r

•

I

f

I

Nr

rERI

1

V

I

REPORT

,

r

----

l

_

,=

.~

-

~

~

=

.

:"

"

=

:

..-

'

_

AN

I

N

T

E

RI

i

\1

REPORT

B

Y

T

Il

E

TASK FORCE

INV

ESTIGATING

ECOi

'

\0

1

\

lIC

CRl

i

\IES

BY ClIARTERIl

OUSE

BA~K A~D RELATE

D

CO

l

\

lPANIES

(Upda

t

ed

fr

o

m

the

iz

"

Nove

mb

e

r

200

-

l int

e

rim

report

,,

,

it!;

l

a

tes

t

find

i

ngs

)

I

NTRODUCTION

Th

e

ta

s

k f

o

r

ce

m

e

t

o

n

28

l

h

and 29

th

Oc

t

obe

r

200

4

to appraise

them

s

e

l

ves

with the task

a

nd draw lip an a

c

ti

o

n

pla

n

.

OBJECT

I

VE

.

:

~

Th

e

t

e

am d

e

fin

e

d

th

e

ir

o

b

jec

tives

a

s

:

1

.

1

To

in

s

titute

an e

co

n

o

mi

c

cn

r

n

c

in

ves

ti

gat

i

o

n

agai

n

s

t

th

e

compa

n

ies

m

e

nti

o

n

e

d

b

e

low

w

ith a vi

e

w to id

e

ntif

y

i

n

g

p

o

t

e

nti

al

T

a

x eva

s

ion

,

illega

l

,

mon

ey

tran

s

f

e

r

s

or vio

l

ation

o

f Banking

A

c

t

wit

h

th

e co

nni

vance

o

f

Ch

a

rt

c

rh

ouse

B

a

nk Ltd

.

Th

e

c

om

pani

es

a

re:

_

r

1

.

1

.

1

C

r

e

ati

ve

f

l

J

J

I

U

V

ali

u

J

ls

L

t

d

.

1.1

.2

S

ail

cs

h

Pr

a

japati

1

.

1

.

3

D

.

S

h

a

h

1

.

1

.

4

K

a

riuki Muigua

&

Co

.

(Cli

e

nt

s Acco

u

n

t

s)

I

..

I

{

,

l

'

1.1.

5

W

. E.

Till

ey

(M

u

thai

g

a)

Ltd

I

.

]

.G

Pao

l

o S

att

a

nino

1

.

1

.

7

T

u

s

k

e

r

Ma

ttr

esse

s

Ltd

1

.

2

To estab

li

s

h

w

h

e

th

e

r

th

e

Bank aid

e

d the s

a

id c

o

mpanie

s

in

co

mm

it

t

i

n

g

ccononuc

cn

r

ncs

1

.

3

To id

e

ntify

the Direc

t

o

r

s

o

f

C

h

a

r

tcrho

u

sc

Ba

n

k

an

d

es

t

abl

i

s

h

a l

ink wi

th

th

e

relat

e

d

c

o

mpa

n

i

e

s

in a po

ssi

ble

ne

t

wo

rk

[

o

r

co

mmi

t

t

i

n

g

e

co

n

o

m

i

c

c

rim

es

w

i

th a

v

iew t

o

breaking

it

MET

H

ODO

L

OGY

T

h

e

t

a

s

k f

o

rce u

n

de

r

took

the following

s

t

ep

s to achieve

its

o

bjec

tive:

~

-

'

--.

:

-

_

-----------

-

f

f

1

.

4

Ca

rri

ed

ou

t a

sea

r

ch

a

t t

he

R

eg

i

s

t

ra

r

of Companies

off

i

ces

for detai

l

s of

the companies

r

eferred

above to obtain thei

r

registration

details.

T

r

ace

d

the p

hysical

ad

d

resse

s

o

f

t

he said companies

to establish

thei

r

locations.

1

.

5

1

.

6

Carried

ou

t

a surprise

visit to Ch::1lie

r

house

Bank to obtai

n

bank account

d

eta

il

s

i

n

r

espect

of various

accounts

held by the above

listed companies

and

i

ndividuals

I

.

7

C

arri

ed

ou

t

a surp

r

ise

v

isi

t

to the specified

compan

i

es

and obtaine

d

doc

um

ents

and

re

co

r

ds

r

eb

t

i

n

g

to their bus

i

ness

ac

t

ivities

for the peri

o

d

s

tar

ti

n

g

1

s

l

J

an

uar

y

1

999

t

o

4

th

Nove

m

be

r

200

4

T

h

e v

i

s

i

ts to

t

he com

p

a

ni

es'

pr

e

mi

ses

au

d

th

e ba

nk

we

r

e

car

r

ic

d

out simu

l

taneous

l

y.

1

.

8

Wro

te t

o

th

e

K

e

n

y

a Rev

e

n

u

e

A

uth

ori

t

y

and ob

t

ai

n

e

d

t

ax records

i

n respec

t

o

f th

e

c

o

m

pa

n

ies

l

is

ted a

bov

e

1

.

()

S

t

ar

t

e

d

si

ftin

g

thr

o

u

g

h

t

h

e

d

oc

um

e

nt

s

ob

t

ai

ned

fr

o

m

the companies

and

t

h

e b

a

n

k t

o

tr

y a

nd e

s

tabli

s

h

an

y i

ncid

ence

o

f

Y A

T

evas

i

o

n

S

J IORT

TEI{

J

\

I

SCOPE

The team se

t

ou

t

a s

h

ort-

I

cr

m

ob

j

ec

t

ive,

w

h

ic

h w

as to

tr

y a

nd

es

t

a

bl

is

h

an

y

li

ke

l

ihood

o

f

Y AT

eva

s

ion

by the said com

p

a

n

ies

fo

r th

e

p

e

r

io

d

b

eg

inn

i

n

g

2

nd

o

f

May 2003

t

o

September

2004

The rea

so

n

for this

s

hort-term

sco

p

e was to

t

ake into accoun

t

th

e fo

l

low

in

g

fac

t

ors:

I

.

To take advantage

of the

p

erio

d

Ke

n

ya

Anti - Corrup

t

io

n

Co

m

mission

became

o

perati

o

nal

and within which per

i

od i

t

can legally i

l

1\"est

i

gate and p

r

osecute

2

.

The

team

appre

c

iated

that

the exercise

is com

p

l

ex

and

w

i

ll

t

ake

l

o

ng

e

r

t

o

co

mpl

e

t

e

h

e

n

c

e it wa

s

necessar

y

to d

efine a s

h

o

rt term goal fo

r

immed

i

a

t

e

acti

o

n

w

hil

e

the

l

o

n

g te

rm o

b

j

ec

tive

wi

ll be pursued

syste

matically

as the invesugation

e

xp

a

n

ds

J

-

f

-

-

-

-

----------

r

f

I

:

'i

TERL\l

FIN

DI

I

\GS

CREATIVE I

;

\

i

\OVATIO

~S

LTD

F

r

o

m

t

h

e

d

ocu

m

ents

co

l

lect

e

d

f

r

o

m

the

c

o

mpany's

premis

es

and

from

Cha

r

te

r

ho

usc

Bank,

t

h

e fo

l

lowing

was

o

b

s

e

r

ved:

'

r

T

h

at th

e

COIllP:lI1Y

o

p

era

t

es

f

o

ur bank accounts

with the Cha

r

t

e

rh

o

u

s

e

Bank

»:

O

nl

y

tw

o

a

ccoun

t

s

a

r

e di

s

clo

s

ed

in

t

he company's

o

ff

i

c

i

a

l

r

ec

o

rds.

T

he

s

e arc

:

o

CA

.

0

1

- 00

1

000

00

9

o

C

1

\

0

1

- 000

1

00027

5

r

The

o

th

e

r

t

w

o

a

cco

un

t

s

as show

n

b

elow

wit

h

de

p

os

it

s

amo

u

n

tin

g

to Kshs

.

262,

1 U

5,659

a

r

c

n

o

t di

s

c

l

ose

d

in th

e

co

mp

a

n

y

'

s

Ba

l

a

n

ce

S

h

ee

t

f

o

r

t

h

e pe

ri

o

d

un

d

e

r r

ev

i

ew (

i

e f

r

o

m

2

nd

May

200

3

to Oc

t

ober

200

-

+

).

o

CA 0

1 -

0

1

00007

4

o

C1

\

0

1

- 0

1

000206

K

s

h

s.2

3

7

,

268,640

K

s

h

s,

2

4

,8

3

7,0

1

9

262,105,659

'

;

-

I

I

i

s ev

i

de

nt

that th

ese

d

e

p

o

si

ts

a

rc co

mp

a

n

y

in

co

m

e

fr

o

m

s

al

es a

n

d have n

o

t

bee

n

a

s

se

s

se

d

fo

r

VAT a

nd I

nco

m

e

Tax

s

in

ce

th

ey

ar

e

n

o

t di

sc

l

ose

d

in th

e companies

of

f

icia

l

recor

d

s

I

l

.

)

.

;

-

The fig

ur

e

s

h

ow

n

above is

f

or

t

he

p

e

ri

o

d

un

de

r r

eview sta

rtin

g

f

ro

m M

ay 2003 to

October

200

4

.

I

t wi

ll

ce

r

tai

n

ly

grow once

th

e

p

r

i

o

r p

e

ri

o

d i

s

c

o

mput

e

d

r

C

omput

e

d

VAT

eva

s

ions

p

l

us

pe

nalti

es

f

o

r

t

he

pe

r

io

d

a

m

o

unt

to Ks

h

s

.

2

02,4lJ1,4

9

8

f

o

r

t

ha

t

p

e

riod

.

;

.

..

T

he c

o

rre

s

p

o

nding

VAT an

d

Additiona

l

Tax

l

iabi lit

y

for t

h

e period Ma

y

2

00

3 to

Oct

o

b

e

r

200

4 i

s

K

s

h

s.

44,

8

39

,

492.

01

1

1

C

I

O

ob scrva tio

n

S

r

Th

e

c

o

mpany

ma

i

n

ly

d

ea

l

s

with im

p

o

rts

11

10s

t

o

f whi

c

h

i

s s

upp

l

i

e

d

t

o Na

k

u

m

at

t

I

I

o

l

d

i

ngs

Lt

d.

I

t was observed

t

hat

the

c

o

mpany

in

re

s

p

e

ct

o

f th

es

e

s

u

pp

li

es

t

o

,

'

\akull1attl

1oJ

dil1gs

mainta

i

n

s

1

10

proper

docume

ntatio

n

o

Prime Catch Ltd

Tanza

n

ia

~

~

~

~

-

-----------

[

.

r

'

f

.

.

"

r

It has al

so come t

o t

he Co

mm

iss

i

ons

k

nowledgc

tha

t

the company

lS

a majo

r

su

pplie

r

o

f

certai

n

o

i

ls

/

lubricants

to the follow

i

ng

corpo

r

a

t

i

ons

the

i

n

co

me o

f

which may

n

ot have

been di

sclos

ed

in thei

r

boo

ks

o

Keny

a P

orts Auth

ority

o

Keny

a

A

ir

ports

Auth

o

rit

y

o

K

en

y

a Powe

r

8

:

.

L

i

g

htin

g

C

o

mpany

Next course

of action

;

..-

Co

mpil

e

a

ca

s

e

fi

l

e

and

recommend

charges

o

n

the

Di

r

ectors

o

f Creat

i

ve

I

n

n

o

vati

o

n

s

f

o

r fai

l

ure

t

o

p

ay VA

T

and Add

i

tio

n

al

T

ax

in t

he tune of Kshs.

4

4,

8

3

9

,

4

92

t

o

th

e

K

e

n

y

a

Reve

nu

e

A

uth

ori

t

y

in th

e

p

e

ri

o

d

fr

om March 2

0

03

t

o

Oct

o

b

e

r

200

4

.J

•

r

"

!

r

T

he

Ken

ya

R

eve

nu

e

Auth

or

it

y

t

o

r

ecove

r

fr

o

m

Cr

ea

tiv

e

I

n

n

ovations

Lt

d t

he

a

m

o

unt

s

owe

d in

V

AT

an

d

A

dditional

T

ax.

Offence

likely

to he di

s

closed

F

a

ilure

t

o

pa

y

ta

xes

co

ntr

a

r

y

t

o sec

t

io

n

45

(

1

)

(

d

)

o

f t

he A

nti

-Co

rnl

pt

i

o

n

and

Economics

A

c

t

o

f

2003

\V E TILLEY

(MUTIIAIGA)

LTD

From doc

um

e

nt

s

ob

t

a

in

e

d

fr

o

m th

e b

ank and

t

h

e

c

o

mp

a

n

y

'

s

pr

e

mi

ses,

t

h

e fo

l

lowing

h

as

bl:(

;

l

lob

s

erved:

;

..-

The company

is a fis

h p

roce

s

s

in

g

finn

wi

th

ex

p

o

rt

s

f

on

nin

g

95% of

t

heir sa

l

es

and the re

m

ai

n

de

r

5

%

be

in

g

l

oca

l

sa

l

es

;

.

from

the above obse

r

vatio

n

s

i

t

fol

l

ows

th

a

t th

e

bulk

o

f th

e

ir

sa

l

es

p

roceeds a

r

c i

n

foreign currency i.e

.

US Do

l

lars

r

The compan

y

has three other

r

e

l

at

e

d c

o

mpa

ni

es

f

o

r

w

h

ic

h

th

ey al

l

e

ge to handle

t

h

e

ir

e

x

p

o

rt

thr

o

u

g

h

Ken

y

a

.

The dir

ec

t

o

rships

a

r

e

th

e same

fo

r

al

l

t

h

e f

o

ur

co

mpanie

s.

Th

e

three c

o

m

p

ani

e

s

arc

:

o

Ma

ra F

is

h Pa

c

k

e

r

s

L

t

d

Tanzan

i

a

o

V

ict

o

r

i

a Fi

sh

P

a

c

ke

r

s

&

P

r

ocessors

Ltd

Uga

nda

r

:

T

he compan

y

ope

r

ates

six bank a

ccounts spread as s

ho

wn

be

lo

w

5

-

[

-

'

-----

--

-----

o

Chart

c

rh

o

u

s

c

B:

:

l

I1

k

•

CAO

I

-6

0

01

78

•

C

A 0

1

-

0

1

0006

30

us

D

O

LLAR A

C

C

UL

'

N

T

KSHS. A

C

COUN

T

o

Im

pe

ri

a

l

Commerci

a

l

Bank

•

1

0

0805

1

62

•

1

0080

5

O

O

G

U

S DOLL

A

R

ACC

O

UN

T

K

SHS

. ACC

O

Ul'i

T

o

Fid

eli

t

y

Com

m

erc

i

a

l

Acco

u

n

t

•

115

0

2443

•

1110

2

442

U

S DOLL

A

R

AC

CO

UN

T

K

SHS

.

AC

C

O

UN

T

;

;

..

The

t

o

tal credit

s

for the p

e

riod

Januar

y

t

o S

e

ptemb

e

r

2

00

4 into

t

h

e s

i

x ac

counts

amount

to K

s

h

s

5

,8

93,464,

79

8.

Th

i

s figure is not adju

s

t

e

d

b

y

op

e

n

i

n

g

a

n

d

c

lo

s

in

g

d

e

bt

o

rs

although

the d

e

p

os

its

s

till appear to b

e o

n th

e

hi

g

h

e

r

s

ide

r

The t

o

tal sal

e

s f

o

r

the

s

ame period am

o

unt

to K

s

hs 1,351,

87

4

,

2

6

9

:

,-

Th

e

n;

are num

e

r

o

u

s

t

rans

f

ers

from doll

a

r

a

c

count

s

to

s

h

il

lin

g

acco

u

nt

s

1

11

th

e

sa

me bank

and a

c

ro

ss

t

he other b

a

nks

a

s

well ra

is

ing

th

e

p

oss

ibilit

y

of d

ou

b

le

.

cr

e

dit

s

in computin

g

th

e

abo

v

e fi

g

ure

r

Ther

e

i

s

al

s

o evid

e

nce

of heav

y

tradin

g

in f

o

r

e

i

g

n cur

r

e

ncy

b

e

t

wee

n

t

he co

mpan

y

a

nd

s

everal

F

o

r

ex

Bur

e

aus

i

n th

e

cit

y

)

.:

-

T

h

e

c

o

mpan

y

claim

s

to rec

e

ive

e

xp

o

rt

proceed

s

f

o

r its r

e

lated

c

o

mp

a

ni

e

s

and

ba

nking

i

t in it

s ow

n

ac

count

s

:r

It

' was o

b

s

erv

e

d

that

.

the comp

a

n

y

banks a lot in Afro Forex Bur

e

au

bank

ac

count

wi

th

Fi

d

e

lit

y

Co

mmer

c

i

a

l

b

a

nk

;

;

..

H

u

ge

pa

y

m

e

nt

s

are al

s

o mad

e

to p

e

r

s

ons

who on the face of it d

o

n

o

t

see

m to

have a

n

y

r

e

l

a

ti

ons

hip

with

t

he n

a

ture

o

f th

e

c

o

mpan

y

's

bu

s

in

e

ss

ac

ti

v

iti

es

Add

i

ti

o

nal

findin

g

s

r

:

TO

t

:l

1 sales

f

o

r th

e

pe

r

iod

M

a

y

20

0

3

to Oc

t

obe

r

2

0

0

4

am

oun

t

ed

t

o

K

s

h

s.

5,

230,

206

,

7

<

J

1

.

25

wh

i

le the t

o

tal dep

o

si

ts

i

n

t

o

t

hei

r

of

fi

cia

l

bank a

ccou

n

t

s

a

m

o

un

t

[0

K

s

h

s

.

5

,

6

3

0,

6

11,

4

7

6.

0

0

.

.

..

,

r

I

.

(

(

<

?

All

o

wing

l

o

r

e

xchange

rate

g

ains

(

l

osses)

it s

ee

ms

t

he d

e

p

osi

ts

i

n

th

e

i

r

o

ffi

c

ia

l

b

ank

acc

o

un

t

s

c

o

m

p

e

n

s

at

e

f

o

r t

he sales proceeds

o

f

t

he thr

e

e

s

ister c

o

m

p

a

n

i

e

s.

G

-.

J

---..

:

.-

--

------------

(

f

r

Bu

t th

e co

mp

any

only de

c

la

r

es

the

s

a

l

e

s proceeds

of the K

e

n

y

an operati

o

ns

to the

Kenya

n Tax Auth

o

r

ity

.

'

r

No

evide

n

ce

h

o

we

ver

IS

seen

of remittanc

e

s

to

the Tanzanian

com

p

an

i

es

to

account

for thei

r

exp

o

r

ts,

»:

T

h

e

r

e

is ev

i

dence

t

hat

t

h

e

c

o

mp

any

t

r

ad

e

s

h

e

avily

In f

o

r

eign

cur

r

enc

y

with a

n

u

mber

of Forcx Burea

u

s

.

r

.

I

Nex

t

cou

r

se

of action

r

Co

n

tac

t

t

he Tanzanian

Revenue

Authority

t

o

f

i

n

d

ou

t

whether

the

T

a

nz

ania

n

si

s

t

e

r

co

m

pa

n

ies

declare

t

heir export earnings

i

n Ta

n

z

ania

.

,

.

I

f

th

e a

m

o

unt

s

a

r

e no

t br

ou

g

ht

to charge

in T

anzan

i

a,

t

he

n

the re

l

evan

t

Kenya

n

t

ax w

ill b

e

a

ssesse

d

o

n th

e

ba

l

an

c

e

n

o

t d

ec

lar

e

d

in K

e

n

ya

.

:

r

Es

ta

b

li

s

h

th

e

i

m

p

l

i

ca

t

io

n

s

of

tr

ad

in

g

i

n f

oreig

n

c

ur

re

n

cy,

ass

e

ss

the income

ea

rn

e

d

,

d

e

t

e

rm

i

n

e

t

he

t

ax

impli

c

ati

ons

a

nd

reco

mm

e

nd

a

ppr

o

p

r

i

a

t

e

action.

r

P

r

e

p

a

r

e

a case file a

n

d

r

ecom

m

e

nd

charges

o

n

the

D

i

r

ec

t

o

r

s

fo

r

failing to declare

i

nco

m

e

and p

ay

t

axes

t

o

th

e

K

e

n

ya Reve

nu

e

Autho

r

i

t

y.

Off

e

nce

lik

e

ly to be di

s

c

l

os

e

d

1

.

Fa

i

l

ur

e

t

o pay

t

axes co

ntrar

y

t

o sec

ti

o

n

4

5 (

1

)

(

d) of

th

e Ant

i

-Corruptio

n

a

nd

Eco

n

om

i

cs

Ac

t

0[2003

2

.

Money

l

a

und

er

i

ng

a

ctiv

it

ies

TUSKE

R

l

\IATTRE

SSES

LTD

A

sc

rutiny

of

t

he documents

obtained

fro

m th

e co

mp

a

n

y's

p

r

e

m

ises

and

th

e Cha

r

tcr

h

ousc

Dank re

v

eal

e

d

th

e

foll

o

wing:

r

T

he company

operates

a c

u

rren

t

bank accou

n

t

No 30

1

w

h

ic

h

h

ad a bal

a

nce of

K

s

hs

.

4.3 billion

from 2

nd

May 2003 to Se

p

te

mb

e

r

2000

4

r

The bank

account

was opened

in the yea

r

2001

but was n

o

t

discl

os

ed

I

I

I

the

o

ffi

c

i

a

l

b

oo

ks

of

a

c

c

oun

ts

f

o

r the

ye

ar

s

2

0

0 I and 2

0

02

r

H

o

w

eve

r

Ch

a

rt

c

r

house

bank

is in

c

l

ud

ed

in the fina

l

a

cco

unts

f

o

r

t

h

e

y

ears 2

00

3

a

n

d

200

.

+

r

W

e

ha

ve

al

so

di

scove

r

e

d

that t

he c

o

mpan

y

'

s

D

i

re

c

t

o

rs

o

p

e

r

ate

num

e

r

ou

s

o

ther

a

c

c

o

unts

w

i

t

h

t

he Char

l

erh

o

use

Dank in the

tO

I

lH

o

f fixed

de

p

os

i

t

a

ccounts

,

7

-

f

-

~

-----------~

sa

vings

a

cc

oun

t

s,

and

cur

r

ent

acc

ou

n

t

s

an

d

call

a

ccou

n

ts.

T

hese

accou

nts

numbe

ring

ab

ou

t

seventy-f

i

v

e

re

flec

t

huge

b

alance

s

Additional

findings

"

;

.-

G

o

ing

b

y

ban

k

e

d

sal

es

and

V AT

decl

a

red

acco

unt

,

we

o

bserve

t

ha

t t

he

s

u

p

e

rma

r

k

e

t

h

as

un

der

de

c

l

a

red

thei

r

sal

e

s

b

y Ks

hs

.

9

1

1

,

(

1

9)

87

be

t

wee

n Ju

l

y

]

9

9

9

to J

u

n

e 2

0

0

-

1

-

wh

ic

h

w

o

u

l

d

a

t

t

ra

c

t a

V

AT l

ev

y

of a

pp

ro

x

imatel

y

1G

0

,

998

,2

30

i

n

prin

c

ip

a

l

am

o

unt

al

o

n

e.

r

The corre

s

pond

i

n

g

fi

gu

re

[o

r p

e

r

io

d

u

n

de

r r

e

vi

e

w i

.e

. Jul

y 20

0

3 t

o

J

u

n

e 2

0

0

..

+we

f

i

nd an und

e

r

-

d

ec

larat

io

n

o

f K

shs

.

5

9

,

3

9

7

,

968

,

w

hi

c

h w

o

uld a

t

t

r

ac

t a V

A

T

le

vy o

f

approximat

e

ly

Kshs

.

9,5

0

3

,

6

7

4

in principal

am

o

unt al

o

ne.

r

Between

July 2002 and Jun

e

20

0

4, the company

also und

e

rstated

th

e

ir p

u

rcha

se

s

b

y

K

s

I1

S

.

437

,

679,93

7

,

whi

c

h

would

attract Kshs.

7

5,

8

0

8

,414

in prin

c

i

pa

l

V

AT

l

e

vy.

r

The c

o

rr

es

p

o

nding

figure [

o

r

July 2

00

3

to June

2

0

0

4

is K

s

h

s.

14

8

,

698,6

6

2

,

w

hi

c

h

would attra

c

t the VAT levy

o

f

K

s

hs

,

23,

7

91

,

7

8

5

in prin

c

ipal

s

um.

r

:

The ab

o

ve figures can only

be

confirmed

after

:

o

Cro

ss

checking

with the

s

al

e

s account in the comput

e

r

.

o

Cro

s

s

c

heck

s

al

e

s to oth

e

r

s

upermarkets

in th

e

ch

a

in

o

Anal

yz

ing

s

tock records

o

Verif

y

in

g

the input t

a

x

Next course

of action

J

t

.

(

;

.

:

-

Access

th

e

c

o

mput

e

r

data and v

e

rify th

e

figur

e

s quoted above.

;

.....

Es

t

a

bl

is

h

th

e

final ta

x

abl

e

amount and a

s

se

s

s tax.

r

Obt

a

i

n

Ba

n

k

acco

unt

r

ecor

d

s

o

f th

e

num

e

rous

fixed

d

e

p

os

it,

ca

ll d

e

p

os

it

s

an

d

c

u

rre

nt

acc

o

u

nt

d

epo

s

i

t

s

o

f t

he compa

n

y

a

nd the Dir

e

ct

o

r

s

h

el

d at

C

h

a

r

te

rh

o

u

s

e

Dank and Ba

r

cla

ys

B

ank an

d i

nv

es

ti

g

ate

if

a

n

y of

th

e

sup

e

rm

a

rk

et

sal

e

s pr

o

c

ee

d

s

are bank

e

d d

i

rectl

y

int

o

th

ose

a

c

c

ount

s

r

P

r

epar

e

a el

se

fil

e a

nd rec

om

m

e

n

d

charge

s

o

n the

D

i

r

ect

o

r

s

o

f

T

us

ke

r

.

\

I

a

ttr

csse

s

f

o

r

fa

il

ing

to

dec

l

a

r

e

i

ncome a

n

d p

ay taxes c

l

u

e

t

o t

h

e

K

e

ny

a

R

e

v

enue

A

uth

o

r

i

ty.

r

:

K

e

n

y

a R

eve

n

ue

A

uth

o

rity

t

o

c

ommence

recovery

o

f t

he t

axes d

u

e.

,

.

,

I

-1-

'

-

-

----------

-

"

---

Th

e se

cond

phase

of the inve

s

ti

ga

ti

o

ns

wi

l

l f

o

cus on the remain

i

ng

f

o

ur enti

t

i

e

s with the

aim of unrave

l

i

n

g

t

he n

etwork

o

f secr

c

t ban

k

acco

unts

with the attendant

tax eva

s

ions,

i

l

lega

l

money

t

ransfers

an

d vi

o

l

at

ion

o

f banking

rules

by big busines

s

es.

Th

i

s s

e

cond

p

h

ase sh

o

uld star

t

as s

oo

n a

s

th

c f

i

rs

t p

ha

se is c

o

nsid

e

rably

c

o

n

c

l

ud

ed

.

P

re

p

ared

b

y:

HE

N

RY

i

\l

l

\l\VITIIIA

30

T

I

I

l

\OVE

i

\lBER

2

00

-

l

I

r

.

f

~

I

.

.

.

I

~

{

l