Table 0.1: Summary evaluation of levy-based and ETS-based MBMs.
Criterion/ MBM |
Levy-based |
ETS-based |
GHG reduction effectiveness |
Considerable, depending on the level of the levy |
Considerable for a global ETS Questionable for an EU ETS |
Compatibility with existing legał framework |
May encounter legał obstacles |
May encounter legał obstacles. |
Implementation timeline |
Unclear at global level Industry R&D fund on the table at IMO |
Unclear at global level EU ETS is forthcoming |
Potential impacts on States |
Potentially considerable |
Potentially considerable |
Administrative burden |
Low |
Considerable |
Practical feasibility |
High |
Questionable |
Avoidance of Split incentives |
No serious split incentives |
Serious split incentives |
Commercial impacts |
Considerable and in many sectors |
Considerable but uncertain due to uncertainty on carbon price |