A
LSOBY
R
ICHARD
G
ROSSMAN
BoldVoices
Choosing&Changing
TheOtherMedicines
TheNaturalFamilyDoctor(withAndrewStanway)
AYearwithEmerson
ForRedSchillerandforShantiNorris
All philosophy, of East and West, has the same
centripetence.
—E
MERSON
,RepresentativeMen
AN
OTETOTHE
R
EADER
Thisisonebook,butwithinitaretwomanuscripts.Thefirst,
printedinitalicsontheleft-hand(verso)pages,isbasedonthe
classical1891renditionoftheeighty-oneversesofthesacred
Chinese text known as the Tao Te Ching, credited to a sage
called Lao Tse and translated by the British Sinologist James
Legge. On the right-hand (recto) pages is the “second”
manuscript(inromantype),thesameeighty-oneversesofthe
TaoTeChing,interpretedinwordsculledandorganizedbyme
from the writings of Ralph Waldo Emerson, the great
nineteenth-centuryAmericanphilosopherandpoet.
The inspiration for creating these parallel texts comes from
the epigraph to this book—“all philosophy, of East and West,
has the same centripetence”—an observation recorded by
EmersoninhisessayonPlatowhenhewasthirty-threeyears
old,andalreadyontheroadtobecoming“America’sFounding
Thinker.” Centripetence, of course, refers to the tendency of
energytomoveorprogresstowardthecenter,totheessenceof
things. As Emerson later wrote, “the hero is he who is
immovablycentered,”andasLaoTseputit,“yourinnerbeing
guard,andkeepitfree”—bothmenstandingforwhatEmerson
would later call the “infinitude of the human soul.” This
veneration of both the depths and heights of the human soul
blossomsintheirwritingsintoacredofortheconductoflife
thatelevatesquietude,self-awareness,humility,andreverence
forthenaturalworldtosuchalevelthatithascaptivatedand
inspiredgenerationsofmenandwomen.Thevaluescontained
withinthewordsthesesageswrote,nomatterhowcrypticor
mysticaltheymayseeminsomeinstances,havegivenrisetoa
kind of “spiritual anthropology,” focused first on a site in
ancientChinahousingarelicdocumentover2,500yearsold,
andsecondonabodyofworkcreatedbyapoet/philosopherin
the quite early days of a new and animated country in the
Westernworld.Eachsetofwritingshascaptivatedandinspired
seekerstorevisitthemandprobetheirwisdominsearchofa
guidingpersonaltruth.
This book is an effort to bring together these two kindred
works.UsingfragmentsofEmerson’swritingsranginginlength
from a phrase to an entire passage, I have tried to construct
new poetic interpretations of Lao Tse’s words. It is not the
intentofthisrenditionoftheTaoTeChingthroughtheprose
andpoetryofRalphWaldoEmersontocreateanamusingword
game by plundering the works of Emerson with a pair of
scissors.Anygreatwriter’swordscan,bysuchmanipulation,be
madetoreproducetheworkofanyotherwriter.
Inthisinstance,theprocessbywhichEmerson’swritingsare
shownasparalleltotheversesoftheTaoTeChingisonein
which the shared sense and spirit and philosophy of the two
men is displayed. To do this I spent a great deal of time
immersed alternately in the work of the two authors, and
recollectingthecomparablethoughtsIdiscoveredineach.For
instance,inChapter2oftheTaoTeChing,whichisintendedto
lay out the Taoist notions of complementarity (the yin/yang
principle), a close student of Emerson thinks immediately of
Emerson’sessay“Compensation,”devotedatleastinparttothe
sameidea:theuniverseischaracterizedbytheswaybetween
nonantagonistic, but opposite forces, “as: spirit, matter; man,
woman; odd, even; motion, rest….” Thus, Chapter 2 in my
“translation” employs five sentences taken from the
“Compensation”essay.Butthereisadeeperconnectiontobe
seenwhenthededicatedreaderofEmersonrecallsthathealso
exploredthisthemeinotherplaces:inhispoem“EachandAll,”
forinstance,andinhisaddress“TheMethodofNature”aswell
as in his essay “Spiritual Laws.” Thus, one or more sentences
from those sources become the Emersonian “version” of the
sacred Taoist text. Conversely, in my daily rereading of
Emerson,Ihighlightedanyphrasethatformehadtheringof
theTaoistmaster.Inthislatterprocess,forexample,asIread
the phrase, “I am a weed by the wall” in Emerson’s essay
“Circles,” I heard immediately the reverberation of the self-
deprecatingtoneofLaoTseinChapter20,“Ialoneseemlistless
andstill…”
Thefocusofthisendeavor,then,isnotsomuchonLaoTse’s
and Emerson’s similarities of verbal expression as it is on the
wonderful ways in which philosophical ideas appear and
reappear throughout history and across cultures, and are
enrichedineachnewincarnation.
C
ONTENTS
L
ISTOF
I
LLUSTRATIONS
Thelargecharacteris“Tao;”thethreecharactersnexttoTao
I
NTRODUCTION
Over 120 translations of the Tao Te Ching
English since 1891. It has lured a variety of Sinologists, poets,
philosophers,scientists,andscholarstotryagainandagaintoplumbits
cryptic,provocativetextfordeepermeaningsandfornuancesthatmight
make the wisdom of Lao Tse either more accessible, more modern, or
more personally relevant to the Western reader. Some have wished to
make the poetry more pronounced; others have wanted to make the
translation more precisely like the original Mandarin language; still
othershavetriedtomaketheTaoTeChingamorereligiousdocument,
akindofTaoistBible.
Almost all the translators of the Tao Te Ching, including James
Legge,
whose translation is used in this book, called their work
“interpretations,”acknowledgingtheenduringfactthatitisimpossible
forthelanguageofonetraditiontoprovideexactverbalequivalentsfor
allthecreativeideasofanothertradition.InTheTaoofEmersonIhave
not had to be concerned with “verbal equivalency” because I have
concentratednotsomuchonthewordsoftheTaoTeChing,butrather
on the ideas embedded in them. I have taken this approach because,
aftermanyyearsofreadingandstudyingboththeideasofLaoTse,the
rural mystic, and the works of the Sage of Concord, I have become
convinced that in a mysterious but remarkable way, Ralph Waldo
Emerson,aself-defrockedAmericanministerofthenineteenthcentury,
evolvedapersonalworldviewandphilosophicalstancesoparalleltothe
Tao Te Ching that his own oeuvre of over forty volumes of poetry,
lectures, addresses, personal journals, and notebooks contains the
essenceofthesacredancienttext.
These two men, separated in history by almost 2,500 years, one a
citizenoftheworld’soldestempireandtheotherofoneofitsyoungest
republics, were sages whose messages were remarkably alike: live the
simple, tranquil life; trust your intuition; find and revere the spiritual
grace in the natural world; act without self-assertion; commit no
violenceagainstlivingthingsorpersons;trytoharmonizewiththeebb
andflowofnatureandcircumstances—andaboveall,assurethatthere
isaplaceintheworldforhumility,yielding,gentleness,andserenity.
One reason for their kinship may be found in the study of the
prophetictradition.ThescholarRichardGroff,whodescribesprophets
as“articulatemystics,”hadthistosay:
Throughtheagesresoundthe voicesoftheprophets, the
authenticmen.Wemaynotknowthetongueofthewise
man,butwealwaysrecognizehisvoice….Jesus,Buddha,
LaoTse,Socrates,Fox,Emerson—workedatthetasksthey
feltwerelaiduponthembyahigherauthority,taskswhich
they were not at liberty to set aside. For countless
generations those seeking to find their way in darkness
havefoundlampsinthelivesofmenlikethese….Prophet,
saint, sage, savior—the differences among them are lost
amidtheirsimilarities.Forgetthelabels.Wisdomiswhere
youfindit.
ItseemstomethatEmersonvirtuallyreincarnatedLaoTse’swisdom
in his own work, and that his brand of fresh, vigorous, homegrown
EnglishaddsaradiantcolortothewordsofLaoTse.Emersonhimself,in
his essay “History,” noted that “Nature is full of sublime family
likenesses throughout her works … and there are compositions of the
samestraintobefoundinthebooksofallages.”Hisownobservation
suggeststhatanEmersonianrenditionoftheTaoTeChingmighthavea
specialresonanceforthemodernreader.
TheTaoTeChing—pronounceddowasindowel,der,asintheslightly
slurredlastsyllableofunder,andjing,asinjingo—isashortandsimple
bookfilledwithaphorisms,epigrams,folkwisdom,andwhatonewriter
has called “polemic proverbs,” all concerned with the mystery and
beautyoftheuniverse,accompaniedbyprofoundadviceonhowhuman
beings might negotiate that universe in a fruitful, peaceful, and
ultimatelytranscendentway.
WiththeHolyBibleandtheBhagavadGita,theTaoTeChingisoneof
thethreemosttranslatedbooksinallofhumanhistory,despitethefact
that its authorship, its date, and the circumstances of its original
publication are still debated among scholars worldwide. There is,
however, no argument that it was published in ancient China, around
571B.C.,afactconfirmedasrecentlyas1993,whenfourteeninscribed
strips of bamboo containing about 40 percent of the known text (to
whichtwotranslators,RogerT.AmesandDavidL.Hall,havegiventhe
titleTheGreatOneGivesBirthtotheWaters)werediscoveredinaroyal
tutor’stombatGuodian,nearthecityofYing,oncethecapitalofthe
southernkingdomofChu.
WhatisalsoascertainasthephysicalhistoryoftheTaoTeChing—a
titlethatisgenerallytakentomean“TheClassicBookoftheWayandIts
Power,” or “The Classic Book of the Ultimate Reality and Its Ideal
Manifestation”—istheuniversalmagnetismithasexertedonreadersfor
centuries. Whatever historical arguments surround its roots, the little
more than five thousand words of its text have been consistently
recognized as among the most provocative and inspiring mystic
teachings ever written. Whether rendered as rhyming verses
or short
chaptersofprose,thecryptic,paradoxical,andyetsimpleandpowerful
text sets forth the central themes of Taoist thought as the British
philosopher Bertrand Russell saw and admired them: “Production
without possession, action without self-assertion, and development
withoutdomination.”Inourcurrentageofspiritualquesting,religious
revisionism, and political and military conflicts, the Tao Te Ching
continues to offer seekers a fascinating framework in which to pursue
the paths to peaceful prosperity, the possibility of reincarnation, the
confirmation(ordisconfirmation)oftheexistenceofthesoul,theright
waytogovernwith“alighthand,”the“moralequivalenttowar,”and
othereternalquestionsoflife’smeaning.
Thisgreatworkcontinuestobeabeaconforthemodernreadereven
thoughtheTaoTeChingwaswritteninanancientMandarindialectthat
is no longer spoken, and the text arose in a cultural background even
more different from our modern Western environment than
contemporary China is. The thoughts of Lao Tse remain influential
aroundtheworld,aswitnessed,forexample,bythecontinuingspreadof
interest in and practice of Zen Buddhism, which owes much of its
groundwork to Taoist principles as offered in the Tao Te Ching.
Likewise,millionsofunaffiliatedmenandwomenwhopursueaspiritual
searchforadeepermeaningtothehumanconditionturntotheeighty-
oneversesorchaptersthatmakeupthisclassic.
The original text was divided into two parts, the first thirty-seven
chaptersbeingconsideredthe“Upper”part,devotedtoTao,whichisthe
supreme, cosmic, indestructible energy or universal force (or what, in
theisticsystems,issuggestedbythewordGod).Thesecond,or“Lower,”
partofforty-fourversesdealswithTe,themanifestation,thebehavior,
theshapeandthepoweroftheTao.Inpurely
Western,modemtermswemightsaythatTaoiswhatwecallNature,
and Te is the way Nature works in her many forms and actualities.
(Chingisthetermdesignatingaclassic,orsacredtext.)
The name Lao Tse (really “The Old Boy”) was an honorific given a
man who was probably born in a town some fifty miles south of the
moderncityofShangchui;professionallyhewasanarchivist,orKeeper
of Royal Documents, in the dynasty capital of Loyang. His real name
may have been Li Erh; posthumously he was given two additional
honorificnames:Tan(meaning“long-eared,”andhence,wise)andthe
provocativeappellation“PrincePositive.”Inspiteofhismodest,though
respected,stationinlife,hewaswidelyknownasasage,butdespairing
of the decadence of the dynasty, he chose to leave his homeland and
head west. Legend has it that when he reached Hanku, the most
formidable pass in all of China, his arrival had been foretold, and the
Warden of the Pass, Yin-hsi, implored the great man for some
instruction, whereupon Lao Tse gave him the Tao Te Ching, and
continued on to unknown regions of the far west. This event is
affectionatelydescribedbytheplaywrightandpoetBertoltBrechtinhis
little-knownworkLegendoftheOriginoftheBookTao-Te-ChingonLao-
Tse’sRoadintoExile,thelaststanzaofwhichis:
Butthehonorshouldnotberestricted
Tothesagewhosenameisclearlywrit.
Forawiseman’swisdomneedstobeextracted.
Sothecustommandeserveshisbit,
Itwashewhocalledforit.
ButEmersonknewnothingofthecharminglegendofLaoTseorthe
Taoistphilosophyitspawned.TheTaoTeChingwasnottobeavailable
inEnglishuntil1891,nineyearsafterhisdeath.Thus,ifheevereven
encountered the word Tao it was in his reading of Confucius, a man
twenty years junior to Lao Tse, whose Analects is the literary and
philosophical counterpoint to the Tao Te Ching, and whose followers
dominatedthesocialandpoliticalstructureofChinainthelatesixthand
earlyfifthcenturyB.C.Bythattime,asArthurKirbyhassaid,“Chinese
wisdom expressed itself in the outward symbolical relation of each
individualtotheEmperorandtheTao,notinthoughtsabouttheTao;
for the early spirit of Lao Tse had died in the letter….”
The
ConfucianismEmersonreadaboutandadmired(“Iamreadingabetter
Pascal”)wasimpressivetohimbecauseitappearedtoemphasizecivic
duty, moral education, and “the efficacy of the good example of the
superiorman.”AndsurelyEmersonandConfuciuswerelinkedbytheir
common belief in what Emerson once called “the infinitude of the
Asiaticsoul.”
Butinpractice,ConfucianismwasnotaphilosophytowhichEmerson
couldhavewhollysubscribed,sinceitwasalmostexclusivelyconcerned
withsocietalstructure,worldlytransactions,codifiedrulesofbehavior,
and what might be called patriarchal politics. While many of these
themes interested Emerson, they all fall into the realm of “Society,”
whichforhimwasonlyapartofhumanreality,needingalwaystobe
counterpoisedwith“Solitude,”whereintherichnessofthespirituallife
becomespossible.SoitiswiththecontrastbetweenConfuciusandLao
Tse—the former standing for stern authority, official discipline, the
pursuit of “fame and reputation,” where the latter sees all these
characteristics as “so many handcuffs and fetters,” preferring to stress
theconnectionbetweenatranscendentNatureandthematerialdiversity
oftheuniverse,orthewell-known“tenthousandthings.”
The Chinese-American philosopher and scientist Lin Yutang saw this
when he wrote in his authoritative The Wisdom of China and India,
“Generally, the reader will find reading Chinese philosophers like
reading the best intuitive passages in Emerson.”
doubtlessthinkingprimarilyofLaoTse,theauthoroftheTaoTeChing.
Forinallhiswork,Emersontheparadoxical(“thehighestprudenceis
the lowest prudence”), Emerson the mystical (“the world is but the
incarnationofathought”),Emersontheexistential(“Youareyou,andI
amI”),Emersonthepresent-centered(“Lifeonlyavails,notthehaving
lived”), Emerson the epigrammatist (“a foolish consistency is the
hobgoblinoflittleminds”)isnotcomparabletotheordered,compulsive
positivist Confucius, but rather to the flowing, spontaneous lover of
analogiesandallusions,thenaturalisticandmysticLaoTse.
The Viennese cultural historian Egon Friedell caught these atavistic
“Oriental” qualities of Emerson’s personality and style in his book A
CulturalHistoryoftheModernAge:
Hisspiritualrhythmremindsone…ofthegentleflowing
of a meadow stream that hollows its bed slowly and
peacefully….Heholdshiscandledirectlyuptothingsand
looksthemstraightinthefacelikeahealthymanwhois
not cowed by learned traditions…. He is an absolute
Impressionistinhisstyle,hiscomposition,andhisthought.
He never propounds his ideas in a definite, logical or
artisticform,butalwaysinthenaturalandoftenaccidental
orderwhichtheyhaveinhishead….
He knows only provisional opinions, momentary
truths…. He begins to develop this or that view, and we
thinkheisgoingontoweaveitsystematically,elucidateit
from all sides, entrench it against all possible attack. But
then, suddenly some alien picture or simile, epigram or
aperçu strikes him full in the middle of his chain of
thought,andthethemethenceforwardrevolvesonquitea
newaxis….
ThismightbeanexegesisoftheTaoTeChingitself,emphasizingasit
does the loose presentation of sage ideas, the intuitive confidence, the
informalityanddirectness,theearthyframeofreference,andultimately,
thesimplicityofthewiseman.AndagainweareremindedofbothLao
TseandEmersonwhenFriedellsaysofthelatter,“Hestopsstill,listens
tohisheart,andwritesashelistens….”
Notes
.Since1976thepreferredmethodofromanizingtheChineselanguage
hasbeenthepinyinsystem,whichrendersLaoTseasLaozi,andhis
bookastheDaoDeJing(whichis,infact,thewaythetitleis
pronounced,evenwhenwrittenastheTaoTeChing).WheneverChinese
wordsoccurinthisvolume,IhavechosentousetheolderWade-Giles
systemofRomanizationbecauseitwasinusethroughoutthenineteenth
century,whenbothJamesLeggeandEmersonlived.
.JamesLegge(1815-1897)wasanearcontemporaryofEmerson,who
wasbornin1803anddiedin1882.Thetwonevermetonanyof
Emerson’svisitstoEngland.AScotch-Presbyterianminister,Leggefirst
wenttoChinain1839asamissionaryFornearlythirtyyearshelivedin
variouspartsofChina,wherehestudiedandtranslatedmanyofthe
greatChineseclassics.Thisworkculminatedinhisdeveloping,withF.
MaxMuller,themonumentalSacredBooksoftheEastseries,publishedin
fiftyvolumesbetween1879and1891,ofwhichVolume39isLegge’s
translationoftheTaoTeChing.LeggeheldthechairinChinese
languageandliteratureatOxfordUniversityfortwentyyears.
.Groff,Richard.ThoreauandthePropheticTradition.LosAngeles:The
ManasPublishingCo.,1961.
.InthisbookbothJamesLegge’stranslationoftheTaoTeChingand
theversionIhavegleanedfromthewritingsofRalphWaldoEmerson
aresetmainlyasfreeverse,followingthecustominthevastmajorityof
translationsofLaoTse’sclassicsincethefirstone,writteninLatin,in
1788.
.Brecht,Bertolt.Poems1913-1956.EditedbyJohnWillettandRalph
ManheimwiththecooperationofErichFried.LondonandNewYork:
Methuen,1980.
.Christy,Arthur.TheOrientinAmericanTranscendentalism.NewYork:
OctagonRooks,1978.
.LinYutang.TheWisdomofChinaandIndia.NewYork:RandomHouse,
TheTaoofEmerson
1
TheTaothatcanbetroddenisnotthe
enduringandunchangingTao.
Thenamethatcanbenamedisnotthe
enduringandunchangingname.
Conceivedashavingnoname,
itistheOriginatorofheavenandearth;
Havinganame,itistheMotherofallthings.
Alwayswithoutdesirewemustbefound,
Ifitsdeepmysterywewouldsound;
Butifdesirewithinusbe,
Itsouterfringeisallthatweshallsee.
Underthesetwoaspects
itisreallythesame;
Butasdevelopmenttakesplace
itreceivesthedifferentnames.
TogetherwecallthemtheMystery.
WheretheMysteryisthedeepest
isthegateofallthatissubtleandwonderful.
Thatgreatnatureinwhichwerest,
thatUnity,thatOver-Soul,
IsanImmensitynotpossessed,
andthatcannotbepossessed.
Theanimaleyesees,withwonderful
accuracy,
sharpoutlinesandcoloredsurfaces.
Toamoreearnestvision,
outlinesandsurfaces
becometransparent;
Causesandspirits
areseenthroughthem.
Thewisesilence,
theuniversalbeauty,
Towhicheverypartandparticle
isequallyrelated,
Isthetideofbeingwhichfloatsus
intothesecretofnature;
Andwestandbefore
thesecretoftheworld.
2
Allintheworldknowthebeautyofthebeautiful,
Andindoingthistheyhavetheideaofwhatuglinessis;
Theyallknowtheskilloftheskillful,
Andindoingthistheyhavetheideaofwhat
thewantofskillis.
Soitisthatexistenceandnon-existencegivebirth
onetotheother,
Difficultyandeaseproduceeachother,
Lengthandshortnessfashionoutthefigureoftheother;
Heightandlownessarisefromthecontrastof
theonewiththeother;
Musicalnotesandtonesbecomeharmonious
throughtherelationofonetotheother;
Beingbeforeandbehindgivetheideaof
onefollowinganother.
Thereforethesagemanagesaffairswithoutdoinganything,
andconveyshisinstructionswithouttheuseofspeech.
Theworkisdone,buthownoonecansee;
Tisthisthatmakesthepowernotceasetobe.
Eachthingisahalf,andsuggestsanotherthing
tomakeitwhole.
As:spirit,matter;
man,woman;odd,even;
in,out;upper,under;
motion,rest;yea,nay.
Allareneededbyeachone.
Nothingisfairorgoodalone;
Toemptyhere,youmustcondensethere.
Agreatmanisalwayswillingtobelittle;
Thewisemanthrowshimselfontheside
ofhisassailants;
Postponesalwaysthepresenthour
tothewholelife,
Postponestalenttogenius,
andspecialresultstocharacter,
Isverywillingtoloseparticularpowers
andtalents
Sothathegainintheelevation
ofhislife.
Actionandinactionarealiketothetrue.
3
Nottoemploymenofsuperiorability
isthewaytokeepthepeoplefromrivalryamongthemselves;
Nottoprizearticleswhicharedifficulttoprocure
isthewaytokeepthemfrombecomingthieves;
Nottoshowthemwhatislikelytoexcitetheirdesires
isthewaytokeeptheirmindsfromdisorder.
Thereforethesage,intheexerciseofhisgovernment,
emptiestheirminds,fillstheirbellies,
weakenstheirwillsandstrengthenstheirbones.
Heconstantlytriestokeepthemwithoutknowledge
andwithoutdesire,
Andwheretherearethosewhohaveknowledge,
tokeepthemfrompresumingtoactonit.
Whenthereisthisabstinencefromaction
goodorderisuniversal.
Nothingissecurebutlife,transition,
theenergizingspirit.
Theonethingwhichweseek
withinsatiabledesire
Istoforgetourselves,tobesurprised
outofourpropriety,
Toloseoursempiternalmemory
Anddosomethingwithoutknowing
howorwhy.
Notruthissosublimebutitmaybe
trivialtomorrow.
Peoplewishtobesettled;
Onlyasfarastheyareunsettled
isthereanyhopeforthem.
Thepoorandthelowhavetheirway
ofexpressingthelastfactsofphilosophy:
“Blessedbenothing.Theworsethingsare
thebettertheyare.”
4
TheTaoisliketheemptinessofavessel;
Andinouremploymentofitwemust
guardagainstallfullness.
Howdeepandunfathomableitis,
asifitweretheHonoredAncestorofallthings!
Weshouldbluntoursharppoints,
Andunravelthecomplicationofthings;
Weshouldtemperourbrightness,
Andbringourselvesintoagreement
withtheobscurityofothers.
HowpureandstilltheTaois,asifitwould
eversocontinue.
Thereisneverabeginning,
Thereisneveranend
totheinexplicablecontinuityofthisweb.
Systemonsystem,shootinglikerays,
upward,downward,
withoutcenter,withoutcircumference.
Inthemassandintheparticle,
Naturehastenstorenderaccountofherself.
Undereverycause,anothercause;
Truthsoarstoohighanddivestoodeep
forthemostresoluteinquirer.
5
Heavenandearthdonotactfromanywish
tobebenevolent.
Theydealwithallthingsasthedogsofgrass
aredealtwith.
Maynotthespacebetweenheavenandearth
becomparedtoabellows?
Tisemptied,yetitlosesnotitspower;
Tismovedagain,andsendsforthairthemore.
Muchspeechtoswiftexhaustionleadwesee;
Yourinnerbeingguard,andkeepitfree.
Wefindnaturetobethecircumstance
whichdwarfseveryothercircumstance,
Andjudgeslikeagod
allmenwhocometoher.
Thereisnoendinnature,
Buteveryendisabeginning;
Thereisalwaysanotherdawnrisenonmid-noon,
Andundereverydeepalowerdeepopens.
Goodasisdiscourse,
Silenceisbetter,andshamesit.
6
Thevalleyspiritdiesnot,ayethesame;
Thefemalemysterythusdowename,
Itsgate,fromwhichatfirsttheyissuedforth,
Iscalledtherootfromwhichgrewheavenand
earth.
Longandunbrokendoesitspowerremain,
Usedgently,andwithoutthetouchofpain.
Inshowers,insweepingshowers,theSpring
visitsthevalley,
Themiracleofgenerativeforce,
Far-reachingconcordsofastronomy.
Natureistranscendental,
everworksandadvances.
Itisundefinable,unmeasurable,
Butweknowthatitpervadesandcontainsus.
7
Heavenislongenduringandearthcontinueslong.
Thereasonwhyheavenandearthareabletoendure
andcontinuethuslong
Isbecausetheydonotliveof,orfor,themselves.
Thisishowtheyareabletocontinueandendure.
Thereforethesageputshisownpersonlast,
Andyetitisfoundintheforemostplace;
Hetreatshispersonasifitwereforeigntohim,
Andyetthatpersonispreserved.
Isitnotbecausehehasnopersonalandprivateends,
thatthereforesuchendsarerealized?
Theuniverseisrepresentedinanatom
inamomentoftime.
Itcallsthelightitsown,andfeels
thatthegrassgrowsandthestonefalls,
Yettakesnothoughtforthemorrow.
Geniusandvirtuepredictinman
thesameabsenceofprivateends,
andofcondescensiontocircumstance,
Unitedwitheverytraitandtalent
ofbeautyandpower.
Thepathwhichtheherotravelsalone
isthehighwayofhealthandbenefittomankind.
Whatistheprivilegeandnobilityofournature
butitspersistency,
Throughitspowertoattachitself
towhatispermanent?
8
Thehighestexcellenceislikethatofwater.
Theexcellenceofwaterappearsinitsbenefitingallthings,
andinitsoccupying,withoutstriving,
thelowplacewhichallmendislike.
HenceitswayisneartothatoftheTao.
Theexcellenceofaresidenceisinthesuitabilityoftheplace;
thatofthemindisinabysmalstillness;
thatofassociationsisintheirbeingwiththevirtuous;
thatofgovernmentisinitssecuringgoodorder;
thatoftheconductofaffairsisinitsability;
andthatofanymovementisinitstimeliness.
Andwhenonewiththehighestexcellence
Doesnotwrangleabouthislowposition,
noonefindsfaultwithhim.
Justiceistherhymeofthings;
Tradeandcountinguse
Theself-sametunefulmuse.
Waterwasthebeginningofallthings.
Itisinthatsameliquidstate
thatsubstancesuniteto
andidentifythemselveswithorganizedbodies.
Theaimofthewisemanwillalwaysbe
tosethistimeonsuchakeyashecanhold,
tobringhislifelevelwiththelawsofthemind,
notthebody.
9
Itisbettertoleaveavesselunfilled
thantoattempttocarryitwhenitisfull.
Ifyoukeepfeelingapointthathasbeensharpened,
thepointcannotlongpreserveitssharpness.
Whengoldandjadefillthehall,
theirpossessorcannotkeepthemsafe.
Whenwealthandhonorsleadtoarrogance,
thisbringsitsevilonitself.
Whentheworkisdone,andone’sname
isbecomingdistinguished,
towithdrawintoobscurity
isthewayofHeaven.
Allthetoysthatinfatuatemen—
houses,land,money,luxury,
power,fame—
aretheself-samething.
Themanwhoseeyesarenailed,
notonthenatureofhisact,
Butonthewages,whetheritbe
moneyorofficeorfame,
isequallylow.
Naturearmseachmanwithsomefaculty
whichenableshimtodoeasily
somefeatimpossibletoanyother,
Andthismakeshimnecessarytosociety.
Theperilofeveryfinefaculty
isthedelightofplayingwithitforpride.
10
Whentheintelligentandanimalsoulsareheldtogether
inoneembrace,
Theycanbekeptfromseparating.
Whenonegivesundividedattentiontothevitalbreath,
andbringsittotheutmostdegreeofpliancy,
Hecanbecomeasatenderbabe.
Whenhehascleansedawaythemostmysterioussights
ofhisimagination,
Hecanbecomewithoutaflaw.
Inlovingthepeopleandrulingthestate,
cannotheproceedwithoutanypurposefulaction?
Intheopeningandshuttingofhisgatesofheaven,
cannothedosoasafemalebird?
Whilehisintelligencereachesineverydirection,
Cannotheappeartobewithoutknowledge?
TheTaoproducesallthingsandnourishesthem;
Itproducesthemanddoesnotclaimthemasitsown.
Itdoesall,andyetdoesnotboastofit;
Itpresidesoverall,andyetdoesnotcontrolthem.
ThisiswhatiscalledtheMysteriousQualityoftheTao.
Byyieldingtothespiritwhichisinnate
ineveryman,
Canstthousilentlie?
Canstthou,thyprideforgot,likenature
passintothewinternight’s
extinguishedmood?
Canstthoushinenow,thendarkle?
Andbeinglatentfeelthyselfnoless?
Wiltthounotopenthyhearttoknow
Whatrainbowsteachandsunsetsshow?
Butyoumusthavethebelievingandpropheticeye.
Respectthechild.
Benottoomuchhisparent.
Trespassnotonhissolitude.
Havetheself-commandyouwishtoinspire.
11
Thethirtyspokesuniteintheonenave;
butitisontheemptyspace
thattheuseofthewheeldepends.
Clayisfashionedintovessels;
butitisontheiremptyhollowness
thattheirusedepends.
Doorsandwindowsarecutouttoformanapartment;
butitisontheemptyspacewithin
thatitsusedepends.
Therefore,whathasapositiveexistenceserves
forprofitableadaptation,
Andwhathasnotthatforactualusefulness.
Aninevitabledualismbisectsnature;
Ifthesouthattracts,thenorthrepels.
Whatwegaininpowerislostintime.
Ifthegoodisthere,soistheevil.
Iftheaffinity,sotherepulsion.
Iftheforce,sothelimitation.
Allthingsaredouble,oneagainstanother.
Whilsttheworldisthusdual,
soiseveryoneofitsparts.
Theentiresystemofthings
getsrepresentedineveryparticle.
12
Color’sfivehuesfromth’eyestheirsight
willtake;
Music’sfivenotestheearsasdeafcanmake;
Theflavorsfivedeprivethemouthoftaste;
Thechariotcourse,andthewildhuntingwaste
Makemadthemind;andobjectsrareandstrange,
Soughtfor,men’sconductwilltoevilchange.
Thereforethesageseekstosatisfythecraving
ofthebelly,
Andnottheinsatiablelongingoftheeyes.
Heputsfromhimthelatter,
andpreferstoseektheformer.
Assoonasleisureplayswithresemblances
foramusement,
WecallitsactionFancy.
Fancyrelatestosurfaces,
iswillful,superficial,
Aplayaswithdollsandpuppets.
Fancysurprisesandamusestheidle,
butissilentinthepresenceofgreatpassion.
Wemustlearnthehomelylawsoffireandwater.
Wemustfeed,wash,plant,build.
Thesearetheendsofnecessity,
andfirstintheorderofnature,
thehouseofhealthandlife.
13
Favor and disgrace would seem equally to be feared; Honor
andgreatcalamity,
toberegardedaspersonalconditionsofthesamekind.
Whatismeantbyspeakingthusoffavoranddisgrace?
Disgraceisbeinginalowpositionaftertheenjoymentoffavor.
Gettingthatfavorleadstotheapprehensionoflosingit,
andlosingitleadstothefearofstillgreatercalamity—
Thisiswhatismeantbysayingthatfavoranddisgrace
wouldseemequallytobefeared.
Andwhatismeantbysayingthathonorandgreatcalamity
aretoberegardedaspersonalconditions?
Whatmakesmeliabletogreatcalamityismyhavingthebody,
whichIcallmyself,
IfIhadnotthebody,whatgreatcalamitycouldcometome?
Therefore,hewhowouldadministerthekingdom,
Honoringitashehonorshisownperson,
maybeemployedtogovernit.
Andhewhowouldadministeritwiththelove
whichhebearstohisownpersonmaybeentrustedwithit.
Blameissaferthanpraise.
Everysweethathitssour,everyevilitsgood.
Domendesirethemoresubstantial
andpermanentgrandeurofgenius?
Neitherhasthisanimmunity.
Hewhobyforceofwillorofthoughtisgreat
hasthechargesofthateminence.
Witheveryinfluxoflightcomesnewdanger.
Hashelight?Hemustbearwitness
tothatlight
Andalwaysoutrunthatsympathy
whichgiveshimsuchkeensatisfaction.
Welcomeevermoretogodsandmen
istheself-helpingman.
Forhim,alldoorsareflungwide:
Himalltonguesgreet,allhonorscrown,
alleyesfollowwithdesire.
14
Welookatit,andwedonotseeit,andwenameit
theEquable.
Welistentoit,andwedonothearit,andwenameit
theInaudible.
Wetrytograspit,andwedonotgetholdofit,andwenameit
theSubtle.
Withthesethreequalities,itcannotbemadethesubject
ofdescription;
Andhence,weblendthemtogetherandobtainTheOne.
Itsupperpartisnotbright,anditslowerpartisnotobscure.
Ceaselessinitsaction,ityetcannotbenamed,andthen
itagainreturnsandbecomesnothing.
ThisiscalledtheFormoftheFormless,
andtheSemblanceoftheInvisible;
ThisiscalledtheFleetingandIndeterminable.
Thetrueorderofnaturebeholdsthevisible
asproceedingfromtheinvisible.
Therushingstreamwillnotstop
tobeobserved;
Sooldandsounutterable,
Itisinexactandboundless.
Butalltheusesofnatureadmitofbeing
summedinone.
Hereaboutuscoilsforever
theancientenigma.
Itisfaithfultothecause
whenceithaditsorigin.
Itisaperpetualeffect,
Agreatshadowpointingalways
tothesunbehindus.
Howsilent,howspacious,whatroomforall,
yetwithoutplacetoinsertanatom;
Itwillnotbedissected,norunraveled,
norshown.
Welearnthatbehindnature,
throughoutnature,
Spiritispresent,oneandnotcompound;
Thehistoryofthegenesisoftheoldmythology
repeatsitself.
15
Theskillfulmastersinoldtimes,
withasubtleandexquisitepenetration,
Comprehendeditsmysteriesandweredeep
soastoeludemen’sknowledge.
Astheywerethusbeyondmen’sknowledge,
Iwillmakeanefforttodescribewhatsort
theyappearedtobe.
Shrinkinglookedthey,likethose
whowadethroughastreaminwinter;
Irresolutelikethosewhoareafraidofallaroundthem;
Gravelikeaguestinaweofhishost;
Evanescentlikeicethatismeltingaway;
Unpretentious,likewood
thathasnotbeenfashionedintoanything
Vacantlikeavalleyanddulllikemuddywater.
Whocanmakethemuddywaterclear?
Letitbestill,anditwillgraduallybecomeclear.
Whocansecuretheconditionofrest?
Letmovementgoon,
andtheconditionofrestwillgraduallyarise.
TheywhopreservethismethodoftheTao
donotwishtobefullofthemselves.
Itisthroughtheirnotbeingfullofthemselves
thattheycanaffordtoseemwornandnotappear
newandcomplete.
Inallnationstherearemindswhichincline
todwellintheconceptionofthefundamentalUnity.
Theworldisupheldbytheveracityofgreatmen;
Theymaketheearthwholesome.
Thosewholivewiththemfindlifegladandnutritious.
Whattheyknow,theyknowforus.
Witheachnewmind,anewsecretofnaturetranspires.
Greatmenarethenacollyriumtoclearoureyes
fromegotism,
Andenableustoseeotherpeopleandtheirworks.
Theyteachusthequalitiesofprimarynature—
admitustotheconstitutionofthings.
Theescapefromallfalseties.
Couragetobewhatweare
Andlovewhatissimpleandbeautiful.
Thesearetheessentials.
Buttruegeniusseekstodefendusfromitself.
Truegeniuswillnotimpoverish,
butwillliberateandaddnewsenses.
Heisgreatwhoiswhatheisfromnature
andwhoneverremindsusofothers.
Theheroishewhoisimmovablycentered.
16
Thestateofvacancyshouldbebroughttotheutmostdegree,
andthatofstillnessguardedwithanunwearyingvigor.
Allthingsalikegothroughtheirprocessesofactivity,
Andthenweseethemreturntotheiroriginalstate.
Whenthingsinthevegetableworld
havedisplayedtheirluxuriantgrowth,
Weseeeachofthemreturntoitsroot.
Thisreturningtotheirrootiswhatwecall
thestateofstillness;
Andthatstillnessmaybecalledareporting
thattheyhavefulfilledtheirappointedend.
Thereportofthatfulfillmentistheregular,unchangingrule.
Toknowthatunchangingruleistobeintelligent;
Nottoknowitleadstowildmovementsandevilissues.
Theknowledgeofthatunchangingruleproduces
acapacityandforbearance,
Andthatcapacityandforbearanceleadtoacommunity
offeelingwithallthings.
Fromthiscommunityoffeelingcomesakinglinessofcharacter;
Andhewhoisking-likegoesontobeheaven-like.
Inthatlikenesstoheaven,hepossessestheTao.
PossessedoftheTao,heendureslong;
andtotheend
ofhisbodilylife,isexemptfromalldangerofdecay.
Thenretireandhide,
andfromthevalley
Beholdthemountain.
Havesolitaryprayerandpraise.
Realactionisinsilentmoments,
inathoughtwhichrevises
ourentiremanneroflife.
Bethelowlyministersofthepureomniscience.
Thesanityofmanneedsthepoiseof
thisimmanentforce.
Hisnobilityneedstheassuranceof
thisinexhaustiblepower.
Ifhelistenswithinsatiableears,
richerandgreaterwisdomistaughthim.
Heisborneawayaswithaflood.
Hishealthandgreatnessconsist
inhisbeingthechannel
throughwhichheavenflowstoearth.
Hewhoknowsthismost,hewhoknows
whatsweetsandvirtuesareintheground,
Thewaters,theplants,theheavens,
Andwhoknowshowtocomeattheseenchantments
istherichandroyalman.
17
Inthehighestantiquity,thepeople
didnotknowthattherewererulers.
Inthenextagetheylovedthemandpraisedthem.
Inthenexttheyfearedthem;inthenexttheydespisedthem.
Thus it was that when faith in the Tao was deficient in the
rulers,
awantoffaithinthemensuedinthepeople.
Howirresolutedidthoseearlyrulersappear,
showingbytheirreticencetheimportance
whichtheysetupontheirwords!
Theirworkwasdoneandtheirundertakingsweresuccessful,
whilethepeoplesaid,“Weareasweare,ofourselves!”
Theoldstatesmanknowsthatsocietyisfluid;
Therearenosuchrootsandcenters;
Butanyparticlemaysuddenlybecome
thecenterofthemovement.
Thewiseknowthatfoolishlegislation
isaropeofsand,
whichperishesinthetwisting;
Thatthestatemustfollow,andnotlead
thecharacterandprogressofthecitizen.
Theappearanceofcharactermakesthestateunnecessary.
Thewisemanisthestate.
18
WhenthegreatTaoceasedtobeobserved,
benevolenceandrighteousnesscameintovogue.
Thenappearedwisdomandshrewdness,
andthereensuedgreathypocrisy.
Whenharmonynolongerprevailed
throughoutthesixkinships,
filialsonsfoundtheirmanifestation;
Whenthestatesandclansfellintodisorder,
loyalministersappeared.
Societygainsnothingwhilstaman,
nothimselfrenovated,
Hasbecometediouslygoodinoneparticular
butnegligentornarrowintherest.
Hypocrisyistheattendantoffalsereligion.
Whenpeopleimaginethatothers
canbetheirpriest,
Whenevertheyunderstandthatnoreligion
candothemanymoregoodthan
theyactuallytaste,
Theyhavedonefearinghypocrisy.
19
Ifwecouldrenounceoursageness
anddiscardourwisdom,
itwouldbebetterforthepeopleahundredfold.
Ifwecouldrenounceourbenevolence
anddiscardourrighteousness,
thepeoplewouldagainbecomefilialandkindly.
Ifwecouldrenounceartfulcontrivances
anddiscardourschemesforgain,
therewouldbenothievesorrobbers.
Thosethreemethodsofgovernment
Thoughtoldofwaysinelegancedidfail
Andmadethesenamestheirwantofworthtoveil;
Butsimpleviews,andcoursesplainandtrue
Wouldselfishendsandmanylustseschew.
Theinnerlifesitsathome,
anddoesnotlearntodothings.
Itlovestruthbecauseitisitselfreal,
itknowsnothingelse;
Butitmakesnoprogress,wasaswise
inourfinalmemoryofitasnow.
Itlivesinthegreatpresent;
Itmakesthepresentgreat.
Thistranquil,well-founded,wide-seeingsoul
isnoexpress-rider,noattorney,nomagistrate.
Itliesinthesunandbroodsontheworld.
20
Whenwerenouncelearningwehavenotroubles.
Theready“yes”andtheflattering“yea”—
Smallisthedifferencetheydisplay.
Butmarktheirissuesgoodandill—
Whatspacethegulfbetweenshallfill?
Themultitudeofmenlooksatisfiedandpleased;
Asifenjoyingafullbanquet,asifmountedonatower
inspring.
Ialoneseemlistlessandstill,mydesireshavingasyet
givennoindicationoftheirpresence.
Iamlikeaninfantwhichhasnotyetsmiled.
Ilookdejectedandforlorn,
asifIhadnohometogoto.
Themultitudeofmenallhaveenoughandtospare.
Mymindisthatofastupidman;Iaminastateofchaos.
Ordinarymenlookbrightandintelligent,whileIalone
seembenighted.
Theylookfullofdiscrimination,whileIalone
amdullandconfused.
Iseemtobecarriedaboutasonthesea,driftingasif
Ihadnowheretorest.
Allmenhavetheirspheresofaction,whileIalone
seemdullandincapable,likearudeborderer.
ThusIaloneamdifferentfromothermen,butI
valuetheTao.
Awayprofanephilosopher!
Seekestthouinnaturethecause?
Thisreferstothat,andthattothenext,
Andthenexttothethird,andeverythingrefers.
Theworldrolls,thedinoflife
isneverhushed,
Thecarnival,themasqueradeisatitsheight;
Nobodydropshisdomino.
ButIamonlyanexperimenter;
DonotsettheleastvalueonwhatIdo
ortheleastdiscreditonwhatIdonot,
AsifIpretendedtosettleanythingastrueorfalse;
Iunsettleallthings.
Nofactsaretomesacred,noneareprofane.
Isimplyexperiment,anendlessseeker,
withnopasttomyback.
Iamaweedbythewall.
IseethatIamapensioner,notacause,
butasurprisedspectatorofthisetherealwater;
ThatIdesireandlookup,
Andputmyselfintheattitudeofreception;
Butfromsomealienenergy,
thevisionscome.
21
Thegrandestformsofactiveforce
FromtheTaocome,theironlysource.
WhocanofTaothenaturetell?
Oursightitflies,ourtouchaswell.
Eludingsight,eludingtouch,
Theformsofthingsallinitcrouch;
Eludingtouch,eludingsight,
Therearetheirsemblances,allright.
Profounditis,darkandobscure;
Things’essencesallthereendure.
Thoseessencesthetruthenfold.
Ofwhat,whenseen,shallthenbetold.
Nowitisso;’twassoofold.
Itsname—whatpassesnotaway;
So,intheirbeautifularray,
Thingsformandneverknowdecay.
Therearenofixturesinnature;
Theuniverseisfluidandvolatile.
Thereisnooutside,noinclosingwall,
nocircumferencetous.
Everynaturalfact
isasymbolofsomespiritualfact.
Thesage,untilhehitthesecret,
Wouldhanghisheadforshame,
Butourbrothershavenotreadit;
Noonehasfoundthekey.
Thusthereisnosleep,nopause,
nopreservation,
Butallthingsrenew,germinate
andspring.
22
The partial becomes complete; the crooked, straight; The
empty,full;theworn-out,new.
Hewhosedesiresarefewgetsthem;
Hewhosedesiresaremanygoesastray.
Thereforethesageholdsinhisembrace
theonething,humility,andmanifestsittoalltheworld.
Heisfreefromself-display,andthereforeheshines;
Fromself-assertion,andthereforeheisdistinguished;
From self-boasting, and therefore his merit is acknowledged;
From self-complacency, and therefore he acquires superiority.
Itisbecauseheisthusfreefromstriving
thatthereforenooneintheworldisabletostrivewithhim.
Thatsayingoftheancients
that“thepartialbecomescomplete”wasnotvainlyspoken—
Allrealcompletioniscomprehendedunderit.
Thosewhoarecapableofhumility,
ofjustice,oflove,ofaspiration,
Standalreadyonaplatformthatcommands
actionandgrace.
Thisenergydidnotdescendintoindividuallife
onanyothercondition
thanentirepossession.
Itcomestothelowlyandthesimple;
Itcomestowhomsoeverwillputoff
whatisforeignandproud;
Itcomesasinsight,itcomesas
serenityandgrandeur.
23
Abstainingfromspeechmarkshimwhoisobeying
thespontaneityofhisnature.
Aviolentwinddoesnotlastforawholemorning;
Asuddenraindoesnotlastforthewholeday.
Towhomisitthatthesetwothingsareowing?
Toheavenandearth.
Ifheavenandearthcannotmakesuchactionslastlong,
howmuchlesscanman!
Therefore,whenoneismakingtheTaohisbusiness,
Thosewhoarealsopursuingit,agreewithhiminit,
Andthosewhoaremakingthemanifestationofitscourse
theirobjectagreewithhiminthat;
Whileeventhosewhoarefailinginboththesethings
agreewiththemwheretheyfail.
Hence,thosewithwhomheagreesastotheTao
havethehappinessofattainingtoit;
Thosewithwhomheagreesastoitsmanifestation
havethehappinessofattainingtoit;
Andthosewithwhomheagreesintheirfailure
havealsothehappinessofattainingtotheTao.
Butwhenthereisnotfaithsufficientonhispart,
Awantoffaithinhimensuesonthepartoftheothers.
Silenceisbetterthanspeech.
Allthingsareincontact,
Everyatomhasasphereofrepulsion.
Fornature,whoabhorsmaneuvers,
hassetherheartonbreakingupallstylesandtricks.
Naturekeepsherselfwhole,
andherrepresentationcomplete.
Insplendidvarietythesechangescome,
allputtingquestionstothehumanspirit.
Thosemenwhocannotanswerbyasuperiorwisdom
thesefactsorquestionsoftime,servethem.
Factsencumberthem,tyrannizeoverthem,
andmakethemenofroutinethemenofsense,
Inwhomaliteralobediencetofact
hasextinguishedeverysparkofthatlight
bywhichmanistrulyman.
Butifthemanistruetohisbetterinstincts
orsentiments,andrefusesthedominionoffacts,
Asonethatcomesofahigherrace
remainsfastbythesoulandseestheprinciple,
Thenthefactsfallaptlyandsupple
intotheirplaces;
Theyknowtheirmaster,andthemeanestofthem
glorifieshim.
24
Hewhostandsonhistiptoesdoesnotstandfirm;
Hewhostretcheshislegsdoesnotwalkeasily.
So,hewhodisplayshimselfdoesnotshine;
Hewhoassertshisownviewsisnotdistinguished;
Hewhovauntshimselfdoesnotfindhismeritacknowledged;
Hewhoisself-conceitedhasnosuperiorityallowedtohim.
Suchconditions,viewedfromthestandpointoftheTao,
Arelikeremnantsoffood,ortumorsonthebody,
whichalldislike.
HencethosewhopursuetheTaodonotadoptandallowthem.
Ifamanlosehisbalance,andimmerse
himselfinanytradesandpleasures
fortheirownsake,
Hemaybeagoodwheelorpin,
Butheisnotacultivatedman.
Themanoftheworldavoidsallbrag.
Prudenceconsistsinavoidingandgoingwithout,
notintheinventingofmeansandmethods,
notinadroitsteering,notingeneralrepairing.
Suchisthevalueofthesematters
Thatamanwhoknowsotherthings,
canneverknowtoomuchofthese.
25
Therewassomethingundefinedandcomplete,
comingintoexistencebeforeHeavenandEarth.
Howstillitwasandformless,
standingalone,andundergoingnochange,
reachingeverywhereandinnodangerofbeingexhausted!
ItmayberegardedastheMotherofallthings.
Idonotknowitsname,andIgiveitthedesignationoftheTao
(theWayorCourse).
Makinganefforttogiveitaname
IcallittheGreat.
Great,itpassesoninconstantflow.
Passingon,itbecomesremote.
Havingbecomeremote,itreturns.
Therefore,theTaoisgreat;
Heavenisgreat;Earthisgreat;
Andthesageisalsogreat.
Intheuniversetherearefourthataregreat,
Andthesageisoneofthem.
MantakeshislawfromtheEarth;
TheEarthtakesitslawfromHeaven;
HeaventakesitslawfromtheTao.
ThelawoftheTaoisitsbeingwhatitis.
Fortheworldwasbuiltinorder
Andtheatomsmarchintune,
Rhymethepipe,andtimethewarder,
Thesunobeysthemandthemoon.
Wecannotlearnthecipher
That’swrituponourcell.
Starstauntusbyamystery
Whichwecouldneverspell.
Theconsciousstarsaccordabove,
thewaterswildbelow.
Fornaturelistensintherose
andhearkensintheberry’sbell.
Thereisamelodybornofmelody
whichmeltstheworldintoasea.
Natureisamutablecloud,
Whichisalwaysandneverthesame.
Nothingdivinedies.
Thebeautyofnaturereformsitselfinthemind,
andnotforbarrencontemplation,butfornewcreation.
26
Gravityistherootoflightness;
stillness,therulerofmovement.
Therefore,awiseprince,marchingthewholeday,
doesnotgofarfromhisbaggagewagons.
Althoughhemayhavebrilliantprospectstolookat,
hequietlyremainsinhisproperplace,
indifferenttothem.
Howshouldthelordofamyriadchariots
carryhimselflightlybeforethekingdom?
Ifhedoactlightly,hehaslosthisroot;
Ifheproceedtoactivemovement,
hewilllosehisthrone.
Thefactoftwoforces,centripetalandcentrifugal,
isuniversal.
Andeachforcebyitsownactivity
developstheother.
Naturewillnothaveusfretandfume.
Ourpainfullaborsareunnecessaryandfruitless.
Onlyinoureasy,simple,spontaneousaction
arewestrong.
Thereisnoneedofstruggle,convulsions,
anddespairs,
Orthewringingofhandsandthegnashingofteeth.
Wemiscreateourownevils.
27
Theskillfultravelerleavesnotraces
ofhiswheelsorfootsteps;
Theskillfulspeakersaysnothing
thatcanbefoundfaultwithorblamed;
Theskillfulreckonerusesnotallies;
Theskillfulcloserneedsnoboltsorbars,
whiletoopenwhathehasshutwillbeimpossible;
Theskillfulbinderusesnostringsorknots,
whiletounloosewhathehasboundwillbeimpossible.
Inthesamewaythesage
isalwaysskillfulatsavingmen,
Andsohedoesnotcastawayanyman;
Heisalwaysskillfulatsavingthings,
Andsohedoesnotcastawayanything.
Thisiscalled“hidingthelightofhisprocedure.”
Therefore,themanofskillisamastertobelookedupto
byhimwhohasnottheskill;
Andhewhohasnottheskillisthehelper
ofthereputationofhimwhohastheskill.
Iftheonedidnothonorhismaster,
andtheotherdidnotrejoiceinhishelper,
Anobserver,thoughintelligent,mightgreatlyerraboutthem.
Thisiscalled“theutmostdegreeofmystery.”
’Tisaseasytotwistironanchors,
andbraidcannons,astobraidstraw,
Toboilgranite,astoboilwater,
ifyoutakeallstepsinorder.
Bysimpleliving,byanillimitablesoul,
youinspire,youcorrect,youinstruct,
youraise,youembellishall.
Byyourownact,youteachthebeholder
howtodothepracticable.
Accordingtothedepthfromwhichyou
drawyourlife,
Suchisthedepthofyourmannersandpresence.
Bythepermanenceofnature,
mindsaretrainedalike,
Andaremadeintelligibletoeachother.
Goodisagooddoctor,butBadissometimesabetter.
Whoknowshismanhood’sstrength,
Yetstillhisfemalefeeblenessmaintains;
Astoonechannelflowthemanydrains,
Allcometohim,yea,allbeneaththesky.
Thushetheconstantexcellenceretains—
Thesimplechildagain,freefromallstains.
28
Whoknowshowwhiteattracts:
Yetalwayskeepshimselfwithinblack’sshade,
Thepatternofhumilitydisplayed,
Displayedinviewofallbeneaththesky;
Heintheunchangingexcellencearrayed,
Endlessreturntoman’sfirststatehasmade.
Whoknowshowgloryshines,
Yetlovesdisgrace,nore’erforitispale;
Beholdhispresenceinaspaciousvale,
Towhichmencomefromallbeneaththesky,
Theunchangingexcellencecompletesitstale
Thesimpleinfantmaninhimwehail.
Menofgeniusaresaidtopartakeof
themasculineandfemininetraits.
Asmuchasamanisawhole,
soishealsoapart.
Speakasyouthink,bewhatyouare,
Lookuponthesimpleandchildishvirtues
ofveracityandhonesty
astherootofallthatissublimeincharacter.
Amultitudeoftriflesimpedethemind’seye
fromthegreatsearch
ofthatfinehorizon-linethattruthkeeps.
Thewaytoknowledgeandpower
isnotthroughplentyandsuperfluity,
Butbydenialandrenunciation
intosolitudeandprivation.
Letusapplytothissubjectthesametorch
bywhichwehavelookedatall
thephenomenaofthetime,
Theinfinitude,namely,ofeveryman.
Everythingteachesthat.
29
Ifanyoneshouldwishtogetthekingdomforhimself,
andtoeffectthisbywhathedoes,
Iseethathewillnotsucceed.
Thekingdomisaspirit-likething,
andcannotbegotbyactivedoing.
Hewhowouldsowinitdestroysit;
Hewhowouldholditinhisgrasplosesit.
Thecourseandnatureofthingsissuchthat
Whatwasinfrontisnowbehind;
Whatwarmedanonwefreezingfind.
Strengthisofweaknessoftthespoil;
Thestoreinruinsmocksourtoil.
Hencethesageputsawayexcessiveeffort,
extravagance,andeasyindulgence.
Naturehasself-poiseinallherworks;
Certainproportionsinwhichoxygenandazotecombine,
Andnotlessaharmonyinfaculties,
afitnessinthespringandtheregulator.
Soletmanbe,
Lethimemptyhisbreastofhiswindyconceits
Andshowhislordshipbymannersanddeeds
onthescaleofnature.
Nature,hatingartandpains,
Balksandbafflesplottingbrains.
Thedivinecirculationsneverrestnorlinger;
Weareencampedinnature,notdomesticated.
Itisfirmwater,itiscoldflame.
30
Hewhowouldassistalordofmen
inharmonywiththeTao
Willnotasserthismasteryinthekingdom
byforceofarms.
Suchacourseissuretomeetwithitsproperreturn.
Whereverahostisstationed,briarsandthornsspringup.
Inthesequenceofgreatarmies,therearesuretohehadyears.
AskillfulcommanderstrikesadecisiveMowandstops.
Hedoesnotdaretoassertandcompletehismastery.
HewillstrikeaMow,hutwillheonhisguard
againstbeingvainorboastfulorarrogant
inconsequenceofit.
Hestrikesitasamatterofnecessity;
Hestrikesit,butnotfromawishformastery.
Whenthingshaveattainedtheirmaturity,theybecomeold.
ThismaybesaidtobenotinaccordancewiththeTao,
Andwhatisnotinaccordancewithitsooncomestoanend.
Warbeginstolooklikeanepidemicinsanity,
Breakingouthereandtherelikethecholera
orinfluenza
Infectingmen’sbrains.
Whenseenintheremotepast,
intheinfancyofsociety,
Appearsapartoftheconnectionofevents
andinitsplace,necessary.
Warandpeacethusresolvethemselves
intoamercuryofthestateofcultivation.
Atcertainstages,themanfights,
ifhebeofsoundbodyandmind.
Atacertainhigherstage,
hemakesnooffensivedemonstration.
Hiswarlikenatureisallconcertedinto
anactivemedicinalprinciple.
31
Nowarms,howeverbeautiful,
areinstrumentsofevilomen,
Hateful,itmaybesaid,toallcreatures.
ThereforetheywhohavetheTaodonotliketoemploythem.
Thesuperiormanordinarilyconsidersthelefthand
themosthonorableplace,
Butintimeofwartherighthand.
Thosesharpweaponsareinstrumentsofevilomen,
andnottheinstrumentsofthesuperiorman—
Heusesthemonlyonthecompulsionofnecessity.
Calmandreposearewhatheprizes;
Victorybyforceofarmsistohimundesirable.
Toconsiderthisdesirablewouldbetodelight
intheslaughterofmen;
Andhewhodelightsintheslaughterofmen
cannotgethiswillinthekingdom.
Hewhohaskilledmultitudesofmen
Shouldweepforthemwiththebitterestgrief.
Theinstinctofself-helpisveryearlyunfolded
inthecoarseandmerelybruteformofwar.
Tomenofasedateandmaturespirit,
inwhomisanyknowledgeormentalactivity,
Thedetailofbattlebecomesunsupportably
tediousandrevolting.
Nothingisplainerthanthatthesympathy
withwar
Isajuvenileandtemporarystate.
Thestandingarmy,thearsenal,thecamp
andthegibbet
Donotappertaintoman.
Theyonlyserveasanindextoshow
wheremanisnow;
Whatabad,unorganizedtemperhehas;
Whatanuglyneighborheis;howlowhishopelies.
Cannotlovebe,aswellashate?
Cannotpeacebe,aswellaswar?
32
TheTao,consideredasunchanging,hasnoname.
Thoughinitsprimordialsimplicity,itmaybesmall,
Thewholeworlddaresnotdealwithitasaminister.
Ifafeudalprinceorkingcouldguardandholdit,
Allwouldspontaneouslysubmitthemselvestohim.
Heavenandearth,underitsguidance,unitetogether
andsenddownthesweetdew,
Which,withoutthedirectionsofmen,
reachesequallyeverywhereasofitsownaccord.
Assoonasitproceedstoaction,ithasaname.
Whenitoncehasthatname,
Mencanknowtorestinit.
Whentheyknowtorestinit,
Theycanbefreefromallriskoffailureorerror.
TherelationoftheTaotoalltheworld
islikethatofthegreatriversandseas
tothestreamsfromthevalleys.
Thisdeeppowerinwhichwerest
Andwhosebeatitudesareallaccessibletous,
Isnotonlyself-sufficingandperfect
ineveryhour;
Buttheactofseeingandthethingseen,
Theseerandthespectacle,
Thesubjectandtheobject,
areone.
NaturejudgeslikeaGodallmenthat
cometoher.
Thatpower,whichdoesnotrespectquantity,
Whichmakesthewholeandtheparticle
itsequalchannel,
Delegatesitssmiletothemorning,
Anddistillsitsessenceintoeverydropofrain.
33
Hewhoknowsothermenisdiscerning;
Hewhoknowshimselfisintelligent.
Hewhoovercomesothersisstrong;
Hewhoovercomeshimselfismighty.
Hewhoissatisfiedwithhislotisrich;
Hewhogoesonactingwithenergyhasafirmwill.
Hewhodoesnotfailintherequirementsofhisposition,
continueslong;
Hewhodiesandyetdoesnotperish,haslongevity.
Hewhoknowsthatpowerisinborn,
Thatheisweakbecausehehaslooked
forgoodoutofhim,
andelsewhere,
Andsoperceiving,throwshimself
unhesitatinglyonhisthoughts,
Instantlyrightshimself,standsin
theerectposition,
Commandshislimbs,worksmiracles,
Justasamanwhostandsonhisfeet
isstrongerthanamanwhostandsonhishead.
34
All-pervadingisthegreatTao!
Itmaybefoundonthelefthand
andontheright.
Allthingsdependonitfortheirproduction,
Whichitgivestothem,notonerefusingobediencetoit.
Whenitsworkisaccomplished,
itdoesnotclaimthenameofhavingdoneit.
Itclothesallthingsaswithagarment,
Andmakesnoassumptionofbeingtheirlord—
Itmaybenamedinthesmallestthings.
Allthingsreturntotheirrootanddisappear,
Anddonotknowthatitisitwhichpresides
overtheirdoingso—
Itmaybenamedinthegreatestthings.
Hencethesageisableinthesameway
toaccomplishhisgreatachievements.
Itisthroughhisnotmakinghimselfgreat
thathecanaccomplishthem.
Forwisdomisinfusedintoeveryform;
Thedivinecirculationsneverrestorlinger.
Thedanceofthehoursgoesforwardstill;
likeanodorofincense,likeastrainofmusic,
likesleep,
Itisinexactandboundless.
Thisenergycomestothelowlyandsimple.
Itcomestowhomeverwillputoff
whatisforeignandproud;
Itcomesasinsight;itcomesasserenity
andgrandeur.
35
TohimwhoholdsinhishandtheGreatImage
oftheInvisibleTao,
Thewholeworldrepairs.
Menresorttohim,andreceivenohurt,
Butfindrest,peace,andthefeelingofease.
Musicanddaintieswillmakethepassingguest
stopforatime.
ButthoughtheTao,asitcomesfromthemouth,
seemsinsipidandhasnoflavor,
Thoughitseemsnotworthbeinglookedat
orlistenedto,
Theuseofitisinexhaustible.
Heisgreatwhoiswhatheisfromnature,
andneverremindsusofthis.
Theworldisupheldbytheveracityofgoodmen.
Theymaketheearthwholesome.
Wevaluetotalpowersandeffects,
asthespiritorqualityoftheman.
Wehaveanothersight,andanewstandard,
Aninsightwhichdisregardswhatisdonefortheeye;
Anearwhichhearsnotwhatmensay
butwhattheydonotsay.
36
Whenoneisabouttotakeaninspiration,
heissuretomakeapreviousexpiration;
Whenheisgoingtoweakenanother,
hewillfirststrengthenhim;
Whenheisgoingtooverthrowanother,
hewillfirsthaveraisedhimup;
Whenheisgoingtodespoilanother,
hewillfirsthavemadegiftstohim—
Thisiscalled“hidingthelightofhisprocedure.
Thesoftovercomesthehard;
Andtheweak,thestrong.
Fishesshouldnotbetakenfromthedeep;
Instrumentsfortheprofitofastate
shouldnotbeshowntothepeople.
Polarity,oractionandreaction,wemeet
ineverypartofnature;
Intheinspirationandexpirationof
plantsandanimals;
Asurplusagegiventoonepart
ispaidoutofareductionfromanotherpart.
Whatwegaininpowerislostintime.
Everysweethathitssour;
everyevilitsgood.
Foreverythingyougain,youlosesomething.
Thereisalwayssomelevelingcircumstance
thatputsdowntheoverbearing,thestrong.
37
TheTaoinitsregularcoursedoesnothing
forthesakeofdoingit,
Andsothereisnothingwhichitdoesnotdo.
Ifprincesandkingswereabletomaintainit,
Allthingswouldofthemselves
Betransformedbythem.
Ifthistransformationbecametome
anobjectofdesire,
Iwouldexpressthedesirebythenamelesssimplicity.
Simplicitywithoutaname
Isfreefromallexternalaim.
Withnodesire,atrestandstill,
Allthingsgorightasoftheirwill.
Whenaman,throughstubbornness,
insiststodothisorthat,
Somethingabsurdorwhimsical,
onlybecausehewill,
Heisweak.
Heblowswithhislipsagainstthetempest;
Hecalmstheincomingoceanwithhiscane.
Shunpassion,foldthehandsofthrift,
Sitstillandtruthisnear;
Suddenly,itwilluplift
Youreyelidstothesphere:
Waitalittle,youshallsee.
38
Thosewhopossessedinthehighestdegree
theattributesoftheTao
Didnotseektoshowthem,
Andthereforetheypossessedtheminfullestmeasure.
Thosewhopossessedinalowerdegreethoseattributes
Soughthownottolosethem,
Andthereforetheydidnotpossesstheminfullestmeasure.
Thosewhopossessedinthehighestdegreethoseattributes
Didnothingwithapurpose,andhadnoneedtodoanything
Thosewhopossessedtheminalowerdegree
werealwaysdoing,andhadneedtobesodoing.
Thosewhopossessedthehighestbenevolence
werealwaysseekingtocarryitout,
andhadnoneedtobedoingso.
Thosewhopossessedthehighestrighteousness
werealwaysseekingtocarryitout,
andhadneedtobesodoing.
ThusitwasthatwhentheTaowaslost,
itsattributesappeared;
Whenitsattributeswerelost,benevolenceappeared;
Whenbenevolencewaslost,righteousnessappeared;
Andwhenrighteousnesswaslost,theproprietiesappeared.
Thusitisthatthegreatmanabidesbywhatissolid,
andeschewswhatisflimsy;
Dwellswiththefruitandnotwiththeflower.
Menachieveacertaingreatnessunawares
whenworkingtoanotheraim.
Theyteachusthequalitiesofprimarynature,
admitustotheconstitutionofthings.
Whattheyknow,theyknowforus.
Witheachnewmananewsecretofnaturetranspires.
Theescapefromallfalseties;
couragetobewhatweare;
andloveofwhatissimpleandbeautiful;
Thesearetheessentials.
Thewisemanshowshiswisdominseparation,
ingradation,
Andhisscaleofcreaturesandofmerits
isaswideasnature.
Thefoolishhavenorangeintheirscale,
butsupposeeverymanisaseveryotherman.
Whatisnotgood,theycalltheworst,
Andwhatisnothateful,theycallthebest.
Inlikemanner,whatgoodheednatureformsinus!
Shepardonsnomistakes.
Heryeaisyea,hernay,nay.
Theheroishewhoisimmovablycentered.
39
ThethingswhichfromofoldhavegottheTaoare—
Heavenwhichbyitisbrightandpure;
Earthrenderedtherebyfirmandsure;
Spiritswithpowersbyitsupplied;
Valleyskeptfullthroughouttheirvoid;
Allcreatureswhichthroughitdolive;
Princesandkingswhofromitget
Themodelwhichtoalltheygive.
AllthesearetheresultsoftheTao.
Ifheavenwerenotthuspure,itsoonwouldrend;
Ifearthwerenotthussure,’twouldbreakandbend;
Withoutthesepowers,thespiritssoonwouldfail;
Ifnotsofilled,thedroughtwouldparcheachvale;
Withoutthatlife,creatureswouldpassaway;
Princesandkings,withoutthatmoralsway,
Howevergrandandhigh,wouldalldecay.
Itistheuniversalnature,whichgivesworth
toparticularmenandthings.
Natureisanimmutablecloud,whichisalways
andneverthesame.
Everychemicalsubstance,everyplant,
everyanimalinitsgrowth,
Teachestheunityofcause,thevarietyofappearance.
Alllawsderivehencetheirultimatereason;
Allexpressmoreorlessdistinctlysomecommandof
thissupreme,illimitableessence.
Thereisnogreatandnosmall
Tothesoulthatmakethall.
Andwhereitcometh,allthingsare;
Anditcometheverywhere.
Eyesarefoundinlight;earsinauricularair;
Feetonland;finsinwater;wingsinair.
Andeachcreaturewhereitwasmeanttobe,
withamutualfitness.
40
ThemovementoftheTao
Bycontrariesproceeds;
Andweaknessmarksthecourse
OfTao’smightydeeds.
Everynaturalfactisanemanation,
andthatfromwhichitemanates
isanemanationalso,
Andfromeveryemanation
isanewemanation.
Amysteriousprincipleoflife
mustbeassumed,
Whichnotonlyinhabitstheorgan,
butmakestheorgan.
41
Scholarsofthehighestclass,whentheyhearabouttheTao,
earnestlycarryitintopractice.
Scholarsofthemiddleclass,whentheyhaveheardaboutit,
seemnowtokeepitandnowtoloseit.
Scholarsofthelowestclass,whentheyhaveheardaboutit,
laughgreatlyatit.
Ifitwerenotthuslaughedat,itwouldnothefittohetheTao.
Therefore,thesentencemakershavethusexpressedthemselves:
TheTao,whenbrightestseen,seemslighttolack;
Whoprogressinitmakes,seemsdrawingback;
Itsevenwayislikearuggedtrack.
Itshighestvirtuefromthevaledothrise;
Itsgreatestbeautyseemstooffendtheeyes:
Andhehasmostwhoselottheleastsupplies.
Itsfirmestvirtueseemshutpoorandlow;
Itssolidtruthseemschangetoundergo;
Itslargestsquaredothyetnocornershow;
Avesselgreat,itistheslowestmade.
Loudisitssound,hutneverworditsaid.
Asemblancegreat,theshadowofashade.
Thereisacertainwisdomofhumanity
Whichiscommontothegreatestmanwiththelowest;
Thelearnedandstudiousofthought
havenomonopolyofwisdom.
Weowemanyvaluableobservationstopeople
whoarenotveryacuteorprofound.
Theactionofthesoulisoftenerinthat
whichisfeltandleftunsaid,
Thanthatwhichissaidinanyconversation.
Weknowbetterthanwedo.
Thatwhichonceexistedinintellectaspurelaw
hasnowtakenbodyasnature.
Itexistedalreadyinthemindinsolution;
Nowithasbeenprecipitated,
Andthebrightsedimentistheworld.
Wecouldneversurprisenatureinacorner;
Itisinexactandboundless.
Talentgoesfromwithoutinward.
WhenGeniusarrives,itflowsoutofadeepersource
thantheforegoingsilence.
Hereaboutuscoilsforevertheagentenigma,
soold,andsounutterable.
42
TheTaoproducedOne;OneproducedTwo;
TwoproducedThree;Threeproducedallthings.
AllthingsleavebehindthemtheObscurity
outofwhichtheyhavecome,
AndgoforwardtoembracetheBrightness
intowhichtheyhaveemerged,
WhiletheyareharmonizedbytheBreathofVacancy.
Whatmendislikeistobeorphans,
tohavelittlevirtue,tobeascarriageswithoutnaves;
Andyetthesearethedesignationswhichkings
andprincesuseforthemselves.
Soitisthatsomethingsareincreasedbybeingdiminished,
andothersarediminishedbybeingincreased.
Whatothermenteach,Ialsoteach.
Theviolentandstrongdonotdietheirnaturaldeath.
Iwillmakethisthebasisofmyteaching.
Theincessantmovementandprogress
inwhichallthingspartake
Couldneverbecomesensibletousbutbycontrast
Tosomeprincipleoffixtureorstabilityinthesoul.
Wecanneverbequitestrangersorinferiorsinnature.
Itisfleshofourflesh,andboneofourbone.
’Tistheoldsecretofthegods,
Thattheycomeinlowdisguises.
’Tisthevulgargreat,whocomedizened
withgoldandjewels.
Realkingshidetheircrownsawayintheirwardrobes,
andaffectaplainandpoorexterior.
Therealandlastingvictoriesarethoseofpeace,
andnotofwar.
Thewaytoconquertheforeignartisan
isnottokillhim,buttobeathiswork.
43
Thesoftestthingintheworlddashesagainst
andovercomesthehardest;
Thatwhichhasnosubstantialexistenceenters
wherethereisnocrevice.
Iknowherebywhatadvantagebelongs
todoingnothingwithapurpose.
Thereareafewintheworldwhoattain
totheteachingwithoutwords,
Andtheadvantagearisingfromnon-action.
Allisriddle,andthekeytoariddle
isanotherriddle.
Tochangeandtoflow,thegasbecomessolid,
Andphantomsandnothings
returntobethings.
Prudenceconsistsinavoiding
andgoingwithout,
Notintheinventingofmeansandmethods,
Notinadroitsteering,notingentlerepairing.
44
Orfameorlife,
Whichdoyouholdmoredear?
Orlifeorwealth,
Towhichwouldyouadhere?
Keeplifeandlosethoseotherthings;
Keepthemandloseyourlife—which
brings
Sorrowandpainmorenear?
Thuswemaysee
Whocleavestofame
Rejectswhatismoregreat;
Wholoveslargestores
Givesupthericherstate.
Whoiscontent
Needsfearnoshame.
Whoknowstostop
Incursnoblame.
Fromdangerfree
Longliveshallhe.
Geniusconsistsinneitherimprovingnor
remembering,
Butinbothtremblesthebeam
ofthebalanceofnature.
Twobrainsineveryman
Whowalksinwaysthatareunfamed
Andfeatsachievedbeforethey’renamed.
Thereisateachingforhimfromwithin
whichisleadinghiminanewpath,
And,themoreitistrusted,
Separatesandsignalizeshim,
Whileitmakeshimmoreimportantand
necessarytosociety.
Sothathisdoing,whichisperfectlynatural,
Appearsmiraculoustodullpeople.
45
Whothinkshisgreatachievementspoor
Shallfindhisvigorlongendure.
Ofgreatestfullness,deemedavoid,
Exhaustionne’ershallstemthetide.
Dothouwhat’sstraightstillcrookeddeem;
Thygreatestartstillstupidseem,
Andeloquenceastammeringscream.
Constantactionovercomescold;
Beingstillovercomesheat.
Purityandstillnessgivethecorrectlaw
toallunderheaven.
Themenwecallgreatestareleast
inthiskingdom.
Hethatdespisethsmallthings
willperishlittlebylittle.
Lethimesteemnatureaperpetualcounselor
andherperfectionstheexact
measureofourdeviations.
Donotcrazeyourselfwiththinking,
Butgoaboutyourbusinessanywhere.
Lifeisnotintellectualorcritical,
butsturdy.
46
WhentheTaoprevailsintheworld,
Theysendbacktheirswifthorsestodraw
thedung-carts.
WhentheTaoisdisregardedintheworld,
Thewarhorsesbreedintheborderlands.
Thereisnoguiltgreaterthantosanctionambition;
Nocalamitygreaterthantobediscontented
withone’slot;
Nofaultgreaterthanthewishtobegetting.
Therefore,thesufficiencyofcontentmentisanenduring
andunchangingsufficiency.
Aman’swisdomistoknowthat
allendsaremomentary.
Ifhelistenswithinsatiableears,
richerandgreaterwisdomistaughthim.
Heisthefoolofideasandleadsaheavenlylife.
Hishealthandgreatnessconsists
inhisbeingthechannelthroughwhich
heavenflowstoearth.
Whatman,seeingthis,canloseit
fromhisthoughts.
47
Withoutgoingoutsidehisdoor,oneunderstands
allthattakesplaceunderthesky;
Withoutlookingoutfromhiswindow,onesees
theTaoofHeaven.
Thefartherthatonegoesoutfromhimself,
thelessheknows.
Thereforethesagesgottheirknowledge
withouttraveling;
Gavetheirrightnametothingswithoutseeingthem;
Andaccomplishedtheirendswithoutanypurpose
ofdoingso.
Thesoulisnotraveler;
Thewisemanstaysathome.
Hedoesnotgoabroadwiththehopeoffinding
somewhatgreaterthanheknows.
Thesoulthatisplainandtrue
dwellsinthehourthatnowis,
intheearnestexperienceofthecommonday
Andthemeretriflebecomesporoustothought,
andbibuloustotheseaoflight.
48
Hewhodevoteshimselftolearningseeks
fromdaytodaytoincreasehisknowledge;
HewhodevoteshimselftotheTaoseeks
fromdaytodaytodiminishhisdoing.
Hediminishesitandagaindiminishesit,
tillhearrivesatdoingnothing(onpurpose).
Havingarrivedatthispointofnon-action,thereis
nothingwhichhedoesnotdo.
Letusunlearnourwisdomoftheworld.
Letustakeourbloatednothingnessoutof
thepathofdivinecircuits.
Letuslielowandlearnthattruthalone
makesrichandgreat.
Therichmindliesinthesunandsleeps,
andisnature.
Tothinkistoact.
49
Thesagehasnoinvariablemindofhisown;
Hemakesthemindofthepeoplehismind.
Tothosewhoaregoodtome,Iamgood;
Andtothosewhoarenotgoodtome,
Iamalsogood—
Andthus,allgettobegood.
Tothosewhoaresincerewithme,
Iamsincere;
Andtothosewhoarenotsincerewithme,
Iamalsosincere—
Andthusallgettobesincere.
Thesagehasintheworldanappearance
ofindecision,
Andkeepshismindinastateofindifferencetoall.
Thepeopleallkeeptheireyesandearsdirectedtohim,
andhedealswiththemallashischildren.
Bythepermanenceofnature,mindsaretrainedalike
andmadeintelligibletoeachother.
Goodandbadarebutnamesveryreadily
transferabletothatorthis.
Ioughttogouprightandvital
andspeaktherudetruthinallways.
Mylifeisforitselfandnotforspectacle.
Thegreatmanishewhointhemidstofthecrowd
Keepswithperfectsweetness
theindependenceofsolitude.
Thewisemanshallmakemensensible
bytheexpressionofhiscountenance,
Thathegoesthemissionaryofwisdomandvirtue.
50
Mencomeforthandlive;theyenteragainanddie.
Ofeveryten,threeareministersoflife;
Andthreeareministersofdeath.
Therearealsothreeineveryten
whoseaimistolive,
butwhosemovementstendtothelandofdeath.
Andforwhatreason?
Becauseoftheirexcessiveendeavorstoperpetuatelife.
ButIhaveheardthathewhoisskillful
atmanagingthelifeentrustedtohim
Foratimetravelsontheland
withouthavingtoshunrhinocerosortiger,
Andentersahostwithouthavingtoavoid
buffcoatorsharpweapon.
Therhinocerosfindsnoplaceinhim
intowhichtothrustitshorn,
Northetigeraplaceinwhichtofixitsclaws,
Northeweaponaplacetoadmititspoint.
Andforwhatreason?
Becausethereisinhimnoplaceofdeath.
Thenameofdeathwasneverterrible
tohimthatknewtolive.
Amanofthoughtiswillingtodie,
willingtolive.
Theworldisdeliveredintoyourhand,
butontwoconditions—
Notforproperty,butforuse,
Useaccordingtothenoblenatureofthegift,
notfortoys,andnotforself-indulgence.
Thingsworktotheirends,notyours,
Andwillcertainlydefeatanyadventurer
whofightsagainstthisordination.
Onthebordersofthegrave,thewiseman
looksforwardwithelasticityofmind,orhope.
51
AllthingsareproducedbytheTao,
andnourishedbyitsoutflowingoperation.
Theyreceivetheirformsaccordingtothenatureofeach,
andarecompletedaccording
tothecircumstancesoftheircondition.
Thereforeallthingswithoutexception
honortheTao,
Andexaltitsoutflowingoperation.
ThusitisthattheTaoproducesallthings,
Nourishesthem,bringsthemtotheirfullgrowth,
Nursesthem,completesthem,maturesthem,
maintainsthem,andoverspreadsthem.
Itproducesthemandmakesnoclaim
tothepossessionofthem;
Itcarriesthemthroughtheirprocesses
anddoesnotvauntitsabilityindoingso;
Itbringsthemtomaturityandexercises
nocontroloverthem—
Thisiscalleditsmysteriousoperation.
Themethodofnature:whocouldeveranalyzeit?
Thesimplicityofnatureisnotthat
whichmaybeeasilyread,
Butitisinexhaustible.
Thespiritandpeculiarityofthatimpressionis
Thatitdoesnotexisttoanyoneortoanynumber
ofparticularhands,
Buttonumberlessandendlessbenefit.
Thereisinitnoprivatewill,norebelleaforlimb,
butthewholeisoppressedby
oursuperincumbenttendency.
Natureconvertsitselfintoavastpromise,
andwillnotberashlyexplained.
52
TheTaowhichoriginatedallunderthesky
Istobeconsideredasthemotherofthemall.
Whenthemotherisfound,
Weknowwhatherchildrenshouldbe.
Whenoneknowsthatheishismother’schild,
andproceedstoguardthemotherthatbelongstohim,
Totheendofhislifehewillbefreefromallperil.
Lethimkeephismouthclosed,andshutup
theportalsofhisnostrils,
Andallhislifehewillbeexemptfromlaboriousexertion.
Lethimkeephismouthopened,
andspendhisbreath
inthepromotionofhisaffairs,
Andallhislifetherewillbenosafetyforhim.
Theperceptionofwhatissmallisthesecret
ofclear-sightedness;
Theguardingofwhatissoftandtender
isthesecretofstrength.
Whouseswellhislight,
Revertingtoitssourcesobright,
Willfromhisbodywardallblight,
Andhidestheunchangingfrommen’ssight.
Underallthisrunningseaofcircumstance,
whosewatersebbandflowwithperfectbalance,
liestheaboriginalabyssofrealBeing.
Letmeseeeverytriflebristlingwith
thepolaritythatrangesitinstantly
onaninternallaw.
Andtheshop,theplough,andtheledger
refertothelikecausebywhich
lightundulatesandpoetssing.
Theworldliesnolongeradullmiscellany,
buthasformandorder;
Thereisnotrifle,thereisnopuzzle;
Butonedesignwritesandanimates
thefarthestpinnacleandthelowesttrench.
Thereisalwayslifefortheliving;
Whatamanhasdoneamancando.
Everymanisprovidedwithakeytonature,
Andthatmanonlyrightlyknowshimself
asfarashehasexperimentedonthings.
53
IfIweresuddenlytobecomeknown,
Andputinapositiontoconduct
agovernmentaccordingtothegreatTao,
WhatIshouldhemostafraidofwouldheaboastfuldisplay.
ThegreatTaoisverylevelandeasy;
Butpeoplelovethebyways.
Theircourtyardsandbuildingsshallbewellkept,
Buttheirfieldsshallheillcultivated,
andtheirgranariesveryempty.
Theyshallwearelegantandornamentedrobes,
carryasharpswordattheirgirdle,
pamperthemselvesineatinganddrinking,
andhaveasuperabundanceofpropertyandwealth—
Suchprincesmaybecalledrobbersandboasters.
ThisiscontrarytotheTaosurely!
Whatamandoes,thathehas.
Lethimregardnogoodassolid,
butthatwhichisinhisnature.
Thegoodsoffortunemaycomeandgo
likesummerleaves;
Lethimscatterthemoneverywind
asmomentarysigns.
Virtueistheadherenceinaction
tothenatureofthings,
Andthenatureofthingsmakesitprevalent.
Itconsistsinaperpetualsubstitution
ofbeingforseeming.
Whyneedyouchoosesopainfullyyourplace,
andoccupation,andassociationandmodesofaction?
Foryou,thereisareality,afitplace
andcongenialduties.
54
WhatTao’sskillfulplanterplants
Canneverbeuptorn;
Whathisskillfularmsenfold,
Fromhimcanne’erbeborne.
Sonsshallbringinlengtheningline,
Sacrificestohisshrine.
Tao,whennursedwithinone’sself
Hisvigorwillmaketrue;
Andwherethefamilyitrules
Whatricheswillaccrue!
Theneighborhoodwhereitprevails
Inthrivingwillabound;
Andwhen’tisseenthroughoutthestate,
Goodfortunewillbefound.
Employitinthekingdomo’er
Andmenthriveallaround.
Allpowerisofonekind.
Themindthatisparallelwiththelawsofnature
Willbeinthecurrentofeventsandstrong
withtheirstrength.
Whohaslearnedtoroothimselfinbeing,
andwhollytoceasefromseeming,
Heisdomestic,andheisattheheartofnature.
Concentrationisthesecretofstrength.
Theimportanceofonepersonwhohasthetruth
overnationswhohaveitnot,
Isbecausepowerobeysreality,andnotappearance,
accordingtoquality,andnotquantity.
55
Hewhohasinhimselfabundantly
theattributesoftheTaoislikeaninfant.
Poisonousinsectswillnotstinghim;
Fiercebeastswillnotseizehim;
Birdsofpreywillnotstrikehim.
Theinfant’sbonesareweak
Anditssinewssoft,butyetitsgraspisfirm.
Itknowsnotyettheunionofmaleandfemale,
Andyetitsvirilemembermaybeexcited—
showingtheperfectionofitsphysicalessence.
Alldaylongitwillcryoutwithoutbecominghoarse
showingtheharmonyinitsconstitution.
Tohimbywhomthisharmonyisknown,
ThesecretoftheunchangingTaoisshown,
Andintheknowledgewisdomfindsitsthrone.
Alllife-increasingartstoevilturn;
Wherethemindmakesthevitalbreathtoburn,
Falseisthestrength,ando’eritweshouldmourn.
Whenthingshavebecomestrong,
Theythenbecomeold,
WhichmaybesaidtobecontrarytotheTao.
WhateveriscontrarytotheTaosoonends.
Thewillconstitutestheman.
Hehashislifeinnature,likeabeast,
Butchoiceisborninhim;
Hechoosesastherestofcreationdoesnot.
Butwill,pureandperceiving,isnotwillfulness.
Thehigh,contemplative,all-commandingvision,
thesenseofRightandWrong,isalikeinall.
Itsattributesareself-existence,eternity,
intuition,andcommand.
Itisthemindofthemind.
Webelongtoit,notittous.
Whilstamanseekgoodends,
Heisstrongbythewholestrengthofnature.
Insofarasherovesfromtheseends,
Hebereaveshimselfofpower,
Hebecomeslessandless.
56
HewhoknowstheTaodoesnotcaretospeakaboutit;
Hewhoiseverreadytospeakaboutitdoesnotknowit.
Hewhoknowsitwillkeephismouthshut
andclosetheportalsofhisnostrils.
Hewillblunthissharppoints
andunravelthecomplicationsofthings;
Hewilltemperhisbrightness,andbringhimself
intoagreementwiththeobscurityofothers.
Thisiscalledthemysteriousagreement.
Suchaonecannotbetreatedfamiliarly
ordistantly;
Heisbeyondallconsiderationofprofit
orinjury;
Ofnobilityormeanness—
Heisthenoblestmanunderheaven.
Hethatthinksmostwillsaytheleast.
Thelessamanthinksorknowsabouthisvirtues,
thebetterwelikehim.
Tofinishthemoment,hefindsthejourney’send
ineverystepoftheroad;
Tohim,thegreatestnumberofgoodhoursiswisdom.
Foritisonlythefinitethathaswrought
andsuffered;
Theinfiniteliesstretchedinsmilingrepose.
57
Astatemayberuledbymeasuresofcorrection;
Weaponsofwarmaybeusedwithcraftydexterity;
Butthekingdomismadeone’sown
onlybyfreedomfromactionandpurpose.
HowdoIknowthatitisso?Bythesefacts—
Inthekingdom,themultiplicationofprohibitiveenactments
increasesthepovertyofthepeople;
The more implements to add to their profit that the people
have,
thegreaterdisorderisthereinthestateandclan;
Themoreactsofcraftydexteritythatmenpossess,
themoredostrangecontrivancesappear;Themoredisplay
thereisoflegislation,
themorethievesandrobbersthereare.
Therefore,asagehassaid,“Iwilldonothingofpurpose,
andthepeoplewillbetransformedofthemselves.
Iwillbefondofkeepingstill,
andthepeoplewillofthemselvesbecomecorrect.Iwilltake
thetroubleaboutit,
andthepeoplewillthemselvesbecomerich;
Iwillmanifestnoambition,
andthepeoplewillofthemselvesattain
totheprimitivesimplicity.”
Weliveinaverylowstateoftheworld
andpayunwillingtributetogovernments
foundedinforce.
Thetendenciesofthetimesfavor
theideaofself-government
Andleavetheindividual,forallcode,
totherewardsandpenaltiesofhisownconstitution.
Therefore,allpublicendslookvagueandquixotic
besideprivateones.
Foranylawsbutthosewhichmen
makeforthemselvesarelaughable.
Hence,thelessgovernmentwehavethebetter,
thefewerlaws,andthelessconfidedpower.
Thepoweroflove,asthebasisofthestate,
hasneverbeentried.
Wemustnotimaginethatallthings
arelapsingintoconfusion,
Ifeverytenderprotestantbenotcompelled
tobearhispartincertainsocialconventions:Nordoubt
thatroadscanbebuilt,
Letterscarried,andthefruitoflaborerssecured
whenthegovernmentofforceisathand.
Couldnotanationoffriendsdeviseabetterway?
58
Thegovernmentthatseemsthemostunwise,
Oftgoodnesstothepeoplebestsupplies;
Thatwhichismeddling,touchingeverything,
Willworkbutill,anddisappointmentbring.
Misery!—happinessistobefoundbyitsside!
Happiness!—miserylurksbeneathit!
Whoknowswhateitherwillcometointheend?
Shallwethendispensewithcorrection?
Themethodofcorrectionshallbyaturn
becomedistortion,
Andthegoodinitshallbyaturnbecomeevil.
Thedelusionofthepeopleonthispoint
hasindeedsubsistedforalongtime.
Thereforethesageislikeasquare,
Whichcutsnoonewithitsangles;
Likeacorner,whichinjuresnoonewithitssharpness.
Heisstraightforward,butallowshimselfnolicense;
Heisbright,butdoesnotdazzle.
Ourtimeistoofullofactivityandperformance.
Theworldisgovernedtoomuch;
Thingshavetheirlaws,aswellasman;
andrefusetobetrifledwith.
Inchangingmoon,intidalwave,
GlowsthefeudofWantandHave,
Mountaintallandoceandeep
Tremblingbalancedulykeep.
Aninevitabledualismbisectsnature.
Thereaction,sograndintheelements,
isrepeatedwithinsmallboundaries.
Everyexcesscausesadefect;
Everydefectanexcess.
Everysweethathitssour,everyevilitsgood.
Awisemanwillextendthislesson
toallpartsoflife;
Whenheispushed,tormented,defeated,
Hehasachancetolearnsomething,
iscuredoftheinsanityofconceit,
hasgotmoderationandrealskill.
59
For regulating the human and rendering service to the
heavenly,
thereisnothinglikemoderation.
Itisonlybythismoderationthatthereiseffected
anearlyreturntoman’snormalstate.
ThatearlyreturniswhatIcalltherepeatedaccumulation
oftheattributesoftheTao.
With that repeated accumulation of those attributes, there
comes
asubjugationofeveryobstacletosuchreturn.
Ofthissubjugationweknownotwhatshallbethelimit;
Andwhenoneknowsnotwhatthelimitshallbe,
hemaybetherulerofastate.
Hewhopossessesthemotherofthestatemaycontinuelong.
Hiscaseislikethatoftheplant,ofwhichwesay
thatitsrootsaredeepanditsflowerstalksfirm—
Thisisthewaytosecurethatitsenduringlife
shalllongbeseen.
Byyourownactyouteachthebeholder
howtodothepracticable.
Accordingtothedepthfromwhichyoudraw
yourlife,
Suchisthedepthnotonlyofyourstrenuouseffort,
butofyourmannersandpresence.
Leavethemilitaryhurryandadoptthepaceofnature.
Hersecretispatience.
Havetheself-commandyouwishtoinspire.
Yourteachinganddisciplinemusthave
thereserveandtaciturnityofnature.
Saylittle;donotsnarl;donotchide;
butgovernbytheeye.
Seewhattheyneedandtherightthingisdone.
60
Governingagreatstateislikecookingsmallfish.
LetthekingdombegovernedaccordingtotheTao,
Andthemanesofthedepartedwillnotmanifest
theirspiritualenergy.
Itisnotthatthosemaneshavenotthatspiritualenergy,
butitwillnotbeemployedtohurtmen.
Itisnotthatitcouldnothurtmen,
butneitherdoestherulingsagehurtthem.
Whenthesetwodonotinjuriouslyaffecteachother,
TheirgoodinfluencesconvergeinthevirtueoftheTao.
Fear,CraftandAvarice
cannotrearastate;
Themorereason,thelessgovernment.
Inasensiblefamily,nobodyhears
thewords“shall”and“shan’t.”
Nobodycommandsandnobodyobeys
butallconspireandjoyfullycooperate.
Thewiseknowthatfoolishlegislation
isaropeofsand
whichperishesinthetwisting.
Thelawisonlyamemorandum.
Whenthestatehouseisthehearth,
theperfectstateiscome.
61
Whatmakesagreatstateisitsbeinglikealow-lying,
down-flowingstream—
Itbecomesthecentertowhichtend
allthesmallstatesunderheaven.
Toillustratefromthecaseofallfemales—
Thefemalealwaysovercomesthemalebyherstillness.
Stillnessmaybeconsideredasortofabasement.
Thusitisthatagreatstate,bycondescending
tosmallstates,gainsthemforitself,
Andthatsmallstates,byabasingthemselves
toagreatstate,winitovertothem.
Intheonecasetheabasementleadsto
gainingadherents,
Intheothercasetoprocuringfavor.
Thegreatstateonlywishestounitementogether
andnourishthem;
Asmallstateonlywishestobereceivedby,andtoserve,the
other.
Eachgetswhatitdesires,
butthegreatstatemustlearntoabaseitself.
Theexcellenceofmenconsists
inthecompletenesswithwhich
thelowersystemistakenupintothehigher—
Aprocessofmuchtimeanddelicacy.
Thosewhoarecapableofhumility,ofjustice,
oflove,ofaspiration,
Standalreadyonaplatformthatcommands
actionandgrace.
Thisisthelawofmoralandmentalgain.
Thesimplestriseasbyspecificlevity,
notintoaparticularvirtue,
Butintotheregionofallvirtues.
Sympathy,thefemaleforce,ismoresubtle,andlasting,
andcreative.
62
Taohasofallthingsthemosthonoredplace.
Notreasuresgivegoodmensorichagrace;
Badmenitguardsanddoththeirillefface.
Itsadmirablewordscanpurchasehonor;
Itsadmirabledeedscanraisetheirperformeraboveothers.
Evenmenwhoarenotgoodarenotabandonedbyit.
WhywasitthattheancientsprizedthisTaosomuch?
Wasitnotbecauseitcouldbegotbyseekingforit,
Andtheguiltycouldescapefromthestainoftheirguiltbyit?
Thisisthereasonwhyallunderheavenconsiderit
themostvaluablething.
Withageometryofsunbeams,thesoul
laysthefoundationofnature.
Ofthispurenature,everymanisatsometimesensible.
Languagecannotpaintitwithitscolors.
Itistoosubtle,itisindefinable,
unmeasurable,
Butweknowthatitpervadesandcontainsus.
Thetruthandgrandeurofthisthought
isprovedbyitsscopeandapplicability,
Foritcommandstheentireschedule
andinventoryofthingsforitsillustration.
63
ItisthewayoftheTaotoact
withoutthinkingofacting;
Toconductaffairswithoutfeeling
thetroubleofthem;
Totastewithoutdiscerninganyflavor;
Toconsiderwhatissmallasgreat,
andafewasmany;
Andtorecompenseinjurywithkindness.
Themasterofitanticipatesthingsthataredifficult
whiletheyareeasy
Anddoesthingsthatwouldbecomegreat
whiletheyaresmall.
Alldifficultthingsintheworldaresuretoarise
fromapreviousstateinwhichtheywereeasy,
Andallgreatthingsfromoneinwhichtheyweresmall
Hewholightlypromisesissuretokeep
butlittlefaith;
Hewhoiscontinuallythinkingthingseasy
issuretofindthemdifficult.
Thereforethesageseesdifficulty
eveninwhatseemseasy,
Andsoneverhasanydifficulties.
Clingingtonature,orthatprovinceofnature
whichheknows,
Hemakesnomistake,butworksafterherlaws,
andatherownpace.
Thatmanwillgofar—
Foryouseeinhismanners
thatrecognitionofhimbyothersis
notnecessarytohim.
Sothathisdoing,whichisperfectlynatural,
appearsmiraculous.
Asensiblemandoesnotbrag,
Omitshimselfashabitually
asanothermanobtrudeshimselfinthediscourse.
64
Thatwhichisatrestiseasilykeptholdof
Beforeathinghasgivenindicationsofitspresence,
itiseasytotakemeasuresagainstit;
Thatwhichisbrittleiseasilybroken;
Thatwhichisverysmalliseasilydispersed.
Actionshouldbetakenbeforeathing
hasmadeitsappearance;
Ordershouldbesecuredbeforedisorderhasbegun.
Thetreewhichfillsthearmsgrew
fromthetiniestsprout;
Thetowerofninestoriesrosefromasmallheapofearth;
Thejourneyofathousandli
commencedwithasinglestep.
Hewhoactswithanulteriorpurposedoesharm;
Hewhotakesholdofathinginthesameway
loseshishold.
Thesagedoesnotactso,
andthereforedoesnoharm;
Hedoesnotlayholdso,
andthereforedoesnotlosehishold.
Thesagedesireswhatothermendonotdesire,
anddoesnotprizethingsdifficulttoget;
Helearnswhatothermendonotlearn,andturnsback
towhatthemultitudeofmenhavepassedby.
Thushehelpsthenaturaldevelopmentofallthings,
Anddoesnotdaretoactwithanulteriorpurposeofhisown.
Everyultimatefactisonlythefirst
ofanewseries.
Thereisnooutside,noinclosingwall,
nocircumferencetous.
Thatwhichbuildsisbetterthan
thatwhichisbuilt.
Causeandeffect,meansandends,seedandfruit
cannotbesevered;
Fortheeffectalreadybloomsinthecause,
Theendpreexistsinthemeans,
Thefruitisintheseed.
Ourstrengthgrowsourweakness;
Whilstamansitsonthecushionofadvantages,
hegoestosleep.
Themanwhorenounceshimself,
comestohimself.
Everystepsodownward,isastepupward.
Wordsandactionsarenottheattributesof
abrutenature;
Theycannotcoverthedimensionsof
whatisintruth.
Thewiseman,indoingonething,doesall;
Or,intheonethinghedoesrightly,
Heseesthelikenessofallwhichisdonerightly.
65
TheancientswhoshowedtheirskillinpracticingtheTao
didsonottoenlightenthepeople,
Butrathertomakethemsimpleandignorant.
Thedifficultyingoverningthepeoplearises
fromtheirhavingmuchknowledge.
Whotriestogovernthestatebyhiswisdom
isascourgetoit;
Whilehewhodoesnottrytodosoisablessing.
Hewhoknowsthesetwothingsfindsinthem
alsohismodelandrule.
Abilitytoknowthismodelandruleconstituteswhatwecall
themysteriousexcellenceofagovernor.
Deepandfar-reachingissuchmysteriousexcellence,
Showingindeeditspossessorasoppositetoothers,
Butleadingthemtoagreatconformitytohim.
Asfastasthepublicmindisopened
tomoreintelligence,
Thecodeisseentobebruteandstammering.
ThewiseknowthattheStatemustfollowandnotlead
thecharacterandprogressofthecitizen.
Thestrongestusurperisquicklygotridof,
Andthatformofgovernmentwhichprevails
Istheexpressionofwhatcultivationexists
inthepopulationwhichpermitsit.
ThehistoryoftheStatesketchesincoarseoutline
theprogressofthought.
Andfollowsatadistancethedelicacy
ofcultureandaspiration.
66
Thatwherebytheriversandseasareabletoreceive
thehomageandtributeofallthevalleystreams,
istheirskillinbeinglowerthanthey—
Itisthusthattheyarethekingsofthemall.
Soitisthatthesage,wishingtobeabovemen,
putshimselfbyhiswordsbelowthem,
Andwishingtobebeforethem,placeshispersonbehindthem.
Asensiblemanavoidsintroducingthenames
ofhiscreditablecompanions,
Andiscontentputtinghisfactortheme
simplyonitsground.
Youshallnottellmethatyourcommercialhouse,
yourpartnersoryourselfareofimportance;
Youshallnottellmethatyouhavelearned
toknowmen;
Youshallmakemefeelthat
yoursayingsounsaysit.
67
Alltheworldsaysthat,whilemyTaoisgreat,
Ityetappearstobeinferiortoothersystemsofteaching.
Nowitisjustitsgreatnessthatmakesitseemtoheinferior.
Ifitwerelikeanyothersystem,
forlongwoulditssmallnesshavebeenknown!
WithgentlenessIcanhebold;
WitheconomyIcanheliberal;
Shrinkingfromtakingprecedenceofothers,
Icanbecomeavesselofthehighesthonor.
Nowadaystheygiveupgentleness
andareallforbeingbold;
Economy,andareallforbeingliberal;
Thehindmostplace,andseekonlytobeforemost;
ofallwhichtheendisdeath.
Gentlenessissuretobevictoriouseveninbattle,
andfirmlytomaintainitsground.
Heavenwillsaveitspossessor,
byhisverygentlenessprotectinghim.
Self-trustisthefirstsecretofsuccess.
Ifearthepopularnotionofsuccess
standsindirectoppositiononallpoints
totherealandwholesomesuccess.
Oneadorespublicopinion,theotherprivateopinion,
onefame,theotherdesert;
onefeats,theotherhumility;
onelucre,theotherlove.
Whatisespeciallytrueoflove,
isthatitisastateofextremeimpressionability;
Theloverhasmoresensesandfinersensesthanothers,
Hiseyeandeararetelegraphs;
Hereadsomensontheflower,andcloud,
andface,andgesture,
Andreadsthemright.
68
HewhoinTao’swarshasskill
Assumesnomartialfort;
Hewhofightswithmostgoodwill
Toragemakesnoresort.
Hewhovanquishesyetstill
Keepsfromhisfoesapart;
Hewhosebehestsmenmostfulfill
Yethumblyplieshisart.
Thuswesay,“Hene’ercontends,
Andthereinishismight.”
Thuswesay,“Men’swillshebends,
Thattheywithhimunite.”
Thuswesay,“LikeHeaven’shisends,
Nosageofoldmorebright.”
Itisavulgarerrortosupposethat
amanmustbereadytofight.
Theutmostthatcanbedemandedoftheman
isthatheisincapableofalie.
Youmayspituponhim;nothingcould
inducehimtospituponyou—
Nopraises,nopossessions,nocompulsion
ofpublicopinion.
Youmaykickhim;hewillthinkit
thekickofabrute,
andwillnotkickyouinreturn,
Butneitheryourknife,norpistol
willevermaketheslightestimpression.
69
Amasteroftheartofwarhassaid,
“Idonotdaretobethehost(tocommencethewar);
Iprefertobetheguest(toactonthedefensive).
Idonotdaretoadvanceaninch;
Iprefertoretireafoot.”
Thisiscalledmarshalingtherankswhentherearenoranks;
Baringthearmstofightwhentherearenoarmstobare;
Graspingtheweaponwhenthereisnoweapontograsp;
Advancingagainsttheenemywhenthereisnoenemy.
Thereisnocalamitygreaterthanlightlyengaginginwar.
Todothatisnearlosingthegentlenesswhichissoprecious.
Thusitisthatwhenopposingweaponsareactuallycrossed,
hewhodeploresthesituationconquers.
Hewholovesthebristleofbayonets
onlyseesintheirglitter
whatbeforehandhefeelsinhisheart.
Theleastchangeinthemanwillchange
hiscircumstances;
Theleastenlargementofhisideas,
Theleastmitigationofhisfeelings
inrespecttoothermen.
If,forexample,hecouldbeinspired
withatenderkindnesstothesoulsofmen,
Andshouldcometofeelthateverymanwasanotherself,
withwhomhemightcometojoin—
Everydegreeoftheascendancyofthisfeeling
would cause the most striking of changes of external
things.
70
Mywordsareveryeasytoknowandeasytopractice;
Butthereisnooneintheworld
whoisabletoknowandabletopracticethem.
Thereisanoriginatingandall-comprehending
principleinmywords,
Andanauthoritativelawforthethings
whichIenforce.
Itisbecausetheydonotknowthese,
thatmendonotknowme.
Theywhoknowmearefew,
AndIamonthataccounttobeprized.
Itisthusthatthesagewearsapoorgarment
ofhaircloth,
Whilehecarrieshissignetofjadeinhisbosom.
Mywillfulactionsandacquisitions
arebutroving;
Theidlestreverie,thefaintestnativeemotion
commandsmycuriosity.
Myperceptionisasmuchafactasthesun.
Wheneveramindissimple
andreceivesadivinewisdom,
Oldthingspassaway—
Means,teachers,texts,templesfall.
Amancannotbehappyandstrong
untilhe,too,lives
withnature,inthepresent,abovetime.
71
Toknowandyetthinkwedonotknow
isthehighestattainment;
Nottoknowandyetthinkwedoknow
isadisease.
Itissimplybybeingpainedatthethought
ofhavingthisdisease
thatwearepreservedfromit.
Thesagehasnotthedisease.
Heknowsthepainthatwouldbe
inseparablefromit;
Andthereforehedoesnothaveit.
Ifanyofusknewwhatweweredoing,
orwherewearegoing,
Thenwhenwethinkwebestknow!
Weglidethroughnatureandshouldnotknow
ourplaceagain.
Allthingsswimandglitter;
Ourlifeisnotsomuchthreatenedas
ourperception.
Butinthesolitudetowhicheveryman
isalwaysreturning,
Hehasasanityandrevelations,
whichinhispassageintonewworlds
hewillcarrywithhim.
72
Whenthepeopledonotfearwhat
theyoughttofear,
Thatwhichistheirgreatestdread
willcometothem.
Letthemnotthoughtlesslyindulgethemselves
intheirordinarylife;
Letthemnotactasifwearyofwhat
lifedependson.
Itisbyavoidingsuchindulgencethat
suchwearinessdoesnotarise.
Thereforethesageknowsthesethings,
butdoesnotparadehisknowledge;
Loves,butdoesnotappeartosetavalue
onhimself.
Andthusheputsthelatteralternativeaway
andmakesachoiceoftheformer.
Theuseoftheworldisthatmanmay
learnitslaws.
Whenamanstupidbecomesamaninspired,
Whenoneandthesameman
Passesoutofthetorpidintotheperceivingstate,
Leavesthedinoftrifles,thestuporofthesenses,
toenterintothequasi-omniscienceofhigherthought—
Upanddown,allaroundgo,
Alllimitsdisappear,
Nohorizonshutsdown.
Heseesthingsintheircauses,
allfactsintheirconnection.
73
Hewhoseboldnessappearsinhisdaring
todowrong,indefianceofthelaws,
isputtodeath;
Hewhoseboldnessinhisnotdaringtodoso,
liveson.
Ofthesetwocasestheoneappearstobe
advantageous,andtheothertobeinjurious.
But
WhenHeaven’sangersmitesaman,
Whothecauseshalltrulyscan?
Onthisaccountthesagefeelsadifficulty
astowhattodointheformercase.
ItisthewayofHeavennottostrive,
andyetitskillfullyovercomes;
Nottospeak,andyetitisskillful
inobtainingareply;
Nottocall,andyetmencometoitofthemselves.
Itsdemonstrationsarequiet,
Andyetitsflansareskillfulandeffective.
ThemeshesofthenetofHeavenarelarge;
Farapart,butlettingnothingescape.
Crimeandpunishmentgrowoutofonestem.
Punishmentisafruitthatunsuspectedripens
withintheflowerofthepleasurewhichconcealedit.
Everyactrewardsitself,integratesitself
inatwo-foldmanner;
Firstinthething,orinrealnature,
Andsecondlyinthecircumstance,
orapparentnature.
Thecausalretributionisinthething,
andisseenbythesoul.
Theretributionofthecircumstance
isseenbytheunderstanding.
Whatwecallretributionistheuniversalnecessity
bywhichthewholeappearswheneverapartappears.
74
Thepeopledonotfeardeath;
Towhatpurposeisittotrytofrightenthemwithdeath?
Ifthepeoplewerealwaysinaweofdeath,
AndIcouldalwaysseizethosewhodowrong,
andputthemtodeath,
Whowoulddaretodowrong?
ThereisalwaysOnewhopresidesover
theinflictionofdeath.
Hewhowouldinflictdeathintheroomofhim
whosopresidesoverit
Maybedescribedashewingwood
insteadofagreatcarpenter.
Seldomisitthathewhoundertakesthehewing,
insteadofthegreatcarpenter,
Doesnotcuthisownhands!
Whyarethemasses,fromthedawnof
historydown,
Foodforknivesandpowder?
Theideadignifiedafewleaders,
whomadewaranddeathsacred,
Butwhatforthewretches
whomtheyhireandkill?
Thecheapnessofmaniseveryday’stragedy.
Itisadoctrinealikeoftheoldest,
andofthenewestphilosophy,
Thatmanisone,andthatyoucannot
injureanymember
Withoutasympatheticinjury
toallthemembers.
75
Thepeoplesufferfromfaminebecause
ofthemultitudeoftaxesconsumedbytheirsuperiors.
Itisthroughthisthattheysufferfamine.
Thepeoplearedifficulttogovernbecause
oftheexcessiveagencyoftheirsuperiors.
Itisthroughthisthattheyaredifficulttogovern.
Thepeoplemakelightofdyingbecause
ofthegreatnessoftheirlabors
inseekingforthemeansofliving.
Itisthiswhichmakesthemthinklightofdying.Thusitisthat
toleavethesubjectofliving
altogetheroutofview
Isbetterthantosetahighvalueonit.
Thewholeinstitutionofpropertyonitspresenttenures
isinjurious,anditsinfluenceonpersons
deterioratinganddegrading;
Truly,theonlyinterestfortheconsiderationofthestate
ispersons;
Propertywillalwaysfollowpersons.
Thehighestendofgovernmentisthecultureofmen.
Ifmencouldbeeducated,theinstitutionswill
sharetheirimprovement,
Andthemoralsentimentwillwritethelawoftheland.
76
Manathisbirthissuppleandweak;
athisdeath,firmandstrong.
Soitiswithallthings.
Treesandplants,intheirearlygrowth,
aresoftandbrittle;
Attheirdeath,dryandwithered.
Thusitisthatfirmnessandstrengthare
theconcomitantsofdeath;
Softnessandweakness,theconcomitantsoflife.
Hence,hewhoreliesonthestrengthofhisforces
doesnotconquer;
Andatreewhichisstrongwillfilltheoutstretchedarms,
andtherebyinvitesthefeller.
Thereforetheplaceofwhatisfirmandstrongisbelow,
Andthatofwhatissoftandweakisabove.
Whenwecomeintotheworld
Awonderfulwhispergivesusadirection
forthewholeroad.
Ah!Ifonecouldkeepthissensibility,
andliveinthehappy,sufficingpresent,
Andfindthedayandhischiefmeanscontenting,
whichonlyaskreceptivityinyou,
andnostrainedexertionorcankeringambition.
Wearenotstrongbyourpowertopenetrate,
tohavedistinctionandlaurelsandconsumption;
Theworldisenlargedforusnotbynewobjects,
Butbyfindingmoreaffinitiesandpotencies
thanthosewehave.
77
MaynottheTaoofHeavenhecompared
tothemethodofbendingahow?
Thepartofthehowwhichwashighisbroughtlow,
Andwhatwaslowisraisedup.
SoHeavendiminisheswherethereissuperabundance,
andsupplementswherethereisdeficiency.
ItistheWayofHeaventodiminishsuperabundance,
andtosupplementdeficiency.
Itisnotsowiththewayofman.
Hetakesawayfromthosewhohavenotenough
toaddtohisownsuperabundance.
Whocantakehisownsuperabundanceand
therewithserveallunderHeaven?
OnlyhewhoisinpossessionoftheTao!
Iambornintothegreat,theuniversalmind.
I,theimperfect,adoremyownPerfect.
Iamsomehowreceptiveofthegreatsoul,
AndtherebydoIoverlookthesunandstars.
Moreandmorethesurgesofeverlastingnature
enterintome.
Iamwillingalsotobeaspassive
tothegreatforcesIacknowledge,
asthethermometer,ortheclock,
Andquitepartwithallwillassuperfluous.
Iamawillowofthewilderness,
lovingthewindthatbentme.
78
Thereisnothingintheworldmoresoft
andweakthanwater,
Andyetforattackingthingsthatarefirmandstrong
thereisnothingthatcantakeprecedenceofit—
Forthereisnothingforwhichitcanhechanged.
Everyoneintheworldknowsthatthesoft
overcomesthehard,andtheweakthestrong,
Butnooneisabletocarryitoutinpractice.
Thereforeasagehassaid,
“Hewhoacceptshisstate’sreproach,
Ishailedthereforeitsaltars’lord;
Tohimwhohearsmen’sdirefulwoes
Theyallthenameofkingaccord.”
Wordsthatarestrictlytrueseemtoheparadoxical.
Thereisaprinciplewhichisthebasisofthings.
Asimple,quiet,undescribed,undescribablepresence,
isdwellingverypeacefullyinus.
Wearenottodo,buttoletdo;
nottowork,buttobeworkedupon.
Wecannotdisenchant,wecannot
impoverishourselvesbyobedience;
Butbyhumilitywerise,byobediencewecommand;
Bypovertywearerich,bydyingwelive.
Thesefactshavealwayssuggestedtoman
thesublimecreed.
79
Whenareconciliationiseffectedafteragreatanimosity,
Thereissuretobeagrudgeremaining
inthemindoftheonewhowaswrong.
Andhowcanthisbebeneficialtotheother?
Therefore,toguardagainstthis,thesagekeeps
theleft-handportionoftherecordoftheengagement,
Anddoesnotinsistonthespeedyfulfillmentofit
bytheotherparty.
So,hewhohastheattributesoftheTao
regardsonlytheconditionsoftheengagement,
Whilehewhohasnotthoseattributes
regardsonlytheconditionsfavorabletohimself.
IntheWayofHeaven,thereisnopartialityoflove;
Itisalwaysonthesideofthegoodman.
Bygoingonestepfartherbackinthought,
Discordantopinionsarereconciled
bybeingseenastwoextremesofoneprinciple,
Andwecannevergosofarbackasto
precludeastillhighervision.
Whenwegetanadvantage
Itisbecauseouradversaryhascommittedafault.
Forgivehiscrime,forgivehisvirtues,too,
Thosesmallerfaults,halfconverttotheright.
80
Inalittlestatewithasmallpopulation,
Iwouldsoorderit,that,
Thoughtherewereindividualswiththeabilities
oftenorahundredmen,
Thereshouldbenoemploymentofthem;
Iwouldmakethepeople,
Whilelookingondeathasagrievousthing,
Yetnotremoveelsewheretoavoidit.
Thoughtheyhadboatsandcarriages,
Theyshouldhavenooccasiontorideinthem;
Thoughtheyhadbuffcoatsandsharpweapons,
Theyshouldhavenooccasiontodonorusethem.
Iwouldmakethepeoplereturntotheuse
ofknottedcordsinsteadofthewrittencharacters.
Theyshouldthinktheircoarsefoodsweet;
Theirplainclothesbeautiful;
Theirpoordwellingsplacesofrest;
Andtheirsimplewayssourcesofenjoyment.
Thereshouldbeaneighboringstatewithinsight,
Andthevoicesofthefowlsanddogs
shouldbeheardallthewayfromittous,
ButIwouldmakethepeopletooldage,eventodeath,
nothaveanyintercoursewithit.
Toeducatethewiseman,theStateexists;
Andwiththeappearanceofthewiseman,
theStateexpires.
Theappearanceofcharacter
makestheStateunnecessary.
Thewisemanneedsnoarmy,port,ornavy—
Helovesmentoowell;
Nobribe,nofeast,orpalacetodraw
friendstohim;
Novantageground,nofavorablecircumstance.
Heneedsnolibrary,forhehasnotdonethinking;
Nochurch,forheisaprophet;
Nostatutebook,forhehasthelawgiver;
Noroad,forheisathomewhereheis;
Noexperience,forthelifeofthecreator
shinesthroughhimandlooksfromhiseyes.
Hisrelationtomenisangelic;hismemory
ismyrrhtothem;
Hispresence,frankincenseandflowers.
81
Sincerewordsarenotfine;
Finewordsarenotsincere.
ThosewhoareskilledintheTao
donotdisputeaboutit;
Thedisputatiousarenotskilledinit.
ThosewhoknowtheTaoarenotextensivelylearned;
Theextensivelylearneddonotknowit.
Thesagedoesnotaccumulateforhimself.
Themorethatheexpendsforothers,
Themoredoeshepossessofhisown;
Themorethathegivestoothers,
Themoredoeshehavehimself.
WithallthesharpnessoftheWayofHeaven,
itinjuresnot;
Withallthedoinginthewayofthesage
hedoesnotstrive.
Letusnotbethevictimsofwords;
Theywhospeakhavenomore,—haveless.
Iamexplainedwithoutexplaining;
Iamfeltwithoutaction,
andwhereIamnot.
Thethingutteredinwordsisnotthereforeaffirmed;
Heteacheswhogivesandhelearnswhoreceives;
Heisgreatwhoconfersthemostbenefits.
Aconsenttosolitudeandinaction,
whichproceedsoutofanunwillingness
toviolatecharacter,
Isthecenturywhichmakesthegem.
Imustactwithtruth,thoughIshouldnevercometoact,
asyoucallit,witheffect.
Imustconsenttoinaction,apatiencewhichisgrand.
E
MERSON
S
OURCES
(Unlessotherwiseindicatedallexcerptsaretakenfromessays)Chapter
1.“TheOver-Soul/’“Idealism,”“ThePoet”
Chapter 2. “Compensation/’ “Each and All” (poem), “Man the
Reformer”(lecture),“SpiritualLaws”
Chapter3.“Circles”
Chapter4.“TheAmericanScholar”(address),“SensesandSoul”
Chapter5.“Nature,”“Circles”
Chapter 6. “Musketaquid” (poem), “The Transcendentalist,” “The
Over-Soul”
Chapter7.“TheTranscendentalist,”“TheOver-Soul”
Chapter8.“Merlin”(poem),Journals1830,Journals1831
Chapter9.“Fate,”“Worship,”“Wealth,”“TheScholar”
Chapter10.“Threnody”(poem),“Musketaquid”(poem),“TheOver-
Soul,”“Education”
Chapter11.“Compensation”
Chapter12.“PoetryandImagination”
Chapter13.“Self-Reliance,”“Compensation”
Chapter14.“TheMethodofNature”(address),“Spirit”
Chapter15.“Plato,”“TheUsesofGreatMen,”“Considerationsbythe
Way”
Chapter16.Journals1838,“SpiritualLaws,”“TheMethodofNature”
(address)Chapter17.“Politics”
Chapter18.“NewEnglandReformers,”Journals1832
Chapter19.“Success”
Chapter20.“Illusions,”“Circles,”“TheMethodofNature”(address),
“TheOver-Soul”
Chapter21.“Language,”“Circles,”“TheWorld-Soul”
Chapter22.“TheOver-Soul”
Chapter23.“NominalistandRealist,”“History”
Chapter24.“Prudence,”“Culture”
Chapter 25. “Monadnoc” (poem), “The World-Soul,” “Concord
Hymn” (poem), “Nature” (poem), “Fate” (poem), “History,”
“Beauty”
Chapter26.“SpiritualLaws,”“Politics”
Chapter27.“ConsiderationsbytheWay,”“Education”
Chapter 28. Journals 1839, “Nominalist and Realist,” “Illusions,”
“Education”
Chapter 29. “Worship,” “Fate,” “Nature” (poem), “Nominalist and
Realist,”“Nature”(essay)Chapter30.“War”(address)
Chapter31.“War”(address)
Chapter32.“Nature,”“TheOver-Soul”
Chapter33.“Self-Reliance”
Chapter34.“Nature,”“TheOver-Soul”
Chapter35.“TheUsesofGreatMen,”“Worship”
Chapter36.“Compensation”
Chapter37.“Character”(lecture)
Chapter38.“ConsiderationsbytheWay,”“Discipline”
Chapter39.“History,”“Fate”
Chapter 40. “The Method of Nature” (address) Chapter 41. “The
MethodofNature”(address),“TheOver-Soul”
Chapter42.“Circles,”“TheMethodof
Nature” (address), “Works and Days,” “War” (address) Chapter 43.
“Illusions,”“Prudence”
Chapter44.Journals1846,“Nature”(poem),“Greatness”
Chapter45.“Experience,”“Prudence”
Chapter 46. “The Method of Nature” (address) Chapter 47. “Self-
Reliance,”“TheOver-Soul”
Chapter48.“SpiritualLaws”
Chapter49.“Education,”“Self-Reliance,”“SpiritualLaws”
Chapter50.“Immortality,”“PerpetualForces”
Chapter 51. “Nature,” “Spiritual Laws,” “The Method of Nature”
(address) Chapter 52. “Compensation,” “The American Scholar”
(address),sources”
Chapter53.“SpiritualLaws”
Chapter54.“Power,”Journals1841,“TheProgressofCulture”
Chapter55.“Character”(address)
Chapter56.“Spirit,”“Experience,”“SpiritualLaws”
Chapter57.“Politics”
Chapter 58. “Lecture on the Times,” “New England Reformers,”
“Politics,”“Compensation”
Chapter59.“Education”
Chapter60.“Character,”“Politics”
Chapter 61. “The Sovereignty of Ethics,” “The Over-Soul,”
“Education”
Chapter62.“TheOver-Soul,”“Intellect”
Chapter63.“Greatness”
Chapter64.“Circles,”“Compensation”
Chapter65.“Politics”
Chapter66.“Greatness”
Chapter67.“Success”
Chapter68.Journals1849
Chapter69.“War”(address)
Chapter70.“Self-Reliance”
Chapter71.“Experience”
Chapter72.“Education”
Chapter73.“Compensation”
Chapter74.“TheUsesofGreatMen,”“LectureontheTimes”
Chapter75.“Politics”
Chapter76.Journals1845,“Success”
Chapter 77. “Spiritual Laws,” “The Over-Soul,” Journals 1835,
“Musketaquid”(poem)Chapter78.Worship,”“TheSovereigntyof
Ethics, “The Divinity School Address Chapter 79. “Circles,”
“Courage”
Chapter80.“Politics”
Chapter 81. “Society and Solitude,” “Ex-”Spiritual Laws,”
“Compensation”“LectureontheTimes”
B
IBLIOGRAPHY
Ames, Roger T. and David L. Hall. Dao De Jing: A Philosophical Translation. New York:
BallantineBooks,2003.
Bahm, Archie J. Too the King by Lao Tzu; Interpreted as Nature and Intelligence. New York:
FrederickUngarPublishing,1958.
Blofeld,John.TheSecretandSublime:TaoistMysteriesandMagic.NewYork:E.P.Dutton,
1973.
Brecht, Bertolt. Poems 1913-1956. Edited by John Willett and Ralph Manheim with the
cooperationofErichFried.LondonandNewYork:Methuen,1980.
Bynner, Witter. The Way of Life According to Lao Tzu: An American Version. New York:
CapricornBooks,1962.
Cabot,JamesElliott.AMemoirofRalphWaldoEmerson.2vols.London:HoughtonMifflin,
1897.
Chen, Ellen M. The Too Te Ching: A New Translation with Commentary. St. Paul, Minn.:
ParagonHouse,1989.
Christy,Arthur.TheOrientinAmericanTranscendentalism,NewYork:OctagonBooks,1978.
Chungliang Al Huang. Embrace Tiger, Return to Mountain: The Essence of Tai Ji. 1973.
Berkeley,Calif:CelestialArts,1987.
_______.QuantumSoup:APhilosophicalEntertainment.NewYork:E.P.Dutton,1983.
Clarke,J.J.TheToooftheWest.LondonandNewYork:Routledge,2000.
Emerson, Ralph Waldo. The Collected Works of Ralph Waldo Emerson. Edited by Alfred R.
Ferguson,JosephSlater,DouglasEmoryWilson,etal.12vols,todate.Cambridge,Mass.:
HarvardUniversityPress,1971-2003.
_______.TheJournalsandMiscellaneousNotebooksofRalphWaldoEmerson.
Edited by William A. Gilman, Ralph H. Orth, et al. 16 vols. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard
UniversityPress,1982-2003.
Ferguson, Andy. Zen’s Chinese Heritage: The Masters and Their Teachings. Boston: Wisdom
Publications,2000.
Friedell,Egon.ACulturalHistoryoftheModernAge.3vols.NewYork:AlfredA.Knopf,1933.
Geldard,Richard.TheSpiritualTeachingsofRalphWaldoEmerson.Hudson,N.Y:Lindisfarne
Press,2001.
Gia-Fu Feng and Jane English, Tao Te Ching [by] Lao Tzu: A New Translation. New York:
Knopf,1972.
Groff,Richard.ThoreauandthePropheticTradition.LosAngeles:TheManasPublishingCo.,
1961.
Grossman,Richard.AYearwithEmerson.Boston:DavidGodine,2003.
Henricks,RobertG.Lao-tzu:Te-taoChing:ANewTranslationBasedontheRecentlyDiscovered
Ma-wang-tuiTexts.NewYork:TheModernLibrary,1993.
Lau,D.C.LaoTzu:TaoTeChing:TranslatedwithanIntroduction.NewYork:Penguin,1963.
Legge,James.TheTextsofTaoism.Oxford:OxfordUniversityPress,1891.
LinYutang.TheWisdomofLaotse.NewYork:RandomHouse,1948.
_______.TheWisdomofChinaandIndia.NewYork:RandomHouse,1942.
Merton,Thomas.TheWayofChuangTzu.NewYork:NewDirections,1965.
Mitchell,Stephen.TaoteChing:ANewEnglishVersion.NewYork:Harper&Row,1988.
Paramananda,Swami.EmersonandVedanta.1918.Boston:TheVedantaCenter,2ndedition,
revisedandenlarged,ND.
Perry,Bliss.TheHeartofEmerson’sJournals.Boston:HoughtonMifflin,1926.
Porte, Joel. Emerson in His Journals. Cambridge, Mass.: The Belknap Press of the Harvard
UniversityPress,1982.
Rawson,Philip,andLaszloLegeza.Too:TheChinesePhilosophyofTimeandChange.London:
ThamesandHudson,1979.
RedPine.Lao-tzu’sTaoteching:TranslatedbyRedPinewithSelectedCommentariesofthePast
2000Years.SanFrancisco:MercuryHouse,1996.
Richardson,RobertD.,Jr.Emerson:TheMindonFire.Berkeley:UniversityofCaliforniaPress,
1995.
Richter,GregoryC.TheGateofAllMarvelousThings:AGuidetoReadingtheTaoTeChing.San
Francisco:RedMansionsPublishing,1998.
Roberts,Moss.DaoDeJing:TheBookoftheWay.Berkeley:UniversityofCaliforniaPress,
2001.
Star,Jonathan.TaoTeChing:TheDefinitiveEditionbyLaoTzu:TranslationandCommentaryby
JonathanStar.NewYork:JeremyP.Tarcher/Penguin,2003.
WaleyArthur.ThreeWaysofThoughtinAncientChina.1939.London:GeorgeAllen&Unwin,
1963.
_______.TheWayandItsPower:AStudyoftheTooTeChingandItsPlaceinChineseThought.
NewYork:GrovePress,1958.
_______.TheAnalectsofConfucius.NewYork:RandomHouse,1938.
Watson, Burton. Chuang Tzu: Basic Writings. New York and London: Columbia University
Press,1964.
Watts, Alan, with Chungliang Al Huang. Tao: The Watercourse Way. New York: Pantheon
Books,1975.
Welch,Holmes.Taoism:ThePartingoftheWay.Boston:BeaconPress,1966.
Wu,JohnC.H.TaoTeChingbyLaoTzu.Boston:Shambhala,1989.
A
CKNOWLEDGMENTS
The magnificent calligraphy in this book is the work and the
gift of my old friend Chungliang Al Huang, a Taoist master,
author,musician,dancer,andinternationallyknownteacherof
TaiJiandtheartofChinesewriting.Ofhismanybooks,the
first,EmbraceTiger,ReturntoMountain,afterremaininginprint
for thirty-four years in English, is now available in thirteen
languagesaroundtheworld.Iamhonoredbyhiscontribution
toTheTaoofEmerson.
Forpersonalandeditorialsupport,Iamespeciallygratefulto
Dr. Richard Geldard, a noted Emerson and Transcendentalist
scholar,andhisassociatesDavidBeardsleyAlecEmerson,and
Jim Manley at The Ralph Waldo Emerson Institute. This
organization maintains the website rwe.org, which provides
access on the Internet to every word Emerson ever wrote,
includingadigitalversionofthecompleteJournals.Noonecan
engage in the serious study of Emerson without using this
invaluable resource. I have been the beneficiary of an
extraordinaryamountofsuchassistancewiththisproject.
I am continually grateful to Jill Kneerim of Kneerim &
Williams for her steady, patient, and always enthusiastic
shepherdingofmybooksfromideatopublication.
My thanks, too, to those who have given me willing and
invaluable help in the development of this book: David
Ebershoff, W. S. Merwin, Jon Swan, Larry Volper, Paul de
Paolo, Deborah Smith, Ron Ragusa, my colleagues at Smith
FarmCenterforHealingandtheArts,JonUmhoeferandThe
Arts and Humanities Foundation, and my special gratitude to
my editor, Judy Sternlight, for her understanding and
collegialityintheproductionofacomplexbook.
Alwaysattheendoflistslikethese,butalwayspreeminently
first in providing help and wisdom whenever I need them, I
thankmywife,AnnArensberg.
A
BOUTTHE
E
DITOR
R
ICHARD
G
ROSSMAN
is a psychotherapist, medical educator,
essayist, and former book editor and publisher who taught
about Taoism and Emerson for many years as associate
professor of humanities at New York University and Hunter
College.HehasalsobeenonthefacultyoftheAlbertEinstein
College of Medicine and the Residency Program in Urban
FamilyMedicineatBethIsraelMedicalCenter.
HewascontributingeditortoHealthmagazinefortenyears,
and his articles on health and psychology have appeared in
dozensofmedicaljournalsandpopularmagazines.Amonghis
sixpreviousbooksareBoldVoices,ChoosingandChanging,and
AYearwithEmerson,whichwasawardedtheUmhoeferPrizein
2006 for achievement in the humanities by the Arts and
Humanities Foundation. He is married to the novelist Ann
ArensbergandlivesinSalisbury,Connecticut.
T
HE
M
ODERN
L
IBRARY
E
DITORIAL
B
OARD
MayaAngelou
•
A.S.Byatt
•
CalebCarr
•
ChristopherCerf
•
HaroldEvans
•
CharlesFrazier
•
VartanGregorian
•
JessicaHagedorn
•
RichardHoward
•
CharlesJohnson
•
JonKrakauer
•
EdmundMorris
•
AzarNafisi
•
JoyceCarolOates
•
ElainePagels
•
JohnRichardson
JohnRichardson
•
SalmanRushdie
•
•liverSacks
•
CarolynSee
•
GoreVidal
2007ModemLibraryEditionCompilationcopyright©2007byRandom
House,Inc.
IntroductionandBibliographycopyright©2007byRichardGrossman
Brushcalligraphycopyright©2007byChungliangAlHuangAllrights
reserved.
PublishedintheUnitedStatesbyModernLibrary,
animprintofTheRandomHousePublishingGroup,
adivisionofRandomHouse,Inc.,NewYorkeISBN:978-0-30742440-2
v3.0