74

.U]\V]WRI.RĞFLHOQLDN

<HPHQWKHWHUP5ۉ011ZDVXVHIXOWRSURSDJDWHWKHGRFWULQHRIWKH7ULQLW\

ZKDWZHREVHUYHLQWKH$EUDKD¶V,QVFULSWLRQRQWKH0DULE'DP&,6Ä,Q

WKHSRZHURIWKH$OOPHUFLIXODQG+LV0HVVLDKDQGWKH+RO\6SLULW´,QWKHVDPH

WLPHWKH6\ULDF&KULVWLDQVXVHG$UDPDLFWHUP5DۊPƗQƗIRU-HVXV

32

,WZDVPHQWLRQHGWKDWPDQ\0XVOLPDXWKRUVFRQQHFWWKHWHUP5ۉ011

RQO\ZLWKPRQRWKHLVWUHOLJLRQVVWUHVVLQJWKDW-HZVDQG&KULVWLDQVXVHGUFKP

DQGDU5DۊPƗQDVDWWULEXWHVRIWKH*RGRI,VUDHO,QWKHVHFRQGSRVLWLRQDUHWKH

2ULHQWDOLVWVZKRH[SODLQKRZGLGWKLVWHUPHYROYHIURP3DJDQLVPWR-XGDLVP

DQG&KULVWLDQLW\)RUH[DPSOH$QGUHZ9DUJREHOLHYHVWKDW0XKDPPDGPRVW

OLNHO\WKRXJKWWKDWWKHXVHRIDU5DۊPƗQDVDQDPHIRU*RGZDV³DJRRG

PDUNHWLQJSOR\´7DNLQJWKHQDPHDU5DۊPƗQIRU,VODPLFWKHRORJ\KHFRXOG

DWWUDFWERWKWKH-HZVDQGVRPH3DJDQVWRKLVQHZUHOLJLRQ

33

5ۉ011±$U5DۊPƗQZHOONQRZQLQ6RXWK$UDELDEHIRUHWKHDGYHQW

RI,VODPKDGPDQ\FRQQHFWLRQV3UREDEO\0XKDPPDGERUURZHGWKLVQDPH

IURPWKUHHVRXUFHVZKLFKFRXOGREVHUYHLQKLVPLOLHX5ۉ011±$U5DۊPƗQ

XQGHUVWRRGE\-HZVDQG&KULVWLDQVDV³/RUGWKH0HUFLIXO0DVWHURI+HDYHQ´

ZDVXVHIXOIRU,VODPQHZ0RQRWKHLVWLFUHOLJLRQ2QWKHRWKHUKDQG5ۉ011

LQ6RXWK$UDELDVLJQL¿HGDPRRQJRGZKRP0XKDPPHGHYHQRFFDVLRQDOO\

FRQIXVHGZLWKRUXVHGDVDVXEVWLWXWHIRUµ$OODK¶,WLVSURSHUWRUHPHPEHUWKDW

DJRGFDOOHG0DU$OODKZDVUHFRJQL]HGIURPLQVFULSWLRQDOHYLGHQFHVLQQRUWKHUQ

$UDELD7KH.RUDQPHQWLRQV$U5DۊPƗQRFFDVLRQDOO\IRUH[DPSOHLQVXUD
43

௘௘ZKLFKPRVWWUDQVODWRUVKDYHUHQDPHGDV*RGRU$OODKVLQFHWKH\DV

0XKDPPHGIRXQGQRGLIIHUHQFHEHWZHHQWKHVHWZR6RXWK$UDELDQPRRQJRGV

32

9JO++LUVFKIHOG1HZ5HVHDUFKHVLQWRWKH&RPSRVLWLRQDQG([HJHVLVRIWKH4RUDQ

/RQGRQS

33

9JO$9DUJR5HVSRQVHVWR,VODPLF$ZDUHQHVV5DKPDQDQ5+011±$Q$QFLHQW6RXWK

$UDELDQ0RRQ*RG"LQKWWSZZZDQVZHULQJLVODPRUJ5HVSRQVHV6DLIXOODKUDKPDQBDYKWP

DFFHVVHG

$JQLHV]ND.XF]NLHZLF])UDĞ

-DJLHOORQLDQ8QLYHUVLW\LQ.UDNRZ

$NEDUWKH*UHDW±DQG&KULVWLDQLW\

%HWZHHQUHOLJLRQDQGSROLWLFV

7KHVHFRQGKDOIRIWKH

WK

FHQWXU\GXULQJWKHUHLJQRI,QGLD¶VWKLUGDQG

ZLGHO\UHJDUGHGDVWKHJUHDWHVWUXOHURIWKH0XJKDOG\QDVW\-DOƗOXG'ƯQ

0XতDPPDG$NEDUZDVDOVRWKHWLPHZKHQWKH(XURSHDQVZHUHEHFRPLQJ

LQFUHDVLQJO\SUHVHQWRQWKH,QGLDQ6XEFRQWLQHQW(VSHFLDOO\DFWLYHDPRQJWKHP

ZHUHWKH3RUWXJXHVH±ERWKLQWKHSROLWLFDODQGHFRQRPLFVHQVHDVZHOODVLQ

WKHFXOWXUDODQGWKHUHOLJLRXVGLPHQVLRQ

$IWHUUHDFKLQJ,QGLDZLWKWKHH[SHGLWLRQRI9DVFRGD*DPDLQWKH

3RUWXJXHVHYHU\TXLFNO\±DOUHDG\LQ±VWDUWHGWKHLUH[SDQVLRQRQWKH

:HVWHUQFRVWRIWKH6XEFRQWLQHQWDQGWKURXJKRXWWKHQH[WWKLUW\\HDUVFRQTXHUHG

WKHWHUULWRULHVRI*RDZKHUHWKH\HVWDEOLVKHGDSRZHUIXOWUDGLQJSRVWDQGZKLFK

DOVREHFDPHWKHVHDWRIWKHYLFHUR\DQGFRXQFLODSSRLQWHGE\WKH3RUWXJXHVH

NLQJLQ/LVERQDQG'LX)URPWKH3RUWXJXHVHIRUFHVRFFXSLHGDOVR

'DPDQZKLFKZDVDQLPSRUWDQWSRUWRQ

WKH&DPED\*XOIDQGWKXVFUHDWHG

DJUHDWSUREOHPIRUWKH0XJKDOVHVSHFLDOO\DIWHUWKHDQQH[DWLRQRIWKHULFK

DQGSURVSHURXVSURYLQFHRI*XMDUDWLQWRWKH0XJKDO(PSLUHLQ7KH

3RUWXJXHVHQDYDOGRPLQDQFHRYHUWKH$UDELDQ6HDFDXVHGWKDWQR,QGLDQVKLS

FRXOGVDLOZLWKRXWWKHVRFDOOHGFDUWD]RUVSHFLDOSDVVIRUVDIHFRQGXFWV)RU

,QGLDQ0XVOLPVWKLVVLWXDWLRQZDVHVSHFLDOO\RSSUHVVLYHVLQFHWKHSRUWVRIWKH

:HVWHUQFRDVWZHUHWKHSRLQWRIHPEDUNDWLRQIRUSLOJULPVJRLQJWR0HFFD

7KH

FRQÀLFWVDOVRWKHDUPHGRQHVEHWZHHQWKH0XJKDODXWKRULWLHVRIWKHSURYLQFH

DQGWKH3RUWXJXHVHKDSSHQHGGXULQJWKHZKROHRIWKH$NEDU¶VUHLJQ

,WZDVUHSRUWHGE\%DGƗގnjQƯWKDWWKHSLOJULPVJRLQJWR0HFFDE\VHD³KDGWRSXWXSZLWK

LQGLJQLWLHVIURPWKH3RUWXJXHVHZKRVHSDVVSRUWVKDGSLFWXUHVRI0DU\DQG-HVXVSHDFHEHXSRQ

+LPVWDPSHGRQWKHP´DQG±DV%DGƗގnjQƯUHPDUNV±IRUWKH0XVOLPVWRPDNHXVHRIWKHP

³ZRXOGPHDQWRFRXQWHQDQFHLGRODWU\´0XQWD[DEDOWDYƗUƯ[,,

25,(17$/,$&+5,67,$1$&5$&29,(16,$

77

$JQLHV]ND.XF]NLHZLF])UDĞ

$NEDUWKH*UHDW±DQG&KULVWLDQLW\%HWZHHQUHOLJLRQDQGSROLWLFV

:LWKWKH3RUWXJXHVHWHUULWRULDODQGHFRQRPLFH[SDQVLRQDOVRWKH&DWKROLF

PLVVLRQDULHVVWDUWHGDUULYLQJLQ,QGLD7KH3RUWXJXHVHDFWXDOO\KDGDPRQRSRO\

RQSURPRWLQJ&KULVWLDQLW\LQ$VLDDQGRQFRQGXFWLQJWUDGHLQWKHRYHUVHDV

WHUULWRULHVSURYLGHGLQE\3RSH1LFKRODV9LQWKHIDPRXVEXOO5RPDQXV

3RQWLIH[DGGUHVVHGWR.LQJ$OIRQVR9RI3RUWXJDO,QWKH'LRFHVHRI*RD

ZDVHVWDEOLVKHGFRYHULQJLQIDFWWKHZKROH(DVWIURPWKH&DSHRI*RRG+RSH

WR&KLQD7KHPLVVLRQDULHVIURPWKHQHZO\IRXQGHG-HVXLWRUGHUZHUHVHQWWKHUH

SDUWO\WRVHUYHWKH3RUWXJXHVHDVFKDSODLQVDQGSDUWO\IRUJHQXLQHPLVVLRQDU\

DFWLYLWLHV7KHFRORQLDODXWKRULWLHVLQ*RDVXSSRUWHGWKHPLVVLRQZLWKYDULRXV

DFWLRQVOLNHGLVWULEXWLQJULFHDPRQJWKHSRRUSURYLGLQJMREVLQDGPLQLVWUDWLRQ

RUHYHQRIIHULQJPLOLWDU\DVVLVWDQFHWRWKHORFDO,QGLDQUXOHUV

7KLVSHULRGRIWKH,QGLDQKLVWRU\±WKHWLPHRI$NEDU¶VUHLJQDQGRIWKH

VWUHQJWKHQLQJWKHSUHVHQFHRI3RUWXJXHVH±LVYHU\ZHOOGRFXPHQWHGLQWKH

KLVWRULFDOVRXUFHV2QWKHRQHKDQGWKHUHDUHUHFRUGVRI0XVOLPFKURQLFOHUV

WKHPRVWSURPLQHQWSODFHDPRQJZKRPEHORQJVWR$EX¶O)D਌O

2

µ$EGX¶O4ƗGLU

%DGƗގnjQƯ

3

DQG1L਌ƗPX¶G'ƯQ$তPDG%D[ãƯ

4

RQWKHRWKHUKDQGDJUHDWDPRXQW

RIGRFXPHQWVDQGOHWWHUVZULWWHQE\3RUWXJXHVHPLVVLRQDULHVZKRRIWHQVSHQW

PDQ\\HDUVDWWKHLPSHULDOFRXUW

$OOWKHVHZULWLQJVGHSLFW$NEDUDVDPDQ

2

$EX¶O)D਌Oµ$OOƗPƯ±±$NEDU¶VFRXUWKLVWRULDQVHFUHWDU\DQGELRJUDSKHU

PLOLWDU\FRPPDQGHUDQGWKHRORJLDQ+HFULWLFLVHGWKHWUDGLWLRQDO0XVOLPFOHUJ\µXODPƗDQG

LQÀXHQFHGWKHGHYHORSPHQWRI$NEDU¶VUHOLJLRXVV\QWKHVLV2SSRVLQJWKHQDUURZPLQGHGQHVV

RIWKHUHOLJLRXVOHDGHUVDQGEODPLQJWKHLULQYROYHPHQWLQVKDOORZIRUPVRIZRUVKLSLQVWHDGRI

WKHSUDLVHRIWUDQVFHQGHQW*RG$EX¶O)D਌OKDGDYDVWLQÀXHQFHDWFRXUW+LVPDMRUOLWHUDU\

DFKLHYHPHQWZDVDKLVWRU\RI$NEDUDQGKLVSUHGHFHVVRUV$NEDUQƗPD³%RRNRI$NEDU´WKH

ODVWSDUWRIZKLFKLVFRQVWLWXWHGE\ƖµƯQL$NEDUƯ³7KH,QVWLWXWLRQVRI$NEDU´%RWKZRUNV

JLYHDYLYLGDQGGHWDLOHGGHVFULSWLRQRI$NEDU¶VFRXUWDQGUHLJQ$EX¶O)D਌ODOVRWUDQVODWHGWKH

%LEOHLQWR3HUVLDQ

3

µ$EGX¶O4ƗGLU%DGƗގnjQƯF±DQ,QGR3HUVLDQKLVWRULDQRQHRIWKHPRVWLPSRUWDQW

ZULWHUVFRQFHUQLQJWKH0XJKDOSHULRGLQ,QGLD)URPKHZRUNHGLQWKHUHOLJLRXVRI¿FHDWWKH

FRXUWRI$NEDUDQGUHFHLYHGPRQH\IURPKLP+LVPRVWLPSRUWDQWZRUNLVWKH0XQWD[DEDOWDYƗUƯ[

³6HOHFWLRQIURP+LVWRU\´DOVRFDOOHG7ƗUƯ[H%DGƗҴnjQƯ³%DGƗގnjQƯ¶V+LVWRU\´DKLVWRU\RI

0XVOLP,QGLDLQFOXGLQJDGGLWLRQDOVHFWLRQVRQ0XVOLPUHOLJLRXV¿JXUHVSK\VLFLDQVSRHWVDQG

VFKRODUV7KHZRUNFRQWDLQVWKHDXWKRU¶VKRVWLOHUHPDUNVDERXW$NEDUDQGKLVUHOLJLRXVSUDFWLFHV

4

1L਌ƗPDO'ƯQ$তPDGLEQ0XতDPPDG0XTƯP+DUDYƯG±DSURPLQHQWRI¿FLDO

GXULQJWKHUHLJQRI$NEDUIURPDSD\PDVWHUDQGFRPPDQGHULQFKLHIED[ãƯRIWKHHQWLUH

HPSLUH+HEHFDPHIDPRXVDVWKHDXWKRURIWKHPXFKFHOHEUDWHGKLVWRU\RI,QGLDܑDEDTƗWL

$NEDUƯZKLFKLVDFRPSUHKHQVLYHKLVWRULFDOVWXG\RIWKHUXOHRI$NEDUDQGLQFOXGHVDVWXG\RI

WKHRWKHU,QGR0XVOLPG\QDVWLHVIURPWKH

WK

WRWKH

WK

FHQWXULHV+LVZRUNZDVWKH¿UVWJHQHUDO

KLVWRU\GHYRWHGVROHO\WR,QGLDDQGEHFDPHDPRGHOIRUODWHUDXWKRUVZKRZHUHWRXQGHUWDNH

VLPLODUKLVWRULFDOSURMHFWV

2QHKDVWRUHPHPEHUWKDWWKHPLVVLRQDULHVZHUHQRWFDVXDOWUDYHOOHUVLQWKH0XJKDOHPSLUH

EXWWKH\KDGWKHRSSRUWXQLW\RIWKHFORVHVWFRQWDFWVZLWK$NEDUDQGZHUHRIWHQDFTXDLQWHGZLWK

,QGLDQODQJXDJHVDQGFXVWRPV7KHGHWDLOHGDFFRXQWVRIWKH,QGLDQÀRUDDQGIDXQDUHOLJLRQVDQG

WUDGLWLRQVHWKQRJUDSK\DQGKLVWRU\ZKLFKWKH\VHQWWRWKHLUVXSHULRUVLQ(XURSHZHUHXVXDOO\

LQYDOXDEOHDQGXQELDVHGUHFRUGV7KHUHDUHWKUHHPDLQSXEOLVKHGERRNVZKLFKFRQWDLQWKHHDUOLHVW

RIH[WUDRUGLQDU\LQWHOOHFWDOWKRXJKKHZDVLOOLWHUDWHLQWHUHVWHGLQWKHZRUOG

WROHUDQW¿QGLQJSOHDVXUHLQSKLORVRSKLFDODQGUHOLJLRXVGHOLEHUDWLRQVZLWK

DWHQGHQF\WRP\VWLFLVPZKRVHJUHDWGHVLUHZDVWR¿QGDUHOLJLRXVV\VWHP

WKDWZRXOGVDWLVI\DOODVSHFWVRIKLVH[SHFWDWLRQV $NEDUZDVDOVRXQGRXEWHGO\

DEULOOLDQWDQGVNLOIXOSROLWLFLDQDQGDVVXFKKHXQGHUVWRRGZHOOWKDWWKHUHLJQ

RIKLVG\QDVW\PLJKWODVWRQO\DVORQJDVLWZDVZLGHO\DFFHSWHGE\WKRVHRYHU

ZKRPKHUHLQHG(YHQWKRXJKFRQYHUVLRQVWR,VODPZHUHUHODWLYHO\FRPPRQ

DIWHUWKHDUULYDORI0XVOLPVLQWKH,QGLDQ6XEFRQWLQHQWVWLOOWKHUHZDVQRGRXEW

WKDWWKHROGUHOLJLRQVGLGQRWGLVDSSHDUDQGWKDWQRWDOOWKHSHRSOHRI,QGLDZRXOG

DGRSW,VODP $NEDUNQHZWKDWWKHUHPXVWEHVRPHFRQFHVVLRQVLQVXFKDUHDVDV

UHOLJLRQODQJXDJHRUFXVWRPVWRHQVXUHSHDFHLQWKHFRXQWU\

$NEDUXQGHUWRRNDZKROHUDQJHRIDFWLRQVWKDWZHUHVXSSRVHGWRSURYHWKDW

KHZDQWHGWREHDUXOHUDQGSURWHFWRURIDOOFLWL]HQVRIKLVUHDOPUHJDUGOHVVRI

WKHUHOLJLRQVWKH\SURIHVVHG $PRQJRWKHUWKLQJVLQKHDEROLVKHGML]\D

±DSROOWD[OHYLHGRQQRQ0XVOLPVZKLFKLQDVHQVHUHVXOWHGWKDWRQO\0XV

OLPVZHUHIXOOFLWL]HQVRIWKHHPSLUHZKLOHWKHUHVWRIWKHVRFLHW\ZDVPHUHO\

WROHUDWHG±SURYLGHGKRZHYHUWKDWWKH\KXPEO\HQGXUHGWKHFRQGLWLRQRIEHLQJ

VXEMHFWHG&RQVHTXHQWO\+LQGXVDQG0XVOLPVFRXOGIHHOWREHHTXDOVKDUHUVLQ

DFRPPRQFLWL]HQVKLSIRUWKH¿UVWWLPH$QRWKHUUHVWULFWLRQUHYRNHGE\$NEDU

ZDVDEDQRQHUHFWLQJWHPSOHVLQKRQRXURIYDULRXVJRGV7KHUHIRUH+LQGX

SODFHVRIZRUVKLSEHJDQWRULVHDJDLQIURPWKHJURXQGLQWKHHQWLUHFRXQWU\

/DWHUWKLVSULYLOHJHZDVDOVRH[WHQGHGWR&KULVWLDQVZKLFKDOORZHGWKHHUHFWLQJ

RIFKXUFKHVLQ/ƗKDXUDQGƖJUƗ

7KHUHLVQRGRXEWWKDWWKHVHGHFLVLRQVZHUHGLFWDWHGE\$NEDU¶VSROLWLFDO

FRQVLGHUDWLRQVDQGSULQFLSOHVRIKLVGRPHVWLFSROLF\WKHEDVLFJXLGHOLQHRI

ZKLFKZDV³SHDFHZLWKDOO´܈XOۊLNXOO2QHREMHFWLYHRIVXFKDFWLRQVZDV

WRSURYLGHDOOKLVVXEMHFWVZLWKWKHHTXDOVWDWXVDQGULJKWVWKHRWKHULQWHQWLRQ

ZDVWROLPLWWKHLQÀXHQFHRIDVWURQJIDFWLRQRIWKHRUWKRGR[0XVOLPFOHUJ\

µXODPƗDWWKHFRXUW%XWVXUHO\QHLWKHURIWKHPZRXOGKDYHEHHQSRVVLEOHLI

WKHHPSHURUKDGEHHQODFNLQJLQQDWHWROHUDQFHDQGDV\QFUHWLFZD\RIWKLQNLQJ

,QWKHEHJLQQLQJRI$NEDURUGHUHGWKHHUHFWLRQRIDVSDFLRXVHOHJDQW

VWUXFWXUH³FRQVLVWLQJRIIRXUKDOOVQHDUWKHQHZSDODFHLQ)DWতS~U´

LQKLVQHZO\

-HVXLWVRXUFHVUHJDUGLQJWKH$NEDU¶VWLPHV/HWWHUVIURPWKH0XJKDO&RXUWWKH¿UVW-HVXLWPLVVLRQ

WR$NEDU±HGLWHGDQGLQWURGXFHGE\-RKQ&RUUHLD$IRQVRZKRH[DPLQHVWKH

OHWWHUVRIWKH¿UVW-HVXLW0LVVLRQDW)DWতSnjU6ƯNUƯDQGƖJUƗ7KHFRPPHQWDU\RI)DWKHU0RQVHUUDWH

6-RQKLVMRXUQH\WRWKHFRXUWRI$NEDU WUDQVODWHGIURPWKHRULJLQDO/DWLQE\-6+R\ODQGDQG

DQQRWDWHGE\61%DQMHUHH±FIIRRWQRWHDQG$NEDUDQGWKH-HVXLWVDQDFFRXQWRI

WKH-HVXLWPLVVLRQVWRWKHFRXUWRI$NEDUE\3LHUUH'X-DUULFUHSULQUHSURGXFLQJ

RUUHFDSLWXODWLQJWKHPRVWYDOXDEOHPLVVLRQDULHV¶OHWWHUVZULWWHQSULRUWR

0XQWD[DEDOWDYƗUƯ[,,

$JQLHV]ND.XF]NLHZLF])UDĞ

$NEDUWKH*UHDW±DQG&KULVWLDQLW\%HWZHHQUHOLJLRQDQGSROLWLFV

EXLOWFDSLWDORI)DWতSnjU6ƯNUƯ

7

7KHVWUXFWXUHNQRZQDVµ,EƗGDW[ƗQD³+RXVHRI

:RUVKLS´ZDVWRIXQFWLRQDVDKDOOIRUUHOLJLRXVDQGSKLORVRSKLFDOGHEDWHVWKDW

WRRNSODFHHDFK7KXUVGD\HYHQLQJ9DULRXV0XVOLPVFKRODUVDQGOHDUQHGPHQ

SLRXVãDL[VRUWKRGR[‘XODPƗVDQGGLJQL¿HGVDL\LGVUHSUHVHQWLQJGLIIHUHQW

VFKRROVRI,VODPDVZHOODVWKHQREOHVRIWKHFRXUWZHUHLQYLWHGWRWDNHSDUWLQ

WKHGHEDWHVDQGGLVFXVVLPSRUWDQWTXHVWLRQVRIODZDQGIDLWK

%XWYHU\VRRQ

LWDSSHDUHGWKDWWKHSDUWLFLSDQWVRIWKHVHPHHWLQJVIDLOHGWRUHDFKDJUHHPHQW

HLWKHURQLVVXHVRIIXQGDPHQWDOLPSRUWDQFHRULQPLQRUFDVHVDQGWKHLUPXWXDO

DJJUHVVLRQFDXVHGWKHSDODFHJXDUGWRLQWHUYHQHDIHZWLPHV³$NEDUZDV>«@

IDLUO\GLVJXVWHG>«@KHQHYHUSDUGRQHGSULGHDQGFRQFHLWLQDPDQDQGRIDOO

NLQGVRIFRQFHLWWKHFRQFHLWRIOHDUQLQJZDVPRVWKDWHIXOWRKLP´

DQG¿QDOO\

GLVDSSRLQWHGKHVXVSHQGHGWKHGHEDWHV

$NEDU¶VGLVVDWLVIDFWLRQZLWKWKH‘XODPƗVOHGKLPWRWKHGHFLVLRQZKLFK

HYHQWXDOO\ZDVWREUHDNWKHLUSRZHUXS,Q6HSWHPEHUDGRFXPHQWNQRZQ

DVWKHPDۊܲDUZDVDQQRXQFHGDQGVLJQHGE\WKHOHDGLQJ‘XODPƗVDOWKRXJK

DJDLQVWWKHLUZLOO

$FFRUGLQJWRWKLVGHFUHH$NEDUSXWKLPVHOILQDSRVLWLRQ

RIWKH,PƗPLƖGLO³HTXLWDEOHOHDGHU´WKHKLJKHVWOHJDODXWKRULW\LQWKHUHDOP

DQGVXSUHPHDUELWHULQDOOGLVSXWHV

+LVYHUGLFWV±ERWKUHOLJLRXVDQGVHFXODU

±ZHUHWREH¿QDOZLWKQRSRVVLELOLW\RIDSSHDOKHDOVRKDGWKHSULYLOHJHRI¿QDO

LQWHUSUHWDWLRQRIOHJDOSURYLVLRQVFRQWDLQHGLQWKH4XUƗQZKLFKVWLOOUHPDLQHGWKH

KLJKHVWOHJDODQGUHOLJLRXVDXWKRULW\LQWKHHPSLUH

6RRQDIWHUWKHSURFODPDWLRQ

7

7KHH[DFWORFDWLRQRIWKHVWUXFWXUHLVQRWNQRZQVLQFHQREXLOGLQJVXLWLQJWKHGHVFULSWLRQ

JLYHQE\%DGƗގnjQƯRU$EX¶O)D਌OKDVUHPDLQHGDW)DWতSnjU7KHVSHFL¿FDWLRQOHIWE\WKHFKURQL

FOHUVFOHDUO\LQGLFDWHVVRPHEXLOGLQJUHVHPEOLQJ'ƯYDQLµƗPHQFORVLQJDJUHDWTXDGUDQJOH&I

+DYHOO3DUW6L[WHHQ)DWHKSXU6LNULIRRWQRWHKWWSZZZFROXPELDHGXLWFPHDODF

SULWFKHWWDUWOLQNVDJUDBKDYHOOIDWDKSXUVLNULKWPO!

%DGƗގnjQƯGHVFULEHVWKHVHLQLWLDOPHHWLQJVLQWKHIROORZLQJZD\³«HYHU\7KXUVGD\HYHQLQJ

KH>$NEDU@LQYLWHG6D\\LGV6KDLNKV8ODPiDQG$PtUV%XWLOOIHHOLQJDURVHLQWKHFRPSDQ\

DERXWWKHVHDWVDQGRUGHURISUHFHGHQFHVR+LV0DMHVW\RUGHUHGWKDWWKH$PtUVVKRXOGVLWRQ

WKHHDVWVLGHWKH6D\\LGVRQWKHZHVWWKH8ODPiRQWKHVRXWKDQGWKH6KDLNKVRQWKHQRUWK

+LV0DMHVW\ZRXOGJRIURPWLPHWRWLPHWRWKHVHYDULRXVSDUWLHVDQGFRQYHUVHZLWKWKHPDQG

DVFHUWDLQWKHLUWKRXJKWV«´0XQWD[DEDOWDYƗUƯ[,,

%DGƗގnjQƯ¶V0XQWD[DEDOWDYƗUƯ[,,TXRWHGLQWKHƖµƯQL$NEDUƯLQWUDQVODWLRQRI

+%ORFKPDQQFIƖµƯQL$NEDUƯ,

0XQWD[DEDOWDYƗUƯ[,,

7KHWH[WRIWKHPDۊܲDULVTXRWHGE\%DGƗގnjQƯ0XQWD[DEDOWDYƗUƯ[,,±&IDOVR

)U\NHQEHUJ6PLWK±5L]YL±

³«VKRXOGWKHUHIRUHLQIXWXUHDUHOLJLRXVTXHVWLRQFRPHXSUHJDUGLQJZKLFKRIWKH

RSLQLRQVRIWKH0XMWDKLGV>MXULVWWKHKLJKHVWDXWKRULW\LQMXULVSUXGHQFH±$.)@DUHDWYDULDQFH

DQG+LV0DMHVW\LQKLVSHQHWUDWLQJXQGHUVWDQGLQJDQGFOHDUZLVGRPEHLQFOLQHGWRDGRSWIRUWKH

EHQH¿WRIWKHQDWLRQDQGDVDSROLWLFDOH[SHGLHQWDQ\RIWKHFRQÀLFWLQJRSLQLRQVZKLFKH[LVW

RQWKDWSRLQWDQGLVVXHDGHFUHHWRWKDWHIIHFWZHGRKHUHE\DJUHHWKDWVXFKDGHFUHHVKDOOEH

ELQGLQJRQXVDQGRQWKHZKROHQDWLRQ>«@VKRXOG+LV0DMHVW\WKLQN¿WWRLVVXHDQHZRUGHU

ZHDQGWKHQDWLRQVKDOOOLNHZLVHEHERXQGE\LWSURYLGHGDOZD\VWKDWVXFKRUGHUEHQRWRQO\

RIWKHPDۊܲDUWKHUHOLJLRXVGHEDWHVLQµ,EƗGDW[ƗQDZHUHUHVXPHGEXWQRZDOVR

WKHUHSUHVHQWDWLYHVRIRWKHUUHOLJLRQVZHUHLQYLWHGWRWDNHSDUWLQWKHPDQGWKH

VFRSHRIWKHGLVSXWHVZDVH[WHQGHGWRLQFOXGHYLHZVDQGGRJPDVRIUHOLJLRXV

V\VWHPVGLIIHUHQWIURP,VODP)XUWKHUPRUH$NEDU¶VLQWHUHVWLQRWKHUUHOLJLRQV

ZDVQRWDQHZSKHQRPHQRQ±IRUTXLWHDORQJWLPHKHZDVVWXG\LQJWKHVHFUHWV

RIWKH=RURDVWULDQVDQGHYHQREVHUYHGVRPHRIWKHLUULWXDOVKHZDVDOVRYLYLGO\

LQWHUHVWHGLQ+LQGXLVP-DLQLVP%XGGKLVPDQG&KULVWLDQLW\

$NEDU¶V¿UVWHQFRXQWHUZLWK&KULVWLDQLW\PLJKWKDYHEHHQLQ7KH

DSSDUHQWO\LQVLJQL¿FDQWQHZVDERXWWZR&KULVWLDQPLVVLRQDULHV¶DUULYDOLQ%HQJDO

UHDFKHGWKHHPSHURU5HIXVLQJWKHPDEVROXWLRQWKH\VHYHUHO\UHSURYHGVRPH

3RUWXJXHVHPHUFKDQWVZKRZHUHDFFXVHGRIGHIUDXGLQJWKH0XJKDOVWDWHWUHDVXU\

E\QRWSD\LQJWKHUHTXLUHGWD[HV

7KHHPSHURUZDVYHU\LPSUHVVHGERWK

EHFDXVHRIWKHQDWXUHRIWKH&KULVWLDQSULHVWVDQGWKHGRJPDVRIWKHLUUHOLJLRQ

ZKLFKKHFRQVLGHUHGH[FHSWLRQDOO\YDOXDEOHVLQFHLWFRQGHPQHGFDWHJRULFDOO\

DQ\GLVKRQHVW\±HYHQLQUHODWLRQWRDIRUHLJQJRYHUQPHQW

:LVKLQJWROHDUQPRUHDERXWWKH&KULVWLDQGRFWULQH$NEDULQYLWHG)DWKHU-XOLDQ

3HUHLUDWKHWKHQ9LFDU*HQHUDOLQ%HQJDOWRKLVFRXUW<HWWKHSLRXVEXWSRRUO\

HGXFDWHGFOHUJ\PDQZDVQRWDEOHWRVDWLVI\WKHHPSHURU¶VFXULRVLW\6LPLODUO\

QHLWKHU3LHWUR7DYjUHVD3RUWXJXHVHRI¿FHULQKLVVHUYLFHDQGWKHFRPPDQGDQW

RIWKHSRUWRI+XJOLQRU$QWRQLR&DEUDOVHQWWRKLVFRXUWDVDQDPEDVVDGRURI

WKH3RUWXJXHVH9LFHUR\'RP'LRJRGH0HQHVHVFRXOGDXWKRULWDWLYHO\JLYH

IXUWKHUGHWDLOVDERXWWKHPRUHSURIRXQGPDWWHUVRIWKHIDLWKHYHQWKRXJKWKH\

ZHUHDEOHWRSURYLGHWKHHPSHURUZLWKDFRQVLGHUDEOHDPRXQWRILQIRUPDWLRQ

FRQFHUQLQJ&KULVWLDQPDQQHUVDQGFXVWRPV,QWKLVVLWXDWLRQ$NEDUGHFLGHGWR

VHHNWKHDVVLVWDQFHRIWKH3RUWXJXHVH&DWKROLFPLVVLRQWKDWKDGEHHQUHVLGLQJ

LQ*RDIRUWKHODVWVHYHUDOGHFDGHV,Q'HFHPEHU$NEDUVHQWDIROORZLQJ

OHWWHUWRWKHDXWKRULWLHVLQ*RD

7KHFRPPDQGPHQWRI=HODOGLQXVWKH*UHDW.LQJE\*RGFRQVWLWXWHG.QRZRFKLHI)DWKHUV

RIWKH2UGHURI6W3DXO

WKDWZHDUHYHU\ZHOOGLVSRVHGXQWR\RX:HDUHVHQGLQJXQWR

LQDFFRUGDQFHZLWKVRPHYHUVHRIWKH4XU¶iQEXWDOVRRIUHDOEHQH¿WWRWKHQDWLRQDQGIXUWKHU

WKDWDQ\RSSRVLWLRQRQWKHSDUWRIKLVVXEMHFWVWRVXFKDQRUGHUSDVVHGE\+LV0DMHVW\VKDOO

LQYROYHGDPQDWLRQLQWKHZRUOGWRFRPHDQGORVVRISURSHUW\DQGUHOLJLRXVSULYLOHJHVLQWKLV«´

0XQWD[DEDOWDYƗUƯ[,,±

0RUHRQ$NEDU¶VDWWLWXGHWRZDUGVRWKHUUHOLJLRQVFIHJ1L]DPL5L]YL

7KHRFFXUUHQFHZDVGHVFULEHGE\-RKQ&RUUHLD$IRQVRLQWKH,QWURGXFWLRQWRKLVERRN

DQGWKHQDPHVRIWKHWZRPLVVLRQDULHVFDQDOVREHIRXQGWKHUH±$QWKRQ\9D]DQG3HWHU'LDV

&I&RUUHLD$IRQVR

7KH-HVXLW)DWKHUVDW*RDZHUHNQRZQDV3DXOLVWVRQDFFRXQWRIWKH&ROOHJHRI6W3DXO

ZKLFKJDYHULVHWRWKLVQDPH7KHFROOHJH±SULPDULO\DQRUGLQDU\OD\VHPLQDU\±ZDVFRQYHUWHG

LQWRD-HVXLWLQVWLWXWLRQE\6W)UDQFLV;DYLHU0DQ\-HVXLWSULHVWVZHUHWUDLQHGWKHUHDQGWKH

FROOHJHZDVVHHQE\WKH)DWKHUVRIWKH6RFLHW\DVWKHLU,QGLDQ$OPD0DWHU&I'X-DUULF

QRWH

$JQLHV]ND.XF]NLHZLF])UDĞ

$NEDUWKH*UHDW±DQG&KULVWLDQLW\%HWZHHQUHOLJLRQDQGSROLWLFV

\RX(EDGXOOD

RXUHQYR\DQG'RPLQLFXV3HWULFXV

WKDWWKH\PD\FRPPXQLFDWHWR\RXLQ

RXURZQZRUGVRXUGHVLUHWKDWWZROHDUQHGSULHVWVVKRXOGEHVHQWXQWRXVWREULQJWKHFKLHI

ERRNVRIWKH/DZDQGWKH*RVSHOLQRUGHUWKDWZHPD\OHDUQWKH/DZDQGLWVIXOOPHDQLQJ

DQGSHUIHFWWUXWKVLQHYHU\UHVSHFW)RU,HDUQHVWO\GHVLUHWKRURXJKO\WROHDUQWKDW/DZ/HW

WKHPQRWKHVLWDWHWKHUHIRUHWRVHWRXWZLWKWKHVDPHHQYR\VZKHQWKH\OHDYH*RDRQWKH

UHWXUQMRXUQH\DQGOHWWKHPEULQJWKHERRNVRIWKH/DZZLWKWKHP/HWWKHSULHVWVXQGHUVWDQG

WKDW,VKDOOUHFHLYHWKHPZLWKDOOSRVVLEOHNLQGQHVVDQGKRQRXU7KHLUDUULYDOZLOOEHDJUHDW

GHOLJKWWRPHDQGZKHQ,KDYHOHDUQWZKDW,ORQJWRNQRZDERXWWKHODZDQGLWVSHUIHFWLRQDQG

WKHVDOYDWLRQLWRIIHUVWKH\VKDOOEHDOORZHGWRUHWXUQDVVRRQDVWKH\OLNH,VKDOOVHQGWKHP

EDFNDJDLQGLJQL¿HGZLWKYHU\PDQ\KRQRXUVDQGJLIWV/HWWKHPKDYHQRIHDULQFRPLQJ

)RU,WDNHWKHPXQGHUP\RZQSURWHFWLRQDQGJXDUDQWHH)DUHZHOO

7KHOHJDWLRQUHDFKHG*RDLQ6HSWHPEHUDQGZDVZHOFRPHGDFFRUGLQJ

WRWKHVWDWHFHUHPRQ\XVXDOO\UHVHUYHGIRUWKHDUULYDORIDQHZ3RUWXJXHVH

9LFHUR\7KHHPSHURU¶VLQYLWDWLRQDURXVHGJUHDWHQWKXVLDVPDQGKLJKKRSHV

DPRQJPLVVLRQDULHVZKRIRUPDQ\\HDUVWULHGWR¿QGDZD\RISUHDFKLQJ*RG¶V

ZRUGLQWKH0XJKDO¶VHPSLUHZLWKRXWDQ\VXFFHVV7KHSURVSHFWRIZLQQLQJ

VXFKDSRZHUIXOUXOHUDQGVXFKDYDVWFRXQWU\IRUWKHJORU\RIWKH&KXUFK

DQGWKHEHQH¿WVRIWKH3RUWXJXHVHZDVZRUWKWDNLQJDQ\ULVNV'HVSLWHWKH

LQLWLDOUHVLVWDQFHIURPWKH9LFHUR\LWZDVGHFLGHGLQ1RYHPEHUWKDWDPLVVLRQ

FRQVLVWLQJRIWKUHHFDUHIXOO\VHOHFWHGSULHVWVZRXOGEHVHQWWRWKHFRXUWRIWKH

*UHDW0XJKDO7KHVHSULHVWVZHUH5XGROI$TXDYLYDDJHGWKHKHDGRI

WKHPLVVLRQ FRPLQJIURPDQDULVWRFUDWLFIDPLO\IURP1DSOHVDQLQWHOOHFWXDO

DQGH[SHUWLQSKLORVRSK\ZKRVSRNHWKHORFDOODQJXDJHV.RQNDQLDQGODWHU

DOVR3HUVLDQ$QWRQLR0RQVHUUDWHD&DWDODQDJHGDV$TXDYLYD¶VGHSXW\

DQGFKURQLFOHURIWKHH[SHGLWLRQ

DQG)UDQoRLV+HQULTXpVD0XVOLPFRQYHUW

RI3HUVLDQRULJLQFRPLQJIURP2UPX]ZKRZDVWRDFWDVDQLQWHUSUHWHUDQG

DVVLVWDQWWRWKHPLVVLRQ

$IWHUDWLULQJDQGGDQJHURXVMRXUQH\ZKLFKODVWHGRYHUWKUHHPRQWKVWKH

PLVVLRQDULHVUHDFKHG)DWতSnjU6ƯNUƯRQ)HEUXDU\$NEDUZDVZDLWLQJ

,WZDVPRVWSUREDEO\6D\\LGµ$EGDOOƗKRQHRI$NEDU¶VRI¿FHUVPHQWLRQHGE\$EX¶O)D਌O

DPRQJWKHFRPPDQGHUVRIWKHVHYHQKXQGUHGQRFIƖµƯQL$NEDUƯ,

'RPLQLF3HUH]ZDVDQ$UPHQLDQ&KULVWLDQDWWKH$NEDU¶VFRXUWPDUULHGWRDQ,QGLDQZLIH

+HVHUYHGDVDQLQWHUSUHWHURIWKH$NEDU¶VHPEDVVLHVWR*RDLQDQG&I0RQVHUUDWH

IRRWQRWHDQG'X-DUULFQRWH

7KHWH[WRIWKHOHWWHULVFLWHGKHUHDIWHU0RQVHUUDWH,WVVOLJKWO\GLIIHUHQW(QJOLVK

YHUVLRQVZHUHDOVRSXEOLVKHGLQHJ6PLWK'X-DUULF&RUUHLD$IRQVR

,WLVZRUWKPHQWLRQLQJKHUHWKDWWKHFKURQLFOHVRI$QWRQLR0RQVHUUDWHWLWOHG0RQJROLFDH

/HJDWLRQLV&RPPHQWDULXVGLVFRYHUHGLQDQGSXEOLVKHGLQLQ(QJOLVKWUDQVODWLRQDV

7KH&RPPHQWDU\RI)DWKHU0RQVHUUDWH6-RQKLV-RXUQH\WRWKH&RXUWRI$NEDUKDYHDXQLTXH

KLVWRULFDOLPSRUWDQFHEHLQJWKHHDUOLHVWIURPWKHWLPHVRI9DVFRGD*DPD(XURSHDQUHSRUW

FRQFHUQLQJ1RUWK,QGLD0RQVHUUDWHGHVFULEHG±DPRQJRWKHUWKLQJV±WKHGHWDLOVRIDVXFFHVVIXO

FDPSDLJQUXQE\$NEDULQDJDLQVWKLVUHEHOOLRXVKDOIEURWKHU0LU]ƗণDNƯPJRYHUQRURI.ƗEXO

+HDOVRLQFOXGHGDPDSRI1RUWK,QGLDSUHSDUHGRQWKHEDVLVRIKLVDVWURQRPLFDOREVHUYDWLRQV

ZKLFKKDVEHHQWKHROGHVW(XURSHDQPDSRI,QGLDVLQFHWKHWLPHVRI3WROHP\DQG(UDWRVWKHQHV

IRUWKHPZLWKJUHDWDQWLFLSDWLRQDQGDVVRRQDVWKH\KDGDUULYHGWKH\ZHUH

WDNHQEHIRUHWKHHPSHURUDQGVWD\HGZLWKKLPWLOOODWHLQWKHQLJKWDQVZHULQJ

KLVTXHVWLRQVDERXWWKH&KULVWLDQIDLWK$NEDU¶VVRQVDJHGIURPWRDV

ZHOODVKHZRUH3RUWXJXHVHFORWKHVVFDUOHWFORDNVZLWKJROGHQIDVWHQLQJVDQG

3RUWXJXHVHKDWV±ZKLFKWKHHPSHURUXVHGWRZHDUWRSOHDVHKLVJXHVWV+HDOVR

SUHVHQWHGWKH-HVXLWVZLWKFRQVLGHUDEOHDPRXQWRIJROGEXWWKH)DWKHUVERXQG

E\WKHYRZRISRYHUW\UHIXVHGWKHJLIWDQG³>Q@RWKLQJWKDWKHFRXOGVD\ZRXOG

SHUVXDGHWKHPWRDFFHSWWKHSUHVHQW´

7KLVDURXVHGWKHHPSHURU¶VLPPHQVH

VXUSULVHEHFDXVHDWWKDWWLPHRIIHULQJPRQH\DQGDFFHSWLQJJLIWVRIWKLVW\SH

ZDVDXQLYHUVDOO\UHFRJQLVHGFXVWRP

7KHIROORZLQJGD\WKHPLVVLRQDULHVZHUHDJDLQUHFHLYHGE\$NEDULQDSULYDWH

DXGLHQFHDQGDIHZGD\VODWHURQ0DUFKWKH\SUHVHQWHGWRKLPDEHDXWL

IXOO\ERXQGFRS\RI%LEOLD5HJLDDOVRNQRZQDV3ODQWLQ3RO\JORWLQHLJKW

YROXPHVFRPPLVVLRQHGE\)LOLS,,WKH.LQJRI6SDLQDQGSULQWHGLQ$QWZHUS

E\&KULVWRSKHU3ODQWLQEHWZHHQDQG

:LWKLPPHQVHDVWRQLVKPHQW

WKHPLVVLRQDULHVREVHUYHGWKDW$NEDU³UHFHLYHGWKHVHKRO\ERRNVZLWKJUHDW

UHYHUHQFHWDNLQJHDFKLQWRKLVKDQGRQHDIWHUWKHRWKHUDQGNLVVLQJLWDIWHU

ZKLFKKHSODFHGLWRQKLVKHDGZKLFKDPRQJVWWKHVHSHRSOHVLJQL¿HVKRQRXU

DQGUHVSHFW+HDFWHGWKXVLQWKHSUHVHQFHRIDOOKLVFRXUWLHUVDQGFDSWDLQVWKH

JUHDWHUSDUWRIZKRPZHUH0DKRPHWDQV$IWHUZDUGVKHLQTXLUHGZKLFKRIWKHVH

ERRNVFRQWDLQHGWKH*RVSHOVDQGZKHQLWZDVSRLQWHGRXWWRKLPKHORRNHG

DWLWYHU\LQWHQWO\NLVVHGLWDVHFRQGWLPHDQGSODFHGLWDVEHIRUHRQKLVKHDG

+HWKHQJDYHRUGHUVWRKLVDWWHQGDQWVWKDWWKHERRNVZHUHWREHFRQYH\HGWRKLV

RZQDSDUWPHQWDQGRUGHUHGDULFKFDELQHWWREHPDGHIRUWKHLUUHFHSWLRQ´

22

+H

DOVRRUGHUHGWKHFRXUWDUWLVWVWRSURGXFHDJROGHQUHOLTXDU\DQGPDNHFRSLHVRI

SRUWUDLWVRI&KULVWWKH6DYLRXURIWKHZRUOGDQG9LUJLQ0DU\KLVKRO\0RWKHU

ZKLFKWKH-HVXLWVEURXJKWZLWKWKHP

23

0RQVHUUDWH$QGGX-DUULFDGGV³$VIRUWKHLUOLYHOLKRRGIRUZKLFKWKH.LQJ

XUJHGWKHPWRDFFHSWZKDWKHRIIHUHGWKHPWKH\VDLGWKDWLWZDVVXI¿FLHQWKDSSLQHVVIRUWKHPWR

HQMR\KLVIDYRXUDQGWKDWWKH\WUXVWHGWR*RGWRVXSSO\WKHLUGDLO\QHHGV7KH.LQJZDVPXFK

LPSUHVVHGE\WKHLUUHIXVDORIWKHPRQH\DQGIRUDORQJWLPHFRXOGWDONWRKLVFRXUWLHUVRIQRWKLQJ

HOVH´'X-DUULF

)LIWHHQ\HDUVODWHULQ$NEDURIIHUHGWKLV3RO\JORWDWRJHWKHUZLWKRWKHU(XURSHDQ

ERRNVWKDWKHKDGLQKLVOLEUDU\WRWKH-HVXLWSULHVWVRIWKHWKLUGPLVVLRQVHQWIURP*RD$PRQJWKH

GRQDWHGYROXPHVWKHUHZHUH³GLIIHUHQW%LEOHVDQGFRQFRUGDQFHVWKH6XPPDWKHRORJLDHDQGRWKHU

ZRUNVRI7KRPDV$TXLQDVVXUHO\LQ/DWLQZRUNVRI'RPLQJRGH6RWRRI$QWRQLR)RUFLJOLRQH

+LVWRULD3RQWL¿FDOLV>RI-RKQRI6DOLVEXU\±$.)@&KURQLFOHVRI6W)UDQFLV&RQVWLWXWLRQVRIWKH

6RFLHW\RI-HVXVDQG6SLULWXDO([HUFLVHVRI6W,JQDWLXV´)HUQDQGR*LVSHUW6DXFK

$OOWKHVHERRNV$NEDUKDGLQKLVSRVVHVVLRQDVDUHVXOWRIKLVLQWHUDFWLRQVZLWKWKH(XURSHDQV

DQGWKH\SURYHKRZULFKDQGZHOOHTXLSSHGKLVOLEUDU\ZDV0RUHRQ$NEDU¶VOLEUDU\VHHDOVR

'X-DUULF

22

'X-DUULF

23

,ELGS

$JQLHV]ND.XF]NLHZLF])UDĞ

$NEDUWKH*UHDW±DQG&KULVWLDQLW\%HWZHHQUHOLJLRQDQGSROLWLFV

7KHFKDSHOZDVEXLOWLQWKHSDODFHDQGRQHRI$NEDU¶VVRQV0XUƗGWKHQDER\

RIWHQZDVHQWUXVWHGWR)DWKHU0RQVHUUDWHWRVWXG\WKH3RUWXJXHVHODQJXDJH

DQGWKHSULQFLSOHVRI&KULVWLDQHWKLFV

24

7KHSULHVWVZHUHDOORZHGWRSUHDFKDQG

FRQYHUWIUHHO\LQWKHZKROHFLW\DQGWKH\FRXOGSHUIRUPSXEOLFO\WKHLUUHOLJLRXV

VHUYLFHVZKLFKZDVLQRSSRVLWLRQWRWKHSULQFLSOHVRI,VODP:KHQDFHUWDLQ

3RUWXJXHVHKDGGLHGDWDFRXUW$NEDUDFFHGHGWRRUJDQLVH³DSXEOLFIXQHUDOZLWK

&KULVWLDQULWHVWKDWLVWRVD\ZLWKOLJKWHGFDQGOHVDQGSUHFHGHGE\WKHFURVV´

7KH-HVXLWVHQMR\HGXQOLPLWHGFRQWLQXRXVDFFHVVWRWKHHPSHURU

DQGZHUH

DOVRUHJXODUSDUWLFLSDQWVLQWKHUHOLJLRXVGHEDWHVLQµ,EƗGDW[ƗQDDVZHOODVLQ

WKRVHFRQGXFWHGRXWVLGHWKHFRXUWGXULQJWKHPLOLWDU\RUKXQWLQJH[SHGLWLRQV

7KHUHLVQRGRXEWWKDWWKH-HVXLWPLVVLRQDULHVZHUHDPD]HGE\WKHWROHUDQFH

RIWKH0XJKDOUXOHU±WKH\ZHUHFRPLQJDIWHUDOOIURP(XURSHGRPLQDWHGDW

WKDWWLPHE\WKHUDJLQJ,QTXLVLWLRQWUDFNLQJGRZQDQGSHUVHFXWLQJKHUHWLFV

ZKHUHWKHVRYHUHLJQVLPSRVHGWKHLURZQUHOLJLRQRQWKHLUVXEMHFWVDFFRUGLQJWR

WKHSULQFLSOH

&XLXVUHJLRHLXVUHOLJLR7KHPLVVLRQDULHVWRRNLWIRUJUDQWHGWKDW

$NEDUZDVFORVHWRUHMHFW,VODPWRWDOO\DQGEHFRPHD&KULVWLDQ7KLVHUURQHRXV

EHOLHIZDVVXUHO\VWUHQJWKHQHGE\WKHUHSRUWVRI%DGƗގnjQƯZKRGHVFULEHGWKH

WHUULEOHUHODWLRQVKLSWKDWSUHYDLOHGEHWZHHQWKHUXOHUDQGWKH3KLOLVWLQHRUWKRGR[

0XVOLPFOHUJ\)RUWKHFRQVHUYDWLYHKLVWRULDQLWZDVRQHRIWKHSURRIVRIWKH

HPSHURU¶VDQWL,VODPLFDWWLWXGH

27

7KXVWKH)DWKHUVZHUHWUXO\GLVDSSRLQWHGZKHQ

24

)DWKHU0RQVHUUDWHSUDLVHGWKH\RXQJSULQFHWREH³DQLGHDOSXSLODVUHJDUGVQDWXUDODELOLW\

JRRGFRQGXFWDQGLQWHOOHFWXDOFDSDFLW\,QDOOWKHVHUHVSHFWVLWZRXOGKDYHEHHQKDUGWR¿QGDQ\

&KULVWLDQ\RXWKOHWDORQHDSULQFHVXUSDVVLQJKLP´0RQVHUUDWH

'X-DUULF7KHIXQHUDOSURFHVVLRQWKDWSDVVHGWKURXJKWKHFLW\RI

)DWতSnjU6ƯNUƯ

DURXVHGJUHDWFXULRVLW\DPRQJLWVLQKDELWDQWV³WKHLQ¿GHOV>«@ZHUHVWURQJO\LPSUHVVHGE\

UHYHUHQWUHVSHFWVKRZQE\WKH3RUWXJXHVHWRZDUGVWKHLUGHDGDQGPDQ\HYHQRIWKH6DUDFHQV

XWWHUHGSUD\HUVIRUWKHGHFHDVHGDQGRIIHUHGWRDVVLVWLQWKHLQWHUPHQW´,ELG

,WKDSSHQHGTXLWHRIWHQWKDW$NEDUFRQGXFWHGORQJQLJKWWLPHFRQYHUVDWLRQVZLWKWKH-HVXLWV

LQWKHSULYDF\RIKLVRZQWKURQHURRPLQRQHRIKLVOHWWHUVWR)DWKHU9LQFHQWHGDWHG-XO\

5XGROI$TXDYLYDZULWHVWKDWVXFKGLVFXVVLRQVRFFXUUHG³DWOHDVWRQFHDZHHNWLOOPLGQLJKW

DQGDWWLPHVEH\RQGWKDW´&RUUHLD$IRQVR

27

%DGƗގnjQƯFKDUJHV$NEDUZLWKUHMHFWLQJ³WKH5HVXUUHFWLRQDQG-XGJPHQWDQGRWKHUGHWDLOV

DQGWUDGLWLRQVRIZKLFKWKH3URSKHWZDVWKHUHSRVLWRU\´0XQWD[DEDOWDYƗUƯ[,,+HVWDWHV

WKDW³DIWHU¿YHRUVL[\HDUVQRWDWUDFHRI,VOiPZDVOHIWLQKLP>$NEDU@DQGHYHU\WKLQJZDV

WXUQHGWRSV\WXUY\´,ELGDQGDGPLWVRSHQO\WKDW³+LV0DMHVW\¿UPO\EHOLHYHGLQWKHWUXWK

RIWKH&KULVWLDQUHOLJLRQDQGZLVKLQJWRVSUHDGWKHGRFWULQHVRI-HVXVRUGHUHG3ULQFH0XUiGWR

WDNHDIHZOHVVRQVLQ&KULVWLDQLW\XQGHUJRRGDXVSLFHVDQGFKDUJHG$EXOID]OWRWUDQVODWHWKH

*RVSHO,QVWHDGRIWKHXVXDO%LVPLOOiKLUUDۊPiQLUUDۊtQWKHIROORZLQJOLQHZDVXVHG$LQiPt

YH\*HVX&KULVWXWKDWLV©2WKRXZKRVHQDPHLVPHUFLIXODQGYHU\ERXQWLIXOª´,ELG

%DGƗގnjQƯDFFXVHVWKH)DWKHUV³WKRVHDFFXUVHGPHQ´DQGRWKHU³SHUVRQVRIQRYHODQGZKLPVLFDO

RSLQLRQVLQDFFRUGDQFHZLWKWKHLUSHUQLFLRXVLGHDVDQGYDLQGRXEWV´,ELGRIFDXVLQJWKLV

GLVDVWURXVVLWXDWLRQ7KH&KULVWLDQPLVVLRQDULHVPDNHWKHVDPHVWDWHPHQW³$QG\HWRQHGRHVQRW

NQRZIRUFHUWDLQZKDWODZKHIROORZVIRUWKRXJKKHLVFHUWDLQO\QRWD0DKRPHWDQDVKLVDFWLRQV

VKRZSODLQO\HQRXJK«´'X-DUULF

LW¿QDOO\WXUQHGRXWWKDWWKHHDUQHVWGHVLUHWR¿QGVSLULWXDOWUXWKVRFKDUDFWHULVWLF

RI$NEDUZDVFDXVHGE\KLVLQFOLQDWLRQVWRZDUGVP\VWLFLVPUDWKHUWKDQKLV

VLQFHUHGHVLUHRIFRQYHUVLRQHYHQWKRXJKVRPHRIKLVGHHGVPLJKWKDYHFUHDWHG

VXFKDQLPSUHVVLRQ

2QWKHRWKHUKDQGWKHEHKDYLRXURIWKH-HVXLWVZDVXQFRPSURPLVLQJHYHQ

IDQDWLFDODQGPDQ\DWLPHLWZDVRQO\WKHDXWKRULW\RIWKHHPSHURUWKDWVDYHG

WKHLUOLYHV7KHSULHVWVEURNHWKHUXOHVRIFRXUWHWLTXHWWHUHSHDWHGO\DQGVSRNH

LQDGHURJDWRU\PDQQHUDERXW,VODPDQGLWVSURSKHW7KHLUSUHVHQFHDWWKHFRXUW

DQG$NEDU¶VH[SOLFLWIDYRXUVLQWHQVL¿HGGLVFRQWHQWDQGWKHKRVWLOHDWWLWXGHDPRQJ

WKHFRXUWLHUV±HVSHFLDOO\WKRVHFRQQHFWHGZLWKWKHFRQVHUYDWLYH0XVOLPIDFWLRQ

'XULQJWKHGHEDWHVWKHGLVSXWHFRQFHUQLQJWKHVXSHULRULW\RIWKH%LEOHRYHUWKH

4XU¶ƗQDQGYLFHYHUVDUHWXUQHGRYHUDQGRYHUDJDLQ7KHRUGHDOE\¿UHZDV

HYHQSURSRVHGDVDPHDQVRISURYLQJWKHWUXHQHVVRIWKHFODLPVRIERWKSDUWLHV

EXWHYHQWXDOO\LWQHYHUWRRNSODFH)RUWKH-HVXLWVWKHXQVROYDEOHSUREOHPZDV

SRO\JDP\±XQDFFHSWDEOHIRUWKHPEXWDWWKHVDPHWLPHLPSRVVLEOHWREHJLYHQ

XSE\$NEDU7KHHPSHURUFRXOGQRWDQGGLGQRWZDQWWRUHMHFWWKHSUDFWLFHRI

KDYLQJPDQ\ZLYHVIRUSXUHO\SROLWLFDOUHDVRQV±WKHDOOLDQFHVHVWDEOLVKHGE\

PDUU\LQJZRPHQIURPSRZHUIXOIDPLOLHVZKRZHUHPRVWO\GDXJKWHUVRIWKH

PLJKW\ORFDOUXOHUV3RO\JDP\ZDVRQHRIWKHSLOODUVRIWKHLPSHULDOSROLF\RI

H[SDQVLRQDQGXQLWLQJ,QGLDQWHUULWRULHVXQGHUWKH0XJKDOUXOH0RUHRYHUWKH

PLVVLRQDULHVZHUHXQDEOHWRFRPHWRWHUPVZLWKWKHIDFWWKDW$NEDUDOORZHGKLV

VXEMHFWVWRHQMR\FRPSOHWHIUHHGRPRIUHOLJLRQDQGFRQVHTXHQWO\³FDUHGOLWWOH

WKDWLQDOORZLQJHYHU\RQHWRIROORZKLVRZQUHOLJLRQKHZDVLQUHDOLW\YLRODWLQJ

DOOUHOLJLRQV´

±DV)DWKHU0RQVHUUDWHFRPPHQWHG

$NEDURFFDVLRQDOO\WRRNSDUWLQ&KULVWLDQVHUYLFHVNQHHOLQJEDUHKHDGHGKHSURVWUDWHG

KLPVHOIEHIRUHWKHLPDJHRIWKH6DYLRXURUHYHQNLVVHGDQLFRQRI-HVXVRQDSXEOLFRFFDVLRQ

&I&RUUHLD$IRQVR

%RWK%DGƗގnjQƯDQG$EX¶O)D਌OPHQWLRQWKHVHHYHQWVWKRXJKWKHLUUHSRUWVGLIIHUZKHQLW

FRPHVWRLQGLFDWLQJZKLFKRIWKHSDUWLHVSURSRVHGWKHRUGHDOE\¿UH$FFRUGLQJWR%DGƗގnjQƯLWZDV

4X৬EXGGƯQRI-DOHVDUUHJDUGHGDVDKRO\PDQPDM]

և njELQWR[LFDWHG[DUƗEƯZLWKWKH'LYLQH

/RYHZKR³EURXJKW>«@WRDFRQIHUHQFHZLWKVRPH&KULVWLDQSULHVWVDQGSKLORVRSKHUVDQGJUHDW

ODZDXWKRULWLHVRIWKHDJHDIWHUDGLVFXVVLRQ>«@H[FODLPHG©/HWXVPDNHDSHDW¿UHDQGLQWKH

SUHVHQFHRI+LV0DMHVW\ZHZLOOSDVVWKURXJKLWDQGZKLFKHYHUJHWVVDIHO\WKURXJKLWZLOOSURYH

WKHUHE\WKHWUXWKRIKLVUHOLJLRQª7KH¿UHZDVPDGH7KH6KDLNKSXOOHGRQHRIWKH&KULVWLDQSULHVWV

E\WKHFRDWDQGVDLGWRKLP©&RPHRQLQWKHQDPHRI*RGª%XWQRQHRIWKHSULHVWVKDGWKH

FRXUDJHWRJR´0XQWD[DEDOWDYƗUƯ[,,$EX¶O)D਌OUHODWHVKRZHYHU³7KH3DGUH>5XGROI

±$.)@TXLHWO\DQGZLWKDQDLURIFRQYLFWLRQVDLG©$ODVWKDWVXFKWKLQJVVKRXOGEHWKRXJKWWR

EHWUXH,QIDFWLIWKLVIDFWLRQKDVVXFKDQRSLQLRQRIRXU%RRNDQGUHJDUGWKH)XUTƗQ4RUDQ

DVWKHSXUH:RUGRI*RGLWLVSURSHUWKDWDKHDSHG¿UHEHOLJKWHG:HVKDOOWDNHWKH*RVSHOVLQ

RXUKDQGVDQGWKHµ8ODPƗRIWKDWIDLWKVKDOOWDNHWKHLUERRNDQGWRJHWKHUZHVKDOOHQWHUWKDW

WHVWLQJSODFHRIWUXWK7KHHVFDSHRIDQ\RQHZLOOEHDVLJQRIKLVWUXWKIXOQHVVª´$NEDUQƗPD,,,

&IDOVR0RQVHUUDWH±5L]YLII1L]DPL±

0RQVHUUDWH

$JQLHV]ND.XF]NLHZLF])UDĞ

$NEDUWKH*UHDW±DQG&KULVWLDQLW\%HWZHHQUHOLJLRQDQGSROLWLFV

$OWKRXJKKLVDWWLWXGHWRZDUGVWKH&KULVWLDQPLVVLRQDULHVZDVYHU\SRVLWLYH

HYHQFRUGLDO

$NEDUGLGQRWVWRSWDNLQJPRUHRUOHVVDPELJXRXVDWWHPSWVWR

UHPRYHWKH3RUWXJXHVHIURPWKHWHUULWRULHVRFFXSLHGE\WKHPRQWKH:HVWHUQ

FRDVW7KHPDLQJRDOZDVWRUHJDLQIURPWKHIRUHLJQKDQGVWKHKDUERXUVRI'LX

DQG'DPDQZKLFKZDVMXVWL¿HGE\WKHQHFHVVLW\RISURYLGLQJ,QGLDQ0XVOLPV

ZLWKWKHSRVVLELOLW\RIVHWWLQJRIIWRণLMƗ]ZLWKRXWDGGLWLRQDOWURXEOHVFDXVHG

E\WKH3RUWXJXHVHDXWKRULWLHV+RZHYHUPLOLWDU\DFWLRQVWDNHQGXULQJWKH\HDUV

±GLGQRWEULQJDQ\UHVXOWVDQG¿QDOO\$NEDUJDYHXSWKHVHSODQV

SUREDEO\KDYLQJUHDOLVHGWKDWLWZDVLPSRVVLEOHWRGHDOHIIHFWLYHO\ZLWKWKH

3RUWXJXHVHQDYDOSRZHUZLWKRXWVWURQJÀHHWZKLFKWKH0XJKDOVGLGQRWKDYH

+RZHYHUWKH-HVXLWVOHDUQHGDERXWWKHDFWLRQVWDNHQE\$NEDUDJDLQVWWKH

3RUWXJXHVHDQGDFNQRZOHGJHGWKHPWREHGHFHLWIXODQGDPELJXRXV7KH\DOVR

DEDQGRQHGKRSHWKDWWKH\ZRXOGPDQDJHWRSHUVXDGH$NEDUWRDFFHSW&KULVWLDQLW\

DQGVXFFHHGLQFKDQJLQJKLPLQWR³$VLDQ&RQVWDQWLQHWKH*UHDW´HVSHFLDOO\

WKDWWKHHPSHURUVWDUWHGWRUHYHDOKLVLQFUHDVLQJO\VWURQJHUWHQGHQF\WRUHOLJLRXV

V\QFUHWLVP

32

7KHLUREVHUYDWLRQVDQGUDWKHUXQIDYRXUDEOHLPSUHVVLRQVRIWKH

SURVSHFWVRIWKHPLVVLRQZHUHUHSRUWHGWRWKHSURYLQFLDOLQ*RDZKRVXPPRQHG

WKHPWRUHWXUQLIRQO\WKH\GHFLGHGWKDWWKHUHZHUHQRFKDQFHVIRUDQ\SRVLWLYH

UHVXOWVRIWKHLUVWD\LQJDW$NEDU¶VFRXUW7KH¿UVWZKRUHWXUQHGWR*RDDOUHDG\LQ

EHIRUHWKHWHUPLQDWLRQRIWKHPLVVLRQZDV)DWKHU+HQULTXpV$\HDUODWHU

$GHVFULSWLRQRI$NEDU¶VIULHQGO\HYHQDIDPLOLDUDWWLWXGHWRZDUGVWKH-HVXLWVFDQEHIRXQG

HJLQ0RQVHUUDWH¶V&RPPHQWDU\FI,ELG±

32

0RQVHUUDWHHPSKDVLVHV$NEDU¶VHFOHFWLFLVPTXRWLQJKLVZRUGVZLWKZKLFKKHFRQFOXGHG

RQHRIWKHUHOLJLRXVGHEDWHV³,SHUFHLYHWKDWWKHUHDUHYDU\LQJFXVWRPVDQGEHOLHIVRIYDU\LQJ

UHOLJLRXVSDWKV)RUWKHWHDFKLQJVRIWKH+LQGXVWKH0XVDOPDQVWKH-D]GLQL>=RURDVWULDQV

±$.)@WKH-HZVDQGWKH&KULVWLDQVDUHDOOGLIIHUHQW>«@:KHUHIRUH,GHVLUHWKDWRQDSSRLQWHG

GD\VWKHERRNVRIDOOWKHUHOLJLRXVODZVEHEURXJKWIRUZDUGDQGWKDWWKHGRFWRUVPHHWWRJHWKHU

DQGKROGGLVFXVVLRQVVRWKDW,PD\KHDUWKHPDQGWKDWHDFKRQHPD\GHWHUPLQHZKLFKLVWKH

WUXHVWDQGPLJKWLHVWUHOLJLRQ´,ELG+HIXUWKHUVWDWHVWKDW³«WKHSULHVWVEHJDQWRVXVSHFW

WKDWKHZDVLQWHQGLQJWRIRXQGDQHZUHOLJLRQZLWKPDWWHUWDNHQIURPDOOWKHH[LVWLQJV\VWHPV´

,ELG7KLVRSLQLRQVKDUHGDOVRE\%DGƗގnjQƯZKRFKDUJHG$NEDUZLWKDSRVWDV\DQGUHDG

KLVLQWHQWLRQVDVDVLJQ

WKDWKHKDGDEDQGRQHG,VODPZDVWKHQYDVWO\UHSHDWHGE\WKHKLVWRULDQV

LQUHIHUHQFHWR7DXۊƯGLLOƗKƯ'LYLQH8QLW\WKHFLUFOHRIVFKRODUVDQGIROORZHUVZKLFK$NEDU

LQLWLDWHGLQ7DXۊƯGLLOƗKƯFDOOHGE\3LUEKDLDNLQGRI³WKHRVRSKLFDOVRFLHW\´UHVHPEOLQJ

DৡnjIƯRUGHUEXWLQFRUSRUDWLQJVRPHULWHVPRUHXVXDOO\UHODWHGWR+LQGXLVPOLNHYHJHWDULDQLVP

RUFUHPDWLRQFI3LUEKDLKDVEHHQZLGHO\UHJDUGHGDV$NEDU¶VDWWHPSWWRFRQVWUXFW

DQHZUHOLJLRQIRUDOOKLV,QGLDQVXEMHFWV+RZHYHUWKHLGHDRIWKH'LYLQH8QLW\HYHQWKRXJK

EXLOWRQ$NEDU¶VVWURQJIDLWKLQPRQRWKHLVPDQGৡnjIƯEHOLHIVFRQFHUQLQJWKHFRPPXQLRQZLWK

*RGWDXۊƯG±µGHFODULQJ*RGWREHRQHDORQH¶µEHOLHYLQJLQWKHXQLW\RI*RG¶DOVRKDGDVWURQJ

SROLWLFDOPRWLYDWLRQ$NEDUZDVWU\LQJWRVKDSHKLVVWDWHDQGLWVUXOLQJFODVVRQWKHEDVLVRIVXFK

SULQFLSOHVDVOLEHUDWLRQWROHUDQFHMXVWLFHDQGHTXDOWUHDWPHQWWRDOOIDLWKV7KLVZDVDJRDOZKLFK

QHLWKHU&KULVWLDQPLVVLRQDULHVQRUQDUURZPLQGHG0XVOLP

µXODPƗVXFKDV%DGƗގnjQƯFRXOGUHDOLVH

RUVXSSRUW7DXۊƯGLLOƗKƯKHOSHG$NEDUWRFUHDWHDWUDGLWLRQRIDEVROXWHOR\DOW\WRWKH0XJKDO

WKURQHZKLFKEHFDPHKLVOHJDF\WRKLVVXFFHVVRUV0RUHRQUHOLJLRXVDQGSROLWLFDODVSHFWVRI

7DXۊƯGLLOƗKƯFI3LUEKDLSDVV&KDQGUD±

$QWRQLR0RQVHUUDWHOHIWWKHFRXUWEXWKHZDVGHOHJDWHGE\$NEDUWREHFRPHRQHRI

WKHPHPEHUVRIWKHSODQQHG0XJKDOOHJDWLRQWRWKHNLQJRI6SDLQ0RQVHUUDWHZDV

HTXLSSHGZLWKDZULWWHQUHTXHVWWRVHQGDQRWKHU&KULVWLDQLQKLVSODFHDVZHOODV

PRUHERRNVFRQFHUQLQJ&KULVWLDQLW\+RZHYHUWKHHPEDVV\WR6SDLQQHYHUFDPHWR

IUXLWLRQDQG0RQVHUUDWHVWD\HGLQ*RD7KHODVWPHPEHUDQGOHDGHURIWKHPLVVLRQ

5XGROI$TXDYLYDUHPDLQHGDWWKHFRXUWIRUDQRWKHU\HDUDQGHYHQWXDOO\KHWRRN

OHDYHRI$NEDULQ)HEUXDU\ZLWKJUHDWDQGPXWXDOUHJUHW7KHHPSHURUDQG

WKHPLVVLRQDU\ZKREHIULHQGHGHDFKRWKHUGXULQJWKRVHWKUHH\HDUVZHUHQHYHUWR

PHHWDJDLQ±$TXDYLYDZDVPDUW\UHGDIHZZHHNVDIWHUKLVUHWXUQWR*RD

7KXVWKH¿UVW&KULVWLDQPLVVLRQWRWKH0XJKDOHPSLUHHQGHGXSLQDQDS

SDUHQWIDLOXUH0RQVHUUDWHVXPPDULVHGLWZLWKGLVDSSRLQWPHQW³+HQFHZHPD\

MXVWO\VXVSHFWWKDW=HODOGLQXVKDGEHHQOHGWRVXPPRQWKH&KULVWLDQSULHVWVQRW

E\DQ\GLYLQHSURPSWLQJEXWE\FXULRVLW\DQGWRDUGHQWDQLQWHUHVWLQKHDULQJ

QHZWKLQJVRUSHUKDSVE\DGHVLUHWRDWWHPSWWKHGHVWUXFWLRQRIPHQ¶VVRXOVLQ

VRPHQRYHOIDVKLRQ)RULIWKLVHQWHUSULVHKDGEHHQRI*RGLWFRXOGKDYHEHHQ

KLQGHUHGE\QRKDUGVKLSRUREVWDFOHV6LQFHLWZDVQRWRI*RGLWFROODSVHGRI

LWVHOILQVSLWHRIWKH.LQJ¶VREVWLQDF\´

33

%XWZDVWKHIDLOXUHRIWKHPLVVLRQUHDOO\VRFRPSOHWH",QIDFWVHYHQ\HDUV

ODWHU$NEDUVHQWDQRWKHUZULWWHQUHTXHVWWRWKHDXWKRULWLHVLQ*RDDVNLQJDJDLQ

IRUVHQGLQJ&KULVWLDQSULHVWVWRKLVFRXUW7KHOHWWHUREYLRXVO\GLFWDWHGE\

WKHHPSHURUKLPVHOIPD\LQGLFDWHWKDWLQWKH\HDU$NEDUPD\KDYHKDG

VRPHWKRXJKWVRIDFFHSWLQJ&KULVWLDQIDLWK

34

:HFDQUHDGWKHUHWKHIROORZLQJ

SDVVDJHV³,KDYHNQRZOHGJHRIDOOWKHIDLWKVRIWKHZRUOGERWKRIWKRVHRI

WKH*HQWLOH

RIYDULRXVVRUWVDQGWKHODZRI0DKRPHWH[FHSWLQJRQO\WKDWRI

-HVXV&KULVWZKLFKLVWKHODZRI*RGDQGDVVXFKLVDFFHSWHGDQGIROORZHGE\

PDQ\>«@)DWKHUV>«@PD\GLVSXWHZLWKP\GRFWRUVDQG>«@,E\FRPSDULQJ

WKHNQRZOHGJHDQGRWKHUTXDOLWLHVGLVSOD\HGRQHLWKHUVLGHPD\EHDEOHWR

VHHWKHVXSHULRULW\RIWKH)DWKHUVRYHUP\RZQOHDUQHGPHQZKRPZHFDOO

&D]LTXHVDQGZKRE\WKLVPHDQVPD\EHWDXJKWWRNQRZWKHWUXWK>«@´

$QG

WKHGRFXPHQWZKLFK$NEDUVHQWWRWKHJRYHUQRUVRIWKHSURYLQFHVLQRUGHUWR

HQVXUHDVDIHMRXUQH\RIWKH-HVXLWVIURP*RDWR/ƗKDXUVD\VDJDLQ³,KRSH

>«@WRHQVXUHWKHGHVSDWFKRIFHUWDLQRWKHU)DWKHUVZKRP,KDYHLQYLWHGWRFRPH

WRPHIURP*RDDQGWKURXJKZKRVHKRO\GRFWULQH,KRSHWREHUHVWRUHGIURP

33

0RQVHUUDWH

34

&I6PLWK

*HQWLOHVLVDZRUGRI/DWLQRULJLQXVXDOO\HPSOR\HGLQWKHSOXUDOGHVLJQDWLQJSULPDULO\

LQWKH(QJOLVKYHUVLRQVRIERWK7HVWDPHQWVWKHQDWLRQVGLVWLQFWIURPWKH-HZLVKSHRSOH6LQFH

WKHVSUHDGRI&KULVWLDQLW\WKHZRUG*HQWLOHVGHVLJQDWHVLQWKHRORJLFDOSDUODQFHWKRVHZKRDUH

QHLWKHU-HZVQRU&KULVWLDQVLHWKH\GRQRWZRUVKLSWKHWUXH*RG&I*LJRWKWWS

ZZZQHZDGYHQWRUJFDWKHQDKWP!

'X-DUULF

$JQLHV]ND.XF]NLHZLF])UDĞ

$NEDUWKH*UHDW±DQG&KULVWLDQLW\%HWZHHQUHOLJLRQDQGSROLWLFV

GHDWKWROLIHHYHQDVWKHLUPDVWHU-HVXV&KULVWZKRFDPHGRZQIURPKHDYHQ

WRHDUWKUDLVHGPDQ\IURPWKHGHDGDQGJDYHWKHPQHZOLIH´

37

,QUHVSRQVHWR$NEDU¶VUHTXHVWDQGLQKRSHRIKLVSURVSHFWLYHFRQYHUVLRQ

DPLVVLRQFRQVLVWLQJRIWZR-HVXLWSULHVWV

DQGDOD\EURWKHUZDVVHQWIURP*RD

DQGUHDFKHG/ƗKDXULQ%XWYHU\VRRQLWDSSHDUHGWKDWLQIDFWWKHHPSHURU

GLGQRWLQWHQGWRDGRSW&KULVWLDQLW\,WLVKLJKO\SUREDEOHWKDWKLVGHFODUDWLRQV

VXJJHVWLQJKLVGHYRWLRQWR&KULVWLDQLW\ZHUHQHYHUWUXO\VLQFHUH+HPLJKWKDYH

YDOXHG&KULVWLDQGRJPDVDERYHWKRVHRIRWKHUUHOLJLRQV+RZHYHUKHQHYHU

GHFODUHGRSHQO\DQ\GHVLUHWREHEDSWL]HGQRUDGPLWWHGSXEOLFO\WKDWKHZDV

DIROORZHURI&KULVW7KHVHFRQGPLVVLRQIDLOHGYHU\VRRQZKLFKZDVPRVW

OLNHO\FDXVHGE\WKHVWURQJUHVLVWDQFHRIWKHLQÀXHQWLDOPHPEHUVRIWKHUR\DO

FRXUW7KHSDUWDNHUVRIWKHH[SHGLWLRQUHWXUQHGWR*RDDIWHUVHYHUDOPRQWKV

+RZHYHUGHVSLWHWKHDEVHQFHRI&KULVWLDQPLVVLRQDULHVLQWKHLPPHGLDWH

YLFLQLW\RI$NEDUKLVWROHUDQWDWWLWXGHWRZDUGV&KULVWLDQLW\±DVZHOODVWRZDUGV

RWKHUUHOLJLRQV±ZDVFRQVWDQWDQGVWURQJ$IDUPƗQGHFUHHLVVXHGLQ

JXDUDQWHHGWKHULJKWRI&KULVWLDQVWRSUHDFKDQGFDUU\RXWFRQYHUVLRQVDVZHOODV

WRHUHFWFKXUFKHVQRWRQO\LQƖJUƗDQG/ƗKDXUEXWDOVRLQ%RPED\DQG৫KD৬৬D

$NEDU¶VWKUHHJUDQGVRQV±RIIVSULQJRIKLV\RXQJHVWVRQ'ƗQL\ƗOZKRGLHGLQ

±ZHUHHYHQEDSWL]HGDOWKRXJKWKH\FRQYHUWHGEDFNWR,VODPVRRQ<HWLW

ZDVLQDOOSUREDELOLW\DSXUHO\SROLWLFDOSOR\GHVLJQHGWRHOLPLQDWHWKHVHWKUHH

JUDQGVRQVIURP¿JKWIRUVXFFHVVLRQDIWHU$NEDU¶VGHDWK

7KHWKLUGDQGODVWWLPH$NEDUUHQHZHGKLVZLVKWRLQYHVWLJDWHWKHVHFUHWV

RIIDLWKLQ&KULVWLQZKHQKHVHQWDUHTXHVWWRWKH3RUWXJXHVH9LFHUR\

LQ*RDDVNLQJKLPWRGHOHJDWHSULHVWVWRKLVFRXUW+DYLQJH[SHULHQFHGWZR

HDUOLHUXQVXFFHVVIXOPLVVLRQVWKH-HVXLWVZHUHUDWKHUUHOXFWDQWWRVHQGDQRWKHU

H[SHGLWLRQEXWWKHVHFXODUDXWKRULWLHVRIWKHFRORQ\±GH¿QLWHO\IRUSROLWLFDO

UHDVRQV±LQVLVWHGRQPHHWLQJWKHGHPDQGVRIWKH*UHDW0XJKDO7KH*HQHUDO

RIWKH2UGHULQ5RPHDOVRIDYRXUHGWKHLGHDVWURQJO\7KHJUDQGQHSKHZRI6W

)UDQFLV;DYLHUNQRZQDV-HURPH;DYLHURI1DYDUUDZDVDSSRLQWHGWRKHDG

WKHPLVVLRQ

7KLVWLPHWKH)DWKHUVZHUHOXFNLHUWKH-HVXLWPLVVLRQODVWHGDW

WKH0XJKDOFRXUWWKURXJKRXWWKHQH[WWZRFHQWXULHV1DWXUDOO\LWVFKDUDFWHU

WUDQVIRUPHGRYHUWLPHDQGWKHSURVSHULW\RIWKHPLVVLRQDOVRFKDQJHGFRQWLQXDOO\

GHSHQGLQJRQZKRVDWRQWKHLPSHULDOWKURQH)LQDOO\WKHDWWHPSWVWRFRQYHUW

WKH0XJKDOHPSHURUWR&KULVWLDQLW\ZHUHDEDQGRQHGWKHSULPDU\WDVNRIWKH

PLVVLRQDULHVZDVWRWDNHVSLULWXDOFDUHDQGWRVXSSRUWWKH&KULVWLDQVJDWKHUHG

DURXQGWKH0XJKDOFRXUW-HURPH;DYLHUZKRSRVVHVVHGIDLUO\JRRGNQRZOHGJH

RIWKH3HUVLDQODQJXDJHZDVWKHDXWKRURIVHYHUDOERRNVGHYRWHGWRYDULRXV

37

,ELG

)DWKHU(GZDUG/HLRWRQ/HLWDQXVDQG)DWKHU&KULVWRSKHUGL9HJD

7ZRRWKHUSULHVWVZHUHVHQWWRDVVLVWKLP)DWKHU(PPDQXHO3LQKHLURD3RUWXJXHVHDQG

%URWKHUFRDGMXWRU%HQHGLFWGH*RHV

DVSHFWVRI&KULVWLDQLW\7KH-HVXLWVVWXGLHGJHRJUDSK\DQGDVWURQRP\DQG

FRQGXFWHGUHVHDUFKZRUNLQWKHREVHUYDWRULHVLQ'HOKLDQG-DLSXU

2QHRIWKHSUREDEOHUHDVRQVZK\$NEDUUHTXLUHGFRQVWDQWSUHVHQFHRI

-HVXLWVDWKLVFRXUWZDVWKHLUXQH[SHFWHGLPSDFWRQWKHFXOWXUDODQGDUWLVWLF

OLIHRIWKHPLOLHXLQ'HOKLDQGƖJUƗ7KHH[LVWHQFHRIWKHPLVVLRQSURYLGHG

DVXSSO\RIERRNVRIWHQULFKO\LOOXVWUDWHGDVZHOODVRI(XURSHDQSDLQWLQJVRU

WKHLUUHSURGXFWLRQV7KH(XURSHDQVZKRDUULYHGLQWKH0XJKDO,QGLDLQWKH

¿UVWKDOIRIWKH

WK

FHQWXU\ZHUHDPD]HGWRVHHQXPHURXVH[DPSOHVRIPXUDOV

IHDWXULQJ-HVXV&KULVWWKH%OHVVHG9LUJLQDQG&DWKROLFVDLQWVRQWKHZDOOVRI

SDODFHVDQGPDXVROHXPV&KULVWLDQPRWLYHVZHUHDOVRHPSOR\HGLQPLQLDWXUH

SDLQWLQJMHZHOOHU\DQGVFXOSWXUH

,QWKHGHFOLQLQJ\HDUVRI$NEDU¶VUHLJQSROLWLFDOWHQVLRQEHWZHHQWKH3RU

WXJXHVHFRORQLDODXWKRULWLHVDQGWKH0XJKDOVZDVJURZLQJDQGWKLVVLWXDWLRQ

LQHYLWDEO\DIIHFWHGWKHSUHVHQFHRI&KULVWLDQPLVVLRQDWKLVFRXUWWRVRPHH[WHQW

$NEDUZDVDQH[FHOOHQWDQGVKUHZGSROLWLFLDQ+HWUHDWHGKLV&KULVWLDQJXHVWV

ZLWKJUHDWUHYHUHQFHDQGIRQGQHVVDVZHOODVPDLQWDLQHGIULHQGO\FRQWDFWVZLWK

WKHDXWKRULWLHVLQ*RDEXWKLVUHDOLQWHQWLRQVWRZDUGVWKH3RUWXJXHVHZHUH

QRWIULHQGO\,QYDLQGLGKHWU\WRFRQFHDOWKLVIDFWIURP)U$TXDYLYDDQG)U

0RQVHUUDWHGXULQJWKH¿UVWPLVVLRQEXWQHDUO\WZHQW\\HDUVODWHUKHGHFODUHG

KLVDWWLWXGHRSHQO\+LVIULHQGO\OHJDWLRQVVHQWDYRZHGO\ZLWKWKHLQQRFHQW

JRDOVRIDWWDLQLQJUHOLJLRXVLQVWUXFWLRQVDQGSXUFKDVLQJ(XURSHDQZDUHVKDG

EDOHIXOSROLWLFDOLQWHQWLRQVDWWKHVDPHWLPHDQGZHUHXVHGDVPHDQVRIHVSL

RQDJH2QWKHRWKHUKDQGWKH-HVXLWIDWKHUVHVSHFLDOO\WKRVHZKRFDPHZLWK

WKHWKLUGPLVVLRQDOWKRXJKGHHSO\UHOLJLRXVDQGYHU\HQWKXVLDVWLFDERXWWKHLU

PLVVLRQDU\ZRUNDQGWKHLUVHUYLFHWRWKH&KXUFKWULHGWRVHUYHWKHLQWHUHVWVRI

WKHLUKRPHODQGV8QGRXEWHGO\WKH\ZHUHSHUFHLYHGE\WKHLUVXSHULRUVDVVRPH

NLQGRI3RUWXJXHVHRU6SDQLVKDJHQWVZKRKDGWRSOD\FHUWDLQSROLWLFDOUROHV

'HVSLWHWKHFRQVWDQWIULHQGOLQHVVRIWKHHPSHURUKLPVHOIWKHPLVVLRQDULHV

H[SHULHQFHGRYHUWKRVWLOLW\DWKLVFRXUWZKLFKRQWKHRQHVLGHZDVWUDGLWLRQDOO\

H[SRVHGE\WKHFRQVHUYDWLYH0XVOLPQREOHVDQGRQWKHRWKHUKDQGIXHOOHG

E\WKHPDFKLQDWLRQVRIRWKHU(XURSHDQVZKREHJDQDUULYLQJLQLQFUHDVLQJ

QXPEHUVWRWKHUHDOPRIWKH*UHDW0XJKDO&RQVHTXHQWO\WKHXQLTXHSRVLWLRQ

ZKLFKWKH\HQMR\HGSUDFWLFDOO\KDYLQJDPRQRSRO\RQFRQWDFWVZLWK$NEDUZDV

ZHDNHQHGVRVLJQL¿FDQWO\WKDWZKHQLQ2FWREHUWKHHPSHURUZDVO\LQJRQ

KLVGHDWKEHGWKH-HVXLWVZHUHQRWDOORZHGWRDVVLVWDWKLVVLGH7KH\HDUROG

HPSHURU³GLHGDVKHKDGOLYHGIRUDVQRQHNQHZZKDWODZKHIROORZHGLQKLV

OLIHWLPHVRQRQHNQHZWKDWLQZKLFKKHGLHG´

±GX-DUULFFRPPHQWHG³6RPH

ZLVKHGWRSUD\IRUKLPLQWKH6DUDFHQPDQQHURWKHUVGLGQRWGDUHWRDQGLQWKH

HQGQHLWKHU6DUDFHQVQRU*HQWLOHVQRU&KULVWLDQVZRXOGFODLPKLPDVWKHLUV

'X-DUULF

$JQLHV]ND.XF]NLHZLF])UDĞ

$NEDUWKH*UHDW±DQG&KULVWLDQLW\%HWZHHQUHOLJLRQDQGSROLWLFV

VRWKDWKHKDGWKHSUD\HUVRIQRQH´

+LVLPSUHVVLYHPRQXPHQWDOPDXVROHXP

LQ6LNDQGUƗZKLFKKHGHVLJQHGIRUKLPVHOIZKLOHVWLOODOLYHLVWKHODVWSURRI

RIKLVV\QFUHWLFZD\RIWKLQNLQJFRPELQLQJHOHPHQWVRIDOOWKUHHDUFKLWHFWXUDO

VW\OHV0XVOLP+LQGXDQG&KULVWLDQ

%LEOLRJUDSK\

ƖµƯQL$NEDUƯ

$Enj¶O)D਌Oµ$OOƗPƯ7KHƖ¶ƯQL$NEDUƯYRO,WUDQVOE\+%ORFKPDQQ

HG'&3KLOORWWYRO,,,,,WUDQVOE\+6-DUUHW&DOFXWWD$VLDWLF

6RFLHW\±UHSU

$NEDUQƗPD

7KH$NEDUQƗPDRI$EXO)DܲOYRO,,,,WUDQVOIURPWKH3HUVLDQE\

+%HYHULGJH&DOFXWWD$VLDWLF6RFLHW\

&KDQGUD

6DWLVK&KDQGUD0HGLHYDO,QGLDIURP6XOWDQDWWRWKH0XJKDOV9RO

1HZ'HOKL+DU$QDQG3XEOLFDWLRQV

&RUUHLD$IRQVR /HWWHUVIURPWKH0XJKDO&RXUWWKH¿UVW-HVXLWPLVVLRQWR$NEDU

±HGLWHGZLWKDQLQWURGXFWLRQRI-RKQ&RUUHLD$IRQVR

6WXGLHVLQ,QGLDQ+LVWRU\DQG&XOWXUHRIWKH+HUDV,QVWLWXWHYRO

$QDQG*XMDUDW6DKLW\D3UDNDVK

'X-DUULF

3LHUUH'X-DUULF$NEDUDQGWKH-HVXLWVDQDFFRXQWRIWKH-HVXLW

PLVVLRQVWRWKHFRXUWRI$NEDUWUDQVODWHGZLWKLQWURGXFWLRQDQGQRWHV

E\&+3D\QH/RQGRQ*HRUJH5RXWOHGJH6RQVUHSU

/RQGRQ5RXWOHGJH

)HUQDQGR*LVSHUW6DXFK

/HRQDUG)HUQDQGR**LVSHUW6DXFK&KULVWLDQLW\LQ,QGLD7ZR

7KRXVDQG<HDUVRI)DLWK1HZ'HOKL9LNLQJ

)U\NHQEHUJ

5REHUW(ULF)U\NHQEHUJ&KULVWLDQVDQG0LVVLRQDULHVLQ,QGLD

&URVVFXOWXUDO&RPPXQLFDWLRQVLQFH/RQGRQ5RXWOHGJH&XU]RQ

)U\NHQEHUJ

5REHUW(ULF)U\NHQEHUJ&KULVWLDQLW\LQ,QGLD)URP%HJLQQLQJVWR

WKH3UHVHQW2[IRUG1HZ<RUN2[IRUG8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV

*LJRW

*LJRW)UDQFLV*HQWLOHV>LQ@7KH&DWKROLF(QF\FORSDHGLD9RO

1HZ<RUN5REHUW$SSOHWRQ&RPSDQ\UHWULHYHG-XO\

KWWSZZZQHZDGYHQWRUJFDWKHQDKWP!

+DYHO

(UQHVW%LQ¿HOG+DYHOO$+DQGERRNWR$JUDDQGWKH7DM6LNDQGUD

)DWHKSXU6LNULDQGWKH1HLJKERXUKRRG/RQGRQ/RQJPDQV*UHHQDQG

&RKWWSZZZFROXPELDHGXLWFPHDODFSULWFKHWWDUWOLQNV

DJUDBKDYHOOIDWDKSXUVLNULKWPO!

-DFNVRQ

3DXO-DFNVRQµ-HVXLWVDWWKH0RJKXO&RXUW¶9LG\DM\RWL9RO

'HOKLSS±

,ELG

0DFODJDQ

6LU(GZDUG0DFODJDQ7KH-HVXLWVDQGWKH*UHDW0RJXO/RQGRQ

%XUQV2DWHV:DVKERXUQH

0RQVHUUDWH

7KHFRPPHQWDU\RI)DWKHU0RQVHUUDWH6-RQKLVMRXUQH\WRWKH

&RXUWRI$NEDU WUDQVODWHGIURPWKHRULJLQDO/DWLQE\-6+R\ODQG

DQGDQQRWDWHGE\61%DQHUMHH/RQGRQ+XPSKUH\0LOIRUG

0XQWD[DEDOWDYƗUƯ[ µ$EGX¶O4ƗGLU,EQL0XOnjN6KƗKNQRZQDV$O%DGƗRQL0XQWDNKDEX

WWDZƗUƯNKWUDQVODWHGIURPWKHRULJLQDO3HUVLDQDQGHGLWHGE\*HRUJH

6$5DQNLQJYRO,:+/RZHYRO,,DQG6LU:ROVHOH\+DLJ

YRO,,,&DOFXWWD$VLDWLF6RFLHW\RI%HQJDO±

1HLOO

6WHSKHQ1HLOO$KLVWRU\RI&KULVWLDQLW\LQ,QGLDWKHEHJLQQLQJVWR

$'&DPEULGJH&DPEULGJH8QLYHUVLW\3UHVV

1L]DPL

.KDOLT$KPDG1L]DPL$NEDUUHOLJLRQ'HOKL,GDUDKL$GDEL

\DWL'HOOL

3LUEKDL

05H]D3LUEKDL5HFRQVLGHULQJ,VODPLQD6RXWK$VLDQ&RQWH[W

6RFLDO6FLHQFHVLQ$VLD9RO/HLGHQ%RVWRQ%ULOO

5L]YL

6DL\LG$WKDU$EEDV5L]YL,

5HOLJLRXVDQGLQWHOOHFWXDOKLVWRU\RI

WKH0XVOLPVLQ$NEDU¶VUHLJQZLWKVSHFLDOUHIHUHQFHWR$EX¶O)D]O

±1HZ'HOKL0XQVKLUDP0DQRKDUODO

6FKLPPHO

$QQHPDULH6FKLPPHO7KHHPSLUHRIWKHJUHDW0XJKDOVKLVWRU\

DUWDQGFXOWXUHWUDQVODWHGE\&RULQQH$WZRRGHGLWHGE\%XU]LQH

.:DJKPDU/RQGRQ5HDNWLRQ

6PLWK

9LQFHQW$UWKXU6PLWK$NEDUWKH*UHDW0RJKXO±2[IRUG

&ODUHQGRQ3UHVV

ܑDEDTƗWL$NEDUƯ

1L]ƗPDO'ƯQ$KPDG7KHܒDEDTƗWL$NEDUƯDKLVWRU\RI,QGLDIURP

WKHHDUO\0XVDOPƗQLQYDVLRQVWRWKHWKLUW\HLJKW\HDURIWKHUHLJQ

RI$NEDUWUDQVODQGDQQRWDWHGE\%UDMHQGUDQDWK'HUHYDQGHGE\

%DLQL3UDVKDG&DOFXWWD5R\DO$VLDWLF6RFRI%HQJDO

7UROO

&KULVWLDQ:7UROO,VODPLQ,QGLD6WXGLHVDQG&RPPHQWDULHV9RO,

7KH$NEDU0LVVLRQDQG0LVFHOODQHRXV6WXGLHV1HZ'HOKL