biblioteka mysli współczesnej
5
5(3(7<725,80=&=à2:,(.$
1DXNDSUĊGNRJQLMH
z Dziadów $GDPD0LFNLHZLF]D
: XELHJá\P VWXOHFLX DQWURSRORJLD QDMUR]OHJOHMV]D ] QDXN
V]F]HJyáRZ\FK]DMĊáDPLHMVFH]UyĪQ\FKSU]\F]\QRSXV]F]R-
QHSU]H]ILOR]RILĊDMHV]F]HZF]HĞQLHM±WHRORJLĊ.RPSDUD-
W\ZQ\FKDUDNWHUWHMQDXNLMHMSUDNW\F]Q\WHUHQRZ\FKDUDNWHU
LQLH]EĊGQRĞüWHRULLMXĪZZDUVWZLHRSLVXMDNĪDGQąLQQą
XVSRVDELDá\ Mą GR VWDZLDQLD S\WDĔ R WRĪVDPRĞü F]áRZLHND
LMHJRRGUĊEQRĞüJDWXQNRZą2GSLHUZV]\FKFKZLOLVWQLHQLD
]DU\VRZDáDVLĊZQLHMU\ZDOL]DFMDGZyFKQDXNDIDNW\F]-
QLHGZyFKUDG\NDOQLHUyĪQ\FKREUD]yZĞZLDWDLVSRVREyZ
SRMPRZDQLDQDXNLDQWURSRORJLLIL]\F]QHMLNXOWXURZHM3R
NDWDVWURILH +RORNDXVWX EĊGąFHJR Z LVWRFLH XU]HF]\ZLVW-
QLHQLHP ]áRZURJLHJR SURMHNWX DQWURSRORJLF]QHJR QDZHW
]XSHáQLH QLHZLQQH RGPLDQ\ DQWURSRORJLL IL]\F]QHM ]RVWDá\
]G\VNUHG\WRZDQH
1
%HQHILFMHQWHPWHMV\WXDFMLVWDáDVLĊU]HF]
MDVQDDQWURSRORJLDNXOWXURZDNWyUDVZRMąPRUDOQąSU]HZDJĊ
QD SROX QDXN R F]áRZLHNX Z\NRU]\VW\ZDáD Z VSRVyE QLH
]DZV]H RGSRZLHG]LDOQ\
2
: UH]XOWDFLH SRGSRU]ąGNRZDQD
1
1DWHPDWUDVLVWRZVNLHJRXZLNáDQLDUR]PDLW\FKDQWURSRORJLLDWDNĪH
DPELZDOHQWQ\FKSROLW\NQDXNRZ\FKUyĪQ\FKNUDMyZHXURSHMVNLFKL86$
]RE ©Volkgeist» as Method and Ethic. Essays on Boasian Ethnography
and the German Anthropological Tradition*HRUJH:6WRFNLQJ-UUHG
0DGLVRQ8QLYHUVLW\RI:LVFRQVLQ3UHVV
2
$PHU\NDĔVND V]NRáD )UDQ]D %RDVD ]DZG]LĊF]D VZą SR]\FMĊ W\OHĪ
NDSLWDáRZL LQWHOHNWXDOQHPX MHM WZyUFyZ FR RGG]LDá\ZDQLX Z\MąWNRZR
VSU]\MDMąFHJRSRODQDXNRZHJRLSROLW\F]QHJRNRPSURPLWDFMLSURJUDPyZ
HXWDQD]\MQ\FKDPHU\NDĔVNLHMSROLW\NLmelting potL]Z\FLĊVWZDLGHDáyZ
ÄNXOWXURZHMGRJPDW\FH´ELRORJLDSU]H]EOLVNRGZLHGHNDG\
]QDMGRZDáD VLĊ Z GHIHQV\ZLH NWyUHM ĞZLDGHFWZHP PRĪH
E\ü Z\GDQ\ Z ODWDFK V]HĞüG]LHVLąW\FK L X QDV ]ELyU Rasa
a nauka
3
6\WXDFMDPXVLDáDVWDüVLĊQDSUDZGĊJURWHVNRZD
VNRURSRODWDFKMHGHQ]HZVSyáDXWRUyZWRPX&ODXGH/pYL
6WUDXVV Z DWPRVIHU]H VNDQGDOX Z 81(6&2 ]GHF\GRZDá
VLĊ VNRPHQWRZDü JR QDVWĊSXMąFR Ä$E\ Z\NRU]HQLü SU]H-
VąG\QLHZ\VWDUF]\MXĪSRZWDU]DQLHZNyáNRW\FKVDP\FK
DUJXPHQWyZSU]HFLZDQWURSRORJLLIL]\F]QHMMHMSRPLDURP
V]NLHOHWRZ\P MHM VNDORZDQLX NRORUyZ VNyU\ RF]X L ZáR-
VyZ:DOND]UDVL]PHP]DNáDGDG]LVLDMRWZDUW\GLDORJ]JH-
QHW\Ną SRSXODFML FKRFLDĪE\ GODWHJR ĪH JHQHW\F\ SRWUDILą
R ZLHOH OHSLHM QLĪ P\ >DQWURSRORG]\ NXOWXURZL ± J.T.-B@
GRZLHĞüIDNW\F]QHMDOER]DVDGQLF]HMQLHPRĪQRĞFLRNUHĞOHQLD
FRZF]áRZLHNXMHVWZURG]RQHDFRQDE\WH3RQLHZDĪMHGQDN
S\WDQLHMHVWREHFQLHIRUPXáRZDQHZMĊ]\NXQDXNLDQLHIL-
OR]RILF]QLHRGSRZLHG]LQDQLHQDZHWQHJDW\ZQHSU]HVWDMą
PLHüFKDUDNWHUGRJPDWX>@1LFWDNQLHSU]HV]NDG]DZDOFH
]UDVL]PHPRVáDELDMąFMąRGZHZQąWU]LEXG]ąFQLHVPDNMDN
WREH]FHUHPRQLDOQHQDGXĪ\ZDQLHWHUPLQX´
4
0QLHMZLĊFHMZF]DVLHJG\/pYL6WUDXVVZ\SRZLDGDáWH
VáRZDRJáRVGODDQWURSRORJLLELRORJLF]QHMEH]NRPSURPLVRZR
XSRPQLDáDVLĊVRFMRELRORJLD-HMWZyUFD(GZDUG2:LOVRQ
RGU]XFDáVDPRSRMĊFLHNRQG\FMLOXG]NLHMGHNODUXMąFĪHÄVR-
FMRORJLDLLQQHQDXNLKXPDQLVW\F]QHVąRVWDWQLPLG]LDáDPL
ELRORJLL F]HNDMąF\PL QD ZáąF]HQLH GR ZVSyáF]HVQHM V\Q-
WH]\´
5
3R W\P UHZDQĪX Z QDXNDFK R F]áRZLHNX ]DSDQR-
GHVHJUHJDFMLSR,,ZRMQLHĞZLDWRZHM]RE'HUHN)UHHPDQMargaret Mead
and Samoa. The Making and Unmaking of an Anthropological Myth&DP-
EULGJH0$+DUYDUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVVRUD]LGThe Fateful Hoaxing
of Margaret Mead. A Historical Analysis of Her Samoan Research%RXOGHU
&2:HVWYLHZ3UHVV
3
=RE/HVOLH&'XQQ2WWR.OLQHEHUJ&ODXGH/pYL6WUDXVVRasa a na-
uka. Trzy studiaWáXP-DQLQD'HPVND:DUV]DZD3:1
4
&ODXGH/pYL6WUDXVVPrzedmowaZSpojrzenie z oddaliWáXP:LQ-
FHQW\*UDMHZVNLHWDO:DUV]DZD3,:V
5
(GZDUG2:LOVRQSociobiology. The New Synthesis&DPEULGJH0$
+DUYDUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVVV.RPHQWDU]/pYL6WUDXVVDÄ7HQHJRLV-
ZDá ± L WUZD GR GQLD G]LVLHMV]HJR ± LPSDV VSRZRGRZDQ\
QLHW\ONRUR]SDF]OLZąQLHZVSyáPLHUQRĞFLąNRPSHWHQFMLDOH
LEUDNLHPGREUHMZROLSRREXVWURQDFK:Z\NRQDQLXNXOWX-
URZHJRRGáDPXDQWURSRORJLLQLHPDONDĪGDZ\SRZLHGĨRQD-
WXU]HOXG]NLHMMHVWZRSLQLLVDP\FKELRORJyZQD]QDF]RQD
RVWHQWDF\MQ\POHNFHZDĪHQLHPLFKG\VF\SOLQ\,vice versa
RLVWQLHQLXSRGREQHMWHQGHQFMLXDQWURSRORJyZIL]\F]Q\FK
XSHZQLDQLHVSRW\NDQDMHGQRP\ĞOQRĞüHWQRORJyZFRGRWHJR
ĪHÄZSUyĪQLSR]RVWDZLRQHMSU]H]ELRORJLĊMHVWPLHMVFHGOD
F D á H M >SRGNUHĞO±J.T.-B@DQWURSRORJLL´
:RVWDWQLFKGHNDGDFKSHM]DĪNU\W\F]Q\QDXNRF]áRZLHNX
VNRPSOLNRZDáVLĊGRGDWNRZRZVNXWHNSRMDZLHQLDVLĊGUXJLHM
IDOLIHPLQL]PXNWyUHJRVRMXV]]DQWURSRORJLąE\ZDUyZQLH
LQVWUXPHQWDOQ\LSURZL]RU\F]Q\MDNMHJRVRMXV]]NRQVHUZD-
W\VWDPLZVIHU]HVSRáHF]QHM
3RQDGWRGRGHEDW\ZáąF]\á\VLĊ
PQLHMOXEEDUG]LHMUDG\NDOQHRGPLDQ\HNRORJyZLREURĔFyZ
SUDZ]ZLHU]ąW]SR]\FMLPRUDOQ\FKDWDNXMąF\FKWUDG\F\MQH
G\VW\QNFMHDQWURSRORJLF]QHZW\PHW\F]QHNRQVHNZHQFMH
RGUĊEQRĞFLJDWXQNRZHMF]áRZLHND)DNWWHQPDZ\GĨZLĊN
RW\OHLURQLF]Q\ĪHZVSRPQLDQHDWDNLQDVLODMąVLĊZSRQDG
Syá ZLHNX SR QD]LVWRZVNLFK L DPHU\NDĔVNLFK SURJUDPDFK
HXJHQLF]Q\FKWRMHVWZFKZLOLJG\MXĪPDáRNRJRQLHSR-
NRLVXEZHUV\ZQD]ELHĪQRĞü6LQJHURZVNLHMNDWHJRULLÄĪ\FLH
QLHZDUWHĪ\FLD´]QD]LVWRZVNLPRNUHĞOHQLHPlebensunwertes
Leben
NZDOLILNXMąF\PGRHXWDQD]ML
W\F]Q\UDFKXQHN>PRZDRVRFMRELRORJLF]QHMNRQFHSFMLDGDSWDFMLZáąF]DMą-
FHMinclusive fitness±. J.T.-B@GRNWyUHJRGDMąVLĊVSURZDG]LüZV]\VWNLH
QLHĞZLDGRPH]DFKRZDQLDOXG]NLHZG]LZDF]Q\VSRVyESU]\ZRáXMHVWDUHJR
XSLRUDhomo oeconomicus]MDZLDMąFHJRVLĊREHFQLHZSU]HEUDQLXhomo
geneticus±OLF]ąFHJRWHUD]QDVZRMHJHQ\MDNNLHG\ĞQD]\VNL´LELGV
0DUVKDOO6DKOLQVThe Use and Abuse of Biology. An Anthropological
Critique of Sociobiology/RQGRQ7DYLVWRFNV
1DWHQWHPDW]RE5LFKDUG6KZHGHUMapy zasad moralnych, zarozu-
PLDáRĞü3LHUZV]HJRĝZLDWDLQRZLHZDQJHOLĞFLZKultura ma znaczenie.
-DN ZDUWRĞFL ZSá\ZDMą QD UR]ZyM VSRáHF]HĔVWZ /DZUHQFH ( +DUULVRQ
6DPXHO3+XQWLQJWRQUHGWáXP6áDZRPLU'\PF]\N3R]QDĔ=\VN
V
=RE3HWHU6LQJHU2Ī\FLXLĞPLHUFL8SDGHNHW\NLWUDG\F\MQHMWáXP
$QQD$OLFKQLHZLF]$QQD6]F]ĊVQD:DUV]DZD3,:]REWDNĪHZ\-
3RGF]DVJG\ELRORJLF]QHLNXOWXURZHQDXNLRF]áRZLHNX
OHNFHZDĪąVLĊQDZ]DMHPSU]HZLG\ZDOQLHRSRZLDGDMąFVLĊSR
REXVWURQDFKGHEDW\nature–nurture
RSLQLDSXEOLF]QDGR-
PDJDVLĊRGQLFKRGSRZLHG]LQDS\WDQLDZURG]DMXÄ©&RWR
MHVWĪ\FLHRGNLHG\LGODF]HJR"ª©'ODF]HJRLVWQLHMHĞPLHUü
L FLHUSLHQLH"ª ©&R MHVW GREU]H F]\QLü D FR ĨOH"ª ©-DNLH
FHOH Vą VáXV]QH D MDNLH QLH"ª L ©-DN SRZLQQLĞP\ P\ĞOHü
F]XüLG]LDáDü"ª´
3RPLMDMąFHNVFHQWU\NyZĪDGHQV]DQX-
MąF\VLĊEDGDF]QLHEĊG]LHDVSLURZDáGRUR]VWU]\JDQLDW\FK
NZHVWLL1HLO3RVWPDQSU]\WRPQLH]DXZDĪDĪHQDSU]\NáDG
MHĞOLFKRG]LRSRF]ąWHNĪ\FLDQDXNDPRĪHQDPSRZLHG]LHü
NLHG\]DF]\QDELüVHUFHNLHG\]DF]\QDMąVLĊUXFK\DOERMDNLH
VąGDQHVWDW\VW\F]QHQDWHPDWSU]HĪ\ZDOQRĞFLSáRGyZZUyĪ-
Q\PZLHNXSR]DRUJDQL]PHPPDWNLDOHÄQLHPDZLĊNV]HM
QLĪW\LMDZáDG]\E\XVWDQDZLDüNU\WHULDWDNLHMDN©SUDZ-
G]LZDªGHILQLFMDĪ\FLDEąGĨPRPHQWRGNWyUHJR]DF]\QDVLĊ
F]áRZLHF]HĔVWZROXERVREDOXG]ND1DXNLVSRáHF]QHPRJą
QDV SRLQIRUPRZDü MDN ]DFKRZXMą VLĊ OXG]LH Z REHFQRĞFL
NRJRĞNRJRXZDĪDMą]DSU]HGVWDZLFLHODSUDZRPRFQHMZáD-
G]\DOHQLHPRJąQDPSRZLHG]LHüNLHG\>@SRVáXV]HĔVWZR
ZáDG]\MHVWU]HF]ąVáXV]QąNLHG\]DĞQLH´
=ZUDFDQLHVLĊGRQDXNL]SRGREQ\PLS\WDQLDPLMHVWMDN
PyZL3RVWPDQR]QDNąÄVFMHQW\]PXQDSR]LRPLHNXOWXUR-
Z\P´F]\OLPyZLąFSROXG]NXZLHONLHMELHG\ZGXV]DFK
ZLDG6áDZRPLUD=DJyUVNLHJRL7RPDV]DĩXUDG]NLHJR]6LQJHUHP1LHNDĪGH
Ī\FLHMHVWZDUWHĪ\FLDÄ*D]HWD:\ERUF]D´±OXWHJRLSRU]WHUPLQR-
ORJLąQDSU]\NáDGZSUDF\(ORID$[HOD&DUOVRQDThe Unfit. A History of Bad
Idea&ROG6SULQJ+DUERU1<&ROG6SULQJ+DUERU/DERUDWRU\3UHVV
OXE Z SRSXODUQRQDXNRZ\P RSUDFRZDQLX (GZLQD %ODFND Wojna przeciw
VáDE\P(XJHQLNDLDPHU\NDĔVNDNDPSDQLDQDU]HF]VWZRU]HQLDUDV\SDQyZ
WáXP+DQQD-DQNRZVND:DUV]DZD 0X]D
'HEDWD WD NWyUHM QD]ZĊ Z ZROQ\P SU]HNáDG]LH PRĪQD RGGDü MDNR
G\OHPDW ÄJHQ\ F]\ Z\FKRZDQLH´ ]RVWDáD V]F]HJyáRZR ]DSUH]HQWRZDQD
ZSUDF\]ELRURZHMSexual Meanings. The Cultural Construction of Gender
and Sexuality6KHUU\%2UWQHU+DDUULHW:KLWHKHDGUHG&DPEULGJH±1HZ
<RUN&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV
1HLO 3RVWPDQ 7HFKQRSRO 7ULXPI WHFKQLNL QDG NXOWXUą WáXP$QQD
7DQDOVND'XOĊED:DUV]DZD0X]DV
INFOTAINMENT
1DXNRZF\]UHJXá\RULHQWXMąVLĊQDMDNLHS\WDQLDLFKSUR-
FHGXU\GDMąRGSRZLHGĨDQDMDNLHQLH'ODF]HJRZLĊFQLH
SURWHVWXMąJG\SUH]\GHQW5HDJDQRĞZLDGF]DLĪÄRVRELĞFLH
MHVWSU]HNRQDQ\ĪHDERUFMDMHVW]áHPDOHQDXFHPXVLP\SR-
]RVWDZLüRU]HF]HQLHNLHG\SáyGMHVWMXĪLVWRWąĪ\Zą´
11
"-DN
Z\WáXPDF]\üRZąQDGUHSUH]HQWDFMĊHNVSHUWyZRGF]áRZLHND
ÄQDHNUDQDFKQDV]\FKWHOHZL]RUyZQDOLVWDFKEHVWVHOOHUyZ
LZG]LDáDFKVDPRSRPRF\ZVWRLVNDFKNVLĊJDUVNLFKQDORWQL-
VNDFK´"'ODF]HJRZPHGLDFKWDNU]DGNRZLG]LVLĊXF]RQHJR
NWyU\RGPDZLDZ]LĊFLDXG]LDáXZinfotainment±LQIRUPDFML
QLHRGUyĪQLDOQHMRGUR]U\ZNL"&]\QLHGODWHJRĪHSRS\WZ\-
WZDU]DSRGDĪLMHĞOLEDGDF]QLHSU]\MPLHUHJXáG\NWRZDQ\FK
SU]H]PHGLDXWUDFLLWDNMXĪRJUDQLF]RQąUROĊDXWRU\WDW\Z-
QHJRNRPHQWDWRUD
12
":WHQZáDĞQLHVSRVREPHGLDOQDHSLVWH-
PRORJLDZSá\ZDQDNV]WDáWG]LVLHMV]HMQDXNL
1HLO 3RVWPDQ IRUPXáXMH ]DVDGĊ ] NWyUą ]JRG]LáRE\ VLĊ
ZLHOXEDGDF]\WHFKQRORJLLRG3ODWRQDGR-DFND*RRG\¶HJR
NDĪGHQRZHPHGLXP]PLHQLD]QDF]HQLHFDáHJRSRSU]HG]D-
MąFHJRMHVáRZQLNDÄ7HOHZL]MD]PLHQLáDVHQVWHJRFRQLH-
JG\ĞR]QDF]DáR©GHEDWĊSXEOLF]Qąª©ZLDGRPRĞFLª©RSLQLĊ
SXEOLF]Qąª.RPSXWHU]QyZ]PLHQLD©LQIRUPDFMĊª3LVPR
]PLHQLáRWRFRQLHJG\ĞUR]XPLHOLĞP\SU]H]©SUDZGĊªL©SUD-
ZRª´
13
2WRMHGQD]SU]\SRZLHĞFLRSUDZG]LHZGRELHWHOHZL]ML
:\REUDĨP\VRELH]Z\Ná\G]LHĔURNXLS\WDQLDQĊNDMąFH
OXG]LÄ&]\JUR]LQDPZRMQD"´Ä&]\in vitro MHVWHW\F]QH"´
Ä&]\(XURSDSU]HWUZD"´:ĞZLHFLHQĊNDQ\PSRGREQ\PL
SUREOHPDPLWHOHZLG]RZLHQLHĪ\F]ąVRELHVFHSW\F]QHMSUDZ-
G\F]\OLNROHMQHMRSRZLHĞFLOXG]LUyZQ\FKVRELHQDZHWWD-
11
,ELG
12
0LFKDHO +HU]IHOG Antropologia. Praktykowanie teorii w kultur-
]H L VSRáHF]HĔVWZLH WáXP 0DULD 0 3LHFKDF]HN .UDNyZ :\GDZ
8QLZHUV\WHWX-DJLHOORĔVNLHJRV
13
1HLO3RVWPDQTechnopolV