Wydawnictwo Helion
ul. Koœciuszki 1c
44-100 Gliwice
tel. 032 230 98 63
IDZ DO
IDZ DO
KATALOG KSI¥¯EK
KATALOG KSI¥¯EK
TWÓJ KOSZYK
TWÓJ KOSZYK
CENNIK I INFORMACJE
CENNIK I INFORMACJE
CZYTELNIA
CZYTELNIA
Thinking in Java. Edycja
polska. Wydanie IV
Poznaj najnowsz¹ wersjê jêzyka Java
• Opanuj zasady projektowania obiektowego
• Wykorzystaj Javê do tworzenia aplikacji
• Zastosuj najnowsze narzêdzia i techniki
Popularnoœæ Javy stale roœnie, a ka¿da nastêpna wersja tego jêzyka wnosi coœ nowego.
Poznanie wszystkich mo¿liwoœci drzemi¹cych w Javie wymaga siêgniêcia do
sprawdzonego Ÿród³a wiedzy — ksi¹¿ki „Thinking in Java”. To œwiatowy bestseller, który
zyska³ zas³u¿on¹ s³awê najlepszego podrêcznika do nauki Javy. Wzbudzi³ entuzjazm
i uznanie programistów przede wszystkim dziêki wyj¹tkowej przejrzystoœci,
przemyœlanej strukturze i trafnie dobranym przyk³adom.
Ksi¹¿ka „Thinking in Java. Edycja polska. Wydanie IV” zawiera szczegó³owe omówienie
zasad programowania w Javie. Przeznaczona jest dla pocz¹tkuj¹cych programistów
i dla ekspertów. Przystêpnie prezentuje zarówno zagadnienia podstawowe, jak
i zaawansowane. Dziesi¹tki przyk³adów u³atwiaj¹ zrozumienie ka¿dego tematu.
Wszystko to sprawia, ¿e poznajemy prawdziw¹ Javê — uniwersaln¹, czyteln¹,
niezale¿n¹ od platformy systemowej. Czytaj¹c tê ksi¹¿kê, dowiesz siê, co jest
niezbêdne do tworzenia wydajnych i bezpiecznych aplikacji w Javie.
• Projektowanie obiektowe
• Zasady dokumentowania kodu Ÿród³owego
• Operatory i sterowanie przebiegiem wykonywania programu
• Inicjalizacja i usuwanie obiektów
• Kolekcje obiektów
• Obs³uga b³êdów
• Operacje wejœcia i wyjœcia
• Programowanie wspó³bie¿ne
• Projektowanie interfejsów u¿ytkownika
Przekonaj siê, dlaczego ksi¹¿ka „Thinking in Java”
jest uznawana za najlepszy podrêcznik Javy dostêpny na rynku
Autor: Bruce Eckel
T³umaczenie: Przemys³aw Szeremiota
ISBN: 83-246-0111-2
Tytu³ orygina³u:
Thinking in Java (4th Edition)
Format: B5, stron: 1256
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?63,6GRF
3U]HGPRZD
:SURZDG]HQLH
5R]G]LDä :SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ
3RVW SXM FDDEVWUDNFMD
2ELHNWSRVLDGDLQWHUIHMV
2ELHNWGRVWDUF]DXVáXJL
8NU\ZDQLHLPSOHPHQWDFML
:LHORNURWQHZ\NRU]\VWDQLHLPSOHPHQWDFML
']LHG]LF]HQLH
Ä%\FLHF]\P ´DÄE\FLHSRGREQ\PGRF]HJR ´
:\PLHQLDOQR üRELHNWyZ]X \FLHPSROLPRUIL]PX
+LHUDUFKLD]SRMHG\QF]\PNRU]HQLHP
.RQWHQHU\
7\S\SDUDPHWU\]RZDQHW\S\RJyOQH
7ZRU]HQLHRELHNWyZLF]DVLFK \FLD
2EVáXJDZ\M WNyZ²HOLPLQRZDQLHEá GyZ
:VSyáELH QR ü
-DYDL,QWHUQHW
&]\PMHVWVLHü:::"
3URJUDPRZDQLHSRVWURQLHNOLHQWD
3URJUDPRZDQLHSRVWURQLHVHUZHUD
3RGVXPRZDQLH
5R]G]LDä :V]\VWNRMHVWRELHNWHP
'RVW SGRRELHNWyZSRSU]H]UHIHUHQFMH
:V]\VWNLHRELHNW\WU]HEDVWZRU]\ü
*G]LHSU]HFKRZXMHP\GDQH
3U]\SDGHNVSHFMDOQ\W\S\SRGVWDZRZH
7DEOLFHZ-DYLH
1LJG\QLHPDSRWU]HE\QLV]F]HQLDRELHNWX
=DVL J
=DVL JRELHNWyZ
:áDVQHW\S\GDQ\FK²VáRZRFODVV
3RODLPHWRG\
0HWRG\DUJXPHQW\LZDUWR FL]ZUDFDQH
/LVWDDUJXPHQWyZ
7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?63,6GRF
7ZRU]HQLHSURJUDPXZ-DYLH
:LGRF]QR üQD]Z
:\NRU]\VWDQLHLQQ\FKNRPSRQHQWyZ
6áRZRNOXF]RZHVWDWLF
7ZyMSLHUZV]\SURJUDPZ-DYLH
.RPSLODFMDLXUXFKRPLHQLH
.RPHQWDU]HRUD]GRNXPHQWRZDQLHNRGX
'RNXPHQWDFMDZNRPHQWDU]DFK
6NáDGQLD
2VDG]RQ\+70/
1LHNWyUH]QDF]QLNLGRNXPHQWDF\MQH
3U]\NáDGGRNXPHQWRZDQLDNRGX
6W\OSURJUDPRZDQLD
3RGVXPRZDQLH
ûZLF]HQLD
5R]G]LDä 2SHUDWRU\
3URVWDLQVWUXNFMDZ\M FLD
8 \ZDQLHRSHUDWRUyZ-DY\
.ROHMQR üRSHUDWRUyZ
3U]\SLVDQLH
7ZRU]HQLHQD]ZZZ\ZRáDQLDFKPHWRG
2SHUDWRU\PDWHPDW\F]QH
-HGQRDUJXPHQWRZHRSHUDWRU\PLQXVLSOXV
2SHUDWRU\]ZL NV]DQLDL]PQLHMV]DQLD
2SHUDWRU\UHODFML
6SUDZG]DQLHUyZQR FLRELHNWyZ
2SHUDWRU\ORJLF]QH
6NUDFDQLHREOLF]HQLDZ\UD HQLDORJLF]QHJR
/LWHUDá\
=DSLVZ\NáDGQLF]\
2SHUDWRU\ELWRZH
2SHUDWRU\SU]HVXQL ü
2SHUDWRUWUyMDUJXPHQWRZ\LIHOVH
2SHUDWRU\L GODNODV\6WULQJ
1DMF] VWV]HSXáDSNLSU]\X \ZDQLXRSHUDWRUyZ
2SHUDWRU\U]XWRZDQLD
2EFLQDQLHD]DRNU JODQLH
3URPRFMDW\SX
:-DYLHQLHPDÄVL]HRI´
.RPSHQGLXPRSHUDWRUyZ
3RGVXPRZDQLH
5R]G]LDä 6WHURZDQLHSU]HELHJLHPZ\NRQDQLD
3UDZGDLIDáV]
LIHOVH
,WHUDFMD
GRZKLOH
IRU
2SHUDWRUSU]HFLQND
6NáDGQLDIRUHDFK
UHWXUQ
EUHDNLFRQWLQXH
1LHVáDZQHÄJRWR´
VZLWFK
3RGVXPRZDQLH
6SLVWUH FL
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?63,6GRF
5R]G]LDä ,QLFMDOL]DFMDLVSU]ñWDQLH
*ZDUDQWRZDQDLQLFMDOL]DFMDSU]H]NRQVWUXNWRU
3U]HFL DQLHPHWRG
5R]Uy QLDQLHSU]HFL RQ\FKPHWRG
3U]HFL DQLHDW\S\SRGVWDZRZH
3U]HFL DQLHSU]H]ZDUWR FL]ZUDFDQH
.RQVWUXNWRU\GRP\ OQH
6áRZRNOXF]RZHWKLV
:\ZRá\ZDQLHNRQVWUXNWRUyZ]NRQVWUXNWRUyZ
=QDF]HQLHVáRZDVWDWLF
6SU] WDQLHILQDOL]DFMDLRG PLHFDQLHSDPL FL
'RF]HJRVáX \ILQDOL]H
0XVLV]SU]HSURZDG]LüVSU] WDQLH
:DUXQHN]DNR F]HQLD
-DNG]LDáDRG PLHFDF]SDPL FL
,QLFMDOL]DFMDVNáDGRZ\FK
2NUH ODQLHVSRVREXLQLFMDOL]DFML
,QLFMDOL]DFMDZNRQVWUXNWRU]H
.ROHMQR üLQLFMDOL]DFML
,QLFMDOL]DFMD]PLHQQ\FKVWDW\F]Q\FK
-DZQDLQLFMDOL]DFMDVWDW\F]QD
,QLFMDOL]DFMDHJ]HPSODU]D
,QLFMDOL]DFMDWDEOLF
=PLHQQHOLVW\DUJXPHQWyZ
7\S\Z\OLF]HQLRZH
3RGVXPRZDQLH
5R]G]LDä .RQWURODGRVWöSX
3DNLHW²MHGQRVWNDELEOLRWHF]QD
2UJDQL]DFMDNRGX
7ZRU]HQLHXQLNDWRZ\FKQD]ZSDNLHWyZ
:áDVQDELEOLRWHNDQDU] G]LRZD
:\NRU]\VWDQLHLQVWUXNFMLLPSRUWGR]PLDQ\]DFKRZDQLD
3XáDSND]ZL ]DQD]SDNLHWDPL
0RG\ILNDWRU\GRVW SXZ-DYLH
'RVW SSDNLHWRZ\
SXEOLFGRVW SGRLQWHUIHMVX
SULYDWHQLHGRW\NDü
SURWHFWHGGRVW SÄQDSRWU]HE\´G]LHG]LF]HQLD
,QWHUIHMVLLPSOHPHQWDFMD
'RVW SGRNODV
3RGVXPRZDQLH
5R]G]LDä :LHORNURWQHZ\NRU]\VWDQLHNODV
6NáDGQLDNRPSR]\FML
6NáDGQLDG]LHG]LF]HQLD
,QLFMDOL]DFMDNODV\ED]RZHM
'HOHJDFMH
à F]HQLHNRPSR]\FMLLG]LHG]LF]HQLD
=DSHZQLHQLHSRSUDZQHJRVSU] WDQLD
8NU\ZDQLHQD]Z
:\EyUPL G]\NRPSR]\FM DG]LHG]LF]HQLHP
SURWHFWHG
5]XWRZDQLHZJyU
'ODF]HJRÄZJyU ´
-HV]F]HRNRPSR]\FMLLG]LHG]LF]HQLX
7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?63,6GRF
6áRZRNOXF]RZHILQDO
=PLHQQHILQDOQH
0HWRG\ILQDOQH
.ODV\ILQDOQH
2VWUR QLH]GHNODUDFM ILQDO
,QLFMDOL]DFMDLáDGRZDQLHNODV
,QLFMDOL]DFMDZSU]\SDGNXG]LHG]LF]HQLD
3RGVXPRZDQLH
5R]G]LDä 3ROLPRUIL]P
5]XWRZDQLHZJyU UD]MHV]F]H
=DSRPLQDQLHRW\SLHRELHNWX
0Dá\WULN
:L ]DQLHZ\ZRáDQLDPHWRG\
8]\VNLZDQLHSRSUDZQHJRG]LDáDQLD
5R]V]HU]DOQR ü
3XáDSNDÄSU]HVáDQLDQLH´PHWRGSU\ZDWQ\FK
3XáDSNDVWDW\F]QHSRODLPHWRG\
.RQVWUXNWRU\DSROLPRUIL]P
.ROHMQR üZ\ZRáD NRQVWUXNWRUyZ
']LHG]LF]HQLHDVSU] WDQLH
=DFKRZDQLHPHWRGSROLPRUILF]Q\FKZHZQ WU]NRQVWUXNWRUyZ
.RZDULDQFMDW\SyZ]ZUDFDQ\FK
3URMHNWRZDQLH]X \FLHPG]LHG]LF]HQLD
6XEVW\WXFMDNRQWUDUR]V]HU]DQLH
5]XWRZDQLHZGyáDLGHQW\ILNDFMDW\SXZF]DVLHZ\NRQDQLD
3RGVXPRZDQLH
5R]G]LDä ,QWHUIHMV\
.ODV\LPHWRG\DEVWUDNF\MQH
,QWHUIHMV\
5R]G]LHOHQLH]XSHáQH
Ä']LHG]LF]HQLHZLHORED]RZH´Z-DYLH
5R]V]HU]DQLHLQWHUIHMVXSRSU]H]G]LHG]LF]HQLH
.ROL]MHQD]ZSRGF]DVá F]HQLDLQWHUIHMVyZ
$GDSWRZDQLHGRLQWHUIHMVX
3RODZLQWHUIHMVDFK
,QLFMDOL]DFMDSyOLQWHUIHMVyZ
=DJQLH G DQLHLQWHUIHMVyZ
,QWHUIHMV\DZ\WZyUQLH
3RGVXPRZDQLH
5R]G]LDä .ODV\ZHZQöWU]QH
7ZRU]HQLHNODVZHZQ WU]Q\FK
3Rá F]HQLH]NODV ]HZQ WU]Q
WKLVLQHZ
.ODV\ZHZQ WU]QHDU]XWRZDQLHZJyU
.ODV\ZHZQ WU]QHZPHWRGDFKL]DVL JDFK
$QRQLPRZHNODV\ZHZQ WU]QH
-HV]F]HRZ]RUFX)DFWRU\0HWKRG
.ODV\]DJQLH G RQH
.ODV\ZHZQ WU]LQWHUIHMVyZ
6L JDQLHQD]HZQ WU]]NODV\ZLHORNURWQLH]DJQLH G RQHM
6SLVWUH FL
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?63,6GRF
'ODF]HJRNODV\ZHZQ WU]QH
'RPNQL FLDLZ\ZRáDQLD]ZURWQH
.ODV\ZHZQ WU]QHDV]NLHOHW\VWHURZDQLD
']LHG]LF]HQLHSRNODVDFKZHZQ WU]Q\FK
&]\NODV\ZHZQ WU]QHPRJ E\üSU]HVáDQLDQH"
/RNDOQHNODV\ZHZQ WU]QH
,GHQW\ILNDWRU\NODVZHZQ WU]Q\FK
3RGVXPRZDQLH
5R]G]LDä .ROHNFMHRELHNWÑZ
.RQWHQHU\W\SRZDQHLXRJyOQLRQH
3RM FLDSRGVWDZRZH
'RGDZDQLHJUXSHOHPHQWyZ
:\SLV\ZDQLH]DZDUWR FLNRQWHQHUyZ
,QWHUIHMV/LVW
,QWHUIHMV,WHUDWRU
,QWHUIHMV/LVW,WHUDWRU
.ODVD/LQNHG/LVW
.ODVD6WDFN
,QWHUIHMV6HW
,QWHUIHMV0DS
,QWHUIHMV4XHXH
3ULRULW\4XHXH
&ROOHFWLRQNRQWUD,WHUDWRU
,WHUDWRU\DS WOHIRUHDFK
,GLRPPHWRG\DGDSWHUD
3RGVXPRZDQLH
5R]G]LDä 2EVäXJDEäöGÑZ]DSRPRFñZ\MñWNÑZ
=DU\VNRQFHSFML
3RGVWDZ\REVáXJLZ\M WNyZ
$UJXPHQW\Z\M WNyZ
3U]HFKZ\W\ZDQLHZ\M WNX
%ORNWU\
2EVáXJDZ\M WNyZ
7ZRU]HQLHZáDVQ\FKZ\M WNyZ
5HMHVWURZDQLHZ\M WNyZ
6SHF\ILNDFMDZ\M WNyZ
3U]HFKZ\W\ZDQLHGRZROQHJRZ\M WNX
6WRVZ\ZRáD
3RQRZQHZ\U]XFDQLHZ\M WNyZ
6HNZHQFMHZ\M WNyZ
6WDQGDUGRZHZ\M WNL-DY\
3U]\SDGHNVSHFMDOQ\5XQWLPH([FHSWLRQ
5RELHQLHSRU] GNyZZILQDOO\
'RF]HJRVáX \ILQDOO\
:VSyáG]LDáDQLHILQDOO\]UHWXUQ
3XáDSND]DJXELRQ\Z\M WHN
2JUDQLF]HQLDZ\M WNyZ
.RQVWUXNWRU\
'RSDVRZ\ZDQLHZ\M WNyZ
5R]ZL ]DQLDDOWHUQDW\ZQH
+LVWRULD
3HUVSHNW\Z\
7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?63,6GRF
3U]HND]\ZDQLHZ\M WNyZQDNRQVRO
=DPLDQDZ\M WNyZVSUDZG]DQ\FKQDQLHVSUDZG]DQH
:VND]yZNL
3RGVXPRZDQLH
5R]G]LDä&LñJL]QDNÑZ
1LH]PLHQQR üFL JyZ]QDNRZ\FK
6WULQJ%XLOGHUNRQWUDSU]HFL RQ\RSHUDWRUµ¶
1LH]DPLHU]RQDUHNXUVMD
2SHUDFMHQDHJ]HPSODU]DFKNODV\6WULQJ
)RUPDWRZDQLHZ\M FLD
)XQNFMDSULQWI
6\VWHPRXWIRUPDW
.ODVD)RUPDWWHU
6SHF\ILNDWRU\IRUPDWX
.RQZHUVMH
0HWRGD6WULQJIRUPDW
:\UD HQLDUHJXODUQH
3RGVWDZ\
7ZRU]HQLHZ\UD H UHJXODUQ\FK
.ZDQW\ILNDWRU\
.ODV\3DWWHUQRUD]0DWFKHU
PHWRGDVSOLW
2SHUDFMH]DVW SRZDQLD
0HWRGDUHVHW
:\UD HQLDUHJXODUQHLRSHUDFMHZHM FLDZ\M FLD-DY\
6NDQRZDQLHZHM FLD
6HSDUDWRU\ZDUWR FLZHM FLRZ\FK
6NDQRZDQLHZHM FLDSU]\X \FLXZ\UD H UHJXODUQ\FK
.ODVD6WULQJ7RNHQL]HU
3RGVXPRZDQLH
5R]G]LDä ,QIRUPDFMHRW\SDFK
3RWU]HEDPHFKDQL]PX577,
2ELHNW&ODVV
/LWHUDá\&ODVV
5HIHUHQFMHNODVXRJyOQLRQ\FK
1RZDVNáDGQLDU]XWRZDQLD
6SUDZG]DQLHSU]HGU]XWRZDQLHP
8 \FLHOLWHUDáyZNODV
'\QDPLF]QHLQVWDQFHRI
=OLF]DQLHUHNXUHQF\MQH
:\WZyUQLHUHMHVWURZDQH
LQVWDQFHRIDUyZQRZD QR üRELHNWyZ&ODVV
5HIOHNVMD²LQIRUPDFMDRNODVLHZF]DVLHZ\NRQDQLD
(NVWUDNWRUPHWRG
'\QDPLF]QHSUR[\
2ELHNW\SXVWH
,PLWDFMHL]DO NL
,QWHUIHMV\D577,
3RGVXPRZDQLH
6SLVWUH FL
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?63,6GRF
5R]G]LDä 7\S\RJÑOQH
3RUyZQDQLH]M ]\NLHP&
3URVWHXRJyOQLHQLD
%LEOLRWHNDNURWHN
.ODVDVWRVX
5DQGRP/LVW
8RJyOQLDQLHLQWHUIHMVyZ
8RJyOQLDQLHPHWRG
:\NRU]\VW\ZDQLHGHGXNFMLW\SXDUJXPHQWX
0HWRG\XRJyOQLRQH]H]PLHQQ\PLOLVWDPLDUJXPHQWyZ
0HWRGDXRJyOQLRQDZVáX ELHNODV\*HQHUDWRU
8QLZHUVDOQ\*HQHUDWRU
8SUDV]F]DQLHVWRVRZDQLDNURWHN
8QLZHUVDOQ\NRQWHQHU6HW
$QRQLPRZHNODV\ZHZQ WU]QH
%XGRZDQLHPRGHOL]áR RQ\FK
7DMHPQLFD]DFLHUDQLD
-DNWRVL URELZ&
6áRZRR]JRGQR FLPLJUDFML
.áRSRWOLZR ü]DFLHUDQLD
1DNUDZ G]L
.RPSHQVDFMD]DFLHUDQLD
7ZRU]HQLHHJ]HPSODU]\W\SyZ
7DEOLFHW\SyZRJyOQ\FK
5DP\
6\PEROHZLHOR]QDF]QH
-DNE\VWU\MHVWNRPSLODWRU"
.RQWUDZDULDQFMD
6\PEROHZLHOR]QDF]QHEH]UDPNRQNUHW\]DFML
.RQZHUVMD]SU]HFKZ\FHQLHPW\SX
3UREOHP\
7\S\SRGVWDZRZHMDNRSDUDPHWU\W\SRZH
,PSOHPHQWRZDQLHLQWHUIHMVyZSDUDPHWU\]RZDQ\FK
2VWU]H HQLDSU]\U]XWRZDQLX
3U]HFL DQLH
=DZáDV]F]HQLHLQWHUIHMVXZNODVLHED]RZHM
7\S\VDPRVNLHURZDQH
2VREOLZDUHNXUHQFMDXRJyOQLHQLD
6DPRVNLHURZDQLH
.RZDULDQFMDDUJXPHQWyZ
'\QDPLF]QDNRQWURODW\SyZ
:\M WNL
'RPLHV]NL
'RPLHV]NLZ&
'RPLHV]NL]X \FLHPLQWHUIHMVyZ
=DVWRVRZDQLHZ]RUFDSURMHNWRZHJR'HFRUDWRU
'RPLHV]NLZSRVWDFLG\QDPLF]Q\FKSUR[\
7\SRZDQLHXWDMRQH
.RPSHQVDFMDEUDNXW\SRZDQLDXWDMRQHJR
5HIOHNVMD
$SOLNRZDQLHPHWRG\GRVHNZHQFMLRELHNWyZ
.LHG\QLHPDSRGU N RGSRZLHGQLHJRLQWHUIHMVX
6\PXORZDQLHW\SRZDQLDXWDMRQHJR]DSRPRF DGDSWHUyZ
7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?63,6GRF
2ELHNW\IXQNF\MQHZUROLVWUDWHJLL
3RGVXPRZDQLH²F]\U]XWRZDQLHMHVWD WDN]áH"
'DOV]DOHNWXUD
5R]G]LDä 7DEOLFH
&RZQLFKWDNLHJRVSHFMDOQHJR"
7DEOLFHWRSHáQRSUDZQHRELHNW\
7DEOLFHZUROLZDUWR FL]ZUDFDQ\FK
7DEOLFHZLHORZ\PLDURZH
7DEOLFHDW\S\RJyOQH
:\WZDU]DQLHGDQ\FKWHVWRZ\FK
0HWRGD$UUD\VILOO
*HQHUDWRU\GDQ\FK
7ZRU]HQLHWDEOLF]DSRPRF JHQHUDWRUyZ
1DU] G]LDNODV\$UUD\V
.RSLRZDQLHWDEOLF
3RUyZQ\ZDQLHWDEOLF
3RUyZQ\ZDQLHHOHPHQWyZWDEOLF
6RUWRZDQLHWDEOLF
3U]HV]XNLZDQLHWDEOLF\SRVRUWRZDQHM
3RGVXPRZDQLH
5R]G]LDä .RQWHQHU\]EOLVND
3HáQDWDNVRQRPLDNRQWHQHUyZ
:\SHáQLDQLHNRQWHQHUyZ
5R]ZL ]DQLH]JHQHUDWRUHP
*HQHUDWRU\GODNRQWHQHUyZDVRFMDF\MQ\FK
6WRVRZDQLHNODVDEVWUDNF\MQ\FK
,QWHUIHMV&ROOHFWLRQ
2SHUDFMHRSFMRQDOQH
2SHUDFMHQLHREVáXJLZDQH
,QWHUIHMV/LVW
.RQWHQHU\6HWDNROHMQR üHOHPHQWyZ
6RUWHG6HW
.ROHMNL
.ROHMNLSULRU\WHWRZH
.ROHMNLGZXNLHUXQNRZH
.RQWHQHU\DVRFMDF\MQH
:\GDMQR ü
6RUWHG0DS
/LQNHG+DVK0DS
+DV]RZDQLHLNRG\KDV]XM FH
=DVDGDG]LDáDQLDKDVK&RGH
+DV]RZDQLHDV]\ENR ü
3U]HVáRQL FLHPHWRG\KDVK&RGH
:\EyULPSOHPHQWDFML
,QIUDVWUXNWXUDWHVWRZD
:\ELHUDQLHSRPL G]\OLVWDPL
=DJUR HQLDWHVWRZDQLDZPDáHMVNDOL
:\ELHUDQLHSRPL G]\]ELRUDPL
:\ELHUDQLHSRPL G]\RGZ]RURZDQLDPL
1DU] G]LDGRGDWNRZH
6RUWRZDQLHLSU]HV]XNLZDQLHOLVW
1LHPRG\ILNRZDOQHNRQWHQHU\&ROOHFWLRQL0DS
6\QFKURQL]DFMD&ROOHFWLRQL0DS
6SLVWUH FL
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?63,6GRF
3U]HFKRZ\ZDQLHUHIHUHQFML
:HDN+DVK0DS
.RQWHQHU\-DYDL
9HFWRUL(QXPHUDWLRQ
+DVKWDEOH
6WDFN
%LW6HW
3RGVXPRZDQLH
5R]G]LDä:HM FLHZ\M FLH
.ODVD)LOH
:\SLV\ZDQLH]DZDUWR FLNDWDORJX
1DU] G]LHGRSU]HJO GDQLDNDWDORJyZ
7ZRU]HQLHNDWDORJyZLVSUDZG]DQLHLFKREHFQR FL
:HM FLHLZ\M FLH
7\S\,QSXW6WUHDP
7\S\2XWSXW6WUHDP
'RGDZDQLHDWU\EXWyZLX \WHF]Q\FKLQWHUIHMVyZ
2GF]\W],QSXW6WUHDP]DSRPRF )LOWHU,QSXW6WUHDP
=DSLVGR2XWSXW6WUHDP]DSRPRF )LOWHU2XWSXW6WUHDP
.ODV\5HDGHUL:ULWHU
UyGáDLXM FLDGDQ\FK
0RG\ILNDFMD]DFKRZDQLDVWUXPLHQLD
.ODV\QLH]PLHQLRQH
2VREQDLVDPRG]LHOQD5DQGRP$FFHVV)LOH
7\SRZH]DVWRVRZDQLDVWUXPLHQLZHM FLDZ\M FLD
%XIRURZDQ\SOLNZHM FLD
:HM FLH]SDPL FL
)RUPDWRZDQHZHM FLH]SDPL FL
:\M FLHGRSOLNX
3U]HFKRZ\ZDQLHLRG]\VNLZDQLHGDQ\FK
2GF]\WL]DSLVGRSOLNyZRGRVW SLHVZRERGQ\P
6WUXPLHQLHSRWRNL
1DU] G]LDGR]DSLVXLRGF]\WXGDQ\FK]SOLNyZ
2GF]\WSOLNyZELQDUQ\FK
6WDQGDUGRZHZHM FLHZ\M FLH
&]\WDQLH]HVWDQGDUGRZHJRZHM FLD
=DPLDQD6\VWHPRXWQD3ULQW:ULWHU
3U]HNLHURZ\ZDQLHVWDQGDUGRZHJRZHM FLDZ\M FLD
6WHURZDQLHSURFHVDPL]HZQ WU]Q\PL
1RZHZHM FLHZ\M FLH
.RQZHUVMDGDQ\FK
3RELHUDQLHSRGVWDZRZ\FKW\SyZGDQ\FK
:LGRNLEXIRUyZ
0DQLSXORZDQLHGDQ\PLSU]\X \FLXEXIRUyZ
6]F]HJyáRZHLQIRUPDFMHREXIRUDFK
3OLNLRGZ]RURZ\ZDQHZSDPL FL
%ORNRZDQLHSOLNyZ
.RPSUHVMD
3URVWDNRPSUHVMDGRIRUPDWX*=,3
3U]HFKRZ\ZDQLHZLHOXSOLNyZZIRUPDFLH=LS
$UFKLZD-DY\-$5
7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?63,6GRF
6HULDOL]DFMDRELHNWyZ
2GQDMG\ZDQLHNODV\
.RQWURODVHULDOL]DFML
6WRVRZDQLHWUZDáR FL
;0/
3UHIHUHQFMH
3RGVXPRZDQLH
5R]G]LDä 7\S\Z\OLF]HQLRZH
3RGVWDZRZHFHFK\W\SyZZ\OLF]HQLRZ\FK
:\OLF]HQLDDLPSRUW\VWDW\F]QH
'RGDZDQLHPHWRGGRW\SyZZ\OLF]HQLRZ\FK
3U]HVáDQLDQLHPHWRGW\SXZ\OLF]HQLRZHJR
:\OLF]HQLDZLQVWUXNFMDFKZ\ERUX
7DMHPQLFDPHWRG\YDOXHV
,PSOHPHQWXMHQLHG]LHG]LF]\
:\EyUORVRZ\
2UJDQL]DFMDQDED]LHLQWHUIHMVyZ
(QXP6HW]DPLDVW]QDF]QLNyZ
6WRVRZDQLHNODV\(QXP0DS
0HWRG\VSHFMDOL]RZDQHGODHOHPHQWyZZ\OLF]HQLD
7\S\Z\OLF]HQLRZHZáD FXFKXRGSRZLHG]LDOQR FL
7\S\Z\OLF]HQLRZHDDXWRPDW\VWDQyZ
5R]SURZDG]DQLHZLHORNURWQH
5R]SURZDG]DQLH]XG]LDáHPW\SyZZ\OLF]HQLRZ\FK
6WRVRZDQLHPHWRGVSHFMDOL]RZDQ\FKGODHOHPHQWyZZ\OLF]HQLD
5R]SURZDG]DQLH]DSRPRF (QXP0DS
=WDEOLF GZXZ\PLDURZ
3RGVXPRZDQLH
5R]G]LDä $GQRWDFMH
3RGVWDZ\VNáDGQLDGQRWDFML
'HILQLRZDQLHDGQRWDFML
0HWDDGQRWDFMH
3URFHVRU\DGQRWDFML
(OHPHQW\DGQRWDFML
2JUDQLF]HQLDZDUWR FLGRP\ OQ\FK
*HQHURZDQLHSOLNyZ]HZQ WU]Q\FK
$GQRWDFMHQLHGDM VL G]LHG]LF]\ü
,PSOHPHQWRZDQLHSURFHVRUD
3U]HWZDU]DQLHDGQRWDFML]DSRPRF DSW
3URJUDPDSWDZL]\WDFMH
$GQRWDFMHZWHVWRZDQLXMHGQRVWNRZ\P
#8QLWDW\S\RJyOQH
,PSOHPHQWDFMD#8QLW
8VXZDQLHNRGXWHVWXM FHJR
3RGVXPRZDQLH
5R]G]LDä :VSÑäELH QR è
2EOLF]DZVSyáELH QR FL
6]\EV]HZ\NRQDQLH
8OHSV]DQLHSURMHNWX
3RGVWDZ\ZLHORZ WNRZR FL
'HILQLRZDQLH]DGD
.ODVD7KUHDG
:\NRQDZF\
6SLVWUH FL
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?63,6GRF
=ZUDFDQLHZDUWR FL]]DGD
8V\SLDQLH²ZVWU]\P\ZDQLHZ WNX
3ULRU\WHWZ WNX
3U]Há F]DQLH
: WNLGHPRQ\
:DULDFMHQDWHPDWZ WNyZ
7HUPLQRORJLD
à F]HQLHZ WNyZ
7ZRU]HQLHUHDNW\ZQHJRLQWHUIHMVXX \WNRZQLND
*UXS\Z WNyZ
3U]HFKZ\W\ZDQLHZ\M WNyZ
:VSyáG]LHOHQLH]DVREyZ
1LHZáD FLZ\GRVW SGR]DVREyZ
5R]VWU]\JDQLHZVSyá]DZRGQLFWZDR]DVRE\ZVSyáG]LHORQH
$WRPRZR üLZLGRF]QR ü
.ODV\ÄDWRPRZH´
6HNFMHNU\W\F]QH
6\QFKURQL]DFMDGRVW SXQDED]LHLQQ\FKRELHNWyZ
/RNDOQDSDPL üZ WNX
3U]HU\ZDQLHZ\NRQDQLD]DGD
2JUyGERWDQLF]Q\V\PXODFMD
3U]HU\ZDQLH]DEORNRZDQHJRZ WNX
:\PXV]DQLHSU]HUZDQLDZ\NRQDQLD
6SUDZG]DQLHSU]HUZDQLD
:VSyáG]LDáDQLHZ WNyZ
0HWRG\ZDLWLQRWLI\$OO
QRWLI\NRQWUDQRWLI\$OO
3URGXFHQFLLNRQVXPHQFL
3URGXFHQFLNRQVXPHQFLLNROHMNL
3U]HND]\ZDQLHGDQ\FKSRPL G]\]DGDQLDPL]DSRPRF SRWRNyZ
=DNOHV]F]HQLH
1RZHNRPSRQHQW\ELEOLRWHF]QH
&RXQW'RZQ/DWFK
&\FOLF%DUULHU
'HOD\4XHXH
3ULRULW\%ORFNLQJ4XHXH
6WHURZDQLHV]NODUQL ²SODQRZDQLHXUXFKDPLDQLD]DGD
6HPDSKRUH
([FKDQJHU
6\PXODFMH
6\PXODFMDRNLHQNDNDVRZHJR
6\PXODFMDVDOLUHVWDXUDF\MQHM
5R]G]LHODQLH]DGD
:\GDMQR ü
3RUyZQDQLHWHFKQRORJLLPXWHNVyZ
.RQWHQHU\EH]EORNDG
%ORNRZDQLHRSW\PLVW\F]QH
%ORNDG\5HDG:ULWH/RFN
2ELHNW\DNW\ZQH
3RGVXPRZDQLH
'DOV]DOHNWXUD
7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?63,6GRF
5R]G]LDä *UDILF]QHLQWHUIHMV\X \WNRZQLND
$SOHW\
3RGVWDZ\ELEOLRWHNL6ZLQJ
3ODWIRUPDSUH]HQWDF\MQD
7ZRU]HQLHSU]\FLVNX
3U]HFKZ\W\ZDQLH]GDU]HQLD
2EV]DU\WHNVWRZH
5R]PLHV]F]DQLHHOHPHQWyZLQWHUIHMVX
%RUGHU/D\RXW
)ORZ/D\RXW
*ULG/D\RXW
*ULG%DJ/D\RXW
3R]\FMRQRZDQLHEH]SR UHGQLH
%R[/D\RXW
1DMOHSV]HUR]ZL ]DQLH"
0RGHO]GDU]H Z6ZLQJX
5RG]DMH]GDU]H LRGELRUQLNyZ
OHG]HQLHZLHOX]GDU]H
:\EUDQHNRPSRQHQW\6ZLQJ
3U]\FLVNL
,NRQ\
3RGSRZLHG]L
3RODWHNVWRZH
5DPNL
0LQLHG\WRU
3RODZ\ERUX
3U]\FLVNLZ\ERUX
/LVW\UR]ZLMDQH
/LVW\
=DNáDGNL
2NQDNRPXQLNDWyZ
0HQX
0HQXNRQWHNVWRZH
5\VRZDQLH
2NQDGLDORJRZH
2NQDGLDORJRZHSOLNyZ
+70/ZNRPSRQHQWDFK6ZLQJ
6XZDNLLZVND QLNLSRVW SX
=PLDQDVW\OXLQWHUIHMVX
'U]HZNDWDEHOHLVFKRZHN
-1/3RUD]-DYD:HE6WDUW
6ZLQJDZVSyáELH QR ü
=DGDQLDGáXJRWUZDáH
:L]XDOL]DFMDZLHORZ WNRZR FLLQWHUIHMVXX \WNRZQLND
3URJUDPRZDQLHZL]XDOQHLNRPSRQHQW\-DYD%HDQ
&]\PMHVWNRPSRQHQW-DYD%HDQ"
:\GRE\FLHLQIRUPDFMLRNRPSRQHQFLHSRSU]H]NODV ,QWURVSHFWRU
%DUG]LHMZ\V]XNDQ\NRPSRQHQW
.RPSRQHQW\-DYD%HDQLV\QFKURQL]DFMD
3DNRZDQLHNRPSRQHQWX-DYD%HDQ
%DUG]LHM]áR RQDREVáXJDNRPSRQHQWyZ-DYD%HDQ
:L FHMRNRPSRQHQWDFK-DYD%HDQ
$OWHUQDW\Z\ZREHFELEOLRWHNL6ZLQJ
6SLVWUH FL
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?63,6GRF
)OH[²DSOLNDFMHNOLHQFNLHZIRUPDFLH)ODVK
$KRM)OH[
.RPSLORZDQLH0;0/
0;0/LVNU\SW\$FWLRQ6FULSW
.RQWHQHU\LNRQWURONL
(IHNW\LVW\OH
=GDU]HQLD
3Rá F]HQLH]-DY
0RGHOHGDQ\FKLZL ]DQLHGDQ\FK
.RPSLORZDQLHLLQVWDODFMD
$SOLNDFMH6:7
,QVWDORZDQLH6:7
$KRM6:7
(OLPLQRZDQLHSRZWDU]DM FHJRVL NRGX
0HQX
3DQHOH]DNáDGHNSU]\FLVNLL]GDU]HQLD
*UDILND
:VSyáELH QR üZ6:7
6:7F]\6ZLQJ"
3RGVXPRZDQLH
=DVRE\
'RGDWHN$ 0DWHULDä\X]XSHäQLDMñFH
6XSOHPHQW\GRSREUDQLD
7KLQNLQJLQ&
6]NROHQLH7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD
6]NROHQLHQD&'520LH+DQGV2Q-DYD
6]NROHQLH7KLQNLQJLQ2EMHFWV
7KLQNLQJLQ(QWHUSULVH-DYD
7KLQNLQJLQ3DWWHUQVZLWK-DYD
6]NROHQLH7KLQNLQJLQ3DWWHUQV
.RQVXOWDFMDLDQDOL]DSURMHNWyZ
'RGDWHN% =DVRE\
2SURJUDPRZDQLH
(G\WRU\L URGRZLVNDSURJUDPLVW\F]QH
.VL NL
$QDOL]DLSURMHNWRZDQLH
3\WKRQ
/LVWDPRLFKNVL HN
6NRURZLG]
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
5R]G]LDä
Ä']LHOLP\RWDF]DM F\QDV ZLDWLNDWHJRU\]XMHP\JRSU]\SLVXM FSRGURG]HW\PNDWHJR
ULRP ]QDF]HQLD ² SRQLHZD MHVWH P\ F] FLDPL VSRáHF]H VWZD ED]XM FHJR QD PRZLH
NWyUHJRVHQVMHVWZPRZLH]DNRGRZDQ\«1LHPRJOLE\ P\SRUR]XPLHZDüVL QLHVWDM F
VL F] FL WHMVSRáHF]QR FLLQLHNRU]\VWDM F]WHJRV\VWHPXNODV\ILNDFML´
²%HQMDPLQ/HH:KRUI±
*HQH] UHZROXFMLNRPSXWHURZHME\áDPDV]\QD²GODWHJRJHQH] M ]\NyZSURJUDPRZDQLD
E\áRÄXGDZDQLH´PDV]\Q\
.RPSXWHU\MHGQDNEDUG]LHMQL PDV]\QDPLV ÄZ]PDFQLDF]DPLXP\VáX´OXEÄURZHUDPLGOD
XP\VáX´²MDNPDZLD6WHYH-REVDWDN HQRZ\P URGNLHPHNVSUHVML:UH]XOWDFLHZFRUD]
PQLHMV]\PVWRSQLXSU]\SRPLQDM PDV]\Q\DZFRUD]ZL NV]\PIUDJPHQW\QDV]HJRXP\VáX
D]DUD]HPNODV\F]QHG]LHG]LQ\V]WXNLWDNLHMDNOLWHUDWXUDPDODUVWZRU]H EDDQLPDFMDLILOP
3URJUDPRZDQLH]RULHQWRZDQHRELHNWRZRMHVWF] FL UXFKXFKF FHJRXF]\QLü]NRPSXWHUD
NROHMQ\ URGHNHNVSUHVML
:W\PUR]G]LDOHSU]HGVWDZL SRGVWDZRZHLGHHSURJUDPRZDQLD]RULHQWRZDQHJRRELHNWRZR
DQJ2EMHFW2ULHQWHG3URJUDPPLQJ223'RNRQDPWDN HSU]HJO GXRELHNWRZ\FKPHWRG
WZRU]HQLD RSURJUDPRZDQLD 3RGREQLH MDN UHV]WD NVL NL UR]G]LDá WHQ ]DNáDGD SHZLHQ
SR]LRPGR ZLDGF]HQLD&]\WHOQLNDZSURJUDPRZDQLXSURFHGXUDOQ\PFKRüQLHNRQLHF]QLH
ZM ]\NX&.WRQLHF]XMHVL PRFQ\ZWHMG]LHG]LQLHSRZLQLHQSU]HM üPXOWLPHGLDOQ\
NXUV7KLQNLQJLQ&GRVW SQ\GRSREUDQLDQDVWURQDFKZLWU\Q\ZZZ0LQG9LHZQHW
7UH üUR]G]LDáXVWDQRZLSRGVWDZ DMHGQRF]H QLHPDWHULDáX]XSHáQLDM F\UHV]W NVL NL
:LHOHRVyEQLHFKFH]DJá ELDüVL ZSURJUDPRZDQLHRELHNWRZHEH]XSU]HGQLHJR]UR]XPLH
QLDMHJRRJyOQ\FKNRQFHSFML²GODWHJRRSLV] WXZLHOH]QLFKWZRU] FZWHQVSRVyEVROLGQ\
REUD]FDáHMWHFKQLNL=GUXJLHMMHGQDNVWURQ\V WDF\NWyU]\PDM SUREOHP\]H]UR]X
PLHQLHPRJyOQ\FKLGHLSU]HGSR]QDQLHPÄPHFKDQLNL´²OXG]LHFLPRJ SRF]XüVL ]D
JXELHQLL]DNáRSRWDQLEH]MDNLHJR IUDJPHQWXNRGXMDNRSXQNWX]DF]HSLHQLD-H HOLQDOH \V]
GRWHMGUXJLHMJUXS\LQLHPR HV]VL MX GRF]HNDüRPDZLDQLDVSHF\ILNLM ]\NDRF]\ZL FLH
7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
PR HV]RSX FLüWHQUR]G]LDá²QDW\PHWDSLHQLHXQLHPR OLZLWRSLVDQLDSURJUDPyZLQDXNL
M ]\ND3RZLQLHQH MHGQDN HSRZUyFLüGRQLHJRSy QLHMDE\]UR]XPLHüGODF]HJRRELHNW\V
ZD QHLMDNSU]\LFKX \FLXSURMHNWRZDüRSURJUDPRZDQLH
3RVWöSXMñFDDEVWUDNFMD
.D G\M ]\NSURJUDPRZDQLDGRVWDUF]DSHZQHMDEVWUDNFML0R QDSUyERZDüEURQLüWH]\ H
]áR RQR üSUREOHPyZMDNLHMHVWH P\ZVWDQLHUR]ZL ]DüMHVWEH]SR UHGQLR]DOH QDRG
URG]DMXLMDNR FLX \ZDQHMDEVWUDNFML3U]H]ÄURG]DM´DEVWUDNFMLUR]XPLHPRGSRZLHG QD
S\WDQLHÄ&]\PMHVWWRF]HJRDEVWUDNFMLGRNRQXMHP\"´- ]\NDVHPEOHUMHVWQLHZLHON
DEVWUDNFM PDV]\Q\:LHOHW]ZLPSHUDW\ZQ\FKM ]\NyZNWyUHVWZRU]RQRSy QLHMWDNLFK
MDN)RUWUDQ%$6,&L&VWDQRZLáRQLHZLHON DEVWUDNFM DVHPEOHUD%\á\ZSRUyZQDQLX
]QLP]QDF]Q\PXVSUDZQLHQLHPMHGQDNSLHUZRWQDDEVWUDNFMDSR]RVWDáDQLH]PLHQLRQD²
ZFL Z\PDJDQHE\áRP\ OHQLHZNDWHJRULDFKVWUXNWXU\NRPSXWHUDDQLHVWUXNWXU\UR]
ZL ]\ZDQHJR SUREOHPX 3URJUDPLVWD PXVLDá GRNRQDü SRZL ]DQLD SRPL G]\ PRGHOHP
PDV]\Q\ZÄSU]HVWU]HQLUR]ZL ]DQLD´F]\OLPLHMVFXZNWyU\PPRGHOXMHP\SUREOHP
WDNLPMDNNRPSXWHUDPRGHOHPVDPHJRUR]ZL ]\ZDQHJRSUREOHPXZÄSU]HVWU]HQLSUR
EOHPX´F]\OLPLHMVFXZNWyU\PSUREOHPLVWQLHMHQSZG]LDáDOQR FLILUP\:\VLáHN
Z\PDJDQ\SU]\NRQVWUXNFMLWDNLHJRRGZ]RURZDQLDZSRá F]HQLX]IDNWHPL MHVWRQR
F]\P ]HZQ WU]Q\P Z VWRVXQNXGRM ]\NDSURJUDPRZDQLDSRZRGXMH HSURJUDP\V
WUXGQHGRQDSLVDQLDLNRV]WRZQHZSLHO JQDFML8ERF]Q\PVNXWNLHPW\FKNáRSRWyZMHVWSR
ZVWDQLHFDáHMJDá ]LZLHG]\]ZDQHMÄPHWRGDPLSURJUDPRZDQLD´
$OWHUQDW\Z GODPRGHORZDQLDPDV]\Q\MHVWPRGHORZDQLHVDPHJRSUREOHPX:F]HVQH
M ]\NLSURJUDPRZDQLDWDNLHMDN/,63F]\$3/SU]\MPRZDá\RNUH ORQ\VSRVyEZLG]HQLD
ZLDWDÄ:V]\VWNLHSUREOHP\V ZRVWDWHF]QR FLOLVWDPL´DOERÄ:V]\VWNLHSUREOHP\V
DOJRU\WPLF]QH´352/2*VSURZDG]DZV]\VWNLHSUREOHP\GRFL JyZGHF\]ML3RZVWDá\
M ]\NL SU]H]QDF]RQH GR SURJUDPRZDQLD RSDUWHJR QD RJUDQLF]HQLDFK DQJ FRQVWUDLQW
EDVHGSURJUDPPLQJRUD]GRSURJUDPRZDQLDZ\á F]QLHSRSU]H]PDQLSXODFM V\PERODPL
JUDILF]Q\PLWHRVWDWQLHRND]Dá\VL ]E\WUHVWU\NF\MQH.D GH]W\FKSRGHM üMHVWRGSR
ZLHGQLHGODRNUH ORQHMNODV\SUREOHPyZGODNWyUHM]RVWDá\RSUDFRZDQHMHGQDNZLQQ\FK
SU]\SDGNDFKVWDMHVL QLHHIHNW\ZQH
3URJUDPRZDQLHRELHNWRZHLG]LHNURNGDOHMGRVWDUF]DM FSURJUDPL FLHQDU] G]LHGRUH
SUH]HQWRZDQLD HOHPHQWyZ Z SU]HVWU]HQL SUREOHPX 5HSUH]HQWDFMD WD MHVW GRVWDWHF]QLH
RJyOQDE\QLHRJUDQLF]DáDVL GRMDNLHJR NRQNUHWQHJRW\SXSUREOHPyZ2GZRáXMHP\
VL GRHOHPHQWyZZSU]HVWU]HQLSUREOHPXMDNLGRLFKRGSRZLHGQLNyZZSU]HVWU]HQL
UR]ZL ]DQLDX \ZDM FWHJRVDPHJRVáRZD²ÄRELHNW´RF]\ZL FLHSRWU]HEQHV UyZ
QLH RELHNW\NWyUHQLHPDM RGSRZLHGQLNyZZSU]HVWU]HQLSUREOHPX3RP\VáSROHJDQD
XPR OLZLHQLXSURJUDPRZLGRVWRVRZDQLDVL GRVSHF\ILF]QHJRM ]\NDGDQHJRSUREOHPX
SRSU]H]GRGDQLHQRZ\FKW\SyZRELHNWyZG]L NLF]HPXSU]\F]\WDQLXNRGXRSLVXM FHJR
UR]ZL ]DQLHQDWUDILDP\QDVáRZDZ\UD DM FHVDPSUREOHP$EVWUDNFMDWDNDMHVWSRW QLHMV]D
L EDUG]LHM HODVW\F]QD RG W\FK NWyU\PL G\VSRQRZDOL P\ ZF]H QLHM
3URJUDPRZDQLH
RELHNWRZHSR]ZDODZL FRSLV\ZDüSUREOHPUDF]HMZNDWHJRULDFKPXZáD FLZ\FKQLH]D
1LHNWyU]\SURMHNWDQFLM ]\NyZX]QDOL HSURJUDPRZDQLHRELHNWRZHVDPRZVRELHQLHZ\VWDUF]DDE\ZSURVW\
VSRVyEUR]ZL ]DüZV]\VWNLHSUREOHP\SURJUDPLVW\F]QH3URPXM RQLNRPELQDFM NLONXUy Q\FKUR]ZL ]D
]ZDQ SURJUDPRZDQLHP]ZLHORPDSDUDG\JPDWDPLDQJPXOWLSDUDGLJPSURJUDPPLQJODQJXDJHV
3DWU]7LPRWK\%XGG0XOWLSDUDGLJPSURJUDPPLQJLQ/HGD$GGLVRQ:HVOH\
5R]G]LDä
u
:SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
ZNDWHJRULDFKNRPSXWHUDQDNWyU\P]RVWDQLHXUXFKRPLRQHUR]ZL ]DQLH3Rá F]HQLH]NRP
SXWHUHP MHGQDN ZFL LVWQLHMH .D G\ RELHNW SU]\SRPLQD PDá\ NRPSXWHU ² PD VZyM
ZHZQ WU]Q\VWDQRUD]]HVWDZRSHUDFMLNWyUHPR HZ\NRQDüMH OL]RVWDQLHRWRSRSUR
V]RQ\1LHZ\GDMHVL WRMHGQDN]á DQDORJL GRRELHNWyZ ZLDWDU]HF]\ZLVWHJR²RQH
UyZQLH PDM SHZQ FKDUDNWHU\VW\N RUD]]DFKRZXM VL ZRNUH ORQ\VSRVyE
$ODQ.D\SRGVXPRZDáSL üSRGVWDZRZ\FKFHFK6PDOOWDONDSLHUZV]HJRXGDQHJRM ]\ND
RELHNWRZHJRD]DUD]HPMHGQHJR]SRSU]HGQLNyZ-DY\&HFK\WHUHSUH]HQWXM F]\VWHSR
GHM FLHRELHNWRZH
:V]\VWNRMHVWRELHNWHP0R QDZ\REUD]LüVRELHRELHNWMDNRZ\P\ OQ ]PLHQQ
²WDN NWyUDQLHW\ONRSU]HFKRZXMHGDQHDOHPR HWDN HUHDOL]RZDü GDQLD
F]\OLZ\NRQ\ZDüQDVRELHSHZQHRSHUDFMH7HRUHW\F]QLHGRZROQHSRM FLD]H ZLDWD
UR]ZL ]\ZDQHJRSUREOHPXSV\EXG\QNLXVáXJLLWGPR QDUHSUH]HQWRZDü
ZSURJUDPLH]DSRPRF RELHNWX
3URJUDPMHVW]ELRUHPRELHNWyZNWyUHSRSU]H]Z\V\áDQLHNRPXQLNDWyZ
PyZL VRELHQDZ]DMHPFRURELüÄ:\VáDQLHNRPXQLNDWX´GRRELHNWXWRLQDF]HM
]D GDQLHZ\NRQDQLDSU]H]QLHJRSHZQHMRSHUDFML0R QDWH P\ OHüRNRPXQLNDFLH
MDNRRZ\ZRáDQLXIXQNFMLSU]\QDOH QHMGRNRQNUHWQHJRRELHNWX
.D G\RELHNWSRVLDGDZáDVQ SDPL üQDNWyU VNáDGDM VL LQQHRELHNW\
,QQ\PLVáRZ\QRZ\RELHNWWZRU]\P\á F] FZMHGHQSDNLHWJUXS MX LVWQLHM F\FK
RELHNWyZ%XGXMHP\ZWHQVSRVyE]áR RQHSURJUDP\XNU\ZDM FMHGQRF]H QLH
LFK]áR RQR ü]DSURVWRW RELHNWyZ
.D G\RELHNWSRVLDGDVZyMW\S0yZL FSRWRF]QLHND G\RELHNWMHVWLQVWDQFM
SHZQHMNODV\JG]LHÄNODVD´MHVWV\QRQLPHPÄW\SX´1DMLVWRWQLHMV] FHFK Z\Uy QLDM F
NODV MHVWRGSRZLHG QDS\WDQLHÄ-DNLHNRPXQLNDW\PR QDGRQLHMZ\V\áDü"´
:V]\VWNLHRELHNW\GDQHJRW\SXPRJ RWU]\P\ZDüWHVDPHNRPXQLNDW\
7RVWZLHUG]HQLHMDNVL Sy QLHMSU]HNRQDP\PR HE\üQLHFRP\O FH3RQLHZD
RELHNWW\SXÄRNU J´MHVWMHGQRF]H QLHRELHNWHPW\SXÄILJXUD´]DWHPÄRNU J´PR H
RWU]\P\ZDüNRPXQLNDW\RGSRZLHGQLHGODÄILJXU\´2]QDF]DWRL PR OLZHMHVW
SLVDQLHNRGXRGZRáXM FHJRVL GRÄILJXU\´NWyU\E G]LHDXWRPDW\F]QLHREVáXJLZDá
ZV]\VWNLHRELHNW\SDVXM FHGRRSLVXW\SXÄILJXUD´7D]DVW SRZDOQR üMHVWMHGQ
]QDMSRW QLHMV]\FKLGHLSURJUDPRZDQLDRELHNWRZHJR
%DUG]LHM]ZL ]á\LSU]HMU]\VW\RSLVRELHNWXSRGDMH%RRFK
2ELHNWPDVWDQ]DFKRZDQLHLWR VDPR ü
2]QDF]DWR HRELHNWPR HSRVLDGDüGDQHZHZQ WU]QHRNUH ODM FHMHJRVWDQPHWRG\
VWDQRZL FH]DFKRZDQLHRELHNWXLND G\RELHNWPR QDZMHGQR]QDF]Q\VSRVyERGUy QLü
RGZV]HONLFKLQQ\FKRELHNWyZ²DNRQNUHWQLHU]HF]ELRU F]ND G\PRELHNWHPMHVWVNR
MDU]RQ\XQLNDOQ\DGUHVSDPL FL
=DáR HQLHWRMHVWQLHFRRJUDQLF]DM FHJG\ PR QDVRELHZ\REUD]LüRELHNW\LVWQLHM FHQDUy Q\FKNRPSXWHUDFK
RUD]ZUy Q\FKSU]HVWU]HQLDFKDGUHVRZ\FKLVWQLHMHPR OLZR üSU]HFKRZ\ZDQLDRELHNWyZQDG\VNX:WDNLFK
SU]\SDGNDFKWR VDPR üRELHNWXQDOH \RNUH ODüQLHQDSRGVWDZLHDGUHVXSDPL FLOHF]ZLQQ\VSRVyE
7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
2ELHNWSRVLDGDLQWHUIHMV
3LHUZV]\PF]áRZLHNLHPNWyU\SURZDG]LáGRNáDGQHUR]ZD DQLDQDGSRM FLHPW\SXE\á
SUDZGRSRGREQLH$U\VWRWHOHV²PyZLáRQRÄNODVLHU\E´RUD]ÄNODVLHSWDNyZ´,GHDPy
ZL FD HZV]\VWNLHRELHNW\E G FXQLNDWRZ\PLQDOH MHGQRF]H QLHGRSHZQ\FKNODV
RELHNWyZRZVSyOQ\FKFHFKDFKLVSRVREDFK]DFKRZDQLD]RVWDáDEH]SR UHGQLRZ\NRU]\
VWDQDZM ]\NX6LPXOD3RGVWDZRZ\PVáRZHPNOXF]RZ\PWHJRSLHUZV]HJRRELHNWR
ZHJRM ]\NDE\áRVáRZR
ENCUU
ZSURZDG]DM FHGRSURJUDPXQRZ\W\S
-DNVDPDQD]ZDZVND]XMH6LPXOD]RVWDáD]DSURMHNWRZDQDZFHOXWZRU]HQLDV\PXODFML
WDNLFKMDNNODV\F]Q\ÄSUREOHPNDVMHUDEDQNRZHJR´0DP\ZQLPGRF]\QLHQLD]H]ELRUHP
NDVMHUyZ NOLHQWyZ NRQW WUDQVDNFML RUD] VXP SLHQL Q\FK ² PQyVWZHP ÄRELHNWyZ´
2ELHNW\NWyUHV LGHQW\F]QH]Z\M WNLHPLFKVWDQXSRGF]DVZ\NRQ\ZDQLDSURJUDPXV
SRJUXSRZDQH Z ÄNODV\ RELHNWyZ´ ² VW G ZáD QLH Z]L áR VL VáRZR NOXF]RZH
ENCUU
NODVD 7ZRU]HQLH DEVWUDNF\MQ\FK W\SyZ GDQ\FK NODV MHVW MHGQ ] IXQGDPHQWDOQ\FK
NRQFHSFMLSURJUDPRZDQLD]RULHQWRZDQHJRRELHNWRZR$EVWUDNF\MQHW\S\GDQ\FK]DFKR
ZXM VL SUDZLHWDNVDPRMDNW\S\SRGVWDZRZHPR QDWZRU]\ü]PLHQQHWDNLHJRW\SX
ZM ]\NXSURJUDPRZDQLDRELHNWRZHJRQD]\ZDQHRELHNWDPLOXE HJ]HPSODU]DPL D QD
VW SQLHPDQLSXORZDüQLPLSURFHVWHQQD]\ZDP\Z\V\áDQLHPNRPXQLNDWyZOXE GD
²Z\V\áDP\GRRELHNWXNRPXQLNDWDRQÄGRP\ ODVL ´FR]QLP]URELü6NáDGRZHHOH
PHQW\GDQHMNODV\SRVLDGDM SHZQHFHFK\ZVSyOQHQSND GHNRQWRPDVDOGRND G\NDVMHU
PR HSU]\M üZSáDW UyZQRF]H QLHMHGQDNSRV]F]HJyOQHVNáDGQLNLPRM VZyMLQG\ZL
GXDOQ\VWDQ²ND GHNRQWRPDLQQHVDOGRND G\NDVMHULQDF]HMVL QD]\ZDLWG$]DWHP
ND G\NOLHQWNRQWRWUDQVDNFMDPRJ E\üUHSUH]HQWRZDQHZSURJUDPLHNRPSXWHURZ\P
SU]H]XQLNDWRZ\E\W%\WWHQMHVWRELHNWHPDND G\RELHNWQDOH \GRRNUH ORQHMNODV\
NWyUDGHILQLXMHMHJRFHFK\L]DFKRZDQLH
7DNZL FPLPRL ZSURJUDPRZDQLXRELHNWRZ\P]DMPXMHP\VL WDNQDSUDZG WZRU]H
QLHPQRZ\FKW\SyZQLHPDOZV]\VWNLHRELHNWRZHM ]\NLSURJUDPRZDQLDVWRVXM VáRZR
NOXF]RZHFODVVQLHW\SH=DWHPNLHG\ZLG]LP\VáRZRÄW\S´SRZLQQL P\SRP\ OHüÄNODVD´
²LQDRGZUyW
3RQLHZD NODVDRSLVXMH]ELyURELHNWyZRWHMVDPHMFKDUDNWHU\VW\FHGDQ\FKVNáDGRZ\FK
RUD]W\FKVDP\FKPR OLZ\FK]DFKRZDQLDFKPR OLZR FLDFKMHVWW\SHPGDQ\FKWDNVDPR
SUDZG]LZ\PMDNQSOLF]ED]PLHQQRSU]HFLQNRZDNWyUDWDN HSRVLDGDSHZQHGDQHFKD
UDNWHU\VW\F]QHF]\OLVZRM ZDUWR üL]HVWDZGR]ZRORQ\FKQDQLHMRSHUDFML]DFKRZD
-HG\QD Uy QLFD SROHJD QD W\P H SURJUDPLVWD GHILQLXMH NODV\ RGSRZLDGDM FH UDF]HM
UR]ZL ]\ZDQHPXSUREOHPRZL²QLHMHVW]PXV]RQ\GRX \ZDQLDLVWQLHM F\FKW\SyZ
]DSURMHNWRZDQ\FKZFHOXUHSUH]HQWRZDQLDZáD FLZ\FKPDV]\QLHMHGQRVWHNSU]HFKR
Z\ZDQLDLQIRUPDFML'RNRQXMHP\ZL FUR]V]HU]HQLDM ]\NDSRSU]H] GRGDQLH QRZ\FK
W\SyZGDQ\FKVSHF\ILF]Q\FKGODQDV]\FKSRWU]HE6\VWHPSURJUDPLVW\F]Q\SU]\MPXMH
QDV]HNODV\L]DSHZQLDLPWDN VDP ÄRSLHN ´MDNW\SRPZEXGRZDQ\Pá F]QLH]HVSUDZ
G]DQLHP]JRGQR FLW\SyZ
3URJUDPRZDQLHRELHNWRZHQLHRJUDQLF]DVL GREXGRZDQLDV\PXODFML0R QDQLH]JDG]Dü
VL ]WH] HND G\SURJUDPMHVWZSHZQ\PVHQVLHV\PXODFM UR]ZL ]\ZDQHJRSU]H]
VLHELHSUREOHPXMHGQDNPLPRWRSUDZG SR]RVWDMH HWHFKQLNLRELHNWRZHPRJ ]áDWZR
FL VSURZDG]LüGX NODV SUREOHPyZGRSURVW\FKUR]ZL ]D
1LHNWyU]\GRNRQXM WXUR]Uy QLHQLDWZLHUG] F HW\SRNUH ODW\ONRLQWHUIHMVQDWRPLDVWNODVDMHVWSHZQ
LPSOHPHQWDFM WHJRLQWHUIHMVX
5R]G]LDä
u
:SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
*G\NODVDMHVWMX VWZRU]RQDPR HP\XWZRU]\üGRZROQ OLF]E MHMRELHNWyZDQDVW SQLH
PDQLSXORZDüQLPLWDNMDNJG\E\LVWQLDá\ZSU]HVWU]HQLSUREOHPX-HGQ\P]SRGVWDZRZ\FK
]DGD ZSURJUDPRZDQLXRELHNWRZ\PMHVWVWZRU]HQLHMHGQR]QDF]QHJRRGZ]RURZDQLDSR
PL G]\SU]HVWU]HQL SUREOHPXDSU]HVWU]HQL UR]ZL ]DQLD
-DNMHGQDN]PXVLüRELHNWGR]URELHQLDF]HJR SR \WHF]QHJR"0XVLLVWQLHüMDNL VSRVyE
]D GDQLDRGQLHJRZ\NRQDQLDSHZQHMRSHUDFMLWDNLHMMDN]DNR F]HQLHWUDQVDNFMLQDU\
VRZDQLHF]HJR QDHNUDQLHF]\WH ]PLDQDSRáR HQLDSU]Há F]QLND3R]DW\PND G\RELHNW
PR H]UHDOL]RZDüW\ONR FL OHRNUH ORQHRSHUDFMH GDQLDMDNLHPR QDVNLHURZDüSRGDG
UHVHPGDQHJRRELHNWX]GHILQLRZDQHV SU]H]MHJRLQWHUIHMVDLQWHUIHMVMHVWZ\]QDF]RQ\
SU]H]W\SRELHNWX3URVW\PSU]\NáDGHPPR HE\üUHSUH]HQWDFMD DUyZNL
CTQYMC TPGY CTQYMC
T\CRCN
,QWHUIHMVXVWDODMDNLH GDQLDPR QDNLHURZDüGRGDQHJRRELHNWXPXVLMHGQDNLVWQLHü
NRGUHDOL]XM F\WH GDQLD7RRQZUD]]XNU\W\PLGDQ\PLVNáDGDVL QDLPSOHPHQWDFM
=SXQNWXZLG]HQLDSURJUDPRZDQLDSURFHGXUDOQHJRQLHMHVWWRVNRPSOLNRZDQH7\SSRVLDGD
SRZL ]DQ ]ND G\PPR OLZ\P GDQLHPIXQNFM NWyUDMHVWZ\ZRá\ZDQDZFKZLOLJG\
RNUH ORQH GDQLHMHVWNLHURZDQHSRGDGUHVHPMDNLHJR RELHNWX3URFHVWHQMHVWRNUH ODQ\
MDNRÄSU]HV\áDQLHNRPXQLNDWX´ GDQLHGRRELHNWXLWRRELHNWZLHMDNQDGDQ\NRPX
QLNDW]DUHDJRZDüZ\NRQXMHNRG
:SRZ\ V]\PSU]\NáDG]LHW\SHPNODV MHVW
CTQYMC
QD]Z NRQNUHWQHJRRELHNWXW\SX
CTQYMC
MHVW
T
D GDQLDMDNLH
CTQYMC
PR HREVáX \üWR]DSDOHQLH]JDV]HQLHUR]MD
QLHQLHLSU]\FLHPQLHQLH6WZRU]HQLHRELHNWXNODV\
CTQYMC
SROHJDQD]GHILQLRZDQLXÄUH
IHUHQFML´
T
GODWHJRRELHNWXDQDVW SQLHZ\ZRáDQLXRSHUDWRUD
PGY
UHDOL]XM FHJR GD
QLHVWZRU]HQLDQRZHJRRELHNWXGDQHJRW\SX:FHOXZ\VáDQLDGRRELHNWXNRPXQLNDWX
SLV]HP\MHJRQD]Z Lá F]\P\M ]DSRPRF NURSNL]QD]Z NRPXQLNDWXMDNLFKFHP\
Z\VáDü=SXQNWXZLG]HQLDX \WNRZQLNDNODV]GHILQLRZDQ\FKSU]H]NRJR LQQHJRSR
ZLHG]LHOL P\MX ZV]\VWNRQDWHPDWSURJUDPRZDQLD]Z\NRU]\VWDQLHPRELHNWyZ
3U]HGVWDZLRQ\ SRZ\ HM GLDJUDP MHVW ]JRGQ\ ] IRUPDWHP ]GHILQLRZDQ\P SU]H] 80/
DQJ 8QLILHG 0RGHOLQJ /DQJXDJH ² XMHGQROLFRQ\ M ]\N PRGHORZDQLD .D GD NODVD
MHVWUHSUH]HQWRZDQDSU]H]SURVWRN WNWyUHJRJyUQDF] üSU]H]QDF]RQDMHVWQDMHMQD]Z
URGNRZDQDSRODGDQ\FKWHNWyUHFKFHP\RSLV\ZDüGROQD]D QDIXQNFMHVNáDGRZH
IXQNFMHQDOH FHGRRELHNWXWRRQHRWU]\PXM RVWDWHF]QLHZV]HONLHNRPXQLNDW\SU]H
VáDQHGRRELHNWX%DUG]RF] VWRZGLDJUDPDFKSURMHNWRZ\FKM ]\ND80/SU]HGVWDZLDQH
V W\ONRQD]ZDLIXQNFMHVNáDGRZHNODV\GODWHJR URGNRZDF] üSURVWRN WDQLHMHVWU\
VRZDQD-H OLLQWHUHVXMHQDVW\ONRQD]ZDNODV\²SRPLMDP\WDN HF] üGROQ
7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
2ELHNWGRVWDUF]DXVäXJL
3RPLPRSUyEWZRU]HQLDL]UR]XPLHQLDSURMHNWXSURJUDPXMHGQ\P]QDMOHSV]\FKVSRVR
EyZSRMPRZDQLDRELHNWyZMHVWP\ OHQLHRQLFKMDNRRÄGRVWDZFDFKXVáXJ´6DPSURJUDP
ZLDGF]\SHZQHXVáXJLGODX \WNRZQLNDUHDOL]XM FMHSU]\X \FLXXVáXJRIHURZDQ\FK
SU]H]LQQHRELHNW\1DV]\PFHOHPMHVWVWZRU]HQLHJUXS\RELHNWyZDMHV]F]HOHSLHM²
RGV]XNDQLH LVWQLHM FHM ELEOLRWHNL ]DZLHUDM FHM WDNLH RELHNW\ XGRVW SQLDM F\FK XVáXJL
NWyUHRSW\PDOQLHQDGDM VL GRUR]ZL ]DQLDSUREOHPX
-HGQ\P]HVSRVREyZZMDNLPR QDUR]SRF] üUHDOL]DFM WHJR]DGDQLDMHVW]DGDQLHVRELH
S\WDQLDÄ*G\E\PZMDNL PDJLF]Q\VSRVyEPyJáZ\FL JQ üMH]NDSHOXV]DMDNLHRELHNW\
UR]ZL ]Dá\E\ PyMSUREOHP"´ 1D SU]\NáDG SU]\SX FLP\ H SLV]HP\ SURJUDP NVL JRZ\
0R QDE\VRELHZ\REUD]LüRELHNW\]DZLHUDM FHVWRVRZQHSUHGHILQLRZDQHIRUPXODU]H
JUXS RELHNWyZUHDOL]XM F\FKRGSRZLHGQLHREOLF]HQLDNVL JRZHRUD]RELHNWREVáXJXM F\
GUXNRZDQLHF]HNyZLIDNWXUQDZV]HONLHJRW\SXGUXNDUNDFK0R HQLHNWyUH]W\FKRELHNWyZ
MX LVWQLHM DMH OLQLHWRMDNSRZLQQ\Z\JO GDü"-DNLHXVáXJLSRZLQQ\XGRVW SQLDüWH
RELHNW\RUD]MDNLFKLQQ\FKRELHNWyZE G RQHSRWU]HERZDüZFHOXUHDOL]DFMLVZ\FK]R
ERZL ]D "3RVW SXM FZWHQVSRVyEPR QDZNR FXGRM üGRHWDSXZNWyU\PE G]LH
PR QDVWZLHUG]Lü HÄWHQRELHNWMHVWQDW\OHSURVW\ HPR QDJRV]\ENRQDSLVDü´DOER
ÄMHVWHPSHZQ\ HWDNLRELHNWMX LVWQLHMH´7REDUG]RUR]V GQ\VSRVyEGHNRPSR]\FML
SUREOHPXQD]ELyURELHNWyZ
:\REUD DQLHVRELHRELHNWXMDNRGRVWDZF\XVáXJPDMHV]F]HMHGQ ]DOHW SRPDJDZSR
SUDZLHQLXVSyMQR FL RELHNWX :\VRND VSyMQR ü RELHNWX MHVW SRGVWDZRZ\P Z\]QDF]QLNHP
MDNR FL SURMHNWX RSURJUDPRZDQLD 2]QDF]D RQD H Uy QH DVSHNW\ IUDJPHQWyZ RSURJUD
PRZDQLDWDNLFKMDNRELHNW\OHF]PR HWRWDN HGRW\F]\üPHWRGOXEELEOLRWHNRELHNWyZ
GREU]HÄSDVXM GRVLHELH´-HGQ\P]SUREOHPyZNWyUHVL SRMDZLDM SRGF]DVSURMHNWR
ZDQLD RELHNWyZ MHVW Z\SHáQLHQLH QLFK ]E\W ZLHORPD PR OLZR FLDPL IXQNFMRQDOQ\PL
1DSU]\NáDGWZRU] FPRGXáGUXNXM F\PR QDGRM üGRZQLRVNX HNRQLHF]Q\E G]LH
RELHNWNWyU\ÄZLHZV]\VWNR´QDWHPDWIRUPDWRZDQLDLGUXNRZDQLD=DSHZQHRND HVL
HWR]E\WZLHOHMDNQDMHGHQRELHNWL HZU]HF]\ZLVWR FLNRQLHF]QHV WU]\OXEQDZHW
ZL FHMRELHNWyZ-HGHQ]QLFKPyJáE\E\üNDWDORJLHP]DZLHUDM F\PZV]\VWNLHPR OLZH
IRUPDW\F]HNyZ]QLHJRE\á\E\SRELHUDQHLQIRUPDFMHGRW\F] FHVSRVREXGUXNRZDQLD
F]HNyZ.ROHMQ\RELHNWOXEJUXSDRELHNWyZPyJáE\VWDQRZLüRJyOQ\LQWHUIHMVGUXNX
M F\NWyU\G\VSRQRZDáE\ZLHG] QDWHPDWZV]\VWNLFKURG]DMyZGUXNDUHNOHF]QLH
ZLHG]LDáE\QLF]HJRQDWHPDWNVL JRZR FL²WDNLRELHNWEDUG]LHMQDGDMHVL GRNXSLHQLD
QL GR VDPRG]LHOQHJR QDSLVDQLD 7U]HFL RELHNW PyJáE\ NRU]\VWDü ] XVáXJ GZyFK SR
SU]HGQLFKDE\UHDOL]RZDü]DPLHU]RQH]DGDQLH$]DWHPND G\]RELHNWyZG\VSRQXMH
VSyMQ\P]ELRUHPXGRVW SQLDQ\FKXVáXJ:SRSUDZQ\PRELHNWRZR]RULHQWRZDQ\PSUR
MHNFLHND G\RELHNWUHDOL]XMHGREU]HMHGQR]DGDQLHOHF]QLHVWDUDVL URELü]E\WZLHOH-DN
PR QDVL E\áRSU]HNRQDüUR]ZL ]DQLHWDNLHQLHW\ONRSRPDJDZRGQDMG\ZDQLXRELHNWyZ
NWyUHPR QDE\Z\NRU]\VWDüRELHNWVWDQRZL F\LQWHUIHMVGUXNRZDQLDOHF]WDN HVWZDU]D
PR OLZR üSLVDQLDRELHNWyZQDGDM F\FKVL GRZLHORNURWQHJRZ\NRU]\VWDQLDZUy Q\FK
SURJUDPDFKQDSU]\NáDGNDWDORJF]HNyZ
7UDNWRZDQLHRELHNWXMDNRGRVWDZF\XVáXJMHVWSRGHM FLHPNWyUHZLHOHXáDWZLDLMHVWSU]\
GDWQHQLHW\ONRSRGF]DVSURFHVXSURMHNWRZDQLDOHF]WDN HZV\WXDFMDFKJG\LQQHRVRE\VWD
UDM VL SU]HDQDOL]RZDüNRGOXESRZWyUQLHZ\NRU]\VWDüRELHNW\²MH OLPR QDRFHQLü
ZDUWR üRELHNWXQDSRGVWDZLH ZLDGF]RQ\FKSU]H]QLHJRXVáXJ]QDF]QLHáDWZLHMPR QD
JRGRSDVRZDüGRWZRU]RQHJRSURMHNWX
5R]G]LDä
u
:SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
8NU\ZDQLHLPSOHPHQWDFML
:DUWRGRNRQDüUR]Uy QLHQLDSRPL G]\WZyUFDPLNODVDQJFODVVFUHDWRUVNWyU]\GHILQLXM
QRZHW\S\GDQ\FKDSURJUDPLVWDPLNOLHQWDPLDQJFOLHQWSURJUDPPHUV
ÄNRQVXPHQWDPL´
NODVNWyU]\Z\NRU]\VWXM WHW\S\GDQ\FKZVZRLFKDSOLNDFMDFK&HOHPSURJUDPLVW\NOLHQWD
MHVW]HEUDQLH]HVWDZXNODVQDU] G]LJRWRZ\FKGRZ\NRU]\VWDQLDZV]\ENLPWZRU]HQLX
DSOLNDFML &HOHP WZyUF\ NODV MHVW QDWRPLDVW SU]\JRWRZ\ZDQLH WDNLFK NODV NWyUH XGR
VW SQLDM SURJUDPL FLHNOLHQWRZLMHG\QLHWRFRGODQLHJRQLH]E GQHDFDá UHV]W WU]\
PDM ZXNU\FLX'ODF]HJR"3RQLHZD WRFRXNU\WHQLHPR H]RVWDüZ\NRU]\VWDQHSU]H]
SURJUDPLVW NOLHQWDD]DWHPWZyUFDPR H]PLHQLüQLHZLGRF]Q F] üQLHSU]HMPXM F
VL HZHQWXDOQ\PZSá\ZHPW\FK]PLDQQDLQQHF] FL8NU\WDF] ü]Z\NOHUHSUH]HQ
WXMHGHOLNDWQHZQ WU]HRELHNWXNWyUHPRJáRE\]áDWZR FL ]RVWDüÄSRSVXWH´SU]H]QLH
XZD QHJROXEQLHGRLQIRUPRZDQHJRSURJUDPLVW NOLHQWD=WHJRSRZRGXXNU\ZDQLHLP
SOHPHQWDFML]PQLHMV]DOLF]E Eá GyZZSURJUDPDFK
1LHVSRVyESU]HFHQLüLGHLXNU\ZDQLDLPSOHPHQWDFML:ND GHMUHODFMLLVWRWQHMHVWLVWQLH
QLHRJUDQLF]H UHVSHNWRZDQ\FKSU]H]ZV]\VWNLHXF]HVWQLF] FHZQLHMVWURQ\*G\WZR
U]\P\ ELEOLRWHN QDZL ]XMHP\ UyZQRF]H QLH SHZQ UHODFM ] MHM NOLHQWHP E G F\P
UyZQLH SURJUDPLVW DOHWDNLPNWyU\PDQDFHOXÄ]áR HQLH´DSOLNDFML]DSRPRF QDV]HM
ELEOLRWHNLHZHQWXDOQLH]EXGRZDQLHELEOLRWHNLZL NV]HM*G\ZV]\VWNLHVNáDGQLNLNODV\
V GRVW SQHGODZV]\VWNLFKZWHG\SURJUDPLVWDNOLHQWPR H]NODV ]URELüZV]\VWNR²
QLHLVWQLHMH DGHQVSRVyEQDZ\PXV]HQLHSU]HVWU]HJDQLDUHJXá1DZHWMH OLQDSUDZG QLH
FKFHP\DE\NOLHQWPDQLSXORZDáEH]SR UHGQLRQLHNWyU\PL]HVNáDGQLNyZQDV]HMNODV\EH]
PHFKDQL]PyZ NRQWUROL GRVW SX QLH LVWQLHMH VSRVyE XQLHPR OLZLHQLD WHJR :V]\VWNR MHVW
SXEOLF]QHLZLGRF]QHGODFDáHJR ZLDWD
3LHUZV]\PX]DVDGQLHQLHPNRQWUROLGRVW SXMHVWFK üZ\PXV]HQLDQDNOLHQFLHWU]\PDQLD
U N]GDOHNDRGU]HF]\NWyU\FKQLHSRZLQLHQGRW\NDü²F] FLQLH]E GQ\FKGRZ\NR
Q\ZDQLDZHZQ WU]Q\FKRSHUDFMLQDV]HJRW\SXGDQ\FKQLHE G F\FKMHGQDNF] FL LQ
WHUIHMVX NWyUHJR SRWU]HEXM X \WNRZQLF\ GR UR]ZL ]\ZDQLD NRQNUHWQ\FK SUREOHPyZ
.RQWURODWDNDMHVWNRU]\VWQDGODX \WNRZQLNyZSR]ZDODLPERZLHPáDWZRRGUy QLüWR
FRGODQLFKLVWRWQHRGWHJRFRPRJ ]LJQRURZDü
'UXJLPSRZRGHPZSURZDG]HQLDNRQWUROLGRVW SXMHVWXPR OLZLHQLHSURMHNWDQWRZLELEOLR
WHNLZ\PLDQ\ZHZQ WU]Q\FKPHFKDQL]PyZNODV\EH]]DVWDQDZLDQLDVL QDGZSá\ZHPWHM
F]\QQR FLQDSURJUDPLVWyZNOLHQWyZ0R QDQDSU]\NáDG]DLPSOHPHQWRZDüMDN NODV
ZSU\PLW\ZQ\VSRVyEZFHOXXSURV]F]HQLDSUDF\DZSy QLHMV]\PWHUPLQLHMH OLRND H
VL WRNRQLHF]QHSU]HSLVDüM DE\G]LDáDáDV]\EFLHM-H HOLLQWHUIHMVLLPSOHPHQWDFMDV RG
VLHELHZ\UD QLHRGG]LHORQHLFKURQLRQHZWHG\RVL JQL FLHWHJRQLHMHVWWUXGQH
-DYDSRVLDGDWU]\VáRZDNOXF]RZHVáX FHGRXVWDQRZLHQLDUR]JUDQLF]H ZNODVDFK6 WR
RWDNKE
SXEOLF]Q\
RTKXCVG
SU\ZDWQ\L
RTQVGEVGF
FKURQLRQ\,FKX \FLHL]QDF]HQLH
MHVWGRV\üRF]\ZLVWH6 WRW]ZVSHF\ILNDWRU\GRVW SXDQJDFFHVVVSHFLILHUV²RNUH
ODM NWRMHVWXSRZD QLRQ\GRX \ZDQLDQDVW SXM F\FKSRQLFKGHILQLFML6SHF\ILNDWRU
RWDNKE
R]QDF]D HGHILQLFMHV GRVW SQHGODND GHJRQDWRPLDVW
RTKXCVG
HGRVW SGR
QLFKSRVLDGDMHG\QLHWZyUFDGDQHMNODV\ZHZQ WU]MHMIXQNFMLVNáDGRZ\FK-H HOLNWR
7HUPLQWHQDXWRU]DZG]L F]DSU]\MDFLHORZL6FRWWRZL0H\HUVRZL
7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
SUyEXMHX \ZDüSU\ZDWQ\FK
RTKXCVG
HOHPHQWyZQDV]HMNODV\SRZRGXMHW\PVDP\P
Z\VW SLHQLHEá GXMX ZF]DVLHNRPSLODFMLSURJUDPX6áRZRNOXF]RZH
RTQVGEVGF
G]LDáD
SUDZLHWDNVDPRMDN
RTKXCVG
²Uy QLFDSROHJDQDW\P HNODV\G]LHG]LF] FH]QDV]HM
PDM GRVW SGRHOHPHQWyZW\SX
RTQVGEVGF
QLHPDM QDWRPLDVWGRW\FKRNUH ORQ\FKMDNR
RTKXCVG
3RM FLHG]LHG]LF]HQLDZSURZDG] MX QLHGáXJR
-DYDSRVLDGDWDN HÄGRP\ OQ\´WU\EGRVW SXNWyU\MHVWZ\NRU]\VW\ZDQ\MH OLQLHSRGDP\
DGQHJR]HZVSRPQLDQ\FKVSHF\ILNDWRUyZ2NUH ODQ\MHVWRQF]DVHPMDNRÄSDNLHWRZ\´
DQJSDFNDJHDFFHVVSRQLHZD GRVNáDGRZ\FKSDNLHWRZ\FKPRJ VL RGZRá\ZDüLQQH
NODV\]WHJRVDPHJRSDNLHWXQDWRPLDVWSR]DSDNLHWHPZLG]LDQHV RQHMDNRSU\ZDWQH
:LHORNURWQHZ\NRU]\VWDQLHLPSOHPHQWDFML
6WZRU]RQDLSU]HWHVWRZDQDNODVDSRZLQQDZV\WXDFMLLGHDOQHMVWDQRZLüX \WHF]Q\IUDJ
PHQWNRGX2ND]XMHVL MHGQDNL RVL JQL FLHWDNLHJRVWDQXU]HF]\QLHMHVWWDNSURVWHMDN
PRJáRE\VL QLHNWyU\PZ\GDZDü²VWZRU]HQLHGREUHJRUR]ZL ]DQLDZ\PDJDVSRUHJR
GR ZLDGF]HQLDLLQWXLFML*G\MHGQDNUR]ZL ]DQLHWDNLHMX SRZVWDQLHZWHG\D SURVLVL
RZLHORNURWQHZ\NRU]\VWDQLH8PR OLZLHQLHWDNLHJRZLHORNURWQHJRZ\NRU]\VWDQLDNRGX
MHVWMHGQ ]JáyZQ\FK]DOHWRELHNWRZR]RULHQWRZDQ\FKM ]\NyZSURJUDPRZDQLD
1DMSURVWV]\PVSRVREHPZ\NRU]\VWDQLDNRGXNODV\MHVWEH]SR UHGQLHX \FLHRELHNWXWHM
NODV\PR QDMHGQDNUyZQLH XPLH FLüRELHNWZHZQ WU]QRZHMNODV\1D]\ZDP\WRÄWZR
U]HQLHPRELHNWXVNáDGRZHJR´1RZDNODVDPR HE\ü]EXGRZDQD]GRZROQHMOLF]E\RELHN
WyZPRJ RQHWDN HQDOH HüGRUy Q\FKW\SyZSRá F]RQ\FKZGRZROQHNRPELQDFMH
SRWU]HEQHGRRVL JQL FLDSR GDQ\FKPR OLZR FL3RQLHZD WZRU]\P\QRZHNODV\X \
ZDM FNODVMX LVWQLHM F\FKGODWHJRNRQFHSFMDWDQD]\ZDVL NRPSR]\FM DQJFRPSRVLWLRQ
MH OLGRNRPSR]\FMLGRFKRG]LG\QDPLF]QLHZF]DVLHZ\NRQDQLDSURJUDPXPyZLP\RQLHM
MDNRRDJUHJDFMLDQJDJJUHJDWLRQ.RPSR]\FMDMHVWF] VWRRNUH ODQDMDNRUHODFMDW\SX
ÄSRVLDGD´WDNMDNZ]GDQLXÄVDPRFKyGSRVLDGDVLOQLN´
1D SRZ\ V]\P GLDJUDPLH M ]\ND 80/ NRPSR]\FMD ]D]QDF]RQD MHVW ]D SRPRF Z\
SHáQLRQHJRURPEX=Z\NOHE G]LHP\X \ZDüSURVWV]HMIRUP\²NUHVNLQLH]DNR F]RQHM
URPEHP²GODR]QDF]HQLDDVRFMDFML
.RPSR]\FMDXPR OLZLDZ\VRNLVWRSLH HODVW\F]QR FL2ELHNW\VNáDGRZHQDV]HMQRZHMNODV\
V ]Z\NOHSU\ZDWQHDZL FQLHGRVW SQHGODX \ZDM F\FKMHMSURJUDPLVWyZNOLHQWyZ0R QD
]DWHPVNáDGRZHWHSRGPLHQLDüQLH]DNáyFDM FLVWQLHM FHJRNRGXNOLHQWD2ELHNW\VNáD
GRZHPR QDWDN HZ\PLHQLDüZF]DVLHZ\NRQDQLDFRSR]ZDODQDG\QDPLF]Q ]PLDQ
]DFKRZDQLDSURJUDPX2SLVDQHGDOHMG]LHG]LF]HQLHQLH]DSHZQLDWDNLHMHODVW\F]QR FL
SRQLHZD RJUDQLF]HQLDQDNODV\XWZRU]RQH]DMHJRSRPRF QDNáDGDQHV MX ZF]DVLH
NRPSLODFML
7DNLSR]LRPV]F]HJyáRZR FLMHVWZ\VWDUF]DM F\GODZL NV]R FLGLDJUDPyZ]D]Z\F]DMQLHMHVWWDN H
NRQLHF]QHUR]Uy QLHQLHDJUHJDFMLRGNRPSR]\FML
5R]G]LDä
u
:SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
3RQLHZD G]LHG]LF]HQLHMHVWWDNLVWRWQHZSURJUDPRZDQLX]RULHQWRZDQ\PRELHNWRZR
F] VWRMHJR]QDF]HQLHMHVWQDGPLHUQLHSRGNUH ODQHFRPR HXSRF] WNXM FHJRSURJUDPLVW\
Z\WZRU]\üIDáV]\Z\SRJO G HQDOH \MHVWRVRZDüZV] G]LH:UH]XOWDFLHWZRU]\RQQLH
HOHJDQFNLHL]E\WQLRVNRPSOLNRZDQHSURJUDP\3U]\WZRU]HQLXQRZ\FKNODVSRZLQQL P\
UDF]HMZSLHUZV]HMNROHMQR FLUR]ZD DüX \FLHNRPSR]\FMLNWyUDMHVWSURVWV]DLEDUG]LHM
HODVW\F]QD']L NLWDNLHPXUR]ZL ]DQLXSURMHNW\SURJUDPyZE G ]QDF]QLHF]\WHOQLHMV]H
=LGHQW\ILNRZDQLHV\WXDFMLZ\PDJDM F\FKX \FLDG]LHG]LF]HQLDMHVWJG\MX ]GRE G]LH
VL SHZQHGR ZLDGF]HQLHVWRVXQNRZRSURVWH
']LHG]LF]HQLH
,GHDRELHNWXMHVWVDPDZVRELHZ\JRGQ\PQDU] G]LHP3R]ZDODSRá F]\ü]HVRE GDQH
L]HVWDZ\IXQNFMLZFHOXUHSUH]HQWRZDQLDRNUH ORQHJRSRM FLD]SU]HVWU]HQLSUREOHPXEH]
X \ZDQLDVSHF\ILF]QHJRM ]\NDPDV]\Q\3RM FLDWDNLHV Z\UD DQHMDNRSRGVWDZRZH
MHGQRVWNLZM ]\NXSURJUDPRZDQLDG]L NLX \FLXVáRZDNOXF]RZHJR
ENCUU
1LHGREU]HE\E\áRJG\E\SRUR]ZL ]DQLXZV]\VWNLFKSUREOHPyZ]ZL ]DQ\FK]WZRU]H
QLHPNODV\WU]HEDE\áRWZRU]\üRGSRGVWDZQRZ NODV SRVLDGDM F SRGREQ IXQNFM
àDWZLHMV]HE\áRE\ÄVNORQRZDQLH´LVWQLHM FHMNODV\LZ\NRQDQLHQDSRZVWDáHMNRSLLZ\
PDJDQ\FKSU]HUyEHNLUR]V]HU]H 7RZáD QLHHIHNW\ZQLHRVL JDP\SRSU]H]Z\NRU]\VWDQLH
G]LHG]LF]HQLDDQJLQKHULWDQFH²]W\P HJG\RU\JLQDOQDNODVDQD]\ZDQDNODV ED
]RZ OXEQDGNODV ]RVWDQLH]PRG\ILNRZDQDZWHG\QDV]ÄNORQ´QD]\ZDQ\NODV SR
WRPQ NODV SRFKRGQ OXESRGNODV RG]ZLHUFLHGOLUyZQLH WH]PLDQ\
6WU]DáNDQDSRZ\ V]\PGLDJUDPLH80/MHVWVNLHURZDQDRGNODV\SRFKRGQHMGRED]RZHM
-DNSy QLHM]REDF]\P\NODVSRFKRGQ\FKPR HE\üZL FHM
7\S QLH RSLVXMH MHG\QLH ZL ]yZ QDNáDGDQ\FK QD SHZLHQ ]ELyU RELHNWyZ ² ZFKRG]L
WDN HZUHODFMH]LQQ\PLW\SDPL'ZDW\S\PRJ SRVLDGDüZVSyOQHFHFK\L]DFKRZDQLD
DOHMHGHQ PR H]DZLHUDü ZL FHMGDQ\FK QL GUXJL OXE REVáXJLZDü ZL FHM NRPXQL
NDWyZDOERREVáXJLZDüMHLQDF]HM']LHG]LF]HQLHZ\UD DWHJRURG]DMXSRGRELH VWZR
PL G]\W\SDPLX \ZDM FSRM FLDW\SyZED]RZ\FKLW\SyZSRFKRGQ\FK7\SED]RZ\
SRVLDGD WH FHFK\ L VSRVRE\ ]DFKRZDQLD NWyUH V ZVSyOQH GOD ZV]\VWNLFK MHJR W\SyZ
SRFKRGQ\FK7ZRU]\P\JRGRUHSUH]HQWRZDQLDWU]RQXSRGVWDZRZ\FKLGHLZVSyOQ\FK
GODSHZQHMJUXS\RELHNWyZ:\ZLHG]LRQH]QLHJRW\S\SRFKRGQHUHSUH]HQWXM QDWRPLDVW
Uy QHPR OLZR FLUHDOL]DFMLW\FKLGHL
5R]ZD P\QDSU]\NáDGPDV]\Q VRUWXM F RGSDGNLZFHOXRG]\VNXVXURZFyZ7\SHP
ED]RZ\PE G]LHÄRGSDGHN´.D G\RGSDGHNSRVLDGDSHZQ ZDJ ZDUWR üLWG0R H
E\ü SRFL W\ SU]HWRSLRQ\ OXE UR]áR RQ\ QD F] FL 'DOHM PR QD ZSURZDG]Lü EDUG]LHM
7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
VSHF\ILF]QHW\S\ PLHFL²WDNLHNWyUHPDM GRGDWNRZHFHFK\QSEXWHONDSRVLDGDNRORU
LVSRVRE\]DFKRZDQLDSXV]NDDOXPLQLRZDPR H]RVWDü]JQLHFLRQDSXV]NDVWDORZDUHDJXMH
QDSROHPDJQHW\F]QH1LHNWyUH]DFKRZDQLDPRJ GRGDWNRZRXOHF]PLDQLHQSZDUWR üSD
SLHUX]DOH \RGMHJRURG]DMXRUD]VWDQX:\NRU]\VWDQLHG]LHG]LF]HQLDSR]ZDOD]EXGRZDü
KLHUDUFKL NODVZ\UD DM F UR]ZL ]\ZDQ\SUREOHPZáD QLHZNDWHJRULDFKZ\VW SXM F\FK
ZQLPW\SyZ
-DNRGUXJLUR]ZD \P\NODV\F]Q\SU]\NáDG]ILJXUDPLJHRPHWU\F]Q\PL²PR HWRE\ü
F] üV\VWHPXNRPSXWHURZHJRZVSRPDJDQLDSURMHNWRZDQLDDOERV\PXODFMLJU\%D]RZ\P
W\SHPE G]LHWXÄILJXUD´SRVLDGDM FD]DZV]HUR]PLDUNRORUSR]\FM LWS.D GDILJXUD
PR H]RVWDüQDU\VRZDQDZ\PD]DQDSU]HVXQL WDSRNRORURZDQDLWG:\ZRG]LP\]QLHM
SRSU]H]G]LHG]LF]HQLHUy QHVSHF\ILF]QHW\S\ILJXURNU JLNZDGUDW\WUyMN W\LLQQH
]NWyU\FKND G\PR HSRVLDGDüGRGDWNRZHFHFK\LVSRVRE\]DFKRZDQLD1LHNWyUHILJXU\
PRJ E\üQSREUyFRQHÄGRJyU\QRJDPL´1LHNWyUH]DFKRZDQLDPRJ E\üUy QHQS
SROHILJXU\OLF]\P\ZUy Q\VSRVyE+LHUDUFKLDW\SyZZ\UD D]DUyZQRSRGRELH VWZDMDN
LUy QLFHSRPL G]\SRV]F]HJyOQ\PLURG]DMDPLILJXU
2SLVDQLHUR]ZL ]DQLDZWHUPLQDFKSUREOHPXGDMHROEU]\PLHNRU]\ FLSRQLHZD SU]HM FLH
RGRSLVXSUREOHPXGRRSLVXUR]ZL ]DQLDQLHZ\PDJDMX ]DVWRVRZDQLDOLF]Q\FKPRGHOL
SR UHGQLFK*G\X \ZDP\RELHNWyZKLHUDUFKLDNODVVWDQRZLPRGHOSLHUZRWQ\]DWHP
SU]HFKRG]LP\ZSURVWRGRSLVXV\VWHPXZ ZLHFLHU]HF]\ZLVW\PGRRSLVXV\VWHPXZNRG]LH
-HGQ\P]JáyZQ\FKSUREOHPyZSURMHNWRZDQLDRELHNWRZHJRMHVW]E\WSURVWDGURJDRGSR
F] WNXGRNR FD3URVWRWDF] VWR]ELMDSRF] WNRZR]WURSXXP\Vá\Z\WUHQRZDQHZSRV]X
NLZDQLXVNRPSOLNRZDQ\FKUR]ZL ]D
3RSU]H]G]LHG]LF]HQLHWZRU]\P\QRZ\W\SNWyU\QLHW\ONR]DZLHUDZV]\VWNLHVNáDGRZH
FKRüWH]DGHNODURZDQHMDNRSU\ZDWQHV XNU\WHLQLHGRVW SQHDOHWDN HFRZD QLHMV]H
NRSLXMHLQWHUIHMVNODV\ED]RZHM$]DWHPZV]\VWNLHNRPXQLNDW\MDNLHPR QDZ\V\áDüGR
RELHNWyZNODV\ED]RZHMPRJ E\üZ\V\áDQHUyZQLH GRRELHNWyZNODV\SRFKRGQHM3R
QLHZD WR]HVSyáRGELHUDQ\FKNRPXQLNDWyZZ\]QDF]DW\SPR QDSRZLHG]LHü HNODVD
SRFKRGQDMHVWWHJRVDPHJRW\SXFRED]RZD2GZRáDMP\VL GRQDV]HJRRVWDWQLHJRSU]\
NáDGXÄ2NU JMHVWILJXU ´7DRVL JDQDSU]H]G]LHG]LF]HQLHUyZQRZD QR üMHVWMHGQ\P
]SRGVWDZRZ\FKHWDSyZ]UR]XPLHQLDVHQVXSURJUDPRZDQLD]RULHQWRZDQHJRRELHNWRZR
3RQLHZD ]DUyZQRNODVDED]RZDMDNLSRFKRGQDPDM WHQVDPLQWHUIHMVPXVL]DWHPLVWQLHü
MDND ]ZL ]DQD]QLPLPSOHPHQWDFMDW]QPXVLLVWQLHüNRGZ\NRQ\ZDQ\JG\RELHNW
RWU]\PDRNUH ORQ\NRPXQLNDW-H HOLZV]\VWNRFR]URELP\WRVWZRU]HQLHQRZHMNODV\]D
5R]G]LDä
u
:SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
SRPRF G]LHG]LF]HQLDPHWRG\NODV\ED]RZHMVWDQRZL FHMHMLQWHUIHMVUyZQLH SU]HFKRG]
GRNODV\SRFKRGQHM²D]DWHPRELHNW\PDM QLHW\ONRWHQVDPW\SFRNODVDED]RZDDOH
WDN H]DFKRZXM VL GRNáDGQLHWDNVDPRFRQLHMHVWV]F]HJyOQLHLQWHUHVXM FH
,VWQLHM GZDVSRVRE\RGUy QLHQLDQRZHMNODV\SRFKRGQHMRGRU\JLQDOQHMNODV\ED]RZHM
3LHUZV]\MHVWGRV\üSURVW\GRGDMHP\GRQLHMSRSURVWXQRZHPHWRG\1LHV RQHF] FL
LQWHUIHMVXNODV\ED]RZHM2]QDF]DWR HNODVDED]RZDQLHURELáDZV]\VWNLHJRF]HJR GDOL
P\D]DWHPX]XSHáQLOL P\MHM]HVWDZPHWRG7RSURVWHLSU\PLW\ZQHX \FLHG]LHG]LF]HQLD
MHVWMDNQDUD]LHLGHDOQ\PUR]ZL ]DQLHPSUREOHPX:DUWRMHGQDN H]DVWDQRZLüVL F]\
NODVDED]RZDQLHSRWU]HEXMHW\FKGRGDWNRZ\FKPHWRG7DNLSURFHVLWHUDF\MQHJRRGNU\ZD
QLDZáD FLZHJRSURMHNWXZ\VW SXMHF] VWRZSURJUDPRZDQLXRELHNWRZ\P
&KRüG]LHG]LF]HQLHZ\GDMHVL F]DVDPLV]F]HJyOQLHZ-DYLHJG]LHZSURZDG]DVL MH]D
SRPRF VáRZDNOXF]RZHJR
GZVGPFU
F]\OLUR]V]HU]DüVXJHURZDüNRQLHF]QR üGRGDQLD
QRZ\FKPHWRGGRLQWHUIHMVXQLHMHVWWRGRNR FDSUDZG 'UXJLP²LGRWHJRZD QLHM
V]\P²VSRVREHPG]L NLNWyUHPXPR HP\XF]\QLüNODV SRFKRGQ Uy Q RGED]RZHM
MHVW]PLDQD]DFKRZDQLDLVWQLHM FHMMX PHWRG\ED]RZHMRNUH ODQDMDNRMHMSU]HVáRQL FLH
DQJRYHUULGLQJ
:FHOXSU]HGHILQLRZDQLDPHWRG\SRSURVWXWZRU]\P\ZNODVLHSRFKRGQHMMHMQRZ GHIL
QLFM 0yZLP\Ä&KF WXZ\NRU]\VWDüW VDP PHWRG ]LQWHUIHMVXDOHGODQRZHJRW\SXPD
RQDURELüFR LQQHJR´
7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
e%\FLHF]\P sDeE\FLHSRGREQ\PGRF]HJR s
:NZHVWLLG]LHG]LF]HQLDPR HSRZVWDüSHZQDZ WSOLZR üF]\QLHQDOH DáRE\RJUDQL
F]\üVL MHG\QLHGRSU]HGHILQLRZ\ZDQLDPHWRG\NODV\ED]RZHMSRZVWU]\PXM FVL RG
GRGDZDQLD QRZ\FK" 2]QDF]DáRE\ WR H NODVD SRFKRGQD MHVW GRNáDGQLH WHJR VDPHJR
W\SXFRED]RZDSRQLHZD PDWDNLVDPLQWHUIHMV:UH]XOWDFLHRELHNWNODV\SRWRPQHM
MHVWGRNáDGQ\PVXEVW\WXWHPRELHNWXNODV\ED]RZHM²PR HP\PyZLüRF]\VWHM]DVW SR
ZDOQR FLDFDáHWRVWDQRZLVNRMHVWRNUH ODQHPLDQHP]DVDG\]DVW SRZDOQR FLDQJVXEVWL
WXWLRQSULQFLSOH-HVWWRZSHZQ\PVHQVLHLGHDOQ\VSRVyEWUDNWRZDQLDG]LHG]LF]HQLD=ZL
]HNSRPL G]\NODV ED]RZ DSRFKRGQ RNUH ODP\ZW\PSU]\SDGNXF] VWRMDNRUHODFM
E\FLDF]\P DQJLVDUHODWLRQVKLSSRQLHZD PR HP\SRZLHG]LHüÄRNU JMHVWILJXU ´
6SUDZG]LDQSRSUDZQR FLX \FLDG]LHG]LF]HQLDSROHJDQD]EXGRZDQLXSRGREQHJR]GDQLD
GODQDV]\FKNODVLVWZLHUG]HQLXF]\PDRQRVHQV
:QLHNWyU\FKV\WXDFMDFKGRGDQLHZW\SLHSRFKRGQ\PQRZ\FKHOHPHQWyZLQWHUIHMVXMHVW
MHGQDNNRQLHF]QH²WDNLHMHJRUR]V]HU]HQLHWZRU]\QRZ\W\S0R HRQE\üQDGDOX \ZDQ\
]DPLDVWW\SXED]RZHJRMHGQDN H]DVW SRZDOQR üQLHMHVWMX LGHDOQDSRQLHZD QRZH
IXQNFMHQLHV GRVW SQH]SR]LRPXED]RZHJR7HQURG]DMUHODFMLPR HP\RNUH OLüMDNRE\FLH
SRGREQ\PGRF]HJR QRZ\W\SSRVLDGDFDá\LQWHUIHMVVWDUHJRW\SXMHGQDN H]DZLHUDWDN H
LQQHPHWRG\SU]H]FRQLHPR QDSRZLHG]LHü HMHVWWDNLVDP5R]ZD P\QDSU]\NáDG
NOLPDW\]DFM 3U]\SX üP\ HPDP\]DLQVWDORZDQ\ZGRPXV\VWHPFKáRG] F\D]DWHP
LQWHUIHMVSR]ZDODM F\QDNRQWURO FKáRG]HQLD:\REUD P\VRELH HNOLPDW\]DFMDSVXMHVL
L]DVW SXMHP\VWDU\V\VWHPQRZ SRPS FLHSOQ NWyUDSR]ZDOD]DUyZQRFKáRG]LüMDN
LRJU]HZDü=DVDGDG]LDáDQLDSRPS\FLHSOQHMMHVWSRGREQDGRG]LDáDQLDNOLPDW\]DFMLDOH
SRPSDPR H]URELüZL FHMRGQLHM3RQLHZD V\VWHPFKáRG] F\MHVW]DSURMHNWRZDQ\GR
NRQWUROLFKáRG]HQLDMHVWRJUDQLF]RQ\GR NRPXQLNRZDQLD VL ] FKáRG] F F] FL QRZHJR
RELHNWX,QWHUIHMVWHJRRELHNWX]RVWDáSRV]HU]RQ\DOHLVWQLHM F\V\VWHPQLH]QDQLF]HJRSR]D
LQWHUIHMVHPRU\JLQDOQ\P
2F]\ZL FLHSRSU]HVWXGLRZDQLXWHJRSURMHNWXVWDMHVL MDVQH HNODVDED]RZD
5[UVGO
%J QF\æE[
QLHMHVWGRVWDWHF]QLHRJyOQDLSRZLQQD]RVWDü]PLHQLRQDQDÄV\VWHPNRQWUROL
WHPSHUDWXU\´DE\PRJáDREVáXJLZDüUyZQLH RJU]HZDQLH²SRF]\P]DVDGD]DVW SR
ZDOQR FL]DF] áDE\]QRZXG]LDáDü'LDJUDPWHQSU]HGVWDZLDMHGQDNV\WXDFM MDNDPR H
VL ]GDU]\üZSURMHNWRZDQLXLZ ZLHFLHU]HF]\ZLVW\P
3R]DSR]QDQLXVL ]]DVDG ]DVW SRZDOQR FLPR QDSRP\ OHü HWRUR]ZL ]DQLHF]\VWD
]DVW SRZDOQR üMHVWMHG\Q\PVáXV]Q\PLIDNW\F]QLHGREU]HMHVWJG\SURMHNWG]LDáDZWHQ
VSRVyE=F]DVHPMHGQDNPRJ Z\VW SLüV\WXDFMHZNWyU\FKNRQLHF]QR üGRGDQLDQRZ\FK
IXQNFMLZLQWHUIHMVLHNODV\SRFKRGQHMMHVWUyZQLHMDVQD3RGRNáDGQ\P]EDGDQLXUR]Uy QLHQLH
PL G]\W\PLSU]\SDGNDPLSRZLQQRE\üRF]\ZLVWH
5R]G]LDä
u
:SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
:\PLHQLDOQR èRELHNWÑZ
]X \FLHPSROLPRUIL]PX
3U]\SUDF\]KLHUDUFKLDPLW\SyZFKFHP\F] VWRWUDNWRZDüGDQ\RELHNWQLHMDNRUHSUH
]HQWDQWDW\SXVSHFMDOL]RZDQHJROHF]UDF]HMED]RZHJR3R]ZDODWRQDSLVDQLHNRGXQLH
]DOH QHJRRGNRQNUHWQHJRW\SX:SU]\NáDG]LH]ILJXUDPLIXQNFMHPDQLSXOXM QLPLQLH
]ZUDFDM FXZDJLQDWRF]\PDM GRF]\QLHQLD]RNU JDPLNZDGUDWDPLWUyMN WDPLF]\WH
WDNLPLILJXUDPLNWyUHQLH]RVWDá\MHV]F]HQDZHW]GHILQLRZDQH:V]\VWNLHRQHPRJ E\ü
QDU\VRZDQHZ\PD]DQHOXESU]HVXQL WH]DWHPIXQNFMHWHSU]HV\áDM SRSURVWXNRPXQLNDW\
GRRELHNWXW\SXILJXUDQLHSU]HMPXM VL VSRVREHPZMDNLRELHNWUHDJXMHQDWHNRPXQLNDW\
1DNRGWDNLQLHPDZSá\ZXGRGDZDQLHQRZ\FKW\SyZDGRGDZDQLHWDNLHMHVWQDMSRZ
V]HFKQLHMV]\PVSRVREHPUR]V]HU]DQLDSURJUDPXRELHNWRZHJRZFHOXREVáX HQLDQRZ\FK
V\WXDFML0R HP\QDSU]\NáDGVWZRU]\üQRZ\W\SILJXU\]ZDQ\SL FLRN WHPQLHPRG\IL
NXM FIXQNFMLRGQRV] F\FKVL MHG\QLHGRRJyOQ\FKILJXU7DNDPR OLZR üUR]V]HU]DQLD
SURJUDPXSRSU]H]WZRU]HQLHQRZ\FKW\SyZSRFKRGQ\FKMHVWZD Q\PVSRVREHPKHUPH
W\]DFML]PLDQSRQLHZD ]QDF] FRXOHSV]DSURMHNW\REQL DM FUyZQRF]H QLHNRV]W\SLHO
JQDFMLRSURJUDPRZDQLD
3U]\SUyELHWUDNWRZDQLDW\SyZSRFKRGQ\FKMDNRLFKRJyOQ\FKW\SyZSRGVWDZRZ\FKQS
RNU JyZMDNRILJXUURZHUyZMDNRSRMD]GyZNRUPRUDQyZMDNRSWDNyZLWGSRZVWDMH
MHGQDNSHZLHQSUREOHP-H HOLIXQNFMD]DPLHU]DSRZLHG]LHüRJyOQHMILJXU]HDE\VL QD
U\VRZDáD RJyOQHPX SRMD]GRZL DE\ MHFKDá OXE RJyOQHPX SWDNRZL DE\ VL SRUXV]\á
NRPSLODWRUQLHPR HZF]DVLHNRPSLODFMLRNUH OLüNWyU\NDZDáHNNRGXSRZLQLHQ]RVWDü
Z\NRQDQ\²IXQNFMDU\VRZDQLDPR HUyZQLHGREU]HGRW\F]\üRNU JXNZDGUDWXF]\
WUyMN WDDRELHNWZ\NRQDRGSRZLHGQLNRGZ\NRU]\VWXM FVZyMZáD FLZ\VSHF\ILF]Q\W\S
-H HOLQLHPXVLP\ZLHG]LHüNWyU\IUDJPHQWNRGXE G]LHZ\NRQDQ\ZWHG\SU]\GRGD
ZDQLXQRZHJRSRGW\SXNRGSU]H]QLHJRZ\NRQ\ZDQ\PR HE\üLQQ\EH]NRQLHF]QR FL
GRNRQ\ZDQLD]PLDQZZ\ZRáDQLDFKPHWRG.RPSLODWRUQLHPR HZL FZLHG]LHüNWyU\
NDZDáHNNRGX]RVWDQLHZ\NRQDQ\&R]DWHPUREL"1DSU]\NáDGQDSRQL V]\PU\VXQNX
NODVD
5VGTQYPKM2VCMC
SUDFXMHZ\á F]QLH]RJyOQ\PLRELHNWDPLW\SX
2VCM
QLH]QDM FLFK
NRQNUHWQ\FKW\SyZ-HVWWRZ\JRGQH]SXQNWXZLG]HQLDNODV\
5VGTQYPKM2VCMC
SRQLHZD
QLHPXVLRQD]DZLHUDüVSHFMDOQHJRNRGXZ\]QDF]DM FHJRGRNáDGQ\W\SOXE]DFKRZDQLH
2VCMC
]MDNLPPDGRF]\QLHQLD-DNZL FVL WRG]LHMH HFKRü
RQTWU\CL
Z\ZRá\ZDQH
MHVWEH]]QDMRPR FLNRQNUHWQHJRW\SX
2VCMC
WRMHGQDNPDPLHMVFHZáD FLZH]DFKRZDQLH
)ú
ELHJQLHOHFLOXESá\QLH
2KPIYKP
ELHJQLHOXESá\QLH"
7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
2GSRZLHG]L MHVW SRGVWDZRZD V]WXF]ND SURJUDPRZDQLD RELHNWRZHJR NRPSLODWRU QLH
PR HZ\ZRáDüIXQNFMLZWUDG\F\MQ\VSRVyE:\ZRáDQLDIXQNFMLJHQHURZDQHSU]H]NRP
SLODWRU\M ]\NyZQLH]RULHQWRZDQ\FKRELHNWRZRX \ZDM W]ZZF]HVQHJRZL ]DQLDDQJ
HDUO\ELQGLQJ²WHUPLQXWHJRPR QDQLH]QDüSRQLHZD ZF]H QLHMIXQNFMLQLHPR QD
E\áRZ\ZRá\ZDüLQDF]HM=QDF]\WR HNRPSLODWRUJHQHUXMHZ\ZRáDQLHIXQNFMLRRNUH ORQHM
QD]ZLHSURJUDPá F] F\DQJOLQNHU]DPLHQLD]D WRZ\ZRáDQLHQDEH]Z]JO GQ\DGUHV
NRGXNWyU\PD]RVWDüZ\NRQDQ\:SURJUDPRZDQLXRELHNWRZ\PDGUHVRGSRZLHGQLHJR
IUDJPHQWXNRGXQLHPR H]RVWDüZ\]QDF]RQ\D GRF]DVXZ\NRQDQLD]DWHPSU]\Z\
V\áDQLXNRPXQLNDWXGRRJyOQHJRRELHNWXNRQLHF]QHMHVWLQQHUR]ZL ]DQLH
: FHOX UR]ZL ]DQLD WHJR SUREOHPX SURJUDPRZDQLH RELHNWRZH ZSURZDG]D NRQFHSFM
Sy QHJRZL ]DQLDDQJODWHELQGLQJ3U]\Z\V\áDQLXNRPXQLNDWXGRRELHNWXNRGNWyU\
E G]LHZ\ZRáDQ\QLHMHVW]GHWHUPLQRZDQ\D GRF]DVXZ\NRQDQLD.RPSLODWRUXSHZQLD
VL HPHWRGDLVWQLHMHVSUDZG]DW\S\DUJXPHQWyZLW\S]ZUDFDQHMZDUWR FLQLHZLHMHGQDN
MDNLNRGQDOH \Z\NRQDü
:FHOXSU]HSURZDG]HQLDSy QHJRZL ]DQLD-DYDXPLHV]F]D]DPLDVWEH]Z]JO GQHJRZ\
ZRáDQLDVSHFMDOQ\IUDJPHQWNRGXREOLF]DM F\DGUHVFLDáDPHWRG\QDSRGVWDZLHLQIRUPD
FMLSU]HFKRZ\ZDQHMZRELHNFLHSURFHVWHQMHVWV]F]HJyáRZRRSLVDQ\ZUR]G]LDOH
Ä3ROLPRUIL]P´.D G\RELHNWPR H]DWHP]DFKRZ\ZDüVL LQDF]HMZ]DOH QR FLRGZ\
QLNXG]LDáDQLDWHJRPDáHJRIUDJPHQWXNRGX*G\Z\V\áDP\NRPXQLNDWGRRELHNWXRELHNW
GHF\GXMHFR]QLP]URELü
:QLHNWyU\FKM ]\NDFKPXVLP\MDZQLH]DGHNODURZDü HRF]HNXMHP\RGIXQNFMLHODVW\F]
QR FL]DSHZQLDQHMSU]H]Sy QHZL ]DQLHZM ]\NX&ZW\PFHOXZ\NRU]\VW\ZDQHMHVW
VáRZRNOXF]RZH
XKTVWCN
:M ]\NDFKW\FKZ\ZRáDQLDIXQNFMLVNáDGRZ\FKGRP\ OQLHQLH
V G\QDPLF]QLHZL ]DQH3RZRGRZDáRWRSUREOHP\GODWHJRZ-DYLHG\QDPLF]QHZL ]DQLH
MHVWGRP\ OQHLQLHPXVLP\X \ZDü DGQ\FKGRGDWNRZ\FKVáyZNOXF]RZ\FKDE\VNRU]\
VWDü]SROLPRUIL]PX
5R]ZD P\SU]\NáDG]ILJXUDPL5RG]LQDNODVED]XM F\FKQDW\PVDP\PLQWHUIHMVLH]R
VWDáDSU]HGVWDZLRQDQLHFRZF]H QLHMQDGLDJUDPLH$E\]DGHPRQVWURZDüG]LDáDQLHSR
OLPRUIL]PXFKFLHOLE\ P\QDSLVDüIUDJPHQWSURJUDPXLJQRUXM F\FKDUDNWHU\VW\F]QHGOD
W\SXV]F]HJyá\LZ\NRU]\VWXM F\MHG\QLHLQWHUIHMVNODV\ED]RZHM.RGWHQE G]LHQLH]D
OH Q\RGLQIRUPDFMLVSHF\ILF]QHMGODW\SXDSU]H]WRSURVWV]\GRQDSLVDQLDLáDWZLHMV]\GR
]UR]XPLHQLD3R]DW\PMH OLQRZ\W\SQS
5\G EKQMæV
]RVWDQLHGRGDQ\SRSU]H]G]LH
G]LF]HQLHNRGNWyU\QDSLV]HP\E G]LHG]LDáDá]W\PQRZ\PW\SHPILJXU\WDNVDPRGR
EU]HMDN]LVWQLHM F\PLZF]H QLHMW\SDPL3URJUDPMHVW]DWHPUR]V]HU]DOQ\
-H HOLQDSLV]HVL Z-DYLHDQLHGáXJRQDXF]\P\VL WRURELüQDVW SXM F PHWRG
XQKF\TÎD%Q (KIWTCH]
HY[OC
HPCT[UWL
_
NRPXQLNXMHVL RQD]GRZROQ ILJXU MHVWZL FQLH]DOH QDRGNRQNUHWQHJRW\SXRELHNWX
NWyU\PDE\üU\VRZDQ\LZ\PD]\ZDQ\-H HOLIXQNFM
\TÎD%Q
Z\NRU]\VWDP\ZMDNLP
LQQ\PIUDJPHQFLHSURJUDPX
5R]G]LDä
u
:SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
1MTæIQPGY1MTæI
6TÎLMæVVPGY6TÎLMæV
.KPKCNPGY.KPKC
\TÎD%Q Q
\TÎD%Q V
\TÎD%Q N
Z\ZRáDQLD
\TÎD%Q
E G DXWRPDW\F]QLHG]LDáDüSRSUDZQLHEH]Z]JO GXQDGRNáDGQ\
W\SRELHNWX
:LVWRFLHMHVWWRGRV\ü]DVNDNXM FDV]WXF]ND5R]ZD P\ZLHUV]
\TÎD%Q Q
1MTæI
MHVWSU]HND]\ZDQ\IXQNFMLRF]HNXM FHMDUJXPHQWXW\SX
(KIWTC
3RQLHZD
1MTæI
MHVW
URG]DMHPILJXU\PR HZL FE\ü]DWDN X]QDZDQ\SU]H]PHWRG
\TÎD%Q
=QDF]\WR H
ND G\NRPXQLNDWMDNL
\TÎD%Q
PR HZ\VáDüGRRELHNWXW\SX
(KIWTC
PR HE\ü]DDN
FHSWRZDQ\SU]H]
1MTæI
7RFRWXWDMURELP\MHVWZL FFDáNRZLFLHORJLF]QHLEH]SLHF]QH
3URFHVWDNLSROHJDM F\QDWUDNWRZDQLXW\SXSRFKRGQHJRWDNMDNE\E\áVZRLPW\SHPED
]RZ\PQD]\ZDP\U]XWRZDQLHPZJyU DQJXSFDVWLQJ5]XWRZDQLHX \ZDQHMHVWWX
ZVHQVLHGRVWRVRZ\ZDQLDGRSHZQHMIRUP\ZJyU ]D RGQRVLVL GRVSRVREXZMDNL]Z\
NOHU\VXMHVL GLDJUDP\G]LHG]LF]HQLD²]NODV ED]RZ QDV]F]\FLHLNODVDPLSRFKRG
Q\PLUR]ZLMDM F\PLVL ZGyá5]XWRZDQLHGRW\SXED]RZHJRR]QDF]D]DWHPSU]HVXZDQLH
VL ZJyU GLDJUDPXMHVWZL FU]HF]\ZL FLHÄU]XWRZDQLHPZJyU ´
3URJUDP]RULHQWRZDQ\RELHNWRZR]DZLHUDZSHZQ\FKPLHMVFDFKU]XWRZDQLHZJyU SR
QLHZD ZWHQVSRVyEXZDOQLDP\VL RGNRQLHF]QR FL]QDMRPR FLGRNáDGQHJRW\SX]NWyU\P
SUDFXMHP\6SyMU]P\QDNRGPHWRG\
\TÎD%Q
HY[OC
HPCT[UWL
-DNZLGDüQLHQDSLVDOL P\WXÄ-H OLMHVWH RNU JLHP]UyEWRMH OLMHVWH NZDGUDWHP]UyE
WDPWRLWG´-H OLSLV]HP\NRGVSUDZG]DM F\ZV]\VWNLHW\S\MDNLHPR HPLHü
(KIWTC
VWDMH
VL WRQLHHOHJDQFNLHDSR]DW\PPXVLE\ü]PLHQLDQHSU]\ND G\PGRGDQLXQRZHJRURG]DMX
ILJXU\:SRZ\ V]\PIUDJPHQFLHPyZLP\SRSURVWXÄ-H HOLMHVWH ILJXU WR]QDF]\ H
SRWUDILV]Z\PD]DüVL LQDU\VRZDü=UyEZL FWRL]DMPLMVL RGSRZLHGQLRV]F]HJyáDPL´
:NRG]LHPHWRG\
\TÎD%Q
LPSRQXMHIDNW HZMDNL VSRVyEG]LHMHVL WRFRSRZLQQR
:\ZRáDQLH
PCT[UWL
GODRELHNWX
1MTæI
SRZRGXMHZ\NRQDQLHLQQHJRNRGXQL WHQZ\NR
Q\ZDQ\SU]\Z\ZRáDQLXWHMVDPHMPHWRG\GOD
-YCFTCV
DOER
.KPKC
MHGQDNMH OLNRPXQLNDW
7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
PCT[UWL
]RVWDQLHZ\VáDQ\GRDQRQLPRZHM
(KIWT[
ZWHG\PDPLHMVFH]DFKRZDQLHSR
SUDZQH GOD U]HF]\ZLVWHJR W\SX WHM
(KIWT[
-HVW WR ]DG]LZLDM FH SRQLHZD ² MDN MX
ZVSRPQLDáHP²NRPSLODWRU-DY\NRPSLOXM F
\TÎD%Q
QLHZLH]MDNLPLGRNáDGQLHW\SDPL
PDGRF]\QLHQLD1RUPDOQLHRF]HNLZDOLE\ P\]DWHP HX \MHRQZHUVML
PCT[UWL
L
Y[OC
]GHILQLRZDQ\FKGODED]RZHMNODV\
(KIWTC
QLH]D VSHF\ILF]Q\FKGOD
1MTæI
-YCFTCV
F]\
.KPKC
0LPRWRG]L NLSROLPRUIL]PRZLG]LHMHVL WRFRSRZLQQR.RPSLODWRULV\VWHP
F]DVXZ\NRQDQLD]DMPXM VL V]F]HJyáDPL²PXVLP\MHG\QLHZLHG]LHü HWRG]LDáDLFR
LVWRWQLHMV]HMDNSURMHNWRZDü]Z\NRU]\VWDQLHPWHJRPHFKDQL]PX*G\Z\ OHP\NRPX
QLNDWGRRELHNWX]URELRQWRFRSRZLQLHQQDZHWMH OLX \WHE\áRU]XWRZDQLHZJyU
+LHUDUFKLD]SRMHG\QF]\PNRU]HQLHP
-HGQ ]NZHVWLLVSRUQ\FKGRW\F] F\FKSURJUDPRZDQLDRELHNWRZHJRF] VWRSRUXV]DQ RG
F]DVXSRMDZLHQLDVL &MHVWWRF]\ZV]\VWNLHNODV\SRZLQQ\RVWDWHF]QLHG]LHG]LF]\üSR
ZVSyOQHMNODVLHED]RZHM:-DYLHSRGREQLHMDNZQLHPDOZV]\VWNLFKM ]\NDFKRELHNWR
Z\FKRGSRZLHG EU]PLÄWDN´QD]Z WHMZVSyOQHMNODV\ED]RZHMMHVW]D
1DLGEV
2ND
]XMHVL HKLHUDUFKLD]SRMHG\QF]\PNRU]HQLHPGDMHOLF]QHNRU]\ FL
:KLHUDUFKLL]SRMHG\QF]\PNRU]HQLHPZV]\VWNLHRELHNW\SRVLDGDM ZVSyOQ\LQWHUIHMVZL F
ZRVWDWHF]QR FLZV]\VWNLHV WHJRVDPHJRW\SX$OWHUQDW\ZDGRVWDUF]DQDSU]H]&
SROHJDQDW\P HQLHZLHP\F]\ZV]\VWNRPDWHQVDPIXQGDPHQWDOQ\W\S=SXQNWX
ZLG]HQLDZVWHF]QHM]JRGQR FLRGSRZLDGDWREDUG]LHMPRGHORZL&DOHMHVWPQLHMRJUDQL
F]DM FH-HGQDNMH OLFKFHP\SURJUDPRZDüZSHáQLRELHNWRZRPXVLP\EXGRZDüZáDVQ
KLHUDUFKL DE\X]\VNDüWDN VDP Z\JRG MDNDMHVWZEXGRZDQDZLQQHM ]\NLRELHNWRZH
'RGDWNRZRZND GHMQRZHMELEOLRWHFHNODVMDN SR]\VNDP\X \W\E G]LHMDNL LQQ\QLH
]JRGQ\LQWHUIHMV'RSDVRZDQLHWHJRQRZHJRLQWHUIHMVXGRQDV]HJRSURMHNWXZ\PDJDüE G]LH
Z\VLáNXDE\üPR HWDN HZLHORNURWQHJRG]LHG]LF]HQLD&]\GRGDWNRZDÄHODVW\F]QR ü´
&MHVWWHJRZDUWD"-H HOLVL MHMSRWU]HEXMH²MH HOL]DLQZHVWRZDáRVL ZLHOHZ&²
ZWHG\MHVWGRV\üFHQQD-H HOL]DF]\QDP\RG]HUDLQQHRSFMHWDNLHMDN-DYDPRJ RND]Dü
VL EDUG]LHMSURGXNW\ZQH
:KLHUDUFKLL]SRMHG\QF]\PNRU]HQLHPPDP\JZDUDQFM SRVLDGDQLDSHZQ\FKIXQNFML
SU]H]ZV]\VWNLHRELHNW\:LHP\ HSHZQHSRGVWDZRZHRSHUDFMHPR QDZ\NRQDüQD
ND G\PRELHNFLHZV\VWHPLH:V]\VWNLHRELHNW\PR QDáDWZRWZRU]\üZSDPL FLVWHUW\
FR]QDF] FRXSURV]F]DUyZQLH SU]HND]\ZDQLHDUJXPHQWyZ
+LHUDUFKLDRSRMHG\QF]\PNRU]HQLXZGX \PVWRSQLXXáDWZLDLPSOHPHQWDFM PHFKDQL]PX
SU]\ZUDFDQLDSDPL FLFRMHVWMHGQ ]ZD QLHMV]\FK]DOHW-DY\ZREHF&3RQLHZD
LQIRUPDFMDF]DVXZ\NRQDQLDRW\SLHMHVW]DJZDUDQWRZDQDZND G\PRELHNFLHQLJG\QLH
SR]RVWDQLHP\]RELHNWHPNWyUHJRW\SXQLHPR HP\RNUH OLü-HVWWRV]F]HJyOQLHLVWRWQH
ZSU]\SDGNXRSHUDFMLQDSR]LRPLHV\VWHPXWDNLFKMDNREVáXJDZ\M WNyZRUD]GODXPR
OLZLHQLDZL NV]HMHODVW\F]QR FLZSURJUDPRZDQLX
5R]G]LDä
u
:SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
.RQWHQHU\
6NRUR]DVDGQLF]RQLHZLHP\LOHRELHNWyZE G]LHQDPSRWU]HEQ\FKGRUR]ZL ]DQLDRNUH
ORQHJRSUREOHPXDQLMDNGáXJRRELHNW\WHE G LVWQLHüQLHZLHP\UyZQLH ZMDNLVSR
VyERELHNW\WHSU]HFKRZ\ZDü6N GPDP\ZLHG]LHüLOHPLHMVFDGODQLFKSU]H]QDF]\ü"
7DLQIRUPDFMDMHVWQLHGRVW SQDD GRF]DVXZ\NRQDQLDSURJUDPX
5R]ZL ]DQLDZL NV]R FLSUREOHPyZZSURMHNWRZDQLXRELHNWRZ\PZ\GDM VL G]LZQLH
SURVWHWZRU]\P\QRZ\W\SRELHNWyZ:SU]\SDGNXRPDZLDQHJRSUREOHPXW\PQRZ\P
W\SHPMHVWRELHNWSU]HFKRZXM F\UHIHUHQFMHGRLQQ\FKRELHNWyZ0RJOLE\ P\RF]\ZL FLH
X]\VNDüDQDORJLF]Q\HIHNWX \ZDM FWDEOLFGRVW SQ\FKZQLHPDOND G\PM ]\NXSUR
JUDPRZDQLD'RVWDMHP\MHGQDNZL FHMQRZ\RELHNW]ZDQ\NRQWHQHUHPOXENROHNFM
OHF]VáRZRWRMHVWX \ZDQHZ-DYLHZLQQ\P]QDF]HQLXZ]ZL ]NX]W\PZWHMNVL FH
E G]LHX \ZDQ\WHUPLQÄNRQWHQHU´E G]LHUR]V]HU]DáVL JG\E G]LHWRNRQLHF]QHE\
SU]\M üZV]\VWNRFRGRQLHJRZVWDZLP\1LHPXVLP\ZL FZLHG]LHüLOHRELHNWyZ
E G]LHSU]HFKRZ\ZDQ\FKZNRQWHQHU]H3RSURVWXWZRU]\P\JRLSR]ZDODP\PX]DM ü
VL V]F]HJyáDPL
1DV]F] FLHND G\GREU\M ]\NRELHNWRZ\GRVWDUF]DQ\MHVW]]HVWDZHPNRQWHQHUyZ:&
]HVWDZWDNLMHVWF] FL ELEOLRWHNLVWDQGDUGRZHMLRNUH ODQ\MHVWF]DVDPLDNURQLPHP67/
6WDQGDUG7HPSODWH/LEUDU\:M ]\NX2EMHFW3DVFDONRQWHQHU\VWDQRZL F] üELEOLRWH
NL9&/9LVXDO&RPSRQHQW/LEUDU\6PDOOWDONSRVLDGDEDUG]RUR]EXGRZDQ ELEOLRWHN
NRQWHQHUyZ7DN H-DYDSRVLDGDNRQWHQHU\ZVZHMELEOLRWHFHVWDQGDUGRZHM:QLHNWyU\FK
ELEOLRWHNDFKRJyOQ\NRQWHQHUXZD DQ\MHVW]DZ\VWDUF]DM FRGREU\GRZV]\VWNLFK]DVWR
VRZD ZLQQ\FK]D QSZ-DYLHLVWQLHM Uy QHW\S\NRQWHQHUyZGODUy Q\FKSRWU]HENLOND
Uy Q\FKURG]DMyZNODV
.KUV
VáX F\FKGRSU]HFKRZ\ZDQLDVHNZHQFMLNODV\
/CR
]ZDQH
WDN HWDEOLFDPLDVRFMDF\MQ\PLNWyUHNRMDU] MHGQHRELHNW\]LQQ\PLNODV\
5GV
GRSU]H
FKRZ\ZDQLD QLHSRZWDU]DM F\FK VL HOHPHQWyZ %LEOLRWHNL NRQWHQHUyZ PRJ UyZQLH
]DZLHUDüNROHMNLGU]HZDVWRV\LWG
=SURMHNWRZHJRSXQNWXZLG]HQLDZV]\VWNRF]HJRSRWU]HEXMHP\WRNRQWHQHUNWyU\P
PR QDVL SRVáXJLZDüZFHOXUR]ZL ]DQLDSUREOHPX*G\E\SRMHG\QF]\W\SNRQWHQHUD
Z\VWDUF]DáQLHE\áRE\SRWU]HE\SRVLDGDQLDUy Q\FKLFKURG]DMyZ,VWQLHM GZDSRZRG\
GODNWyU\FKSRWU]HEQ\MHVWZ\EyUPL G]\NRQWHQHUDPL3RSLHUZV]HNRQWHQHU\SRVLD
GDM Uy QHLQWHUIHMV\L]HZQ WU]QH]DFKRZDQLD=DFKRZDQLHVL LLQWHUIHMVVWRVXV Uy QH
RGW\FK]DSHZQLDQ\FKSU]H]NROHMN NWyUD]NROHLUy QLVL RG]ELRUXF]\OLVW\2NUH ORQ\
LQWHUIHMVPR H]DSHZQLDüEDUG]LHMHODVW\F]QHUR]ZL ]DQLHQDV]HJRSUREOHPXQL LQQ\
3R GUXJLH NRV]W Z\NRQDQLD W\FK VDP\FK RSHUDFML QD Uy Q\FK NRQWHQHUDFK MHVW LQQ\
1DMOHSV]\SU]\NáDGVWDQRZL
#TTC[.KUV
L
.KPMGF.KUV
2ELHWHNODV\UHSUH]HQWXM SURVWH
OLVW\HOHPHQWyZPDM LGHQW\F]QHLQWHUIHMV\LFHFKXM VL SRGREQ\P]DFKRZDQLHP]H
ZQ WU]Q\P-HGQDNRNUH ORQHRSHUDFMHPRJ PLHüGODQLFK]DVDGQLF]RUy]Q\NRV]W'R
VW SVZRERGQ\GRHOHPHQWyZZNODVLH
#TTC[.KUV
MHVWRSHUDFM Z\NRQ\ZDQ ZF]DVLHVWD
á\P²WUZDWDNVDPRGáXJREH]Z]JO GXQDWRGRNWyUHJRHOHPHQWXVL RGZRáXMHP\
-HGQDN H Z SU]\SDGNX
.KPMGF.KUV
Z\EUDQLH RNUH ORQHJR HOHPHQWX Z\PDJD SU]HM FLD
SU]H]HOHPHQW\SRSU]HG]DM FHJRQDOL FLHFRMHVWRSHUDFM W\PNRV]WRZQLHMV] LPGD
OHMQDOL FLH]QDMGXMHVL HOHPHQW=GUXJLHMVWURQ\GRGDQLHHOHPHQWXZ URGNXOLVW\MHVW
7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
]QDF]QLHWD V]HZZ\SDGNXOLVW\SRZL ]DQHM
.KPMGF.KUV
7HLLQQHRSHUDFMHPDM ]Uy QL
FRZDQ HIHNW\ZQR üZ]DOH QR FLRGZHZQ WU]QHMLPSOHPHQWDFMLOLVW\:ID]LHSURMHNWR
ZDQLDPRJOLE\ P\]DF] üRGZ\NRU]\VWDQLDOLVW\SRZL ]DQHMSRF]\PSU]\GRVWUDMDQLX
HIHNW\ZQR FLSU]HVWDZLüVL QDZHNWRU
#TTC[.KUV
']L NL]DSHZQLDQHMSU]H]LWHUDWRU\
DEVWUDNFMLZSá\ZWDNLHM]PLDQ\QDNRGE\áE\PLQLPDOQ\
7\S\SDUDPHWU\]RZDQHW\S\RJÑOQH
: ZHUVMDFK M ]\ND SRSU]HG]DM F\FK Z\GDQLH -DYD 6( NRQWHQHU\ SU]HFKRZ\ZDá\ HOH
PHQW\MHGQHJRXQLZHUVDOQHJRW\SX
1DLGEV
+LHUDUFKLD]SRMHG\QF]\PNRU]HQLHPLPSOL
NXMH HZV]\VWNLHRELHNW\V UHSUH]HQWDQWDPLNODV\
1DLGEV
D]DWHPNRQWHQHU\PRJ FH
SU]HFKRZ\ZDüRELHNW\WHMNODV\PRJ SU]HFKRZ\ZDüFRNROZLHN
7RZáD QLHG]L NLWHPX
NRQWHQHU\QDGDM VL GRWDNSRZV]HFKQHJRVWRVRZDQLD
8 \ZDM FWDNLHJRNRQWHQHUDZVWDZLDP\GRQLHJRSRSURVWXUHIHUHQFMHGRRELHNWyZDSy
QLHMSURVLP\RLFK]ZURW-HGQDNVNRURNRQWHQHUSU]HFKRZXMHRELHNW\NODV\
1DLGEV
SU]\
ZVWDZLDQLXGRNRQWHQHUDGRNRQXMHVL U]XWRZDQLDQDW NODV SU]H]FRWUDFLP\LQIRUPDFM
RNRQNUHWQ\PW\SLHZVWDZLDQHJRRELHNWX:\MPXM FRELHNWRWU]\PXMHP\UyZQLH UHIHUHQFM
GRW\SX
1DLGEV
DQLHGRRU\JLQDOQHJRW\SXZáR RQHJRRELHNWX-DN]DWHP]DPLHQLüM QD
SRZUyWQDFR RLQWHUIHMVLHRELHNWXNWyU\ZVWDZLOL P\GRNRQWHQHUD"
,ZW\PSU]\SDGNXSRWU]HEXMHP\U]XWRZDQLDMHGQDNQLHE G]LHWRMX U]XWRZDQLHZJyU
KLHUDUFKLLG]LHG]LF]HQLDGODX]\VNDQLDEDUG]LHMRJyOQHJRW\SX²U]XWXMHP\WHUD]ZGyá
Z FHOX X]\VNDQLD W\SX VSHFMDOL]RZDQHJR 7HQ URG]DM U]XWRZDQLD QD]\ZDP\ ZáD QLH
U]XWRZDQLHPZGyáDQJGRZQFDVWLQJ*G\U]XWXMHP\ZJyU ZLHP\QDSU]\NáDG H
ÄRNU J´MHVWURG]DMHPÄILJXU\´WDNZL FU]XWRZDQLHMHVWWX]DZV]HEH]SLHF]QH1LHPR HP\
MHGQDN]JyU\SU]HZLG]LHü HGDQ\RELHNWW\SX
1DLGEV
MHVW]SHZQR FL ÄRNU JLHP´F]\
ÄILJXU ´²WUXGQRZL FX]QDüWHQURG]DMU]XWRZDQLD]DEH]SLHF]Q\FK\ED HZMDNL VSRVyE
SR]QDP\ZáD FLZ\W\SRELHNWX]NWyU\PPDP\GRF]\QLHQLD
6\WXDFMDQLHMHVWMHGQDNEDUG]RQLHEH]SLHF]QD²GRNRQXM FU]XWRZDQLDQDQLHZáD FLZ\W\S
VSRZRGXMHP\Z\VW SLHQLHEá GXF]DVXZ\NRQDQLD]ZDQHJRZ\M WNLHPDQJH[FHSWLRQ
²RZ\M WNDFKGRZLHP\VL ZL FHMMX QLHEDZHP0LPRWRSU]\Z\MPRZDQLX]NRQWHQHUD
UHIHUHQFMLGRRELHNWyZPXVLP\ZFHOXGRNRQDQLDSUDZLGáRZHJRU]XWRZDQLDSDPL WDü
MDNLHJRZáD FLZLHWHRELHNW\V W\SX
5]XWRZDQLHZGyáZSRá F]HQLX]NRQLHF]QR FL Z\NRQ\ZDQLDWHVWyZF]DVXZ\NRQDQLD
SRZRGXMHSHZLHQQDU]XWF]DVRZ\ZG]LDáDM F\PSURJUDPLHRUD]Z\PDJDGRGDWNRZHJR
Z\VLáNX RG SURJUDPLVW\ 0R QD ]DS\WDü F]\ QLH GDáRE\ VL Z MDNL VSRVyE VWZRU]\ü
NRQWHQHUDÄ]QDM FHJR´W\SSU]HFKRZ\ZDQ\FKSU]H]VLHELHRELHNWyZLZ\HOLPLQRZDüZWHQ
VSRVyENRQLHF]QR üU]XWRZDQLDRUD]PR OLZR üSRSHáQLHQLDEá GyZ"5R]ZL ]DQLHPV
W\S\ SDUDPHWU\]RZDQH DQJ SDUDPHWUL]HG W\SHV ² NODV\ NWyUH NRPSLODWRU DXWRPD
W\F]QLHGRVWRVRZXMHGRSUDF\]SRGDQ\PLW\SDPLSDUDPHWUDPL1DSU]\NáDGSDUDPHWU\
]RZDQ\NRQWHQHUPR H]RVWDüSU]\VWRVRZDQ\WDNDE\DNFHSWRZDáW\ONRRELHNW\NODV\
(KIWTC
L]ZUDFDáWDN HW\ONR
(KIWT[
1LHGRW\F]\áRWRW\SyZHOHPHQWDUQ\FKPHFKDQL]PSDNRZDQLDZDUWR FLHOHPHQWDUQ\FKVNDODUQ\FK
ZRELHNWDFKDQJDXWRER[LQJZSURZDG]RQ\Z-DYLH6(Z\HOLPLQRZDáWRRJUDQLF]HQLHQLHPDO
FDáNRZLFLH:UyFLP\GRWHJRZGDOV]HMF] FLNVL NL
5R]G]LDä
u
:SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
-HGQ ]ZD QLHMV]\FKQRZR FLZ-DYLH6(MHVWZáD QLHREHFQR üW\SyZSDUDPHWU\]R
ZDQ\FK]ZDQ\FKWH W\SDPLRJyOQ\PLDQJJHQHULFV3DUDPHWU\]DFM UR]SR]QDMHP\SR
REHFQR FLQDZLDVyZN WRZ\FKSU]\QD]ZLHNODV\]OLVW W\SyZSDUDPHWU\]XM F\FKGDQ
NODV 1DSU]\NáDGRELHNWNODVD
#TTC[.KUV
NODV\NRQWHQHUDZZHUVMLSU]\VWRVRZDQHMGR
SU]HFKRZ\ZDQLDRELHNWyZNODV\
(KIWTC
WZRU]\VL WDN
#TTC[.KUV(KIWTC HKIWT[PGY#TTC[.KUV(KIWTC
3DUDPHWU\]DFMDW\SyZVSRZRGRZDáDOLF]QH]PLDQ\ZLHOXNRPSRQHQWyZELEOLRWHNLVWDQ
GDUGRZHMM ]\ND-DYD-DNVL QLHEDZHPRND HGRVW SQR üW\SyZRJyOQ\FKZSá\QLHQD
ZL NV]R üNRGyZSU]\NáDGRZ\FKSUH]HQWRZDQ\FKZWHMNVL FH
7ZRU]HQLHRELHNWÑZLF]DVLFK \FLD
.D G\RELHNWDE\PyJáLVWQLHüZ\PDJD]DVREyZ²SU]HGHZV]\VWNLPSDPL FL.LHG\
RELHNWSU]HVWDMHE\üSRWU]HEQ\QDOH \SRQLPÄSRVSU] WDü´F]\OL]ZROQLüSU]\G]LHORQHPX
]DVRE\DE\PR QDMHE\áRSRZWyUQLHZ\NRU]\VWDü=D]Z\F]DMSUREOHPÄSRVSU] WDQLD´SR
RELHNFLHQLHZ\GDMHVL E\üV]F]HJyOQ\PZ\]ZDQLHP²RELHNWMHVWWZRU]RQ\VWRVRZDQ\
WDNGáXJRMDNMHVWSRWU]HEQ\DQDVW SQLHQDOH \JRXVXQ ü-HGQDNQLHWUXGQRVSRWNDüV\
WXDFMH]QDF]QLHEDUG]LHMVNRPSOLNRZDQH
=Dáy P\ H WZRU]\P\ V\VWHP REVáXJL UXFKX SRZLHWU]QHJR GOD ORWQLVND 7HJR VDPHJR
PRGHOXPR QDE\WDN HX \ZDüGR]DU] G]DQLDWRZDUDPLZPDJD]\QLHZV\VWHPLHZ\
SR \F]DQLD NDVHW ZLGHR OXE ILUPLH ]DMPXM FHM VL WUHVXU ]ZLHU] W 1D SLHUZV]\ U]XW
RND ]DGDQLH Z\GDMH VL SURVWH WU]HED VWZRU]\ü NRQWHQHU VáX F\ GR SU]HFKRZ\ZDQLD
VDPRORWyZDQDVW SQLHXPLH FLüZQLPND G\VDPRORW]QDMGXM F\VL ZNRQWURORZD
Q\PREV]DU]HSU]HVWU]HQLSRZLHWU]QHM:UDPDFKVSU] WQL FLDQDOH \XVXQ üRELHNWVD
PRORWXNWyU\RSX FLáNRQWURORZDQ\REV]DU
%\üPR HMHGQDNG\VSRQXMHP\LQQ\PV\VWHPHPGRUHMHVWUDFMLGDQ\FKRVDPRORWDFKE\ü
PR HQLHV WRGDQHZ\PDJDM FHWDNQDW\FKPLDVWRZHMXZDJLMDNJáyZQHIXQNFMHVWHUR
ZDQLDORWDPL%\üPR HMHVWWR]DSLVSODQXORWyZZV]\VWNLFKPDá\FKVDPRORWyZVWDUWX
M F\FK]ORWQLVND$]DWHPPDP\GUXJLNRQWHQHUGODPDá\FKVDPRORWyZL]DND G\PUD]HP
JG\WZRU]RQ\MHVWRELHNWVDPRORWXMH OLMHVWWRVDPRORWPDá\]DSLVXMHP\JRWDN HZW\P
GUXJLPNRQWHQHU]H1DVW SQLHSRGF]DVRNUHVyZEH]F]\QQR FLV\VWHPXMDNL SURFHVG]LD
áDM F\ZWOHZ\NRQXMHQDW\PNRQWHQHU]HSHZQHRSHUDFMH
7HUD]SUREOHPVL VNRPSOLNRZDáZMDNLVSRVyERNUH OLüNLHG\PR QDXVXQ üRELHNW"
*G\RELHNWQLHMHVWMX SRWU]HEQ\ZMHGQHMF] FLV\VWHPXLQQHZFL PRJ ]QLHJRNRU]\
VWDü7HQVDPSUREOHPPR HVL SRMDZLDüZZLHOXUy Q\FKV\WXDFMDFKDZV\VWHPDFK
SURJUDPLVW\F]Q\FKZ\PDJDM F\FKMDZQHJRXVXZDQLDRELHNWyZWDNLFKMDN&PR H
RQVWDüVL EDUG]R]áR RQ\
*G]LH]QDMGXM VL GDQHRELHNWXLMDNMHVWNRQWURORZDQ\F]DVMHJR \FLD"- ]\N&
SU]\MPXMH ]DáR HQLH H QDMZD QLHMV] VSUDZ MHVW NRQWUROD HIHNW\ZQR FL GODWHJR GDMH
SURJUDPL FLHZ\EyU:FHOXRVL JQL FLDPDNV\PDOQHMV]\ENR FLF]DVXZ\NRQDQLDPR H
RQRNUH OLüVSRVyZSU]HFKRZ\ZDQLDLF]DV \FLDRELHNWXQDHWDSLHSLVDQLDSURJUDPXSR
SU]H]XPLHV]F]HQLHJRQDVWRVLHPyZLVL ZWHG\F]DVDPLR]PLHQQ\FKDXWRPDW\F]Q\FK
7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
DOERORNDOQ\FKDOERZREV]DU]HSDPL FLVWDW\F]QHM.áDG]LHVL ZWHQVSRVyEQDFLVNQD
V]\ENLHUH]HUZRZDQLHL]ZDOQLDQLHPLHMVFDSR ZL FDM FMHGQDN HHODVW\F]QR üSRQLHZD
PXVLP\]QDüGRNáDGQ OLF]E F]DV \FLDRUD]W\SRELHNWyZQDHWDSLHSLVDQLDSURJUDPX
-H HOLSUyEXMHP\UR]ZL ]DüEDUG]LHMRJyOQ\SUREOHPWDNLMDNNRPSXWHURZHZVSRPD
JDQLHSURMHNWRZDQLD]DU] G]DQLHPDJD]\QHPOXENRQWURODUXFKXSRZLHWU]QHJRZWHG\
VWDMHVL WR]E\WSRZD Q\PRJUDQLF]HQLHP
'UXJLH UR]ZL ]DQLH SROHJD QD G\QDPLF]Q\P WZRU]HQLX RELHNWyZ Z REV]DU]H SDPL FL
]ZDQ\PVWHUW 6WRVXM FWRUR]ZL ]DQLHQLHZLHP\D GRF]DVXZ\NRQDQLDLOXRELHNWyZ
SRWU]HEXMHP\MDNLPDE\üF]DVLFK \FLDRUD]GRNáDGQ\W\S.ZHVWLHWHV UR]VWU]\JDQH
Z RGSRZLHGQLP PRPHQFLH SRGF]DV G]LDáDQLD SURJUDPX -H HOL SRWU]HEXMHP\ QRZHJR
RELHNWXWZRU]\P\JRSRSURVWXQDVWHUFLH3RQLHZD SDPL üMHVW]DU] G]DQDG\QDPLF]QLH
ZF]DVLHZ\NRQDQLD]DWHPRNUHVQLH]E GQ\GRMHM]DUH]HUZRZDQLDQDVWHUFLHMHVWRZLHOH
GáX V]\QL WHQSRWU]HEQ\GR]URELHQLDWHJRVDPHJRQDVWRVLH]DUH]HUZRZDQLHPLHMVFD
QDVWRVLHZL HVL F] VWRMHG\QLH]SRMHG\QF] LQVWUXNFM DVHPEOHURZ GRSU]HVXQL FLD
ZVND QLNDVWRVXZGyáRUD]GUXJ GRSU]HVXQL FLDJR]SRZURWHPZJyU F]DVNRQLHF]Q\
GRXWZRU]HQLDPLHMVFDQDVWHUFLH]DOH \QDWRPLDVWRGNRQVWUXNFMLPHFKDQL]PXREVáXJL
SDPL FL&]DVG\QDPLF]QHJRSU]\G]LDáXZSDPL FLVWHUW\MHVW]D ]DOH Q\RGV]F]HJy
áyZPHFKDQL]PXREVáXJLSDPL FLZGDQ\PV\VWHPLH
5R]ZL ]DQLHG\QDPLF]QHED]XMHQDVáXV]Q\P]DáR HQLX HRELHNW\PRJ E\üVNRPSOL
NRZDQHD]DWHPQDU]XW]ZL ]DQ\]VDP\P]QDMGRZDQLHPL]ZDOQLDQLHPPLHMVFDQDWH
RELHNW\QLHE G]LHPLDáLVWRWQHJRZSá\ZXQDWZRU]HQLHRELHNWX3RQDGWR]ZL NV]RQDHOD
VW\F]QR üWHJRUR]ZL ]DQLDPDSRGVWDZRZH]QDF]HQLHGODUR]ZL ]\ZDQLDRJyOQ\FKSUR
EOHPyZSURJUDPLVW\F]Q\FK
-DYDVWRVXMHZ\á F]QLHGUXJLHUR]ZL ]DQLH
=DND G\PUD]HPJG\WZRU]\P\RELHNW
X \ZDP\VáRZDNOXF]RZHJR
PGY
DE\XWZRU]\üMHJRG\QDPLF]Q\HJ]HPSODU]
,QQ VSUDZ VWDQRZLF]DV \FLDRELHNWX:M ]\NDFKSR]ZDODM F\FKQDWZRU]HQLHRELHNWyZ
QDVWRVLHNRPSLODWRUZ\]QDF]DF]DVWUZDQLDRELHNWXLPR HJRDXWRPDW\F]QLH]QLV]F]\ü
-H HOLMHGQDNRELHNW]RVWDQLHVWZRU]RQ\QDVWHUFLHZWHG\NRPSLODWRUQLH]QDF]DVXMHJR
\FLD:M ]\NXWDNLPMDN&PXVLP\SURJUDPRZRRNUH OLüNLHG\QDOH \]QLV]F]\ü
RELHNWFRSURZDG]LGRZ\FLHNyZSDPL FLMH OLQLHURELVL WHJRSRSUDZQLHDMHVWWRF] VW\
SU]\SDGHNZSURJUDPDFK&-DYDSRVLDGDXGRJRGQLHQLH]ZDQHRG PLHFDF]HPSDPL FL
DXWRPDW\F]QLHZ\NU\ZDM F\PNWyU\RELHNWQLHMHVWMX X \ZDQ\DQDVW SQLHQLV]F] F\P
JR2G PLHFDF]DQJJDUEDJHFROOHFWRUMHVWUR]ZL ]DQLHP]QDF]QLHZ\JRGQLHMV]\PSR
QLHZD UHGXNXMHOLF]E ]GDU]H NWyUHPXVLP\ OHG]LüRUD]LOR üNRGXMDNLPXVLP\QD
SLVDü&RZD QLHMV]HVWDQRZLRQ]QDF]QLHZ\ V]\VWRSLH ]DEH]SLHF]HQLDSU]HGSUREOH
PHPZ\FLHNyZSDPL FLNWyU\]QLZHF]\áZLHOHSURMHNWyZZ&
:-DYLHSUREOHP]ZDOQLDQLDSDPL FL]RVWDáRGGHOHJRZDQ\GRVSHFMDOQLH]DSURMHNWRZD
QHJRRG PLHFDF]DSDPL FLFKRüQLHREHMPXMHRQSR]RVWDá\FKDVSHNWyZÄVSU] WDQLD´SR
RELHNWDFK2G PLHFDF]ÄZLH´NLHG\RELHNWQLHMHVWMX SRWU]HEQ\L]ZDOQLDSU]\G]LHORQ
PXSDPL ü']L NLWHPXRUD]]HZ]JO GXQDIDNW HZV]\VWNLHRELHNW\G]LHG]LF] SR
MHGQHMNODVLHED]RZHM²
1DLGEV
DZV]\VWNLHRELHNW\PR QDWZRU]\üW\ONRZMHGHQVSR
VyE ² QD VWHUFLH SURFHV SURJUDPRZDQLD Z -DYLH MHVW ]QDF]QLH SURVWV]\ QL Z &
0QLHMWXGHF\]MLGRSRGM FLDLSUREOHPyZGRUR]ZL ]DQLD
6SHFMDOQ\SU]\SDGHNVWDQRZL W\S\SRGVWDZRZHNWyUHSR]QDP\Sy QLHM
5R]G]LDä
u
:SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
2EVäXJDZ\MñWNÑZ
vHOLPLQRZDQLHEäöGÑZ
2GSRF] WNyZLVWQLHQLDM ]\NyZSURJUDPRZDQLDREVáXJDEá GyZE\áDMHGQ\P]QDMWUXG
QLHMV]\FK]DGD =SRZRGXWUXGQR FLMDNLFKQDVWU F]D]DSURMHNWRZDQLHGREUHJRVFKHPDWX
WDNLHMREVáXJLZLHOHM ]\NyZSRSURVWXLJQRUXMHWR]DJDGQLHQLH]U]XFDM FRGSRZLHG]LDOQR ü
QDSURMHNWDQWyZELEOLRWHN3URSRQXM RQL]Z\NOHSyá URGNLG]LDáDM FHSRSUDZQLHZZLHOX
V\WXDFMDFKE G FHMHGQDNáDWZHGRREHM FLDQDMF] FLHMSRSURVWXSU]H]LFK]LJQRURZD
QLH3RGVWDZRZ\PSUREOHPHPZL NV]R FLVFKHPDWyZREVáXJLEá GyZMHVWWR HLFKSRG
VWDZ MHVWJRWRZR üSURJUDPLVW\GRSU]HVWU]HJDQLDSHZQHMXVWDORQHMNRQZHQFMLQLHREVáX
JLZDQHMZ DGHQVSRVyESU]H]M ]\N*G\SURJUDPLVWDQLHPDQDWRRFKRW\D]GDU]DVL WR
F] VWRQSJG\VL VSLHV]\PR H]áDWZR FL RNRQZHQFML]DSRPQLHü
0HFKDQL]PREVáXJLZ\M WNyZDQJH[FHSWLRQKDQGOLQJZL HEH]SR UHGQLRREVáXJ Eá
GyZ]M ]\NLHPSURJUDPRZDQLDDF]DVHPZU F]]V\VWHPHPRSHUDF\MQ\P:\M WHNMHVW
RELHNWHPNWyU\MHVWÄZ\U]XFDQ\´]PLHMVFDZ\VW SLHQLDEá GXDQDVW SQLHPR H]RVWDü
ÄSU]HFKZ\FRQ\´SU]H]RGSRZLHGQL SURFHGXU REVáXJLZ\M WNXDQJH[FHSWLRQKDQGOHU
²]DSURMHNWRZDQ VSHFMDOQLHGRUDG]HQLDVRELH]GDQ\PW\SHPEá GyZ2EVáXJDZ\M WNyZ
MHVWDOWHUQDW\ZQ FLH N SU]HSá\ZXVWHURZDQLDZ\ELHUDQ ZSU]\SDGNXJG\FR SyMG]LH
QLHWDN²G]L NLWHPXQLHPXVLVL PLHV]Dü]NRGHPZ\NRQ\ZDQ\PZQRUPDOQHMV\WXDFML
&]\QLWRWHQRVWDWQL]QDF]QLHSURVWV]\PGRQDSLVDQLDSRQLHZD QLHWU]HEDEH]SU]HUZ\
VSUDZG]DüF]\QLHZ\VW SLá\MDNLH Eá G\=JáDV]DQLHÄZ\U]XFDQLH´Z\M WNXUy QLVL RG
XVWDZLDQLD]QDF]QLNDEá GXF]\]ZUDFDQLDXVWDORQHMR]QDF]DM FHMEá GZDUWR FLWDN H
W\P HZSU]HFLZLH VWZLHGRQLFKQLHPR H]RVWDü]LJQRURZDQH²PDP\]DWHPJZD
UDQFM HZ\M WHN]RVWDQLHZSHZQ\PPRPHQFLHREVáX RQ\:\M WNLGRVWDUF]DM WDN H
JRGQ\]DXIDQLDVSRVyEZ\M FLD]H]áHMV\WXDFML=DPLDVWSRSURVWXSU]HUZDüG]LDáDQLH
SURJUDPXPR QDF] VWRSU]\ZUyFLüZDUXQNLGRMHJRGDOV]HJRZ\NRQ\ZDQLD²QDSLVDQH
ZWHQVSRVyESURJUDP\V ]QDF]QLHVROLGQLHMV]H
3RG Z]JO GHP REVáXJL Z\M WNyZ -DYD ]QDF] FR Uy QL VL RG LQQ\FK M ]\NyZ SURJUD
PRZDQLDJG\ PHFKDQL]P\WH]RVWDá\ZEXGRZDQHZM ]\NDSURJUDPL FLV ]PXV]HQL
GRNRU]\VWDQLD]QLFK-H OLWZRU]RQ\NRGQLHE G]LHZSRSUDZQ\VSRVyEREVáXJLZDü
Z\M WNyZSRGF]DVMHJRNRPSLODFMLSRMDZL VL Eá G\7DJZDUDQWRZDQDNRQVHNZHQFMD
F]DVDPLPR HXáDWZLüREVáXJ Eá GyZ
:DUWR]D]QDF]\ü HFKRüZM ]\NDFK]RULHQWRZDQ\FKRELHNWRZRZ\M WHNMHVW]Z\NOHUH
SUH]HQWRZDQ\SU]H]RELHNWWRMHGQDNVDPPHFKDQL]PREVáXJLZ\M WNyZQLHMHVWFHFK
SU]\QDOH Q MHG\QLHW\PM ]\NRP²SRZVWDáRGQLFKZF]H QLHM
:VSÑäELH QR è
-HGQ ]SRGVWDZRZ\FKNRQFHSFMLSURJUDPRZDQLDMHVWSRP\VáZ\NRQ\ZDQLDNLONX]D
GD ZW\PVDP\PF]DVLH/LF]QHSUREOHP\SURJUDPLVW\F]QHZ\PDJDM DE\SURJUDP
E\áZVWDQLHSU]HUZDüVZ ELH F DNW\ZQR ü]DáDWZLüMDN LQQ VSUDZ LSRZUyFLüGR
JáyZQHJR]DGDQLD3UyERZDQRZLHOXUR]ZL ]D 3RF] WNRZR SURJUDPL FL SRVLDGDM F\
7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
QLVNRSR]LRPRZ ZLHG] QDWHPDWPDV]\Q\SLVDOLSURFHGXU\REVáXJLSU]HUZD D]DZLH
V]DQLHJáyZQHJRSURJUDPXE\áRLQLFMRZDQHSU]H]SU]HUZDQLDVSU] WRZH&KRüG]LDáDáRWR
]DGRZDODM FRE\áRMHGQDNVNRPSOLNRZDQHLQLHSU]HQR QHF]\QL FSURFHVSU]HQRV]HQLD
SURJUDPXQDQRZ\W\SPDV]\Q\SRZROQ\PLNRV]WRZQ\P
3U]HUZDQLDV F]DVDPLQLH]E GQHGODREVáXJL]DGD RNU\W\F]Q\FKRJUDQLF]HQLDFKF]D
VRZ\FKMHGQDN HZSU]\SDGNXGX HMNODV\SUREOHPyZFKRG]LQDPRSRG]LHOHQLH]DGDQLD
QDZ\NRQXM FHVL QLH]DOH QLHIUDJPHQW\G]L NLF]HPXSURJUDPMDNRFDáR üVWDMHVL EDU
G]LHM HIHNW\ZQ\ :HZQ WU] SURJUDPX WH QLH]DOH QLH Z\NRQXM FH VL IUDJPHQW\ QD]\
ZDP\Z WNDPLDFDáDLGHDQRVLQD]Z ZVSyáELH QR FLDQJFRQFXUUHQF\OXEZLHORZ W
NRZR FLDQJPXOWLWKUHDGLQJ7\SRZ\PSU]\NáDGHPZ\NRU]\VWDQLDZLHORZ WNRZR FL
MHVWLQWHUIHMVX \WNRZQLND']L NLZ WNRPX \WNRZQLNPR HRWU]\PDüV]\EN UHDNFM QD
QDFL QL FLHSU]\FLVNXQLHE G F]PXV]RQ\PGRRF]HNLZDQLDQD]DNR F]HQLHZ\NRQ\
ZDQLDSU]H]SURJUDPMHJRDNWXDOQHJR]DGDQLD
: WNLV ]Z\NOHMHG\QLHVSRVREHPSRG]LDáXF]DVXSRMHG\QF]HJRSURFHVRUD-H HOLMHGQDN
V\VWHPRSHUDF\MQ\REVáXJXMHZLHOHSURFHVRUyZZWHG\ND G\Z WHNPR H]RVWDüSU]\
G]LHORQ\LQQHPX]QLFKG]L NLF]HPXE G VL RQHZ\NRQ\ZDüU]HF]\ZL FLHUyZQROHJOH
-HGQ ]]DOHWZLHORZ WNRZR FLQDSR]LRPLHM ]\NDMHVWWR HSURJUDPLVWDQLHPXVLLQWH
UHVRZDüVL F]\PDGRG\VSR]\FMLZLHOHSURFHVRUyZF]\WH W\ONRMHGHQ3URJUDPMHVW
ORJLF]QLHSRG]LHORQ\QDZ WNLLMH HOLPDV]\QDSRVLDGDZLHOHSURFHVRUyZZWHG\G]LDáD
V]\EFLHMEH] DGQ\FKSRSUDZHN
3RZ\ V]HVWZLHUG]HQLDPRJ VXJHURZDü HZLHORZ WNRZR üMHVWSURVW\P]DJDGQLHQLHP
-HVWMHGQDNSHZQDSXáDSND²]DVRE\ZVSyOQH-H HOLZL FHMQL MHGHQZ WHNPD]DPLDU
RGZRá\ZDüVL GRWHJRVDPHJR]DVREXZWHG\SRZVWDMHSUREOHP1DSU]\NáDGGZDSURFHV\
QLHPRJ UyZQRF]H QLHZ\V\áDüLQIRUPDFMLQDGUXNDUN :FHOXUR]ZL ]DQLDWHJRSUREOHPX
]DVRE\NWyUHPRJ WDNMDNGUXNDUNDE\üG]LHORQHPXV] E\üEORNRZDQHQDF]DVX \FLD
$]DWHPZ WHNEORNXMH]DVyEZ\NRQXMHVZRMH]DGDQLHSRF]\P]ZDOQLDEORNDG DE\
XPR OLZLüLQQ\PZ WNRPVNRU]\VWDQLH]]DVREX
:LHORZ WNRZR ü MHVW Z -DYLH F] FL M ]\ND Z -DYD 6( GRF]HNDáD VL WH LVWRWQHJR
ZVSDUFLDELEOLRWHF]QHJR
-DYDL,QWHUQHW
-H OLWDNQDSUDZG -DYDMHVWMHV]F]HMHGQ\PM ]\NLHPSURJUDPRZDQLDPR QD]DS\WDü
F]HPXZREHFWHJRMHVWWDNZD QDLGODF]HJRMHVWRNUH ODQDMDNRUHZROXF\MQ\NURNZSUR
JUDPRZDQLX"=SXQNWXZLG]HQLDWUDG\F\MQHJRSURJUDPRZDQLDRGSRZLHG QLHMHVWRGUD]X
RF]\ZLVWD -DYD MHVW EDUG]R X \WHF]QD SU]\ UR]ZL ]\ZDQLX WUDG\F\MQ\FK SUREOHPyZ SUR
JUDPLVW\F]Q\FKLUR]ZL ]XMHUyZQLH SUREOHP\SURJUDPRZDQLDGODVLHFL:RUOG:LGH:HE
&]\PMHVWVLHè:::"
3RF] WNRZRVLHü:::PR HVL Z\GDZDüWDMHPQLF]DUD]HP]W\PLZV]\VWNLPLVXU
IRZDQLDPLSUH]HQWDFMDPLLVWURQDPLGRPRZ\PL0R HZDUWRSU]\MU]HüVL ]ERNXWHPX
F]\PWDNQDSUDZG MHVW:::"-HGQDNDE\WR]URELüQDOH \]UR]XPLHüPRGHOV\VWHPyZ
W\SXNOLHQWVHUZHU²NROHMQ\SHáHQQLHSRUR]XPLH DVSHNWLQIRUPDW\NL
5R]G]LDä
u
:SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
3U]HWZDU]DQLHW\SXNOLHQWVHUZHU
3RGVWDZ V\VWHPXNOLHQWVHUZHUMHVW]DáR HQLH HPDP\FHQWUDOQHUHSR]\WRULXPLQIRUPDFML
MDNLHJR URG]DMXGDQ\FKF] VWR]DSLVDQ\FKZED]LHGDQ\FKNWyUHFKFHP\UR]V\áDüQD
GDQLHGRSHZQHMJUXS\OXG]LOXEPDV]\Q.OXF]HPPRGHOXNOLHQWVHUZHUMHVWFHQWUDOQH
SRáR HQLHVNáDGQLF\LQIRUPDFML-H OLLQIRUPDFMH]RVWDQ ]PLHQLRQHZV]\VWNLH]PLDQ\
]RVWDQ SU]HND]DQHLFKRGELRUFRP&DáR üVNáDGQLFDLQIRUPDFMLRSURJUDPRZDQLHUR]
V\áDM FHLQIRUPDFMHRUD]PDV]\QDQDNWyUHM]QDMGXMHVL LQIRUPDFMDLMHMRSURJUDPRZDQLH
QD]\ZDQHMHVWVHUZHUHP.OLHQWHPQD]\ZDVL RSURJUDPRZDQLH]QDMGXM FHVL QDPDV]\QLH
]GDOQHMNWyUHNRPXQLNXMHVL ]VHUZHUHPSRELHUDLQIRUPDFMHSU]HWZDU]DMHLZ\ ZLHWOD
QDWHMPDV]\QLH
3RGVWDZRZDLGHDSU]HWZDU]DQLDW\SXNOLHQWVHUZHUQLHMHVWVSHFMDOQLHVNRPSOLNRZDQD
3UREOHP\Z\QLNDM ]WHJR HPDP\MHGHQVHUZHUSUyEXM F\MHGQRF]H QLHREVáX \üZLHOH
NOLHQWyZ2JyOQLHSURMHNWDQWZ\NRU]\VWXM FV\VWHP\]DU] G]DQLDED]DPLGDQ\FKVWDUD
VL UyZQRPLHUQLHUR]PLH FLüGDQHZWDEHODFKDE\RVL JQ üMDNQDMZL NV] X \WHF]QR ü
V\VWHPX'RGDWNRZRV\VWHP\F] VWRSR]ZDODM NOLHQWRPQDZSURZDG]DQLHQRZ\FKLQ
IRUPDFMLGRVHUZHUD2]QDF]DWR HWU]HEDSLOQRZDüDE\QRZHGDQHMHGQHJRNOLHQWDQLH
]DPD]Dá\QRZ\FKGDQ\FKLQQHJROXE HE\GDQHQLH]DJLQ á\ZSURFHVLHGRGDZDQLDLFK
GRED]\QD]\ZDVL WRSU]HWZDU]DQLHPWUDQVDNF\MQ\P.LHG\RSURJUDPRZDQLHNOLHQWD
VL ]PLHQLDPXVLE\üNRPSLORZDQHWHVWRZDQHLLQVWDORZDQHQDPDV]\QDFKNOLHQWyZ
FRRND]XMHVL EDUG]LHMVNRPSOLNRZDQHLNRV]WRZQHQL PRJáRE\VL Z\GDZDü:LHOX
SUREOHPyZSU]\VSDU]DREVáXJDUy Q\FKW\SyZNRPSXWHUyZLV\VWHPyZRSHUDF\MQ\FK
1DGRGDWHNDNWXDOQ\SR]RVWDMHSUREOHPZ\GDMQR FLZND GHMFKZLOLPRJ SRWHQFMDOQLH
LVWQLHüVHWNL GD VNLHURZDQ\FKSU]H]NOLHQWyZGRVHUZHUDD]DWHPND GHRSy QLHQLH
MHVWNU\W\F]QH$E\RJUDQLF]\üWHRSy QLHQLDSURJUDPL FLFL NRSUDFXM QDGW\PDE\
SU]HQLH üSU]HWZDU]DQH]DGDQLDQDPDV]\Q NOLHQWDDF]DVHPQDLQQHPDV]\Q\SRVWUR
QLHVHUZHUDVNáDGDM FHVL QDWDN]ZDQ ZDUVWZ SR UHGQL DQJPLGGOHZDUH:DUVWZD
SR UHGQLDSRSUDZLDUyZQLH PR OLZR üNRQVHUZDFMLV\VWHPX
3URVWDLGHDUR]V\áDQLDOXG]LRPLQIRUPDFMLPDWDNZLHOHSR]LRPyZ]áR RQR FL HFDá\SUR
EOHPPR HVL Z\GDZDüEDUG]R]DJPDWZDQ\-HGQRF]H QLHMHVWEDUG]RZD Q\SU]HWZD
U]DQLHW\SXNOLHQWVHUZHUVWDQRZLSRáRZ ZV]\VWNLFKSU]HGVL Z]L üSURJUDPLVW\F]Q\FK
2GSRZLDGD]DZV]\VWNRSRF] ZV]\RGSU]\MPRZDQLD]DPyZLH LWUDQVDNFMLSU]\X \
FLXNDUWNUHG\WRZ\FKVNR F]\ZV]\QDUR]SRZV]HFKQLDQLXGRZROQHJRW\SXGDQ\FK²
JLHáGRZ\FK QDXNRZ\FK U] GRZ\FK : SU]HV]áR FL SRMDZLDá\ VL W\ONR LQG\ZLGXDOQH
UR]ZL ]DQLDGODLQG\ZLGXDOQ\FKSUREOHPyZ²]DND G\PUD]HPZ\QDMG\ZDQRQRZH
%\á\RQHWUXGQHGRWZRU]HQLDLX \ZDQLDL]DND G\PUD]HPX \WNRZQLNPXVLDáVL QD
XF]\üREVáXJLQRZHJRLQWHUIHMVX3UREOHPNOLHQWVHUZHUZ\PDJDUR]ZL ]D QDGX VNDO
6LHè:::MDNRJLJDQW\F]Q\VHUZHU
6LHü:::MHVWZáD FLZLHJLJDQW\F]Q\PV\VWHPHPW\SXNOLHQWVHUZHU1DZHWZL FHM
²SRQLHZD ZV]\VWNLHVHUZHU\LNOLHQW\ZVSyáLVWQLHM MHGQRF]H QLHZWHMVDPHMVLHFL
1LHWU]HEDRW\PZLHG]LHüJG\ ZV]\VWNRRFRWU]HEDVL ]DWURV]F]\üZGDQ\PPRPHQFLH
WRSRá F]HQLHLLQWHUDNFMD]MHGQ\PW\ONRVHUZHUHPDOHDE\JR]QDOH üPR QDSU]HV]XNDü
Syá ZLDWD
7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
3RF] WNRZRE\áWRSURVW\SURFHVMHGQRNLHUXQNRZ\1D GDQLHSU]HVáDQHGRVHUZHUDSU]H
ND]\ZDáRQ]SRZURWHPSOLNNWyU\E\áLQWHUSUHWRZDQ\LIRUPDWRZDQ\SU]H]SU]HJO GDUN
QDPDV]\QLHORNDOQHMNOLHQWD:NUyWFHOXG]LH]DF] OL GDüF]HJR ZL FHMQL W\ONRGR
VWDUF]DQLD VWURQ ] VHUZHUD &KFLHOL SHáQ\FK PR OLZR FL NOLHQWVHUZHU WDN DE\ NOLHQW
PyJáRGV\áDüLQIRUPDFMHGRVHUZHUDQDSU]\NáDG]D GDüNRQNUHWQ\FKGDQ\FK]VHUZHUD
GRGDüQRZHLQIRUPDFMHOXE]áR \ü]DPyZLHQLHFRZ\PDJDáRZL NV]\FK]DEH]SLHF]H
QL WHRIHURZDQHSU]H]RU\JLQDOQ\V\VWHP6 WR]PLDQ\MDNLH]DV]á\ZUR]ZRMX:::
3U]HJO GDUND:::²DZáD FLZLHVDPSRP\Vá HWDVDPDLQIRUPDFMDPR HE\üZ\
ZLHWORQDQDNRPSXWHU]HGRZROQHJRW\SXEH]]PLHQLDQLDMHM²E\áDZLHONLPNURNLHP
QDSU]yG -HGQDN H SU]HJO GDUNL E\á\ QDGDO SU\PLW\ZQH L QLH VSHáQLDá\ VWDZLDQ\FK LP
GD :V]F]HJyOQR FLQLHE\á\LQWHUDNW\ZQHLPLDá\VNáRQQR üGREORNRZDQLD]DUyZQR
VHUZHUyZMDNL,QWHUQHWXERZLHP]DND G\PUD]HPNLHG\NRQLHF]QHE\áRZ\NRQDQLH
F]HJR FRZ\PDJDáRSU]HWZDU]DQLDWU]HEDE\áRZ\VáDüLQIRUPDFM ]SRZURWHPGRVHUZHUD
DE\GRSLHURWDP]RVWDáDSU]HWZRU]RQD0RJáRXSá\Q üZLHOHVHNXQGOXEPLQXWQLPRND
]DáRVL H GDQLHE\áREá GQLHVIRUPXáRZDQH3U]HJO GDUNDVáX \áDMHG\QLHGRRJO GDQLD
ZL FQLHPRJáDZ\NRQ\ZDüQDZHWQDMSURVWV]\FK]DGD REOLF]HQLRZ\FK]GUXJLHMVWURQ\
E\áDEH]SLHF]QDSRQLHZD QLHPRJáDQDORNDOQHMPDV]\QLHZ\NRQ\ZDü DGQ\FKSUR
JUDPyZNWyUHPRJá\E\]DZLHUDüEá G\OXEZLUXV\
$E\UR]ZL ]DüWHQSUREOHPSU]\M WRNLONDUR]ZL ]D 1DSRF] WHNVWDQGDUG\JUDILF]QH
SRV]HU]RQRWDNE\XPR OLZLüOHSV] DQLPDFM REUD]XZSU]HJO GDUNDFK5R]ZL ]DQLHP
SR]RVWDá\FKSUREOHPyZMHVWXPR OLZLHQLHSU]HJO GDUFHXUXFKDPLDQLDSURJUDPyZSRVWUR
QLHNOLHQWD1D]\ZDP\WRSURJUDPRZDQLHPSRVWURQLHNOLHQWD
3URJUDPRZDQLHSRVWURQLHNOLHQWD
3LHUZRWQ\ SURMHNW DUFKLWHNWXU\ VLHFLRZHM W\SX VHUZHUSU]HJO GDUND ]DSHZQLDá LQWHUDN
W\ZQ ]DZDUWR üDOHE\áDRQDZFDáR FLGRVWDUF]DQDSU]H]VHUZHU6HUZHUSURGXNRZDá
VWDW\F]QHVWURQ\GODSU]HJO GDUNLNOLHQWDNWyUDMHSRSURVWXLQWHUSUHWRZDáDLZ\ ZLHWODáD
3RGVWDZRZ\+70/]DZLHUDSURVWHPHFKDQL]P\SRELHUDQLDGDQ\FKSRODWHNVWRZH SROD
Z\ERUXSRODZLHORNURWQHJRZ\ERUXOLVW\LOLVW\UR]ZLMDQHRUD]SU]\FLVNLNWyUHPR QD
]DSURJUDPRZDüW\ONRGRZ\F]\V]F]HQLDIRUPXODU]DOXEZ\VáDQLDDQJVXEPLWGDQ\FK
IRUPXODU]D]SRZURWHPGRVHUZHUD7R GDQLHSU]HFKRG]LSU]H]&RPPRQ*DWHZD\,QWHU
IDFHXQLZHUVDOQ\LQWHUIHMVNRPXQLNDF\MQ\ZVNUyFLH&*,GRVWDUF]DQ\SU]H]ZV]\VWNLH
VHUZHU\:::7HNVWZHZQ WU] GDQLDPyZL&*,FRQDOH \]QLP]URELü1DMF] VWV]\P
G]LDáDQLHPMHVWZ\NRQDQLHSURJUDPX]QDMGXM FHJRVL QDVHUZHU]HZNDWDORJXQD]\ZD
Q\P]Z\NOHFJLELQREVHUZXM FRNLHQNRDGUHVXQDJyU]HSU]HJO GDUNLNLHG\QDFLVNDV]
SU]\FLVNQDVWURQLHVLHFLRZHMPR HV]F]DVHP]REDF]\üFJLELQSRPL G]\LQQ\PL]QDMGX
M F\PLVL WDP PLHFLDPL3URJUDP\WHPRJ E\üSLVDQHZZL NV]R FLM ]\NyZ1DMF]
FLHMZ\ELHUDQ\MHVW3HUOSRQLHZD MHVWSU]H]QDF]RQ\GRPDQLSXORZDQLDWHNVWHPDSUR
JUDP\ZQLPQDSLVDQHV Z\NRQ\ZDQHSU]H]LQWHUSUHWHUZL FPR HE\üLQVWDORZDQ\QD
GRZROQ\FKVHUZHUDFKQLH]DOH QLHRGSURFHVRUDLV\VWHPXRSHUDF\MQHJR&RUD]ZL NV]
SRSXODUQR ü]GRE\ZDMHGQDN3\WKRQPyMXOXELRQ\²SDWU]ZZZ3\WKRQRUJJáyZQLH
]HZ]JO GXQDVZRMHRJURPQHPR OLZR FLLSURVWRW
2EHFQLHZLHOHGX \FKZLWU\QLQWHUQHWRZ\FK]EXGRZDQRZ\á F]QLH]Z\NRU]\VWDQLHP
&*,]DSRPRF NWyUHJRPR QD]URELüSUDNW\F]QLHZV]\VWNR-HGQDN HXWU]\PDQLHZL
WU\Q ]EXGRZDQ\FK QD SURJUDPDFK &*, PR H V]\ENR VWDü VL EDUG]R VNRPSOLNRZDQH
5R]G]LDä
u
:SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
3UREOHPHPMHVWUyZQLH GáXJLF]DVUHDNFML2GSRZLHG SURJUDPX&*,]DOH \RGOLF]E\
GDQ\FKNWyUHPXV] ]RVWDüSU]HVáDQHRUD]RGREFL HQLDVHUZHUDL,QWHUQHWXSR]DW\P
XUXFKDPLDQLH SURJUDPX &*, MHVW QD RJyá ZROQH 3LHUZVL SURMHNWDQFL ,QWHUQHWX QLH
SU]HZLG]LHOL HMHJRSU]HSXVWRZR ü]RVWDQLHWDNJZDáWRZQLHZ\F]HUSDQDSU]H]Uy QR
URGQH DSOLNDFMH 3U]\NáDGRZRQLHGDVL ]UHDOL]RZDüSURFHVXG\QDPLF]QHJRWZRU]HQLD
JUDILNLSRQLHZD SOLN*,)*UDSKLFV,QWHUFKDQJH)RUPDWPXVL]RVWDüVWZRU]RQ\LSU]H
VáDQ\RGVHUZHUDGRNOLHQWDGODND GHMZHUVMLREUD]X.D G\EH]Z WSLHQLDPLDáEH]SR
UHGQLNRQWDNW]F]\P WDNSURVW\PMDNVSUDZG]HQLHGDQ\FKZIRUPXODU]X3RQDFL
QL FLXSU]\FLVNXÄ=DWZLHUG ´GDQHV SU]HV\áDQH]SRZURWHPGRVHUZHUD6HUZHUXUXFKDPLD
SURJUDP&*,NWyU\Z\NU\ZDEá GIRUPXáXMHVWURQ +70/LQIRUPXM F REá G]LHDQD
VW SQLHRGV\áDM ]SRZURWHP7U]HEDZWHG\FRIQ üVL GRSRSU]HGQLHMVWURQ\LVSUyERZDü
SRQRZQLH-HVWWRQLHW\ONRZROQHDOHLQLHHOHJDQFNLH
5R]ZL ]DQLHPMHVWSURJUDPRZDQLHSRVWURQLHNOLHQWD:L NV]R üNRPSXWHUyZQDNWyU\FK
SUDFXM SU]HJO GDUNLWRSRW QHPDV]\Q\E G FHZVWDQLHZ\NRQDüRJURPQ LOR üRE
OLF]H DSU]\SLHUZRWQ\PVSRVRELHSUDF\VWDW\F]QHJR+70/DF]HNDM FHEH]F]\QQLH
D VHUZHUSRGDLPQDVW SQ VWURQ 3URJUDPRZDQLHSRVWURQLHNOLHQWDVSUDZLD HSU]HJO
GDUND:::]RVWDMH]DSU] JQL WDGRSUDF\DGODX \WNRZQLNDR]QDF]DWRRZLHOHERJDWV]H
LQWHUDNW\ZQHSU]H \FLDSRGF]DVNRU]\VWDQLD]WDNLHMZLWU\Q\
3U]\RPDZLDQLXSURJUDPRZDQLDSRVWURQLHNOLHQWDSUREOHPHPMHVWWR HQLHUy QLVL RQR
MDNR V]F]HJyOQLHRGSURJUDPRZDQLDZRJyOH3DUDPHWU\V QLHPDO HWDNLHVDPHDOHLQQD
MHVWSODWIRUPDSU]HJO GDUNDLQWHUQHWRZDMHVWMDNRJUDQLF]RQ\V\VWHPRSHUDF\MQ\:NR FX
QDGDOWU]HEDSURJUDPRZDüDWRZL HVL ]]DZURWQ OLF]E SUREOHPyZLUR]ZL ]D VWZD
U]DQ\FKSU]H]SURJUDPRZDQLHSRVWURQLHNOLHQWD5HV]WDWHJRSRGUR]G]LDáXSU]HGVWDZLD
SU]HJO GNZHVWLL]ZL ]DQ\FK]SURJUDPRZDQLHPSRVWURQLHNOLHQWD
0RGXä\UR]V]HU]DMñFH
-HGQ\P]EDUG]LHM]QDF] F\FKNURNyZZNLHUXQNXSURJUDPRZDQLDSRVWURQLHNOLHQWDMHVW
VWZRU]HQLHPRGXáyZUR]V]HU]DM F\FKDQJSOXJLQ-HVWWRVSRVyEZMDNLSURJUDPPR H
GRGDüQRZHIXQNFMHGRSU]HJO GDUNLSU]H] FL JQL FLHNDZDáNDNRGXNWyU\MHVWGRá F]DQ\
ZRGSRZLHGQLHPLHMVFHSU]HJO GDUNL0yZLRQSU]HJO GDUFHÄRGWHMSRU\PR HV]Z\
NRQ\ZDüWDNLHDWDNLHQRZHF]\QQR FL´PRGXáUR]V]HU]DM F\áDGXMHVL MHGQRUD]RZR
']L NLUR]V]HU]HQLRPSU]HJO GDUND]RVWDMHZ]ERJDFRQDRSRW QHPR OLZR FLMHGQDN
SLVDQLHLFKQLHMHVW]DGDQLHPWU\ZLDOQ\PL]DSHZQHQLNWQLHFKFLDáE\WHJRURELüZSURFH
VLHEXGRZDQLDNRQNUHWQHMVWURQ\0RGXá\UR]V]HU]DM FHPDM GX ZDUWR üGODSURJUD
PRZDQLDNOLHQWVHUZHUSRQLHZD SR]ZDODM GR ZLDGF]RQHPXSURJUDPL FLHQDVWZRU]HQLH
QRZHJRM ]\NDSURJUDPRZDQLDLGRGDQLHJRGRSU]HJO GDUNLEH]NRQLHF]QR FLX]\VNDQLD
]JRG\MHMWZyUF\=DWHPUR]V]HU]HQLDGRVWDUF]DM GRGDWNRZHPHWRG\WZRU]HQLDQRZ\FK
M ]\NyZSURJUDPRZDQLDSRVWURQLHNOLHQWDMHGQDNQLHZV]\VWNLHM ]\NLV LPSOHPHQWR
ZDQHMDNRPRGXá\UR]V]HU]DM FH
-ö]\NLVNU\SWRZH
:SURZDG]HQLHPRGXáyZUR]V]HU]DM F\FK]DRZRFRZDáRHNVSOR]M M ]\NyZVNU\SWRZ\FK
.RG UyGáRZ\SURJUDPXQDSLVDQHJRZM ]\NXVNU\SWRZ\PLG]LDáDM FHJRSRVWURQLHNOLHQWD
MHVWRVDG]RQ\ZHZQ WU]VWURQ\+70/0RGXáLQWHUSUHWXM F\WHQNRGMHVWDXWRPDW\F]QLH
DNW\ZRZDQ\ZPRPHQFLHZ\ ZLHWODQLDWDNLHMVWURQ\- ]\NLVNU\SWRZHV QDRJyááDWZH
7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
GR]UR]XPLHQLDLMDNRWHNVWV F] FL NRGX+70/3URJUDPZWDNLPM ]\NXMHVWWHN
VWHPVWDQRZL F\PIUDJPHQWVWURQ\+70/GODWHJRáDGXMHVL ]VHUZHUDMDNRF] üWHJRVD
PHJR GDQLDNWyUHZ\ ZLHWODVWURQ :DG WHJRUR]ZL ]DQLDMHVWWR HNRG UyGáRZ\SUR
JUDPXPR HE\üSU]HJO GDQ\RUD]VNUDG]LRQ\SU]H]ND GHJR-HGQDNQLHZ\GDMHVL WRE\ü
]E\WZ\VRN FHQ SRQLHZD ZM ]\NDFKVNU\SWRZ\FKQLHUHDOL]XMHP\Z\V]XNDQ\FK]DGD
-HVWWDNLM ]\NVNU\SWRZ\NWyUHJRREVáXJLLWREH]GRGDWNRZ\FKPRGXáyZUR]V]HU]DM
F\FKPR QDRF]HNLZDüRGZL NV]R FLQRZRF]HVQ\FKSU]HJO GDUHN:::WR-DYD6FULSW
NWyU\QLHPDQLFZVSyOQHJR]-DY ²]RVWDáWDNQD]ZDQ\ HE\VL Ä]DáDSDü´QDWURFK
PDUNHWLQJRZHJRS GX]ZL ]DQHJR]-DY 1LHVWHW\ZHUVMHM ]\ND]DLPSOHPHQWRZDQH
ZUy Q\FKSU]HJO GDUNDFKPRJ VL ]QDF]QLHRGVLHELHUy QLü6\WXDFM SRSUDZLáDQLHFR
VWDQGDU\]DFMDM ]\ND-DYD6FULSWZSRVWDFL(&0$6FULSWDOH]NROHLSRZV]HFKQHZGUR H
QLHWHJRVWDQGDUGXZOHF]HVL QLHPLáRVLHUQLHPDZW\PVZyMXG]LDáILUPD0LFURVRIWIRU
VXM FDVZyMM ]\NVNU\SWRZ\9%6FULSWZLHOFH]UHV]W SRGREQ\GR-DYD6FULSW=DVDGQLF]R
QDOH DáRE\ SU]\ SURJUDPRZDQLX SR VWURQLH NOLHQWD RJUDQLF]\ü VL GR QDMPQLHMV]HJR
ZVSyOQHJR PLDQRZQLND Uy Q\FK LPSOHPHQWDFML -DYD6FULSW ² W\ONR ZWHG\ PR QD PLHü
QDG]LHM EH]SUREOHPRZHJRG]LDáDQLDNRGXZUy Q\FKSU]HJO GDUNDFK'LDJQRVW\N LZ\
FKZ\W\ZDQLHEá GyZZNRG]LH-DYD6FULSWPR QDRSLVDüMHG\QLHMDNRXGU N 'RZRGHP
VWRSQLD]áR RQR FLSUREOHPXMHVWFKRüE\WR HGRSLHURQLHGDZQRSRZVWDáSLHUZV]\QD
SUDZG UR]EXGRZDQ\SURMHNW]X \FLHP-DYD6FULSW²PRZDR*RRJOH*0DLO
:LGDü]WHJR HM ]\NLVNU\SWRZHX \ZDQHZHZQ WU]SU]HJO GDUHN:::V SU]H]QDF]R
QHGRUR]ZL ]\ZDQLDVSHF\ILF]QHJRW\SXSUREOHPyZJáyZQLHGRWZRU]HQLDERJDWV]\FK
L EDUG]LHM DWUDNF\MQ\FK JUDILF]Q\FK LQWHUIHMVyZ X \WNRZQLND DQJ JUDSKLFDO XVHU LQ
WHUIDFHZVNUyFLH*8,- ]\NLVNU\SWRZHPRJ UR]ZL ]DüSURFHQWSUREOHPyZQDSR
W\NDQ\FKSU]\SURJUDPRZDQLXSRVWURQLHNOLHQWD5yZQLH 7ZyMSUREOHPPR HZFDáR FL
PLH FLüVL ZW\FKSURFHQWDFKDSRQLHZD M ]\NLVNU\SWRZHSR]ZDODM QDáDWZLHMV]
LV]\EV] SURGXNFM VWURQ:::SRZLQLHQH UR]ZD \üLFKX \FLH]DQLP]ZUyFLV]VL
NXEDUG]LHM]áR RQ\PUR]ZL ]DQLRPMDNSURJUDPRZDQLHZM ]\NX-DYD
-DYD
-H OLM ]\NLVNU\SWRZHPRJ UR]ZL ]DüSURFHQWSUREOHPyZSURJUDPRZDQLDNOLHQW
VHUZHUFR]SR]RVWDá\PLSURFHQWDPL²W\PLQDSUDZG WUXGQ\PL"2EHFQLHQDMSR
SXODUQLHMV]\PUR]ZL ]DQLHPMHVW-DYD-HVWWRQLHW\ONRSRW Q\M ]\NSURJUDPRZDQLD
VWZRU]RQ\MDNREH]SLHF]Q\SU]HQR Q\LPL G]\QDURGRZ\-DYDMHVWFL JOHUR]V]HU]DQD
E\GRVWDUF]DüQRZHUR]ZL ]DQLDNWyUHREVáXJXM SUREOHP\X]QDZDQH]DWUXGQHZWUD
G\F\MQ\FKM ]\NDFKWDNLHMDNZLHORZ WNRZR üGRVW SGRED]GDQ\FKSURJUDPRZDQLH
VLHFLRZHF]\SU]HWZDU]DQLHUR]SURV]RQH-DYDXPR OLZLDSURJUDPRZDQLHSRVWURQLHNOLHQWD
SRSU]H]DSOHW\RUD]WHFKQRORJL -DYD:HE6WDUW
$SOHWMHVWPLQLSURJUDPHPNWyU\G]LDáDZ\á F]QLHSRGNRQWURO SU]HJO GDUNL-HVWRQáD
GRZDQ\DXWRPDW\F]QLHMDNRHOHPHQWVWURQ\:::WDNVDPRMDNREUD]HN.LHG\DSOHW
]RVWDQLHDNW\ZRZDQ\Z\NRQDVZyMSURJUDP-HVWWRMHJRGX \SOXV²]DSHZQLDPHWRG
DXWRPDW\F]QHJRUR]SRZV]HFKQLDQLDRSURJUDPRZDQLDNOLHQWD]VHUZHUDZPRPHQFLHNLHG\
X \WNRZQLNJRSRWU]HEXMHDQLHZF]H QLHM8 \WNRZQLNRWU]\PXMHQDMQRZV] ZHUVM
RSURJUDPRZDQLDNOLHQWDEH]ERU\NDQLDVL ]WUXGQR FLDPLSRQRZQHMLQVWDODFML-DYD]R
VWDáD]DSURMHNWRZDQDZWDNLVSRVyE HSURJUDPLVWDWZRU]\W\ONRMHGHQSURJUDPNWyU\
DXWRPDW\F]QLHE G]LHG]LDáDáQDZV]\VWNLFKNRPSXWHUDFKZ\SRVD RQ\FKZSU]HJO GDUNL
5R]G]LDä
u
:SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
]ZEXGRZDQ\PLQWHUSUHWHUHP-DY\PR QDGRQLFK]DOLF]\üZL NV]R üPDV]\Q3RQLH
ZD -DYDMHVWZSHáQLUR]ZLQL W\PM ]\NLHPSURJUDPRZDQLDPR QDZL FREDUF]\üNOLHQWD
GX LOR FL SUDF\]DUyZQRSU]HGMDNLSRZ\VáDQLX GDQLDGRVHUZHUD1DSU]\NáDGQLH
WU]HEDZ\V\áDü GDQLDDE\RGNU\ü H OHSRGDáH GDW OXELQQ\SDUDPHWUDVDPNOLHQW
PR HV]\ENRZ\NRQDüFDá SUDF ]ZL ]DQ ]HVSRU] G]HQLHPZ\NUHVX]DPLDVWF]HNDü
D VHUZHUSU]\JRWXMHZ\NUHVLZ\ OHJRWRZ\REUD]HN2WU]\PXMHV]QDW\FKPLDVWRZ\Z]URVW
SU GNR FLG]LDáDQLDDRJyOQ\UXFKVLHFLLREFL HQLHVHUZHUyZPRJ ]RVWDü]UHGXNRZDQH
SU]\VSLHV]DM FW\PVDP\PG]LDáDQLHFDáHJR,QWHUQHWX
$OWHUQDW\Z\
*ZROL V]F]HUR FL DSOHW\ -DY\ QLH VSHáQLá\ GR NR FD SRNáDGDQ\FK Z QLFK SLHUZRWQLH
RF]HNLZD .LHG\-DYDXMU]DáD ZLDWáRG]LHQQHZV]\VF\IDVF\QRZDOLVL ZáD QLHDSOH
WDPLMDNRZ\F]HNLZDQ\PLQDU] G]LDPLSURJUDPRZDQLDSRVWURQLHNOLHQWDDZL F]ZL N
V]DQLHPUHDNW\ZQR FLL]PQLHMV]HQLHPZ\PDJD FRGRV]\ENR FLNDQDáXWUDQVPLV\MQHJR
ZDSOLNDFMDFKLQWHUQHWRZ\FK$SOHWRPSURURNRZDQRZLHON NDULHU
:U]HF]\VDPHMZVLHFL:::ZLGXMHVL ZLHOFH]P\ OQHDSOHW\DOHQLJG\QLHGRV]áR
GRSUDZG]LZHMPLJUDFMLGRWHMWHFKQRORJLL1DMZL NV]\PSUREOHPHPE\áDQDMSUDZGRSRGRE
QLHMQLHFK üSU]HFL WQ\FKX \WNRZQLNyZGR FL JDQLDLLQVWDORZDQLD URGRZLVNDZ\NR
QDZF]HJR-DY\-5(RG-DYD5XQWLPH(QYLURQPHQWZSRVWDFLPHJDEDMWRZHJRSDNLHWX
/RVDSOHWyZPyJá]RVWDüSU]\SLHF] WRZDQ\GHF\]M ILUP\0LFURVRIWRQLHZá F]DQLX-5(GR
SU]HJO GDUNL,QWHUQHW([SORUHU7DNF]\LQDF]HMDSOHW\-DY\QLH]DLVWQLDá\QDZL NV] VNDO
0LPRWRDSOHW\MDNRWDNLHLWHFKQRORJLD-DYD:HE6WDUWZFL RND]XM VL ZSHZQ\FK
V\WXDFMDFK SU]\GDWQH =QDMGXM ]DVWRVRZDQLH ZV] G]LH WDP JG]LH ]DFKRG]L SRWU]HED
NRQWURORZDQLDPDV]\QX \WNRZQLNyZQDSU]\NáDGZREU ELHV\VWHPXLQIRUPDW\F]QHJR
NRUSRUDFMLVáX WDPGRUR]SURZDG]DQLDLDNWXDOL]DFMLDSOLNDFMLNOLHQFNLFKSU]\]QDF]QHM
RV]F] GQR FLF]DVXRUD]]DVREyZOXG]NLFKLILQDQVRZ\FK²ZLGRF]QHM]ZáDV]F]DWDP
JG]LHDNWXDOL]DFMHV F] VWH
: UR]G]LDOH Ä*UDILF]QH LQWHUIHMV\ X \WNRZQLND´ SU]\MU]\P\ VL QRZHM RELHFXM FHM
WHFKQRORJLL)OH[ILUP\0DFURPHGLDNWyUDSR]ZDODQDWZRU]HQLHRGSRZLHGQLNyZDSOH
WyZ W\OH H RSDUW\FK QD WHFKQRORJLL )ODVK 3RQLHZD MDNLH SURFHQW SU]HJO GDUHN
:::G\VSRQXMHRGWZDU]DF]DPLIRUPDWX)ODVKGRW\F]\WRSU]HJO GDUHNGODZV]\VW
NLFKSRSXODUQ\FKV\VWHPyZRSHUDF\MQ\FKPR QDJRX]QDü]DSRZV]HFKQLHSU]\M W\
VWDQGDUG,QVWDODFMDLDNWXDOL]DFMHRGWZDU]DF]D)ODVKRGE\ZDM VL V]\ENRLSURVWR6WR
VRZDQ\WXM ]\N$FWLRQ6FULSWED]XMHQDM ]\NX(&0$6FULSWSU]H]FRáDWZRVL GRQLH
JRSU]\]Z\F]DLüDOH)OH[SR]ZDODQDSURJUDPRZDQLHEH]PDUWZLHQLDVL RFKDUDNWHU\
VW\N SU]HJO GDUNLFRF]\QLJR]QDF]QLHDWUDNF\MQLHMV]\PRG-DYD6FULSWX:G]LHG]LQLH
SURJUDPRZDQLDSRVWURQLHNOLHQWDMHVWWR]SHZQR FL DOWHUQDW\ZDJRGQDUR]ZD HQLD
1(7L&
2G GáX V]HJR F]DVX JáyZQ\P NRQNXUHQWHP DSOHWyZ -DY\ E\á\ NRPSRQHQW\ $FWLYH;
FKRüZ\PDJDá\RQHDE\NOLHQWG]LDáDáZV\VWHPLHRSHUDF\MQ\P:LQGRZV1DVW SQLH
0LFURVRIWVWZRU]\áJRGQHJRU\ZDODGOD-DY\²SODWIRUP 1(7RUD]M ]\N&3ODWIRUPD
1(7MHVWPQLHMZL FHMW\PVDP\PFRZLUWXDOQDPDV]\QD-DY\RUD]ZV]\VWNLHELEOLRWHNLWHJR
M ]\NDDSRGRELH VWZDM ]\NyZ&L-DYDV RF]\ZLVWH%H]Z WSLHQLDMHVWWRQDMOHSV]D
7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
URERWDMDN 0LFURVRIWZ\NRQDáZG]LHG]LQLHM ]\NyZSURJUDPRZDQLDL URGRZLVNSUR
JUDPLVW\F]Q\FK2F]\ZL FLH0LFURVRIWPLDá]QDF] F SU]HZDJ JG\ PyJáSU]HDQDOL
]RZDüFRZ-DYLHE\áRGREUHDFR]áHLED]RZDüQDWHMZLHG]\-HGQDN]RVWDáDRQDZ\
NRU]\VWDQD]GRVNRQDá\PUH]XOWDWHP3RUD]SLHUZV]\RGPRPHQWXSRMDZLHQLDVL -DYD
]\VNDáDJRGQHJRVLHELHNRQNXUHQWDG]L NLWHPX]NROHLSURMHNWDQFLM ]\ND-DYDSU]\VLH
GOLIDáGyZLSU]\JO GDM FVL &RUD]SU]\F]\QRPGODNWyU\FKSURJUDPL FLPRJ Z\ELH
UDüJRDQLH-DY RGSRZLHG]LHOLUR]V]HU]HQLHP-DY\ZSRVWDFLZ\GDQLD-DYD6(]MHJR
IXQGDPHQWDOQ\PLXVSUDZQLHQLDPL
$NWXDOQLHJáyZQ\PVáDE\PSXQNWHPRUD]S\WDQLHPGRW\F] F\PSODWIRUP\1(7MHVWWR
F]\0LFURVRIW]H]ZROLQDSU]HQLHVLHQLHJRZFDáR FLQDLQQHSODWIRUP\V\VWHPRZH0LFURVRIW
WZLHUG]L HQLHSRZLQQRWRE\ü DGQ\PSUREOHPHPDSURMHNW0RQRZZZJRPRQRFRP
VWDQRZLF] FLRZ LPSOHPHQWDFM SODWIRUP\1(7G]LDáDM F ZV\VWHPDFK/LQX[-HGQDN
GRPRPHQWX]DNR F]HQLDSUDFQDGSHáQ LPSOHPHQWDFM LSRGM FLDSU]H]0LFURVRIWGHF\]ML
GRW\F] FHMZV]\VWNLFKHOHPHQWyZSODWIRUP\1(7Z\NRU]\VWDQLHMHMMDNRUR]ZL ]DQLD
PL G]\V\VWHPRZHJRMHVWU\]\NRZQH
,QWHUQHWNRQWUDLQWUDQHW
6LHü:::MHVWQDMRJyOQLHMV]\PUR]ZL ]DQLHPSUREOHPXNOLHQWVHUZHUZL FZ\GDMHVL
VHQVRZQHX \FLHWHMVDPHMWHFKQRORJLLGRSRG]ELRUXWHJRSUREOHPX²ZV]F]HJyOQR FL
NODV\F]QHJRSUREOHPXNOLHQWVHUZHUZHZQ WU]ILUP\3U]\WUDG\F\MQ\PSRGHM FLXNOLHQW
VHUZHUZ\VW SXM WUXGQR FL]SRZRGXZLHOXW\SyZNRPSXWHUyZSRVWURQLHNOLHQWyZRUD]
NáRSRW\]LQVWDODFM QRZHJRRSURJUDPRZDQLD2E\GZDSUREOHP\V GREU]HUR]ZL ]\
ZDQHSU]H]SU]HJO GDUN :::LSURJUDPRZDQLHSRVWURQLHNOLHQWD.LHG\WHFKQRORJLD
:::MHVWX \ZDQDZVLHFLLQIRUPDF\MQHMRJUDQLF]RQHMGRNRQNUHWQHMILUP\RNUH ODVL
M PLDQHPLQWUDQHWX,QWUDQHWGRVWDUF]DRZLHOHZ\ V]\SR]LRPEH]SLHF]H VWZDQL ,QWHUQHW
SRQLHZD PR QDIL]\F]QLHNRQWURORZDüGRVW SGRILUPRZ\FKVHUZHUyZ-H OLZ]L ü]D
SRGXZDJ V]NROHQLHSUDFRZQLNyZZ\GDMHVL HNLHG\MX ]UR]XPLHM RJyOQH]DVDG\
SUDF\]SU]HJO GDUN MHVWLPGX RáDWZLHMUDG]LüVRELH]Uy QLFDPLPL G]\G]LDáDQLHPVWURQ
LDSOHWyZDF]DVSRWU]HEQ\GRQDXF]HQLDVL QRZ\FKV\VWHPyZMHVWNUyWV]\
3UREOHPEH]SLHF]H VWZDGRSURZDG]LáGRMHGQHJR]SRG]LDáyZSRZVWDá\FKDXWRPDW\F]
QLHZ ZLHFLHSURJUDPRZDQLDW\SXNOLHQWVHUZHU-H OLSURJUDPG]LDáDZ,QWHUQHFLHQLH
ZLHP\QDMDNLHMSODWIRUPLHE G]LHSUDFRZDáDMHGQRF]H QLH]ZUDFDP\V]F]HJyOQ XZDJ
DE\QLHUR]SRZV]HFKQLDüNRGX]DZLHUDM FHJREá G\3RWU]HEXMHP\F]HJR WDNSU]HQR QHJR
LEH]SLHF]QHJRMDNM ]\NVNU\SWRZ\OXE-DYD
3UDFXM FZLQWUDQHFLHQDSRW\NDP\]HVWDZLQQ\FKRJUDQLF]H 1LHMHVWU]HF] QLH]Z\
Ná HZV]\VWNLHPDV]\Q\E G SUDFRZDüQDSODWIRUPLH,QWHO:LQGRZV:LQWUDQHFLH
RGSRZLDGDP\]DMDNR üZáDVQHJRNRGXLPR HP\QDSUDZLDüEá G\]DUD]SRLFKZ\NU\FLX
:GRGDWNXF] VWRWU]HEDZ\NRU]\VWDüNRGSR]RVWDá\SRZF]H QLHMV]\FKWUDG\F\MQ\FK
LPSOHPHQWDFMDFKV\VWHPX7U]HEDZWHG\IL]\F]QLHLQVWDORZDüSURJUDP\NOLHQWyZSU]\
ND GRUD]RZ\P XDNWXDOQLHQLX &]DV WUDFRQ\ QD LQVWDORZDQLH XDNWXDOQLH MHVW QDMF] VW
V]\PSRZRGHPSU]HM FLDQDNRU]\VWDQLH]SU]HJO GDUNLSRQLHZD WXWDMXDNWXDOQLHQLDV
QLHZLGRF]QHLDXWRPDW\F]QH-H OLMHVWH ]DDQJD RZDQ\ZWHJRW\SXSURMHNWLQWUDQHWRZ\
QDMUR]V GQLHMV]\PUR]ZL ]DQLHPMHVWREUDQLHQDMSURVWV]HMGURJLXPR OLZLDM FHMZ\NRU]\
VWDQLHLVWQLHM FHMED]\NRGX]DPLDVWSU]HSLV\ZDQLDSURJUDPyZSRQRZQLHZQRZ\PM ]\NX
5R]G]LDä
u
:SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
:SU]\SDGNXWDNNRQVWHUQXM FHJRERJDFWZDUR]ZL ]D SUREOHPXNOLHQWVHUZHUQDMOHSV]\P
Z\M FLHPMHVWDQDOL]DNRV]WyZLNRU]\ FL5R]ZD RJUDQLF]HQLDSRVWDZLRQHJRSUREOHPX
LRGV]XNDMQDMNUyWV] FLH N GRUR]ZL ]DQLD3RQLHZD SURJUDPRZDQLHSRVWURQLHNOLHQWD
QDGDOSR]RVWDMHSURJUDPRZDQLHP]DZV]HGREU\PSRP\VáHPMHVWSU]\M FLHSRGHM FLD
QDMV]\EFLHMSURZDG] FHJRGRUR]ZL ]DQLD-HVWWRDJUHV\ZQDSRVWDZDSU]\JRWRZXM FDQD
VSRWNDQLH]SUREOHPDPLQLHXQLNQLRQ\PLSU]\WZRU]HQLXRSURJUDPRZDQLD
3URJUDPRZDQLHSRVWURQLHVHUZHUD
:GRW\FKF]DVRZHMG\VNXVMLSRPLMDQ\E\áWHPDWSURJUDPRZDQLDSRVWURQLHVHUZHUD&RVL
G]LHMHZPRPHQFLHZ\VáDQLD GDQLDGRVHUZHUD"1DMF] VWV]\P GDQLHPMHVWSURVWH
Ä:\ OLMPLWHQSOLN´1DVW SQLHSU]HJO GDUNDLQWHUSUHWXMHRWU]\PDQ\SOLNZRGSRZLHGQL
VSRVyEMDNRVWURQ +70/REUD]HNDSOHW-DY\VNU\SWLWG
%DUG]LHMVNRPSOLNRZDQH GDQLDNLHURZDQHGRVHUZHUDZ\PDJDM QDRJyáNRPXQLNDFML
] ED] GDQ\FK : ZLHOX SU]\SDGNDFK Z\PDJD WR Z\NRQDQLD ]áR RQHJR ]DS\WDQLD QD
ED]LHGDQ\FKNWyUHVHUZHUIRUPDWXMHMDNRVWURQ +70/LRGV\áD]SRZURWHPGRNOLHQWD
RF]\ZL FLHMH OLNOLHQWPDZL NV]HPR OLZR FL²G]L NL-DYLHOXEM ]\NRPVNU\SWR
Z\P²WRVXURZHGDQHPRJ E\üSU]HVáDQHLVIRUPDWRZDQHSRVWURQLHNOLHQWDFRMHVW
V]\EV]HLPQLHMREFL DVHUZHU3RGREQLHUHMHVWUDFMDX \WNRZQLNDZFKZLOLGRá F]HQLD
GRJUXS\G\VNXV\MQHMOXE]áR HQLD]DPyZLHQLDZ\PDJDZSURZDG]HQLD]PLDQZED]LH
GDQ\FK7HZV]\VWNLH GDQLDPXV] ]RVWDüSU]HWZRU]RQHSU]H]MDNL SURJUDPG]LDáDM
F\SRVWURQLHVHUZHUDFRRJyOQLHRNUH ODQHMHVWMDNRSURJUDPRZDQLHSRVWURQLHVHUZHUD
7UDG\F\MQLH SURJUDP\ &*, G]LDáDM FH SR VWURQLH VHUZHUD E\á\ WZRU]RQH SU]\ X \FLX
3HUOD3\WKRQDOXE&DOHSRMDZLDá\VL WH EDUG]LHMZ\V]XNDQHV\VWHP\:H P\SRG
XZDJ QSVHUZHU\VLHFLRZHZ\NRU]\VWXM FH-DY 8PR OLZLDM RQHZ\NRQDQLHFDáR FL
SURJUDPRZDQLDSRVWURQLHVHUZHUDSU]H]SLVDQLHVHUZOHWyZ6HUZOHW\LLFKSRFKRGQD
-63 HOLPLQXM SUREOHP\ ]ZL ]DQH ] Uy QRURGQ\P SR]LRPHP ]DDZDQVRZDQLD Uy QHJR
W\SXSU]HJO GDUHN=WHJRSRZRGXZLHOHILUPWZRU] F\FKVWURQ\:::SU]HFKRG]LQD
-DY 7H]DJDGQLHQLD]RVWDá\RSLVDQHZNVL FH7KLQNLQJLQ(QWHUSULVH-DYD²]REDF]
ZZZ0LQG9LHZQHW
:L NV]R üV]XPXZRNyá-DY\]ZL ]DQDE\áD]DSOHWDPL:U]HF]\ZLVWR FL-DYDMHVWM
]\NLHPSURJUDPRZDQLDRJyOQHJRSU]H]QDF]HQLDNWyU\PR HUR]ZL ]\ZDüGRZROQ\UR
G]DMSUREOHPyZ6Lá -DY\MHVWQLHW\ONRMHMSU]HQR QR üDOHWDN HPR OLZR FLSURJUD
PLVW\F]QHQLH]DZRGQR üSRZV]HFKQR üGRVW SQR üELEOLRWHNVWDQGDUGRZ\FKLOLF]Q\FK
áDWZRGRVW SQ\FKL \ZLRáRZRUR]ZLMDM F\FKVL ELEOLRWHNGRGDWNRZ\FK
3RGVXPRZDQLH
:V]\VF\ZLHP\MDNZ\JO GDSURJUDPSURFHGXUDOQ\GHILQLFMHGDQ\FKLZ\ZRáDQLDIXQNFML
$E\RGJDGQ ü]QDF]HQLHWDNLHJRSURJUDPXWU]HEDVL WURV]N QDSUDFRZDüSU]H OHG]Lü
Z\ZRáDQLDIXQNFMLL]EDGDüQLVNRSR]LRPRZHSRM FLDDE\VWZRU]\üZáDVQ\P\ ORZ\PR
GHO=WHJRSRZRGXSRWU]HEXMHP\UHSUH]HQWDFMLSR UHGQLFKSU]\SURMHNWRZDQLXSURJUDPX
SURFHGXUDOQHJR²SURJUDP\WHVDPHZVRELHPRJ E\üQLH]UR]XPLDáHSRQLHZD URGNL
Z\UD]XV VNLHURZDQHEDUG]LHMQDNRPSXWHU\QL QDUR]ZL ]\ZDQ\SUREOHP
7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND
'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF
3RQLHZD SURJUDPRZDQLHRELHNWRZHGRGDMHZLHOHSRM üGRW\FKNWyUHPR QD]QDOH ü
ZM ]\NDFKSURFHGXUDOQ\FKPR HVL Z\GDZDüQDWXUDOQ\P]DáR HQLHP HZ\QLNRZ\
SURJUDPZM ]\NX-DYDPR HE\üRZLHOHEDUG]LHMVNRPSOLNRZDQ\QL MHJRUyZQRZD QLN
ZM ]\NXSURFHGXUDOQ\P7XWDMVSRW\NDQDVPLáDQLHVSRG]LDQNDGREU]HQDSLVDQ\SURJUDP
MHVWQDRJyáRZLHOHáDWZLHMV]\GR]UR]XPLHQLDQL RGSRZLDGDM F\PXNRGSURFHGXUDOQ\
7RFRZLG]LP\WRGHILQLFMHRELHNWyZUHSUH]HQWXM F\FKSRM FLD]SU]HVWU]HQLSUREOHPX
DQLHNZHVWLH]ZL ]DQH]UHSUH]HQWDFM NRPSXWHURZ RUD]NRPXQLNDW\Z\V\áDQHGR
W\FKRELHNWyZUHSUH]HQWXM FHG]LDáDQLDZSU]HVWU]HQLSUREOHPX-HGQ ]SU]\MHPQ\FK
VWURQSURJUDPRZDQLD]RULHQWRZDQHJRRELHNWRZRMHVWWR HGREU]H]DSURMHNWRZDQ\SUR
JUDPPR QD]UR]XPLHüF]\WDM FMHJRNRG1DMF] FLHMNRGMHVWWH RZLHOHNUyWV]\SR
QLHZD ZLHOHSUREOHPyZ]RVWDáRUR]ZL ]DQ\FKSU]H]]DVWRVRZDQLHNRGX]LVWQLHM F\FK
ELEOLRWHN
3URJUDPRZDQLHRELHNWRZHL-DYDQLHPXV] E\üGREUHGODND GHJR:D QHMHVWE\RFH
QLüVZRMHSRWU]HE\L]GHF\GRZDüF]\-DYDZVSRVyERSW\PDOQ\MH]DVSRNDMDF]\WH
OHSLHM E G]LH X \ü LQQHJR M ]\ND SURJUDPRZDQLD ZOLF]DM F REHFQLH X \ZDQ\ -H OL
ZLDGRPR HZSU]HZLG\ZDOQHMSU]\V]áR FLVWDZLDQHZ\PDJDQLDE G EDUG]RVSHFMDOQH
LMH OLGRGDWNRZRSRMDZLDM VL VSHF\ILF]QHRJUDQLF]HQLDNWyU\FK-DYDQLHZ\HOLPLQXMH
OHSLHM E G]LH ]EDGDü UR]ZL ]DQLD DOWHUQDW\ZQH Z V]F]HJyOQR FL SROHFDP ]ZUyFHQLH
XZDJLQDM ]\N3\WKRQSDWU]ZZZ3\WKRQRUJ-H OLRVWDWHF]QLHZ\EyUSDGQLHQD-DY
MDNRSUHIHURZDQ\M ]\NSURJUDPRZDQLDE G]LHWR ZLDGRPDGHF\]MDSRGM WDSRUR]ZD
HQLXLQQ\FKRSFML