CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 1
© CIEH, 2008
CIEH Level 3 Award in
Risk Assessment
–
Principles and practice
Walt Anderson
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 2
© CIEH, 2008
Session 1
–3
1. Health and safety in the workplace
2. Legislation
3. Principles of risk assessment
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 3
© CIEH, 2008
Introduction
• it is a moral requirement that employers protect
employees from risks arising from work activities
• laws regulating health and safety in the workplace
must be correctly implemented
• it makes economic sense to reduce the number
of days lost to preventable occupational injury
and sickness
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 4
© CIEH, 2008
Occupational health and safety
• the safety and health of people in relation to
work, working and the working environment
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 5
© CIEH, 2008
Accident
• an unplanned and uncontrolled event that could
or did lead to harm or damage
• This could also be a food safety related event
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 6
© CIEH, 2008
Near miss
• an event or situation that did not result in harm
or damage but nearly did, in time or distance
• Product that was stopped from leaving the
factory or was recalled from depot
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 7
© CIEH, 2008
Hazard
• anything with the potential to cause harm
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 8
© CIEH, 2008
Risk
• the likelihood (chance/probability) that harm will
occur, the degree of harm and the number of
people affected
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 9
© CIEH, 2008
Control measure
• something (a control) that prevents or reduces risk
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 10
© CIEH, 2008
Work-related fatalities 2006/7
Top three causes:
1. Falls from height
2. Being struck by falling/flying objects
3. Being struck by transport/vehicles
Total 221 reported fatalities
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 11
© CIEH, 2008
Major injuries 2006/07
Top three causes:
1. Slips, trips and falls
2. Manual handling
3. Struck by falling/flying objects
Total 28,000 reported major injuries
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 12
© CIEH, 2008
‘Over-three-day’ injuries 2006/07
Top three causes:
1. Manual handling
2. Slips, trips and falls
3. Struck by falling/flying objects
Total 141,350 reported over-three-day injuries
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 13
© CIEH, 2008
Work-related ill health 2006/07
Top three causes:
1. Stress
2. Musculoskeletal disorders
3. Skin disease
Total 30 million days lost due to ill-health
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 14
© CIEH, 2008
Working days lost
• 36 million each year
• 30 million due to ill-health (13 million stress and
11 million musculoskeletal disorders)
• 6 million due to accidents
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 15
© CIEH, 2008
Costs to employers
• sick pay, overtime and temporary labour provision
• lost time and production delays
• damage or loss of product, raw materials
and equipment
• insurance investigation time
• fines and legal costs
• loss of contracts
• loss of business reputation
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 16
© CIEH, 2008
Costs to employees
• loss of earnings due to sickness
• pain and physical suffering endured
• reduced quality of life as a result of injury
• loss of pension and other entitlements
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 17
© CIEH, 2008
Costs to society
• medical and rehabilitation costs
• payment of incapacity benefit
• loss of tax revenue
• investigation and legal costs
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 18
© CIEH, 2008
Annual cost of occupational ill-health
• £5–11 billion – health conditions (treatment)
• £29 billion – worklessness (benefit costs)
• £28–36 billion – loss of income taxes
• £63 billion – worklessness (lost production)
• £25–35 billion – informal care
• £5–11 billion – health care.
Total cost to the UK of occupational ill health
in 2008
– £103–£129 billion
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 19
© CIEH, 2008
Benefits of improved health
and safety
• greater productivity caused by healthy, content
efficient workforce and greater profits (employer)
• improved corporate social responsibility image
and company reputation (employer)
• better working environment (employee)
• improved standard of living (employee)
• a good health and safety record is the
cornerstone of a civilised society (society)
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 20
© CIEH, 2008
Reporting of Injuries Diseases
and Dangerous Occurrences
Regulations 1995 (RIDDOR)
• work-related fatalities
• major injuries
• over-three-day injuries
• work-related diseases
• dangerous occurrences
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 21
© CIEH, 2008
Benefits of reporting and
investigation
• to prevent recurrence
• so that the HSE and local authorities can identify risks
and investigate incidents
• to identify if the law has been broken through
enforcement inspector investigations
• to identify hazards/risks and take preventative action
• to find out whether controls are working
• to identify trends of incidence
• to learn lessons and share these with others
• for insurance and compensation purposes
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 22
© CIEH, 2008
Under-reporting of dangerous
occurrences
• employees reluctant to report apparently
trivial events
• seen as time consuming and costly
• lack of understanding of the accident triangle
• difficulty defining what constitutes a dangerous
occurrence/near miss
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 23
© CIEH, 2008
The accident triangle
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 24
© CIEH, 2008
Four factors affecting health
and safety
• occupational
• organisational
• environmental
• human
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 25
© CIEH, 2008
Occupational factors
• type of work
• occupational risks
• risks caused by equipment and machinery
• need for protective clothing or equipment
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 26
© CIEH, 2008
Organisational factors
• the management attitude to health and safety
• the effectiveness of health and safety systems
• the level of risk assessment
• the existence of a health and safety policy
• provision of health and safety training
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 27
© CIEH, 2008
Environmental factors
• temperature
• ventilation
• noise
• dust or fumes in the air
• light
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 28
© CIEH, 2008
Human factors
• individual health
• behaviour
• fatigue
• language
• competence
• training
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 29
© CIEH, 2008
Health and Safety at Work etc.
Act 1974
• Section 2 – duties of employers to employees
• Section 2 – safety policy
• Section 3 – duties of employers and
self-employed to others
• Section 7 – duties of employees
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 30
© CIEH, 2008
‘So far as is reasonably practicable’
Control health and safety risks except where the
cost (in terms of time, effort and money) of doing
so is ‘grossly disproportionate’ to the reduction in
the risk
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 31
© CIEH, 2008
Employers’ duty to employees
The general duty of employers to employees is
described under Section 2 of the Act:
‘It shall be the duty of every employer to ensure,
so far as is reasonably practicable, the health,
safety and welfare of all his employees’
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 32
© CIEH, 2008
Employers’ duties
• maintaining plant and systems of work
• ensuring safety and absence of risk to health
• the provision of information, instruction, training
and supervision
• the provision and maintenance of a working
environment that is safe
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 33
© CIEH, 2008
Employers’ duties
If five or more staff employed, a health and
safety policy:
• a short statement of commitment by the
employer signed and dated by a senior person
• details of staff responsibilities for health and
safety and related tasks
• details of the arrangements made to promote
health and safety
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 34
© CIEH, 2008
Employees’ duties
• follow safe systems and safe methods of work
• wear personal protective equipment and clothing
• report any damage or defects
• report any dangerous situation
• suggest where health and safety might be improved
• follow the information, instructions and training given
• remain alert to risk
• do not do anything that will put yourself at risk
• do not do anything that will put anyone else at risk
• do not interfere with or misuse any health and
safety device provided to protect people
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 35
© CIEH, 2008
Employees’ duties
• take reasonable care
• take reasonable care of others
• co-operate with employers or anyone else for reasons
of health and safety
• follow instructions and training in the use of machinery,
equipment, substances, transport equipment, or
safety devices
• inform employers of any dangerous work situation
• inform employers if health and safety could be
improved
• not interfere with anything provided for the
purposes of health and safety
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 36
© CIEH, 2008
Management of Health and
Safety at Work Regulations 1999
• Regulation 3 – Risk assessment
• Regulation 4 – Principles of prevention
• Regulation 16 – Risk assessment for new or
expectant mothers
• Regulation 19 – Protection of young persons
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 37
© CIEH, 2008
Regulation 3
– Risk assessment
The employer must assess the risk to:
• the health of employees
• the safety of employees
• the health and safety of anyone who might be
affected by the employer’s business and activities
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 38
© CIEH, 2008
Risk assessment review
An assessment shall be reviewed by an
employer when:
• there is reason to suspect it is no longer valid
• there has been a significant change to the
matters to which it relates
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 39
© CIEH, 2008
Records
Where an employer employs more than five
employees he shall keep a record of:
• the significant findings of the assessment
• any group of his employees identified by it as
being especially at risk
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 40
© CIEH, 2008
Young persons
No employer shall employ a young person for work:
• which is beyond their physical or psychological
capacity
• involving harmful exposure to dangerous agents
• involving harmful exposure to radiation
• involving the risk of accidents due to lack of
experience or training
• where there is a risk to health from extreme
cold or heat, noise or vibration
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 41
© CIEH, 2008
Young persons
An employer of young people must take into account:
• inexperience, lack of awareness and immaturity
• layout of the workplace and workstation
• nature, degree and duration of exposure to
physical, biological and chemical agents
• form, range and use of work equipment
• organisation of processes and activities
• extent of health and safety training provided
• risks from certain specific and specified
harmful agents, processes and work
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 42
© CIEH, 2008
New and expectant mothers
• those who are pregnant or have recently
given birth
• protect the mother and the unborn child
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 43
© CIEH, 2008
Regulation 4
– Principles of
prevention (schedule 1)
Actions employers must take to prevent and reduce risk:
• avoid risks
• evaluate risks that cannot be avoided
• combat risks at source
• adapt the work to the individual
• adapt to technical progress
• replace dangerous with non-dangerous
• develop an overall prevention policy
• give collective measures priority over individual ones
• give appropriate instructions to employees
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 44
© CIEH, 2008
Other regulations
• Control of Substances Hazardous to Health
Regulations 2002
• Health and Safety (Display Screen Equipment)
Regulations 1992
• Manual Handling Operations Regulations 1992
• Control of Noise at Work Regulations 2005
• Control of Vibration at Work Regulations 2005
• Work at Height Regulations 2005
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 45
© CIEH, 2008
Substances hazardous to health
Control of Substances Hazardous to Health
Regulations 2002
• assess the risks
• prevent or control exposure
• eliminate or substitute
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 46
© CIEH, 2008
Display screen equipment
Health and Safety (Display Screen Equipment)
Regulations 1992
• assess the risks
• reduce risks
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 47
© CIEH, 2008
Manual handling
Manual Handling Operations Regulations 1992
• avoid
• assess the risks
• reduce risks
• provide information about the weight and
distribution of weight of the item
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 48
© CIEH, 2008
Noise
Control of Noise at Work Regulations 2005
• assess the risks
• reduce risks
• observe working practices
• measure the level of noise
• assess exposure values
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 49
© CIEH, 2008
Vibration
Control of Vibration at Work Regulations 2005
• assess the risks
• reduce risks
• observe working practices
• measure the level of vibration
• assess exposure values
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 50
© CIEH, 2008
Work at height
Work at Height Regulations 2005
• assess the risks
• avoid working at height where possible
• prevent falling
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 51
© CIEH, 2008
Enforcement
• authorities / officers
– Health and Safety Executive
– Local Authorities
• powers
– entry and inspection
– notices
– other powers
• courts and penalties
– prosecutions
– imprisonment and fines
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 52
© CIEH, 2008
The role of risk assessment
A risk assessment is simply a careful examination
of what, in your work, could cause harm to people,
so that you can weigh up whether you have
taken enough precautions or should do more
to prevent harm
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 53
© CIEH, 2008
Common law duty of care
• imposes a duty on employers to care for their
employees and protect them from risk
• employees (and others) can sue employers for
compensation if they have been injured as a
result of a breach of this duty
• risk assessment plays a vital role in determining
whether there has been a breach
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 54
© CIEH, 2008
A suitable and sufficient risk
assessment
• clearly identify the risk
• provide detail proportionate to the risk
• be based on specialist advice if the risks increase
or are more specialised
• consider ‘others’
• indicate how long the risk assessment remains valid
• provide details of the evidence on which it
is based
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 55
© CIEH, 2008
Sources of information
• external sources
• internal sources
Sources must be:
• up to date
• relevant and appropriate to the type
of business or situation
• authoritative and reliable
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 56
© CIEH, 2008
External sources of information
• HSE and HSE website www.hse.gov.uk
• HSE publications
• the internet
• trade associations
• trade unions
• Business Link
• chambers of commerce
• universities and educational establishments
• encyclopaedias, journals and other publications
• employer bodies (for instance, the Federation
of Small Businesses or the Institute of Directors)
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 57
© CIEH, 2008
Internal sources of information
• health and safety policy
• risk assessments
• accident/incident/sickness records
• team meetings and briefings
• intranet
• safety representatives and committees
• training records
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 58
© CIEH, 2008
The process of risk assessment
1. Identify the hazards
2. Identify who might be harmed and how
3. Evaluate the risk and decide on precautions
4. Record findings and implement them
5. Review assessment and update if necessary
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 59
© CIEH, 2008
Identify the hazards
• walk around your workplace
• ask employees
• visit the HSE website or call HSE Infoline
• contact trade associations
• check manufacturers’ instructions and data sheets
• check accident and ill-health records
• consider long-term hazards to health
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 60
© CIEH, 2008
Identify who might be harmed
and how
• groups of people who may be harmed
• workers with particular requirements and risks
• cleaners, visitors, contractors, maintenance
workers etc, who may not be in the workplace
all the time
• members of the public
• others in a shared workplace
• ask employees
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 61
© CIEH, 2008
Evaluate the risk and decide on
precautions
• observation
• analysing accident and health trends
• staff consultation
• use existing research
• create a simple risk rating chart
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 62
© CIEH, 2008
Evaluating risk
• What is the probability or likelihood of
harm occurring?
• How serious is the potential harm?
• How many people are at risk?
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 63
© CIEH, 2008
Evaluating risk
– factors to consider
Simple matrix
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 64
© CIEH, 2008
Risk rating chart
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 65
© CIEH, 2008
Risk rating chart
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 66
© CIEH, 2008
General principles of control
• avoid risk altogether if possible
• evaluate the risks that can not be avoided
• combat risks at source
• adapt the work to the individual
• take advantage of technological and technical advances
• implement a risk prevention strategy
• give priority to measures which protect the
whole workforce
• ensure that workers are competent to do their tasks
• promote a positive health and safety culture in
the organisation
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 67
© CIEH, 2008
Common control measures
• providing proper induction for new workers
• placing signs and notices
• arranging training, information and instruction
• ensuring supervision
• providing protective equipment and clothing
• providing safe means of access and egress
• providing first aid facilities
• providing welfare facilities
• having a safety policy and safety systems
of work
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 68
© CIEH, 2008
Slips, trips and falls
– controls
• keeping the workspace tidy
• ensuring floors are level
• maintaining floors
• making sure surfaces have good grip
• avoiding changes in level
• managing spillages
• providing appropriate footwear
• banning running
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 69
© CIEH, 2008
Manual handling
– controls
• reducing the load
• reducing frequency of movement
• choosing healthy and fit workers
• reducing stooping movements
• reducing twisting or turning movements
• using mechanical aids
• automating and mechanising procedures
• marking weight on loads
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 70
© CIEH, 2008
Fire
– controls
• removing naked flames from the building
• encouraging good housekeeping to remove potential
sources of fuel
• installing fire detection system
• installing and maintaining fire alarms and fire points
• providing fire fighting equipment
• creating safe emergency routes
• installing fire doors
• enlisting fire wardens
• providing safe places of assembly
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 71
© CIEH, 2008
Recording risk assessments
• no statutory rule
• businesses employing five or more must record
significant findings
• all businesses should record results to monitor
risk and controls
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 72
© CIEH, 2008
Recording risk assessments
The record must demonstrate that:
• a proper check was made
• there is an understanding of who might
be affected
• all the obvious significant hazards, taking into
account the number of people who could be
involved, were dealt with
• reasonable precautions were taken and the
remaining risk is low
• staff or their representatives were involved
in the process
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 73
© CIEH, 2008
Devising a plan of action
• make a list, beginning with the most important changes
• identify a few cheap or easy improvements
• look at long-term solutions
• train employees to control remaining risks
• make sure that the control measures stay in place
• allocate responsibilities
• regularly update the plan
• set a review date
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 74
© CIEH, 2008
Reviewing risk assessments
The law requires a review of risk assessments:
• when no longer valid
• due to significant changes.
• Other reasons for reviewing risk assessments:
• cases of ill health being reported
• accidents, incidents or near misses occurring
• as part of a wider monitoring of health and safety
• in the case of a claim for compensation
• when an enforcement officer calls
• as part of staff training and development
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 75
© CIEH, 2008
Preparing to carry out a risk
assessment
• collect forms and equipment required
• examine previous risk assessments
• check any relevant committee minutes
• check existing safety policies and procedures
• use accident/incident book and records of absences
for staff
• collect any necessary documentation
• gain access to training records
• inform workers
• assess the risks for your risk assessment
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 76
© CIEH, 2008
Specialised risk assessment
• the nuclear industry
• jobs involving electricity or gas
• jobs involving hazardous chemicals
• mining
• diving
• working on an oil rig
• working at height
• manual handling tasks
• working under stress
• slip test, noise assessments or display screen
equipment may require specialist analysis
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 77
© CIEH, 2008
Competency
• a ‘competent person’ can be defined as
someone who has had sufficient training and
experience or knowledge and other qualities to
enable them properly to undertake a task
• ENTO National occupational standards HSS6 is
the national standard for competence in risk
assessment
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 78
© CIEH, 2008
Competency
A competent risk assessor will understand:
• legislation
• workplace hazards
• the aims and objectives of risk assessments
• procedures for carrying out a risk assessment
• the particular health and safety risks and the
precautions to be taken
CIEH Level 2 and 3 Awards in Risk Assessment:
slide 79
© CIEH, 2008
Competency
• resources required
• appropriate information sources
• what to do with the results of the risk assessment
• importance of dealing with and reporting risks
• limitations, job responsibilities and capabilities
• where to find expert advice and guidance
• the work areas and people being assessed
• work activities in area being assessed
• effective communication methods