’tjustbeenpartiallyoglinghisfriend.“Where
wereyouandhowwereyouabletobuzzmeintothebuilding?”
“ThebuzzerisconnectedtomycellphonesoI’mabletobuzzanyoneinfromanywhere.”He
shrugged.“Youshouldbehappyaboutthat,right?Atleastyoudidn’thavetowaitoutsideforme.”
“I’mnotcomplaining,wasjustcurious.”Ishruggedandstoodupasheheadedtowardsme.Igave
himanawkwardhugandhewentforakissonmylipsbutgotmycheekinsteadasIturnedmyfaceat
thelastmoment.
“Didyoumissme,then?”heasked,notseemingtorealizethatsomethingwasoff.
“Yeah,”Iliedandlookedathimwithanawkwardsmile.WhatthehellwasIdoinginthis
situation?FeelinguncomfortableandweirdwiththisguyIthoughtwasattractive,butalittleoff.
“Wedon’thavetogoouttoeatifyoudon’twant.”Hishandfelltothesmallofmyback.“Wecan
justeathere.”
“Oh?”Isaid,wonderingifhewasgoingtocookforme.Thatcouldberomantic.“Whatwould
youmake?”
“Iwouldn’tmakeanything.”Helookedconfused.“Mybodyisalreadyhereandsoisyours.”
“Huh?”Ifrowned,lookingconfused.“Whatdoesthathavetodowithanything?”
“Wecaneathereorinmybedroom.”Hewinked.
“Oh.”Ijuststaredathim.Thiswasalmostworsethanifhe’dtakenmeforEthiopianfood.Didhe
reallythinkthiswason?Invitingmetodinner,gettingmeexcitedforfreefood,makingmewait
twenty-plusminutes,subjectingmetohishotfriendandthenbasicallycheapeningoutandsayinghe
wantedsex?Andnotevenaftersomefood.Whatthehellwasgoingonhere?
“Idon’tthinkJessisdownforthatplan.”AdeepvoiceenteredtheroomandIfroze.Evanwas
back.Notthathe’dgoneanywhere,buthewasbackinthesameroomasme.
“Oh,you’vemetJess?”PierceturnedaroundandlookedatEvan.
“Yeah,wejustmet.Whileyouwereout.”Evannoddedandwalkedtowardsus,hiseyesglittering
ashestaredatme.“Shewassurprisedtoseeme.”
“Yeah,Iforgottotellheryouwerehere.”Piercenodded.“Well,Ididn’trealizeyou’dstillbe
here.Ithoughtyouhadabusinessdinner?”
“Itgotcancelled.”Evanshrugged.“FiguredI’dstickaroundthecityforthenight,butmaybeI’ve
overstayedmywelcome.”
“Ofcoursenot.”Pierceshookhishead.“Wannajoinusfordinner?”
“Inyourbedroom?”EvanraisedaneyebrowandlookedatPierceandwinkedbeforehestarted
laughing.
“Haha,yeahright.”PiercelaughedaswellandtheybothlookedatmewithanimatedfacesasI
stoodthereuncomfortably,wonderingifthiswassomesortoftest.MaybePiercehaddeliberatelyput
meinthispositiontotestme.MaybeEvanhadbeenwaitinginthekitchenonpurpose.Been
deliberatelyprovocative.Maybetheywerehopingforsomesortofkinkythreesome.Icouldfeelmy
skinwarmingasIstaredatthetwohandsomemeninfrontofme.
“Youhavethewronggirl,fellas,”Isaid,myvoiceindignant.
“Sorry,what?”Piercelookedatmeinconfusion,butIcouldseethatEvan’seyeswerealightwith
mischief.HeknewexactlywhatIwastalkingabout.
“I’mnotthatsortofgirl,”IsaidlouderthistimeasItookastepbackfromPierce.“I’mnot
interestedinthatsortofthing.”
“Whatsortofthing?”Pierceaskedme,scratchinghishead.
“Aménageàtrois.”Iglaredathim.“Youmusthavethoughtyou’dgottenagoodoneattheclub
theothernight,butIamnotthatsortofgirl.I’mshockedyouhaven’trealizedthatyet.Actually,I’m
notshocked.”Ishookmyhead.
“Whyareyounotshocked?”Piercelookedevenmoreconfusedashestudiedmyface.
“BecauseyoutookmeoutforEthiopianfoodtwotimesinarow.”
“So?”Hepursedhislipsandlookedevenmoreconfused.“DidyouwantEthiopianagaintonight?
Isthatwhatthisisallabout?Wecangoout.Don’tgetyourknickersinatwist,Iwasjustteasingyou.”
“No,Idon’twantanyhorribleEthiopianfood.”Iglaredathim.“ThisiswhatImean.I’vetoldyou
twotimesnow,Idon’tlikeit.Idon’twantit.Ever.”
“Oh,okay.”Heshrugged.“Wedon’thavetogetit.Ionlysuggesteditbecauseyoubroughtitup.”
“IbroughtitupbecauseIwastryingtomakeapoint.”Isighedloudly,feelingfrustratedand
annoyed.EvanwasstaringatmewithahugegrinonhisfaceandIcouldtellthathewastryingnotto
laugh,whichwasevenmoreannoyingtome.
“Whatpoint?”heaskeddumblyandIstartedtowonderwhatI’dseeninhim.
“ThepointaboutwhyIwouldn’tbeshockedifyouthoughtIwasthesortofgirlwhowouldwant
athreesomewithyouandthinkI’dbedown,eventhoughitwasclearfromallofmysignsthatIwas
notinterestedinthatsortofthingatall.Imean,wehaven’tevenhadsexyet,soIdon’tknowwhy
you’dthinkI’dbedownforanythingmorethanthat.I’mnotdownforrandom-asssex.And
especiallynotaménageàtrois.Iwouldneverbedownforthat.”Iwasn’tsurewhyI’dmentionedwe
hadn’thadsexyet.MaybeasubconsciouspartofmewantedEvantoknowthat.Itoldyou,I’m
certifiablycrazy.
“DidIaskyouforaménageàtrois?”Piercelookedatmeandblinked.Thenhelookedoverat
Evan.“AmImissingsomethinghere?”
“Ithinkit’sJessthat’smissingsomething,”Evansaidwithastraightface.Iglaredathimashe
tappedtwofingersnexttothetopofhishead.Iglaredathimevenharderandhestartedgrinningat
me,enjoyingthefactthathewasmakingmeangry.
“You’resorude,”Isaid,myjawdroppingashespunhisfingerinacirclenexttohishead,
blatantlytryingtoprovokemebycallingmecrazy.
“Sorry,what?”Evansaid,hisfaceamaskofinnocence.
“You’renotsorry.”
“IneversaidIwassorry.Isaid,‘sorry,what?’”Hepausedandthenstartedspeakingslowly.“Iwas
saying‘sorry,what?’toindicatethatIhadnoideawhyyouwerecallingmerudeandwouldyoubeso
kindastoexplaintomewhatthatreasonwas?”
“YoureallyhavenoideaastowhyIthinkyou’rerude?”Ishookmyheadathim.“Yeah,right?”I
lookedoveratPiercetoseewhathewasgoingtosay,buthedidn’tsayordoanything.
“Nope.”Evanclearedhisthroat.“Butifyouclarify,thenImighthaveanidea.”
“It’sfine.”Ipursedmylips,feelinglikeIwasevenmoreconfusedmyselfnow.Iwasn’tevensure
whatwewerearguingaboutanymore.Hewastalkingincirclesandthesparkleinhiseyeswas
makingmeforgetmyownname.IknewthatheknewexactlywhathewasdoingandIwasprettysure
thatIwasmakingmyselflooklikeanidiotinthesituation,butIcouldn’thelpit.“It’sfine.Maybewe
justhadamisunderstanding.”
“Yeah,Ifeellikeseveralwiresgotcrossedhere,”Piercesaidwithasmallsmile.“Maybewe’reall
justhungry.”
“Yeah,maybethat’sit,”Isaidwithasmallfrown,wantingtorollmyeyes,butknowingthatwould
bechildish.IwishedthatAlyssaweretheresoshecouldseehowridiculousthesituationwas.How
couldPiercenotseehowrudeEvanwas?Maybeheknew,buthedidn’tcareormaybehewasjust
oblivioustoitnow.Maybehe’ddealtwithEvan’sinappropriatecommentssomanytimesbeforethat
hefeltitwasnormal.Idon’tknowwhatthatsaidabouthim,butIknewthatIshouldgivehimthe
benefitofthedoubt.Itwasn’thisfaultthathehadadoucheyfriend.AndEvandefinitelylookedolder
thanPierce,soheshouldknowbetter.Muchbetter.IlookedoveratEvanandhestillhadaslight
smirkonhisfaceandIknewhewasaninstigator.Heknewexactlywhathewasdoing.Iwondernow
ifhe’dknownfromthebeginning.Ifhe’dhadaplanfromthestartand,ifnot,whentheplancame
intoplace.Iftherewasaplan,ofcourse.Whoknows?SometimesIwonderifitwasallme.
SometimesIwonderifIwastheinstigator,thefire-starter.Maybeapartofmehadbeenfedupofmy
staidandboringlife.Maybeapartofmewantedsomethingexcitingtohappen.Though,I’mnotsure
thatIwouldhavewantedittochangethatmuch.Iwasn’tcrazy.OratleastI’dneverthoughtthatIwas
crazybefore.
“Shallweallgoandgrababite,then?”Evanaskedwithasmallsmile.“Mytreat,asIseemtobe
partofthereasonforallthisconfusionanddrama.”
“Iwon’tsaynotoafreemeal.”PiercegrinnedandIjuststaredathim.WhathadhappenedtoMr.
confidentandgenerousfromtheclub?Wherewasthemanwhojustwantedtospendtimealonewith
me?Couldn’theseethatEvanwastrouble?Couldn’theseethesparksflying?Couldn’theseethat
thiswasabadidea?Obviouslynot.
“Good.Iknowagreatplace.”Evannoddedwithasatisfiedsmileandhegavemeasmallwink.
“Thefoodisgood,buttheviewsareevenbetter.Iknowyou’llappreciatethat,Jess.”
“Yeah,you’resothoughtful.”Ijuststaredathimwithnarrowedeyes.Iwasn’tgoingtorisetothe
baitanymore.Iwasnotgoingtolethimrilemeup.Atleastthat’swhatItoldmyself.Aww,thelieswe
tellourselvesinthehopesthattheywillturnouttobetrue.
J
C H A P T E R 4
ess
T
HE
FIRST
TOUCH
shouldhavealertedmetothefactthatEvanwasn’tjustalltalk.Imean,thereare
accidentaltouchesandthenthereareaccidentaltouches.Aquickkneegrabisnotanaccidentaltouch
byanystretchoftheimagination.Akneegraze,maybe,butakneesqueeze,noway.Especiallynot
onethatlastsforoverfiveseconds.Fivesecondsdoesn’tsoundlikealotoftime,buttrycountingit
out.One.Two.Three.Four.Five.That’salotoftimeforahand—astrangehand—tobeonyourknee,
squeezingit.
Whoevensqueezesaknee?Itseemssoweird.It’snotlikekneesareknowntobehugely
erogenouszones.AtleastIdidn’tthinkthattheywereknowntobe,butaswealreadyknowI’mnot
exactlythesexexpert.
AndperhapsEvanis.Hemostdefinitelyseemstobeifthethrillthatranthroughmybodywhenhe
touchedmykneewasanythingtogoby.WhenItellyouIthoughtmykneewasgoingtocatchonfire,
I’mnotexaggerating.Atfirst,IthoughtitwasPierce’shandonmykneeandIwasgoingtopluckit
away.Iwasalreadyannoyedwithhim.Imean,howcouldhethinkthatitwasokaytoturnourdate
intoathree-waydinner?Itwasn’treallyagreatsignwhenthepersonyouwereinterestedinwantedto
bringsomeoneelseonthedate.Theonlyconsolationwasthatitwasn’tanothergirl.Thatwouldhave
beenfriggingridiculous.Butyeah,backtotheknee-grab.IknewafteraboutasecondthatitwasEvan
andnotPiercegrabbingmyknee,justfromthewaythatEvan’shandsqueezedsowarmlyand
intimately.Itwaslikemybodyknew,heythisissomeoneelse.Someonesuper-hot.Someonethat
wouldbegreatinbed,anditreactedimmediatelytothatthought.Iknowthatsoundscrazy.Itsounds
crazyinmyownheadaswell,butthat’stheonlywaytoexplainthewayIfelt.Assoonashetouched
me,IfeltasifIweregoingtointernallycombust.Anditwaslikeheknewit,ifthesmileonhisface
wasanyindication.IdecidednottochastisehimforthekneesqueezebecausereallywhatcouldIsay?
HewouldprobablyclaimthatithadbeenanaccidentandI’dlooklikeanidiotifItriedtoobjectto
that.EspeciallyafterhowcoolI’dbeenearlierintheapartmentandsoIsaidnothing.Whichmost
likelyisthereasonwhyhebelievedthathecouldbeevenmoredaringwhenwewereordering
dessert.
Themealhadgonefairlywellupuntilthatpoint.Ihadn’tsaidmuch.AndEvanandPiercehadn’t
caredtotrytoincludemeintheconversationmuch.Thatnormallywouldhavebotheredme,sinceI
wantedtobeincluded,butIwasalreadyfeelingconfusedsoIdidn’treallymindthatmuch.Isatthere
listeningtothemandIwonderedtomyselfexactlyhowtheykneweachother.IwantedtoaskbutI
didn’t.I’daskPiercelater.Ididn’twantEvantothinkthatIcaredaboutanythingtodowithhim.
Thesecondtouchwasmuchmoreofathrillandmademejump.InfactIalmostknockedovermy
glassofwineasIjumpedoutofmyseat.ThistimeEvanwasn’tjustgoingforakneesqueeze.This
timeEvanwasgoingforathighsqueezeand,yeah,thatshockedme.WhenIfelthisfingersonmy
thigh,Ifroze.Thenhisfingerssqueezedand,foronecrazysecond,Ithoughtthathewasgoingtotry
todosomethingevenmoreoutrageous.Ithoughthewasgoingtomovehisfingershigher.Thatwas
whyIjumped.Icouldn’tbelievewhathewasdoingandofcoursePiercewasoblivious.Ididn’tknow
howsomeonewhohadseemedsowithitinthebeginningcouldbesodumb,orifthiswaspartofhis
planortheirplan.Ihadn’tcompletelydisownedthefactthatperhapstheywereinonsomecraziness
together.Partofmethoughtthatwastheonlythingthatmadesense.WhyelsewouldEvanbesocrazy
anddaring?Didn’thethinkIorPiercewouldgetupsetathisactions?Itseemedtomethathewas
takingabigriskforacoupleofcheapthrills.
ThesadpartwasthatIdidn’thateit.Imean,ofcourseIwasaghast.I’mnotacompleteheathen.I
mean,yes,eventhoughIwasshockedandtakenaback,Ikindoflikedit,thethrill.Thedangerous
excitementthathesparkedinmewithhistouchwasintoxicating.Itbothscaredandexcitedme.Iwas
prettysureifPiercehadattemptedthesamethingIwouldhavedismissedhimrightaway.Iwould
haveslappedhishandawayandtoldhimwheretogetoff.AsmuchasIlikedhim,Ididn’tlethimget
awaywiththatsortofcrap.HehadtriedhardthatfirstnightbutIhadn’tfeltthisknee-jerkreactionto
him.Imeanthat’skindofunfairtosay.Ihadthoughthewassuperattractive,Imean,howcould
anyonenotthinkthat?Hehadananimalmagnetismthatmostmendidn’tpossess,butunfortunately
forPierce,Evanwasevenmoremagnetic.Hehadasparkthatwasevenmoreelectrifying.Itwas
somethingIcouldn’texplainandIthinkheknewit.That’swhyhewaspushinghishand,inmore
waysthanone.Heenjoyedplayingwithmeandgettingariseoutofme,thoughIwasn’tsurewhy.
Whatdidhehavetogainfromflirtingwithmeandtryingtopushhiswill?Allitdidwasshowthathe
wasn’tagoodfriendtoPierce.Hewasn’tagoodfriendatall,unlesstheywerebothtryingtotestme
insomeway.WhichIwasprettysurewasn’ttrue.Pierceseemedprettyoblivioustoeverythingthat
wasgoingonandIdidn’tthinkhewasthatgoodofanactor.Notatall.Itseemedtomethatifheknew
whathewasdoinghewouldhavebeengivingmeknowinglooksandprobablysmallsmirksand
winks.Hewasn’tthesubtlesort.Notatall.Hewasblatantinwhathewantedandwhilethatwaseasier
tounderstand,itwassomethingalittlenicetonotknowandtobeontheedgeofattraction.
Iwouldneveradmitthatoutloud.Imean,whatwomanreallywantedtoadmitthatconfusioncan
beanaphrodisiac?Whatwomanwantstoadmitthatwecanbelikeboysaswell?Thechase,thenot
exactlyknowingwherewestandcanmaketheeventualconquestalotsweeter.NotthatIwasahunter
andnotthatIwantedtobepreyeither.Hellno,Ididn’treallywanttobeeither.Itwasaweirdthingto
bedating.Itwasaweirdthingtodecidewhoyouwantedtomakeloveto.Iknewwhyguyswere
alwayssoconfusedbygirls.Itwasbecausewewereconfusedourselves.Justafewweeksago,I
wouldhavebeenhappytohavemetahotguylikePierce;yeah,maybeweweren’tamatchmadein
heaven,buthewasagoodegoboostfornow.
Now,itseemsPiercewasn’tgoodenough.NotthatIwantedEvan.Icertainlydidn’twantEvan.
Notatall.Justbecausehewashotandsexyandjustwouldn’tseemtodisappearfrommymind,even
thoughI’djustmethim.Ireallydidn’tunderstandwhyhewasoveratPierce’sapartmentandseemed
socomfortabletalkingtomehoweverhewanted.Ihadn’taskedPiercebecauseIdidn’twanthimto
thinkthatIwasinterestedinEvan.Ididn’twanttoletanythingslip.Hecouldn’tknowIwasattracted
tohisfriend.Hecouldn’tknowthathisfriendhadplayedwithmykneeandranhisfingersupmyleg
underthetableandthatI’denjoyedit.TherewasnowayIcouldtellhimthat.Andtherewascertainly
nowayIwantedhimtosuspecttherewaspossiblyanyinterestonmyside,whichhemightthinkifI
broughtupEvan.I’dbescaredhe’dsenseitinmyvoiceandquestionmeastowhyIwantedtoknow
anything.Imean,Ididn’tthinkitwouldbecrazyformetohavesomequestions,butIwasscaredthat
Iwouldn’tbeabletostopmyself.Thequestionsmightstartwith,“HowdoyouknowEvan?”and
“HowoldisEvan?Heseemsolderthanyou.”ThenImightstartgoingcrazy.WhatifIaskedifhe
wassingle?Ugh,thatwouldbeterrible.Piercewouldsurelyknowthenbytheeagerlookonmyface
asIwaitedonhisanswerthatImighthaveamorevestedinterestinhisanswers,andIsurelydidn’t
wanthimtothinkthat.Notatall,sothat’swhyIdidn’taskanything.Itwastoomuchofarisk,too
muchofaslipperyslopeandIsureashelldidn’tneedtoruinwhateverwasgoingonwithPierceand
Ijustforsomestupidnon-flirtationwithEvan.Arrogantprick.Heprobablydidthiswithevery
womanhemetbecauseheknewhecould.Mostprobablygotoffonsomepowertrip,seeinghowfar
hecouldgetwomentogo.Iknewtherewereguyslikethat,guyswhodidn’treallywantrelationships.
Didn’tevencareaboutthewomentheywereflirtingwith.Itwasallaboutwhattheycouldgetthe
womentodo.Howfartheycouldgethertogo,andifshewereinarelationshipwithsomeoneelse,it
wasevenmoreofathrill.
Iwishnow,ofcourse,thatI’dasked.IwishnowthatI’dsuckeditup.ThatIhadn’tbeensoscared
andstupid.IfIhadasked,maybeIwouldhaveavoidedalotofembarrassment.MaybethenIwouldn’t
havegonedownthesameroad.MaybethenIwouldhavedonethingsdifferently.Actually,whoamI
kidding?Iwouldn’thavedoneanythingdifferently.Ihadn’treallyhadthatmuchofasayinthe
matter.
J
C H A P T E R 5
ess
Y
OU
’
RE
MOST
PROBABLY
WONDERING
whyIcontinuedtodatePiercewhenitwasfairlyobviousthatwhile
we’dhadagreatinitialmeeting,oursubsequentdateshadn’tbeenallthat.Ontopofthat,it’squite
obviousIwasattractedtoEvan.ThefactisIwaslonely.Piercewasattractiveandhelikedmeandhe
wasgoodfunwhenhewantedtobe.Hedidn’tpushmeforsex,whichIreallyliked.Iwasn’tsurehow
longhe’dbecoolwiththeno-sexthing,butAlyssathoughtthathe’dalreadyshownremarkable
constraintgiventhecircumstancesunderwhichwe’dmet.AndIhadtoagreewithher.
“Jess,thatguymusthaveblueballsthatgoontotheendofdays,”Alyssahadjokedoneevening
whenwe’dstayedhometowatchrerunsofGilmoregirlsonNetflix.
“Blueballsfordays?”I’dburstoutlaughingathercomment.
“Notjustfordays,”Alyssasaidwithasmirk.“Blueballsuntiltheendofdays.”
“Endofdays,huh?”Ishookmyheadather.“That’salongtimetohavethem.”
“Yeah,itis.That’swhatyou’vedonetohim.”
“Ihaven’tdoneanythingtohim,”IsaidandallIcouldthinkaboutwasEvan.Iknow.I’mahot
mess.
“He’sagoodguy,Jess,”Alyssasaidslightlyenviously.
“He’snotbad.He’snotexactlyinlinetobeapopeoranything.Idon’tthinkSt.Peter ’saboutto
givehimanykeys.”
“Who?”Alyssaaskedblankly.
“Noone,”Isaidwithasmallsmileandshakeofmyhead.
“Sodoyouthinkyou’llsleepwithhimsoon?Puthimoutofhismisery?”
“Idon’tknow,”Isaidhonestly.Ireallydidn’tknowwhatIwasgoingtodowithPierce.Imean,a
partofmethoughtIshouldjustgetitoutoftheway.Itwasn’tlikeIdidn’tlikesex.Itwasn’tlikeI
didn’tcravethatintimacy.Ijustdidn’tknowifIcraveditwithPierce.Eventhoughhewasprettyhot
andclearlywantedme,whichwasahugeegoboost,wasanegoboostenoughforalasting
relationship?Ididn’tknow.Iwassoconfusedabouteverything.So,soconfused.
“I’dlovetomeetaguylikePierce,”Alyssacontinuedwistfully.“You’resolucky.Hemustreally
loveyou.”
“What?”Ialmostchokedatherwords.“Love?Webarelyknoweachother.Alyssa,hedoesn’t
loveme.Hebarelyknowsme.Whywouldyoueventhinkorsaythat?Areyoucrazy?”
“Girl,hehastoloveyou,”shesaidseriously.“Idon’tknowmanyguyswhowouldputupwithno
sex.AndI’mtalkinguglyguysandwebothknowthatPiercedoesn’tqualifyasugly.He’shotashell.
Hecanhavemodelsinhisbedeverynightoftheweekifhewants,yethe’sbeingcalmandpatient
withyou,waitingaroundforwhoknowswhat.”
“It’sbecauseI’machallenge.”Ifrowned.“Butthanks,Alyssa,you’resuremakingmefeelbetter
aboutmyself.”
“Whatdoyoumean?”Shesatupandlookedatme.
“Imean,I’mgladhecouldhaveahotmodelinhisbedeverynight,buthe’ssettlingforme.”
“Ididn’tsayhe’ssettlingforyou.”Shesighed.“Andyou’rehottoo,youknowthat.”
“Uhhuh.Let’snotcomparemetosomeVictoria’sSecretmodelthough,whichweknowhecan
get.”
“Oh,Jess.”Alyssagotupfromhercouchandwalkedovertome.“That’snotwhatImeantand
youknowthat.That’snotwhatImeantatall.Iwasjustsayingthatyouhaveagoodguywhoreally
likesyouandthatshouldmakeyouhappy.Thatshouldmakeyoufeelgoodaboutyourself.Idon’t
knowwhyyouaren’thappier.”
“What’stheretobehappyabout?”
Ilookedatherwithasmallfrown.“IfanythingI’mnotlivinguptomyendofthebargain.I’mnot
givinghimwhathedeserves—whatother,morebeautiful,womenwouldgivehim.”
“Jess,whatisgoingonwithyou?Whereareyougettingthatfrom?”Alyssatouchedmyshoulder.
“Areyouokay?”Ifeellikeyou’renotactinglikeyou’resuperhappyforsomeonewho’sinthis
situation.”
“Whatsituation,Alyssa?WhatsituationamIinthatshouldmakemesohappy?”Iturnedtoher
andfrowned.“Imetahotguyinaclub.Welefttheclub,madeout.Hewashopingforsex,didn’tget
it.We’vebeenonacoupleofdates—well,morethanacouple,andI’msurehe’sstillhopingforsex
andmaybethat’swhyhe’skeepingmearound.Therehavebeennodeclarationsofloveoranything
closetothat.Noflowers,nojewelry.Nonothingofsubstance.Idon’tevenknowifhereallylikesme
orifhe’sjustwaitingtogetlaid.Andhonestly,I’mnotsurehowIfeelabouthim,orifIwantto
possiblyhookupwithhishotfriend,Evan,becauseIsuck.”
“Wait,what?’Alyssagaspedloudly.“WhothefuckisEvan?Andwhyhaven’tIheardofhim
before?”
“Evanisthebigproblem.”Isighedandleanedbackonthecouch,groaning.“Oh,myGod,
Alyssa,Ihaven’tbeenabletotalkaboutitbecauseI’msoembarrassedandashamedbutthisguy
Evan…Argh.”IgroanedloudlyandclosedmyeyesforafewsecondsasIpicturedhisface.“Oh,my
God,Ihaven’tbeenabletogethimoutofmymind.He’sthereasonwhyIhaven’tbeenabletosleep
withPierceyet.Youdon’tknowhowthisguyhasgottenundermyskinalready.It’scrazy.Idon’teven
knowhim.Barelymethimonceortwice.Barelyhadaconversationwithhimandtheconversations
wehavehadhaveshownmethathe’sanarrogantasshole.Arealbastard.Idon’tevenknowwhat’s
wrongwithme.He’sabsolutelyhorrible.Cocky,fullofhimself.Arealjerk.Andheeventouchedme.
Albeititwasonmykneeandkindaonmythigh,butstill—howrude,right?Buteventhoughhe’s
everythingwehateinaguythere’ssomethingabouthimthat’sgottenundermyskinandIjustdon’t
knowwhy.IjustdonotunderstandwhyIcan’tstopthinkingabouthim.I’mahorrible,horrible
person,Alyssa.IknowIam.Ifeelabsolutelyhorrible,butIjustcan’thelpmyself.And,man,he’sso,
sococky—Isaidthat,right?What’sworseisthatheseemstobereallyclosetoPierce,soheseemsto
alwaysbearound.It’slikethisweirdkindoftorture.”Ifinallystoppedtalkingandlookedoverat
AlyssatoseeherexpressiontowhatI’djustconfessedtoher.Iwassurprisedtoseeahugesmileon
herface.“What’ssofunny?Iaskedherwithnarrowedeyes.
“You.”Shegiggled.“IneverthoughtI’dseethisday.”
“Whatday?”Ifrowned.
“Thedaythatyoubecameaplayer.”
“I’mnotaplayer.”Ipoutedmylips.“I’mfarfromaplayer.”
“Youaresoaplayer.”Alyssaalmostcackledingleeasshebouncedupanddownonthecouch.
“Whowouldhavethunkit?”
“Alyssa,I’mnotaplayer.Youhavetobedatingmultipleguystobeaplayer.I’mnotdoingthat.
I’mbarelydatingoneguy.”
“Yeah,butyouarekindaintohisfriendandfromwhatyou’resaying,italsoseemslikehe’sinto
youaswell.”Shesmiledatmeinglee.“Imean,ifhe’stouchingyou,itsoundslikehehasaninterest
inyouaswell.”
“Alyssa,ugh.Don’t.He’stheplayer.He’snotintome.He’sjusttryingtoplayme.”Imadeaface.
“Imagineifyoustartdatingbothofthematthesametime.”Hereyeswidenedandsheclappedher
handsexcitedlylikealittlechild.“Oh,myGod,Ican’tbelieveyou,Jess.Thisissoexciting!”
“Whatareyoutalkingabout?”IglancedatherbutIcouldn’tstopasmallsmilefromcrossingmy
face.“Thisishardlyexciting.”
“Yes,itis.I’minshock.”Alyssajumpedup.“Thiscallsforsomemusicandasmalldanceparty.”
“Danceparty?”Igaveheralook.“Really?Adanceparty?Whydoesthiscallforadanceparty?”
“Becausedancingisfunandyou’refinallybecomingawoman!”
“Huh?”Igaveheraconfusedlook.“Whatthehellareyoutalkingabout?”
“You’refinallyhittingyourstrideinyoursexuality.”Shegrinned.
“Iam?”
“Surelookslikeittome.”Shenoddedandreachedoutherhandstome.“PauseLoreleiandRory
andlet’sgetsomePitbullupinhere.”
“Alyssa,youmakemelaugh.”Ishookmyheadather.“HereIamfeelinglikeshitaboutmyself,
yetyou’reactinglikeIjusttoldyouIwonthelottery—andnotadollarscratch-offeither.You’re
actinglikeItoldyouthatIjustwonamillionbucksorsomething.Thisisnotsomethingdeservingof
adancepartyanddefinitelynotPitbull.Nextthingyou’llbesayingisthatweneedsomeNickiMinaj
aswellandyouknowthatthatisjustnoton.”
“Oh,Jess,comeon,let’shavesomefun.Stopbeingsorepressed.Ownit.Shit,fuckPierceand
Evan.Whocares?Ifyouwanttodoit,doit.Justmakesureyouuseprotection.Wedon’tneedany
babiesupinhereandwesureashelldon’twanttobeonMaury.”
“Maury?”Iaskedherinconfusion.
“Howelsewouldweknowwhothebabydaddyis?”Alyssaaskedwithawink.
“Alyssa,”Ishoutedatherandlaughed.“You’reabsolutelyhorrible.Iamnotaslut.”
“Well,maybeyoushouldbe.”Shewinkedagain.
“Dude,youwerejustsayingPiercehasblueballs.Idon’tgofromgivingoneguyblueballsto
notgivingtwoguysblueballs.”
“Doesthatsentenceevenmakesense,Jess?”AlyssawalkedovertoherBoseSpeaker.“Ithink
not.”Shepluggedherphoneintothespeakerandpressedplay.TaylorSwifteruptedintotheroom
tellingusto“shakeitoff”andwebothstartedlaughing.Ijumpedupoffofthecouchandwalkedover
toAlyssaandwestarteddancinginthemiddleoftheroomasifneitherofushadacareintheworld.
MyworriesaboutPierceandEvanweregoneandhersadnessofhavingnoonewasgonewaswell,
losttothemusicasweletourselvesletgoofallourconcerns.
“DidItellyouthatPierceadoptedadog?”IsaidasIdancedaroundtheroomwithAlyssa.“His
nameisSquirrel.”
“Squirrel?”Alyssagavemeanastonishedlookandwebothjuststartedgigglinguncontrollably.
MaybeIneededtonottakethissituationsoseriously.MaybeAlyssawasright.Ijustneededtogowith
it.Besides,whateverwasgoingtohappenwasgoingtohappenregardlessofhowmuchIanalyzedor
thoughtaboutit.
J
C H A P T E R 6
ess
H
AVE
youevergoneintoasituationknowingthatitwasn’tgoingtobewhatyouexpected?Like,you
knewthingswouldbedifferent,yetyoustillwentintoit,notreallycaringorevenhopingforthe
outcometobedifferent?
IknewthenightthatIdecidedtogoovertoPierce’splacetolookafterhisdogwhilehewasout
oftownwasgoingtobeoneofthosesituations.I’mnotsurehoworwhy.Itwasn’tasifIknewthat
Evanwouldbethere.Imean,I’dhopedthathewouldbe.I’dhopedthatwe’dgettobanterbackand
forthagainandI’dgettomakesarcasticjabsathimwhileadmiringhimfromafar.Imean,hewasa
jerkandIcouldn’tstandhim.Hewasjustfartoococky.Especiallyforamanhisage.Whodidhe
thinkhewas?Ididn’tthinkitwasappropriateforhimtoflirtwithmeinthewayhehadknowingthatI
waskindofdatingPierce.Itseemed—forgetseemed,itwascompletelyinappropriate.Yet,therewas
somethinginhisactionsthatmadethesituationevenmoreexcitingandsexy.Dangerous,even.How
farcouldwepushit?Howmuchcouldhesay?HowrudecouldIbebacktohim?Atwhatpointwould
wereachthelinethatshouldn’tbecrossed?Maybenever,maybewe’djustcontinuelikethis?But
then,howcouldthiscontinue?WhatwouldPiercethink?Wouldhefinditstrange?Ofcourse,he’d
finditstrange.ButIdidn’tcare.Iwasn’tthinkingaboutanyofthat.Iwasn’tthinkingabouttheifs,
ands,orbuts.Iwasonlythinkingabouttheexcitement.Iwasonlythinkingaboutthebanter.Andso
that’swhyIeagerlywenttopet-sitthatnight.That’swhyIagreedtodosomethingIknewcould
potentiallyleadtosomethingprettycrazy.It’sasifIwantedtogodownCrazyStreet.
IarrivedatPierce’saroundsix.Hisdog“Squirrel”—astupiddognameifeverIheardone—ran
uptome,histailwaggingasIenteredtheapartment.IgroanedwhenIrealizedthathe’dalreadyhad
anaccidentonthefloor.I’dthoughtPiercehadsaidthedogwashouse-trainedwhenhe’dadopted
him.IconsideredleavingthepeeonthefloorandpretendingthathehaddoneitafterI’dleftbutthenI
realizedthathemostlikelywoulddoitagain.Andseveralpuddlesofpeeinthelivingroomwouldn’t
beexplainedaslastminuteanditwouldprobablystinkintheapartment.Itwasalreadystartingto
smellalittlebadandhe’donlydoneonepeesofar.
“Hey,Squirrel.”Ireacheddowntoscratchhimbetweentheearsandheeagerlylickedmyhand,
leavingalargeamountofslobberonmyskinthatIimmediatelywipedawayonmyjeans.Gross!
Yeah,soifyoudidn’tknowbynow,I’mnotexactlyadogperson.Notreally.Whichiswhyitmakesit
evenshadierthatI’dagreedtodog-sit.IneverwouldhavedoneitifIhadn’tthoughtthattherewould
beapossibilitythatEvanwouldbethere.Yeah,Itoldyou,Ilikeplayingwithfire.
“Squirrel,doyouwanttogoonawalk?”Iaskedthedog,stupidlywaitingforananswer,asifI
thoughthe’drespond.HedidwaghistailandIknewthathewaseagerforawalk.Igroanedinwardly,
sinceIdidn’treallywanttowalkhim.Ihadnocluehowtoproperlywalkadogandespeciallynoton
thestreetsofSanFranciscowherethereweresomanyhills.Iwasn’tinbadshape,butthethoughtof
walkingapoopingandpeeingSquirrelupanddownhillswasn’tanexcitingprospectforme.
“Okay,okay,where’syourleash?”Ilookedaroundtheroomandsighed,knowingthatI’dhaveto
tidyupthemessthathealreadymadeintheapartmentaswell.ItamazedmethatPiercehadadopteda
dog.Hewasjustsoputtogetherandsuave.Hejustwasn’tthesortofguywhoyou’dthinkwouldown
anoverweightbassethoundthatseemedtohavetoiletissues.Andhecertainlydidn’tseemtobethe
sortofguytonamesaiddogSquirrel.Like,whatthehell?Hadhebeenhighwhenhenamedhisdog?
Ormaybe—andIwassurprisedthatatwingeofjealousyhadn’thitmeatthethought—anex-
girlfriendhadnamedapreviousdogthathe’downedSquirrelandshe’dkeptthedogwhenthey
brokeup.Maybetheexhadevenlivedwithhim.Ilookedaroundthelivingroom,considering.Was
thisthesortofroomaguywouldhavechosenthefurniturefor?Everythingseemedtomatchsowell.
ItalmostlookedlikeaphotofromaPotteryBarnorRestorationHardwarecatalog.Hmm,maybe
Piercehadevenbeenengagedbefore?Maybehewasstillinlovewithher.Iwaitedtofeelthe
inevitablechurninginmystomachatthethoughtofhimtrulylovingsomeoneelse,butitneverhit
me.Iwassurprised.WasmylackofjealousyrelatedtothefactthatIdidn’tcareenough,orwasit
relatedtothefactthatIfeltthatconfidentinour“relationship”?We’donlymetacoupleofweeksago
andmadeoutacoupleoftimes.Wehadn’tevenhadsexyet.AfactthatIthinksurprisedbothofusfor
differentreasons.Partofmethoughtthatthereasonhestillkeptmearoundwasrelatedtothefactthat
I’dbecomeachallengetohim.Maybehewasonlyspendingtimewithmebecausehewantedtoget
meintobed.Maybethatwashisendgameandoncehehadmeitwouldallbedone.Imean,Iknew
howguyswere.Iknewthatsexwasabigthingandtheylikedachase.MaybehethoughtIwasplaying
games.MaybehethoughtthatIwasoneofthosegirlswhowasusingsexasagatewayintoamore
seriousrelationship.Iwasn’tsurewhathewasthinkingandIwasn’tsurewhyIhadn’tsleptwithhim
yet.Itwasn’tbecauseIdidn’tfancyhim;Ithoughthewashotashell.AndIwasphysicallyattractedto
him.Mybodydidwanthim,yetsomethingalwaysstoppedmefromgoingalltheway.Maybeitwas
becauseIwasn’tsureI’dbeabletokeepupwithhiminbed.MaybeitwasbecauseIwasscaredhe’d
getmetodoallsortsofkinkythingsthatIwasn’tdownfor.I’mnotonehundredpercentsurebutallI
knewwasthatIwasinthisquasi-relationshipwiththishotguy,dog-sittingforhiscrazydogand
hopingtoseehissemi-rude,veryhotfriend.
“Squirrel,whereisyourleash?”IspoketothedogagainasIlookedaroundtheroom.HowwasI
goingtowalkthedogifIcouldn’tfindhisleash?Squirrelstartedwhininginresponseandranupto
thefrontdoor,liftinghispawsuptoscratchagainstthewood.
“Nothelpful,Squirrel.”Igroaned.“Nothelpfulatall.”Iwalkedtothekitchenandlookedfora
leashoranythingthatIcouldpossiblytiearoundhisneckandwalkhimwith.Iwantedtocryas
Squirrelkeptwhiningandshakinghisass.IthoughtIheardasoundthatsoundedsuspiciouslycloseto
afart,butonlyreallytooknoticewhenahorriblewaftgotpastmynose.Squirrelhadfartedand,by
thesmellofit,hewasdangerouslyclosetopooping.AndIsureashelldidn’twanttocleanuphis
stinkypooandpeefromthefloor.
“Squirrel,please,pleasedonotpoopinthehouse.“ImoanedoutloudandhurriedtoPierce’s
bedroomtoseeifsomehowhe’dlefttheleashinthere.Iwalkedintoseethathisbedwasunmadeand
hehadclothesalloverthefloor.IhadtoadmitIwassurprised.Ihadn’tthoughtthatPiercewouldbe
sountidy.Imean,youjustdon’texpectasexy,suavemantoendupbeingaslob.Ibentdowntopick
upsomeofhisclothesandthrowthemonthebedandthenthoughtInoticedsomethingthatlooked
likealeashinthecornerofhisroom,besidehischestofdrawers.IcouldhearSquirrelstillwhining
andIhopedthathehadn’tpoopedyet.Ibentdownandgrabbedtheleatherstrapthatwasonthe
groundandpulledonit.ItwascaughtbehindthedresserandsoIpulledharder.IpausedasIthoughtI
heardanoise,butIknewthatIhadtobeimaginingit.PiercewasinMiamisoIknewhewasn’there.It
wasprobablyjustSquirreldartingaroundtheroom,probablyplayinginhispeeandmakingabigger
messformetocleanup.
Ipulledtheleatherstrapagain,tuggingashardasIcould,willingittocomeout.Itdidn’teven
occurtomethatthiswouldbeaweirdplaceforSquirrel’sleashtogetcaught.Ikeptpullingandfell
backslightlyasitcameloose.
“Ooh,”IthoughttomyselfandthenIexclaimedoutloud.“Whatthehell?”asIrealizedthatwhatI
washoldingwasnotaleashatallbutsomesortofleatherstrapthatwasintendedforsomesortof
sexualplay,ifthefeathersandspikesontheotherendwereanyindication.
“Sowhat’sgoingonhere,then?”ThedeepvoicebehindmemademejumpandIturnedaround
bothinsurpriseandexcitement.
“Whatdoyouthinkisgoingon?”Iaskedsnarkily,asIglancedatEvan,whowasstandingthere
withasmuglookonhisfaceasheglanceddownatmeasifIweresomepeasantgirlonhisfarmand
heweredeigningtotalktome.
“Itlookslikeyou’replayingwithasextoy,allbyyourself,”hesaidwithaself-satisfiedsmile.
“Andit’snotgoingwell.Thereareschoolsthatcanteachyouthings,youknow.AndYouTube
videos.”
“Teachmethings?”Ilookedupathimwithafrown.“Whatthings?”IgroanedasIrealizedhow
stupidmyquestionwas.WhatsortofthingsdidIthinkhewasgoingtotalkabout?
“Thingsthatwouldensurethatyouwereawomanwhoknowswhatsheisdoing.”Heraisedan
eyebrowatme.“Andfromthelookofthings,you’renotcurrentlythatwoman.”
“Whatever.”Irolledmyeyesathimandstoodup.“Whatareyoudoinghere?”
“WhatamIdoinghere?”HegavemealookthatindicatedthathethoughtIwasstupid,andI
wantedtojumpupandsmackthesmirkoffhisface.
“That’swhatIaskedyou,”Isaid,tryingtogivehimmymostindignantlook.“Doyouhave
troubleunderstandingEnglish?”
“Doyouhavetroublebeingpolite?”
“That’srichcomingfromyou.”
“Excuseme?”hesaidwithasmirkonhisface.
“You’reoneofthemostimpolitemenI’veevermet.”Iglaredathim.
“Andyou’veknownmanymen,then?”Heraisedaneyebrowatme.“Surprising.”
“Excuseme?Whatisthatsupposedtomean?”Ifrownedathim.
“Imean,youdon’tseemtobethatexperienced,soI’msurprisedthatyou’vebeenaroundtown.”
“Beenaroundtown?”
“Beenaroundtheblock.”Hepausedandgavemeanotheroneofhis“areyoudumb?”looks.
“Whatthehellareyoutryingtosay?”
“I’mnotsayinganything.I’mjusttryingtoclarifywhatyoujusttoldme.”
“Ididn’tjusttellyouanything.”Iglaredathim.“You’redeliberatelytryingtobeconfusing.”
“Idon’tdeliberatelytrytobeanything.Ifyoufindmeconfusingthat’sbecauseyoucan’tkeepup.”
“Idon’tknowthatIwanttokeepupwithyou,”Isaid,suddenlyfeelinglikeIhadmadeahuge
mistakecomingheretonight.Staringathimmademefeelweirdinside.Itstruckmeunawares,but
somethingabouthimmademebelievethathehadthepowertohurtme.Thiswasallfunandgames,
untilsomeonecrossedthelineandthingsgotawkward.Anditwasstartingtofeellikeitcouldget
awkwardreallyquickly.
“Yousureaboutthat?”heaskedmesoftly,histonechangingandbecomingmoreserious.He
watchedmeasIwatchedhim,carefully,oureyestakingineverydetailofeachother'sappearance.
Hislipswerecracked.Minewerepinkish-redfrombothmylip-glossandthestrawberrylollipopI'd
beensuckingbeforeI’darrived.Heprobablywantedtoknowwhymylipswerebrightpinkandredat
thesametimejustasbadlyasIwantedtoknowwhyhiswerecracked.Morethanlikely,bothofus
werewonderinghowfarwecouldpushitandifthisflirtationwasasinnocentasitseemed,ifwe
werebothjustplayinggameswitheachother,orifperhapstherewassomeoneelseineitherofour
lives.NotPierce,obviously.Pierce,webothknewabout.Hewasnotimportantinthisequation.But
anotherparty,anotherpartyoneitherofoursides,wasmoredangerous.Couldbeacausefor
jealousy.Craziness,right?Howcouldyoubejealousofsomeoneyouhadnothingwith?
Idon’tknowhowtoexplainmyattractiontoEvan.It’sjustoneofthosethings.EverytimeIsaw
himmystomachflippedandmyheartbeaterratically.Hishairwascropped,lowtothebaseofhis
head,sexyinaMarine-styleway.Helookedlikehe’dhadahaircutfromthelasttimeI’dseenhim.I
wonderedwhathewoulddoifIstrokedhishair,ranmyfingersalonghishead.Histresseslooked
liketheywouldfeelsilkyagainstmyfingers,evenifslightlyspikey.Iplayedwithmyhairhastily,
tryingtosmoothitout.Minewasmessy,unkempt,myravenlocksdisheveled.Notexactlythefemme
fatalelook.Iwonderedwhathe'ddoifIchangedtherules.Wonderwhathe’dsayifIleanedinand
toldhim,“Comeon,then,bigboy,showmewhatyougot.Stopwiththetalk.Let’sjustdothis.”I
knewthatwouldlikelyshockhim,takehimaback.Hewouldneverexpectit.Neverinamillionyears.
Guyslikehimdidn’tthinkgirlslikemewouldactuallystartplayingthegameback.Apartofme
wantedtochangetherulesonhim.Makehimfeeluncomfortable,butIknewIdidn’thaveitinme.I
wastooscared.Tooscaredthathe’dacceptandthenI’dbetheonewhocouldn’tbackout.
“I’mnotsurewhatyou’redoinghere,butI’mheretowalkSquirrel.Nothingmoreandnothing
less.Andtobehonest,Idon’tevenknowwhyIhadtocome?Imean,ifyou’rehere,whydoIhaveto
walkSquirrel?”
“Youvolunteered,didn’tyou?”Evanlookedatmewithasmirk.“Thatwasyourmistake.”
“Ididn’tvolunteertowalkhim.”Imadeaface.“I’mnotreallyintocleaninguppoopandpee.”
“Idon’tthinkyouhavetocleanupthepee.”Evanlaughed.“Unlessyouwanttomopitup.”
“Well,it’snotlikeI’mgoingtoleaveitonthegroundtostainthefloors.”
“Yougoingtomopitupfromthegrassaswell?”
“Mopitupfromthegrass?”Ilookedathimwithconfusioninmyeyes.
“Yeah.Thegrass.Hewouldn’tbepissingonthegroundifyouweretogethimoutsideintime.”
“WhywouldIbemoppinguppissfromthegrass?”Iglaredathim.
“Idon’tknow.”Heshrugged.“That’swhyIwasaskingyou.”
“You’reinsufferable.”Inarrowedmyeyesathim.“You’reoneofthemostannoyingmenIthink
I’veevermetinmylife.”
“Youhaven’tmetmanymeninyourlife,then?”Helaughed.
“Grrr.”Ijustshookmyheadandturnedaway.“Squirrel,”Ishouted.“Whereareyou?Squirrel,
comeon,let’sgo.”IwalkedtowardsthedoorandSquirrelcamebarrelingintomeinexcitement,
tonguewaggingandfartingalltheway.IturnedmynoseupatthesmellandprayedtoGodthathe
hadn’tletapoopoutinthelivingroom.
“Icantellyoureallylovedogs,”EvansaidasheglancedatmestaringatSquirrel’sbuttin
disgust.
“I’mjusttryingtoseeifSquirrelwenttothetoilet.”Ididn’tseeanydiscoloringfromSquirrel’s
butt,soIwashopefulthatIdidn’thavetotendtoanybuttemergencies.
“Ifyou’rethatworriedthatSquirrelneedstogothatbadly,maybeyoushouldtakehimoutnow,
insteadofsittinghereflirtingwithme.”
“Flirtingwithyou?”MyjawdroppedandIglancedathim.“Areyoufriggingkiddingmeright
now?”Istaredatthetwinkleinhiseyesandthenlookedawayquickly.Ijustcouldn’twiththisguy.He
wastoomuch.Heknewexactlyhowtogetmegoing,inmorewaysthanone.HewastroubleifeverI
sawtrouble.“DoyouknowwhereSquirrel’sleashis?”Ipinchedmylipstogether,knowingthatIhad
toaskhimifIeverwantedtogetSquirreloutofthehouse.
“Inhisdoggybox,withallhisotherstuff,Ipresume,”Evansaidmatter-of-factlyandIwantedto
punchhim.
“Andwhereisthat?”Iaskedthroughpursedlips.
“Inthekitchen,bythepantry,whereithasalwaysbeen.”
“Okay.”Iwalkedoutofthebedroomandhurriedtothekitchen,stoppingmyselffromsaying
anythingelse.Evanwassuchadouchebagandsocondescending.Ijustdidn’tknowhowPierceor
anyoneelseputupwithhim.Nowonderhewassingle.Well,Ididn’tknowthathewassingleforsure,
butIcouldonlyassume.Orsecretlyhope.Iwasn’tsurewhichstatementwasmoreaccurate.DidI
assumeorhope?Iwasn’tsureandIdidn’treallywanttofindout.
“IfIwantedyou,Icouldhaveyourightnow.”Hiswordswereteasingandtormentingashe
followedmeoutoftheroomandIturnedaroundandstaredathiminshock.
“Excuseme?”Isaid,afterallowingmyshocktosubsidealittle.“Whodoyouthinkyou’retalking
to?”
“Doyouseeanyoneelseintheroom?”Helookedaroundandgavemean“Areyouallrightin
thehead?”look.
“No,butIknowyoucan’tbetalkingtomelikethat.”Ishookmyheadathimandtookastepback.
“You’resoinappropriate.”
“Iam?”Helaughedandtookastepclosertome.“Ifyouthinkthisisinappropriatethenyouain’t
seennothingyet.”
“Idon’twanttoseeanything.”Iturnedbackaroundandstartedopeningcupboarddoors,
forgettingwhichonewasthepantry.Iwasstartingtopanic.EvanwasalotmorebrazenthanI’d
thoughthewasgoingtobe.Imean,therewasflirtingandbeingobnoxiousandthentherewasbeing
absolutelycrazy.Hewasabsolutelycrazy.Imean,thiswasridiculous.Howcouldhebetellingmehe
couldhavemerightnow?EspeciallyknowingIwasdatinghisfriend.Hewasabsolutelycrazyand
thesickpartofmewasthatIlovedit.Ilovedthathewassoinappropriate.Iwasalotsickerinthe
headthanIthoughtIwas,obviously.“Hereweare.”IcouldhearthereliefinmyvoiceasIfounda
boxofdogtoys,whichalsocontaineddogfoodandSquirrel’selusiveleash.“Squirrel,come,”I
shoutedandSquirrelcamerunningintothekitchen,probablyhopingforsomesortofjuicytreat,but
Iwasn’tabouttoriskanythinggettinghisstomachgoingbeforeweexitedtheapartment.“Sit,boy,
sit,”Isaidashestoppedinfrontofme,butthestupiddogdidn’tseemtoknowwhatthatmeant.
Insteadhejumpedupandtriedtogetintohisdogboxandsnatchabagoftreatshimself.“Squirrel,
sit,”Isaidloudlyandpushedhisbuttdown.Heignoredmeandthengrabbedabagfromtheboxand
wentoffrunning.“No,Squirrel,no.”Igroaned,andignoredEvanashestartedlaughing.Hewasso
notagentleman.AgentlemanwouldhavehelpedmegetSquirrelonhisleash.“Squirrel…”Igrabbed
theleashandwentchasingafterthedog.IwasstartingtofeelreallyfrustratedandknewthatIwould
neverbedumbenoughtotakeonaresponsibilitylikethisagain.NotunlessIwasbeingcompensated
orgettingsomethingreallygoodfromit.IfeltlikeIwasbeingpunishedbecauseIhadagreedtohelp
Piercewithslightlybadintentionsinmymind.IhadkindofhopedthatIwouldseeEvanhere,evenif
allofmedidn’twanttotrulybelievethat.Imean,whoadmitstothemselvesthattheywanttoput
themselfinareallystupidposition?It’snotliketherewasanygoodreasonformetoseeEvan,none
atall.TherewereonlybadreasonswhyIwouldwanttobeengagingwithhim.Reasonsthathad
nothingtodowithhelpingSquirrelorPierce.Iwassobad.
“Squirrel,stop.”IgroanedasIwatchedthemuttpullingaparthistreatbagandstuffingtreats
downhisface.“No,badboy.”Isighedashejustlookedupatmeandcontinuedeating.
“Squirrel,come,boy.”Evanhadfollowedmeintotheroomandcalledouttothedog.Squirrel
listenedtohimimmediately,droppedthebagandranovertohim.“Sit,”Evansaidcalmlyandmyjaw
droppedasSquirrelsatforhimlikeagoodboy.“Handmetheleash,”Evansaidandputhishandout
tome.IhandedittohimsilentlyandwatchedashereacheddownandclippedtheleashonSquirrel’s
collar.“Here.”Hehandedtheleashbacktome.“Youshouldtakehimoutnowbeforehehasan
accident.”
“Yeah.”InoddedandbecauseIdidn’tknowwhatelsetosayIjustgavehimasmallgratefulsmile
andpulledonSquirrel’sleashandheadedtowardsthefrontdoorquickly.“Comeon,Squirrel,”Isaid
softly,gratefulthatthedogwasactuallycomingalongthistime.Thedogfollowedmethroughthe
frontdooranddownthestairsanditwasn’tamomenttoosoonasheletoutaloadassoonaswe
madeittothepavement.IjuststaredashedidhisbusinessrightoutsidethefrontdoorandIwondered
tomyselfwhatwouldhavehappenedifEvanhadn’thelpedmeattheverylastmoment.Thathadbeen
niceofhim.Andithadbeenimpressive.Hisvoicehadbeensocommanding,sostrong,soassertive.
Squirrelhadlistenedandobeyedrightaway.ItwasalittleinfuriatingthatSquirrelhadlistenedtohim
andnottome,butIwasjustgladthatSquirrelhadlistenedtosomeonebeforeithadbeentoolate.I
wasn’tsurewhatIwouldhavedoneifEvanhadn’tbeentheretotakechargerightattheend.Ialso
wasn’tsurewhatIwouldhavedoneifEvanhadpushedmebackagainstthewallandpushedhimself
intomeandtoldmethathewasreadytotakemethenandthere.Apartofmewasn’tsurethatI’dhave
beenabletosayno.Apartofmekindawishedhewouldhavetried.
J
C H A P T E R 7
ess
“J
ESS
,Iwantyoutoknowhowspecialyouaretome.”Piercegazedatmewithanintensityinhiseyes
thatIhadn’tseenbefore.“ItmeanssomuchtomethatyoutookcareofSquirrelformewhileIwas
outoftown.”
“Noworries,”Isaidandgavehimasmallsmile.Iwasn’tabouttotellhimthatitwasunlikelyto
happenagain.Squirrelhadgivenmeaworkoutthatmylegsdidn’tappreciate,andmyfingernails
didn’tappreciatehavingtopickupsomuchdirt,debrisandpoop.
“Itreallymeansalottome.Manygirlswouldn’thavedonethatfortheirboyfriends.”
“Uh,yeah.”Myeyeswidenedathiswords.Didhejustcallhimselfmyboyfriend?Whatwas
goingon?Insteadoffeelingjubilationandexcitementathiswords,Iwasstartingtofeelpanicked.
“You’rereallyspecialtome,Jess.”
“Yeah,youjustsaidthat.”Ilookeddownatmysaladawkwardly.Oh,God,hewasn’tgoingto
propose,washe?Oh,myGod,thatwouldjustbemyluck.I’dalwayshopedinmyheadsomething
crazy,wackyandromanticlikethiswouldhappentome,butthiswasn’twhatI’dhopedfor.Imean,
shit,anyproposalwouldbenice,andhewashot,butthisdidn’tfeelasgoodasIthoughtitwouldfeel.
“IjustwantedyoutoknowI’mreallyhappyImetyou.”Helookedalittlenervous.“AndIjust
wanted...”Hefrownedandpausedashelookedme.“Areyouokay?Youlookalittlesick.”
“I’mfine.”Igulped.Oh,God,whatwasIgoingtotellAlyssa?Gettingengagedafteramonthof
datingandnosexwasreallyfast.Iwasn’tsureifshewouldbepleasedformeorsadforherself.
“IjustwantedtosayIknowthatwhenwemet,IwaskindapushingforasexualrelationshipandI
madeitclearthatIwantedtoknowyouonanintimatelevel,”hecontinued.“Andnormallythatismy
numberoneconcern,butthisisdifferent.You’redifferent.”Hepaused.
Hereitcomes,Ithoughttomyself.Yeah,Icanbeabitdelusional.I’mnotreallysurewhyI
thoughthewasgoingtopropose.MaybebecauseIreallyhavenocluewhenitcomestomenand
relationships.MaybebecauseI’mwhatmyfriendscall“extra.”Ialwaysseemtothinkthatthemost
extraordinarythingisgoingtohappeninallsituations.Isupposethatitwasquiteappropriatethat
eventuallythatendedupbeingtrue.Butthiswasnotoneofthosesituations.Piercewasnotaboutto
propose,asI’msureyoumostlikelyalreadyguessed.OnlyIcouldhavethoughtthatPiercewas
goingtoproposeinthatmomentbecauseI’dcleanedupsomeofhisdog’spoopforaweek.
“I’msurprisedthatyou’restilldatingme.”Ihalf-laughed.
“Why?”heaskedcuriously.
“BecauseIhaven’tsleptwithyouasyet.”Ishruggedandhesmiledwidely.
“That’sbecauseyou’respecial.”Hereachedoverandtouchedmyhand.
“BecauseIlookedafterSquirrel?”
“Notjustbecauseofthat.”Heshookhishead.“Ican’texplainit.Youjustmakemethinkabout
differentthings.”
“Oh?”Pleasedon’tsayhavingafamily.I’mnotreadyforthatrightnow.Notwithyou,atleast,I
thoughtguiltily.NotthatIwascrazyenoughtobethinkingofhavingafamilywithEvan.AllIwanted
wastoseewhatitwouldfeelliketokisshim.Yeah,Icanadmitit.Iwantedtokisshim.Iwantedtofeel
hisbodynexttomine.Youknowhowbadthatfeelstorealizethatyouwanttokissyourboyfriend’s
friendasyou’resittingtherethinkinghewantstoproposetoyou?Notthatgreat.
“Yeah.I’mgladthatIdidn’tjustgetpissedoffthatfirstnightafteryouplayedthosegameswith
me.”
“Huh?”Ifrowned.“Whatgames?”
“Thepullandtuggames.”
“Whatpullandtuggames?”Myvoicerose.
“The‘Iwantyoutofuckme,butI’mgoingtopretendIdon’t,’”hesaidknowingly.
“Excuseme?”MyvoiceroseagainasIglancedathim.“Whatareyoutalkingabout?”
“Weleftthatclubbothknowingweweregoingtogetdownanddirty.”Heshrugged.“The
condomsinmywalletwereexcitedthattheywereabouttogetused.”
“Isee.”Ipursedmylipsandinthatmomentallthoughtsandworriesthathewasgoingtopropose
tomefledoutthewindow.
“Imean,webothknewthat,right?”
“Uhm,no,Ididn’tknowthatyourcondomswereexcitedbecausetheythoughtthattheywere
goingtogetused.”
“That’snotwhatI’msaying.I’msayingthatIthinkthatwebothhadtheunderstandingthatwe
weregoingtobegettingtoknoweachotherintimatelythatnight.”
“Youmeaninthebackalleybehindtheclub?”Iaskedhim,oneeyebrowraised.
“Thatwouldhavebeenhot,right?”HewinkedatmeandItriednottomakeafaceathim.Now,if
I’mbeinghonest,Ishouldhavegottenupandleftrightthenandthere.Iknewinthatmomentthat
PierceandIwerenotamatchmadeinheaven.HowcouldInot?ButIdidn’tgetup.Ididn’tleave.I
didn’tleavebecauseIknewthatifIdid,itwouldbeunlikelythatIwouldgettoseeEvanagainand
thatwassomethingthatIreallywanted.Iknow,Iknow,I’mahorribleperson.Youdon’thaveto
remindmeofthat.
“Idon’tknowaboutthat.”Ishookmyhead.
“Anyways,we’regettingsidetracked.”Heshookhisheadaswell.“It’snotevenaboutwhatcould
havehappened.I’mgladitdidn’thappen.Youmeanmoretomethanthat.”
“Ido?”Ilookedathim,tryingtounderstandwhathewastalkingabout.Imean,I’mallfor
romanticgestures.I’mallforguysdeclaringtheirundyinglove,especiallytome,butevenIhadto
admitthatwedidn’thavemuchofahistoryorthatmuchofaconnectionforhimtobemakingthese
declarations.I’msureIwouldhavethoughtdifferentlyaboutitifheweresomeonethatIwasreally
andtrulyinterestedin.
“Doyoulikeme,Jess?”Hecockedhisheadtotheside.“Sometimes,Ican’treallytell.”
“Whatdoyoumean?”Iblinkedathim,panicfillingmeandnotbecauseIthoughthewasgoingto
propose.DidheknowthatIlikedEvan?
“Idon’tknow.SometimesIcan’ttellifyouwanttobemygirlfriendornot?”
“Oh.”Ilickedmylipsnervously.WhatdidIsaytothat?
“You’reanenigma.”Heleanedforward.“Ithinkthat’spartofthereasonwhyIlikeyousomuch.”
Forafewseconds,Istaredathiminshock,thinkingthathe’djustsaidthathelovedme,butthenI
calmeddownandreplayedwhathe’dsaidinmyhead.Like,notlove,like.Muchbetter.Ifhe’dsaid
love,I’mnotsurewhatIwouldhavedone.
“Oh,interesting,”IsaidandgiggledwhileIplayedwithmysalad.WhyhadIgottenasalad?I
didn’tevenlikesalads.Ishouldhavegottenthelobsterrollandfries.Iwouldhavemuchpreferred
that.Iwasannoyedatmyself.Iwonderedifitwastoolatetoordersomefries.Friesandsaladdidn’t
reallygo,though.IwonderedifhewouldthinkIwasweirdifIorderedsomefriesnow?
“Sowhatdoyouthink?”Pierce’svoiceinterruptedmythoughts.
“Thinkaboutwhat?”Isaid,wonderingifhecouldreadmymind.WasheaskingifIthoughtI
shouldorderthefriesornot?
“Aboutbeingmygirlfriend.”Hesqueezedmyhand.“Areyouhappy?IknowthatIkindajust
assumedweweretogetherlikethat.”
“Uhm,Idon’tmind,”Imumbled.
“Somymomwantstothrowabirthdaypartyformenextweekandwedon’twantittobe
awkward.”
“Awkward?”Iglancedathimcuriously.
“Whywoulditbeawkward?”
“Well,youknow,Evan.”HeshruggedandgavemealookasifIshouldknowexactlywhathewas
talkingabout.WhichofcourseIdidn’t.WashesayingthatheandhismomknewthatEvanhadbeen
inappropriatewithme?OrwashesayingthatheknewthatIhadaslightinterest?
“Ohyeah,yeah.Imean,Idon’tthinkitwouldbeawkward,right?”Igavehimaslowsmileand
hopedforthebest.
“Yeah,Ithinkitwillbefine.Especiallybecauseyou’llbethere.Mymomisexcitedtomeetmy
newgirlfriend.”
“Sheis?”Isaidfaintly,mystomachdropping,wonderingwhatI’dgottenmyselfinto.What
exactlyhadhetoldhismomaboutme?Forasecond,Ifeltslightlypanicked,worriedthatperhapshe
wasgoingtoproposeattheparty.Thatwouldsuck,butIletmyselftakeafewdeepbreathsbeforeI
startedpanickingagain.StopbeinganidiotJess,Ilecturedmyself.Piercewasnotabouttopropose
anytimesoon.Iwasn’tsurewhythatthoughtkeptpoppingupinmymind.Itwassoentirely
ridiculous.
“Yeah,tobehonest,you’llbethefirstgirlfriendthatshe’smet.”Hegrinnedatme.“Nopressure.”
“Haha,yeah,nopressure.”Oh,God,Ithoughttomyself.Thiswasalmostasbadashim
proposing.Thiswasalmostasbad.Andthiswasn’tjustinmyhead.Thiswasforreal.IknewthatI
shouldhavejustlefttherestaurantandneverlookedback.IknewthatIshouldhavejustcutmylosses.
Imean,whatgoodwasgoingtocomefromthissituation?Whatgoodwasgoingtocomefrom
pretendingIwasfarmoreinterestedinhimthanIwas?Imean,yeah,Ilikedhim,andyeah,thefirst
timeImethim,Ithoughtthatperhapswehadaconnection.Therehadbeenaphysicalattraction.AndI
thinkinthatmomentI’ddecidedtogoalongwithit.Figuredmaybeitcouldbebetter.MaybeIjust
hadtogiveitabitmoretime.Figuredmaybeeverythingwouldworkoutwell,regardlessofthefact
thateverythingwasmuddledinmymind.
J
C H A P T E R 8
ess
T
HE
INVITATION
CAME
VIA
.Itwasn’tcompletelyunexpected,yetitwasmuchmoreformalthanI
wouldhaveexpectedforabirthdayinvite.
D
EAR
J
ESS
,
YouarecordiallyinvitedtothethirtiethbirthdaypartyofPierceJohnsonon
SaturdayJuly15
th
.PleaseRSVPbyMondaythe10
th
.
LindaJohnson
P.S.I’msoveryexcitedtomeetyou,Jess.Piercehastoldmesomuchaboutyou.I’msureyoumustbe
averyspecialpersoninhislife.
I
READ
theemailandmystomachdropped.Ihadn’texpectedforhertoincludeapersonalmessagein
theemail.ExactlywhathadPiercetoldhisparentsaboutme?Ididn’tevenknowmuchabouthim,let
alonehisparents.
IstartedtofeelnervousthinkingaboutwhatPierce’sparents’expectationsweregoingtobewhen
wemet.IwasalsoworriedthatEvanwasgoingtobethere.Andwhatifhewasuptohisoldtricks?
Whatifhetriedtoteasemeortouchmeanddiditinfrontoftheparents?WhatiftheynoticedthatI
wasmorereceptivetoitthanIshouldhavebeen?WhatiftheythoughtIwasflirtingback?They’d
thinkIwasahorriblegirlfriend.MightevenmakeasceneandsaythatIwasacheaterorsomething.
WhattheniftheytoldPiercethatI’dbeenflirtingwithhisfriend?WhatifPiercewentuptoEvanand
startedanargumentwithhim?Whatiftheygotintoafight?Ahugebustup,fistsflying,blackeyes
mightbegiven—shit,oneofthemmightbreakahand,oranarmoraleg,orsomething.Thatwould
beabsolutelycrazy.Thatwouldruintheparty.Imean,itwouldbekindacooltohavetwoguys
fightingoverme.Itwouldbethefirsttimeanditwouldbekindofcool.Itwouldbenicetohavetwo
hotguysfightingoverme.Thoughmaybenotinthissituation.MaybenotatPierce’sbirthday.Infront
ofhisparentsandfriends.EspeciallyafterPierce’smomhadsentmesuchanicepersonalmessage
alongwithmyinvitation.Thewayshewasgoingonmademethinkshethoughttherewaspotential
forhertobemymother-in-law.Ididn’twanttobreakherheartthefirsttimeshemetme.Thatcould
happenlateron.Shit,hopefullyIwasn’tgoingtohavetomeetheragain.MaybeI’dhavetohavea
conversationwithPiercesoonerratherthanlater.Ididn’twanthimtellinghisparentsanythingabout
me,makingthemthinkthiswassomethingitwasn’t.Iwasmostlysurprisedtobeinsucha
relationship.IneverwouldhaveexpectedPiercetobelikethis.Itjustboggledmymindthatsucha
good-lookingguywouldbeactingthiscrazy.Itmademewonderwhathe’dsayifIweretodothe
samething.Whatifmymomwerecontactinghim,askinghimquestionsthatmadeitseemlikeI
thoughtwehadsomesortofseriousrelationship?Iwassurethathe’dbefreakingout.MaybeI
shoulddothesamething.MaybeIshouldrampitup.ThatwayIwouldn’tbethebadguyinthe
situation.IfIstartedtogetcrazymaybehewouldhavedoubtsaboutmeandthatwouldmakeitalot
easier.AtleastthenIwouldn’tfeellikethebadpersoninthesituation.EveniftechnicallyIwas
alreadythebadpersoninthesituation.Well,notinactualitybutinmyheadforsure.
Iwasn’tsureifIshouldgetdressedupfortheparty.Piercewantedmetohostthepartywithhim,
butIthoughtthatwasweird.Thiswasn’tthesortofthingthatweneededtohosttogether.Itwasn’t
evenappropriate.Notforourlevelofrelationship.Imean,itevenfeltweirdsaying“relationship”for
whatwehad.Istillcouldn’tbelievethatwewereboyfriendandgirlfriend.Basedonwhat,exactly,I
didn’tknow.ItwasalmostasifwewereintheTwilightZoneandIwaswatchingfromtheliving
room,unabletolookawayfromthecrazinessthatwasmylife.
“Youlookhot,Jess.”Alyssagrinnedasshetookinmyshortblackdressandbroughtmelipstick.
“WhatanicebirthdaypresentforPierce.”
“What’sanicebirthdaypresentforPierce?”Iaskedhercuriously.
“You,ofcourse.”Shegrinnedasshewinkedatme.“Tonightisgoingtobehot,right?”
“Whatareyoutalkingabout?”Ifrownedather.
“Youarewearingyoursexyunderwear.”Shewinkedatmeagain.
“What?”
“Girl,you’rewearingathong.”Shelaughed.“Youonlywearthatwhenyou’regoingtogetlaid.”
“That’snottrue.”Ishookmyhead,thoughthatwasalie.Ineverworethongs.Ihatedthefeeling.I
onlyworethemtofeelsexy.IonlyworethemifIthoughtthattherewasaprobabilitythatIwasgoing
togetlaid.ThoughIhadnoplanstosleepwithPiercethatevening,oranyoneelsereally.Imean,it’s
notlikeIcouldsleepwithanyoneelsethenightofPierce’sbirthdayparty.NotthatIhadanyonein
mind,ofcourse.
“Jess,whodoyouthinkyou’relyingto?”Alyssagrinnedatme.“Iknowmythongsfrommy
grannypanties;I’mnotaguy.”
“Alyssa.”Irolledmyeyesandthenlookeddownatherinherreddress.“Areyouwearingany
panties?”Iaskedherincredulously.
“Haha,youhavetoask?”Shestartedlaughing.“Amateur.”
“Whyareyouwearingnopanties,Alyssa?”Iaskedher,notsurewhyIwasfeelingshocked.
“BecauseI’mhopingtonightisgoingtobealuckynightforme.”
“Aluckynight?”Irepeated.
“Whoknows,right?Imean,youneverknow.Pierceishotandyou’vealreadysaidthathisone
friendishot,right?”
“Evan?”Mystomachstartedchurning.WasshegoingtotryandhookupwithEvan?
“Yeah,soifhehasonehotfriend,I’msurehe’sgotothers.Hotguysruninposses.”Shestuckher
tongueoutatmeandmystomachsank.Wasshereallytalkingaboutotherguysorwasshethinkingof
Evan?HadIplayedhimuptoomuch?Oh,myGod,whatwasIgoingtodoifAlyssaandEvan
hookedup?Icouldfeelthejealousyinmystomachalready.Iwasn’tsurewhyIwasfeelingso
uncomfortablealready.Itwasn’tlikeEvanandIhadanything.AndIknewhewouldn’tturndown
Alyssa.Imean,whatguywould?Shewasgorgeous.Andshewasn’twearinganypanties.Shedidn’t
playgames.Ifaguywantedtogetlaid,shewouldbedown.AndIknewshewouldbedownforEvan.
Whowouldn’tbedownforEvan?Hewashotashell.
“Uhm,sure,”Isaidweakly,wonderingifithadbeensuchagoodideatoinviteAlyssaafterall.
IfsheendeduphookingupwithEvan,Iwasgoingtobeveryupset.Upsetandpissed.Iwasn’tsure
I’dbesoupsetifshehookedupwithPierce,andIwasn’tsurewhatthatsaidaboutme.Ihadafeeling
thatthenightwasgoingtobeahotmessandIwasn’tsurehowIwasgoingtopreventthatfrom
happening.
“Youdon’tmindifIhookupwithoneofhisfriends,doyou?Thatwon’tbeawkward,willit?”
“Youcandowhatyouwant,Alyssa.”Ishrugged.“You’reyourownwoman.”
“Jess.”Shepausedandgrabbedmyshoulders.“What’sgoingon?Yourfacelookslikeyouwant
tokillme.”
“Idon’twanttokillyou.”Iglaredather.“Whatareyoutalkingabout?”
“Jess.Iknowyoubetterthanyouknowyourself.You’remybestfriend.”Alyssasighed.“And
rightnow,Icantellthatyou’renothappy.”
“I’mfine.”
“Jess,tellmewhat’sgoingon.”
“Nothingisgoingon.”
“We’renotleavingthishouseuntilyoutellmewhat’sgoingon.”Shegrabbedmyhandandpulled
metothecouch.“What’swrong?”
“Alyssa,there’snothingwrong.”IsighedasIsatdownandclosedmyeyes.“Nothing.”
“Thatsuredidn’tsoundlikenothing.”Hervoicewassoft.“Talktome,Jess.”
“Alyssa,Ijustdon’tknowwhattothinkorfeelanymore.IfeellikeI’mobsessedorbewitchedor
somethinganditmakesnosense.”
“Bewitchedbywhat?”Shefrowned.
“Evan,”Isaidsoftly,notwantingtoadmitittoher,notevenwantingtoadmitittomyself.
“Pierce’sfriend?”Sheblinkedatme.“Youreallylikehim,huh?”
“Idon’tknowhimwellenoughtosayIlikehim.”Isighed.“Idon’tknowwhatitis,Idon’tknow
whyIfeelthisway.Ijustcan’tstopthinkingabouthimandwonderingwhatitwouldbeliketobewith
him.”
“Bewithhim?”Hereyeswidened.“Asinasexualnature?”
“Yes,Alyssa.”Ilaughed.“Asinasexualnature.”Igroaned.“Oh,myGod,Isuck.What’smy
problem?”
“Ithinkyoucan’thelpwhoyou’reinterestedinandthisEvanseemslikequitetheguy.”
“Ugh,he’snotagoodguy.Heseemslikeaplayer.”Igroaned.“AndIjustdon’tknowwhyI’mso
attractedtohim.It’snotasifPierceisn’tattractiveaswell.”
“Butifyou’renotasattractedtohim…”
“Ugh,Idon’tevenknow.WhatthehellamIdoing?”Iburiedmyfaceinmyhands.“Ireallysuck.
Thisreallysucks.Idon’tevenwanttogotonight.Youknowhismomisgoingtobethereandseems
tothinkwehavesomesortofseriousrelationship.Andwhatifhisdadisthereaswell?Whatifthey
thinkwe’rereallytightandthentheyseemewithEvan,andhetriestoflirtortouchmeor
something?”
“DoyouwantmetoflirtwithEvan,then?Distracthim?”
“No,”Ialmostshouted,andhereyeswidened.
“Oh,shit,you’rereallyintothisEvan,aren’tyou?”
“It’samess.”Inoddedandgroanedagain.“WhatamIgoingtodo?”
“Ignorehimasbestasyoucan.”Shelaughed.“AndIwilldothesame.”
“Oh,Alyssa,whatamIdoing?AndhowdidIgetsoluckytogetabestfriendlikeyou?”
“Youhaveabestfriendlikemebecauseyou’reawesome.”
“Iknow.”Igrinnedather.“Butyou’reevenmoreawesome.”
“Istheresuchathing?”Shewinkedatmeandwebothstartedlaughing.
“Idon’tknow.Perhaps?”Igiggledandgrabbedherhands.“Thanksformakingmefeelbetter
aboutallofthis.IfeellikeafoolforbeingjealousofyoupossiblyflirtingwithEvan.What’swrong
withme?”
“There’snothingwrongwithyou,”shesaid,andwebothknewthatwasonlypartiallytrue.Ihave
toadmitthatI’mnotquiteasinnocentasIwouldleadyoutobelieve.Iammeaninreallife—Iam.It’s
hardnottobeifyou’reasshyandinsecureasIam.Alyssadoesn’talwaysbelievemewhenIsayI
feeluncomfortableinthosetypesofsituations.Ithinkit’sbecauseontheoutsideIpretendI’mmore
confidentthanIam.Icanfakeitquitewell.That’sbecauseIdon’twanttobeasadcase.Myparents
raisedmetobestrong.MydadwasintheArmyandsohewasprettyclosedoff,andmymom…well,
shejustwasn’tverygoodwithexpressingfeelings.SoIgrewupkeepingeverythinginside.Andwhen
Isayeverything,Imeaneverything:feelings,emotions,wants,needs.SomemightsayI’msexually
repressed.I’vealwayshadfantasiesandthoughtsaboutdifferentthingsandscenariosI’dliketobein,
butI’veneveractedonthem.Icertainlyneverthoughtanyofthemwouldcometrue.AndIcan’tsay
thatI’veeverwantedtosleepwithaboyfriend’sfriendbefore.EspeciallyonelikeEvan.Ithink
though,thatEvanwastheonlysortofguyIwouldeverreallyfindmyselfinsuchasituationwith.
ThethingsIdespisedabouthimwerethethingsthatdrewmetohim.Hewascondescending,rude,
egotistical,narcissistic—everythingIdidn’twantinaman.Anditwasn’tasifhewantedmefor
anythingreal.Buttherewassomethingabouthimthatdrewmetohimanditwasn’tjusthislooks.I
can’tevenreallyexplainit.Butitwastheverythingsthatturnedmeoffofhimthatdrewmetohim.
I’dalwaysfoundmyselfattractedtotheguysthatIshouldn’thaveorwant.Therewassomething
aboutgettingattentionfrombadboysthatmademefeelmorealivethanatothertimes.Itwaslikemy
bodycravedtheunknown,thedark,thedevious.Ican’tevenexplainit.It’snotwhatIwantina
relationship.It’snotwhatIwantinaromance,yetIcan’tstopmyself.
“WebothknowI’vegotissues.”
“We’veallgotissues.”Shelookedmeintheeyes.“Don’tthinkthatyourissuesdefineyouorthat
youcan’tgetoverthem.”
“Ijustdon’twanttobethisperson,Alyssa.Idon’twanttokeepseekingouttheseguyswhoaren’t
goodforme.It’snothealthyandIjustdon’twanttokeepgoingdownthisroad.”
“Jess…”Alyssagavemeasmallsmile.“Let’sberealhere.Youdidn’tseekoutEvan.Infact,
you’renotevendatingEvan.Iwouldn’tbesodownonyourself.”
“Youdon’tthinkI’mcrazyforfeelingjealousthatyoumighthookupwithhimtonightata
birthdaypartyforadifferentguyI’mmeanttobedating?”
“Howdoyouwantmetoanswerthat?”Shelaughed.“Yes?No?Idon’tknowthisEvan,butIknow
whatit’sliketobeirrationallyjealous.Maybenotthisexactsituation,butI’vebeeninsimilar
situationsthatarecrazy.”
“ShouldIbreakupwithPierce?”Iaskedher,wantinghertotellmewhattodo.ThenIgroaned.
“IsitcrazythatIdon’tevenfeellikeI’mactuallydatinghim?”
“Well,I’veneverheardofaboyfriendandagirlfriendnothavingsex.”Alyssagrinnedatme
wickedly.“ButwhatdoIknow?”
“Nothing.”Ilaughed.“Absolutelynothing.”
“Exactly.”Shelaughed.“Let’sgoandhavefun.AndifyouendupbreakingupwithPiercetonight,
thenwhocares?Life’stooshorttobewithsomeoneyoudon’twanttobewith.”Herexpression
changedandshelookedatmeseriously.Shegrabbedmyhandsandthentookadeepbreath.“Okay,
I’mgoingtobeserioushereforafewseconds.”
“Uh-oh.”Imadeafaceandgiggled,butherexpressiondidn’tchange.
“Iwanttotellyousomething,”shesaidandcontinuedlookingintomyeyes.“Seriouslynow.”
“Serious?”Mystomachchurned.“AmIgoingtocry?”
“You’dbetternot.”Sheshookherheadandtookadeepbreath.“We’vebeenbestfriendsfora
longtime,Jess.AndIknowyoubetterthanIthinkanyonedoes,andyouknowmebetterthanIthink
anyonedoes,andwe’realwayshereforeachother.Iknow—andletmespeakbeforeyoutryand
interruptme—Iknowthatyourdadhaskindamessedwithhowyoureactanddealwithmen.Iknow
becausemydadwasunemotionaltooandthathasaffectedmeaswell,butinadifferentway.Iknow
wehaveourissues,emotional,andsensitiveandhardtounderstand.ButIwantyoutoknowhow
specialyouareandhowyou’reoneofthebestpeopleIknow.You’reseriouslyoneofthebestpeople
IknowandIhatetoseeyouinsuchself-doubt.Youthinkaboutotherssomuchandalwaysbefore
yourself,butsometimesyouneedtothinkofyourselffirst.Seriously,youcan’talwaysavoidhurting
someoneinlife.That’sjusthowlifegoes.Andguys…well,guysarecomplicated.Lifeis
complicated.Loveiscomplicated.That’sjusthowitgoes.Andit’scomplicatedforallofus.Don’t
beatyourselfup.Nomatterwhathappens.You’regreatandnomatterwhathappens,Iwillalwaysbe
hereforyou.Iwillalwayshaveyourback.Youdowhatyouneedtodo.Idon’tcareifit’ssomething
crazy,somethingscandalous,somethingthatyou’lllookbackonintenyearsandsay‘oh,myGod.’I
willalwaysbehereforyou.I’myourrideordie.Iwillalwaysloveyou.Iwillalwayshaveyourback.
Youcanalwaystellmeanything.Anything.Ifyoufuckingkillsomeone,youcantellme.Iwillalways
behereforyou.Throughboyfriends,husbands,kids,grandkids,throughfriggingdeath,youhear
me?Iwillalwaysbeyourbestfriend.Youcanalwaystellmeanything.”Shesqueezedmyhands.
“Don’teverdoubtyourselforworryaboutwhatyou’rethinkingorfeeling.Oreverdoubtyoucan
tellmeanything.Youhearme?”Shetookadeepbreath.“Wow,thatwasalot.”Shelookedmeinthe
eyes.“ButIhopeitallcamethrough.”
“Iloveyou,Alyssa.”Ibitdownonmylowerlip.“Youknowwhattosaytomakemefeelbetter,
everysingletime.Howdoyouknowhowtodothat?”
“’CauseI’myourplatonicsoulmate.”Shegavemeasmallsmile.“Andyou’vebeenthereforme
somanytimesinthepast.Andyou’vealwaysknownhowtomakemefeelbetter.Iwantyoutoknow
thatyoudon’talwayshavetobetherock.Icanbetherockaswell.Icanbeyourrock.I’myour
rock.”
“Iknow,girl.You’remyrock.”
“I’msolidasarock.”Shelaughed.
“Solidasarock,”Isangandshesangalongwithme.“Solidasarock.”
“Let’sdothis,”Isaidandjumpedup.“Let’sgoandgetdrunkandjusthaveagreatnight.Wegot
this.”
“Yousure?Wedon’thavetogo.”
“Don’tyouwanttoseeEvan?Theguywhohasmeinknots?WhoIbarelyevenknow?”
“Areyoujoking?”Shelaughed.“I’vebeendyingtoseeEvansinceyoustartedtalkingabouthim.”
“Haha,Ibet.Let’shavesomeshotsbeforewego.IthinkIneedtoshowupalittlebuzzed.”
“Ithoughtyou’dneversuggestthem.”Shegrinned.“Vodkaortequila?”
“Both.”Igrinnedbackather.“Weneedtogetsuperdrunk.Well,notsuperdrunk,butIcan’tshow
upsober.”
“Meeither.”Shelaughed.“Iwon’tbeontopofmygameifI’msober.”
“You’realwaysontopofyourgame.”Ilaughed.
“That’strue.”Shenodded.“That’soneofmytalents.Ihadtohaveone.”
“Youhavemorethanone.”
“Yeah,true.Theotheroneismakingbadassshots,”shesaidasshepouredahealthydoseof
alcoholintotworegularglasses.”
“Alyssa,thosearenotshotglasses.”
“Oops,”shesaidwithagiggleandpassedmeaglass.“Let’sgetdrunk,baby.”
“Here’stobaddecisions.”IgiggledtooasIsippedthevodka.“Oh,myGod,whatamIsaying?”
“Whatwe’reboththinking,”shesaidwithasmile.“Baddecisionsandregretsinthemorning.”
“Idon’twantanyregretsinthemorning,”Isaidandthenwinkedather.“Well,there’soneregretI
wouldn’tmind.”
“Oh,Jess.”Shelaughed.“Tonightisgoingtobeinteresting.”
“Yeah,itwillbe.”Ilaughed.“Oh,myGod,whatamIsaying?”
“Itdoesn’tmatterwhatyousay,it’sallaboutwhatyoudo.Orwhoyoudo.”Shesippedhervodka.
“AndIhaveafeelingyou’llbedoingsomeonetonight.”
“Alyssa!”Igasped.
“What?”Shesaidwithawink.
“There’snoway,”Isaid.Butofcourseshewasright.Alyssawasalwaysright.Imean,itwasn’t
likeIdidn’tkindofseeitcoming.IknewIhadtomakeadecision.Ijustdidn’tthinkitwouldgo
downasitdid.Imean,whoreallyexpectsforcrazytobethatcrazy?Icertainlydidn’texpectmy
crazytobesocrazy.Imean,there’scrazyandthenthereiscrazywithacapitalC.Ididn’texpectmy
crazytobeGuinnessWorldRecordscrazy.Ishouldhaveknown,though.Myguttoldmethatthere
wassomethingslightlyoffinthewholesituation.Ijustcouldn’thaveknownhowoffeverythingwas.
J
C H A P T E R 9
ess
T
HERE
’
S
amomentinlifethat’sthepivotalmoment.Somemightsaythattherearemanypivotal
moments.Somemaysaythat,butIbelievethatthereisonepivotalmomentthat’smoreimportantthan
alltheothermoments.Onemomentthatwillimpactyourlifeforever.Itsoundskindofcrazy,ifyou
thinkaboutit.Onemomentthatcanchangeeverythinginyourlife.Onemomentthatcanmeanyour
lifeisgoingtogoinonedirectionoranother.Thecraziestpartisthatyouneverknowwhenyou’re
goingtohavethatmoment.Therearemanymomentsthatseemliketheymightbethatmoment.There
aremomentsthatseemliketheymightbebiginthegrandschemeofthings,butthentheyhappenand
theyjustaren’tasbigasyouthoughttheyweregoingtobe.However,thismoment,thismomentin
mylifeiscrazybigandnotinthewayyouwouldhaveimagined.
AlyssaandIarrivedatPierce’splaceaboutanhourafterthepartyhadstarted.Ithinkthathe’d
beenslightlyupsetthatIwasn’ttherewhenthepartyhadstarted,butIreallyhadn’twantedtobethere
rightatthebeginning.Ididn’twanttobegreetinghisfriendsandfamilylikeweweresomething
reallyspecial.Imean,IknewIhadtobeagoodgirlfriend,butIalsocouldn'tpretendwewereina
placethatweweren’tin.Normallyitwasthegirlwhowastryingtopushthingstoofast,butitseemed
tomethatPiercewasactinglikethegirl,andithadunnervedme.Iwasn’tsurewhyhe’dgrownso
attachedtomesoquickly.AndpartofmecouldonlyassumeitwasbecauseofthechallengeI
presentedtohim.Theno-sexthingwasobviouslygettingtohim.ThefunnypartwasthatIwasn’t
holdingoutonhimbecauseIwantedhimtobemoreseriousaboutme.Thiswasn’tagame.Apartof
methoughtIshouldjustsleepwithhimandthenseewhathappened.Iwasprettysurethathe’dbe
donewithmefasterthanIcouldblinkifIsleptwithhimand,surprisingly,thatdidn’thaveme
worriedorconcerned.
“Mom,IwantyoutomeetJess,”Piercesaid,introducingmetohismotherconfidently,andher
adoringlookathimandthebenevolentlookatmetoldmeallIneededtoknow.Piercewasa
momma’sboy,whichIwouldn’thaveguessed,atleastbasedonourfirstmeeting.Actually,Inever
wouldhaveguessedatanyfacetsofhispersonalitybasedonourfirstmeeting.Iguessfirst
impressionsaren’talwayswhattheyseem.
“Sonicetomeetyou,Jess.”Hismomgazedatmewithahugesmileandthenwentinforahug,
whichIwasn’texpecting.Igaveherasmallhugbackandshejustlookedmeover.
“You’reevenprettierinpersonthanIthoughtyou’dbe.”Shegavemeanapprovingnodandthen
lookedatPierce.“Iknewyou’dmakeagooddecisionwhenyoufinallydecidedonaserious
girlfriend.”
Ihavetoadmitthatmyheartstartedthuddingthenandnotinagoodway.TheonlyreasonwhyI
didn’tjuststraightupleavethepartythenwasbecause:1.Iwasalreadydrunk;2.ItlookedlikeAlyssa
washavingfun;and3.IwasstillhopingtoseeEvan.Andyes,Iwascasuallylookingaroundthe
apartmenttoseeifIcouldseehim,evenasPierce’smomwasgrinningatme.Yes,Isuck.Idon’tdeny
that.Ireallyandtrulysuck.Piercedeservedsomeonebetterthanme;thoughifI’mhonest,our
relationshipwasn’treallybuiltonanything.Technically,wedidn’tevenreallyhaveareal
relationship.Idon’tknowifI’mjusttryingtomakeexcusesorwhat,butIseriouslydon’tthinkwe
arethatserious.Especiallyforthewayhismomwasgoingon.Itjustseemedkindofofftome.But,
yeah,Iknewthatsomethingwasoffbeforetheparty,soIshouldhavesaidsomethingbeforeitall
wentdown.ButwebothknowthatIdidn’tsayanything,sothefalloutthatcamewasreallyallmy
fault.
IknewassoonasEvanenteredtheapartment.TheairchangedandIcouldfeelthehairsonthe
backofmyneckrising.Ihadn’tevenseenhim,orheardhim.Ijustknewhewasthere.Itwassome
sortofsixthsense.IguessyoucouldcallitmyEvan-sense.MyEvan-sensewasinfullswingthat
night.And,boy,wasitanight.Itwasthenightthatchangedeverything.
E
C H A P T E R 1 0
van
T
HE
FIRST
THING
IdidwhenIwalkedintotheapartmentwaslookforJess.I'dtimedmyarrivaltothe
partytoensureshe'dbetherefirst.MyheartstilledasIsawherstandingtherenexttoPierceand
Linda,lookingsexyashellinhershortblackdress.Iwasn’tsureifshehaddressedupforme,butall
Icouldthinkaboutwashowhotshe’dlookifsheweren’twearingthedress.Iwasn’tevenreallysure
whyI’dcomeorwhatIwashopingtoaccomplishbybeinghere.IknewIwasplayingwithfire.Jess
wasPierce’sgirlandbyallaccounts,hewasfairlyseriousabouther.Muchmoreseriousthanhe’d
everbeenaboutanygirlbefore.Itsurprisedme,asJesswasn’tthesortofgirlthatIwouldhave
thoughthe’dwanttobewith.Shewasn’thisusualtype.Heusuallywentfortallskinnyblondes,and
thatwasn’tJess.Shewasaboutfivefootsix,curvywithlongdarkhairandbigbrowneyesthat
flashedfirewhenshewasupset.Whichshewasfrequentlyatme.WhichIliked.Justthinkingabout
whataspitfireshewasturnedmeon.Iwonderedifshehadsuchextremereactionsinthebedroomas
well.
IknewthesecondthatJessrealizedIwastherebecauseIsawherturnaroundandhereyesfound
mine.Shegazedatmeforabriefsecondandalmostgavemeasmallsmilebeforesheturnedaway
abruptly.Iresistedtheurgetogostraighttoher.Ihadtotakeitcool.Itwouldn’tdoifIshowedmy
handsosoonintheevening.Ireallyshouldn’tshowmyhandatall,thoughIwasn’tsurethatIwould
beabletoresist.NotifIwasaroundherfortoolong.
IneverexpectedtofallforJess.Withhersmartmouthandawkwardsmile,shewasn'tthegirlI
thoughtshewasatfirst.Hereyes,whenshelookedatme,castheruncertaintyoutintotheroomandI
alwaysfeltmyselfpausingforafewsecondsbeforecontinuingtoteaseher.Icouldn'tstopmyself.I
lovedtowatchherreactionstowhatIsaid,lovedtoseehereyesnarrowingassheglared,andtheway
shenervouslylickedherlipswhenshethoughtIwasn'tlooking.JesswasacomplicationIhadn't
countedon.Atfirstithadbeenagame,butveryquicklyithadturnedintosomethingdifferent.I
couldn'tgetheroffmymind.IaskedPierceallthetime—thoughverycasually—ifshewasgoingto
becomingaround,andIknewIwasplayingwithfire.Butheneversuspectedanything.Whywould
he?Hewouldneverexpecttobebetrayedlikethat.Especiallyfromme.
“Evan,howyoudoing,man?”Braydon,oneofPierce’sbestfriendsapproachedmeandgaveme
ahug.
“Howareyou,Braydon?”Iaskedhimwithasmallsmile,havingtoneglectmythoughtsofJess
forafewminutes.
“Good.Ihaven’tseenyouinawhile.Piercetoldmeyouwereintown.Thinkingofmoving
here?”
“Yeah,I’mthinkingofmovingback.”Inodded.“Howareyou?Howareyourparents?”
“They’regood.Ithinkthey’regoingtomovetoFlorida.”Hemadeaface.“SunshineStateandall
that.”
“Sure.”Inoddedagain.“Goodforthem.Yourdadcangolfalldaythen.”
“Yeah,somethinglikethat.”Helaughedandturnedaround.“I’msurprisedyoucame,withLinda
here.”
“Really?”IlaughedandthoughtquicklyofsomethingelsetosayasIwantedtochangethesubject.
“HaveyoumetJess?”Iaskedhim,almostgroaning.ShewasthelastpersonIwantedtobetalking
about.
“Jess?”Braydonpausedandthenshookhishead.“Oh.That’sPierce’snewgirlfriend,right?”
“Yeah.”Inodded,wonderingexactlywhatPiercewastellingeveryoneaboutJessandexactlyhow
serioushewasabouther.Icouldn’timaginehewassuperseriousabouther,seeingastheyhadjust
starteddating,butyouneverknewwithPierce.HewasoneofthemostunpredictablepeopleIknew
andhadalwaysbeenthatway.Hewasacontrarycharacter,thoughnotalotofpeoplerealizedthat.
“She’sverynice.”
“Yeah,that’swhathesaid.”Braydonnoddedandlookedoverather.“Hemetherinsome
nightclub,Ithink.Ibetshemustbegoodinbed.”
“Idon’tknowthatthey’veslepttogether,”Isaid,annoyedathisassumption,andwonderedwhatI
woulddoifIfoundoutthattheyhadandhowirrationalthatwouldbeofmetobeupsetifIfoundout
thatPiercehadsleptwithhisgirlfriend.Iwastoooldforthisshit.
“Oh,ofcoursethey’vebanged.”Braydongavemealook.“ThisisPiercewe’retalkingabout.
There’snowaythathewouldn’thavesleptwithherasyet.They’vebeendatingforawhileandshe’s
allupbyhissideonhisbirthday.Piercewouldneverhavethathappeningifhewasn’thittingthat.”
“Isee.”IlookedintoBraydon’ssparklingblueeyesandstaredathishugegrinandwondered
whatitwasaboutyoungguysandbeingcrude.
“Yeah,man.Whataboutyou?Gotanynicechicas?”
“Nochicashere.”Ishookmyhead.“You?”
“Youknow.”Helaughed.“I’vegotafewhereandafewthere.”Hewiggledhiseyebrowsatme.
“ButI’malwaysdownformore.”
“Yeah,I’msureyouare.”Ilaughedalongwithhim,wantingtoturnaroundandlookatJessand
seewhatshewasdoing,butnotwantingtocallattentiontomyself,orthefactthatIwasinterestedin
whatshewasdoing.
“Sowhatelseisgood,man?”Braydonspoketome,butIcouldseehiseyesonablondewhowas
dancingbyherselfinthecorneroftheroomwithaglassofsomethinginherhands.
“Notmuch.Sameold,sameold,”Isaidandlookedatthegirl,whoseemedtobeveryintoxicated
asshedancedaround.
“Jess,”shecalledoutloudly,andIfroze.“Jess,comeanddancewithme.”ShelookedovertoJess
andIrealizedthatthismustbeherfriendAlyssathatshe’dmentionedseveraltimes.
“Justasec,”JessrespondedandIsawhergivingPiercealookandaquicktouchontheback
beforeheadingovertoherfriend.Iwantedtogooverandjointhem.WantedtopullJessintomy
arms,askherifshepreferreditroughorgentleandifshecouldgoallnightlong.Iwantedtoseeher
facegoingred.Iwantedtomakehersquirm.Iwantedtohearhercallingmedirtyorobnoxiousor
annoyinginthatwaythattoldmethatasmuchasshehatedit,sheloveditaswell.Isobadlywantedto
touchher.Iwasn’tsurewhyIfeltthisattractiontoher,wasn’tsurewhatitwasthatmademewantto
playwithfiresomuch.IknewthatwhatIwasdoingwaswrong.Iknewthattherewasserious
potentialforeverythingtoblowupinmyface.AndIknewthatifthathappened,itwouldbeallmy
fault.IknewthatJesswouldcomeoffbadlyaswell,butnotasbadlyasme.AndallIcouldthinkwas,
woulditbeworthit?Foreitherofus?That,Ididn’tknow.Washotsexworthit?I’dfoundinmylife
thatsexitselfwasn’tworthanydrama,butthisseemedlikeitwasmorethansex.Itseemedlikethis
hadpotentialtobemore.Iwasn’tsureexactlywhatmore,butIwasinterestedinfindingout.Ijust
wasn’tsurethatI’deverhaveachance.
“Shit,thatblondchickissexyashell,”Braydonsaid,hiseyesalmostbuggingoutofhisheadas
hecontinuedtowatchAlyssadancing,herbodymovinginsensualrhythmtothemusicthatwas
poundingthroughouttheapartment.IcouldtellbythewayshewasdancingthatAlyssaknewexactly
whatshewasdoingandthatshewashopingforasmuchmaleattentionasshecouldget.Thelookon
herfaceandthewayherlipswerecurveduptoldmethatsheknewthateverysingle—andnotsingle
—guywaswatchingherassheflittedaround.Well,allthesingleguysbutme.MyeyeswereonJess
andonlyJess.Sexy,beautifulJess.
“Whydon’tyougooverandtalktoher?”Iaskedhimwithasmallsmile.“I’llcomewithyouif
youneedawingman.”
“YouthinkIshould?”heasked,notreallyneedingtobeconvinced.
“Yeah,man.Ithinkshe’sbeenlookingatyou,”Ilied.“She’sprobablywaitingforyoutocome
overrightnow.”
“ThenIshouldn’tdisappointher.”Hetooksomelargegulpsofhisbeerandthenputthebottle
downontheground.“Okay,I’mready.Letmeshowblondiewho’stheboss.”
“Yeah,youdothat,Braydon,”Isaidandgavehimasmallnod,tryingnottorollmyeyes.
“Let’sgo.”Hegavemeanassertivelookandheadedtowardsthecorner,whereAlyssaandJess
weregyratingtothemusic.Ifollowedbehindhim,tryingtoactnonchalantasweapproachedthetwo
girls.“Hey,wassup,”BraydonsaidashestoppednexttoAlyssaandItriedagainnottorollmyeyes.
Hehadabsolutelynogame.Butthatwasn’tmyproblem.
“Hello.”AlyssalookedhimoverandIcouldtellfromtheexpressiononherfacethatshewas
pleasedwithwhatshesaw.Obviouslyshehadnodiscerningtaste.NotthatIcared.
“Hello,I’mEvan,”Isaid,reachingmyhandouttointroducemyselftoher.
“Hello,Evan,”shesaidandIsawhergivingJessaquicklookbeforelookingbackatme.
Interesting,Ithoughttomyself.ItseemedthatJesshadmentionedmetoAlyssa,ifthatlookwas
anythingtogoby.“I’mAlyssa.”
“Nicetomeetyou,Alyssa,”IsaidasIshookherhand.IlookedoveratJessandgaveheranod.
“Jess,goodtoseeyouagain.”
“Uhhuh,”shesaid,hereyesnarrowed.
“IsthatallIgetinresponse?”Iaskedherwithasmallsmile.“No‘nicetoseeyouagaintoo,
Evan’?”
“Idon’tliketolie.”
“Really?Youcan’tevenfakeitforme?”
“WhywouldIwanttodothat?”Shecockedherheadtothesideandgavemeasmallsmileasshe
swayedbackandforth.
“Noreason.”Iwantedtowipethatsmileoffherfacebyshockingherwithahugekissor
somethingequallydecadent,butIknewIcouldn’tdothatandcallitoffasajoke.Noonewouldbe
coolwithmesmoochingJessatthismoment.AndIcouldn’triskgettingthrownoutoftheparty,not
yet.TherewasnogoodexplanationformegettingclosetoherandIknewit.Thatdidn’tmeanI
didn’twanttoattemptsomethingwithher.Verybadly.
“So,hadanyfundateswithSquirrelrecently?”Iaskedherwithasmallsmile.“Anycleanup
duty?”
“No.”Hereyesnarrowedatme.“Whataboutyou?Youseemlikeyou’dbegoodwiththeshit.”
“Whydoyousaythat?”
“Maybebecauseyou’refullofit,”shesaidunderherbreathandhereyesflashedatmebriefly.I
gaveherahugesmileinreturnandsheflushed.IlookedoveratBraydonandwassurprisedtosee
thathewasdancingwithAlyssaandshehadherarmswrappedaroundhisneck.
“Yourfriendisn’tshy,isshe?”IsaidtoJess,andshelookedoveratAlyssa.Isawhereyes
widening,butshedidn’tlookshocked.Interesting.
“Doyoucare?”Shepausedasshelookedbackatme.“Sadyoumissedout?”
“Who,me?Nah.”Ilookeddownather.“IknowwhatIwant.”
“Isee.”Shelickedherlipsnervouslyandlookedawayfromme.
“What’swrong,Jess?”Iaskedhersoftly.
“Nothing.”Shefrowned.“Whydoyouthinksomethingiswrong?”
“Idon’tknow,”Isaid.“Youjustlookoutofsorts.”Herfingersstartedplayingwithherlongdark
hairthenandIwatchedasshepacedbackandforthnervously.“Idon’tmakeyouuncomfortable,doI,
Jess?”
“No.”SheswallowedandIsawherlookingawayagain.Igrinned.Thiswasliketakingcandy
fromababy.Shewassointome,itwasn’tfunny.Andwhileapartofmewasexcitedaboutthefact
thatIwasprettyconfidentshewasintome,Ifeltalittlehesitant.IknewthatbypursuingherIwas
goingtobemakingeverythingawkwardforallofus.AndIwasn’tsureIwantedtodothat.What
wouldhappenifIhadmywickedwaywithher?Wouldshehatemeafterwards?Andwhatwouldthat
meantomyrelationshipwithPierce?We’donlyrecentlyreconnectedandIwasn’tsurethiswasthe
rightwaytomakesurethateverythingwasgoingtobekosher.However,Iwasn’tsureIcould
continuefightingmyattractiontoJess.Therewasjustsomethingaboutherthatfeltsocompelling
andattractive.Anditwasn’tjustaboutherbeauty.Ithadtodowiththefurtiveglancesshegaveme
whenshethoughtIwasn’tlooking.Ithadtodowiththewaysheranthetipofhertonguealongher
lipsnervously,wettingthem.Thewaysheappliedherlip-glossslowly,delicately,carefully,making
mewishitwasmeglidingacrossherlips.Ithadtodowiththewayhereyesflashedatmewhenshe
wasmad.Thewaythewordstrippedoffherlipsinamad,annoyedway,yettheyweresocarefully
chosen.Therewassomethingaboutherenergy.Somethinginthewayshemoved.Somethingthat
captivatedmemorethanI’deverbeencaptivatedbefore.Apartofmewasscaredbythatfact,butthe
otherpartofmewantedtopursueit,wantedtoseewhereitcouldgo.Iwantedtobewithher.Iwanted
tobeinher.Iwantedher.
“Thereyouare.”IheardPierce’svoicebehindmeandIfrozeforasecond.“Jess,Ihavesome
friendsI’dlikeyoutomeet.”
“IwasjustdancingwithAlyssaandthenEvancameandjoinedme,”Jessexplainedquickly,
soundingguilty,thoughIwasn’tsurewhyshedid.Itwasn’tlikewe’ddoneanything.
“Oh,hey.”Piercereachedoverandhuggedme.“Ididn’tevenseeyoucomein.Sohappythatyou
madeit.”
“Wouldn’thavemisseditfortheworld,”Irepliedanditwasmyturntofeelguilty.Whatsortof
personwasI?“HappyBirthday.”
“Momishereandshe’sgoingcrazy,stilltryingtoplaneverything.”Piercerolledhiseyes.“Itold
herthepartyisalreadyhalfover,what’sworkingisalreadyworkingandwhat’sgoingtofailcan’tbe
stoppedrightnow.”
“Yeah.”Inoddedandlaughed.“I’msureshedidn’tlisten,though.Youknowyourmom.”
“Yeah.”Helaughedagain.“She’sstillrunningaround,tryingtofixthingsthatdon’tneedtobe
fixed.”HeturnedtoJessthenandrubbedherback.“Shereallylikesyou,though.”Hegaveherahuge
grin.“Shethinksyou’reagreatgirl.”
“Oh,thanks,”Jesssaidsoftly,andIcouldtellfromherresponsethatshewasn’tasenthusiasticas
Piercewasbythatfact.
“Yeah,Itoldherthatwecouldgotobrunchtomorrow.That’scool,right?”
“Iguessso.”Shenodded.
“IwasthinkingEthiopianfood,”hecontinued,andIsawhereyesdartingtohisfacewitha
shockedlook.
“You’rejoking,right?”Shegavehimahalfsmile,aworriedlookonherface.
“No,whywouldIbejoking?”Helookedatherinconfusion.
“Ethiopian?”shesaidwithafrown.
“Yeah?”HecockedhisheadandIwantedtolaugh.EvenIknewbythispointthatJesshated
Ethiopianfood.ItwassadthatPiercestilldidn’tremember,butIthinkitwaspartofthereasonwhyI
feltitwasokaytocontinuemypursuitofJess.Iwasn’tsurewhatgamehewasplayingwithher,but
somethingwasoffinthissituation.Itdidn’tseemtomethathewasreallyinterestedinher.He
couldn’thavebeenthatinterestedifhedidn’tevenrememberthatshehatedEthiopianfood.
“Nothing.”Shesighedandjustlookedaway.“Itdoesn’tevenmatter.”
“Okay.”Heshrugged.“Youwannacomewithustoo,Evan?”
“I’mnotsurethatthatwouldbeagoodidea.”Ishookmyhead.Thatsoundedliketorturetome.
No,thankyou.
“Jess,comewithme.”Hegrabbedherhandandgavemeaquicklook.“Excuseus,Iwantherto
meetsomemoreofmyfriends,”hesaidandIwatchedastheyhurriedacrosstotheothersideofthe
roomandtowardsagroupofguysandgirlswholookedslightlyfamiliar.Icouldseeoneredheadin
particularwhowasglaringatthembothandsomethingaboutthewayPiercewaslookingathermade
methinkthatthiswomanmightbeanotherclueinthepuzzlethatwasJessandPierce’srelationship.
TheredheadtouchedhisarmsoftlyandInoticedthatshewaslookingathimcoylyandgivingJess
smallglares,whichJessdidn’tseemtorecognize.Itmademewonderwhatrelationshiptheredhead
andPiercehadhadinthepast.Itwasobviouslysomethingmorethanplatonic.AndifthewayPierce
wasstandingclosetoboththeredheadandJesswasanyindication,itseemedtomethatPiercewas
tryingtoplaysomesortofgamewithbothofthesewomen,whichmademefeelawholelot
differentlyabouthowguiltyIwouldfeelaboutpursuingJessformyself.Ifhewasbeingshadyand
didn’thavegoodintentionstowardsJess,thiswasaverydifferentsituation.
IleftAlyssaandBraydonandwalkedovertothesideoftheroomtogetadrinkandtothink.Ihad
somedecisionstomakeaboutwhatIwasgoingtodo.Tonightwasthenightformetomakeahuge
moveorjustwalkawayandleteverythinggo.Itookashotofbourbon,andthenasecondoneand
lookedbackoveratJessandPierceandthewayhisarmwasaroundherwaistpossessively.Iknewin
thatinstantthatIalreadyknewwhatdecisionIwasgoingtomake.Notthattherehadreallybeenany
otheroption.NotwiththewayIwascurrentlyfeeling.Ijusthadtomakeithappen.
E
C H A P T E R 1 1
van
I
T
WAS
midnightandIcouldhearsomeonewalkingaroundthelivingroom.NormallyIwouldn’thave
paidmuchattention,butcuriositygotthebetterofme.IwantedtoknowifitwasJess,andifitwas,
whatshewasdoingup.IwonderedifshewasthinkingofmeandifshewasasrestlessasIwas.I
couldn’tsleepatall.Iwasinvadedwiththoughtsofherandtheconstantflirtingwe’ddoneallnight.
AllIcouldthinkaboutwasherandifshewasascuriousaboutwhatIwasthinkingasIwas.Didshe
wonderwhatwouldhavehappenedbetweenusifshehadn’tmetPiercefirst?IknewIcertainly
thoughtaboutit.ButIdidn’tknowifshewouldhaveevenpaidattentiontomeifshe’dmetmeina
differentsetting.Shelikelywouldn’thaveevengivenmethetimeofdayifI’dapproachedheratthe
club.ThoughI’mnotsurethatwouldhavestoppedme.ShewassomeoneI’dhavetakenachancewith
ifI’dhadtheopportunity.Though,itwouldhavebeenamuchdifferentsituation.Thesituationwe
wereinnow,thoughnotideal,somehowmadeitevenmoreexciting.Eventhoughitshouldn’thave.I
knewthatitwaskindofsick,thisgameIwasplaying,butIcouldn’tstopmyself.
Ijumpedoutofmybedandheadedtowardsthekitchen,withthepretenseofneedingtogetaglass
ofwater,whichwasn’texactlyalie,basedonallthealcoholI’dconsumedattheparty.Ilookeddown
atmyboxersanddebatedputtingonaT-shirt,butdecidedagainstit.Iwalkedtothekitchenquickly,
myheartracing,wonderingwhoIwasgoingtosee.IfeltthegrincrossingmyfaceasIsawJess’s
figureinthekitchenwithherbacktome.Iwalkedupbehindhersoftly,wantingtosurpriseherand
seehowshewasgoingtoreact.Istoppedbehindherandgrabbedheraroundthewaistandpushed
myselfintoher.Sheyelpedslightlyatmytouch.
“Hey,honey,”Isaidsoftlyandwhisperedintoherear.ThiswasthemomentI’dbeenwaitingfor.I
hadn’tbeenabletosaymuchelsetoheratthepartyandithaddrivenmecrazy.I’dbeenhopingall
nightthatIwouldbeabletoseeheraloneandthatI’dgettoteaseherandtormenther.Ihadn’tbeen
giventheopportunityattheparty,butIwasbeinggiventheopportunitynow.
“Evan.”Shegasped,notmovingawayfromme.
“Yes,Jess,”Isaid,runningmyfingersgentlyacrossherstomachandfeelingmyselfgrowing
hardagainstherass.Ipushedmyselfintoheralittlefirmersoshecouldseeexactlyhowshewas
affectingme.Iwasn’tgoingtoholdanythingbackinthismoment.SheneededtoknowexactlyhowI
felt.AndIneededtoknowifthiswasgoingtobemorethanagameornot.Hadshegottenuptogeta
glassofwaterbecauseshewantedthismomenttohappen,orwasthismerelyacoincidence?Every
partofmebelievedthatthiswasbecauseshewantedtobewithmeandthiswashowshewasmaking
hermove,butIneededtofindoutifthatwastrueornot.
“Whatareyoudoing?”Shegaspedagain,yetshedidn’tmove.
“Exactlywhatyouwantmetodo,”Imuttered,voicedeepwithraw,unbridledpassion.Ijust
wantedtobendheroverandtakeher,butIknewthatwouldbewaytoomuchrightnow.Thougha
partofmethoughtthatshewouldenjoyit.
“Whatareyoutalkingabout?”shesaidandIcouldfeelherbodytremblingagainstme.Imoved
myfingersfartherupherstomachandpausedthemrightunderneathherbreasts.
“Whatdoyouthink,sexy?”Igroanedagainsther.“Iwanttofuckyou.”
“Evan.”Shesoundedshockedanditwasatthatpointthatshepushedawayfrommeandsteppedto
theside.
“Whatthehelldoyouthinkyou’redoing?”Shegasped,hereyesflashingatmefuriously.
“Ialreadytoldyou,”Isaidwithagrin,lickingmylips.“Doyouhaveaproblemwiththat?”
“OfcourseIhaveaproblemwiththat.Howdareyoutalktomelikethat?”
“Talktoyoulikewhat?”Ipretendedtolookconfused,butIcouldn’tstopmyselffromsmilingasI
lookedatherhardnipplesprotrudingfromhernightgown.
“You’reapig.”Sheshookherheadandmadetomovepastme.
“Whereareyougoing?”Iasked,feelingdisappointedthatshewasgoingtoleavethekitchen.
“I’mgoingbacktobed.”Sheshookherheadatme,uncertaintyinhervoice.“Piercewillbe
wonderingwhereIam.”
“He’sfastasleep.”Itriednottosoundaggravated.Ididn’twanttohearaboutPiercerightnow.I
didn’twanttofeelguiltyandIdidn’twanthertobethinkingofhimeither.Theonegoodthingwas
thatIwasprettyconfidentthattheyhadn’thadsexbecausehe’dbeenreadytopassoutbeforetheparty
hadevenended.Notthatthatshouldhavebeenagoodthingforme.IwasgoingtohellandIknewit.I
figuredImightaswellenjoytheridethere.
“Whatdoyouwantfromme,Evan?”ShebitdownonherlowerlipandIwantedtoleanoverand
kissher.
“YouknowwhatIwant.”
“No,Idon’t”
“Yes,youdo.”Istaredatherandstoppedsmiling.“YouknowwhatIwantbecauseyouwantit
too.”
“Ihavenoideawhatyou’retalkingabout.”Shemadeafaceatme.
“Yes,youdo,andyouknowhowIknow?”
“How?”SherolledhereyesbutIcouldseeherstartingtolooknervouslyatmeasshefidgeted.
“Iknowbecauseyou’restillherewithme,”Isaidmatter-of-factly.“Ifyouhadabsolutelyno
interest,youwouldhavefledfromthekitchenassoonasIenteredandputmyarmsaroundyour
waist.”
“Evan,Idon’tknowwhatyouwantmetosay.”ShelookedatmychestforafewsecondsandI
winkedatherwhenshelookedbackupintomyeyes.
“Justsayyou’reasintriguedbymeasIambyyou.”Imovedclosertoherandstoppedright
beforeIwastouchingheragain.
“Idon’tknowwhatyou’rethinking.”Shemadeaface.
“YouknowwhatI’mthinking.YouknowwhatIwant.”
“ButI’mdatingyourfriend.”Shealmostmoaned,turningmeonevenmore.Iwonderedhow
loudlyshewouldscreamwhenIslammedintoher.
“Myfriend?”Irepeatedafterherandalmostlaughedatherwords.Soherhesitancywasn’t
becausesheknewthetruth.Interesting.Iknewnowwasnotthetimetotellhereverythingshedidn’t
know.
“Ithinkyou’renotsuchagoodfriendtoPierceforcomingontomesomuch.”Shepushedher
handsagainstmychestasifshewantedtopushmeaway,buttherewasnoforcetohermovement.I
almostlaughed,butthiswastooseriousofamoment.Iwantedtoknowwhatwasgoingthroughher
head.Iwantedtoknowexactlywhatshewasthinkingandwhatherhesitancieswere.Didshecraveme
asmuchasIwascravingher?
“IguessI’mnot.”Itookastepclosertoherandthistimeourbodieswerebrushingagainsteach
other.“Ithinkwebothknowthatalready.”Igrabbedherhandsandpulledthemtotheside,entwining
themwithmine.
“Sowhyareyoustillhere?”shesaid,hereyeswideningasIpushedmyfaceclosertohers.
“Becausewebothknowwhatwewant,”Isaid,mylipspressingdownonherssoftly.Herlips
trembledbeneathmine,butshekissedmeback,eventhoughitwasalittlehesitantly.Ideepenedthe
kissandpulledherintome,hard.Herarmscreptaroundmyneckandshestartedplayingwithmy
hair.Itookthatasaninvitationtodeepenthekissfurtherandpushedmytongueintohermouthand
immediatelystartedsuckingonhertongue.Shetastedsweetandfaintlyofvodka.Herbodywaswarm
againstmineandherbreastsfeltsoftagainstthehardnessofmychest.Herfingersranacrossmy
headandscratchedagainstmyshornheadandIreacheddownandgrabbedherass,squeezedandthen
pushedherinevenfarthertowardsme,soshecouldseeexactlywhatshewasdoingtome.
ShegaspedloudlyasIgyratedmyhardnessagainsther.
“Wrapyourlegsaroundmywaist,”Iurgedher,wantingtofeelherclosertome,wantingtobe
insideofherasintimatelyaspossible.
“No.”Sheshookherhead,thoughshedidn’tpullawayfromme.
“Ineedtobeinsideofyou,Jess.”
“Evan…”shemumbledagainstmylips.Herfingerswerenowonmyback,runningupanddown,
drivingmecrazy.
“Jess,please.”
“Wecan’tdothis,Evan.”
“Youknowyouwantme.Youdon’twantPierce.Let’sbereal.”
“Evan,thisisn’tright.”Shegroanedasmyrighthandcreptuptoherbreastandsqueezed,my
fingertipsrunningacrosshernipple,pinchinggentlyandthenalittlerougher.Ienjoyedthewayshe
moanedandreactedtomytouch.Herbodyarchedtowardsmeasherbreastpushedintomyhand,
wantingtobecaressedfurther.
“Ifitisn’tright,whydoesitfeelsogood?”ImumbledasIkissedherneckandcollarbone.She
moanedinpleasure,andapartofmewantedtoreachdowntoseeifshewaswet,butIdidn’twantto
scareherandmovetoofast.Thoughittookeverythinginmenottoreachdownandtouchher,rub
her,enterherwithmyfingers.
“Evan,weshouldn’t.”Shesighedasherfingersdugintomyback.“WhatifPiercewakesup?”
“Hewon’t,”Isaid,allreasonandrationalthoughtgonefrommymind.
“Thisjustdoesn’tseemsafe,”shesaidwithasigh,andIlookedupatherface.
“Doyouwantmetostop?”Iaskedher,pullingherincloser.
“Yes.No.”Shemoaned.“Idon’tevenknow.”
“Youdon’tknow?”Isteppedbackfromher,disappointed.Iwantedhertocometomeincertainty,
evenifshewasworriedaboutPierce.WecouldworryaboutPiercelater.Rightnow,Ineededtoknow
shewantedme.Andifshewantedme,shehadtobeonehundredpercentconfidentinthatfact.Iwas
allaboutgamesandteasing,butifweweregoingtobeintimate,itwasgoingtomeansomething
reallyspecial.Oratleast,ifitdidn’tmeansomethingreallyspecial,itwasgoingtobesomethingthat
webothdidwithnoregrets.
“Idon’tknow,”shesaidsoftly,bitingdownonherlowerlipnervously.
“Liar,”Isaidwithamutter.Ineededhertoadmitshewantedthis—me—asbadlyasIwantedher.I
neededhertoadmitit.Iwasn’tsurewhyitmatteredsomuchtome.Iwasn’tsurewhatIwasdoing.
AllIknewwasIreallywantedher.AllIknewwasthatthismomentmattered.Thiswasthemakeand
breakmomentforme.Forus.Hellbedamned.IwantedJess.AndIneededtoknowthatshewanted
measwell.Ineededtoknowthiswasforreal.Ineededtoknowwehadsomesortofconnectionhere.
Iwasn’tsurewhyitwassoimportanttome.Itjustwas.
“Whatdoyouwantfromme,Evan?”Shegroanedandlookedintomyeyes,herslooking
confusedandfulloflust.“Idon’tevenunderstandwhatisgoingonhere.”
“Doestherehavetobeanythinggoingonhere?”Iaskedherwithafrown.“Whatdoyouwantme
tosay?”
“Idon’tknowwhatIwantyoutosay.Ijustdon’tthinkthisisagoodidea.”
“Whenisanythingagoodidea?”Ilookedather,tryingtofigureoutexactlywhatitwasshe
wantedmetosay.Whatdidsheexpectfromme?
“Ijustthinkifwedothis,we’llbecomplicitinsomethingreallyshady.”Shebitherlowerlip
againandIleanedoverandsuckedonit.
“Atleastwewillhavebeencomplicitinsomethingreallygood,”IsaidasIkissedherdeeplyand
pulledherintome.
“Evan…”Shegroaned,kissingmebackhard,herfingernailsdiggingintomyback.
“Jess,”Imutteredasmytongueenteredhermouthandshesuckedoniteagerly,pushingher
breastsintomychest,nolongerholdingback.“Oh,Jess,”Isaidasshewantonlyranherhandsdown
mybackandtomyassandsqueezed.“Youdowantme,don’tyou?”
“Stoptalking.”ShemoanedandItookthatasmyopeningtocontinueandacceleratethepace
betweenus.Iliftedherupandplacedheronthecountertop,spreadingherlegsandleaninginand
thenpullingherforwardsoherlegswerewrappedaroundmywaist.Ikissedhernoseandthenher
foreheadbeforeheadingbackdowntoherlipsandkissingthemgently.NowthatIknewshe
definitelywantedme,Iwantedtogoslowly,Iwantedtoconcentrateonherpleasure,makesurethis
wasamomentsheneverforgot.Iwantedtomakesuresheknewthismomentwasspecialandnot
sordid.IhadtomakeitaperfectmomentbecauseIknewtheaftermathwasgoingtobecrazy.
Absolutelycrazy.
“Letmetakeyoutomyroom.”IgroanedasIfeltmyselfabouttolosecontrol.IfIwasn’tcareful,
I’dbetakingherhereinthekitchenandIcertainlydidn’twanttodothat.NotthatIwouldn’tloveto
takeherrighthereandnow.Itdidseemlikeanappropriateplace,seeingasthefirsttimeI’dseenher
wasinthisveryroom.I’dlovetostriphernakedandtakeherrightnow,butIcouldn’triskit.Not
hereandnow.
“Shouldwebedoingthis?”ShemoanedasIpickedherupandcarriedherinmyarms,walkingas
quicklyasIcouldbeforeshecouldchangehermind.
“Tellmenow,wouldyouratherthisbemeorPierce?”Iaskedherhuskily,alreadyknowingin
myheartwhatshewasgoingtosay.
“Youknowtheanswertothat,”shesaidassheheldontome.
“Tellme,”IsaidasIcarriedherintothebedroom.“Tellmethatyouwantme.”
“Iwantyou.Iwantyoumorethanyouknow.”ShegroanedasIdroppedherontothebedandthen
shutthedoorbeforereturningtoher.
“Good,”Igrunted.“Now,Icanteachyouallthethingsyou’vewantedtolearnbutneverwereable
to.”
“Excuseme?”Sheblinkedupatme,herbodyshakingasshewrithedaroundonthebed.
“You’reexcused.”IgrinnedasIpulledoffmyboxershortsandstoodtherenakedinfrontofher.I
watchedasshelookeddownatmyhardnessandgasped,hereyeswideningasshetookinthesizeof
mymember.Ihidasmile,knowingshewasimpressedbyit.Shewasgoingtobeevenmore
impressedwhenIenteredher.Icouldn’twaittohearherscreamsandgaspsassheorgasmed,butshe
wasgoingtohavetobequietaswecouldn’taffordtowakeupPierceorLinda.
“You’reabadboy,Evan.”
“I’mbadtothebone.”IgrowledasIgotdownonthebednexttoherandstartedkissingherneck.
“I’msobadthatI’mgoingtodevouryourightnow,”Isaid,myhandsgrabbinghernightieand
pullingituptoripitoffherbody.IstareddownathernakednessandfeltmyselfgrowingharderasI
glancedatherbodytremblingbeneathmytouch.
“Evan,Idon’tknowifweshould...”HervoicetrailedoffandshegaspedasIbentdownandkissed
alongherthighs.
“Youdon’tknowifweshouldwhat?”Ilookedupatherandgrinned.
“What?”Hereyesflutteredasshelookeddownatme.HerbreastswereheavingandIreachedup
andplayedwithhernipples,enjoyingthewayhereyesdilatedandherbreathinggrewheavierasI
teasedher.
“Youdon’tknowifweshouldwhat?”Isaidagain,andbentdownandlickedmytonguebetween
herlegsandlightlysuckedonherbud.
“Evan…”ShemoanedandIcouldfeelhergrowingwetter.
“That’smyname.”Ilickedagainandthenmovedaway.“Yes?”
“Evan,stopplayingaround.”ShemoanedagainandIcouldseehereyesbeggingmetocontinue
playingwithher.
“Stopplayingaround?”Ifrowned.“Ithoughtyoujustsaidyoudon’tknowifweshould—”
“Oh,shutup.”Shegroanedandpushedmyheadbackdownbetweenherlegs.
“Oh,sonowyouwantme.”Ilaughed,lovinghowaggressiveshewasbeing.Iknewshehaditin
her.
“Youwantme.”ShemoanedandIheardherwhimperingasIstuckmytongueinsideofherand
startedpleasuringher.HerbodyconvulsedbeneathmeasIfuckedherwithmytongueandIheldthe
sidesofherhipsasIwentasdeepasIcould.MycockgrewharderandharderandallIwantedwasto
enterherandfeelherontopofme,ridingtheshitoutofme.Iwantedtowatchherbreastsbouncing
upanddownandthenI’dreachupandsuckonhernipplesandpullherhairandwatchherfacego
wideinsurpriseasIgaveherthebiggestandbestorgasmofherlife.
“Youknowit,”ImutteredasIfelthercomingonmyface.IlappedupherjuiceseagerlyandthenI
reachedovertothenightstandandgrabbedacondomfromthedrawer,rippedoffthewrapper
quicklyandsliditontomycock.Iloweredmyselfdown,lookedintoJess’seagerface.Shegavemea
quicksmileandnodandIenteredherswiftly,lovingthefeelingofherpussyasittightenedaround
mycock.ShemoanedandwiggledbeneathmeasIslidinandoutofherandIgroanedasshe
tightenedherlegsaroundmywaist.Hotdamn,thisgirlknewexactlyhowtogetmegoing.Ileaned
downandkissedherasIcontinuedthrustingintoher,mytongueenteringhermouthaseagerlyasmy
cockwasenteringher.Sheranherfingersdownmyback,hernailsscratchingasshedugintomy
skin.Iwelcomedtherawpassionofourbodiesmeetingandbecomingintimate.Itonlyseemedto
makesensethatwewouldbeprimalandsearchinginourfirstunion.Ipulledoutofherandflipped
heroverontoherkneessoIcouldslideintoherdoggy-styleandfuckherfastandfurious.Ifeltlike
I’dbeenwaitingforforevertohaveherandasshescreamedintothepillow,herassuphigh,Ifelt
myselfcomingintoherhardandfastwithnootherthoughtsonmymindaboutwhatwasgoingto
happennext.IcertainlyhadnoguiltaboutbetrayingPierce.Thatshouldhavetoldmethenandthere
thatIwasabadpersonandthatthiswasabadsituationtobein,butallIcouldthinkaboutwashow
Jess’sbodyfeltasgoodasIthoughtitwouldandthatshewasadrugIwouldlovetooverdoseon.
J
C H A P T E R 1 2
ess
H
OT
DAMN
,there'sawarmbodypressingintomefrombehind.And—whoa—Ithinkthatwhoever ’s
behindmeisveryhappyI'mawake,ifthehardnesspushingintomybuttisanyindication.Shit,my
eyesareblinkingrapidlyasIthinkbacktothepreviousnight.Toomanycocktails.Andthenthose
glassesofwine.Andthetwobeers.WhatwasIthinking?Oh,shit.Ifrozeasmymindimmediately
rememberedhimslidingintome,deepandhard.Icanpicturehisintenseeyes,hisloudgrowlsashe'd
slammedintome.Oh,fuck,whathadIdone?
"Morning,Jess,"hewhisperedintomyearashishandslidaroundtograbmybreast."Readyfor
roundtwo?"HepinchedmynippleandImoanedandclosedmyeyes.Iwasahorribleperson.I
couldn'tbelieveIwashereinbedwithhim.Icouldn'tbelievewe'dhadsex.Shit,Icouldn'tbelievewe
weregoingtohavesexagain.Iwasabad,badgirlforhavingsleptwithhim.Butfuckit,whatwasthe
pointofresistingroundtwowhentherehadalreadybeenaroundone?I'dpayformysinslater.What
wasdonewasdone.We'dalreadycrossedthelineofnoreturn.
“Isaidgoodmorning,Jess,”hesaidashenibbledonmyearlobe,andIsquealedslightlyasI
turnedtolookathim.
“Morning,Evan,”Isaidwithasmallandslightlyembarrassedsmile.“Andit’snotreallyagood
morning,isit?IfI’minyourbed,PiercemustbewonderingwhereIam.”Ibitdownonmylowerlip
asIthoughtaboutPierce.“Oh,myGod,whatdidwedo?”
“Youmeanyouforgotalready?”Hisfingersslidbetweenmylegsasheteasedme.
“No,”ImoanedasIstartedtogrowwet.“Evan,”ImoanedhisnameoutloudasIclosedmyeyes
andthenstartedtoshiftawayfromhim.“Weneedtostop.Ineedtoleavethisbednowbeforeyougo
anyfurther.”
“ButIwanttogoalotfurther.”Hegrunted.“Ihavemanymorethingstoshowyou.”
“Evan.”IgroanedandthenfrozeasIheardanoiseoutsidethedoor.Forsomereasonmygut
instinctkickedinandIsliddownunderthecoversquicklyasIheardthedooropening.
“Evan?”IheardLinda’svoiceinthedoorwayandIwonderedwhatshewasdoingthereandifshe
wastryingtohookupwithherson’sfriend.WaseveryonePierceknewshady?
“Morning,Linda,”hesaidwithwhatsoundedlikeanexasperatedvoice.“HowcanIhelpyou?”
“IthoughtIheardsomenoises,”shesaidsuspiciously.“Ijustwantedtomakesureyouwere
okay.”
“I’mfine,”hesaidstiffly.“I’mstillinbed.”
“That,Icansee.SoisPierce,”shesaidsoftly.“I’mgladyouguysaregettingalongagain.”
“Yes,soamI,”Evansaid,andmyheadstartedspinning.Whyhadtheyfallenoutpreviously?Had
EvansleptwithanotheroneofPierce’sgirlfriends?OrhadPiercemaybesleptwithoneofEvan’s
girlfriends?Wasthisrevenge?WasthatwhyEvanhadcomeafterme?Icouldfeelmynakedbody
startingtoshakeasIthoughtofthatpossibility.
“He’smissedhisdad.”
“Iknow,”Evansaid.AndIfrowned,wonderingwhatthathadtodowithEvan.WherewasPierce’s
dadandwhywashemissinghim?Iwasgenuinelycurious,butwasn’tsureI’deverfindoutthe
answertothatquestion,seeingasIwasplanningonbreakingupwithPierceassoonaspossible.I
didn’twantPiercetothinkthatwehadanythingspecialoranythingthatwasgoingtolastpastthis
moment.IfelttremendouslyguiltyforhavingsleptwithEvan,butIthinkwehadbothknownlast
nightthatwewantedeachotherandboyhaditbeenworthit.He’dbeendynamiteinbed.Iwasn’tsure
whatwasgoingtohappenbetweenusnow,butIalmostdidn’tcare.Iwaswillingtogowiththeflow
andseewhathappened.
“I’vemissedyoutoo,”Lindasaid,andIfroze.Whatwasshetalkingabout?Evanhadsleptwith
Pierce’smomaswell?Whatwasgoingonhere?
“Linda,let’snotgetintothis.Youknowweweren’trightforeachother.”
“Shouldn’tPiercehavehisparentstogetheragain?”Hisparents?What?MyheartstoppedandI
couldfeelmylipstrembling.Oh,myGod,whatwasgoingon?EvanwasPierce’s...
“Hey,what’sgoingon,Mom?”Pierce’svoicereverberatedintotheroomandIcouldfeelmy
bodyshakingevenmore.Icouldfeelmyfaceflushingandmywholebodygrowinghot.
“Justtalking.”
“Morning,Evan,”Piercesaid,andIfrowned.
“Whydoyouinsistoncallinghim,Evan?”Lindasaidwithanannoyedtone.“Whycan’tyoujust
callhimDad?”
“It’sfine,”EvansaiddrylyandIcouldfeelmyeyeswellingupwithtearsasmybodygreweven
hotter.Whatthehellwasgoingonhere?EvanwasPierce’sdad?Thismadethewholethingeven
morefuckedup.
Itoldyouthatitwasgoingtogetcrazy.ItoldyouthatIdidsomethingbad.Youjustdidn’tknow
howbaditwas,didyou?Whosleepswiththeirboyfriend’sdad?Thenightoftheirbirthdayparty?
Whohidesinbedwithsaiddadastheboyfriendandmomhaveaconversationwithhim?Iwasgoing
tohellonaone-wayticketandthefirewasalreadysingingmyskin.ThenIfeltEvan’shandreaching
downtotouchmeandIknewhewasgoingonthatsametrainridetohell.Ibitdownonmylowerlip
tostopmyselffromgasping.ThiswastheabsoluteworstpositionIhadeverbeenininmylifeandI
wasn’tsurehowIwasgoingtogetoveritoroutofit.
“Mom,youknowI’vebeencallinghimEvansinceIwasaboutthirteenyearsold.”Piercesounded
slightlyexasperated.“You’veneverthoughtitwasabigdealbefore.”
“Well,IjustthinkthatnowyoushouldcallhimDad.”Lindasoundedannoyed.“It’sweirdforyou
tocallyourdadbyhisfirstname.Icertainlywouldn’tallowforyoutocallmeLinda.”
“Idon’tdothatthough,doI,Mom?”PierceteasedhismomandIbitdownonmylowerlip,
hopingtheywouldleavetheroomsoon.Thiscouldreallyturnintoabiggermessthanitalreadywas
andIwasn’tsurewhatwouldhappeniftheyrealizedIwasinbedwithEvanandthatwewerenaked.
MybodystartedtotingleasIrememberedwhatithadfeltliketofeelhiminsideofme.Oh,mygosh,
I’dneverhadsexthatgoodbeforeinmylife.Hiscockhadbeenlikemagic,seemingtohitmyG-spot
everysingletimeheenteredmeandhe’dknownjustwhentorubmyclit,sothatIcamewithsuch
forcethatIthoughtmywholebodywasgoingtoexplodeinorgasm.Iwasshiveringjustthinking
aboutit.I’mnotsurewhatcameovermeinthatinstant,butIreachedmyhanddowntograbhiscock
andsqueeze.IfelthisbodystiffeningatmytouchandIalmostlaughedashegruntedslightly.Ibethe
wasn’tthinkingeverythingwassofunnynow.ImovedmyhandsupanddownhisshaftandIfelthis
handgrabbingontomywristtightly,tryingtostopme.Iwantedsobadlytopushhishandoffme,but
Iknewthatwouldn’tbesmart.I’dprobablyendupfallingoutofthebedandthenI’dprobablybe
kickedoutoftheapartment.Nakedandembarrassed.Myfacewasgrowinghotjustthinkingaboutit.
Thatwouldbethewalkofshametoendallwalksofshame.Oh,God,whathadIdone?Suddenlythe
fullrealizationofwhatI’dparticipatedinduringthenight(well,reallythemorningbefore)came
thunderingdownonmelikeatonofbricks.AndIknewthatIwasgoingtopayforitinonewayor
another.
J
C H A P T E R 1 3
ess
S
O
NOW
YOU
knowmydirtylittlesecret.Youmightormightnotbejudgingmerightnow.Youmight
evenbethinkingit’snotabigdeal.Imean,it’snotlikeIwasthatintoPierceandit’snotlikehewasa
PrinceCharming,right?Wedidn’tevenreallyhaveagreatrelationship.Anditwasn’treallymyfault
thatIsleptwithhisdad.Ididn’tevenknowthatwashisdadatthetime.Imean,upuntilthatpoint,I
wasprettymuchaninnocent.Okay,maybethat’sabitofastretch.MaybeIwasn’texactlyaninnocent.
MaybeIwasstillprettybad.Andunfortunately,Igotworse.Canyoubelievethat?Maybenot.Maybe
yes.I’msureyouwanttoknowhowitcouldhavegottenworse.IshouldhavejustleftPierce’splace
thatdayandneverlookedback.
Iknowwhatyou’rethinking.Iknowyou’rejudgingme.Thinkingthisdidn’thavetogetworse.
ThinkingthatIshouldhavejustleft.Imean,whydidn’tI?Ihonestlydon’tknow.Idon’tknowwhat
cameoverme.Ihavenogoodreasonfornotleavingrightaway.Maybeit’sbecauseIwantedtomake
surethatthiswasn’tjustabooty-callforEvan.MaybeIwantedtomakesurehefeltasnaughtyand
guiltyasIdid?I’mnotreallysure.Idon’thaveagoodanswer.WhenIlookbackateverything,I
reallythinkthatIshouldhavejustdartedoutofthebedandoutoftheroomasquicklyaspossible.
That’swhatasmartgirlwouldhavedone.Butyeah,I’mnotsmart.I’mnotsmartatall.I’m
embarrassedtoadmitthatafterLindaandPierceclosedthedoorthatmorning,IhadsexwithEvan
onceagain.Yes,andhehadtokeephishandovermymouthtostopmefromscreamingloudly
becauseheknewaswellasIdidthatthenoisesIwasmakingwereboundtobringpeoplerunningto
theroomasquicklyaspossible.
IsnuckoutofEvan’sroomandintothebathroomatabout9a.m.andrantheshowerrightaway.
Hedidn’tevenstopme,whichmademefeelslightlyupset,butItoldmyselfthatheknewthattime
wasoftheessenceandwedidn’treallyhavetimetotalkaboutwhathadhappened.Ihoppedintothe
showerandscrubbedmybodyhard.ItwasmyhopethatPiercewouldthinkIhadbeenintheshower
theentiremorning,thoughIknewitwasalongshot.Ifhepusheditandasked,Iwouldtellhimthat
I’dbeenscaredIwasgoingtothrowup,soIhadsatbythetoiletbowl.Gross,Iknow,butthatwas
reallyoneofmyonlyoptionsinregardstowhatIcouldhopehewouldbelieve.It’snotlikeIcould
tellhimI’dbeenhookingupwithhisdad.Oh,yeah,thatwouldgodownwell.Inallhonesty,itworked
outwellforme.Icameoutoftheshowerasheandhismomweretalkingaboutbreakfastandneither
oneofthemlookedsuspiciousorweirdedout.
“Morning,Jess.Sleepwell?”PiercecameforwardandgavemeakissonthecheekandIjust
noddedathim,relieffillingmethathedidn’tseemsuspiciousofmeandwhereI’dbeenallmorning.
“Oh,yeah,great.”InoddedwithasmallsmileandlookedatLindatoseeifshewaslookingatme
funny.However,shewasbeamingatmeandIcouldtellbytheexpressioninhereyesthatshestill
lovedmeasmuchasshehadthedaybefore.“Whataboutthetwoofyou?”
“Yeah,Isleptgreat.SorryIcrashedlastnight.”Hemadeaface.“Seemslikeitwouldhavebeena
reallyspecialnight.”
“Don’tworryaboutit,”Isaidwithasmallsmile,thankingGodhehadconkedoutrightaway.“I
justhopeyouhadagreatnightandenjoyedyourbirthdayparty.”
“Oh,yeah,itwasgreat.”Henodded.“DidAlyssahavefun?”heaskedmeandwinked,andIsmiled
backathimweakly.
“Yeah,Ithinkso.”Inodded.“Actually,IthinkIneedtogohomenowandcheckonher.”I
pretendedtolooksad,thoughIwashopinghewouldbuymyexcusetoleave.
“Oh,no.”Hemadeaface.“IwashopingwecouldgotobreakfastwithMomandDad.”
“Yousaid‘Dad.’”Ilookedathiminsurpriseandannoyance.Whywasthisthefirsttimehewould
choosetocallEvan‘Dad’?
“Yeah,MomprefersmetocallhimDadandnotEvan.”Helaughed.“SoI’mtryingtorespecther
wishes,atleastfornow.”
“That’swhyyou’remyfavoriteson.”Lindabeamedathiminapproval.
“That’sbecauseI’myouronlyson.”Helaughedandleanedoverandgaveherakissonthecheek.
“Areyousureyoucan’tcometobreakfastwithusthismorning?”Helookedatmeandpouted.I
lookedbackathimnervously,wonderingifhewouldbeabletotellthatI’dhadsexthatmorningjust
bylookingatme.
“IreallywishIcould,”Isaid,tryingtopretendIwasreallyupset.ThoughIwasjustcounting
downtheminutesinmyheaduntilIcouldleavetheapartment.
“Youreallywishyoucouldwhat?”Evanwalkedoutofthebedroomandlookedrightatmeand
gavemeawinkashelookedmybodyupanddown.Icouldfeeltheheatrisingupmybodyashe
staredatmeasifhewantedtoeatme.AndIhopedthathecouldsensethatIwantedtobeeatinghimas
well.Itfeltoddlytantalizingjusttobestandingherewithhimandtheothers,inbroaddaylight,
knowingwhatwe’djustbeendoingacoupleofminutesago.
“GotobrunchwithPierceandLinda,”Isaid,wonderingifhewouldgetjealousorupset.Hoping
hewouldlookpissed.
“Oh,awesome.I’mhungrymyself.”HegrinnedatmeandthenlookedatPierceandLinda.
“Whereareyouguysthinkingofgoing?”
Myjawnearlydroppedopenathiswords.Hewasseriouslyaskingthemwheretheyweregoing?
Withoutacareintheworld.Didhereallythinkthatwascool?Didhenotcarethatwehadjustslept
togetherandnearlybeencaught?
“Sadyoucan’tmakeit,Jess,butmaybelater.”
“Maybelater,what?”Iaskedhimwithafrown.
“Maybewe’llseeyoulater.Ifyouwanttocome...”HisvoicetrailedoffandIstaredathimwitha
shockedexpression.Icouldn’tbelievehehadjustsaidthattome,infrontofeveryone.Whatwasup
withtheinnuendos?Didhewanteveryonetoknow?Didhefeelnoshame?Whatsoever?
“Comewhere?”Iaskedhimwithpursedlips.
“Whereveryouwant.”HelaughedandIcouldseePierceandLindalookingatuscuriously.My
faceflushedredandIwassureitwasobviouswehadslepttogetherandhadsomethinggoingon.
“Well,youguyscanletmeknowwhatyou’reuptolaterthisevening,”Isaidwithasmallsmile
andthenIlookedatPierceandgavehimahugesmile.“Ihopeyouhadagreatbirthdayparty.”
“Itwasfantastic.”Henodded.“Ihadareallygreattime.Iwassogladthatyouwereherewithme.
Itmeantalottome.”
“I’msoglad.”Ireachedoverandgavehimakissonthecheek.“YoudeservedagreatdayandI
thinkthatyourmomisawesome.”IlookedoveratLinda.“Thanksforbeingsoawesome.”
“No,thankyou.”Shebeamedatme.“You’vebeenwonderful.Anabsolutedelight.Perfectionina
bottle.”
“Well,thanks,”Isaidwithasmallsmile,wonderingwhyshewaslayingitonsostrong.Itwasn’t
likeshereallyknewmethatwellanditwasn’tlikePierceandIwerethatclose.Orthatwehadbeen
datingforasuperlongtime.It’snotlikewehadanysortoflongrelationship.Everythingaboutthis
familywasalittleoffandIjustcouldn’tunderstandwhytheyallseemedtohavetheseweirdreactions
tothingsthatweresosmall.Imean,comeonnow,PierceandIbarelyhadanything.Whywas
everyoneactinglikeweweresoulmatesorsomething?ItcouldhavebeenflatteringifIwasreally
interestedinhimlikethat,butIjustwasn’t.AndsleepingwithEvanhadreallycomplicated
everything;well,notreally.Iwasn’tevensureifithadmeantanythingtohimorifhewantedtosee
meagain.Orifweweregoingtogoonarealdateorifhecaredaboutmeinanyway.Myheart
thuddedslightlyasIthoughtabouthimandIwonderedwhatI’ddone.Iwasaskank,thatIknew,but
hadIbeenaskankforagoodreason?WhatwasIgoingtogetfromthisandwasthereareasonwhy
everythingseemedsoweird?Ididn’thavetheanswersthen.Obviously.IfIhadknownexactlywhat
wasgoingonIwouldhaverunawayasquicklyaspossible.Atleastthat’swhatItellmyself.IfI’d
knownexactlywhatwasbeingplanned.IfI’dknownthewholetruthabouttheentiresituation,I’dlike
tothinkIwouldhavedonethesmartthingandjustbackedthehellawayfromthewholebunchof
them,butwhoreallyknows?IthinkI’vealreadyproventhatI’mnotthesmartesttoolinthetoolbox
oratleastIwaswillingtopretendthatIdidn’tseethingsclearly.I’mnotsurewhoIthoughtIwas
fooling.I’mnotsurewhyIthoughtIwasgoingtogetawayscot-freewithnoremorseandno
heartache.Lifeneverworkslikethatanditcertainlydidn’tworklikethatforme.
J
C H A P T E R 1 4
ess
“Sowhathappenedlastnight?”AlyssapracticallyjumpedonmeasIwalkedthroughthe
frontdoor,ahugegrinonherface.
“Howdoyouknowsomethinghappened?”Iaskedhercuriously,wonderingifsomehowword
hadgottenaroundtownthatIwastheslutwhohadsleptwithmyboyfriend’sfatherathisbirthday
party.
“BecauseIjustknow.”Alyssagrinnedatmeandgrabbedmyhands.“Nowtellmeeverything.”
“There’snothingtotell,”Isaidwithanembarrassedlookonmyface.“Honestly.”
“Yeah,right.Yousmellofsex.”
“What?”Ialmostscreamed.“Areyoujoking?”
“DoIlooklikeI’mjoking?”Shelaughedandthenwinked.“But,no,youdon’tsmellofsex,Jess.
ButI’mguessingyoudidgetlaid.”
“You’rehorrible.”Igroaned.“IhadashowerthismorningsoIknewitwasunlikelythatIsmelled
likesex.”
“Didyoushowerwithanyone?”
“No,why?”Ilookedathercuriouslyandsheslappedherhandagainsthermouth.
“What?”Iaskedher,myeyesnarrowed.
“YoutotallysleptwithEvan,didn’tyou?”Hereyeswerewide.
“Howdoyouknowthat?”
“BecauseifithadbeenPierce,youguyswouldhaveshoweredtogetheranditwouldn’thavebeen
abigdealformetohaveaskedyouthatquestion.”
“Uhm,smart,”Isaid,andgrinnedather.“Butyes,IdidsleepwithEvananditwasprettydarn
amazing.”
“Howamazingisamazing?”sheaskedwithawink.
“Holdup.”Ilookedathercuriously.“Iwanttoknowwhatwentdownwithyoufirst.”
“Whatdoyouthink?”Shewinkedatme.
“Youguyshadsex?”
“Duh.”Shelaughed.“Inthekitchen,onthecouch,inthelivingroom,intheshower.”
“Whoa,what?”Igasped.“Pleasedon’tsayonmybedaswell.”
“Iwouldneverdoitinyourbed,Jess.”Shelaughed.“Unlessyouexpresslyaskedmeto.”
“Iwouldneverexpresslyaskyoutodothat.”Irolledmyeyesather.
“Thenyouneverhavetoworry.”Shelaughedagain.“Now,enoughaboutme,tellmewhatwent
downwithyouandEvan.”Sheshookherhead.“You’resobad.Ican’tbelieveyousleptwithPierce’s
friend.”
Igroanedatherwords.“Oh,shit,youdon’tevenknowthehalfofit,”Isaidandmadeafaceather
beforeburrowingmyfaceinmyhands.
“Whatdoyoumean?”Shenarrowedhereyes.
“EvanisnotjustPierce’sfriend.”
“Oh,myGod,”sheshouted.“Theyweren’tlovers,werethey?”
“What?”Iblinkedather.“No,thatwouldbegross.”
“Youneedtobemoreopen-minded,Jess.”AlyssawinkedatmeandIgroanedagain.
“Listen,you’renotevengoingtobelievethis.”Ipausedfordramaticeffect.
“Oh,thissoundslikeit’sgoingtobejuicy.”Sheclappedherhandsexcitedly.“Tellme,tellme.”
“So,PierceandEvanaremorethanfriends.”Ipauseddramaticallyagain.
“Yeah,yousaidthat.”Shenodded.“Continue.”
“Evanis….”Istoppedandpretendedtocollapseontothefloor.
“Notawoman?”Alyssa’seyeswidened.“Donottellmethatthatsexybeastofamanisreallya
woman.”
“Alyssa…”Irolledmyeyesather.“Really?YouthinkthatEvanusedtobeawoman?Areyou
freakingjoking?”
“Idon’tknow.”Sheshruggedandlaughed.“I’mnotamindreader.Youshouldjusttellme.”
“I’mtryingto,”Isaid,feelingexasperatedandoverlydramatic.
“Sojustdoit,then.”
“EvanisPierce'sdad,”IsaidandstaredatAlyssa’sface.ItwouldhavebeencomicalifIwasn’tso
investedinthesituation.
“He’swhat?”Alyssa’sjawdroppedandhereyespoppedopen.“He’swhat?”
“Youheardmecorrectly,”Isaidandlaughed.“EvanisPierce’sdad.”
“Oh,myGod,yousleptwithyourboyfriend’sdad?”Hervoicewasinawe.“Youreallyarea
slut.”
“Alyssa…”
“Jess?”shemimickedme.“That’scrazy.Absolutelycrazy.Ican’tbelieveit.”
“Areyoujudgingme?”Iaskedherindisbelief,myheartsinking.IfAlyssawasjudgingmeand
thinkingIwascrazyandshocking,thenIreallyhadoversteppedtheline.EventhoughIalreadyknew
that.IguessI’dkindabeenhopingthatAlyssawouldbetheonepersonwhowouldn’tjudgeme.IfI
couldn’tcountonhertomakemefeelbetter,Icouldn’tcountonanyone.
“Ofcoursenot.”Shestartedlaughing.“You’remybloodyheroandit’snotasifyouknewthat
washisdad.”
“Ihadnoclue.Notuntilthismorning,”Isaidandgroaned.“I’mgoingtogotohell.”
“Nah,it’snotlikehe’syourhusband.YoubarelyknowPierce.”Alyssashookherhead.“You’re
fine.”
“I’msonotfine.I’mahorrible,creepy,weirdo.”
“Nah,it’snotlikeyou’vebeenwithbothofthemandevenifyouhad,that’snotevenabigdeal.
Evanistheonlydouchebaginthissituation.”
“Imean,that’strue.”Isighed.Hereallywasadouchebag.Agoodlover,butanawfulguy.Imean,
whosleptwiththeirson’sgirlfriend?Thatwassoshady.Hehadn’tcaredatall.He’dbeen
inappropriatefromthebeginning,whichmademewonderwhyhehadbeeninappropriatefromthe
beginning.Itmadenosensetome.Whathadhebeentryingtoaccomplish?Andwhyhadhe
continuedtopursueandplaywithme?Whathadhewantedfromme?Hadhebeentestingme?Andif
so,whatwasthetest?Obviously,I’dfailedit,butwheredidwegofromhere?
“Whatareyouthinkingabout?”Alyssatouchedmyarm.“Youtotallyjustspacedout.”
“I’mwonderingwhatI’mgoingtodonow?DoIseeEvanagain?Ishegoingtowanttoseemeor
wasIjustabootycall?”Imadeaface.“AndwhataboutPierce?”
“Whatabouthim?”
“DoItellhimthetruth?”
“Areyoujoking?”AlyssalookedatmelikeIwascrazy.“Whywouldyoutellhimanything?Just
ignorehim.”
“So…”Ilookedatherguiltilyandmyvoicetrailedoff.
“Sowhat?”Shefrownedatme.“Oh,myGod,Jess,whatdidyoudo?”
“Stopsayingthelord'snameinvain.”Imadeafaceather.
“Okay.”Sherolledhereyes.“Stopchangingthesubjectandtellmewhatyoudid.”
“WhosaidIdidanything”
“Jess,Iknowyoubetterthanyouknowyourself.Iknowyoudidsomething.Tellme.”
“Grr,”Irespondedandmadeaface.
“What’sgrr?”shesaid.
“Justgrr.”
“Justgrr?”
“ItoldhimI’dgotodinnerwithhim.”Imoaned.
“I’mguessingthatthe‘him’you’retalkingaboutisnotEvanbecauseIthinkyou’dbesmiling.”
Alyssalookedatmeexpectantly.
“Thatiscorrect.”Imadeaface.
“Letmegetthisstraight,”shesaidwithaslightfrown.“YousleptwithEvan,youfancyEvan,yet
youacceptedadinnerdatewithPierce.”
“Yeah.”Iwrinkledmynose.
“Areyououtofyourmind?”Shegavemeanotherlook,butthistimeshewasn’tsmiling.“Whyin
hellwouldyouacceptanotherdatewithPierce,whenyoudon’tevenlikehim?”
“BecauseIdidn’tknowwhattosay.”
“That’snotagoodreasontosayyes,Jess.”Shelookedannoyedwithme.“Whatthehellareyou
thinking?Youknowthiscanonlygobadlyforyou.”
“Well,Iwasputonthespot.”Imadeaface.“IfIsaidnoitwould’velookedsuspicious.Andhis
momwasthere.HowwasIgoingtodeclinehisinvitationinfrontofhismom?”
“Youcould’vesaidyouwerebusyandthatyou’dcallhimorsomething.Youcould’vesaid
anythingbutyes.”
“Yeah,Iknow.”Ijuststaredather.“Isuck.”
“Youdon’tsuck.”Sheshookherhead.“Youcanstillcancelthedate.Tellhimsomethingcame
up.”
“Yeah,Icandothat.”Ipaused.
“What’sthehesitancy,Jess?”
“Well,Idon’tknowwhenI’mgoingtoseeEvanagain.Wehaven’tmadeanyplansand,well—”
“Oh,mygosh.”Alyssacutmeoff.“You’reworriedyouwon’tseeEvanagainifyoudon’t
continuetodatePierce.”
“Well,kinda.”Imadeaface.Iknewitwashorrible.IfEvandidn’twanttoseemeagain,thenit
wasdegradingformetobechasinghim,andquitehurtfultoPiercetobegoingafterhim,knowing
thatIwasonlyinterestedincontinuingtoseehimbecauseIwantedtoseeEvan.
“Thatsoundshorrible,doesn’tit?”
“Jess,honestly,ifEvandoesn’twanttoseeyouagain,he’sanass.”Shepausedandgavemea
hesitantlook.
“What?”Iaskedexpectantly.
“Honestly,heseemslikehe’skindaanassanyway.”Shegavemealookandpaused.“Heknew
youweredatingPierceandhestillsleptwithyouandheknewthatPiercewashisson.Imean,what
sortofshittyfatherdoesthat?”
“Whatareyousaying?”
“I’msaying…”Andshelookedseriousforafewmoments.“Jess,I’msayingthatwhileI’mglad
youhadfunandagoodnight,I’mnotsureIwouldbewastingmytimetryingtoinvestinthis
friendshiporinanythingwithhim.”
“Why?”Ifelthurtatherwords.
“BecauseIdon’tthinkhehasanyplanstoinvestanythingwithyou.Imeanthisseemslikethisis
allfunandgamestohim.”Shemadeaface.“Inthissituation,howcouldanythingreallyprosperor
getbetter?”Shelookedserious.“Imean,he’sneveraskedyouonadate.He’sneverimpliedhewants
arelationshipwithyou.Hedidn’teventellyouhewasPierce’sdad.Seemstomehe’saselfishjerk
whowantedsexandthat’saboutallhewanted.”
“Soyouthinkit’sawasteoftimeformetotrytogettoknowhimbetter?”AsIsaidthewords,I
knewIwasbeingstupid.Itwasn’tasifEvanwaseventryingtogettoknowmebetter.Thatwasone
thingIhatedaboutbeingawoman:alwaysthinkingaboutsituationsandoutcomesthathavenothing
todowithrealityandwhat’sactuallygoingon.Imean,whydidIcareifIthoughtitwasawasteof
timetogettoknowhimbetterornot?Itwasn’tasifitwasevenanoptionatthismoment.Evanwasn’t
tryingtogettoknowmebetter.Iknewthat.Heknewthat.Yet,mybrain,heartandbodyweretryingto
convincemyselfofsomethingdifferent.Itoldyou,I’mnotinmyrightmind.Notatall.
“Jess,hasheaskedyouout?”sheaskedmeseriously.“Hashecaredaboutanythinginyourlife
asidefromteasingyouandmakingsexjokes?”
“Youknowtheanswertothat.”Istartedtofeelahollownessinsideofmeasmyheartfell.
Therealityofthesituationwashittingmelikeatonofbricks.Alyssawascorrect.Therewas
absolutelynothingthathadoccurredbetweenusthatwouldleadmetobelievethatEvanwas
interestedinabsolutelyanythingwithme.EvenwhenI’dleftthismorninghehadn’tsaidanything,
hadn’ttriedtosnatchmeawaytotalkandseewherewestood.Ifitwasn’tformesayingyesto
Pierce’sdinnerdate,therewasapossibilitythatI’dneverseeanyofthemagain.IswallowedhardasI
realizedI’dsleptwithamanwhoreallydidn’tgivearat’sassaboutme.Ithadseemedallfunand
exciting,inthemorning,buttherealityofthefactwasthatI’dbeennothingbutabootycalltoEvan.
Sometwo-bittrampwhohadopenedherlegseasilyandlethimtakewhathewantedwithouteven
havingbeentakenonadate.IwasanidiotandthefactthatIwasstillhopingEvanwouldbeinterested
insomethingmorethanI’dalreadygottenconfirmedthat.Hehadneverevenbeensupernicetome.
Somerudeconversationsdidn’tmeanmuchattheendoftheday.
J
C H A P T E R 1 5
ess
“S
O
I
WAS
THINKING
MAYBE
wecouldgoonarealdate?”Ispokeintothemirrorandmadeafaceatmy
reflection.Isoundedpathetic.“SoIwasthinkingthatperhapswecouldgoout,maybeonadate?”I
saidagainandtriedtogivemyselfasexysmile.Ugh,whywouldEvanwanttotakemeonadateafter
everythingthathadgonedownbetweenus?WhywasItryingtomakethissomethingthatitwasn’t?
“Somaybebeforewehavesexagain,youcouldactuallyspendsomemoneyonme?”Igroanedatthe
wordsandwalkedovertomybedandthenfelldownonthemattress.“Yousuck,Jess.”Imoanedout
loudandstaredattheceiling.AndIsuckedformultiplereasons.One,becauseIwashopinghewould
takemeonarealdate,andtwo,becauseIthoughtwe’dactuallyhavesexagain.Andthenthree,
becauseIhadadatewithPierceplannedforthatevening.
“Talkingtoyourselfagain?”Alyssawalkedpastmybedroomandlookedintomyroom,giving
measmallsmile.
“Again?”Imadeafaceather.“AreyoutryingtosayyouthinkI’mgoingcrazy?”
“You’velongbeencrazy,Jess.”Alyssawalkedintotheroomandsatdownnexttome.“Whatare
youmumblingonabout?”
“I’mjusttryingtothinkofawaytoconvinceEvantogoonadatewithme.”
“What?”AlyssasighedandIcouldtellshewastryingtostopherselffromsayingsomethingelse.
“Iknow,it’sstupid.I’mstupid.”Imadeafaceather.
“You’renotstupid.”Shepursedherlips.“Youjusthavebadtasteinmen.That’snotuniquetoyou.
Wealldo.”
“Yeah,thatmakesmefeelalotbetter.”Irolledmyeyesather.“Itjustsucks.”
“Yeah,itdoessuck,butyoucangetoverit,ifyoufocusandjustconcentrateonmovingon.”
“That’seasiersaidthandone,Alyssa.”Isighed.“IwouldifIcould.”
“Maybeyouneedtotryalittleharder.Idon’treallyfeellikeyou’vedonemuchtogetoverthis
situationandmoveon.”
“Whatwouldyouhavemedo?”Iwhined.“Wejusthadsexlastnight.Ilikehim.Iwanttoseehim
again.Iwanttoseeifperhapshemightlikeme.”Imadeaface,knowinghowstupidIsounded.Why
wouldhelikeme?Hedidn’tevenknowmeandIdidn’tthinkIwasthatgoodinthesack.
“Stoptalkingtotheasshole.”Hervoicegrewlouder.“Stoptalkingtohim.Stopsleepingwithhim.
Stopseeinghim.That’stheonlywaytomoveon.Youguyshookeduponce.It’snotlikehepromised
youthemoonoranything.Justdon’ttryandmakethissomethingthatitisn’t.”
“Iknow.Iknow.I’mtrying.”
“You’renottryingveryhard.”
“Alyssa,givemesomecredit,please.”Istaredather,paininmyeyes.“Thisisnoteasyforme.”
“Iknowit’snoteasy,butit’snotgoingtogeteasier.It’sonlygoingtogetharder.Andit’sonly
goingtogetmorepainful.Andthelongeryouwaittogetoutofthissituationtheharderitisgoingto
be.”
“That’swhatshesaid,”Ijoked,butAlyssadidn’tlaugh.“Ithoughtthatwasfunny,”Isaidandgave
herawrysmile.“Youdon’tagree?”
“Ifyou’reafifteen-year-oldboy,it’sfunny,otherwiseit’snot.”
“Haveasenseofhumor.”Imadeafaceather.
“Jess,Idon’twantyoutogetcaughtupinthisguy.”
“I’mnotcaughtup,”Iprotestedandthenmadeafaceatheragain.“AndIthoughtyouwerethe
onewhothoughtitwasexcitingformetobedatingEvan?”
“No,Ithoughtitwasexcitingthatyouwereflirtingwithtwodifferenthotguys.Ithoughtitwas
exhilaratingand,yeah,maybeIthoughtitwouldbecoolifyouhookedupwithoneofthem.AndI
didn’tcarewhichone,butnowIknowthatEvanisPierce’sdad.Itkindamakesitallalittleickier.I
mean,whatguysleepswithhisson’sgirlfriend?It’sjustshady.Andwhatareyoutalkingabout?
You’renotdatinghim.Youhadsexwithhim.That’sabigdifference.”
“Wedon’tknowhisreasons,though.”Iignoredmostofhercomments.“Maybeheforgothewas
Pierce’sdadorsomething…”Myvoicetrailedoff.“Maybehehadagoodreason...”
“Isthereanypossiblegoodreasonforhimtohookupwithyou?”Shegavemealook.“Imean,
let’sbereal,whatgoodreasoncouldhehave?”
“Idunno.”Isighed.“It’snotsomethingI’vebeenthinkingaboutalot.Ijustwanthimtolikeme.”
“Iknowyouwanthimtolikeyou,butmaybe,justmaybe,he’snotthesortofguythatyoushould
wanttobewith,evenifhedidlikeyou.”
“Sonowyou’resayingthatit’sawasteoftimeformetowanthimtolikeme?”
“Yes.”
“Whoa.”Ilookedatherfacecarefully.“Youreallydon’tlikehim?”
“Ithinkhe’sbadnewsandbadnewsmeansabrokenheartandhe’snotworthabrokenheart.”She
madeaface.“Trustme,he’snotworththetearshewillbring.”
“Whydoyousaythat?MaybeIjustwantsomefunaswell.”
“Maybe.”Shesighed.“Butwebothknowyou’renotthatkindofgirl.Youdon’twantfun.That’s
notwhatyou’reaboutinrelationships.”
“Notinrelationships,butthisisn’tarelationship.Asyoujustsaid,”Isaidandtriedtosmile,butI
couldn’tquitemakeit.IlookedatAlyssaandsighedmyself.
“Oh,myGod,whatamIdoing?Thisisalreadyahotmess.Ishouldjustmoveonwithmylifeand
pretendlikeInevermetEvanorPierce.”
“Iagree,”Alyssasaidwithanod.“Forgetthemboth.”
“I’mgoingtodoit.”Inodded.“Next!”
“Next!”Shereachedovertohugme.“Wannagoouttonight?Maybewecangoclubbing?Meet
somehotties?”
“Alyssa…”Ijuststaredather.“Really?That’swhatgotusinthispredicamentinthefirstplace.
Well,me,anyways.Idon’tsupposeyouhaveanyissuewithBraydon?”
“Yougotthatright.”Shelaughed.“Braydonisgoodforanightortwo,butI’mnotinterestedin
anythingmorethanthat.”
“Well,goodforyou.I’mgladyou’reabletomoveonsoquickly.”
“Iwouldn’tcallitmovingonsinceweneverhadanythinginthefirstplace.”
“Iknowwhatyou’regoingtosaynext.”Icouldfeelmystomachlurching.
“WhatamIgoingtosaynext?”Sheraisedaneyebrowatme.
“You’regoingtosayIdon’treallyhavemuchmovingontodo,either,becauseEvanandInever
hadanything.”Iblinked,tryingtoignorethewarmheatrisingthroughmystomach.Iwasstartingto
feelsickandmyskinwasfeelingclammy.IhadnoideawhyIwasfeelingsopoorlyoverthis.Itwas
truewhatIsaid.EvanandIdidn’thaveanysortofrelationship.We’dmetandflirtedandargued.I’d
calledhimanassandhe’dteasedmeand,yes,nowwe’dalsohadsex,butthatdidn’treallymean
anything.Itdidn’tmeanwewereconnectedinanyway.Itdidn’tmeanweweremeanttobetogetheror
thathelikedme.GuyshadsexeasilyandI’dlethim.Imean,itwasn’tlikeIhadn’twantedit,butreally
itdidn’tmeananything.Iwasprettysurehewasn’tforecastinganysortoffuturewithmeand,really,
whyshouldhe?Iwasnoonetohim.Infact,anysortofrelationshipwouldlikelybedoomedbasedon
howwekneweachother.Whatwouldwesayifweevergotmarried?‘Oh,Jesswasdatingmyson
whenwemetandwehookedupthenightofhisbirthdayparty.’Hiphiphooray.Threecheersforthe
brideandgroom?Yearight,thatwasunlikelytohappen.Very,veryunlikely.AndwouldIevenwant
thattohappen,evenifitwereapossibility?AndwasIcrazyforeventhinkingthesethoughtsinthe
firstplace?Yes,yes,ofcourseIwas.Thatwasn’tmyfirstsignthatIwascrazy.Imean,let’sbereal,I
sleptwithmyboyfriend’sdad.Youknowyoualreadyhavetobecrazyifyou’redoingsomethinglike
that.Ijustdidn’trealizehowbonkersIreallywas.MaylightningstrikemedownifIcontinueonthis
crazytrain.Sometimes,Ijustdon’tunderstandwhyIalwaysseemtofindmyselfinthesesituations.I
canneverjustmeetthenormal,niceandsweetguyandstickwithhim.Therealwaysseemstohaveto
besomedrama.AndI’msooverdrama.Notthatyouwouldknowthatfrommyhistoryorcurrent
day.
“Whatareyouthinkingabout,Jess?”Alyssasoundedconcerned.
“I’mthinkingthatI’mafool,maybeahugefool.”AndIcouldn’tevenlietomyselfandsaythatI
wasn’t.
“Whyareyouahugefool?”Shelookedconcernedatmymelodramatictone.Eitherconcernedor
annoyed.Icouldn’tquitetell.
“BecauseIcareaboutthisguyandIdon’tthinkIcanjustignorehimthateasily.”Ibitdownonmy
lowerlip.“Idon’tknowthatIcanjustmoveonandnotfeelanything.”
“Oh,Jess.”Alyssarubbedmyshoulder.“Don’ttellmeyou’vefallenforhim.”
“Okay,Iwon’ttellyouthen.”Imadeafaceatherandthengroanedloudly.“Whydoesthisalways
happentome?”
“Justignorehim,babe.It’llbeokay.”
“Idon’tknowhowtoignorehim.”Istaredintohereyes.
“Well,hashecontactedyouyet?”sheaskedcuriously,andIshookmyhead.
“So,yeah,let’sworryaboutyouignoringhimafterhekeepstryingtoblowyouup.”
“Youdon’tthinkhe’sgoingtocall,doyou?”ImadeafaceatherandmyheartsankbecauseI
didn’tthinkhewasgoingtocallortext,either,whichjustmadethewholethingevensadder.HereI
waspracticallycryingmyheartoutandhehadn’tevencalled.Iwasprettysureheprobablywasn’t
eventhinkingaboutme,period.Sad.
“Imean,hemight.”Shelookedlikeshewastryingnottohurtmyfeelings.IknewitbecauseI
knowshedidn’treallythinkhemightcallortext.Iknewshedidn’tthinkhewouldbecauseIcertainly
didn’tthinkhewould.Imean,whywouldhe?I’djustbeacomplicationinhislifeandwhywouldhe
wantacomplicationlikeme?WhatpositiveswasIbringingthatwouldoutweighallthenegativesthat
wouldcomealongwithhimwantingtoseemeagain?Therewerenorealpositivesthatwouldcome
fromusbeingtogetherandnoreasonswhyhewouldwanttopursueit,either.Whybuythebiggest
bitchofacowwhenyou’dalreadygottenthemilkforfree?
“Webothknowhe’snotgoingtocallmeortextme,”Isaidandsighed.“Thebiggerissueis
obviouslyme.AmIgoingtotextorcallhim?AmIgoingtobetheweaklink?”
“Jess,youcan’tthinkaboutitlikethat.”Alyssapausedandthencontinued.“ThoughIwould
recommendyoudon’ttextorcallhim.Whyputyourselfouttheretobehurt?Honestly,he’snota
goodguy.Astandupguywouldneverhaveputyouinthatpositioninthefirstplace.Hewould’ve
toldyouwhohewas,would’vetriedtomakethingsrightbeforeyouguyshookedup.He’snotastand
upguy,trustmeonthat,sothere’sabsolutelynopointontryingtogettoknowhimbetterorgiving
himachance.Nopointwhatsoever.”
“Wow,youreallydon’tlikehim.”
“Iknowthesesortsofguys.Theyaren’tworthit.He’llneverbeworthit.”
“Whydoesitalreadyfeellikeit’sgoingtohurt,though?”IcouldfeelmyheartachingasI
thoughtaboutneverseeingEvanagain.Whydideverythingfeelsomelodramaticalready?WhydidI
feellikemyheartwasgoingtobebroken?WhydidIfeelliketherewasnothingIcoulddotostopthe
painthatIknewwascoming?
“Oh,Jess,you’veinvestedinhimemotionallyandphysically.”Alyssalookedworried.“You
knowyou’renotthesortofgirlwhocansleepwithaguyandnotfeelsomethingforhim.That’sjust
yourpersonality.”
“Idon’twantthattobemypersonality.Idon’twanttothinkabouthimorcareabouthim.Idon’t
wanttobefeelinghurtalready.Idon’tevenknowthisguy.Idon’twanttofeellikehe’sconsuming
mylife.”
“Jess,theonlythingIcantellyouisthatyouneedtojustnotcontinueonwithhim.Gettingout
andmeetingnewguyscouldhelpwiththat.”
“Alyssa,Idon’twanttogoclubbing.Idon’twanttomeetnewguys.Ican’tmoveonthatquickly.
That’snothowIwork.IalreadyfeellikeshitabouteverythingandnowIfeellikemyheartisgoing
tobebrokenforbeingsomeheathenslut.”
“Jess,STOP,STOP,STOP.Youaretotallyoverreactingabouteverything.Youcangetoverthis
quiteeasilyifyoujustlistentomyadvice.”
“I’mlistening.”
“You’relistening,butI’mnotsureyou’rereallypayingattention.I’mnotsureyou’regoingto
listentomeandfollowmyadvice.”
“He’snotcalling,soIdon’tthinkwehaveaproblemrightnow,doyou?”Ipursedmylips.“Don’t
worry,I’mnotgoingtoaskhimifhewantstotakemeonarealdate.”
“Youshouldn’tevenhavetoaskhimthat,Jess.Ifhewasreallyinterestedinthat,hewould’ve
askedyoualready.Let’sbereal,ifhe’sinterestedinagenuineway,hewillbeaskingyoualotmore
thancanItakeyouonadate.He’dbewooingyou,hopinghecouldtakeyouonmanydates.He’dbe
hopingthathecandowhateverhecantomakeyoufeelbetteraboutthissituation.He’dbelettingyou
knowhowmuchhelikesyouandhe’dbehopingthatyoufeelthesameway.He’dbetalkingabout
howhe’ssorryfornottellingyouthetruth—which,bytheway,whatdidhesayaboutthat?”
“Nothing,”Imumbled,feelingdumb.
“What?”Shescrewedherfaceup.“Whatdoyoumeanbynothing?”
“Imeanhesaidnothing.”Igroaned.“IwasinbedwithhimwhenIfoundout.AndwhenIsayin
bed,ImeanthatPiercehadkindaenteredtheroomandthat’showIfoundout.AndthenIrushedtothe
showerandtheneveryonewasthereandthenbasicallyweallchattedandIsaidIcouldn’tmake
brunchbecauseyouneededmeandthenPierceaskedifIwantedtododinnerinsteadandIsaidyes
andthenIleft.”
“Oh,myGod.”Alyssashookherhead.“CallPierceandtellhimthatyoudon’twanttododinner.
Tellhimyoucan’tseehimanymore.Tellhimthateverythinghasbeenmovingtooquicklyforyou
andthatyouneedsometimetothink.”
“Really?”Imadeafaceandmyheartlurched.“Won’tthatlooksuspicious?”
“Whobloodycares?”Alyssasoundedannoyed.“Justdoit.YouowenothingtoPierceortoEvan.
Absolutelynothing.Youjustneedtogetoverthemboth.Andthebestwaytodothatisnottosee
eitherofthemagain.”
“Oh,myGod,”Isaid.“I’mnotsureIcandothat.”Mystomachsank.“Ireallylikehim.Ijustcan’t
notseehimagain.”
“Yes,youcan.”Alyssalookedannoyednow.“It’stheonlywaytomakesurethisdoesn’tblowup
inyourface.”
“Itwon’tblowupinmyface.”Ibitdownonmylowerlip.“I’llbegood.”
“It’snotyouI’mworriedabout,Jess.You’replayingwithfireandIsweartoGod,you’retheonly
onewho’sgoingtogetburnedinthissituation.”
“Why?”Iburiedmyfaceinmyhands.“Oh,God,why…”
“Justlistentome,Jess.JustcallPiercenowandcalloffthedinnerdate.”
“Okay.”Inoddedandsighed.“I’lldoit.”Ipeekedatherthroughmyfingers.“I’lldoit.”Ijumped
upandthencollapsedbackdownonthemattressandgroaned.“Whyme?Whyohwhy?”
J
C H A P T E R 1 6
ess
Y
OU
EVER
TELL
yourselfthatyou’redoingsomethingforonereasonwhenyou’rereallydoingitfor
quiteadifferentreason?That’ssomethingthatIdoallofthetime.That’ssomethingIdidwhenI
decidedtogoovertoPierce’sapartmenttopickupadressandcardiganthatI’dleftthereatsome
point.EventhoughIhadcancelleddinnerwithPierceandtoldhimthatIwasn’tfeelingwelland
neededtimealone,IstillconvincedmyselfitwasagoodideatogoovertohisplaceandthatIreally
neededmydressandcardiganbecause,well,youknow,itwasobviouslyamatteroflifeanddeath.
ThesadpartwasthatEvanhadn’treachedouttomeatallinthethreedayssinceI’dsleptwithhim.
Andthathadkilledme.Icouldn’tstopthinkingabouthim,wonderingwhathewasthinking.Telling
myselfthathewasn’tcontactingmebecausehewasn’tsurehowIfeltandifIwouldbecoolwithhim
afterwhathadhappened.MaybehewasworriedI’dfeellikehehadtakenadvantageofme.Maybe
he’dthinkIdidn’twanttoseehimagain.Ididn’tknow.Iknewinmyheartofheartsthatallofthose
thoughtswerelikelyuntrue.Iknewhemostlikelywasn’teventhinkingaboutme.IknewthatIwas
probablynothingtohim,butthatdidn’tstopmefromwishingthattherealitywassomethingdifferent.
Imean,don’tweallwishthattherealityissomethingdifferent?Sothat’swhyIfoundmyselfheaded
overtoPierce’sapartmentonaThursdayafternoonwhenthelastthingIshouldhavebeendoingwas
headingovertohisplace.
Irangthedoorbellandheldmybreath,wonderingwhowasgoingtoanswerandbuzzmeup,if
anyone.
“Hello?”Evan’sdeepvoicespokethroughtheintercom,andmyheartstopped.“Hello,”hesaida
fewsecondslater,asI’dbeenunabletospeak.
“It’sme.It’sJess,”Isaidfinally.Silence.Ifeltmyfacegrowingred.Whywasn’thesaying
anything?Oh,myGod,I’dmadeamistake.
“Jess?”hesaidafterwhatseemedlikeadecade.
“Ileftsomethingintheapartment.Icametogetit.”
“Okay,”hesaid,hisvoicesoundinghesitant,andIjustwantedtorunaway.
“CanIcomeup?”
“Ofcourse.”HebuzzedmeupandthedoorcrackedopenasIpusheditandheadedtowardsthe
stairs.MyheartwasracingasImademywayupthestairs,wonderingwhathewasthinkingandifI’d
madeahugemistakecominghere.Hehadn’tsoundedlikehe’dmissedmeorbeenthinkingaboutme
atall.
E
C H A P T E R 1 7
van
T
HREE
DAYS
.ThatwashowlongithadtakenforJesstocomeover.Iwassurprisedithadtakenthis
long.Infact,itmademedoubtmyownskillsinbed.Thefactthatshehadn’tevencontactedmeor
triedtoseemebeforethispointwassurprisingandI’dfeltabitputout.Normallyawomansleptwith
meanditwaslikeshe’dbeenconsumedwithavirus.Normallytheycouldn’tgetenoughofme.
ObviouslyJesshadn’tfeltthatway.Thoughshehadeventuallyshoweduptoday,threedayslater.
Hmm,I’dhavetoshowherthatthatwasn’tacceptable.Threedayswastoolong.I’dbeencravingher
sincethemomentshe’dleftmybedtheothermorning.AllIcouldthinkaboutwasthewayshe’dfelt
nexttomeandhowshe’dtouchedmeandI’dfeltwholeinsideofher.Ithadfeltlikeheavenonearth.
AndwhileI’dfeltguiltyaboutwhathadoccurred,Icouldn’tstopthinkingthatthiswasoneofthe
hottestmomentsinmylife.Oh,Jesshadbeensoeager,sowilling,sotempting,andshehadloved
everypartofitjustasIhad.
Butdamn,threebloodydays.Howcouldshehavegonethatlongwithoutseeingmeorwantingto
bewithme?Ididn’tunderstandit.
IheardthelightknockingonthedoorandIwalkedovertoitinexcitement.Icouldn’twaittosee
herfaceorherbody.Icouldn’twaittotouchher.Ifsheletme.Ididn’twanttoplaygameswithher.I
couldn’twaittoseeherlipstremblingasItouchedher.Icouldn’twaittobewithher.Ijusthopedshe
feltthesamewayandthatshecouldn’twaittobewithme.IwashopingIhadbeenonhermindas
muchasshe’dbeenonmine.
Iopenedthedoorandremovedthesmilefrommyface.Ididn’twanthertothinkIwastooeager.I
didn’twanthertothinkI’dbeencountingdownthehourstothismoment;thatI’dbeenanxioustosee
heragain.Ididn’twanthertothinkIcaredasmuchasIdid.Therewasnothinggoodthatwouldcome
ofthat.
“Hello,Jess,”Isaid,takinginherappearanceeagerly.Herhairhunglongdownpasther
shouldersandshewaswearingapairofshort-shortsandatighttanktopthattoldmesecretsofher
bodythatIwantedtoremember—oh,howIwantedtoremember.
“Hi.”Shedidn’tsmileasshelookedatmeandIcouldtellshewaspissedoff.
“Wanttocomein?”
“That’swhyI’mhere.”SherolledhereyesatmeandallIwantedtodowaspullherinforakiss.
“Then,comein.”Iwalkedawayfromthedoor.Iwasn’tgoingtomakethiseasieronher.
“Whatareyouherefor?”
“I’mheretocollectmystuff,”shesaidstiffly.
“Yourstuff?”Iraisedaneyebrowather.“Whatstuff?Yoursextoys?”
“Mywhat?”Sheglaredatme.
“WasInotloudenough?”Ispokeuplouder.“Isaidyoursextoys?”
“Idon’thaveanysextoys,”shesaidindignantly.
“Atallorjusthere?”Isaidwithalaugh.“Youshouldreallyhaveadildoathomeforthelonely
nights.”
“You’reajerk.”Shegasped,andIlaughed.
“Original.”Iheadedtowardsthekitchen.“Wantadrink?”
“No.”Shedidn’tfollowbehindme.
“Wantsomethingtoeat?”Isaid.
“No.”
“Wantaquickfuck?”
“No,”shescreeched.
“Wantalongfuck,then?”
“No,ohmygod,you’resuchapervert.”Shesoundedexacerbated,andthistimeIdidturnaround
andlookather.
“Really?You’rethatshocked?”Ilookedatherbody.“Isn’tthatwhyyoucameoverthis
afternoon?”
“Excuseme?”Sheglaredatme.
“Youwantedanotherpieceofme.”
“Iwantnopieceofyou,”shesaid,herlipsquivering,andIalmostlaughed.Itwassoobviousto
methatshewantedmeasbadlyasIwantedherbutIwasgoingtokeepplayingthisgamewithher.
Thatwouldteachhertoleavemewantingforthreedays.Threedaysindeed.Didn’tsherealizeIhad
needs?Didn’tsherealizeshewasluckyenoughtohavegottenanightwithme?Thatwasn’t
somethingthathappenedtoalotofwomenandsheshouldbethankfulforthat.I’dhavetoteachhera
lesson.I’dhavetoteachheralessonshewouldn’tforget.
“You’realiar,”Isaidwithasmirk.
“You’restillanass.”
“Anassyouenjoyedtheothernight.”
“Isthatallyouthinkabout?”
“Doyouthinkaboutanythingelse?”Iaskedherandleanedovertowhisperintoherear.
“Haveyouthoughtaboutanythingelsesincethatnight?”
“Whatareyoutalkingabout?”Shetriedtotakeastepback,butIgrabbedaholdofherarmand
pulledherclosertome.
“Haveyouthoughtaboutanythingotherthanmebeinginsideofyou,makingyoumine?”
“You’reapervert.”
“Isn’tthatwhatyoulikedsomuchaboutme?”Ilaughed.“Didn’tyoulikemypervertedself
slidingupinsideofyou,whileyourfingernailsdugintomyshouldersandback?Didn’tyouenjoy
thewayImadeyouscreamandcome?Isn’tthatwhyyoucameback?”
“Icamebackformydressandmycardigan.”Shegasped,herbreathcomingquicklynow.“Idon’t
wantyou.You’resofullofyourself.”
“Youwantmerightnow.Youwanttorideme,andIthinkI’mgoingtoletyoudoit.”
“No,Idon’t.”HereyeswidenedandIlaughedasshelickedherlipsnervously.“OrIcantakeyou
frombehind.Iseemtorememberyoulikedthataswell.Ireallyseemedtohitthespot,didn’tI?”
“Icameformydressandcardigan,”sheprotested,eyeswide.
“Liar.”Ipushedmyerectionintoher.“Youcametocome.”
“You’resuchapervert.”
“Andthat’swhatyouloveaboutme.”
“Idon’tloveanythingaboutyou,”sheprotested.“Allyoucareaboutissex.”
“That’snottrue.”
“You’veneveraskedmeoutonadate.”
“Youwanttogoonadate?”Ileanedforwardandtookherlowerlipinmymouth.“Thatcanbe
arranged.”
“Idon’twanttogoonadate.I’mjustsayingthatyou’renotastandupguy.Youhaven’tevenasked
meonadate,yetyoulovetotalkaboutsexallthetime.Ithinkyou’redisgusting.”
“YouthinkI’mdisgusting?”
“Yes.”
“Uhhuh.”Isteppedbackandhadagrinatherbereftexpression.“Okaythen,let’sfindyourdress
andcardiganandthenyoucanleave.”
“What?”Shefrownedinconfusion.
“Idon’twantyoutothinkI’mheretokeepyouagainstyourwill.”Ishrugged.“Obviously,Iread
thesignsincorrectly.Let’sgetyourstuffandthenyoucango.”
“Oh,okay.”Shestilllookedconfused.“Uh,whataboutPierce?”
“Whatabouthim?”Isaidsoftly,waitingtoseeifshe’dcrack.
“Nothing.”Sheshookherhead.“Absolutelynothing.”Shelookedlostforafewsecondsanda
partofmefeltsorryforher.Shehadabsolutelynoideashewasplayingaroundwithamastermind.
Andhowwouldshe?ShewasoutofherleagueandthatwaspartofwhyIfoundthegamesomuch
fun.Shehadabsolutelynoideahowtokeepupwithme.
Ifeltalittlehesitationassheglancedupatmethroughherlonglashes.Apartofmefeltguilty.
MaybeIshouldn’tplaythisgamewithher.MaybeIshouldjustletitgo.Maybe,justmaybe,Ishould
letJessbetheonewhodidn’tgetcaughtupinthetrap.
Ishouldbethemanthatdidn’tletJessgetcaughtupinthetrapbut,forselfishreasons,Ididn’t
wanttobethatman.Forselfishreasons,IwantedtobethemanthatletJessgettrappedupinallofmy
tangledanddeviouswebs.IwantedtoseehowfarIcouldtakeeverything.IwonderedhowfarIcould
pushit,howfarshewaswillingtogo.IwassurprisedshehadevenbroughtPierceup.ThoughIwas
sureshewasprobablystillshockedaboutwhathadgoneon.Whowouldn’tbe?
“Sodoyouknowwhereyouleftit,then?”Iaskedher,feigningnonchalance.IfshethoughtI
wantedhertoleave,thenshewouldlikelynotwanttoleave.Thatwasthepsychologyofhowthese
thingswenteverysingletime.
“Leftwhat?”Shelookedmoreconfusedthaneverandshestartedplayingwithherhair.Iwanted
toreachoverandrunmyfingersthroughitandpullitalittle.Iwantedtowatchhereyeswidenin
surpriseandshockandmaybealittleindesire,wonderingwhatIwasgoingtodonext,butIdidn’t.A
partofmewasstartingtofeelguilty.ShewassoverynaïveandgullibleandIcouldn’tquitebelieve
she’dfallenforeverything.Icouldn’tbelieveit,yetIwashappyshewashere.Ijusthadnoideahow
muchfurtherthingswouldgoandifI’dbeokaywiththat.
“Thestuffyoucametocollect,”Isaidsoftly.“Isn’tthatwhyyou’rehere,afterall?”
“Ofcourseitis.WhyelsewouldIbehere?”
“Maybeforme?”Ilaughedassheblushed.“Maybetorideme?”
“You’resuchapervert.”
“Isn’tthatwhatmakeseverythingfun?”Iwinkedather.“Isn’tthatwhyyou’vebeenattractedtome
thiswholetime?”Istaredather,wonderingwhyandhowshedidn’tgetit.Didnothingseemoffto
her?
“Ican’tbelieveyou.”Sheshookherheadindisgustatme.“You’reahorribledadtoPierce.Ican’t
believeyouwoulddothattoyourownson.”
“Ifyou’resoconcerned,whydon’tyougoonadatewithhim,then,andmakeituptohim?”Her
wordsannoyedme.Shehadnoideawhatshewastalkingabout.Iwonderedhowshecouldjusttake
everythingatfacevalue.Didn’tshequestionanything?Iwantedtotellhertojustslowdownandthink
abouteverythingproperly.Iwantedtotellherthatsheshouldhavemorefaithinme.Thatmaybe
Piercewasn’tthegoodguyshethoughthewas.IwantedtotellherthatIthoughtmaybebothofushad
beenplayed,butIknewitdidn’tmatter.Itdidn’tmatterbecauseIknewthetruth,thewholetruth,the
fulltruth,thesickeningtruth.Andwhile,inthebeginning,ithadseemedlikeharmlessfun,itwas
startingtomakemefeelguilty.AndthatwasafeelingIdidn’tunderstandorwanttounderstand.I
didn’twanttodevelopaconscience,notnow.Notwheneverythingwassoupintheairandso
complicated.Thiswasmeanttobefun.Ithadalwaysbeenfun.Icouldn’tletthatchangenow.
“MaybeIwill.MaybeI’lljuststickwithhim.Heseemslikehe’sabetterguythanyou.”
“Youthink?”SomethinginmystomachgrowledandIcouldfeelmyselfgrowingangry.Didshe
reallythinkthat?AndwhatdidIcareifshedid?Ishouldhaveknownfromthebeginningthatthiswas
goingtobeoverlycomplicated.Ijustshouldhaveknown.
“Well,it’snotlikeyoutoldmeanything.Orexplained.Ortriedtocallme.Ortext.Oranything.”
ShepursedherlipsandIcouldseeshewasupset.“Butwhatever,itdoesn’tmatter.”
“Okaythen,”Iresponded,notreallysurewhattosay.Orhowtofeel.
“Okaythen?That’sallyouhavetosay?”
“Idon’tknowwhatyouwantmetosay.”Ijustwantedtotouchandkissher.Ididn’twanttothink
aboutanythingelse.
“Typical.”Herbrowneyeslookedsad,andIfeltsomethinginsideofmecringing.I’dhurther.I
didn’twanttohurther.Ididn’twanttofeellikeIwasresponsibleformakingherfeelbad.
“Whatdoyouwanttotalkabout?”Iaskedher,thoughmyinsideswererebellingagainstthe
words.Ididn’twanttotalkaboutanythingtoodeep.
“Nothing.”Shebitdownonherlowerlip.“It’sobvioustomethatyoudon’tcare,sowhyshould
I?”
“Stopplayingthesegames.Ifyouwanttotalkaboutsomething,justtellme.Idon’thavetimefor
this.”
“Whatdoyouhavetimefor,Evan?”shesnappedandhereyesflashedatme.
“Somelovemaking.”Iwinkedather,hopingtomakeherlaugh,butshejustshookherhead.
“You’reanasshole.”
“Youwantmetodowhatwithyourasshole?”MyeyeswidenedasIcrackedajokeandshejust
lookedatmeandrolledhereyes.
“Ican’tbelieveyou’reanyone’sdad,”shesaid,shakingherhead,andIwantedtorespondwith,
well,whydoyouthen?butIkeptmymouthshut.“Stillnoresponse?”Shelookedannoyed.“Allyou
doiscrackjokesormakecommentariesaboutsex.Doyouhavenofeelings?”
“Whatdoyouwantfromme,Jess?”Iaskedherquietly,suddenlyfeelingoverwhelmedandsadat
thesituation.Andratherconfused.Ijustdidn’tknowwhattothinkorfeelanymoreandIhatedfeeling
likeIwasinthispositionofpowerlessnessandoutofcontrol.AndIwasstartingtofeellikeajerk.
AndIneverfeltlikeajerk.It’saweirdfeelingtohavethewindknockedoutofyou.Andthat’swhat
thatmomentdidtome.Itmademethinkandlookateverythingdifferently.Itmademelookat
everythingthroughJess’seyes.Ifevenforafewbriefseconds.Andthatstrucksomethinginme.
SomethingIdidn’twanttoacknowledge.
“Idon’twantanything.Ibarelyknowyou.”Sheshruggedandlookedaway.“MaybeIshouldjust
go.”Shesteppedtowardsthedoor,andIcouldfeelmyselfpanicking.
“Okay,go,”Isaid,hatingmyselfforbeingsocruel,wonderingwhatwaswrongwithme.Maybe
nothing.Maybeeverything.Ididn’treallywanttothinkaboutit.
“Youjustdon’tcare,doyou?”Shesoundedexasperated,andasIstaredatherfaceIcouldseeshe
wasn’tgoingtostartlaughingandtellmethatshewasn’treallyupset.Ididn’treallyknowwhatshe
wantedfromme,whatshecouldpossiblybeexpecting.Itmadenosensetome.Howcouldshewant
somethingmorethanwhatwasrealistic?
“Idon’treallyknowwhatyouwantmetosay.”
“Justsayanything.”
“IfIhadsomethingtosay,Iwouldsayit.”Isighedandthentookadeepbreath.“Look,Jess,I
didn’tmeantohurtyou.Ididn’tmeantomakeyoufeelbad.I’msorryabouthoweverythinghasgone
down.”
“Areyou?Areyoureally?”
“Yes,Iam.”Itookadeepbreath.“MaybeIcantakeyoutolunchorsomething.Getyoutoforgive
meforbeinganass.”
“Youwanttotakemetolunch?”ShelookedupatmeandIsworeIcouldseeeagernessinher
eyes.Iwasn’tsureifI’dmadeamistake.Maybethiswasn’tagoodidea.Itwasdeviatingfromthe
plan.Ididn’twanttogiveherafalseexpectationofwhatwasgoingtohappennext.Ididn’twantto
givemyselfafalseexpectationeither.Thiswasn’tgoingtogoanywhere.Notleastbecauseshehadno
clueexactlywhatwasgoingonandwhensheknewthefulltruthaboutthesituation,Iwasprettysure
shewouldnevertalktomeagain.AdullthudpoundedinmyheartasIthoughtaboutherhatingme
morethanshehatedmenow.
“Ifyou’llletme.”Ismiledathergently.“Wehadfuntheothernight.Ithoughtwewerestartingto
geton.Ithoughtwehadaconnection.Ididn’trealizewe’dleftthingssopoorly.Ididn’trealizethat
thenexttimeIsawyou,itwouldbethisawkward.I’msorry.”
“Youdidn’tcall.Youdidn’ttext.”
“Neitherdidyou,”Isaidsimply.
“But…”Shesighed.“Idon’tknowwhattosay.”
“Justsayyou’llgotolunchwithme.”
“Fine.I’llgo.”
“Doyouwanttogo?”Iaskedherwithasmallsmile.
“Yes.”Shenoddedandlookedmedirectlyintheeyes.“MaybeI’mcrazy,butyes,yesIdo.”
“Good.”Iwalkedovertoher,grabbedherarmsandpulledhertowardsme.“MaybeI’mcrazy
too.”
“Whydoyousaythat?”sheaskedasshelookedupintomyeyes,herlashesbattinginnocentlyas
shestaredatme,searchingforanswerstoquestionsshewasn’tasking.
“Becausethiswholesituationjustfeelslikeadream.”
“Itdoes,doesn’tit?”ShelaughedandIcouldn’tstopmyselffromleaningdowntokissherhard.
HerlipsweresoftandsweetbeneathmineandIbreathedinheressence.Oh,howI’dmissedherinthe
lastfewdays.ItscaredmethatI’dmissedher.ItscaredmethatIcared,evenalittlebit.Ididn’twantto
care.Notatall.EverythingwasgoingtoshitandIhadnoideawhatIwasgoingtodo.Noideaatall.
P
ART
2
Evan
There’ssomethingyoushouldknow.SomethingIshouldtellyou,lestyouhatemeforever.I’m
notPierce’sdad.Iknow,Iknow,whatthehellamIsaying?HowcouldInotbePierce’sdad,after
everythingthat’sgonedown?YoumightevenbethinkingI’mabiggerjerkthanyou’dpreviously
thought.Thoughthatmightnotbehard.I’mnotgoingtomakeapunabouthowhardIcanget.That
wouldn’tbeappropriateandyoudon’tknowmewellenoughforthatyet.
SoletmegobacktowhatIwassaying.I’mnotPierce’sdad.Iknow,yourmindisallflummoxed.
AndIknowyou’rethinkingwhatthehellisgoingonhere?Maybeyou’renotthinkingthat.Maybe
youdon’tswearorthinkthingslikehell.Ifyou’reoneofthoseperfectpeople,thencongrats.I’m
prettyconfidentI’llneverchangeyourmindintothinkingI’manalrightsortofguymostofthetime.
Totherestofyou,theoneswhoarehuman,andnotperfect,letmepleadmycasebeforewecontinue
withthestory.Ineedtopleadmycasenow,becauseIdon’twantyoutohateme.Idon’twantyouto
thinkI’mnotgoodenoughforJess.EventhoughI’mnotreallygoodenough.
PierceandIarefratbrothers.I’molderthanhim.Byagoodsevenyears.Iwashishousebrother
whenhewasinthefrathouse.I’dbeenworkingonmyPhDandtookthejobsoIcouldhaveafree
placetolive.Ourfratwascrazy,asaremostfrats,andwewereimmature,asaremostguysin
college.Okay,weweremaybemoreimmatureandweneverreallygrewoutofthatmentality.Pierce
andIandacoupleotherbrothersusedtoplayagamewherewewouldgotoaclub,seeagirl,and
guesswhowethoughtshe’dhookupwith,orwhenwecouldgetherinbed,orwhatlieswecould
convinceherweretrue.LikeIsaid,wewereimmatureanddumb.Andstillare.Ouranticshavegrown
bolderovertheyearsandI’mashamedtosay,we’vepulledsomereallyshadyshit.LikewithJess.
Piercehasthisthingwherehethinkshecangetanygirl.IhavethisthingwhereIthinkIcangetany
girlthatPiercethinkshecanget.Sowemadeabet.Andtomakeitmoreinterestingwedecidedto
twistitup.Wedecidedtopickagirlwethoughtlookedlikemoreofaninnocent,sothatitwouldn’t
beinhernaturetojust‘cheat’orflirtwithme.AndthenPiercehadthecrazyideathatweshould
pretendIwashisbrotherorhisdad.Wejokinglydecidedupondad,becauseIhavegreyhair,butI
neverinabillionyearswouldhavethoughtanyonewouldhaveboughtthatstory.Imean,itstill
bogglesmymindthatJessactuallythinksI’mPierce’sdad.
Sohere’sthepartwhereIshouldtellyouwhyI’mexplainingeverythingtoyounow.I’mina
quandary.IlikeJess.AndI’mstartingtothinkPierceisanasshole.Imean,we’rebothassholes,but
I’mstartingtothinkPiercewasdeliberatelyplayingwithJess’sfeelingstogetanothergirljealous.
And,well,thatpissesmeoff.Okay,IknowIhavenoreasontobepissedoff.Ihavenoreasontofeel
likeI’mbetterthanPierce.Webothgotintothisshittogether.I’mtheonewhoplayedher.I’mtheone
whoteasedandtormentedherwhenshewascomingoverforPierce.IknowI’mnotthegoodguy
here.IknowI’vedoneandsaidthingsIshouldn’thave.ThingsIcan’ttakeback.Yet,Idofeelbad
aboutmyactions.Idofeelbadaboutthelies.Youshouldknowthat.YoushouldknowifIhadtodoit
allagain,I’dhavedonealotofthingsdifferently.IwishIcouldtellyouthatIwasagoodguy,thatI
owneduptomymistakesrightaway.ThatItriedtomakethingsbetter.ThatIdidn’thurtJess.
Unfortunately,Ican’tsaythat.However,youshouldknowbeforewegoanyfurtherthatIdohave
feelingsforJess.IdidhavefeelingsforJess,evenbeforeeverythingwentdown.It’strueIdidn’t
knowexactlywhatthefeelingsmeant.It’strueIwascaughtupinthegame.Iwasn’tthebestguy.A
partofmelikedplayingwithher.Apartofmeenjoyedthebackandforth.Itmadeeverythingreally
exciting.I’dneverhadarelationshipwithsomeonelikeIhadwithJess.Thedynamicwas
exhilarating:shehadthespecialblendofbeingnaïve,sexy,andwinsome.Ijustcouldn’tquitefollow
herandIenjoyedthatchallenge.Ienjoyednotknowingexactlywhatshewasthinking,yetseeingin
hereyesthatshewasfeelingsomethingspecial.IwantedtoletyouknowI’mnotabadguy,nomatter
whatyoumightthink.Iwantedtoletyouknowbeforewecontinued.Iknowmywordsmightnotbe
enoughtomakeyouthinkbetterofme.Iknowmywordsmightnotmakeyoulikeme,butIhaveto
try.Ihavetohavesomeoneinmycorner.AndIfeeltheneedtohaveyouknowthetruthbeforeI
continue.YouneedtoknowwhereI’mcomingfrom.ButIdigress,intheendnothingreallymatters
asidefromwhatJessthinks.AndwhatJesswants.AndwhatJessfeels.Andthat’sanyone’sguess.I
mayhavereallyandtrulyfuckeditallup.AndIdon’tknowifIcanlivewithmyselfifthat’swhat’s
happened.
E
C H A P T E R 1 8
van
“Y
OU
’
RE
GOING
outwithJess?”Pierce’seyesnarrowedashegazedatmewithafrown.“Why?”
“IthoughtIwouldtakeheroutforlunch.Seehowshe’sdoing?”
“Why?”Hesoundedconfused.“Ijustdon’tunderstandwhy.”
“IthoughtIshouldgettoknowher,aftereverythingthat’shappened.”
“Doyouthinkthat’sagoodidea?”
“Idon’tthinkit’sabadidea.”
“Evan…”Hislipsthinned.“Wecan’tchangetheplannow.Don’tbeanidiot.”
“Thisdoesn’tseemright.”Ipursedmylips.“She’snotliketheothers.”
“SoyouthinkweshouldhavegonewithAlyssa?”
“Ithinkweshouldn’thavedoneit.”Iwasn’tsurewhyallofasuddenIfeltbadaboutourplan.
We’dpickedupgirlsatbarsbeforeandI’dneverhadthesesameconcerns,butsomehowitfelt
differentwithJess.Itfeltnastier,meanerinaway.
“Dude,it’sjustforfun.It’snotlikewe’vedoneanythingtrulywrong.”Piercegavemealookthat
showedthathethoughtIwasbeinganidiot.
“Pierce,”Isaidwithasigh,“itdoesn’tseemright.”Ipursedmylipsandstoppedmyselffrom
continuing.IwasthelastpersontobepreachingtoPierce.EspeciallysinceIhadbeentheonewho
hadintroducedhimtothegamesincollege.I’dbeentheonewhohadoriginallycomeupwithallthe
crazywaystotrickwomenand‘testthem’.
“Evan,sincewhenhaveyoucaredaboutwhat’sright?”
“We’renotincollegeanymore.”Isighed,notsurehowtoexplainwhatIwasthinkingandgoing
throughinside.Ididn’tevenreallyknowmyself.
“Wewereneverincollegeatthesametime.”Isighedagain.“Thisisashitshow.”
“Imean,she’stheonewhobelievesyou’remydad.She’stheonewhohookedupwithyou.She’s
theonewhoisstillgoingtogoonadatewithyou.”
“Wehaven’tbeenfairtoher.”Iknewmywordssoundedweak.
“Dude,whocares?”Piercegavemealook.AndIshruggedandshookmyhead.WhywasI
bothering?IknewPiercedidn’tcare.Andwhyshouldhe?Thiswasjustagametohim.Justlikeithad
alwaysbeenagametomeaswell.
“Who’stheredhead?”Ichangedthesubject.“Seemstomethatyouhaven’tbeencompletely
honestyourself.Seemstomethatyoumighthavehadulteriormotivesyourself.”
“Idon’thaveanyulteriormotives.”Heblinkedatme.“Dude,thishasbeenatraditionforSigmas
foryears.We’rejustcontinuingthetradition.”
“Aren’twetoooldforthis?”
“Maybeyouare.”
“I’mnotthatmucholderthanyou,Pierce.”Irolledmyeyesathim.
“Jessthinksyou’reoldenoughtobemydad.”Hestartedlaughing.“Ihonestlyneverthought
she’dbelievethat.”
“IguessIlookgoodformyage.”Igrinnedathimandthenshookmyhead.“Wesuck.Youknow
that,right?Wereallysuck.”
“Nah,yousuckalotmorethanme.”PierceshookhisheadatmeandbentdowntostrokeSquirrel
betweentheears.“You’retheonewhotookher.”
“Tookher?”
“Sleptwithher.”Heputahanduptohigh-fivemeandIignoredhim.“I’mshockedshedecidedon
youoverme.”
“Dude,whatdidyouthinkafteryouinvitedhertoeatEthiopianfood,like,tentimesinarow,
knowingshehatedit?”
“Allpartoftheplan,right?Howmuchwouldshetake?Whatwouldshedo?”
“Yeah,Isuppose.Justseemswrong.”
“Imean,webothknowit’snotlikesheremainedforme.Shewasn’tstickingaroundforme,she
wasstickingaroundforyou.Thatshouldmakeyoufeelgood.”Hemadeaface.“Everydinnershe
couldbarelykeephereyesoffofyou.I’mnotsurewhoshethoughtshewasfooling.”
“Itdoesn’tmakemefeelgoodthatwe’vebeenlyingtothisgirl.AndIfeellikeyoutriedtomake
herfeellikeyoureallycaredaboutherandIfeellikeyouwerejustusinghertomakethatredhead
jealous.”
“WouldIdothat?”Piercelaughed.
“Yes.”Isighed,annoyed.“That’swrong.”
“I’mnotanymorewrongthanyouare,dude.Ifanything,youweremorefuckedupthanme.
You’retheonewhoactuallybaggedher.”
“Enough.”Isighedagain.“IjustwantedyoutoknowthatI’mgoingtobetakinghertolunchina
fewdays.”
“Andthepointofthisis?”Hisexpressionchangedandhelookedannoyed.“Whatareyouhoping
isgoingtohappen?”
“Ijustwanttomakesureshefeelsbetterabouteverythinggoingforward.Idon’twanthertofeel
used.”
“Uhhuh.Sure.That’swhatyouwant.”
“ThatiswhatIwant.”
Ididn’tnormallytryandmakeitbetterwiththewomenPierceandItricked.Iftrickedwasthe
rightword.Ididn’tknowwhyIwasmessingwithournormalprogram.Maybebecausethistime,it
didn’tseemright.Jesswasn’tliketheothergirls.Sheseemedlikedshewasreallyinvestedinme.
Muchmoreinvestedthananyoneelsehadbeen.Shehadbeenreallyupset.Reallysad.Really
emotional.Ihadabadfeelingshewasreallyfallingforme.AndthatwassomethingIdidn’twantto
happen.Somethingthatwouldmakeeverythingalotmorecomplicated.Asifitwasn’talready.I
shouldhaveknownfromthemomentshe’denteredtheapartmentthatdayandhadgivenmetitfortat
thatshewasdifferent.I’mnotsurewhyI’dsleptwithher.I’mnotsurewhyI’dgonealongwiththe
wholefarce.PierceandIweretoooldforthisshitnow.Istillcouldn’tquitebelieveshe’dbelieved
thatwewererelated.Wedidn’tevenlookalike.AndIwasnowhereoldenoughtobePierce’sdad.I
wasonlysevenyearsolderthanhim.GrantedIhadafewgreyhairs,butdamn.Whatwasshe
thinking?Ijusthadnoclue.Itwasalmosttooeasy.Liketakingcandyfromachild.Orrather,like
givingcandytoachildinaparkandleadingthemoffintoavan.That’swhatitmademefeellike:
dirty,manipulativeandevil.Ihatedfeelingthisway.I’dneverfeltthiswaybefore.Idon’tknowifthis
meantIwasgrowingaconsciencethatI’dneverhadbefore.Idon’tknowifthismeantIwas
becomingamanwithfeelings.Thatmademecringe.Iwantedneitherofthosethings.
“What’reyougoingtodoifsheasksaboutLinda?”
“Whatdoyoumean?”Iblinkedathim.
“I’mnothiringheragain.”Pierceshookhishead.“Thatshitcostmefivehundredbucks.”
“Fivehundred?”Iwasshockedhe’dpaidthatmuchjusttohaveafakemomattheparty.
“Shechargedmeextraforsleepingover.Eventhoughtherewasnosex.”
“You’retheonewhowantedtohiresomeonetoplaytheroleofyourmom.”
“Dude,itwasclassic.”Piercestartedlaughing.“IjustwishIcouldhaveseenJess’sfacewhenshe
heardthatLindawasyourex-wifeandIwasyourson.”
“Ididn’tgettoseeiteither.”Ishookmyhead,thoughIhadasmallsmirkonmyface.“Itwould
havebeenpriceless,I’msure.”
“Youknowit.Shit,weshouldhavehadavideocamera.”
“Thatshitwould’vebeensuperinvasive.”Ishookmyhead.“Ineverwould’veagreedtothat.”Ilet
outahugesighandstaredatPierceandthehugesmileonhisface.Itmademefeelsadanddepressed.
HadIreallybeenasbadashim?
“StopactinglikethePope,dude.”Piercesoundedannoyed.“Yougotthegoodies.Justmoveon.
Why’reyoudealingwiththischickanymore?”
“Pierce,”Isnappedathim,“enough.I’mnotgoingtoexplainmyselftoyouanymore.I’mjust
tellingyouthatI’mtakingJessoutandI’mgoingtotryandmakethisright.Whatwedidwaswrong.”
“Waawaa.”Piercerolledhiseyes.“Whatever,dude.Thatmusthavebeensomegoodpussy.”
“You’reapig,”Igrowled.
“Yeah,Imightbe,butthensoareyou,daaaad.”HestartedlaughingandIjustwalkedawayfrom
him,knowingIwasnevergoingtogetthroughtohim.Ididn’tevenknowwhyIwasevenbothering.
Ididn’tknowwhereJessandIweregoingtogofromhereandIdidn’tthinkIcouldevertellher
therealtruth.Ididn’tthinkshe’deverforgivemeforhavingtrickedherthisbadly.
“S
O
THIS
IS
A
NICE
PLACE
,right?”Iaskedherwithasmallsmileaswesatdownatourcosycornertable,
thecandlelightmakingeverythingseemalotmoreromanticthanI’danticipated.
“Yeah,it’sverynice.”Jessadjustedhertightreddressasshesatdownandlookedupatmewith
beguilingeyes.“Ithoughtyouwantedtodolunchandnotdinner?”
“Well,youknow.Thisseemedtoworkoutbetter,”Isaidsmoothly,notwantingtobeexplicitthatI
thoughtIhadabetterchanceofgettingherbacktomybedifwediddinner.NotthatIwasallabout
sex,butlet’sbereal.I’mstillaman.
“Ifyousayso.”Shelaughedandlickedherlipsnervously.“Youjustwanttotakemetobed
again.”
“Wouldthatbesuchabadthing?”Igrinnedather,gladshewasn’tnaïveenoughtonotknowthat.
Andgladshewasboldenoughtocallmeoutforit.
“Idon’tknow.”Shestaredatme.“Alyssa,myroommate,wouldthinkso.”
“IknowwhoAlyssais,butwhywouldshethinkthat?”Iraisedaneyebrowather.“Shedoesn’t
likeme?”
“Shethinksthiswholesituationissuperweird.”
“It’snotsuperweird,”Ilied,wonderingwhatAlyssawouldthinkifsheknewtherealtruth.She’d
probablykidnapJessandneverletherseemeagain.
“Yes,itis.”Shesighedandshuffledaroundinherseat.“Itissuperduperweird.Idon’tevenknow
whyIagreedtocomewithyoutonight.Imustbecrazy.”
“Didn’tweagreethatwe’rebothcrazytogether?”
“Yeah,butIthinkI’mcrazier.”
“Yousaidthat,notme,rememberthat.”Igrinnedather,happytobeherewithherandtoputmy
talkwithPiercetotheside.Ididn’twanttothinkaboutanythingelse,otherthanthismoment.Ijust
wantedtoenjoywhatwehadandliveforthefunwecouldhavenow.Imean,apartofmewishedI
couldtellJessthetruth.Tellhereverythingthathadhappenedfromthebeginning.Explaintoherthat
I’dbeenplayingthesegamesforalongtime.TellherthatIusedtobeastupidimmaturefratguy.
ThatmyfratbrothersandIhadplayedstupidgamesformany,manyyearsandwe’dneverreallyseen
aproblemwithit.Ijustneverthoughtitwasaproblem.Neverhadaguiltyconscienceaboutitbefore.
Butnow,noweverythingfeltdifferent.Everythingfeltsomuchmoretwisted.HowcouldItellher
thatI’dbeenintheclubthatnight?HowcouldItellherthatI’dbeenwithPiercewhenhe’dselected
hertobethegirlhewentovertothatnight?HowcouldItellherthatI’dtoldhimtogoforAlyssa,
buthe’dthoughtJesswouldbemoreofachallenge?HowcouldItellallofthetwistedtruthaboutthe
gameswe’dbeenplayingwithher?Ijustdidn’tknow.Ijustdidn’tknowwhattosay.HowcouldIbe
honestabouteverything?She’dnevertalktome.AndIguessIdidn’treallydeserveforhertotalkto
me.Imean,whatwe’ddonewashorrible.Irealizedthatnow.MaybethebestthingIcoulddoforher
andformewastogethertostoplikingme.MaybeIneededtostopbeingsoselfish.Iwantedto
continuetoseeher,howbadlyIwantedtoseeherandtalktoherandwatchhersmilingandlistento
herlaughing.HowbadlyIwantedtokissherandholdherclosetome.HowbadlyIwantedtotakeher
tomybed.Only,thistime,IwantedittobesoftandgentleandthenroughandhardandIwantedto
makeherscream.Iwantedtohearherpanting,cryingoutmyname.Iwantedtomakeherbegmeto
keepgoingallnightlong.Iwantedforeverythingtobeperfect.Onlyitwasnevergoingtobeperfect.
Andifitwas,itwouldneverlast.Itwouldneverlastbecausetherewerealreadytoomanylies.So
maybeitwasbetterformetojustgethertohateme.Iknewshewasfallingforme.IknewIwas
fallingforher.ButI’dalreadygoneandfuckeditup.I’dalreadygoneandmadethingsshitty.This
wasnofairytalebeginningandtherewouldcertainlybenofairytaleending.IfIreallycaredforher,
I’dbeanasstokeepthischaradegoing.IfIreallycaredforher,thebestthingIcoulddowouldbeto
gethertohateme.I’dgethertonotwanttobewithme.Itwasn’tfairtoherforhertofalldeeperfor
meandIwasn’tsureitwasfairformetodumpher,either.Itjustdidn’tseemright.Itshouldbeher
decision.Thatwouldempowerher.Thatwouldallowhertomoveonwithoutfeelingliketherewas
somethingwrongwithher.
“You’resupposedtosaythatI’mnotcrazy,”shesaidandlaughed,hereyeslightingupasshe
gazedatmealmostadoringly.IknewIwasoverreacting,butsomethingaboutherglancemademe
panic.Shewasalreadyinfartoodeep.Icouldalreadytellshehadfeelings.Ididn’twanthertohave
feelings.Ididn’twanttobreakherheart.Ididn’twanttoberesponsibleforthat.
“You’renotcrazy.”Ismiledatherandthen,becauseIdidn’tknowwhatelsetodo,Ilooked
around.IwatchedastwowomenwalkedpastusandIsmiledwidelyattheblonde,whowasshaking
herhipsbackandforthandgivingmeawinningsmile.Iwinkedatherandsheplayedwithherhair
andthenIturnedbacktoJess,whowaslookingatmewithanuncertainsmileandaslightlyjealous
glare.“Atleastthat’swhatIhavetosay,right?”
“Whatever.”ShelookedawayfrommeandwhileIfeltlikeshit,IknewIwasdoingtheright
thing.IfshewantedtothinkIwasapigandblatantenoughtostareatotherwomen,maybeshe’dfall
outoflustwithme.Orwhateveritwasshewasthinkingandfeeling.Ididn’tknow.Ididn’tcare.I
didn’twanttoknow.Infact,Ididn’tevenwanttobeinthisposition.HowhadIfuckedthisupso
royally?
“It’sbeenawhilesinceI’vefeltthiswayaboutsomeone,”Isaidsoftly,andlookedatJess,
wonderingwhatshewasthinking,wantinghertohateme,butnotreallywantingherto.Itwasareally
complicatedsituationandIwasn’tsurehowtonavigateit.
“Uhhuh.”Jessgavemeaglance.“Ifeellikethat’ssomethingyousaytoeveryone.”
“Everyone?”Iraisedaneyebrowather.“Really?”
“HowamIsupposedtoknow?”Sheglaredatme.“Idon’treallyknowyou,doI?”
“Whatdoyouwanttoknow?”Ileanedforward.“Youcanaskmeanything.”
“Likewhydidn’tyoutellmethatyouwerePierce’sdad?”Sherolledhereyes.“Orthatyou’ve
beenlyingtomeforalongtimeandplayingme.”
“Iwasn’tplayingyou.Whatwouldyouhavedoneifyouwereme,Jess?HowwasIgoingtobring
thatup?”
“Youshouldn’thaveflirtedwithmeandwhenyousawIwasreciprocatingyoushouldhavetold
methetruth.”
“Wouldyouhavestillwantedtogettoknowmeifyouwould’veknownthetruth?”Iaskedsoftly.
“Like,really?Wouldyouhavewantedtoknow?”
“WhatcanIsay?”Shesighed.“Yes,no,Idon’tknow.Ijustfeellikehonestyisthebestpolicy.”
“Iagreeit’sthebestpolicy.”Isighedtooandwonderedifthiswasthetimeformetocomeout
withthefulltruthabouteverything.Wouldshereallywanttoknowthetruth?Wouldsheevertalkto
meagain?Wouldshebeforgiving?Ialreadyknewtheanswertothat.Iknewshewouldn’twantto
haveanythingtodowithmeifsheknew.Andthatmademefeelsicktomystomach.Iknewthiswould
beit.AndIjustcouldn’thavethat.Notyet.Notnow.Icouldn’tdealwithlosingher.NotwhenI’d
barelyhadher.Iknewitwasselfishofmeanditwasn’tfairanditdidn’tmakesense.
“Whydidyouinvitemetothisdinner?”Shelookedatmeexpectantly,andIwasn’treallysure
whattosay.
“I’mnotreallysure,”Iansweredhonestly.“Iwantedtoseeyou,Isuppose.Iwantedtomakesure
youwereokay.”
“Isupposethat’sniceofyou.”Shemadeafaceandwejuststaredateachotherforafewmoments,
bothofuswonderingexactlywhatweweredoingthere.Iknewthatthatwasn’ttheanswershewanted
tohear.Iknewthatbothofusreallydidn’tknowwhatweweredoingthere,whatwewantedto
happen,whatwethoughtcouldhappen.AndatthatpointIdidn’tcare.AtthatpointallIwantedwas
anotheropportunitytogetherintomybed.
“Yeah,everyoneknowsI’maniceguy,”Isaidwithasmalllaughandthenreachedunderthetable
andranmyhandupherleganddidn’tstopuntilIreachedthetopofherthigh.Isawhereyes
wideningasIranmyfingersdownthemiddleofherlegsandshegaspedasIrubbedgently.
“Wouldn’tyouagree?”Isaidwithawinkandlickedmylipsslowlyasshegazedatmewithdesirein
hereyesandshemovedherbodybackandforthslowly.
“W
HERE
ARE
WE
GOING
?”Jessgiggledtipsilyaswewalkedoutoftherestaurant,feelinglighthearted
fromcopiousamountsofwineandgoodfood.
“It’sasurprise.”
“Asurprise,huh?”Sheturnedherheadtolookatmeandgavemeasweetsmile.Therewasa
sparkleinhereyesthatmademesmilebackwidelyatherandIwonderedwhatIwasdoing.Wasn’tI
supposedtobeturningheroffofme?Notmakingherfallformeharder.
“Yes,asurprise.Don’tyoulikesurprises?”
“Ilovesurprises,”shesaidagainandshereachedoverandgrabbedmyhandbeforepullingit
awayquickly.“Oops,sorry.”
“Don’tbesorry,”Isaid,myheartthudding.Ihadn’theldhandswithagirlinyearsanditmademe
feeluncomfortable.“Come,let’scrossthestreetbeforethelightschange,”Isaidandstartedjogging
acrossthestreet.Iwatchedassheraninherheelsslightlyclumsilyandshegaspedwhenshemetme
overontheotherside.
“Wecould’vewaitedforthelightstochangeagain,”shesaidasshestaredatme,andIlooked
downatherlegsforafewsecondsbeforeresponding.
“Wecouldhave,butwedidn’t,”Isaidwithasmallsmile.“Now,comeon,let’sgo.”
“Idon’tevenknowwherewe’regoing,”shesaid,pursingherlipsandmumblingsomething
underherbreath.
“Whatareyoumumbling?”Iaskedher,andsheshookherhead.
“Nothing.”
“Uhhuh.”Ilickedmylips.“Don’tmakemespanktheansweroutofyou.”
“Spanktheansweroutofme?”Shegavemealookandstartedlaughing.“Youwish.”
“DoIreally?”Iaskedherandstareddownatherass.
“Yes.”ShegiggledandIreachedoverandgrabbedherandpulledhertowardsmeforalong,
deepkiss.“Oh,Evan.”Shesighedasshewrappedherarmsaroundmyneck.Myhandsfelltoherass
andsqueezedslightlyandherbodymeltedintomine.Icouldfeelmyselfgrowinghardatthefeelof
herbodyagainstmineandallIwantedhertodowasliftherdressupandpullherpantiestotheside
soIcouldtakeher.Ididn’tevencarethatwewerestillinthestreet.Ididn’tcarethatitwouldbe
entirelyinappropriateofmetodoanything.Inappropriateandselfish.
“Whatareyoudoing,Evan?”ShewiggledagainstmybodyandIheldherclosertome.“Wasthis
thesurprise?”
“Doyouwantthistobethesurprise?”Iwhisperedagainstherlips,breathingherin.“Doyouwant
metotakeyourightnow?”
“We’reinthestreet.”Hereyeswidened.
“So?”Ibitdownonherlowerlip.“HowhotwoulditbeifIfuckedyourighthereandnow,
quickly,soquicklythatnoonewouldevenknow?Onlyus.”
“I’mnotanexhibitionist.”Shetriedtostepback,andIwatchedassheswallowedhard.“Iwould
neverdothat.”
“I’msuretherearemanythingsyousaidyou’dneverdobefore.”Igazedintohereyes.
“Likesleepwithmykinda-boyfriend’sdad?”
“Yeah,likethat.”Myheartdropped.Ireallydidn’twanttokeepthatliegoinganymore,butI
didn’tknowhowtoletherknowthetruth.
“Idon’twanttokeepdoingthingsIdon’tthinkIshouldbedoing.”Shelickedherlipsnervously.
“Whynot?”Myhandsslidupherwaistandtowardsherbreasts.
“Becausethat’snotwhoIam.”
“That’snotwhoIameither.”
“You’reaplayer,”shesaidsoftly.“You’replayinggameswithme.”
“You’replayinggameswithmeaswell.”
“Idon’tknowwhatwe’redoinghere.”ShesighedandIcouldseeshewasstartingtothinktoo
much.
“NeitherdoI,butmaybewedon’thavetoknow.”
“Yeah,maybewedon’thavetoknow.”Shemadeaface.“WhatamIdoing?”Shemadeamoaning
noiseandlookedupatme.“IthinkImightbecrazy.Likecertifiablycrazy.”
“Why?”
“BecauseI’mherewithyouandIhavenoideawhatwe’redoingorwhatI’mdoingandIjust
don’tknow.”Shegroanedandlickedherlipsnervouslyagain.“Idon’tevenknowwhyI’mtelling
youthis.”
“I’mgladyou’retellingme.I’mgladyou’reopenwithme,”Itoldherhonestly.
“Why?”sheasked,battinghereyelashesupatme.
“Idon’tknow.”Isighedandthenpulledaway.Ireacheddownandgrabbedherhand.“Comewith
me,though.Iwanttotakeyousomewhere.”HerhandfeltsmallandwarminmineandIheldittighter
asIledhertooneofmyfavoriteplacesinthecity.
“Wherearewegoing?”
“You’llsee,”Isaidaswewalked.WegottotheparkentranceandIsawtheconfusedlookonher
faceasIescortedherthroughthegates.
“We’regoingtothepark?”sheaskedmeasshewalkedquickly.
“Don’tyoulikefeedingducks?”Iteased.
“Whatarewegoingtofeedtheducks?”shesaidslowly.“Andaretheyevenawakerightnow?”
“Hmm,that’sagoodpoint,”Isaidwithalaugh.“Iwasgoingtofeedyoutotheducks,butmaybe
they’resleepingrightnow.”
“Youweregoingtofeedmetotheducks?”shesaidbreathlessly.
“Yeah,butIdecidedIwantedtohaveyoualltomyself.”
“Soyou’regoingtofeedmetoyourself?”shesaidslowlyandthenlaughed.“Doesthatsentence
evenmakesense?”
“Ifyou’reaskingifI’dliketoeatyou,thentheanswerisyes,andyesitmakessense.”
“Oh,”shesaidbreathlessly,andIlaughed.
“Don’tworry,that’snotwhat’sgoingtohappenrightnow,though.We’renotabouttogoandhave
orgasmsinthegrass,thoughIthinkthatwouldbeamazingfun.”
“Evan,”shegroaned.
“That’smyname.Nexttimeyousayit,you’llbescreaming.”
“Evan,”shesaidagainsoftlyandgiggled.“Sorry,notscreaming.”
“Funny.”Ilaughed.“Let’sseeifyou’llbegigglinglater.”
“Why,what’sgoingtobehappeninglater?”
“You’llsee,”Isaidandthenstoppedsuddenly.“Okay,closeyoureyesnow.”
“Closemyeyes?”Shelookedatmewithwideeyes.“Why?”
“Because…”
“Becausewhy?”
“BecauseIsaidso.”
“That’snotagoodenoughreasonformetoclosemyeyes.”
“Stopbeingdifficult,Jess.”
“I’mnotbeingdifficult.”Shemadeafaceatme.“You’rethedifficultone.TellmewhyI’m
closingmyeyesandthenI’lldecideifIwanttodoit.”
“Justtrustme.”
“WhyshouldItrustyou?”
“BecauseI’maskingyouto,quitenicelyaswell.”
“Andthat’sagoodenoughreason?”
“Ithinkso?Don’tyou?”
“You’vealreadyliedtomeonce.”Shemadeafaceatme,andIalmostlaughedatthecute
expressionshewasmaking.Iwouldhavelaughedifthetruthofthematterwasn’tthatI’dactuallylied
tohermorethanonceandthatthebiggestliewasstilloutstanding.HowcouldItellherthat?Ijust
couldn’ttellherthat.
“Jess,please?”
“Fine.Fine.Fine.”Sheputherhandsonherhipsandglaredatme.“Ifyoudumpmeinanywater,I
willscreamandnevertalktoyouagain.”
“WhywouldIdumpyouinanywater?”
“Idon’tknow.”Shepursedherlips.“ButIknowyouguys.Youalwaysdodumbthings.”
“I’vedoneplentyofdumbthingsinmylife,yes.ButIpromiseyouthatIwillnotbedumpingyou
inanywatertonight.”
“Okay,good,”shesaidandthenslowlyclosedhereyes.“Oh,myGod,”shemumbledasIgrabbed
herhandsandstartedguidingherslowly.“IhopeIwon’tregretthis.”
“Youwon’t,”IsaidandthenstartedhummingFrankSinatra’ssong,“StrangersintheNight”.Ifelt
quitecalmandhappy,andoddlyexcited.Iwasn’tsurewhy,butIwasenjoyingmyself.Iwasenjoying
beinginthismoment.Andithadnothingtodowithmysexualattractiontoher.Ithadnothingtodo
withmewantingher.ItwasjustthatIenjoyedhercompany.Shewasagirl.AndIwasaboy.Andwe
hadthisweirdconnection.Andwhileitwasdefinitelyweird,itwasuniqueandspecialandIdidn’t
wanttoquestionit.Orher.Ijustwantedtobeinthismomentandenjoymyself.Ididn’twanttothink
aboutwhatwasgoingtohappenifandwhenshefoundoutthetruth.IknewIwasgoingbackand
forthonwhatIshouldexpectfromherandhowIshouldtreather,butIcouldn’tstopmyself.WhileI
knewthebestthingforherwouldbetoforgetme,IalsoknewIdidn’twanttojustgiveherupthat
easily.Itwastoohard.Itwasn’tsomethingIwantedtodo.Ijustdidn’tknowhowtocontinueinthis
situation.Ididn’twanttobeselfishandhurther,butIalsojustcouldn’tgiveherup.Shewaslikea
drugtome.ShewassomethingIwasalreadycraving.Ineededforhertobesomepartofmylife.In
thismoment.JustuntilI’dhadenoughofher.OnceI’dhadenoughofher,thenIcouldgiveherup
andeverythingwouldbeokay.Ijustwasn’tsureifthatmeantbothofuswouldbedevastatedbythe
end.IknewIwasahorribleman.Iknewthatineveryfiberofmybeing.However,Ijustdidn’tknow
howtonotbethatman.I’dbeenhimforallofmylife.
“Youcanopenyoureyesnow,”Isaidaswereachedtheswingsthatoverlookedoneoftheponds
inthepark.
“Icanbarelysee,”shesaidassheblinkedandhereyesadjustedtothedarkness.“Oh,theswings?”
“Yeah,doyoulikeswings?”Iasked,notsurewhatshewouldthinkaboutthem.
“Yeah,swingsarefun.”Shelookedatmeandgavemeasmallsmile.“AlyssaandIactuallyliketo
goswinginglateatnightforfun.”
“Really?”Isaidwithasmallsmile.
“Yeah,it’sfun.Exhilarating.There’saswinginEcuador,whereyou’reactuallyswingingoverthe
city.We’dlovetogothereoneday.”
“IthinkI’veheardofit.”Inoddedaswegotontotheswings.
“Yeah,itlookssuperscary,butreallycoolaswell,”shesaidasshestartedgainingmomentum
andmovingbackandforthfaster,herhairandskirtflyinginthewindasshestartedmovinghigher
andhigher.
“Yeah,thatwouldbesupercool.”
“Didyouknowthereareeightthousandstarsintheskyrightnow?”Jesssaidbreathlesslyasshe
swungbackandforthontheswing.
“Exactlyeightthousand?”IsaidteasinglyasIglancedoverather.
“Yes,exactlyeightthousand.”Shelaughed.
“Howdoyouknowthereareexactlyeightthousandstars?”
“BecauseIcountedthemall.”Shegiggled,thesoundmakingmefeelwarminside.
“That’salotofcounting,”Isaidwithasmirk.
“DidyouthinkIcouldn’tcountthathigh?”
“Idon’tknowwhattothink.”Ilaughedasshescrunchedupherfaceinthemoonlight.
“You’remean,”shesaidasshecontinuedswinginghigherandhigherandlaughed.“IfeellikeI’m
flyingrightnow.”
“Soyou’rehavingfun?”Isaidhopefully,wonderingifshewasreallyenjoyingthesimple
pleasureofswingingontheswing.
“Yes,”shesaidsimply.“Iam.”
“I’mglad,”IsaidasIkickedmylegsoutandstaredatthestarsinthesky,whileweswungin
companionablesilenceandsynchronization.IstaredupatthemoonandwonderedifNeilArmstrong
hadgazeddownatEarthandwonderedwhatthebillionsofhumanbeingsweredoingandthinkingas
hewalkedonthemoon.
“YouknowwhatIthinkaboutsometimes?”Jessinterruptedmythoughts,hervoicesoftasher
hairflappedinthewind.
“No,whatdoyouthinkaboutsometimes?”Iaskedhercuriously.
“Iwonderifthere’saGodandifhe’slookingatmeandwonderingwhatI’mdoingwithmylife.”
“Whatdoyouthinktheansweris?”Iaskedhercuriously.
“Imean,Idon’treallyknow,”shesaid.“ButI’dliketothinkthatthereis.I’dliketothinkthathe’s
watchingoverme,guardingme,protectingme.”
“Yeah,that’sanicethoughttohave.”
“You’renotabeliever?”Sheglancedoveratmeassheswayedbackandforth,hervoicecarrying
inthewind.
“Idon’tknowifIbelieve,”Isaidhonestly.“Ihavemanydifferentthoughtsinmymind.”
“Goodthoughtsorbadthoughts?”
“Both.”
“Isee,”shesaid,andIwatchedasshestartedslowingherselfontheswing.
“Youseeandknowalottonight.”
“WhatcanIsay?I’manaturallyinquisitiveperson.”
“Suresoundslikeyouare,”Isaidandstartedtoslowmyswingdownaswell.“That’sreally
good,”Icontinued.“Ilikepeoplewhoquestionlife.”
“Thanks,pops,”shesaidandthenlookedatme.“Oops,that’skindofawkward.”
“Onlyifyouwantittobeawkward,”Isaidwithasmallsmile.IfonlysheknewthatIwasalot
closerinagetoherthanshethought.
“Idon’twantitbeawkward.”Shegroaned.“Ithinkyou’retheonewhomadeitawkwardbybeing
Pierce’sdad.”
“Youcanalwayscallmebigdaddyifyouwant.”
“Evan,that’sgross.”
“Oh,justdaddy.”Ilaughed.“Youcouldscreamout‘go,daddy,go’.”
“You’resick,youknowthat,right?”Hervoicesoundedshocked.“That’snotevenfunny.”
“Notevenalittlebit?”Ilaughed,knowingthatsheprobablythoughtIwassomesortofpervert
withallthedaddyjokes;especiallybecauseshethoughtIwasactuallythedaddy.Iwasdefinitely
goingtogotohellandtherewasgoingtobenoreturnticketback.
“Notevenalittlebit.”
“Fuckmeharder,daddy.Oh,yeah.Oh,yeah,”Isaidloudly,andshescreamed.“You’resucha
pervert,Evan.Thatisabsolutelydisgusting.”
“Aww,man,areyoucallingmeapervert?”Iputonasadvoice.
“Whatdoyouthink?Ithinkyourcommentsarehighlyinappropriate.”Jessdidn’tsoundpleased.
“Iwasjoking,”IsaidandeventhoughIwantedtomakeanotherdaddyjoke,Ikeptitinside,
knowingshereallywouldn’tappreciateit.
“Uhhuh,”shesaid.
“Imean,youcancallmewhateveryouwantinthebedroom.Iwon’tjudgeyou.”
“Evan,”Shegroaned.
“That’smynameandyoucan’twearitout.”
“You’resoimmature.SometimesIfinditreallyhardtobelievethatyou’readad.”
“Oh,yeah?”Isaidsoftly.That’sbecauseI’mnot,Ithoughtinmyhead,wishingIcouldtellher.
Wishingshewouldjustfigureitout.Wishingwecouldjokeaboutit,likesomesortofprolonged
reallybadAprilFooljoke.
“Yeah,”shesighed.“ButIguessI’mtheidiotfornotfiguringitout.”
“You’renotanidiot,”Isaidsoftlyandlookedbackatthesky,wonderinghowwewereevergoing
togetoutofthissituation.
“Whatareyouthinkingabout?”Jessaskedmequietlyafterafewminutesofsilence.
“Shouldn’tIbeaskingyouthatquestion?”Irespondedtoher,notwantingtotellherthatIwas
thinkingabouther.
“Don’tdeflect,”shesaid.“Youdothatalot,ortryandmakeajokeoutofasituationortryand
teaseme.”
“Youdon’tlikemeteasingyou?”Iasked.“WouldyoupreferthatItickleyouinstead?”
“Evan,”shesighed.
“Jess,”Isighed,mimickingher.
“Evan,comeon.”
“Jess,comeon.”
“Evan!”
“Jess!”
“Stopit.”
“Stopit,”Irespondedandlaughed.
“You’resuchachild.”Shehuffed.
“You’resuchachild.”Ihuffedbackandwatchedasshejumpedoffofherswing.“Whereareyou
going?”Ijumpedoffofmyswingandfollowedbehindher.
“I’mgoinghome.Ifyou’renotgoingtohaveaproperconversationwithme,thenwhyshouldI
bothersittinghere,playingthesegames?”
“Whatgames?”
“Evan,Ithoughtthewholepointofusgettingtogethertonightwastodiscusswhatwasgoingon
andseewherethiscouldgo?”Hervoicetrailedoff.“Well,notwherethiscouldgo,butexactlywhat
wehavebetweenus.Notthatwehaveanything,butyouknowwhatImean.”
“Whatdoyouwanttotalkabout?”Iaskedherseriously,standinginfrontofher,myheartbeating
quickly.Ididn’twanttohurther.Ireallydidn’twanttohurther.That’sallIknew.Evenifthatmeant
hurtingmyself.Evenifitmeanthurtingheralittlebit.Ididn’twanttobreakherheart.Ididn’twant
hertofallformemorethanshealreadyhad.Ididn’twanttocauseheartache.Ineededtoremember
that.IneededtorememberthatasmuchasIwantedher.Andneededher.Andwantedtoseewherethis
couldgo,Ineededtothinkofherfirst.I’dalreadyplayedhertoomuch.Ididn’twanttobethereason
forheartacheandtears.Icouldn’tbe.Ididn’twanttobe.Itwasn’tfair.Myheartwouldn’tallowthat.
Notwhenshewasstandinghere,bigwidebrowneyesinfrontofme,lookingdeepintomysoul,
wantinganswerstoquestionsshewastooafraidtoask.Herlipswerequiveringslightly,waitingtobe
kissed.Herfingersweretrembling,waitingtobeheld.Shewaslookingupatmewithhopeinher
eyes,andIcouldfeelmyheartdroppingintomystomach.Ididn’tknowwhattodo.Ijustdidn’tknow
whattodo.Iwasalreadyintoodeep.Wewerebothintoodeep.Therewasgoingtobenowaywe
couldextricateourselvesfromthismomentwithoutanypain.Itwasalreadytoolateforthat.
“W
E
CAN
’
T
GO
BACK
toPierce’s,”Jesssaidbreathlesslyaswewalkedalongtheemptystreets,hand-in-
hand.
“Whynot?”Isaid.“He’soutoftown.”
“Itjustdoesn’tseemright.”
“Well,wecantalkthere.Ithoughtyouwantedtotalk.Unlessyouwanttogobacktoyourplace.”
“No,weshouldn’tgobacktomyplace,”shesaidquickly.“Alyssaishome.”
“Andshedoesn’tlikeme,huh?”Isighed.
“No,shedoesn’t…well,Idon’tknowthatshedoesn’tlikeyou,perse,”shesaidquickly.
“Shedoesn’tlikeme.”Ilaughedandshookmyhead.“Ican’tblameher.”
“Fine,wecangobacktoPierce’s.Itjustfeelsweird.”Shemadeaface,andIsqueezedherhand.
“It’sokay.IdothinkyoushouldbreakthingsoffwithPierce,though.”
“Imean,asfarasIwasconcerneditwasalreadyover,”shesaid.“NotthatIfeltwereallyhad
much.Gosh,youmustthinkI’mahorribleperson.”
“IthinkI’mnotreallythepersonwhocouldthinkthat,right?”Isaidsoftly.
“SoexactlywhatarewegoingtotalkaboutwhenwegettoPierce’s?”sheaskedandglancedover
atme.
“Whateveryouwant,”Isaid,thoughmyplanwasn’treallytodomuchtalking.
“Okay,”shesaid,andIcouldtellthatthatwasn’ttheanswershe’dbeenexpecting.Itwasn’treally
theanswerI’dbeenthinkingIwasgoingtogive,either,butIwasallovertheplaceandIdidn’treally
knowwhattodoorsayinthisinstance.Ididn’tknowhowtoactorwhattosaytomakeeverything
betterforbothofus.
“I
JUST
WANT
tokissyou,”Isaidaswesatonthecouch,beersinhand.
“Okay.”Sheglancedatme.
“CanI?”Ilookedatherlips.
“I’msurprisedyou’reasking,”shesaidasshetookaswigofherbeer.“Youdon’tnormallyask.”
“Well,IthoughtI’dbeagentlemantoday.”
“Wow,Ididn’tknowyouhadthatinyou,”shesaidwithagiggleasshelookedupatmeunderher
lashes.
“Ididn’tknowIhaditinmeeither,”Isaidandtookaswigofmybeer.“Iguessfortheright
woman,anymancanbeagentleman.”
“Oh.”Sheglancedatme.“AmItherightwoman?”
“Idon’tknow,areyou?”Isaidwithasmallsmile.
“Whoknows?”ShetookanotherswigofbeerandIreachedoverandgrabbeditfromherand
placeditonthecoffeetableinfrontofus.ThenItookmybeerandplaceditonthetableaswell.
“Iguessneitheroneofus,”IsaidsoftlyasIleanedforwardtokissher.“Butthat’saworryfor
anothertime.”
“Oh?”
“Yeah,”Isaidsoftly.“RightnowIjustwanttofeelyoursoftlipsonmine.”
“Oh?”shesaidandgazedatme.
“Yeah.”Ileanedbackandwinkedather.“Orsomewhereelse.Yourpick.”
“Mypick?”Sheglancedatmewithasmallfrown.“Whatdoyoumeansomewhereelse?”She
staredatmeforafewsecondsandthenshookherhead.“You’reapervert.”
“Thankyou.”Igrinnedatherandadjustedmygrowingpackage.“WhatcanIsay?Youmakeme
feelgood—or‘hard’mightbeabetterword.”
“Evan.”
“Jess.”
“Oh,mygosh,you’renotgoingtostartthatagain,areyou?”
“Startwhatagain?”Ilookedatherwithablankface.
“Nothing.”SheshookherheadandIcouldseetheuncertaintyinhereyes.Ileanedforwardand
pressedmylipshardagainstherandpushedmytongueintohermouth.Sheranherhandsthroughmy
hairandpulledslightlyonmylocks,andIranmyhandstoherbreastsandpinchedhernipples
lightly.“Oh,Evan.”
“Youcansayitalittlelouderifyouwantto.”
“Idon’twantto.”Shesquealedasmyfingersreacheddowntoherthighsandupinsideherdress
andtowardsherpanties.
“Iwantyouto,”Igrowledagainstherlips.“Iwantyoutobeasloudasyoucanbe.”
“I’mnotloud.”Shemoanedasmyfingersslippedinsideofherpanties,andsheshiftedonthe
couch.“Evan.”Shesighedandgrippedherlegstogether.
“Yes,Jess?”Imovedmylipstowardsherneckandbitdownandsucked.“Whatdoyouwantmeto
do,Jess?”
“Evan.”Sheclosedhereyesandrestedherheadback,herhandsnowonmyback,fingersdigging
intomyskin.
“Tellmewhatyouwantmetodo,Jess?”
“Don’tstop.”ShemoanedasIstartedtomovemyfingersaway.“Justdon’tstop.”
“Don’tworry,Ihavenoplansonstopping,”Isaid,movingmylipstowardherearandblowing
intoitsoftlybeforeputtingmytongueinherearandthennibblingonherearlobes.“I’mnotgoingto
stopuntilyouscreammynameoutinecstasy.”
“You’dstopthen?”Shelookedconfused.
“No,that’sjustwhenI’llreallygetstarted.”Ilaughedandmovedbackslightly.“Nowstandup,
quickly,Iwanttotakeyourdressoff.”
“Sobossy,”shesaidasshestoodup.
“Isn’tthatwhatyouloveaboutme?”Ipaused.“Notlove-love,ofcourse,butsexy-love.”
“Sexy-love?”ShestaredatmeasIpulledherdressoffofherandundidherbra.
“YouknowwhatImean,”IsaidasIpulledmyshirtoffandthrewitontothefloor.”
“Notreally,”shesaidandsighed.“Wedidn’teventalkyet.”
“Wecanstopandtalkfirstifyouwant.”
“Youknowthat’snotwhatIwantrightnow.”ShegavemeasmallshylookasIplayedwithher
breasts.“Youthinkyou’resoclever,don’tyou?”
“Idon’tknowthatIthinkI’mclever.”Ilaughed.“Iknowit.”
“Witholdagecomeswisdom,huh?”Shelaughed.
“Youshouldknow.Whatdoyouthink?”
“Ithinkyouneedtostoptalkingandstartdoing.”
“Youdon’thavetosaythattometwice,”IsaidasIunbuckledmypantsandpulledthemdown.
“Youwanttotakemyboxersoff?”IgrinnedatherasIstoodthereinfrontofus,bothofusjustin
ourunderwear.Istaredatherbreasts,wantingtoreachoverandsuckonthembutnotwantingtorush
thenight.Iwantedtogoslowly.Iwantedtotantalizeherbody.Iwantedtohavehereverynerve
endingwantingandwaitingtoseewhatIwasgoingtodonext.Iwantedhertobegmetofinallytake
her.Iwantedhertohavethebestorgasmofherlife.Iwantedthistobethenightofherlife.Iwanted
tobeingrainedinherbrainandbodyforever.
“Doyouwantmetotakeyourboxersoff?”sheaskedmewithashysmile.
“Verymuchso,”Isaidandsteppedtowardsher.
“Okaythen,”shesaid,andIwatchedasshesteppedforwardandstoppedrightinfrontofme,
lookingupatmewithasmallsmileasherhandsfelltothetopofmyboxersandgrippedtheelastic.
“I’mgoingtodoit.”
“Good,doit.I’mwaiting.”Iheldmybreathinanticipation.
“I’mdoingit,”shesaid.AndthenIfelthertuggingmyboxersdownquickly.Iliftedupmyright
legandthenmyleftlegandsteppedoutofthemquickly,mycockstandingtoattention.“Someoneis
happytoseeme.”
“Veryhappy.Wouldbeevenhappiertotouchyou.”
“Orformetotouchit,I’mbetting?”sheaskedmewithasmallsmile.
“Well,ifyouwantto.”
“Dependsonwhatyouwant.”
“Iwantitall,”IsaidasIgazedatherbody.“Iwantallofyou.”
“AndI,wantallofyou,”shesaidandthenshedroppedtoherkneesandtookmeintohermouth,
andIfeltlikeIhadbeentransportedtoheaven.IknewIshouldn’tbeinthismomentasmuchasIwas,
butIjustcouldn’tstopmyself.Notwhenitfeltthisgoodbeingwithher.
J
C H A P T E R 1 9
ess
"Weneedtocometoanunderstanding,"hesaidashegotreadytocatchacab.Ithadbeen
twoweekssinceourdinnerandwe’djusthadanicelunchtogether,andeventhoughIdidn’treally
knowwhereanythingwasgoingbetweenus,Iwasstillfairlycontentinthatheseemedinterestedin
seeingme.Evenif‘seeingme’meantthathemainlyjustwantedtohavesex.Iwasn’tsurehowIfelt
aboutthat,butIknewIjusthadtoacceptwhathewaswillingtogivemeatthispointintime.I
couldn’tmakeitsomethingitwasn’t,nomatterhowbadlyIwantedtodoso.Nomatterthatattheback
ofmymind,IsomehowstillfeltlikeIwasbeingused.
"Anunderstanding?"Iglancedathimandhiscockysmile,andfrowned."Anunderstandingabout
what?"MyheartthuddedasIgazedathim,wonderingwhathewasgoingtosay.CouldhetellIwas
developingfeelingsforhim?CouldhetellIwashopingforsomethingmore?
"Anunderstandingaboutwhatthisisandwhatthisisn't."
"Uhm,okay?"Itriednottorollmyeyesathim.Itriedtoignorethesinkingfeelinginmyheart
andthesuddenheavinessinmystomachandeyesasIlookedathim.
"Idon'twantyougettingthewrongidea."
"WhosaidIhadanyideasinmyheadinthefirstplace?"Ilied,mythroatswellingupandmyface
startingtofeelwarm.Ifeltasiftearswerewellingupinmyeyes.IfeltasifIwantedtojustcrawl
awayfromhim.MybackstartedtoacheontherightsideandIlookedawayfromhim.Iwasn’tsureI
wasgoingtobeabletokeepittogether.
"Idon'twantyoufallinginlovewithme,"hesaid,hisvoicestiffandhiseyesseriousandintense.
Onceagain,Ifeltmyheartdropping.
"Fallinginlovewithyou?"Iscoffedandstaredathislips,myheartpoundinglikeitwasgoingto
jumpoutofmychest.Ididn’twanttofeelthiswayandIdidn’twanttocry.Ijustwantedtocall
Alyssa,butIknewshewouldhavenosympathyforme.Howcouldshe?She’dalreadywarnedmeto
stayawayfromhim.AndIhadn’tlistened.I’dmademybedandnowIwaslyinginit.Iwasinthe
exactsortofsituationthatI’dneverwantedtofindmyselfin.
"I'mnotthesortofguyyoushouldfallinlovewith."Hiseyesnarrowedandhislipsthinned.I
didn’tunderstandwhyhewastellingmethisnow.We’djusthadagreatlunch.We’dbeenhavinga
greatweek.Well,kindof.Itwasn’teverythingI’dhopeditwouldbe.Itstillfeltslightlyawkward.
"Igatheredthatalready,trustme."
"Oh,really?"Hepaused,hisfacestillingashegazedintomyeyesintently."Howdidyougather
that?"
"Whatdoyoucare?"Ishruggedandlookedawayfromhim.Hisblueeyesweremakingmyheart
racetooerraticallyandIcouldfeelmybodygrowingwarm.
"Iwasjustcurious."HesteppedclosertomeandIcouldfeelhisbodyheatbouncingoffofme.
Anditmademejustwanttohavethegroundswallowupanddie.Ortouchhim.Ijustwantedtoreach
outtotouchhim.Iwantedhimtograbme,pullmeintohisarmsandtellmethathewasjustjoking.I
wantedhimtotellmehelovedme.IwantedhimtotellmethathewasjustjokingandthathehopedI
wasfallinginlovewithhimaswell.Iwantedhimtotellmethatfromthefirstmomenthe’dmetme,
he’dknownIwastheone.IwantedthefairytaleandIdidn’tevenknowwhyIwantedthat.OrwhyI
thoughthecouldgiveittome.Ididn’tknowwhyIcaredsomuch.Didn’tknowwhyI’dletmyselffall
inlovewithamanwhowaseverythingIshouldn’twantinaman.Whathadheshownmeordonefor
methatmademethinkhecouldbethekeeperofmyheart?Iwasadumbass.Arealdumbass.Andit
mademehatemyself.Really,reallyhatemyself.
"Curiositykilledthecat,"Isaid,stoppingmyselffrommovingbackandawayfromhim.Ididn't
wanttolethimseehowmuchheaffectedme.Howmuchhemademewanttoretreat.Howmuchhe
washurtingmyfeelingsrightnow.Ididn’twanthimtoseehowbadlyIwantedtocry.
"Ijustwanttomakesureyoudon'tfalltoohardforme,"hesaid,staringatmylips,andI
swallowed.Pleasedon’tcry,Jess,pleasedon’tcry.That’sallIcouldthinktomyself.Pleasedon’tcry.
"Myconcernisthatyoudon'tfalltoohardforme,"Isaidsoquietlythatitwasalmostawhisper.
Whycan’tyoufeelthesamethingformethatIfeelforyou?Howwasitpossibleformetofeelso
muchsoquickly,andforhimtoseeminglyfeelnothing?Howwasitpossibleformetofeelsucha
connection?Ididn’tunderstandhowhecouldstareintomyeyesandintomysoulandyetnotfeelthe
samepangsofloveandadorationthatIfelt.Howwasitpossibleforhimtobeinmymindallthe
time?Howwasitpossibleformetowanttospendeverysecondwithhim?Howwasitpossiblethat
heneverwantedtospendthatmuchtimewithme?
"Oh?"Hefrowned.
"Yeah,Idon'twantyoutofallinlovewithme,"Ilied."Idon'twantyoutogethurt."Iwantyouto
beashurtasIamrightnow.IwantyoutofeelthepaininyoursoulthatIfeelinmine.Iknewthatwas
wrongofme.ButIjustwantedhimtofeel.Ijustwantedhimtoknowthathewasputtingmethrough
hell.AndIdidn’tevenknowthatheknewwhatthatfeltlike.Ididn’tevenknowifheknewwhatitfelt
liketothinkofsomeoneallthetime.ApartofmefeltlikeIwaspossessedbythoughtsofhim.Apart
ofmefeltlikehewasapartofmybody.Apartofmefeltlikehewasinmysoulinmymind.AndI
hatedit.IhatedfeelinglikehewasallIcouldthinkabout.IhatedthinkingIwouldnevergethimout
ofmysystem.Becausehewasapartofmysoulandbody,andjustbeingaroundhimmademefeel
happy.Justbeingaroundhimmademefeellikeeverythingwasgoingtoberightintheworld.He
mademethinkeverythinginlifewasgoingtobefine.NomatterhowsadorupsetIwas.Nomatter
howbadlymydayhadgone.Justseeinghissmilemademefeellikeeverythingwasgreat.Isawbirds
inthesky,Isawbutterfliesflying.Isawthesunshiningongreydays.Everythingwasgood.And
whenhewasn’taround,Ifeltdeep,dark,soulless.AndIcried.IcriedsomanytearsthatIthoughtI
wasgoingtodie.AndIknewitdidn’tmakesense.Iknewitdidn’tmakesensethatnotbeingwithhim
mademefeelsuchwithdrawal.AnditpainedmetothinkofadaywhenIwouldn’tbewithhim.We
weren’tanofficialcouple.Andhehadnevertoldmehelikedmealotorlovedmeorthathewanted
anythingfromme.We’dnevermentionedbeingacouple.HereIwasdreamingofadaywhenwe
wouldbetogetherforever,andherehewastellingmenottogettooclosetohim.Itwaskillingme
inside.LiterallykillingmeandIhadnoideawhattodo.IhadnoideahowtofeelandIwasscaredI
neverwouldbeabletogetoverhim.AndIhadnoonetotalktoaboutit.Noonewhowould
understandjusthowmuchIlovedhim.HowcouldIloveamansomuchwhohadnevergivenme
anything?HowcouldIloveamanwhodidn’twantmeasIwantedhim?Ijustdidn’tunderstandit.
"Hurt?"HelickedhislipsslowlyandIcouldtellhewastakenabackbymywords.
"Yeah,whenyourealizeyoucan'tlivewithoutme."Ipaused."I'dhatetobreakyourheartwhenI
walkaway."Whichwasalie.Ididwanttobreakhisheart.IwantedhimtorealizeIwasthebestthing
thathadeverhappenedtohim.IwantedhimtoknowI’dhadtowalkawaybecausehehadmademe.I
wantedhimtoregreteverything.Iwantedhimtowishhe’dneverhadthisconversationwithme.How
couldhebringupthesewordstome?Howcouldhehurtmelikethisandlooksononchalantashedid
it?Howcouldhelookatotherwomen?Howcouldhetalktootherwomen?Howcouldheflirtwith
otherwomen?Withmethere?Washetryingtohurtme?Didhenotcareaboutmyfeelings?Ijust
didn’tunderstandwhyIwasn’tenough.Ididn’tunderstandwhatIhadtodo.Ididn’tunderstandwhy
hecouldn’tfeelthesamewayasme.I’drecentlystartedprayingagain.I’dstartedprayingthathe’d
wakeuponedayandrealizehewasbeingafool.Iprayedwitheverythinginmypowerthathecould
justlovemeasmuchasIlovedhim.Andsomedays,somedays,whenhiseyeslitupwhenhesawme,
Ireallythoughthefeltthesameway.Ireallythoughttodaywasgoingtobetheday.Ireallythought
thatsomehowithadclickedinhim.Howcouldhenotfeelwhatwehadbetweenuswasreal?How
couldhenotknow?IstoodthereinfrontofhimandIfeltlikeIjustwantedtofallontotheground
andcry.Iwantedtograbhislegs.Iwantedtoholdhimsohecouldn’tgoaway.Iwantedtotellhim,to
beghim,topleaseloveme.Toaskhimwhyhedidn’t.Iknewitwaspitiful.IknewIwaspitiful.Iknew
everythingIwasfeelinginsidemademealoser.AndIhatedthataboutmyself.BecauseIknewwhat
Alyssahadsaidwasright:hedidn’tcareaboutme,notinthatway.Heneverwasgoingtocareabout
meinthatway.AndallIhadwasmoreheartachecoming.WitheverydaythatIhadhope,allIwas
doingwaslettingmoreheartachein,lettingmorepainin.
"Walkaway?"HisfingerstouchedmychinandpushedmyfaceupsothatIwasstaringintohis
eyesagain."Whywouldyouwalkaway?"Hisfacelookeduncertain,notasconfidentandarrogantas
before,andmystomachflippedasIgazedintohiseyes,myfacehotandnerveswhirlinginmy
stomach.
"Whydoyouthink?"Ilickedmylipsnervously.Pleasetellmeyouloveme.Pleasetellmeyou
don’twantmetowalkaway.Please.Please.IfthereisaGod.IfthereisaGod,hewillloveme.Hewill
tellmenow.Hewillprofesshislovetomeandeverythingwillbeokay.Wewillbeokay.Iwillbeokay.
Iwilllaughaboutthis.Abouteverything.Itwillbeastorytotellourkids.Itwillhavebeenworthit.It
wouldallhavebeenworthit.
"Becauseyoulovemetoomuch?"Healmostgrunted,andIstartedlaughing.NotbecauseI
thoughthewasfunnyorbecauseIthoughtitwasfunny,butbecauseitwassoclosetothetruthandI
didn'twanthimtoknow.Ididn'twanthimtoknowthatthisconversationwasalreadytoolate.Ididn't
wanthimtoknowthatIlovedhim.Ididn'twanthimtoknowIalreadyknewthatwheneverwhatever
wehadwasendedIwasgoingtobeheartbroken.Hecouldn'tknow.Iwastooproudforthat.Istarted
laughingsothatIwouldn’tstartcrying.BecauseIknewifIstartedcrying,itwouldbealloverandhe
wouldthinkIwasapsychopath.Orjustcrazyinthehead.WhichIwasalreadystartingtothinkwas
true.
"That'sfunny."Ishookmyheadandsmiledwidely,pretendinganonchalanceIdidn'tfeel."We
don'tneedtocometoanunderstandingbecausethereisnoworryaboutmefallingforyouand
expectingtoomuch."Ireachedoverandtouchedhischest."Ifanyoneshouldbeworried,it'syou.
BecausewhenIwalkaway,you'regoingtorealizethatIwasthebestthingyoueverhad."Hegrabbed
myhandandheldittohischestforafewsecondsandthensighedlightly.
"Don'tplaywithfire,Jess."Heleanedforwardandwhisperedinmyear."Oneofusisgoingtoget
burnedanditsureashellisn'tgoingtobeme."
"It'snotgoingtobeme,either,"IsaidemphaticallyasIpulledawayfromhimandlookedintohis
eyes."I'mnotgoingtofallinlovewithyou."
"Good,"hesaidashestaredatmeandeverythinginhisfacetoldmethathedidn'treallyfeelthat
way.Everythinginhisfacetoldmethathewashurtandthatjustconfusedmeevenmore.Itconfused
mebecauseIdidn’tknowwhattodo.Ididn’tknowhowIwasgoingtocontinuelikethis.Ifhewasmy
Mr.Right,itshouldn’tbethishard.Shouldit?
“S
O
A
LYSSA
WON
’
T
BE
BACK
forafewdays,”Isaidaswesatonthecouchinmylivingroom.“Youcan
stayoverifyouwant.”
“Thanks,”hesaid,notlookingupfromhisphone.Isatnexttohim,willingmyselftonotlook
downathisphone.Ididn’twanttobenoseyandIdidn’twanttomakemyselfupset,buthehadbeen
textingforthelasthourwithsomeoneandbarelylookingatme,anditwasdrivingmecrazy.
“Soareyougoingtostayover?”Iaskedfeebly.“Ithoughtmaybewecouldgotothiscoolbrunch
placeinthemorning.Thisplacecalled‘Mama’sonWashington’.”
“Eh,don’tthinkIcanstayover.”Helookedupatmeandshrugged.“Butthanks.”
“Oh,okay,”Isaid,feelingdisappointed,andIglanceddownathisphonescreen.Myheart
droppedasIsawaphotoonthescreenofsomebeautifulwomanandabunchoftextsbackandforth
betweenthetwoofthem.Itriedtolookawayfromthescreen,butIcouldn’tstopmyselffromreading
hislastmessagetoher.“Beautifulphoto,thanksforsharing.”Myheartsank.AndIcouldfeelthe
stirringsofjealousyinmysoul.Ilookedawayfromthephone,wantingtomakeacommenttohim
butnotknowingwhattosay.WhatcouldIsay?DidIhavearighttosayanything?Ilookedbackdown
atthescreenandreadsomeoftheothermessages.“Busytonight,butmaybetomorrow?”Wasthe
messagebeforethephoto?“Maybethiswillmakeyouchangeyourmind,”wasthemessagethat
accompaniedthephotoshe’dsenthim.Itriednottostareatherfaceandherbody.Shewasyoungand
beautiful.Really,reallybeautiful.Icouldn’tstopmyselffromstaring.Icouldn’tstopmyselffrom
feelinginadequate.Maybethiswaswhyhedidn’tloveme.Iwasn’tprettyenough.Iwasn’tenough.I
wasnevergoingtobeenough.NomatterwhatIdid.NomatterwhatIsaid.Itwasobvioustomein
thatmomentthatnothingwasgoingtochange.Ever.Hewasn’tgoingtowakeupandtellhimselfhe
wasinlovewithme.Thatwasnevergoingtohappen.Itwasn’tsuddenlygoingtohithim,likeitdid
inthemovies.Themoviesweren’treality.Hejustwasn’tthatintome.Hedidn’tcare.Hedidn’tcareat
all.Hedidn’tloveme.Heneverwould.He’dbeensittingherewithme,laughingandtextingbackand
forthwithsomehotgirl.Basicallyflauntingitinmyface.Likehedidn’tcareatall.Hedidn’tcareifI
saw.Maybehewasdoingitonpurpose.MaybehewantedtomakeitcleartomethatIknewhedidn’t
care.HewantedtomakesureIdidn’tfallinlovewithhim.HewantedtomakesureIknewhecould
dobetterandhewasandthatImeantnothingtohim.Isatbackinthecouchandclosedmyeyes,
tryingtobreathedeeplyandnotcry.AllIcouldseewasthegirl’sfaceinmymind.AllIcouldthink
aboutwasthemkissing.Himtouchingher.Himwantingher.Himthinkingabouther.Himstaringat
herinwonder.Himtellingherhelovedher.Himthinkingshewaseverything.Himjustthinkingshe
waseverythingIwasn’t.BecauseobviouslyshewaseverythingIwasn’t.Shewastheonehewanted.
Shewastheonehecaredabout.Andwhywouldn’the?Shewasgorgeous.Shelookedsexyashell.I
betshedidn’thaveanyinsecurities.Imean,anygirlwhocouldsendaphotolikethatofherselfdidn’t
haveanyinsecurities.Shewaseverythingamancouldwant.Unlikeme.
“Hey,what’swrong?”EvantouchedmelightlyontheshoulderandIlookedoverathim.
“Nothing,why?”
“Youwentquiet.”Hiseyeslookeddownatmyfaceandhelookedconcerned.
“I’mfine.”Ishrugged.“Ididn’thavemuchtosay.Youwerebusytexting.”
“I’msorryIcan’tstayovertonight.Ihavethingstodo.”
“Yeah,I’msure.”
“Sorry,I’mabusyguy.”Helookedannoyed.“Ican’tbewithyouallthetime.”
“Idon’texpectyoutobewithmeallthetime.Ibarelyseeyou.”
“Iseeyoualot.IprobablyseeyoumorethanIseemostotherpeople.”
“Cool,”Isaidandlookedawayfromhim.
“Itoldyounottogettooinvestedinme,Jess.”Hesighed.“IgiveyouasmuchasIcan.”
“IknowandI’mnot.”Ijumpedupoffofthecouch.“Doyouwantadrink?I’mgoingtothe
kitchennow.”
“No,I’mgood.”HeshookhisheadandIcouldfeelhiseyesonmeasIwalkedoutoftheroom.
ItriednottocryasIreachedthekitchen.Itriednottobreakdown.ItwasmyownfaultthatIwas
hurt.Itwasn’tlikewe’dhadagreatstart.I’dneverthoughthewassomegreatguy.Ishouldhave
knownthateverythingwasgoingtobecomplicated.Imean,yes,ithadbeenfunforabit,butreally
whatdidthatmean?Ishouldhaveknownnothingfunandexcitinglastsforlong.Imean,whywould
it?Thisislifeandmylifehasnevergonesmoothly.Andit’snotEvan’sfaultIhadfallenforhim
hook,line,andsinker.Itwasn’thisfaulthewasallIcouldthinkabout.Itwasn’thisfaultInownoticed
allofthewomenthathehitoneverytimewewereout.Itwaslikebloodyclockwork.Everytimea
girlwalkedby,hiseyeswouldrushtothemsohecouldcheckthemout.Everysingletime.Itdidn’t
matterwhatthegirllookedlike,buttheprettiertheywerethelongerhiseyeswouldremainonthem,
andthenhewouldlookbackatmelikeitwasnothing,likehewasn’trippingmyheart.LikeIwasn’t
jealousofeverysinglegirlthathecheckedout.Ipretendeditdidn’tmakemefeelinferior.I
pretendedjealousydidn’tstrikethroughmyhearteverysingletime.Itwasmyownfault.Ideservedto
bejealousandupsetandinsecureafterwhatI’ddone.I’dsleptwithmyboyfriend’sdad.Imean,it
wasn’tlikeI’dknownatthetime.Itwasn’tlikeI’dknownanything.Butthatdidn’texcuseit.BecauseI
hadthoughtthatEvanwasPierce’sfriendandsoevenifIhadn’tknowntheirexactrelationship,Idid
knowtheykneweachother.Andeveniftheyhadn’tknowneachother,itstillwouldhavebeenshady.I
meantechnicallyIcheatedonmyboyfriend,eventhoughI’dneverpersonallycaredforPierceinthat
wayandhadn’treallyconsideredhimmyboyfriend.Imeantechnicallythatdidn’tcountbecauseI’d
neveralertedPiercetothatfact.AndnowhereIwas,scornedbyPierceanddatingamanwhodrove
mecrazyandIcouldn’tevensayanythingbecauseIdidn’twanthimtothinkIwascrazy.Hehadn’t
promisedmeanything.Infactourwholedynamichadbeenbuiltuponadangerousflirtation.Maybe
hewasn’teveninterestednowthathehadmeandthatdangerwasgone.Thoughitsurprisedmethat
he’dbeenwillingtogothroughallofthisjustforsomesex.Imean,I’dbeenhisson’sgirlfriend.In
realityhewasreallytheshadyone.ThoughinrealityhewastheoneIwanted.Badly.IthinkIknow
theexactmomentIlosttheupperhandintherelationship.IknowtheexactmomentIrealizedthat
perhapsIwasn’tgoingtohaveafairytaleending.Itwasreallyasimplething.Itshouldn’thavemeant
anything,butitdid.ItwaswhenIsawhimusinganewhandkerchief.I’dnoticedthathe’dbeenusing
theonehe’dtakenfrommeinourfirstmeetingconsistently.EverysingletimeIsawhim,hehadthat
handkerchief.Itsymbolizedsomethingtome,mademethinkthatperhapsIwassomeonespecial.And
then,thenonedayInoticedhimusingadifferenthandkerchief,onethathadhisinitials
monogrammedinnavyblueinthecorners.AndwhenIsawthat,myheartdropped.Itdroppedinto
mystomachandIknewthenthatIwasmuchmoreinvestedinthiswholethingthanhewas.Iknew
thenthathemeantsomethingreallyspecialtome.Whoknewthatahandkerchiefcouldmakemefeel
somuch?ItwassohardformetounderstandwhyhehadstoppedusingthehandkerchiefI’dgiven
him.ButnowIrealizedthatithadn’tmeantanythinginthefirstplace.Muchlikeeverythingelse.Ihad
builtitallupinmyhead.Allinmyhead.AndnowIwasdrivingmyselfcrazy.BecauseIwascrazy.I
wasanidiot.AndnowIwaspayingtheprice.
“T
HANKS
FOR
MAKING
DINNER
.It’sdelicious.”Evan’sfacelookedrelaxedasheatethelasagnaI’dmade.I
wonderedifhe’sjustcountingdownthehoursuntilhecanleaveandgoandbewiththeotherwoman.
Iwantedtoaskhimwhyhe’shere.Whathewantsfromme.Whyhe’splayingme.ButIdon’t.
“Gladyoulikeit.”
“It’sgreat.Maybeoneofthebestlasagna’sI’veeverhad.”
“Thatsoundslikealie.”Ilaughed,thoughthecommentwarmedme.Iwishnowthatthesaying
aboutfoodbeingthewaytoaman’sheartwastrue.
“WouldIlie?”Hesaysashestuffsanotherforkfulintohismouth.“Actuallydon’tanswerthat.”I
stareatforafewsecondswantingtoaskhimwhathewantsfromme.Andwhathewantsmetosay?
Whatdoeshewantfromusspendingtimetogether?ButIdon’t.I’mscaredoftheanswer.I’mscared
thatit’llconfirmtomethatIshouldwalkaway.AndI’mscaredbecauseIdon’tthinkthatIcan.
“Whatnoanswer?”hesaidandthenIwatchedasheputhisforkdownonhisplateandclearedhis
throat.Istaredathim,withmyeyesburningintohis.Mystomachstartedtodoflip-flopsandIcould
feelmyselfgrowingcold.ColderthanI’deverbeenbeforeinmylife.There’sacoldbeforetheheat.
There’saheatbeforetheburning.Andthenitallgoescoldagain.Mybodychangestemperaturesand
Ifeelnumb.He’ssittingacrossthetablefrommeandallIcanthinkaboutisthefactthathedoesn’t
lovemelikeIlovehim.Infact,hedoesn’tcareatall.Iknowhedoesn’tcare.Iknowhewillnever
care.IknowthatmyheartisdestinedtoremainbrokenforeverandIjustdon’tknowwhattodo.I
don’tknowhowtofixit.Idon’tknowhowI’llevergetoverthisfeeling.Idon’tfeelliketherewill
everbeabrighterday.IfeelasifI’mgoingtobeforeverbrokenandIdon’tknowhowtogetoverit.
He’stheloveofmylife.WhenIlookintohiseyes,Ifeelathome,Ifeelasenseofkinship.Ifeel
somethingthatI’veneverfeltbefore.Yet,somehowhedoesn’tseemtofeelit.Hedoesn’tgetit.Or
me.HewillnevergetmeorlovemethewayIlovehimandthatmakesmedoubtabsolutely
everythingaboutmyself.TherearedaysIwakeupandIjustwanttodie.TherearedaysthatIfeelI
willneverbeabletolivethelifeIwantifhecan’treciprocatemyfeelings.Ijustdon’tunderstandwhy
hedoesn’t.Itdoesn’tmakesensetome.He’sallI’veeverprayedfor.He’sallI’veeverwanted,and
yet,it’snotenough.I’mnotenough.Sittingacrossthetablefromhim,pretendingthatI’mokay,is
killer.Itmakesmewanttocry.Itmakesmewanttoshedsomanytears.Itmakesmewanttobeghim,
pleadwithhim,grabhim.Ijustwanttoknowwhy?Ijustwanttounderstand.IknowtheonlywayI’m
goingtogetoverthisandhimistocuthimoutofmylifecompletely.Iknowtheonlywaymyheart
willhealwillbeifIneverseehimagain.Ican’tseehim.Ican’ttouchhim.Ican’tsmellhim.Ican’t
talktohim.It’salltoomuch.It’stoohard.Idon’tknowhowI’lleverbeabletosurvivewithouthimin
mylife,butIdon’tknowifIcankeeponlivinglikethis,withhimdictatingeveryemotioninmy
body.
“Whatareyouthinkingabout?”HiswordsinterruptmythoughtsandIlookupathimwithasmall
smile.
“Notmuch,you?”Isaid,hopingmyvoicewasn’tgoingtocrack.“Justwaitingtoseewhatyou
weregoingtosay.”
“JustthinkingabouthowI’dlovetotakeatripsomewhere.”
“Oh?”Isaid,wonderingifhewasgoingtomentiontakingmeonthetripwithhim.Icouldfeel
myheartstartingtorise.Maybethiswasit.Maybethiswasthemoment.
“Yeah,IfeellikeIneedabreak.”Henodded.“Someplaceformetojustrelax.”Hegrinned.“A
relaxationvacation.”
“Aww,Isee.Soundsnice.”Myheartdroppedagain.Itdidn’tseemlikehewasmakinga
suggestionforthebothofus.
“Yeah.”Henoddedagain.“Youshouldtryitsometime.Youmightfindyoulikeitaswell.Might
makeyoufeellessstressedout.”
“Yeah,Iwill,”Isaid,tryingtolooknormal.“I’mnotstressedout,bytheway.”
“Well,youseemtobestressedout.”Hegavemealook.“Maybeavacationwilldoyougood.”
“Yeah,”Isnapped,“Iwillthinkaboutit.”Iwasstartingtofeelangry,atbothhimandmyselffor
lettinghimputmethroughthis.
“Hey,noneedtosnapmyheadoff.”
“I’mnot.It’sfine.I’mjusttired.Maybeyoushouldgosoon.”
“Areyouaskingmetoleave?”
“Yeah,Ikindaam,”Isaid,lookingawayfromhim,startingtofeelcoldagain.Ididn’twanttofeel
thisfeeling.Ididn’twanttofeelthishurt.Ididn’twanttofeelthisemptiness.Iwassittingherewith
him,butIfeltlikeIwasalone.IfeltlikeIwasthemostaloneI’deverbeeninmylife.So,soalone.I
justwantedhimtoleavesoIcouldgotomyroom,lockthedoor,andcrymyeyesout.Ihadtonot
seehimanymore.Ihadtocuthimoutofmylifeforgood.Ifeltastabbinginmygutatthethought.
HowwasIgoingtodothis?Itwouldbelikerippingapieceofmyselfout.Ididn’tknowifIcoulddo
it.Ididn’tknowifIcould,butIknewIhadto.Icouldn’tlivelikethisanymore.Icouldn’tcontinue
staringintohisbigblueeyesandwishinghewouldfeelsomethingdifferentforme.Itwasnever
goingtochange.AndIwasfoolforthinkingitwould.IwasafoolforthinkingIwouldevermean
anythingrealtohim.
“Areyouupsetwithme?”
“No,whywouldIbeupset?”Ijuststaredathimblankly.
“Ifthisisn’tworkingoutforyou…”Hisvoicetrailedoffandhelookedatmeuncomfortably.
“Isitworkingoutforyou?”
“DoyouregretdumpingPierceforme?”
“Whatdoyouthink?”Isnapped,annoyed,wonderingifitwasalwaysgoingtocomebackto
Pierce.
“Idon’tknow.”Heshrugged.“Butyouseemunhappywithme.”
“MybeingunhappyhasnothingtodowithPierce.”Isighed,myvoicegettinglouder.Washe
beingdeliberatelyobtuse?
“Dowehaveanunderlyingissuehere?”Hepursedhislipsandhiseyesnarrowedashelookedat
me.Icouldfeelmybodyalternatingbetweenhotandcold.Didhereallynotgetit?“Ifwedo,maybe
weneedtochangesomething,”hecontinued.
“Changewhat?”Icouldheartheslightpanicinmyvoice.
“Idon’tknow.”Heshrugged.“Butyouwantmetoleave?”
“Idon’tgetyou,Evan.Idon’tknowwhatyouwantfromme.Idon’tknowhowyoufeel.Idon’t
knowwhatthisis.”
“DoyouthinkI’mleadingyouon?”hesaid,hiseyesboringintomineinacoldway.“Doyou
thinkI’mplayingwithyourfeelings?”
“No.”Myfacewentbrightredandfeltincrediblyhot.
“BecauseIdon’twantyoutothinkthat.YouknowwhereI’mcomingfrom.”Hisvoicesounded
coldandmean,andIwasstartingtofeelhatetowardshim.
“Iknowwhereyou’recomingfromandIknowwhereI’mcomingfrom,”Isaid.“Thisisjustfor
fun,Iknowthat.”
“Doyoureally,though?”Hiseyessearchedmineandhisfacelookedslightlyred.
“Yes.”Ibitdownonmylowerlipandlookedawayforafewseconds.Ididn’tunderstandhowwe
couldgofromlovingtocontentiousinmerehours.Ididn’tunderstandthegamehewasplayingwith
me.
“Look,Ihavetogo.”Helookedathiswatch.“Ihaveplanstonight.”
“Sureyoudo.”Istoodupandwalkedtowardsthedoorway.“Bye.”
“Really,Jess?”Hewalkedovertomeandstopped.“It’sgoingtobelikethis?”
“Justgo,”IsaidasIwalkedtothefrontdoor.Icouldhearhimwalkingbehindme,buthedidn’t
sayanything.“Justtellmeonething,”IsaidtohimasIopenedthefrontdoor.
“Yes?”Hisfacelookedsad,andIwasn’tsureIwasgoingtobeabletoholdmytearsbackfor
anothersecond.
“Haveyoubeengoingondateswhileyou’vebeenseeingme?”Iaskedsoftly.“Andareyougoing
onadatetonight?”
“Whatareyoutalkingabout?”heasked,soundingannoyed.
“Ilookedatyourphonewhenyouweretextingtoday.Isawthescreen.Isawthephoto.Isawthe
text.”Ishrugged.
“Youinvadedmyprivacy?”
“Notonpurpose.”Ishookmyhead.
“Youwereinmypersonalspaceandyoureadmypersonaltextmessages?”hesnapped.
“Itwasn’tlikethat.”Ishookmyhead.“You’retwistingit.”
“Idon’tappreciateyouinmyspaceandbusiness,Jess.”Hesoundedangry.
“Really?You’regoingtotwistthisonmeandmakethismyfault?”Myjawfellopen.“Areyou
joking?”
“Whatdoyouwantmetosay?”
“Answermyquestion,”Isnapped.“Areyoudatingotherwomen?”
“We’renotdating,Jess,”hesaidinanangryvoice.“IcandowhatIwant.Buttoansweryour
question,yes,Ihavebeenondates.”
“Isee.”Istaredathim,allblooddrainingfrommyface,allemotionleavingmyheartandIfelt
likeIjustwantedtodie.Havingitallconfirmedmademefeelsicktomystomach.Itrulywasafool.
“Youshouldbedatingaswell,”hesaidashelookedatme.“Goonlotsandlotsofdates.”
“I’mgoingto.I’mgoingtogoonplentyofdatesandIhopetomeetaniceguy,”Isaid,myheart
breaking.“Bye.”Istaredathimandthenthedoorway.
“Bye,”hesaidslowlyashewalkedthroughthedoor.Islammeditbehindhimandrantomy
bedroom,fellonmybedandstartedcryingimmediately.Icouldn’tbelievethewordshehadsaidto
meandhowshittyhehadmademefeel.Worsethanthatwasthefactthathedidn’tevenseemtocare
thathe’dbeencuttingandhurtful.Hedidn’tseemtocarethathewasbreakingmyheart.Howcouldhe
sononchalantlytellmetodateotherguys?Ihatedhim.Absolutelyhatedhim.Iwhippedoutmyphone
andsenthimalongtextmessage.Ihateyou.Ineverwanttoseeyouagain.Idon’tconsideryoua
goodfriend.Orapossibleboyfriend.Youdon’tdeservetobeinmylife.I’moverthisbullshit.
I’vewastedmyenergyinvestinginthissituation.I’vebeenanidiot.Ihateyousomuch.I’mdone.
Ipressedsendandthencriedintomypillowsomemore.Ikeptpressingmyphonetoseeifhe’d
responded,buttherewasnoreply.ThatmademeangrierandevenmorehurtandIthrewmyphone
acrosstheroomandhearditslamintothewallbeforeitcrashedtothefloor.Igrabbedmypillowto
myfaceandsobbedharder,feelinglikemyheartwasbeingwrenchedoutofmychest.Iheardabeep
frommyphoneandjumpedupoffthebed,myheartracingasIwenttocheckmymessages,praying
itwasfromhim.Prayingthatmymessageshadscaredhimtohissenses.Prayingthatnowhewould
sayhewassorry.Thathedidn’twanttodateanyone.Thatheonlywantedtobewithme.Iprayedthat
hewasgoingtoask,goingtobeg,ifhecouldcomebackandtalktome.Ipickedupthephoneandmy
heartsankwhenIsawthetextfrommycreditcardcompanytellingmethatmypaymenthadgone
through.TherewasnotextmessagefromEvan.IlookedbackatmymessagetomakesureIhadhit
send.Ihad.Ipoweredthephoneonandoff,justincase,andthenstaredatitasitpoweredbackon,
hopinganewbeepwouldcome.Nothing.Absolutelynothing.Iwalkedbacktomybedslowly,feeling
depressedandsad,andfellbackonthebedandstaredupattheceiling,myhandonmyphone.I
checkedthescreenincessantly,waitingforhisresponse,yetnothingcame.
Imusthavefallenasleepbecauseabeepingat4a.m.mademewakeup.MyeyesflewopenandI
glancedatmyphone.IsawEvan’snameandIlookedawayfromthephoneforafewsecondsasmy
heartracedandIfeltnervous.Whatwashegoingtosaytomytext?WashegoingtosaywhatI
wantedhimtosay?Itookadeepbreathandopenedthetextandmyheartsankathisreply:Ok.Ithink
that’sforthebest.Thatwasit.Thatwasbloodyit.Hedidn’tcareatall.Notoneiota.Hedidn’tcare.
Thetearsstartedupagain.AndIthrewmyphoneagain,notcaringifitbrokeornot.“Ihateyou,”I
screamedintothenightairofmyroom.“Ihateyou.”ThetearsstreameddownmyfaceandIpunched
mypillow,wantingtohurtsomethingorsomeoneasbadlyasIwasfeelinghurtinside.Evan’sface
flashedintomymindandsadnessfilledme.“Whycouldn’tyoujustloveme?”Iwhisperedtomyself
andthenfearoverwhelmedme.Myfeelingsweresoextreme.Iwasactingcrazyanditscaredme.
WhywasIfeelingso,sohurt?Whywasthisaffectingmesomuch?Wassomethingwrongwithme?
Wasitnormaltolovesomeonethismuch,eventhoughwe’dneverreallyhadarelationship?Itscared
methatIwassoupsetandhurt.ButIcouldn’tignoretheemptinessinmyheart.Icouldn’tignorethe
factthatIfeltlikethingsinmylifewerenevergoingtoberightagain.Icouldn’tignorethefeeling
thatIlovedEvanwitheverythingthatIhad,andknowinghedidn’tfeelthesamemademewanttosink
intoaholeanddisappear.
J
C H A P T E R 2 0
ess
Hi,Imissyou.Iwanttotalktoyou.Iwanttocallyou.Iwanttotextyou,butIcan't.Ican't
becauseI'mweakandIneedtoletyougo,butit'shardbecauseIloveyou.AndIdon'tknowhowto
stop.It'skillingmeinside.AllIthinkaboutisyou.Youhaveeverypartofmyheart.Youhaveevery
partofme.Idon'tknowhowtoletyougo.Idon'tknowhowtostopthepain.Ijustwanttoclosemy
eyesandimagineyouherewithme.IthinkI'mgoingtodrivemyselfcrazy.IthinkI'vealreadydriven
myselfcrazy.Myheartfeelsweak.Myeyesaredryfromcryingsomanytears.Ifeelemptywithout
youandIcan'teventellyou.
Hi,Iwroteyoualettertoday.Iwroteyoualettertogetitallout.Ithoughtitwouldhelp.Ithought
itwouldmakemefeelbetter.Ithoughtitwouldletmefeellikeeverythingisgoingtobeokay.Butit
didn’t.Itdidn’tatall.Itmademefeelcrazier.WhydoIloveyousomuch?Itdoesn’tmakesense.It
doesn’tmakesensethatIwouldfeelsobetrayed.Sosad.Soangry.Soundeniablyconfusedandlost.
Doyoueventhinkofme?DoIcrossyourmind,ever?
Hi,apartofmefeelslikeyou’remysoulmate.ApartofmefeelslikethereasonwhyIfellfor
youfromthebeginningisbecauseweweremadeforeachother.ButthenIthinkaboutwhatyousaid
tome.AndIthinkabouttheliesyoutoldmeandIthinkI’mwrong.Idon’tknowwhyyoudidn’tcare
enough.Idon’tknowwhyyoudidn’tloveme.Idon’tthinkwecaneverreallyknow?Idon’tknow.I
justdon’tunderstandwhyIcanyouloveyousomuchandyoucanfeelnothing.Imissyou.
Hi,I’msomadatyou.Youhaven’tcalledme.Youhaven’ttextedme.Howcanyoutreatmelike
this?HowcanImeansolittletoyou?Iwanttosendthesemessagessobadly.Iwanttoseeyou.Iwant
youtowanttoseeme.Whydon’tyouwanttoseeme?Whydon’tyouwanttotalktome?DidImean
solittletoyou?HowcouldImeansolittletoyou?Idon’tunderstand.Ijustdon’tunderstand.
Hi,Ithoughtaboutyoutoday.IwonderedifyouhatedmebecauseImadeyouhateyourself
becauseofwhatyoudidtoPierce.Weallmakemistakes.Neitheroneofuswasintheright.Iwish
youwouldcallme.Imissyou.Thisfeelslikeit’ssomeoneelse’slife.Icanbarelygotenminutes
withoutthinkingofyouandtryingtocallyou.Whywon’tyoucontactme?Please.
Hi,Ihaven’tsentanyofthesemessagesandI’mnotgoingtosendthem.I’mtryingtobestrong.
I’mtryingnottocryeverymorningandeverynight.I’mtryingtogetoveritandyou.Ijoineda
datingapp.Ihateit.Ihatemakingsmalltalk,butIknowIneedtogetoutthere.Ineedtomeetaguy.I
needtomeetsomeonethatwillgetmymindoffofyou.It’snotlikewehadanything,butitmakesme
feelguilty.ItmakesmefeellikewewilldefinitelyneverbetogetherifIstartdating,butthenIthink
aboutwhatyousaid.Youwantmetodate.Youwanttodate.Youdon’tcare.Andifyoudon’tcare,
whyshouldI?
Hi,it’sbeenthreeweeksandstillnowordfromyou.Ican’tbelievethatIeverthoughtyouwere
theone.Ican’tbelievethatIthoughtthatIlovedyou.Obviouslythisisn’ttruelove.Thisisnothing.
Nothing.Nothing.I’mdone.I’moveryou.Imissyou.Andyouwillneverknow.You’llneverknow
becauseyoudon’tcare.
HiEvan,
Iwantedtoseehowyou’redoing.Iwroteyouabunchofmessages,butIdidn’tsendthem.Ihope
thisfindsyouwell.Ijustwantedtoreachoutandsaythattherearenohardfeelings.Ijustwantedtobe
honestaboutwhereIwascomingfrom.Youreallyhurtme.Youmademefeellikewehadsomething
specialandultimately,Iendedupfeelingusedandlikeyoudidn’tcare.Iknowweweren’tina
relationship,butstillIfeltlikeyoucouldhavebeenmorerespectfulofmyfeelings.Iputalotintomy
timewithyouandIjustfeltlikeyoudidn’tcare.Ijustneededtogetthisout.Ineededtoletyouknow.
I’msorryifIactedcrazy.I’msorryifyoufeltlikeIinvadedyourprivacythedayIglancedatyour
phone.Ididn’tmeantodothat.Ijustlookeddownandsawit.Anyway,IjustwantedtosaythatI’m
sorryitcametothis.AndI’mkindofupsetthatIhadtobetheonetoreachout.IreallythoughtI
wouldhaveheardfromyoubynow.YoureallyhurtmyfeelingsandI’mnotsurehowyoucoulddo
thatandbeokaywiththat.ButI’mnottryingtomakeyoufeelbad.Ijustwantedtobehonest.
Jess
Ihitsendandimmediatelyregrettedit.IthadbeenamonthofnocontactandIhatedthatIwasthe
weakone.HatedthatIcouldn’tjustmoveon.HatedthatI’dsentanemailthatmademelookpitiful.
HatedthathewouldknowhowmuchIcared.Ihatedit,yet,Iwasstillhopeful.Iwashopefulthathe’d
respond.Iwashopefulthathe’dapologize.Feelbad.Something.
Aftertwodaysofnoresponse.AllhopeleftmeonceagainandIdeletedhisnumberfrommy
phoneandtriednottojumpeverytimeamessagecamethrough.
E
C H A P T E R 2 1
van
T
HERE
’
S
somethingIwishshewouldunderstand.IwishshewouldunderstandthatInevermeantto
hurther.Ineverintendedforhertofallforme.Ineverintendedforhertofallinlovewithme.I
neverwantedthat.Ididn’tseemyselfinarelationship.Ididn’tseemyselfinarelationshipwithher,
especially.Notwithhowourrelationshiphadstarted.Ihadn’tcountedonherfallingformywitand
charmasdeeplyasshehad.Nootherwomanhadbeenabletoputupwithmeandallofmyquirks
before;notthatIhadcared.Iwasstuckinmyways.ThatwaswhyPierceandIhadbeensoimmature
forsolong.Iwasapompousarrogantjerk.That’swhatmostwomensaidaboutme,andtheyweren’t
wrong.Ididn’tcarethatIcameacrossthatway.Ididn’tgenerallycareifwomenbecametooinvested,
butthiswasdifferent.Shewasdifferent.Ididn’twanttohurther.Ihadn’twantedtobreakherheart.I
didn’twanthertobecomeinvestedinmeatall.Iwishedshewouldunderstandthat.Iwishedshe
wouldrealizethatthoughthisstartedasagametome,Ididn’tthinkofitasagame.Ithadjustall
gottenoutofhand.Andfeelingswerehurt.IalmostwishIcouldgobacktothebeginning.IfIcould
goback,thereweremany,manythingsIwouldchange.ManythingsI’dtrytomakeright.Many
thingsI’ddodifferently.Buthindsightisfifty-fiftyandlifeneverseemstogoaccordingtoplan.
IknewIhadscreweduproyallywhenJesskickedmeoutofherapartmentthatday.Ihad
deliberatelybeenflirtingandtextingwithotherwomeninfrontofher.Ihadwantedhertoconfront
me.Ihadwantedhertogetridofme.I’dknownthatwouldbetheeasiestthing.Thebestwayto
extricatemyselffromthesituationwithouthavingtotellherthetruth.Iwasn’tsurewhyI’dthought
thatwouldbethebestway.Iwasn’tsurewhyIhadn’tjusttoldheraboutthelies.IguessI’dbeentoo
scared.Scaredofherreactionandthenscaredofwhatwouldhappennext.Iwasn’treallysurewhat
I’dwantedtohappenbetweenus.
ItriedtocallJessexactlyonceandshehadn’tpickedupthephone,soIknewshewasreallyupset.
SoI’ddecidedtowaitforhertotextmeoremailme.Butshehadn’t.Shehadn’tcalledortexted.
BeingignoredbyJessinfuriatedmeandalmostmademegocrazy.Iwasn’tsurewhyitaffectedme
sobadly.Iwasn’tsurewhatshewantedfromme.ShehadexpectationsthatIwasn’tsureIcouldfulfil.
EverythinghadgottenoutofhandandIknewthathadbeenmyfault.IhadgivenherthetalkthatI
normallygavewomenwhenIthoughttheywerefallingforme.IwouldletthemknowIwasn’t
lookingforanythingserious.Ineverwantedtofindmyselfconfinedtoarelationshiporanother
person.Ididn’tneedthatintimacyorbondtoexist.Didn’tneedit.Didn’tcraveit.Andcertainlydidn’t
wantit.Ididn’twantanyonerelyingonmeforemotionalstabilityorsupport.IknewIwasn’tableto
giveawomantheattentionshewouldwant.IthadneverworkedinthepastandIknewitwasunlikely
toworkinthefuture.Nopartofmehadchangedthatmuchandnopartofmewantedtochange.Itwas
justhowitwas.GrantedI’dnevermetanyonelikeJessbefore.Neverhadsomeonemademefeel
trulyguiltyandworriedabouttheirfeelingsandiftheyweremadatme.Iknewshewassomething
special,someonespecial,butIdidn’tknowexactlywhatthatmeantinasituationlikethis.Whatcould
Ihavesaidtoherthatwouldn’tseemlikeafalsepromiseortoomuchhope?Iwasn’treallysure.I
wantedhertoknowIcaredforher.Ireallyandtrulydid,butIhadn’tknownifIhadanydeeper
feelingsforherandIhadn’tknownifIwantedtohavedeeperfeelings,either.Shewasn’tthesortof
womanIwouldhavechosenformyself.Icertainlydidn’twanttofallintoherspell.Ididn’twantto
fallinlove.Lovewasafoolishman’sgame.AndIwasnofool.Ididn’tloveherandIdidn’twanther
tofallinlovewithme,either.IfeltlikeIhadnorealsolutionstothequandaryIwasin.Iwasannoyed
thatshewasignoringme.Imissedher.Iwantedtoknowwhatshewasdoing,butIdidn’twantto
reachoutbecauseIdidn’twanthertoseethatasanindicationthatIwaswillingtogivehermorethan
Icould.ItpainedmyphysicallytothinkthatIwashurtingher,thatinsomeway,herheartacheddueto
whatI’ddonetoher,butitscaredmemoretothinkabouthavingtocommittoher.Havingtospend
therestofmylifewithher,tryingtomakeherhappy.Itmademewanttothrowup.ItwassomethingI
couldn’tdo.Icouldn’tbethatmaninherlife.Iwasn’ttheguytogiveherthehappilyeverafter.I
wasn’ttheguytogiveherpromisesofsunsetsandrainbowsandblackstallionsridingoffdownthe
beach.AndIdidn’twanthertothinkthatIcouldbethatguyforher.Ididn’twanthertothinkthatI
couldbeherMr.Right.IwasdefinitelynotaMr.Right.IwasaMr.Wrong.Wrongforher.Wrongfor
alifetime.Wrongformanyreasons.Ididn’twantherlikethat.Andyet…yetsometimesIcouldn’t
think,couldn’tsleep,couldn’tevenmusteruptheenergytowatchTVorreadabookbecausemy
mindwasfocusedonherandwhatshe’sbeendoingandwhatshe’sthinkingandwhereshe’sbeen.
SometimesI’msooverwhelmedbythoughtsofherthatitscaresme.ItscaresmethatIcaresomuch.
ItscaresmethatIthinkabouthersooften.Ihonestlydon’tunderstandwhy.Idon’tknowwhyshe’sin
myhead.SometimesIfeellikeshe’sbewitchedme.Iknowmybestbetistofindanotherwoman,bed
another,maybemultipleothers,andhavethemtakeoverthatspotinmymind.Iknowthatmost
womenknewthescore.AndIalsoknewthatmostwomendidn’taffectmelikethis.Ididn’tlikenot
beingincontrol.Ididn’tlikefeelinglikemyheadwasgoingtoplacesthatIdidn’twantittogoto.I
didn’tlikegoingtobedthinkingofherandwakingupthinkingofheranddreamingofher.Ididn’t
wantherinmylifelikethat.Ididn’twantanyoneinmylifelikethat.Iwastooold,toojaded,too
comfortableinmyowninertiatohavesomeonethatdeeplyinmylife.Ididn’twantanyoneinmylife
whowasgoingtoconsumeme.Ididn’twantanyoneinmylifewhowasgoingtomakemeforget
whereIendedandtheybegan.Lovewasayoungman'sgame.Anditwasn’tforme.Iknewthatitwas
bestformetojustletJessgo.IknewthatIcouldgoonandshecouldgoonandwe’dbothsurvive.
She’dprobablyfindtruelove,aguywhowouldloveherandadoreherandshe’dforgetme.Andthat
stung.Itstunghard.ItmademefeellikeIcouldn’tbreathe.Worsestill,itmademefeellikeIdidn’t
wanttobreathe.LikeIdidn’twanttogoon.Andtherewasnothingworsethanthat.Ididn’tevenlike
tothinkofherwithsomeoneelse.Didn’tliketothinkofhersmiling,ortouchinganotherman.It
mademewanttokillsomethingorsomeone.Iknewthatwasn’tagoodsign.Iknewthatthatlikely
meantIwasalreadyindeeperthanIthoughtandwouldhavehoped,butthatwaswhyIwasstaying
away.AslongasIdidn’tfallanydeeper.Ithadstartedoffsolightheartedandfun.Wehadbothknown
thescore.Thiswasnevermeanttobeanything,butsomekinkyfun.Eventhoughourattractionhad
beenimmediate,ithadn’tbeenanythingseriousorachinglydeep.
IhadwantedJesstostopignoringme.UntilI’dgottenhermessage.Hermessagereekedofher
hurtandpainandithurtmeeverytimeIreadit.AndI’dreaditatleasttwentytimesnow.NotthatI’d
respondedyet.Ididn’tknowwhattosay.Ididn’tknowhowtorespond.Ijustwantedtotalktoher.See
her.Touchher.Ijustwantedtobewithheronmyterms,butIknewshewasn’treallyinterestedinthat.
Iknewshe’dbeenignoringmebecauseshewasupsetwithme.Iknewtheonlywaytostopherfrom
beingupsetwastouttersomesortofdeclarationofloveorcommitmentthatIdidn’treallywantto
expressatthistime,orever.Ididn’twanttoleadheron.Eventhoughmyheartachedforher.Even
thoughapartofmewantedtotellherthatIwantedtoreachupandpulldowneverystarforher.ThatI
wantedtonameeveryflowerafterher.ThatIwantedtosingsongsandplayriffsanddedicatepoems
toher.Iwantedtotellherthatshewasalwaysinmythoughts,evenwhenIdidn’twanthertobe.Even
whenIwastryinghardtothinkofsomethingorsomeoneelse.Shewasalwaysthere,inthebackof
mymind.Shewaseverythingtome,yetshewasnothing.Shehadtobenothing.Ifshebecamemore,I
wasn’tsurewhatI’ddo.Iwasn’tsurehowI’dfunctionifIbecametotallyconsumedbyandwithher.I
didn’twanthertobeinmythoughtsallofthetime.Iwantedtoregaincontrol.Ididn’twantherto
consumeeveryaspectofmylife.Icouldn’taffordtobeheartbrokenandincomplete.Notagain.I
couldn’triskbeingbrokenbecauseIwasn’tsureI’devergetoverthepainoflosingsomeonelikeher
onceI’dcompletelypossessedher.Iwasn’tsurethatI’deverbeabletoliveifshewasnolongerin
mylifeinsomeway.
IwasscaredinawaythatI’dneverbeenbefore.Ididn’twanttorespondtoher.Ididn’twanttotell
herthetruth.Yet,IknewthatIhadto.Icouldn’tleaveeverythinglikethis.Icouldn’tleaveherinthis
pain.Ihadtobehonestwithher.Evenifthatmeantshewasgoingtohatemeevenmore.Ijustneeded
toseeheronemoretime.Iwasn’tsureifIwasmakingamistake,butIhadtoreachouttoher.Iknew
Ihadtodoit.
DearJess,
Ithinkweshouldmeetupandtalkinperson,ifyou’reupforit.Ihopeyou’vebeenwell.I’vebeen
thinkingofyou.Letmeknowifyou’refreethisweekend.Icanbeavailableatanytimeofthedayon
eitherSaturdayorSunday.
Evan
Ipressedsendandwaited,hopingthatshewouldrespondandwouldwanttoseemesoon.
Though,IhadnoideawhatIwasgoingtosay.Absolutelynoideaatall.
E
C H A P T E R 2 2
van
Ineverknewthatwaitingforsomeonetoarrivecouldbesonerve-wracking.IneverknewthatI
couldfeelsuchexcitementandfearatthesametime.I’dneverconsideredmyselfananxiousperson.
NeverthoughtthatIcouldbesomeonewhowouldhavemyfeelingsdictatedbysomeoneelse,but
waitingforJesstoarriveattheparksothatwecouldtalkmademefeelnervousasheck.Iwasn’tsure
whatshewasexpecting.Iwasn’tsurewhatshewasgoingtosay.Ifshestillhatedme.Ifshenever
wantedtoseemeagainaftertoday.Maybeshehatedmealready.Ithadtakenheroveraweekto
respondtomymessage.AweekthathadleftmefeelinglikeIdidn’tknowwhatIwasgoingtodowith
mylifeifshedidn’twanttorespond.Ifeltguttedinside,guttedandnervousandguiltyasheck.Ihad
noideawhatshewasgoingtosayorhowshewasgoingtoreact.Ihadnoideawhatshewasgoingto
think.IhadnoideawhatIevenwanted.Imean,inmyheartofhearts,Iknew,butIdidn’twanttoadmit
ittomyself.HowcouldIadmitittomyself?HowcouldIwantsomethingwithheraftereverything
I’ddone?Italsowasn’tinmynaturetowantarelationship.Iwasn’tsureIwasthesortofguywho
couldbeagoodboyfriend.Iwasn’tsurethatIwasthesortofguywhocouldmakeherhappy,atthe
endoftheday.Iwasn’tsureshe’deverreallytrustme.Andwhywouldshe?Iwasn’tagoodguy.I
wasn’tsomeonethatI’dwanthertodate.ThoughIdidn’twanthertodateanyoneelse.Itkilledmeto
thinkthatperhapsshewasdatingsomeoneelse.Itkilledmethatmaybeshe’dkissedsomeoneelse.I
couldn’teventhinkabouthersleepingwithsomeoneelse.I’dkillhim.Isighed.Mystomachwasin
knotsasIstoodthere.IwasannoyedatmyselfthatI’dplayedthegameswithher.KilledmethatI’d
hurtherbysayingIwasdatingothergirlsandtextingotherwomenasifshedidn’tmatter.Thefactof
thematterwasthatIhadn’tseenanyoneelsesinceI’dmether.Hadn’twantedtoseeanyone.Hadn’t
wantedtokissanotherwoman.Hadn’teventhoughtofanotherwomanlikethat.Butshewasn’tto
knowthat.Icouldbarelybelieveitmyself,andIknewthatPiercewasdisgustedwithme.Butmuchin
thewaythatIwasdisgustedwithhim.Icouldn’tbelievethatwe’dbeenfriendsforsuchalongtime.I
couldn’tbelievethatwe’dbeensuchassholes.NowthatIwasfinallyoverthosegames,Irealizedhow
immatureandhurtfulwe’dreallybeen.IfeltashamedofmyselfandIfeltashamedthatI’dtaughtmy
fraternitybrothersthosetricksaswell.WeweredisrespectfultowomenandIcouldn’tbelievethatI
actuallybelievedthatnow.Iknewthatnooneelsewantedtohearaboutit.IknewthatPiercethoughtI
wasafoolandhedidn’tevenknowhowbadlyIhadfallenforJess.Hedidn’tevenknowthatapartof
methoughtthatImightbeinlovewithher,butthatwasbecauseapartofmedidn’tevenwantto
recognizethatasapossibility.HowcouldIhavefalleninlovewiththiswomanthatIbarelyknew?It
waslikeapunishmentforbeingsuchahorriblehumanbeing.
“Hi.”Hervoice,soft,wasrightinfrontofme.Ilookedupandstaredintoherbigbrowneyes.
“Hi,”Isaidbacktoher,feelingawashofemotionsinmystomachthatIhadneverfeltbefore.
“Howareyou?”Iaskedher,staringintohereyes,wonderingwhatshewasfeeling,feelingmore
insecureaboutmeetingwithawomanthanI’deverfeltinmylife.
“I’mgood.Howareyou?”Shegavemeasmallsmile,theemotionnotquitereachinghereyes,
whichInoticedlookedbloodshotandred.
“Prettygood,”Ilied,wantingtoteaseherandsaysomethingtomakethesituationlessawkward
butnotknowingwhattosay.WhatcouldIsayinthissituationtomakeitbetter?
“Good.”Shenoddedherheadandlookedaway.ShewasplayingwithhershirtandIcouldtellshe
wasnervous.IwonderedifshecouldtellhownervousIwasaswell.WonderedifsheknewthatI’d
spentthelastmonthfeelinglikeshitandwonderinghowshewasdoing.
“You’relookingwell,”IsaidtoherasIlookedoverherbody,mybodyfeelingwarmandmy
mindwantingtoknowifanothermanhadtouchedhersinceshe’dlastbeenwithme.
“Thanks,youtoo,”shesaidassheglancedatmeagainandlookedmeover.“Yougotahaircut?”
“Yeah.”Inodded.
“Itmakesyoulookyounger,”shesaidandgavemeasmallsmile.“Noonewouldeverguessyou
wereoldenoughtobePierce’sdad,ever.”Shelaughedasshegazedatmeandshookherhead.“I
honestlywouldneverhaveguessed.”
“Yeah,”IsaidandItookadeepbreath.“Ineedtotalktoyouaboutthat.”
“Oh?”Shecockedherheadtothesideandlookedatmecuriously.“Whatdidyouwanttotalk
about?NotPierceagain?”
“No,well,kinda.”Imadeafaceandshelookedannoyed.Iputmyhandupandsighed.“It’snot
whatyouthink.Ineedtotellyousomestuff.”
“Oh?”Shelickedherlipsnervously.“Whatdoyouneedtotellme??”
“Thisisgoingtobehard,”Isaidandletoutadeepbreath.“Shallwetakeawalk?”
“Iguess.”Sheshrugged,lookingconfused.“Ifthat’swhatyouwant?”
“Yeah.”Inodded.“Itmightcomeouteasier.”
“Okay,”shesaidandwestartedwalkinginsilence.Istaredatthepebblesinfrontofmeand
wonderedwhyitwassohardformetobringeverythingup.Ijustneededtogetitout.
“Firstoff,Ineedtoapologizeforourlastmeeting.I’msorryIhurtyou.I’msorryaboutthe
wordsthatIsaid.IwasmeanandIhatethatIwasthatpersontoyou.”
“It’sokay,”shesaidsoftly,andIshookmyhead.
“No,itwasn’t.Ireadyouremail.I’msorryIhurtyou.I’msorrythatImadeyoufeellikeyou
didn’tmatter.I’msorrythatImadeyoufeellikeIdidn’tcare.I’msorrythatIputyouinthatmental
state.”
“It’sfine.”Sheshrugged.“Itwasmyownfault.Youwereright.Ineededtojuststartdating.I
neededtoputmyselfoutthere.Iwastooreliantonyouandbeingwithyouandthatwasn’tfairtoyou.
Thatwasn’tfairtohavethoseexpectationsofyou.I’msorryforwantingmorefromyouthanyou
werewillingtogive.”
“I’msorrythatIcouldn’tbethatmanforyou,”Isaid,startingtofeelannoyed.“Soareyoudating
someonenow?”
“I’mgoingondates,yes,”shesaidsoftly,andIfeltmyheartdropandIcouldfeelmystomach
churning.
“Oh?”ThatwasnottheanswerthatI’dwantedtohear.Iwantedtoaskwhatsortofdatesandhow
serious.Andwhatthey’ddoneandifshecaredaboutthem.Iwantedtoknowifshethoughtofme
whenshekissedthem,butIdidn’twanttoask.Ididn’twanttoaskbecauseIdidn’treallywanttoknow
theanswers.Ididn’twanttohearthatshewaskissingthemandnotthinkingofthem.Ididn’twantto
hearthatshewasinterestedinsomeoneelse.Ididn’twanttoknow.Notiftheanswerwassomething
thatwouldmakemefeellikeshit.
“That’snotwhyyouwantedtomeetthough?”Shelickedherlipsnervously,andItookadeep
breath.
“No,it’snot.Wanttosit?”Ipointedtoapatchofgrasstotherightofusandthenlookedoverat
her.
“Sure.”Shenoddedandwewalkedovertothegrassandsatdownandfacedeachother.
“So…”Isaid,andmyvoicedriftedoff.
“So…”shesaid,staringatme,herfaceamask.
“It’sbeenawhilesinceI’veseenyou,”Istartedagainandthenstartedtolaugh.Myfratbrothers
wouldnotbelievetheguysittinghereonthegrasswithJess.Thiswasn’tme.Iwasn’tunsureof
myself.Iwasn’tuncomfortable.Iwasneveratalossforwords.Especiallynotwithwomen.Iwasthe
kingwithwomen.Ihadthegiftofgab.Iknewexactlywhattosayandwhen.Iknewexactlywhatthey
wanted.Myfratbrothersusedtocometomewhentheywantedhelpbaggingagirl.Iwastheman.I
hadnoideawhennowIcouldn’tgetthewordsoutatall.IhadnoideawhyIfeltlikeIwasgoingto
messeverythingupifIsaidthewrongwords.
“Yeah,ithas.”Shenoddedandlookedawayfromme.
“So,Ineedtotellyousomethingreallyimportant,”Istartedagain.“Somethingthatmightmake
youhatemeevenmorethanyoualreadyhateme.SomethingthatmightmakeyouthinkI’majerk.Or
abastard.Orwhatever.Andyouwouldn’tbewrongforhavingthosefeelings.Ijustwantyoutoknow
thatI’mashamedofmyself.BeforeIevensayanything,beforeItellyoueverything,Iwantyouto
knowthatI’mashamedofmyself.Iregreteverything,andifIcouldtakeitbackIwould.Itruly
would.”
“You’rescaringme,Evan.”ShelookedworriedandIsawherplayingwithherfingersagain.
“Whatdoyouhavetotellme?Areyoudying?”
“No,I’mnotdying.”Iclosedmyeyesforafewsecondsandthentookadeepbreathandlookedat
her.“Jess,I’mnotPierce’sdad.I’mnothisrealdad.I’mnothisstepdad.I’mnotrelatedtohimatall.
I’mnotevenoldenoughtobehisdad.”
“What?”Hereyeswidenedasshegazedatme.“Whatareyousaying?”Hermouthfellopenand
shelookedlikeshewasabouttohaveaheartattack.
“PierceandIwerefraternitybrothers.Iwasafewyearsaheadofhim.”Ilookedatherandmadea
face.“Wewerethetypicalimmaturedrunkfratboysandweplayedalotofgameswithalotofgirls
withwomenandpulledalotoftricksandpranksandwell…”Myvoicetrailedoff.Iwasn’tsurehow
tocontinue.Ididn’twanttosaythewordsoutloud.Ididn’twanttotellherandweprankedyou.
“Well,what?”SheblinkedatmeandIcouldseeherthinkinghard.
“Jess,”Isaidandsighed,“Idon’tknowwhat…”Myvoicetrailedoffagain.
“Sothiswasagametoyou?”Shefrowned.“Allofthis?Everythinghasbeenagamefromthe
beginning?”Sheranherhandsacrosshereyebrowsandrubbedherforehead.“Fromthevery
beginning?Soyou’veneverbeenPierce’sdad?Youbeingintheapartmentthatday?Flirtingwith
me?Wasthatpartofthesetup?Wasthatwhenitstarted?”
“Thatwaspartofthesetup.”Inodded.“Thatwasn’twhenitstarted,though.”
“Thatwasn’twhenitstarted?”Hervoicetrailedoff.“What?Whendiditstart,then?”Hereyes
widened.“Itstartedattheclub,didn’tit?Whenhecameovertome?”
“Yeah.”Inoddedandpursedmylips.“I’msorry.”
“ButLinda…”Hervoicetrailedoff.“Howdidyougethismomtopretendyouwerethedadas
well?”
“Lindawasapaidactress,”Isaidsoftly.“I’msorry,Jess.”
“Thiswholethingwasasickjoke.Thiswholething.Oh,myGod.”Shelookedatmewithahurt
expression.“Ican’tbelieveyoudidthistome.Ican’tbelievethiswholethinghasbeenalie.This
wholetime.Howcouldyoudothistome?IthoughtIwasinlovewithyou.Ithoughtyoucouldbethe
one.Youhadmequestioningeverythingaboutmyself.YouhadmethinkingIwasgoingcrazy.You
hadmeintears.YouhadmethinkingthatIwasareallybadperson.Howcouldyoudothattome?
Howcouldyoudothattoanyhumanbeing?Howcouldyoujustnotcare?”
“Idocareaboutyou,Jess.Itkilledmeinside,butIjustdidn’tknowwhattosay.Ididn’tknowhow
totellyouthatwe’dlied.Itjustallfeltlikeitwastoomuchandthatitwastoolate.Ididn’twantyouto
hateme.Ididn’twantyoutothinkIwasahorribleman.IknewIwasplayingwithfireandItold
myselfthatitwasokay.Itoldmyselfthatwebothknewthescore.Andifwewerebothonthesame
page,itwouldbeokay.Itoldmyselfthatwecouldhavefunandneitheroneofuswouldgethurt.”
“ButIdidgethurt.Youcrushedme,Evan.Youmademefeellikeshit.YoumademefeellikeI
almostruinedafamily.Youmademefeellikesomesortofsicko.Andthenyoujustditchedmeand
mademefeellikeitwasallmyfault.Howcouldyoudothattome?”
“I’msosorry,Jess.Idon’tknowwhattosay.Itwasallfuckedfromthebeginning.Imessedup.
I’manasshole.Iknowthat.I’majerk.Ideservetobehated.Ididn’twantforyoutofallforme.I
knewIwasn’tgoodenoughforyoufromthebeginning.Iknewthat.IknewthatIcouldneverbethe
manthatyouwantedmetobe.Iwantedtomakesurethatyouleftme.Iwantedittobeonyourterms.I
wantedyoutofeelempowered.ButIthinkIendeduphurtingyoumore.AndI’msorryforthat.I’m
sorrythatIplayedthosegames.I’msorrythatImadeyouthinkIwasseeingotherwomen.Inever
metanotherwoman.Ineverdatedanotherwoman.Iwasdoingthatsoyouwouldgetmadandhate
me.Iwantedyoutohateme.Ineededyoutohateme.IneededforyoutowalkawaybecauseIwas
scared.”
“Scaredofwhat?”Hervoicewastingedwithsarcasmandhurt.
“Iwasscaredofgettinghurt.”
“Hurtbywho?”Shewasgettingangrier.“Allyoucaredaboutwasgettinglaidandtrickingme.
Ugh,whenIthinkofallthebullshityouputmethrough.Allthoseconversations?Howcouldyou?I
justdon’tgetit.Howcouldyou?”
“Jess.”Imovedclosertoher.“Idon’tknowwhattosay,butIwantyoutoknowthatIneverwanted
tohurtyou.Ineverwantedtomakeyoufeelbadinanyway.Youhavetoknowthat.Yes,inthe
beginning,Ididn’tcare.Ididn’tknowyou.Iwasn’tthinkingaboutanyofthat.Iwasjustplayinga
gamewithmyfriend.Agamewealwaysplayed.Thatwasmylife.Youhavetounderstandthat.Itwas
neverpersonaltoyou.AndthenIgottoknowyouandIrealizedyouwerespecial.Reallyspecial.
AndIdidn’twanttohurtyou.I’msorry.I’msorry.”
“Okay.”Sheshrugged.“Isthatit?Anyotherliesyouwanttotellmeabout,orcanIgo?”
“Youwanttogo?”
“Whatelsedowehavetosay,Evan?”Sheshruggedagain.“Alyssawasrightaboutyou.You’re
justanasshole.”
“I’dliketothinkIcouldchangehermindaboutthat,”Itriedtojoke,butJessdidn’tlaugh.
“Whatelsedoyouwant,Evan?”Sheglaredatme.
“I’dliketothinkthatwecouldmovepastthis?”
“Youwanttobemyfriend?”Sheburstoutlaughinghysterically.“Areyoufuckingkidding?Do
youreallythinkthatIwanttobefriendswithyou?Doyouthinkthatthat’severgoingtohappen?You
playedme.Youmakemefeelsicktomystomach.Iwantnothingtodowithyou.”
“Jess.”Igrabbedaholdofherhand,myheartbeatingfast,andIknewthatIhadneverfeltmore
worriedorscaredinmylife.“I’msorry.I’msosorry.”
“Yeah,yeah,Igetthat.”Shepulledherhandawayfromme.“Hopefullyyouwon’tdothisto
anothergirlinthefuture.”
“Jess,Iloveyou,”Isaidsoftly,almosttomyself.“Iloveyou,Jess.”Ilookedoverandintoher
eyes,andshelookedshocked.MaybeasshockedasIfeltathavingsaidthewordsoutloud.“Say
something,”IsaidtoherasIlookedather,waitingforaresponse.
“Idon’tknowwhattosay.”Hervoicewasbreathless.“Idon’tevenknowwhyyou’resayingthat.I
don’tevenknowwhattobelieve.Idon’tevenfeellikeIknowyou,Evan.”
“IguessIdeservethat,”Isaid,feelingreallydisappointed.Apartofmehadbeenhopingshe
wouldtellmethatshelovedmeaswell.Apartofmehadhopedshewouldlaughandfallintomy
armsandwe’dstartkissingandwe’dmakeloveonthegrasswithwildabandon.Yeah,mythoughts
andhopesweren’talwaysrealistic.
“I’mgoingtogo.”ShetriedtogetupagainandIgrabbedaholdofherhand.
“Youstillwanttogo?”EvenafterIjusttoldyouIloveyou?”
“Thatdoesn’tmeananythingtome,Evan.Idon’tknowwhatyouwantmetosay.”Sheshrugged,
herbrowneyeslookingatmewithuncertainty.“Whatdoyouwantfromme?”
“Howdoyoufeelaboutme?”Iaskedher,almosthesitantly.“Whatareyourfeelings?”
“Idon’tknowwhattosay.”Shepursedherlips.“WhatcanIsay?”
“Idon’tknow.”Isighedandleanedback.“TherearethingsIwanttotellyou.Thingsinside.
ThingsthatIfindithardtoshare.Thisishardforme.IknowI’vehurtyou.Iknowyoumightfindit
hardtotrustme.Iknowthat.I’mgoingtotrymybesttobeopenandhonest,though.Willyouatleast
listentome?”
“I’lllisten.”Shechewedonherlowerlipandnodded.
“I’veonlyhadoneseriousrelationshipinmylife.Myfirstyearofcollege.Shebrokemyheart.I
nearlyfailedmyclassesthatsemesterandflunkedout.Ithoughtmylifewasover.I’dneverbeen
throughanythinglikethatbefore.I’dneverfeltdespair.I’dneverknownwhatitwastonotbeableto
function.AfterthatIvowedthatIwouldn’tletanothergirlgetcloseenoughtometohurtmethatway.
SoIjoinedthefratandI’vesleptaroundandplayedgamesandneverreallycared.AndIwascontent
withmylife.Happy,even.Toanextent.AndthenImetyou.Andsomethingaboutyoudidsomething
tome.Somethingaboutyouchangedsomethinginme.AndIcouldfeelmyselfbeingdrawntoyou.I
lovedteasingyou.AndIlovedyourreactionstomeandIlovedtouchingyouandtalkingtoyouand
kissingyouandtalkingtoyou.Anditwasallgoodfun,untilIrealizedthatitwassomethingIwas
lookingforwardtoeveryday.UntilIrealizedthatyouweregrowingonmeinwaysthatmadeno
sense.WhenIrealizedthatIcaredaboutyourfeelings.Whenthesadlookonyourfacemademefeel
worried.Mademescared.WhenIstartedtofeelwhatyouwerefeeling.That’swhenIrealizedIwas
gettingintoodeepandIknewIcouldn’thavethat.IknewthatIcouldn’tfallforyou,fortworeasons:
Ididn’twantyoutohatemeforthelies,andIdidn’twantyoutofallformebecauseIdidn’tthinkI
wastheguyforyou.Ididn’tthinkIwasgoodenough.AndfranklyIwasscared.Iwasscaredtofallin
loveagain.Ididn’twanttobetiedtosomeoneelse.Ididn’twantyoutocontrolmyfeelings.Ididn’t
wanttobetiedtosomeoneelse.Ididn’twanttobeyourMr.Right.Iwasscaredaboutbeing
someone’sforevermate.Ididn’twantyoutogettoknowmeandthendropme.Iknewthatbeing
droppedbyyouwouldbemuchworsethanitwasincollege.IknewthatifIopenedmyselfuptoyou
andallowedmyselftoloveyou,itwouldkillmeifyoudidn’twantme.AndIwasright.”Ipausedand
lookedatherandIcouldseetearsinhereyes.“Jess?”Iaskedhersoftly.“Areyouokay?”
ShenoddedatmeandIgrabbedherhandandwaspleasedwhenshedidn’tpullawaythistime.“So
I’msureyou’rewonderingwhatallthismeansnow.Well,inthislastmonth,I’verealizedI’vebeena
bigfool,becauseIcouldn’tstopmyselffromhavingfeelingsforyou.Icouldn’tstopthefactthatI’d
falleninlovewithyou.AndIrealizedthatI’mafool.AndIdeserveallthehateyouhaveforme.I
deserveforyoutonevertalktomeagain.Ideserveforyoutogetupandwalkawayandneverwant
toseemeagain.”Isqueezedherfingersandthenlookedinhereyes.“Ideservethat,butI’mtelling
younowthatI’mnotgoingtowalkawayagain.Ijustwanttobewithyou.Iwillwaitforhowever
longittakes.EventhoughIdidn’twanttobeyourMr.Right,Iam.Iamthemanwhowillwaitforever
tobewithyou.Iwilldowhateveryouwantmetodo.Iwillwaitfortherestofmylifeforyouto
forgiveme.IloveyouwithallofmyheartandI’mnotscaredanymore.I’mnotscaredtoloseyou.
I’mnotscaredtonothaveyou.I’monlyscaredthatIwouldnothavetheopportunitytoshowyou
howmuchIloveyou.Iwilldowhateveryouwantmetodo.Iwillwaitaslongasyouwantmeto
wait.Iwillbehereforyou,wheneveryouneedme.Wheneveryouwantme.Iwillalwaysbeherefor
you.Iwillneverwalkaway.Iwanttoprovemyselftoyou.Iwanttoloveyouwithallmyheart.Ijust
needtoknowthatthat’sokaywithyou.Ijustneedtoknowthatmaybeonedayyoucanforgiveme.
Maybeonedayyoucangivemeachance?Doyouthinkthatyoucan?Doyouthinkthatyouwillever
beabletoforgiveme?Doyouthinkthatyoucaneverloveme?FeelwhatIfeelforyou?”
“Oh,Evan.”Hervoicecrackedasshegazedatmewithahugesmile.“Iloveyousomuch.Ilove
youmorethanwordscansay.Idon’tevenknowhowtotellyouwhatyourwordsmeantome.Idon’t
evenknowhowtotellyouhowmuchIloveyou.It’sbeenkillingmetokeepitinside.Ifeellikewe
weremadeforeachother.Doesthatmakemecrazy?”
“Notanycrazierthanme.”Ireachedoverandpulledhertowardsme,myfaceahugegrin.“ButI
likethatyou’reascrazyasme.Wecanbecrazyinlovetogether.”
“IfeellikeI’minadreamrightnow,”shesaid,rubbinghereyesbeforereachingovertokissme.
“Ican’tbelievethatthisishappening.”
“Ican’tbelievethatthisishappeningeither.Iloveyouwithallmyheartandsoul.Ineverwantto
loseyouagain.PleaseletmebeyourMr.Rightfortherestofyourlife.”
“Ofcourse.”Shesighedincontentment.“You’llalwaysbetheoneforme.I’mjustgladthatyou
finallycametoyoursenses.”
“SoamI,mydear.SoamI.”
THEEND
ThankyouforpurchasingaJ.S.Cooperbook.Ihopeyouenjoyedit.Please
tobenotifiedofallnewreleasesandtobenotifiedifIwriteafreeepiloguetoMr.Right.Youcan
emailmeat