Thinking in Java Edycja polska Wydanie IV thija4

background image

Wydawnictwo Helion
ul. Koœciuszki 1c
44-100 Gliwice
tel. 032 230 98 63

e-mail: helion@helion.pl

PRZYK£ADOWY ROZDZIA£

PRZYK£ADOWY ROZDZIA£

IDZ DO

IDZ DO

ZAMÓW DRUKOWANY KATALOG

ZAMÓW DRUKOWANY KATALOG

KATALOG KSI¥¯EK

KATALOG KSI¥¯EK

TWÓJ KOSZYK

TWÓJ KOSZYK

CENNIK I INFORMACJE

CENNIK I INFORMACJE

ZAMÓW INFORMACJE

O NOWOœCIACH

ZAMÓW INFORMACJE

O NOWOœCIACH

ZAMÓW CENNIK

ZAMÓW CENNIK

CZYTELNIA

CZYTELNIA

FRAGMENTY KSI¥¯EK ONLINE

FRAGMENTY KSI¥¯EK ONLINE

SPIS TREœCI

SPIS TREœCI

DODAJ DO KOSZYKA

DODAJ DO KOSZYKA

KATALOG ONLINE

KATALOG ONLINE

Thinking in Java. Edycja
polska. Wydanie IV

Poznaj najnowsz¹ wersjê jêzyka Java

• Opanuj zasady projektowania obiektowego
• Wykorzystaj Javê do tworzenia aplikacji
• Zastosuj najnowsze narzêdzia i techniki

Popularnoœæ Javy stale roœnie, a ka¿da nastêpna wersja tego jêzyka wnosi coœ nowego.
Poznanie wszystkich mo¿liwoœci drzemi¹cych w Javie wymaga siêgniêcia do
sprawdzonego Ÿród³a wiedzy — ksi¹¿ki „Thinking in Java”. To œwiatowy bestseller, który
zyska³ zas³u¿on¹ s³awê najlepszego podrêcznika do nauki Javy. Wzbudzi³ entuzjazm
i uznanie programistów przede wszystkim dziêki wyj¹tkowej przejrzystoœci,
przemyœlanej strukturze i trafnie dobranym przyk³adom.

Ksi¹¿ka „Thinking in Java. Edycja polska. Wydanie IV” zawiera szczegó³owe omówienie
zasad programowania w Javie. Przeznaczona jest dla pocz¹tkuj¹cych programistów
i dla ekspertów. Przystêpnie prezentuje zarówno zagadnienia podstawowe, jak
i zaawansowane. Dziesi¹tki przyk³adów u³atwiaj¹ zrozumienie ka¿dego tematu.
Wszystko to sprawia, ¿e poznajemy prawdziw¹ Javê — uniwersaln¹, czyteln¹,
niezale¿n¹ od platformy systemowej. Czytaj¹c tê ksi¹¿kê, dowiesz siê, co jest
niezbêdne do tworzenia wydajnych i bezpiecznych aplikacji w Javie.

• Projektowanie obiektowe
• Zasady dokumentowania kodu Ÿród³owego
• Operatory i sterowanie przebiegiem wykonywania programu
• Inicjalizacja i usuwanie obiektów
• Kolekcje obiektów
• Obs³uga b³êdów
• Operacje wejœcia i wyjœcia
• Programowanie wspó³bie¿ne
• Projektowanie interfejsów u¿ytkownika

Przekonaj siê, dlaczego ksi¹¿ka „Thinking in Java”

jest uznawana za najlepszy podrêcznik Javy dostêpny na rynku

Autor: Bruce Eckel
T³umaczenie: Przemys³aw Szeremiota
ISBN: 83-246-0111-2
Tytu³ orygina³u:

Thinking in Java (4th Edition)

Format: B5, stron: 1256

background image

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?63,6GRF

3U]HGPRZD
:SURZDG]HQLH

5R]G]LDä :SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ

3RVW SXM FDDEVWUDNFMD

2ELHNWSRVLDGDLQWHUIHMV

2ELHNWGRVWDUF]DXVáXJL

8NU\ZDQLHLPSOHPHQWDFML

:LHORNURWQHZ\NRU]\VWDQLHLPSOHPHQWDFML

']LHG]LF]HQLH

Ä%\FLHF]\P ´DÄE\FLHSRGREQ\PGRF]HJR ´

:\PLHQLDOQR üRELHNWyZ]X \FLHPSROLPRUIL]PX

+LHUDUFKLD]SRMHG\QF]\PNRU]HQLHP

.RQWHQHU\

7\S\SDUDPHWU\]RZDQHW\S\RJyOQH

7ZRU]HQLHRELHNWyZLF]DVLFK \FLD

2EVáXJDZ\M WNyZ²HOLPLQRZDQLHEá GyZ

:VSyáELH QR ü

-DYDL,QWHUQHW

&]\PMHVWVLHü:::"

3URJUDPRZDQLHSRVWURQLHNOLHQWD

3URJUDPRZDQLHSRVWURQLHVHUZHUD

3RGVXPRZDQLH

5R]G]LDä :V]\VWNRMHVWRELHNWHP

'RVW SGRRELHNWyZSRSU]H]UHIHUHQFMH

:V]\VWNLHRELHNW\WU]HEDVWZRU]\ü

*G]LHSU]HFKRZXMHP\GDQH

3U]\SDGHNVSHFMDOQ\W\S\SRGVWDZRZH

7DEOLFHZ-DYLH

1LJG\QLHPDSRWU]HE\QLV]F]HQLDRELHNWX

=DVL J

=DVL JRELHNWyZ

:áDVQHW\S\GDQ\FK²VáRZRFODVV

3RODLPHWRG\

0HWRG\DUJXPHQW\LZDUWR FL]ZUDFDQH

/LVWDDUJXPHQWyZ

background image

7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?63,6GRF

7ZRU]HQLHSURJUDPXZ-DYLH

:LGRF]QR üQD]Z

:\NRU]\VWDQLHLQQ\FKNRPSRQHQWyZ

6áRZRNOXF]RZHVWDWLF

7ZyMSLHUZV]\SURJUDPZ-DYLH

.RPSLODFMDLXUXFKRPLHQLH

.RPHQWDU]HRUD]GRNXPHQWRZDQLHNRGX

'RNXPHQWDFMDZNRPHQWDU]DFK

6NáDGQLD

2VDG]RQ\+70/

1LHNWyUH]QDF]QLNLGRNXPHQWDF\MQH

3U]\NáDGGRNXPHQWRZDQLDNRGX

6W\OSURJUDPRZDQLD

3RGVXPRZDQLH

ûZLF]HQLD

5R]G]LDä 2SHUDWRU\

3URVWDLQVWUXNFMDZ\M FLD

8 \ZDQLHRSHUDWRUyZ-DY\

.ROHMQR üRSHUDWRUyZ

3U]\SLVDQLH

7ZRU]HQLHQD]ZZZ\ZRáDQLDFKPHWRG

2SHUDWRU\PDWHPDW\F]QH

-HGQRDUJXPHQWRZHRSHUDWRU\PLQXVLSOXV

2SHUDWRU\]ZL NV]DQLDL]PQLHMV]DQLD

2SHUDWRU\UHODFML

6SUDZG]DQLHUyZQR FLRELHNWyZ

2SHUDWRU\ORJLF]QH

6NUDFDQLHREOLF]HQLDZ\UD HQLDORJLF]QHJR

/LWHUDá\

=DSLVZ\NáDGQLF]\

2SHUDWRU\ELWRZH

2SHUDWRU\SU]HVXQL ü

2SHUDWRUWUyMDUJXPHQWRZ\LIHOVH

2SHUDWRU\L GODNODV\6WULQJ

1DMF] VWV]HSXáDSNLSU]\X \ZDQLXRSHUDWRUyZ

2SHUDWRU\U]XWRZDQLD

2EFLQDQLHD]DRNU JODQLH

3URPRFMDW\SX

:-DYLHQLHPDÄVL]HRI´

.RPSHQGLXPRSHUDWRUyZ

3RGVXPRZDQLH

5R]G]LDä 6WHURZDQLHSU]HELHJLHPZ\NRQDQLD

3UDZGDLIDáV]

LIHOVH

,WHUDFMD

GRZKLOH

IRU

2SHUDWRUSU]HFLQND

6NáDGQLDIRUHDFK

UHWXUQ

EUHDNLFRQWLQXH

1LHVáDZQHÄJRWR´

VZLWFK

3RGVXPRZDQLH

background image

6SLVWUH FL

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?63,6GRF

5R]G]LDä ,QLFMDOL]DFMDLVSU]ñWDQLH

*ZDUDQWRZDQDLQLFMDOL]DFMDSU]H]NRQVWUXNWRU

3U]HFL DQLHPHWRG

5R]Uy QLDQLHSU]HFL RQ\FKPHWRG

3U]HFL DQLHDW\S\SRGVWDZRZH

3U]HFL DQLHSU]H]ZDUWR FL]ZUDFDQH

.RQVWUXNWRU\GRP\ OQH

6áRZRNOXF]RZHWKLV

:\ZRá\ZDQLHNRQVWUXNWRUyZ]NRQVWUXNWRUyZ

=QDF]HQLHVáRZDVWDWLF

6SU] WDQLHILQDOL]DFMDLRG PLHFDQLHSDPL FL

'RF]HJRVáX \ILQDOL]H

0XVLV]SU]HSURZDG]LüVSU] WDQLH

:DUXQHN]DNR F]HQLD

-DNG]LDáDRG PLHFDF]SDPL FL

,QLFMDOL]DFMDVNáDGRZ\FK

2NUH ODQLHVSRVREXLQLFMDOL]DFML

,QLFMDOL]DFMDZNRQVWUXNWRU]H

.ROHMQR üLQLFMDOL]DFML

,QLFMDOL]DFMD]PLHQQ\FKVWDW\F]Q\FK

-DZQDLQLFMDOL]DFMDVWDW\F]QD

,QLFMDOL]DFMDHJ]HPSODU]D

,QLFMDOL]DFMDWDEOLF

=PLHQQHOLVW\DUJXPHQWyZ

7\S\Z\OLF]HQLRZH

3RGVXPRZDQLH

5R]G]LDä .RQWURODGRVWöSX

3DNLHW²MHGQRVWNDELEOLRWHF]QD

2UJDQL]DFMDNRGX

7ZRU]HQLHXQLNDWRZ\FKQD]ZSDNLHWyZ

:áDVQDELEOLRWHNDQDU] G]LRZD

:\NRU]\VWDQLHLQVWUXNFMLLPSRUWGR]PLDQ\]DFKRZDQLD

3XáDSND]ZL ]DQD]SDNLHWDPL

0RG\ILNDWRU\GRVW SXZ-DYLH

'RVW SSDNLHWRZ\

SXEOLFGRVW SGRLQWHUIHMVX

SULYDWHQLHGRW\NDü

SURWHFWHGGRVW SÄQDSRWU]HE\´G]LHG]LF]HQLD

,QWHUIHMVLLPSOHPHQWDFMD

'RVW SGRNODV

3RGVXPRZDQLH

5R]G]LDä :LHORNURWQHZ\NRU]\VWDQLHNODV

6NáDGQLDNRPSR]\FML

6NáDGQLDG]LHG]LF]HQLD

,QLFMDOL]DFMDNODV\ED]RZHM

'HOHJDFMH

à F]HQLHNRPSR]\FMLLG]LHG]LF]HQLD

=DSHZQLHQLHSRSUDZQHJRVSU] WDQLD

8NU\ZDQLHQD]Z

:\EyUPL G]\NRPSR]\FM DG]LHG]LF]HQLHP

SURWHFWHG

5]XWRZDQLHZJyU

'ODF]HJRÄZJyU ´

-HV]F]HRNRPSR]\FMLLG]LHG]LF]HQLX

background image

7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?63,6GRF

6áRZRNOXF]RZHILQDO

=PLHQQHILQDOQH

0HWRG\ILQDOQH

.ODV\ILQDOQH

2VWUR QLH]GHNODUDFM ILQDO

,QLFMDOL]DFMDLáDGRZDQLHNODV

,QLFMDOL]DFMDZSU]\SDGNXG]LHG]LF]HQLD

3RGVXPRZDQLH

5R]G]LDä 3ROLPRUIL]P

5]XWRZDQLHZJyU UD]MHV]F]H

=DSRPLQDQLHRW\SLHRELHNWX

0Dá\WULN

:L ]DQLHZ\ZRáDQLDPHWRG\

8]\VNLZDQLHSRSUDZQHJRG]LDáDQLD

5R]V]HU]DOQR ü

3XáDSNDÄSU]HVáDQLDQLH´PHWRGSU\ZDWQ\FK

3XáDSNDVWDW\F]QHSRODLPHWRG\

.RQVWUXNWRU\DSROLPRUIL]P

.ROHMQR üZ\ZRáD NRQVWUXNWRUyZ

']LHG]LF]HQLHDVSU] WDQLH

=DFKRZDQLHPHWRGSROLPRUILF]Q\FKZHZQ WU]NRQVWUXNWRUyZ

.RZDULDQFMDW\SyZ]ZUDFDQ\FK

3URMHNWRZDQLH]X \FLHPG]LHG]LF]HQLD

6XEVW\WXFMDNRQWUDUR]V]HU]DQLH

5]XWRZDQLHZGyáDLGHQW\ILNDFMDW\SXZF]DVLHZ\NRQDQLD

3RGVXPRZDQLH

5R]G]LDä ,QWHUIHMV\

.ODV\LPHWRG\DEVWUDNF\MQH

,QWHUIHMV\

5R]G]LHOHQLH]XSHáQH

Ä']LHG]LF]HQLHZLHORED]RZH´Z-DYLH

5R]V]HU]DQLHLQWHUIHMVXSRSU]H]G]LHG]LF]HQLH

.ROL]MHQD]ZSRGF]DVá F]HQLDLQWHUIHMVyZ

$GDSWRZDQLHGRLQWHUIHMVX

3RODZLQWHUIHMVDFK

,QLFMDOL]DFMDSyOLQWHUIHMVyZ

=DJQLH G DQLHLQWHUIHMVyZ

,QWHUIHMV\DZ\WZyUQLH

3RGVXPRZDQLH

5R]G]LDä .ODV\ZHZQöWU]QH

7ZRU]HQLHNODVZHZQ WU]Q\FK

3Rá F]HQLH]NODV ]HZQ WU]Q

WKLVLQHZ

.ODV\ZHZQ WU]QHDU]XWRZDQLHZJyU

.ODV\ZHZQ WU]QHZPHWRGDFKL]DVL JDFK

$QRQLPRZHNODV\ZHZQ WU]QH

-HV]F]HRZ]RUFX)DFWRU\0HWKRG

.ODV\]DJQLH G RQH

.ODV\ZHZQ WU]LQWHUIHMVyZ

6L JDQLHQD]HZQ WU]]NODV\ZLHORNURWQLH]DJQLH G RQHM

background image

6SLVWUH FL

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?63,6GRF

'ODF]HJRNODV\ZHZQ WU]QH

'RPNQL FLDLZ\ZRáDQLD]ZURWQH

.ODV\ZHZQ WU]QHDV]NLHOHW\VWHURZDQLD

']LHG]LF]HQLHSRNODVDFKZHZQ WU]Q\FK

&]\NODV\ZHZQ WU]QHPRJ E\üSU]HVáDQLDQH"

/RNDOQHNODV\ZHZQ WU]QH

,GHQW\ILNDWRU\NODVZHZQ WU]Q\FK

3RGVXPRZDQLH

5R]G]LDä .ROHNFMHRELHNWÑZ

.RQWHQHU\W\SRZDQHLXRJyOQLRQH

3RM FLDSRGVWDZRZH

'RGDZDQLHJUXSHOHPHQWyZ

:\SLV\ZDQLH]DZDUWR FLNRQWHQHUyZ

,QWHUIHMV/LVW

,QWHUIHMV,WHUDWRU

,QWHUIHMV/LVW,WHUDWRU

.ODVD/LQNHG/LVW

.ODVD6WDFN

,QWHUIHMV6HW

,QWHUIHMV0DS

,QWHUIHMV4XHXH

3ULRULW\4XHXH

&ROOHFWLRQNRQWUD,WHUDWRU

,WHUDWRU\DS WOHIRUHDFK

,GLRPPHWRG\DGDSWHUD

3RGVXPRZDQLH

5R]G]LDä 2EVäXJDEäöGÑZ]DSRPRFñZ\MñWNÑZ

=DU\VNRQFHSFML

3RGVWDZ\REVáXJLZ\M WNyZ

$UJXPHQW\Z\M WNyZ

3U]HFKZ\W\ZDQLHZ\M WNX

%ORNWU\

2EVáXJDZ\M WNyZ

7ZRU]HQLHZáDVQ\FKZ\M WNyZ

5HMHVWURZDQLHZ\M WNyZ

6SHF\ILNDFMDZ\M WNyZ

3U]HFKZ\W\ZDQLHGRZROQHJRZ\M WNX

6WRVZ\ZRáD

3RQRZQHZ\U]XFDQLHZ\M WNyZ

6HNZHQFMHZ\M WNyZ

6WDQGDUGRZHZ\M WNL-DY\

3U]\SDGHNVSHFMDOQ\5XQWLPH([FHSWLRQ

5RELHQLHSRU] GNyZZILQDOO\

'RF]HJRVáX \ILQDOO\

:VSyáG]LDáDQLHILQDOO\]UHWXUQ

3XáDSND]DJXELRQ\Z\M WHN

2JUDQLF]HQLDZ\M WNyZ

.RQVWUXNWRU\

'RSDVRZ\ZDQLHZ\M WNyZ

5R]ZL ]DQLDDOWHUQDW\ZQH

+LVWRULD

3HUVSHNW\Z\

background image

7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?63,6GRF

3U]HND]\ZDQLHZ\M WNyZQDNRQVRO

=DPLDQDZ\M WNyZVSUDZG]DQ\FKQDQLHVSUDZG]DQH

:VND]yZNL

3RGVXPRZDQLH

5R]G]LDä&LñJL]QDNÑZ

1LH]PLHQQR üFL JyZ]QDNRZ\FK

6WULQJ%XLOGHUNRQWUDSU]HFL RQ\RSHUDWRUµ¶

1LH]DPLHU]RQDUHNXUVMD

2SHUDFMHQDHJ]HPSODU]DFKNODV\6WULQJ

)RUPDWRZDQLHZ\M FLD

)XQNFMDSULQWI

6\VWHPRXWIRUPDW

.ODVD)RUPDWWHU

6SHF\ILNDWRU\IRUPDWX

.RQZHUVMH

0HWRGD6WULQJIRUPDW

:\UD HQLDUHJXODUQH

3RGVWDZ\

7ZRU]HQLHZ\UD H UHJXODUQ\FK

.ZDQW\ILNDWRU\

.ODV\3DWWHUQRUD]0DWFKHU

PHWRGDVSOLW

2SHUDFMH]DVW SRZDQLD

0HWRGDUHVHW

:\UD HQLDUHJXODUQHLRSHUDFMHZHM FLDZ\M FLD-DY\

6NDQRZDQLHZHM FLD

6HSDUDWRU\ZDUWR FLZHM FLRZ\FK

6NDQRZDQLHZHM FLDSU]\X \FLXZ\UD H UHJXODUQ\FK

.ODVD6WULQJ7RNHQL]HU

3RGVXPRZDQLH

5R]G]LDä ,QIRUPDFMHRW\SDFK

3RWU]HEDPHFKDQL]PX577,

2ELHNW&ODVV

/LWHUDá\&ODVV

5HIHUHQFMHNODVXRJyOQLRQ\FK

1RZDVNáDGQLDU]XWRZDQLD

6SUDZG]DQLHSU]HGU]XWRZDQLHP

8 \FLHOLWHUDáyZNODV

'\QDPLF]QHLQVWDQFHRI

=OLF]DQLHUHNXUHQF\MQH

:\WZyUQLHUHMHVWURZDQH

LQVWDQFHRIDUyZQRZD QR üRELHNWyZ&ODVV

5HIOHNVMD²LQIRUPDFMDRNODVLHZF]DVLHZ\NRQDQLD

(NVWUDNWRUPHWRG

'\QDPLF]QHSUR[\

2ELHNW\SXVWH

,PLWDFMHL]DO NL

,QWHUIHMV\D577,

3RGVXPRZDQLH

background image

6SLVWUH FL

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?63,6GRF

5R]G]LDä 7\S\RJÑOQH

3RUyZQDQLH]M ]\NLHP&

3URVWHXRJyOQLHQLD

%LEOLRWHNDNURWHN

.ODVDVWRVX

5DQGRP/LVW

8RJyOQLDQLHLQWHUIHMVyZ

8RJyOQLDQLHPHWRG

:\NRU]\VW\ZDQLHGHGXNFMLW\SXDUJXPHQWX

0HWRG\XRJyOQLRQH]H]PLHQQ\PLOLVWDPLDUJXPHQWyZ

0HWRGDXRJyOQLRQDZVáX ELHNODV\*HQHUDWRU

8QLZHUVDOQ\*HQHUDWRU

8SUDV]F]DQLHVWRVRZDQLDNURWHN

8QLZHUVDOQ\NRQWHQHU6HW

$QRQLPRZHNODV\ZHZQ WU]QH

%XGRZDQLHPRGHOL]áR RQ\FK

7DMHPQLFD]DFLHUDQLD

-DNWRVL URELZ&

6áRZRR]JRGQR FLPLJUDFML

.áRSRWOLZR ü]DFLHUDQLD

1DNUDZ G]L

.RPSHQVDFMD]DFLHUDQLD

7ZRU]HQLHHJ]HPSODU]\W\SyZ

7DEOLFHW\SyZRJyOQ\FK

5DP\

6\PEROHZLHOR]QDF]QH

-DNE\VWU\MHVWNRPSLODWRU"

.RQWUDZDULDQFMD

6\PEROHZLHOR]QDF]QHEH]UDPNRQNUHW\]DFML

.RQZHUVMD]SU]HFKZ\FHQLHPW\SX

3UREOHP\

7\S\SRGVWDZRZHMDNRSDUDPHWU\W\SRZH

,PSOHPHQWRZDQLHLQWHUIHMVyZSDUDPHWU\]RZDQ\FK

2VWU]H HQLDSU]\U]XWRZDQLX

3U]HFL DQLH

=DZáDV]F]HQLHLQWHUIHMVXZNODVLHED]RZHM

7\S\VDPRVNLHURZDQH

2VREOLZDUHNXUHQFMDXRJyOQLHQLD

6DPRVNLHURZDQLH

.RZDULDQFMDDUJXPHQWyZ

'\QDPLF]QDNRQWURODW\SyZ

:\M WNL

'RPLHV]NL

'RPLHV]NLZ&

'RPLHV]NL]X \FLHPLQWHUIHMVyZ

=DVWRVRZDQLHZ]RUFDSURMHNWRZHJR'HFRUDWRU

'RPLHV]NLZSRVWDFLG\QDPLF]Q\FKSUR[\

7\SRZDQLHXWDMRQH

.RPSHQVDFMDEUDNXW\SRZDQLDXWDMRQHJR

5HIOHNVMD

$SOLNRZDQLHPHWRG\GRVHNZHQFMLRELHNWyZ

.LHG\QLHPDSRGU N RGSRZLHGQLHJRLQWHUIHMVX

6\PXORZDQLHW\SRZDQLDXWDMRQHJR]DSRPRF DGDSWHUyZ

background image

7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?63,6GRF

2ELHNW\IXQNF\MQHZUROLVWUDWHJLL

3RGVXPRZDQLH²F]\U]XWRZDQLHMHVWD WDN]áH"

'DOV]DOHNWXUD

5R]G]LDä 7DEOLFH

&RZQLFKWDNLHJRVSHFMDOQHJR"

7DEOLFHWRSHáQRSUDZQHRELHNW\

7DEOLFHZUROLZDUWR FL]ZUDFDQ\FK

7DEOLFHZLHORZ\PLDURZH

7DEOLFHDW\S\RJyOQH

:\WZDU]DQLHGDQ\FKWHVWRZ\FK

0HWRGD$UUD\VILOO

*HQHUDWRU\GDQ\FK

7ZRU]HQLHWDEOLF]DSRPRF JHQHUDWRUyZ

1DU] G]LDNODV\$UUD\V

.RSLRZDQLHWDEOLF

3RUyZQ\ZDQLHWDEOLF

3RUyZQ\ZDQLHHOHPHQWyZWDEOLF

6RUWRZDQLHWDEOLF

3U]HV]XNLZDQLHWDEOLF\SRVRUWRZDQHM

3RGVXPRZDQLH

5R]G]LDä .RQWHQHU\]EOLVND

3HáQDWDNVRQRPLDNRQWHQHUyZ

:\SHáQLDQLHNRQWHQHUyZ

5R]ZL ]DQLH]JHQHUDWRUHP

*HQHUDWRU\GODNRQWHQHUyZDVRFMDF\MQ\FK

6WRVRZDQLHNODVDEVWUDNF\MQ\FK

,QWHUIHMV&ROOHFWLRQ

2SHUDFMHRSFMRQDOQH

2SHUDFMHQLHREVáXJLZDQH

,QWHUIHMV/LVW

.RQWHQHU\6HWDNROHMQR üHOHPHQWyZ

6RUWHG6HW

.ROHMNL

.ROHMNLSULRU\WHWRZH

.ROHMNLGZXNLHUXQNRZH

.RQWHQHU\DVRFMDF\MQH

:\GDMQR ü

6RUWHG0DS

/LQNHG+DVK0DS

+DV]RZDQLHLNRG\KDV]XM FH

=DVDGDG]LDáDQLDKDVK&RGH

+DV]RZDQLHDV]\ENR ü

3U]HVáRQL FLHPHWRG\KDVK&RGH

:\EyULPSOHPHQWDFML

,QIUDVWUXNWXUDWHVWRZD

:\ELHUDQLHSRPL G]\OLVWDPL

=DJUR HQLDWHVWRZDQLDZPDáHMVNDOL

:\ELHUDQLHSRPL G]\]ELRUDPL

:\ELHUDQLHSRPL G]\RGZ]RURZDQLDPL

1DU] G]LDGRGDWNRZH

6RUWRZDQLHLSU]HV]XNLZDQLHOLVW

1LHPRG\ILNRZDOQHNRQWHQHU\&ROOHFWLRQL0DS

6\QFKURQL]DFMD&ROOHFWLRQL0DS

background image

6SLVWUH FL

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?63,6GRF

3U]HFKRZ\ZDQLHUHIHUHQFML

:HDN+DVK0DS

.RQWHQHU\-DYDL

9HFWRUL(QXPHUDWLRQ

+DVKWDEOH

6WDFN

%LW6HW

3RGVXPRZDQLH

5R]G]LDä:HM FLHZ\M FLH

.ODVD)LOH

:\SLV\ZDQLH]DZDUWR FLNDWDORJX

1DU] G]LHGRSU]HJO GDQLDNDWDORJyZ

7ZRU]HQLHNDWDORJyZLVSUDZG]DQLHLFKREHFQR FL

:HM FLHLZ\M FLH

7\S\,QSXW6WUHDP

7\S\2XWSXW6WUHDP

'RGDZDQLHDWU\EXWyZLX \WHF]Q\FKLQWHUIHMVyZ

2GF]\W],QSXW6WUHDP]DSRPRF )LOWHU,QSXW6WUHDP

=DSLVGR2XWSXW6WUHDP]DSRPRF )LOWHU2XWSXW6WUHDP

.ODV\5HDGHUL:ULWHU

UyGáDLXM FLDGDQ\FK

0RG\ILNDFMD]DFKRZDQLDVWUXPLHQLD

.ODV\QLH]PLHQLRQH

2VREQDLVDPRG]LHOQD5DQGRP$FFHVV)LOH

7\SRZH]DVWRVRZDQLDVWUXPLHQLZHM FLDZ\M FLD

%XIRURZDQ\SOLNZHM FLD

:HM FLH]SDPL FL

)RUPDWRZDQHZHM FLH]SDPL FL

:\M FLHGRSOLNX

3U]HFKRZ\ZDQLHLRG]\VNLZDQLHGDQ\FK

2GF]\WL]DSLVGRSOLNyZRGRVW SLHVZRERGQ\P

6WUXPLHQLHSRWRNL

1DU] G]LDGR]DSLVXLRGF]\WXGDQ\FK]SOLNyZ

2GF]\WSOLNyZELQDUQ\FK

6WDQGDUGRZHZHM FLHZ\M FLH

&]\WDQLH]HVWDQGDUGRZHJRZHM FLD

=DPLDQD6\VWHPRXWQD3ULQW:ULWHU

3U]HNLHURZ\ZDQLHVWDQGDUGRZHJRZHM FLDZ\M FLD

6WHURZDQLHSURFHVDPL]HZQ WU]Q\PL

1RZHZHM FLHZ\M FLH

.RQZHUVMDGDQ\FK

3RELHUDQLHSRGVWDZRZ\FKW\SyZGDQ\FK

:LGRNLEXIRUyZ

0DQLSXORZDQLHGDQ\PLSU]\X \FLXEXIRUyZ

6]F]HJyáRZHLQIRUPDFMHREXIRUDFK

3OLNLRGZ]RURZ\ZDQHZSDPL FL

%ORNRZDQLHSOLNyZ

.RPSUHVMD

3URVWDNRPSUHVMDGRIRUPDWX*=,3

3U]HFKRZ\ZDQLHZLHOXSOLNyZZIRUPDFLH=LS

$UFKLZD-DY\-$5

background image

7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?63,6GRF

6HULDOL]DFMDRELHNWyZ

2GQDMG\ZDQLHNODV\

.RQWURODVHULDOL]DFML

6WRVRZDQLHWUZDáR FL

;0/

3UHIHUHQFMH

3RGVXPRZDQLH

5R]G]LDä 7\S\Z\OLF]HQLRZH

3RGVWDZRZHFHFK\W\SyZZ\OLF]HQLRZ\FK

:\OLF]HQLDDLPSRUW\VWDW\F]QH

'RGDZDQLHPHWRGGRW\SyZZ\OLF]HQLRZ\FK

3U]HVáDQLDQLHPHWRGW\SXZ\OLF]HQLRZHJR

:\OLF]HQLDZLQVWUXNFMDFKZ\ERUX

7DMHPQLFDPHWRG\YDOXHV

,PSOHPHQWXMHQLHG]LHG]LF]\

:\EyUORVRZ\

2UJDQL]DFMDQDED]LHLQWHUIHMVyZ

(QXP6HW]DPLDVW]QDF]QLNyZ

6WRVRZDQLHNODV\(QXP0DS

0HWRG\VSHFMDOL]RZDQHGODHOHPHQWyZZ\OLF]HQLD

7\S\Z\OLF]HQLRZHZáD FXFKXRGSRZLHG]LDOQR FL

7\S\Z\OLF]HQLRZHDDXWRPDW\VWDQyZ

5R]SURZDG]DQLHZLHORNURWQH

5R]SURZDG]DQLH]XG]LDáHPW\SyZZ\OLF]HQLRZ\FK

6WRVRZDQLHPHWRGVSHFMDOL]RZDQ\FKGODHOHPHQWyZZ\OLF]HQLD

5R]SURZDG]DQLH]DSRPRF (QXP0DS

=WDEOLF GZXZ\PLDURZ

3RGVXPRZDQLH

5R]G]LDä $GQRWDFMH

3RGVWDZ\VNáDGQLDGQRWDFML

'HILQLRZDQLHDGQRWDFML

0HWDDGQRWDFMH

3URFHVRU\DGQRWDFML

(OHPHQW\DGQRWDFML

2JUDQLF]HQLDZDUWR FLGRP\ OQ\FK

*HQHURZDQLHSOLNyZ]HZQ WU]Q\FK

$GQRWDFMHQLHGDM VL G]LHG]LF]\ü

,PSOHPHQWRZDQLHSURFHVRUD

3U]HWZDU]DQLHDGQRWDFML]DSRPRF DSW

3URJUDPDSWDZL]\WDFMH

$GQRWDFMHZWHVWRZDQLXMHGQRVWNRZ\P

#8QLWDW\S\RJyOQH

,PSOHPHQWDFMD#8QLW

8VXZDQLHNRGXWHVWXM FHJR

3RGVXPRZDQLH

5R]G]LDä :VSÑäELH QR è

2EOLF]DZVSyáELH QR FL

6]\EV]HZ\NRQDQLH

8OHSV]DQLHSURMHNWX

3RGVWDZ\ZLHORZ WNRZR FL

'HILQLRZDQLH]DGD

.ODVD7KUHDG

:\NRQDZF\

background image

6SLVWUH FL

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?63,6GRF

=ZUDFDQLHZDUWR FL]]DGD

8V\SLDQLH²ZVWU]\P\ZDQLHZ WNX

3ULRU\WHWZ WNX

3U]Há F]DQLH

: WNLGHPRQ\

:DULDFMHQDWHPDWZ WNyZ

7HUPLQRORJLD

à F]HQLHZ WNyZ

7ZRU]HQLHUHDNW\ZQHJRLQWHUIHMVXX \WNRZQLND

*UXS\Z WNyZ

3U]HFKZ\W\ZDQLHZ\M WNyZ

:VSyáG]LHOHQLH]DVREyZ

1LHZáD FLZ\GRVW SGR]DVREyZ

5R]VWU]\JDQLHZVSyá]DZRGQLFWZDR]DVRE\ZVSyáG]LHORQH

$WRPRZR üLZLGRF]QR ü

.ODV\ÄDWRPRZH´

6HNFMHNU\W\F]QH

6\QFKURQL]DFMDGRVW SXQDED]LHLQQ\FKRELHNWyZ

/RNDOQDSDPL üZ WNX

3U]HU\ZDQLHZ\NRQDQLD]DGD

2JUyGERWDQLF]Q\V\PXODFMD

3U]HU\ZDQLH]DEORNRZDQHJRZ WNX

:\PXV]DQLHSU]HUZDQLDZ\NRQDQLD

6SUDZG]DQLHSU]HUZDQLD

:VSyáG]LDáDQLHZ WNyZ

0HWRG\ZDLWLQRWLI\$OO

QRWLI\NRQWUDQRWLI\$OO

3URGXFHQFLLNRQVXPHQFL

3URGXFHQFLNRQVXPHQFLLNROHMNL

3U]HND]\ZDQLHGDQ\FKSRPL G]\]DGDQLDPL]DSRPRF SRWRNyZ

=DNOHV]F]HQLH

1RZHNRPSRQHQW\ELEOLRWHF]QH

&RXQW'RZQ/DWFK

&\FOLF%DUULHU

'HOD\4XHXH

3ULRULW\%ORFNLQJ4XHXH

6WHURZDQLHV]NODUQL ²SODQRZDQLHXUXFKDPLDQLD]DGD

6HPDSKRUH

([FKDQJHU

6\PXODFMH

6\PXODFMDRNLHQNDNDVRZHJR

6\PXODFMDVDOLUHVWDXUDF\MQHM

5R]G]LHODQLH]DGD

:\GDMQR ü

3RUyZQDQLHWHFKQRORJLLPXWHNVyZ

.RQWHQHU\EH]EORNDG

%ORNRZDQLHRSW\PLVW\F]QH

%ORNDG\5HDG:ULWH/RFN

2ELHNW\DNW\ZQH

3RGVXPRZDQLH

'DOV]DOHNWXUD

background image

7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?63,6GRF

5R]G]LDä *UDILF]QHLQWHUIHMV\X \WNRZQLND

$SOHW\

3RGVWDZ\ELEOLRWHNL6ZLQJ

3ODWIRUPDSUH]HQWDF\MQD

7ZRU]HQLHSU]\FLVNX

3U]HFKZ\W\ZDQLH]GDU]HQLD

2EV]DU\WHNVWRZH

5R]PLHV]F]DQLHHOHPHQWyZLQWHUIHMVX

%RUGHU/D\RXW

)ORZ/D\RXW

*ULG/D\RXW

*ULG%DJ/D\RXW

3R]\FMRQRZDQLHEH]SR UHGQLH

%R[/D\RXW

1DMOHSV]HUR]ZL ]DQLH"

0RGHO]GDU]H Z6ZLQJX

5RG]DMH]GDU]H LRGELRUQLNyZ

OHG]HQLHZLHOX]GDU]H

:\EUDQHNRPSRQHQW\6ZLQJ

3U]\FLVNL

,NRQ\

3RGSRZLHG]L

3RODWHNVWRZH

5DPNL

0LQLHG\WRU

3RODZ\ERUX

3U]\FLVNLZ\ERUX

/LVW\UR]ZLMDQH

/LVW\

=DNáDGNL

2NQDNRPXQLNDWyZ

0HQX

0HQXNRQWHNVWRZH

5\VRZDQLH

2NQDGLDORJRZH

2NQDGLDORJRZHSOLNyZ

+70/ZNRPSRQHQWDFK6ZLQJ

6XZDNLLZVND QLNLSRVW SX

=PLDQDVW\OXLQWHUIHMVX

'U]HZNDWDEHOHLVFKRZHN

-1/3RUD]-DYD:HE6WDUW

6ZLQJDZVSyáELH QR ü

=DGDQLDGáXJRWUZDáH

:L]XDOL]DFMDZLHORZ WNRZR FLLQWHUIHMVXX \WNRZQLND

3URJUDPRZDQLHZL]XDOQHLNRPSRQHQW\-DYD%HDQ

&]\PMHVWNRPSRQHQW-DYD%HDQ"

:\GRE\FLHLQIRUPDFMLRNRPSRQHQFLHSRSU]H]NODV ,QWURVSHFWRU

%DUG]LHMZ\V]XNDQ\NRPSRQHQW

.RPSRQHQW\-DYD%HDQLV\QFKURQL]DFMD

3DNRZDQLHNRPSRQHQWX-DYD%HDQ

%DUG]LHM]áR RQDREVáXJDNRPSRQHQWyZ-DYD%HDQ

:L FHMRNRPSRQHQWDFK-DYD%HDQ

$OWHUQDW\Z\ZREHFELEOLRWHNL6ZLQJ

background image

6SLVWUH FL

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?63,6GRF

)OH[²DSOLNDFMHNOLHQFNLHZIRUPDFLH)ODVK

$KRM)OH[

.RPSLORZDQLH0;0/

0;0/LVNU\SW\$FWLRQ6FULSW

.RQWHQHU\LNRQWURONL

(IHNW\LVW\OH

=GDU]HQLD

3Rá F]HQLH]-DY

0RGHOHGDQ\FKLZL ]DQLHGDQ\FK

.RPSLORZDQLHLLQVWDODFMD

$SOLNDFMH6:7

,QVWDORZDQLH6:7

$KRM6:7

(OLPLQRZDQLHSRZWDU]DM FHJRVL NRGX

0HQX

3DQHOH]DNáDGHNSU]\FLVNLL]GDU]HQLD

*UDILND

:VSyáELH QR üZ6:7

6:7F]\6ZLQJ"

3RGVXPRZDQLH

=DVRE\

'RGDWHN$ 0DWHULDä\X]XSHäQLDMñFH

6XSOHPHQW\GRSREUDQLD

7KLQNLQJLQ&

6]NROHQLH7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD

6]NROHQLHQD&'520LH+DQGV2Q-DYD

6]NROHQLH7KLQNLQJLQ2EMHFWV

7KLQNLQJLQ(QWHUSULVH-DYD

7KLQNLQJLQ3DWWHUQVZLWK-DYD

6]NROHQLH7KLQNLQJLQ3DWWHUQV

.RQVXOWDFMDLDQDOL]DSURMHNWyZ

'RGDWHN% =DVRE\

2SURJUDPRZDQLH

(G\WRU\L URGRZLVNDSURJUDPLVW\F]QH

.VL NL

$QDOL]DLSURMHNWRZDQLH

3\WKRQ

/LVWDPRLFKNVL HN

6NRURZLG]

background image

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

5R]G]LDä

Ä']LHOLP\RWDF]DM F\QDV ZLDWLNDWHJRU\]XMHP\JRSU]\SLVXM FSRGURG]HW\PNDWHJR

ULRP ]QDF]HQLD ² SRQLHZD MHVWH P\ F] FLDPL VSRáHF]H VWZD ED]XM FHJR QD PRZLH

NWyUHJRVHQVMHVWZPRZLH]DNRGRZDQ\«1LHPRJOLE\ P\SRUR]XPLHZDüVL QLHVWDM F

VL F] FL WHMVSRáHF]QR FLLQLHNRU]\VWDM F]WHJRV\VWHPXNODV\ILNDFML´

²%HQMDPLQ/HH:KRUI±

*HQH] UHZROXFMLNRPSXWHURZHME\áDPDV]\QD²GODWHJRJHQH] M ]\NyZSURJUDPRZDQLD

E\áRÄXGDZDQLH´PDV]\Q\

.RPSXWHU\MHGQDNEDUG]LHMQL PDV]\QDPLV ÄZ]PDFQLDF]DPLXP\VáX´OXEÄURZHUDPLGOD

XP\VáX´²MDNPDZLD6WHYH-REVDWDN HQRZ\P URGNLHPHNVSUHVML:UH]XOWDFLHZFRUD]

PQLHMV]\PVWRSQLXSU]\SRPLQDM PDV]\Q\DZFRUD]ZL NV]\PIUDJPHQW\QDV]HJRXP\VáX

D]DUD]HPNODV\F]QHG]LHG]LQ\V]WXNLWDNLHMDNOLWHUDWXUDPDODUVWZRU]H EDDQLPDFMDLILOP

3URJUDPRZDQLH]RULHQWRZDQHRELHNWRZRMHVWF] FL UXFKXFKF FHJRXF]\QLü]NRPSXWHUD

NROHMQ\ URGHNHNVSUHVML

:W\PUR]G]LDOHSU]HGVWDZL SRGVWDZRZHLGHHSURJUDPRZDQLD]RULHQWRZDQHJRRELHNWRZR

DQJ2EMHFW2ULHQWHG3URJUDPPLQJ223'RNRQDPWDN HSU]HJO GXRELHNWRZ\FKPHWRG

WZRU]HQLD RSURJUDPRZDQLD 3RGREQLH MDN UHV]WD NVL NL UR]G]LDá WHQ ]DNáDGD SHZLHQ

SR]LRPGR ZLDGF]HQLD&]\WHOQLNDZSURJUDPRZDQLXSURFHGXUDOQ\PFKRüQLHNRQLHF]QLH

ZM ]\NX&.WRQLHF]XMHVL PRFQ\ZWHMG]LHG]LQLHSRZLQLHQSU]HM üPXOWLPHGLDOQ\

NXUV7KLQNLQJLQ&GRVW SQ\GRSREUDQLDQDVWURQDFKZLWU\Q\ZZZ0LQG9LHZQHW

7UH üUR]G]LDáXVWDQRZLSRGVWDZ DMHGQRF]H QLHPDWHULDáX]XSHáQLDM F\UHV]W NVL NL

:LHOHRVyEQLHFKFH]DJá ELDüVL ZSURJUDPRZDQLHRELHNWRZHEH]XSU]HGQLHJR]UR]XPLH

QLDMHJRRJyOQ\FKNRQFHSFML²GODWHJRRSLV] WXZLHOH]QLFKWZRU] FZWHQVSRVyEVROLGQ\

REUD]FDáHMWHFKQLNL=GUXJLHMMHGQDNVWURQ\V WDF\NWyU]\PDM SUREOHP\]H]UR]X

PLHQLHPRJyOQ\FKLGHLSU]HGSR]QDQLHPÄPHFKDQLNL´²OXG]LHFLPRJ SRF]XüVL ]D

JXELHQLL]DNáRSRWDQLEH]MDNLHJR IUDJPHQWXNRGXMDNRSXQNWX]DF]HSLHQLD-H HOLQDOH \V]

GRWHMGUXJLHMJUXS\LQLHPR HV]VL MX GRF]HNDüRPDZLDQLDVSHF\ILNLM ]\NDRF]\ZL FLH

background image

7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

PR HV]RSX FLüWHQUR]G]LDá²QDW\PHWDSLHQLHXQLHPR OLZLWRSLVDQLDSURJUDPyZLQDXNL

M ]\ND3RZLQLHQH MHGQDN HSRZUyFLüGRQLHJRSy QLHMDE\]UR]XPLHüGODF]HJRRELHNW\V

ZD QHLMDNSU]\LFKX \FLXSURMHNWRZDüRSURJUDPRZDQLH

3RVWöSXMñFDDEVWUDNFMD

.D G\M ]\NSURJUDPRZDQLDGRVWDUF]DSHZQHMDEVWUDNFML0R QDSUyERZDüEURQLüWH]\ H

]áR RQR üSUREOHPyZMDNLHMHVWH P\ZVWDQLHUR]ZL ]DüMHVWEH]SR UHGQLR]DOH QDRG

URG]DMXLMDNR FLX \ZDQHMDEVWUDNFML3U]H]ÄURG]DM´DEVWUDNFMLUR]XPLHPRGSRZLHG QD

S\WDQLHÄ&]\PMHVWWRF]HJRDEVWUDNFMLGRNRQXMHP\"´- ]\NDVHPEOHUMHVWQLHZLHON

DEVWUDNFM PDV]\Q\:LHOHW]ZLPSHUDW\ZQ\FKM ]\NyZNWyUHVWZRU]RQRSy QLHMWDNLFK

MDN)RUWUDQ%$6,&L&VWDQRZLáRQLHZLHON DEVWUDNFM DVHPEOHUD%\á\ZSRUyZQDQLX

]QLP]QDF]Q\PXVSUDZQLHQLHPMHGQDNSLHUZRWQDDEVWUDNFMDSR]RVWDáDQLH]PLHQLRQD²

ZFL Z\PDJDQHE\áRP\ OHQLHZNDWHJRULDFKVWUXNWXU\NRPSXWHUDDQLHVWUXNWXU\UR]

ZL ]\ZDQHJR SUREOHPX 3URJUDPLVWD PXVLDá GRNRQDü SRZL ]DQLD SRPL G]\ PRGHOHP

PDV]\Q\ZÄSU]HVWU]HQLUR]ZL ]DQLD´F]\OLPLHMVFXZNWyU\PPRGHOXMHP\SUREOHP

WDNLPMDNNRPSXWHUDPRGHOHPVDPHJRUR]ZL ]\ZDQHJRSUREOHPXZÄSU]HVWU]HQLSUR

EOHPX´F]\OLPLHMVFXZNWyU\PSUREOHPLVWQLHMHQSZG]LDáDOQR FLILUP\:\VLáHN

Z\PDJDQ\SU]\NRQVWUXNFMLWDNLHJRRGZ]RURZDQLDZSRá F]HQLX]IDNWHPL MHVWRQR

F]\P ]HZQ WU]Q\P Z VWRVXQNXGRM ]\NDSURJUDPRZDQLDSRZRGXMH HSURJUDP\V

WUXGQHGRQDSLVDQLDLNRV]WRZQHZSLHO JQDFML8ERF]Q\PVNXWNLHPW\FKNáRSRWyZMHVWSR

ZVWDQLHFDáHMJDá ]LZLHG]\]ZDQHMÄPHWRGDPLSURJUDPRZDQLD´
$OWHUQDW\Z GODPRGHORZDQLDPDV]\Q\MHVWPRGHORZDQLHVDPHJRSUREOHPX:F]HVQH

M ]\NLSURJUDPRZDQLDWDNLHMDN/,63F]\$3/SU]\MPRZDá\RNUH ORQ\VSRVyEZLG]HQLD

ZLDWDÄ:V]\VWNLHSUREOHP\V ZRVWDWHF]QR FLOLVWDPL´DOERÄ:V]\VWNLHSUREOHP\V

DOJRU\WPLF]QH´352/2*VSURZDG]DZV]\VWNLHSUREOHP\GRFL JyZGHF\]ML3RZVWDá\

M ]\NL SU]H]QDF]RQH GR SURJUDPRZDQLD RSDUWHJR QD RJUDQLF]HQLDFK DQJ FRQVWUDLQW

EDVHGSURJUDPPLQJRUD]GRSURJUDPRZDQLDZ\á F]QLHSRSU]H]PDQLSXODFM V\PERODPL

JUDILF]Q\PLWHRVWDWQLHRND]Dá\VL ]E\WUHVWU\NF\MQH.D GH]W\FKSRGHM üMHVWRGSR

ZLHGQLHGODRNUH ORQHMNODV\SUREOHPyZGODNWyUHM]RVWDá\RSUDFRZDQHMHGQDNZLQQ\FK

SU]\SDGNDFKVWDMHVL QLHHIHNW\ZQH
3URJUDPRZDQLHRELHNWRZHLG]LHNURNGDOHMGRVWDUF]DM FSURJUDPL FLHQDU] G]LHGRUH

SUH]HQWRZDQLD HOHPHQWyZ Z SU]HVWU]HQL SUREOHPX 5HSUH]HQWDFMD WD MHVW GRVWDWHF]QLH

RJyOQDE\QLHRJUDQLF]DáDVL GRMDNLHJR NRQNUHWQHJRW\SXSUREOHPyZ2GZRáXMHP\

VL GRHOHPHQWyZZSU]HVWU]HQLSUREOHPXMDNLGRLFKRGSRZLHGQLNyZZSU]HVWU]HQL

UR]ZL ]DQLDX \ZDM FWHJRVDPHJRVáRZD²ÄRELHNW´RF]\ZL FLHSRWU]HEQHV UyZ

QLH RELHNW\NWyUHQLHPDM RGSRZLHGQLNyZZSU]HVWU]HQLSUREOHPX3RP\VáSROHJDQD

XPR OLZLHQLXSURJUDPRZLGRVWRVRZDQLDVL GRVSHF\ILF]QHJRM ]\NDGDQHJRSUREOHPX

SRSU]H]GRGDQLHQRZ\FKW\SyZRELHNWyZG]L NLF]HPXSU]\F]\WDQLXNRGXRSLVXM FHJR

UR]ZL ]DQLHQDWUDILDP\QDVáRZDZ\UD DM FHVDPSUREOHP$EVWUDNFMDWDNDMHVWSRW QLHMV]D

L EDUG]LHM HODVW\F]QD RG W\FK NWyU\PL G\VSRQRZDOL P\ ZF]H QLHM

3URJUDPRZDQLH

RELHNWRZHSR]ZDODZL FRSLV\ZDüSUREOHPUDF]HMZNDWHJRULDFKPXZáD FLZ\FKQLH]D

1LHNWyU]\SURMHNWDQFLM ]\NyZX]QDOL HSURJUDPRZDQLHRELHNWRZHVDPRZVRELHQLHZ\VWDUF]DDE\ZSURVW\

VSRVyEUR]ZL ]DüZV]\VWNLHSUREOHP\SURJUDPLVW\F]QH3URPXM RQLNRPELQDFM NLONXUy Q\FKUR]ZL ]D

]ZDQ SURJUDPRZDQLHP]ZLHORPDSDUDG\JPDWDPLDQJPXOWLSDUDGLJPSURJUDPPLQJODQJXDJHV

3DWU]7LPRWK\%XGG0XOWLSDUDGLJPSURJUDPPLQJLQ/HGD$GGLVRQ:HVOH\

background image

5R]G]LDä

u

:SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

ZNDWHJRULDFKNRPSXWHUDQDNWyU\P]RVWDQLHXUXFKRPLRQHUR]ZL ]DQLH3Rá F]HQLH]NRP

SXWHUHP MHGQDN ZFL LVWQLHMH .D G\ RELHNW SU]\SRPLQD PDá\ NRPSXWHU ² PD VZyM

ZHZQ WU]Q\VWDQRUD]]HVWDZRSHUDFMLNWyUHPR HZ\NRQDüMH OL]RVWDQLHRWRSRSUR

V]RQ\1LHZ\GDMHVL WRMHGQDN]á DQDORJL GRRELHNWyZ ZLDWDU]HF]\ZLVWHJR²RQH

UyZQLH PDM SHZQ FKDUDNWHU\VW\N RUD]]DFKRZXM VL ZRNUH ORQ\VSRVyE

$ODQ.D\SRGVXPRZDáSL üSRGVWDZRZ\FKFHFK6PDOOWDONDSLHUZV]HJRXGDQHJRM ]\ND

RELHNWRZHJRD]DUD]HPMHGQHJR]SRSU]HGQLNyZ-DY\&HFK\WHUHSUH]HQWXM F]\VWHSR

GHM FLHRELHNWRZH

:V]\VWNRMHVWRELHNWHP0R QDZ\REUD]LüVRELHRELHNWMDNRZ\P\ OQ ]PLHQQ

²WDN NWyUDQLHW\ONRSU]HFKRZXMHGDQHDOHPR HWDN HUHDOL]RZDü GDQLD

F]\OLZ\NRQ\ZDüQDVRELHSHZQHRSHUDFMH7HRUHW\F]QLHGRZROQHSRM FLD]H ZLDWD

UR]ZL ]\ZDQHJRSUREOHPXSV\EXG\QNLXVáXJLLWGPR QDUHSUH]HQWRZDü

ZSURJUDPLH]DSRPRF RELHNWX

3URJUDPMHVW]ELRUHPRELHNWyZNWyUHSRSU]H]Z\V\áDQLHNRPXQLNDWyZ

PyZL VRELHQDZ]DMHPFRURELüÄ:\VáDQLHNRPXQLNDWX´GRRELHNWXWRLQDF]HM

]D GDQLHZ\NRQDQLDSU]H]QLHJRSHZQHMRSHUDFML0R QDWH P\ OHüRNRPXQLNDFLH

MDNRRZ\ZRáDQLXIXQNFMLSU]\QDOH QHMGRNRQNUHWQHJRRELHNWX

.D G\RELHNWSRVLDGDZáDVQ SDPL üQDNWyU VNáDGDM VL LQQHRELHNW\

,QQ\PLVáRZ\QRZ\RELHNWWZRU]\P\á F] FZMHGHQSDNLHWJUXS MX LVWQLHM F\FK

RELHNWyZ%XGXMHP\ZWHQVSRVyE]áR RQHSURJUDP\XNU\ZDM FMHGQRF]H QLH

LFK]áR RQR ü]DSURVWRW RELHNWyZ

.D G\RELHNWSRVLDGDVZyMW\S0yZL FSRWRF]QLHND G\RELHNWMHVWLQVWDQFM

SHZQHMNODV\JG]LHÄNODVD´MHVWV\QRQLPHPÄW\SX´1DMLVWRWQLHMV] FHFK Z\Uy QLDM F

NODV MHVWRGSRZLHG QDS\WDQLHÄ-DNLHNRPXQLNDW\PR QDGRQLHMZ\V\áDü"´

:V]\VWNLHRELHNW\GDQHJRW\SXPRJ RWU]\P\ZDüWHVDPHNRPXQLNDW\

7RVWZLHUG]HQLHMDNVL Sy QLHMSU]HNRQDP\PR HE\üQLHFRP\O FH3RQLHZD

RELHNWW\SXÄRNU J´MHVWMHGQRF]H QLHRELHNWHPW\SXÄILJXUD´]DWHPÄRNU J´PR H

RWU]\P\ZDüNRPXQLNDW\RGSRZLHGQLHGODÄILJXU\´2]QDF]DWRL PR OLZHMHVW

SLVDQLHNRGXRGZRáXM FHJRVL GRÄILJXU\´NWyU\E G]LHDXWRPDW\F]QLHREVáXJLZDá

ZV]\VWNLHRELHNW\SDVXM FHGRRSLVXW\SXÄILJXUD´7D]DVW SRZDOQR üMHVWMHGQ

]QDMSRW QLHMV]\FKLGHLSURJUDPRZDQLDRELHNWRZHJR

%DUG]LHM]ZL ]á\LSU]HMU]\VW\RSLVRELHNWXSRGDMH%RRFK

2ELHNWPDVWDQ]DFKRZDQLHLWR VDPR ü

2]QDF]DWR HRELHNWPR HSRVLDGDüGDQHZHZQ WU]QHRNUH ODM FHMHJRVWDQPHWRG\

VWDQRZL FH]DFKRZDQLHRELHNWXLND G\RELHNWPR QDZMHGQR]QDF]Q\VSRVyERGUy QLü

RGZV]HONLFKLQQ\FKRELHNWyZ²DNRQNUHWQLHU]HF]ELRU F]ND G\PRELHNWHPMHVWVNR

MDU]RQ\XQLNDOQ\DGUHVSDPL FL

=DáR HQLHWRMHVWQLHFRRJUDQLF]DM FHJG\ PR QDVRELHZ\REUD]LüRELHNW\LVWQLHM FHQDUy Q\FKNRPSXWHUDFK

RUD]ZUy Q\FKSU]HVWU]HQLDFKDGUHVRZ\FKLVWQLHMHPR OLZR üSU]HFKRZ\ZDQLDRELHNWyZQDG\VNX:WDNLFK

SU]\SDGNDFKWR VDPR üRELHNWXQDOH \RNUH ODüQLHQDSRGVWDZLHDGUHVXSDPL FLOHF]ZLQQ\VSRVyE

background image

7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

2ELHNWSRVLDGDLQWHUIHMV

3LHUZV]\PF]áRZLHNLHPNWyU\SURZDG]LáGRNáDGQHUR]ZD DQLDQDGSRM FLHPW\SXE\á

SUDZGRSRGREQLH$U\VWRWHOHV²PyZLáRQRÄNODVLHU\E´RUD]ÄNODVLHSWDNyZ´,GHDPy

ZL FD HZV]\VWNLHRELHNW\E G FXQLNDWRZ\PLQDOH MHGQRF]H QLHGRSHZQ\FKNODV

RELHNWyZRZVSyOQ\FKFHFKDFKLVSRVREDFK]DFKRZDQLD]RVWDáDEH]SR UHGQLRZ\NRU]\

VWDQDZM ]\NX6LPXOD3RGVWDZRZ\PVáRZHPNOXF]RZ\PWHJRSLHUZV]HJRRELHNWR

ZHJRM ]\NDE\áRVáRZR

ENCUU

ZSURZDG]DM FHGRSURJUDPXQRZ\W\S

-DNVDPDQD]ZDZVND]XMH6LPXOD]RVWDáD]DSURMHNWRZDQDZFHOXWZRU]HQLDV\PXODFML

WDNLFKMDNNODV\F]Q\ÄSUREOHPNDVMHUDEDQNRZHJR´0DP\ZQLPGRF]\QLHQLD]H]ELRUHP

NDVMHUyZ NOLHQWyZ NRQW WUDQVDNFML RUD] VXP SLHQL Q\FK ² PQyVWZHP ÄRELHNWyZ´

2ELHNW\NWyUHV LGHQW\F]QH]Z\M WNLHPLFKVWDQXSRGF]DVZ\NRQ\ZDQLDSURJUDPXV

SRJUXSRZDQH Z ÄNODV\ RELHNWyZ´ ² VW G ZáD QLH Z]L áR VL VáRZR NOXF]RZH

ENCUU

NODVD 7ZRU]HQLH DEVWUDNF\MQ\FK W\SyZ GDQ\FK NODV MHVW MHGQ ] IXQGDPHQWDOQ\FK

NRQFHSFMLSURJUDPRZDQLD]RULHQWRZDQHJRRELHNWRZR$EVWUDNF\MQHW\S\GDQ\FK]DFKR

ZXM VL SUDZLHWDNVDPRMDNW\S\SRGVWDZRZHPR QDWZRU]\ü]PLHQQHWDNLHJRW\SX

ZM ]\NXSURJUDPRZDQLDRELHNWRZHJRQD]\ZDQHRELHNWDPLOXE HJ]HPSODU]DPL D QD

VW SQLHPDQLSXORZDüQLPLSURFHVWHQQD]\ZDP\Z\V\áDQLHPNRPXQLNDWyZOXE GD

²Z\V\áDP\GRRELHNWXNRPXQLNDWDRQÄGRP\ ODVL ´FR]QLP]URELü6NáDGRZHHOH

PHQW\GDQHMNODV\SRVLDGDM SHZQHFHFK\ZVSyOQHQSND GHNRQWRPDVDOGRND G\NDVMHU

PR HSU]\M üZSáDW UyZQRF]H QLHMHGQDNSRV]F]HJyOQHVNáDGQLNLPRM VZyMLQG\ZL

GXDOQ\VWDQ²ND GHNRQWRPDLQQHVDOGRND G\NDVMHULQDF]HMVL QD]\ZDLWG$]DWHP

ND G\NOLHQWNRQWRWUDQVDNFMDPRJ E\üUHSUH]HQWRZDQHZSURJUDPLHNRPSXWHURZ\P

SU]H]XQLNDWRZ\E\W%\WWHQMHVWRELHNWHPDND G\RELHNWQDOH \GRRNUH ORQHMNODV\

NWyUDGHILQLXMHMHJRFHFK\L]DFKRZDQLH
7DNZL FPLPRL ZSURJUDPRZDQLXRELHNWRZ\P]DMPXMHP\VL WDNQDSUDZG WZRU]H

QLHPQRZ\FKW\SyZQLHPDOZV]\VWNLHRELHNWRZHM ]\NLSURJUDPRZDQLDVWRVXM VáRZR

NOXF]RZHFODVVQLHW\SH=DWHPNLHG\ZLG]LP\VáRZRÄW\S´SRZLQQL P\SRP\ OHüÄNODVD´

²LQDRGZUyW

3RQLHZD NODVDRSLVXMH]ELyURELHNWyZRWHMVDPHMFKDUDNWHU\VW\FHGDQ\FKVNáDGRZ\FK

RUD]W\FKVDP\FKPR OLZ\FK]DFKRZDQLDFKPR OLZR FLDFKMHVWW\SHPGDQ\FKWDNVDPR

SUDZG]LZ\PMDNQSOLF]ED]PLHQQRSU]HFLQNRZDNWyUDWDN HSRVLDGDSHZQHGDQHFKD

UDNWHU\VW\F]QHF]\OLVZRM ZDUWR üL]HVWDZGR]ZRORQ\FKQDQLHMRSHUDFML]DFKRZD

-HG\QD Uy QLFD SROHJD QD W\P H SURJUDPLVWD GHILQLXMH NODV\ RGSRZLDGDM FH UDF]HM

UR]ZL ]\ZDQHPXSUREOHPRZL²QLHMHVW]PXV]RQ\GRX \ZDQLDLVWQLHM F\FKW\SyZ

]DSURMHNWRZDQ\FKZFHOXUHSUH]HQWRZDQLDZáD FLZ\FKPDV]\QLHMHGQRVWHNSU]HFKR

Z\ZDQLDLQIRUPDFML'RNRQXMHP\ZL FUR]V]HU]HQLDM ]\NDSRSU]H] GRGDQLH QRZ\FK

W\SyZGDQ\FKVSHF\ILF]Q\FKGODQDV]\FKSRWU]HE6\VWHPSURJUDPLVW\F]Q\SU]\MPXMH

QDV]HNODV\L]DSHZQLDLPWDN VDP ÄRSLHN ´MDNW\SRPZEXGRZDQ\Pá F]QLH]HVSUDZ

G]DQLHP]JRGQR FLW\SyZ
3URJUDPRZDQLHRELHNWRZHQLHRJUDQLF]DVL GREXGRZDQLDV\PXODFML0R QDQLH]JDG]Dü

VL ]WH] HND G\SURJUDPMHVWZSHZQ\PVHQVLHV\PXODFM UR]ZL ]\ZDQHJRSU]H]

VLHELHSUREOHPXMHGQDNPLPRWRSUDZG SR]RVWDMH HWHFKQLNLRELHNWRZHPRJ ]áDWZR

FL VSURZDG]LüGX NODV SUREOHPyZGRSURVW\FKUR]ZL ]D

1LHNWyU]\GRNRQXM WXUR]Uy QLHQLDWZLHUG] F HW\SRNUH ODW\ONRLQWHUIHMVQDWRPLDVWNODVDMHVWSHZQ

LPSOHPHQWDFM WHJRLQWHUIHMVX

background image

5R]G]LDä

u

:SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

*G\NODVDMHVWMX VWZRU]RQDPR HP\XWZRU]\üGRZROQ OLF]E MHMRELHNWyZDQDVW SQLH

PDQLSXORZDüQLPLWDNMDNJG\E\LVWQLDá\ZSU]HVWU]HQLSUREOHPX-HGQ\P]SRGVWDZRZ\FK

]DGD ZSURJUDPRZDQLXRELHNWRZ\PMHVWVWZRU]HQLHMHGQR]QDF]QHJRRGZ]RURZDQLDSR

PL G]\SU]HVWU]HQL SUREOHPXDSU]HVWU]HQL UR]ZL ]DQLD

-DNMHGQDN]PXVLüRELHNWGR]URELHQLDF]HJR SR \WHF]QHJR"0XVLLVWQLHüMDNL VSRVyE

]D GDQLDRGQLHJRZ\NRQDQLDSHZQHMRSHUDFMLWDNLHMMDN]DNR F]HQLHWUDQVDNFMLQDU\

VRZDQLHF]HJR QDHNUDQLHF]\WH ]PLDQDSRáR HQLDSU]Há F]QLND3R]DW\PND G\RELHNW

PR H]UHDOL]RZDüW\ONR FL OHRNUH ORQHRSHUDFMH GDQLDMDNLHPR QDVNLHURZDüSRGDG

UHVHPGDQHJRRELHNWX]GHILQLRZDQHV SU]H]MHJRLQWHUIHMVDLQWHUIHMVMHVWZ\]QDF]RQ\

SU]H]W\SRELHNWX3URVW\PSU]\NáDGHPPR HE\üUHSUH]HQWDFMD DUyZNL

CTQYMC TPGY CTQYMC

T\CRCN

,QWHUIHMVXVWDODMDNLH GDQLDPR QDNLHURZDüGRGDQHJRRELHNWXPXVLMHGQDNLVWQLHü

NRGUHDOL]XM F\WH GDQLD7RRQZUD]]XNU\W\PLGDQ\PLVNáDGDVL QDLPSOHPHQWDFM

=SXQNWXZLG]HQLDSURJUDPRZDQLDSURFHGXUDOQHJRQLHMHVWWRVNRPSOLNRZDQH7\SSRVLDGD

SRZL ]DQ ]ND G\PPR OLZ\P GDQLHPIXQNFM NWyUDMHVWZ\ZRá\ZDQDZFKZLOLJG\

RNUH ORQH GDQLHMHVWNLHURZDQHSRGDGUHVHPMDNLHJR RELHNWX3URFHVWHQMHVWRNUH ODQ\

MDNRÄSU]HV\áDQLHNRPXQLNDWX´ GDQLHGRRELHNWXLWRRELHNWZLHMDNQDGDQ\NRPX

QLNDW]DUHDJRZDüZ\NRQXMHNRG

:SRZ\ V]\PSU]\NáDG]LHW\SHPNODV MHVW

CTQYMC

QD]Z NRQNUHWQHJRRELHNWXW\SX

CTQYMC

MHVW

T

D GDQLDMDNLH

CTQYMC

PR HREVáX \üWR]DSDOHQLH]JDV]HQLHUR]MD

QLHQLHLSU]\FLHPQLHQLH6WZRU]HQLHRELHNWXNODV\

CTQYMC

SROHJDQD]GHILQLRZDQLXÄUH

IHUHQFML´

T

GODWHJRRELHNWXDQDVW SQLHZ\ZRáDQLXRSHUDWRUD

PGY

UHDOL]XM FHJR GD

QLHVWZRU]HQLDQRZHJRRELHNWXGDQHJRW\SX:FHOXZ\VáDQLDGRRELHNWXNRPXQLNDWX

SLV]HP\MHJRQD]Z Lá F]\P\M ]DSRPRF NURSNL]QD]Z NRPXQLNDWXMDNLFKFHP\

Z\VáDü=SXQNWXZLG]HQLDX \WNRZQLNDNODV]GHILQLRZDQ\FKSU]H]NRJR LQQHJRSR

ZLHG]LHOL P\MX ZV]\VWNRQDWHPDWSURJUDPRZDQLD]Z\NRU]\VWDQLHPRELHNWyZ

3U]HGVWDZLRQ\ SRZ\ HM GLDJUDP MHVW ]JRGQ\ ] IRUPDWHP ]GHILQLRZDQ\P SU]H] 80/

DQJ 8QLILHG 0RGHOLQJ /DQJXDJH ² XMHGQROLFRQ\ M ]\N PRGHORZDQLD .D GD NODVD

MHVWUHSUH]HQWRZDQDSU]H]SURVWRN WNWyUHJRJyUQDF] üSU]H]QDF]RQDMHVWQDMHMQD]Z

URGNRZDQDSRODGDQ\FKWHNWyUHFKFHP\RSLV\ZDüGROQD]D QDIXQNFMHVNáDGRZH

IXQNFMHQDOH FHGRRELHNWXWRRQHRWU]\PXM RVWDWHF]QLHZV]HONLHNRPXQLNDW\SU]H

VáDQHGRRELHNWX%DUG]RF] VWRZGLDJUDPDFKSURMHNWRZ\FKM ]\ND80/SU]HGVWDZLDQH

V W\ONRQD]ZDLIXQNFMHVNáDGRZHNODV\GODWHJR URGNRZDF] üSURVWRN WDQLHMHVWU\

VRZDQD-H OLLQWHUHVXMHQDVW\ONRQD]ZDNODV\²SRPLMDP\WDN HF] üGROQ

background image

7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

2ELHNWGRVWDUF]DXVäXJL

3RPLPRSUyEWZRU]HQLDL]UR]XPLHQLDSURMHNWXSURJUDPXMHGQ\P]QDMOHSV]\FKVSRVR

EyZSRMPRZDQLDRELHNWyZMHVWP\ OHQLHRQLFKMDNRRÄGRVWDZFDFKXVáXJ´6DPSURJUDP

ZLDGF]\SHZQHXVáXJLGODX \WNRZQLNDUHDOL]XM FMHSU]\X \FLXXVáXJRIHURZDQ\FK

SU]H]LQQHRELHNW\1DV]\PFHOHPMHVWVWZRU]HQLHJUXS\RELHNWyZDMHV]F]HOHSLHM²

RGV]XNDQLH LVWQLHM FHM ELEOLRWHNL ]DZLHUDM FHM WDNLH RELHNW\ XGRVW SQLDM F\FK XVáXJL

NWyUHRSW\PDOQLHQDGDM VL GRUR]ZL ]DQLDSUREOHPX
-HGQ\P]HVSRVREyZZMDNLPR QDUR]SRF] üUHDOL]DFM WHJR]DGDQLDMHVW]DGDQLHVRELH

S\WDQLDÄ*G\E\PZMDNL PDJLF]Q\VSRVyEPyJáZ\FL JQ üMH]NDSHOXV]DMDNLHRELHNW\

UR]ZL ]Dá\E\ PyMSUREOHP"´ 1D SU]\NáDG SU]\SX FLP\ H SLV]HP\ SURJUDP NVL JRZ\

0R QDE\VRELHZ\REUD]LüRELHNW\]DZLHUDM FHVWRVRZQHSUHGHILQLRZDQHIRUPXODU]H

JUXS RELHNWyZUHDOL]XM F\FKRGSRZLHGQLHREOLF]HQLDNVL JRZHRUD]RELHNWREVáXJXM F\

GUXNRZDQLHF]HNyZLIDNWXUQDZV]HONLHJRW\SXGUXNDUNDFK0R HQLHNWyUH]W\FKRELHNWyZ

MX LVWQLHM DMH OLQLHWRMDNSRZLQQ\Z\JO GDü"-DNLHXVáXJLSRZLQQ\XGRVW SQLDüWH

RELHNW\RUD]MDNLFKLQQ\FKRELHNWyZE G RQHSRWU]HERZDüZFHOXUHDOL]DFMLVZ\FK]R

ERZL ]D "3RVW SXM FZWHQVSRVyEPR QDZNR FXGRM üGRHWDSXZNWyU\PE G]LH

PR QDVWZLHUG]Lü HÄWHQRELHNWMHVWQDW\OHSURVW\ HPR QDJRV]\ENRQDSLVDü´DOER

ÄMHVWHPSHZQ\ HWDNLRELHNWMX LVWQLHMH´7REDUG]RUR]V GQ\VSRVyEGHNRPSR]\FML

SUREOHPXQD]ELyURELHNWyZ
:\REUD DQLHVRELHRELHNWXMDNRGRVWDZF\XVáXJPDMHV]F]HMHGQ ]DOHW SRPDJDZSR

SUDZLHQLXVSyMQR FL RELHNWX :\VRND VSyMQR ü RELHNWX MHVW SRGVWDZRZ\P Z\]QDF]QLNHP

MDNR FL SURMHNWX RSURJUDPRZDQLD 2]QDF]D RQD H Uy QH DVSHNW\ IUDJPHQWyZ RSURJUD

PRZDQLDWDNLFKMDNRELHNW\OHF]PR HWRWDN HGRW\F]\üPHWRGOXEELEOLRWHNRELHNWyZ

GREU]HÄSDVXM GRVLHELH´-HGQ\P]SUREOHPyZNWyUHVL SRMDZLDM SRGF]DVSURMHNWR

ZDQLD RELHNWyZ MHVW Z\SHáQLHQLH QLFK ]E\W ZLHORPD PR OLZR FLDPL IXQNFMRQDOQ\PL

1DSU]\NáDGWZRU] FPRGXáGUXNXM F\PR QDGRM üGRZQLRVNX HNRQLHF]Q\E G]LH

RELHNWNWyU\ÄZLHZV]\VWNR´QDWHPDWIRUPDWRZDQLDLGUXNRZDQLD=DSHZQHRND HVL

HWR]E\WZLHOHMDNQDMHGHQRELHNWL HZU]HF]\ZLVWR FLNRQLHF]QHV WU]\OXEQDZHW

ZL FHMRELHNWyZ-HGHQ]QLFKPyJáE\E\üNDWDORJLHP]DZLHUDM F\PZV]\VWNLHPR OLZH

IRUPDW\F]HNyZ]QLHJRE\á\E\SRELHUDQHLQIRUPDFMHGRW\F] FHVSRVREXGUXNRZDQLD

F]HNyZ.ROHMQ\RELHNWOXEJUXSDRELHNWyZPyJáE\VWDQRZLüRJyOQ\LQWHUIHMVGUXNX

M F\NWyU\G\VSRQRZDáE\ZLHG] QDWHPDWZV]\VWNLFKURG]DMyZGUXNDUHNOHF]QLH

ZLHG]LDáE\QLF]HJRQDWHPDWNVL JRZR FL²WDNLRELHNWEDUG]LHMQDGDMHVL GRNXSLHQLD

QL GR VDPRG]LHOQHJR QDSLVDQLD 7U]HFL RELHNW PyJáE\ NRU]\VWDü ] XVáXJ GZyFK SR

SU]HGQLFKDE\UHDOL]RZDü]DPLHU]RQH]DGDQLH$]DWHPND G\]RELHNWyZG\VSRQXMH

VSyMQ\P]ELRUHPXGRVW SQLDQ\FKXVáXJ:SRSUDZQ\PRELHNWRZR]RULHQWRZDQ\PSUR

MHNFLHND G\RELHNWUHDOL]XMHGREU]HMHGQR]DGDQLHOHF]QLHVWDUDVL URELü]E\WZLHOH-DN

PR QDVL E\áRSU]HNRQDüUR]ZL ]DQLHWDNLHQLHW\ONRSRPDJDZRGQDMG\ZDQLXRELHNWyZ

NWyUHPR QDE\Z\NRU]\VWDüRELHNWVWDQRZL F\LQWHUIHMVGUXNRZDQLDOHF]WDN HVWZDU]D

PR OLZR üSLVDQLDRELHNWyZQDGDM F\FKVL GRZLHORNURWQHJRZ\NRU]\VWDQLDZUy Q\FK

SURJUDPDFKQDSU]\NáDGNDWDORJF]HNyZ

7UDNWRZDQLHRELHNWXMDNRGRVWDZF\XVáXJMHVWSRGHM FLHPNWyUHZLHOHXáDWZLDLMHVWSU]\

GDWQHQLHW\ONRSRGF]DVSURFHVXSURMHNWRZDQLDOHF]WDN HZV\WXDFMDFKJG\LQQHRVRE\VWD

UDM VL SU]HDQDOL]RZDüNRGOXESRZWyUQLHZ\NRU]\VWDüRELHNW\²MH OLPR QDRFHQLü

ZDUWR üRELHNWXQDSRGVWDZLH ZLDGF]RQ\FKSU]H]QLHJRXVáXJ]QDF]QLHáDWZLHMPR QD

JRGRSDVRZDüGRWZRU]RQHJRSURMHNWX

background image

5R]G]LDä

u

:SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

8NU\ZDQLHLPSOHPHQWDFML

:DUWRGRNRQDüUR]Uy QLHQLDSRPL G]\WZyUFDPLNODVDQJFODVVFUHDWRUVNWyU]\GHILQLXM

QRZHW\S\GDQ\FKDSURJUDPLVWDPLNOLHQWDPLDQJFOLHQWSURJUDPPHUV

ÄNRQVXPHQWDPL´

NODVNWyU]\Z\NRU]\VWXM WHW\S\GDQ\FKZVZRLFKDSOLNDFMDFK&HOHPSURJUDPLVW\NOLHQWD

MHVW]HEUDQLH]HVWDZXNODVQDU] G]LJRWRZ\FKGRZ\NRU]\VWDQLDZV]\ENLPWZRU]HQLX

DSOLNDFML &HOHP WZyUF\ NODV MHVW QDWRPLDVW SU]\JRWRZ\ZDQLH WDNLFK NODV NWyUH XGR

VW SQLDM SURJUDPL FLHNOLHQWRZLMHG\QLHWRFRGODQLHJRQLH]E GQHDFDá UHV]W WU]\

PDM ZXNU\FLX'ODF]HJR"3RQLHZD WRFRXNU\WHQLHPR H]RVWDüZ\NRU]\VWDQHSU]H]

SURJUDPLVW NOLHQWDD]DWHPWZyUFDPR H]PLHQLüQLHZLGRF]Q F] üQLHSU]HMPXM F

VL HZHQWXDOQ\PZSá\ZHPW\FK]PLDQQDLQQHF] FL8NU\WDF] ü]Z\NOHUHSUH]HQ

WXMHGHOLNDWQHZQ WU]HRELHNWXNWyUHPRJáRE\]áDWZR FL ]RVWDüÄSRSVXWH´SU]H]QLH

XZD QHJROXEQLHGRLQIRUPRZDQHJRSURJUDPLVW NOLHQWD=WHJRSRZRGXXNU\ZDQLHLP

SOHPHQWDFML]PQLHMV]DOLF]E Eá GyZZSURJUDPDFK

1LHVSRVyESU]HFHQLüLGHLXNU\ZDQLDLPSOHPHQWDFML:ND GHMUHODFMLLVWRWQHMHVWLVWQLH

QLHRJUDQLF]H UHVSHNWRZDQ\FKSU]H]ZV]\VWNLHXF]HVWQLF] FHZQLHMVWURQ\*G\WZR

U]\P\ ELEOLRWHN QDZL ]XMHP\ UyZQRF]H QLH SHZQ UHODFM ] MHM NOLHQWHP E G F\P

UyZQLH SURJUDPLVW DOHWDNLPNWyU\PDQDFHOXÄ]áR HQLH´DSOLNDFML]DSRPRF QDV]HM

ELEOLRWHNLHZHQWXDOQLH]EXGRZDQLHELEOLRWHNLZL NV]HM*G\ZV]\VWNLHVNáDGQLNLNODV\

V GRVW SQHGODZV]\VWNLFKZWHG\SURJUDPLVWDNOLHQWPR H]NODV ]URELüZV]\VWNR²

QLHLVWQLHMH DGHQVSRVyEQDZ\PXV]HQLHSU]HVWU]HJDQLDUHJXá1DZHWMH OLQDSUDZG QLH

FKFHP\DE\NOLHQWPDQLSXORZDáEH]SR UHGQLRQLHNWyU\PL]HVNáDGQLNyZQDV]HMNODV\EH]

PHFKDQL]PyZ NRQWUROL GRVW SX QLH LVWQLHMH VSRVyE XQLHPR OLZLHQLD WHJR :V]\VWNR MHVW

SXEOLF]QHLZLGRF]QHGODFDáHJR ZLDWD

3LHUZV]\PX]DVDGQLHQLHPNRQWUROLGRVW SXMHVWFK üZ\PXV]HQLDQDNOLHQFLHWU]\PDQLD

U N]GDOHNDRGU]HF]\NWyU\FKQLHSRZLQLHQGRW\NDü²F] FLQLH]E GQ\FKGRZ\NR

Q\ZDQLDZHZQ WU]Q\FKRSHUDFMLQDV]HJRW\SXGDQ\FKQLHE G F\FKMHGQDNF] FL LQ

WHUIHMVX NWyUHJR SRWU]HEXM X \WNRZQLF\ GR UR]ZL ]\ZDQLD NRQNUHWQ\FK SUREOHPyZ

.RQWURODWDNDMHVWNRU]\VWQDGODX \WNRZQLNyZSR]ZDODLPERZLHPáDWZRRGUy QLüWR

FRGODQLFKLVWRWQHRGWHJRFRPRJ ]LJQRURZDü

'UXJLPSRZRGHPZSURZDG]HQLDNRQWUROLGRVW SXMHVWXPR OLZLHQLHSURMHNWDQWRZLELEOLR

WHNLZ\PLDQ\ZHZQ WU]Q\FKPHFKDQL]PyZNODV\EH]]DVWDQDZLDQLDVL QDGZSá\ZHPWHM

F]\QQR FLQDSURJUDPLVWyZNOLHQWyZ0R QDQDSU]\NáDG]DLPSOHPHQWRZDüMDN NODV

ZSU\PLW\ZQ\VSRVyEZFHOXXSURV]F]HQLDSUDF\DZSy QLHMV]\PWHUPLQLHMH OLRND H

VL WRNRQLHF]QHSU]HSLVDüM DE\G]LDáDáDV]\EFLHM-H HOLLQWHUIHMVLLPSOHPHQWDFMDV RG

VLHELHZ\UD QLHRGG]LHORQHLFKURQLRQHZWHG\RVL JQL FLHWHJRQLHMHVWWUXGQH

-DYDSRVLDGDWU]\VáRZDNOXF]RZHVáX FHGRXVWDQRZLHQLDUR]JUDQLF]H ZNODVDFK6 WR

RWDNKE

SXEOLF]Q\

RTKXCVG

SU\ZDWQ\L

RTQVGEVGF

FKURQLRQ\,FKX \FLHL]QDF]HQLH

MHVWGRV\üRF]\ZLVWH6 WRW]ZVSHF\ILNDWRU\GRVW SXDQJDFFHVVVSHFLILHUV²RNUH

ODM NWRMHVWXSRZD QLRQ\GRX \ZDQLDQDVW SXM F\FKSRQLFKGHILQLFML6SHF\ILNDWRU

RWDNKE

R]QDF]D HGHILQLFMHV GRVW SQHGODND GHJRQDWRPLDVW

RTKXCVG

HGRVW SGR

QLFKSRVLDGDMHG\QLHWZyUFDGDQHMNODV\ZHZQ WU]MHMIXQNFMLVNáDGRZ\FK-H HOLNWR

7HUPLQWHQDXWRU]DZG]L F]DSU]\MDFLHORZL6FRWWRZL0H\HUVRZL

background image

7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

SUyEXMHX \ZDüSU\ZDWQ\FK

RTKXCVG

HOHPHQWyZQDV]HMNODV\SRZRGXMHW\PVDP\P

Z\VW SLHQLHEá GXMX ZF]DVLHNRPSLODFMLSURJUDPX6áRZRNOXF]RZH

RTQVGEVGF

G]LDáD

SUDZLHWDNVDPRMDN

RTKXCVG

²Uy QLFDSROHJDQDW\P HNODV\G]LHG]LF] FH]QDV]HM

PDM GRVW SGRHOHPHQWyZW\SX

RTQVGEVGF

QLHPDM QDWRPLDVWGRW\FKRNUH ORQ\FKMDNR

RTKXCVG

3RM FLHG]LHG]LF]HQLDZSURZDG] MX QLHGáXJR

-DYDSRVLDGDWDN HÄGRP\ OQ\´WU\EGRVW SXNWyU\MHVWZ\NRU]\VW\ZDQ\MH OLQLHSRGDP\

DGQHJR]HZVSRPQLDQ\FKVSHF\ILNDWRUyZ2NUH ODQ\MHVWRQF]DVHPMDNRÄSDNLHWRZ\´

DQJSDFNDJHDFFHVVSRQLHZD GRVNáDGRZ\FKSDNLHWRZ\FKPRJ VL RGZRá\ZDüLQQH

NODV\]WHJRVDPHJRSDNLHWXQDWRPLDVWSR]DSDNLHWHPZLG]LDQHV RQHMDNRSU\ZDWQH

:LHORNURWQHZ\NRU]\VWDQLHLPSOHPHQWDFML

6WZRU]RQDLSU]HWHVWRZDQDNODVDSRZLQQDZV\WXDFMLLGHDOQHMVWDQRZLüX \WHF]Q\IUDJ

PHQWNRGX2ND]XMHVL MHGQDNL RVL JQL FLHWDNLHJRVWDQXU]HF]\QLHMHVWWDNSURVWHMDN

PRJáRE\VL QLHNWyU\PZ\GDZDü²VWZRU]HQLHGREUHJRUR]ZL ]DQLDZ\PDJDVSRUHJR

GR ZLDGF]HQLDLLQWXLFML*G\MHGQDNUR]ZL ]DQLHWDNLHMX SRZVWDQLHZWHG\D SURVLVL

RZLHORNURWQHZ\NRU]\VWDQLH8PR OLZLHQLHWDNLHJRZLHORNURWQHJRZ\NRU]\VWDQLDNRGX

MHVWMHGQ ]JáyZQ\FK]DOHWRELHNWRZR]RULHQWRZDQ\FKM ]\NyZSURJUDPRZDQLD

1DMSURVWV]\PVSRVREHPZ\NRU]\VWDQLDNRGXNODV\MHVWEH]SR UHGQLHX \FLHRELHNWXWHM

NODV\PR QDMHGQDNUyZQLH XPLH FLüRELHNWZHZQ WU]QRZHMNODV\1D]\ZDP\WRÄWZR

U]HQLHPRELHNWXVNáDGRZHJR´1RZDNODVDPR HE\ü]EXGRZDQD]GRZROQHMOLF]E\RELHN

WyZPRJ RQHWDN HQDOH HüGRUy Q\FKW\SyZSRá F]RQ\FKZGRZROQHNRPELQDFMH

SRWU]HEQHGRRVL JQL FLDSR GDQ\FKPR OLZR FL3RQLHZD WZRU]\P\QRZHNODV\X \

ZDM FNODVMX LVWQLHM F\FKGODWHJRNRQFHSFMDWDQD]\ZDVL NRPSR]\FM DQJFRPSRVLWLRQ

MH OLGRNRPSR]\FMLGRFKRG]LG\QDPLF]QLHZF]DVLHZ\NRQDQLDSURJUDPXPyZLP\RQLHM

MDNRRDJUHJDFMLDQJDJJUHJDWLRQ.RPSR]\FMDMHVWF] VWRRNUH ODQDMDNRUHODFMDW\SX

ÄSRVLDGD´WDNMDNZ]GDQLXÄVDPRFKyGSRVLDGDVLOQLN´

1D SRZ\ V]\P GLDJUDPLH M ]\ND 80/ NRPSR]\FMD ]D]QDF]RQD MHVW ]D SRPRF Z\

SHáQLRQHJRURPEX=Z\NOHE G]LHP\X \ZDüSURVWV]HMIRUP\²NUHVNLQLH]DNR F]RQHM

URPEHP²GODR]QDF]HQLDDVRFMDFML

.RPSR]\FMDXPR OLZLDZ\VRNLVWRSLH HODVW\F]QR FL2ELHNW\VNáDGRZHQDV]HMQRZHMNODV\

V ]Z\NOHSU\ZDWQHDZL FQLHGRVW SQHGODX \ZDM F\FKMHMSURJUDPLVWyZNOLHQWyZ0R QD

]DWHPVNáDGRZHWHSRGPLHQLDüQLH]DNáyFDM FLVWQLHM FHJRNRGXNOLHQWD2ELHNW\VNáD

GRZHPR QDWDN HZ\PLHQLDüZF]DVLHZ\NRQDQLDFRSR]ZDODQDG\QDPLF]Q ]PLDQ

]DFKRZDQLDSURJUDPX2SLVDQHGDOHMG]LHG]LF]HQLHQLH]DSHZQLDWDNLHMHODVW\F]QR FL

SRQLHZD RJUDQLF]HQLDQDNODV\XWZRU]RQH]DMHJRSRPRF QDNáDGDQHV MX ZF]DVLH

NRPSLODFML

7DNLSR]LRPV]F]HJyáRZR FLMHVWZ\VWDUF]DM F\GODZL NV]R FLGLDJUDPyZ]D]Z\F]DMQLHMHVWWDN H

NRQLHF]QHUR]Uy QLHQLHDJUHJDFMLRGNRPSR]\FML

background image

5R]G]LDä

u

:SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

3RQLHZD G]LHG]LF]HQLHMHVWWDNLVWRWQHZSURJUDPRZDQLX]RULHQWRZDQ\PRELHNWRZR

F] VWRMHJR]QDF]HQLHMHVWQDGPLHUQLHSRGNUH ODQHFRPR HXSRF] WNXM FHJRSURJUDPLVW\

Z\WZRU]\üIDáV]\Z\SRJO G HQDOH \MHVWRVRZDüZV] G]LH:UH]XOWDFLHWZRU]\RQQLH

HOHJDQFNLHL]E\WQLRVNRPSOLNRZDQHSURJUDP\3U]\WZRU]HQLXQRZ\FKNODVSRZLQQL P\

UDF]HMZSLHUZV]HMNROHMQR FLUR]ZD DüX \FLHNRPSR]\FMLNWyUDMHVWSURVWV]DLEDUG]LHM

HODVW\F]QD']L NLWDNLHPXUR]ZL ]DQLXSURMHNW\SURJUDPyZE G ]QDF]QLHF]\WHOQLHMV]H

=LGHQW\ILNRZDQLHV\WXDFMLZ\PDJDM F\FKX \FLDG]LHG]LF]HQLDMHVWJG\MX ]GRE G]LH

VL SHZQHGR ZLDGF]HQLHVWRVXQNRZRSURVWH

']LHG]LF]HQLH

,GHDRELHNWXMHVWVDPDZVRELHZ\JRGQ\PQDU] G]LHP3R]ZDODSRá F]\ü]HVRE GDQH

L]HVWDZ\IXQNFMLZFHOXUHSUH]HQWRZDQLDRNUH ORQHJRSRM FLD]SU]HVWU]HQLSUREOHPXEH]

X \ZDQLDVSHF\ILF]QHJRM ]\NDPDV]\Q\3RM FLDWDNLHV Z\UD DQHMDNRSRGVWDZRZH

MHGQRVWNLZM ]\NXSURJUDPRZDQLDG]L NLX \FLXVáRZDNOXF]RZHJR

ENCUU

1LHGREU]HE\E\áRJG\E\SRUR]ZL ]DQLXZV]\VWNLFKSUREOHPyZ]ZL ]DQ\FK]WZRU]H

QLHPNODV\WU]HEDE\áRWZRU]\üRGSRGVWDZQRZ NODV SRVLDGDM F SRGREQ IXQNFM

àDWZLHMV]HE\áRE\ÄVNORQRZDQLH´LVWQLHM FHMNODV\LZ\NRQDQLHQDSRZVWDáHMNRSLLZ\

PDJDQ\FKSU]HUyEHNLUR]V]HU]H 7RZáD QLHHIHNW\ZQLHRVL JDP\SRSU]H]Z\NRU]\VWDQLH

G]LHG]LF]HQLDDQJLQKHULWDQFH²]W\P HJG\RU\JLQDOQDNODVDQD]\ZDQDNODV ED

]RZ OXEQDGNODV ]RVWDQLH]PRG\ILNRZDQDZWHG\QDV]ÄNORQ´QD]\ZDQ\NODV SR

WRPQ NODV SRFKRGQ OXESRGNODV RG]ZLHUFLHGOLUyZQLH WH]PLDQ\

6WU]DáNDQDSRZ\ V]\PGLDJUDPLH80/MHVWVNLHURZDQDRGNODV\SRFKRGQHMGRED]RZHM

-DNSy QLHM]REDF]\P\NODVSRFKRGQ\FKPR HE\üZL FHM

7\S QLH RSLVXMH MHG\QLH ZL ]yZ QDNáDGDQ\FK QD SHZLHQ ]ELyU RELHNWyZ ² ZFKRG]L

WDN HZUHODFMH]LQQ\PLW\SDPL'ZDW\S\PRJ SRVLDGDüZVSyOQHFHFK\L]DFKRZDQLD

DOHMHGHQ PR H]DZLHUDü ZL FHMGDQ\FK QL GUXJL OXE REVáXJLZDü ZL FHM NRPXQL

NDWyZDOERREVáXJLZDüMHLQDF]HM']LHG]LF]HQLHZ\UD DWHJRURG]DMXSRGRELH VWZR

PL G]\W\SDPLX \ZDM FSRM FLDW\SyZED]RZ\FKLW\SyZSRFKRGQ\FK7\SED]RZ\

SRVLDGD WH FHFK\ L VSRVRE\ ]DFKRZDQLD NWyUH V ZVSyOQH GOD ZV]\VWNLFK MHJR W\SyZ

SRFKRGQ\FK7ZRU]\P\JRGRUHSUH]HQWRZDQLDWU]RQXSRGVWDZRZ\FKLGHLZVSyOQ\FK

GODSHZQHMJUXS\RELHNWyZ:\ZLHG]LRQH]QLHJRW\S\SRFKRGQHUHSUH]HQWXM QDWRPLDVW

Uy QHPR OLZR FLUHDOL]DFMLW\FKLGHL

5R]ZD P\QDSU]\NáDGPDV]\Q VRUWXM F RGSDGNLZFHOXRG]\VNXVXURZFyZ7\SHP

ED]RZ\PE G]LHÄRGSDGHN´.D G\RGSDGHNSRVLDGDSHZQ ZDJ ZDUWR üLWG0R H

E\ü SRFL W\ SU]HWRSLRQ\ OXE UR]áR RQ\ QD F] FL 'DOHM PR QD ZSURZDG]Lü EDUG]LHM

background image

7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

VSHF\ILF]QHW\S\ PLHFL²WDNLHNWyUHPDM GRGDWNRZHFHFK\QSEXWHONDSRVLDGDNRORU

LVSRVRE\]DFKRZDQLDSXV]NDDOXPLQLRZDPR H]RVWDü]JQLHFLRQDSXV]NDVWDORZDUHDJXMH

QDSROHPDJQHW\F]QH1LHNWyUH]DFKRZDQLDPRJ GRGDWNRZRXOHF]PLDQLHQSZDUWR üSD

SLHUX]DOH \RGMHJRURG]DMXRUD]VWDQX:\NRU]\VWDQLHG]LHG]LF]HQLDSR]ZDOD]EXGRZDü

KLHUDUFKL NODVZ\UD DM F UR]ZL ]\ZDQ\SUREOHPZáD QLHZNDWHJRULDFKZ\VW SXM F\FK

ZQLPW\SyZ

-DNRGUXJLUR]ZD \P\NODV\F]Q\SU]\NáDG]ILJXUDPLJHRPHWU\F]Q\PL²PR HWRE\ü

F] üV\VWHPXNRPSXWHURZHJRZVSRPDJDQLDSURMHNWRZDQLDDOERV\PXODFMLJU\%D]RZ\P

W\SHPE G]LHWXÄILJXUD´SRVLDGDM FD]DZV]HUR]PLDUNRORUSR]\FM LWS.D GDILJXUD

PR H]RVWDüQDU\VRZDQDZ\PD]DQDSU]HVXQL WDSRNRORURZDQDLWG:\ZRG]LP\]QLHM

SRSU]H]G]LHG]LF]HQLHUy QHVSHF\ILF]QHW\S\ILJXURNU JLNZDGUDW\WUyMN W\LLQQH

]NWyU\FKND G\PR HSRVLDGDüGRGDWNRZHFHFK\LVSRVRE\]DFKRZDQLD1LHNWyUHILJXU\

PRJ E\üQSREUyFRQHÄGRJyU\QRJDPL´1LHNWyUH]DFKRZDQLDPRJ E\üUy QHQS

SROHILJXU\OLF]\P\ZUy Q\VSRVyE+LHUDUFKLDW\SyZZ\UD D]DUyZQRSRGRELH VWZDMDN

LUy QLFHSRPL G]\SRV]F]HJyOQ\PLURG]DMDPLILJXU

2SLVDQLHUR]ZL ]DQLDZWHUPLQDFKSUREOHPXGDMHROEU]\PLHNRU]\ FLSRQLHZD SU]HM FLH

RGRSLVXSUREOHPXGRRSLVXUR]ZL ]DQLDQLHZ\PDJDMX ]DVWRVRZDQLDOLF]Q\FKPRGHOL

SR UHGQLFK*G\X \ZDP\RELHNWyZKLHUDUFKLDNODVVWDQRZLPRGHOSLHUZRWQ\]DWHP

SU]HFKRG]LP\ZSURVWRGRSLVXV\VWHPXZ ZLHFLHU]HF]\ZLVW\PGRRSLVXV\VWHPXZNRG]LH

-HGQ\P]JáyZQ\FKSUREOHPyZSURMHNWRZDQLDRELHNWRZHJRMHVW]E\WSURVWDGURJDRGSR

F] WNXGRNR FD3URVWRWDF] VWR]ELMDSRF] WNRZR]WURSXXP\Vá\Z\WUHQRZDQHZSRV]X

NLZDQLXVNRPSOLNRZDQ\FKUR]ZL ]D

3RSU]H]G]LHG]LF]HQLHWZRU]\P\QRZ\W\SNWyU\QLHW\ONR]DZLHUDZV]\VWNLHVNáDGRZH

FKRüWH]DGHNODURZDQHMDNRSU\ZDWQHV XNU\WHLQLHGRVW SQHDOHWDN HFRZD QLHMV]H

NRSLXMHLQWHUIHMVNODV\ED]RZHM$]DWHPZV]\VWNLHNRPXQLNDW\MDNLHPR QDZ\V\áDüGR

RELHNWyZNODV\ED]RZHMPRJ E\üZ\V\áDQHUyZQLH GRRELHNWyZNODV\SRFKRGQHM3R

QLHZD WR]HVSyáRGELHUDQ\FKNRPXQLNDWyZZ\]QDF]DW\SPR QDSRZLHG]LHü HNODVD

SRFKRGQDMHVWWHJRVDPHJRW\SXFRED]RZD2GZRáDMP\VL GRQDV]HJRRVWDWQLHJRSU]\

NáDGXÄ2NU JMHVWILJXU ´7DRVL JDQDSU]H]G]LHG]LF]HQLHUyZQRZD QR üMHVWMHGQ\P

]SRGVWDZRZ\FKHWDSyZ]UR]XPLHQLDVHQVXSURJUDPRZDQLD]RULHQWRZDQHJRRELHNWRZR

3RQLHZD ]DUyZQRNODVDED]RZDMDNLSRFKRGQDPDM WHQVDPLQWHUIHMVPXVL]DWHPLVWQLHü

MDND ]ZL ]DQD]QLPLPSOHPHQWDFMDW]QPXVLLVWQLHüNRGZ\NRQ\ZDQ\JG\RELHNW

RWU]\PDRNUH ORQ\NRPXQLNDW-H HOLZV]\VWNRFR]URELP\WRVWZRU]HQLHQRZHMNODV\]D

background image

5R]G]LDä

u

:SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

SRPRF G]LHG]LF]HQLDPHWRG\NODV\ED]RZHMVWDQRZL FHMHMLQWHUIHMVUyZQLH SU]HFKRG]

GRNODV\SRFKRGQHM²D]DWHPRELHNW\PDM QLHW\ONRWHQVDPW\SFRNODVDED]RZDDOH

WDN H]DFKRZXM VL GRNáDGQLHWDNVDPRFRQLHMHVWV]F]HJyOQLHLQWHUHVXM FH

,VWQLHM GZDVSRVRE\RGUy QLHQLDQRZHMNODV\SRFKRGQHMRGRU\JLQDOQHMNODV\ED]RZHM

3LHUZV]\MHVWGRV\üSURVW\GRGDMHP\GRQLHMSRSURVWXQRZHPHWRG\1LHV RQHF] FL

LQWHUIHMVXNODV\ED]RZHM2]QDF]DWR HNODVDED]RZDQLHURELáDZV]\VWNLHJRF]HJR GDOL

P\D]DWHPX]XSHáQLOL P\MHM]HVWDZPHWRG7RSURVWHLSU\PLW\ZQHX \FLHG]LHG]LF]HQLD

MHVWMDNQDUD]LHLGHDOQ\PUR]ZL ]DQLHPSUREOHPX:DUWRMHGQDN H]DVWDQRZLüVL F]\

NODVDED]RZDQLHSRWU]HEXMHW\FKGRGDWNRZ\FKPHWRG7DNLSURFHVLWHUDF\MQHJRRGNU\ZD

QLDZáD FLZHJRSURMHNWXZ\VW SXMHF] VWRZSURJUDPRZDQLXRELHNWRZ\P

&KRüG]LHG]LF]HQLHZ\GDMHVL F]DVDPLV]F]HJyOQLHZ-DYLHJG]LHZSURZDG]DVL MH]D

SRPRF VáRZDNOXF]RZHJR

GZVGPFU

F]\OLUR]V]HU]DüVXJHURZDüNRQLHF]QR üGRGDQLD

QRZ\FKPHWRGGRLQWHUIHMVXQLHMHVWWRGRNR FDSUDZG 'UXJLP²LGRWHJRZD QLHM

V]\P²VSRVREHPG]L NLNWyUHPXPR HP\XF]\QLüNODV SRFKRGQ Uy Q RGED]RZHM

MHVW]PLDQD]DFKRZDQLDLVWQLHM FHMMX PHWRG\ED]RZHMRNUH ODQDMDNRMHMSU]HVáRQL FLH

DQJRYHUULGLQJ

:FHOXSU]HGHILQLRZDQLDPHWRG\SRSURVWXWZRU]\P\ZNODVLHSRFKRGQHMMHMQRZ GHIL

QLFM 0yZLP\Ä&KF WXZ\NRU]\VWDüW VDP PHWRG ]LQWHUIHMVXDOHGODQRZHJRW\SXPD

RQDURELüFR LQQHJR´

background image

7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

e%\FLHF]\P sDeE\FLHSRGREQ\PGRF]HJR s

:NZHVWLLG]LHG]LF]HQLDPR HSRZVWDüSHZQDZ WSOLZR üF]\QLHQDOH DáRE\RJUDQL

F]\üVL MHG\QLHGRSU]HGHILQLRZ\ZDQLDPHWRG\NODV\ED]RZHMSRZVWU]\PXM FVL RG

GRGDZDQLD QRZ\FK" 2]QDF]DáRE\ WR H NODVD SRFKRGQD MHVW GRNáDGQLH WHJR VDPHJR

W\SXFRED]RZDSRQLHZD PDWDNLVDPLQWHUIHMV:UH]XOWDFLHRELHNWNODV\SRWRPQHM

MHVWGRNáDGQ\PVXEVW\WXWHPRELHNWXNODV\ED]RZHM²PR HP\PyZLüRF]\VWHM]DVW SR

ZDOQR FLDFDáHWRVWDQRZLVNRMHVWRNUH ODQHPLDQHP]DVDG\]DVW SRZDOQR FLDQJVXEVWL

WXWLRQSULQFLSOH-HVWWRZSHZQ\PVHQVLHLGHDOQ\VSRVyEWUDNWRZDQLDG]LHG]LF]HQLD=ZL

]HNSRPL G]\NODV ED]RZ DSRFKRGQ RNUH ODP\ZW\PSU]\SDGNXF] VWRMDNRUHODFM

E\FLDF]\P DQJLVDUHODWLRQVKLSSRQLHZD PR HP\SRZLHG]LHüÄRNU JMHVWILJXU ´

6SUDZG]LDQSRSUDZQR FLX \FLDG]LHG]LF]HQLDSROHJDQD]EXGRZDQLXSRGREQHJR]GDQLD

GODQDV]\FKNODVLVWZLHUG]HQLXF]\PDRQRVHQV
:QLHNWyU\FKV\WXDFMDFKGRGDQLHZW\SLHSRFKRGQ\PQRZ\FKHOHPHQWyZLQWHUIHMVXMHVW

MHGQDNNRQLHF]QH²WDNLHMHJRUR]V]HU]HQLHWZRU]\QRZ\W\S0R HRQE\üQDGDOX \ZDQ\

]DPLDVWW\SXED]RZHJRMHGQDN H]DVW SRZDOQR üQLHMHVWMX LGHDOQDSRQLHZD QRZH

IXQNFMHQLHV GRVW SQH]SR]LRPXED]RZHJR7HQURG]DMUHODFMLPR HP\RNUH OLüMDNRE\FLH

SRGREQ\PGRF]HJR QRZ\W\SSRVLDGDFDá\LQWHUIHMVVWDUHJRW\SXMHGQDN H]DZLHUDWDN H

LQQHPHWRG\SU]H]FRQLHPR QDSRZLHG]LHü HMHVWWDNLVDP5R]ZD P\QDSU]\NáDG

NOLPDW\]DFM 3U]\SX üP\ HPDP\]DLQVWDORZDQ\ZGRPXV\VWHPFKáRG] F\D]DWHP

LQWHUIHMVSR]ZDODM F\QDNRQWURO FKáRG]HQLD:\REUD P\VRELH HNOLPDW\]DFMDSVXMHVL

L]DVW SXMHP\VWDU\V\VWHPQRZ SRPS FLHSOQ NWyUDSR]ZDOD]DUyZQRFKáRG]LüMDN

LRJU]HZDü=DVDGDG]LDáDQLDSRPS\FLHSOQHMMHVWSRGREQDGRG]LDáDQLDNOLPDW\]DFMLDOH

SRPSDPR H]URELüZL FHMRGQLHM3RQLHZD V\VWHPFKáRG] F\MHVW]DSURMHNWRZDQ\GR

NRQWUROLFKáRG]HQLDMHVWRJUDQLF]RQ\GR NRPXQLNRZDQLD VL ] FKáRG] F F] FL QRZHJR

RELHNWX,QWHUIHMVWHJRRELHNWX]RVWDáSRV]HU]RQ\DOHLVWQLHM F\V\VWHPQLH]QDQLF]HJRSR]D

LQWHUIHMVHPRU\JLQDOQ\P

2F]\ZL FLHSRSU]HVWXGLRZDQLXWHJRSURMHNWXVWDMHVL MDVQH HNODVDED]RZD

5[UVGO

%J QF\æE[

QLHMHVWGRVWDWHF]QLHRJyOQDLSRZLQQD]RVWDü]PLHQLRQDQDÄV\VWHPNRQWUROL

WHPSHUDWXU\´DE\PRJáDREVáXJLZDüUyZQLH RJU]HZDQLH²SRF]\P]DVDGD]DVW SR

ZDOQR FL]DF] áDE\]QRZXG]LDáDü'LDJUDPWHQSU]HGVWDZLDMHGQDNV\WXDFM MDNDPR H

VL ]GDU]\üZSURMHNWRZDQLXLZ ZLHFLHU]HF]\ZLVW\P
3R]DSR]QDQLXVL ]]DVDG ]DVW SRZDOQR FLPR QDSRP\ OHü HWRUR]ZL ]DQLHF]\VWD

]DVW SRZDOQR üMHVWMHG\Q\PVáXV]Q\PLIDNW\F]QLHGREU]HMHVWJG\SURMHNWG]LDáDZWHQ

VSRVyE=F]DVHPMHGQDNPRJ Z\VW SLüV\WXDFMHZNWyU\FKNRQLHF]QR üGRGDQLDQRZ\FK

IXQNFMLZLQWHUIHMVLHNODV\SRFKRGQHMMHVWUyZQLHMDVQD3RGRNáDGQ\P]EDGDQLXUR]Uy QLHQLH

PL G]\W\PLSU]\SDGNDPLSRZLQQRE\üRF]\ZLVWH

background image

5R]G]LDä

u

:SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

:\PLHQLDOQR èRELHNWÑZ

]X \FLHPSROLPRUIL]PX

3U]\SUDF\]KLHUDUFKLDPLW\SyZFKFHP\F] VWRWUDNWRZDüGDQ\RELHNWQLHMDNRUHSUH

]HQWDQWDW\SXVSHFMDOL]RZDQHJROHF]UDF]HMED]RZHJR3R]ZDODWRQDSLVDQLHNRGXQLH

]DOH QHJRRGNRQNUHWQHJRW\SX:SU]\NáDG]LH]ILJXUDPLIXQNFMHPDQLSXOXM QLPLQLH

]ZUDFDM FXZDJLQDWRF]\PDM GRF]\QLHQLD]RNU JDPLNZDGUDWDPLWUyMN WDPLF]\WH

WDNLPLILJXUDPLNWyUHQLH]RVWDá\MHV]F]HQDZHW]GHILQLRZDQH:V]\VWNLHRQHPRJ E\ü

QDU\VRZDQHZ\PD]DQHOXESU]HVXQL WH]DWHPIXQNFMHWHSU]HV\áDM SRSURVWXNRPXQLNDW\

GRRELHNWXW\SXILJXUDQLHSU]HMPXM VL VSRVREHPZMDNLRELHNWUHDJXMHQDWHNRPXQLNDW\

1DNRGWDNLQLHPDZSá\ZXGRGDZDQLHQRZ\FKW\SyZDGRGDZDQLHWDNLHMHVWQDMSRZ

V]HFKQLHMV]\PVSRVREHPUR]V]HU]DQLDSURJUDPXRELHNWRZHJRZFHOXREVáX HQLDQRZ\FK

V\WXDFML0R HP\QDSU]\NáDGVWZRU]\üQRZ\W\SILJXU\]ZDQ\SL FLRN WHPQLHPRG\IL

NXM FIXQNFMLRGQRV] F\FKVL MHG\QLHGRRJyOQ\FKILJXU7DNDPR OLZR üUR]V]HU]DQLD

SURJUDPXSRSU]H]WZRU]HQLHQRZ\FKW\SyZSRFKRGQ\FKMHVWZD Q\PVSRVREHPKHUPH

W\]DFML]PLDQSRQLHZD ]QDF] FRXOHSV]DSURMHNW\REQL DM FUyZQRF]H QLHNRV]W\SLHO

JQDFMLRSURJUDPRZDQLD

3U]\SUyELHWUDNWRZDQLDW\SyZSRFKRGQ\FKMDNRLFKRJyOQ\FKW\SyZSRGVWDZRZ\FKQS

RNU JyZMDNRILJXUURZHUyZMDNRSRMD]GyZNRUPRUDQyZMDNRSWDNyZLWGSRZVWDMH

MHGQDNSHZLHQSUREOHP-H HOLIXQNFMD]DPLHU]DSRZLHG]LHüRJyOQHMILJXU]HDE\VL QD

U\VRZDáD RJyOQHPX SRMD]GRZL DE\ MHFKDá OXE RJyOQHPX SWDNRZL DE\ VL SRUXV]\á

NRPSLODWRUQLHPR HZF]DVLHNRPSLODFMLRNUH OLüNWyU\NDZDáHNNRGXSRZLQLHQ]RVWDü

Z\NRQDQ\²IXQNFMDU\VRZDQLDPR HUyZQLHGREU]HGRW\F]\üRNU JXNZDGUDWXF]\

WUyMN WDDRELHNWZ\NRQDRGSRZLHGQLNRGZ\NRU]\VWXM FVZyMZáD FLZ\VSHF\ILF]Q\W\S

-H HOLQLHPXVLP\ZLHG]LHüNWyU\IUDJPHQWNRGXE G]LHZ\NRQDQ\ZWHG\SU]\GRGD

ZDQLXQRZHJRSRGW\SXNRGSU]H]QLHJRZ\NRQ\ZDQ\PR HE\üLQQ\EH]NRQLHF]QR FL

GRNRQ\ZDQLD]PLDQZZ\ZRáDQLDFKPHWRG.RPSLODWRUQLHPR HZL FZLHG]LHüNWyU\

NDZDáHNNRGX]RVWDQLHZ\NRQDQ\&R]DWHPUREL"1DSU]\NáDGQDSRQL V]\PU\VXQNX

NODVD

5VGTQYPKM2VCMC

SUDFXMHZ\á F]QLH]RJyOQ\PLRELHNWDPLW\SX

2VCM

QLH]QDM FLFK

NRQNUHWQ\FKW\SyZ-HVWWRZ\JRGQH]SXQNWXZLG]HQLDNODV\

5VGTQYPKM2VCMC

SRQLHZD

QLHPXVLRQD]DZLHUDüVSHFMDOQHJRNRGXZ\]QDF]DM FHJRGRNáDGQ\W\SOXE]DFKRZDQLH

2VCMC

]MDNLPPDGRF]\QLHQLD-DNZL FVL WRG]LHMH HFKRü

RQTWU\CL

Z\ZRá\ZDQH

MHVWEH]]QDMRPR FLNRQNUHWQHJRW\SX

2VCMC

WRMHGQDNPDPLHMVFHZáD FLZH]DFKRZDQLH

ELHJQLHOHFLOXESá\QLH

2KPIYKP

ELHJQLHOXESá\QLH"

background image

7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

2GSRZLHG]L MHVW SRGVWDZRZD V]WXF]ND SURJUDPRZDQLD RELHNWRZHJR NRPSLODWRU QLH

PR HZ\ZRáDüIXQNFMLZWUDG\F\MQ\VSRVyE:\ZRáDQLDIXQNFMLJHQHURZDQHSU]H]NRP

SLODWRU\M ]\NyZQLH]RULHQWRZDQ\FKRELHNWRZRX \ZDM W]ZZF]HVQHJRZL ]DQLDDQJ

HDUO\ELQGLQJ²WHUPLQXWHJRPR QDQLH]QDüSRQLHZD ZF]H QLHMIXQNFMLQLHPR QD

E\áRZ\ZRá\ZDüLQDF]HM=QDF]\WR HNRPSLODWRUJHQHUXMHZ\ZRáDQLHIXQNFMLRRNUH ORQHM

QD]ZLHSURJUDPá F] F\DQJOLQNHU]DPLHQLD]D WRZ\ZRáDQLHQDEH]Z]JO GQ\DGUHV

NRGXNWyU\PD]RVWDüZ\NRQDQ\:SURJUDPRZDQLXRELHNWRZ\PDGUHVRGSRZLHGQLHJR

IUDJPHQWXNRGXQLHPR H]RVWDüZ\]QDF]RQ\D GRF]DVXZ\NRQDQLD]DWHPSU]\Z\

V\áDQLXNRPXQLNDWXGRRJyOQHJRRELHNWXNRQLHF]QHMHVWLQQHUR]ZL ]DQLH

: FHOX UR]ZL ]DQLD WHJR SUREOHPX SURJUDPRZDQLH RELHNWRZH ZSURZDG]D NRQFHSFM

Sy QHJRZL ]DQLDDQJODWHELQGLQJ3U]\Z\V\áDQLXNRPXQLNDWXGRRELHNWXNRGNWyU\

E G]LHZ\ZRáDQ\QLHMHVW]GHWHUPLQRZDQ\D GRF]DVXZ\NRQDQLD.RPSLODWRUXSHZQLD

VL HPHWRGDLVWQLHMHVSUDZG]DW\S\DUJXPHQWyZLW\S]ZUDFDQHMZDUWR FLQLHZLHMHGQDN

MDNLNRGQDOH \Z\NRQDü

:FHOXSU]HSURZDG]HQLDSy QHJRZL ]DQLD-DYDXPLHV]F]D]DPLDVWEH]Z]JO GQHJRZ\

ZRáDQLDVSHFMDOQ\IUDJPHQWNRGXREOLF]DM F\DGUHVFLDáDPHWRG\QDSRGVWDZLHLQIRUPD

FMLSU]HFKRZ\ZDQHMZRELHNFLHSURFHVWHQMHVWV]F]HJyáRZRRSLVDQ\ZUR]G]LDOH

Ä3ROLPRUIL]P´.D G\RELHNWPR H]DWHP]DFKRZ\ZDüVL LQDF]HMZ]DOH QR FLRGZ\

QLNXG]LDáDQLDWHJRPDáHJRIUDJPHQWXNRGX*G\Z\V\áDP\NRPXQLNDWGRRELHNWXRELHNW

GHF\GXMHFR]QLP]URELü

:QLHNWyU\FKM ]\NDFKPXVLP\MDZQLH]DGHNODURZDü HRF]HNXMHP\RGIXQNFMLHODVW\F]

QR FL]DSHZQLDQHMSU]H]Sy QHZL ]DQLHZM ]\NX&ZW\PFHOXZ\NRU]\VW\ZDQHMHVW

VáRZRNOXF]RZH

XKTVWCN

:M ]\NDFKW\FKZ\ZRáDQLDIXQNFMLVNáDGRZ\FKGRP\ OQLHQLH

V G\QDPLF]QLHZL ]DQH3RZRGRZDáRWRSUREOHP\GODWHJRZ-DYLHG\QDPLF]QHZL ]DQLH

MHVWGRP\ OQHLQLHPXVLP\X \ZDü DGQ\FKGRGDWNRZ\FKVáyZNOXF]RZ\FKDE\VNRU]\

VWDü]SROLPRUIL]PX

5R]ZD P\SU]\NáDG]ILJXUDPL5RG]LQDNODVED]XM F\FKQDW\PVDP\PLQWHUIHMVLH]R

VWDáDSU]HGVWDZLRQDQLHFRZF]H QLHMQDGLDJUDPLH$E\]DGHPRQVWURZDüG]LDáDQLHSR

OLPRUIL]PXFKFLHOLE\ P\QDSLVDüIUDJPHQWSURJUDPXLJQRUXM F\FKDUDNWHU\VW\F]QHGOD

W\SXV]F]HJyá\LZ\NRU]\VWXM F\MHG\QLHLQWHUIHMVNODV\ED]RZHM.RGWHQE G]LHQLH]D

OH Q\RGLQIRUPDFMLVSHF\ILF]QHMGODW\SXDSU]H]WRSURVWV]\GRQDSLVDQLDLáDWZLHMV]\GR

]UR]XPLHQLD3R]DW\PMH OLQRZ\W\SQS

5\G EKQMæV

]RVWDQLHGRGDQ\SRSU]H]G]LH

G]LF]HQLHNRGNWyU\QDSLV]HP\E G]LHG]LDáDá]W\PQRZ\PW\SHPILJXU\WDNVDPRGR

EU]HMDN]LVWQLHM F\PLZF]H QLHMW\SDPL3URJUDPMHVW]DWHPUR]V]HU]DOQ\

-H HOLQDSLV]HVL Z-DYLHDQLHGáXJRQDXF]\P\VL WRURELüQDVW SXM F PHWRG

XQKF\TÎD%Q (KIWTCH]

HY[OC

HPCT[UWL

_

NRPXQLNXMHVL RQD]GRZROQ ILJXU MHVWZL FQLH]DOH QDRGNRQNUHWQHJRW\SXRELHNWX

NWyU\PDE\üU\VRZDQ\LZ\PD]\ZDQ\-H HOLIXQNFM

\TÎD%Q

Z\NRU]\VWDP\ZMDNLP

LQQ\PIUDJPHQFLHSURJUDPX

background image

5R]G]LDä

u

:SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

1MTæIQPGY1MTæI

6TÎLMæVVPGY6TÎLMæV

.KPKCNPGY.KPKC

\TÎD%Q Q

\TÎD%Q V

\TÎD%Q N

Z\ZRáDQLD

\TÎD%Q

E G DXWRPDW\F]QLHG]LDáDüSRSUDZQLHEH]Z]JO GXQDGRNáDGQ\

W\SRELHNWX

:LVWRFLHMHVWWRGRV\ü]DVNDNXM FDV]WXF]ND5R]ZD P\ZLHUV]

\TÎD%Q Q

1MTæI

MHVWSU]HND]\ZDQ\IXQNFMLRF]HNXM FHMDUJXPHQWXW\SX

(KIWTC

3RQLHZD

1MTæI

MHVW

URG]DMHPILJXU\PR HZL FE\ü]DWDN X]QDZDQ\SU]H]PHWRG

\TÎD%Q

=QDF]\WR H

ND G\NRPXQLNDWMDNL

\TÎD%Q

PR HZ\VáDüGRRELHNWXW\SX

(KIWTC

PR HE\ü]DDN

FHSWRZDQ\SU]H]

1MTæI

7RFRWXWDMURELP\MHVWZL FFDáNRZLFLHORJLF]QHLEH]SLHF]QH

3URFHVWDNLSROHJDM F\QDWUDNWRZDQLXW\SXSRFKRGQHJRWDNMDNE\E\áVZRLPW\SHPED

]RZ\PQD]\ZDP\U]XWRZDQLHPZJyU DQJXSFDVWLQJ5]XWRZDQLHX \ZDQHMHVWWX

ZVHQVLHGRVWRVRZ\ZDQLDGRSHZQHMIRUP\ZJyU ]D RGQRVLVL GRVSRVREXZMDNL]Z\

NOHU\VXMHVL GLDJUDP\G]LHG]LF]HQLD²]NODV ED]RZ QDV]F]\FLHLNODVDPLSRFKRG

Q\PLUR]ZLMDM F\PLVL ZGyá5]XWRZDQLHGRW\SXED]RZHJRR]QDF]D]DWHPSU]HVXZDQLH

VL ZJyU GLDJUDPXMHVWZL FU]HF]\ZL FLHÄU]XWRZDQLHPZJyU ´

3URJUDP]RULHQWRZDQ\RELHNWRZR]DZLHUDZSHZQ\FKPLHMVFDFKU]XWRZDQLHZJyU SR

QLHZD ZWHQVSRVyEXZDOQLDP\VL RGNRQLHF]QR FL]QDMRPR FLGRNáDGQHJRW\SX]NWyU\P

SUDFXMHP\6SyMU]P\QDNRGPHWRG\

\TÎD%Q

HY[OC

HPCT[UWL

-DNZLGDüQLHQDSLVDOL P\WXÄ-H OLMHVWH RNU JLHP]UyEWRMH OLMHVWH NZDGUDWHP]UyE

WDPWRLWG´-H OLSLV]HP\NRGVSUDZG]DM F\ZV]\VWNLHW\S\MDNLHPR HPLHü

(KIWTC

VWDMH

VL WRQLHHOHJDQFNLHDSR]DW\PPXVLE\ü]PLHQLDQHSU]\ND G\PGRGDQLXQRZHJRURG]DMX

ILJXU\:SRZ\ V]\PIUDJPHQFLHPyZLP\SRSURVWXÄ-H HOLMHVWH ILJXU WR]QDF]\ H

SRWUDILV]Z\PD]DüVL LQDU\VRZDü=UyEZL FWRL]DMPLMVL RGSRZLHGQLRV]F]HJyáDPL´

:NRG]LHPHWRG\

\TÎD%Q

LPSRQXMHIDNW HZMDNL VSRVyEG]LHMHVL WRFRSRZLQQR

:\ZRáDQLH

PCT[UWL

GODRELHNWX

1MTæI

SRZRGXMHZ\NRQDQLHLQQHJRNRGXQL WHQZ\NR

Q\ZDQ\SU]\Z\ZRáDQLXWHMVDPHMPHWRG\GOD

-YCFTCV

DOER

.KPKC

MHGQDNMH OLNRPXQLNDW

background image

7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

PCT[UWL

]RVWDQLHZ\VáDQ\GRDQRQLPRZHM

(KIWT[

ZWHG\PDPLHMVFH]DFKRZDQLHSR

SUDZQH GOD U]HF]\ZLVWHJR W\SX WHM

(KIWT[

-HVW WR ]DG]LZLDM FH SRQLHZD ² MDN MX

ZVSRPQLDáHP²NRPSLODWRU-DY\NRPSLOXM F

\TÎD%Q

QLHZLH]MDNLPLGRNáDGQLHW\SDPL

PDGRF]\QLHQLD1RUPDOQLHRF]HNLZDOLE\ P\]DWHP HX \MHRQZHUVML

PCT[UWL

L

Y[OC

]GHILQLRZDQ\FKGODED]RZHMNODV\

(KIWTC

QLH]D VSHF\ILF]Q\FKGOD

1MTæI

-YCFTCV

F]\

.KPKC

0LPRWRG]L NLSROLPRUIL]PRZLG]LHMHVL WRFRSRZLQQR.RPSLODWRULV\VWHP

F]DVXZ\NRQDQLD]DMPXM VL V]F]HJyáDPL²PXVLP\MHG\QLHZLHG]LHü HWRG]LDáDLFR

LVWRWQLHMV]HMDNSURMHNWRZDü]Z\NRU]\VWDQLHPWHJRPHFKDQL]PX*G\Z\ OHP\NRPX

QLNDWGRRELHNWX]URELRQWRFRSRZLQLHQQDZHWMH OLX \WHE\áRU]XWRZDQLHZJyU

+LHUDUFKLD]SRMHG\QF]\PNRU]HQLHP

-HGQ ]NZHVWLLVSRUQ\FKGRW\F] F\FKSURJUDPRZDQLDRELHNWRZHJRF] VWRSRUXV]DQ RG

F]DVXSRMDZLHQLDVL &MHVWWRF]\ZV]\VWNLHNODV\SRZLQQ\RVWDWHF]QLHG]LHG]LF]\üSR

ZVSyOQHMNODVLHED]RZHM:-DYLHSRGREQLHMDNZQLHPDOZV]\VWNLFKM ]\NDFKRELHNWR

Z\FKRGSRZLHG EU]PLÄWDN´QD]Z WHMZVSyOQHMNODV\ED]RZHMMHVW]D

1DLGEV

2ND

]XMHVL HKLHUDUFKLD]SRMHG\QF]\PNRU]HQLHPGDMHOLF]QHNRU]\ FL

:KLHUDUFKLL]SRMHG\QF]\PNRU]HQLHPZV]\VWNLHRELHNW\SRVLDGDM ZVSyOQ\LQWHUIHMVZL F

ZRVWDWHF]QR FLZV]\VWNLHV WHJRVDPHJRW\SX$OWHUQDW\ZDGRVWDUF]DQDSU]H]&

SROHJDQDW\P HQLHZLHP\F]\ZV]\VWNRPDWHQVDPIXQGDPHQWDOQ\W\S=SXQNWX

ZLG]HQLDZVWHF]QHM]JRGQR FLRGSRZLDGDWREDUG]LHMPRGHORZL&DOHMHVWPQLHMRJUDQL

F]DM FH-HGQDNMH OLFKFHP\SURJUDPRZDüZSHáQLRELHNWRZRPXVLP\EXGRZDüZáDVQ

KLHUDUFKL DE\X]\VNDüWDN VDP Z\JRG MDNDMHVWZEXGRZDQDZLQQHM ]\NLRELHNWRZH

'RGDWNRZRZND GHMQRZHMELEOLRWHFHNODVMDN SR]\VNDP\X \W\E G]LHMDNL LQQ\QLH

]JRGQ\LQWHUIHMV'RSDVRZDQLHWHJRQRZHJRLQWHUIHMVXGRQDV]HJRSURMHNWXZ\PDJDüE G]LH

Z\VLáNXDE\üPR HWDN HZLHORNURWQHJRG]LHG]LF]HQLD&]\GRGDWNRZDÄHODVW\F]QR ü´

&MHVWWHJRZDUWD"-H HOLVL MHMSRWU]HEXMH²MH HOL]DLQZHVWRZDáRVL ZLHOHZ&²

ZWHG\MHVWGRV\üFHQQD-H HOL]DF]\QDP\RG]HUDLQQHRSFMHWDNLHMDN-DYDPRJ RND]Dü

VL EDUG]LHMSURGXNW\ZQH

:KLHUDUFKLL]SRMHG\QF]\PNRU]HQLHPPDP\JZDUDQFM SRVLDGDQLDSHZQ\FKIXQNFML

SU]H]ZV]\VWNLHRELHNW\:LHP\ HSHZQHSRGVWDZRZHRSHUDFMHPR QDZ\NRQDüQD

ND G\PRELHNFLHZV\VWHPLH:V]\VWNLHRELHNW\PR QDáDWZRWZRU]\üZSDPL FLVWHUW\

FR]QDF] FRXSURV]F]DUyZQLH SU]HND]\ZDQLHDUJXPHQWyZ

+LHUDUFKLDRSRMHG\QF]\PNRU]HQLXZGX \PVWRSQLXXáDWZLDLPSOHPHQWDFM PHFKDQL]PX

SU]\ZUDFDQLDSDPL FLFRMHVWMHGQ ]ZD QLHMV]\FK]DOHW-DY\ZREHF&3RQLHZD

LQIRUPDFMDF]DVXZ\NRQDQLDRW\SLHMHVW]DJZDUDQWRZDQDZND G\PRELHNFLHQLJG\QLH

SR]RVWDQLHP\]RELHNWHPNWyUHJRW\SXQLHPR HP\RNUH OLü-HVWWRV]F]HJyOQLHLVWRWQH

ZSU]\SDGNXRSHUDFMLQDSR]LRPLHV\VWHPXWDNLFKMDNREVáXJDZ\M WNyZRUD]GODXPR

OLZLHQLDZL NV]HMHODVW\F]QR FLZSURJUDPRZDQLX

background image

5R]G]LDä

u

:SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

.RQWHQHU\

6NRUR]DVDGQLF]RQLHZLHP\LOHRELHNWyZE G]LHQDPSRWU]HEQ\FKGRUR]ZL ]DQLDRNUH

ORQHJRSUREOHPXDQLMDNGáXJRRELHNW\WHE G LVWQLHüQLHZLHP\UyZQLH ZMDNLVSR

VyERELHNW\WHSU]HFKRZ\ZDü6N GPDP\ZLHG]LHüLOHPLHMVFDGODQLFKSU]H]QDF]\ü"

7DLQIRUPDFMDMHVWQLHGRVW SQDD GRF]DVXZ\NRQDQLDSURJUDPX

5R]ZL ]DQLDZL NV]R FLSUREOHPyZZSURMHNWRZDQLXRELHNWRZ\PZ\GDM VL G]LZQLH

SURVWHWZRU]\P\QRZ\W\SRELHNWyZ:SU]\SDGNXRPDZLDQHJRSUREOHPXW\PQRZ\P

W\SHPMHVWRELHNWSU]HFKRZXM F\UHIHUHQFMHGRLQQ\FKRELHNWyZ0RJOLE\ P\RF]\ZL FLH

X]\VNDüDQDORJLF]Q\HIHNWX \ZDM FWDEOLFGRVW SQ\FKZQLHPDOND G\PM ]\NXSUR

JUDPRZDQLD'RVWDMHP\MHGQDNZL FHMQRZ\RELHNW]ZDQ\NRQWHQHUHPOXENROHNFM

OHF]VáRZRWRMHVWX \ZDQHZ-DYLHZLQQ\P]QDF]HQLXZ]ZL ]NX]W\PZWHMNVL FH

E G]LHX \ZDQ\WHUPLQÄNRQWHQHU´E G]LHUR]V]HU]DáVL JG\E G]LHWRNRQLHF]QHE\

SU]\M üZV]\VWNRFRGRQLHJRZVWDZLP\1LHPXVLP\ZL FZLHG]LHüLOHRELHNWyZ

E G]LHSU]HFKRZ\ZDQ\FKZNRQWHQHU]H3RSURVWXWZRU]\P\JRLSR]ZDODP\PX]DM ü

VL V]F]HJyáDPL

1DV]F] FLHND G\GREU\M ]\NRELHNWRZ\GRVWDUF]DQ\MHVW]]HVWDZHPNRQWHQHUyZ:&

]HVWDZWDNLMHVWF] FL ELEOLRWHNLVWDQGDUGRZHMLRNUH ODQ\MHVWF]DVDPLDNURQLPHP67/

6WDQGDUG7HPSODWH/LEUDU\:M ]\NX2EMHFW3DVFDONRQWHQHU\VWDQRZL F] üELEOLRWH

NL9&/9LVXDO&RPSRQHQW/LEUDU\6PDOOWDONSRVLDGDEDUG]RUR]EXGRZDQ ELEOLRWHN

NRQWHQHUyZ7DN H-DYDSRVLDGDNRQWHQHU\ZVZHMELEOLRWHFHVWDQGDUGRZHM:QLHNWyU\FK

ELEOLRWHNDFKRJyOQ\NRQWHQHUXZD DQ\MHVW]DZ\VWDUF]DM FRGREU\GRZV]\VWNLFK]DVWR

VRZD ZLQQ\FK]D QSZ-DYLHLVWQLHM Uy QHW\S\NRQWHQHUyZGODUy Q\FKSRWU]HENLOND

Uy Q\FKURG]DMyZNODV

.KUV

VáX F\FKGRSU]HFKRZ\ZDQLDVHNZHQFMLNODV\

/CR

]ZDQH

WDN HWDEOLFDPLDVRFMDF\MQ\PLNWyUHNRMDU] MHGQHRELHNW\]LQQ\PLNODV\

5GV

GRSU]H

FKRZ\ZDQLD QLHSRZWDU]DM F\FK VL HOHPHQWyZ %LEOLRWHNL NRQWHQHUyZ PRJ UyZQLH

]DZLHUDüNROHMNLGU]HZDVWRV\LWG

=SURMHNWRZHJRSXQNWXZLG]HQLDZV]\VWNRF]HJRSRWU]HEXMHP\WRNRQWHQHUNWyU\P

PR QDVL SRVáXJLZDüZFHOXUR]ZL ]DQLDSUREOHPX*G\E\SRMHG\QF]\W\SNRQWHQHUD

Z\VWDUF]DáQLHE\áRE\SRWU]HE\SRVLDGDQLDUy Q\FKLFKURG]DMyZ,VWQLHM GZDSRZRG\

GODNWyU\FKSRWU]HEQ\MHVWZ\EyUPL G]\NRQWHQHUDPL3RSLHUZV]HNRQWHQHU\SRVLD

GDM Uy QHLQWHUIHMV\L]HZQ WU]QH]DFKRZDQLD=DFKRZDQLHVL LLQWHUIHMVVWRVXV Uy QH

RGW\FK]DSHZQLDQ\FKSU]H]NROHMN NWyUD]NROHLUy QLVL RG]ELRUXF]\OLVW\2NUH ORQ\

LQWHUIHMVPR H]DSHZQLDüEDUG]LHMHODVW\F]QHUR]ZL ]DQLHQDV]HJRSUREOHPXQL LQQ\

3R GUXJLH NRV]W Z\NRQDQLD W\FK VDP\FK RSHUDFML QD Uy Q\FK NRQWHQHUDFK MHVW LQQ\

1DMOHSV]\SU]\NáDGVWDQRZL

#TTC[.KUV

L

.KPMGF.KUV

2ELHWHNODV\UHSUH]HQWXM SURVWH

OLVW\HOHPHQWyZPDM LGHQW\F]QHLQWHUIHMV\LFHFKXM VL SRGREQ\P]DFKRZDQLHP]H

ZQ WU]Q\P-HGQDNRNUH ORQHRSHUDFMHPRJ PLHüGODQLFK]DVDGQLF]RUy]Q\NRV]W'R

VW SVZRERGQ\GRHOHPHQWyZZNODVLH

#TTC[.KUV

MHVWRSHUDFM Z\NRQ\ZDQ ZF]DVLHVWD

á\P²WUZDWDNVDPRGáXJREH]Z]JO GXQDWRGRNWyUHJRHOHPHQWXVL RGZRáXMHP\

-HGQDN H Z SU]\SDGNX

.KPMGF.KUV

Z\EUDQLH RNUH ORQHJR HOHPHQWX Z\PDJD SU]HM FLD

SU]H]HOHPHQW\SRSU]HG]DM FHJRQDOL FLHFRMHVWRSHUDFM W\PNRV]WRZQLHMV] LPGD

OHMQDOL FLH]QDMGXMHVL HOHPHQW=GUXJLHMVWURQ\GRGDQLHHOHPHQWXZ URGNXOLVW\MHVW

background image

7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

]QDF]QLHWD V]HZZ\SDGNXOLVW\SRZL ]DQHM

.KPMGF.KUV

7HLLQQHRSHUDFMHPDM ]Uy QL

FRZDQ HIHNW\ZQR üZ]DOH QR FLRGZHZQ WU]QHMLPSOHPHQWDFMLOLVW\:ID]LHSURMHNWR

ZDQLDPRJOLE\ P\]DF] üRGZ\NRU]\VWDQLDOLVW\SRZL ]DQHMSRF]\PSU]\GRVWUDMDQLX

HIHNW\ZQR FLSU]HVWDZLüVL QDZHNWRU

#TTC[.KUV

']L NL]DSHZQLDQHMSU]H]LWHUDWRU\

DEVWUDNFMLZSá\ZWDNLHM]PLDQ\QDNRGE\áE\PLQLPDOQ\

7\S\SDUDPHWU\]RZDQHW\S\RJÑOQH

: ZHUVMDFK M ]\ND SRSU]HG]DM F\FK Z\GDQLH -DYD 6( NRQWHQHU\ SU]HFKRZ\ZDá\ HOH

PHQW\MHGQHJRXQLZHUVDOQHJRW\SX

1DLGEV

+LHUDUFKLD]SRMHG\QF]\PNRU]HQLHPLPSOL

NXMH HZV]\VWNLHRELHNW\V UHSUH]HQWDQWDPLNODV\

1DLGEV

D]DWHPNRQWHQHU\PRJ FH

SU]HFKRZ\ZDüRELHNW\WHMNODV\PRJ SU]HFKRZ\ZDüFRNROZLHN

7RZáD QLHG]L NLWHPX

NRQWHQHU\QDGDM VL GRWDNSRZV]HFKQHJRVWRVRZDQLD

8 \ZDM FWDNLHJRNRQWHQHUDZVWDZLDP\GRQLHJRSRSURVWXUHIHUHQFMHGRRELHNWyZDSy

QLHMSURVLP\RLFK]ZURW-HGQDNVNRURNRQWHQHUSU]HFKRZXMHRELHNW\NODV\

1DLGEV

SU]\

ZVWDZLDQLXGRNRQWHQHUDGRNRQXMHVL U]XWRZDQLDQDW NODV SU]H]FRWUDFLP\LQIRUPDFM

RNRQNUHWQ\PW\SLHZVWDZLDQHJRRELHNWX:\MPXM FRELHNWRWU]\PXMHP\UyZQLH UHIHUHQFM

GRW\SX

1DLGEV

DQLHGRRU\JLQDOQHJRW\SXZáR RQHJRRELHNWX-DN]DWHP]DPLHQLüM QD

SRZUyWQDFR RLQWHUIHMVLHRELHNWXNWyU\ZVWDZLOL P\GRNRQWHQHUD"

,ZW\PSU]\SDGNXSRWU]HEXMHP\U]XWRZDQLDMHGQDNQLHE G]LHWRMX U]XWRZDQLHZJyU

KLHUDUFKLLG]LHG]LF]HQLDGODX]\VNDQLDEDUG]LHMRJyOQHJRW\SX²U]XWXMHP\WHUD]ZGyá

Z FHOX X]\VNDQLD W\SX VSHFMDOL]RZDQHJR 7HQ URG]DM U]XWRZDQLD QD]\ZDP\ ZáD QLH

U]XWRZDQLHPZGyáDQJGRZQFDVWLQJ*G\U]XWXMHP\ZJyU ZLHP\QDSU]\NáDG H

ÄRNU J´MHVWURG]DMHPÄILJXU\´WDNZL FU]XWRZDQLHMHVWWX]DZV]HEH]SLHF]QH1LHPR HP\

MHGQDN]JyU\SU]HZLG]LHü HGDQ\RELHNWW\SX

1DLGEV

MHVW]SHZQR FL ÄRNU JLHP´F]\

ÄILJXU ´²WUXGQRZL FX]QDüWHQURG]DMU]XWRZDQLD]DEH]SLHF]Q\FK\ED HZMDNL VSRVyE

SR]QDP\ZáD FLZ\W\SRELHNWX]NWyU\PPDP\GRF]\QLHQLD

6\WXDFMDQLHMHVWMHGQDNEDUG]RQLHEH]SLHF]QD²GRNRQXM FU]XWRZDQLDQDQLHZáD FLZ\W\S

VSRZRGXMHP\Z\VW SLHQLHEá GXF]DVXZ\NRQDQLD]ZDQHJRZ\M WNLHPDQJH[FHSWLRQ

²RZ\M WNDFKGRZLHP\VL ZL FHMMX QLHEDZHP0LPRWRSU]\Z\MPRZDQLX]NRQWHQHUD

UHIHUHQFMLGRRELHNWyZPXVLP\ZFHOXGRNRQDQLDSUDZLGáRZHJRU]XWRZDQLDSDPL WDü

MDNLHJRZáD FLZLHWHRELHNW\V W\SX

5]XWRZDQLHZGyáZSRá F]HQLX]NRQLHF]QR FL Z\NRQ\ZDQLDWHVWyZF]DVXZ\NRQDQLD

SRZRGXMHSHZLHQQDU]XWF]DVRZ\ZG]LDáDM F\PSURJUDPLHRUD]Z\PDJDGRGDWNRZHJR

Z\VLáNX RG SURJUDPLVW\ 0R QD ]DS\WDü F]\ QLH GDáRE\ VL Z MDNL VSRVyE VWZRU]\ü

NRQWHQHUDÄ]QDM FHJR´W\SSU]HFKRZ\ZDQ\FKSU]H]VLHELHRELHNWyZLZ\HOLPLQRZDüZWHQ

VSRVyENRQLHF]QR üU]XWRZDQLDRUD]PR OLZR üSRSHáQLHQLDEá GyZ"5R]ZL ]DQLHPV

W\S\ SDUDPHWU\]RZDQH DQJ SDUDPHWUL]HG W\SHV ² NODV\ NWyUH NRPSLODWRU DXWRPD

W\F]QLHGRVWRVRZXMHGRSUDF\]SRGDQ\PLW\SDPLSDUDPHWUDPL1DSU]\NáDGSDUDPHWU\

]RZDQ\NRQWHQHUPR H]RVWDüSU]\VWRVRZDQ\WDNDE\DNFHSWRZDáW\ONRRELHNW\NODV\

(KIWTC

L]ZUDFDáWDN HW\ONR

(KIWT[

1LHGRW\F]\áRWRW\SyZHOHPHQWDUQ\FKPHFKDQL]PSDNRZDQLDZDUWR FLHOHPHQWDUQ\FKVNDODUQ\FK

ZRELHNWDFKDQJDXWRER[LQJZSURZDG]RQ\Z-DYLH6(Z\HOLPLQRZDáWRRJUDQLF]HQLHQLHPDO

FDáNRZLFLH:UyFLP\GRWHJRZGDOV]HMF] FLNVL NL

background image

5R]G]LDä

u

:SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

-HGQ ]ZD QLHMV]\FKQRZR FLZ-DYLH6(MHVWZáD QLHREHFQR üW\SyZSDUDPHWU\]R

ZDQ\FK]ZDQ\FKWH W\SDPLRJyOQ\PLDQJJHQHULFV3DUDPHWU\]DFM UR]SR]QDMHP\SR

REHFQR FLQDZLDVyZN WRZ\FKSU]\QD]ZLHNODV\]OLVW W\SyZSDUDPHWU\]XM F\FKGDQ

NODV 1DSU]\NáDGRELHNWNODVD

#TTC[.KUV

NODV\NRQWHQHUDZZHUVMLSU]\VWRVRZDQHMGR

SU]HFKRZ\ZDQLDRELHNWyZNODV\

(KIWTC

WZRU]\VL WDN

#TTC[.KUV(KIWTC HKIWT[PGY#TTC[.KUV(KIWTC

3DUDPHWU\]DFMDW\SyZVSRZRGRZDáDOLF]QH]PLDQ\ZLHOXNRPSRQHQWyZELEOLRWHNLVWDQ

GDUGRZHMM ]\ND-DYD-DNVL QLHEDZHPRND HGRVW SQR üW\SyZRJyOQ\FKZSá\QLHQD

ZL NV]R üNRGyZSU]\NáDGRZ\FKSUH]HQWRZDQ\FKZWHMNVL FH

7ZRU]HQLHRELHNWÑZLF]DVLFK \FLD

.D G\RELHNWDE\PyJáLVWQLHüZ\PDJD]DVREyZ²SU]HGHZV]\VWNLPSDPL FL.LHG\

RELHNWSU]HVWDMHE\üSRWU]HEQ\QDOH \SRQLPÄSRVSU] WDü´F]\OL]ZROQLüSU]\G]LHORQHPX

]DVRE\DE\PR QDMHE\áRSRZWyUQLHZ\NRU]\VWDü=D]Z\F]DMSUREOHPÄSRVSU] WDQLD´SR

RELHNFLHQLHZ\GDMHVL E\üV]F]HJyOQ\PZ\]ZDQLHP²RELHNWMHVWWZRU]RQ\VWRVRZDQ\

WDNGáXJRMDNMHVWSRWU]HEQ\DQDVW SQLHQDOH \JRXVXQ ü-HGQDNQLHWUXGQRVSRWNDüV\

WXDFMH]QDF]QLHEDUG]LHMVNRPSOLNRZDQH

=Dáy P\ H WZRU]\P\ V\VWHP REVáXJL UXFKX SRZLHWU]QHJR GOD ORWQLVND 7HJR VDPHJR

PRGHOXPR QDE\WDN HX \ZDüGR]DU] G]DQLDWRZDUDPLZPDJD]\QLHZV\VWHPLHZ\

SR \F]DQLD NDVHW ZLGHR OXE ILUPLH ]DMPXM FHM VL WUHVXU ]ZLHU] W 1D SLHUZV]\ U]XW

RND ]DGDQLH Z\GDMH VL SURVWH WU]HED VWZRU]\ü NRQWHQHU VáX F\ GR SU]HFKRZ\ZDQLD

VDPRORWyZDQDVW SQLHXPLH FLüZQLPND G\VDPRORW]QDMGXM F\VL ZNRQWURORZD

Q\PREV]DU]HSU]HVWU]HQLSRZLHWU]QHM:UDPDFKVSU] WQL FLDQDOH \XVXQ üRELHNWVD

PRORWXNWyU\RSX FLáNRQWURORZDQ\REV]DU

%\üPR HMHGQDNG\VSRQXMHP\LQQ\PV\VWHPHPGRUHMHVWUDFMLGDQ\FKRVDPRORWDFKE\ü

PR HQLHV WRGDQHZ\PDJDM FHWDNQDW\FKPLDVWRZHMXZDJLMDNJáyZQHIXQNFMHVWHUR

ZDQLDORWDPL%\üPR HMHVWWR]DSLVSODQXORWyZZV]\VWNLFKPDá\FKVDPRORWyZVWDUWX

M F\FK]ORWQLVND$]DWHPPDP\GUXJLNRQWHQHUGODPDá\FKVDPRORWyZL]DND G\PUD]HP

JG\WZRU]RQ\MHVWRELHNWVDPRORWXMH OLMHVWWRVDPRORWPDá\]DSLVXMHP\JRWDN HZW\P

GUXJLPNRQWHQHU]H1DVW SQLHSRGF]DVRNUHVyZEH]F]\QQR FLV\VWHPXMDNL SURFHVG]LD

áDM F\ZWOHZ\NRQXMHQDW\PNRQWHQHU]HSHZQHRSHUDFMH

7HUD]SUREOHPVL VNRPSOLNRZDáZMDNLVSRVyERNUH OLüNLHG\PR QDXVXQ üRELHNW"

*G\RELHNWQLHMHVWMX SRWU]HEQ\ZMHGQHMF] FLV\VWHPXLQQHZFL PRJ ]QLHJRNRU]\

VWDü7HQVDPSUREOHPPR HVL SRMDZLDüZZLHOXUy Q\FKV\WXDFMDFKDZV\VWHPDFK

SURJUDPLVW\F]Q\FKZ\PDJDM F\FKMDZQHJRXVXZDQLDRELHNWyZWDNLFKMDN&PR H

RQVWDüVL EDUG]R]áR RQ\

*G]LH]QDMGXM VL GDQHRELHNWXLMDNMHVWNRQWURORZDQ\F]DVMHJR \FLD"- ]\N&

SU]\MPXMH ]DáR HQLH H QDMZD QLHMV] VSUDZ MHVW NRQWUROD HIHNW\ZQR FL GODWHJR GDMH

SURJUDPL FLHZ\EyU:FHOXRVL JQL FLDPDNV\PDOQHMV]\ENR FLF]DVXZ\NRQDQLDPR H

RQRNUH OLüVSRVyZSU]HFKRZ\ZDQLDLF]DV \FLDRELHNWXQDHWDSLHSLVDQLDSURJUDPXSR

SU]H]XPLHV]F]HQLHJRQDVWRVLHPyZLVL ZWHG\F]DVDPLR]PLHQQ\FKDXWRPDW\F]Q\FK

background image

7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

DOERORNDOQ\FKDOERZREV]DU]HSDPL FLVWDW\F]QHM.áDG]LHVL ZWHQVSRVyEQDFLVNQD

V]\ENLHUH]HUZRZDQLHL]ZDOQLDQLHPLHMVFDSR ZL FDM FMHGQDN HHODVW\F]QR üSRQLHZD

PXVLP\]QDüGRNáDGQ OLF]E F]DV \FLDRUD]W\SRELHNWyZQDHWDSLHSLVDQLDSURJUDPX

-H HOLSUyEXMHP\UR]ZL ]DüEDUG]LHMRJyOQ\SUREOHPWDNLMDNNRPSXWHURZHZVSRPD

JDQLHSURMHNWRZDQLD]DU] G]DQLHPDJD]\QHPOXENRQWURODUXFKXSRZLHWU]QHJRZWHG\

VWDMHVL WR]E\WSRZD Q\PRJUDQLF]HQLHP

'UXJLH UR]ZL ]DQLH SROHJD QD G\QDPLF]Q\P WZRU]HQLX RELHNWyZ Z REV]DU]H SDPL FL

]ZDQ\PVWHUW 6WRVXM FWRUR]ZL ]DQLHQLHZLHP\D GRF]DVXZ\NRQDQLDLOXRELHNWyZ

SRWU]HEXMHP\MDNLPDE\üF]DVLFK \FLDRUD]GRNáDGQ\W\S.ZHVWLHWHV UR]VWU]\JDQH

Z RGSRZLHGQLP PRPHQFLH SRGF]DV G]LDáDQLD SURJUDPX -H HOL SRWU]HEXMHP\ QRZHJR

RELHNWXWZRU]\P\JRSRSURVWXQDVWHUFLH3RQLHZD SDPL üMHVW]DU] G]DQDG\QDPLF]QLH

ZF]DVLHZ\NRQDQLD]DWHPRNUHVQLH]E GQ\GRMHM]DUH]HUZRZDQLDQDVWHUFLHMHVWRZLHOH

GáX V]\QL WHQSRWU]HEQ\GR]URELHQLDWHJRVDPHJRQDVWRVLH]DUH]HUZRZDQLHPLHMVFD

QDVWRVLHZL HVL F] VWRMHG\QLH]SRMHG\QF] LQVWUXNFM DVHPEOHURZ GRSU]HVXQL FLD

ZVND QLNDVWRVXZGyáRUD]GUXJ GRSU]HVXQL FLDJR]SRZURWHPZJyU F]DVNRQLHF]Q\

GRXWZRU]HQLDPLHMVFDQDVWHUFLH]DOH \QDWRPLDVWRGNRQVWUXNFMLPHFKDQL]PXREVáXJL

SDPL FL&]DVG\QDPLF]QHJRSU]\G]LDáXZSDPL FLVWHUW\MHVW]D ]DOH Q\RGV]F]HJy

áyZPHFKDQL]PXREVáXJLSDPL FLZGDQ\PV\VWHPLH

5R]ZL ]DQLHG\QDPLF]QHED]XMHQDVáXV]Q\P]DáR HQLX HRELHNW\PRJ E\üVNRPSOL

NRZDQHD]DWHPQDU]XW]ZL ]DQ\]VDP\P]QDMGRZDQLHPL]ZDOQLDQLHPPLHMVFDQDWH

RELHNW\QLHE G]LHPLDáLVWRWQHJRZSá\ZXQDWZRU]HQLHRELHNWX3RQDGWR]ZL NV]RQDHOD

VW\F]QR üWHJRUR]ZL ]DQLDPDSRGVWDZRZH]QDF]HQLHGODUR]ZL ]\ZDQLDRJyOQ\FKSUR

EOHPyZSURJUDPLVW\F]Q\FK

-DYDVWRVXMHZ\á F]QLHGUXJLHUR]ZL ]DQLH

=DND G\PUD]HPJG\WZRU]\P\RELHNW

X \ZDP\VáRZDNOXF]RZHJR

PGY

DE\XWZRU]\üMHJRG\QDPLF]Q\HJ]HPSODU]

,QQ VSUDZ VWDQRZLF]DV \FLDRELHNWX:M ]\NDFKSR]ZDODM F\FKQDWZRU]HQLHRELHNWyZ

QDVWRVLHNRPSLODWRUZ\]QDF]DF]DVWUZDQLDRELHNWXLPR HJRDXWRPDW\F]QLH]QLV]F]\ü

-H HOLMHGQDNRELHNW]RVWDQLHVWZRU]RQ\QDVWHUFLHZWHG\NRPSLODWRUQLH]QDF]DVXMHJR

\FLD:M ]\NXWDNLPMDN&PXVLP\SURJUDPRZRRNUH OLüNLHG\QDOH \]QLV]F]\ü

RELHNWFRSURZDG]LGRZ\FLHNyZSDPL FLMH OLQLHURELVL WHJRSRSUDZQLHDMHVWWRF] VW\

SU]\SDGHNZSURJUDPDFK&-DYDSRVLDGDXGRJRGQLHQLH]ZDQHRG PLHFDF]HPSDPL FL

DXWRPDW\F]QLHZ\NU\ZDM F\PNWyU\RELHNWQLHMHVWMX X \ZDQ\DQDVW SQLHQLV]F] F\P

JR2G PLHFDF]DQJJDUEDJHFROOHFWRUMHVWUR]ZL ]DQLHP]QDF]QLHZ\JRGQLHMV]\PSR

QLHZD UHGXNXMHOLF]E ]GDU]H NWyUHPXVLP\ OHG]LüRUD]LOR üNRGXMDNLPXVLP\QD

SLVDü&RZD QLHMV]HVWDQRZLRQ]QDF]QLHZ\ V]\VWRSLH ]DEH]SLHF]HQLDSU]HGSUREOH

PHPZ\FLHNyZSDPL FLNWyU\]QLZHF]\áZLHOHSURMHNWyZZ&

:-DYLHSUREOHP]ZDOQLDQLDSDPL FL]RVWDáRGGHOHJRZDQ\GRVSHFMDOQLH]DSURMHNWRZD

QHJRRG PLHFDF]DSDPL FLFKRüQLHREHMPXMHRQSR]RVWDá\FKDVSHNWyZÄVSU] WDQLD´SR

RELHNWDFK2G PLHFDF]ÄZLH´NLHG\RELHNWQLHMHVWMX SRWU]HEQ\L]ZDOQLDSU]\G]LHORQ

PXSDPL ü']L NLWHPXRUD]]HZ]JO GXQDIDNW HZV]\VWNLHRELHNW\G]LHG]LF] SR

MHGQHMNODVLHED]RZHM²

1DLGEV

DZV]\VWNLHRELHNW\PR QDWZRU]\üW\ONRZMHGHQVSR

VyE ² QD VWHUFLH SURFHV SURJUDPRZDQLD Z -DYLH MHVW ]QDF]QLH SURVWV]\ QL Z &

0QLHMWXGHF\]MLGRSRGM FLDLSUREOHPyZGRUR]ZL ]DQLD

6SHFMDOQ\SU]\SDGHNVWDQRZL W\S\SRGVWDZRZHNWyUHSR]QDP\Sy QLHM

background image

5R]G]LDä

u

:SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

2EVäXJDZ\MñWNÑZ

vHOLPLQRZDQLHEäöGÑZ

2GSRF] WNyZLVWQLHQLDM ]\NyZSURJUDPRZDQLDREVáXJDEá GyZE\áDMHGQ\P]QDMWUXG

QLHMV]\FK]DGD =SRZRGXWUXGQR FLMDNLFKQDVWU F]D]DSURMHNWRZDQLHGREUHJRVFKHPDWX

WDNLHMREVáXJLZLHOHM ]\NyZSRSURVWXLJQRUXMHWR]DJDGQLHQLH]U]XFDM FRGSRZLHG]LDOQR ü

QDSURMHNWDQWyZELEOLRWHN3URSRQXM RQL]Z\NOHSyá URGNLG]LDáDM FHSRSUDZQLHZZLHOX

V\WXDFMDFKE G FHMHGQDNáDWZHGRREHM FLDQDMF] FLHMSRSURVWXSU]H]LFK]LJQRURZD

QLH3RGVWDZRZ\PSUREOHPHPZL NV]R FLVFKHPDWyZREVáXJLEá GyZMHVWWR HLFKSRG

VWDZ MHVWJRWRZR üSURJUDPLVW\GRSU]HVWU]HJDQLDSHZQHMXVWDORQHMNRQZHQFMLQLHREVáX

JLZDQHMZ DGHQVSRVyESU]H]M ]\N*G\SURJUDPLVWDQLHPDQDWRRFKRW\D]GDU]DVL WR

F] VWRQSJG\VL VSLHV]\PR H]áDWZR FL RNRQZHQFML]DSRPQLHü

0HFKDQL]PREVáXJLZ\M WNyZDQJH[FHSWLRQKDQGOLQJZL HEH]SR UHGQLRREVáXJ Eá

GyZ]M ]\NLHPSURJUDPRZDQLDDF]DVHPZU F]]V\VWHPHPRSHUDF\MQ\P:\M WHNMHVW

RELHNWHPNWyU\MHVWÄZ\U]XFDQ\´]PLHMVFDZ\VW SLHQLDEá GXDQDVW SQLHPR H]RVWDü

ÄSU]HFKZ\FRQ\´SU]H]RGSRZLHGQL SURFHGXU REVáXJLZ\M WNXDQJH[FHSWLRQKDQGOHU

²]DSURMHNWRZDQ VSHFMDOQLHGRUDG]HQLDVRELH]GDQ\PW\SHPEá GyZ2EVáXJDZ\M WNyZ

MHVWDOWHUQDW\ZQ FLH N SU]HSá\ZXVWHURZDQLDZ\ELHUDQ ZSU]\SDGNXJG\FR SyMG]LH

QLHWDN²G]L NLWHPXQLHPXVLVL PLHV]Dü]NRGHPZ\NRQ\ZDQ\PZQRUPDOQHMV\WXDFML

&]\QLWRWHQRVWDWQL]QDF]QLHSURVWV]\PGRQDSLVDQLDSRQLHZD QLHWU]HEDEH]SU]HUZ\

VSUDZG]DüF]\QLHZ\VW SLá\MDNLH Eá G\=JáDV]DQLHÄZ\U]XFDQLH´Z\M WNXUy QLVL RG

XVWDZLDQLD]QDF]QLNDEá GXF]\]ZUDFDQLDXVWDORQHMR]QDF]DM FHMEá GZDUWR FLWDN H

W\P HZSU]HFLZLH VWZLHGRQLFKQLHPR H]RVWDü]LJQRURZDQH²PDP\]DWHPJZD

UDQFM HZ\M WHN]RVWDQLHZSHZQ\PPRPHQFLHREVáX RQ\:\M WNLGRVWDUF]DM WDN H

JRGQ\]DXIDQLDVSRVyEZ\M FLD]H]áHMV\WXDFML=DPLDVWSRSURVWXSU]HUZDüG]LDáDQLH

SURJUDPXPR QDF] VWRSU]\ZUyFLüZDUXQNLGRMHJRGDOV]HJRZ\NRQ\ZDQLD²QDSLVDQH

ZWHQVSRVyESURJUDP\V ]QDF]QLHVROLGQLHMV]H

3RG Z]JO GHP REVáXJL Z\M WNyZ -DYD ]QDF] FR Uy QL VL RG LQQ\FK M ]\NyZ SURJUD

PRZDQLDJG\ PHFKDQL]P\WH]RVWDá\ZEXGRZDQHZM ]\NDSURJUDPL FLV ]PXV]HQL

GRNRU]\VWDQLD]QLFK-H OLWZRU]RQ\NRGQLHE G]LHZSRSUDZQ\VSRVyEREVáXJLZDü

Z\M WNyZSRGF]DVMHJRNRPSLODFMLSRMDZL VL Eá G\7DJZDUDQWRZDQDNRQVHNZHQFMD

F]DVDPLPR HXáDWZLüREVáXJ Eá GyZ

:DUWR]D]QDF]\ü HFKRüZM ]\NDFK]RULHQWRZDQ\FKRELHNWRZRZ\M WHNMHVW]Z\NOHUH

SUH]HQWRZDQ\SU]H]RELHNWWRMHGQDNVDPPHFKDQL]PREVáXJLZ\M WNyZQLHMHVWFHFK

SU]\QDOH Q MHG\QLHW\PM ]\NRP²SRZVWDáRGQLFKZF]H QLHM

:VSÑäELH QR è

-HGQ ]SRGVWDZRZ\FKNRQFHSFMLSURJUDPRZDQLDMHVWSRP\VáZ\NRQ\ZDQLDNLONX]D

GD ZW\PVDP\PF]DVLH/LF]QHSUREOHP\SURJUDPLVW\F]QHZ\PDJDM DE\SURJUDP

E\áZVWDQLHSU]HUZDüVZ ELH F DNW\ZQR ü]DáDWZLüMDN LQQ VSUDZ LSRZUyFLüGR

JáyZQHJR]DGDQLD3UyERZDQRZLHOXUR]ZL ]D 3RF] WNRZR SURJUDPL FL SRVLDGDM F\

background image

7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

QLVNRSR]LRPRZ ZLHG] QDWHPDWPDV]\Q\SLVDOLSURFHGXU\REVáXJLSU]HUZD D]DZLH

V]DQLHJáyZQHJRSURJUDPXE\áRLQLFMRZDQHSU]H]SU]HUZDQLDVSU] WRZH&KRüG]LDáDáRWR

]DGRZDODM FRE\áRMHGQDNVNRPSOLNRZDQHLQLHSU]HQR QHF]\QL FSURFHVSU]HQRV]HQLD

SURJUDPXQDQRZ\W\SPDV]\Q\SRZROQ\PLNRV]WRZQ\P

3U]HUZDQLDV F]DVDPLQLH]E GQHGODREVáXJL]DGD RNU\W\F]Q\FKRJUDQLF]HQLDFKF]D

VRZ\FKMHGQDN HZSU]\SDGNXGX HMNODV\SUREOHPyZFKRG]LQDPRSRG]LHOHQLH]DGDQLD

QDZ\NRQXM FHVL QLH]DOH QLHIUDJPHQW\G]L NLF]HPXSURJUDPMDNRFDáR üVWDMHVL EDU

G]LHM HIHNW\ZQ\ :HZQ WU] SURJUDPX WH QLH]DOH QLH Z\NRQXM FH VL IUDJPHQW\ QD]\

ZDP\Z WNDPLDFDáDLGHDQRVLQD]Z ZVSyáELH QR FLDQJFRQFXUUHQF\OXEZLHORZ W

NRZR FLDQJPXOWLWKUHDGLQJ7\SRZ\PSU]\NáDGHPZ\NRU]\VWDQLDZLHORZ WNRZR FL

MHVWLQWHUIHMVX \WNRZQLND']L NLZ WNRPX \WNRZQLNPR HRWU]\PDüV]\EN UHDNFM QD

QDFL QL FLHSU]\FLVNXQLHE G F]PXV]RQ\PGRRF]HNLZDQLDQD]DNR F]HQLHZ\NRQ\

ZDQLDSU]H]SURJUDPMHJRDNWXDOQHJR]DGDQLD

: WNLV ]Z\NOHMHG\QLHVSRVREHPSRG]LDáXF]DVXSRMHG\QF]HJRSURFHVRUD-H HOLMHGQDN

V\VWHPRSHUDF\MQ\REVáXJXMHZLHOHSURFHVRUyZZWHG\ND G\Z WHNPR H]RVWDüSU]\

G]LHORQ\LQQHPX]QLFKG]L NLF]HPXE G VL RQHZ\NRQ\ZDüU]HF]\ZL FLHUyZQROHJOH

-HGQ ]]DOHWZLHORZ WNRZR FLQDSR]LRPLHM ]\NDMHVWWR HSURJUDPLVWDQLHPXVLLQWH

UHVRZDüVL F]\PDGRG\VSR]\FMLZLHOHSURFHVRUyZF]\WH W\ONRMHGHQ3URJUDPMHVW

ORJLF]QLHSRG]LHORQ\QDZ WNLLMH HOLPDV]\QDSRVLDGDZLHOHSURFHVRUyZZWHG\G]LDáD

V]\EFLHMEH] DGQ\FKSRSUDZHN

3RZ\ V]HVWZLHUG]HQLDPRJ VXJHURZDü HZLHORZ WNRZR üMHVWSURVW\P]DJDGQLHQLHP

-HVWMHGQDNSHZQDSXáDSND²]DVRE\ZVSyOQH-H HOLZL FHMQL MHGHQZ WHNPD]DPLDU

RGZRá\ZDüVL GRWHJRVDPHJR]DVREXZWHG\SRZVWDMHSUREOHP1DSU]\NáDGGZDSURFHV\

QLHPRJ UyZQRF]H QLHZ\V\áDüLQIRUPDFMLQDGUXNDUN :FHOXUR]ZL ]DQLDWHJRSUREOHPX

]DVRE\NWyUHPRJ WDNMDNGUXNDUNDE\üG]LHORQHPXV] E\üEORNRZDQHQDF]DVX \FLD

$]DWHPZ WHNEORNXMH]DVyEZ\NRQXMHVZRMH]DGDQLHSRF]\P]ZDOQLDEORNDG DE\

XPR OLZLüLQQ\PZ WNRPVNRU]\VWDQLH]]DVREX

:LHORZ WNRZR ü MHVW Z -DYLH F] FL M ]\ND Z -DYD 6( GRF]HNDáD VL WH LVWRWQHJR

ZVSDUFLDELEOLRWHF]QHJR

-DYDL,QWHUQHW

-H OLWDNQDSUDZG -DYDMHVWMHV]F]HMHGQ\PM ]\NLHPSURJUDPRZDQLDPR QD]DS\WDü

F]HPXZREHFWHJRMHVWWDNZD QDLGODF]HJRMHVWRNUH ODQDMDNRUHZROXF\MQ\NURNZSUR

JUDPRZDQLX"=SXQNWXZLG]HQLDWUDG\F\MQHJRSURJUDPRZDQLDRGSRZLHG QLHMHVWRGUD]X

RF]\ZLVWD -DYD MHVW EDUG]R X \WHF]QD SU]\ UR]ZL ]\ZDQLX WUDG\F\MQ\FK SUREOHPyZ SUR

JUDPLVW\F]Q\FKLUR]ZL ]XMHUyZQLH SUREOHP\SURJUDPRZDQLDGODVLHFL:RUOG:LGH:HE

&]\PMHVWVLHè:::"

3RF] WNRZRVLHü:::PR HVL Z\GDZDüWDMHPQLF]DUD]HP]W\PLZV]\VWNLPLVXU

IRZDQLDPLSUH]HQWDFMDPLLVWURQDPLGRPRZ\PL0R HZDUWRSU]\MU]HüVL ]ERNXWHPX

F]\PWDNQDSUDZG MHVW:::"-HGQDNDE\WR]URELüQDOH \]UR]XPLHüPRGHOV\VWHPyZ

W\SXNOLHQWVHUZHU²NROHMQ\SHáHQQLHSRUR]XPLH DVSHNWLQIRUPDW\NL

background image

5R]G]LDä

u

:SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

3U]HWZDU]DQLHW\SXNOLHQWVHUZHU

3RGVWDZ V\VWHPXNOLHQWVHUZHUMHVW]DáR HQLH HPDP\FHQWUDOQHUHSR]\WRULXPLQIRUPDFML

MDNLHJR URG]DMXGDQ\FKF] VWR]DSLVDQ\FKZED]LHGDQ\FKNWyUHFKFHP\UR]V\áDüQD

GDQLHGRSHZQHMJUXS\OXG]LOXEPDV]\Q.OXF]HPPRGHOXNOLHQWVHUZHUMHVWFHQWUDOQH

SRáR HQLHVNáDGQLF\LQIRUPDFML-H OLLQIRUPDFMH]RVWDQ ]PLHQLRQHZV]\VWNLH]PLDQ\

]RVWDQ SU]HND]DQHLFKRGELRUFRP&DáR üVNáDGQLFDLQIRUPDFMLRSURJUDPRZDQLHUR]

V\áDM FHLQIRUPDFMHRUD]PDV]\QDQDNWyUHM]QDMGXMHVL LQIRUPDFMDLMHMRSURJUDPRZDQLH

QD]\ZDQHMHVWVHUZHUHP.OLHQWHPQD]\ZDVL RSURJUDPRZDQLH]QDMGXM FHVL QDPDV]\QLH

]GDOQHMNWyUHNRPXQLNXMHVL ]VHUZHUHPSRELHUDLQIRUPDFMHSU]HWZDU]DMHLZ\ ZLHWOD

QDWHMPDV]\QLH

3RGVWDZRZDLGHDSU]HWZDU]DQLDW\SXNOLHQWVHUZHUQLHMHVWVSHFMDOQLHVNRPSOLNRZDQD

3UREOHP\Z\QLNDM ]WHJR HPDP\MHGHQVHUZHUSUyEXM F\MHGQRF]H QLHREVáX \üZLHOH

NOLHQWyZ2JyOQLHSURMHNWDQWZ\NRU]\VWXM FV\VWHP\]DU] G]DQLDED]DPLGDQ\FKVWDUD

VL UyZQRPLHUQLHUR]PLH FLüGDQHZWDEHODFKDE\RVL JQ üMDNQDMZL NV] X \WHF]QR ü

V\VWHPX'RGDWNRZRV\VWHP\F] VWRSR]ZDODM NOLHQWRPQDZSURZDG]DQLHQRZ\FKLQ

IRUPDFMLGRVHUZHUD2]QDF]DWR HWU]HEDSLOQRZDüDE\QRZHGDQHMHGQHJRNOLHQWDQLH

]DPD]Dá\QRZ\FKGDQ\FKLQQHJROXE HE\GDQHQLH]DJLQ á\ZSURFHVLHGRGDZDQLDLFK

GRED]\QD]\ZDVL WRSU]HWZDU]DQLHPWUDQVDNF\MQ\P.LHG\RSURJUDPRZDQLHNOLHQWD

VL ]PLHQLDPXVLE\üNRPSLORZDQHWHVWRZDQHLLQVWDORZDQHQDPDV]\QDFKNOLHQWyZ

FRRND]XMHVL EDUG]LHMVNRPSOLNRZDQHLNRV]WRZQHQL PRJáRE\VL Z\GDZDü:LHOX

SUREOHPyZSU]\VSDU]DREVáXJDUy Q\FKW\SyZNRPSXWHUyZLV\VWHPyZRSHUDF\MQ\FK

1DGRGDWHNDNWXDOQ\SR]RVWDMHSUREOHPZ\GDMQR FLZND GHMFKZLOLPRJ SRWHQFMDOQLH

LVWQLHüVHWNL GD VNLHURZDQ\FKSU]H]NOLHQWyZGRVHUZHUDD]DWHPND GHRSy QLHQLH

MHVWNU\W\F]QH$E\RJUDQLF]\üWHRSy QLHQLDSURJUDPL FLFL NRSUDFXM QDGW\PDE\

SU]HQLH üSU]HWZDU]DQH]DGDQLDQDPDV]\Q NOLHQWDDF]DVHPQDLQQHPDV]\Q\SRVWUR

QLHVHUZHUDVNáDGDM FHVL QDWDN]ZDQ ZDUVWZ SR UHGQL DQJPLGGOHZDUH:DUVWZD

SR UHGQLDSRSUDZLDUyZQLH PR OLZR üNRQVHUZDFMLV\VWHPX

3URVWDLGHDUR]V\áDQLDOXG]LRPLQIRUPDFMLPDWDNZLHOHSR]LRPyZ]áR RQR FL HFDá\SUR

EOHPPR HVL Z\GDZDüEDUG]R]DJPDWZDQ\-HGQRF]H QLHMHVWEDUG]RZD Q\SU]HWZD

U]DQLHW\SXNOLHQWVHUZHUVWDQRZLSRáRZ ZV]\VWNLFKSU]HGVL Z]L üSURJUDPLVW\F]Q\FK

2GSRZLDGD]DZV]\VWNRSRF] ZV]\RGSU]\MPRZDQLD]DPyZLH LWUDQVDNFMLSU]\X \

FLXNDUWNUHG\WRZ\FKVNR F]\ZV]\QDUR]SRZV]HFKQLDQLXGRZROQHJRW\SXGDQ\FK²

JLHáGRZ\FK QDXNRZ\FK U] GRZ\FK : SU]HV]áR FL SRMDZLDá\ VL W\ONR LQG\ZLGXDOQH

UR]ZL ]DQLDGODLQG\ZLGXDOQ\FKSUREOHPyZ²]DND G\PUD]HPZ\QDMG\ZDQRQRZH

%\á\RQHWUXGQHGRWZRU]HQLDLX \ZDQLDL]DND G\PUD]HPX \WNRZQLNPXVLDáVL QD

XF]\üREVáXJLQRZHJRLQWHUIHMVX3UREOHPNOLHQWVHUZHUZ\PDJDUR]ZL ]D QDGX VNDO

6LHè:::MDNRJLJDQW\F]Q\VHUZHU

6LHü:::MHVWZáD FLZLHJLJDQW\F]Q\PV\VWHPHPW\SXNOLHQWVHUZHU1DZHWZL FHM

²SRQLHZD ZV]\VWNLHVHUZHU\LNOLHQW\ZVSyáLVWQLHM MHGQRF]H QLHZWHMVDPHMVLHFL

1LHWU]HEDRW\PZLHG]LHüJG\ ZV]\VWNRRFRWU]HEDVL ]DWURV]F]\üZGDQ\PPRPHQFLH

WRSRá F]HQLHLLQWHUDNFMD]MHGQ\PW\ONRVHUZHUHPDOHDE\JR]QDOH üPR QDSU]HV]XNDü

Syá ZLDWD

background image

7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

3RF] WNRZRE\áWRSURVW\SURFHVMHGQRNLHUXQNRZ\1D GDQLHSU]HVáDQHGRVHUZHUDSU]H

ND]\ZDáRQ]SRZURWHPSOLNNWyU\E\áLQWHUSUHWRZDQ\LIRUPDWRZDQ\SU]H]SU]HJO GDUN

QDPDV]\QLHORNDOQHMNOLHQWD:NUyWFHOXG]LH]DF] OL GDüF]HJR ZL FHMQL W\ONRGR

VWDUF]DQLD VWURQ ] VHUZHUD &KFLHOL SHáQ\FK PR OLZR FL NOLHQWVHUZHU WDN DE\ NOLHQW

PyJáRGV\áDüLQIRUPDFMHGRVHUZHUDQDSU]\NáDG]D GDüNRQNUHWQ\FKGDQ\FK]VHUZHUD

GRGDüQRZHLQIRUPDFMHOXE]áR \ü]DPyZLHQLHFRZ\PDJDáRZL NV]\FK]DEH]SLHF]H

QL WHRIHURZDQHSU]H]RU\JLQDOQ\V\VWHP6 WR]PLDQ\MDNLH]DV]á\ZUR]ZRMX:::

3U]HJO GDUND:::²DZáD FLZLHVDPSRP\Vá HWDVDPDLQIRUPDFMDPR HE\üZ\

ZLHWORQDQDNRPSXWHU]HGRZROQHJRW\SXEH]]PLHQLDQLDMHM²E\áDZLHONLPNURNLHP

QDSU]yG -HGQDN H SU]HJO GDUNL E\á\ QDGDO SU\PLW\ZQH L QLH VSHáQLDá\ VWDZLDQ\FK LP

GD :V]F]HJyOQR FLQLHE\á\LQWHUDNW\ZQHLPLDá\VNáRQQR üGREORNRZDQLD]DUyZQR

VHUZHUyZMDNL,QWHUQHWXERZLHP]DND G\PUD]HPNLHG\NRQLHF]QHE\áRZ\NRQDQLH

F]HJR FRZ\PDJDáRSU]HWZDU]DQLDWU]HEDE\áRZ\VáDüLQIRUPDFM ]SRZURWHPGRVHUZHUD

DE\GRSLHURWDP]RVWDáDSU]HWZRU]RQD0RJáRXSá\Q üZLHOHVHNXQGOXEPLQXWQLPRND

]DáRVL H GDQLHE\áREá GQLHVIRUPXáRZDQH3U]HJO GDUNDVáX \áDMHG\QLHGRRJO GDQLD

ZL FQLHPRJáDZ\NRQ\ZDüQDZHWQDMSURVWV]\FK]DGD REOLF]HQLRZ\FK]GUXJLHMVWURQ\

E\áDEH]SLHF]QDSRQLHZD QLHPRJáDQDORNDOQHMPDV]\QLHZ\NRQ\ZDü DGQ\FKSUR

JUDPyZNWyUHPRJá\E\]DZLHUDüEá G\OXEZLUXV\

$E\UR]ZL ]DüWHQSUREOHPSU]\M WRNLONDUR]ZL ]D 1DSRF] WHNVWDQGDUG\JUDILF]QH

SRV]HU]RQRWDNE\XPR OLZLüOHSV] DQLPDFM REUD]XZSU]HJO GDUNDFK5R]ZL ]DQLHP

SR]RVWDá\FKSUREOHPyZMHVWXPR OLZLHQLHSU]HJO GDUFHXUXFKDPLDQLDSURJUDPyZSRVWUR

QLHNOLHQWD1D]\ZDP\WRSURJUDPRZDQLHPSRVWURQLHNOLHQWD

3URJUDPRZDQLHSRVWURQLHNOLHQWD

3LHUZRWQ\ SURMHNW DUFKLWHNWXU\ VLHFLRZHM W\SX VHUZHUSU]HJO GDUND ]DSHZQLDá LQWHUDN

W\ZQ ]DZDUWR üDOHE\áDRQDZFDáR FLGRVWDUF]DQDSU]H]VHUZHU6HUZHUSURGXNRZDá

VWDW\F]QHVWURQ\GODSU]HJO GDUNLNOLHQWDNWyUDMHSRSURVWXLQWHUSUHWRZDáDLZ\ ZLHWODáD

3RGVWDZRZ\+70/]DZLHUDSURVWHPHFKDQL]P\SRELHUDQLDGDQ\FKSRODWHNVWRZH SROD

Z\ERUXSRODZLHORNURWQHJRZ\ERUXOLVW\LOLVW\UR]ZLMDQHRUD]SU]\FLVNLNWyUHPR QD

]DSURJUDPRZDüW\ONRGRZ\F]\V]F]HQLDIRUPXODU]DOXEZ\VáDQLDDQJVXEPLWGDQ\FK

IRUPXODU]D]SRZURWHPGRVHUZHUD7R GDQLHSU]HFKRG]LSU]H]&RPPRQ*DWHZD\,QWHU

IDFHXQLZHUVDOQ\LQWHUIHMVNRPXQLNDF\MQ\ZVNUyFLH&*,GRVWDUF]DQ\SU]H]ZV]\VWNLH

VHUZHU\:::7HNVWZHZQ WU] GDQLDPyZL&*,FRQDOH \]QLP]URELü1DMF] VWV]\P

G]LDáDQLHPMHVWZ\NRQDQLHSURJUDPX]QDMGXM FHJRVL QDVHUZHU]HZNDWDORJXQD]\ZD

Q\P]Z\NOHFJLELQREVHUZXM FRNLHQNRDGUHVXQDJyU]HSU]HJO GDUNLNLHG\QDFLVNDV]

SU]\FLVNQDVWURQLHVLHFLRZHMPR HV]F]DVHP]REDF]\üFJLELQSRPL G]\LQQ\PL]QDMGX

M F\PLVL WDP PLHFLDPL3URJUDP\WHPRJ E\üSLVDQHZZL NV]R FLM ]\NyZ1DMF]

FLHMZ\ELHUDQ\MHVW3HUOSRQLHZD MHVWSU]H]QDF]RQ\GRPDQLSXORZDQLDWHNVWHPDSUR

JUDP\ZQLPQDSLVDQHV Z\NRQ\ZDQHSU]H]LQWHUSUHWHUZL FPR HE\üLQVWDORZDQ\QD

GRZROQ\FKVHUZHUDFKQLH]DOH QLHRGSURFHVRUDLV\VWHPXRSHUDF\MQHJR&RUD]ZL NV]

SRSXODUQR ü]GRE\ZDMHGQDN3\WKRQPyMXOXELRQ\²SDWU]ZZZ3\WKRQRUJJáyZQLH

]HZ]JO GXQDVZRMHRJURPQHPR OLZR FLLSURVWRW

2EHFQLHZLHOHGX \FKZLWU\QLQWHUQHWRZ\FK]EXGRZDQRZ\á F]QLH]Z\NRU]\VWDQLHP

&*,]DSRPRF NWyUHJRPR QD]URELüSUDNW\F]QLHZV]\VWNR-HGQDN HXWU]\PDQLHZL

WU\Q ]EXGRZDQ\FK QD SURJUDPDFK &*, PR H V]\ENR VWDü VL EDUG]R VNRPSOLNRZDQH

background image

5R]G]LDä

u

:SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

3UREOHPHPMHVWUyZQLH GáXJLF]DVUHDNFML2GSRZLHG SURJUDPX&*,]DOH \RGOLF]E\

GDQ\FKNWyUHPXV] ]RVWDüSU]HVáDQHRUD]RGREFL HQLDVHUZHUDL,QWHUQHWXSR]DW\P

XUXFKDPLDQLH SURJUDPX &*, MHVW QD RJyá ZROQH 3LHUZVL SURMHNWDQFL ,QWHUQHWX QLH

SU]HZLG]LHOL HMHJRSU]HSXVWRZR ü]RVWDQLHWDNJZDáWRZQLHZ\F]HUSDQDSU]H]Uy QR

URGQH DSOLNDFMH 3U]\NáDGRZRQLHGDVL ]UHDOL]RZDüSURFHVXG\QDPLF]QHJRWZRU]HQLD

JUDILNLSRQLHZD SOLN*,)*UDSKLFV,QWHUFKDQJH)RUPDWPXVL]RVWDüVWZRU]RQ\LSU]H

VáDQ\RGVHUZHUDGRNOLHQWDGODND GHMZHUVMLREUD]X.D G\EH]Z WSLHQLDPLDáEH]SR

UHGQLNRQWDNW]F]\P WDNSURVW\PMDNVSUDZG]HQLHGDQ\FKZIRUPXODU]X3RQDFL

QL FLXSU]\FLVNXÄ=DWZLHUG ´GDQHV SU]HV\áDQH]SRZURWHPGRVHUZHUD6HUZHUXUXFKDPLD

SURJUDP&*,NWyU\Z\NU\ZDEá GIRUPXáXMHVWURQ +70/LQIRUPXM F REá G]LHDQD

VW SQLHRGV\áDM ]SRZURWHP7U]HEDZWHG\FRIQ üVL GRSRSU]HGQLHMVWURQ\LVSUyERZDü

SRQRZQLH-HVWWRQLHW\ONRZROQHDOHLQLHHOHJDQFNLH

5R]ZL ]DQLHPMHVWSURJUDPRZDQLHSRVWURQLHNOLHQWD:L NV]R üNRPSXWHUyZQDNWyU\FK

SUDFXM SU]HJO GDUNLWRSRW QHPDV]\Q\E G FHZVWDQLHZ\NRQDüRJURPQ LOR üRE

OLF]H DSU]\SLHUZRWQ\PVSRVRELHSUDF\VWDW\F]QHJR+70/DF]HNDM FHEH]F]\QQLH

D VHUZHUSRGDLPQDVW SQ VWURQ 3URJUDPRZDQLHSRVWURQLHNOLHQWDVSUDZLD HSU]HJO

GDUND:::]RVWDMH]DSU] JQL WDGRSUDF\DGODX \WNRZQLNDR]QDF]DWRRZLHOHERJDWV]H

LQWHUDNW\ZQHSU]H \FLDSRGF]DVNRU]\VWDQLD]WDNLHMZLWU\Q\

3U]\RPDZLDQLXSURJUDPRZDQLDSRVWURQLHNOLHQWDSUREOHPHPMHVWWR HQLHUy QLVL RQR

MDNR V]F]HJyOQLHRGSURJUDPRZDQLDZRJyOH3DUDPHWU\V QLHPDO HWDNLHVDPHDOHLQQD

MHVWSODWIRUPDSU]HJO GDUNDLQWHUQHWRZDMHVWMDNRJUDQLF]RQ\V\VWHPRSHUDF\MQ\:NR FX

QDGDOWU]HEDSURJUDPRZDüDWRZL HVL ]]DZURWQ OLF]E SUREOHPyZLUR]ZL ]D VWZD

U]DQ\FKSU]H]SURJUDPRZDQLHSRVWURQLHNOLHQWD5HV]WDWHJRSRGUR]G]LDáXSU]HGVWDZLD

SU]HJO GNZHVWLL]ZL ]DQ\FK]SURJUDPRZDQLHPSRVWURQLHNOLHQWD

0RGXä\UR]V]HU]DMñFH

-HGQ\P]EDUG]LHM]QDF] F\FKNURNyZZNLHUXQNXSURJUDPRZDQLDSRVWURQLHNOLHQWDMHVW

VWZRU]HQLHPRGXáyZUR]V]HU]DM F\FKDQJSOXJLQ-HVWWRVSRVyEZMDNLSURJUDPPR H

GRGDüQRZHIXQNFMHGRSU]HJO GDUNLSU]H] FL JQL FLHNDZDáNDNRGXNWyU\MHVWGRá F]DQ\

ZRGSRZLHGQLHPLHMVFHSU]HJO GDUNL0yZLRQSU]HJO GDUFHÄRGWHMSRU\PR HV]Z\

NRQ\ZDüWDNLHDWDNLHQRZHF]\QQR FL´PRGXáUR]V]HU]DM F\áDGXMHVL MHGQRUD]RZR

']L NLUR]V]HU]HQLRPSU]HJO GDUND]RVWDMHZ]ERJDFRQDRSRW QHPR OLZR FLMHGQDN

SLVDQLHLFKQLHMHVW]DGDQLHPWU\ZLDOQ\PL]DSHZQHQLNWQLHFKFLDáE\WHJRURELüZSURFH

VLHEXGRZDQLDNRQNUHWQHMVWURQ\0RGXá\UR]V]HU]DM FHPDM GX ZDUWR üGODSURJUD

PRZDQLDNOLHQWVHUZHUSRQLHZD SR]ZDODM GR ZLDGF]RQHPXSURJUDPL FLHQDVWZRU]HQLH

QRZHJRM ]\NDSURJUDPRZDQLDLGRGDQLHJRGRSU]HJO GDUNLEH]NRQLHF]QR FLX]\VNDQLD

]JRG\MHMWZyUF\=DWHPUR]V]HU]HQLDGRVWDUF]DM GRGDWNRZHPHWRG\WZRU]HQLDQRZ\FK

M ]\NyZSURJUDPRZDQLDSRVWURQLHNOLHQWDMHGQDNQLHZV]\VWNLHM ]\NLV LPSOHPHQWR

ZDQHMDNRPRGXá\UR]V]HU]DM FH

-ö]\NLVNU\SWRZH

:SURZDG]HQLHPRGXáyZUR]V]HU]DM F\FK]DRZRFRZDáRHNVSOR]M M ]\NyZVNU\SWRZ\FK

.RG UyGáRZ\SURJUDPXQDSLVDQHJRZM ]\NXVNU\SWRZ\PLG]LDáDM FHJRSRVWURQLHNOLHQWD

MHVWRVDG]RQ\ZHZQ WU]VWURQ\+70/0RGXáLQWHUSUHWXM F\WHQNRGMHVWDXWRPDW\F]QLH

DNW\ZRZDQ\ZPRPHQFLHZ\ ZLHWODQLDWDNLHMVWURQ\- ]\NLVNU\SWRZHV QDRJyááDWZH

background image

7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

GR]UR]XPLHQLDLMDNRWHNVWV F] FL NRGX+70/3URJUDPZWDNLPM ]\NXMHVWWHN

VWHPVWDQRZL F\PIUDJPHQWVWURQ\+70/GODWHJRáDGXMHVL ]VHUZHUDMDNRF] üWHJRVD

PHJR GDQLDNWyUHZ\ ZLHWODVWURQ :DG WHJRUR]ZL ]DQLDMHVWWR HNRG UyGáRZ\SUR

JUDPXPR HE\üSU]HJO GDQ\RUD]VNUDG]LRQ\SU]H]ND GHJR-HGQDNQLHZ\GDMHVL WRE\ü

]E\WZ\VRN FHQ SRQLHZD ZM ]\NDFKVNU\SWRZ\FKQLHUHDOL]XMHP\Z\V]XNDQ\FK]DGD

-HVWWDNLM ]\NVNU\SWRZ\NWyUHJRREVáXJLLWREH]GRGDWNRZ\FKPRGXáyZUR]V]HU]DM

F\FKPR QDRF]HNLZDüRGZL NV]R FLQRZRF]HVQ\FKSU]HJO GDUHN:::WR-DYD6FULSW

NWyU\QLHPDQLFZVSyOQHJR]-DY ²]RVWDáWDNQD]ZDQ\ HE\VL Ä]DáDSDü´QDWURFK

PDUNHWLQJRZHJRS GX]ZL ]DQHJR]-DY 1LHVWHW\ZHUVMHM ]\ND]DLPSOHPHQWRZDQH

ZUy Q\FKSU]HJO GDUNDFKPRJ VL ]QDF]QLHRGVLHELHUy QLü6\WXDFM SRSUDZLáDQLHFR

VWDQGDU\]DFMDM ]\ND-DYD6FULSWZSRVWDFL(&0$6FULSWDOH]NROHLSRZV]HFKQHZGUR H

QLHWHJRVWDQGDUGXZOHF]HVL QLHPLáRVLHUQLHPDZW\PVZyMXG]LDáILUPD0LFURVRIWIRU

VXM FDVZyMM ]\NVNU\SWRZ\9%6FULSWZLHOFH]UHV]W SRGREQ\GR-DYD6FULSW=DVDGQLF]R

QDOH DáRE\ SU]\ SURJUDPRZDQLX SR VWURQLH NOLHQWD RJUDQLF]\ü VL GR QDMPQLHMV]HJR

ZVSyOQHJR PLDQRZQLND Uy Q\FK LPSOHPHQWDFML -DYD6FULSW ² W\ONR ZWHG\ PR QD PLHü

QDG]LHM EH]SUREOHPRZHJRG]LDáDQLDNRGXZUy Q\FKSU]HJO GDUNDFK'LDJQRVW\N LZ\

FKZ\W\ZDQLHEá GyZZNRG]LH-DYD6FULSWPR QDRSLVDüMHG\QLHMDNRXGU N 'RZRGHP

VWRSQLD]áR RQR FLSUREOHPXMHVWFKRüE\WR HGRSLHURQLHGDZQRSRZVWDáSLHUZV]\QD

SUDZG UR]EXGRZDQ\SURMHNW]X \FLHP-DYD6FULSW²PRZDR*RRJOH*0DLO

:LGDü]WHJR HM ]\NLVNU\SWRZHX \ZDQHZHZQ WU]SU]HJO GDUHN:::V SU]H]QDF]R

QHGRUR]ZL ]\ZDQLDVSHF\ILF]QHJRW\SXSUREOHPyZJáyZQLHGRWZRU]HQLDERJDWV]\FK

L EDUG]LHM DWUDNF\MQ\FK JUDILF]Q\FK LQWHUIHMVyZ X \WNRZQLND DQJ JUDSKLFDO XVHU LQ

WHUIDFHZVNUyFLH*8,- ]\NLVNU\SWRZHPRJ UR]ZL ]DüSURFHQWSUREOHPyZQDSR

W\NDQ\FKSU]\SURJUDPRZDQLXSRVWURQLHNOLHQWD5yZQLH 7ZyMSUREOHPPR HZFDáR FL

PLH FLüVL ZW\FKSURFHQWDFKDSRQLHZD M ]\NLVNU\SWRZHSR]ZDODM QDáDWZLHMV]

LV]\EV] SURGXNFM VWURQ:::SRZLQLHQH UR]ZD \üLFKX \FLH]DQLP]ZUyFLV]VL

NXEDUG]LHM]áR RQ\PUR]ZL ]DQLRPMDNSURJUDPRZDQLHZM ]\NX-DYD

-DYD

-H OLM ]\NLVNU\SWRZHPRJ UR]ZL ]DüSURFHQWSUREOHPyZSURJUDPRZDQLDNOLHQW

VHUZHUFR]SR]RVWDá\PLSURFHQWDPL²W\PLQDSUDZG WUXGQ\PL"2EHFQLHQDMSR

SXODUQLHMV]\PUR]ZL ]DQLHPMHVW-DYD-HVWWRQLHW\ONRSRW Q\M ]\NSURJUDPRZDQLD

VWZRU]RQ\MDNREH]SLHF]Q\SU]HQR Q\LPL G]\QDURGRZ\-DYDMHVWFL JOHUR]V]HU]DQD

E\GRVWDUF]DüQRZHUR]ZL ]DQLDNWyUHREVáXJXM SUREOHP\X]QDZDQH]DWUXGQHZWUD

G\F\MQ\FKM ]\NDFKWDNLHMDNZLHORZ WNRZR üGRVW SGRED]GDQ\FKSURJUDPRZDQLH

VLHFLRZHF]\SU]HWZDU]DQLHUR]SURV]RQH-DYDXPR OLZLDSURJUDPRZDQLHSRVWURQLHNOLHQWD

SRSU]H]DSOHW\RUD]WHFKQRORJL -DYD:HE6WDUW

$SOHWMHVWPLQLSURJUDPHPNWyU\G]LDáDZ\á F]QLHSRGNRQWURO SU]HJO GDUNL-HVWRQáD

GRZDQ\DXWRPDW\F]QLHMDNRHOHPHQWVWURQ\:::WDNVDPRMDNREUD]HN.LHG\DSOHW

]RVWDQLHDNW\ZRZDQ\Z\NRQDVZyMSURJUDP-HVWWRMHJRGX \SOXV²]DSHZQLDPHWRG

DXWRPDW\F]QHJRUR]SRZV]HFKQLDQLDRSURJUDPRZDQLDNOLHQWD]VHUZHUDZPRPHQFLHNLHG\

X \WNRZQLNJRSRWU]HEXMHDQLHZF]H QLHM8 \WNRZQLNRWU]\PXMHQDMQRZV] ZHUVM

RSURJUDPRZDQLDNOLHQWDEH]ERU\NDQLDVL ]WUXGQR FLDPLSRQRZQHMLQVWDODFML-DYD]R

VWDáD]DSURMHNWRZDQDZWDNLVSRVyE HSURJUDPLVWDWZRU]\W\ONRMHGHQSURJUDPNWyU\

DXWRPDW\F]QLHE G]LHG]LDáDáQDZV]\VWNLFKNRPSXWHUDFKZ\SRVD RQ\FKZSU]HJO GDUNL

background image

5R]G]LDä

u

:SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

]ZEXGRZDQ\PLQWHUSUHWHUHP-DY\PR QDGRQLFK]DOLF]\üZL NV]R üPDV]\Q3RQLH

ZD -DYDMHVWZSHáQLUR]ZLQL W\PM ]\NLHPSURJUDPRZDQLDPR QDZL FREDUF]\üNOLHQWD

GX LOR FL SUDF\]DUyZQRSU]HGMDNLSRZ\VáDQLX GDQLDGRVHUZHUD1DSU]\NáDGQLH

WU]HEDZ\V\áDü GDQLDDE\RGNU\ü H OHSRGDáH GDW OXELQQ\SDUDPHWUDVDPNOLHQW

PR HV]\ENRZ\NRQDüFDá SUDF ]ZL ]DQ ]HVSRU] G]HQLHPZ\NUHVX]DPLDVWF]HNDü

D VHUZHUSU]\JRWXMHZ\NUHVLZ\ OHJRWRZ\REUD]HN2WU]\PXMHV]QDW\FKPLDVWRZ\Z]URVW

SU GNR FLG]LDáDQLDDRJyOQ\UXFKVLHFLLREFL HQLHVHUZHUyZPRJ ]RVWDü]UHGXNRZDQH

SU]\VSLHV]DM FW\PVDP\PG]LDáDQLHFDáHJR,QWHUQHWX

$OWHUQDW\Z\

*ZROL V]F]HUR FL DSOHW\ -DY\ QLH VSHáQLá\ GR NR FD SRNáDGDQ\FK Z QLFK SLHUZRWQLH

RF]HNLZD .LHG\-DYDXMU]DáD ZLDWáRG]LHQQHZV]\VF\IDVF\QRZDOLVL ZáD QLHDSOH

WDPLMDNRZ\F]HNLZDQ\PLQDU] G]LDPLSURJUDPRZDQLDSRVWURQLHNOLHQWDDZL F]ZL N

V]DQLHPUHDNW\ZQR FLL]PQLHMV]HQLHPZ\PDJD FRGRV]\ENR FLNDQDáXWUDQVPLV\MQHJR

ZDSOLNDFMDFKLQWHUQHWRZ\FK$SOHWRPSURURNRZDQRZLHON NDULHU

:U]HF]\VDPHMZVLHFL:::ZLGXMHVL ZLHOFH]P\ OQHDSOHW\DOHQLJG\QLHGRV]áR

GRSUDZG]LZHMPLJUDFMLGRWHMWHFKQRORJLL1DMZL NV]\PSUREOHPHPE\áDQDMSUDZGRSRGRE

QLHMQLHFK üSU]HFL WQ\FKX \WNRZQLNyZGR FL JDQLDLLQVWDORZDQLD URGRZLVNDZ\NR

QDZF]HJR-DY\-5(RG-DYD5XQWLPH(QYLURQPHQWZSRVWDFLPHJDEDMWRZHJRSDNLHWX

/RVDSOHWyZPyJá]RVWDüSU]\SLHF] WRZDQ\GHF\]M ILUP\0LFURVRIWRQLHZá F]DQLX-5(GR

SU]HJO GDUNL,QWHUQHW([SORUHU7DNF]\LQDF]HMDSOHW\-DY\QLH]DLVWQLDá\QDZL NV] VNDO

0LPRWRDSOHW\MDNRWDNLHLWHFKQRORJLD-DYD:HE6WDUWZFL RND]XM VL ZSHZQ\FK

V\WXDFMDFK SU]\GDWQH =QDMGXM ]DVWRVRZDQLH ZV] G]LH WDP JG]LH ]DFKRG]L SRWU]HED

NRQWURORZDQLDPDV]\QX \WNRZQLNyZQDSU]\NáDGZREU ELHV\VWHPXLQIRUPDW\F]QHJR

NRUSRUDFMLVáX WDPGRUR]SURZDG]DQLDLDNWXDOL]DFMLDSOLNDFMLNOLHQFNLFKSU]\]QDF]QHM

RV]F] GQR FLF]DVXRUD]]DVREyZOXG]NLFKLILQDQVRZ\FK²ZLGRF]QHM]ZáDV]F]DWDP

JG]LHDNWXDOL]DFMHV F] VWH

: UR]G]LDOH Ä*UDILF]QH LQWHUIHMV\ X \WNRZQLND´ SU]\MU]\P\ VL QRZHM RELHFXM FHM

WHFKQRORJLL)OH[ILUP\0DFURPHGLDNWyUDSR]ZDODQDWZRU]HQLHRGSRZLHGQLNyZDSOH

WyZ W\OH H RSDUW\FK QD WHFKQRORJLL )ODVK 3RQLHZD MDNLH SURFHQW SU]HJO GDUHN

:::G\VSRQXMHRGWZDU]DF]DPLIRUPDWX)ODVKGRW\F]\WRSU]HJO GDUHNGODZV]\VW

NLFKSRSXODUQ\FKV\VWHPyZRSHUDF\MQ\FKPR QDJRX]QDü]DSRZV]HFKQLHSU]\M W\

VWDQGDUG,QVWDODFMDLDNWXDOL]DFMHRGWZDU]DF]D)ODVKRGE\ZDM VL V]\ENRLSURVWR6WR

VRZDQ\WXM ]\N$FWLRQ6FULSWED]XMHQDM ]\NX(&0$6FULSWSU]H]FRáDWZRVL GRQLH

JRSU]\]Z\F]DLüDOH)OH[SR]ZDODQDSURJUDPRZDQLHEH]PDUWZLHQLDVL RFKDUDNWHU\

VW\N SU]HJO GDUNLFRF]\QLJR]QDF]QLHDWUDNF\MQLHMV]\PRG-DYD6FULSWX:G]LHG]LQLH

SURJUDPRZDQLDSRVWURQLHNOLHQWDMHVWWR]SHZQR FL DOWHUQDW\ZDJRGQDUR]ZD HQLD

1(7L&

2G GáX V]HJR F]DVX JáyZQ\P NRQNXUHQWHP DSOHWyZ -DY\ E\á\ NRPSRQHQW\ $FWLYH;

FKRüZ\PDJDá\RQHDE\NOLHQWG]LDáDáZV\VWHPLHRSHUDF\MQ\P:LQGRZV1DVW SQLH

0LFURVRIWVWZRU]\áJRGQHJRU\ZDODGOD-DY\²SODWIRUP 1(7RUD]M ]\N&3ODWIRUPD

1(7MHVWPQLHMZL FHMW\PVDP\PFRZLUWXDOQDPDV]\QD-DY\RUD]ZV]\VWNLHELEOLRWHNLWHJR

M ]\NDDSRGRELH VWZDM ]\NyZ&L-DYDV RF]\ZLVWH%H]Z WSLHQLDMHVWWRQDMOHSV]D

background image

7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

URERWDMDN 0LFURVRIWZ\NRQDáZG]LHG]LQLHM ]\NyZSURJUDPRZDQLDL URGRZLVNSUR

JUDPLVW\F]Q\FK2F]\ZL FLH0LFURVRIWPLDá]QDF] F SU]HZDJ JG\ PyJáSU]HDQDOL

]RZDüFRZ-DYLHE\áRGREUHDFR]áHLED]RZDüQDWHMZLHG]\-HGQDN]RVWDáDRQDZ\

NRU]\VWDQD]GRVNRQDá\PUH]XOWDWHP3RUD]SLHUZV]\RGPRPHQWXSRMDZLHQLDVL -DYD

]\VNDáDJRGQHJRVLHELHNRQNXUHQWDG]L NLWHPX]NROHLSURMHNWDQFLM ]\ND-DYDSU]\VLH

GOLIDáGyZLSU]\JO GDM FVL &RUD]SU]\F]\QRPGODNWyU\FKSURJUDPL FLPRJ Z\ELH

UDüJRDQLH-DY RGSRZLHG]LHOLUR]V]HU]HQLHP-DY\ZSRVWDFLZ\GDQLD-DYD6(]MHJR

IXQGDPHQWDOQ\PLXVSUDZQLHQLDPL

$NWXDOQLHJáyZQ\PVáDE\PSXQNWHPRUD]S\WDQLHPGRW\F] F\PSODWIRUP\1(7MHVWWR

F]\0LFURVRIW]H]ZROLQDSU]HQLHVLHQLHJRZFDáR FLQDLQQHSODWIRUP\V\VWHPRZH0LFURVRIW

WZLHUG]L HQLHSRZLQQRWRE\ü DGQ\PSUREOHPHPDSURMHNW0RQRZZZJRPRQRFRP

VWDQRZLF] FLRZ LPSOHPHQWDFM SODWIRUP\1(7G]LDáDM F ZV\VWHPDFK/LQX[-HGQDN

GRPRPHQWX]DNR F]HQLDSUDFQDGSHáQ LPSOHPHQWDFM LSRGM FLDSU]H]0LFURVRIWGHF\]ML

GRW\F] FHMZV]\VWNLFKHOHPHQWyZSODWIRUP\1(7Z\NRU]\VWDQLHMHMMDNRUR]ZL ]DQLD

PL G]\V\VWHPRZHJRMHVWU\]\NRZQH

,QWHUQHWNRQWUDLQWUDQHW

6LHü:::MHVWQDMRJyOQLHMV]\PUR]ZL ]DQLHPSUREOHPXNOLHQWVHUZHUZL FZ\GDMHVL

VHQVRZQHX \FLHWHMVDPHMWHFKQRORJLLGRSRG]ELRUXWHJRSUREOHPX²ZV]F]HJyOQR FL

NODV\F]QHJRSUREOHPXNOLHQWVHUZHUZHZQ WU]ILUP\3U]\WUDG\F\MQ\PSRGHM FLXNOLHQW

VHUZHUZ\VW SXM WUXGQR FL]SRZRGXZLHOXW\SyZNRPSXWHUyZSRVWURQLHNOLHQWyZRUD]

NáRSRW\]LQVWDODFM QRZHJRRSURJUDPRZDQLD2E\GZDSUREOHP\V GREU]HUR]ZL ]\

ZDQHSU]H]SU]HJO GDUN :::LSURJUDPRZDQLHSRVWURQLHNOLHQWD.LHG\WHFKQRORJLD

:::MHVWX \ZDQDZVLHFLLQIRUPDF\MQHMRJUDQLF]RQHMGRNRQNUHWQHMILUP\RNUH ODVL

M PLDQHPLQWUDQHWX,QWUDQHWGRVWDUF]DRZLHOHZ\ V]\SR]LRPEH]SLHF]H VWZDQL ,QWHUQHW

SRQLHZD PR QDIL]\F]QLHNRQWURORZDüGRVW SGRILUPRZ\FKVHUZHUyZ-H OLZ]L ü]D

SRGXZDJ V]NROHQLHSUDFRZQLNyZZ\GDMHVL HNLHG\MX ]UR]XPLHM RJyOQH]DVDG\

SUDF\]SU]HJO GDUN MHVWLPGX RáDWZLHMUDG]LüVRELH]Uy QLFDPLPL G]\G]LDáDQLHPVWURQ

LDSOHWyZDF]DVSRWU]HEQ\GRQDXF]HQLDVL QRZ\FKV\VWHPyZMHVWNUyWV]\

3UREOHPEH]SLHF]H VWZDGRSURZDG]LáGRMHGQHJR]SRG]LDáyZSRZVWDá\FKDXWRPDW\F]

QLHZ ZLHFLHSURJUDPRZDQLDW\SXNOLHQWVHUZHU-H OLSURJUDPG]LDáDZ,QWHUQHFLHQLH

ZLHP\QDMDNLHMSODWIRUPLHE G]LHSUDFRZDáDMHGQRF]H QLH]ZUDFDP\V]F]HJyOQ XZDJ

DE\QLHUR]SRZV]HFKQLDüNRGX]DZLHUDM FHJREá G\3RWU]HEXMHP\F]HJR WDNSU]HQR QHJR

LEH]SLHF]QHJRMDNM ]\NVNU\SWRZ\OXE-DYD

3UDFXM FZLQWUDQHFLHQDSRW\NDP\]HVWDZLQQ\FKRJUDQLF]H 1LHMHVWU]HF] QLH]Z\

Ná HZV]\VWNLHPDV]\Q\E G SUDFRZDüQDSODWIRUPLH,QWHO:LQGRZV:LQWUDQHFLH

RGSRZLDGDP\]DMDNR üZáDVQHJRNRGXLPR HP\QDSUDZLDüEá G\]DUD]SRLFKZ\NU\FLX

:GRGDWNXF] VWRWU]HEDZ\NRU]\VWDüNRGSR]RVWDá\SRZF]H QLHMV]\FKWUDG\F\MQ\FK

LPSOHPHQWDFMDFKV\VWHPX7U]HEDZWHG\IL]\F]QLHLQVWDORZDüSURJUDP\NOLHQWyZSU]\

ND GRUD]RZ\P XDNWXDOQLHQLX &]DV WUDFRQ\ QD LQVWDORZDQLH XDNWXDOQLH MHVW QDMF] VW

V]\PSRZRGHPSU]HM FLDQDNRU]\VWDQLH]SU]HJO GDUNLSRQLHZD WXWDMXDNWXDOQLHQLDV

QLHZLGRF]QHLDXWRPDW\F]QH-H OLMHVWH ]DDQJD RZDQ\ZWHJRW\SXSURMHNWLQWUDQHWRZ\

QDMUR]V GQLHMV]\PUR]ZL ]DQLHPMHVWREUDQLHQDMSURVWV]HMGURJLXPR OLZLDM FHMZ\NRU]\

VWDQLHLVWQLHM FHMED]\NRGX]DPLDVWSU]HSLV\ZDQLDSURJUDPyZSRQRZQLHZQRZ\PM ]\NX

background image

5R]G]LDä

u

:SURZDG]HQLHZ ZLDWRELHNWÑZ

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

:SU]\SDGNXWDNNRQVWHUQXM FHJRERJDFWZDUR]ZL ]D SUREOHPXNOLHQWVHUZHUQDMOHSV]\P

Z\M FLHPMHVWDQDOL]DNRV]WyZLNRU]\ FL5R]ZD RJUDQLF]HQLDSRVWDZLRQHJRSUREOHPX

LRGV]XNDMQDMNUyWV] FLH N GRUR]ZL ]DQLD3RQLHZD SURJUDPRZDQLHSRVWURQLHNOLHQWD

QDGDOSR]RVWDMHSURJUDPRZDQLHP]DZV]HGREU\PSRP\VáHPMHVWSU]\M FLHSRGHM FLD

QDMV]\EFLHMSURZDG] FHJRGRUR]ZL ]DQLD-HVWWRDJUHV\ZQDSRVWDZDSU]\JRWRZXM FDQD

VSRWNDQLH]SUREOHPDPLQLHXQLNQLRQ\PLSU]\WZRU]HQLXRSURJUDPRZDQLD

3URJUDPRZDQLHSRVWURQLHVHUZHUD

:GRW\FKF]DVRZHMG\VNXVMLSRPLMDQ\E\áWHPDWSURJUDPRZDQLDSRVWURQLHVHUZHUD&RVL

G]LHMHZPRPHQFLHZ\VáDQLD GDQLDGRVHUZHUD"1DMF] VWV]\P GDQLHPMHVWSURVWH

Ä:\ OLMPLWHQSOLN´1DVW SQLHSU]HJO GDUNDLQWHUSUHWXMHRWU]\PDQ\SOLNZRGSRZLHGQL

VSRVyEMDNRVWURQ +70/REUD]HNDSOHW-DY\VNU\SWLWG

%DUG]LHMVNRPSOLNRZDQH GDQLDNLHURZDQHGRVHUZHUDZ\PDJDM QDRJyáNRPXQLNDFML

] ED] GDQ\FK : ZLHOX SU]\SDGNDFK Z\PDJD WR Z\NRQDQLD ]áR RQHJR ]DS\WDQLD QD

ED]LHGDQ\FKNWyUHVHUZHUIRUPDWXMHMDNRVWURQ +70/LRGV\áD]SRZURWHPGRNOLHQWD

RF]\ZL FLHMH OLNOLHQWPDZL NV]HPR OLZR FL²G]L NL-DYLHOXEM ]\NRPVNU\SWR

Z\P²WRVXURZHGDQHPRJ E\üSU]HVáDQHLVIRUPDWRZDQHSRVWURQLHNOLHQWDFRMHVW

V]\EV]HLPQLHMREFL DVHUZHU3RGREQLHUHMHVWUDFMDX \WNRZQLNDZFKZLOLGRá F]HQLD

GRJUXS\G\VNXV\MQHMOXE]áR HQLD]DPyZLHQLDZ\PDJDZSURZDG]HQLD]PLDQZED]LH

GDQ\FK7HZV]\VWNLH GDQLDPXV] ]RVWDüSU]HWZRU]RQHSU]H]MDNL SURJUDPG]LDáDM

F\SRVWURQLHVHUZHUDFRRJyOQLHRNUH ODQHMHVWMDNRSURJUDPRZDQLHSRVWURQLHVHUZHUD

7UDG\F\MQLH SURJUDP\ &*, G]LDáDM FH SR VWURQLH VHUZHUD E\á\ WZRU]RQH SU]\ X \FLX

3HUOD3\WKRQDOXE&DOHSRMDZLDá\VL WH EDUG]LHMZ\V]XNDQHV\VWHP\:H P\SRG

XZDJ QSVHUZHU\VLHFLRZHZ\NRU]\VWXM FH-DY 8PR OLZLDM RQHZ\NRQDQLHFDáR FL

SURJUDPRZDQLDSRVWURQLHVHUZHUDSU]H]SLVDQLHVHUZOHWyZ6HUZOHW\LLFKSRFKRGQD

-63 HOLPLQXM SUREOHP\ ]ZL ]DQH ] Uy QRURGQ\P SR]LRPHP ]DDZDQVRZDQLD Uy QHJR

W\SXSU]HJO GDUHN=WHJRSRZRGXZLHOHILUPWZRU] F\FKVWURQ\:::SU]HFKRG]LQD

-DY 7H]DJDGQLHQLD]RVWDá\RSLVDQHZNVL FH7KLQNLQJLQ(QWHUSULVH-DYD²]REDF]

ZZZ0LQG9LHZQHW

:L NV]R üV]XPXZRNyá-DY\]ZL ]DQDE\áD]DSOHWDPL:U]HF]\ZLVWR FL-DYDMHVWM

]\NLHPSURJUDPRZDQLDRJyOQHJRSU]H]QDF]HQLDNWyU\PR HUR]ZL ]\ZDüGRZROQ\UR

G]DMSUREOHPyZ6Lá -DY\MHVWQLHW\ONRMHMSU]HQR QR üDOHWDN HPR OLZR FLSURJUD

PLVW\F]QHQLH]DZRGQR üSRZV]HFKQR üGRVW SQR üELEOLRWHNVWDQGDUGRZ\FKLOLF]Q\FK

áDWZRGRVW SQ\FKL \ZLRáRZRUR]ZLMDM F\FKVL ELEOLRWHNGRGDWNRZ\FK

3RGVXPRZDQLH

:V]\VF\ZLHP\MDNZ\JO GDSURJUDPSURFHGXUDOQ\GHILQLFMHGDQ\FKLZ\ZRáDQLDIXQNFML

$E\RGJDGQ ü]QDF]HQLHWDNLHJRSURJUDPXWU]HEDVL WURV]N QDSUDFRZDüSU]H OHG]Lü

Z\ZRáDQLDIXQNFMLL]EDGDüQLVNRSR]LRPRZHSRM FLDDE\VWZRU]\üZáDVQ\P\ ORZ\PR

GHO=WHJRSRZRGXSRWU]HEXMHP\UHSUH]HQWDFMLSR UHGQLFKSU]\SURMHNWRZDQLXSURJUDPX

SURFHGXUDOQHJR²SURJUDP\WHVDPHZVRELHPRJ E\üQLH]UR]XPLDáHSRQLHZD URGNL

Z\UD]XV VNLHURZDQHEDUG]LHMQDNRPSXWHU\QL QDUR]ZL ]\ZDQ\SUREOHP

background image

7KLQNLQJLQ-DYD(G\FMDSROVND

'?5RERF]\-DUHN?PDNLHW\SRSUDZNLGUXNSGI?7KLQNLQJLQ-DYDWKHGLWLRQ?GUXN?UGRF

3RQLHZD SURJUDPRZDQLHRELHNWRZHGRGDMHZLHOHSRM üGRW\FKNWyUHPR QD]QDOH ü

ZM ]\NDFKSURFHGXUDOQ\FKPR HVL Z\GDZDüQDWXUDOQ\P]DáR HQLHP HZ\QLNRZ\

SURJUDPZM ]\NX-DYDPR HE\üRZLHOHEDUG]LHMVNRPSOLNRZDQ\QL MHJRUyZQRZD QLN

ZM ]\NXSURFHGXUDOQ\P7XWDMVSRW\NDQDVPLáDQLHVSRG]LDQNDGREU]HQDSLVDQ\SURJUDP

MHVWQDRJyáRZLHOHáDWZLHMV]\GR]UR]XPLHQLDQL RGSRZLDGDM F\PXNRGSURFHGXUDOQ\

7RFRZLG]LP\WRGHILQLFMHRELHNWyZUHSUH]HQWXM F\FKSRM FLD]SU]HVWU]HQLSUREOHPX

DQLHNZHVWLH]ZL ]DQH]UHSUH]HQWDFM NRPSXWHURZ RUD]NRPXQLNDW\Z\V\áDQHGR

W\FKRELHNWyZUHSUH]HQWXM FHG]LDáDQLDZSU]HVWU]HQLSUREOHPX-HGQ ]SU]\MHPQ\FK

VWURQSURJUDPRZDQLD]RULHQWRZDQHJRRELHNWRZRMHVWWR HGREU]H]DSURMHNWRZDQ\SUR

JUDPPR QD]UR]XPLHüF]\WDM FMHJRNRG1DMF] FLHMNRGMHVWWH RZLHOHNUyWV]\SR

QLHZD ZLHOHSUREOHPyZ]RVWDáRUR]ZL ]DQ\FKSU]H]]DVWRVRZDQLHNRGX]LVWQLHM F\FK

ELEOLRWHN

3URJUDPRZDQLHRELHNWRZHL-DYDQLHPXV] E\üGREUHGODND GHJR:D QHMHVWE\RFH

QLüVZRMHSRWU]HE\L]GHF\GRZDüF]\-DYDZVSRVyERSW\PDOQ\MH]DVSRNDMDF]\WH

OHSLHM E G]LH X \ü LQQHJR M ]\ND SURJUDPRZDQLD ZOLF]DM F REHFQLH X \ZDQ\ -H OL

ZLDGRPR HZSU]HZLG\ZDOQHMSU]\V]áR FLVWDZLDQHZ\PDJDQLDE G EDUG]RVSHFMDOQH

LMH OLGRGDWNRZRSRMDZLDM VL VSHF\ILF]QHRJUDQLF]HQLDNWyU\FK-DYDQLHZ\HOLPLQXMH

OHSLHM E G]LH ]EDGDü UR]ZL ]DQLD DOWHUQDW\ZQH Z V]F]HJyOQR FL SROHFDP ]ZUyFHQLH

XZDJLQDM ]\N3\WKRQSDWU]ZZZ3\WKRQRUJ-H OLRVWDWHF]QLHZ\EyUSDGQLHQD-DY

MDNRSUHIHURZDQ\M ]\NSURJUDPRZDQLDE G]LHWR ZLDGRPDGHF\]MDSRGM WDSRUR]ZD

HQLXLQQ\FKRSFML


Wyszukiwarka

Podobne podstrony:
ebook Bruce Eckel Thinking in Java Edycja polska Wydanie IV (thija4) helion onepress free ebook da
Thinking in Java Edycja polska Wydanie IV thija4
Thinking in Java Edycja polska Wydanie IV
Thinking in Java Edycja polska Wydanie IV 2
Thinking in Java Edycja polska Wydanie IV 2
Thinking in Java Edycja polska 2
Thinking in Java Edycja polska thijav
Thinking in Java Edycja polska
Thinking in Java Edycja polska thijav
Java cwiczenia praktyczne Wydanie IV 2
Java cwiczenia praktyczne Wydanie IV
Thinking in Java
Java cwiczenia praktyczne Wydanie IV
Java cwiczenia praktyczne Wydanie IV cwjav4 2

więcej podobnych podstron