© 2008 Turkish Forum —
About Us
—
Contact Us
—
Our Projects
—
Dues & Donations
—
Turkce
> Minority Nationalism in Belgium and Spain
Minority Nationalism in Belgium and Spain
Globalization and free market economy
m o v e m e n t s h a v e s t r o n g l y a f f e c t e d o n t h e r i s e o f
minority nations ’ voice. Although European Union does
not have any direct implementation on providing special
rights and conditions for minority nations, reality of
rising rights of minority nations and regions cannot be
covered. While Catalonia, Flemish, Wales within the EU
and Qu ébec in NAFTA are getting stronger and minority
national regions which are gaining rights on the way of
becoming international actor. Each of them shows some
differences from the one another in various areas like social and security rights, education, economic welfare, right
to vote and elected. “Furthermore, as compared to Canada and the United Kingdom, Belgium presents a unique
situation, in part because Flanders, the region where the sub state nationalism is strong, is the country ’s richest
and most populated area. ”
Religion and linguistic differences of minority nations within a state trigs the demands on the right asked
from the government and even independence. Because of the supports of organizations such as EU and NAFTA,
minority nations in their member states become stronger in terms of linguistic, economic, and social areas in the
state that they exist. The conditions in demanding on independence show slight differences especially among the
members of EU.
This article concentrates on two minority nations in EU which are Flemish and Catalans. By analyzing these two
minority nations, article provides the reasons behind not only gained rights but also rights that they still demand.
Education in their own language plays such an important role for minorities within a state. When we turn our face
to Flemish and Catalans weare able to see that gaining educational rights in their own language was holding the
importance on way to showing their existence.
Flemish Case in Belgium
Flanders, as a minority nation in Belgium, have been gained rights since industrial revolution which means
in constant to general view as Belgium Federate State have been established in 1993, it is not correct. Decline
of heavy industry, during 1950s, Flemish realized that they are richer than Walloons in terms of underground
resources and do not would like to allow them to use Flemish ’s underground resources anymore. In order to
protect their own rights they had asked special rights for them. Although there is a constitutional rights have been
given in 1993, since twenty years processes have been started on way of federalism. Process started by
institutional reforms in 1970, so we can claim that Flemish were on the way of federalism more than twenty years
before the official announcement in 1993. According to CAPRON H. and MEEUSEN W., with four consecutive state
reforms, Belgium transforms to a federal state. These state reforms held in 1970 71, 1980 81, 1988 89, 1993 94,
and 2001.
A s a l l m i n o r i t y n a t i o n s ’ common problem, Flemish made an effort to have linguistic and cultural
equalities. They had a fear of grind under French speaking autonomy during the unitary system. According to
STEPHENSON G.V., protection of the surrounding Flemish towns against loss of their cultural identity is vitally
important. The reason behind the all tensions raised by minority nations in states as it happened in Belgium
(Flemish), Spain (Catalonia and Bask region), and UK (Wales and Scotland) is participate in government and
announce their presence as in part of that state.
In Belgium, Flemish was achieving certain rights such as cultural, educational and social areas since 1970.
“Besides the two ministers of culture mentioned earlier, there are two departments of education
and two radio television systems (BRTFlemish and RTBFrench).” Flemish was able to impress them more
independently. KALAYCI H. claims that Flemish ’ movements that having cultural demands in the first stage turned
into political soon. Identity issue grow up from the Flemish in Belgium and comparably French speaking population
called themselves as Walloon, just after the Flanders movements. So, by these inter regional transfers Walloons
and Flemish were became power sharing groups under the umbrella of unitary Belgium.
Globalization and increase the economic developments highly effected the role and position of minority nations
especially in European Union. “Belgium, following the adoption of a new federal constitution in 1995,
allowed its regions of Flanders and Wallonia to sign treaties and other agreements with sovereign
states and have an international role that equals and sometime surpasses that of the Belgian
State itself. ”Flanders took a chance to enjoyed benefits and opportunities provided by industrial movements and
globalization. New federal constitution in 1995 brings the opportunity to Flemish to right to have an education in
their own language.
Belgium have been tried to minimize the tensions by providing some equalities to both Flemish and
Walloons. Minorities who have gained equal rights in Belgium were not going to demand independence anymore
which means that Belgium have been played all cards that it has in order to hold state as it is.
Asymmetric Federalism in Spain Instead of Separation
Catalans shows slight differences from among the seventeen regions in Spain, because they have linguistic
and wealth differences from the others. By 1978 constitution, after Franco ’s dictatorship, Catalans demanded some
extra rights from Madrid because they accepted themselves as a different nation from the others in Spain.
Spanish Parliament has been provided not only linguistic rights but also opportunity of impressing themselves to
Catalans by media.
Spanish constitution avoided using the term “federal state ” to protect the tensions of possible separation in Spain.
“The Spanish constitution establishes ‘the indissoluble unity of Spanish Nation ’ (article 2) and
defines the ‘Spanish People ’ as subject of ‘National Sovereignty ’ (article 1). ” As it is clearly mentioned
in the Spanish constitution, Spanish parliament resist on division by independence. Instead of losing part of its own
territory, parliament accepted to give Catalans some more rights than the other by taking into consideration of
their historically differences in terms of wealth and also language. The solution that Spanish Parliament has been
found is providing the rights that Catalans demands and form Spanish state by eliminating the differences among
regions.
C a t a l a n s ’ ultimate aim is achieving a sit within a European Parliament. Although they have a right to
attend some kind of issues related by their own policy areas, they reject the limitation and ask for actual sit like
an actual state. “Spanish autonomous communities ’ participation in EU decision making process is limited to
series of policy specific Sectoral Conferences as well as the Conferencia para Asuntos Relacionados con la
Comunidad Europea (CARCE) (Sectoral Conference Relating to EU Affairs), chaired by the Minister of Public
Administration. ” Catalans may participate in EU Parliament only their own policy related issues are going to be
discussed on the agenda.
Conclusion
Catalans and Flemish proved how minority nationalism plays such an important role within Europe and as a
result of their attempt they have achieved their aims. Having even a limited sit within the EU Parliament have
extreme important for awareness of their existence and the specialty of Catalan ’s condition among the others.
On the other hand, Flemish, have been achieved their rights that exist today by five state reforms. Even
today, there are still some disagreements between Walloons and Flemish. Because of disagreements, they had very
problematic election in 2007.
Briefly, the article have analyzed why minority nations and regions demands for some certain rights.
Article support the strategy of providing rights to minority nations and regions in order to protection of separation
of state. As long as given rights do not treat sovereignty and welfare of state, each and every minority have a
right to take education in their own language, conditions for continuity of their own history of culture and also
participate to parliament.
REFERANCES
1. BELAND D., LECOURS A. , 2008 , “Nationalism and Social Policy ”, Oxford University Press, US
2. BOURNE A.K. , 2004, “The EU and territorial politics within member states: conflict or co operation?”, BRILL
3. CAPRON H., MEEUSEN W. , 2000, “The National Innovation System of Belgium ”, Published by Springer,
Belgium
4. GAGNON A., TULLY J. , 2001, “Multinational Democracies”, Cambridge University Press, USA
5. JAMES P., MICHAUD N., O ’REILLY M.J., “Handbook of Canadian Foreign Policy ”, Lexington Books, Canada,
2006
6. KALAYCI H., “Üniter Devletten Federasyon ’ a Bel çika’da ne de ğişti?”, Stratejik Analiz Dergisi, Ocak 2006
7. KALAYCI K., “Avrupa Birliği ve Mikro Milliyet çilik” , Stratejik Analiz Dergisi, May s 2006
8. STEPHENSON G. V., “Cultural Regionalism and the Unitary State Idea in Belgium ”, Geographical Review, Vol.
62, No. 4 (Oct., 1972), American Geographical Society
Behre Ünverdi – Caspian Weekly
Eastern Mediterranean University
Department of International Relations
http://www.caspianweekly.org/index.php/component/content/article/54comperative politics/1001
whydoyouthinkminoritynationalismhasbecome more important inrecent years examine two
countries.html
No related posts, here are some random posts for you
l
March 5, 2009
Why the CIA has to spy on Britain
l
September 4, 2008
“Turkey ’s current steps remind of Iran ’s actions in 1992, which rescued
Armenia ”
l
November 1, 2009
‘Turkey ’s Kissinger ’ Leads Foreign Policy Balancing Act
l
May 23, 2009
Please, Iran, Release My Cousin Now, Too By Klara Moradkhan
l
September 6, 2008
ANCA OUTLINES CONCERNS ABOUT GUL VISIT TO ARMENIA
l
August 10, 2009
U.S. Hopes For Sarkisian Visit To Turkey
l
March 2, 2009
A FRIEND IN AMERICAN CONGRESS
l
June 14, 2009
PROVOCATION AGAINST TURKEY
l
April 22, 2009
Special Sufism Lecture
l
September 5, 2009
Ruling Party Against Referendum On Turkey
SEND TO MY FRIEND |
WRITE YOUR COMMENTS |
PRINT THIS PAGE |
BOOKMARK THIS PAGE!
This article is written on Tuesday, 02 June 2009, 22:32 under
Belgium
,
EU Members
,
Europe
,
Main Issues
,
Racism
,
Regions
,
Spain
,
The European Parliament
,
UN
category. To receive the comments to this post please use
RSS 2.0
.
You
can comment on this post
, o r g i v e a
ping
back from your web site.
no comments yet
NAME
EMAIL (WILL NOT BE PUBLISHED)
SITE
Please write your comment
LAST CAPITAL OF OTTOMAN EMPIRE
LOWERCASE LETTERS
Gönder
TAGS
RECENT COMMENTS
LAND, CLAIMS TURKISH JOURNALIST
HARVARD UNIVERSITY UNDERMINES ITS
OWN PRESTIGE “IN SERVICE” OF GENOCIDAL
LAND, CLAIMS TURKISH JOURNALIST
LAND, CLAIMS TURKISH JOURNALIST
INTERNAL DOCUMENTS REVEAL.. BY
on
TAKE ME BACK TO CONSTANTINOPLE
Robert on
A CALL TO MOBILIZE THE DIASPORA,
INTERNAL DOCUMENTS REVEAL.. BY
Search
© 2007 2008
Turkish Forum
|
Turkipedia
|
Learn Turkish
|
Forums
© 2008 Turkish Forum —
About Us
—
Contact Us
—
Our Projects
—
Dues & Donations
—
Turkce
HOME PAGE
>
BELGIUM
,
EU MEMBERS
,
EUROPE
,
MAIN ISSUES
,
RACISM
,
REGIONS
,
SPAIN
,
THE EUROPEAN
PARLIAMENT
,
UN
> Minority Nationalism in Belgium and Spain
SEND TO MY FRIEND |
WRITE YOUR COMMENTS |
PRINT THIS PAGE |
BOOKMARK THIS PAGE!
Minority Nationalism in Belgium and Spain
Globalization and free market economy
m o v e m e n t s h a v e s t r o n g l y a f f e c t e d o n t h e r i s e o f
minority nations ’ voice. Although European Union does
not have any direct implementation on providing special
rights and conditions for minority nations, reality of
rising rights of minority nations and regions cannot be
covered. While Catalonia, Flemish, Wales within the EU
and Qu ébec in NAFTA are getting stronger and minority
national regions which are gaining rights on the way of
becoming international actor. Each of them shows some
differences from the one another in various areas like social and security rights, education, economic welfare, right
to vote and elected. “Furthermore, as compared to Canada and the United Kingdom, Belgium presents a unique
situation, in part because Flanders, the region where the sub state nationalism is strong, is the country ’s richest
and most populated area. ”
Religion and linguistic differences of minority nations within a state trigs the demands on the right asked
from the government and even independence. Because of the supports of organizations such as EU and NAFTA,
minority nations in their member states become stronger in terms of linguistic, economic, and social areas in the
state that they exist. The conditions in demanding on independence show slight differences especially among the
members of EU.
This article concentrates on two minority nations in EU which are Flemish and Catalans. By analyzing these two
minority nations, article provides the reasons behind not only gained rights but also rights that they still demand.
Education in their own language plays such an important role for minorities within a state. When we turn our face
to Flemish and Catalans weare able to see that gaining educational rights in their own language was holding the
importance on way to showing their existence.
Flemish Case in Belgium
Flanders, as a minority nation in Belgium, have been gained rights since industrial revolution which means
in constant to general view as Belgium Federate State have been established in 1993, it is not correct. Decline
of heavy industry, during 1950s, Flemish realized that they are richer than Walloons in terms of underground
resources and do not would like to allow them to use Flemish ’s underground resources anymore. In order to
protect their own rights they had asked special rights for them. Although there is a constitutional rights have been
given in 1993, since twenty years processes have been started on way of federalism. Process started by
institutional reforms in 1970, so we can claim that Flemish were on the way of federalism more than twenty years
before the official announcement in 1993. According to CAPRON H. and MEEUSEN W., with four consecutive state
reforms, Belgium transforms to a federal state. These state reforms held in 1970 71, 1980 81, 1988 89, 1993 94,
and 2001.
A s a l l m i n o r i t y n a t i o n s ’ common problem, Flemish made an effort to have linguistic and cultural
equalities. They had a fear of grind under French speaking autonomy during the unitary system. According to
STEPHENSON G.V., protection of the surrounding Flemish towns against loss of their cultural identity is vitally
important. The reason behind the all tensions raised by minority nations in states as it happened in Belgium
(Flemish), Spain (Catalonia and Bask region), and UK (Wales and Scotland) is participate in government and
announce their presence as in part of that state.
In Belgium, Flemish was achieving certain rights such as cultural, educational and social areas since 1970.
“Besides the two ministers of culture mentioned earlier, there are two departments of education
and two radio television systems (BRTFlemish and RTBFrench).” Flemish was able to impress them more
independently. KALAYCI H. claims that Flemish ’ movements that having cultural demands in the first stage turned
into political soon. Identity issue grow up from the Flemish in Belgium and comparably French speaking population
called themselves as Walloon, just after the Flanders movements. So, by these inter regional transfers Walloons
and Flemish were became power sharing groups under the umbrella of unitary Belgium.
Globalization and increase the economic developments highly effected the role and position of minority nations
especially in European Union. “Belgium, following the adoption of a new federal constitution in 1995,
allowed its regions of Flanders and Wallonia to sign treaties and other agreements with sovereign
states and have an international role that equals and sometime surpasses that of the Belgian
State itself. ”Flanders took a chance to enjoyed benefits and opportunities provided by industrial movements and
globalization. New federal constitution in 1995 brings the opportunity to Flemish to right to have an education in
their own language.
Belgium have been tried to minimize the tensions by providing some equalities to both Flemish and
Walloons. Minorities who have gained equal rights in Belgium were not going to demand independence anymore
which means that Belgium have been played all cards that it has in order to hold state as it is.
Asymmetric Federalism in Spain Instead of Separation
Catalans shows slight differences from among the seventeen regions in Spain, because they have linguistic
and wealth differences from the others. By 1978 constitution, after Franco ’s dictatorship, Catalans demanded some
extra rights from Madrid because they accepted themselves as a different nation from the others in Spain.
Spanish Parliament has been provided not only linguistic rights but also opportunity of impressing themselves to
Catalans by media.
Spanish constitution avoided using the term “federal state ” to protect the tensions of possible separation in Spain.
“The Spanish constitution establishes ‘the indissoluble unity of Spanish Nation ’ (article 2) and
defines the ‘Spanish People ’ as subject of ‘National Sovereignty ’ (article 1). ” As it is clearly mentioned
in the Spanish constitution, Spanish parliament resist on division by independence. Instead of losing part of its own
territory, parliament accepted to give Catalans some more rights than the other by taking into consideration of
their historically differences in terms of wealth and also language. The solution that Spanish Parliament has been
found is providing the rights that Catalans demands and form Spanish state by eliminating the differences among
regions.
C a t a l a n s ’ ultimate aim is achieving a sit within a European Parliament. Although they have a right to
attend some kind of issues related by their own policy areas, they reject the limitation and ask for actual sit like
an actual state. “Spanish autonomous communities ’ participation in EU decision making process is limited to
series of policy specific Sectoral Conferences as well as the Conferencia para Asuntos Relacionados con la
Comunidad Europea (CARCE) (Sectoral Conference Relating to EU Affairs), chaired by the Minister of Public
Administration. ” Catalans may participate in EU Parliament only their own policy related issues are going to be
discussed on the agenda.
Conclusion
Catalans and Flemish proved how minority nationalism plays such an important role within Europe and as a
result of their attempt they have achieved their aims. Having even a limited sit within the EU Parliament have
extreme important for awareness of their existence and the specialty of Catalan ’s condition among the others.
On the other hand, Flemish, have been achieved their rights that exist today by five state reforms. Even
today, there are still some disagreements between Walloons and Flemish. Because of disagreements, they had very
problematic election in 2007.
Briefly, the article have analyzed why minority nations and regions demands for some certain rights.
Article support the strategy of providing rights to minority nations and regions in order to protection of separation
of state. As long as given rights do not treat sovereignty and welfare of state, each and every minority have a
right to take education in their own language, conditions for continuity of their own history of culture and also
participate to parliament.
REFERANCES
1. BELAND D., LECOURS A. , 2008 , “Nationalism and Social Policy ”, Oxford University Press, US
2. BOURNE A.K. , 2004, “The EU and territorial politics within member states: conflict or co operation?”, BRILL
3. CAPRON H., MEEUSEN W. , 2000, “The National Innovation System of Belgium ”, Published by Springer,
Belgium
4. GAGNON A., TULLY J. , 2001, “Multinational Democracies”, Cambridge University Press, USA
5. JAMES P., MICHAUD N., O ’REILLY M.J., “Handbook of Canadian Foreign Policy ”, Lexington Books, Canada,
2006
6. KALAYCI H., “Üniter Devletten Federasyon ’ a Bel çika’da ne de ğişti?”, Stratejik Analiz Dergisi, Ocak 2006
7. KALAYCI K., “Avrupa Birliği ve Mikro Milliyet çilik” , Stratejik Analiz Dergisi, May s 2006
8. STEPHENSON G. V., “Cultural Regionalism and the Unitary State Idea in Belgium ”, Geographical Review, Vol.
62, No. 4 (Oct., 1972), American Geographical Society
Behre Ünverdi – Caspian Weekly
Eastern Mediterranean University
Department of International Relations
http://www.caspianweekly.org/index.php/component/content/article/54comperative politics/1001
whydoyouthinkminoritynationalismhasbecome more important inrecent years examine two
countries.html
No related posts, here are some random posts for you
l
March 5, 2009
Why the CIA has to spy on Britain
l
September 4, 2008
“Turkey ’s current steps remind of Iran ’s actions in 1992, which rescued
Armenia ”
l
November 1, 2009
‘Turkey ’s Kissinger ’ Leads Foreign Policy Balancing Act
l
May 23, 2009
Please, Iran, Release My Cousin Now, Too By Klara Moradkhan
l
September 6, 2008
ANCA OUTLINES CONCERNS ABOUT GUL VISIT TO ARMENIA
l
August 10, 2009
U.S. Hopes For Sarkisian Visit To Turkey
l
March 2, 2009
A FRIEND IN AMERICAN CONGRESS
l
June 14, 2009
PROVOCATION AGAINST TURKEY
l
April 22, 2009
Special Sufism Lecture
l
September 5, 2009
Ruling Party Against Referendum On Turkey
SEND TO MY FRIEND |
WRITE YOUR COMMENTS |
PRINT THIS PAGE |
BOOKMARK THIS PAGE!
This article is written on Tuesday, 02 June 2009, 22:32 under
Belgium
,
EU Members
,
Europe
,
Main Issues
,
Racism
,
Regions
,
Spain
,
The European Parliament
,
UN
category. To receive the comments to this post please use
RSS 2.0
.
You
can comment on this post
, o r g i v e a
ping
back from your web site.
no comments yet
NAME
EMAIL (WILL NOT BE PUBLISHED)
SITE
Please write your comment
LAST CAPITAL OF OTTOMAN EMPIRE
LOWERCASE LETTERS
Gönder
TAGS
Ahmet Davutoglu
Armenia
BBC
BNP
Brzezinski
CIA
Crimea
Davos
DEBKA
East Turkestan
East
Turkistan
Economic Crisis
Energy
Erdogan
Ergenekon
ethocide
Gaza
genocide
Global Economy
Gulen
HUMAN RIGHTS
IMF
Iran
Istanbul
jda
Karabakh
Nabucco
Nagorno
Karabakh
norman israel
obama
POLITICS
Racism
Tataristan
Tatars
tereset
Terrorism
Turkey
Turkey and Armenia
TURKMEN
Uighur
Uighurs
UK
Uyghur
Water
Zionism
RECENT COMMENTS
robert's dsm on
NAGORNO KARABAKH IS ARMENIAN
LAND, CLAIMS TURKISH JOURNALIST
Hally on
HARVARD UNIVERSITY UNDERMINES ITS
OWN PRESTIGE “IN SERVICE” OF GENOCIDAL
TURKEY
Robert on
NAGORNO KARABAKH IS ARMENIAN
LAND, CLAIMS TURKISH JOURNALIST
Anonymous on
FETULLAH GULEN’S SCHOOLS ARE
ALL OVER THE US
OSMAN
on
NAGORNO KARABAKH IS ARMENIAN
LAND, CLAIMS TURKISH JOURNALIST
Sona on
INTERNAL DOCUMENTS REVEAL.. BY
HARUT SASSOUNIAN
HALUK
on
TAKE ME BACK TO CONSTANTINOPLE
Robert on
A CALL TO MOBILIZE THE DIASPORA,
Robert on
AZNAVOUR DEMANDS WESTERN
ARMENIAN LANDS
Robert on
INTERNAL DOCUMENTS REVEAL.. BY
HARUT SASSOUNIAN
Search
© 2007 2008
Turkish Forum
|
Turkipedia
|
Learn Turkish
|
Forums
HomePage
Authors
Main Issues
News
Regions
Dues & Donations
Subscribe
DE
TR
© 2008 Turkish Forum —
—
—
—
HOME PAGE
>
BELGIUM
,
EU MEMBERS
,
EUROPE
,
MAIN ISSUES
,
RACISM
,
REGIONS
,
SPAIN
,
THE EUROPEAN
PARLIAMENT
,
UN
> Minority Nationalism in Belgium and Spain
SEND TO MY FRIEND |
WRITE YOUR COMMENTS |
PRINT THIS PAGE |
BOOKMARK THIS PAGE!
Minority Nationalism in Belgium and Spain
Globalization and free market economy
m o v e m e n t s h a v e s t r o n g l y a f f e c t e d o n t h e r i s e o f
minority nations ’ voice. Although European Union does
not have any direct implementation on providing special
rights and conditions for minority nations, reality of
rising rights of minority nations and regions cannot be
covered. While Catalonia, Flemish, Wales within the EU
and Qu ébec in NAFTA are getting stronger and minority
national regions which are gaining rights on the way of
becoming international actor. Each of them shows some
differences from the one another in various areas like social and security rights, education, economic welfare, right
to vote and elected. “Furthermore, as compared to Canada and the United Kingdom, Belgium presents a unique
situation, in part because Flanders, the region where the sub state nationalism is strong, is the country ’s richest
and most populated area. ”
Religion and linguistic differences of minority nations within a state trigs the demands on the right asked
from the government and even independence. Because of the supports of organizations such as EU and NAFTA,
minority nations in their member states become stronger in terms of linguistic, economic, and social areas in the
state that they exist. The conditions in demanding on independence show slight differences especially among the
members of EU.
This article concentrates on two minority nations in EU which are Flemish and Catalans. By analyzing these two
minority nations, article provides the reasons behind not only gained rights but also rights that they still demand.
Education in their own language plays such an important role for minorities within a state. When we turn our face
to Flemish and Catalans weare able to see that gaining educational rights in their own language was holding the
importance on way to showing their existence.
Flemish Case in Belgium
Flanders, as a minority nation in Belgium, have been gained rights since industrial revolution which means
in constant to general view as Belgium Federate State have been established in 1993, it is not correct. Decline
of heavy industry, during 1950s, Flemish realized that they are richer than Walloons in terms of underground
resources and do not would like to allow them to use Flemish ’s underground resources anymore. In order to
protect their own rights they had asked special rights for them. Although there is a constitutional rights have been
given in 1993, since twenty years processes have been started on way of federalism. Process started by
institutional reforms in 1970, so we can claim that Flemish were on the way of federalism more than twenty years
before the official announcement in 1993. According to CAPRON H. and MEEUSEN W., with four consecutive state
reforms, Belgium transforms to a federal state. These state reforms held in 1970 71, 1980 81, 1988 89, 1993 94,
and 2001.
A s a l l m i n o r i t y n a t i o n s ’ common problem, Flemish made an effort to have linguistic and cultural
equalities. They had a fear of grind under French speaking autonomy during the unitary system. According to
STEPHENSON G.V., protection of the surrounding Flemish towns against loss of their cultural identity is vitally
important. The reason behind the all tensions raised by minority nations in states as it happened in Belgium
(Flemish), Spain (Catalonia and Bask region), and UK (Wales and Scotland) is participate in government and
announce their presence as in part of that state.
In Belgium, Flemish was achieving certain rights such as cultural, educational and social areas since 1970.
“Besides the two ministers of culture mentioned earlier, there are two departments of education
and two radio television systems (BRTFlemish and RTBFrench).” Flemish was able to impress them more
independently. KALAYCI H. claims that Flemish ’ movements that having cultural demands in the first stage turned
into political soon. Identity issue grow up from the Flemish in Belgium and comparably French speaking population
called themselves as Walloon, just after the Flanders movements. So, by these inter regional transfers Walloons
and Flemish were became power sharing groups under the umbrella of unitary Belgium.
Globalization and increase the economic developments highly effected the role and position of minority nations
especially in European Union. “Belgium, following the adoption of a new federal constitution in 1995,
allowed its regions of Flanders and Wallonia to sign treaties and other agreements with sovereign
states and have an international role that equals and sometime surpasses that of the Belgian
State itself. ”Flanders took a chance to enjoyed benefits and opportunities provided by industrial movements and
globalization. New federal constitution in 1995 brings the opportunity to Flemish to right to have an education in
their own language.
Belgium have been tried to minimize the tensions by providing some equalities to both Flemish and
Walloons. Minorities who have gained equal rights in Belgium were not going to demand independence anymore
which means that Belgium have been played all cards that it has in order to hold state as it is.
Asymmetric Federalism in Spain Instead of Separation
Catalans shows slight differences from among the seventeen regions in Spain, because they have linguistic
and wealth differences from the others. By 1978 constitution, after Franco ’s dictatorship, Catalans demanded some
extra rights from Madrid because they accepted themselves as a different nation from the others in Spain.
Spanish Parliament has been provided not only linguistic rights but also opportunity of impressing themselves to
Catalans by media.
Spanish constitution avoided using the term “federal state ” to protect the tensions of possible separation in Spain.
“The Spanish constitution establishes ‘the indissoluble unity of Spanish Nation ’ (article 2) and
defines the ‘Spanish People ’ as subject of ‘National Sovereignty ’ (article 1). ” As it is clearly mentioned
in the Spanish constitution, Spanish parliament resist on division by independence. Instead of losing part of its own
territory, parliament accepted to give Catalans some more rights than the other by taking into consideration of
their historically differences in terms of wealth and also language. The solution that Spanish Parliament has been
found is providing the rights that Catalans demands and form Spanish state by eliminating the differences among
regions.
C a t a l a n s ’ ultimate aim is achieving a sit within a European Parliament. Although they have a right to
attend some kind of issues related by their own policy areas, they reject the limitation and ask for actual sit like
an actual state. “Spanish autonomous communities ’ participation in EU decision making process is limited to
series of policy specific Sectoral Conferences as well as the Conferencia para Asuntos Relacionados con la
Comunidad Europea (CARCE) (Sectoral Conference Relating to EU Affairs), chaired by the Minister of Public
Administration. ” Catalans may participate in EU Parliament only their own policy related issues are going to be
discussed on the agenda.
Conclusion
Catalans and Flemish proved how minority nationalism plays such an important role within Europe and as a
result of their attempt they have achieved their aims. Having even a limited sit within the EU Parliament have
extreme important for awareness of their existence and the specialty of Catalan ’s condition among the others.
On the other hand, Flemish, have been achieved their rights that exist today by five state reforms. Even
today, there are still some disagreements between Walloons and Flemish. Because of disagreements, they had very
problematic election in 2007.
Briefly, the article have analyzed why minority nations and regions demands for some certain rights.
Article support the strategy of providing rights to minority nations and regions in order to protection of separation
of state. As long as given rights do not treat sovereignty and welfare of state, each and every minority have a
right to take education in their own language, conditions for continuity of their own history of culture and also
participate to parliament.
REFERANCES
1. BELAND D., LECOURS A. , 2008 , “Nationalism and Social Policy ”, Oxford University Press, US
2. BOURNE A.K. , 2004, “The EU and territorial politics within member states: conflict or co operation?”, BRILL
3. CAPRON H., MEEUSEN W. , 2000, “The National Innovation System of Belgium ”, Published by Springer,
Belgium
4. GAGNON A., TULLY J. , 2001, “Multinational Democracies”, Cambridge University Press, USA
5. JAMES P., MICHAUD N., O ’REILLY M.J., “Handbook of Canadian Foreign Policy ”, Lexington Books, Canada,
2006
6. KALAYCI H., “Üniter Devletten Federasyon ’ a Bel çika’da ne de ğişti?”, Stratejik Analiz Dergisi, Ocak 2006
7. KALAYCI K., “Avrupa Birliği ve Mikro Milliyet çilik” , Stratejik Analiz Dergisi, May s 2006
8. STEPHENSON G. V., “Cultural Regionalism and the Unitary State Idea in Belgium ”, Geographical Review, Vol.
62, No. 4 (Oct., 1972), American Geographical Society
Behre Ünverdi – Caspian Weekly
Eastern Mediterranean University
Department of International Relations
No related posts, here are some random posts for you
l
March 5, 2009
Why the CIA has to spy on Britain
l
“Turkey ’s current steps remind of Iran ’s actions in 1992, which rescued
l
November 1, 2009
‘Turkey ’s Kissinger ’ Leads Foreign Policy Balancing Act
l
May 23, 2009
Please, Iran, Release My Cousin Now, Too By Klara Moradkhan
l
September 6, 2008
ANCA OUTLINES CONCERNS ABOUT GUL VISIT TO ARMENIA
l
August 10, 2009
U.S. Hopes For Sarkisian Visit To Turkey
l
March 2, 2009
l
June 14, 2009
l
April 22, 2009
l
September 5, 2009
Ruling Party Against Referendum On Turkey
This article is written on Tuesday, 02 June 2009, 22:32 under
,
,
,
,
category. To receive the comments to this post please use
no comments yet
NAME
EMAIL (WILL NOT BE PUBLISHED)
SITE
Please write your comment
LAST CAPITAL OF OTTOMAN EMPIRE
LOWERCASE LETTERS
Gönder
TAGS
Ahmet Davutoglu
Armenia
BBC
BNP
Brzezinski
CIA
Crimea
Davos
DEBKA
East Turkestan
East
Turkistan
Economic Crisis
Energy
Erdogan
Ergenekon
ethocide
Gaza
genocide
Global Economy
Gulen
HUMAN RIGHTS
IMF
Iran
Istanbul
jda
Karabakh
Nabucco
Nagorno
Karabakh
norman israel
obama
POLITICS
Racism
Tataristan
Tatars
tereset
Terrorism
Turkey
Turkey and Armenia
TURKMEN
Uighur
Uighurs
UK
Uyghur
Water
Zionism
RECENT COMMENTS
robert's dsm on
NAGORNO KARABAKH IS ARMENIAN
LAND, CLAIMS TURKISH JOURNALIST
Hally on
HARVARD UNIVERSITY UNDERMINES ITS
OWN PRESTIGE “IN SERVICE” OF GENOCIDAL
TURKEY
Robert on
NAGORNO KARABAKH IS ARMENIAN
LAND, CLAIMS TURKISH JOURNALIST
Anonymous on
FETULLAH GULEN’S SCHOOLS ARE
ALL OVER THE US
OSMAN
on
NAGORNO KARABAKH IS ARMENIAN
LAND, CLAIMS TURKISH JOURNALIST
Sona on
INTERNAL DOCUMENTS REVEAL.. BY
HARUT SASSOUNIAN
HALUK
on
TAKE ME BACK TO CONSTANTINOPLE
Robert on
A CALL TO MOBILIZE THE DIASPORA,
Robert on
AZNAVOUR DEMANDS WESTERN
ARMENIAN LANDS
Robert on
INTERNAL DOCUMENTS REVEAL.. BY
HARUT SASSOUNIAN
Search
© 2007 2008
HomePage
Authors
Main Issues
News
Regions
Dues & Donations
Subscribe
DE
TR
Wyszukiwarka
Podobne podstrony:
Home is Where You Serve Globalization and Nationalism in Korean Popular Music
Phenology of the wild service tree (Sorbus torminalis (L ) Crantz] in Poznań and Wielkopolski Nation
Осіпян Рец на Serhii Plokhy, The Cossack Myth History and Nationhood in the Ages of Empires
Estimation of Dietary Pb and Cd Intake from Pb and Cd in blood and urine
automating with step 7 in lad and fbd simatic (1)
Key Concepts in Language and Linguistics
Guide to the properties and uses of detergents in biology and biochemistry
2008 4 JUL Emerging and Reemerging Viruses in Dogs and Cats
2002 3 MAY Lasers in Medicine and Surgery
In vivo MR spectroscopy in diagnosis and research of
Numerical methods in sci and eng
conceptual storage in bilinguals and its?fects on creativi
20090602 01 ANSF, Coalition Forces further disable IED?lls in Khowst and Zabul
01 [ABSTRACT] Development of poplar coppices in Central and Eastern Europe
Nukariya; Religion Of The Samurai Study Of Zen Philosophy And Discipline In China And Japan
PROF DREWS Infections in pregn and puerp (1)
więcej podobnych podstron