~

l

~

_

.

r

f

'

[

I

[

I

r

-

r

I

!

EXECUTIVE

SU

l

\I

i

\

'

IARY

I

NTER

I

l

\

'

1

REPOR1~

AN INTERI

l

\I

REPORT

ill

'

TIlE TASK FORCE

INYESTIGATI:\G

ECO~O;\IIC

CIU

l

\IES ill

'

CHARTEIUIOUSE

i

l

A~K AND RELATED

CO

l

\lPA

1

'ILES

'

r

Th

e

K

c

n

y

a

Anti-

C

orrupti

o

n

C

o

mmi

ss

ion

b

ac

k

e

d

by off

i

ce

r

s

fr

o

m th

e

K

enya

Rc

v

enuc

Auth

o

rit

y

a

n

d

the B

a

nking

Fraud

In

v

c

st

i

ga

ti

o

n

D

e

p

a

rt

men

t

mad

e

a

s

urpri

s

e

raid to th

e

follm

v

ing

f

ou

r

es

ta

b

li

s

hll

lc

ll

tS.

1) Charterhouse

Bank

2) Tu

s

k

e

r

Mattre

sses

3)

Cr

c

ati vc Inn

o

v

a

t

io

ns

Lim it

e

d

4)

WE

Tilley (Muthaiga)

Ltd

r

Fr

o

m the Chart

c

rhou

s

c

Bank,

a

c

c

o

unt

records

f

o

r th

e

f

o

ll

owi

n

g

co

mp

a

ni

es

a

nd

per

so

n

s

were c

o

ll

e

ct

e

d:

J

)

Tu

s

k

e

r

M attrc

sscs

2

)

Cr

e

at

i

ve

Inn

o

vati

o

n

s

3)

WE Till

ey

(Muth

a

i

g

a)

Ltd

4

)

S

aile

s

h

Pra

j

apati

5

) D

S

h

a

h

G)

P

ao

l

o S

att

a

nino

;

.:

.

Fo

r the

co

n

ve

nicn

ce

o

f

o

p

c

rat

i

n

g

within the p

e

riod within

whi

c

h th

e K

en

y

a

A

nti

-

Corr

u

ptio

n

Com

mi

ss

i

o

n

can

I

cgn

ll

y

i

n

ve

s

ti

ga

t

c,

the

Ta

s

k

F

o

r

c

e

d

ec

id

e

d

to

i

n

i

t

ially

scr

ut

in

i

ze

the

r

eco

rd

s

o

f t

he

fir

s

t t

h

r

ee co

mpan

ies

s

t

ar

tin

g

fr

o

m

2

n

J

1\

l

ay

2003 to da

t

e wi

th

a view to est:

.

tblishing

any i

l

lc

i

dence

of V

AT

a

n

d

I

ncome T

a

x

e\

'

a

S

l

o

n

.

;

.-

The fol

l

ow

i

ng

f

i

ndings

ha

v

e b

ee

n ma

d

e f

o

llowi

n

g

t

he sc

r

utiny

o

f

the c

o

mpan

y

'

s

r

e

cord

s

\

'

i

s

-:'t

-

vis (he bank re

c

or

ds

,

f

I

, !

1

. C

R

EA

TI

V

E

I

NN

O

VA

TIO

NS

LTD

:

r

We

h

ave

di

sco

ve

r

ed

two u

n

d

i

sclose

d

Bank accoun

t

s o

f

C

r

eative

I

nnov

a

tio

n

s wi

th

d

e

p

os

i

ts

t

o

ta

l

i

ng

to K

sh

s. 262

,

1

0

5,659

w

i

t

h

in

t

he pe

r

io

d ]

anuary 1999

t

o

O

c

t

o

be

r

2

00

4

.

)

.-

Comp

u

t

ed

V

AT

evas

i

o

ns

p

lu

s

penal

t

ies

fo

r

t

he

period

a

m

o

u

n

t

to Kshs.

20

2,4

9

1,4

98

f

o

r th

at per

i

od.

,

.

Th

e co

rr

espo

n

d

in

g

VA

T

a

nd A

dd

i

tio

n

al

Ta

x liabi

l

i

ty

[

o

r th

e period M

a

y 2

0

0

3 t

o

O

c

t

o

b

e

r

200

4

is

K

shs.

44,

83

9

,

4

92.

2.

\

V E T

I

LLE

Y

(MU

THAI

GA

) LTD

N

e

xt

COUI

'

SC

o

f acti

o

n

I

'

!

"

\

>

-

Compil

e

a ca

s

e

fil

e

and

re

c

omm

e

n

d

char

ges

o

n

th

e

D

irec

t

o

r

s

o

f Cr

eative

I

n

n

ova

ti

o

ns

[

o

r f

a

il

u

re

t

o pa

y

VAT and Additi

o

n

a

l

T

ax

in t

he

t

unc o

f

Ks

h

s

.

44,839

,

492

t

o

th

e

K

e

n

y

a

Re

ve

n

u

e

Auth

o

r

i

t

y

i

n t

h

e

p

e

r

i

o

d

fr

o

m

Marc

h

200

3 t

o

O

c

t

o

b

e

r

200

4

r

T

h

e

Ken

ya

Re

ve

n

u

e

A

ut

h

o

r

i

t

y

t

o

r

ecove

r

fr

o

m Cre

a

ti

ve

In

novat

i

ons

L

td

th

e

a

m

o

u

n

t

s

owed

i

n

V

AT

a

nd Add

i

ti

o

n

a

l

Ta

x

.

l

I

,

'

r

W E T

ill

ey

M

uth

a

i

g

a

L

t

d

I

S

a

fi

s

h pr

ocess

in

g

and

e

x

p

o

rt

c

o

mp

a

n

y

w

ith

s

i

s

t

e

r

com

p

a

n

ies

T

a

n

za

n

ia.

I

(

I

I

.

r:

T

h

e

Ke

n

ya

n

c

om

pa

n

y

h

a

nd

l

es

a

l

l

t

h

e

e

x

p

o

r

t

s

o

n

b

e

half

o

f th

e

Tan

za

n

ian

com

p

anies

a

nd

receives

p

ay

m

e

n

ts

o

n th

e

ir b

e

hal

f

.

r

Total

sa

l

es

fo

r

the

p

erio

d

May

2003

t

o Octo

b

e

r

200

-

1

a

m

oun

t

ed

t

o K

s

h

s.

5,230,2

0

6,

7

9

1

.

25

while

t

he

t

o

ta

l

deposits

into

th

e

ir

off

i

c

i

a

l

ba

n

k

a

cc

o

unts am

o

unt

t

o

K

s

hs

,

5,030,611,4

7

6

.00.

:,

...

All

o

wing

f

o

r exch

a

nge

rate

gains (losses

)

it

s

eems

t

he dep

os

i

ts

in t

h

eir

o

f

f

i

c

ial

bank a

ccou

nts

c

ompe

n

sate

for

t

h

e sales p

r

o

cee

d

s o

f the thre

e s

i

st

er

com

pani

e

s

.

3

~f

~

_

s

,

f

'

[

.

;

.

..

But th

e com

p

any

on

l

y dec

l

ares

the sales procee

d

s

of

t

he Ke

n

ya

n

op

e

rati

o

ns

t

o the

K

cny

an

Tax Authorit

y.

:

r

N

o

eviden

c

e

h

owever

I

S

s

e

en

of remitt

an

ce

s

to the Tanzania

n

c

o

mpanies

to

a

c

count

f

or th

e

ir e

xports

.

r

T

h

e

r

e

is evid

e

nce

t

h

a

t th

e

c

o

mpan

y

trades

heavily

I

I

1

f

o

r

ei

g

n

cur

re

n

cy

with a

numb

e

r

o

fFor

e

x

Bur

e

aus.

Next course

of ac

t

ion

'.

r

...

•

~

\

r

:

r

'

"

.

r

:

,

r

:

Co

nt

ac

t

t

h

e

T

a

n

za

ni

a

n

Reve

nu

e

Au

th

o

rit

y

to

f

ind ou

t

w

h

ethe

r

t

hc Tanzanian

s

i

s

t

e

r

co

m

pa

ni

e

s

d

ec

l

a

r

e

th

e

ir export

ea

r

n

i

ngs

in T

a

n

za

n

ia .

If th

e a

m

ou

nt

s

a

r

c

n

o

t

br

oug

ht

to ch

arge

in Tan

zan

i

a

,

th

e

n th

e re

l

evan

t

Kenyan

t

ax wi

ll b

e assesse

d

o

n th

e

b

a

l

a

n

ce

n

o

t d

ec

l

a

r

ed

in K

e

n

ya

.

Es

t

ab

l

is

h

the impli

ca

t

io

n

s

o

f

t

ra

din

g

in

fo

r

e

i

g

n

cu

rr

e

n

cy,

as

s

ess

the

i

nc

o

m

e

ea

rn

ed, de

t

e

rmin

e

th

e

ta

x

imp

l

i

c

ati

o

n

s

an

d r

eco

mm

e

n

d

appro

pr

iate

a

c

tion

.

Pr

e

p

a

r

e

a case f

il

e

and r

eco

mm

e

nd

cha

r

ges on

th

e Direc

t

ors

fo

r

failing to declare

i

n

co

m

e

a

n

d

p

ay

t

axes

t

o t

h

e Ke

n

ya

R

eve

n

ue

Au

th

or

i

ty.

3

.

TUSKl

~

R MATTRE

S

SES

LTD

L

(

[

C

.

\

..

r

Going

b

y

banked

sales

and

V A

T

dec

l

ared

accou

nt

,

we

ob

s

erve

that

t

he

s

upermarket

has und

e

r

dec

l

ared

t

hei

r

sa

l

es by Kshs

.

9)

1

,6

1

9,287

b

e

twe

e

n

J lily

1999 to June 2004 which would a

tt

rac

t

a VAT

l

evy o

f

approximately

160,998,230

in prin

c

ipal

amount

alone

.

,

..

Th

e co

rre

s

p

o

nding

figure [or period unde

r r

ev

i

ew

i

.

e. J

u

ly 2003 to June 2

0

04

w

e

find an und

e

r

-

declarati

o

n

of Ksh

s.

5

9

,39

7

,968,

w

hi

ch would a

t

tra

c

t a VAT lev

y

o

f

appr

ox

im

a

t

e

l

y

K

s

h

s

.

9

,50

3

,

G

7

4 in

p

rin

c

ipal

am

o

un

t

alone.

;

,

-

B

e

t

w

e

e

n

July 20

0

2

and

Jun

e 200

4

,

ti

le

c

o

mpany

al

so

un

de

r

s

tat

e

d

t

he

ir p

u

r

c

ha

ses

b

y

K

s

h

s

. 4

37

,

679

,

9

3

7,

whic

h

w

o

ul

d

attr

a

c

t

K

s

hs

. 7

5,S

0

8

,

414

in

pr

i

nc

ipal

VA

T

lev)'

.

-

f

'

r

The c

o

rr

es

ponding

fi

g

ure f

o

r Jul

y

20

0

3 t

o

June 2

00

4 i

s

K

sh

s

.

14

8,

6

98,66

2,

w

h

i

ch

wo

uld attr

ac

t the V

AT levy of Kshs

.

23,791,78

5

i

n p

r

i

ncip

al

sum.

r:

Th

e

a

b

o

v

e fi

gurcs can

o

nly bc c

o

nfirmed

af

t

e

r

:

o

Cr

ossc

h

ecking

witl

:

the sales account

i

n the co

mp

uter

.

o

Cr

oss

ch

eck sales

t

o other s

up

e

rm

arkets

i

n the

ch

ain

o

A

na

l

yz

in

g

s

t

ock records

o

Ve

r

ifying

t

he

i

npu

t

ta

x

Next course

of

action

l

.

·~

)

;

-

Acccss

the computer

data and verify the figures quoted ab

o

ve.

;

Y

Establi

s

h

the final taxab

l

e amount and a

s

sess tax

.

>

-

J

•

I.

)

..-

\

.

.

,

r

:

)

..-

Obtain

Bank

account

records

of the numer

o

us

fix

e

d d

e

po

s

it,

c

a

ll d

e

po

s

its

and

current

account

dep

os

its

of the company

and the Dir

e

ct

o

rs

h

e

ld at

C

h

a

rt

c

rh

o

u

sc

Bank and Bare la

y

s Bank and investigate

if any of the

su

p

e

rmark

e

t

sa

l

e

s pr

o

c

e

eds

are banked dir

e

ctly into th

os

e a

c

counts

r

Prepare

a ca

s

e fi Ie and recommend

charg

e

s

on the Dir

e

ct

o

r

s

of Tu

s

ker Mattre

ss

e

s

f

o

r failin

g

to d

e

clare income and

pay

taxes due to the K

e

n

y

a Re

v

enu

e

A

uthorit

y.

Ken

y

a Revenue

Authorit

y

to commence

recovery

of the ta

x

e

s

due

.

4.

~(ARIUKI

l\lUIGUA

& CO. (CLIENTS

ACCOUNT)

Chartcrh

o

u

s

c

Bank declined

to provide

any documents

on this account

citing a

hi

g

h

co

urt

o

rd

e

r barrin

g

an

y

b

o

dy

from invc

s

tigating

it

.

La

t

er

th

c

bank f

o

r

w

ard

e

d

a c

o

p

y o

f

a

n

o

th

e

r

hi

g

h

Cal

iri

o

rd

e

r barin

g

th

e

K

e

n

ya

A

n

t

i

-Co

rrup

t

i

o

n

Co

mm

issio

n

fr

o

m in

ves

t.

g

atin

g

t

he a

ccou

nt

.

r

:

Thi

s la

t

e

r l

I

i

g

l

: Co

ur

t orde

r h

as

n

o

t

bee

n

se

rv

e

d

o

n th

e

C

om

m

issio

n

as

at

t

h

e

t

ime

of making

t

h

i

s

r

e

p

or

t

.

)

..-

I

t

is believed

that the account

i

s

o

p

e

ra

t

e

d

by

big businesse

s

in

t

own tha

t d

eposit

s

al

e

s pr

o

ceed

s

i

nto the acc

ount

and h

o

p

e

(

0

hide

t

he

m

using the cloak of cli

e

nt

'

s

C

O

i

l

fid

c

n t

i

~

l

!

it

y

und

e

r

t

h

e ad

vee

ales

ac t

.

5

N

ex

t co

urse

of a

c

tion

>

-

Awai

t

service

of

t

he orde

r t

o determine

the next co

u

rse

o

f a

c

ti

o

n

.

5

.

D

S

H

Al

l

ACCOUN

T

>

-

B

e

t

wee

n

5

th

May 2

00

3 and

yd

N

o

vemb

e

r

2

00

4

, the ac

co

un

t

r

e

ce

i

ved a tota

l

o

f

K

s

h

s

.

601%8

1

7

1

.33

in de

p

osi

t

s

.

)

;

.-

Som

e

o

f th

e

d

e

p

osi

t

s

h

a

v

e

bee

n

c

s

t

ab l

i

s

h

e

d

as cas

h

t

ran

s

f

e

rs

fr

o

m

s

un

dry

cr

e

dit

o

r

s.

;

-

T

h

e e

qu

iva

l

e

nt

i

s

th

en

t

a

k

e

n

o

ut a

s Idd

i

ssue

d b

y o

rd

e

r

o

f

M

r

.

D

Sha

h

f

"

[

N

e

xt course

of action

)

.-

Tr

ac

e th

e fdds

a

nd tr

y to es

t

ablish

th

e be

n

e

fi

c

i

a

r

i

e

s

of

t

he tra

n

s

fers

.

/

'"

Es

t

a

bli

s

h

t

h

e

r

ea

l

sou

r

ce o

f fund

s a

nd d

e

t

e

n

ni

n

c

w

h

e

th

er

i

t

i

s a para

l

l

e

l

accoun

t

t

o

hid

e sa

l

es

pr

oceeds

f

or com

p

a

ni

es

.

r

As

s

ess

th

e i

n

fo

rm

a

ti

on

an

d r

eco

mm

en

d

a

p

p

r

o

pri

a

t

e

ac

ti

o

n.

[

J

{

:.

-

r

,

\

-

r:

r

:

r

G

.

SA

ILE

S

II

PRAJAPATTI

ACCOUT

No account

ope

n

ing

doc

u

me

n

ts

avai

l

e

d

.

Th

ey we

r

e a

l

l

e

ged

l

y

bur

nt

in a go

c

d

ow

n

fi r

eo

K

s

ll

S. 55

5,

6

1

8,

102.

2

5

d

e

p

os

i

t

ed

be

tween 2

n

d

Ma

y

2

00

3 and 2

nd

Augu

s

t

2

00

4

Mos

t d

e

p

osi

t

s

fr

o

m

Na

ku

r

natt h

oldi

n

gs

and

t

ran

s

f

er

s

from

s

undr

y c

r

e

dit

o

r

s.

In

o

n

e

i

ns

t

a

n

c

e

an

eq

u

iv

al

e

n

t

o

f th

e

a

mo

unt

tran

s

f

e

r

red

fr

o

m S

u

n

d

r

y C

r

e

dit

o

r

s

i

s

t

ake

n

out

t

hro

u

gh

I

di

l

's by o

r

de

r

ofvarious

p

e

r

so

n

s

6

-1

-

'

-----.

:

....-

-

------

-

---

-

-

-

--

::

---

-

Ne

xt

co

ur

s

e

o

f acti

o

n

r

Tr

a

ce the Idds

t

o e

st

a

b

l

is

h

t

he

ir b

e

neficiar

i

es

r

Trace the sour

c

e

of funds and establis

h

w

h

e

th

e

r

is a s

c

hem

e

t

o

hid

e s

a

l

es pr

o

ceeds

to evad

e

tax

.

f

I

I
L

·

'

r

'

r

D

e

t

e

rmine

the ext

e

nt

o

f

lia

bi

lit

y

and rec

o

mm

e

nd

a

p

propr

ia

te

ac

tion

.

7.

P

AOLO SAT

TA

N

I

I

\O

ACC

O

Ul

\

TS

a)

CA 0

1

-6

000

6 Approx

K

s

hs. 52 M

i

l

l

ion

in d

e

p

o

s

its

.

b)

CA 0

1

- 800145 Approx 4

0

,

8

0

8

,2

98

in d

e

posits

.

c)

CA 0

1

-

700

1

54

App

r

ox

7

1

2,200 in deposits.

r

No a

c

count

ope

n

ing

docume

n

ts

.

,

.

Acco

un

ts

h

e

l

d i

n

fo

r

eign

curre

n

cy

.

;,

..

W

i

thd

r

awals

mo

s

t

ly by Te

l

egraphic

tr

ansfer

s

.

(

Ne

xt c

o

ur

s

e

o

f a

c

t

io

n

"

.

r

E

s

tabli

s

h

t

he purpo

s

e

of the funds

t

ransferred

i

n

t

o his accounts

;

,

.

Establish

the tax implicatio

n

s

on

t

he activities

of

t

hese accoun

t

s.

/"

A

sses

s

appropriate

tax

;

;

-

Char

g

e

tho

s

e

re

s

pon

s

ible

[or

t

ax evas

i

on with

the

o

ffen

c

e

of c

o

mmitting

an

eC

O

nOl1lIC c

r

ime

;

,

.

Pur

s

u

e

the destination

of ti

l

e funds transferred

out of t

i

le a

c

count

b

y

t

e

l

eg

r

a

ph ar

,

e

s

tabli

s

h

wh

e

ther

an

y

laws have b

e

en con

t

rave

n

e

d

.

CO

N

CL

U

SION

Th

e

-

firs

t ph

a

s

e

o

f thi

s

exe

rci

se

f

o

c

u

se

d

o

n

t

h

e

fir

s

t three

co

mpani

es

wit

h

t

h

e

ann

o

f

inve

s

tigatin

g

a

l

legatio

n

s

o

f

VA

T

a

n

d

I

ncome

T

:

-

Ix

ev

a

sion

s

.

Th

e

t

h

r

ee

ar

e

:

i)

Creat

i

ve

I

n

n

ova

t

ion

s

ji)

\

V E Ti

l

l

ey

(

J

\lu

th:l

iga)

L

td

ii

i)

T

u

sker :-

'

l

at

tr

ess

cs

'7

I

-

v

The se

c

ond

p

hJ

SC of

t

hc i

nves

t

igations

will focu

s

o

n the

r

e

m

a

i

ning

f

ou

r e

nt

i

ties

w

i

t

h

t

h

c

a

i

m of unra

vel

in

g

t

h

c

net

work

of s

e

cret

ba

n

k accounts

w

i

t

h the

a

t

t

end

ant

tax ev

as

io

ns,

i

l

l

e

g

a

l

mo

n

ey

tra

nsfe

rs

and viol

a

tion

o

f banking

r

u

l

e

s

by

b

i

g b

us

i

nesses.

T

hi

s

se

cond

p

h

a

se

s

h

ou

ld

s

ta

rt a

s s

o

o

n

as th

e

fi

r

s

t

phase is c

o

ns

i

derably

con

cl

ude

d

.

Pr

e

p

a

r

e

d

b

y:

IIE

:

\RY

;

\I

l

\

l\YITIIIA

30

TII

N

OVE

I

\

IB

E

R

200

-

t

I

.'

1

-~

.

.

'

.

.••

L

,

\

I

l

~

.

r

I

'

OT

II

E

R

ENT

I

T

I

ES

Bank

a

cco

un

t

d

e

t

ails

we

r

e

so

u

gh

t

f

o

r

t

he

f

o

l

low

ing

enti

t

ies

and

bel

o

w

are

t

he

o

b

s

e

r

va

t

i

o

ns

fro

m t

he inform

ation

obtained

from

Char

t

crhousc

Bank

K

A

RI

U

KI

M

U

IG

U

A

&

CO

. (C

L

IE~TS

ACC

O

U

~TS)

C

h

ar

t

er

h

ouse

;\

l

a

n

ag

i

ng

D

irector

d

e

c

l

in

e

d

t

o

d

i

ndgc

any inf

or

mat

io

n

or d

o

c

u

ments

w

i

t

h

r

eg

ard

t

o

th

is account

ci

t

ing

a High Co

u

rt

ord

e

r

,

wh

i

c

h

h

e claimed,

bar

r

e

d h

i

m fron

:

di

sc

l

osi

n

g

an

y

inf

o

rm

a

ti

o

n

w

i

t

h

regar

d

to

t

he above

na

m

e

d

accounts

,

I

-

I

e cou

l

d o

n

ly

pr

o

du

c

e

a c

o

urt

o

r

de

r

ba

r

ring

ce

r

tai

n

r

es

p

onde

n

ts

fr

om a

c

cess

in

g

t

he

i

nf

o

rm

ati

o

n

wit

h

r

eg

ard

t

o

that ban

k

a

cco

unt

o

f

w

hi

c

h th

e

Ken

y

a An

t

i-C

o

rr

u

pti

o

n

Com

mi

ss

i

o

n

o

r

i

t

s agc

nt

wa

s

n

o

t

a

m

o

n

g

them

f

.

.

H

o

w

cv

er,

a

cco

rdin

g

t

o

d

oc

um

e

nt

s

a

v

ail

e

d

from

o

th

e

r

so

u

rce

s

w

ithin the ta

sk f

o

rc

e, o

n

e

of

th

e acco

unt

s,

CA 0

1

- 000563

r

e

cei

ve

d

d

e

p

os

it

s

a

m

ou

nt

ing

t

o Ks

h

s. 380

,

5

4

8,898

s

tartin

g

f

r

o

m

8

i

h

M

a

r

c

h

200

4 t

o

l

S

I

S

e

ptem

be

r

200

4

.

I

n

f

o

rm

a

ti

o

n

f

r

o

m t

he

s

a

m

e sou

r

ce

a

l

so

-

in

d

i

c

at

e

d

that the bank

ac

t

s o

n un

s

i

g

ned

in

s

tru

c

ti

o

n

s

su

pp

ose

dl

y

fr

om

Kar

iu

ki

f\

lui

g

ua

,

rai

si

n

g

th

e

p

oss

ibilit

y

th

a

t

t

h

e

in

s

tructi

o

n

s

ar

c

pr

e

p

a

r

ed

wi

t

h

in th

e

b

an

k

.

It i

s a

l

so

be

l

ieve

d

t

h

at th

e

a

cco

unt

i

s ac

tua

l

l

y

o

p

e

r

a

t

e

d

b

y so

m

e

o

f t

he

bi

g

b

us

i

nesses

in t

ow

n but

s

hi

e

ld

ed

by

th

e c

l

o

ak

o

f

c

li

e

nts

'

c

o

nfid

e

nti

a

lit

y.

L

a

t

es

t

devel

o

pments

r:

The bank

forwa

r

de

d

a

co

p

y o

f

a

n

o

th

e

r

hi

g

h

co

urt

o

rd

e

r b

a

rin

g

th

e

K

e

n

y

a A

nti

-

Corruption

Co

mmi

ssio

n

fr

o

m

i

nv

cs

t

iga

t

i

n

g

th

e a

cc

o

unt

.

>

Thi

s

later Hig

h

Co

urt

o

rd

e

r

h

a

s

n

o

t

bee

n

se

r

ve

d

o

n th

e Co

mm

issio

n

as a

t t

he

t

i

m

c

o

fJ

1

lakin

g

thi

s

r

e

p

o

rt

.

r

I

t i

s

beli

e

ved

that t

h

e a

c

c

o

unt

is operat

e

d

by big

b

usinesses

in t

ow

n t

hat d

e

posit

s

al

es procee

d

s

into th

e

a

ccou

n

t

and h

o

p

e

to hid

e

t

h

e

m

u

s

ing

t

he c

l

o

ak

o

f clien

t

's

co

nf

i

d

entia

lit

y

u

n

d

e

r the

advoc

at

es

a

c

t

.

Next c

o

u

rse

of actio

n

r

Awai: service of

t

he o

r

der

t

o determ

ine

thc ncx: c

ou

r

se o

fa

c

ti

o

l

l.

8

_

..

J

' .

I

Offence

likely

to he disclosed

Fail

ure

t

o

pay

t

axes b

y

t

h

e c

o

m

panies

us

in

g t

h

i

s acc

ou

nt

as

p

ara

lle

l

accou

n

ts

c

o

ntrary to

s

e

ct

io

n

4

5

(

1

)

(d) o

f t

he Anti-

Corru

p

ti

o

n

and Eco

n

om

ics

A

c

t of2

00

3

D SIL\H

ACCOCNT

I

,

.

L

'

~

Th

is

<lCCO

Ul

1

th

as

r

ec

e

i

ved

a

total

o

f

Ksh

s.

GOl,%8,1

7

1

.

33

i

n dep

o

sits

f

o

r

t

h

e pe

r

io

d

s

tartin

g

fr

0111

5

l

h

May 200

3 t

o 3

rJ

Novembe

r

200

4 m

ostly i

n

huge

c

as

h d

eposits

.

It

is

also

r

e

ilc

e

t

s

h

u

ge

ca

s

h

w

i

th

d

rawals

.

I

t

is be

li

e

v

e

d

t

ha

t t

he

r

elate

d

compan

i

es

use this accoun

t

as

a

sec

r

e

t p

a

ral

le

l

accoun

t

t

h

r

ough

wh

i

c

h

to hide sa

l

e

s pr

oceeds.

Th

e acco

u

n

t

o

pe

nin

g

d

oc

um

c

nt

s

c

o

uld n

o

t r

eve

al th

e ow

n

e

r

.

Additional

findings

r

So

m

e

o

f

th

e

d

e

p

os

it

s

h

ave

b

ee

n

es

t

ab

li

s

h

e

d

as cas

h

t

ransfe

r

s

from su

ndr

y

cr

e

dit

o

r

s.

r:

T

he

e

qui

v

al

e

nt

i

s

then tak

e

n

o

ut a

s

fdd i

ss

u

e

d

by o

r

de

r

o

f

1\

'

1r

.

D Shah

Next course

of action

I

..

(

"

'

;

-

Co

ll

ec

t

d

ebi

t

an

d

c

r

edi

t v

ouc

h

e

r

s

eff

e

ctin

g

e

nt

r

ie

s

into thi

s

a

c

c

o

unt

a

n

d est

abl

is

h

th

e so

ur

ce o

f th

e

fund

s

'

r

In

t

e

r

view

C

h

arte

rh

ouse

b

a

n

k o

ffi

c

i

a

l

s

and tr

y

t

o

trace th

e ow

n

e

r

o

f th

e

a

cco

unt

;

.

If a case

is es

t

a

bli

s

h

e

d

o

f

VA

T

a

nd Inc

o

me

Ta

x

e

v

a

s

ion

,

th

e

n

c

h

arg

e

t

h

e

com

p

ani

e

s

their dir

e

c

t

o

r

s

wit

h

co

mmittin

g

an

e

c

o

n

o

mic

cr

i

me

,

.

Tra

c

e the fdJ'

s

and try to e

s

tab

li

s

h

the

b

e

n

efic

i

aries

o

f t

he

tr

a

n

sfe

r

s

.

r

E

s

tabli

s

h

the

r

ea

l

so

ur

ce of

f

unds and dete

rm

ine

w

h

e

th

e

r

it i

s

a p

a

r

alle

l

a

c

c

o

u

nt t

o

h

id

e s

al

es

pr

o

c

ee

d

s

f

o

r c

o

mpani

e

s

.

»

:

As

s

e

ss

th

e i

n

fo

rmat

io

n

a

nd r

eco

mm

e

n

d

ap

p

r

op

riate

a

c

t

i

o

n

.

9

~

..

[

Offences

likely

to be disclosed

Ta

x evasio

n

co

ntr

ary

t

o secti

o

n

4

5

(

I

) (d) o

f

the An

ti-C

o

r

r

uption

and Ec

o

nomi

c

s

Crim

e

s

A

c

t

0

[2

00

3

I

SAILESII

I'RAJAPATI

ACCOUNT

CA 01 - 0

00148

Th

e b

ank cl

ai

m

ed

tha

t

a

c

c

o

unt-

o

p

e

n

in

g

d

o

cum

e

nts

in re

s

pect

to this a

cc

ount

w

e

re bu

r

n

t

dow

n

i

n a fi

re,

H

oweve

r

,

b

e

t

wee

n

2

"

d

1\

'

1

:

1y2

00

3

an

d

2

nJ

Aug

u

s

t

2

0

0

4

the

a

c

coun

t

r

e

c

eiv

e

d

Kshs.

551,518,102.25

in t

he

f

o

rm

o

f

h

u

ge

ca

s

h

de

p

osits

,

an

d

ch

e

ques

f

r

o

m

N

ak

u

mm

at

t

H

o

ldin

gs.

The a

cco

u

n

t

al

s

o

r

ef

l

ects

cas

h

w

i

t

h

d

ra

wa

l

s

in

a

n

usual

l

y

h

uge amoun

t

s

.

It is

b

e

lie

ve

d

th

a

t thi

s

i

s a

c

cou

nt

is

a

l

s

o u

se

d b

y

big b

us

in

ess

i

n t

ow

n l

i

k

e to hide sa

l

es

pro

cee

d

s

.

Ie

I

Additional

findings

r

.

Mo

s

t d

e

p

os

it

s

fro

m

Na

kum

a

tt

h

o

l

d

in

gs a

nd tr

ans

f

er

s

fr

o

m

s

u

n

d

r

y

c

r

edi

t

ors

.

:

r

.

1

1

1

on

e in

s

tan

ce

a

n

e

qui

va

l

ent

o

f th

e a

m

ou

nt

tr

a

n

s

f

e

rr

c

d

f

r

o

m

S

u

ndry

C

r

e

d

ito

r

s

i

s

tak

e

n out thr

o

u

g

h

fJJ

's

b

y o

rd

e

r

o

f

va

ri

o

u

s

p

e

r

so

n

s

Ne

xt course

of action

r

Co

ll

ec

t

d

e

bit

a

nd

c

r

e

dit v

o

uch

e

rs

eff

e

ctin

g

cntr

i

es into thi

s accou

nt

a

nd

e

s

t

ab

l

is

h

t

he so

u

rc

e

o

f

the fu

nd

s

;

;

.

Trace

t

he

Id

c

l'

s to es

t

ab

li

s

h

t

hei

r

be

n

ef

i

c

i

a

r

ie

s

r

Int

e

r

vi

e

w

C

h

ar

l

c

rh

o

u

se

b

ank of

fi

cia

l

s a

nd tr

y

t

o

tr

ace

th

e

O

W

1

1e

r

of

th

e ac

co

unt

r

If a ca

s

e

is e

s

t

ab

l

is

h

e

d

of VA

T

a

nd

In

co

me

Ta

x

e

va

s

i

o

n,

t

h

e

n

c

h

a

r

ge t

h

e

co

mpanies

th

e

ir dire

c

t

o

r

s

wit

h

co

mmitt

i

n

g

a

n

eco

n

o

m

ic

crim

e

.

P

AOL

O

SAT

L\

N

I

NO

ACC

O

UN

T

S

Iv

!

1

'

.

P

ao

l

o

Sa

tl

ani

n

o

operates

t

hr

ee

foreig

n

a

c

c

o

u

nt

s

wi

th

Chart

cr

h

ousc

Ba

n

k.

H

owe\'c\'c

r

,

t

h

e ba

n

k open

i

ng dOc

l

lIllents contains

t

he na

m

e o

f

Capr

i

c

o

rn

S

RL

T

he

ban

k

off

i

c

i

al

s

claime

d

t

ha

t

those

are

t

he docum

en

t

s

f

o

r

t

he

a

ccoun

t

.

Th

e

ba

nk opening

docllI

l

lents

arc

al1

acc

o

unt opening

J{J!1l1a

n

d

two lette

r

s s

igne

d b

y

P

aolo

Sat

tunino

one as

10

1

1

-

l

-

'

--------------

---

--

,

-

•

hirn

sc

l

f

a

nd the

o

t

he

r

as t

h

e Ma

n

ag

in

g

Di

rec

t

o

r

o

f

Cap

ri

c

o

rn

SR

L

.

T

he let

t

e

r

s a

u

t

h

o

ri

ze

t

he b

a

n

k to

a

c

t o

n

1

2 -

Ma

il

in

s

t

r

u

c

ti

o

n

s

fr

o

m the wri

t

e

r

.

The three a

c

count

s

ar

c:

-

1.

ACCO

U

~T

1

'

(0. CA

0

1 -

60

0

06

A

US

DOLLAR

ACCOU~T

[

i

I

.

A

sc

ruti

ny

o

f th

e

ban

k

stat

e

m

e

nt

r

e

v

ealed

that

the

abov

e

a

c

c

o

un

t

r

e

ceived

US

D

657,65

1

.

2

(

th

e eq

u

ivalent

of Ks

h

s,

52

mil

l

ion

)

be

t

ween

1

51

Ap

ri

l

2

00

4

and 3

rJ

No

v

e

m

be

r

200

4

b

y

w~

y o

f t

ran

s

f

e

r

m

o

s

tl

y

fr01

11 Cr

e

at

i

ve

Inn

o

va

t

i

o

ns

and K

i

ng

s

way

.

T

elegraphic

tran

s

f

e

r

o

f f

o

r

eig

n

e

x

c

h

a

nge

ta

k

e

s

ou

t

a

n

eq

ui

vale

nt

am

o

unt

t

o recipients

l

ike

s

eve

r

a

l

re

c

ipi

e

n

t

s

lik

e

Tra

dc

x

.

S

t

e

p

s

t

o he

un

de

rt

aken

?

E

s

tabl i

s

h the purp

os

e

o

f th

e

funds tran

s

f

e

rr

e

d

i

n

t

o

hi

s acc

o

unt

'

r

E

s

tabli

s

h

th

e

ta

x

impli

c

ati

o

n

s

o

n th

e ac

ti

v

i

t

i

es

o

f t

h

i

s acco

unt

.

r

l\

SS

CS

S

a

ppr

o

pr

ia

t

e

l

ax

)

....

Char

g

e

th

ose

r

es

p

o

n

s

i

bl

e

[

o

r t

ax

ev

a

s

i

o

n

\V

it11

t

h

e o

ff

e

n

ce

o

f

C0

I1

1

11

1

i

l

t

i

n

g

a

n

c

co

n

o

nuc

c

nrn

c

r

:

Pur

s

ue

th

e

d

e

s

t

i

nati

o

n

o

f th

e

funds tr

a

n

s

f

e

rr

e

d

o

ut

o

f th

e

a

cco

unt

by

t

e

l

eg

r

ap

h and

es

tabli

s

h

w

h

e

th

e

r

an

y laws

h

a

ve b

ee

n c

o

ntra

v

e

n

ed

.

2.

ACCO

U

NT

NO. C

1

\ 01 - 800

1

45

EU

R

O

ACCOUNT

(

T

h

is

a

cc

o

unt

r

ece

i

ve

d

a

t

o

tal

o

f

E

ur

o

s

392,3

8

7

.

4

9

(

the equival

e

nt

of K

s

h

s

,

40,

808,29

8

)

in

the

s

h

or

t p

e

r

io

d

be

t

ween

1

s

t

A

pri

l

200

4

a

nd

2

2

n

J

O

c

t

o

b

e

r

20

0

4.

Sim

i

l

a

rl

y

,

th

e

d

e

p

os

it

s

were

by way

of

tr

a

n

s

f

e

r

s

f

r

o

m Cr

ea

ti

v

e

Inn

o

v

a

ti

o

ns

and D Shah

acco

unts

,

D

e

bits in the

accoun

t

a by wa

y

o

f t

e

l

eg

raph

ic

tr

a

n

s

f

e

r

s

t

o fo

r

e

i

g

n de

s

tin

a

ti

o

n

s

.

S

t

e

p

s

to h

e

undertak

e

n

r

Es

t

a

bli

s

h

t

he p

u

r

po

s

e

o

f

t

h

e

f

unds

t

ransf

e

r

r

e

d

i

nt

o

h

i

s

a

c

c

o

unt

»

:

E

s

tabli

s

h

th

e

ta

x

impli

c

ati

o

n

s

o

n

th

e ac

t

i

v

i

t

i

es

o

f thi

s

a

c

co

u

nt

.

r

:

l

\

s

sess

ap

p

ropria

t

e

tax

r

C

h

a

r

ge

t

ho

s

e

r

e

s

p

onsib

l

e

f

o

r t

ax

ev

a

sio

n

w

i

th

t

h

e o

ff

e

n

ce

of co

m

m

i

t

tin

g

a

n

I

1

.

e

c

o

n

o

m

i

c

crrmc

~_

..

,

----.

:

....--

_-----------

f

J

Offc

n

c os

l

ike

l

y

to be disc

l

osed

Ta

x evas

i

on

co

ntrar

y

t

o sec

ti

o

n 4

5 (

1

) (d) o

f t

he An

ti

-Co

rr

u

pti

o

n

an

d

E

co

n

o

mi

cs

Crim

e

s

Ac

t

o

f

2003

1

r

SA

I

LES

II

PRAJAPATI

ACCO

UN

T

CA 01 - 000148

The bank cl

a

im

e

d

th

a

t

ac

c

o

u

n

t

-o

p

ening

document

s

in r

espec

t

t

o

th

i

s a

ccoun

t

we

r

e bu

r

n

t

do

w

n in a fire

.

H

o

wever,

b

e

tw

ee

n

2

/

l

d

1\

1

:

1

1'

2

003

a

n

d 2

n

d

Augu

s

t

2

00

4

the

a

ccoun

:

r

eceiv

ed

Kshs

.

551,5

1

8,102.25

in th

e

f

o

rm

of hu

g

e

c

as

h

d

e

po

s

its,

and

c

h

e

q

u

es

fr

o

m

Nak

umm

a

u

Holding

s

.

The account

al

s

o reflect

s

ca

s

h withdrawal

s

in an u

s

uall

y

hu

g

e

a

m

o

u

n

t

s.

It is

believed

that this

is account

is al

s

o u

s

ed b

y

big busine

s

s

in t

ow

n like to hid

e s

al

e

s

proce

e

d

s.

Addi

t

iona

l

f

indings

r

Mo

s

t depo

s

its

Ir

o

rn

Nakumau

holdin

g

s and tran

s

fers

fr

o

m

s

undr

y

cr

e

dit

o

r

s.

:,

:

..

1

1

1

o

ne in

s

tance

an equival

e

nt

of the amount

transf

e

rred

from

S

undr

y

C

re

dit

o

rs i

s

taken out throu

g

h

fJd's by ord

e

r of various per

so

n

s

Next cour

-

se of action

>

C

o

ll

e

ct

debit and credit vou

c

hers

effecting

entries into this ac

c

ount

and e

s

tabli

s

h

th

e s

our

c

e

o

f th

e

fund

s

:

r

T

ra

c

e th

e

fdd

s

t

o es

t

a

bli

s

h

th

e

ir b

e

neficiaries

r

In

t

e

r

v

i

ew

C

h

a

rt

c

rh

o

u

s

.

,

b

a

nk offici

a

l

s

and try to trace the oWl

~e

r

o

f the

acco

unt

r

I

f

a

ca

se

is

es

t

a

bli

s

h

e

d

of VAT

and

In

c

ome

Tax

evasi

o

n,

th

e

n

c

har

g

e th

e

co

mp

a

n

ies

th

ei

r dir

ec

t

o

r

s

with c

o

mmittin

g

an ec

o

n

o

mic

crime

.

PAOLO

SA

T

'

L\

N

INO

ACCOUNTS

Mr

.

Paolo

Sat

t

anino

operates

th

r

ee

fo

r

eig

n

accou

nt

s

w

ith

C

h~

l

r

ter

h

ou

sc

B

ank

.

H

owcvcv

c

-

the bank op

e

ning d

o

cuments

c

o

ntains

t

he name o

f Ca

p

ri

cor

n

S

RL

The

b

ank

official

s

claim

e

d

that

th

os

e

arc the d

oc

u

ments

f

o

r the accoun

t

.

T

he hank

o

pening

d

oc

uments

JI

'C

<In a

cco

unt

o

p

e

ni

n

g

f

o

rm

and t

wo lette

rs s

ign

e

d

by Pa

o

lo Sattun

i

n

o

, one as

10

'r

P

u

r

s

u

e

t

h

e

d

es

t

i

nati

o

n

of

t

he funds transf

e

r

r

c

d

ou

t

o

f th

e acco

u

n

t b

y

t

elegrap

h and

c

s

tah

li

s

h

wh

et

h

e

r

an

y

l

a

ws hav

e

been

c

o

ntravened

Off

e

nce

lik

e

l

y

t

o

b

e

di

scl

o

sed

1

.

Fai

l

ure

to p

J

.

y

tax

es contrary

to sectio

n

45

(

1 )

(d) o

f

the An

ti-C

o

rr

uptio

n

a

nd

E

cono

mi

cs

A

c

t

o

f

20

0

3

.

2

.

f

u

nd

s

tr

a

n

s

f

e

r

t

o sec

r

et de

s

tination.

Prepared

by:

H

ENR

Y

1

\1

l

\1\VITHIA

12

11

1

N

OVEMB

E

R

200

-

t

f

"

I

/

.

.

f

C

I

·

r

I

I

12