1

Piotr Tomaszewski

Wydział Psychologii

Uniwersytet Warszawski

Rola wychowania dwuj zycznego w procesie

depatologizacji głuchoty

!

"

#

$

%

& #

" '

&

( )

%(

(

&

&

* + &

! &

& &

& , !

# ,

"

&

(

&

&*

&

(

,

%

- &

& .

-

& /" #0 &

1

2

*

"

" '#

! & &,

3

!

&

4

* "

"

& 3#

%

0

!

&

!

(

! %

3

! (

#

#(5

%

3

!

,' (

*

%

3

%

(

6 " &

7 (

"

"

3

!

*

3

8 "

*

)

&

& #

#

&

&

#

9&

(

%

$

: " !

11

*

5

;+

3

#

! !

4&

!

"

3 <

" '

(<

*

&

& !'

&

&

*

"

3

7

0

3

#

! !

&

&, "

! #% ;

# , = & ,

; & "

(=

(

! *

"

* * & " "

"

"

) %

'

#

! !< ! " * 3

( *

!

"

#

&*

" "

&'

3

'

&

&

( %

" >

'#3" ' &

*

"

"

3

&(

!

!

'

#

! !=

2

$

'

?

?

# ,' *

!

" *

# ?"

! "

( " $

(

3

?,

& #

3

! !

3

<

# *

2 #"

"

#

!

#

*

(

#

*

"

4&

3

" !

& ,

! <

#

& "

# &'

& #

& "

&

$

# % #

" )

' ( #

*

!

,

!

&

!

& '

#

! ! - &

&

1 %

! ,?

!

%#&

!

& " #"

3

!

%#",

(

!

& (

! !

'

#'

)

,#(

* #

!

(

& (

3

(

*

#

*

)

&

,%

! ! $

%

(

*

"

@ #

' ( '

#

"

&

!

#'

!

)

%#" &

! %

&

&

' #

@

'

#

&

3

'#

&

!

!

" #

<

" *" '# 3 <

"

? *&

*

)

&

! "

( " " '# 3)

4&

3 (

! ! & ;

#

"= %

" 8

"

& &

# " * & " "

" %* ( " & #

"

,' & "

3

A

!

*

"

"

&'

#

3

#

"

&" %*

"

&

! 8

"

#

&

,

%

(

&

#

%

* #

&

)

", )

"

" '#

( " "

&

4 &

3

#

( ! 8

*

"

! %#

" '

&

! "

3)

#

' & 6

(

##

"

& 0 & %

!

& , !

'

&

*

&

&

!

"

#

%

(

" '

( )

%(

*&

% 0

%

0

!

4

"

#

@% " (

% '

3 %( ? " &

%

' " 3

1 : B

1 -# &"

C D"

C + "

&

2 #

-

%

E

@

"

&

% "

! "

$ #

# " (

(

"

"

%#" &

! %

#

*

"

& ,

! & #

!

3

7 #

!

! !

'

*

%

#'(

%( ? & #

3

!

! 2

&

3

! !

'

( & 3#

#%

F

#

( & 3#

9&

(

#

3 $

: " !

11 "

& 3# !

& ,

(

" %( ?4

3

! ! 2

*

#

& #

&'

(

(

! "

&#

(

!

' #

-

& ,

'

"

&#

'

!

#' 3 ( & #

(

'# #

&

"

7 /

! >

! /

G #

& 3# * #

! !

# & , ! & #

"

,' & "

#

* & "

$

1

G

6 # &

E : " !

E .

#

#

E

7

" &

4 &

3) #

! ! & ,

( * $ #&"

9* & "

" $9

"

& ' " 3

@

&

C

H

0 &

/ "

!

( "

& "

#' 3

3

! ! G% ) *

*3 ( % ! )

4&

) *

(

)

!

&

& #

9&

' (9!

D

1

#

,%

& ,

(#&& #%3

0

!

! &

% & #

!

& "

"

& #

"

& , " ( *% &

% &

!

" (% )

'

%

!

! " !

8 #'

& 3#) '

&

& #

#

! ! ,'

" *

"

( " # ?"

*

"#

& (

4 ,

"

!

( ! G%

" )4& '

3)

! !

"

%& " & #

"

#' " )

!

& ,

!& #

& ! &5

"#

" *

$ #&" 9* & "

"

* & "

#&"F

$

$

%

& #

F E

&

(

F

& #

! !F

&

& 4 &

(

3

! !FC

$

&

"

$

%

I &

3

" 3

"

,

#

! " '

)

# ,'

& #

!

& 4#&

" *

( "

! "

'

#' % & #

%

*% 3 * &

7

%

! %#

&

"

'

!

"

4& '

# "

(

$ #

"

&

"

% "

#

(

"

& #

! %

#

*

& ,

& #

! 8

#

#

*

*

#

* & "

&

#

4 " & "

&

#

4

! !

( ! * " * & "

*

(

"

&

% "

(

4 &

)

*

& #

,

3,

! !

&

( !

J &

!

& " '

) "

" # 4 &

3

( ! $ " " % &

!

( !

0

% #

"

! " '

" )

"

%

,#

4 &

& 8

*

&

5

! "

% )

& "

' ( "

& KI (

*4&

'& #

3

( !

, "

* (

#' %

#)

(

7

#&"

3"

& *%

"

#

( ' % &#%

'0

!

!

& & ,

,%

&

, "

#

* &

&

!

6

&

1

@

&

#

!%

!

!

# &

!

J/G @&

*%

" '

!

"

%

&,

"

&

#

!

&,

" '

3

)

3

'

'

)

"

# !

!

* &

!

0

"

'

!

1

2 #

-

%

E L

! &

6#

'

'

! #

&

#'

) '

"

%

)

# " '

) "

&

#

7

&

#

*

#'

4 &

7

&

6

&

! "

*

*

& "

&

* &"

* &4

7 &

(

%

"

* & ",

! !

&

(

'

' * &

&

! <

,

& "

( " <

"

#

1

1

! &

E $ " "

0

* &

!

"

# 3

!

" '#

&

&*'

!

, & #

& " "

* ( !

0 $

&

&*'

! ,

" 4

" #

#

4 &

&

3

5

$

(

!( ,' ((

,

&

4 & "

"

&

, ! #

!5 % #

& #

7

&

A % ' 3) ! #

"

&

)

,?

"

&

>

&

"

! # #

( !

!

&

!

# 3

& #

/&

"

? *&

&

!

" ' ) *?,

"

0

4

"

#

;/

4

"

*

* "= " ' % )

&

&

! "

& , "

%

3 ? *&,

& & # &

4 "

" ( "

? *&

8

4 " & "

&

" '# 3

&

!

" '

%

4 &

6

& & , "

" '# 3

3

0

& &

3

!

0

!

! $

,

&

!

#'

%

3

!

%,

7

&

) *

3

7

&

5

> B

!

&

!

* & ",

"5 ;

&

,%

! ! * &",

#

! &

!

"

*

"

" ( & ,

"

%

%

) & #

3

'

4 &

)

0 = 7

&

"

(

%#" &*

!

&

!

&

!

& #

& 3#

' 5

"

'

"

! ( & #

&

! F

#'

#

* )

(( #

* * &

& "

&

&

!

FE &

* &

*& & , "

&

!

(

&

" 4 &

!

" * & " %*

# * &"

& ,

"

)

#' "

!

&

!

% &

* &

%( ?",

&

#

,#

&

3

* &

F

" '

)

!

*

& ,

(

*

( *

& "

* &

F

&

4&

!

%,

&

! & ,

("

*

* &

4 &

3,

( !

$

'

# 7

&

(

,?

! %

!

!

#

,

"

& 0 & !

& , !

&

'

,#

&

!

" (

! !

,

& ,

!

(

# "

* & "

"

(

"

&

(

/ !#

1 8

1

6

"

!

6

%

0

*

*%

"

! #

&

!

$

* ,

'

"

'

,'

" *

& "

! "

( "

*

,

"

# 4 &

& "

&

*

" 6

&

! 4 &

#"

#

* "

,%

3

&

( <

,%

+ &

*

%

! " (

%

* * & " "

" & ,

*&

3 & ,

&

*&

<

&

3

&

*

&

& "

* &

& "

&

&

!

+ "

&

E

7

&

,% #' &

)

"

&

% " "

! "

)

3 & #

)

#

* % "

" '# 3)

#

&

3

,%

( ! # ,

'

3 #

& #

! !K J" '#

&

! "

4 &

3

!

, ! 3 !

"

#

!

*

'

& &*

!

*

& #

(

(

&

!

,

& #

*

,%

! !

&

3)

,%

( !

% A

6

%

*

%

&

"

&#

( " *

"

,"

"5

"

"

3

! & ,

,% &

&

!

#

3

&

! "

&,

3,

,%

! !

" '

)

%

*&

3

3 #

( !

( !

* "

( ? *& (

;' $

=

. #

! !

. #

( !

/

3)

*

!

"

/ ! " # (

#

" *

" & #

" 5

( "

! "

7

&

(

$

%

#

" '

&

!

" &

$ #& 9* &

$9

!

&

!

!

"

! "

,

3 & "

&

"

% "

! "

*

%

$9

* &

&"

* &

#&

4 "

>

'

"

!

* &

%

&

!

3

*

%(

*

(<

#

(( *

,

"

"

* & " 5 $9

( 4 "( * &

#&

/

&

! "

&,

& "

? *&

% )

#

*

#

" !

# !

!

*)#

!

$

%

&

'

"

&

!

" )

" '# 3)

%

3

&

,

3 &,

!

,%

! !

*&

"

%*

"

"

) & #

3

&'

!

0

&"

3)

! ! >

*

4

"

#

6

%

!

( ( #

*

!

! !F #

%

"

( #

!

'# 3)

4&

# ?"

! "

%

"

3

'

" " '

) "

"

*'

3

"

*

#(

&

&

%

"

" '# 3

1 + "

&

1

6#

"

0

!

& #

'

! ,%

! ! &

#

!

,

,

& # !

&

&

! #

! ! .

& #

3 " '

# " '#

&

! "

4&

3

& "

( !

& #

#

( !

! * & 6 *& "

'

"

&

! " '

) *

%(

& #

( " (( " '# 3)

4 &

,

3,

! ! & 3

& #

( !

9&

3

"

!

&

, ( #

*5

& " "

"

"

" $

&

!

"

'

&

! "

#

&

'

3

#

( ! # &'

* # " * & " "

"

#$9

&" '

3, #

! !

( ! *

0 " * & " %* ( " & #

"

,' & "

#&

3

! ! >

(

'

( $9

* &

#&

4 "

%( ?",

&

! " '

( ()

*

! " '# 3

! * &

!

!

7

! &

! & ! &

J/G /

6

G # M

:

8

7

# : #

*

!# ! *

8

" "

#"

!

! !

!

@B

C $

/

1

: 44"

# N,

:

DB

7 $ #

O

-

!

" !

7

(

& ! &

"

*%

*

&

! !

&

& # "

& # " H

0 & G "

$

# ,

*

! !

# & ,

" (

,#

( "

#"

& &

!

*

! !

+ "

&

E% 2 &

& . #

I

& 6 %

#&

/

&

&

9 !

+

&

#

$

%

9&

3

& 3#

&

!

$ #&

9* &

$9

#

&

" '#

"

, 4 &

! # &'

*

(

& * &

#&

4 "

"

# " '#

",

*

&

(

* 4 &

,

'

3

!

,%

( ! $9

& * & " ;

#

"=

3,

3

,%

( ! 6

* & #

'

# " ,

(

! $9

#

,%

"

! # ,

, P

& (

*

" ' * & 9&

'

$ &

,#

&

'

* & "

#

! !

;

"

=

&

'

!

%#",

!

! !

6#

#

! &

*

" #

$9

#

%*

!

4 "

" $9

!

*

&

!

8 '

( " & , <

"

$ #

<

& 0

% #

'

*

%

$9

#

$

%

!

7 3,

& , !

# ,

' $9

" * & " #

"

" %

"

,

! &

&

<& & "

( "

!

#

! / (

%

*

3)

!

'

%

!

#'( & #

3

! !

( * &

"

&

&

"

&#

8 "

&

##

%

"

& 0 &" * & " "

" G/N

< ,

"

& 0 &"

& " $9 <

' G/N

" * & "

%

& * & ",

( & * #

( >%

9

' &

" N

#

# 1 N#

#<

" 4#

" .#"

I #

#

$

;4

#

"= / &

C N

#

#9!

1

7

! # !

$ #

%

&

* ,

' & #

* &

&

!

*

%

0

$9 I

(

*

$9

& " #

"

&#

( &"

! "

&"

* ! &

& '

#

* & M

1 H

0 &

1 + "

& A

&

+ "

&

E

% A,'

" *

* & " "

"

",

"

*

&

'

&

%

"

# 3

&

"

# 3

!

8 #

* & "

<

,# & '

* & < ! &

*

&#

3 (

6

&#

3) $9

#

" '

& "

4 &

(

,

& #

<

"

"

& #

#"

! ;4

", =

# !

" ( !

(" 4"

&, "

!

( !

"

"

& #

& "%

! " 4",

( *

# <

& , "

( (

&

+ &

* $9

&

"

&#

% "

"

&

&

&5 %,

&,

#

(

( ((

"

'

!

&, "

!

$

* &

#

,

' (

!* & ,

%

(

&#

"

#

& "

&

(

"

&

3) I

" $9

" " " <

&

" ' # *

)% &

3

"

!

&#

"

!

# ( !

&

&

*

& 0

# %

0

#

<

! &

( ! *

&, "

! @ %

!

#

(

'$9

3

)

(

&

,

# ! &" "

(

) *#

(

&

$9

*

* &

! &

A

" ( $9

*

" " 3#

# 4 "(

3

&'

3

& " & "

&

*#

! ! " *

%( $ " "

#

& "

* & <

"

(

< $9

* & " '

"

" (& ,

"

( & "

& #

(

)

"

)

" & "

&

(

0

* ( !

& '

(

4

% &

'

'

&

)

$9

& #

& #

3

3

!

<

#

3 & #

10

#

$

%

&

'

(

8 & ,

#

#

(

&

'

&

$9

% "

#

&

&

&, "

!

" ( (&

&

!

& , " & & $9 %*

&

&

*

*& !

<

%

"

(

$

' $9

&

" '#

* &

",

@

&

% &

&

#

&

* & "

9&

%

"

"

*&

" '# 3

4

&

!

% "

(

%

(

3

4 "

&

" (

&, "

! * &

&

& #

8 & , %

& 3#

'

!

,

! !#

"

( *

"

( (#

&

& #

&

" * 3

'

!

,

( !

"

CC / &#

I !

CC

C1 L

. !

- &

&

1% 6

!

! !

,

" (

& &

* & " "

"

&

* & ",

+ & "

##

%

&

*

3 (

&

! !

'

#

* & "

%

*

* &

&

6

"

(

( *

& #

! !

%* !

" "

*

!

>

" 3)$9 " '

)

* &

#&

#

&

4 "

# &' ",

#"

3

$

( %

&

(

'

,

!

,

! ! & ,

" (& & G"

& 0 &" 9* & "

"

G/N

&

!

,

( !

(

0

G/N<

( *& " " '# 3 "

%

" * 3

'

"

3

&

! !

,

( ! & ,

& *

* G/N

& # #

! ! -

/ ! &

1

! &

8 & , %

&

(

#' 3)

" *

& "

(

* & "

"

" * 3 (

/

$

: 44"

6

&

! 3

" 3 ( * & ( $9 < " '

)

, & "

"

%

#

* &

#&

#

&

4 "

# &' ",

+ "

&

& Q% 6

*

&

#

(

'

,'

* & ",

$ #& 9* &

$9

&

"

# 3

&

"

$9

&

! " '

) *

"

"

& "

3

@&

* ' '

"

!

! " ( "

& "

&

"

#

11

%

"

3

%( ? " * 3

! / %

! &

A

" ( " '

) '

3

&

&

! "

%

* &

#&

4 "

",

#'

) *

" "

$9

#

"

* &

#&

&

%

$

'

3) #

" '

#

* & "

& %

&

#

&

!

& * &

4 " ",

( *

&

( &

"

)

$

*%

' #

$

%

!

M &

/ "

9* &

/9

#

* * & " ",

"

"

'

&, "

! /9

&

" & * &

#&

$9

( & *

"

(

((

"

* &

#&

>

&

&

,%

&

!

"

# /9 " (

#

" '#

"

&

%

&

* &

#&

"

& "

"

" >

#

/9

(

& '

" " '

*& "

'

"

#

"

)

3

! * &

#&

4 "

%( ?",

@%

& #

#

#

! !

$ #

*

/9

" ( ' 4 " & "

&

%*

#

* &

&

!

7

/9

*

"

& 3#

< * & "

"

& "%

"

%"

#

" #

& "

&

# & "

&

+

&

" (

#

,#

$9

!

"

*

"

&

!

"

& ,

#3 " #

& 3#(

* * & " ",

"

"

"

& " "

"

4 "*& "

&

*

8

#'

"

) ' /9

4 &

* &

#

#

%&

* &

#&

* /9 "

! & ! %

7 /9 " " %

" &(

* '

&

*

$9

#

4%

#

*

& 0 , &

,

4& " #

'

&

4 "

* &

!

%

, !"

# 3 5

!

&

'

"

) ' /9

;

# "

%

"= &

"

* &

#&

6

&

*3

# , '

*&

/9

" '# 3

#

&

&

"

* &

#&

&

!

% * &

#&

" (/9

'$9 9

&

( "

##

%

"

* &

&

( '

! & , %

'

12

!

*

( *

'

"

" * 3

'

!

%*

" " /9

!

/ (

'

% "

#

* &

&

" /9 G%

&

! "

) * /9

"

,

'

%

) * & ",

7 ", " '

&

)

" '# 3

%

&

)

#

* &

"

'"

#( "

* * & ",

9&

I #

#

1

&

"

%

!

4(

)

,#

#"

"

#

* & 4

# " (

3

!

3

!

4 "

&

!

(,

&

! +

3

(

&

" 4

" # "

&

"

! &

4 #

"

('( "

*

" * (&, &

(

"

4 "

!

%&

"

( ! *% ? ! 6

*"

#(

"

( * & 4

%*

!(" '

)

" * 3 '

% '

# 3

& #

& "

&

"

# 3

&

$

'

&

(%

/

#

#

7 &

'

!

,

( ! 6-A/ " (

#

&

"

# "

" " * &

",

"

)

(

"

# <

&

#(

&

3)

&

&

* &

! %#'

!

&

#

* &

"

+ &

*

!

!

'

"

#

"

* &

4

% (' (

#

,% & , 4 &

( 3

,%

#

$

'

'

(

( # 3)

3)

*

"

&

! /9

& "

#

"

* & ",

@ # * & 4

,% #

*

*

4 &

(

"

# 3

!

&

& #

( "

# "

#

"

* & ",

"

3

("

# 3

&

%

& ,

&

( * & "

6#

"

*

" '#

%

&

&

+ & *

'

"

&

!

#

/9

" '

)

3

3

(

&,

( !

#

* &

7 "

%

"

"

"

&

! "

/9 " '

#

&

&

)

" '# 3

# &'

*& )

% 0

! "

,

3 * &

&

"

,'

!4 "

"

!$9

+ "

&

6#

%

%

"

%

0

#'

(

*

3

)

&

#

* & "

"

)

3

",

13

#

$

%

'

+,

(

(

-

.

/

( *

#$%

& "

3

& , !

#

! ! '

$9

*

%

%

"

!

#

4 &

6

"

" #

*

"

"

%

%( ?% &

$9 8 & ,

' ( '

!

%

(

& *

$9

& * &

#

>

"

& " '# 3)

$9

&

%

* &

,

( " (

! !

,

&

& ,

%

(

& ,

" (

3

!

3

0

3 (

! ! #

& ,

"

( %

# !

&,

) $9

! & & !

& #

! " @

&#

& #

J

7

&"

(#& $ #&

9 &

$9

(

%

"

(

3

)

! "

)"

( *$9

&

%

* & + "

&

H

0 & - &

&

E + "

& A

&

&

7

"

*

( '

%

(

"

( 4&

)

* &

#

#'

!

&

#

!

" O

%

&

,

' '

%

(

(

# * &"

"

( ) *

% "

*

"

(

# 3)

!

* & 4

"

!

( *

)

,%

"

- 44 !

1

@%

/

! >

!

(

%

% "

G"

& 0 &

9* &

G/N

(

&

%

(

2!

&

#

"

G/N

&

%

* &

9 %

C 7 # R 7 # R

. "

1 8 J

- #

#

7

7

N

& G/N

#

&

,

! ! # &'

( !

! &

#

,

"

G/N

7 $ #

(' % &

# % & , $9

#

!

#

,

,

#

,

"

$9

7

&#

&

*

#

(

&

/9

&

" '

)

'

& &

!

*

&

!

2

/9

&

%&

* &

#&

" '

)

$9

% "

( "

( " */9

9

&

#

( !

/9

%

&

( 4 "( & "

&

! "

8

" #

%

"

!

&,

%

)

% & "

*& "

&

(

$9

"

&

! /9

# *

&, "

!

&

(

&

#

*

14

!

&

)

( !

&

" ' 3

! * &

# <

& ,

" &

"

* &

#&

6#

3

#

"

!

*

! !&

"

" &

$9

&

%

* &

#

,%

( !

!

$ #& #& ,

$9

%

)

,

&

#

! !

& !

&

*

&

*&

# %

,%

( !

!

#

!

,

! # ,

#

,

"

$9 G%

&

) &

,

' 4&

!

%#&

( ! "

& , &

"

%,

$9

#

,%

( !

0

(

+ #

$

%

!%

(

1

*

'

(

(

+ !

7

!

! &

S

#

(

! " (

! !

,

& , " (

& & $9

"

&

S

! ! " ( !

,

( !

6-A/ "

%( ?% & & & * &

"

3

" $9

' !

" #

3

3

$9

3 (

! ! 6#

&

"

#

* &

#

! !

'

*& "

* !

(

,

,#

# (

( ! 8

" '

&

!

! ( ) ' #

! !

,

( !$9

"

" * & " $

" * &

"

*

* &

& ,

& "

&

*

& , " '

)

,%

# < %

# !

&, 8

%*

#'

!

,

*

+

J/G +

T # 5 D

4 !

47 !

6 2 J / - B

" $

6#

#'

()

'

' # 6-A/ # * &

"

%*

" ;"

"= * & "

3# %* ("

<

'

&

& # "

(

%( ?

& '

& & $9

& &

"

,

3 & "

"

% "

! " 8

# 6-A/ & , " ( ,?

& & $9

&

%( ?C# * & %*

#

7

"

" (

*

4& " ' ! &

&

,?

6-A/ &

#

* & "

,

#

" !

" "

* &

%

(

9

&

0

6-A/

%

15

(

& ,

( *

* &

N

3

* & N

# !

& !

( *

N

8 "

6-A/

" (

" '# 3

N (

'

3

$9 6

%

& , !

'

' 6-A/

3

,

"

& 0 &

& "

G/N

' " 4#

"

&

"

&

"

'

!

0 "

! D""

- #

B

7

!

%

!

'

,

' ' 6-A/ & ( *

#&" * & " "

" $9

&

C # "

%

%#"

'

& , ! #" ,

"

! $9

+ "

&

6

(

!

(&

&

%

* & 8

' " "

&

)

6-A/ ,?

(

*$9

&

'5 ; "

)"

'

" '

%)=

7 *

<

&,

& "

# " * &

"

"

#'

)

#

"

*

6-A/ ,?

( ! *$9 >

#

!

*

' ('

!

& ,

(

& "

# " * & "

"

#'

')

&

* &

"

(

! # <

"

( (

& * &

!

$ #

/

% &

#

#

" " (

#

,

,'

* ( ! 3, !

! ! &

, " (% )

'

&(& "

*

% * & !

#

$ #& 9* &

#

&

# " * & "

,%

! ! # ,

'

4

" # "

& "

!

>

" 3)$9

" '#

4&

4 &

& #

,%

! !

& "

3

#

& #

3

( ! + &

* $9

3 (

* #

&

!

# ((

!

3 & #

,%

! !

$

# * & "

!

"

&

!

*

'

# "

(

(& "

& *

" * 3

! E

%

3

4 &

3

#

! ! "

" "

,' ! ,#

! C

' " 3

%

!

&

%

%

"

+ "

&

& Q

7 %

( "

" * &"

" '

)

&

! "

16

* &

#&

6#

#'

)

&

! "

!

*

& ,

" '

)

"

3

#' 3

3

"

*

,

$9

& * &

#&"

4 "

%( ?",

9&

-

&

*

* & ",

"

!

! !

* !

!# <

"

3 (

&

!

&

#

%

3

$

3 &

%

&

" '#

"

& #

*

%

3 !

& , ! #' G

' '

' (

&

!

*

"

"

) %

* '

& &

%

" * &"

#

"

%

"

3) '

& &

" * & " <

#'

&

3)

&

&

! & , 3

%

I &

&

! "

&,

*

3 " '

)

*

'

*

#

%

%(

*

(

(( *% # * & " "

" #

&

(( *

&(& "

(

* &

#&" #

% < , *

(

" ((

) * %

" * &"

" ((

)

"

'

8

" '

,

' #&

') &

&

!

&

!

%#

! 6

&

!

# (

"

&

"

" '

( ()

(

& "

*

* &

#&" (

*

%(

*

( #

" '

)

%#"

(

& #

(

4& (

,

3 & "

( "

+ &

'

3

&

,%

( ! " '

)

%

&

%

8 "

%

! & ,

% #

* $9

'

3

&

*

< 3#

%*

"

!

*

& #

<

(

*

3)

! ! & 3

#

( !

2 ,

G

U

+!

4

#

#

"

,7 5 $ #

# / L #

#

! % +

-

.

/

/

" < $

I

& G 6 %

#&

N &

*

&

! #

! ! 0

1

*

EE

I #

#

J

1 2#

4 " !

" #

%

&

#

7 5 J I #

#

/

.

-

2

,

7

! "

6

4 # I

! M# 5 L # 2! "

2 #

A -

%

+

E 2

!

44" #

! ! #

4

!#

7 5

! &

6 2# &

: #

# # 895

N

D #

% " G

17

2 #

A -

%

+

E /

#

"

# B # " 4

4 !#

5 4" #

! #

" 44 7 5

! & $ /

3

-

.

+

@R4 5 @R4

J B

$

2 &

& . #

6

*

3)

! ! 0

1

*

E

6 " &92

9

.

# $ %#!

6 # &D

E 6 4

#

,4

L #

8 E E

E

6

& 9

1

&

7

OO7

@

#

"

D"

A

C

# I

#

#"

#

4

4

# 7 5 O $

*

.

+5

2 "%

J B

$

D""

. I #

#

J M

G :

$

D44 4

4 T

"" #

B 5 B

4 "

#

44# &

C

E

DB

2! 9

N

B # "

4

5 2

%#

# !

#

M

/

#

!

$ #!/

N

.

EC EEC

M

G

1

# 4

#

.

- #

B

6

6 44

!

4G"

/

N

"

! #

%

4 !#

5

O" #

4

! ,

E

E

- &

& +

1 8 & ,

! #

%#"

,%

! ! 6

E E

- #

&

& +

1%

&

%

7

$ #& . "

G

4

#

- &

& + .

-

& 9 /" #0 & 9

1

7

$7 8

-

G D / ! & I

1 G T

4

&

D

#! % !

"

!#

4

!

"

!

'

-

3

E EC

E

-# &"

8 /

C +! 6 B # " 4 #

#

#

4

,7 5 -# &"

8 / : B

*

N

D #

% " G

$ %#!

- 44 ! $

1

!

"

4

!

!# 4

4

-

.

-

78

-

M

+!

! 4 !

4 !#

%#

#- .

-

: B

1

3

3

-

9

,

N

D #

% "

G

$ %#!

:

I

I#

#"

! "

4

#

!

4

7 5 6 M

G "

G .

!"

9 L L 2#B

4

,

7 !

6 2 F

- #

#

J B

$

: 44" A9

G

4 !

#5 G/N

7 5 2! 2! "% #

9$

4

AO

%

.

:

,

N

D #

% " G

$ %#!

: " !

+

E 6 4 #

#

7 5 2!

. 6 #

-

9

;

,

7 ! $#

8U N

"

$ %#!

-

9 % A

C 9 !

!

#

G/NK+!

4 G/N

# 4

#

7 5 2 N

9

,

7 ! 6 2 - #

#

J B

$

9 !

A D D

2

1 D !

#

#

" 4

4 !#

7 5 2

N

4

G

"

$

O

.

#

#I

E .

*

) ;

*

,

N &$

O

. "

1 G G

#

"

#4 #

4G/N 7 5 2 N

5

.

,

7 !

6 25 - #

#

J B

$

18

.#" D I #

# J

4

: B

J B

$

N

#

#/.

1

-

.

5

+! :

5

N

#

#/. 9!

AD

1 G"

/

N

5 +! $!

#

#I

-

.

-

C

N#

#

6

$

" 4 T

5 DB

4 " !" B " G/N 7 5 2 N

-

7 !

625 - #

#

J B

$

! &

E

,

8

U &5 @R4

J B

$

! &

N

: - G#

%

9G

+

@R4

J B

$

! /

+

,

7 !

6 2 5 - #

#

J B

$

! /

<

=

7 !

6 2 5 $ 2 #

#

8

#

$

" - #

#

J B

. $

C1 D # "

# ""

#

!

4 !#V #

# #

#

""

B 4

E

. $

1

*

J B 42 #4

$

. $

1

/

#

" 4

! # !#

5

4

!

!

! !

!

4

+

*

-

+

E

A$

N

G T

%

4 !#

-

C

"

- 7

CC +!

#

!

4

# &#

# "

# ""

4

#

4

C

6 M

1 +

,

:

!

44# 2 "

I

6

@ #

.

+

7 !

2 6 5

- #

#

J B

$

# N,

D G #

D"

6 G#

A

9G I #W

! A

-

A %

9 -

M

L

6 4

#

%#

#

&

""

5 +!

4

4

#

I

#

7 5 2 N

4

)

,

7 !

6 2 F

- #

#

J B

$

8

D N

A

1 G T

4G"

/

N

7 5 6 O /#%

4

)

:

,

: #

# # 895N

D #

% "

@

& G

C 9"&

#

$

A 4

& 4

$ #&

> (&

-

! ! 0

>

$

%

7

@B

G

C I#

#

4

L

#5 N

""

!

7 5

2 N

9

7 !

6 2 F- #

#

J B

$

$

2

1 +!

4 ""

!

#

4

4

# 7 5 I & 2 I

A

-

,

8

#G

4 ! 6 4

$

2

+!

#

%

""

G/N B %"

! #

7 5 2 N

-

7 ! 625 - #

#

J B

$

$

2 : " !

+

11

?

*

,

: B

J B

$

$ #$

.

/ 6

2G5 /

# $ %#!

-

O

$ &7

'

"

7

7 /$

$

$

/

1 G/N

4

D

#! #

!

%#

#

4

"

# 4

4

.

1

C

19

+ "

& $

1 7 *

"

#

! !

"

( "

( "

E

E

+ "

& $

/

#

B # "

4 !#

,

.

*

C 1

+ "

& $

> %

& "

&

%#"

"

#

&

!

7 5 A # 9

> # &

<

&

7

5 7

G$/

+ "

& $

E $

* & "

&

!

,

! !

,

C

1

+ "

& $

E% 0

&

(

&

$

$

&

(

&

,

A 4

L @ ,#

#&

.

4

8 &

;> %

0

& "

(

3

" 3 ( * & (

"

' = J

7

& 7

E

X

+ "

& $

E

&

@&

(

-

8

%#&

& & O $

! #

$ #& G&

"

8 & 7

+ "

& $

$ #& 9* &

< " 4&

'(

C

+ "

& $

@

& , ! #" !" 4#

$ #&

9* &

5

'

'(

+ "

& $

% @

& , ! #" !" 4#

$ #&

9* &

5

'

'(

E

C

+ "

& $

& Q

, )

"

)K$

&

!

!

*

7 5 6 -

&

-

@

"

>

&

,

,

+ "

& $

& Q% $ #& 9* &

!

*

"

&

!

-

+ "

& $ Y &

G - &

& +

A #

,

&, "

!

,

3 * &

&

!

+ "

& $ A

& $

2

#& * & "

" * & "K 7 5 -

9 *%

& > + &

&

*

@,0

$

%

,6

&,4

,

7

M

@AG+@A N %#

+ "

& $ - &

& + A

&$

8

#&

* & "

&

%

* & 5

2

%

( "

(

) * &

# K*

1

+ "

& $ A

&$

& $ #& 9* &

3

#

( ! +

&

/ !#

: /

. $

-

*

I & # 2G5

J B

42 #4

$

/ %

6 6 8

: G# 6 $

N

"

N

N%

$

D

/ &

7 2

C -

/

N

@

#$

8 1 I 44# 8U5 J B

4I 44#

/

$

$

O G"

/

N

&#

# #

D

#! #

K 7 5 2!

2! "% #

9$

4

A O

%

.

:

,

N

D #

% "

G

$ %#!

/ &#

D A I ! 97

CC +!

4#

4

# "

#

""

! #

B # " 4

4 !#

C

/

# /

#

#

D #!5 +! "

# T

#

B # " 7 5 $

/ # / M !

4

A

5

:

,

2!

5 J B

42!

$

20

/

&

& 9 !

O +

&

$

#&

*

,%

&#

0

1

*

EEE

H

0 &

1 I

*

"

"

#&

* & "

C 1

H

0 &

-

&

%

0

$9

C

1

H

0 &

G "

+

+

4

,

D

4

@ %

/

/ "%

E COX

H

0 &

- &

& +

E 7 *

7 5

H

0 & + - &

&

/

& "

( * & ( & "

& (

( ! 7

J7

7 # R / 7 # R $$

.

4 -

4

-

.

-

.

7 ! 6 2 5 - #

#

J B

$

7

& N /

<

,

7

5 $7 8

L

2

! &

2 ""

%

4 !#

5 O" #

4

# "

# B # " '

*

E1

E1

L

. ! /6

D # "

# ""

4 !#

Z

! B "

E

> B - $

#B

-

/

L

&

#

!

4

4

#

'

-

+

21

The role bilingual education in depathologizing deafness

)

O !

#

B "

# 4

4

4 ! 4

4

4

#

#%

A ! ! 4

4

! #

#"

#

#

#

!

4 !

4

"

#

#

#

"

$ #!

$ #!

/

N

$/N

##

4$ #! 6 42 ""

! ! " "%

#

#

#

#

# 6 4 +!

! !

# 4 !

!

[

! #

=

4

<

44

%

6 4

:

# ! # %

#

# 44

B

+!

%#" 4%#

# B # "

4 !#

!

< !

# 4

$ #!/

N

"

#

#

$ #!

B #

#

&#

#

4#

!

%#

#

< $/N

$ #! G# ! " "

4

! !

" &

44 #

4

4 !#

T

%#

# "

#

#