Porsche 911 Turbo instrukcja obslugi ENG by mobopx

background image

>2+ 

È

+Y0UNOJ-7VYZJOL(.

7VYZJOL [OL 7VYZJOL JYLZ[ *HYYLYH ;HYNH

)V_Z[LY ;PW[YVUPJ HUK ;LX\PWTLU[ HYL YLNPZÌ

[LYLK [YHKLTHYRZ HUK [OL KP Z[P UJ[P ]L ZOHWLZ VM

7VYZJOLH\[VTVIPSLZHYL[YHKLTHYRZVM

+Y0UNOJ-7VYZJOL(.

(SSYPNO[ZYLZLY]LK

7YPU[LKPU.LYTHU`

background image

F"˜§mF:

>L^V\SKSPRL[V[OHUR`V\MVY`V\YW\YJOHZLVM

H7VYZJOL:WVY[ZJHY

1\KNPUN I` [OL JHY `V\ OH]L JOVZLU `V\ HYL H

TV[VYPZ[ VM H ZWLJPHS IYLLK HUK `V\ HYL WYVIÌ

HIS`UVUV]PJL^OLUP[JVTLZ[VH\[VTVIPSLZ

9LTLTILY OV^L]LY HZ ^P[O HU` ]LOPJSL `V\

ZOV\SK[HRL[PTL[VMHTPSPHYPaL`V\YZLSM^P[O`V\Y

7VYZJOL HUK P[Z WLYMVYTHUJL JOHYHJ[LYPZ[PJZ (SÌ

^H`ZKYP]L^P[OPU`V\YV^U\UPX\LJHWHIPSP[PLZHZ

H KYP]LY HUK `V\Y SL]LS VM L_WLYPLUJL ^P[O `V\Y

7VYZJOL ,UZ\YL [OH[ HU`VUL LSZL KYP]PUN `V\Y

7VYZJOLKVLZ[OLZHTL;VWYL]LU[VYTPUPTPaL

PUQ\Y` HS^H`Z \ZL `V\Y ZHML[` ILS[Z 5L]LY JVUÌ

Z\TL HSJVOVS VY KY\NZ ILMVYL VY K\YPUN [OL

VWLYH[PVUVM`V\Y]LOPJSL

;OPZ 6^ULYqZ 4HU\HS JVU[HPUZ H OVZ[ VM \ZLM\S

PUMVYTH[PVU 7SLHZL [HRL [OL [PTL [V YLHK [OPZ

THU\HS ILMVYL `V\ KYP]L `V\Y UL^ 7VYZJOL

)LJVTL MHTPSPHY ^P[O [OL VWLYH[PVU VM `V\Y

7VYZJOL JHY MVY TH_PT\T ZHML[` HUK VWLYH[PUN

WSLHZ\YL;OLIL[[LY`V\RUV^`V\Y7VYZJOL[OL

TVYL WSLHZ\YL `V\ ^PSS L_WLYPLUJL KYP]PUN `V\Y

UL^JHY

(S^H`Z RLLW `V\Y 6^ULYqZ 4HU\HS PU [OL JHY

HUK NP]L P[ [V [OL UL^ V^ULY PM `V\ L]LY ZLSS

`V\Y7VYZJOL

( ZLWHYH[L 4HPU[LUHUJL )VVRSL[ L_WSHPUZ

OV^ `V\ JHU RLLW `V\Y 7VYZJOL PU [VW KYP]PUN

JVUKP[PVUI`OH]PUNP[ZLY]PJLKYLN\SHYS`

( ZLWHYH[L >HYYHU[` HUK *\Z[VTLY 0UMVYÍ

TH[PVU )VVRSL[ JVU[HPUZ KL[HPSLK PUMVYTH[PVU

HIV\[[OL^HYYHU[PLZJV]LYPUN`V\Y7VYZJOL

-VY<:VUS`!

0M`V\ILSPL]L[OH[`V\Y]LOPJSLOHZHMH\S[^OPJO

JV\SKJH\ZLHJYHZOPUQ\Y`VYKLH[O`V\ZOV\SK

PTTLKPH[LS` PUMVYT [OL 5H[PVUHS /PNO^H` ;YHMMPJ

:HML[` (KTPUPZ[YH[PVU 5/;:( PU HKKP[PVU [V

UV[PM`PUN 7VYZJOL *HYZ 5VY[O (TLYPJH 0UJ

7VYZJOL*HYZ5(

0M 5/;:( YLJLP]LZ ZPTPSHY JVTWSHPU[Z P[ TH`

VWLUHUPU]LZ[PNH[PVUHUKPMP[MPUKZ[OH[HZHML[`

WYVISLT L_PZ[Z PU H NYV\W VM ]LOPJSLZ P[ TH`

VYKLY H YLJHSS HUK YLTLK` JHTWHPNU /V^L]LY

5/;:( JHUUV[ ILJVTL PU]VS]LK PU PUKP]PK\HS

WYVISLTZ IL[^LLU `V\ HUK `V\Y KLHSLY VY

7VYZJOL*HYZ5(

;VJVU[HJ[5/;:(`V\TH`LP[OLYJHSS[OL(\[V

:HML[` /V[SPUL [VSSÌMYLL H[ ÌÌÌ  

VYÌPU>HZOPUN[VU+*HYLHVY^YP[L

[V! 5/;:( <: +LWHY[TLU[ VM ;YHUZWVY[H[PVU

>HZOPUN[VU +*   @V\ JHU HSZV VI[HPU

V[OLY PUMVYTH[PVU HIV\[ TV[VY ]LOPJSL ZHML[`

MYVT[OL/V[SPUL

@V\Y JHY OHZ [OV\ZHUKZ VM WHY[Z HUK JVTWVÌ

ULU[Z ^OPJO OH]L ILLU KLZPNULK HUK THU\MHJÌ

[\YLK PU HJJVYKHUJL ^P[O 7VYZJOLqZ OPNO Z[HUKÌ

HYKZVMLUNPULLYPUNX\HSP[`HUKZHML[`

(U`HS[LYH[PVUVM[OL]LOPJSLTH`ULNH[LVY

PU[LYMLYL ^P[O [OVZL ZHML[` MLH[\YLZ I\PS[

PU[V[OL]LOPJSL

@V\Y 7VYZJOL PZ PU[LUKLK [V IL \ZLK PU H ZHML

THUULYVIL`PUN[OLSVJHSSH^ZHUKPU[OLSPNO[VM

KYP]PUN JVUKP[PVUZ MHJLK I` `V\ HUK PU HJJVYKÌ

HUJL ^P[O [OL PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ WYV]PKLK PU [OPZ

6^ULYqZ4HU\HS

+V UV[ TPZ\ZL `V\Y 7VYZJOL I` PNUVYPUN

[OVZL SH^Z HUK KYP]PUN JVUKP[PVUZ VY I`

PNUVYPUN[OLPUZ[Y\J[PVUZPU[OPZTHU\HS

(U` HS[LYH[PVU VYTPZ\ZLVM[OL]LOPJSLJHU

SLHK [V HJJPKLU[Z HUK ZL]LYL VY MH[HS WLYÍ

ZVUHSPUQ\YPLZ

9LN\SHYS` JOLJR `V\Y ]LOPJSL MVY ZPNUZ VM

KHTHNL

+HTHNLK VY TPZZPUN HLYVK`UHTPJ JVTWVÍ

ULU[Z Z\JO HZ ZWVPSLYZ VY \UKLYZPKL WHULSZ

HMMLJ[ [OL KYP]PUN ILOH]PVY HUK [OLYLMVYL

T\Z[ILYLWSHJLKPTTLKPH[LS`

¢˜˜



background image

@V\Y JHY TH` OH]L HSS VY ZVTL VM [OL JVTWVÌ

ULU[ZKLZJYPILKPU[OPZTHU\HS

:OV\SK `V\ OH]L KPMMPJ\S[` \UKLYZ[HUKPUN HU` VM

[OL L_WSHUH[PVUZ VM MLH[\YLZ VY LX\PWTLU[

PUZ[HSSLKPU`V\Y]LOPJSLJVU[HJ[`V\YH\[OVYPaLK

7VYZJOL KLHSLY /L:OL ^PSS IL NSHK [V HZZPZ[

`V\ (SZV JOLJR ^P[O `V\Y KLHSLY VU V[OLY H]HPSÌ

HISLVW[PVUZVYLX\PWTLU[

;OYV\NOV\[ [OPZ IVVRSL[ SLM[ PZ KLZPNUH[LK HZ

[OL KYP]LYqZ ZPKL VM [OL ]LOPJSL HUKYPNO[HZ[OL

WHZZLUNLYqZZPKLVM[OL]LOPJSL

;L_[ PSS\Z[YH[PVUZ HUK ZWLJPMPJH[PVUZ PU [OPZ THÌ

U\HS HYL IHZLK VU [OL PUMVYTH[PVU H]HPSHISL H[

[OL[PTLVMWYPU[PUN

0[ OHZ HS^H`Z ILLU 7VYZJOLqZ WVSPJ` [V JVU[PU\Ì

V\ZS` PTWYV]L P[Z WYVK\J[Z 7VYZJOL [OLYLMVYL

YLZLY]LZ [OL YPNO[ [V THRL JOHUNLZ PU KLZPNU

HUK ZWLJPMPJH[PVU HUK [V THRL HKKP[PVUZ VY

PTWYV]LTLU[Z PU P[Z WYVK\J[ ^P[OV\[ PUJ\YYPUN

HU` VISPNH[PVU [V PUZ[HSS [OLT VU WYVK\J[Z

WYL]PV\ZS`THU\MHJ[\YLK

>L^PZO`V\THU`TPSLZVMZHMLHUKWSLHZ\YHISL

KYP]PUNPU`V\Y7VYZJOL

0TWVY[HU[

-VY `V\Y V^U WYV[LJ[PVU HUK SVUNLY ZLY]PJL SPML

VM `V\Y JHY WSLHZL OLLK HSS VWLYH[PUN

PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ HUK ZWLJPHS ^HYUPUNZ ;OLZL ZWLJPHS

^HYUPUNZ \ZL [OL ZHML[` HSLY[ Z`TIVS MVSSV^LK

I` [OL ^VYKZ +HUNLY >HYUPUN HUK *H\[PVU

;OLZL ZWLJPHS ^HYUPUNZ JVU[HPU PTWVY[HU[ TLZÌ

ZHNLZYLNHYKPUN`V\YZHML[`HUKVY[OLWV[LU[PHS

MVY KHTHNL [V `V\Y 7VYZJOL 0NUVYPUN [OLT

JV\SKYLZ\S[PUZLYPV\ZTLJOHUPJHSMHPS\YLVYL]LU

WO`ZPJHSPUQ\Y`

+V UV[ HS[LY `V\Y 7VYZJOL (U` HS[LYH[PVU JV\SK

JYLH[L KHUNLYV\Z JVUKP[PVUZ VY KLMLH[ ZHML[`

LUNPULLYPUNMLH[\YLZI\PS[PU[V`V\YJHY

+V UV[ TPZ\ZL `V\Y 7VYZJOL <ZL P[ ZHMLS` HUK

JVUZPZ[LU[S` ^P[O [OL SH^ HJJVYKPUN [V [OL KYP]Ì

PUN JVUKP[PVUZ HUK [OL PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ PU [OPZ THÌ

U\HS

(S[LYH[PVU VY TPZ\ZL VM `V\Y 7VYZJOL JV\SK

JH\ZLHJJPKLU[ZHUKZL]LYLVYMH[HSWLYZVUHS

PUQ\YPLZ

p›F˜›p˜p§mF’

0U *HUHKH [OPZ THU\HS PZ HSZV H]HPSHISL PU

-YLUJO;VVI[HPUHJVW`JVU[HJ[`V\YKLHSLYVY

^YP[L[V!

p›F˜"¤¨˜zpzaF›"aF’

(\ *HUHKH VU WL\[ ZL WYVJ\YLY \U L_LTWSHPYL

KL JL 4HU\LS LU MYHU¶HPZ H\WY·Z K\ JVUJLZZPVÌ

UHPYLV\K\!

7VYZJOL*HYZ*HUHKH3[K

(\[VTVIPSLZ7VYZJOL*HUHKH3;,,

6YIP[VY+YP]L

)\PSKPUN :\P[L

4PZZPZZH\NH6U[HYPV

*HUHKH3>@

;LSLWOVULU\TILYMVYJ\Z[VTLYHZZPZ[HUJL!

ÌÌ769:*/,6W[PVU





background image

¤Fd˜¤"da›©

@V\YLUNPULPZKLZPNULK[VWYV]PKLVW[PT\TWLYMVYTHUJLHUKM\LSLJVUVT`\ZPUN

\USLHKLKWYLTP\TM\LS^P[OHUVJ[HULYH[PUNVM 965 *3*VY(20

7VYZJOL[OLYLMVYLYLJVTTLUKZ[OL\ZLVM[OLZLM\LSZPU`V\Y]LOPJSL
7VYZJOLHSZVYLJVNUPaLZ[OH[[OLZLM\LSZTH`UV[HS^H`ZILH]HPSHISL)LHZZ\YLK[OH[`V\Y]LOPJSL^PSSVWLYH[L

WYVWLYS`VU\USLHKLKWYLTP\TM\LSZ^P[OVJ[HULU\TILYZVMH[SLHZ[ 965 *3*VY(20

ZPUJL[OLLUNPULqZs,SLJ[YVUPJ6R[HUL¹RUVJRJVU[YVSr^PSSHKHW[[OLPNUP[PVU[PTPUNPMULJLZZHY`

¤Fd’˜4pm›"amamV˜"d4p^pd˜"m=˜F›^F

:VTLHYLHZVM[OL<:YLX\PYLV_`NLUH[LKM\LSZK\YPUNJLY[HPUWVY[PVUZVM[OL`LHY

6_`NLUH[LKM\LSZHYLM\LSZ^OPJOJVU[HPUHSJVOVSZZ\JOHZTL[OHUVSVYL[OHUVSVYL[OLYZ\JOHZ4;),
<UKLYUVYTHSJVUKP[PVUZ[OLHTV\U[VM[OLZLJVTWV\UKZPU[OLM\LS^PSSUV[HMMLJ[KYP]LHIPSP[`
@V\TH`\ZLV_`NLUH[LKM\LSZPU`V\Y7VYZJOLWYV]PKLK[OLVJ[HULYLX\PYLTLU[ZMVY`V\Y]LOPJSLHYLTL[

>LYLJVTTLUKOV^L]LY[VJOHUNL[VHKPMMLYLU[M\LSVYZ[H[PVUPMHU`VM[OLMVSSV^PUNWYVISLTZVJJ\Y^P[O`V\Y]LOPJSL!

u+L[LYPVYH[PVUVMKYP]LHIPSP[`HUKWLYMVYTHUJL
u:\IZ[HU[PHSS`YLK\JLKM\LSLJVUVT`
u=HWVYSVJRHUKUVUÌZ[HY[WYVISLTZLZWLJPHSS`H[OPNOHS[P[\KLVYH[OPNO[LTWLYH[\YL
u,UNPULTHSM\UJ[PVUVYZ[HSSPUN

¤Fd’˜4pm›"amamV˜

:VTL5VY[O(TLYPJHUM\LSZJVU[HPUHUVJ[HULLUOHUJPUNHKKP[P]LJHSSLKTL[O`SJ`JSVWLU[HKPLU`STHUNHULZL[YPJHYIVU`S44;

0MZ\JOM\LSZHYL\ZLK`V\YLTPZZPVUJVU[YVSZ`Z[LTWLYMVYTHUJLTH`ILULNH[P]LS`HMMLJ[LK

;OLJOLJRLUNPUL^HYUPUNSPNO[ZVU`V\YPUZ[Y\TLU[WHULSTH`[\YUVU

0M[OPZVJJ\YZ7VYZJOLYLJVTTLUKZ`V\Z[VW\ZPUNM\LSZJVU[HPUPUN44;

T˜˜



background image

aF˜F’’¤F’˜Op˜pd=˜aF’

¤hhF˜›aF’˜"m=˜’mp§˜›aF’

-YVU[

WZPIHYV]LYWYLZZ\YL

9LHY

WZPIHYV]LYWYLZZ\YL

pdd"z’a*dF˜’z"F˜§^FFd

=LOPJSLZ^P[OV\[7VYZJOL*LYHTPJ*VTWVZP[L)YHRL!
-YVU[HUKYLHY

WZPIHYV]LYWYLZZ\YL

=LOPJSLZ^P[O7VYZJOL*LYHTPJ*VTWVZP[L)YHRL!
-YVU[HUKYLHY

WZPIHYV]LYWYLZZ\YL

;OLZL[PYLWYLZZ\YLZHYL]HSPKVUS`MVY7VYZJOLHWWYV]LK[PYLZ

-VYYLWSHJLTLU[[PYLZP[PZPTWLYH[P]L[OH[`V\JVUZ\S[[OL;LJOUPJHS+H[HHUK;PYLZ>OLLSZ

ZLJ[PVUZVM[OPZTHU\HSHUKMVSSV^[OLYLJVTTLUKH[PVUZJVU[HPULK[OLYLPU



Q

background image

p’4^F˜"m=˜›^F˜m¦apmhFm›

m¦apmhFm›"d˜V¤a=FdamF’

>L KL]LSVW HUK WYVK\JL L_JS\ZP]L ZWVY[Z JHYZ

^P[OHK]HUJLKLU]PYVUTLU[HSHUKZHML[`[LJOUVSÌ

VN`HUKHNYLH[HIPSP[`[VMHZJPUH[L

6\YLU]PYVUTLU[HSWVSPJ`PZIHZLKVU[OL

MVSSV^PUNWYPUJPWSLZ!



;OL TH_PT\T WVZZPISL \ZL VM LU]PYVUTLU[HS

HUK ZHML[` [LJOUVSVN` [OH[ PZ LJVUVTPJHSS`

Q\Z[PMPHISL



,JVUVTPJHS\ZHNLVMLULYN`HUKYLZV\YJLZ



0U]VS]LTLU[VMV\YI\ZPULZZWHY[ULYZHUKJVUÌ

[YHJ[VYZ PU V\Y LMMVY[Z [V WYV[LJ[ [OL LU]PYVUÌ

TLU[



6WLUKPHSVN\L^P[OHSSZVJPHSNYV\WZ

*HSPMVYUPH7YVWVZP[PVU>HYUPUN

>HYUPUN

,UNPUL L_OH\Z[ ZVTL VM P[Z JVUZ[P[\LU[Z HUK

JLY[HPU ]LOPJSL JVTWVULU[Z JVU[HPU VY LTP[

JOLTPJHSZ RUV^U [V [OL :[H[L VM *HSPMVYUPH [V

JH\ZL JHUJLY HUK IPY[O KLMLJ[Z VY V[OLY YLWYVÌ

K\J[P]LOHYT

0U HKKP[PVU JLY[HPU MS\PKZ JVU[HPULK PU ]LOPJSLZ

HUKJLY[HPUWYVK\J[ZVMJVTWVULU[^LHYJVU[HPU

VYLTP[JOLTPJHSZRUV^U[V[OL:[H[LVM*HSPMVYÌ

UPH [V JH\ZL JHUJLY HUK IPY[O KLMLJ[Z VY V[OLY

YLWYVK\J[P]LOHYT

p=¤4›apm

;OL THU\MHJ[\YL VM 7VYZJOL ]LOPJSLZ PU H MHJÌ

[VY`HKQHJLU[[VHYLZPKLU[PHSHYLHYLX\PYLZTVYL

[OHU TLYL JVTWSPHUJL ^P[O HSS SH^Z HUK YLN\SHÌ

[PVUZ

>OL[OLYPUWYVK\J[PVUVYYLWHPY7VYZJOLHS^H`Z

YLSPLZVULU]PYVUTLU[HSS`MYPLUKS`[LJOUVSVN`

(UL_HTWSLVM[OPZPZ[OL^H[LYÌIHZLKWHPU[\ZLK

PUV\YWHPU[PUNPUZ[HSSH[PVU

>H[LYÌIHZL WHPU[Z HUK UL^ WHPU[PUNTL[OVKZYLÌ

K\JLZVS]LU[LTPZZPVUZI`WLYJLU[

(UK[OL^H[LY\ZLKPU[OLWHPU[PUNPUZ[HSSH[PVUPZ

YLÌJPYJ\SH[LK >HZ[L ^H[LY SLH]LZ [OL 7VYZJOL

MHJ[VY`VUS`HM[LYILPUNHWWYVWYPH[LS`[YLH[LK

( ^HZ[LÌTHUHNLTLU[ Z`Z[LT OHZ ILLU PU[YVÌ

K\JLK[VYLK\JL[OLHTV\U[VM^HZ[L^OPSLZPTÌ

\S[HULV\ZS`PUJYLHZPUN[OLYLJ`JSPUNYH[L

–˜˜



background image

m¦apmhFm›"dd©˜OaFm=d©˜¦F^a4dF’

4VKLYU LU]PYVUTLU[HS [LJOUVSVN` LUZ\YLZ JVTÌ

WSPHUJL ^P[O HSS LTPZZPVU SH^Z HWWSPJHISL ^VYSKÌ

^PKL

;OLZLOH]L[OLMVSSV^PUNHK]HU[HNLZ!



9HWPK VWLYH[PVUHS YLHKPULZZ VM [OL JH[HS`[PJ

JVU]LY[LYZ LUZ\YLZ SV^ LTPZZPVUZ L]LU PU

ZOVY[Ì[YPWVWLYH[PVU



9LSPHISLVWLYH[PVUHUKNVVKLTPZZPVUJVU[YVS

V]LYHSVUN\ZLM\SSPML

7SLHZLUV[L[OLJOHW[LYs-\LS,JVUVT`r

F4©4damV˜J˜Op˜"˜p’4^F:˜›^a’˜a’

¦a›¤"dd©˜"m˜"4"=Fha4˜„¤F’›apm

4VYL [OHU [^VÌ[OPYKZ VM HSS 7VYZJOLZ L]LY I\PS[

HYLZ[PSSY\UUPUN

1\Z[PUJHZLYLJ`JSPUNPZL]LYULJLZZHY`

^L[HRL[OLMVSSV^PUNWYLJH\[PVUHY`

TLHZ\YLZ!



0KLU[PMPJH[PVUVMHSSTH[LYPHSZ



<ZLVMYLJ`JSHISLTH[LYPHSZ



9L\ZHISLJVTWVULU[ZKLZPNULKMVYZPTWSL

YLTV]HS



;OLZL YLHZVUZ YLZ\S[ PU H M\Y[OLY PUJYLHZL PU

[OL YLJ`JSPUN YH[L ^OPJO PZ J\YYLU[S`  WLY

JLU[

ha’’apm˜4pm›pd˜a’˜*¤ad›˜am

0UUV]H[P]L LUNPUL [LJOUVSVN` JVTIPULZ OPNO LUÌ

NPUL WLYMVYTHUJL HUK LU]PYVUTLU[HS JVTWH[PÌ

IPSP[`

;OLLUNPULKPHNUVZPZZ`Z[LTLSLJ[YVUPJHSS`TVUPÌ

[VYZ[OLJVTWVULU[ZHUKZ`Z[LTZ[OH[HMMLJ[L_Ì

OH\Z[NHZLZ

;OPZJVU[PU\V\ZTVUP[VYPUNHUKMH\S[Z[VYHNLLUÌ

HISLZ Z^PM[ YLSPHISL KPHNUVZPZ HUK MH\S[ KL[LJÌ

[PVU

(U` MH\S[ TLZZHNLZ HYL PUKPJH[LK [V [OL KYP]LY

I` [OL s*OLJR ,UNPULr ^HYUPUN SPNO[ HUK [OL VUÌ

IVHYKJVTW\[LY



•

background image

zF"›apm˜pO˜4phh¤ma4"›apm

’©’›Fh’˜"m=˜F„¤azhFm›˜§^adF

=a¦amV

>HYUPUN

;OLYL PZ H KHUNLY VM HU HJJPKLU[ PM `V\

VWLYH[L VY ZL[ [OL VUÍIVHYK JVTW\[LY

YHKPV UH]PNH[PVU Z`Z[LT [LSLWOVUL VY

V[OLYLX\PWTLU[^OLUKYP]PUN

;OPZJV\SKKPZ[YHJ[`V\MYVT[OL[YHMMPJHUK

JH\ZL`V\[VSVZLJVU[YVSVM[OL]LOPJSL

6WLYH[L[OLLX\PWTLU[^OPSLKYP]PUNVUS`PM[OL

[YHMMPJZP[\H[PVUHSSV^Z`V\[VKVZVZHMLS`

*HYY` V\[ HU` JVTWSPJH[LK VWLYH[PUN VY

ZL[[PUN WYVJLK\YLZ VUS` ^P[O [OL ]LOPJSL

Z[H[PVUHY`

p›"*dF˜ ¤Fd˜pm›"amF’

+HUNLY

7VY[HISL M\LS JVU[HPULYZ M\SS VY WHY[PHSS`

LTW[` TH` SLHR JH\ZPUN HU L_WSVZPVU VY

YLZ\S[PUMPYLPUJHZLVMHUHJJPKLU[

5L]LY JHYY` HKKP[PVUHS M\LS PU WVY[HISL JVUÌ

[HPULYZPU`V\Y]LOPJSL

mVamF˜¨^"¤’›

+HUNLY

,UNPULL_OH\Z[PZKHUNLYV\ZPMPUOHSLK

,UNPUL L_OH\Z[ M\TLZ OH]L THU` JVTWVÍ

ULU[Z ^OPJO `V\ JHU ZTLSS ;OL` HSZV JVUÍ

[HPU JHYIVU TVUV_PKL *6 ^OPJO PZ H JVÍ

SVYSLZZHUKVKVYSLZZNHZ

*HYIVU TVUV_PKL JHU JH\ZL \UJVUZJPV\ZÍ

ULZZHUKL]LUKLH[OPMPUOHSLK

5L]LY Z[HY[ VY SL[ [OL LUNPUL Y\U PU HU LUÌ

JSVZLK\U]LU[PSH[LKHYLH

0[ PZ UV[ YLJVTTLUKLK [V ZP[ PU `V\Y JHY MVY

WYVSVUNLKWLYPVKZ^P[O[OLLUNPULVUHUK[OL

JHYUV[TV]PUN

p’4^F˜F"ha4˜phzp’a›F

"cF˜|}

;OL OPNOÌWLYMVYTHUJL IYHRL Z`Z[LT PZ KLZPNULK

MVYVW[PTHSIYHRPUNLMMLJ[H[HSSZWLLKZHUK[LTÌ

WLYH[\YLZ

*LY[HPUZWLLKZIYHRPUNMVYJLZHUKHTIPLU[JVUÌ

KP[PVUZZ\JOHZ[LTWLYH[\YLHUKO\TPKP[`[OLYLÌ

MVYLTPNO[JH\ZLIYHRLUVPZLZ

>LHY VU [OL KPMMLYLU[ JVTWVULU[Z HUK IYHRPUN

Z`Z[LT Z\JO HZ IYHRL WHKZ VY IYHRL KPZJZ

KLWLUKZ[VHNYLH[L_[LU[VU[OLPUKP]PK\HSKYP]Ì

PUNZ[`SLHUK[OLJVUKP[PVUZVM\ZLHUK[OLYLMVYL

JHUUV[ IL L_WYLZZLK PU HJ[\HS TPSLZ VU [OL

YVHK

;OL]HS\LZJVTT\UPJH[LKI`7VYZJOLHYLIHZLK

VU UVYTHS VWLYH[PVU HKHW[LK [V [YHMMPJ >LHY

PUJYLHZLZ JVUZPKLYHIS` ^OLU [OL ]LOPJSL PZ

KYP]LU VU YHJL [YHJRZ VY [OYV\NO HU HNNYLZZP]L

KYP]PUNZ[`SL

7SLHZL JVUZ\S[ `V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY

HIV\[ [OL J\YYLU[ N\PKLSPULZ PU LMMLJ[ ILMVYL

Z\JO\ZLVM`V\Y]LOPJSL

G˜˜



background image

pm›pd’:˜ m’›¤hFm›’

ss˜J˜s¢

^aO›amV˜ F"

s¢Q˜J˜s¢

"am›Fm"m4F:˜"˜"F

s˜J˜sQG

"4›a4"d˜az’:˜hFVFm4©˜F¦a4F

sQn˜J˜¢¬¢

F^a4dF˜ =Fm›aOa4"›apm:˜F4^ma4"d˜"›"

¢¬˜J˜¢sQ

m=F¨

¢s–˜J˜¢¢¬



n

background image

s¬˜˜



background image

pm›pd’:˜ m’›¤hFm›’

)LMVYLKYP]PUNVMM

)YLHRPUOPU[Z 

2L`Z[OLM[WYV[LJ[PVU u

0TTVIPSPaLYZLJ\YP[`^OLLSIVS[Z 

+VVYZKVVY^PUKV^Z

*LU[YHSSVJRPUN u

(SHYTZ`Z[LTPUMYHYLKWHZZLUNLY

JVTWHY[TLU[TVUP[VYPUN 

7V^LY^PUKV^Z 

4PYYVYZPUZPKLHUKKVVY

9LHY^PUKV^KLMVNNLY

KVVYTPYYVYOLH[PUN 

:LH[Zu

:[LLYPUN^OLLSHKQ\Z[TLU[ 

:HML[`ILS[Zu

*OPSKYLZ[YHPU[Z`Z[LTZ u

(PYIHNZ`Z[LT 

7HYRPUNHPKZ 

9L[YHJ[HISLYLHYZWVPSLY 

*S\[JOWHYRPUNIYHRLIYHRLZu

():IYHRLZ`Z[LT 

7:47VYZJOLZ[HIPSP[`THUHNLTLU[ 

-V\YÌ^OLLSKYP]L 

+HZOIVHYKJVU[YVSZHUKPUZ[Y\TLU[Zu

0NUP[PVUZ[HY[LYZ^P[JO 

:[HY[PUNHUKZ[VWWPUN[OLLUNPUL

0UZ[Y\TLU[WHULS  u 

6UÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY  u 

,TLYNLUJ`MSHZOLYZ^P[JO 

3PNO[Z^P[JO

H\[VTH[PJOLHKSPNO[ILHTHKQ\Z[TLU[  

;\YUZPNUHSZ

OLHKSPNO[KPTTLYMSHZOLYSL]LY 

>PUKZOPLSK^PWLY^HZOLYSL]LY

YHPUZLUZVY   

(\[VTH[PJZWLLKJVU[YVS 

(\[VTH[PJHPYJVUKP[PVULY u

*LU[YHSHUKZPKL]LU[Z 

(ZO[YH`JPNHYL[[LSPNO[LY  

9LHY^PWLYZ\U]PZVYZ 

0U[LYPVYSPNO[Z  

:[VYHNLPU[OLWHZZLUNLYJVTWHY[TLU[

*+VYJHZZL[[LOVSKLY 

-YVU[HUKYLHYSPKZ  

3\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[  

;Y\URLU[YHWTLU[ 

7*47VYZJOLJVTT\UPJH[PVUTHUHNLTLU[  

*\WOVSKLY 

*HY[LSLWOVULHUKHM[LYTHYRLKHSHYTZ 

*HYH\KPVVWLYH[PVU[PWZ  

9VVM[YHUZWVY[Z`Z[LT 

3PM[PUNZSPKPUNYVVM u

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

ss

background image

F"˜p’4^F˜§mF

( SV[ OHZ NVUL PU[V [OL THU\MHJ[\YL VM `V\Y

7VYZJOL PUJS\KPUN HK]HUJLK LUNPULLYPUN YPNPK

X\HSP[`JVU[YVSHUKKLTHUKPUNPUZWLJ[PVUZ

;OLZL LUNPULLYPUN HUK ZHML[` MLH[\YLZ ^PSS IL

LUOHUJLKI``V\

›^F˜’"OF˜=a¦F

^OVRUV^ZOPZJHYHUKHSSJVU[YVSZ

^OVTHPU[HPUZ[OL]LOPJSLWYVWLYS`

^OV\ZLZKYP]PUNZRPSSZ^PZLS`HUKHS^H`ZKYP]LZ

^P[OPU OLYOPZ V^U JHWHIPSP[PLZ HUK [OL SL]LS VM

MHTPSPHYP[`^P[O[OL]LOPJSL

@V\ ^PSS MPUK OLSWM\S OPU[Z PU [OPZ THU\HS VU OV^

[V WLYMVYT TVZ[ VM [OL JOLJRZ SPZ[LK VU [OL

MVSSV^PUNWHNLZ

0M PU KV\I[ OH]L [OLZL JOLJRZ WLYMVYTLK I`

`V\YH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

FOpF˜=a¦amV˜pOO

^F4c˜›^F˜Opddp§amV˜a›Fh’˜Oa’›

;\YU [OL LUNPUL VMM ILMVYL `V\ H[[LTW[ HU`

JOLJRZVYYLWHPYZVU[OL]LOPJSL

)LZ\YL[OL[PYLZHYLPUMSH[LKJVYYLJ[S`

*OLJR[PYLZMVYKHTHNLHUK[PYL^LHY

:LL [OH[ ^OLLS IVS[Z HYL WYVWLYS` [PNO[LULK

HUKUV[SVVZLVYTPZZPUN

*OLJRLUNPULVPSSL]LSHKKPMULJLZZHY`

4HRL P[ H OHIP[ [V OH]L LUNPUL VPS JOLJRLK

^P[OL]LY`M\LSMPSSPUN

*OLJR HSS MS\PK SL]LSZ Z\JO HZ ^PUKZOPLSK

^HZOLYHUKIYHRLMS\PKSL]LSZ

)L Z\YL [OL ]LOPJSL IH[[LY` PZ ^LSS JOHYNLK

HUKJYHURZ[OLLUNPULWYVWLYS`

*OLJR HSS KVVYZ HUK SPKZ MVY WYVWLY VWLYH[PVU

HUKSH[JO[OLTWYVWLYS`

*OLJR HUK PM ULJLZZHY` YLWSHJL ^VYU VY

JYHJRLK^PWLYISHKLZ

:LL [OH[ HSS ^PUKV^Z HYL JSLHY HUK \UVIÌ

Z[Y\J[LK

*OLJR HPY PU[HRL ZSV[Z HUK HYLH IL[^LLU S\NÌ

NHNLJVTWHY[TLU[SPKHUK^PUKZOPLSKHYLMYLL

VM ZUV^ HUK PJL ZV [OL OLH[LY HUK [OL ^PUKÌ

ZOPLSK^PWLYZ^VYRWYVWLYS`

0M H JOP SK ^P SS IL YP KP UN P U [OL ]LOP JSL JOLJR

JOPSK ZLH[JOPSK ZLH[ YLZ[YHPU[ Z`Z[LT [V LUÌ

Z\YL[OH[YLZ[YHPU[ZHYLWYVWLYS`HKQ\Z[LK

*OLJR HSS L_[LYPVY HUK PU[LYPVY SPNO[Z MVY VWLYÌ

H[PVUHUK[OH[[OLSLUZLZHYLJSLHU

*OLJR [OL OLHKSP NO[Z MVY WYVWLY HP T HUK P M

ULJLZZHY`OH]L[OLTHKQ\Z[LK

*OLJR\UKLY[OL]LOPJSLMVYSLHRZ

)LZ\YLHSSS\NNHNLPZZ[V^LKZLJ\YLS`

hFVFm4©˜F„¤azhFm›

0[ PZ NVVK WYHJ[PJL [V JHYY` LTLYNLUJ` LX\PWÌ

TLU[PU`V\Y]LOPJSL

:VTLVM[OLP[LTZ`V\ZOV\SKOH]LHYL!

^PUKV^ ZJYHWLY ZUV^ IY\ZO JVU[HPULY VY IHN

VM ZHUK VY ZHS[ LTLYNLUJ` SPNO[ ZTHSS ZOV]LS

MPYZ[ÌHPKRP[L[J

s¢˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

m˜›^F˜=a¦FŒ’˜’F"›

*OLJRVWLYH[PVUVM[OLOVYU

7VZP[PVU ZLH[ MVY LHZ` YLHJO VM MVV[ WLKHSZ

HUKJVU[YVSZ

;VYLK\JL[OLWVZZPIPSP[`VMPUQ\Y`MYVT[OLHPYÌ

IHN KLWSV`TLU[ `V\ ZOV\SK HS^H`Z ZP[ IHJR

HZMHYMYVT[OLZ[LLYPUN^OLLSHZPZWYHJ[PJHS

^OPSLZ[PSSTHPU[HPUPUNM\SS]LOPJSLJVU[YVS

(KQ\Z[ [OL PUZPKL HUK V\[ZPKL YLHY ]PL^ TPYÌ

YVYZ

)\JRSL`V\YZHML[`ILS[Z

*OLJR VWLYH[PVU VM [OL MVV[ HUK WHYRPUN

IYHRL

*OLJR HSS ^HYUPUN HUK PUKPJH[VY SPNO[Z ^P[O

PNUP[PVUVUHUKLUNPULUV[Y\UUPUN

:[HY[ LUNPUL HUK JOLJR HSS ^HYUPUN KPZWSH`Z

MVY^HYUPUNZ`TIVSZ

5L]LYSLH]LHUPKSPUNJHY\UH[[LUKLK

3VJR KVVYZ MYVT PUZPKL LZWLJPHSS` ^P[O JOPSKÌ

YLU PU [OL JHY [V WYL]LU[ PUHK]LY[LU[ VWLUPUN

VMKVVYZMYVTPUZPKLVYV\[ZPKL

+YP]L^P[OKVVYZSVJRLK

m˜›^F˜p"=

5L]LY KYP]L HM[LY `V\ OH]L JVUZ\TLK HSJVOVS

VYKY\NZ

(S^H`ZOH]L`V\YZHML[`ILS[MHZ[LULK

(S^H`ZKYP]LKLMLUZP]LS`

,_WLJ[[OL\UL_WLJ[LK

<ZL ZPNUHSZ [V PUKPJH[L [\YUZ HUK SHUL

JOHUNLZ

;\YU VU OLHKSPNO[Z H[ K\ZR VY ^OLU [OL KYP]Ì

PUNJVUKP[PVUZ^HYYHU[P[

(S^H`Z RLLW H ZHML KPZ[HUJL MYVT [OL]LOPJSL

PUMYVU[VM`V\KLWLUKPUNVU[YHMMPJYVHKHUK

^LH[OLYJVUKP[PVUZ

9LK\JL ZWLLK H[ UPNO[ HUK K\YPUN PUJSLTLU[

^LH[OLY

+YP]PUN PU ^L[ ^LH[OLY YLX\PYLZ JH\[PVU HUK

YLK\JLK ZWLLKZ WHY[PJ\SHYS` VU YVHKZ ^P[O

Z[HUKPUN ^H[LY HZ [OL OHUKSPUN JOHYHJÌ

[LYPZ[PJZ VM [OL ]LOPJSL TH` IL PTWHPYLK K\L

[VO`KYVWSHUPUNVM[OL[PYLZ

(S^H`Z VIZLY]L ZWLLK SPTP[Z HUK VIL` YVHK

ZPNUZHUK[YHMMPJSH^Z

>OLU [PYLK NL[ ^LSS VMM [OL YVHK Z[VW HUK

[HRLHYLZ[;\YU[OLLUNPULVMM+VUV[ZP[PU

[OL]LOPJSL^P[OLUNPULPKSPUN

:LL^HYUPUNZVUs,UNPUL,_OH\Z[r

>OLU WHYRLK HS^H`Z ZL[ [OL WHYRPUN IYHRL

4V]L[OL;PW[YVUPJZLSLJ[VYSL]LY[Vs7rVY[OL

NLHYZOPM[SL]LY[VYL]LYZLVYMPYZ[NLHY

6U OPSSZ HSZV [\YU [OL MYVU[ ^OLLSZ [V^HYK [OL

J\YI

>OLU LTLYNLUJ` YLWHPYZ ILJVTL ULJLZZHY`

TV]L [OL ]LOPJSL ^LSS VMM [OL YVHK ;\YU VU

[OL LTLYNLUJ` MSHZOLY HUK \ZL V[OLY^HYUPUN

KL]PJLZ [V HSLY[ V[OLY TV[VYPZ[Z +V UV[ WHYR

VYVWLYH[L[OL]LOPJSLPUHYLHZ^OLYL[OLOV[

L_OH\Z[Z`Z[LTTH`JVTLPUJVU[HJ[^P[OKY`

NYHZZIY\ZOM\LSZWPSSVYV[OLYMSHTTHISLTHÌ

[LYPHS

4HRLP[HOHIP[[VOH]L[OLLUNPULVPSJOLJRLK

^P[OL]LY`M\LSMPSSPUN

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

F"c˜ m˜ am›’˜Op˜›^F˜Oa’›˜

¢¬¬¬˜hadF’˜|¬¬¬˜cadphF›F’}

;OLMVSSV^PUN[PWZ^PSSILOLSWM\SPUVI[HPUPUNVW[PÌ

T\TWLYMVYTHUJLMYVT`V\YUL^7VYZJOL

+LZWP[L [OL TVZ[ TVKLYU OPNOÌWYLJPZPVU THU\Ì

MHJ[\YPUN TL[OVKZ P[ JHUUV[ IL JVTWSL[LS`

H]VPKLK [OH[ [OL TV]PUN WHY[Z OH]L [V ^LHY PU

^P[OLHJOV[OLY;OPZ^LHYPUNÌPUVJJ\YZTHPUS`PU

[OLMPYZ[TPSLZRT

^FFOpF9

7YLMLYHIS`[HRLSVUNLY[YPWZ

(]VPK MYLX\LU[ JVSK Z[HY[Z ^P[O ZOVY[ÌKPZ[HUJL

KYP]PUN^OLUL]LYWVZZPISL

(]VPKM\SS[OYV[[SLZ[HY[ZHUKHIY\W[Z[VWZ

+V UV[ L_JLLK TH_PT\T LUNPUL ZWLLK VM

YWTYL]VS\[PVUZWLYTPU\[L

+VUV[Y\UHJVSKLUNPULH[OPNOYWTLP[OLYPU

5L\[YHSVYPUNLHY

+V UV[ SL[ [OL LUNPUL SHIVY LZWLJPHSS` ^OLU

KYP]PUN \WOPSS :OPM[ [V [OL UL_[ SV^LY NLHY PU

[PTL\ZL[OLTVZ[MH]VYHISLYWTYHUNL

5L]LY S\N [OL LUNPUL PU OPNO NLHY H[ SV^

ZWLLKZ;OPZY\SLHWWSPLZH[HSS[PTLZUV[Q\Z[

K\YPUN[OLIYLHRÌPUWLYPVK

+V UV[ WHY[PJPWH[L PU TV[VY YHJPUN L]LU[Z

ZWVY[Z KYP]PUN ZJOVVSZ L[J K\YPUN [OL MPYZ[

TPSLZRT

;OLYL TH` IL H ZSPNO[ Z[PMMULZZ PU [OL Z[LLYPUN

NLHYÌZOPM[PUNVYV[OLYJVU[YVSZK\YPUN[OLIYLHRÌPU

WLYPVK^OPJO^PSSNYHK\HSS`KPZHWWLHY

F"c˜am˜*"cF˜z"=’

5L^ IYHRL WHKZ HUK IYHRL KPZJZ OH]L [V IL

rIYVRLU PUs HUK [OLYLMVYL VUS` H[[HPU VW[PTHS

MYPJ[PVU ^OLU [OL JHY OHZ JV]LYLK ZL]LYHS O\UÌ

KYLKTPSLZVYRT

;OL ZSPNO[S` YLK\JLK IYHRPUN HIPSP[` T\Z[ IL

JVTWLUZH[LK MVY I` WYLZZPUN [OL IYHRL WLKHS

OHYKLY ;OPZ HSZV HWWSPLZ ^OLUL]LY [OL IYHRL

WHKZHUKIYHRLKPZJZHYLYLWSHJLK

F§˜›aF’

5L^ [PYLZ KV UV[ OH]L TH_PT\T [YHJ[PVU ;OL`

[LUK[VILZSPWWLY`

)YLHR PU UL^ [PYLZ I` KYP]PUN H[ TVKLYH[L

ZWLLKZK\YPUN[OLMPYZ[[VTPSLZ

[V  RT 3VUNLY IYHRPUN KPZ[HUJLZ T\Z[

ILHU[PJPWH[LK

mVamF˜pad˜4pm’¤hz›apm

+\YPUN [OL IYLHRÌPU WLYPVK VPS JVUZ\TW[PVU TH`

ILOPNOLY[OHUUVYTHS

(Z HS^H`Z [OL YH[L VM VPS JVUZ\TW[PVU KLWLUKZ

VU [OL X\HSP[` HUK ]PZJVZP[` VM VPS [OL ZWLLK H[

^OPJO [OL LUNPUL PZ VWLYH[LK [OL JSPTH[L HUK

YVHK JVUKP[PVUZ HZ ^LSS HZ [OL HTV\U[ VM KPS\Ì

[PVUHUKV_PKH[PVUVM[OLS\IYPJHU[

4HRLHOHIP[VMJOLJRPUNLUNPULVPS^P[OL]LY`

M\LSMPSSPUNHKKPMULJLZZHY`

sT˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

  0UULYKVVYOHUKSL

  +VVYTPYYVYJVU[YVS

  3PNO[Z^P[JO

  0NUP[PVUZ[HY[LYZ^P[JO^P[OZ[LLYPUNSVJR

  ;\YUZPNUHSOLHKSPNO[KPTTLY

 MSHZOLYSL]LY

  ;VNNSLZ^P[JOLZMVY;PW[YVUPJ

  ,TLYNLUJ`MSHZOLYZ^P [JO

  /VYU

  .SV]LJVTWHY[TLU[

 7HYRPUNIYHRL

 +PHNUVZ[PJZVJRL[

 6WLYH[PUNSL]LYMVYVUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY

 3\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[SPKYLSLHZL

 :LH[HKQ\Z[TLU[

 :[LLYPUNÌ^OLLSHKQ\Z[TLU[

 ,UNPULJVTWHY[TLU[SPKYLSLHZL

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

sQ

background image

F¦F˜am¦a›F˜4"˜›^FO›M

(U\USVJRLKJHY^P[O[OLRL`PU[OLPNUP[PVUSVJR

PU]P[LZJHY[OLM[

( Z[LLYP UN ^OLLS SVJR HUK H NVUN HSHYT HYL

Z[HUKHYKLX\PWTLU[PU`V\Y7VYZJOL

;OL NVUN HSHYT ^PSS ZV\UK PM `V\ VWLU [OL

KYP]LYqZ KVVY ^OPSL [OL RL` PZ Z[PSS PU [OL PNUP[PVU

SVJR 0[ PZ `V\Y YLTPUKLY [V W\SS [OL RL` V\[ VM

[OLPNUP[PVUSVJRHUK[VSVJR[OLKVVYZ

>HYUPUN

(U` \UJVU[YVSSLK TV]LTLU[ VM [OL ]LOPJSL

TH` YLZ\S[ PU ZLYPV\Z WLYZVUHS PUQ\Y` HUK

WYVWLY[`KHTHNL

5L]LY SLH]L `V\Y ]LOPJSL \UH[[LUKLK ^P[O

[OL RL` PU [OL PNUP[PVU SVJR LZWLJPHSS` PM

JOPSKYLU HUKVY WL[Z HYL SLM[ \UH[[LUKLK PU

[OL ]LOPJSL ;OL` JHU VWLYH[L WV^LY ^PUÍ

KV^Z HUK V[OLY JVU[YVSZ 0M [OL LUNPUL PZ

SLM[ Y\UUPUN [OL` TH` HJJPKLU[HSS` LUNHNL

[OLZOPM[SL]LY

(S^H`ZYLTV]L[OLPNUP[PVURL`

(S^H`ZZL[[OLWHYRPUNIYHRL

3VJR [OL KVVYZ ^P[O [OL RL` VY ^P[O [OL

YLTV[LJVU[YVS

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMHZLYPV\ZHJJPKLU[

;OL Z[LLYPUN JVS\TU ^PSS SVJR ^OLU `V\

YLTV]L[OLRL`^OPSL`V\HYLKYP]PUNVYHZ

[OL JHY PZ YVSSPUN [V H Z[VW @V\ ^PSS UV[ IL

HISL[VZ[LLY[OLJHY

5L]LY YLTV]L [OL RL` MYVT [OL Z[LLYP UN SVJR

^OPSL`V\HYLKYP]PUN

;V WYV[LJ[ `V\Y ]LOPJSL HUK `V\Y WVZÍ

ZLZZPVUZMYVT[OLM[`V\ZOV\SKHS^H`ZWYVÍ

JLLKHZMVSSV^Z^OLUSLH]PUN`V\Y]LOPJSL!

*SVZL^PUKV^Z

*SVZLSPM[PUNZSPKPUNYVVM

9LTV]LPNUP[PVURL`

,UNHNLZ[LLYPUNSVJR

3VJRZ[VYHNL[YH`IL[^LLU[OLMYVU[ZLH[Z

HUKNSV]LJVTWHY[TLU[

9LTV]L ]HS\HISLZ LN JHY KVJ\TLU[Z YHKP V

JVU[YVS TVK\SL [LSLWOVUL OV\ZL RL`Z MYVT

[OLJHY

3VJRKVVYZ

s–˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

F©’

7SLHZL UV[L JOHW[LYZ s*LU[YHS 3VJRPUN HUK

(SHYT:`Z[LTr

;^V THP U RL`Z HUK VUL ZWHYL RL` HYL Z\WWSP LK

^P[O`V\Y7VYZJOL

;OLZL RL`Z VWLYH[L HSS [OL SVJRZ VU `V\Y ]LÌ

OPJSL

)L JHYLM\S ^P[O `V\Y JHY RL`Z! KV UV[ WHY[

^P[O [OLT L_JLW[ \UKLY L_JLW[PVUHS JPYJ\TÌ

Z[HUJLZ

;VH]VPKIH[[LY`Y\UÌKV^UHS^H`ZYLTV]L[OL

PNUP[PVURL`MYVT[OLPNUP[PVUSVJR

Fzd"4FhFm›˜cF©’

9LWSHJLTLU[ JHY RL`Z JHU IL VI[HPULK VUS`

MYVT `V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY HUK [OPZ

JHUZVTL[PTLZIL]LY`[PTLÌJVUZ\TPUN

@V\ZOV\SK[OLYLMVYLHS^H`ZRLLW[OLZWHYLRL`

VU`V\YWLYZVU

2LLW P[ PU H ZHML WSHJL LN ^HSSL[ I\[ \UKLY

UVJPYJ\TZ[HUJLZPUVYVU[OL]LOPJSL

;OL RL` JVKLZ VM UL^ RL`Z OH]L [V IL

sYLWVY[LKr [V [OL JHY JVU[YVS \UP[ I` `V\Y H\[OÌ

VYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

;OLRL`NYPWVM[OLZWHYLRL`JHUILL_JOHUNLK

MVYHTHPUÌRL`NYPW

+PZHISPUNRL`JVKLZ
0M H RL` PZ SVZ[ [OL RL` JVKLZ JHU IL KPZHISLK

I`HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

(SS [OL YLTHPUPUN JHY RL`Z HYL YLX\PYLK MVY [OPZ

W\YWVZL

+PZHISPUN [OL JVKL LUZ\YLZ [OH[ [OL JHY JHU IL

Z[HY[LKVUS`\ZPUNH\[OVYPaLKRL`Z

5V[L
7SLHZL UV[L [OH[ [OL V[OLYSVJRZJHUZ[PSSILVWÌ

LULK^P[O[OLKPZHISLKRL`

hhp*ada«F

;OLYL PZ H [YHUZWVUKLY HU LSLJ[YVUPJ JVTWVÌ

ULU[PU[OLRL`NYPWJVU[HPUPUNHZ[VYLKJVKL

>OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ Z^P[JOLK VU [OL PNUP[PVU

SVJRJOLJRZ[OLJVKL

;OL PTTVIPSPaLY JHU IL KLHJ[P]H[LK HUK [OL LUÌ

NPUL Z[HY[LK VUS` \ZPUN HU H\[OVYPaLK PNUP[PVU

RL`

5V[L
0M [OL PNUP[PVU PZ SLM[ VU MVY TVYL [OHU [^V

TPU\[LZ ^P[OV\[ Z[HY[PUN [OLLUNPUL[OLPTTVIPÌ

SPaLYPZYLHJ[P]H[LK

0M [OPZ OHWWLUZ [OL PNUP[PVU RL` T\Z[ IL

[\YULKIHJR[V[OLsrWVZP[PVUILMVYL[OLLUÌ

NPULJHUILZ[HY[LK

;OL PTTVIPSPaLY PZ H\[VTH[PJHSS` HJ[P]H[LK ^OLU

[OLPNUP[PVURL`PZ^P[OKYH^U

F4¤a›©˜^FFd˜pd›’

0M^OLLSZOH]L[VILYLTV]LKK\YPUNH^VYRZOVW

]PZP[ KV UV[ MVYNL[ [V OHUK V]LY [OL ZVJRL[ MVY

[OLZLJ\YP[`^OLLSIVS[ZHSVUN^P[O[OLJHYRL`

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

(Í4HPURL`

Í*LU[YHSSVJRPUNI\[[VU

Í3\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[SPKI\[[VU

Í3PNO[ÍLTP[[PUNKPVKL

)Í:WHYLRL`

F©˜§a›^˜"=ap˜Fhp›F˜pm›pd

zF"›amV˜4Fm›"d˜dp4camV:˜"d"h˜’©’›Fh

"m=˜’F"›˜hFhp©

7YLZZI\[[VU

7SLHZL VIZLY]L [OL HWWYVWYPH[L JOHW[LYZ VM [OPZ

4HU\HS

<USVJRPUNS\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[SPK

7YLZZI\[[VUMVYHWWYV_[^VZLJVUKZ

0M [OL ]LOPJSL ^HZ SVJRLK ILMVYL [OL S\NNHNL

JVTWHY[TLU[ PZ VWLULK P[ PZ \USVJRLK ZPT\S[HÌ

ULV\ZS`^P[O[OLS\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[

0U ]LOPJSLZ ^P[O ZLH[ TLTVY` [OL Z[VYLK ZLH[

HUKKVVYTPYYVYWVZP[PVUZHYLH\[VTH[PJHSS`ZL[

;OL]LOPJSL^PSSILSVJRLKHNHPUHWWYV_ZLJÌ

VUKZHM[LY[OLS\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[PZJSVZLKPM

UVULVM[OLKVVYZ^HZVWLULK

5V[L
@V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY JHU WYVNYHT

M\Y[OLY[`WLZVMS\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[\USVJRPUN

;`WL
;OLYLSVJRPUN[PTLVM[OLKVVYZJHUILHKQ\Z[LK

[VZ\P[`V\YPUKP]PK\HSYLX\PYLTLU[Z!

ÌZLJVUKZ

;`WL
;OL KVVYZ Z[H` SVJRLK ^OLU [OL S\NNHNL JVTÌ

WHY[TLU[PZ\USVJRLK

^F˜Fhp›F_4pm›pd˜’›"m=*©˜O¤m4›apm

’§a›4^F’˜pOO˜"O›F˜Q˜="©’

0M[OL]LOPJSLPZUV[Z[HY[LKVY\USVJRLK^P[O[OL

YLTV[LJVU[YVS^P[OPUMP]LKH`Z[OLYLTV[LJVUÌ

[YVS Z[HUKI` M\UJ[PVU PZ Z^P[JOLK VMM [V WYL]LU[

KPZJOHYNPUNVM[OL]LOPJSLIH[[LY`

 0U[OPZJHZL\USVJR[OLKYP]LYqZKVVY^P[O[OL

RL`H[[OLKVVYSVJR

3LH]L[OLKVVYJSVZLKPUVYKLY[VWYL]LU[[OL

HSHYTZ`Z[LTMYVTILPUN[YPNNLYLK

 7YLZZI\[[VUVU[OLYLTV[LJVU[YVS

;OLYLTV[LJVU[YVSPZUV^HJ[P]H[LKHNHPU

sG˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

pp’

mdp4camV:˜dp4camV

<USVJRVYSVJR[OLKVVYSVJRZ^P[O[OLYLTV[L

JVU[YVS VY I` \ZPUN [OL RL` PU [OL KYP]LYqZ

KVVY

0M [OL KVVY ^PUKV^Z HYL JSVZLK [OL` ^PSS IL

H\[VTH[PJHSS` VWLULK I` H ML^ TPSSPTL[LYZ ^OLU

[OL KVVYZ HYL VWLULK HUK ^OLU [OL KVVYZ HYL

JSVZLK [OL` ^PSS IL JSVZLK HNHPU ;OPZ THRLZ P[

LHZPLY[VVWLUHUKJSVZL[OLKVVYZHUKWYV[LJ[Z

[OLZLHSZ

;OLYLMVYL `V\ ZOV\SK W\SS [OL KVVY OHUKSL

ZSV^S` ZV [OH[ [OL KVVY ^PUKV^ JHU IL SV^LYLK

ILMVYL[OLKVVYPZVWLULK

zFmamV˜¤mdp4cF=˜=pp’˜Oph˜p¤›’a=F

:SV^S`W\SSKVVYOHUKSL(

zFmamV˜¤mdp4cF=˜=pp’˜Oph˜am’a=F

:SV^S`W\SSKVVYOHUKSL)

zFmamV˜dp4cF=˜=pp’˜Oph˜am’a=F

:SV^S`W\SSKVVYOHUKSL)[^PJL

(SZVYLMLY[V[OLJOHW[LYr3VJRPUNJVUKP[PVUZs

pp˜’›p"VF˜›"©

(S^H`ZRLLW[OLKVVYZ[VYHNL[YH`*JSVZLKZV

[OH[ [OL ZPKL HPYIHN PZ UV[ VIZ[Y\J[LK PU [OL

L]LU[VMHUHJJPKLU[

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

sn

background image

Fm›"d˜p4camV

<:(! -**0+3?792@"

    -**0+3?7=04

*HUHKH!;_-7"

    9_-7(

;OPZKL]PJLJVTWSPLZ^P[O!

7HY[VM[OL-**9\SLZ

9::ÌVM0UK\Z[Y`*HUHKH

6WLYH[PVUVM[OPZKL]PJLPZZ\IQLJ[[V[OLMVSSV^Ì

PUN[^VJVUKP[PVUZ!



0[TH`UV[JH\ZLOHYTM\SPU[LYMLYLUJLHUK



P[ T\Z[ HJJLW[ HU` PU[LYMLYLUJL YLJLP]LK

PUJS\KPUN PU[LYMLYLUJL [OH[ TH` JH\ZL \UÌ

KLZPYLKVWLYH[PVU

5V[L
;OL THU\MHJ[\YLY PZ UV[ YLZWVUZPISL MVY HU`

YHKPVVY;=PU[LYMLYLUJLJH\ZLKI`\UH\[OVYPaLK

TVKPMPJH[PVUZ[V[OPZLX\PWTLU[

:\JOTVKPMPJH[PVUJV\SK]VPK[OL\ZLYqZH\[OVYP[`

[VVWLYH[L[OLLX\PWTLU[

:LL [OL JOHW[LY VU s3VHK Z^P[JOÌVMMr s7V^LY

^PUKV^ZrHUKs3PM[PUNZSPKPUNYVVMr

)V[O JHY KVVYZ HUK [OL MPSSLY MSHW JHU IL JLUÌ

[YHSS` \USVJRLK VY SVJRLK ^P[O [OL YLTV[L JVUÌ

[YVS

0M[OLKYP]LYqZKVVYPZUV[JVTWSL[LS`JSVZLK[OL

]LOPJSLJHUUV[ILSVJRLK

( ZOVY[ ZPNUHS MYVT [OL HSHYT OVYU ^PSS KYH^

`V\Y H[[LU[PVU [V [OL MHJ[ [OH[ [OL MVSSV^PUN

JVTWVULU[Z HYL UV[ JVTWSL[LS` JSVZLK ^OLU

`V\[Y`[VSVJR[OL]LOPJSL!



7HZZLUNLYqZKVVY



3\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[SPK



,UNPULJVTWHY[TLU[SPK



:[VYHNL[YH`



.SV]LJVTWHY[TLU[

5V[L
<USVJRPUN [OL ]LOPJSL I` \ZPUN [OL RL` PU [OL

KVVYSVJRHUKVWLUPUN[OLKVVYTH`HJ[P]H[L[OL

HSHYTZ`Z[LT^P[OPUZLJVUKZ

¤›ph"›a4˜Fdp4camV

0M [OL JHY PZ \USVJRLK I` YLTV[L JVU[YVS HUK

UVUL VM [OL JHY KVVYZ PZ VWLULK ^P[OPU HWWYV_

ZLJVUKZH\[VTH[PJYLSVJRPUN[HRLZWSHJL

;OPZYLSVJRPUN[PTLJHUILHKHW[LK[V`V\YPUKPÌ

]PK\HS YLX\PYLTLU[Z  Ì  ZLJVUKZ I` HU

H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

p4camV˜4pm=a›apm’

3VJRJHYVUJL

;OL KVVYZ JHUUV[ IL VWLULK MYVT [OL V\[Ì

ZPKL

(SHYT Z`Z[LT HUK PUMYHYLK WHZZLUNLY JVTÌ

WHY[TLU[TVUP[VYPUNHYLZ^P[JOLKVU

0MHWLYZVUVYHUPTHSYLTHPUZPU[OL

]LOPJSL!

8\PJRS`SVJRJHY[^PJL

;OL KVVYZ JHUUV[ IL VWLULK MYVT [OL V\[Ì

ZPKL

;OLPUMYHYLKWHZZLUNLYJVTWHY[TLU[TVUP[VYÌ

PUNPZZ^P[JOLKVMM

<USVJRPUN[OLKVVY^P[O[OLPUULYKVVY

OHUKSL
(U` WLYZVU YLTHPUPUN PU [OL SVJRLK JHY JHU

VWLU[OLKVVY^P[O[OLPUULYKVVYOHUKSL!

 7\SS PUULY KVVY OHUKSL VUJL [V \USVJR KVVY

SVJR

 7\SSPUULYKVVYOHUKSLHNHPU[VVWLUKVVY

5V[L
0UMVYT HU` WLYZVU YLTHPUPUN PU [OL JHY [OH[ [OL

HSHYTZ`Z[LT^PSSIL[YPNNLYLKPM[OLKVVYPZVWÌ

LULK

¢¬˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

hFVFm4©˜pzF"›apm˜J˜pzFmamV

<USVJR [OL KYP]LYqZ KVVY ^P[O [OL RL` H[ [OL

KVVYSVJR

6WLU [OL KVVY HUK Z^P [JO [OL P NUP [P VU VU

^P[OPU  ZLJVUKZ PU VYKLY [V WYL]LU[ [OL

HSHYTZ`Z[LTMYVTILPUN[YPNNLYLK

hFVFm4©˜pzF"›apm˜J˜4dp’amV

8\PJRS` [\YU [OL RL` PU [OL KYP]LYqZ KVVY SVJR

[V [OL SVJR WVZP[PVU [OYLL [PTLZ P U Z\JÌ

JLZZPVU

0M [OLYL PZ H KLMLJ[ PU [OL JLU[YHS SVJRPUN Z`ZÌ

[LT HSS M\UJ[PVUPUN LSLTLU[Z VM [OL JLU[YHS

SVJRPUNZ`Z[LT^PSSILSVJRLK

;OLHSHYTZ`Z[LTPZZ^P[JOLKVU

;OLPUMYHYLKWHZZLUNLYJVTWHY[TLU[TVUP[VYÌ

PUNZ`Z[LTPZZ^P[JOLKVMM

;OL MH\S[ ZOV\SK IL YLTLKPLK PTTLKPH[LS` H[ HU

H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

m=a4"›apm˜*©˜FhFVFm4©˜Od"’^F˜"m=˜

"d"h˜^pm

0M [OL YLTV[L JVU[YVS PZ \ZLK MVY \USVJRPUN VY

SVJRPUN H YLZWVUZL PZ WYV]PKLK I` [OL LTLYÌ

NLUJ`MSHZOLY!



<USVJRPUNuZPUNSLMSHZO



3VJRPUNuKV\ISLMSHZO



3VJRPUN[^PJLuJVU[PU\V\ZPSS\TPUH[PVUMVYHWÌ

WYV_ZLJVUKZHUKZOVY[HSHYTÌOVYUZPNUHS

Fm›"d˜dp4camV˜’§a›4^

;OLJLU[YHSSVJRPUNZ^P[JOVU[OLKHZOIVHYKSL[Z

`V\SVJRHUK\USVJRIV[OKVVYZLSLJ[YPJHSS`

5V[L
0M [OL KVVYZ HYL SVJRLK ^P[O [OL RL` VY YLTV[L

JVU[YVS[OL`JHUUV[ILVWLULKI`WYLZZPUN[OL

JLU[YHSSVJRPUNZ^P[JO

3VJRPUN

7YLZZ[OLYVJRLYÌZ^P[JOZ`TIVS

0UKPJH[VYSPNO[SPNO[Z\WPMPNUP[PVUPZVU

<USVJRPUN

7YLZZ[OLYVJRLYÌZ^P[JOPUKPJH[VYSPNO[

0UKPJH[VYSPNO[NVLZV\[

0M[OLKVVYZ^LYLSVJRLK^P[O[OLJLU[YHSSVJRPUN

Z^P[JO [OL` JHU IL VWLULK I` W\SSPUN [OL PUULY

KVVYOHUKSL!

 7\SS PUULY KVVY OHUKSL VUJL [V \USVJR KVVY

SVJR

 7\SSPUULYKVVYOHUKSLHNHPU[VVWLUKVVY

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

¢s

background image

¤›ph"›a4˜=pp˜dp4camV

@V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY JHU WYVNYHT

KP]LYZL [`WLZ VM H\[VTH[PJ KVVY SVJRPUN PU [OL

JVU[YVS\UP[VM[OLJLU[YHSSVJRPUNZ`Z[LT!

;`WL
+VVYZ SVJR H\[VTH[PJHSS` ^OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ

Z^P[JOLKVU

;`WL
+VVYZSVJRH\[VTH[PJHSS`^OLUHZWLLKVMÌ

RTOÌTWOPZL_JLLKLK

;`WL
+VVYZ SVJR H\[VTH[PJHSS` ^OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ

Z^P[JOLK VU 0M KVVYZ HYL VWLULK ^P[O [OL LUÌ

NPULY\UUPUN[OL`SVJRHNHPUH\[VTH[PJHSS`^OLU

H ZWLLK VM  Ì  RTO  Ì  TWO PZ L_Ì

JLLKLK

;`WL
;OLKVVYZKVUV[SVJRH\[VTH[PJHSS`

5V[L
(\[VTH[PJHSS`SVJRLKKVVYZJHUIL\USVJRLK^P[O

[OL JLU[YHS SVJRPUN I\[[VU VY VWLULK I` W\SSPUN

VU[OLPUZPKLKVVYOHUKSL[^PJL

>HYUPUN

0U HU LTLYNLUJ` ZP[\H[PVU ^OLYL `V\ ULLK

[V L_P[ [OL JHY [OYV\NO HU H\[VTH[PJHSS`

SVJRLK KVVY YLTLTILY [OL MVSSV^PUN WYVÍ

JLK\YL[VVWLU[OLKVVY

<USVJR[OLKVVYZI`WYLZZPUN[OLJLU[YHSSVJRÌ

PUNI\[[VUVY

W\SS [OL PUZPKL KVVY OHUKSL[^PJL[VVWLU[OL

KVVY

"¤d›˜am=a4"›apm

(KV\ISLOVYUZPNUHSK\YPUNSVJRPUNPUKPJH[LZH

KLMLJ[PU[OLJLU[YHSSVJRPUNVYHSHYTZ`Z[LT

/H]L [OL KLMLJ[ YLTLKPLK H[ HU H\[OVYPaLK

7VYZJOLKLHSLY

¦Fdp"=˜zp›F4›apm

0M [OL JLU[YHS SVJRP UN Z`Z[LT P Z VWLYH[LK TVYL

[OHU[LU[PTLZ^P[OPUHTPU\[LM\Y[OLYVWLYH[PVU

PZISVJRLKMVYZLJVUKZ

(Í3PNO[ÍLTP[[PUNKPVKLMVYHSHYTZ`Z[LT

)Í:LUZVYTVK\SLMVYPUMYHYLKWHZZLUNLYJVTWHY[TLU[

  TVUP[VYPUNZ`Z[LT

d"h˜©’›Fh:˜

mO"F=˜"’’FmVF˜phz"›hFm›

pma›pamV

;OL HSHYT Z`Z[LT HUK PUMYHYLK WHZZLUNLY JVTÌ

WHY[TLU[ TVUP[VYPUN Z`Z[LT HYL Z^P[JOLK VU

^OLU [OL KVVYZ HYL SVJRLK ^P[O [OL RL` VY

YLTV[LJVU[YVS

:LL[OLJOHW[LYVUs*LU[YHSSVJRPUNr

¢¢˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

<USVJRPUN [OL ]LOPJSL I` \ZPUN [OL RL` PU

[OL KVVY SVJR HUK VWLUPUN [OL KVVY TH`

HJ[P]H[L [OL HSHYT Z`Z[LT ^P[OPU  ZLJÍ

VUKZ

¤m4›apm˜am=a4"›apm

0M [OL HSHYT Z`Z[LT PZ HJ[P]H[LK SPNO[ÌLTP[[PUN

KPVKL(VU[OLKHZOIVHYKMSHZOLZ

0MHM[LYSVJRPUN[OLSPNO[ÌLTP[[PUNKPVKLKVLZUV[

MSHZO VY HM[LY [LU ZLJVUKZ P[ LTP[Z KV\ISL

MSHZOLZ[OLUUV[HSSHSHYTJVU[HJ[ZHYLJSVZLK

(KKP[PVUHSS`HIYPLMOVYUZPNUHSZV\UKZ

>OLU[OLKVVYZHYL\USVJRLK[OLHSHYTZ`Z[LT

HUKPUMYHYLKWHZZLUNLYJVTWHY[TLU[TVUP[VYPUN

Z`Z[LT HYL Z^P[JOLK VMM HUK [OL SPNO[ÌLTP[[PUN

KPVKLNVLZVMM

^Fm˜›^F˜"d"h˜a’˜"hF=:˜›^F˜Opddp§amV

"F"’˜"F˜hpma›pF=


+VVYZ



3\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[SPK



,UNPULJVTWHY[TLU[SPK



9HKPV



.SV]LJVTWHY[TLU[



:[VYHNL[YH`IL[^LLU[OLMYVU[ZLH[Z



7HZZLUNLYJVTWHY[TLU[

0MVULVM[OLZLHSHYTJVU[HJ[ZPZPU[LYY\W[LK[OL

HSHYTOVYUZV\UKZMVYHWWYV_PTH[LS`TPU\[LZ

(KKP[PVUHSS` [OL LTLYNLUJ` MSHZOLY HUK [OLWHZÌ

ZLUNLY JVTWHY[TLU[ SPNO[ MSHZO MVY HWWYV_PÌ

TH[LS`MP]LTPU\[LZ

>OLU [OL HSHYT PZ [YPNNLYLK [OL SPNO[ÌLTP[[PUN

KPVKLJOHUNLZV]LY[VKV\ISLMSHZOLZ

0UVYKLYUV[[VSPTP[[OLHJ[PVUYHUNLVM[OLPUMYHÌ

YLKWHZZLUNLYJVTWHY[TLU[TVUP[VYPUNZ`Z[LT!

4V]LZ\U]PZVYZ[VVULVM[OLMPUHSWVZP[PVUZ

+VUV[MVSK[OLMYVU[ZLH[IHJRYLZ[ZMVY^HYK

F"4›a¦"›amV˜›^F˜amO"F=˜z"’’FmVF

4phz"›hFm›˜hpma›pamV˜’©’›Fh˜Op

pmF˜dp4camV˜zp4F’’

0M H WLYZVUVYHUPTHSYLTHPUZPU[OLJHY^OPSLP[

PZ SVJRLK [OL PUMYHYLK WHZZLUNLY JVTWHY[TLU[

TVUP[VYPUNZ`Z[LTT\Z[ILZ^P[JOLKVMM

8\PJRS`SVJRJHY[^PJL

;OL KVVYZ HYL SVJRLK I\[ JHU IL VWLULK

MYVT[OLPUZPKL!

 7\SS PUULY KVVY OHUKSL VUJL [V \USVJR KVVY

SVJR

 7\SSPUULYKVVYOHUKSLHNHPU[VVWLUKVVY

5V[L
0UMVYT HU` WLYZVU YLTHPUPUN PU [OL JHY [OH[ [OL

HSHYTZ`Z[LT^PSSIL[YPNNLYLKPM[OLKVVYPZVWÌ

LULK

"¤d›˜am=a4"›apm

(KV\ISLOVYUZPNUHSK\YPUNSVJRPUNPUKPJH[LZH

KLMLJ[PU[OLJLU[YHSSVJRPUNVYHSHYTZ`Z[LT

/H]L [OL KLMLJ[ YLTLKPLK H[ HU H\[OVYPaLK

7VYZJOLKLHSLY

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

¢

background image

p§F˜am=p§’

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMHUHJJPKLU[

+V UV[ W\[ HU`[OPUN VU VY ULHY [OL ^PUKV^Z

[OH[TH`PU[LYMLYL^P[O[OLKYP]LYqZ]PZPVU

9PZRVMPUQ\Y`^OLU[OLKVVY^PUKV^ZJSVZL

;OPZ HWWSPLZ LZWLJPHSS` PM [OL ^PUKV^Z HYL

JSVZLK ^P[O [OL JVTMVY[ M\UJ[PVU ILJH\ZL

^P[O[OPZM\UJ[PVU[OL^PUKV^NVLZ\WH\[VÍ

TH[PJHSS`

4HRL Z\YL UVIVK` JHU IL PUQ\YLK ^OLU [OL

^PUKV^ZJSVZL

9LTV]L [OL PNUP[PVU RL` [V ZO\[ VMM WV^LY [V

[OL ^PUKV^ Z^P[JOLZ ^OLU [OL ]LOPJSL PZ UV[

H[[LUKLKI`HYLZWVUZPISLWLYZVU

F"=amF’’˜Op˜pzF"›apm˜pO˜zp§F

§am=p§’


>P[OLUNPULY\UUPUNVY



PUPNUP[PVURL`WVZP[PVUVY



^P[O KVVY JSVZLK HUK PNUP[PVU RL` ^P[OKYH^U!

VUS`\U[PSMPYZ[VWLUPUNVM[OLKVVY

zFmamV˜§am=p§’

6WLUPUN^P[O[OLYVJRLYZ^P[JO

PU[OLJLU[LYJVUZVSL

7YLZZ YVJRLY Z^P[JO ( \U[PS [OL ^PUKV^ OHZ

YLHJOLK[OLKLZPYLKWVZP[PVU

6ULÍ[V\JOVWLYH[PVU!

7YLZZYVJRLYZ^P[JO(IYPLMS`

>PUKV^TV]LZ[VP[ZMPUHSWVZP[PVU

7YLZZHNHPU[VZ[VW[OL^PUKV^PU[OLKLZPYLK

WVZP[PVU

*VTMVY[M\UJ[PVU^OLU\USVJRPUN

[OL]LOPJSL

<USVJRJHY^P[O[OLYLTV[LJVU[YVS

/VSK JHY RL` PU KVVY SVJR PU [OL \USVJRPUN KPÌ

YLJ[PVU \U[PS [OL ^PUKV^Z OH]L YLHJOLK [OL

KLZPYLKWVZP[PVU

¢T˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

dp’amV˜§am=p§’

*SVZPUN^P[O[OLYVJRLYZ^P[JO

PU[OLJLU[LYJVUZVSL

7YLZZ YVJRLY Z^P[JO ( \U[PS [OL ^PUKV^ OHZ

YLHJOLK[OLKLZPYLKWVZP[PVU

6ULÍ[V\JOVWLYH[PVU!

7YLZZYVJRLYZ^P[JO(IYPLMS`

>PUKV^TV]LZ[VP[ZMPUHSWVZP[PVU

7YLZZHNHPU[VZ[VW[OL^PUKV^PU[OLKLZPYLK

WVZP[PVU

*VTMVY[M\UJ[PVU^OLUSVJRPUN[OL]LOPJSL

H[[OLKVVYSVJR

/VSKJHYRL`PUKVVYSVJRPU[OLSVJRPUNKPYLJÌ

[PVU \U[PS [OL ^PUKV^Z OH]L YLHJOLK [OL

KLZPYLKWVZP[PVU

m›a_4¤’^amV˜zp›F4›apm

0MHZPKL^PUKV^PZISVJRLKK\YPUNJSVZPUNP[^PSS

Z[VWHUKVWLUHNHPUI`HIV\[HUPUJO

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMZL]LYLWLYZVUHSPUQ\YPLZ

0M [OL YVJRLY Z^P[JO PZ WYLZZLK HNHPU ^P[OPU

 ZLJVUKZ VM [OL ^PUKV^ ILPUN ISVJRLK

[OL ^PUKV^ ^PSS JSVZL ^P[O P[Z M\SS JSVZPUN

MVYJL(U[PÍJY\ZOPUNWYV[LJ[PVUPZKPZHISLK

6UJL[OLHU[PÌJY\ZOPUNWYV[LJ[PVUHJ[Z[VZ[VW

[OL^PUKV^HUKVWLUZP[ZSPNO[S`KVUV[WYLZZ

[OL YVJRLY Z^P[JO HNHPU ^P[OPU  ZLJVUKZ

^P[OV\[JOLJRPUN[VTHRLZ\YL[OH[UV[OPUNPZ

ISVJRPUN[OLWH[OVM[OL^PUKV^

;OL^PUKV^^PSSJSVZL^P[OM\SSJSVZPUNMVYJL

6ULÌ[V\JO VWLYH[PVU PZ KPZHISLK MVY  ZLJVUKZ

HM[LYISVJRHNLVMHZPKL^PUKV^

¤›ph"›a4˜§am=p§˜dp§FamV

:LL[OLJOHW[LYVUs+VVYZr

^F˜’›"m=*©˜O¤m4›apm˜pO˜›^F˜zp§F

§am=p§’˜’§a›4^F’˜pOO˜"O›F˜›§p˜^p¤’

>OLU [OL JHY PZ \USVJRLK [OL WV^LY ^PUKV^Z

JHU UV SVUNLY IL VWLYH[LK HM[LY [^V OV\YZ [V

ZH]L[OLJHYIH[[LY`

:^P[JO VU [OL PNUP[PVU VY Z[HY[ [OL LUNPUL [V

YLHJ[P]H[L[OLWV^LY^PUKV^Z

›pamV˜Fm=˜zp’a›apm˜pO˜›^F˜§am=p§’

0M [OL IH[[LY` PZ KPZJVUULJ[LK HUK YLJVUULJ[LK

[OL ^PUKV^Z ^PSS UV[ IL YHPZLK H\[VTH[PJHSS`

^OLU[OLKVVYPZJSVZLK

 *SVZL [OL ^PUKV^Z ^P[O [OL YVJRLY Z^P[JO

VUJL

 7YLZZ MYVU[ OHSM VM YVJRLY Z^P[JO HNHPU [V

Z[VYL [OL LUK WVZP[PVU VM [OL ^PUKV^Z PU [OL

JVU[YVS\UP[

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

¢Q

background image

(Í:LSLJ[VYZ^P[JOKYP]LYqZWHZZLUNLYqZZPKL

)Í4PYYVYHKQ\Z[TLU[

F"˜aF§˜ap’

)LMVYLKYP]PUN[OL]LOPJSLHKQ\Z[[OLV\[ZPKLHUK

PUZPKLTPYYVYZ

0[ PZ PTWVY[HU[ MVY ZHML KYP]PUN [OH[ `V\ OH]L

NVVK]PZPVU[V[OLYLHY

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMHUHJJPKLU[

+V UV[ W\[ HU`[OPUN VU VY ULHY [OL ^PUKV^Z

VY [OL TPYYVYZ [OH[ TH` PU[LYMLYL ^P[O [OL

KYP]LYqZ]PZPVU

pp˜hap’

;OL TPYYVY OV\ZPUN PZ OPUNLK HUK JHU IL MVSKLK

MSH[ HNHPUZ[ [OL JHY [V WYL]LU[ KHTHNL PU [OL

[PNO[WHYRPUNHYLHZ

(KQ\Z[PUN
 :LSLJ[ KYP]LYqZ ZPKL VY WHZZLUNLYqZ ZPKL ^P[O

YVJRLYZ^P[JO(

 4V]L[OLKVVYTPYYVYNSHZZLZPU[OLHWWYVWYPÌ

H[LKPYLJ[PVU\ZPUN[OLJVU[YVSZ^P[JO)

0M[OLLSLJ[YPJHSHKQ\Z[TLU[MHJPSP[`MHPSZ

(KQ\Z[TPYYVYI`WYLZZPUNVU[OLTPYYVYMHJL

(\[VTH[PJHSS`Z^P]LSSPUNKV^UTPYYVYNSHZZ

VU[OLWHZZLUNLYqZZPKL
:LL [OL JOHW[LY VU r7HYRPUN HPKZs HUK s:LH[

TLTVY`r

(Í:LUZVY

)Í:^P[JOMVYH\[VTH[PJHU[PÍNSHYLVWLYH[PVU

*Í3PNO[ÍLTP[[PUNKPVKL

¤›ph"›a4˜m›a_ d"F˜ m›Fap

ap˜"m=˜a¦FŒ’˜pp˜ap

:LUZVYZ VU [OL MYVU[ HUK YLHY ZPKLZ VM [OL PU[LÌ

YPVYTPYYVYTLHZ\YL[OLPUJPKLU[SPNO[

;OL TPYYVYZ H\[VTH[PJHSS` JOHUNL [V HU[PÌNSHYL

WVZP[PVU VY YL]LY[ [V [OLPY UVYTHS Z[H[L KLWLUKÌ

PUNVU[OLSPNO[PU[LUZP[`

>OLU YL]LYZL NLHY PZ ZLSLJ[LK H\[VTH[PJ HU[PÌ

NSHYLVWLYH[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVMM

¢–˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

5V[L
;OL PUJPKLU[ SPNO[ PU [OL HYLH VM [OL ZLUZVYZ

T\Z[ UV[ IL YLZ[YPJ[LK LN I` Z[PJRLYZ VU [OL

^PUKZJYLLU

:^P[JOPUNVMM[OLH\[VTH[PJHU[PÍNSHYL

VWLYH[PVU

7YLZZZ^P[JO)

3PNO[ÌLTP[[PUNKPVKL*NVLZV\[

:^P[JOPUNVU[OLH\[VTH[PJHU[PÍNSHYL

VWLYH[PVU

7YLZZZ^P[JO)

3PNO[ÌLTP[[PUNKPVKL*SPNO[Z\W

>HYUPUN

9PZR VM PUQ\Y` ,SLJ[YVS`[L MS\PK JHU LTLYNL

MYVTHIYVRLUTPYYVYNSHZZ

;OPZMS\PKPYYP[H[LZ[OLZRPUHUKL`LZ

0M [OL LSLJ[YVS`[L MS\PK ZOV\SK JVTL PU[V JVUÌ

[HJ[^P[O[OLL`LZVYZRPUPTTLKPH[LS`YPUZLP[

VMM^P[OJSLHU^H[LY

:LLHKVJ[VYPMULJLZZHY`

9PZR VM KHTHNL [V [OL WHPU[^VYR HUK WSHZÍ

[PJ WHY[Z ,SLJ[YVS`[L MS\PK JHU IL YLTV]LK

VUS`^OPSLP[PZZ[PSS^L[

*SLHU[OLHMMLJ[LKWHY[Z^P[O^H[LY

F"˜am=p§˜FOpVVF:

pp˜ap˜ F"›amV

;OL TPYYVY OLH[LY PZ YLHK` MVY VWLYH[PVU ^OLU

[OLPNUP[PVUPZVU

:^P[JOPUNVU

7YLZZ[OLYVJRLYÌZ^P[JOZ`TIVS

0UKPJH[VYSPNO[PZSP[

(M[LY HIV\[  TPU\[LZ [OL OLH[LY Z^P[JOLZ VMM

H\[VTH[PJHSS`

;OLOLH[LYJHUILZ^P[JOLKIHJRVUHNHPUI`H

M\Y[OLYWYLZZVU[OLZ^P[JO

:^P[JOPUNVMM

7YLZZ[OLPUKPJH[VYSPNO[PU[OLYVJRLYZ^P[JO

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

¢•

background image

F"›’˜=b¤’›hFm›

>HYUPUN

:HML[` ILS[Z VUS` VMMLY WYV[LJ[PVU ^OLU [OL

IHJRYLZ[ PZ \WYPNO[ HUK [OL ILS[Z HYL

WYVWLYS`WVZP[PVULKVU[OLIVK`

0TWYVWLYS` WVZP[PVULK ZHML[` ILS[Z JHU

JH\ZL ZLYPV\Z WLYZVUHS PUQ\Y` PU HU HJJPÍ

KLU[

+VUV[VWLYH[L[OLJHY^P[O[OLKYP]LYVYWHZÌ

ZLUNLY IHJRYLZ[Z L_JLZZP]LS` YLJSPULK ZLL

s:LH[WVZP[PVUr

;OLZLH[TH`TV]L\UL_WLJ[LKS`PM`V\H[Í

[LTW[ [V HKQ\Z[ ^OPSL KYP]PUN ;OPZ JV\SK

JH\ZLZ\KKLUSVZZVMJVU[YVSVYWLYZVUHSPUÍ

Q\Y`

+VUV[HKQ\Z[ZLH[Z^OPSL[OL]LOPJSLPZPUTVÌ

[PVU

;OL IHJRYLZ[ SVJRZ T\Z[ IL LUNHNLK H[ HSS

[PTLZ^OPSL[OL]LOPJSLPZPUTV[PVU

F"›˜zp’a›apm

( JVYYLJ[ ZP[[PUN WVZP[PVU PZ PTWVY[HU[ MVY ZHML

HUKMH[PN\LÌMYLLKYP]PUN

>L YLJVTTLUK [OL MVSSV^PUN WYVJLK\YL MVY

HKQ\Z[PUN [OL KYP]LYqZ ZLH[ [V Z\P[ PUKP]PK\HS

YLX\PYLTLU[Z!

 (KQ\Z[ [OL ZLH[ OLPNO[ [V NP]L `V\YZLSM

LUV\NO OLHKYVVT HUK H NVVK V]LY]PL^ VM

[OL]LOPJSL

 (KQ\Z[ [OL ZLH[ \U[PS ^P[O [OL HJJLSLYH[VY

WLKHSM\SS`KLWYLZZLK`V\YSLNPZZ[YHPNO[I\[

`V\Y LU[PYL MVV[ Z[PSS YLZ[Z VU [OL HJJLSLYH[VY

WLKHS

 .YPW[OL[VWOHSMVM[OLZ[LLYPUN^OLLS

:L[ [OL IHJRYLZ[ HUNSL HUK Z[LLYPUNÌ^OLLS

WVZP[PVU ZV [OH[ `V\Y HYTZ HYL HSTVZ[

V\[Z[YL[JOLK /V^L]LY `V\Y ZOV\SKLYZ T\Z[

Z[PSSYLZ[VU[OLIHJRYLZ[

 0M ULJLZZHY` JVYYLJ[ [OL ZLH[ MVYLÌHUKÌHM[

HKQ\Z[TLU[

dF4›a4"dd©˜"=b¤’›"*dF˜’F"›

7YLZZ [OL Z^P[JO PU [OL KPYLJ[PVU PUKPJH[LK I`

[OL HYYV^Z \U[PS [OL KLZPYLK ZLH[ WVZP[PVU PZ

YLHJOLK

(Í:LH[OLPNO[HKQ\Z[TLU[

)Í-VYLÍHUKÍHM[HKQ\Z[TLU[

*Í:LH[HUNSLHKQ\Z[TLU[

+Í)HJRYLZ[HUNSLHKQ\Z[TLU[

¢G˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

,Í3\TIHYZ\WWVY[

  WLS]PZHUKZWPUHSJVS\TUZ\WWVY[
;VWLYTP[HYLSH_LKZP[[PUNWVZ[\YL[OLIHJRYLZ[

J\Y]H[\YL PZ Z[LWSLZZS` HKQ\Z[HISL PU ]LY[PJHS HUK

OVYPaVU[HS KPYLJ[PVUZ MVY PUKP]PK\HS WLS]PZ HUK

ZWPUHSJVS\TUZ\WWVY[

7YLZZ [OL Z^P[JO PU [OL KPYLJ[PVU PUKPJH[LK I`

[OL HYYV^Z \U[PS [OL KLZPYLK IHJRYLZ[ J\Y]HÌ

[\YLPZYLHJOLK

F"›˜*"4cF’›

-VSKPUNMVY^HYK

7\SS\WSL]LY-PU[OLZPKLWHY[VM[OLIHJRYLZ[

HUKMVSK[OLIHJRYLZ[MVY^HYK

-VSKPUNIHJR

;PS[ IHJR HUK LUNHNL [OL IHJRYLZ[ ZV [OH[ P[

JHUUV[[PWMVY^HYK^OLU[OLJHYPZIYHRLK

zp›’˜F"›(

(Í:LH[OLPNO[HKQ\Z[TLU[

9HPZLSVJRPUNSL]LY

:L[ [OL KLZPYLK ZLH[ OLPNO[ I` ZOPM[PUN `V\Y

IVK`^LPNO[

9LSLHZL[OLSL]LY

)Í-VYLHUKHM[

9HPZLSVJRPUNSL]LY

4V]L ZLH[ [V KLZPYLK WVZP[PVU HUK YLSLHZL

SL]LY

,UZ\YL[OH[[OLZLH[LUNHNLZJVYYLJ[S`

*Í)HJRYLZ[HUNSL

6WLYH[L Z^P[JO \U[PS [OL KLZPYLK IHJRYLZ[

HUNSLPZYLHJOLK

F"›˜*"4cF’›

-VSKPUNMVY^HYK

7\SS \W SL]LY + PU [OL ZPKL WHY[ VM [OL IHJRÌ

YLZ[HUKMVSK[OLIHJRYLZ[MVY^HYK

-VSKPUNIHJR

;PS[ IHJR HUK LUNHNL [OL IHJRYLZ[ ZV [OH[ P[

JHUUV[[PWMVY^HYK^OLU[OLJHYPZIYHRLK

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

¢n

background image

F"›˜Fhp©

0UKP]PK\HS ZLH[ HUK KVVY TPYYVY ZL[[PUNZ JHU IL

Z[VYLKHUKYLJHSSLKMVY[OLKYP]LYqZWVZP[PVU

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMJY\ZOPUN

+\L [V YPZR VM JY\ZOPUN MYVT \UJVU[YVSSLK YLÌ

JHSSPUN [OL TLTVY` VM H ZLH[ ZL[[PUN KV UV[

SLH]LJOPSKYLUPU[OLJHY\UH[[LUKLK

zF"›apm˜§a›^˜zF’pm˜*¤››pm’˜s:˜¢

:[VYPUNZLH[WVZP[PVU
 :^P[JOPNUP[PVUVU

 :L[ [OL KLZPYLK ZLH[ HUK KVVYÌTPYYVY WVZP[Ì

PVUZ

0M`V\^PZOMVY[OLWHZZLUNLYqZTPYYVY[VZ^PÌ

]LS KV^U HZ H WHYRPUN HPK ^OLU YL]LYZPUN

YL]LYZL NLHY T\Z[ IL LUNHNLK ^OLU [OL

ZLH[WVZP[PVUPZZ[VYLK

 2LLW TLTVY`I\[[VU4KLWYLZZLKHUKHKKPÌ

[PVUHSS`WYLZZVULVM[OLWLYZVUI\[[VUZVY



;OLPUKP]PK\HSZL[[PUNPZUV^Z[VYLK\UKLY[OL

KLZPYLKWLYZVUI\[[VU

9LJHSSPUNZLH[WVZP[PVU
 :^P[JO[OLPNUP[PVUVUVY

VWLU[OLKYP]LYqZKVVY

 7YLZZ WLYZVU I\[[VU \U[PS [OL ZLH[ OHZ

YLHJOLKP[ZMPUHSWVZP[PVU

;OL TPYYVY ZL[[PUN ^PSS IL JVTWSL[LK L]LU PM

[OLWLYZVUI\[[VUPZUV[RLW[KLWYLZZLK

5V[L
(\[VTH[PJ ZLH[ HKQ\Z[TLU[ JHU IL PU[LYY\W[LK

PTTLKPH[LS`I`YLSLHZPUN[OLI\[[VU

¬˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

zF"›amV˜§a›^˜›^F˜Fhp›F˜4pm›pd˜pO

›^F˜¦F^a4dF˜cF©

,HJO YLTV[L JVU[YVS \W [V MV\Y JHU IL

HZZPNULK HU PUKP]PK\HS ZLH[ HUK KVVY TPYYVY

WVZP[PVU

;OL Z[VYLK ZLH[ HUK KVVY TPYYVY WVZP[PVU PZ ZL[

H\[VTH[PJHSS`^OLU[OL]LOPJSLPZ\USVJRLK\ZPUN

[OLJVYYLZWVUKPUNYLTV[LJVU[YVS

,HJORL`PZPKLU[PMPLK^P[OHKPMMLYLU[JVSV\Y

:[VYPUNZLH[WVZP[PVU
 :^P[JO[OLPNUP[PVUVU^P[O[OLKLZPYLK]LOPJSL

RL`

 :L[ [OL KLZPYLK ZLH[ HUK KVVYÌTPYYVY WVZP[Ì

PVUZ

0M`V\^PZOMVY[OLWHZZLUNLYqZTPYYVY[VZ^PÌ

]LS KV^U HZ H WHYRPUN HPK ^OLU YL]LYZPUN

YL]LYZL NLHY T\Z[ IL LUNHNLK ^OLU [OL

ZLH[WVZP[PVUPZZ[VYLK

 2LLW TLTVY`I\[[VU4KLWYLZZLKHUKHKKPÌ

[PVUHSS` WYLZZ [OL    I\[[VU ILZPKL [OL

TLTVY`I\[[VU

;OL PUKP]PK\HS ZL[[PUN PZ UV^ HZZPNULK [V[OPZ

YLTV[LJVU[YVSHUK[V[OL    I\[[VU

9LJHSSPUNZLH[WVZP[PVU

<USVJR [OL SVJRLK ]LOPJSL VY S\NNHNL JVTÌ

WHY[TLU[^P[O[OLYLTV[LJVU[YVS

;OLZ[VYLKZLH[WVZP[PVUPZZL[H\[VTH[PJHSS`

;OL ZLH[ WVZP[PVU HZZPNULK [V H YLTV[L JVU[YVS

JHUHSZVILYLJHSSLK^P[O[OL    I\[[VUPM[OL

JVYYLZWVUKPUN RL` ^HZ \ZLK [V \USVJR [OL ]LÌ

OPJSLVY[VZ^P[JOVU[OLPNUP[PVU

0M UV ZLH[ WVZP[PVU ^HZ HZZPNULK [V H YLTV[L

JVU[YVS[OL    I\[[VU^PSSUV[^VYR

5V[L
(\[VTH[PJ ZLH[ HKQ\Z[TLU[ JHU IL PU[LYY\W[LK

PTTLKPH[LS` I` WYLZZPUN [OL JLU[YHS SVJRPUN I\[Ì

[VUVYHU`TLTVY`VYZLH[HKQ\Z[TLU[I\[[VU

*SLHYPUN[OLZ[VYLKZLH[WVZP[PVU
 :^P[JO[OLPNUP[PVUVU^P[O[OLKLZPYLK]LOPJSL

RL`

 :PT\S[HULV\ZS`WYLZZHUKOVSK[OL    I\[Ì

[VU HUK WLYZVU I\[[VU  MVY H[ SLHZ[  ZLJÌ

VUKZ

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

s

background image

(Í:LH[OLH[PUNSLM[

)Í:LH[OLH[PUNYPNO[

F"›F=˜’F"›’

;OL ZLH[ OLH[PUN ^P[O [^V OLH[PUN Z[HNLZ PZ

YLHK`MVYVWLYH[PVU^OLU[OLPNUP[PVUPZVU

§a›4^amV˜pm

/PNOOLH[PUNWV^LY

7YLZZ[OLYVJRLYÌZ^P[JOZ`TIVS

0UKPJH[VYSPNO[NSV^ZYLK

3V^OLH[PUNWV^LY

7YLZZ[OLYVJRLYÌZ^P[JOZ`TIVSHNHPU

0UKPJH[VYSPNO[NSV^ZVYHUNL

;OLOLH[PUNWV^LYJOHUNLZ^OLUL]LY[OLYVJRLY

Z^P[JOPZVWLYH[LK

§a›4^amV˜pOO

7YLZZ[OLPUKPJH[VYSPNO[PU[OLYVJRLYZ^P[JO

¢˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

F"˜F"›˜"4cF’›

,_[YH Z[VYHNL ZWHJL PZ NHPULK I` MVSKPUN [OL

YLHYZLH[IHJRYLZ[MVY^HYK

-VSKPUNIHJRYLZ[MVY^HYK

7\SS SL]LY ( MVY^HYK HUK MVSK [OL IHJRYLZ[

KV^U

-VSKPUNIHJRYLZ[IHJR

;PS[[OLIHJRYLZ[IHJR\U[PSP[JSPJRZPU[VWSHJL

>OLUKVPUN[OPZWH`H[[LU[PVU[V[OLZLH[ILS[

N\PKLMPN\YL

›FFamV˜^FFd˜=b¤’›hFm›

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMHJJPKLU[

;OL Z[LLYPUN ^OLLS TH` TV]L M\Y[OLY [OHU

KLZPYLK PM `V\ H[[LTW[ [V HKQ\Z[ P[ ^OPSL

KYP]PUN

@V\TH`SVZLJVU[YVSVM[OL]LOPJSL

+VUV[HKQ\Z[[OLZ[LLYPUN^OLLS^OPSLKYP]PUN

pmVa›¤=am"d˜"=b¤’›hFm›

 7\ZOSVJRPUNSL]LYKV^U^HYKZ

 (KQ\Z[ Z[LLYPUN ^OLLS [V MP[ [OL JOVZLU IHJRÌ

YLZ[ HUNSL HUK ZLH[ WVZP[PVU I` TV]PUN [OL

Z[LLYPUN^OLLSSVUNP[\KPUHSS`

 :^P]LSSVJRPUNSL]LYIHJR\U[PS`V\MLLSP[

LUNHNL

0MULJLZZHY`TV]LZ[LLYPUN^OLLSZSPNO[S`SVUÌ

NP[\KPUHSS`[VLUZ\YLLUNHNLTLU[

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z



background image

"OF›©˜Fd›’

>HYUPUN

(S^H`Z THRL Z\YL `V\Y HUK `V\Y WHZZLUÍ

NLYZq ZHML[` ILS[Z HYL WYVWLYS` MHZ[LULK

^OPSL[OL]LOPJSLPZPUTV[PVU

-HPS\YL [V MVSSV^ ZHML[` ILS[ ^HYUPUNZ TH`

YLZ\S[PUZLYPV\ZWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`

-VY`V\YHUK`V\YWHZZLUNLYZqWYV[LJ[PVU\ZL

ZHML[`ILS[ZH[HSS[PTLZ^OPSL[OL]LOPJSLPZPU

TV[PVU

<ZLHWWYVWYPH[LJOPSKYLZ[YHPU[Z`Z[LTZMVYHSS

ZTHSSJOPSKYLU

7YVWLY^LHYPUNVMZHML[`ILS[Z

:HML[` ILS[Z T\Z[ IL WVZP[PVULK VU [OL IVK`

HZ [V YLZ[YHPU [OL \WWLY IVK` HUK SHW MYVT

ZSPKPUN MVY^HYK 0TWYVWLYS` WVZP[PVULK ZHML[`

ILS[Z JHU JH\ZL ZLYPV\Z WLYZVUHS PUQ\Y` PU

JHZLVMHUHJJPKLU[

;OL ZOV\SKLY ILS[ ZOV\SK HS^H`Z YLZ[ VU `V\Y

\WWLY IVK` ;OL ZOV\SKLY ILS[ ZOV\SK UL]LY

IL^VYUILOPUK`V\YIHJRVY\UKLY`V\YHYT

-VY TH_PT\T LMMLJ[P]LULZZ [OL SHW ILS[

ZOV\SKIL^VYUSV^HJYVZZ[OLOPWZ

7YLNUHU[ ^VTLU ZOV\SK WVZP[PVU [OL ILS[ HZ

SV^ HZ WVZZPISL HJYVZZ [OL WLS]PZ 4HRL Z\YL

P[PZUV[WYLZZPUNHNHPUZ[[OLHIKVTLU

)LS[ZZOV\SKUV[IL^VYU[^PZ[LK

+VUV[^LHYILS[ZV]LYYPNPKVYIYLHRHISLVIÌ

QLJ[Z PU VY VU `V\Y JSV[OPUN Z\JO HZ L`L

NSHZZLZWLUZRL`ZL[JHZ[OLZLTH`JH\ZL

PUQ\Y`

:L]LYHSSH`LYZVMOLH]`JSV[OPUNTH`PU[LYMLYL

^P[OWYVWLYWVZP[PVUPUNVMILS[Z

)LS[Z T\Z[ UV[ Y\I HNHPUZ[ ZOHYW VIQLJ[Z VY

KHTHNLTH`VJJ\Y[V[OLILS[

;^V VJJ\WHU[Z ZOV\SK UL]LY ZOHYL [OL ZHTL

ILS[H[[OLZHTL[PTL

*HYLHUKTHPU[LUHUJL

2LLWILS[I\JRSLZMYLLVMHU`VIZ[Y\J[PVU[OH[

TH`WYL]LU[HZLJ\YLSVJRPUN

)LS[Z [OH[ OH]L ILLU Z\IQLJ[LK [V L_JLZZP]L

Z[YL[JO MVYJLZ PU HU HJJPKLU[ T\Z[ IL PUÌ

ZWLJ[LKVYYLWSHJLK[VLUZ\YL[OLPYJVU[PU\LK

LMMLJ[P]LULZZPUYLZ[YHPUPUN`V\

;OL ZHTL HWWSPLZ [V ILS[ [LUZPVULY Z`Z[LTZ

^OPJOOH]LILLU[YPNNLYLK

0U HKKP[PVU [OL HUJOVY WVPU[Z VM [OL ILS[Z

ZOV\SKILJOLJRLK

0MZHML[`ILS[ZKVUV[^VYRWYVWLYS`ZLL`V\Y

H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLYPTTLKPH[LS`

0M [OL ILS[Z ZOV^ KHTHNL [V ^LIIPUN IPUKÌ

PUNZI\JRSLZVYYL[YHJ[VYZ[OL`ZOV\SKILYLÌ

WSHJLK[VLUZ\YLZHMLVWLYH[PVU

+VUV[TVKPM`VYKPZHZZLTISL[OLZHML[`ILS[Z

PU`V\Y]LOPJSL

;OL ILS[Z T\Z[ IL RLW[ JSLHU VY [OL YL[YHJÌ

[VYZ TH` UV[ ^VYR WYVWLYS` ZLL HSZV s*HY

JHYLPUZ[Y\J[PVUZr

5L]LYISLHJOVYK`LZHML[`ILS[Z

+V UV[ HSSV^ ZHML[` ILS[Z [V YL[YHJ[ \U[PS [OL`

HYL JVTWSL[LS` KY` HM[LY JSLHUPUN VY [OPZ TH`

JH\ZLKHTHNL[V[OLILS[

Fd›˜›Fm’apmF

+LWLUKPUN VU [OL MVYJL VM H JVSSPZPVU MHZ[LULK

MYVU[ZLH[ILS[ZHYL[PNO[LULKPUHUHJJPKLU[

;OLILS[[LUZPVULYZHYL[YPNNLYLKPU!



-YVU[HUKYLHYPTWHJ[Z

;OLILS[[LUZPVULYZHYLUV[[YPNNLYLKPU!



:PKLPTWHJ[Z



=LOPJSLV]LY[\YUPUN

5V[L
;OLILS[[LUZPVULYZ`Z[LTJHUIL[YPNNLYLKVUS`

VUJL"[OLZ`Z[LTT\Z[ILYLWSHJLKHM[LY^HYK

>VYR TH` IL WLYMVYTLK VU [OL ILS[Ì[LUZPVULY

Z`Z[LTVUS`I`HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

:TVRL PZ YLSLHZLK ^OLU [OLILS[[LUZPVULYZHYL

[YPNNLYLK ;OPZ KVLZ UV[ PUKPJH[L H MPYL PU [OL

]LOPJSL

T˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

"OF›©˜Fd›˜"mamV˜©’›Fh

(U H\KPVÍ]PZ\HS ^HYUPUN Z`Z[LT PZ PU[LYJVUÌ

ULJ[LK^P[O[OLKYP]LYqZZHML[`ILS[

,]LY` [PTL [OL PNUP[PVU PZ [\YULK VU [OL NVUN

^PSS ZV\UK MVY HIV\[  ZLJVUKZ [V YLTPUK [OL

KYP]LYHUKWHZZLUNLY[VI\JRSL\W

;OL ZHML[` ILS[ ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[

WHULSHUKVUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY^PSSNVVMMHZZVVU

HZ[OLKYP]LYOHZI\JRSLK\W

mF›a"˜FFd˜F›"4›p

;OL JVTIPUH[PVU SHWZOV\SKLY ILS[ ^P[O PULY[PH

YLLS SVJRPUN TLJOHUPZT HKQ\Z[Z H\[VTH[PJHSS` [V

`V\YZPaLHUKTV]LTLU[ZHZSVUNHZ[OLW\SSVU

[OLILS[PZZSV^

9HWPKKLJLSLYH[PVUK\YPUNOHYKIYHRPUNVYHJVSSPÌ

ZPVU SVJRZ [OL ILS[ ;OL ILS[ ^PSS HSZV SVJR ^OLU

`V\ KYP]L \W VY KV^U H Z[LLW OPSS VY PU H ZOHYW

J\Y]LV[OLY^PZL[OLZOV\SKLYILS[^PSSUV[PUOPIP[

`V\Y\WWLYIVK`TV]LTLU[

(ZZ\TLHJVTMVY[HISLZP[[PUNWVZP[PVU

;OL ZOV\SKLY ILS[ ZOV\SK HS^H`Z YLZ[ VU `V\Y

\WWLY IVK` ;OL ZOV\SKLY ILS[ ZOV\SK UL]LY

IL^VYUILOPUK`V\YIHJRVY\UKLY`V\YHYT

;V MHZ[LU NYHZW ILS[ HUK W\SS [OL ILS[ PU H

JVU[PU\V\Z ZSV^ TV[PVU HJYVZZ `V\Y JOLZ[

HUKSHW

0UZLY[ILS[[VUN\LPU[VI\JRSLVUPUIVHYKZPKL

VMZLH[7\ZOKV^U\U[PSP[ZLJ\YLS`SVJRZ^P[O

HUH\KPISLJSPJR7\SS[OLILS[[VJOLJR

7\SS ZOV\SKLY ZLJ[PVU [V THRL Z\YL ILS[ MP[Z

ZU\NS`HJYVZZ[OLWLS]PZ

)LS[Z ZOV\SK MP[ ZU\NS` HJYVZZ [OL WLS]PZ HUK

JOLZ[4HRLZ\YL[OLYLPZUVZSHJRPU[OLILS[

;V \UMHZ[LU ILS[ W\ZO PU YLSLHZL I\[[VU

HYYV^ VU I\JRSL )LS[ [VUN\L ^PSS ZWYPUN V\[

VMI\JRSL

;V YLSLHZL H SH[JOLK ILS[ SLHU IHJR [V [HRL

[OLIVK`WYLZZ\YLVMM[OLILS[

;V Z[VYL SHWZOV\SKLY ILS[ HSSV^ [OL ILS[ [V

YL[YHJ[ HZ `V\ N\PKL [OL SH[JO [V P[Z Z[V^LK

WVZP[PVU

7SLHZL UV[L JOHW[LY s(\[VTH[PJ SVJRPUN YL[YHJÌ

[VYr

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

Q

background image

"OF›©˜*Fd›˜^FaV^›˜"=b¤’›hFm›

(KQ\Z[ [OL OLPNO[ VM [OL ZHML[` ILS[ ZV [OH[ P[

Y\UZ HJYVZZ [OL TPKKSL VM [OL ZOV\SKLY UV[

HNHPUZ[[OLULJR

(KQ\Z[PUNILS[OLPNO[

<WuW\ZOILS[KLMSLJ[VY

+V^U u WYLZZ I\[[VU HYYV^ HUK TV]L ILS[

KLMSLJ[VY

¤›ph"›a4˜dp4camV˜F›"4›p

;OL ZHML[` ILS[Z MVY [OL WHZZLUNLY HUK YLHY

ZLH[ZHYLLX\PWWLK^P[OHUH\[VTH[PJSVJRPUNYLÌ

[YHJ[VYMVYZLJ\YPUN[OLJOPSKYLZ[YHPU[Z`Z[LT

>OLU HJ[P]H[LK [OPZ YL[YHJ[VY HSSV^Z `V\ [V ZLÌ

J\YLS` MHZ[LU [OL JOPSK YLZ[YHPU[ Z`Z[LT PU WSHJL

ZV[OH[PUHK]LY[LU[TV]LTLU[Z^PSSUV[VJJ\Y

(J[P]H[PUN[OLH\[VTH[PJSVJRPUNYL[YHJ[VY
 7\SS[OLZHML[`ILS[YL[YHJ[VYJVTWSL[LS`V\[

([ [OPZ WVPU[ [OL SVJRPUN TLJOHUPZT PZ HJ[PÌ

]H[LK

 0UZLY[ [OL ZHML[` ILS[ [VUN\L PU[V [OL I\JRSL

HUKTHRLJLY[HPU[OH[P[PZWYVWLYS`SH[JOLK

 (SSV^[OLZHML[`ILS[[VYL[YHJ[\U[PSP[PZ[PNO[

VU [OL JOPSK YLZ[YHPU[ Z`Z[LT @V\ TH` M\YÌ

[OLY [PNO[LU [OL ILS[ I` W\SSPUN VU P[ [V HSSV^

TVYLVMP[[VYL[YHJ[

9LSLHZPUN[OLZHML[`ILS[
 <UI\JRSL[OLZHML[`ILS[SH[JO

 ;OLU THRL JLY[HPU [OH[ [OL ILS[ OHZ M\SS` YLÌ

[YHJ[LK

([[OPZWVPU[[OLH\[VTH[PJSVJRPUNMLH[\YL^PSS

ILKPZLUNHNLK

–˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

^ad=˜F’›"am›˜m4^p"VF’

7SLHZL UV[L JOHW[LY s(\[VTH[PJ SVJRPUN YL[YHJÌ

[VYr

0M `V\Y JOPSK YLZ[YHPU[ ZLH[ VY ZLH[Z YLX\PYL [OL

\ZL VM H [L[OLY Z[YHW `V\ ^PSS ^HU[ [V \ZL [OL

HUJOVY WVPU[Z WYV]PKLK ILOPUK [OL YLHY ZLH[

IHJRYLZ[Z\UKLY[OLJHYWL[

;V LUZ\YL WYVWLY PUZ[HSSH[PVU ZLL `V\Y H\[OÌ

VYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

;OL [L[OLY Z[YHW JHU IL TV]LK [V [OL V[OLYHUÌ

JOVYWVPU[PMYLX\PYLK

>HYUPUN

*OPSK YLZ[YHPU[ HUJOVYHNLZ HYL KLZPNULK [V

^P[OZ[HUKVUS`[OVZLSVHKZPTWVZLKI`JVYÍ

YLJ[S` MP[[LK JOPSK YLZ[YHPU[Z <UKLY UV JPYÍ

J\TZ[HUJLZ HYL [OL` [V IL \ZLK MVY HK\S[Z

ZHML[` ILS[Z VY OHYULZZLZ :\JO \ZL JV\SK

YLZ\S[PUZLYPV\ZWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`VYKLH[O

+VUV[TPZ\ZL[OLJOPSKYLZ[YHPU[HUJOVYHNLZ

;OL` HYL UV[ KLZPNULK [V ^P[OZ[HUK SVHKZ PTÌ

WVZLKI`HK\S[Z

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

•

background image

^ad=˜F’›"am›˜©’›Fh’

7VYZJOL YLJVTTLUKZ [OH[ HSS PUMHU[Z HUK JOPSKÌ

YLUILYLZ[YHPULKPUJOPSKYLZ[YHPU[Z`Z[LTZH[HSS

[PTLZ ^OPSL [OL ]LOPJSL PZ PU TV[PVU PU HJJVYKÌ

HUJL^P[OHWWSPJHISLSH^Z

;OL \ZL VM PUMHU[ VY JOPSK YLZ[YHPU[Z PZ YLX\PYLK

I` SH^ PU HSS  Z[H[LZ HUK [OL *HUHKPHU WYV]Ì

PUJLZ

;OL JOPSK YLZ[YHPU[ Z`Z[LT ZOV\SK IL VUL [OH[

JVTWSPLZ ^P[O <: -LKLYHS*HUHKPHU 4V[VY =LÌ

OPJSL :HML[` :[HUKHYKZ  HUK ZOV\SK IL ZLÌ

J\YLK I` H SHW ILS[ VY SHW ILS[ WVY[PVU VM H SHWÌ

ZOV\SKLYILS[

( Z[H[LTLU[ I` [OL ZLH[ THU\MHJ[\YLY VM JVTÌ

WSPHUJL ^P[O [OPZ Z[HUKHYK JHU IL MV\UK VU [OL

PUZ[Y\J[PVU SHILS VU [OL YLZ[YHPU[ HUK PU [OL PUÌ

Z[Y\J[PVUTHU\HSWYV]PKLK^P[O[OLYLZ[YHPU[

+HUNLY

9PZR VM ZLYPV\Z WLYZVUHS PUQ\Y` VY KLH[O [V

[OLJOPSK

-VSSV^HSSJOPSKYLZ[YHPU[PUZ[Y\J[PVUZHUK^HYUÌ

PUNZPU[OPZTHU\HS



>OLU\ZPUNHUPUMHU[VYJOPSKYLZ[YHPU[Z`Z[LT

IL Z\YL [V MVSSV^ HSS THU\MHJ[\YLYqZ PUZ[Y\JÌ

[PVUZVUPUZ[HSSH[PVUHUK\ZL



0UMHU[Z HUK ZTHSS JOPSKYLU ZOV\SK UL]LY IL

OLSK VU [OL SHW UVY ZOV\SK [OL` ZOHYL H

ZHML[`ILS[^P[OHUV[OLYVJJ\WHU[^OPSL[OL]LÌ

OPJSLPZPUTV[PVU



*OPSKYLU [VV IPN MVY JOPSK YLZ[YHPU[ Z`Z[LTZ

ZOV\SK \ZL YLN\SHY ZHML[` ILS[Z ( ZOV\SKLY

ILS[ JHU IL \ZLK WYV]PKPUN P[ KVLZ UV[ JYVZZ

[OLMHJLVY[OLULJRVM[OLJOPSK



-VY TH_PT\T ZHML[` HUK WYV[LJ[PVU ^L YLJÌ

VTTLUK [OH[ ZTHSS JOPSKYLU [YH]LS PU [OL YLHY

ZLH[Z

;OL HPYIHN KLHJ[P]H[PVU KL]PJL PUZ[HSSH[PVU

YLX\PYLZ ZWLJPHS WYVNYHTTPUN H]HPSHISL

VUS`MYVT`V\YH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

@V\YH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY^PSSILNSHK

[V HK]PZL `V\ HIV\[ [OL PUZ[HSSH[PVU WVZZPÍ

IPSP[` MVY H 7VYZJOL JOPSK YLZ[YHPU[ Z`Z[LT

^OPJO HSSV^Z KLHJ[P]H[PVU VM [OL WHZÍ

ZLUNLYqZHPYIHNZ

+HUNLY

;OL \ZL VM H JOPSK YLZ[YHPU[ Z`Z[LT PU [OL

WHZZLUNLY ZLH[ ^P[OV\[ HPYIHN KLHJ[P]H[PVU

JHU YLZ\S[ PU ZLYPV\Z WLYZVUHS PUQ\Y` VY

KLH[O [V [OL JOPSK MYVT HU HPYIHN KLWSV`Í

TLU[

;V YLK\JL YPZR VM PUQ\Y` MYVT HU PUMSH[PUN

HPYIHN PU HU HJJPKLU[ 7VYZJOL Z[YVUNS`

YLJVTTLUKZ!

+VUV[\ZLHJOPSKYLZ[YHPU[Z`Z[LTPU[OLWHZÌ

ZLUNLYZLH[\USLZZ[OLWHZZLUNLYHPYIHNZHYL

KLHJ[P]H[LK

G˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

9LHY^HYKMHJPUNJOPSKYLZ[YHPU[Z`Z[LT!

<ZLVUS`PU[OLWHZZLUNLYZLH[

<ZL PU WHZZLUNLY ZLH[ VUS` ^P[O [OL 7VYZJOL

JOPSKYLZ[YHPU[Z`Z[LT^P[OHPYIHNKLHJ[P]H[PVU

JHWHIPSP[`

>OLU\ZPUN[OL7VYZJOLJOPSKYLZ[YHPU[Z`Z[LT

`V\ T\Z[ LUZ\YL [OH[ [OL WHZZLUNLY HPYIHNZ

HYLKLHJ[P]H[LK

-VY^HYKMHJPUNJOPSKYLZ[YHPU[Z`Z[LT!

>OLUL]LYWVZZPISL\ZLPU[OLYLHYZLH[

0M `V\ T\Z[ WSHJL H MVY^HYK MHJPUN JOPSK

YLZ[YHPU[ Z`Z[LT PU [OL WHZZLUNLY ZLH[

[OL WHZZLUNLY HPYIHNZ T\Z[ IL KLHJ[PÍ

]H[LK

,_HTWSL!9LHY^HYKMHJPUNJOPSKYLZ[YHPU[Z`Z[LT

0U VYKLY [V KLHJ[P]H[L [OL WHZZLUNLYqZ HPYÍ

IHNZ [OL ILS[ [VUN\L VM [OL JOPSKqZ ZLH[

T\Z[ HS^H`Z IL PUZLY[LK PU [OL I\JRSL s(r

PUMYVU[VM[OLWHZZLUNLYZLH[

>OLU[OLPNUP[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVUKLHJ[P]H[PVUVM

[OL HPYIHNZ PZ PUKPJH[LK I` [OL HPYIHN ^HYUPUN

SPNO[MSHZOPUNMVYZLJVUKZ

+HUNLY

0M [OL SPNO[ KVLZ UV[ MSHZO [OL HPYIHNZ HYL

UV[ KLHJ[P]H[LK HUK H JOPSK YLZ[YHPU[ Z`ZÍ

[LTT\Z[UV[ILPUZ[HSSLK

/H]L [OL MH\S[ YLTLKPLK PTTLKPH[LS` I` HU

H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

n

background image

a*"V˜©’›Fh’

;OL(PYIHNZPUJVTIPUH[PVU^P[O[OLZHML[`ILS[Z

THRLZ \W H ZHML[` Z`Z[LT ^OPJO VMMLYZ [OL

KYP]LY HUK [OL WHZZLUNLY [OL NYLH[LZ[ RUV^U

WYV[LJ[PVUMYVTPUQ\YPLZPUJHZLVMHJJPKLU[

,]LU PM `V\Y ]LOPJSL PZ LX\PWWLK ^P[O HPYIHNZ

[OL ZHML[` ILS[Z T\Z[ IL ^VYU H[ HSS [PTLZ

ILJH\ZL [OL MYVU[ HPYIHN Z`Z[LT PZ VUS` HJ[\Ì

H[LKI`MYVU[HSJVSSPZPVUZ^P[OHUPTWHJ[VMZ\MMPÌ

JPLU[ZL]LYP[`

:LLMPN\YLMVYYHUNLZVMLMMLJ[P]LULZZ

)LSV^ [OL HJ[\H[PVU [OYLZOVSK VM [OL HPYIHNZ`ZÌ

[LTHUKK\YPUN[`WLZVMJVSSPZPVUZ^OPJOKVUV[

JH\ZL [OL HJ[\H[PVU VM [OL Z`Z[LT [OL ZHML[`

ILS[ZWYV]PKL[OLWYPTHY`WYV[LJ[PVU[V[OLVJJ\Ì

WHU[Z^OLUJVYYLJ[S`^VYU

;OLYLMVYL HSS WLYZVUZ ^P[OPU [OL ]LOPJSL

T\Z[ HS^H`Z ^LHY ZHML[` ILS[Z PU THU`

Z[H[LZ Z[H[L SH^ YLX\PYLZ [OL \ZL VM ZHML[`

ILS[Z:LLHSZV[OLJOHW[LYs:HML[`)LS[Zr

;OLMYVU[HPYIHNZHYLSVJH[LKILOPUK[OLWHKKLK

Z[LLYPUN^OLLSWHULSVU[OLKYP]LYqZZPKLHUKVU

[OLWHZZLUNLYqZZPKLPU[OLKHZOIVHYK

;OL ZPKL HPYIHNZ 76:07 Ì 7VYZJOL :PKL 0TWHJ[

7YV[LJ[PVU :`Z[LT HYL PUZ[HSSLK PU [OL KVVYZ

\UKLY[OLKVVY[YPTWHULS

¤m4›apm

;OL MYVU[ HPYIHNZ HYL [YPNNLYLK K\YPUN H MYVU[HS

JVSSPZPVUVMZ\MMPJPLU[MVYJL

0U [OL L]LU[ VM H ZPKL PTWHJ[ VM JVYYLZWVUKPUN

MVYJL[OLZPKLHPYIHNVU[OLPTWHJ[ZPKLPZ[YPNÌ

NLYLK

;OL PUMSH[PVU WYVJLZZ NLULYH[LZ [OL HTV\U[ VM

NHZYLX\PYLK[VMPSS[OLHPYIHNZH[[OLULJLZZHY`

WYLZZ\YLPUMYHJ[PVUZVMHZLJVUK

(PYIHNZ WYV[LJ[ [OL MHJL HUK\WWLYIVK`^OPSZ[

ZPT\S[HULV\ZS`KHTWPUN[OLTV[PVUVM[OLKYP]LY

HUK WHZZLUNLY PU [OL PTWHJ[ KPYLJ[PVU PU [OL

L]LU[VMHMYVU[HSPTWHJ[VYZPKLPTWHJ[

+HUNLY

;V WYV]PKL VW[PTHS VJJ\WHU[ WYV[LJ[PVU

HPYIHNZT\Z[PUMSH[LH[]LY`OPNOZWLLK

0M `V\ HYL UV[ ^LHYPUN `V\Y ZHML[` ILS[ VY

HYL [VV JSVZL [V [OL HPYIHN ^OLU P[Z KLÍ

WSV`LK PUMSH[PUN HPYIHNZ JHU YLZ\S[ PU

ZLYPV\ZPUQ\Y`VYKLH[O

4HRL Z\YL [OLYL HYL UV WLVWSL HUPTHSZ VY

VIQLJ[Z IL[^LLU [OL KYP]LY VY WHZZLUNLY HUK

[OLHYLHPU[V^OPJO[OLHPYIHNPUMSH[LZ

:P[ IHJR HZ MHY MYVT [OL KHZOIVHYK VY Z[LLYÌ

PUN^OLLSHZPZWYHJ[PJHS^OPSLZ[PSSTHPU[HPUPUN

M\SS]LOPJSLJVU[YVS

+VUV[SLHUHNHPUZ[[OLPUZPKLVM[OLKVVYZ

(S^H`Z OVSK [OL Z[LLYPUN ^OLLS I` [OL V\[LY

YPT

5L]LYYLZ[`V\YOHUKZVU[OLHPYIHNWHULS

5L]LY [YHUZWVY[ OLH]` VIQLJ[Z VU VY PU MYVU[

VM[OLWHZZLUNLYZLH[

(S^H`ZRLLW[OLSPKVM[OLKVVYZ[VYHNLJVTÌ

WHY[TLU[ JSVZLK 6IQLJ[Z T\Z[ UV[ WYV[Y\KL

V\[VM[OLKVVYZ[VYHNLJVTWHY[TLU[

.P]L `V\Y WHZZLUNLY HSS VM [OL PUMVYTH[PVU PU

[OPZJOHW[LY

5V JOHUNLZ T\Z[ IL THKL [V [OL ^PYPUN VY

JVTWVULU[ZVM[OLHPYIHNZ`Z[LT

T¬˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

+V UV[ HKK HU` HKKP[PVUHS JV]LYPUNZ VY

Z[PJRLYZ [V [OL Z[LLYPUN ^OLLS VY PU [OL HYLH

VM [OL WHZZLUNLY HPYIHN HUK ZPKL HPYIHNZ

+VPUNZVTH`HK]LYZLS`HMMLJ[[OLM\UJ[PVUPUN

VM [OL HPYIHN Z`Z[LT VY JH\ZL OHYT [V [OL

VJJ\WHU[ZPM[OLHPYIHNZ`Z[LTZOV\SKKLWSV`

+V UV[ \UKLY[HRL HU` ^PYPUN MVY LSLJ[YPJHS HJÌ

JLZZVY`LX\PWTLU[PU[OL]PJPUP[`VM[OLHPYIHN

^PYPUN OHYULZZLZ +VPUN ZV TH` KPZHISL [OL

HPYIHNZ`Z[LTVYJH\ZLPUMSH[PVU

0M[OL^HYUPUNSPNO[JVTLZVU[OLHPYIHNZ`ZÌ

[LT ZOV\SK IL YLWHPYLK PTTLKPH[LS` I` `V\Y

H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

5V[L
(PYIHN JVTWVULU[Z LN Z[LLYPUN ^OLLS KVVY

[YPT TH` IL KPZHZZLTISLK VUS` I` HU H\[OÌ

VYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

>OLUKPZWVZPUNVMH\ZLKHPYIHN\UP[V\YZHML[`

PUZ[Y\J[PVUZT\Z[ILMVSSV^LK;OLZLPUZ[Y\J[PVUZ

JHU IL VI[HPULK H[ HU` H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL

KLHSLY

"mamV˜daV^›

;OL JLU[YHS [YPNNLYPUN \UP[ TVUP[VYZ [OL VWLYÌ

H[PVUHS YLHKPULZZ VM [OL HPYIHN Z`Z[LT HUK [OL

^HYUPUNSPNO[

(U` THSM\UJ[PVUZ [OH[ TH` VJJ\Y ^PSS IL PUKPÌ

JH[LK I` [OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[

WHULSHUKVUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY

0U [OL MVSSV^PUN JHZLZ `V\ ZOV\SK PTTLÍ

KPH[LS` JVUZ\S[ HU H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL

KLHSLY PU VYKLY [V HZZ\YL [OL HPYIHN Z`ZÍ

[LTPZM\UJ[PVUPUNWYVWLYS`!



0SS\TPUH[PVU VM [OL HPYIHN ^HYUPUN SPNO[ K\YPUN

[YH]LS VY YLWLH[LK PSS\TPUH[PVU SVUNLY [OHU 

ZLJVUKZHM[LY[OLPNUP[PVUJPYJ\P[PZ[\YULKVU



0SS\TPUH[PVU MHPSZ [V SPNO[ \W K\YPUN PNUP[PVU JPYÌ

J\P[HJ[P]H[PVU

0M [OL HPYIHNZ VU [OL WHZZLUNLYqZ ZPKL HYL

Z^P[JOLK VMM I` [OL JOPSK YLZ[YHPU[ Z`Z[LT VY

PM HU PUZ[HSSLK JOPSK YLZ[YHPU[ Z`Z[LT PZ KL[LJ[LK

^OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ Z^P[JOLK VU [OL ^HYUPUN

SPNO[MSHZOLZMVYZLJVUKZ^OLU[OLPNUP[PVUPZ

VU

+HUNLY

0M [OL SPNO[ KVLZ UV[ MSHZO [OL HPYIHNZ HYL

UV[ KLHJ[P]H[LK HUK H JOPSK YLZ[YHPU[ Z`ZÍ

[LTT\Z[UV[ILPUZ[HSSLK

/H]L [OL MH\S[ YLTLKPLK PTTLKPH[LS` I` HU

H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

a*"V˜h"am›Fm"m4F

0UVYKLY[VLUZ\YLSVUNÌ[LYTM\UJ[PVUPUN[OLHPYÌ

IHNZ`Z[LTT\Z[ILPUZWLJ[LKI`HUH\[OVYPaLK

7VYZJOLKLHSLYHM[LYHUK`LHYZMYVT[OL

KH[L VM THU\MHJ[\YL ZOV^U VU [OL ZHML[` JVTÌ

WSPHUJLZ[PJRLYHUKL]LY``LHYZ[OLYLHM[LY

0TWVY[HU[PUMVYTH[PVU
0M `V\ ZLSS `V\Y 7VYZJOL UV[PM` [OL W\YJOHZLY

[OH[ [OL ]LOPJSL PZ LX\PWWLK ^P[O HPYIHNZ HUK

YLMLY [OLT [V [OL JOHW[LY s(PYIHN :`Z[LTZr PU

[OLV^ULYqZTHU\HSZHML[`HUKKPZWVZHSY\SLZ

-\Y[OLYPUMVYTH[PVUVU[OLHPYIHNZ`Z[LTJHUIL

MV\UK VU Z[PJRLYZ H[ [OL Z\U ]PZVYZ HZ ^LSS HZ

VUHSSHPYIHNJVTWVULU[Z

-VYZWLJPHSYLJVTTLUKH[PVUZVU[OL\ZLVMJOPSK

YLZ[YHPU[Z WSLHZL YLMLY [V [OL JOHW[LY VU s*OPSK

9LZ[YHPU[:`Z[LTZr

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

Ts

background image

"camV˜a=’

"camV˜"’’a’›"m›˜|"c’’a’›Fm›}

>OLU [OL KYP]LY IHJRZ \W [OL WHYRPUNHZZPZ[HU[

Z`Z[LT PUKPJH[LZ [OL KPZ[HUJL IL[^LLU [OL JHY

HUK HU VIZ[HJSL ILOPUK P[ I` TLHUZ VM ZPNUHS

[VULZ

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMHJJPKLU[

+LZWP[L \ZL VM [OL WHYRPUN HZZPZ[HU[ Z`ZÍ

[LT[OLKYP]LYPZZ[PSSYLZWVUZPISLMVY[HRPUN

K\L JHYL HUK HZZLZZPUN VIZ[HJSLZ ^OLU

IHJRPUN\W

4HRL Z\YL [OH[ UV WLYZVUZ HUPTHSZ VY VIÌ

Z[HJSLZHYL^P[OPU[OLTHUVL\]YPUNHYLH

;OLWHYRPUNHZZPZ[HU[Z`Z[LTPZHJ[P]H[LKH\[VTH[Ì

PJHSS` ^OLU YL]LYZL NLHY PZ ZLSLJ[LK HUK [OL PNUPÌ

[PVUPZVU

5V[L
)L H^HYL [OH[ [OL WHYRPUN HZZPZ[HU[ Z`Z[LT PZ

UV[ Z^P[JOLK VU PM[OLJHYYVSSZIHJR^HYK^P[OV\[

YL]LYZLNLHYILPUNLUNHNLK

<S[YHZV\UKZLUZVYZ

:LUZVYZ
-V\Y \S[YHZV\UK ZLUZVYZ PU [OL YLHY I\TWLY

TLHZ\YL[OLKPZ[HUJL[V[OLJSVZLZ[VIZ[HJSL



9HUNLTPKKSLZLUZVYZHYV\UKPUJT



9HUNLV\[LYZLUZVYZHYV\UKPUJT

6IZ[HJSLZJHUUV[ILKL[LJ[LKPU[OLsISPUKrZLUÌ

ZVYHYLHLNULHY[OLNYV\UK

5V[L
;OL ZLUZVYZ T\Z[ HS^H`Z IL RLW[ MYLL VM K\Z[

PJL HUK ZUV^ PU VYKLY [V LUZ\YL [OH[ [OL` HYL

M\SS`M\UJ[PVUHS

*H\[PVU

;VH]VPKKHTHNPUN[OLZLUZVYZ!

4HPU[HPUZ\MMPJPLU[KPZ[HUJL^OLUJSLHUPUN^P[O

Z[LHTÌQL[\UP[Z

:PNUHS[VULZM\UJ[PVU
>OLU YL]LYZL NLHY PZ ZLSLJ[LK [OL WHYRPUN HZÌ

ZPZ[HU[JVUMPYTZ[OH[P[PZZ^P[JOLKVUI`PZZ\PUN

HZOVY[ZPNUHS[VUL

(KL[LJ[LKVIZ[HJSLPZZPNUHSSLKI`HUPU[LYTP[Í

[LU[ [VUL ;OL PU[LY]HSZ KLJYLHZL HZ [OL VIÌ

Z[HJSLPZHWWYVHJOLK

( JVU[PU\V\Z [VUL ZV\UKZ ^OLU [OL KPZ[HUJL

ILJVTLZ SLZZ [OHU VUL MVV[ ;OPZ JVU[PU\V\Z

[VUL JHU Z[VW PM [OL VIZ[HJSL PZ HWWYVHJOLK

JSVZLY[OHUVULMVV[

;OL YHKPV ]VS\TL ZOV\SK UV[ IL ZV SV\K HZ

[VKYV^UV\[[OLZPNUHS[VULZ

T¢˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

3PTP[ZVM\S[YHZVUPJTLHZ\YLTLU[
;OLWHYRPUNHZZPZ[HU[Z`Z[LTJHUUV[KL[LJ[!



ZV\UKÌHIZVYIPUN VIZ[HJSLZ LN WV^KLY

ZUV^



ZV\UKÌYLMSLJ[PUN VIZ[HJSLZ LN NSHZZ Z\YÌ

MHJLZMSH[WHPU[LKZ\YMHJLZ



HUK]LY`[OPUVIZ[HJSLZ



6[OLY \S[YHZV\UK ZV\YJLZ LN WUL\TH[PJ

IYHRLZ VM V[OLY ]LOPJSLZ QHJROHTTLYZ JHU

PU[LYMLYL^P[OKL[LJ[PVUVMVIZ[HJSLZ

-H\S[PUKPJH[PVU
;OLWHYRPUNHZZPZ[HU[Z`Z[LTPUKPJH[LZHMH\S[PU

[^V^H`Z!



(M[LY YL]LYZL NLHY OHZ ILLU ZLSLJ[LK [OL

ZOVY[ ZPNUHS [VUL PZ MVSSV^LK I` H JVU[PU\V\Z

[VULVM[OLZHTLWP[JO!

;OPZ PUKPJH[LZ [OH[ ZLUZVYZ HYL ZVPSLK VY

JV]LYLK^P[OPJL



(M[LY YL]LYZL NLHY OHZ ILLU ZLSLJ[LK [OL

ZOVY[ ZPNUHS [VUL PZ MVSSV^LK I` H JVU[PU\V\Z

[VUL^P[OHT\JOSV^LYWP[JO!

;OPZ PUKPJH[LZ H NLULYHS Z`Z[LT MH\S[ 7SLHZL

OH]L [OL MH\S[ YLTLKPLK H[ HU H\[OVYPaLK

7VYZJOLKLHSLY

(Í*VU[YVSZ^P[JOMVYKVVYTPYYVYHKQ\Z[TLU[

§a¦FddamV˜=p§m˜hap˜Vd"’’˜pm˜›^F

z"’’FmVFŒ’˜’a=F

6U ]LOPJSLZ ^P[O ZLH[ TLTVY` `V\ JHU HJ[P]H[L

HUHKKP[PVUHSWHYRPUNHPK

(J[P]H[PUNZLLs:LH[4LTVY`r



>OLU YL]LYZL NLHY PZ LUNHNLK [OL TPYYVY

NSHZZ VU [OL WHZZLUNLYqZ ZPKL Z^P]LSZ KV^U

ZSPNO[S`[VZOV^[OLJ\YIHYLH



;OL TPYYVY NSHZZ YL[\YUZ [V P[Z PUP[PHS WVZP[PVU

^OLU[OLJHYPZZOPM[LKV\[VMYL]LYZLNLHY

4V]PUNTPYYVYNSHZZ[VP[ZPUP[PHSWVZP[PVU

^P[OYL]LYZLNLHYLUNHNLK

)YPLMS`TV]LJVU[YVSZ^P[JO(PUHU`KPYLJ[PVU

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

F›"4›"*dF˜F"˜zpadF

;OLYLHYZWVPSLYYLK\JLZHPYYLZPZ[HUJLHUKWHYÌ

[PJ\SHYS`H[OPNOZWLLKZYLK\JLZYLHYH_SLSPM[

¤›ph"›a4˜4pm›pd

;OL YLHY ZWVPSLY H\[VTH[PJHSS` L_[LUKZ H[ HWÌ

WYV_PTH[LS` TWO RTO HUK YL[YHJ[Z H[

HWWYV_PTH[LS`TWORTO

"mamV˜daV^›

;OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[ PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[ WHULS SPNO[Z

MVYHSHTWJOLJR^OLUPNUP[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVU

;OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[ WHULS HUK

VUÌIVHYK JVTW\[LY NV VU PM [OL YLHY ZWVPSLY

KVLZ UV[ L_[LUK H[ TVYL [OHU  TWO

RTOVYPM[OLLUKWVZP[PVUPZUV[YLHJOLK

0M[OLH\[VTH[PJJVU[YVSMHPSZ!

,_[LUK [OL YLHY ZWVPSLY THU\HSS` I` WYLZZPUN

[OLZWVPSLYYVJRLYZ^P[JO

+HUNLY

9PZRVMHUHJJPKLU[

;OLZWVPSLYHMMLJ[ZTV]LTLU[VMHPYHYV\UK

[OL]LOPJSLHUKPZ\ZLK[VTHPU[HPUHLYVK`Í

UHTPJZ[HIPSP[`HZ]LOPJSLZWLLKZPUJYLHZL

0M[OLZWVPSLYKVLZUV[L_[LUKH\[VTH[PJHSS`

K\L[VTLJOHUPJHSTHSM\UJ[PVUKYP]PUNZ[HÍ

IPSP[` ^PSS IL HK]LYZLS` HMMLJ[LK I` PUÍ

JYLHZLK YLHY H_SL SPM[ ^OPJO JV\SK SLHK [V

SVZZVMJVU[YVS

(KHW[ `V\Y KYP]PUN Z[`SL HUK YLK\JL ZWLLK [V

[OLJOHUNLKHLYVK`UHTPJJVUKP[PVUZ

/H]L [OL MH\S[ YLTLKPLK H[ HU H\[OVYPaLK

7VYZJOLKLHSLY

+VUV[L_JLLK[OLWVZ[LKSLNHSZWLLKSPTP[

TT˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

"m¤"d˜4pm›pd

>OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ VU [OL ZWVPSLY JHU IL L_Ì

[LUKLK HUK YL[YHJ[LK THU\HSS` \ZPUN [OL YVJRLY

Z^P[JO

>HYUPUN

:LYPV\Z PUQ\YPLZ TH` VJJ\Y MYVT JY\ZOPUN

HUKWPUJOPUNH[HSSTV]PUNWHY[ZPU[OLHYLH

VM[OLYL[YHJ[HISLZWVPSLY

,UZ\YL[OH[UVVULJHUILPUQ\YLKHUKUVVIÌ

QLJ[Z JHU IL QHTTLK I` [OL L_[LUZPVU VY YLÌ

[YHJ[PVUVM[OLYLHYZWVPSLY

,_[LUZPVU

7YLZZSLM[OHSMVMYVJRLYZ^P[JOIYPLMS`

;OLZWVPSLYL_[LUKZ[VP[ZMPUHSWVZP[PVU

9L[YHJ[PVU

7YLZZHUKOVSKYPNO[OHSMVMYVJRLYZ^P[JO\U[PS

[OLYLHYZWVPSLYOHZYLHJOLKP[ZMPUHSWVZP[PVU

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

TQ

background image

d¤›4^˜F="d

;OL JS\[JO WLKHS T\Z[ IL KLWYLZZLK M\SS`

ILMVYL[OLZ[HY[LY^PSSLUNHNL

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMHUHJJPKLU[

(S^H`Z JOLJR [OL TV]LTLU[ VM [OL JS\[JO

WLKHS ILMVYL KYP]PUN HUK THRL Z\YL [OH[ P[ PZ

UV[ VIZ[Y\J[LK I` H MSVVY TH[ VY HU` V[OLY

VIQLJ[

:LJ\YL[OLMSVVYTH[[VWYL]LU[P[MYVTZSPKPUN

PU[V WVZP[PVUZ [OH[ JV\SK PU[LYMLYL ^P[O [OL

ZHMLVWLYH[PVUVM`V\Y]LOPJSL

@V\Y 7VYZJOL KLHSLY ^PSS IL NSHK [V VMMLY `V\

MSVVY TH[Z VM [OL JVYYLJ[ ZPaL PUJS\KPUN H ZLÌ

J\YPUNWVZZPIPSP[`

;V H]VPK KHTHNL [V [OL JS\[JO HUK [YHUZÍ

TPZZPVU!

(S^H`Z KLWYLZZ [OL JS\[JO WLKHS M\SS` ^OLU

JOHUNPUNNLHYZ

+VUV[OVSK[OLJHYVUHZ[LLWNYHKL^P[O[OL

JS\[JOWLKHSWHY[PHSS`KLWYLZZLK

:OV\SK [OL MYLL [YH]LS VM [OL JS\[JO WLKHS Z\KÌ

KLUS` ILJVTL IPNNLY P[ JV\SK TLHU H THSM\UJÌ

[PVU VM [OL JS\[JO :LL `V\Y 7VYZJOL KLHSLY MVY

JVYYLJ[PVU

"camV˜"cF

7HYRPUN IYHRL MVYJL PZ TLJOHUPJHSS` [YHUZMLYYLK

[V[OLYLHY^OLLSZI`TLHUZVMJHISLZ

<ZL [OL WHYRPUN IYHRL VUS` HM[LY [OL ]LOPJSL

OHZJVTL[VHM\SSZ[VW

F››amV˜›^F˜z"camV˜*"cF

7\SS[OLSL]LYHSS[OL^H`\WZLLHYYV^

>P[O [OL PNUP[PVU VU [OL WHYRPUN IYHRL ^HYUÌ

PUNSPNO[ZPU[OLPUZ[Y\TLU[WHULSHUKVUÌIVHYK

JVTW\[LY ^PSS JVTL VU PM [OL SL]LY PZ L]LU

ZSPNO[S` YHPZLK ( MPYT W\SS \W^HYK PZ YLX\PYLK

[VWYVWLYS`LUNHNL[OLWHYRPUNIYHRL

0M [OL IYHRL PZ UV[ M\SS` ZL[ [OL ]LOPJSL TH`

YVSS^P[OV\[JVU[YVS

4V]L [OL ZLSLJ[VY SL]LY [V s7r ;PW[YVUPJ VY

TV]L [OL NLHYZOPM[ SL]LY [V YL]LYZL VY MPYZ[

NLHY4HU\HS[YHUZTPZZPVU

)LMVYLL_P[PUN[OL]LOPJSLTHRLZ\YL[OH[[OL

WHYRPUN IYHRL PZ M\SS` ZL[ HUK [OL ]LOPJSL PZ

UV[TV]PUNH[HSS

FdF"’amV˜›^F˜z"camV˜*"cF

7\SS [OL SL]LY ZSPNO[S` \W HZ `V\ KLWYLZZ [OL

YLSLHZL I\[[VU ( HUK [OLU W\ZO [OL SL]LY HSS

[OL^H`KV^U

T–˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

"camV˜*"cF˜§"mamV˜daV^›˜

"camV˜*"cF˜§"mamV˜daV^›

"m"="

;OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z ^PSS NV V\[ HM[LY [OL WHYRPUN

IYHRLPZM\SS`YLSLHZLK

;OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z HYL UV[ HU PUKPJH[VY [OH[ [OL

WHYRPUN IYHRL PZ M\SS` ZL[" P[ PZ VUS` PU[LUKLK [V

IL H ^HYUPUN [V YLSLHZL [OL WHYRPUN IYHRL ILÌ

MVYLKYP]PUN[OLJHY

*H\[PVU

( WHY[PHSS` LUNHNLK IYHRL ^PSS V]LYOLH[[OL

YLHYIYHRLZYLK\JL[OLPYLMMLJ[P]LULZZHUK

JH\ZLL_JLZZP]L^LHY

9LSLHZL[OLWHYRPUNIYHRLM\SS`

>OLUWHYRPUN`V\YJHYHS^H`ZZL[[OLWHYRPUN

IYHRLI`W\SSPUNHSS[OL^H`\WVU[OLSL]LY

4V]L [OL ZLSLJ[VY SL]LY [V s7r ;PW[YVUPJ VY

TV]L [OL NLHYZOPM[ SL]LY [V YL]LYZL VY MPYZ[

NLHY4HU\HS[YHUZTPZZPVU

6UOPSSZHSZV[\YU[OLMYVU[^OLLSZ[V^HYKZ[OL

J\YI

"cF’

4HRLP[HOHIP[[VJOLJR[OLVWLYH[PVUVM`V\Y

IYHRLZILMVYLKYP]PUN

2LLWPUTPUK[OH[[OLIYHRPUNKPZ[HUJLPUJYLHZLZ

]LY` YHWPKS` HZ[OLZWLLKPUJYLHZLZ([TWO

VY  RTO MVY L_HTWSL P[ PZ UV[ [^PJL I\[

MV\Y[PTLZSVUNLY[OHUTWOVYRTO;PYL

[YHJ[PVUPZHSZVSLZZLMMLJ[P]L^OLU[OLYVHKZHYL

^L[VYZSPWWLY`

;OLYLMVYL HS^H`Z THPU[HPU H ZHML KPZ[HUJL

MYVT[OLJHYPUMYVU[VM`V\

5V[L
,]LU [OV\NO [OL IYHRL KPZJZ JVUZPZ[ VM HSSV`LK

NYL`JHZ[PYVU[OL`^PSS\UH]VPKHIS`Z[HY[[VJVYÌ

YVKL PM `V\Y JHY PZ WHYRLK MVY HU L_[LUKLK

WLYPVK ;OL IYHRLZ ^PSS [LUK [V sY\Ir HZ [OL YLÌ

Z\S[

;OL UH[\YL L_[LU[ HUK LMMLJ[Z VM JVYYVZPVU KLÌ

WLUK VU [OL HTV\U[ VM [PTL [OL ]LOPJSL ^HZ

WHYRLK^OL[OLYNYHU\SHYVYSPX\PKYVHKZHS[^HZ

ZWYLHK HUK ^OL[OLY NYLHZLÌKPZZVS]PUN HNLU[Z

^LYL\ZLKPUJHY^HZOLZ

0M[OLIYHRPUNJVTMVY[PZUV[PJLHIS`PTWHPYLK^L

YLJVTTLUK OH]PUN [OL IYHRL Z`Z[LT JOLJRLK

I`L_WLY[ZH[HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

"cF˜’©’›Fh˜O¤m4›apm

@V\Y7VYZJOLPZLX\PWWLK^P[OHWV^LYHZZPZ[LK

O`KYH\SPJ K\HS JPYJ\P[ IYHRL Z`Z[LT ^P[O KPZJ

IYHRLZH[[OLMYVU[HUKYLHY

)V[O JPYJ\P[Z M\UJ[PVU PUKLWLUKLU[S` 6UL IYHRL

JPYJ\P[VWLYH[LZ[OLMYVU[HUK[OLV[OLYVWLYH[LZ

[OLYLHY

0M VUL IYHRL JPYJ\P[ OHZ MHPSLK [OL V[OLY ^PSSZ[PSS

VWLYH[L /V^L]LY `V\ ^PSS UV[PJL HU PUJYLHZLK

WLKHS[YH]LS^OLU`V\HWWS`[OLIYHRLZ

-HPS\YL VM VUL IYHRL JPYJ\P[ ^PSS JH\ZL [OL Z[VWÌ

WPUNKPZ[HUJL[VPUJYLHZL

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMHUHJJPKLU[

0U [OL \USPRLS` L]LU[ VM O`KYH\SPJ MHPS\YL VM

VULIYHRLJPYJ\P[!

7\ZO [OL IYHRL WLKHS KV^U MPYTS` HUK OVSK P[

PU[OH[WVZP[PVU

(TLJOHUPJHSSPURHNLHJ[P]H[LZ[OLZLJVUKJPYÌ

J\P[ HUK `V\ ^PSS IL HISL [V IYPUN [OL ]LOPJSL

[VHZ[VW

(M[LY IYPUNPUN `V\Y ]LOPJSL [V H JVTWSL[L

Z[VW H]VPK KYP]PUN [OL ]LOPJSL HUK PUZ[LHK

OH]L P[ [V^LK [V [OL ULHYLZ[ H\[OVYPaLK

7VYZJOLKLHSLYMVYYLWHPY

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

˜˜˜˜˜˜˜"cF˜§"mamV˜daV^›˜

"cF˜§"mamV˜daV^›˜"m"="

0M [OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[ WHULS HUK

VUÌIVHYK JVTW\[LY NV VU ^OPSL KYP]PUN [OL

IYHRLMS\PKSL]LSTH`IL[VVSV^VYPM[OLIYHRL

WLKHS[YH]LSOHZPUJYLHZLKVULVM[OL[^VIYHRL

JPYJ\P[ZTH`OH]LMHPSLK

( NYLH[LY IYHRPUN WYLZZ\YL ^PSS IL YLX\PYLK

Z[VWWPUN KPZ[HUJLZ ^PSS IL SVUNLY HUK [OL IYHRÌ

PUNILOH]PVY^PSSJOHUNLWHY[PJ\SHYS`PUJ\Y]LZ

>P[O JVYYLJ[S` HKQ\Z[LK IYHRLZ HUK H JVYYLJ[S`

^VYRPUN IYHRL Z`Z[LT [OL WLKHS [YH]LS [V [OL

WVPU[VMIYHRLHJ[\H[PVUZOV\SKILÌPU[V

Ì PUVY[VTT

>OLUL]LY [OL IYHRL WLKHS [YH]LS L_JLLKZ [OPZ

KPZ[HUJLOH]L[OLIYHRLZ`Z[LTJOLJRLK

"cF˜zF="d

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMHUHJJPKLU[

(U` VIZ[Y\J[PVU VM [OL IYHRL WLKHS JV\SK

PUJYLHZL[OLZ[VWWPUNKPZ[HUJL

(S^H`Z JOLJR [OL TV]LTLU[ VM [OL IYHRL

WLKHS ILMVYL KYP]PUN HUK THRL Z\YL [OH[ P[ PZ

UV[ VIZ[Y\J[LK I` H MSVVY TH[ VY HU` V[OLY

VIQLJ[

:LJ\YL[OLMSVVYTH[[VWYL]LU[P[MYVTZSPKPUN

PU[V WVZP[PVUZ [OH[ JV\SK PU[LYMLYL ^P[O [OL

ZHMLVWLYH[PVUVM`V\Y]LOPJSL

@V\Y 7VYZJOL KLHSLY ^PSS IL NSHK [V VMMLY `V\

MSVVY TH[Z VM [OL JVYYLJ[ ZPaL PUJS\KPUN H ZLÌ

J\YPUNWVZZPIPSP[`

5V[L
0U JHZL VUL VM [OL [^V IYHRL JPYJ\P[Z MHPSZ PUÌ

JYLHZLK WLKHS [YH]LS PZ YLX\PYLK [V IYPUN `V\Y

]LOPJSL[VHM\SSZ[VW

>HYUPUN

;V H]VPK V]LYOLH[PUN HUK WYLTH[\YL ^LHY

VM[OLIYHRLZ!

)LMVYL KLZJLUKPUN H Z[LLW NYHKL YLK\JL

ZWLLK HUK ZOPM[ [OL [YHUZTPZZPVU PU[V H SV^LY

NLHYVYKYP]PUNWVZP[PVU[VJVU[YVSZWLLK

+V UV[ sYPKL [OL IYHRLZr I` YLZ[PUN `V\Y MVV[

VU [OL WLKHS ^OLU UV[ PU[LUKPUN [V HWWS`

IYHRLWYLZZ\YL

+V UV[ OVSK [OL WLKHS KV^U [VV SVUN VY [VV

VM[LU

;OPZ JV\SK JH\ZL [OL IYHRLZ [V NL[ OV[ HUK

UV[M\UJ[PVUWYVWLYS`

TG˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

"cF˜*pp’›F

;OL IYHRL IVVZ[LY HZZPZ[Z IYHRPUN VUS`

^OLU[OLLUNPULPZY\UUPUN

>OLU [OL JHY PZ TV]PUN ^OPSL [OL LUNPUL PZ UV[

Y\UUPUN VY PM [OL IYHRL IVVZ[LY PZ KLMLJ[P]L

TVYLWYLZZ\YLVU[OLIYHRLWLKHSPZYLX\PYLK[V

IYPUN[OLJHY[VHZ[VW

4VPZ[\YLVYYVHKZHS[VUIYHRLZHMMLJ[ZIYHRPUN

>OLU [OL ]LOPJSL PZ KYP]LU VU ZHS[LK YVHKZ MVY

L_[LUKLKWLYPVKZ[OLIYHRLZZOV\SKIL^HZOLK

KV^U [OVYV\NOS` HIV\[ L]LY`  ^LLRZ (U H\[VÌ

TH[PJ JHY^HZO MHJPSP[` JHUUV[ KV [OPZ QVI

WYVWLYS`

)YHRLZ ^PSS KY` HM[LY H ML^ JH\[PV\Z IYHRL HWWSPÌ

JH[PVUZ

>HYUPUN

+YP]PUN[OYV\NO^H[LYTH`YLK\JL[YHJ[PVU

4VPZ[\YL VU IYHRLZ MYVT YVHK ^H[LY JHY

^HZO VY JVH[PUN VM YVHK ZHS[ TH` HMMLJ[

IYHRPUNLMMPJPLUJ`

*H\[PV\ZS` HWWS` IYHRLZ [V [LZ[ IYHRLZ HM[LY

ILPUNL_WVZLK

"cF˜§F"

@V\Y JHY OHZ L_JLSSLU[ IYHRLZ I\[ [OL` HYL Z[PSS

Z\IQLJ[ [V ^LHY ;OL YH[L H[ ^OPJO [OL` ^LHY

KLWLUKZVUOV^[OLIYHRLZHYL\ZLK

/H]L[OLIYHRLZ`Z[LTPUZWLJ[LKH[[OLPU[LYÌ

]HSZ YLJVTTLUKLK PU `V\Y 4HPU[LUHUJL

)VVRSL[

"mamV˜daV^›˜

"mamV˜daV^›˜"m"="

0M[OLSPNO[ZPU[OLPUZ[Y\TLU[WHULSHUKVUÌIVHYK

JVTW\[LYZ[H`VU^OLU[OLLUNPULPZY\UUPUNVY

JVTLVU^OPSLKYP]PUN[OLIYHRLWHKZHYL^VYU

L_JLZZP]LS`

+VUV[JVU[PU\L[VVWLYH[L[OL]LOPJSL

/H]L `V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY PUZWLJ[

VYYLWSHJL[OLIYHRLWHKZ

"cF˜z"=’

>LHY VU [OL IYHRL WHKZ HUK IYHRL KPZJZ

KLWLUKZ [V H NYLH[ L_[LU[ VU [OL KYP]PUN Z[`SL

HUK [OL JVUKP[PVUZ VM \ZL HUK [OLYLMVYL JHUUV[

ILL_WYLZZLKPUHJ[\HSTPSLZVU[OLYVHK

;OL OPNOÌWLYMVYTHUJL IYHRL Z`Z[LT PZ KLZPNULK

MVY VW[PTHS IYHRPUN LMMLJ[ H[ HSS ZWLLKZ HUK

[LTWLYH[\YLZ

*LY[HPUZWLLKZIYHRPUNMVYJLZHUKHTIPLU[JVUÌ

KP[PVUZZ\JOHZ[LTWLYH[\YLHUKO\TPKP[`[OLYLÌ

MVYLTPNO[JH\ZLIYHRLUVPZLZ

5L^IYHRLWHKZVYSPUPUNZ
5L^ IYHRL WHKZ HUK IYHRL KPZJZ OH]L [V IL

rIYVRLU PUs HUK [OLYLMVYL VUS` H[[HPU VW[PTHS

MYPJ[PVU ^OLU [OL JHY OHZ JV]LYLK ZL]LYHS O\UÌ

KYLKTPSLZVYRT

;OL ZSPNO[S` YLK\JLK IYHRPUN HIPSP[` T\Z[ IL

JVTWLUZH[LK MVY I` WYLZZPUN [OL IYHRL WLKHS

OHYKLY ;OPZ HSZV HWWSPLZ ^OLUL]LY [OL IYHRL

WHKZHUKIYHRLKPZJZHYLYLWSHJLK

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

Tn

background image

˜"cF˜©’›Fh

|m›adp4c˜"cF˜©’›Fh}

;OL():Z`Z[LTYLWYLZLU[ZHTHQVYJVU[YPI\[PVU

[V [OL LUOHUJLTLU[ VM HJ[P]L ZHML[` PU `V\Y ]LÌ

OPJSL ;OPZ Z`Z[LT WYL]LU[Z [OL ^OLLSZ MYVT

SVJRPUN PU H WHUPJ Z[VW VU HSTVZ[ HSS YVHK Z\YÌ

MHJLZ

>P[O[OL():Z`Z[LTPU`V\Y]LOPJSL[OL

MVSSV^PUNHYLHZHYLLUOHUJLK!
:[LLYPUN
 ]LOPJSL YLTHPUZ Z[LLYHISL \UKLY HSS

IYHRPUNMVYJLZ^OLU():PZLUNHNLK

.VVK KPYLJ[PVUHS JVU[YVS UV Z^LY]PUN JH\ZLK

I`SVJRPUNVM^OLLSZ\UKLYIYHRPUNJVUKP[PVUZ

:OVY[LYZ[VWWPUNKPZ[HUJLZ[VWWPUNKPZ[HUJLZ

HYL \Z\HSS` YLK\JLK ILJH\ZL JVU[YVSSLK IYHRPUN

PZTH_PTPaLK

7YL]LU[PVU VM ^OLLS SVJR \W UV IYHRLÌÌ

PUK\JLK ZSPKPUN HUK [O\Z UV SVJHSPaLK [PYL ^LHY

MYVTLTLYNLUJ`IYHRPUN

;OLJY\JPHSHK]HU[HNLVM[OL():Z`Z[LTV]LYH

JVU]LU[PVUHS IYHRL Z`Z[LT PZ PU [OL HYLH VM

THPU[HPUPUN KPYLJ[PVUHS JVU[YVS HUK THUL\]LYHÌ

IPSP[` VM [OL JHY PU LTLYNLUJ` ZP[\H[PVUZ K\YPUN

UVYTHSKYP]PUNPUJS\KPUNWHUPJIYHRPUNPU[\YUZ

>HYUPUN

;OL PUJYLHZLK JVU[YVS [OH[ PZ WYV]PKLK

ZOV\SKUV[PUK\JL`V\[V[HRLNYLH[LYYPZRZ

^P[O `V\Y ZHML[` ;OL SPTP[Z KPJ[H[LK I` [OL

SH^Z VM WO`ZPJZ JHUUV[ IL V]LYJVTL L]LU

^P[O():

;OL YPZR VM HJJPKLU[Z K\L [V PUHWWYVWYPH[L

ZWLLKJHUUV[ILYLK\JLKL]LUI`[OL():

;OL KYP]LY ILHYZ [OL YLZWVUZPIPSP[` MVY HSS

KYP]PUNTHUL\]LYZ

(KHW[`V\YKYP]PUNZ[`SL[V[OLWYL]HPSPUNYVHK

HUK^LH[OLYJVUKP[PVUZ

6IL`HSS[YHMMPJSH^Z

6[OLY ]LOPJSLZ UV[ LX\PWWLK ^P[O [OL ():

Z`Z[LT TH` UV[ IL HISL [V THPU[HPU JVUÍ

[YVS LZWLJPHSS` VU ^L[ VY WVVY YVHK Z\YÍ

MHJLZ HUK [O\Z TH` IL TVYL SPRLS` [V PTÍ

WHJ[`V\MYVTILOPUK

;V TPUPTPaL [OH[ YPZR \ZL `V\Y (): Z`Z[LT

[V PUJYLHZL `V\Y HIPSP[` [V THUL\]LY [V H]VPK

KHUNLYV\ZZP[\H[PVUZHUKUV[TLYLS`[V[Y`[V

Z[VWPU[OLZOVY[LZ[KPZ[HUJLWVZZPISL

Q¬˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

zF"›apm˜pO˜›^F˜˜’©’›Fh

(^OLLSZWLLKZLUZVYPZTV\U[LK[VLHJOVM[OL

MV\Y ^OLLSZ 0M ^OLLS SVJRÌ\W VM LP[OLY VM [OL

MYVU[^OLLSZVY[OLYLHY^OLLSZPZZLUZLKK\YPUN

IYHRPUN[OLIYHRLWYLZZ\YLPZHKQ\Z[LKH\[VTH[Ì

PJHSS` \U[PS [OL ^OLLS UV SVUNLY ZSPWZ ;OL IYHRL

WYLZZ\YL PZ YLN\SH[LK MVY LHJO MYVU[ ^OLLS PUKPÌ

]PK\HSS` HUK MVY IV[O VM [OL YLHY ^OLLSZ

[VNL[OLY

6UHYVHKZ\YMHJL^OPJOPZZSPWWLY`VUVUS`VUL

ZPKL[OLYLHY^OLLS^OPJOPZIYHRPUNVU[OLZSPWÌ

WLY` Z\YMHJL KL[LYTPULZ [OL IYHRL WYLZZ\YL

^OPJO^PSSILHWWSPLKLX\HSS`[VIV[OYLHY^OLLSZ

;OPZ LUZ\YLZ [OH[ KPYLJ[PVUHS Z[HIPSP[` PZ THPUÌ

[HPULK /V^L]LY PM IYHRPUN MVYJLZ HWWYVHJO [OL

^OLLSSVJRÌ\WWVPU[MVYHSS^OLLSZWHUPJIYHRPUN

[OL():Z`Z[LT^PSSPU[LY]LUL[VWYV]PKLHYHWPK

Y`[OTPJIYHRPUN

;OLWYVWLYVWLYH[PVUVM():PZWLYJLP]LKI`[OL

KYP]LY HZ H W\SZH[PUN IYHRL WLKHS PU JVUQ\UJ[PVU

^P[OH\KPISLUVPZLHUKWLYOHWZZVTL]PIYH[PVU

0M `V\ L_WLYPLUJL [OLZL ZLUZH[PVUZ ^OPSL KYP]Ì

PUN VY H YVHK Z\YMHJL ^P[O X\LZ[PVUHISL [YHJÌ

[PVUYLK\JL]LOPJSLZWLLKHWWYVWYPH[LMVY[OL

WYL]HPSPUNYVHKJVUKP[PVUZ

;OLM\UJ[PVUHSYLHKPULZZVMHSS[OLTHPULSLJ[YPJHS

JVTWVULU[Z VM [OL (): PZ JOLJRLK I` HU LSLJÌ

[YVUPJ TVUP[VYPUN Z`Z[LT IV[O ILMVYL HUK ^OPSL

`V\KYP]L

"mamV˜daV^›˜

"mamV˜daV^›˜"m"="

>OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ Z^P[JOLK VU [OL ():^HYUÌ

PUN SPNO[ ^PSS SPNO[ \W ^OPSL [OL Z`Z[LT PZ LSLJÌ

[YVUPJHSS` PU[LYYVNH[LK HUK NVLZ V\[ ^OLU [OL

LUNPUL PZ Z[HY[LK PM [OL JOLJR PZ UV[ `L[ JVTÌ

WSL[L

0M[OL():^HYUPUNSHTWMHPSZ[VNVV\[[OPZPUKPÌ

JH[LZ [OH[ (): OHZ ILLU KLHJ[P]H[LK K\L [V H

MH\S[0M[OL^HYUPUNSPNO[ZPU[OLPUZ[Y\TLU[WHULS

HUK VUÌIVHYK JVTW\[LY SPNO[ \W ^OPSL `V\ HYL

KYP]PUN [OPZ PUKPJH[LZ [OH[ H MH\S[ OHZ VJJ\YYLK

0U IV[O JHZLZ UVYTHS IYHRPUN HZ PU ]LOPJSLZ

^P[OV\[():PZZ[PSSYL[HPULK

;OL (): Z`Z[LT ZOV\SK OV^L]LY IL L_HTPULK

H[ HU H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY PTTLKPH[LS` [V

WYL]LU[[OLVJJ\YYLUJLVMM\Y[OLYMH\S[Z

0M [OL (): Z`Z[LT ILJVTLZ PUVWLYH[P]L [HRL

`V\Y ]LOPJSL [V `V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL

KLHSLYPTTLKPH[LS`

>HYUPUN

;OLJVU[YVS\UP[VM[OL():IYHRLZ`Z[LTPZ

ZL[ MVY Z[HUKHYK [PYL ZPaL 0M UVUÍZ[HUKHYK

[PYLZHYLPUZ[HSSLK[OLJVU[YVS\UP[TH`TPZÍ

PU[LYWYL[ [OL ZWLLK VM [OL ]LOPJSL ILJH\ZL

VM[OL]HYPHU[KH[HP[YLJLP]LZMYVT[OLZLUÍ

ZVYZVU[OLH_SLZ

<ZL VUS` [PYL THRLZ HUK [`WLZ [LZ[LK I`

7VYZJOL

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

Qs

background image

p’4^F˜›"*ada›©˜"m"VFhFm›

|}

7:4 PZ HU HJ[P]L JVU[YVS Z`Z[LT MVY Z[HIPSPaPUN

[OL]LOPJSLK\YPUNL_[YLTLKYP]PUNTHUL\]LYZ

>HYUPUN

;OL PUJYLHZLK JVU[YVS [OH[ PZ WYV]PKLK

ZOV\SKUV[PUK\JL`V\[V[HRLNYLH[LYYPZRZ

^P[O `V\Y ZHML[` ;OL SPTP[Z KPJ[H[LK I` [OL

SH^Z VM WO`ZPJZ JHUUV[ IL V]LYJVTL L]LU

^P[O7:4

;OL YPZR VM HJJPKLU[Z K\L [V PUHWWYVWYPH[L

ZWLLKJHUUV[ILYLK\JLKL]LUI`7:4

;OL KYP]LY ILHYZ [OL YLZWVUZPIPSP[` MVY HSS

KYP]PUNTHUL\]LYZ

(KHW[`V\YKYP]PUNZ[`SL[V[OLWYL]HPSPUNYVHK

HUK^LH[OLYJVUKP[PVUZ

6IL`HSS[YHMMPJSH^Z

=¦"m›"VF’˜pO˜


:\WLYPVY [YHJ[PVU HUK SHULÌOVSKPUN HIPSP[` PU HSS

KYP]PUN ZP[\H[PVUZ u L]LU VU YVHK Z\YMHJLZ

^P[O]HY`PUNMYPJ[PVU



7:4 HJ[P]LS` Z[HIPSPaLZ [OL ]LOPJSL K\YPUN K`Ì

UHTPJKYP]PUNTHUVL\]YLZLNYHWPKZ[LLYPUN

TV]LTLU[Z K\YPUN SHUL JOHUNLZ VY VU HS[LYÌ

UH[PUNJ\Y]LZ



0TWYV]LK IYHRPUN Z[HIPSP[` PU J\Y]LZ HUK VU

KPMMLYLU[VY]HY`PUNYVHKZ\YMHJLZ

F"=amF’’˜Op˜pzF"›apm

;OL 7:4 PZ LUNHNLK H\[VTH[PJHSS` L]LY` [PTL

`V\Z[HY[[OLLUNPUL

¤m4›apm

:LUZVYZ H[ [OL ^OLLSZ IYHRLZ Z[LLYPUN Z`Z[LT

HUKLUNPULJVU[PU\V\ZS`TLHZ\YL!



+YP]PUNZWLLK



+PYLJ[PVUVM[YH]LS



3H[LYHSHJJLSLYH[PVU



9H[LVM[\YUHIV\[[OL]LOPJSLqZ]LY[PJHSH_PZ

;OL 7:4 \ZLZ [OLZL ]HS\LZ [V KL[LYTPUL [OL

KPYLJ[PVUVM[YH]LSKLZPYLKI`[OLKYP]LY

7:4 PU[LY]LULZ HUK JVYYLJ[Z [OL JV\YZL PM [OL

]LOPJSLqZ HJ[\HS KPYLJ[PVU KL]PH[LZ MYVT [OL

KLZPYLK JV\YZL Z[LLYPUNÌ^OLLS WVZP[PVU 0[

IYHRLZ PUKP]PK\HS ^OLLSZ HZ ULLKLK 0M ULJLZZÌ

HY` [OL 7:4 HKKP[PVUHSS` PUMS\LUJLZ [OL LUNPUL

WV^LYVY[OLNLHYÌJOHUNPUNJOHYHJ[LYPZ[PJVM[OL

;PW[YVUPJPUVYKLY[VZ[HIPSPaL[OL]LOPJSL

;OL L]LU[Z ILSV^PUMVYT[OLKYP]LYVM7:4JVUÌ

[YVSVWLYH[PVUZHUK^HYUOPT[VHKHW[OPZKYP]PUN

Z[`SL[V[OLYVHKJVUKP[PVUZ!



;OL PUMVYTH[PVU SPNO[ PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[ WHULS

SPNO[Z\W



/`KYH\SPJUVPZLZJHUILOLHYK



;OL ]LOPJSL KLJLSLYH[LZ HUK Z[LLYPUNÌ^OLLS

MVYJLZ HYL HS[LYLK HZ [OL 7:4 JVU[YVSZ [OL

IYHRLZ



9LK\JLKLUNPULWV^LY



;OL IYHRL WLKHS W\SZH[LZ HUK P[Z WVZP[PVU PZ

JOHUNLKK\YPUNIYHRPUN

/V^L]LYP[PZWVZZPISLH[HU`[PTL[VHJOPL]L

M\SS]LOPJSLKLJLSLYH[PVUI`PUJYLHZPUN[OLMVV[

WYLZZ\YLZSPNO[S`VU[OLIYHRLWLKHS

Q¢˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

§a›4^amV˜pOO˜

7YLZZ [OL r7:4 6--s SVNV VM [OL YVJRLY

Z^P[JO

7:4PZZ^P[JOLKVMMHM[LYHIYPLMKLSH`

>P[O 7:4 Z^P[JOLK VMM [OL 7:4 6-- ^HYUPUN

SPNO[ PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[ WHULS HUK [OL YVJRLY

Z^P[JOPUKPJH[VYSPNO[HYLSP[

+\YPUN IYHRPUN [OL ]LOPJSL PZ Z[HIPSPaLK L]LU

^OLU7:4PZZ^P[JOLKVMM

6ULÍZPKLKZWPUUPUNVM[OL^OLLSZPZWYL]LU[LK

L]LU^P[O7:4Z^P[JOLKVMM

7:4 ZOV\SK HS^H`Z IL Z^P[JOLK VU K\YPUN

rUVYTHSsKYP]PUN

/V^L]LY P[ JHU IL VM HK]HU[HNL [V Z^P[JO VMM

7:4[LTWVYHYPS`PUL_JLW[PVUHSZP[\H[PVUZ!



6UHSVVZLZ\YMHJLVYPUKLLWZUV^



>OLUrYVJRPUN[OL]LOPJSLMYLLs



>OLU\ZPUNZUV^JOHPUZ

;PW[YVUPJ ]LOPJSLZ! >OLU [OL 7:4 PZ Z^P[JOLK

VMM[OLZSPWTVUP[VYPUNM\UJ[PVUVM[OL;PW[YVUPJPZ

HSZVKLHJ[P]H[LK

§a›4^amV˜˜*"4c˜pm

7YLZZ [OL PUKPJH[VY SPNO[ PU [OL YVJRLY Z^P[JO

7:4PZZ^P[JOLKVUHM[LYHIYPLMKLSH`

mOph"›apm˜daV^›



;OL 7:4 PUMVYTH[PVU SPNO[ PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[

WHULSSPNO[Z\WMVYHSHTWJOLJR^OLU[OLPNÌ

UP[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVU



;OL SPNO[ PUKPJH[LZ 7:4 PU[LY]LU[PVU L]LU

^OLU7:4PZZ^P[JOLKVMMIYHRLYLN\SH[PVUPU

[OLL]LU[VMVULÌZPKLK^OLLSZWPU

"mamV˜daV^›



;OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[ PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[ WHULS

SPNO[Z\WPUJVTIPUH[PVU^P[O[OLPUKPJH[VYSPNO[

PU [OL YVJRLY Z^P[JO MVY H SHTW JOLJR ^OLU

[OLPNUP[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVU



0U JVTIPUH[PVU ^P[O [OL PUKPJH[VY SPNO[ PU [OL

YVJRLY Z^P[JO [OL SPNO[ PUKPJH[LZ [OH[ 7:4 PZ

Z^P[JOLKVMM



;OL SPNO[Z PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[ WHULS HUK PU [OL

VUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LYPUKPJH[LHKLMLJ[

7:4PZV\[VMVYKLY

;OL MH\S[ ZOV\SK IL YLTLKPLK PTTLKPH[LS` H[

HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

p§amV

9LMLY[V[OLJOHW[LYr;V^PUNs

"m=*"cF˜›F’›’˜

/HUKIYHRL [LZ[Z VU [OL YVSSLY [LZ[ Z[HUK T\Z[

ILWLYMVYTLKVUS`^P[O[OLPNUP[PVUZ^P[JOLKVMM

9LMLY[V[OLJOHW[LYr-V\YÌ^OLLSKYP]Ls

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

p¤_^FFd˜a¦F

>P[O [OL MV\YÌ^OLLS KYP]L VM [OL  ;\YIV [OL

LUNPUL WV^LY PZ ]HYPHIS` KPZ[YPI\[LK [V [OL MYVU[

HUKYLHY^OLLSZ

7V^LY KPZ[YPI\[PVU HUK ^OLLS ZWLLK JVTWLUZHÌ

[PVUIL[^LLU[OLMYVU[HUKYLHYH_SLZPZYLHSPZLK

^P[OH]PZJV\ZT\S[PWSLÌKPZJJS\[JO

+PZ[YPI\[PVU VM [OL LUNPUL WV^LY PZ KLWLUKLU[

\WVU [OL ^OLLS ZWLLK KPMMLYLUJL IL[^LLU [OL

[^VH_SLZ

;OL ]PZJV\Z T\S[PWSLÌKPZJ JS\[JO HS^H`Z KLSP]LYZ

Z\MMPJPLU[ KYP]L WV^LY [V [OL MYVU[ ^OLLSZ

HWWYV_ [V [VLUZ\YLVW[PT\T[YHJ[PVU

L]LUVUHWVVYYVHKZ\YMHJL

0U JVTIPUH[PVU ^P[O [OL 7VYZJOL :[HIPSP[` 4HUÌ

HNLTLU[ 7:4 MV\YÌ^OLLS KYP]L LUZ\YLZ VW[PÌ

T\TOHUKSPUNHUKPUJYLHZLKKYP]PUNZ[HIPSP[`

>HYUPUN

;OL PUJYLHZLK JVU[YVS [OH[ PZ WYV]PKLK

ZOV\SKUV[PUK\JL`V\[V[HRLNYLH[LYYPZRZ

^P[O `V\Y ZHML[` ;OL SPTP[Z KPJ[H[LK I` [OL

SH^Z VM WO`ZPJZ JHUUV[ IL V]LYJVTL L]LU

^P[OMV\YÍ^OLLSKYP]L

;OL YPZR VM HJJPKLU[Z K\L [V PUHWWYVWYPH[L

ZWLLK JHUUV[ IL YLK\JLK L]LU I` MV\YÍ

^OLLSKYP]L

;OL KYP]LY ILHYZ [OL YLZWVUZPIPSP[` MVY HSS

KYP]PUNTHUL\]LYZ

(KHW[`V\YKYP]PUNZ[`SL[V[OLWYL]HPSPUNYVHK

HUK^LH[OLYJVUKP[PVUZ

6IL`HSS[YHMMPJSH^Z

©m"hphF›F˜›F’›amV˜zp4F=¤F

:VTL <: Z[H[LZ HUK *HUHKPHU WYV]PUJLZ JVUÌ

K\J[ LTPZZPVUZ PUZWLJ[PVUTHPU[LUHUJL [LZ[PUN

PU]VS]PUN[OL\ZLVM[^VÌ^OLLSK`UHTVTL[LY

( [^VÌ^OLLSLK K`UHTVTL[LY PZ H [YLHKTPSS [`WL

KL]PJL \WVU ^OPJO H ZPUNSL H_SL VM [OL JHY [OL

KYP]PUN H_SL VM [OL ]LOPJSL YV[H[LZ [V ZPT\SH[L

]LOPJSL VWLYH[PVU VU [OL YVHK ^OPSL [OL ]LOPJSL

YLTHPUZZ[H[PVUHY`

@V\Y  ;\YIV OHZ H M\SSÌ[PTL MV\YÌ^OLLS KYP]L

Z`Z[LT ^OPJO JHUUV[ IL KPZHISLK :L]LYL KHTÌ

HNL [V [OL WV^LY[YHPU JHU YLZ\S[ PM [LZ[LK VU H

[^VÌ^OLLSK`UHTVTL[LY

>HYUPUN

;V H]VPK ZL]LYL WV^LY[YHPU KHTHNL HUK H

WVZZPISL \UL_WLJ[LK TV]LTLU[ VM [OL ]LÍ

OPJSL

@V\Y ;\YIV]LOPJSLT\Z[UL]LYIL[LZ[LK

VUH[^VÌ^OLLSK`UHTVTL[LY

(K]PZL[OLLTPZZPVUZ[H[PVUVM[OPZ^HYUPUNILÌ

MVYL[LZ[PUN[OL]LOPJSL

7V^LYTLHZ\YLTLU[
7V^LYTLHZ\YLTLU[ZVUK`UHTVTL[LYZHYLUV[

HWWYV]LKI`7VYZJOL

QT˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

"cF˜›F’›’

)YHRL [LZ[Z T\Z[ IL WLYMVYTLK VUS` VU WSH[LÌ

[`WL[LZ[Z[HUKZVYYVSSLY[LZ[Z[HUKZ

;OLMVSSV^PUNSPTP[]HS\LZT\Z[UV[ILL_JLLKLK

VUYVSSLY[LZ[Z[HUKZ!



;LZ[PUNZWLLKTWORTO



;LZ[K\YH[PVUZLJVUKZ

"m=*"cF˜›F’›’

/HUKIYHRL [LZ[Z VU [OL YVSSLY [LZ[ Z[HUK T\Z[

ILWLYMVYTLKVUS`^P[O[OLPNUP[PVUZ^P[JOLKVMM

"d"m4amV˜§^FFd’˜pm˜›^F˜¦F^a4dF

+\YPUNMPUPZOIHSHUJPUNVM[OL^OLLSZ[OL]LOPJSL

T\Z[ IL OVPZ[LK HUK [OL ^OLLSZ HISL [V YV[H[L

MYLLS`

p§amV

9LMLY[V[OLJOHW[LYr;V^PUNs

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

QQ

background image

Q–˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

zF"›apm:˜ m’›¤hFm›’

  :PKL]LU[
  0NUP[PVUZ[HY[LYZ^P[JO^P[OZ[LLYPUNSVJR

  :WHJLMVYOHUKZÌMYLLTPJYVWOVUL

MVY[LSLWOVUL

  ;\YUZPNUHSZ

OLHKSPNO[KPTTLYMSHZOLYSL]LY

  0UZ[Y\TLU[WHULS

  /VYU
  >PUKZOPLSK^PWLY^HZOLYSL]LY
  ,TLYNLUJ`MSHZOLYZ^P[JO

 9VJRLYZ^P[JOLZMVY

7VYZJOL:[HIPSP[`4HUHNLTLU[7:4

YLHYZWVPSLY

MVV[^LSSSPNO[

 9LHKPULZZKPZWSH`MVYHSHYTZ`Z[LT
 *LU[YHS]LU[
 *\WOVSKLY

 *VU[YVSWHULSMVYOLH[PUN]LU[PSH[PVU

HPYJVUKP[PVUPUN

 9VJRLYZ^P[JOLZMVYJLU[YHSSVJRPUN

YLHY^PUKV^HUKKVVYTPYYVYOLH[PUN

YLHY^PUKV^^PWLY

 :WLHRLY

 3PNO[Z^P[JO
 ;VNNSLZ^P[JOLZMVY;PW[YVUPJ
 6WLYH[PUNSL]LYMVYVUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY

 3VJRPUNSL]LYMVYZ[LLYPUNÌ^OLLSHKQ\Z[TLU[
 6WLYH[PUNSL]LYMVYH\[VTH[PJZWLLKJVU[YVS
 >PWLPU[LY]HSJVU[YVS

YHPUÌZLUZVYZLUZP[P]P[`JVU[YVS

 9VJRLYZ^P[JOLZMVYZLH[OLH[PUN
 9HKPV
 *PNHYL[[LSPNO[LY

 .SV]LJVTWHY[TLU[
 0U[LYPVY[LTWLYH[\YLZLUZVY

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

Vma›apm—›"›F˜§a›4^˜§a›^

"m›a_›^FO›˜›FFamV˜p4c

-VY`V\YZHML[`MHZ[LUZHML[`ILS[Z

:LLHSZV[OLJOHW[LYVUs0TTVIPSPaLYr

FOpF˜’›"›amV˜›^F˜FmVamF

(WWS`[OLOHUKIYHRL

4HU\HS[YHUZTPZZPVU!

4V]L[OLNLHYZOPM[SL]LYPU[VUL\[YHS

;OLJS\[JOWLKHST\Z[ILKLWYLZZLKM\SS`

ILMVYL[OLZ[HY[LY^PSSLUNHNL

;PW[YVUPJ!

4V]L[OLZLSLJ[VYSL]LY[Vs7rVYs5r

§a›4^˜zp’a›apm˜¬

;OL PNUP[PVU RL` JHU IL ^P[OKYH^U PU [OPZ WVZPÌ

[PVUVUS`

;PW[YVUPJTVKLSZ!

;OLPNUP[PVURL`JHUIL^P[OKYH^UVUS`^OLU[OL

ZLSLJ[VYSL]LYPZPU[OLs7rWVZP[PVU

;OL Z[LLYPUN PZ SVJRLK ^OLU [OL RL` PZ ^P[OÌ

KYH^U

,UNHNL[OLZ[LLYPUNSVJRI`TV]PUN[OLZ[LLYÌ

PUN^OLLS[V[OLSLM[VYYPNO[

;\YU[OLZ[LLYPUN^OLLS[V[OLSVJRPUNWVZP[PVU

ILMVYL `V\ Z^P[JO VMM [OL LUNPUL ZV [OH[ `V\

KVUq[ OH]L [V L_LY[ `V\YZLSM ^OLU SVJRPUN VY

\USVJRPUN[OLZ[LLYPUN

QG˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

§a›4^˜zp’a›apm˜s

0NUP[PVUPZVU

(SSLSLJ[YPJHSLX\PWTLU[JHUILZ^P[JOLKVU

;OL^HYUPUNSPNO[ZSPNO[\WMVYHSHTWJOLJR

7SLHZL UV[L [OL KLZJYPW[PVU VM [OL PUKP]PK\HS

^HYUPUNSPNO[Z

>OLU[\YUPUN[OLRL`[VWVZP[PVUYLSPL]L[OL

Z[LLYPUNSVJR^P[OHZSPNO[Z[LLYPUNTV]LTLU[

5V[L
;V JVUZLY]L IH[[LY` WV^LY H[ SV^ YWT [YHMMPJ

QHTZ [V^U KYP]PUN L[J Z^P[JO VMM HSS LSLJ[YPJHS

JVUZ\TLYZ ^OPJO HYL UV[ ULLKLK H[ [OH[ TVÌ

TLU[

§a›4^˜zp’a›apm˜¢

:[HY[PUN[OLLUNPUL

;\YU[OLRL`MYVTWVZP[PVU[VWVZP[PVU

;OL JS\[JO WLKHS T\Z[ IL KLWYLZZLK M\SS`

ILMVYL[OLZ[HY[LY^PSSLUNHNL

;OL MPYZ[ VWLYH[PVU VM [OL Z[HY[LY PZ LUKLK H\[VÌ

TH[PJHSS`^OLU[OLLUNPULZ[HY[Z

0M [OL LUNPUL KVLZ UV[ Z[HY[ Z\IZLX\LU[ Z[HY[LY

VWLYH[PVUZ^PSSUV[ILLUKLKH\[VTH[PJHSS`

0M [OL LUNPUL KVLZ UV[ Z[HY[ H[ [OL MPYZ[ [PTL VY

Z[HSSZ H[ HU` [PTL [OL RL` T\Z[ IL YL[\YULK [V

WVZP[PVU

>OLU [OL LUNPUL PZ Y\UUPUN [OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z

ZOV\SK NV VMM 0M H SPNO[ KVLZ UV[ NV VMM [HRL

HWWYVWYPH[LHJ[PVUHZPUKPJH[LKPU[OPZTHU\HS

§a›4^amV˜FmVamF˜pOO

;\YU [OL PNUP[PVU RL` MYVT WVZP[PVU  [V WVZPÌ

[PVU

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMHUHJJPKLU[

;OL Z[LLYPUN ^OLLS ^PSS SVJR HUK ^PSS JH\ZL

SVZZVMZ[LLYPUN

5L]LY YLTV]L RL` MYVT [OL PNUP[PVU SVJR VY

[\YU[OLRL`VMM^OPSL[OL]LOPJSLPZTV]PUN

;VH]VPKIH[[LY`Y\UÌKV^UHS^H`ZYLTV]L[OL

PNUP[PVURL`MYVT[OLPNUP[PVUSVJR

:LLHSZV[OLJOHW[LYVUs)H[[LY`r

;\YU[OLZ[LLYPUN^OLLS\U[PS[OLZ[LLYPUNSVJR

PZLUNHNLK

5V[L
6U ]LOPJSLZ ^P[O ;PW[YVUPJ P[ PZ VUS` WVZZPISL [V

YLTV]L[OLPNUP[PVURL`PM[OLZLSLJ[VYSL]LYPZPU

WVZP[PVUs7r

pmV

0M`V\SLH]L[OLRL`PU[OLPNUP[PVUZ[LLYPUNSVJR

H NVUN ^PSS ZV\UK ^OLU [OL KYP]LYqZ KVVY PZ

VWLULK;OPZPZHYLTPUKLY[VYLTV]L[OLRL`

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

Qn

background image

›"›amV˜p4F=¤F’

:LLHSZV[OLJOHW[LYVUs0TTVIPSPaLYr

>HYUPUN

:LYPV\Z PUQ\Y` TH` YLZ\S[ PM `V\ HYL PUÍ

]VS]LKPUHJVSSPZPVU^P[OV\[OH]PUNMHZ[LULK

[OLZHML[`ILS[Z

-HZ[LUZHML[`ILS[ZILMVYLKYP]PUNH^H`

FOpF˜’›"›amV˜›^F˜FmVamF

(WWS`[OLOHUKIYHRL

4HU\HS[YHUZTPZZPVU!

4V]L[OLNLHYZOPM[SL]LYPU[VUL\[YHS

;OLJS\[JOWLKHST\Z[ILKLWYLZZLKM\SS`

ILMVYL[OLZ[HY[LY^PSSLUNHNL

;PW[YVUPJ!

4V]L[OLZLSLJ[VYSL]LY[Vs7rVYs5r

;LTWLYH[\YL ZLUZVYZ VU [OL LUNPUL H\[VTH[Ì

PJHSS` WYV]PKL [OL JVYYLJ[ M\LSHPY TP_[\YL YLÌ

X\PYLKMVYZ[HY[PUN

;OLYLMVYL P[ PZ UV[ ULJLZZHY` [VKLWYLZZ[OL

HJJLSLYH[VY WLKHS ^OPSL Z[HY[PUN H JVSK VY H

^HYTLUNPUL

(ZZVVUHZ[OLLUNPULZ[HY[ZYLSLHZL[OLPNUPÌ

[PVURL`

;OL MPYZ[ VWLYH[PVU VM [OL Z[HY[LY PZ LUKLK H\[VÌ

TH[PJHSS`^OLU[OLLUNPULZ[HY[Z

0M [OL LUNPUL KVLZ UV[ Z[HY[ Z\IZLX\LU[ Z[HY[LY

VWLYH[PVUZ^PSSUV[ILLUKLKH\[VTH[PJHSS`

0M [OL LUNPUL MHPSZ [V Z[HY[ HM[LY  VY  ZLJÌ

VUKZVMJYHURPUN!

>HP[ HIV\[  ZLJVUKZ ILMVYL LUNHNPUN [OL

Z[HY[LYHNHPU

+VUV[SL[[OLLUNPULPKSL[V^HYT\W

>OLU Z[HY[PUN [OL LUNPUL IL YLHK` [V KYP]L

PTTLKPH[LS`

+YP]L ]LOPJSL H[ TVKLYH[L ZWLLKZ HUK H]VPK

LUNPUL ZWLLKZ HIV]L  YWT K\YPUN [OL

MPYZ[TPU\[LZ

+HUNLY

,UNPUL L_OH\Z[ M\TLZ OH]L THU` JVTWVÍ

ULU[Z ^OPJO `V\ JHU ZTLSS ;OL` HSZV JVUÍ

[HPU JHYIVU TVUV_PKL *6 ^OPJO PZ H JVÍ

SVYSLZZHUKVKVYSLZZNHZ

*HYIVU TVUV_PKL JHU JH\ZL \UJVUZJPV\ZÍ

ULZZHUKL]LUKLH[OPMPUOHSLK

5L]LY Z[HY[ VY SL[ [OL LUNPUL Y\U PU HU LUÌ

JSVZLK\U]LU[PSH[LKHYLH

0[ PZ UV[ YLJVTTLUKLK [V ZP[ PU `V\Y JHY MVY

WYVSVUNLKWLYPVKZ^P[O[OLLUNPULVUHUK[OL

JHYUV[TV]PUN

(U \UH[[LUKLK ]LOPJSL ^P[O H Y\UUPUN LUÍ

NPULPZWV[LU[PHSS`OHaHYKV\Z

0M^HYUPUNSPNO[ZZOV\SKJVTLVU[VPUKPJH[L

PTWYVWLY VWLYH[PVU [OL` ^V\SK NV \UUVÍ

[PJLK

5L]LYSLH]L[OLLUNPULPKSPUN\UH[[LUKLK

+HUNLYVMMPYL

+V UV[ WHYR VY VWLYH[L [OL ]LOPJSL PU HYLHZ

^OLYL [OL OV[ L_OH\Z[ Z`Z[LT TH` JVTL PU

JVU[HJ[ ^P[O KY` NYHZZ IY\ZO M\LS ZWPSS VY

V[OLYMSHTTHISLTH[LYPHS

0M`V\YJHYJH[JOLZVUMPYLMVYHU`YLHZVUJHSS

[OLMPYLKLWHY[TLU[

+V UV[ LUKHUNLY `V\Y SPML I` H[[LTW[PUN [V

W\[V\[[OLMPYL

–¬˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

›pzzamV˜FmVamF

;\YURL`IHJR[VWVZP[PVU

+V UV[ Z[VW LUNPUL PTTLKPH[LS` HM[LY OHYK VY

L_[LUKLKKYP]PUN

2LLW LUNPUL Y\UUPUN H[ PUJYLHZLK PKSL MVY

HIV\[ [^V TPU\[LZ [V WYL]LU[ L_JLZZP]L OLH[

I\PSKÌ\WILMVYL[\YUPUNVMMLUNPUL

;VH]VPKIH[[LY`Y\UÌKV^UHS^H`ZYLTV]L[OL

PNUP[PVURL`MYVT[OLPNUP[PVUSVJR

4HRL Z\YL [OH[ ^OLU `V\ SLH]L [OL JHY L]LU

IYPLMS``V\OH]L^P[OKYH^U[OLPNUP[PVURL`

,UNHNL[OLZ[LLYPUNSVJRI`TV]PUN[OLZ[LLYÌ

PUN^OLLS[V[OLSLM[VYYPNO[

;\YU[OLZ[LLYPUN^OLLS[V[OLSVJRPUNWVZP[PVU

ILMVYL `V\ Z^P[JO VMM [OL LUNPUL ZV [OH[ `V\

KVUq[ OH]L [V L_LY[ `V\YZLSM ^OLU SVJRPUN VY

\USVJRPUN[OLZ[LLYPUN

>HYUPUN

/V[ LUNPUL JVTWHY[TLU[ JVTWVULU[Z JHU

I\YUZRPUVUJVU[HJ[

)LMVYL^VYRPUNVUHU`WHY[PU[OLLUNPULJVTÌ

WHY[TLU[ [\YU [OL LUNPUL VMM HUK SL[ P[ JVVS

KV^UZ\MMPJPLU[S`

mVamF_4phz"›hFm›˜*dp§F:˜

"=a"›p˜O"m’

;OL YHKPH[VYZ HUK YHKPH[VY MHUZ HYL PU [OL MYVU[

VM[OLJHY

;OL LUNPULÌJVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY PZ TV\U[LK VU

[OLLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[SPK

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMPUQ\Y`

;OL LUNPULÍJVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY HS^H`Z

Y\UZ^OLU[OLPNUP[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVU(M[LY

[OLPNUP[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVMM[OLLUNPULJVTÍ

WHY[TLU[ HUK JVVSHU[ [LTWLYH[\YLZ HYL

TVUP[VYLKMVYHWWYV_TPU\[LZ

+\YPUN [OPZ WLYPVK HUK KLWLUKPUN VU [LTÍ

WLYH[\YL [OL LUNPULÍJVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY

HUK YHKPH[VY MHUZ TH` JVU[PU\L [V Y\U VY

Z[HY[[VY\U

*HYY` V\[ ^VYR PU [OLZL HYLHZ VUS` ^P[O [OL

LUNPULVMMHUKL_LYJPZLL_[YLTLJH\[PVU

¤›ph"›a4˜V""VF˜=pp

;OL PNUP[PVU Z`Z[LT PU `V\Y 7VYZJOL TH` PU[LYÌ

MLYL ^P[O `V\Y LSLJ[YVUPJHSS` VWLYH[LK NHYHNL

KVVY

;VJOLJR[OPZKYP]L`V\Y7VYZJOLJSVZL[V[OL

NHYHNL KVVY 4HRL Z\YL UV[ [V PU[LYMLYL ^P[O

[OLVWLYH[PUNYHUNLVM[OLKVVY

9\U[OLLUNPULH[KPMMLYLU[ZWLLKZ

0M [OL NHYHNL KVVY VWLUZ VY JSVZLZ ^P[OV\[ `V\

VWLYH[PUN[OLNHYHNLKVVY\UP[PU`V\YJHYJVUÌ

[HJ[ [OL KLHSLY ^OV PUZ[HSSLK [OL H\[VTH[PJ NHYÌ

HNL KVVY [V OH]L [OL MYLX\LUJ` HUKVY JVKPUN

VM[OLNHYHNLKVVYZPNUHSJOHUNLKVYTVKPMPLK

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

–s

background image

–¢˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

m’›¤hFm›˜"mFd˜˜p=Fd’

0UMVYTH[PVU HIV\[ PUKP]PK\HS PUKPJH[VYZ PZ

NP]LUVU[OLZWLJPMPLKWHNLZ

  =VS[TL[LY
  :WLLKVTL[LY^P[OHUHSVN\LKPZWSH`

  :WLLKVTL[LY^P[OKPNP[HSKPZWSH`
  (\[VTH[PJZWLLKJVU[YVSPUKPJH[VYSPNO[
  ;HJOVTL[LY

  ;\YUZPNUHSPUKPJH[VYSPNO[SLM[
  /PNOILHTPUKPJH[VYSPNO[

  6UÌIVHYKJVTW\[LYu 
 ;\YUZPNUHSPUKPJH[VYSPNO[YPNO[
 3PNO[ZLUZVYMVYPUZ[Y\TLU[PSS\TPUH[PVU

 *SVJR
 ;PW[YVUPJPUKPJH[VY
 *VVSPUNZ`Z[LT

;LTWLYH[\YLNH\NL^HYUPUNSPNO[

 -\LS

3L]LSNH\NL^HYUPUNSPNO[

 ,UNPULVPSWYLZZ\YLNH\NL

"mamV˜daV^›’—am=a4"›p˜daV^›’

( >HZOLYMS\PKSL]LS^HYUPUNSPNO[
) *OLJRLUNPUL^HYUPUNSPNO[
* 7VYZJOL:[HIPSP[`4HUHNLTLU[7:4

0UMVYTH[PVUSPNO[

+ 7VYZJOL:[HIPSP[`4HUHNLTLU[7:4

>HYUPUNSPNO[

, ():^HYUPUNSPNO[
- )YHRLMS\PKSL]LS

)YHRLKPZ[YPI\[PVU^HYUPUNSPNO[

. 7HYRPUNIYHRL^HYUPUNSPNO[

/ )YHRLWHK^LHY^HYUPUNSPNO[
0 ,UNPULVPSWYLZZ\YL^HYUPUNSPNO[

2 )H[[LY`^HYUPUNSPNO[
3 :HML[`ILS[^HYUPUNSPNO[
4 (PYIHN^HYUPUNSPNO[

5 9L[YHJ[HISLYLHYZWVPSLY^HYUPUNSPNO[
6 3\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[SPK

LUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[SPK^HYUPUNSPNO[

>OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ Z^P[JOLK VU [OL ^HYUÍ

PUNSPNO[ZSPNO[\WMVYHSHTWJOLJR

5V[L
>HYUPUNZ[OH[OH]LILLUNP]LUHYLZ[VYLKPU[OL

HWWYVWYPH[L JVU[YVS \UP[ TLTVY` HUK JHU IL

YLHKV\[H[HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

;OPZPUMVYTH[PVUJHUOLSW[V^HYU`V\HIV\[ZP[\Ì

H[PVUZ ^OPJO TH` IL OHaHYKV\Z [V `V\ VY `V\Y

JHY

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

–

background image

–T˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

m’›¤hFm›˜"mFd˜"m"="˜p=Fd’

0UMVYTH[PVU HIV\[ PUKP]PK\HS PUKPJH[VYZ PZ

NP]LUVU[OLZWLJPMPLKWHNLZ

  =VS[TL[LY
  :WLLKVTL[LY^P[OHUHSVN\LKPZWSH`

  :WLLKVTL[LY^P[OKPNP[HSKPZWSH`
  (\[VTH[PJZWLLKJVU[YVSPUKPJH[VYSPNO[
  ;HJOVTL[LY

  ;\YUZPNUHSPUKPJH[VYSPNO[SLM[
  /PNOILHTPUKPJH[VYSPNO[

  6UÌIVHYKJVTW\[LYu 
 ;\YUZPNUHSPUKPJH[VYSPNO[YPNO[
 3PNO[ZLUZVYMVYPUZ[Y\TLU[PSS\TPUH[PVU

 *SVJR
 ;PW[YVUPJPUKPJH[VY
 *VVSPUNZ`Z[LT

;LTWLYH[\YLNH\NL^HYUPUNSPNO[

 -\LS

3L]LSNH\NL^HYUPUNSPNO[

 ,UNPULVPSWYLZZ\YLNH\NL

"mamV˜daV^›’—am=a4"›p˜daV^›’

( >HZOLYMS\PKSL]LS^HYUPUNSPNO[
) *OLJRLUNPUL^HYUPUNSPNO[
* 7VYZJOL:[HIPSP[`4HUHNLTLU[7:4

0UMVYTH[PVUSPNO[

+ 7VYZJOL:[HIPSP[`4HUHNLTLU[7:4

>HYUPUNSPNO[

, ():^HYUPUNSPNO[
- )YHRLMS\PKSL]LS

)YHRLKPZ[YPI\[PVU^HYUPUNSPNO[

. 7HYRPUNIYHRL^HYUPUNSPNO[

/ )YHRLWHK^LHY^HYUPUNSPNO[
0 ,UNPULVPSWYLZZ\YL^HYUPUNSPNO[

2 )H[[LY`^HYUPUNSPNO[
3 :HML[`ILS[^HYUPUNSPNO[
4 (PYIHN^HYUPUNSPNO[

5 9L[YHJ[HISLYLHYZWVPSLY^HYUPUNSPNO[
6 3\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[SPK

LUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[SPK^HYUPUNSPNO[

>OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ Z^P[JOLK VU [OL ^HYUÍ

PUNSPNO[ZSPNO[\WMVYHSHTWJOLJR

5V[L
>HYUPUNZ[OH[OH]LILLUNP]LUHYLZ[VYLKPU[OL

HWWYVWYPH[L JVU[YVS \UP[ TLTVY` HUK JHU IL

YLHKV\[H[HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

;OPZPUMVYTH[PVUJHUOLSW[V^HYU`V\HIV\[ZP[\Ì

H[PVUZ ^OPJO TH` IL OHaHYKV\Z [V `V\ VY `V\Y

JHY

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

–Q

background image

pd›hF›F

0UKPJH[LZ[OLIH[[LY`]VS[HNL

5VYTHSYHUNL![V]VS[Z

;OL ]VS[HNL TH` KYVW JVUZPKLYHIS` ^OLU [OL

]LOPJSLPZILPUNZ[HY[LK

0M [OL NH\NL PZ JVU[PU\HSS` ILSV^  ]VS[Z

^OLU[OLLUNPULPZY\UUPUN!

/H]L[OLIH[[LY`JOHYNPUNZ`Z[LTJOLJRLKH[

HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

"››F©

"mamV˜daV^›

;OL^HYUPUNSPNO[PU[OLPUZ[Y\TLU[WHULSJVTLZ

VU^OLUPNUP[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVUHUKT\Z[NVVMM

^OLULUNPULPZY\UUPUN

0M[OL^HYUPUNSPNO[ZPU[OLPUZ[Y\TLU[WHULS

HUK VUÍIVHYK JVTW\[LY JVTL VU ^OPSL [OL

LUNPULPZY\UUPUNVY^OPSLKYP]PUN!

:[VW[OLJHYPUHZHMLWSHJLHUKZ[VW[OLLUÌ

NPUL

7VZZPISLJH\ZLZ



+LMLJ[PU[OLIH[[LY`JOHYNPUNZ`Z[LT



)YVRLUKYP]LILS[

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMHUHJJPKLU[HUKYPZRVMLUNPULKHTÍ

HNL

( IYVRLU KYP]L ILS[ TLHUZ [OLYL PZ UV

WV^LY HZZPZ[HUJL [V [OL Z[LLYPUN TVYL LMÍ

MVY[ PZ YLX\PYLK [V Z[LLY HUK JVVSHU[ W\TW

M\UJ[PVU^PSSZ[VW

+VUV[JVU[PU\LKYP]PUN

/H]L [OL MH\S[ YLTLKPLK H[ [OL ULHYLZ[ H\[OÌ

VYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

(Í(KQ\Z[TLU[I\[[VUMVYPUZ[Y\TLU[PSS\TPUH[PVUHUK

 [YPWJV\U[LY

¤›ph"›a4˜zFF=˜pm›pd

m=a4"›p˜daV^›

0UKPJH[LZH\[VTH[PJZWLLKJVU[YVSYLHKPULZZ

––˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

m’›¤hFm›˜ dd¤ham"›apm

;OL PSS\TPUH[PVU PZ H\[VTH[PJHSS` HKQ\Z[LK [V [OL

HTIPLU[ IYPNO[ULZZ I` [OL SPNO[ ZLUZVY PU [OL

[HJOVTL[LY

0UHKKP[PVU^OLU[OLJHYSPNO[ZHYLZ^P[JOLKVU

[OLPUZ[Y\TLU[HUKZ^P[JOZ`TIVSIYPNO[ULZZJHU

ILTHU\HSS`HKQ\Z[LK

>HYUPUN

9PZR VM HU HJJPKLU[ WLYZVUHS PUQ\Y` HUK

SVZZVMJVU[YVS

+V UV[ YLHJO [OYV\NO [OL Z[LLYPUNÌ^OLLS

ZWVRLZ^OPSLKYP]PUN

ahhamV˜am’›¤hFm›˜add¤ham"›apm

;\YU HKQ\Z[TLU[ I\[[VU ( PU [OL HWWYVWYPH[L

KPYLJ[PVU HUK OVSK P[ \U[PS [OL KLZPYLK IYPNO[Ì

ULZZOHZILLUYLHJOLK

;OLJOVZLUSL]LSVMIYPNO[ULZZPZPUKPJH[LKI`

H IHY KPZWSH` PU [OL KPZWSH` MPLSK VM [OL

VUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY

az˜=phF›F

>HYUPUN

9PZR VM HU HJJPKLU[ WLYZVUHS PUQ\Y` HUK

SVZZVMJVU[YVS

+V UV[ YLHJO [OYV\NO [OL Z[LLYPUNÌ^OLLS

ZWVRLZ^OPSLKYP]PUN

F’F››amV˜›p˜«Fp

7YLZZ HKQ\Z[TLU[ I\[[VU ( MVY HWWYV_PTH[LS`

VULZLJVUKVY

9LZL[ [OL KPZ[HUJL PU [OL s:,;r TLU\ VM [OL

VUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY

9LMLY[V[OLJOHW[LYs6UÌIVHYKJVTW\[LYr

(M[LYL_JLLKPUNTPSLZVY RPSVTL[LYZ

[OLJV\U[LYYL[\YUZ[Vsr

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

–•

background image

(Í(KQ\Z[TLU[I\[[VUMVYJOHUNLÍV]LYIL[^LLU

 RPSVTL[LYZTPSLZ

zFF=phF›F

;OL KPNP[HS ZWLLKVTL[LY PZ PU[LNYH[LK PU [OL

WVPU[LYPUZ[Y\TLU[

;OLPUKPJH[PVUJOHUNLZMYVTTWO[VRTO^OLU

[OL\UP[ZHYLJOHUNLKMYVTTPSLZ[VRPSVTL[YLZ

^"mVamV˜p¦F˜*F›§FFm

adF’˜—˜adphF›F’

@V\JHU\ZLHKQ\Z[TLU[I\[[VU([VJOHUNL[OL

\UP[Z VM [OL KPZ[HUJL HUK ZWLLK KPZWSH`Z PU [OL

VUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LYHUKKPNP[HS[HJOVTL[LY

>HYUPUN

9PZR VM HU HJJPKLU[ WLYZVUHS PUQ\Y` HUK

SVZZVMJVU[YVS

+V UV[ YLHJO [OYV\NO [OL Z[LLYPUNÌ^OLLS

ZWVRLZ^OPSLKYP]PUN

§a›4^amV˜*F›§FFm˜¤ma›’

>P[O[OLPNUP[PVUVUOVSKHKQ\Z[TLU[I\[[VU(

[\YULK[V[OLSLM[MVYHWWYV_ZLJVUKZ

5V[L
;OL \UP[Z VM [OL KPZ[HUJL HUK ZWLLK KPZWSH`Z

JHU HSZV IL JOHUNLK PU [OL s:,;r TLU\ VM [OL

VUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY

–G˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

"4^phF›F

;OL [HJOVTL[LY ZOV^Z [OL LUNPUL ZWLLK PU YL]Ì

VS\[PVUZWLYTPU\[LYWT

;OLILNPUUPUNVM[OLYLKTHYRZH[[OLYPNO[LUK

VM [OL ZJHSL PUKPJH[LZ [OL TH_PT\T WLYTPZZPISL

LUNPULYWT

( ZWLLK SPTP[LY WYL]LU[Z [OL LUNPUL MYVT ILPUN

V]LYYL]]LK K\YPUN HJJLSLYH[PVU )LMVYL YLHJOPUN

[OPZ HYLH [OL UL_[ OPNOLY NLHY ZOV\SK IL ZLÌ

SLJ[LK

:OPM[ [V [OL UL_[ SV^LY NLHY ^OLU [OL LUNPUL

YWTKYVWZILSV^YWT

*H\[PVU

;VH]VPKZL]LYLLUNPULKHTHNL

(S^H`Z VIZLY]L [OL LUNPUL YWT ILMVYL KV^UÌ

ZOPM[PUN [V H SV^LY NLHY ZV `V\ KV UV[ L_Ì

JLLK[OLTH_PT\TLUNPULYWT

¤m˜aVm"d˜ m=a4"›p˜aV^›

-SHZOLZPUZ`UJOYVUPZT^P[O[OL[\YUZPNUHSZ

3LM[HYYV^uSLM[[\YUZPNUHSZ

9PNO[HYYV^uYPNO[[\YUZPNUHSZ

0M [OL MYLX\LUJ` VM [OL KPZWSH` ILJVTLZ UVÌ

[PJLHIS` MHZ[LY JOLJR [OL VWLYH[PVU VM [OL

[\YUZPNUHSZ

aV^˜F"h

m=a4"›p˜daV^›

3PNO[Z ^OLU OPNO ILHT VY OLHKSPNO[ MSHZOLY PZ

Z^P[JOLKVU

;OL PUKPJH[VY SPNO[ NVLZ V\[ ^OLU [OL OPNO

ILHTZHYLZ^P[JOLKVMM

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

–n

background image

ppdamV˜©’›Fh

FhzF"›¤F˜V"¤VF˜

PNUP[PVUVU

<:(!+PZWSH`PU‰-

*HUHKH!+PZWSH`PU‰*

7VPU[LY[V[OLSLM[uLUNPULJVSK

(]VPK OPNO LUNPUL ZWLLKZ HUK OLH]` LUNPUL

SVHKPUN

7VPU[LYPU[OLTPKKSLuUVYTHSVWLYH[PUN[LTÌ

WLYH[\YL

;OL WVPU[LY TH` TV]L \W [V [OL YLKHYLH^OLU

LUNPULPZOLH]PS`SVHKLKHUKV\[ZPKL[LTWLYH[\YL

PZ OPNO I\[ ZOV\SK YL[\YU [V sUVYTHSr ^OLU LUÌ

NPULSVHKPZYLK\JLK

"mamV˜daV^›˜Š‰

0M [OL JVVSHU[ [LTWLYH[\YL PZ [VV OPNO [OL

^HYUPUNSPNO[JVTLZVU

(KKP[PVUHSS` H ^HYUPUN PZ KPZWSH`LK PU [OL VUÌ

IVHYKJVTW\[LY

7\SSVMM[OLYVHK[\YUVMM[OLLUNPULHUKHSSV^

[VJVVS

*OLJR YHKPH[VY HUK HPY WHZZHNLZ PU MYVU[ LUK

VMJHYMVYVIZ[Y\J[PVUZ

*OLJRJVVSHU[SL]LS

0MULJLZZHY`HKKJVVSHU[HUKOH]LMH\S[YLTLÌ

KPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

-VSSV^ [OL ^HYUPUNZ HUK PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ PU

[OLs*VVSHU[SL]LSrJOHW[LY

5V[L
;VWYL]LU[L_JLZZP]L[LTWLYH[\YLZ[OLJVVSPUNÌ

HPY WHZZHNLZ T\Z[ UV[ IL YLZ[YPJ[LK I` JV]LYÌ

PUNZLNMPSTZsZ[VULN\HYKZs

0M[OLJVVSHU[SL]LSPZ[VVSV^[OL^HYUPUNSPNO[

MSHZOLZ

(KKP[PVUHSS` H ^HYUPUN PZ KPZWSH`LK PU [OL VUÌ

IVHYKJVTW\[LY

:^P[JOLUNPULVMMHUKHSSV^[VJVVS

(KKJVVSHU[

/H]L [OL JH\ZL VM [OL MH\S[ YLTLKPLK H[ HU

H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

-VSSV^ [OL ^HYUPUNZ HUK PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ PU

[OLs*VVSHU[SL]LSrJOHW[LY

*H\[PVU

9PZRVMLUNPULKHTHNL

0M [OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z JVTL VU L]LU [OV\NO

JVVSHU[ SL]LS PZ JVYYLJ[ KV UV[ JVU[PU\L KYP]Ì

PUN

/H]L [OL MH\S[ YLTLKPLK H[ [OL ULHYLZ[

H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

•¬˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

mVamF˜4phz"›hFm›˜*dp§F˜O"m

0UHKKP[PVU[OPZ^HYUPUNSPNO[MSHZOLZ[VPUKPJH[L

H MH\S[ PU [OL LUNPUL JVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY

MHU

/H]L [OL JH\ZL VM [OL MH\S[ YLTLKPLK H[ HU

H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

az›pma4˜

m=a4"›p˜Op˜’FdF4›p˜dF¦F˜zp’a›apm˜"m=

’FdF4›F=˜VF"

>OLU [OL LUNPUL PZ Y\UUPUN [OL ZLSLJ[VY SL]LY

WVZP[PVUHUKLUNHNLKNLHYHYLPUKPJH[LK

0M[OLZLSLJ[VYSL]LYPZIL[^LLU[^VWVZPÍ

[PVUZ!



;OL ZLSLJ[VY SL]LY WVZP[PVU PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[

JS\Z[LYMSHZOLZHUK



[OL ^HYUPUN rZLSLJ[VY SL]LY UV[ LUNHNLKs

HWWLHYZ VU [OL KPZWSH` VM [OL VUÌIVHYK

JVTW\[LY

,UNHNL[OLZLSLJ[VYSL]LYJVYYLJ[S`

0M[OLYLPZHMH\S[PU[OL[YHUZTPZZPVU!



NLHYMSHZOLZVU[OLKPZWSH`



;OL ^HYUPUN r;PW[YVUPJ LTLYNLUJ` Y\Us

HWWLHYZPU[OLVUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY

(SZVYLMLY[Vr,TLYNLUJ`WYVNYHTs

;V YLTLK` [OL MH\S[ WSLHZL JVUZ\S[ HU H\[OÌ

VYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLYPTTLKPH[LS`

-VSSV^[OLPUZ[Y\J[PVUZPU[OLJOHW[LYr;PW[YVUPJs

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

•s

background image

¤Fd

F¦Fd˜V"¤VF

>OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ VU [OL M\LS SL]LS PZ KPZÌ

WSH`LK

-VY[HURJHWHJP[`ZLLs*HWHJP[PLZrJOHW[LY

0M[OL]LOPJSLqZPUJSPUH[PVUJOHUNLZLNNVPUN\W

VY KV^UOPSS TPUVY KL]PH[PVUZ PU [OL PUKPJH[PVU

TH`VJJ\Y

5V[L
0M [OL [HUR PZ ULHY LTW[` HUK `V\ [VW \W ^P[O

VUS`HZTHSSX\HU[P[`VMM\LS[OPZJHUUV[ILYLNÌ

PZ[LYLKI`[OLSL]LSNH\NLHUKJHSJ\SH[PVUVM[OL

YHUNLYLTHPUPUNPZPTWVZZPISL

"mamV˜daV^›˜Š‰

>OLU [OL LUNPUL PZ Y\UUPUN [OL ^HYUPUN

SPNO[ VM [OL SL]LS NH\NL SPNO[Z \W PM SLZZ [OHU

HWWYV_<:NHSSVUZSP[YLZVMM\LSYLTHPUZ

PU [OL [HUR VY [OL YHUNL VU YLTHPUPUN M\LS MHSSZ

ILSV^HWWYV_TPSLZRT

(KKP[PVUHSS` H ^HYUPUN PZ KPZWSH`LK PU [OL VUÌ

IVHYKJVTW\[LY

-PSS\WH[[OLUL_[VWWVY[\UP[`

*H\[PVU

;V WYL]LU[ KHTHNL[V[OLLTPZZPVUJVU[YVS

Z`Z[LTHUKLUNPUL

5L]LYKYP]L[OL[HURJVTWSL[LS`V\[VMM\LS

(]VPKOPNOJVYULYPUNZWLLKZHM[LY[OL^HYUPUN

SPNO[ZOH]LJVTLVU

-VSSV^ [OL PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ PU [OL s,TPZZPVU *VUÌ

[YVS:`Z[LTrJOHW[LY

0M [OL SL]LS NH\NL ^HYUPUN SPNO[ MSHZOLZ

[OLYLOHZILLUHZ`Z[LTMH\S[

(KKP[PVUHSS` H ^HYUPUN PZ KPZWSH`LK PU [OL VUÌ

IVHYKJVTW\[LY

;OLYL^PSS[OLUILUVYLZLY]L^HYUPUN

;V YLTLK` [OL MH\S[ NV [V HU H\[OVYPaLK

7VYZJOLKLHSLY

•¢˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

(Í(KQ\Z[TLU[I\[[VUMVYJSVJR

)Í*SVJR

dp4c

;OL JSVJR PZ ISHURLK V\[ HWWYV_PTH[LS` MV\Y

TPU\[LZHM[LY[OLPNUP[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVMMVY^OLU

[OLJHYPZSVJRLK

F››amV˜›^F˜›ahF

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMHUHJJPKLU[HUKSVZZVMJVU[YVS

+V UV[ YLHJO [OYV\NO [OL Z[LLYPUNÌ^OLLS

ZWVRLZ^OPSLKYP]PUN

:L[[PUNOV\YZ

7YLZZHKQ\Z[TLU[I\[[VU(MVYHIV\[VULZLJÌ

VUK

/V\YKPZWSH`MSHZOLZ

;\YUI\[[VUPU[OLHWWYVWYPH[LKPYLJ[PVU!

[VYPNO[uPUJYLHZLOV\YZMPN\YL

[VSLM[uKLJYLHZLOV\YZMPN\YL

(KQ\Z[TLU[PUOV\YZu[\YUI\[[VUIYPLMS`

-HZ[HKQ\Z[TLU[KPZWSH`J`JSLZu

[\YUHUKOVSKI\[[VU

:L[[PUNTPU\[LZ

7YLZZHKQ\Z[TLU[I\[[VUHNHPU

4PU\[LZKPZWSH`MSHZOLZ

:L[I`YV[H[PUNHZPUOV\YZTVKL

3LH]PUNHKQ\Z[TLU[TVKL
(\[VTH[PJHSS`HM[LYVULTPU\[LVY!

7YLZZHKQ\Z[TLU[I\[[VUHNHPU

>OLU HKQ\Z[TLU[ TVKL PZ KLSPILYH[LS` SLM[ I`

WYLZZPUN[OLI\[[VU[OL[PTLILNPUZWYLJPZLS`[V

[OLZLJVUK

5V[L
;OL [PTL TVKL JHU IL JOHUNLK IL[^LLU O

HUKOPU[OLVUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

•

background image

mVamF˜ad˜F’’¤F

"¤VF

>P[O H ^HYTLKÌ\W LUNPUL HUK H[ H ZWLLK VM

 YWT [OL LUNPUL VPS WYLZZ\YL ZOV\SK IL

HWWYV_IHYVYOPNOLY

0M [OL VPS WYLZZ\YL KYVWZ HIY\W[S` HUK [OL

^HYUPUN SPNO[Z PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[ WHULS HUK

PU [OL VUÍIVHYK JVTW\[LY JVTL VU ^OPSL

[OLLUNPULPZY\UUPUNVY^OPSLKYP]PUN!

0TTLKPH[LS`Z[VWPUHZ\P[HISLWSHJL

:LLr>HYUPUNSPNO[s

"mamV˜daV^›

;OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[ PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[ WHULS SPNO[Z

\W^OLUPNUP[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVUHUKT\Z[NVV\[

^OLULUNPULPZY\UUPUN

0M[OL^HYUPUNSPNO[ZPU[OLPUZ[Y\TLU[WHULS

HUK PU [OL VUÍIVHYK JVTW\[LY JVTL VU

^P[O[OLLUNPULY\UUPUNVY^OPSLKYP]PUN!

0TTLKPH[LS`Z[VWPUHZ\P[HISLWSHJL

:^P[JOVMM[OLLUNPUL

*OLJR^OL[OLY[OLYLPZHUVI]PV\ZVPSSLHRVU

VY\UKLY[OLJHY

0MUVVPSSLHRJHUILKL[LJ[LK!

4LHZ\YL[OLVPSSL]LS\ZPUN[OLVUÌIVHYKJVTÌ

W\[LY^P[O[OLLUNPULPKSPUN

9LMLY[V[OLJOHW[LYr6UÌIVHYKJVTW\[LYs

(KKLUNPULVPSPMULJLZZHY`

9LMLY[V[OLJOHW[LYr,UNPULVPSSL]LSs

*H\[PVU

9PZRVMLUNPULKHTHNL

+V UV[ JVU[PU\L KYP]PUN PM [OLYL PZ HU VI]PV\Z

VPSSLHR

+V UV[ JVU[PU\L KYP]PUN PM [OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z

JVTLZVUL]LU[OV\NOVPSSL]LSPZJVYYLJ[

/H]L [OL MH\S[ YLTLKPLK H[ [OL ULHYLZ[

H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

•T˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

^F4c˜mVamF

"mamV˜aV^›

;OL^HYUPUNSPNO[PU[OLPUZ[Y\TLU[WHULSJVTLZ

VU ^OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ MPYZ[ [\YULK VU HUK YLÌ

THPUZ VU IYPLMS` HZ H I\SI JOLJR 0M [OL SPNO[

KVLZ UV[ JVTL VU OH]L [OL I\SI YLWSHJLK

WYVTW[S`

0M [OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[ WHULS HUK

VUÌIVHYK JVTW\[LY JVTL VU HUK YLTHPU VU

^OPSLKYP]PUNP[Z\NNLZ[Z!



H WV[LU[PHS LUNPUL JVU[YVS WYVISLT HUK [OL

ULLKMVYZ`Z[LTZLY]PJLVY



HUPTWYVWLYS`MHZ[LULK[HURJHWVY



YLM\LSSPUN^P[OLUNPULY\UUPUN

(S[OV\NO [OL ]LOPJSL PZ \Z\HSS` KYP]LHISL HUK ^PSS

UV[ YLX\PYL [V^PUN ZLL `V\Y KLHSLY MVY ZLY]PJL

HZZVVUHZWVZZPISL

*H\[PVU

0M [OL *OLJR LUNPUL SPNO[ PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[

WHULSPZMSHZOPUNZL]LYLJH[HS`[PJJVU]LY[LY

KHTHNLHUKWV^LYSVZZ^PSSZVVUVJJ\Y

7YVSVUNLK KYP]PUN ^P[O [OL *OLJR LUNPUL

SPNO[ VU JV\SK JH\ZL KHTHNL [V [OL

LTPZZPVU JVU[YVS Z`Z[LT 0[ HSZV JV\SK HMÍ

MLJ[M\LSLJVUVT`HUKKYP]LHIPSP[`

/H]L [OL MH\S[ YLTLKPLK H[ [OL ULHYLZ[ H\[OÌ

VYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLYPTTLKPH[LS`

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

•Q

background image

m_p"=˜phz¤›F˜|}

a’zd"©˜OaFd=

;OLKPZWSH`MPLSKPZILULH[O[OL[HJOVTL[LY

F"=amF’’˜Op˜pzF"›apm


>P[OPNUP[PVUZ^P[JOLKVU



^P[OLUNPULY\UUPUN

zF"›apm:˜4pm›pd’

0[ PZ UV[ WVZZPISL [V KLZJYPIL HSS KL[HPSZ VM [OL

VUÌIVHYK JVTW\[LY M\UJ[PVUZ PU [OPZ 6^ULYqZ

4HU\HS

/V^L]LY [OL L_HTWSLZ ^PSS X\PJRS` MHTPSPHYPaL

`V\ ^P[O [OLM\UJ[PVUHSWYPUJPWSLHUKOLSW`V\[V

UH]PNH[L[OYV\NO[OLTLU\Z[Y\J[\YL

@V\ JHU YLZ[VYL [OL MHJ[VY` KLMH\S[ ZL[[PUNZ H[

HU`[PTLI`\ZPUN[OLr:,;sTLU\

zF"›amV˜dF¦F

;OL VUÌIVHYK JVTW\[LY PZ VWLYH[LK ^P[O [OL

SV^LYSLM[SL]LYVU[OLZ[LLYPUNJVS\TU

:LSLJ[PUNM\UJ[PVUZVM[OLVUÍIVHYK

JVTW\[LY

7\ZOSL]LY\WVYKV^U

*VUMPYTPUNZLSLJ[PVU,U[LY

7\ZOSL]LYMVY^HYK

4V]PUNIHJRVULVYZL]LYHSZLSLJ[PVUSL]LSZ

7\SS[OLSL]LYIHJRVUJLVYZL]LYHS[PTLZ

5V[L!

@V\ JHU HS^H`Z YL[\YU [V [OL IHZPJ TLU\ I`

W\SSPUN[OLVWLYH[PUNSL]LYZL]LYHS[PTLZ

•–˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

¤m4›apm’˜"m=˜=a’zd"©˜zp’’a*ada›aF’

(Í:LSLJ[PVUMPLSK

)Í*VU[PU\H[PVUHYYV^Z`TIVS

*Í;VWKPZWSH`

+Í*LU[YHSKPZWSH`

,Í6UÍIVHYKJVTW\[LYKPZWSH`

)HZPJZL[[PUN



;VWKPZWSH`!6KVTL[LY



*LU[YHSKPZWSH`!;YPWVKVTL[LY

@V\ JHU JOHUNL IV[O KPZWSH`Z [V Z\P[ `V\Y

YLX\PYLTLU[ZI`\ZPUN[OLr:,;sTLU\

*HSSPUNVUÍIVHYKJVTW\[LYM\UJ[PVUZPU

KPZWSH`r,s

7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LY\WVYKV^U

ZLSLJ[PVUMPLSK(T\Z[ILZ^P[JOLKVMM

;OL MVSSV^PUN KPZWSH`Z JHU IL JHSSLK Z[LW I`

Z[LW!

u6\[ZPKL[LTWLYH[\YL‰-

u(]LYHNLZWLLK«TWO

u(]LYHNLJVUZ\TW[PVU«TWN

u9HUNLVUYLTHPUPUNM\LSTP“ )

u,UNPULIVVZ[WYLZZ\YLIHY

u5H]PNH[PVUPUMVYTH[PVU

PMHJ[P]H[LKPU[OLs:,;rTLU\

*HUHKH]LOPJSLZ!

;OL \UP[Z PU [OL VUÌIVHYK JVTW\[LY HYL KPZÌ

WSH`LKPURPSVTL[LYZSP[LYZHUK‰*

;OL ]HS\LZ r;YPW VKVTL[LYs r(]LYHNL ZWLLKs

HUKr(]LYHNLJVUZ\TW[PVUsJHUILYLZL[[VaLYV

\ZPUN[OLr)*sTLU\

5V[L
7\SSPUN [OL VWLYH[PUN SL]LY [V [OL YLHY  [HRLZ

`V\ KPYLJ[S` MYVT H ]HS\L ^OPJO JHU IL YLZL[ [V

[OLr)*sTLU\

:^P[JOPUNZLSLJ[PVUMPLSKr(sVUVYVMM

7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYKVYIHJR

(YYV^Z`TIVSr)sMVYJVU[PU\H[PVU
(YYV^Z`TIVS¶!

7\ZO VWLYH[PUN SL]LY KV^U PU VYKLY [V JVUÌ

[PU\L[OLTLU\

(YYV^Z`TIVSD!

7\ZO VWLYH[PUN SL]LY \W PU VYKLY [V JVU[PU\L

[OLTLU\

C12

111

A B

C D E

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

••

background image

‰  Š

4p¤’›a4˜§"mamV˜’aVm"d˜Op˜

’zFF=˜daha›

;OLHJV\Z[PJ^HYUPUNZPNUHSJHUILHJ[P]H[LKMVY

ZWLLKZHIV]LTWORTO

;OL ZPNUHS ZV\UKZ PM [OL WYLZL[ ZWLLK PZ

L_JLLKLK

-VY[OLZPNUHS[VZV\UKHNHPU[OLKYP]PUNZWLLK

T\Z[ MHSS ILSV^ [OL WYLZL[ ZWLLK I` H[ SLHZ[

TWORTO

:^P[JOPUNVUZLSLJ[PVUMPLSKr(s

7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK

:L[[PUN[OLZWLLK

:LSLJ[r3040;s^P[O[OLVWLYH[PUNSL]LY

7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK

6W[PVU!

(JJLW[J\YYLU[ZWLLK

7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK

;OL HJV\Z[PJ ^HYUPUN ZPNUHS PZ HJ[P]H[LK MVY [OL

J\YYLU[ZWLLK

+PZWSH`!

6W[PVU!

7YLZL[ZWLLK

:LSLJ[ r3040; HJ[P]H[LKs ^P[O [OL VWLYH[PUN

SL]LY

  UV[HJ[P]H[LK

  HJ[P] H[LK

7YLZZ [OL VWLYH[PUN SL]LY MVY^HYK PM [OL rUV[

HJ[P]H[LKsKPZWSH`HWWLHYZ

<ZL [OL VWLYH[PUN SL]LY [V ZLSLJ[ rTWO s VY

rTWOus

7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK\U[PS[OLKLZPYLK

ZWLLKPZYLHJOLK

;OL HJV\Z[PJ ^HYUPUN ZPNUHS PZ HJ[P]H[LK MVY

[OLKLZPYLKZWLLK

:^P[JOPUN[OLHJV\Z[PJ^HYUPUNZPNUHSVMM

:LSLJ[ r3040; HJ[P]H[LKs ^P[O [OL VWLYH[PUN

SL]LY!

7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK

+PZWSH`!

C12

110

C12

113

C12

109

C12

121

C12

120

C12

119

•G˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

‰ Š

"mamV˜hF’’"VF’

:^P[JOPUNVUZLSLJ[PVUMPLSKr(s

7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK

*HSSPUN^HYUPUNTLZZHNLZ

:LSLJ[r*/,*2s^P[O[OLVWLYH[PUNSL]LY

7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK

(U` L_PZ[PUN ^HYUPUN TLZZHNLZ JHU IL JHSSLK

\ZPUN[OLVWLYH[PUNSL]LY

@V\HSZVJHUJHSS^HYUPUNTLZZHNLZ^OPJO^LYL

HJRUV^SLKNLK K\YPUN [OL QV\YUL` VUS` \U[PS [OL

UL_[[PTL[OLPNUP[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVU

7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK

C12

103

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

•n

background image

‰ Š

a’zd"©˜"m=˜hF"’¤FhFm›˜pO˜›^F˜FmVamF

pad˜dF¦Fd

*H\[PVU

9PZRVMLUNPULKHTHNL

9LN\SHYS`JOLJR[OLVPSSL]LSILMVYLYLM\LSSPUN

+V UV[ HSSV^ [OL VPS SL]LS [V MHSS ILSV^ [OL

TPUPT\TTHYR

*VUKP[PVUZMVYTLHZ\YPUN[OLVPSSL]LS
 ,UNPULPKSPUN

 ,UNPULPZH[VWLYH[PUN[LTWLYH[\YL

 =LOPJSLPZSL]LS

 =LOPJSLZ[H[PVUHY`

:^P[JOPUNVUZLSLJ[PVUMPLSKr(s

7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK

0UP[PH[PUNVPSSL]LSTLHZ\YLTLU[

:LSLJ[r603s^P[O[OLVWLYH[PUNSL]LY

7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK

7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK

4LHZ\YLTLU[PZZ[HY[LK

;OL ^HP[PUN[PTLMVYVPSSL]LSTLHZ\YLTLU[PZPUÌ

KPJH[LK I` H [PTL KPZWSH` HUK rJ`JSPUNs ZLNÌ

TLU[ZVM[OLVPSSL]LSKPZWSH`

6UJL [OL TLHZ\YLTLU[ OHZ ILLU JVTWSL[LK

`V\JHUYLHKVMM[OLLUNPULVPSSL]LSVU[OLZLNÌ

TLU[KPZWSH`

0M [OL VPS SL]LS OHZ MHSSLU ILSV^ [OL TPU THYR

[OLZLNTLU[ILSV^[OLTPUTHYRMSHZOLZ

;OL KPMMLYLUJL IL[^LLU [OL TPU HUK TH_

THYRZ VU [OL ZLNTLU[ KPZWSH` PZ HWWYV_

SP[YLZX\HY[Z

6UL ZLNTLU[ VM [OL KPZWSH` JVYYLZWVUKZ [V H

X\HU[P[`VMHWWYV_SP[YLX\HY[

;VW \W LUNPUL VPS 9LMLY [V [OL JOHW[LY r,UNPUL

VPSSL]LSs

5L]LYHKKTVYLLUNPULVPS[OHUYLX\PYLK[V

YLHJO[OLTH_THYR

0UMV
;OL r0UMVs M\UJ[PVU HSSV^Z `V\ [V JHSS [OL WYLÌ

YLX\PZP[LZMVYVPSSL]LSTLHZ\YLTLU[

-HPS\YL
(MHPS\YLVM[OLVPSSL]LSKPZWSH`PZPUKPJH[LKI`H

^HYUPUNTLZZHNLPU[OLVUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY

C12

117

C12

116

C12

106

C12

118

G¬˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

a’zd"©˜‰^F4c˜pad˜dF¦FdŠ

;OL JVTW\[LY KPZWSH` r*OLJR VPS SL]LSs PZ HU HKÌ

KP[PVUHSYLTPUKLY[V`V\[VJOLJR[OLVPSSL]LS

;OL KPZWSH` KLWLUKZ VU [OL KPZ[HUJL [YH]LSSLK

HUK [OL VWLYH[PUN JVUKP[PVUZ HUK KVLZ UV[ PUKPÌ

JH[L^OL[OLYVYUV[[OLVPSSL]LSPZJVYYLJ[

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

Gs

background image

‰Š

"ddamV˜"m=˜F’F››amV˜pm_*p"=

4phz¤›F˜O¤m4›apm’

:^P[JOPUNVUZLSLJ[PVUMPLSKr(s

7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK

,_HTWSL!

9LZL[[PUNH]LYHNLJVUZ\TW[PVU

:LSLJ[r)*s^P[O[OLVWLYH[PUNSL]LY

7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK

:LSLJ[r«TWNs^P[O[OLVWLYH[PUNSL]LY

7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK

7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK

;OLH]LYHNLJVUZ\TW[PVUPZYLZL[[V

ruuu«TWNs

C12

115

G¢˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

‰Š

"’a4˜’F››amV˜pO˜pm_*p"=˜4phz¤›F

:^P[JOPUNVUZLSLJ[PVUMPLSKr(s

7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK

*OHUNPUN[OLIHZPJZL[[PUNVM[OLVUÍIVHYK

JVTW\[LY

:LSLJ[r:,;s^P[O[OLVWLYH[PUNSL]LY

7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK

:LSLJ[ [OL KLZPYLKM\UJ[PVU^P[O[OLVWLYH[PUN

SL]LY!

9LZL[



9LZL[HSS

9LZL[[YPWJV\U[LY

9LZL[H]LYHNLJVUZ\TW[PVU

9LZL[H]LYHNLZWLLK

:WLLKVTL[LYRTTSZ



*OHUNLV]LYIL[^LLURPSVTL[YLZHUKTPSLZ

+PZWSH`

0UKP]PK\HSJVTIPUH[PVUVM\WWLYHUK

JLU[YHSSPULZVM[OLVUÍIVHYKJVTW\[LY



*OHUNPUN[VWKPZWSH`

Ì;V[HSTPSLHNL

Ì;YPWJV\U[LY

Ì(\KPVPUMVYTH[PVUZL[YHKPVZ[H[PVU

Ì6\[ZPKL[LTWLYH[\YL

Ì9HUNLVUYLTHPUPUNM\LS

Ì(]LYHNLZWLLK

Ì(]LYHNLJVUZ\TW[PVU



*OHUNPUNJLU[YHSKPZWSH`

Ì;V[HSTPSLHNL

Ì;YPWJV\U[LY

Ì6\[ZPKL[LTWLYH[\YL

Ì9HUNLVUYLTHPUPUNM\LS

Ì(]LYHNLZWLLK

Ì(]LYHNLJVUZ\TW[PVU

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

5H]PNH[PVU



0U[LNYH[LKPU[OLVUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY

UH]PNH[PVU PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ JHU IL YLJHSSLK PU [OL

VUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LYKPZWSH`



-VYHSS[\YUZ

UH]PNH[PVU PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ HYL KPZWSH`LK VUS`

WYPVY[VKPYLJ[PVUJOHUNLZ

)HZPJZL[[PUN



9LZ[VYL [OL IHZPJ ZL[[PUN VM [OL VUÌIVHYK

JVTW\[LY

3HUN\HNL



:LSLJ[SHUN\HNL]LYZPVU

*VUZ\TW[PVU



:LSLJ[\UP[MVYM\LSJVUZ\TW[PVU!

SRTTSZNHS<:(TWN<2RTS

;LTWLYH[\YL



:LSLJ[\UP[MVY[LTWLYH[\YL!

‰*‰-

OTVKL
:LSLJ[[PTLTVKL!

O ZTHSS ZX\HYLZ VU [OL SLM[ ZPKL VM [OL [PTL

KPZWSH`MVY(474

O

‰ Š

m_*p"=˜4phz¤›F˜=a’zd"©

:^P[JOPUNVUZLSLJ[PVUMPLSKr(s

7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK

:^P[JOPUNVUÍIVHYKJVTW\[LYKPZWSH`VMM

:LSLJ[r6--s^P[O[OLVWLYH[PUNSL]LY

7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK

+PZWSH`PZZ^P[JOLKVMM

:^P[JOPUNVUÍIVHYKJVTW\[LYKPZWSH`VU

HNHPU

7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYPUHU`KPYLJ[PVU

GT˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

FmF"d˜amOph"›apm˜FV"=amV˜›^F

pm_*p"=˜4phz¤›F˜O¤m4›apm’

9HUNLVUYLTHPUPUNM\LS
;OL YHUNL VU YLTHPUPUN M\LS PZ JVU[PU\V\ZS`

YLJVTW\[LK ^OPSL KYP]PUN IHZLK VU M\LS SL]LS

J\YYLU[JVUZ\TW[PVUHUKH]LYHNLJVUZ\TW[PVU

;OL TVYL [OL M\LS SL]LS MHSSZ [OL TVYL ZWVU[HÌ

ULV\ZS` [OL KPZWSH` YLHJ[Z -VY [OPZ YLHZVU

YHUNL VU YLTHPUPUN M\LS PZ UV[ KPZWSH`LK PM SLZZ

[OHURPSVTL[YLZ TPSLZ

0M [OL ]LOPJSLqZ PUJSPUH[PVU JOHUNLZ ^OPSL KYP]PUN

VY YLM\LSSPUN PUJVYYLJ[ YHUNL PUMVYTH[PVU TH`

[LTWVYHYPS`ILNP]LU

5V[L
0M [OL [HUR PZ ULHYS` LTW[` HUK `V\ HKK VUS` H

ZTHSS X\HU[P[` VM M\LS [OPZ JHUUV[ IL \ZLK [V

JHSJ\SH[L[OLYHUNLVUYLTHPUPUNM\LS

(]LYHNLJVUZ\TW[PVUHUKH]LYHNLZWLLK
;OL KPZWSH`LK ]HS\LZ HYL IHZLK VU [OL KPZ[HUJL

[YH]LSSLKZPUJL[OLSHZ[YLZL[[VraLYVs

@V\JHUZL[[OLZ[HY[PUN[PTLMVYHTLHZ\YLTLU[

ILMVYLVYK\YPUN[OL[YPW

:^P[JOPUN [OL PNUP[PVU VMM KVLZ UV[ YLZL[ [OL

TLHZ\YLTLU[Z =HS\LZ JHU [O\Z IL JVSSLJ[LK

V]LYSVUNWLYPVKZ

+PZJVUULJ[PUN [OL JHY IH[[LY` JSLHYZ [OLZL

TLTVYPLZ

6\[ZPKL[LTWLYH[\YL
;OL V\[ZPKL [LTWLYH[\YL KPZWSH` KVLZ UV[ PUKPÌ

JH[LPMPJLPZVU[OLYVHK

,]LU PM H [LTWLYH[\YL HIV]L ‰- ‰* PZ KPZÌ

WSH`LK PJL TH` Z[PSS MVYT VU [OL YVHK MVY PUÌ

Z[HUJL VU IYPKNLZ VY ^OLU [OL YVHK WHZZLZ

[OYV\NOHOLH]PS`ZOHKLKHYLH

mVamF˜*pp’›˜zF’’¤F

(Z[OLLUNPULPZLX\PWWLK^P[OHIVVZ[WYLZZ\YL

JVU[YVSMLH[\YL[OLIVVZ[WYLZZ\YLPZ]HYPHISL

;OL IVVZ[ WYLZZ\YL KLWLUKZ VU [OL HTIPLU[

WYLZZ\YL HUK VU [OL VJ[HUL YH[PUN VM [OL M\LS

\ZLK

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

GQ

background image

"mamV’˜am˜›^F˜ m’›¤hFm›˜"mFd˜"m=˜am˜›^F˜m_p"=˜phz¤›F

0MH^HYUPUNTLZZHNLHWWLHYZHS^H`ZYLMLY[V[OLJVYYLZWVUKPUNJOHW[LYZPU[OL6^ULYqZ4HU\HS

>HYUPUNTLZZHNLZHYLPZZ\LKVUS`PMHSSTLHZ\YLTLU[WYLJVUKP[PVUZHYLTL[;OLYLMVYLJOLJRHSSMS\PKSL]LSZYLN\SHYS`u

PUWHY[PJ\SHYHS^H`ZJOLJR[OLLUNPULVPSSL]LSILMVYLYLM\LSSPUN

0UZ[Y\TLU[

WHULS

6UÍIVHYK

JVTW\[LY

;L_[KPZWSH`PU

VUÍIVHYKJVTW\[LY

4LHUPUNTLHZ\YL

:LH[ILS[

+YP]LYHUKWHZZLUNLYZT\Z[MHZ[LU[OLPY

ZHML[`ILS[Z

<:(

*HUHKH

/HUKIYHRL

/HUKIYHRLUV[YLSLHZLK

0NUP[PVURL`

UV[YLTV]LK

3PNO[ZVU

-YVU[YLHY

SPKUV[

JSVZLK

*SVZLSPKZWYVWLYS`

9LMPSS

^HZOLYMS\PK

;YPWJV\U[LY

YLZL[

;YPWVKVTL[LYPZYLZL[[V

G–˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

0UZ[Y\TLU[

WHULS

6UÍIVHYK

JVTW\[LY

;L_[KPZWSH`PU

VUÍIVHYKJVTW\[LY

4LHUPUNTLHZ\YL

<UP[Z

HYLJOHUNLK

;OL\UP[ZRPSVTL[LYZTPSLZMVYZWLLKHUK

KPZ[HUJL^LYLJOHUNLK

3040;

*HUUV[IL

HJJLW[LK^P[O

]LOPJSLZ[VWWLK

*\YYLU[ZWLLKJHUILHJJLW[LKMVY[OL

HJV\Z[PJ^HYUPUNZPNUHSVUS`PM[OL]LOPJSLPZ

PUTV[PVU

<:(

*HUHKH

3040;

L_JLLKLK

:LSLJ[LKZWLLKSPTP[MVY[OLHJV\Z[PJ^HYUPUN

ZPNUHSOHZILLUL_JLLKLK

(KQ\Z[`V\YZWLLKPMULJLZZHY`

-\LSSL]LSNH\NL

^HYUPUNSPNO[

*VUZPKLYYHUNLVU

YLTHPUPUNM\LS

9LM\LSH[[OLUL_[VWWVY[\UP[`

,UNPULVPS

WYLZZ\YL

[VVSV^

:[VWPTTLKPH[LS`H[HZ\P[HISLWSHJL

TLHZ\YLVPSSL]LS^P[O[OLVUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY

HUKPMULJLZZHY`HKKLUNPULVPS

;LTWLYH[\YL

NH\NL^HYUPUN

SPNO[

,UNPUL

[LTWLYH[\YL

[VVOPNO

:^P[JOLUNPULVMMHUKSL[P[JVVS

*OLJRJVVSHU[SL]LSHUKPMULJLZZHY`

HKKJVVSHU[

;LTWLYH[\YL

NH\NL^HYUPUN

SPNO[MSHZOLZ

*OLJR

JVVSHU[SL]LS

:^P[JOLUNPULVMMHUKSL[P[JVVS

*OLJRJVVSHU[SL]LSHUKPMULJLZZHY`

HKKJVVSHU[

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

0UZ[Y\TLU[

WHULS

6UÍIVHYK

JVTW\[LY

;L_[KPZWSH`PU

VUÍIVHYKJVTW\[LY

4LHUPUNTLHZ\YL

*OLJR,UNPUL

9LMLY[VJOHW[LYs*OLJRLUNPUL^HYUPUNSPNO[r

/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK

7VYZJOLKLHSLY

;LTWLYH[\YL

NH\NL^HYUPUN

SPNO[MSHZOLZ

-HPS\YLVM

LUNPULÌ

JVTWHY[TLU[

ISV^LY

/H]LMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOL

KLHSLY

>HYUPUN

IH[[LY`

NLULYH[VY

:[VWPUHZHMLWSHJLHUKZ^P[JO[OLLUNPUL

VMM+VUV[JVU[PU\LKYP]PUN

/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK

7VYZJOLKLHSLY

-HPS\YLPUKPJH[VY

6PSWYLZZ\YLPUKPJH[VYPZMH\S[`

/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK

7VYZJOLKLHSLY

-HPS\YL

VPSSL]LS

PUKPJH[VY

/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK

7VYZJOLKLHSLY

-HPS\YLPUKPJH[VY

*VVSHU[[LTWLYH[\YLNH\NLPZMH\S[`

/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK

7VYZJOLKLHSLY

-HPS\YLPUKPJH[VY

;OLJVVSHU[[LTWLYH[\YLNH\NL[HJOVÌ

TL[LYVYJY\PZLJVU[YVSL[JJV\SKILMH\S[`

/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK

7VYZJOLKLHSLY

GG˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

0UZ[Y\TLU[

WHULS

6UÍIVHYK

JVTW\[LY

;L_[KPZWSH`PU

VUÍIVHYKJVTW\[LY

4LHUPUNTLHZ\YL

<:(

*HUHKH

:LY]PJL

^LHYVU

IYHRLWHKZ

/H]L[OLIYHRLWHKZYLWSHJLKH[HU

H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY^P[OV\[KLSH`

<:(

*HUHKH

>HYUPUN

IYHRL

MS\PKSL]LS

:[VWPTTLKPH[LS`PUHZ\P[HISLWSHJL

+VUV[JVU[PU\LKYP]PUN/H]L[OLMH\S[

YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

<:(

*HUHKH

>HYUPUN

IYHRL

KPZ[YPI\[PVU

:[VWPTTLKPH[LS`PUHZ\P[HISLWSHJL

+VUV[JVU[PU\LKYP]PUN/H]L[OLMH\S[

YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

<:(

*HUHKH

():MHPS\YL

/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK

7VYZJOLKLHSLY

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

Gn

background image

0UZ[Y\TLU[

WHULS

6UÍIVHYK

JVTW\[LY

;L_[KPZWSH`PU

VUÍIVHYKJVTW\[LY

4LHUPUNTLHZ\YL

-HPS\YLPUKPJH[VY

;OLZWLLKVTL[LY():VY7:4^HYUPUNSPNO[Z

HUKZ`Z[LTZL[JJV\SKILMH\S[`

/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK

7VYZJOLKLHSLY

7:4MHPS\YL

/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK

7VYZJOLKLHSLY

(PYIHNMHPS\YL

/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK

7VYZJOLKLHSLY

-HPS\YL

ZWVPSLY

JVU[YVS

+YP]PUNZ[HIPSP[`PZPTWHPYLK

(KQ\Z[`V\YKYP]PUNZ[`SL

/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK

7VYZJOLKLHSLY

:LSLJ[VYSL]LY

WVZP[PVUPUKPJH[VY

MSHZOLZ

:LSLJ[VY

SL]LY

UV[LUNHNLK

:LSLJ[VYSL]LYJV\SKILIL[^LLU[^V

WVZP[PVUZ

,UNHNL[OLZLSLJ[VYSL]LYJVYYLJ[S`

:LSLJ[VYSL]LY

WVZP[PVUPUKPJH[VY

MSHZOLZ

;PW[YVUPJ

LTLYNLUJ`Y\U

/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK

7VYZJOLKLHSLY

-HPS\YLPUKPJH[VY

;OLKPZWSH`ZVMZL]LYHSZ`Z[LTZTPNO[OH]L

MHPSLK

/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK

7VYZJOLKLHSLY

-HPS\YLVMM\LS

SL]LSPUKPJH[VY

.V[V

^VYRZOVW

/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK

7VYZJOLKLHSLY

n¬˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

0UZ[Y\TLU[

WHULS

6UÍIVHYK

JVTW\[LY

;L_[KPZWSH`PU

VUÍIVHYKJVTW\[LY

4LHUPUNTLHZ\YL

-HPS\YLV\[ZPKL

[LTWLYH[\YL

PUKPJH[VY

/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK

7VYZJOLKLHSLY

4cmp§dF=VamV˜§"mamV˜hF’’"VF’

>HYUPUNTLZZHNLZJHUILLYHZLK

MYVT[OLVUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LYKPZWSH`

7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYVMVUÌIVHYK

JVTW\[LYMVY^HYK

@V\JHUYLJHSSLYHZLK^HYUPUNTLZZHNLZ

PU[OLr*/,*2sTLU\

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

ns

background image

n¢˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

hFVFm4©˜ d"’^F˜§a›4^

6WLYH[PVUHS YLHKPULZZ VM [OL LTLYNLUJ` MSHZOLY

KVLZ UV[ KLWLUK VU [OL PNUP[PVU SVJR HUK [\YU

ZPNUHSSL]LYWVZP[PVU

0M `V\Y JHY PZ KPZHISLK VY WHYRLK \UKLY LTLYÌ

NLUJ` JVUKP[PVUZ Z^P[JO VU [OL LTLYNLUJ`

MSHZOLYPU[OLKHZOIVHYKHYYV^

(SS [\YU ZPNUHSZ HUK [OL PUKPJH[VY SPNO[ PU [OL

Z^P[JOMSHZO^P[O[OLZHTLMYLX\LUJ`

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMHUHJJPKLU[

>OLUL]LY Z[HSSLK VY Z[VWWLK MVY LTLYNLUJ`

YLWHPYZ TV]L [OL JHY ^LSS VMM [OL YVHK

:^P[JO VU [OL LTLYNLUJ` MSHZOLY HUK THYR

[OL JHY ^P[O YVHK MSHYLZ VY V[OLY ^HYUPUN KLÌ

]PJLZ

+VUV[YLTHPUPU[OLJHY:VTLVULHWWYVHJOÌ

PUNMYVT[OLYLHYTH`UV[YLHSPaL`V\Y]LOPJSL

PZZ[VWWLKHUKJH\ZLHJVSSPZPVU

+HUNLYVMMPYL

+V UV[ WHYR VY VWLYH[L [OL ]LOPJSL PU HYLHZ

^OLYL [OL OV[ L_OH\Z[ Z`Z[LT TH` JVTL PU

JVU[HJ[ ^P[O KY` NYHZZ IY\ZO M\LS ZWPSS VY

V[OLYMSHTTHISLTH[LYPHS

/V[ LUNPUL JVTWHY[TLU[ JVTWVULU[Z JHU

I\YUZRPUVUJVU[HJ[

)LMVYL^VYRPUNVUHU`WHY[PU[OLLUNPULJVTÌ

WHY[TLU[ [\YU [OL LUNPUL VMM HUK SL[ P[ JVVS

KV^UZ\MMPJPLU[S`

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

aV^›˜§a›4^

3PNO[ZZ^P[JOLKVMM

7HYRPUN SPNO[Z ZPKL THYRLY SPNO[Z

SPJLUZL WSH[L SPNO[ PUZ[Y\TLU[ PSS\TPUHÌ

[PVU

3V^ILHTOPNOILHT

6US`^P[OPNUP[PVUVU

-VNSPNO[ZPUHKKP[PVU[V

WHYRPUNSPNO[ZVYSV^ILHT!

7\SSZ^P[JO[VMPYZ[JSPJR

0UKPJH[VYSPNO[VU

;OL MVN SPNO[Z ^PSS NV V\[ H\[VTH[PJHSS`

^OLU[OLOPNOILHTZHYLZ^P[JOLKVU

9LHYMVNSPNO[PUHKKP[PVU[V

[OLMVNSPNO[Z!

7\SSZ^P[JO[VZLJVUKJSPJR

0UKPJH[VYSPNO[VU

7HYRPUNSPNO[YPNO[SLM[

6US`^OLUPNUP[PVURL`PZ^P[OKYH^U!

7\SSZ^P[JOV\[ZSPNO[S`PUWVZP[PVUsr

HUK[\YU[V

uWHYRPUNÌSPNO[WVZP[PVUSLM[

uWHYRPUNÌSPNO[WVZP[PVUYPNO[

7HYRPUNSPNO[ZHUKZPKLTHYRLYSPNO[Z

HYLSP[VU[OLZLSLJ[LKZPKL

0M [OL PNUP[PVU RL` PZ ^P[OKYH^U HUK [OL KVVY PZ

VWLULK ^OPSL [OL SPNO[Z UV[ [OL WHYRPUN SPNO[

SLM[YPNO[HYLVUHNVUN^HYUZVMWVZZPISLIH[Ì

[LY`KPZJOHYNL

0U ZVTL JV\U[YPLZ KPMMLYLUJLZ HYL WVZZPISL

K\L[VWYV]PZPVUZVMSH^

¤›ph"›a4˜ F"=daV^›˜F"h

=b¤’›hFm›

>OLU[OLPNUP[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVU[OLSL]LSVM[OL

OLHKSPNO[ILHTH\[VTH[PJHSS`JOHUNLZPUHJJVYKÌ

HUJL^P[O[OL]LOPJSLSVHK

;OL SL]LS VM [OL OLHKSPNO[ ILHT PZ H\[VTH[PJHSS`

RLW[JVUZ[HU[K\YPUNHJJLSLYH[PVUHUKIYHRPUN

*OLJRPUNVWLYH[PVU
 :^P[JO[OLSV^ILHTVU

 :^P[JOPNUP[PVUVU

;OL SPNO[ ILHT MPYZ[ KPWZ HSS [OL ^H` KV^U

HUKPZ[OLUHKHW[LK[V[OL]LOPJSLSVHK

0[ [OPZ [LZ[ P[LT PZ UV[ TL[ [OL OLHKSPNO[

ILHT HKQ\Z[TLU[ T\Z[ IL JOLJRLK I` HU

H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

nT˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

¤m˜aVm"d˜—˜

F"=daV^›˜ahhF— d"’^F˜F¦F

;\YUZPNUHSZSV^ILHTHUKOPNOILHTHYLYLHK`

MVYVWLYH[PVU^OLU[OLPNUP[PVUPZVU

 u ;\YUZPNUHSSLM[

 u ;\YUZPNUHSYPNO[

 u /PNOILHT

 u /LHKSPNO[MSHZOLY

3L]LYPUJLU[LYWVZP[PVUu3V^ILHT

>OLU OPNO ILHT HUK OLHKSPNO[ MSHZOLY HYL ZLÌ

SLJ[LK[OLIS\LPUKPJH[VYSPNO[PU[OL[HJOVTL[LY

PZSP[

;OL [\YU ZPNUHS SL]LY [\YUZ VMM H\[VTH[PJHSS`

^OLU [OL Z[LLYPUN ^OLLS PZ Z[YHPNO[LULK V\[

HM[LYJVTWSL[PUNH[\YU

"mF˜4^"mVF

;V PUKPJH[L `V\Y PU[LU[PVU ^OLU JOHUNPUN

SHULZ VU [OL MYLL^H` ZSPNO[S` SPM[ VY KLWYLZZ

[OLSL]LY[V[OLYLZPZ[HUJLWVPU[

;OLSL]LY^PSSYL[\YU[V[OL6--WVZP[PVU^OLU

YLSLHZLK

0M [OL MYLX\LUJ` VM [OL KPZWSH` ILJVTLZ UVÌ

[PJLHISL MHZ[LY JOLJR [OL VWLYH[PVU VM [OL

[\YUZPNUHSI\SIZ

F"=daV^›˜Od"’^F

>P[OPNUP[PVUVUVYVMM

;V MSHZO [OL OLHKSPNO[Z [V VUJVTTPUN TV[VYÌ

PZ[ZZSPNO[S`W\SS[OLSL]LY[V^HYK[OLZ[LLYPUN

^OLLSHUK[OLUYLSLHZLP[

;OL IS\L PUKPJH[VY SPNO[ PU [OL [HJOVTL[LY ^PSS

NVVUVMMHZ`V\W\SSYLSLHZL[OLSL]LY

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

nQ

background image

am=’^aFd=˜azF˜—˜"’^F˜F¦F

*H\[PVU

+HUNLYVMPUQ\Y`^OLU[OL^PUKZOPLSK^PWLYZ

VWLYH[L\UPU[LU[PVUHSS`

9PZRVMKHTHNL[V[OL^PUKZOPLSKHUK^PWLY

Z`Z[LT

(]VPK Y\UUPUN [OL ^PWLY ISHKLZ V]LY H KY`

^PUKZOPLSK [V WYL]LU[ ZJYH[JOPUN [OL NSHZZ

:WYH`^HZOLYMS\PKVU[OL^PUKZOPLSKMPYZ[

(ZJYH[JOLK^PUKZOPLSK^PSSYLK\JL]PZPIPSP[`

(S^H`ZSVVZLU^PWLYISHKLZMYVTMYVaLUNSHZZ

ILMVYLVWLYH[PUN^PWLYZ[VWYL]LU[KHTHNL[V

[OL^PWLYTV[VYVYISHKLZ

(S^H`Z Z^P[JO VMM ^PUKZOPLSK ^PWLYZ PU JHY

^HZO [V WYL]LU[ [OLT ^PWPUN \UPU[LU[PVUHSS`

PU[LYTP[[LU[VYZLUZVYVWLYH[PVU

(S^H`Z Z^P[JO VMM ^PUKZOPLSK ^PWLYZ ILMVYL

JSLHUPUN [OL ^PUKZOPLSK [V H]VPK \UPU[LU[PVUHS

VWLYH[PVUPU[LYTP[[LU[VYZLUZVYVWLYH[PVU

+V UV[ VWLYH[L [OL OLHKSPNO[ ^HZOLY PU JHY

^HZOLZ

+V UV[ VWLYH[L OLHKSPNO[ ^HZOLY ^OLU P[ PZ

MYVaLU

u >PUKZOPLSK^PWLYZVMM

u >PUKZOPLSK^PWLYZZSV^

u >PUKZOPLSK^PWLYZMHZ[

u 0U[LYTP[[LU[VWLYH[PVU

u >PUKZOPLSK^HZOLYZ`Z[LT!

:WYH`Z^OPSL[OLSL]LYPZW\SSLK[V^HYKZ[OL

Z[LLYPUN^OLLSPU[OLMPYZ[WVZP[PVU

>OLU [OL SL]LY PZ YLSLHZLK H ML^ KY`PUN

^PWLZHYLL_LJ\[LK

u >PUKZOPLSK^PWLYZHUK^HZOLYZ`Z[LT!

:WYH`Z HUK ^PWLZ ^OPSL [OL SL]LY PZ W\SSLK

[V^HYKZ [OL Z[LLYPUN ^OLLS PU [OL ZLJVUK

WVZP[PVU

u /LHKSPNO[^HZOLY!

:WYH`ZVUS`^OPSLSV^ILHTVYOPNOILHTPZ

Z^P[JOLKVU

;OL ZWYH` K\YH[PVU PZ SPTP[LK 0M OLH]PS`

ZVPSLKYLWLH[^HZO

7LYZPZ[LU[ KPY[ LN PUZLJ[ YLTHPUZ ZOV\SK

ILYLN\SHYS`YLTV]LK

:LL[OLJOHW[LYVUs*HY*HYL0UZ[Y\J[PVUZr

5V[L
;OL ^PUKZOPLSK ^HZOLY UVaaSLZ HYL OLH[LK

^OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ VU HZ H WYLJH\[PVU HNHPUZ[

MYLLaPUN

n–˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

azF˜am›F¦"d˜4pm›pd

0U^PUKZOPLSK^PWLYPU[LYTP[[LU[TVKL[OL^PWL

PU[LY]HSZ JHU IL PUMPUP[LS` HKQ\Z[LK UV[ PU ]LÌ

OPJSLZ^P[OHYHPUZLUZVY

:OVY[LUPUN^PWLPU[LY]HSZ

;\YU[O\TI^OLLS(JSVJR^PZL

3LUN[OLUPUN^PWLPU[LY]HSZ

;\YU[O\TI^OLLS(JV\U[LYÌJSVJR^PZL

"am˜’Fm’p

0U]LOPJSLZ^P[OHYHPUZLUZVY[OLHTV\U[VMYHPU

VY ZUV^ ^OPJO OHZ ZL[[SLK VU [OL ^PUKZOPLSK PZ

TLHZ\YLK ;OL ^PWLY ZWLLK PZ JVU[YVSSLK

HJJVYKPUNS` IL[^LLU PU[LYTP[[LU[ HUK JVU[PU\V\Z

VWLYH[PVU^PWLYZWLLKHUK

:^P[JOPUNYHPUZLUZVYVU

4V]L^PWLYSL]LYPUWVZP[PVU

:^P[JOPUNYHPUZLUZVYVMM

4V]L^PWLYSL]LYPUWVZP[PVU

5V[L
;OL YHPU ZLUZVY YLTHPUZ Z^P[JOLK VMM PM [OL

^PWLYSL]LYPZHSYLHK`PUWVZP[PVU^OLU[OLPNUPÌ

[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVU

;VZ^P[JO[OLYHPUZLUZVYVU!

4V]L^PWLYSL]LY[VWVZP[PVUHUK[OLUIHJR

[VWVZP[PVUVY

6WLYH[L^PUKZOPLSK^HZOLYZ`Z[LTVY

*OHUNL [OL ZLUZP[P]P[` VM [OL YHPU ZLUZVY ^P[O

[OL[O\TI^OLLS

:^P[JOÌVU PZ JVUMPYTLK I`VUL^PWLVM[OL^PUKÌ

ZOPLSK

*OHUNPUN[OLZLUZP[P]P[`VM[OLYHPU

ZLUZVY

:LUZP[P]P[`JHUILZL[^P[O[OL[O\TI^OLLS(PU

Z[HNLZ

;\YU [O\TI ^OLLS ( JV\U[LYÌJSVJR^PZL Ì SV^

ZLUZP[P]P[`

;\YU [O\TI ^OLLS ( JSVJR^PZL Ì OPNO ZLUZP[P]Ì

P[`

;OL ZL[[PUN PZ JVUMPYTLK I` VUL ^PWL VM [OL

^PUKZOPLSK

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

(Í(\[VTH[PJZWLLKJVU[YVSYLHKPULZZVMMVU

Í/VSKHUKZ[VYLHJJLSLYH[L

Í+LJLSLYH[LYLZ\TL

Í0U[LYY\W[

¤›ph"›a4˜zFF=˜pm›pd

;OL H\[VTH[PJ ZWLLK JVU[YVS THPU[HPUZ HU`

ZLSLJ[LKZWLLKIL[^LLUTWOHUKTWO

 RTO HUK  RTO ^P[OV\[ `V\ OH]PUN [V

\ZL[OLHJJLSLYH[VY

;OL H\[VTH[PJ ZWLLK JVU[YVS PZ VWLYH[LK ^P[O

[OLSL]LYVU[OLZ[LLYPUN^OLLS

>HYUPUN

(JVUZ[HU[ZWLLKTH`UV[ILZHMLPUOLH]`

[YHMMPJVYVU^PUKPUNVYZSPWWLY`YVHKZ

>P[O [OL ZWLLK JVU[YVS Z`Z[LT LUNHNLK

[OL LUNPUL ZWLLK ^PSS UV[ YL[\YU [V PKSL

^OLU YLTV]PUN [OL MVV[ MYVT [OL HJJLSLYHÍ

[VYWLKHS

+VUV[\ZL[OLZWLLKJVU[YVS^OLUP[TH`IL

\UZHML[VRLLW[OLJHYH[HJVUZ[HU[ZWLLK

6IZLY]LHSSSVJHSHUKUH[PVUHSZWLLKSPTP[Z

§a›4^˜"¤›ph"›a4˜’zFF=˜4pm›pd

F"=amF’’˜pm

7YLZZ I\[[VU ( VU [OL H\[VTH[PJ ZWLLK JVUÌ

[YVSSL]LY

    ;OPZNYLLUPUKPJH[VYSPNO[PU[OL

    ZWLLKVTL[LYUV^PUKPJH[LZYLHKPULZZ

pd=˜"m=˜’›pF˜’zFF=

)YPUN [OL JHY [V [OL KLZPYLK ZWLLK ^P[O [OL

HJJLSLYH[VY

;OLUW\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYKIYPLMS`

44FdF"›amV˜|FV˜›p˜p¦F›"cF}

0UJYLHZLZWLLKHZ\Z\HS^P[O[OLHJJLSLYH[VY

>OLU[OLHJJLSLYH[VYPZYLSLHZLK[OLWYL]PV\ZS`

ZH]LK]HS\LPZHNHPUZL[

(\[VTH[PJ ZWLLK JVU[YVS VWLYH[PVU PZ H\[VTH[Ì

PJHSS` PU[LYY\W[LK OV^L]LY PM [OL ZWLLK PZ PUÌ

JYLHZLKI`TVYL[OHUHIV\[TWORTO

MVYSVUNLY[OHUZLJVUKZVY!

7YLZZ VWLYH[PUN SL]LY MVY^HYK  \U[PS [OL

KLZPYLKZWLLKPZYLHJOLK

;OL ZWLLK YLHJOLK PZ THPU[HPULK HUK Z[VYLK

^OLU[OLSL]LYPZYLSLHZLK

:WLLKJHUILJVYYLJ[LKPUZ[LWZVMRTOHWÌ

WYV_  TWO I` IYPLMS` W\ZOPUN [OL SL]LY MVYÌ

^HYKVYKV^U\W[V[PTLZ

nG˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

F4FdF"›amV

7YLZZVWLYH[PUNSL]LYKV^U\U[PS[OLKLZPYLK

ZWLLKPZYLHJOLK

;OL ZWLLK YLHJOLK PZ THPU[HPULK HUK Z[VYLK

^OLU[OLSL]LYPZYLSLHZLK

:WLLKJHUILJVYYLJ[LKPUZ[LWZVMRTOHWÌ

WYV_  TWO I` IYPLMS` W\ZOPUN [OL SL]LY MVYÌ

^HYKVYKV^U\W[V[PTLZ

m›F¤z›amV˜"¤›ph"›a4˜’zFF=˜4pm›pd

pzF"›apm

7\SS VWLYH[PUN SL]LY IYPLMS` [V^HYKZ [OL Z[LLYÌ

PUN^OLLSVY!

6WLYH[LIYHRLVYJS\[JOWLKHSVY

^P[O ;PW[YVUPJ [YHUZTPZZPVU ZLSLJ[ WVZP[PVU

s5r:LLHSZV[OLJOHW[LYVUs;PW[YVUPJr

;OL ZWLLK KYP]LU ILMVYL [OL PU[LYY\W[PVU YLÌ

THPUZZ[VYLKPU[OLTLTVY`

(\[VTH[PJ ZWLLK JVU[YVS VWLYH[PVU PZ PU[LYÍ

Y\W[LKH\[VTH[PJHSS`!



0M [OL ZL[ ZWLLK PZ L_JLLKLK I` TVYL [OHU

 TWO  RTO MVY SVUNLY [OHU   ZLJÌ

VUKZ



PM [OL HJ[\HS ZWLLK MHSSZ [V  TWO  RTO

ILSV^[OLZL[]LOPJSLZWLLKMVYSVUNLY[OHU

ZLJVUKZ\W^HYKZSVWLZ

F’¤hamV˜›^F˜’›pF=˜’zFF=

7YLZZVWLYH[PUNSL]LYIYPLMS`KV^U

;OLZ[VYLKZWLLKZOV\SKVUS`ILJHSSLK\W^OLU

[YHMMPJ JVUKP[PVUZ HUK [OL YVHK Z\YMHJL ZV WLYÌ

TP[

§a›4^amV˜"¤›ph"›a4˜’zFF=˜4pm›pd

F"=amF’’˜pOO

7YLZZ I\[[VU ( VU [OL H\[VTH[PJ ZWLLK JVUÌ

[YVSSL]LY

;OLNYLLUYLHKPULZZSPNO[PU[OLZWLLKVTL[LY

NVLZVMM

>OLU [OL ]LOPJSL PZ WHYRLK HUK [OL PNUP[PVU

Z^P[JOLKVMM[OLTLTVY`PZJSLHYLK

0TWVY[HU[UV[L
6U \W^HYK VY KV^U^HYK ZSVWLZ [OL ZL[ ZWLLK

JHUUV[ HS^H`Z IL THPU[HPULK I` [OL H\[VTH[PJ

ZWLLKJVU[YVS

;V VI[HPU Z\MMPJPLU[ LUNPUL IYHRPUN VY H IL[[LY

LUNPULÌZWLLK YHUNL [OLYLMVYL `V\ OH]L [V ZLÌ

SLJ[HSV^LYNLHY

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

nn

background image

¤›ph"›a4˜a˜pm=a›apmamV

;OL HPYÌJVUKP[PVUPUN Z`Z[LT JVU[YVSZ [OL WYLZLÌ

SLJ[LK PU[LYPVY [LTWLYH[\YL JVTWSL[LS` H\[VTH[Ì

PJHSS`

0M ULJLZZHY` [OL H\[VTH[PJ Z`Z[LT JHU IL THÌ

U\HSS`VWLYH[LK

3LM[KPZWSH`WHULSu

;LTWLYH[\YLHUKHJ[P]LM\UJ[PVUZ

9PNO[KPZWSH`WHULSu

)SV^LYZWLLKHUKHJ[P]LM\UJ[PVUZ

¤›ph"›a4˜pzF"›apm

7YLZZsH\[VrI\[[VU

(PY X\HU[P[` HUK KPZ[YPI\[PVU HYL H\[VTH[PJHSS`

JVU[YVSSLKHUK]HYPH[PVUZHYLJVTWLUZH[LK

(SSH\[VTH[PJZL[[PUNM\UJ[PVUZJHUILPUKP]PK\HSS`

JOHUNLK

;OPZZL[[PUNPZYL[HPULK\U[PS[OLHWWYVWYPH[LM\UJÌ

[PVUI\[[VUPZWYLZZLKHNHPUVY[OLsH\[VrI\[[VU

PZWYLZZLK

˜J˜FhzF"›¤F˜’F››amV

7YLZZ[OLHWWYVWYPH[LI\[[VU

;V Z\P[ WLYZVUHS JVTMVY[ [OL PU[LYPVY [LTWLYHÌ

[\YL JHU IL ZLSLJ[LK IL[^LLU ‰- HUK ‰-

‰*HUK ‰*

9LJVTTLUKH[PVU!Š-Š*

0M[OLKPZWSH`s36rVYs/0rHWWLHYZ[OLZ`Z[LTPZ

VWLYH[PUNH[TH_PT\TJVVSPUNVYOLH[PUNWV^LY

5V[L
0M [OL WYLZLSLJ[LK [LTWLYH[\YL PZ JOHUNLK [OL

ISV^LYZWLLKJHUPUJYLHZLH\[VTH[PJHSS`PUH\[VÌ

TH[PJVWLYH[PVU

;OL KLZPYLK [LTWLYH[\YL PZ YLHJOLK TVYL

X\PJRS`[OPZ^H`

s¬¬˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

FOp’›amV˜›^F˜§am=’^aFd=

7YLZZI\[[VU

>PUKZOPLSK PZ KLTPZ[LK VY KLMYVZ[LK HZ

X\PJRS`HZWVZZPISL

(PYMSV^Z[V[OL^PUKZOPLSKVUS`

§a›4^amV˜4phzF’’p˜Op

"a_4pm=a›apmamV˜’©’›Fh˜pm˜p˜pOO

>OLUL]LY

V\[ZPKL

[LTWLYH[\YLZ

L_JLLK

‰-‰* [OL HPYÌJVUKP[PVUPUN JVTWYLZZVY PZ HSÌ

^H`ZZ^P[JOLKVUPUH\[VTH[PJVWLYH[PVU

;OL JVTWYLZZVY JHU IL Z^P[JOLK VMM [V ZH]L

M\LSI\[JVU[YVSJVTMVY[PZ[OLUSPTP[LK

7YLZZI\[[VU

;OL JVTWYLZZVY PZ Z^P[JOLK VMM [OL Z`TIVS

PU[OLSLM[ÌOHUKKPZWSH`NVLZV\[

0M [OL PU[LYPVY [LTWLYH[\YL PZ [VV OPNO Z^P[JO

JVTWYLZZVYIHJRVUVYWYLZZsH\[VsÌI\[[VU

;V KY` PUJVTPUN HPY PU KHTW ^LH[OLY KV UV[

Z^P[JOVMM[OLHPYÌJVUKP[PVUPUNJVTWYLZZVY

;OPZWYL]LU[ZTPZ[PUNVM^PUKV^Z

˜J˜=b¤’›amV˜*dp§F˜’zFF=

7YLZZ[OLHWWYVWYPH[LI\[[VU

7YLZL[ ISV^LY ZWLLK PZ PUJYLHZLK VY KLÌ

JYLHZLK HUK r4HU\HSs HWWLHYZ PU [OL YPNO[Ì

OHUKKPZWSH`MPLSK

   ;OLZWLLKZ[HNLZHYLPUKPJH[LKI`H

   IHYKPZWSH`

0M [OL TPU\Z I\[[VU PZ WYLZZLK H[ [OL SV^LZ[

ISV^LY Z[HNL [OL ISV^LY HUK H\[VTH[PJ JVU[YVS

HYLZ^P[JOLKVMM

s6--rPZKPZWSH`LKPU[OLSLM[ÌOHUKKPZWSH`

7YLZZPUNVU[OLWS\ZI\[[VUVY[OLsH\[VrI\[[VU

Z^P[JOLZ[OLISV^LYHUKH\[VTH[PJJVU[YVSIHJR

VUHNHPU

a4¤d"›amV_"a˜’F››amV

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMHJJPKLU[K\L[VOHTWLYLK]PZPVU

0U JPYJ\SH[PUNÍHPY ZL[[PUN [OL ^PUKV^Z JHU

TPZ[\W

6US` ZLSLJ[ JPYJ\SH[PUNÌHPY ZL[[PUN MVY ZOVY[

WLYPVKZ

0M ^PUKV^Z TPZ[ \W [\YU VMM [OL JPYJ\SH[PUNÌHPY

ZL[[PUN I` WYLZZPUN [OL JPYJ\SH[PUNÌHPY I\[[VU

IYPLMS` HUK ZLSLJ[ [OL M\UJ[PVU s+LMYVZ[ ^PUKÌ

ZOPLSKr

:^P[JOPUNJPYJ\SH[PUNÍHPYZL[[PUN

VUVYVMM

7YLZZI\[[VU

;OL V\[ZPKLÌHPY Z\WWS` PZ PU[LYY\W[LK HUK VUS`

[OLPUZPKLHPYPZJPYJ\SH[LK

6]LYHWWYV_Š-Š*
0M [OL HPYÌJVUKP[PVUPUN JVTWYLZZVY ^HZ VMM P[

Z^P[JOLZVUH\[VTH[PJHSS`;OLK\YH[PVUVMJPYJ\Ì

SH[PUNÌHPYTVKLPZUV[SPTP[LK

)LSV^HWWYV_Š-Š*
;OL HPYÌJVUKP[PVUPUN JVTWYLZZVY PZ Z^P[JOLK VMM

*PYJ\SH[PUNÌHPY TVKL PZ H\[VTH[PJHSS` LUKLK HM[LY

HWWYV_TPU\[LZ

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

s¬s

background image

a˜=a’›a*¤›apm˜›p˜Opp›§Fdd

7YLZZI\[[VU

;OLHPYMSV^Z[V[OLMVV[^LSS

a˜=a’›a*¤›apm˜›p˜›^F˜

4Fm›"d˜"m=˜’a=F˜¦Fm›’

7YLZZI\[[VU

;OLHPYMSV^ZMYVT[OLJLU[YHSHUKZPKL]LU[Z

=LU[ZT\Z[ILVWLU

a˜=a’›a*¤›apm˜›p˜

§am=’^aFd=

7YLZZI\[[VU

;OLHPYMSV^Z[V[OL^PUKZOPLSK

FmF"d˜am’›¤4›apm’˜Op˜

"a_4pm=a›apmamV˜4phzF’’p


*HU Z^P[JO VMM IYPLMS` PM LUNPUL PZ \UKLY HU

L_[YLTLSVHK[VLUZ\YLZ\MMPJPLU[LUNPULJVVSÌ

PUN



:^P[JOLZ VMM H\[VTH[PJHSS` H[ [LTWLYH[\YLZ

ILSV^ ‰-‰* HUK JHUUV[ IL Z^P[JOLK VU

L]LUTHU\HSS`



6WLYH[LZ TVZ[ LMMLJ[P]LS` ^P[O ^PUKV^Z

JSVZLK

0M[OLJHYOHZILLUPU[OLZ\UMVYHSVUN[PTL

OV^L]LY P[ PZ H NVVK PKLH [V ]LU[PSH[L [OL PUÌ

[LYPVYIYPLMS`^P[OKVVY^PUKV^ZVWLU



+LWLUKPUNVU[OLV\[ZPKL[LTWLYH[\YLHUKO\Ì

TPKP[` JVUKLUZH[PVU JHU KYPW MYVT [OL L]HWÌ

VYH[VYHUKMVYTHWVVS\UKLY[OLJHY

;OPZPZUVYTHSHUKUV[HZPNUVMSLHRHNL



0M\UJVVSLKHPYMSV^ZV\[^OLU[OLSV^LZ[[LTÌ

WLYH[\YL OHZ ILLU ZL[ Z^P[JO VMM [OL HPYÌJVUÌ

KP[PVUPUN JVTWYLZZVY HUK JVUZ\S[ ^P[O HU

H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

s¬¢˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

(Í*VU[PU\V\ZVWLUPUNHUKJSVZPUN

)Í:L[[PUN]LU[KPYLJ[PVU

Fm›"d˜"m=˜a=F˜Fm›’

zFmamV˜¦Fm›’

9V[H[LRU\YSLK^OLLS\W^HYK

dp’amV˜¦Fm›’

9V[H[LRU\YSLK^OLLSKV^U^HYK

^"mVamV˜"a˜Odp§˜=aF4›apm

4V]L [OL ]HULZ [V THRL [OL HPY MSV^ PU [OL

KLZPYLKKPYLJ[PVU

6\[ZPKL HPY VY JVUKP[PVULK HPY JHU IL KLSP]LYLK

MYVT HSS ]LU[Z KLWLUKPUN VU [OL HPYÌKPZ[YPI\[PVU

ZL[[PUNVU[OLVWLYH[PUNWHULS

F’^_"a˜am›"cF

;VLUZ\YLWYVWLYHPYPU[HRL!

2LLW [OL MYLZOÌHPY PUSL[ IL[^LLU [OL S\NNHNL

JVTWHY[TLU[ SPK HUK [OL ^PUKZOPLSK MYLL

MYVTZUV^PJLHUKSLH]LZ

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

s¬

background image

’^›"©

zFmamV

7YLZZHZO[YH`SPKIYPLMS`

hz›©amV

6WLU HZO[YH` HUK JHYLM\SS` W\SS V\[ HZOPUZLY[

I`[OLSPK

>HYUPUN

+HUNLYVMMPYL

5L]LY \ZL HZO[YH` MVY ^HZ[L WHWLY KPZWVZHS

HZP[JV\SKWVZLHMPYLOHaHYK

aV"F››F˜aV^›F

>HYUPUN

+HUNLYVMMPYLHUKI\YUPUN

;OL JPNHYL[[L SPNO[LY PZ YLHK` MVY \ZL YLÍ

NHYKSLZZVM[OLPNUP[PVUSVJRWVZP[PVU

5L]LYSLH]L\UZ\WLY]PZLKJOPSKYLUPU[OLJHY

5L]LY [V\JO [OL OLH[PUN LSLTLU[ VY ZPKLZ VM

[OLSPNO[LY

/VSK[OLSPNO[LYI`[OLRUVIVUS`

F"›amV˜daV^›F

7\ZOPURUVIVM[OLJPNHYL[[LSPNO[LY

>OLU YLHK` MVY \ZL [OL SPNO[LY ^PSS ZUHW

IHJR

zF"›amV˜"==a›apm"d˜"zzda"m4F’

>P[O [OL JPNHYL[[L SPNO[LY YLTV]LK [OL ZVJRL[

TH` IL \ZLK MVY ZTHSS LSLJ[YPJHS HWWSPHUJLZ

Z\JOHZHZOH]LYVYOHUK]HJ\\TJSLHULY

4H_PT\TYH[PUN!>H[[

+VUV[VWLYH[LLSLJ[YPJHSHWWSPHUJLZMVYTVYL

[OHUTPU\[LZ^OLULUNPULPZVMMIH[[LY`^PSS

V[OLY^PZLKPZJOHYNL

+VUV[KHTHNL[OLZVJRL[I`[Y`PUN[VPUZLY[

WS\NZVM[OL^YVUNKLZPNU

s¬T˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

F"˜azF

*H\[PVU

9PZR VM KHTHNL [V [OL YLHY ^PUKV^ HUK

^PWLYISHKL

6US` ^PWL [OL YLHY ^PUKV^ ^OLU Z\MMPJPLU[S`

^L[V[OLY^PZLP[JV\SKILZJYH[JOLK

-YLLMYVaLU^PWLYISHKLZILMVYLZL[[PUNVMM

:^P[JOPUNVU

;V\JO [OL Z`TIVS VU [OL YVJRLY Z^P[JO Ì [OL

YLHY^PWLY^PWLZ[^PJL

¤m˜a’p’

:^PUN [OL Z\U ]PZVYZ KV^U [V WYL]LU[ NSHYL

MYVT[OLMYVU[

;VWYL]LU[NSHYLMYVT[OLZPKL\UJSPW[OLZ\U

]PZVYMYVT[OLPUULYIYHJRL[HUKZ^P]LSYV\UK

ZV[OH[P[PZPUMYVU[VM[OLKVVY^PUKV^

"ma›©˜hap

;OL]HUP[`TPYYVYVU[OLYLHYVM[OLZ\U]PZVYPZ

JV]LYLKI`HSPK

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMPUQ\Y`

2LLW[OLSPKJSVZLK^OPSLKYP]PUN

0U [OL JHZL VM HU PSS\TPUH[LK ]HUP[` TPYYVY [OL

SPNO[PZZ^P[JOLKVU^OLU[OLSPKPZVWLULK

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

s¬Q

background image

(*Í:^P[JOMVYYLHKPUNSPNO[VUKYP]LYqZ

  WHZZLUNLYqZZPKL

)Í0U[LYPVYSPNO[Z^P[JO

+Í6YPLU[H[PVUSPNO[Z^P[JO

,Í6YPLU[H[PVUSPNO[

m›Fap˜daV^›’

7SLHZLVIZLY]L[OLJOHW[LYr3VHKZ^P[JOÌVMMs

5V[L

:^P[JO VMM [OL H\[VTH[PJ HU[PÌNSHYL VWLYH[PVU

VM [OL TPYYVYZ ILMVYL `V\ Z^P[JO VU [OL PU[LÌ

YPVYSPNO[

6[OLY^PZL [OL TPYYVYZ TPNO[ HJJPKLU[HSS` NV

PU[VHU[PÌNSHYLVWLYH[PVU

m›Fap˜daV^›:˜F"=amV˜daV^›’

:^P[JOPUNVMM

7YLZZSLM[OHSMVMZ^P[JO

:^P[JOPUN[VJVU[PU\V\ZPSS\TPUH[PVU

7YLZZYPNO[OHSMVMZ^P[JO

:^P[JOPUNVUHUKVMMH\[VTH[PJHSS`

4V]LSPNO[SLUZ[VJLU[LYWVZP[PVU

;OLPU[LYPVYSPNO[PZZ^P[JOLKVU^OLUHKVVY

PZ \USVJRLK VY VWLULK VY ^OLU [OL PNUP[PVU

RL`PZ^P[OKYH^UMYVT[OLPNUP[PVUSVJR

;OLPU[LYPVYSPNO[PZZ^P[JOLKVMM^P[OHKLSH`

VM HWWYV_  ZLJVUKZ HM[LY [OL KVVY PZ

JSVZLK

;OL PU[LYPVY SPNO[ NVLZ V\[ PTTLKPH[LS` HZ

ZVVUHZ[OLPNUP[PVURL`PZPUZLY[LKPU[OLPNUPÌ

[PVUSVJRVY[OL]LOPJSLPZSVJRLK

aFm›"›apm˜daV^›

3PNO[ÌLTP[[PUN KPVKLZ PU [OL KVVYZ HUK PU [OL

IYHJRL[VM[OLPU[LYPVYTPYYVYPTWYV]L`V\YVYPLUÌ

[H[PVUPUZPKL[OL]LOPJSL^OLUP[PZKHYR

;OL SPNO[ÌLTP[[PUN KPVKLZ HYL Z^P[JOLK VU ^OLU

[OL ]LOPJSL PZ \USVJRLK HUK Z^P[JOLK VMM HNHPU

^OLU[OL]LOPJSLPZSVJRLK

3PNO[ÍLTP[[PUNKPVKLPU[OLIYHJRL[VM[OL

PU[LYPVYTPYYVY
*OHUNPUN [OL IYPNO[ULZZ VM [OL SPNO[ÌLTP[[PUN

KPVKL!

7YLZZZ^P[JO+

;OLIYPNO[ULZZJOHUNLZ

s¬–˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

pp›§Fdd˜aV^›’

;OLSPNO[ZHYLZ^P[JOLKVUH\[VTH[PJHSS`^OLUH

KVVY PZ VWLULK HUK NV V\[ ^P[O H KLSH` VM

HWWYV_ZLJVUKZHM[LY[OLKVVYPZJSVZLK

:^P[JOPUN[VJVU[PU\V\ZPSS\TPUH[PVU

7YLZZ [OL YVJRLYÌZ^P[JO Z`TIVS PU [OL JLU[LY

JVUZVSL

0UKPJH[VYSPNO[JVTLZVU

;OL SPNO[ IL[^LLU [OL Z\U ]PZVYZ HUK [OL KVVY

N\HYK SPNO[Z HYL Z^P[JOLK VU HKKP[PVUHSS` ;OL

SPNO[Z HYL H\[VTH[PJHSS` Z^P[JOLK VMM HM[LY

HWWYV_ TPU\[LZPUVYKLY[VZH]L[OL]LOPJSL

IH[[LY`

;OLSPNO[ZJHUILZ^P[JOLKIHJRVUI`WYLZZPUN

[OLYVJRLYZ^P[JOHNHPU

:^P[JOPUNSPNO[ZVMM

7YLZZ[OLPUKPJH[VYSPNO[PU[OLYVJRLYZ^P[JO

a¨F=˜F"˜’zpadF

*H\[PVU

9PZRVMKHTHNL[VYLHYZWVPSLY

7SLHZLJVUZ\S[[OLVWLYH[VYILMVYL\ZPUNH\[VÌ

TH[PJJHY^HZOLZ

+VUV[W\ZO[OL]LOPJSLI`[OLZWVPSLY

pm›˜’zpadF

*H\[PVU

9PZR VM KHTHNL K\L [V YLK\JLK NYV\UK

JSLHYHUJL ;OL JHY TH` OH]L NYV\UK JVUÍ

[HJ[

+YP]L ZSV^S` HUK JHYLM\SS` VU Z[LLW \WOPSS HUK

KV^UOPSSZSVWLZLNT\S[PÌZ[VYL`JHYWHYRZ

(]VPKZ[LLWYHTWZ

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

s¥

background image

›p"VF˜am˜›^F˜"’’FmVF

phz"›hFm›

>HYUPUN

<UZLJ\YLK S\NNHNL HUK OLH]` VIQLJ[Z TH`

JVTL SVVZL K\YPUN IYHRPUN YHWPK KPYLJÍ

[PVUHSJOHUNLZVYPUHUHJJPKLU[HUKJH\ZL

ZLYPV\ZWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`VYKLH[O

+V UV[ [YHUZWVY[ HU` OLH]` VIQLJ[Z PU [OL

Z[VYHNL[YH`Z

+VUV[JHYY`\UZLJ\YLKS\NNHNLVYVIQLJ[ZPU

[OLWHZZLUNLYJVTWHY[TLU[

==a›apm"d˜’›p"VF˜zp’’a*ada›aF’


0U[OLKVVYWHULS



PU[OLKVVYZPSSVU[OLWHZZLUNLYZPKL



PU[OLJLU[LYJVUZVSL



ILOPUK[OLYLHYZLH[IHJRYLZ[Z



L_[LUZPVU VM Z[VYHNL ZWHJL I` MVSKPUN [OL

YLHYZLH[IHJRZMVY^HYK



JSV[OLZOVVRVUIHJRVMMYVU[ZLH[Z



WVJRL[VUIHJRVMMYVU[ZLH[ZVUS`VUZWVY[Z

ZLH[Z

dp¦F˜4phz"›hFm›

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMPUQ\Y`I`[OLNSV]LJVTWHY[TLU[SPK

PUJHZLVMHUHJJPKLU[

2LLW [OL NSV]L JVTWHY[TLU[ JSVZLK ^OPSL

KYP]PUN

6WLUPUN

7\SS[OLJH[JOHUKVWLU[OLSPK

3VJRPUN

3VJR[OLJH[JO[VZLJ\YL[OLJVU[LU[ZHNHPUZ[

\UH\[OVYPaLKHJJLZZ

s¬G˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

›p"VF˜›"©˜*F›§FFm˜›^F˜’F"›’

6WLUPUN

7YLZZ[OLSVJRPUNRUVIHUKSPM[[OLSPK

;OLYL PZ H JVPU OVSKLY PU [OL MVY^HYK WHY[ VM

[OLZ[VYHNL[YH`

3VJRPUN

3VJR[OLJVTWHY[TLU[[VZLJ\YL[OLJVU[LU[Z

HNHPUZ[\UH\[OVYPaLKHJJLZZ

˜p˜"’’F››F˜ pd=F

6JJ\WPLK KYH^LYZ HYL PUKPJH[LK I` H YLK ^PUÌ

KV^

6WLUPUNKYH^LYZ

7\ZO [OL I\[[VU VM [OL KYH^LY `V\ ^PZO [V

VWLU

*SVZPUNKYH^LYZ

-VSK[OL*+KYH^LY\WHUKJSVZL\U[PSP[JSPJRZ

ZO\[

*SVZL[OLJHZZL[[LKYH^LY\U[PSP[JSPJRZZO\[

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

s¬n

background image

(Í6WLUPUNS\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[SPK

)Í6WLUPUNLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[SPK

¤VV"VF˜phz"›hFm›˜a=˜"m=

mVamF˜phz"›hFm›˜a=

mdp4camV

>P[O [OL KYP]LYqZ KVVY VWLU VWLYH[L [OL

HWWYVWYPH[L W\SSÌI\[[VU UL_[ [V [OL KYP]LYqZ

ZLH[

;OLS\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[VYLUNPULJVTWHY[Ì

TLU[ PZ PSS\TPUH[LK ^OLU [OL YLZWLJ[P]L SPK PZ

VWLU

(SZVYLMLY[V[OLJOHW[LYr3VHKZ^P[JOÌVMMs

;OL S\NNHNL JVTWHY[TLU[ SPK JHU HSZV IL

VWLULK^P[O[OLYHKPVYLTV[LJVU[YVS

9LMLY[V[OLJOHW[LYr2L`Zs

0TWVY[HU[UV[L
0M [OL ]LOPJSL IH[[LY` PZ KPZJOHYNLK [OL SPKZ JHU

IL VWLULK VUS` I` JVUULJ[PUN HU L_[LYUHS LSLJÌ

[YPJHSWV^LYZV\YJL

7SLHZL VIZLY]L [OL JOHW[LY r,SLJ[YPJHS Z`Z[LTs

VY[OLKLZJYPW[PVUPUZPKL[OLM\ZLIV_JV]LY

"mamV˜daV^›

;OL^HYUPUNSPNO[ZPU[OLPUZ[Y\TLU[WHULSHUKPU

[OL VUÌIVHYK JVTW\[LY JVTL VU PM [OL SPKZ HYL

UV[JVTWSL[LS`JSVZLK

-\SS`JSVZL[OLSPK

ss¬˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

zFmamV˜d¤VV"VF˜4phz"›hFm›˜da=

*H\[PVU

9PZR VM KHTHNL [V S\NNHNL JVTWHY[TLU[

SPKVY^PUKZOPLSK^PWLYZ

4HRL Z\YL [OH[ [OL ^PUKZOPLSK ^PWLYZ HYL UV[

MVSKLK V\[ MVY^HYKZ ^OLU VWLUPUN [OL S\NÌ

NHNLJVTWHY[TLU[SPK

9HPZL SPK ZSPNO[S` HUK \USH[JO [OL ZHML[` JH[JO

^P[O[OLSL]LYHYYV^

dp’amV˜d¤VV"VF˜4phz"›hFm›˜da=˜"m=

FmVamF˜4phz"›hFm›˜da=

3V^LYSPKHUKSL[P[MHSSPU[V[OLSVJR0MULJLZZÌ

HY`W\ZO[OLSPK^P[O[OLWHSTVM`V\YOHUKPU

[OLHYLHVM[OLSVJR

*OLJR [OH[ [OL SPK OHZ JVYYLJ[S` LUNHNLK PU

[OLSVJR

>HYUPUN

9PZR VM SVZZ VM JVU[YVS VY HU HJJPKLU[ YLÍ

Z\S[PUNPUZLYPV\ZWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`

:OV\SK `V\ UV[PJL H[ HU` [PTL ^OPSL KYP]PUN

[OH[ VUL VM [OL SPKZ PZ UV[ ZLJ\YLK WYVWLYS`

WSLHZL Z[VW PTTLKPH[LS` PU H Z\P[HISL WSHJL

HUKJSVZLP[

;OLMYVU[SPKTH`MS`\WPTWHPYPUN]PZPVU

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

sss

background image

¤VV"VF˜4phz"›hFm›

Fhp¦amV˜d¤VV"VF˜4phz"›hFm›˜Odpp

:PT\S[HULV\ZS` W\SS [OL S\NNHNL JVTWHY[TLU[

MSVVYMVY^HYKHUK\WH[[OLMPUNLYOVSL

m’F›amV˜d¤VV"VF˜4phz"›hFm›˜Odpp

0UZLY[ S\NNHNL JVTWHY[TLU[ MSVVY PU [OL YLHY

N\PKLHUKWYLZZP[KV^U

 u =LOPJSLPKLU[PMPJH[PVUU\TILY=05

 u )H[[LY`

 u *VTWHJ[KPZJJOHUNLY

 u 1HJR

 u ;VVSRP[

 u *VTWYLZZVYMVYJVSSHWZPISLZWHYL^OLLS

 u :WHJLMVYMPYZ[HPKRP[

 u -S\PKYLZLY]VPYMVYJSLHUPUN^PUKV^Z

   HUKOLHKSPNO[Z

 u )YHRLÌMS\PKYLZLY]VPY

  u /LHKSPNO[HKQ\Z[TLU[HUKSVJRPUN

    \UKLY[OLJHYWL[

  u 7HPU[KH[H

    \UKLY[OLJHYWL[

 u :WHJLMVY^HYUPUN[YPHUNSL

ss¢˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

3\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[

¤mc˜m›"zhFm›

+LWLUKPUN VU [OL WYVK\J[PVU KH[L `V\Y ]LOPJSL

PZ LX\PWWLK ^P[O HU PU[LYUHS [Y\UR YLSLHZL TLJOÌ

HUPZT

( WLYZVU [YHWWLK PU [OL S\NNHNL JVTWHY[TLU[

JHU YLSLHZL [OL SPK MYVT [OL PUZPKL \ZPUN \UÌ

SVJRPUNOHUKSL(

;OL OHUKSL ( PZ MS\VYLZJLU[ HUK NSV^Z PU [OL

KHYR

"mamV˜daV^›

;OL^HYUPUNSPNO[ZPU[OLPUZ[Y\TLU[WHULSHUKPU

[OL VUÌIVHYK JVTW\[LY SPNO[ \W ^OLU \USVJRPUN

OHUKSL(PZVWLYH[LK

:[VW [OL ]LOPJSL PTTLKPH[LS` ^OLU [OL ^HYUÌ

PUNSPNO[ZSPNO[\W

*OLJR[OLS\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[

*SVZL[OLSPK

-\UJ[PVU^P[O]LOPJSLZ[H[PVUHY`
0M [OL S\NNHNL JVTWHY[TLU[ SPK PZ \USVJRLK ^P[O

\USVJRPUN OHUKSL ( [OL SPK JHU IL VWLULK MYVT

[OLPUZPKLPTTLKPH[LS`

-\UJ[PVU^P[O]LOPJSLPUTV[PVU
0M [OL S\NNHNL JVTWHY[TLU[ SPK PZ \USVJRLK ^P[O

\USVJRPUN OHUKSL ( ^OLU H ZWLLK VM  RTO

 TWO PZ L_JLLKLK [OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z PU [OL

PUZ[Y\TLU[ WHULS HUK PU [OL VUÌIVHYK JVTW\[LY

SPNO[\W

([ [OL ZHTL [PTL [OL SPK PZ \USVJRLK HUK [OL

SH[JO Z[YPRLY WVWZ PU[V [OL JH[JOÌOVVR WVZP[PVU

;OLSPKSVJRPZM\SS`YLSLHZLKHZZVVUHZ[OLJHY

ZSV^Z [V SLZZ [OHU  TWO  RTO HUK [OL

[YHWWLKWLYZVUJHUVWLU[OLSPKPTTLKPH[LS`

+HUNLY

9PZRVMHJJPKLU[

0M[OL^HYUPUNSPNO[ZPU[OLPUZ[Y\TLU[WHULS

HUK PU [OL VUÍIVHYK JVTW\[LY SPNO[ \W

^OLU [OL ]LOPJSL PZ PU TV[PVU [OL SPK TH`

PTWHJ[ PU MYVU[ VM [OL ^PUKZOPLSK HUK JHU

[LHYVMM

@V\JHUSVZLJVU[YVSVM[OL]LOPJSL

:[VW [OL ]LOPJSL PTTLKPH[LS` ^OLU [OL ^HYUÌ

PUNSPNO[ZSPNO[\W

*OLJR[OLS\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[

*SVZL[OLSPK

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

ss

background image

5V[L
;OL SPK JHUUV[ IL VWLULK MYVT [OL PUZPKL PM [OL

IH[[LY`PZKPZJVUULJ[LKVYLTW[`

:HML[` YLHZVUZ [OLYLMVYL YLX\PYL [OH[ `V\

\UZJYL^ [OL SH[JO Z[YPRLY VM [OL SPK SVJR PM

`V\WSHU[VW\[[OL]LOPJSLV\[VMVWLYH[PVU

MVYHUL_[LUKLKWLYPVK

7SLHZLJVUZ\S[`V\YH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

;OL` ^PSS HK]PZL `V\ HIV\[ [OL ULJLZZHY` TLHZÌ

\YLZ

5V[L

>OLU SVHKPUN [OL S\NNHNL JVTWHY[TLU[

THRLZ\YL[OH[P[LTZVMS\NNHNLVYV[OLYVIÌ

QLJ[ZJHUUV[ILJVTLJH\NO[VUOHUKSL(

;OPZJV\SKJH\ZL[OLS\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[[V

VWLU\UPU[LU[PVUHSS`

p’4^F˜phh¤ma4"›apm

"m"VFhFm›˜|}

9LMLY [V [OL ZLWHYH[L VWLYH[PUN PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ

ILMVYLW\[[PUN[OL7*4PU[VVWLYH[PVU

>OLU W\[ PU[V VWLYH[PVU MVY [OL MPYZ[ [PTL H

KPZ[HUJL VM HWWYV_  TPSLZ  RT T\Z[ IL

KYP]LU PU VYKLY MVY [OL UH]PNH[PVU Z`Z[LT [V

JVTWSL[L[OLWYVJLZZVMMPULJHSPIYH[PVU

;OL ZHTL HWWSPLZ ^OLU [OL [PYLZ HYL JOHUNLK

LNZ\TTLYZUV^[PYLZVYUL^[PYLZMP[[LK

-\SSSVJH[PVUHJJ\YHJ`PZUV[`L[HJOPL]LKK\YPUN

[OLMPULÌJHSPIYH[PVUWYVJLZZ

0M [OL ]LOPJSL OHZ ILLU [YHUZWVY[LK LN MLYY`

JHY [YHPU [OL Z`Z[LT TH` [HRL H ML^ TPU\[LZ

HM[LYILPUNZ^P[JOLKVUILMVYLP[KL[LYTPULZ[OL

J\YYLU[SVJH[PVU

:LYPV\Z [PYL ZSPW LN ZWPUUPUN ^OLLSZ VU ZUV^

TH`YLZ\S[PU[LTWVYHYPS`PUHJJ\YH[LUH]PNH[PVU

>OLU[OLIH[[LY`OHZILLUKPZJVUULJ[LKP[TH`

[HRL \W [V  TPU\[LZ ILMVYL [OL UH]PNH[PVU

Z`Z[LTILJVTLZVWLYH[PVUHSHNHPU

ssT˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

¤z^pd=F

|^pd=F˜Op˜=amc’˜4"m’˜"m=˜4¤z’}

2LLW[OLJ\WOVSKLYJSVZLK^OPSLKYP]PUN

>HYUPUN

9PZR VM ZJHSKPUN VY KHTHNL K\L [V ZWPSSPUN

KYPURZ

6US`\ZLJVU[HPULYZ^OPJOMP[

5L]LYW\[V]LYM\SSJVU[HPULYZPU[OLJ\WOVSKLY

5L]LY\ZLOV[KYPURZ

¨›Fm=amV˜4¤z^pd=F

7YLZZ[OLJ\WOVSKLYZ`TIVS

;OL J\WOVSKLY JHU IL W\SSLK V\[ [V HJJVTTVÌ

KH[LHZLJVUKJVU[HPULY

¤ddamV˜4¤z^pd=F˜p¤›

.YHZWJ\WOVSKLYH[[OLOHUKSLYLJLZZHUKW\SS

P[V\[

dp’amV˜4¤z^pd=F

7\ZOJ\WOVSKLYKYH^LYPU

*SVZLHUKLUNHNL[OLJ\WOVSKLY

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

ssQ

background image

"˜FdFz^pmF˜"m=

O›Fh"cF›˜d"h’˜

0TWVY[HU[SLNHSHUKZHML[`PUMVYTH[PVU

YLNHYKPUN[OL\ZLVMJLSS\SHY[LSLWOVULZ
:VTL Z[H[LZ TH` WYVOPIP[ [OL \ZL VM JLSS\SHY

[LSLWOVULZ ^OPSL KYP]PUN H ]LOPJSL *OLJR [OL

SH^Z HUK YLN\SH[PVUZ VU [OL \ZL VM JLSS\SHY [LSLÌ

WOVULZPU[OLHYLHZ^OLYL`V\KYP]L

+HUNLY

9PZRVMHUHJJPKLU[

:L]LYL WLYZVUHS PUQ\Y` VY KLH[O JHU YLZ\S[

PU[OLL]LU[VMHUHJJPKLU[

3VVRPUN H^H` MYVT [OL YVHK VY [\YUPUN

`V\Y H[[LU[PVU H^H` MYVT `V\Y KYP]PUN JHU

JH\ZL HU HJJPKLU[ HUK ZLYPV\Z VY MH[HS PUÍ

Q\Y`

>OLU \ZPUN `V\Y JLSS\SHY [LSLWOVUL `V\ ZOV\SK

HS^H`Z!

.P]LM\SSH[[LU[PVU[V`V\YKYP]PUNÌW\SSVMM[OL

YVHK HUK WHYR ILMVYL THRPUN VY HUZ^LYPUN H

JHSSPM[YHMMPJJVUKP[PVUZZVYLX\PYL"HUK

2LLW IV[O OHUKZ VU [OL Z[LLYPUN ^OLLS Ì \ZL

OHUKZÌMYLLVWLYH[PVUPMH]HPSHISLÌW\SSVMM[OL

YVHK HUK WHYR ILMVYL \ZPUN H OHUKÌOLSK [LSLÌ

WOVUL

0[PZLZZLU[PHS[VVIZLY]L[OLPUZ[Y\J[PVUZVM

[OL [LSLWOVUL THU\MHJ[\YLY ILMVYL W\[[PUN

[OL[LSLWOVULPU[VVWLYH[PVU

(U` WVY[HISL [LSLWOVUL VY YHKPV [YHUZTP[[LY

^OPJO PZ \ZLK PU H 7VYZJOL T\Z[ IL WYVWLYS`

PUZ[HSSLK PU HJJVYKHUJL ^P[O [OL [LJOUPJHS YLÌ

X\PYLTLU[ZVM7VYZJOL

;OL [YHUZTPZZPVU WV^LY T\Z[ UV[ L_JLLK

>

;OL KL]PJLZ T\Z[ WVZZLZZ H [`WL HWWYV]HS MVY

`V\Y]LOPJSLHUKOH]LHUrLsZ`TIVS

0M `V\ ZOV\SK YLX\PYL LX\PWTLU[ ^P[O [YHUZÌ

TPZZPVUWV^LY]HS\LZNYLH[LY[OHU>WSLHZL

JVUZ\S[ `V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY MVY [OPZ

W\YWVZL/LPZMHTPSPHY^P[O[OL[LJOUPJHSYLX\PYLÌ

TLU[ZMVYPUZ[HSSPUNKL]PJLZVM[OPZRPUK

;OL HU[LUUHZ MVY HSS YHKPVZ HUK [LSLWOVULZ ^P[O

H [YHUZTP[[PUN HU[LUUH T\Z[ IL L_[LYUHSS`

TV\U[LK

;OLPTWYVWLYPUZ[HSSH[PVUVMYHKPVZVY[LSLWOVULZ

VY \ZL VM H YHKPV VY [LSLWOVUL ^P[O H [YHUZTP[Ì

[PUN HU[LUUH PUZPKL [OL JHY TH` JH\ZL [OL

^HYUPUNSPNO[Z[VJVTLVU

0TWYVWLYPUZ[HSSH[PVUVMZ\JOLX\PWTLU[JHUJYLÌ

H[L H KPZJOHYNLK IH[[LY` VY L_JLZZP]L J\YYLU[

KYH^MYVTHKKLKLX\PWTLU[

0M HM[LYTHYRL[ Z`Z[LTZ HYL PUZ[HSSLK I` UVUÌ

KLHSLYZOPW [LJOUPJPHUZ VY V\[ZPKL [OL ZLSSPUN

KLHSLYWYVISLTZTH`YLZ\S[0UZ[HSSH[PVUVMHM[LYÌ

THYRL[LX\PWTLU[PZUV[JV]LYLK\UKLY[OL5L^

*HY>HYYHU[`

*VUZ\S[`V\YH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLYHIV\[

[OL PUZ[HSSH[PVU VM UVU 7VYZJOL HWWYV]LK

LX\PWTLU[

9LJLW[PVUX\HSP[`
;OL YLJLW[PVU X\HSP[` VM `V\Y JHY [LSLWOVUL ^PSS

JOHUNL JVUZ[HU[S` ^OLU `V\ HYL KYP]PUN 0U[LYÌ

MLYLUJL JH\ZLK I` I\PSKPUNZ SHUKZJHWL HUK

^LH[OLY PZ \UH]VPKHISL 0[ TH` ILJVTL WHY[PJ\Ì

SHYS` KPMMPJ\S[ [V OLHY ^OLU \ZPUN [OL OHUKZÌMYLL

M\UJ[PVU K\L [V L_[LYUHS UVPZL Z\JO HZ LUNPUL

HUK^PUKUVPZL

ss–˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

"˜¤=ap˜zF"›apm—az’

-VY YHKPV VWLYH[PVU ZLL `V\Y YHKPV THU\HS

^OPJO PZ PUJS\KLK ^P[O `V\Y VUÍIVHYK

SP[LYH[\YL

(SZVZLL[OLJOHW[LYVUs3VHKZ^P[JOÌVMMr

˜F4Fz›apm

( ]LOPJSL PZ UV[ HU PKLHS WSHJL [V SPZ[LU [V H

YHKPV

)LJH\ZL[OL]LOPJSLTV]LZYLJLW[PVUJVUKP[PVUZ

HYLJVUZ[HU[S`JOHUNPUN

)\PSKPUNZ[LYYHPUZPNUHSKPZ[HUJLHUKUVPZLMYVT

V[OLY ]LOPJSLZ HYL HSS ^VYRPUN HNHPUZ[ NVVK YLÌ

JLW[PVU

:VTL JVUKP[PVUZ VM -4 TH` HWWLHY [V IL WYVIÌ

SLTZ^OLU[OL`HYLUV[

;OLMVSSV^PUNJOHYHJ[LYPZ[PJZHYLJVTWSL[LS`UVYÌ

THSMVYHNP]LUYLJLW[PVUHYLHHUK[OL`KVUV[

PUKPJH[LHU`WYVISLT^P[O[OLYHKPVP[ZLSM

5V[L
,SLJ[YVUPJ HJJLZZVYPLZ ZOV\SK VUS` IL PUZ[HSSLK

I``V\YH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

,X\PWTLU[ ^OPJO OHZ UV[ ILLU [LZ[LK HUK HWÌ

WYV]LKI`7VYZJOLTH`PTWHPYYHKPVYLJLW[PVU

-HKPUNHUKKYPM[PUN
-4 YHUNL PZ SPTP[LK [V HIV\[  TPSLZ  RT

L_JLW[MVYZVTLOPNOWV^LYZ[H[PVUZ

0MH]LOPJSLPZTV]PUNH^H`MYVT[OLKLZPYLKZ[HÌ

[PVUqZ [YHUZTP[[LY [OL ZPNUHS ^PSS [LUK [V MHKL

HUKVY KYPM[ ;OPZ JVUKP[PVU PZ TVYL WYL]HSLU[

^P[O -4 [OHU (4 HUK PZ VM[LU HJJVTWHUPLK I`

KPZ[VY[PVU

-HKPUNHUKKYPM[PUNJHUILTPUPTPaLK[VHJLY[HPU

KLNYLL I` JHYLM\S H[[LU[PVU [V MPUL [\UPUN VY ZLÌ

SLJ[PVUVMHZ[YVUNLYZPNUHS

:[H[PJHUKMS\[[LYPUN
>OLU [OL SPULÌVMÌZPNO[ SPUR IL[^LLU H [YHUZTP[[LY

HUK ]LOPJSL PZ ISVJRLK I` SHYNL I\PSKPUNZ VY

TV\U[HPUZ [OL YHKPV ZV\UK TH` IL HJJVTWHÌ

UPLK^P[OZ[H[PJVYMS\[[LYPUNILJH\ZLVM[OLJOHYÌ

HJ[LYPZ[PJVM-4

0U H ZPTPSHY LMMLJ[ H MS\[[LYPUN UVPZL PZ ZVTLÌ

[PTLZOLHYK^OLUKYP]PUNHSVUNH[YLLÌSPULKYVHK

;OPZ Z[H[PJ HUK MS\[[LYPUN JHU IL YLK\JLK I` HKÌ

Q\Z[PUN [OL [VUL JVU[YVS MVY NYLH[LY IHZZ YLÌ

ZWVUZL\U[PS[OLKPZ[\YIHUJLOHZWHZZLK

4\S[PWH[O
)LJH\ZL VM [OL YLMSLJ[PUN JOHYHJ[LYPZ[PJZ VM -4

KPYLJ[ HUK YLMSLJ[LK ZPNUHSZ TH` YLHJO [OL HUÌ

[LUUH H[ [OL ZHTL [PTL T\S[PWH[O HUK JHUJLS

LHJOV[OLYV\[

(Z H ]LOPJSL TV]LZ [OYV\NO [OLZL LSLJ[YVUPJ

KLHK ZWV[Z [OL SPZ[LULY TH` OLHY H TVTLU[HY`

MS\[[LYVYSVZZVMYLJLW[PVU

:[H[PVUZ^HWWPUN
>OLU [^V -4 Z[H[PVUZ HYL JSVZL [V LHJO V[OLY

HUK HU LSLJ[YVUPJ KLHK ZWV[ Z\JO HZ Z[H[PJ VY

T\S[PWH[O HYLH PU[LYY\W[Z [OL VYPNPUHS ZPNUHS

ZVTL[PTLZ [OL Z[YVUNLY ZLJVUK ZPNUHS ^PSS IL

ZLSLJ[LK H\[VTH[PJHSS` \U[PS [OL VYPNPUHS VUL YLÌ

[\YUZ

;OPZZ^HWWPUNJHUHSZVVJJ\YHZ`V\KYP]LH^H`

MYVT [OL ZLSLJ[LK Z[H[PVU HUK HWWYVHJO HUV[OLY

Z[H[PVUVMHZ[YVUNLYZPNUHS

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

ss•

background image

"’’F››F˜›"zF˜zd"©F

*H\[PVU

;V H]VPK KHTHNL [V JHZZL[[L [HWL WSH`LY

HUK[HWLZ

<ZL VUS` JHZZL[[L [HWLZ VM NVVK X\HSP[` OH]Ì

PUNUVKHTHNL

(]VPK \ZPUN [HWLZ ^P[O H [V[HS WSH`PUN [PTL

SVUNLY[OHU TPU\[LZ

3VUNLY [HWLZ HYL UV[ YLJVTTLUKLK ILJH\ZL

VM[OL[OPUULYJYVZZZLJ[PVUVM[OL[HWL

)LZ\YL[OH[[OL[HWLPZUV[ZSHJRHUK[OH[[OL

SHILS PZ MPYTS` ZLJ\YLK VU [OL ZOLSS ILMVYL PUÌ

ZLY[PUN[OLJHZZL[[LPU[V[OLWSH`LY

/H]L [OL [HWL MPYTS` ^V\UK HYV\UK [OL [HWL

I` [\YUPUN [OL O\I ^P[O H WLUJPS VY ZPTPSHY

P[LTZ )L JHYLM\S UV[ [V [V\JO [OL L_WVZLK

[HWLZ\YMHJL

>OLUUV[PU\ZL[HRL[OLJHZZL[[LV\[VM[OL

WSH`LY W\[ P[ IHJR PU[V P[Z JHZL HUK Z[VYL P[

H^H`MYVTK\Z[THNUL[ZHUKKPYLJ[Z\USPNO[

3LH]PUN [OL JHZZL[[L [HWL VU [OL KHZOIVHYK

PU[OLZ\UJHUKHTHNL[OL[HWL

2LLW [OL WSH`IHJR OLHK JHWZ[HU HUK WPUJO

YVSSLYJSLHU

9LTV]L[HWLJVH[PUNYLZPK\LHJJ\T\SH[LKVU

[OL OLHK JHWZ[HU HUK WPUJO YVSSLY VUJL VY

[^PJLHTVU[O

(JSLHUPUN[HWL^OPJOJHUKV[OPZZOV\SKIL

H]HPSHISLPUH\KPVZ[VYLZ

+VUV[VPSHU`WHY[VM[OL[HWLWSH`LYHUKKV

UV[ PUZLY[ HU` VIQLJ[ V[OLY [OHU H JHZZL[[L

[HWLPU[V[OLZSV[

phz"4›˜=a’4˜zd"©F

*H\[PVU

;V H]VPK KHTHNL [V JVTWHJ[ KPZJ WSH`LY

HUKKPZJZ

<ZL VUS` JVTWHJ[ KPZJZ SHILSLK HZ ZOV^U

OH]PUNUVKPY[KHTHNLVY^HYWHNL

5L]LY H[[LTW[ [V KPZHZZLTISL VY VPS HU` WHY[

VM[OLWSH`LY\UP[

+VUV[PUZLY[HU`VIQLJ[V[OLY[OHUHKPZJPU[V

[OLZSV[

9LTLTILY [OLYL HYL UV \ZLYÌZLY]PJLHISL

WHY[ZPUZPKL[OLJVTWHJ[KPZJWSH`LY

+V UV[ HSSV^ [OL KPZJ [V Z\Z[HPU HU` MPUNLYÌ

WYPU[Z ZJYHWLZ VY Z[PJRLYZ VU [OL Z\YMHJLZ

;OPZTH`JH\ZLWVVYZV\UKX\HSP[`

/VSK[OLKPZJVUS`VU[OLLKNLVYJLU[LYOVSL

>OLU UV[ PU \ZL [HRL [OL KPZJ V\[ VM [OL

WSH`LY W\[ [OL KPZJ IHJR PU[V P[Z JHZL HUK

Z[VYL P[ H^H` MYVT K\Z[ OLH[ KHTW HUK KPÌ

YLJ[Z\USPNO[

3LH]PUN[OLKPZJVU[OLKHZOIVHYKPU[OLZ\U

JHUKHTHNL[OLKPZJ

0M[OLKPZJNL[ZKPY[`JSLHU[OLKPZJI`^PWPUN

[OLZ\YMHJLZMYVT[OLJLU[LY[V[OLV\[ZPKLPU

HYHKPHSKPYLJ[PVU^P[OHZVM[JSV[O

+V UV[ \ZL H JVU]LU[PVUHS YLJVYK JSLHULY VY

HU[PÌZ[H[PJYLJVYKWYLZLY]H[P]L

+PZJJSLHULYZHYLH]HPSHISLPUH\KPVZ[VYLZ

ssG˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

ppO˜"m’zp›˜©’›Fh

-VSSV^ [OL ZLWHYH[L PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ MVY MP[[PUN

[OL9VVM;YHUZWVY[:`Z[LT

-P[[PUN JVTTLYJPHSS` H]HPSHISL S\NNHNL YHJRZ PZ

UV[WVZZPISL

;OL 7VYZJOL 9VVM ;YHUZWVY[ :`Z[LT HSSV^Z

[OL[YHUZWVY[VM]HYPV\ZZWVY[ZHUKOVII`LX\PWÌ

TLU[

@V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY ^PSS IL WSLHZLK

[V PUMVYT `V\ HIV\[ [OL THU` \ZLZ VM [OL 9VVM

;YHUZWVY[:`Z[LT

>HYUPUN

9PZR VM HU HJJPKLU[ SVZZ VM JVU[YVS HUK

KHTHNL[V[OL]LOPJSL

*VTWSL[LS` YLTV]L [OL 9VVM ;YHUZWVY[ :`ZÌ

[LTILMVYL\ZPUNHUH\[VTH[PJJHY^HZO

-P[[OLZPKLZ\WWVY[LSLTLU[ZVM[OLIHZPJJHYÌ

YPLY VUS` PU JVUQ\UJ[PVU ^P[O [OL [YHUZ]LYZL

Z\WWVY[PUNWPWLZ

;OL WLYTPZZPISL \ZLHISL SVHK VM  SIZ 

RN [OL WLYTPZZPISL [V[HS ]LOPJSL ^LPNO[ HUK

[OL WLYTPZZPISL H_SL SVHKZ T\Z[ UV[ IL L_Ì

JLLKLK

:LL[OLJOHW[LYVUs>LPNO[Zr

0[LTZ VM S\NNHNL T\Z[ UV[ WYVQLJ[ Z\IZ[HUÌ

[PHSS`IL`VUK[OLZPKLVM[OLSVHKHYLH

+PZ[YPI\[L SVHK L]LUS` ^P[O OLH]` P[LTZ HZ

SV^HZWVZZPISL

,]LY` P[LT T\Z[ IL MP_LK HUK ZLJ\YLK [V [OL

IHZPJ JHYYPLY ^P[O H YVWL VY SHZOPUN Z[YHW KV

UV[\ZLLSHZ[PJY\IILY[LUZPVULYZ

)LMVYL L]LY` QV\YUL` HUK H[ YLN\SHY PU[LY]HSZ

K\YPUN SVUN [YPWZ JOLJR [OH[ 9VVM ;YHUZWVY[

:`Z[LTHUKSVHKHYLZLJ\YL

9L[PNO[LUPMULJLZZHY`HUKZLJ\YLHKKP[PVUHSS`

I`SVJRPUN

0U[OLSVHKLKZ[H[LHKQ\Z[TH_PT\TZWLLK[V

[OL UH[\YL ZPaL HUK ^LPNO[ VM [OL SVHK ILPUN

JHYYPLK

0U UV JHZL OV^L]LY ZOV\SK `V\ KYP]L H[

TVYL[OHU TWORTO

>P[O [OL IHZPJ JHYYPLY PUZ[HSSLK HUK UV SVHK

KVUV[L_JLLKHTH_PT\TZWLLKVMTWO

 RTO ZPUJL KYP]PUN Z[HIPSP[` ^PSS IL HKÌ

]LYZLS`HMMLJ[LK

(KHW[ `V\Y KYP]PUN Z[`SL HUK ZWLLK [V [OL

JOHUNLKJVUKP[PVUZ

5L]LY[OLSLZZ 7VYZJOL YLJVTTLUKZ [OH[ `V\

KVUV[L_JLLK[OLWVZ[LKZWLLKSPTP[

+YP]PUN IYHRPUN HUK Z[LLYPUN ILOH]PVY VM [OL

]LOPJSL JOHUNL K\L [V [OL OPNOLY JLU[LY VM

NYH]P[`HUK[OLNYLH[LY^PUKÌYLZPZ[HU[HYLH

@V\ ZOV\SK HKHW[ `V\Y KYP]PUN Z[`SL HWWYVWYPÌ

H[LS`

5V[L
:PUJL M\LS JVUZ\TW[PVU HUK UVPZL HYLPUJYLHZLK

^P[O [OL 9VVM ;YHUZWVY[ :`Z[LT PUZ[HSSLK P[

ZOV\SKUV[YLTHPUVU[OLJHYPMP[PZUV[PU\ZL

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

ssn

background image

aO›amV—da=amV˜ppO

>HYUPUN

9PZR VM PUQ\Y` ^OLU VWLYH[PUN VY H\[VÍ

TH[PJHSS`JSVZPUN[OLSPM[PUNZSPKPUNYVVM

;HRL JHYL [V LUZ\YL [OH[ UVIVK` JHU IL PUÌ

Q\YLK^OLU[OLSPM[PUNZSPKPUNYVVMPZVWLYH[LK

;OPZHWWSPLZLZWLJPHSS`PM[OLYVVMJSVZLZH\[VÌ

TH[PJHSS`

(S^H`Z YLTV]L [OL PNUP[PVU RL` ^OLU SLH]PUN

[OL]LOPJSL

<UPUMVYTLK WLYZVUZ LN JOPSKYLU JV\SK PUÌ

Q\YL[OLTZLS]LZI`VWLYH[PUN[OLSPM[PUNZSPKPUN

YVVM

0U JHZL VM KHUNLY YLSLHZL [OL I\[[VU VY JHY

RL`PTTLKPH[LS`HUKVWLYH[L[OLSPM[PUNZSPKPUN

YVVMPU[OLVWWVZP[LKPYLJ[PVU

F"=amF’’˜Op˜pzF"›apm


>OLUPNUP[PVUPZVULUNPULVUVYVMMVY



^OLU KVVY PZ JSVZLK HUK PNUP[PVU RL` PZ

YLTV]LK I\[ VUS` \U[PS [OL KVVY PZ MPYZ[ VWÌ

LULK

˜_˜zFmamV˜›^F˜daO›amV—’da=amV˜ppO

7YLZZ IHJR VM YVJRLY Z^P[JO \U[PS SPM[PUNZSPKÌ

PUNYVVMYLHJOLZ[OLKLZPYLKWVZP[PVU

6ULÍ[V\JOVWLYH[PVU

;V\JO IHJR VM YVJRLY Z^P[JO Ì SPM[PUNZSPKPUN

YVVMVWLUZM\SS`[VP[ZLUKWVZP[PVU

:[VWP[PUHU`WVZP[PVUI`[V\JOPUNHU`I\[[VU

5V[L
;OL SPM[PUNZSPKPUNYVVMVWLUZ\U[PSP[YLHJOLZ[OL

ILZ[ WVZP[PVU PU [LYTZ VM ^PUK UVPZL 0[ JHU IL

VWLULK M\SS` OV^L]LY PM `V\ WYLZZ [OL YVJRLY

Z^P[JOHNHPU

s¢¬˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

˜_˜dp’amV˜›^F˜daO›amV—’da=amV˜ppO

7YLZZ MYVU[ VM YVJRLY Z^P[JO \U[PS SPM[PUNZSPKÌ

PUNYVVMYLHJOLZ[OLKLZPYLKWVZP[PVU

6ULÍ[V\JOVWLYH[PVU

;V\JO MYVU[ VM YVJRLY Z^P[JO Ì SPM[PUNZSPKPUN

YVVMJSVZLZM\SS`[VP[ZLUKWVZP[PVU

:[VWP[PUHU`WVZP[PVUI`[V\JOPUNHU`I\[[VU

*SVZPUN[OLSPM[PUNZSPKPUNYVVMH\[VTH[Í

PJHSS`^OLU[OL]LOPJSLPZSVJRLK

/VSK [OL JHY RL` PU [OL KVVY SVJR PU SVJRPUN

WVZP[PVU \U[PS [OL SPM[PUNZSPKPUN YVVM YLHJOLZ

[OLKLZPYLKWVZP[PVU

˜_˜aO›amV˜›^F˜daO›amV—’da=amV˜ppO

7YLZZ JLU[LY VM YVJRLY Z^P[JO \U[PS SPM[Ì

PUNZSPKPUNYVVMYLHJOLZ[OLKLZPYLKWVZP[PVU

6ULÍ[V\JOVWLYH[PVU

;V\JO JLU[LY VM YVJRLY Z^P[JO Ì SPM[PUNZSPKPUN

YVVMVWLUZM\SS`[VP[ZLUKWVZP[PVU

:[VWP[PUHU`WVZP[PVUI`[V\JOPUNHU`I\[[VU

˜_˜p§FamV˜›^F˜daO›amV—’da=amV˜ppO

7YLZZ MYVU[ VM YVJRLY Z^P[JO \U[PS SPM[PUNZSPKÌ

PUNYVVMYLHJOLZ[OLKLZPYLKWVZP[PVU

^F˜’›"m=*©˜O¤m4›apm˜pO˜›^F˜ppO˜=a¦F

’§a›4^F’˜pOO˜"O›F˜›§p˜^p¤’

0M [OL ]LOPJSL PZ \USVJRLK [OL SPM[PUNZSPKPUN YVVM

JHU UV SVUNLY IL VWLYH[LK HM[LY [^V OV\YZ

WYL]LU[PVUVMIH[[LY`KPZJOHYNPUN

;OLWV^LYZ\WWS`PZZ^P[JOLKIHJRVU^OLU[OL

PNUP[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVUVY[OLLUNPULZ[HY[LK

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

s¢s

background image

hFVFm4©˜pzF"›apm

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMZLYPV\ZWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`HUKKHTHNL

[V [OLSPM[PUNZSPKPUNYVVMK\YPUNLTLYNLUJ`

VWLYH[PVU

+\YPUNHUKHM[LYLTLYNLUJ`VWLYH[PVU[OLSPM[Ì

PUNZSPKPUN YVVM TH` UV SVUNLY IL VWLYH[LK

^P[O[OLYVJRLYZ^P[JO

)LMVYL \ZPUN LTLYNLUJ` VWLYH[PVU WSLHZL

JOLJR ^OL[OLY KLMLJ[P]L M\ZLZ HYL [OL JH\ZL VM

[OLTHSM\UJ[PVU

:LLJOHW[LYVUr,SLJ[YPJHSZ`Z[LTs

*SVZPUN[OLSPM[PUNZSPKPUNYVVM
 <ZPUN `V\Y MPUNLY UHPSVYHZJYL^KYP]LYJHYLÌ

M\SS` \UJSPW [OL [^V JV]LYZ ( VM [OL PUMYHYLK

WHZZLUNLYJVTWHY[TLU[TVUP[VYPUNZ`Z[LT

 <UZJYL^[OL[^VZJYL^Z)

 -VSKKV^U[OLJV]LYVM[OLSPM[PUNZSPKPUNYVVM

KYP]L

9LTV]L[OL(SSLURL`HYYV^MYVTP[ZOVSKLY

 0UZLY[[OL(SSLURL`PU[OLKYP]LH_SL

s¢¢˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

 7YLZZ [OL (SSLU RL` PU[V [OL KYP]L H_SL RLLW

P[ WYLZZLK HUK [\YU P[ JSVJR^PZL \U[PS [OL SPM[Ì

PUNZSPKPUNYVVMPZJSVZLK

 >P[OKYH^[OL(SSLURL`

*SVZL[OLJV]LYHUKMHZ[LU[OLZJYL^Z

 7SLHZL OH]L [OL MH\S[ YLTLKPLK H[ HU H\[OÌ

VYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

s¢

background image

s¢T˜˜

*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z

background image

^aO›amV˜ F"

.LHYZOPM[PUN  

;PW[YVUPJ: u

:OPM[PUN.LHY

s¢Q

background image

F"’^aO›amV

;OL WVZP[PVUZ VM [OL NLHYZ HYL ZOV^U VU [OL

NLHYZOPM[SL]LY

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMHUHJJPKLU[

(S^H`Z JOLJR [OL TV]LTLU[ VM [OL JS\[JO

WLKHS ILMVYL KYP]PUN HUK THRL Z\YL [OH[ P[ PZ

UV[ VIZ[Y\J[LK I` H MSVVY TH[ VY HU` V[OLY

VIQLJ[

:LJ\YL[OLMSVVYTH[[VWYL]LU[P[MYVTZSPKPUN

PU[V WVZP[PVUZ [OH[ JV\SK PU[LYMLYL ^P[O [OL

ZHMLVWLYH[PVUVM`V\Y]LOPJSL

@V\Y7VYZJOLKLHSLYJHUVMMLY`V\MSVVYTH[Z

VM[OLJVYYLJ[ZPaLPUJS\KPUNHZLJ\YPUNWVZZPÌ

IPSP[`

;V H]VPK KHTHNL [V [OL JS\[JO HUK [YHUZÍ

TPZZPVU!

(S^H`Z KLWYLZZ [OL JS\[JO WLKHS M\SS` ^OLU

JOHUNPUNNLHYZ

4HRL Z\YL [OH[ [OL NLHYZOPM[ SL]LY PZ JVTÌ

WSL[LS`LUNHNLK

6US`ZOPM[PU[VYL]LYZL^OLU[OLJHYOHZJVTL

[VHJVTWSL[LZ[VW

F¦F’F

+LWYLZZ [OLJS\[JOWLKHSMVYZL]LYHSZLJVUKZ

ILMVYLZOPM[PUNPU[VYL]LYZL

6US`[OLUTV]L[OLNLHYZOPM[SL]LY[V[OLSLM[

V]LYJVTPUN [OL ZWYPUN [LUZPVU HUK [OLU [V

[OLMYVU[

)V[O IHJRÌ\W SPNO[Z JVTL VU ^OLU [OL [YHUZÌ

TPZZPVUPZW\[PU[VYL]LYZL^P[OPNUP[PVUVU

Fha››F=˜FmVamF˜’zFF=

*OHUNL PU[V H OPNOLY NLHY ILMVYL [OL ULLKSL

YLHJOLZ [OL YLK THYR VU [OL [HJOVTL[LY VY

LHZLVMM[OLHJJLSLYH[VY

0M [OL YLK aVUL PZ YLHJOLK K\YPUN HJJLSLYH[PVU

M\LSMLLKPZPU[LYY\W[LK

*H\[PVU

;VH]VPKZL]LYLLUNPULKHTHNL

(S^H`Z VIZLY]L [OL LUNPUL YWT ILMVYL KV^UÌ

ZOPM[PUN [V H SV^LY NLHY ZV `V\ KV UV[ L_Ì

JLLK[OLTH_PT\TLUNPULYWT

s¢–˜˜

:OPM[PUN.LHY

background image

az›pma4˜

;OL 7VYZJOL ;PW[YVUPJ PZ H MP]LÌZWLLK [YHUZÌ

TPZZPVU ^P[O HU r(\[VTH[PJs HUK r4HU\HSs ZLSLJÌ

[PVUTVKL

0U H\[VTH[PJ ZLSLJ[PVU TVKL ZLSLJ[VY SL]LY

WVZP[PVU+NLHYÌJOHUNPUNPZH\[VTH[PJ

@V\ JHU JOHUNL [LTWVYHYPS` MYVT H\[VTH[PJ [V

THU\HS TVKL \ZPUN [OL [VNNSL Z^P[JOLZ VU [OL

Z[LLYPUN^OLLS

0U THU\HS ZLSLJ[PVU TVKL ZLSLJ[VY SL]LY

WVZP[PVU4 `V\  JOHUNL NLHY \ ZPUN [OL [VNNSL

Z^P[JOLZVU[OLZ[LLYPUN^OLLS

@V\ JHU JOHUNL IL[^LLU ZLSLJ[VYSL]LYWVZP[PVU

+HUK4HZ`V\^PZO^OPSLKYP]PUN

5V[L
;HRLJHYLUV[[VVWLYH[L[OL[VNNSLZ^P[JOLZVU

[OL Z[LLYPUN ^OLLS PUHK]LY[LU[S` PU LP[OLY H\[VÌ

TH[PJ VY THU\HS TVKL [OLYLI` [YPNNLYPUN \UÌ

KLZPYLKNLHYJOHUNLZ

p4camV˜*¤››pm

;V WYL]LU[ \UPU[LUKLK NLHY ZOPM[Z [OL SVJRPUN

I\[[VU PU [OL ZLSLJ[VY SL]LY HYYV^ T\Z[ IL

WYLZZLK[VJOHUNL[VWVZP[PVU9VY7

F©dp4c˜zp’a›apm

;OPZ WVZP[PVU HSSV^Z [OL PNUP[PVU RL` [V IL

YLTV]LK VUS` HM[LY [OL NLHYZOPM[ ZLSLJ[VY SL]LY

I\[[VU PZ KLWYLZZLK HUK TV]LK [V WVZP[PVU s7r

;OPZLUZ\YLZ[OH[[OLKYP]LYLUNHNLZ[OLWHYRPUN

SVJR ILMVYL SLH]PUN [OL ]LOPJSL HUK [\YUZ [OL

PNUP[PVURL`[VWVZP[PVUs6r[OLU[OLPNUP[PVURL`

JHUILYLTV]LKMYVT[OLPNUP[PVUZ^P[JO

^aO›dp4c˜|’FdF4›p˜dF¦F˜dp4c}

;OL ZOPM[SVJR Z`Z[LT PZ HUV[OLY MLH[\YL [V WYLÌ

]LU[PUHK]LY[LU[TV]LTLU[VM[OL]LOPJSL

0NUP[PVUZ^P[JOWVZP[PVU
;OLZLSLJ[VYSL]LYSVJRPUNI\[[VUPZSVJRLK

0NUP[PVUZ^P[JOWVZP[PVU
>P[O [OL ]LOPJSL Z[H[PVUHY` [OL ZLSLJ[VY SL]LY

JHUUV[ IL TV]LK MYVT [OL 7 VY 5 WVZP[PVUZ

\USLZZ[OLIYHRLWLKHSPZKLWYLZZLK

›"›amV˜›^F˜FmVamF

;OLLUNPULJHUILZ[HY[LKVUS`PUZLSLJ[VYSL]LY

WVZP[PVU7VY5

a¦amV˜pOO

:LSLJ[ [OL KLZPYLK KYP]L WVZP[PVU + 4 VY 9

MVY KYP]PUN VMM VUS` ^OLU [OL LUNPUL PZ PKSPUN

HUK^OPSLKLWYLZZPUN[OLIYHRLWLKHS

:PUJL [OL JHY JYLLWZ ^OLU PU NLHY KV UV[

YLSLHZL[OLIYHRL\U[PS`V\^HU[[VKYP]LVMM

(M[LYZLSLJ[PUNHNLHYKVUV[HJJLSLYH[L\U[PS

`V\JHUMLLS[OH[[OLNLHYOHZILLUZLSLJ[LK

:OPM[PUN.LHY

s¢•

background image

m=a4"›p˜Op˜’FdF4›p˜dF¦F˜zp’a›apm˜"m=

FmV"VF=˜VF"

>OLU [OL LUNPUL PZ Y\UUPUN [OL ZLSLJ[VY SL]LY

WVZP[PVUHUKLUNHNLKNLHYHYLPUKPJH[LK

0M[OLZLSLJ[VYSL]LYPZIL[^LLU[^V

WVZP[PVUZ!



;OL ZLSLJ[VY SL]LY WVZP[PVU PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[

JS\Z[LYMSHZOLZHUK



[OL ^HYUPUN rZLSLJ[VY SL]LY UV[ LUNHNLKs

HWWLHYZ VU [OL KPZWSH` VM [OL VUÌIVHYK JVTÌ

W\[LY

,UNHNL[OLZLSLJ[VYSL]LYJVYYLJ[S`

0M[OLYLPZHMH\S[PU[OL[YHUZTPZZPVU!



NLHYMSHZOLZVU[OLKPZWSH`



;OL ^HYUPUN r;PW[YVUPJ LTLYNLUJ` Y\Us

HWWLHYZPU[OLVUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY

(SZVYLMLY[Vr,TLYNLUJ`WYVNYHTs

;V YLTLK` [OL MH\S[ WSLHZL JVUZ\S[ HU H\[OÌ

VYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLYPTTLKPH[LS`

s¢G˜˜

:OPM[PUN.LHY

background image

FdF4›p˜F¦F˜p’a›apm’

˜J˜"camV˜dp4c

0U ZLSLJ[VY SL]LY WVZP[PVU 7 [OL KYP]LU ^OLLSZ

HYLTLJOHUPJHSS`SVJRLK

:LSLJ[VUS`^OLUJHYOHZILLUZ[VWWLK

,UNHNL WHYRPUN SVJR HM[LY HWWS`PUN [OL OHUKÌ

IYHRL HUK YLSLHZL P[ ILMVYL YLSLHZPUN [OL

OHUKIYHRL

;OL PNUP[PVU RL` JHU IL ^P[OKYH^U VUS` PU

ZLSLJ[VYSL]LYWVZP[PVU7

˜J˜F¦F’F

:LSLJ[ VUS` ^OLU JHY OHZ ILLU Z[VWWLK HUK

[OLIYHRLPZHWWSPLK

˜J˜F¤›"d

:LSLJ[VY SL]LY WVZP[PVU 5 T\Z[ IL ZLSLJ[LK MVY

[V^PUNVYPUJHY^HZOLZMVYL_HTWSL

:LSLJ[ [OL KLZPYLK WVZP[PVU MVYTV]PUNVMM+

4 VY 9 VUS` ^OLU [OL LUNPUL PZ PKSPUN HUK

^OPSLKLWYLZZPUN[OLIYHRLWLKHS

:LSLJ[WVZP[PVU5^OPSLKYP]PUNVUS`PM[OLJHY

PZ[OYLH[LUPUN[VZRPKPUZSPWWLY`JVUKP[PVUZ

6[OLY^PZL5ZOV\SKUV[ILZLSLJ[LK^OPSLKYP]Ì

PUN

˜J˜¤›ph"›a4˜’FdF4›apm˜hp=F

:LSLJ[ WVZP[PVU + MVY rUVYTHSs KYP]PUN ;OL

NLHYZ HYL ZOPM[LK H\[VTH[PJHSS` HJJVYKPUN [V

[OLHJJLSLYH[VYWVZP[PVUHUKZWLLK

+LWLUKPUN VU [OL ^H` [OL ]LOPJSL PZ KYP]LU HUK

VU[OLYLZPZ[HUJLLN\WOPSS[OLNLHYÌJOHUNPUN

WVPU[Z HYL ZOPM[LK [V^HYKZ OPNOLY VY SV^LY LUÌ

NPULÌZWLLKYHUNLZ

;OL HJJLSLYH[VY WVZP[PVU KYP]PUN ZWLLK LUNPUL

ZWLLK SVUNP[\KPUHS HUK SH[LYHS HJJLSLYH[PVU HUK

[OL YVHK WYVMPSL HSS OH]L HU PUMS\LUJL VU [OL

NLHYÌJOHUNPUNJOHYHJ[LYPZ[PJ

<U^HU[LK \W^HYK ZOPM[Z LN ILMVYL ILUKZ HYL

WYL]LU[LK I` Z^PM[S` YLSLHZPUN [OL HJJLSLYH[VY

WLKHS

+LWLUKPUN VU SH[LYHS HJJLSLYH[PVU \W^HYK ZOPM[Z

VU ILUKZ HYL UV[ THKL \U[PS [OL LUNPULÌZWLLK

SPTP[PZYLHJOLK

<UKLYIYHRPUNHUKKLWLUKPUNVU[OLHTV\U[VM

KLJLSLYH[PVU[OL;PW[YVUPJZOPM[ZKV^ULHYSPLY

-VY Z\IZLX\LU[ JVYULYPUN [OL YPNO[ NLHY PZ LUÌ

NHNLK ^OLU WYLZZ\YL PZ HWWSPLK [V [OL IYHRLZ

ILMVYL[OLILUK

;OL ILUK PZ [HRLU PU [OL YPNO[ NLHY HUK ^OLU

`V\HJJLSLYH[LV\[VM[OLILUK`V\KVUV[OH]L

[VZOPM[KV^U

+YP]PUNVMM
0U UK NLHY [OL ]LOPJSL KYP]LZ VMM ^P[O [OL

[OYV[[SLVUS`ZSPNO[S`VWLU

+YP]L VMM PU Z[ NLHY ^P[O [OL [OYV[[SL VWLU

^PKLYVY^OLU[OLLUNPULPZJVSK

:OPM[PUN.LHY

s¢n

background image

:OPM[PUNNLHYVU[OLZ[LLYPUN^OLLS
>P[O [OL [VNNSL Z^P[JOLZ VU [OL Z[LLYPUN ^OLLS

`V\ JHU JOHUNL [LTWVYHYPS` MYVT H\[VTH[PJ

ZLSLJ[PVUTVKL+[VTHU\HSTVKL4

(K]HU[HNLZ!



:OPM[PUN KV^U ILMVYL ILUKZ HUK VU LU[LYPUN

I\PS[Ì\WHYLHZ



:OPM[PUN KV^U VU KV^U^HYK ZSVWLZ LUNPUL

IYHRPUN



:OPM[PUNKV^UMVYIYPLMZW\Y[ZVMHJJLSLYH[PVU



:LSLJ[PUNZ[NLHYMVYTV]PUNVMM

;OLTHU\HSZLSLJ[PVUTVKLYLTHPUZLUNHNLK!



MVYJVYULYPUNKLWLUKPUNVU[OLSH[LYHS

HJJLSLYH[PVUHUKV]LYY\UUPUN



^OLU[OL]LOPJSLPZZ[H[PVUHY`

LNH[HQ\UJ[PVU

;OLZ`Z[LTSLH]LZTHU\HSZLSLJ[PVUTVKL!



H\[VTH[PJHSS`HM[LYHWWYV_ZLJVUKZ

\USLZZJVYULYPUNVYV]LYY\UUPUN



PM`V\KLWYLZZ[OLHJJLSLYH[VY[VRPJRKV^U



HM[LYTV]PUNVMM

;LTWVYHY`JOHUNLÍKV^U
*VUKP[PVUZ!

:WLLKPZOPNOLY[OHUHWWYV_TWORTO

+LWYLZZHJJLSLYH[VYX\PJRS`

;OL;PW[YVUPJJOHUNLZ[LTWVYHYPS`[V[OLZWVYÌ

[PLZ[ NLHYÌJOHUNPUN THW PL [V [OL OPNOLZ[

WVZZPISL NLHYÌJOHUNPUN WVPU[Z *VYYLZWVUKÌ

PUNS` [OL [YHUZTPZZPVU ZOPM[Z KV^U PTTLKPÌ

H[LS`I`VULVY[^VNLHYZ

,UKPUN[OLM\UJ[PVU!

9LSLHZL [OL HJJLSLYH[VY THYRLKS` I` HWWYV_

 

2PJRKV^U
;OLRPJRKV^UM\UJ[PVUPZHJ[P]LPUZLSLJ[VYSL]LY

WVZP[PVU + L]LU PM `V\ [LTWVYHYPS` JOHUNL [V

THU\HS TVKL 4 \ ZPUN [OL [VNNSL Z^P[JOLZ VU

[OLZ[LLYPUN^OLLS

-VY VW[PT\T HJJLSLYH[PVU LN ^OLU V]LY[HRÌ

PUNKLWYLZZ[OLHJJLSLYH[VYWLKHSIL`VUK[OL

M\SSÌ[OYV[[SLWVPU[RPJRKV^U

;OL [YHUZTPZZPVU ZOPM[Z KV^U KLWLUKPUN VU [OL

ZWLLKVM[YH]LSHUKLUNPULZWLLK

<W^HYK ZOPM[Z VJJ\Y H[ [OL OPNOLZ[ WVZZPISL

LUNPULZWLLKZ

;OLZL NLHYÌJOHUNPUN ZWLLKZ YLTHPU HJ[P]L \U[PS

[OL HJJLSLYH[VY PZ YLSLHZLK [V HWWYV_   VM

[OL^PKLVWLU[OYV[[SLWVZP[PVU

s¬˜˜

:OPM[PUN.LHY

background image

˜_˜"m¤"d˜FdF4›apm˜p=F

;OL J\YYLU[S` ZLSLJ[LK NLHY PZ YL[HPULK PM `V\

JOHUNLMYVT+[V4

0M`V\ZOPM[MYVT4[V+[OLNLHYÌJOHUNPUNTHW

Z\P[HISLMVY`V\YJ\YYLU[KYP]PUNZ[`SLPZZLSLJ[LK

HUK[OLHWWYVWYPH[LNLHYPZZLSLJ[LK

>HYUPUN

;OL RPJRKV^U M\UJ[PVU PZ UV[ HJ[P]L PU

THU\HSZLSLJ[PVUTVKLr4s

;OLYLMVYL ZOPM[ KV^U THU\HSS` ^OLU HJJLSLYHÌ

[PUNLN[VV]LY[HRL

;^V[VNNSLZ^P[JOLZPU[OL\WWLYZ[LLYPUNÌ^OLLS

ZWVRLZ SL[ `V\ JVTMVY[HIS` HUK YLSPHIS` ZLSLJ[

[OLMP]LMVY^HYKNLHYZ

:OPM[PUN\W

7YLZZ\WWLYWHY[VMH[VNNSLZ^P[JO

:OPM[PUNKV^U

7YLZZSV^LYWHY[uVMH[VNNSLZ^P[JO

+LWLUKPUN VU KYP]PUN ZWLLK HUK LUNPUL ZWLLK

`V\JHUZOPM[\WVYKV^UH[HU`[PTL

.LHYJOHUNLZ^OPJO^V\SKL_JLLK[OL\WWLYVY

SV^LYLUNPULÌZWLLKSPTP[HYLUV[L_LJ\[LKI`[OL

JVU[YVSSLY

@V\JHUZOPM[KV^U[^VNLHYZH[VUJLI`X\PJRS`

WYLZZPUN[OL[VNNSLZ^P[JOLZ[^PJL

0M [OL LUNPULÌZWLLK SPTP[ PZ YLHJOLK HU H\[VÌ

TH[PJ \W^HYK ZOPM[ PZ WLYMVYTLK VY Q\Z[ ILMVYL

PKSPUNZWLLKPZYLHJOLKHKV^U^HYKZOPM[PZWLYÌ

MVYTLK

:LSLJ[ HU HWWYVWYPH[LS` SV^ NLHY VU \W^HYK

HUKKV^U^HYKZSVWLZ

;OPZ^PSSLUZ\YLVW[PT\T\ZLVMLUNPULWV^LY

HUKLUNPULIYHRPUN

0M THU\HS TVKL MHPSZ [OL JVU[YVS LSLJ[YVUPJZ

Z^P[JO [V H\[VTH[PJ TVKL 0U [OPZ L]LU[ [OL

PUZ[Y\TLU[JS\Z[LY^PSSKPZWSH`ZLSLJ[VYSL]LYWVZPÌ

[PVU+

;V YLTLK` [OL MH\S[ WSLHZL JVUZ\S[ HU H\[OÌ

VYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

:OPM[PUN.LHY

ss

background image

daz˜hpma›pamV

>OLU [OL ZWLLKZ VM YV[H[PVU VM [OL MYVU[ HUK

YLHYH_SLZKPMMLYI`TVYL[OHU[OLTH_PT\TWLYÌ

TPZZPISL ]HS\L PU[LNYH[LK ZSPW TVUP[VYPUN ZOPM[Z

\W[V[OLUL_[NLHY

;OPZPUJYLHZLZKYP]PUNZ[HIPSP[`VUHZSPWWLY`Z\YÌ

MHJL

5V[L
:SPW TVUP[VYPUN PZ HSZV KLHJ[P]H[LK ^OLU

7VYZJOL:[HIPSP[`4HUHNLTLU[7:4PZZ^P[JOLK

VMM

›pzzamV

-VY H IYPLM Z[VW LN H[ H [YHMMPJ SPNO[ SLH]L

[OL ZLSLJ[VY SL]LY PU KYP]L WVZP[PVU HUK OVSK

[OL]LOPJSL^P[O[OLIYHRLWLKHS

-VY H SVUNLY Z[VW ^P[O [OL LUNPUL Y\UUPUN

ZLSLJ[WVZP[PVU5UL\[YHS

+V UV[ OVSK [OL JHY VU H ZSVWL \ZPUN [OL

HJJLSLYH[VY<ZL[OLIYHRLWLKHSVY[OLOHUKÌ

IYHRLPUZ[LHK

)LMVYL SLH]PUN [OL ]LOPJSL HS^H`Z HWWS` [OL

OHUKIYHRL HUK TV]L [OL ZLSLJ[VY SL]LY [V

WVZP[PVU7

"camV

.VLHZ`VU[OLHJJLSLYH[VY

>OLU WHYRPUN VY THUVL\]LYPUN PU H ZTHSS

ZWHJL JVU[YVS [OL ZWLLK I` JHYLM\S \ZL VM

[OLMVV[IYHRL

a¦amV˜am˜§am›F

0U^PU[LY`YVHKJVUKP[PVUZP[PZHK]PZHISL[V[HRL

Z[LLWPUJSPULZPUTHU\HSTVKL;OPZWYL]LU[Z[OL

VJJ\YYLUJL VM NLHY JOHUNLZ [OH[ JV\SK JH\ZL

^OLLSZWPU

p§_’›"›amV:˜›p§amV

9LMLY[V[OLJOHW[LYr;V^PUNs

hFVFm4©˜zpV"h

([YHUZTPZZPVUMH\S[PZPUKPJH[LKI`[OLMVSSV^PUN

Z`TW[VTZ!



NLHYMSHZOLZVU[OLKPZWSH`VM[OLPUZ[Y\Ì

TLU[JS\Z[LY



;OL ^HYUPUN r;PW[YVUPJ LTLYNLUJ` Y\Us

HWWLHYZPU[OLVUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY



;OL[YHUZTPZZPVUUVSVUNLYZOPM[Z

>HYUPUN

9L]LYZLNLHYSVJRTVUP[VYPUNPZKPZHISLKPU

[OLLTLYNLUJ`Y\UUPUNWYVNYHT

+HTHNL [V [OL ]LOPJSL TH` YLZ\S[ HZ ^LSS

HZ SVZZ VM JVU[YVS PM [OL ]LOPJSL PZ TV]PUN

MVY^HYK MHZ[ LUV\NO [V JH\ZL YLHY ^OLLS

SVJR\W

+VUV[ZOPM[PU[V9^OPSL[OL]LOPJSLPZTV]PUN

MVY^HYK

7YVJLLK HZ MVSSV^Z PU [OL L]LU[ VM H [YHUZÌ

TPZZPVUMH\S[!

 :[VWPUHZHMLWSHJL

 4V]LZLSLJ[VYSL]LY[VWVZP[PVU7Z^P[JO[OL

PNUP[PVUVMMHUK^HP[MVYZLJVUKZ

 :[HY[[OLLUNPUL

UK NLHY PU ZLSLJ[VY WVZP[PVU + HUK YL]LYZL

NLHY9HYLUV^H]HPSHISLHUK^PSSHSSV^`V\[V

YLHJO[OLULHYLZ[H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

 ;V YLTLK` [OL MH\S[ WSLHZL JVUZ\S[ HU H\[OÌ

VYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLYPTTLKPH[LS`

s¢˜˜

:OPM[PUN.LHY

background image

"am›Fm"m4F:˜"˜"F

*H\[PVUZ  

*VVSHU[SL]LS 

,UNPULVPS  u

,UNPULVPSSL]LS 

,UNPULVPSYLJVTTLUKH[PVU 

)YHRLÌMS\PKSL]LS 

-\LSLJVUVT`VWLYH[PUN`V\YJHY

PUV[OLYJV\U[YPLZ 

-\LSMPSSLYMSHWM\LS[HUR  

-\LSYLJVTTLUKH[PVUZ  

7VY[HISLM\LSJVU[HPULYZ 

,TPZZPVUJVU[YVSZ`Z[LT  

-\LSL]HWVYH[PVUJVU[YVS

>HZOLYMS\PK 

7V^LYZ[LLYPUNMS\PKSL]LS 

(PYMPS[LYWHY[PJSLMPS[LY

H\[VTH[PJ[YHUZTPZZPVUMS\PK

THU\HS[YHUZTPZZPVUVPS  

7V^LYTLHZ\YLTLU[Z 

>PWLYISHKLZ 

*HYJHYL u

4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL

s

background image

¨F4a’F˜¨›FhF˜"¤›apm˜§^Fm

pcamV˜pm˜©p¤˜F^a4dF

>HYUPUN

0NUVYPUN [OL MVSSV^PUN PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ TH`

JH\ZLZLYPV\ZWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`

;OLLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[VMHU`TV[VY]LOPJSL

PZHWV[LU[PHSS`OHaHYKV\ZHYLH0M`V\HYLUV[

M\SS`MHTPSPHY^P[OWYVWLYYLWHPYWYVJLK\YLZKV

UV[H[[LTW[[OLHKQ\Z[TLU[ZKLZJYPILKVU[OL

MVSSV^PUNWHNLZ

;OPZJH\[PVUHWWSPLZ[V[OLLU[PYL]LOPJSL

6US` ^VYR VU `V\Y ]LOPJSL V\[KVVYZ VY PU H

^LSS]LU[PSH[LKHYLH

,UZ\YL [OH[ [OLYL HYL UV VWLU MSHTLZ PU [OL

HYLH VM `V\Y ]LOPJSL H[ HU` [PTL ^OLU M\LS

M\TLZ TPNO[ IL WYLZLU[ )L LZWLJPHSS` JH\Ì

[PV\Z VM Z\JO KL]PJLZ Z\JO HZ OV[ ^H[LY

OLH[LYZ^OPJOPNUP[LHMSHTLPU[LYTP[[LU[S`

)LMVYL^VYRPUNVUHU`WHY[PU[OLLUNPULJVTÌ

WHY[TLU[ [\YU [OL LUNPUL VMM HUK SL[ P[ JVVS

KV^U Z\MMPJPLU[S` /V[ LUNPUL JVTWHY[TLU[

JVTWVULU[ZJHUI\YUZRPUVUJVU[HJ[

)L HSLY[ HUK JH\[PV\Z HYV\UK LUNPUL H[ HSS

[PTLZ^OPSL[OLLUNPULPZY\UUPUN

0M ^VYR OHZ [V IL WLYMVYTLK ^P[O [OL LUNPUL

Y\UUPUN HS^H`Z ZL[ [OL WHYRPUN IYHRL HUK

THRL Z\YL [OL ZOPM[ SL]LY PZ PU UL\[YHS VY [OL

ZLSLJ[VYSL]LYPZPUWVZP[PVUs7rVYs5r

0U WHY[PJ\SHY IL ]LY` JHYLM\S [V LUZ\YL [OH[

P[LTZ VM JSV[OPUN [PLZ ZOPY[ ZSLL]LZ L[J

QL^LSY` SVUN OHPY OHUK VY MPUNLYZ JHUUV[ NL[

JH\NO[ PU [OL LUNPULÌJVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY

MHUILS[ZVYV[OLYTV]PUNWHY[Z

;OLYHKPH[VYHUKYHKPH[VYMHUZHYLPU[OLMYVU[

VM[OLJHY

;OL LUNPULÌJVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY PZ TV\U[LK

VU[OLLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[SPK

;OL LUNPULÌJVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY HS^H`Z Y\UZ

^OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ Z^P[JOLK VU (M[LY [OL

PNUP[PVU PZ Z^P[JOLK VMM [OL LUNPUL JVTWHY[Ì

TLU[HUKJVVSHU[[LTWLYH[\YLZHYLTVUP[VYLK

MVYHWWYV_TPU\[LZ

+\YPUN [OPZ WLYPVK HUK KLWLUKPUN VU [LTÌ

WLYH[\YL [OL LUNPULÌJVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY HUK

YHKPH[VY MHUZ TH` JVU[PU\L [V Y\U VY Z[HY[ [V

Y\U

*HYY` V\[ ^VYR PU [OLZL HYLHZ VUS` ^P[O [OL

LUNPULVMMHUKL_LYJPZLL_[YLTLJH\[PVU

@V\Y 7VYZJOL PZ LX\PWWLK ^P[O HU LSLJ[YVUPJ

PNUP[PVU Z`Z[LT >OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ VU OPNO

]VS[HNL PZ WYLZLU[ PU HSS ^PYLZ JVUULJ[LK ^P[O

[OL PNUP[PVU Z`Z[LT" [OLYLMVYL L_LYJPZL L_Ì

[YLTL JH\[PVU ^OLU ^VYRPUN VU HU` WHY[ VM

[OL LUNPUL ^OPSL [OL PNUP[PVU PZ VU VY [OL LUÌ

NPULPZY\UUPUN

(S^H`Z Z\WWVY[ `V\Y JHY ^P[O ZHML[` Z[HUKZ PM

P[ PZ ULJLZZHY` [V ^VYR \UKLY [OL JHY ;OL

QHJRZ\WWSPLK^P[O[OLJHYPZUV[HKLX\H[LMVY

[OPZW\YWVZL

>OLU ^VYRPUN \UKLY [OL JHY ^P[OV\[ ZHML[`

Z[HUKZ I\[ ^P[O [OL ^OLLSZ VU [OL NYV\UK

THRL Z\YL [OL JHY PZ VU SL]LS NYV\UK [OL

^OLLSZ HYL ISVJRLK HUK [OH[ [OL LUNPUL JHUÌ

UV[ILZ[HY[LK

9LTV]L[OLPNUP[PVURL`

+VUV[ZTVRLVYHSSV^HUVWLUMSHTLHYV\UK

[OLIH[[LY`VYM\LS

2LLWHMPYLL_[PUN\PZOLYPUJSVZLYLHJO

0UJVTWSL[L VY PTWYVWLY ZLY]PJPUN TH` JH\ZL

WYVISLTZ PU [OL VWLYH[PVU VM [OL JHY 0M PU

KV\I[ HIV\[ HU` ZLY]PJPUN OH]L P[ KVUL I`

`V\YH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

0TWYVWLY THPU[LUHUJL K\YPUN [OL ^HYYHU[`

WLYPVK TH` HMMLJ[ `V\Y 7VYZJOL ^HYYHU[`

JV]LYHNL

:\WWSPLZ VM MS\PKZ LN LUNPUL VPS IYHRL MS\PK

VYJVVSHU[HYLOHaHYKV\Z[V`V\YOLHS[O

2LLW [OLZL MS\PKZ V\[ VM JOPSKYLUqZ YLHJO HUK

KPZWVZL VM [OLT PU HJJVYKHUJL ^P[O [OL HWÌ

WYVWYPH[LYLN\SH[PVUZ

:VTL JV\U[YPLZ YLX\PYL HKKP[PVUHS [VVSZ HUK

ZWLJPHSZWHYLWHY[Z[VILJHYYPLK

7SLHZLTHRLLUX\PYPLZILMVYLKYP]PUNHIYVHK

sT˜˜

4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL

background image

ppd"m›˜F¦Fd

-VSSV^[OLPUZ[Y\J[PVUZPU[OLs*H\[PVUZrJOHW[LY

;OLJVVSPUNZ`Z[LTPZMPSSLKH[[OLMHJ[VY`^P[OH

WLYTHULU[JVVSHU[

0[ WYV]PKLZ `LHYÌYV\UK WYV[LJ[PVU MYVT JVYYVZPVU

HUK MYLLaPUN KV^U [V u‰-u‰* 5VYKPJ

JV\U[YPLZu‰-u‰*

6US`\ZLHU[PMYLLaLH\[OVYPaLKI`7VYZJOL

^F4camV˜4ppd"m›˜dF¦Fd

;OLL_WHUZPVU[HUR^P[OP[ZMPSSLYVYPMPJLPZPU[OL

LUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[

*OLJR [OL JVVSHU[ SL]LS YLN\SHYS` [OYV\NO [OL

[YHUZWHYLU[L_WHUZPVU[HUR

>OLU[OLLUNPULPZJVSKHUK[OLJHYPZSL]LS[OL

MS\PKSL]LST\Z[SPLIL[^LLU[OLs4PUrHUKs4H_r

THYRPUNZ

pzzamV˜pOO˜4ppd"m›

>HYUPUN

+HUNLY VM ZLYPV\Z WLYZVUHS PUQ\Y` MYVT

ZJHSKPUN *VVSHU[ PZ OHaHYKV\Z [V `V\Y

OLHS[OHUKTH`ILMH[HSPMZ^HSSV^LK

+V UV[ VWLU [OL JHW VM [OL L_WHUZPVU [HUR

^OPSL[OLLUNPULPZOV[

(SSV^[OLLUNPUL[VJVVSKV^UILMVYLVWLUPUN

[OL JHW HUK WYV[LJ[ `V\Y OHUKZ HYTZ HUK

MHJLMYVTHU`WVZZPISLLZJHWLVMOV[JVVSHU[

2LLWJVVSHU[V\[VMJOPSKYLUqZYLHJO

(SZVRLLWJVVSHU[H^H`MYVT`V\YWL[Z

;OL`JHUILH[[YHJ[LK[VP[ZOV\SK[OLYLILH

ZWPSS VY [V \ZLK JVVSHU[ SLM[ PU HU VWLU JVUÌ

[HPULY *VVSHU[ JHU IL KLHKS` [V WL[Z PM JVUÌ

Z\TLK

 :^P[JOLUNPULVMMHUKSL[P[JVVS

:LL[OLJOHW[LYVU[OLs*VVSPUNZ`Z[LTr

 *V]LY [OL L_WHUZPVU [HUR JHW ^P[O H [OPJR

YHN

6WLUJHWZSV^S`HUKJHYLM\SS`HUKHSSV^V]LYÌ

WYLZZ\YL[VLZJHWL

;OLU\UZJYL^JHWJVTWSL[LS`

 6US`HKKHTP_[\YLVMHU[PMYLLaLHUK^H[LYPU

LX\HS WHY[Z HUK KV UV[ L_JLLK [OL s4H_r

THYR

(U[PMYLLaLPUJVVSHU[!

 NP]LZWYV[LJ[PVUKV^U[Vu‰-u‰*

 NP]LZWYV[LJ[PVUKV^U[Vu‰-u‰*

 :JYL^JHWMPYTS`VU

0M PU HU LTLYNLUJ` W\YL ^H[LY OHZ ILLU HKKLK

[OLTP_YH[PVT\Z[ILJVYYLJ[LKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK

7VYZJOLKLHSLY

4HYRLK SVZZ VM JVVSHU[ PUKPJH[LZ SLHRHNL PU [OL

JVVSPUNZ`Z[LT

;OL JH\ZL ZOV\SK PTTLKPH[LS` IL YLTLKPLK H[

HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL

sQ

background image

mVamF_4phz"›hFm›˜*dp§F:˜

"=a"›p˜O"m’

;OL YHKPH[VYZ HUK YHKPH[VY MHUZ HYL PU [OL MYVU[

VM[OLJHY

;OL LUNPULÌJVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY PZ TV\U[LK VU

[OLLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[SPK

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMPUQ\Y`

;OL LUNPULÍJVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY HS^H`Z

Y\UZ^OLU[OLPNUP[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVU(M[LY

[OLPNUP[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVMM[OLLUNPULJVTÍ

WHY[TLU[ HUK JVVSHU[ [LTWLYH[\YLZ HYL

TVUP[VYLKMVYHWWYV_TPU\[LZ

+\YPUN [OPZ WLYPVK HUK KLWLUKPUN VU [LTÍ

WLYH[\YL [OL LUNPULÍJVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY

HUK YHKPH[VY MHUZ TH` JVU[PU\L [V Y\U VY

Z[HY[[VY\U

*HYY` V\[ ^VYR PU [OLZL HYLHZ VUS` ^P[O [OL

LUNPULVMMHUKL_LYJPZLL_[YLTLJH\[PVU

mVamF˜ad

,UNPULVPSJVUZ\TW[PVU

0[PZUVYTHSMVY`V\YLUNPUL[VJVUZ\TLVPS

;OL YH[L VM VPS JVUZ\TW[PVU KLWLUKZ VU [OL

X\HSP[` HUK ]PZJVZP[` VM VPS [OL ZWLLK H[ ^OPJO

[OL LUNPUL PZ VWLYH[LK [OL JSPTH[L YVHK JVUKPÌ

[PVUZHZ^LSSHZ[OLHTV\U[VMKPS\[PVUHUKV_PKHÌ

[PVUVM[OLS\IYPJHU[

0M [OL ]LOPJSL PZ \ZLK MVY YLWLH[LK ZOVY[ [YPWZ

HUK JVUZ\TLZ H UVYTHS HTV\U[ VM VPS [OL LUÌ

NPULVPSTLHZ\YLTLU[TH`UV[ZOV^HU`KYVWPU

[OL VPS SL]LS H[ HSS L]LU HM[LY  TPSLZ 

RTVYTVYL;OPZPZILJH\ZL[OLVPSPZNYHK\HSS`

ILJVTPUNKPS\[LK^P[OM\LSVYTVPZ[\YLTHRPUNP[

HWWLHY[OH[[OLVPSSL]LSOHZUV[JOHUNLK

;OL KPS\[PUN PUNYLKPLU[Z L]HWVYH[L V\[ ^OLU [OL

]LOPJSL PZ KYP]LU H[ OPNO ZWLLKZ HZ VU HU L_Ì

WYLZZ^H` THRPUN P[ [OLU HWWLHY [OH[ VPS PZ L_Ì

JLZZP]LS`JVUZ\TLKHM[LYKYP]PUNH[OPNOZWLLKZ

0M [OL JVUKP[PVUZ `V\ KYP]L `V\Y ]LOPJSL PU HYL

K\Z[` O\TPK VY OV[ [OL MYLX\LUJ` VM [OL VPS

JOHUNLPU[LY]HSZZOV\SKILNYLH[LY

0M [OL ]LOPJSL PZ KYP]LU H[ H OPNO YH[L VM ZWLLK

JSPTH[PJ JVUKP[PVUZ HYL ^HYT HUK [OL SVHK PZ

OPNO[OLVPSZOV\SKILJOLJRLKTVYLMYLX\LU[S`

HZ KYP]PUN JVUKP[PVUZ ^PSS KL[LYTPUL [OL YH[L VM

VPSJVUZ\TW[PVU



;OL LUNPUL PU `V\Y ]LOPJSL KLWLUKZ VU VPS [V

S\IYPJH[LHUKJVVSHSSVMP[ZTV]PUNWHY[Z

;OLYLMVYL [OL LUNPUL VPS ZOV\SK IL JOLJRLK

YLN\SHYS`HUKRLW[H[[OLYLX\PYLKSL]LS



4HRL P[ H OHIP[ [V OH]L [OL LUNPUL VPS SL]LS

JOLJRLK^P[OL]LY`M\LSMPSSPUN



;OL VPS WYLZZ\YL ^HYUPUN SPNO[ PZ UV[ HU VPS

SL]LSPUKPJH[VY

;OL VPS WYLZZ\YL ^HYUPUN SPNO[ PUKPJH[LZ

ZLYPV\Z LUNPUL KHTHNL TH` IL VJJ\YPUN

^OLUSP[PMLUNPULYWTPZHIV]LPKSLZWLLK

s–˜˜

4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL

background image

mVamF˜ad˜F¦Fd

9LN\SHYS` JOLJR [OL VPS SL]LS \ZPUN [OL VUÌ

IVHYKJVTW\[LYLHJO[PTLILMVYLYLM\LSSPUN

9LMLY[V[OLJOHW[LYr6UÌIVHYKJVTW\[LYs

;OL KPMMLYLUJL IL[^LLU [OL TPU HUK TH_

THYRZ VU [OL ZLNTLU[ KPZWSH` VM [OL VUÌ IVHYK

JVTW\[LYPZHWWYV_SP[LYZX\HY[Z

6UL ZLNTLU[ VM [OL KPZWSH` JVYYLZWVUKZ [V H

X\HU[P[`VMHWWYV_SP[LYX\HY[

pzzamV˜pOO˜FmVamF˜pad

>HYUPUN

9PZR VM I\YUPUN MYVT OV[ WHY[Z PU LUNPUL

JVTWHY[TLU[ 9PZR VM PUQ\Y` I` YV[H[PUN

WHY[Z ;OL LUNPUL JVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY VU

[OL LUNPUL JVTWHY[TLU[ SPK JHU Z[HY[ \W

L]LU^P[O[OLLUNPULVMM

,_LYJPZL L_[YLTL JH\[PVU ^OLU ^VYRPUN VU

[OLLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[

-VSSV^ [OL PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ PU [OL JOHW[LY r5V[LZ

VUTHPU[LUHUJLs

;VWVMMLUNPULVPSVUS`^P[O[OLLUNPULVMM

,UNPUL VPS PZ OHaHYKV\Z [V `V\Y OLHS[O HUK

TH`ILMH[HSPMZ^HSSV^LK

2LLWLUNPULVPSV\[VMJOPSKYLUqZYLHJO

<ZLK LUNPUL VPS JVU[HPUZ JOLTPJHSZ [OH[

OH]LJH\ZLKJHUJLYPUSHIVYH[VY`HUPTHSZ

(S^H`Z WYV[LJ[ `V\Y ZRPU I` ^HZOPUN [OVYÌ

V\NOS`^P[OZVHWHUK^H[LY

 ;OL VUÌIVHYK JVTW\[LY PUKPJH[LZ OV^ T\JO

VPST\Z[ILHKKLK

 :^P[JOVMM[OLLUNPUL

<UZJYL^JHWVM[OLVPSMPSSLYVWLUPUN

 (KK H[ TVZ[ OHSM H SP[LY VM LUNPUL VPS H[ H

[PTL

 4LHZ\YLVPSSL]LSHNHPU

(KKTVYLLUNPULVPSPMULJLZZHY`

5L]LYHKKTVYLLUNPULVPS[OHUYLX\PYLK

[VYLHJO[OLTH_THYR

 *SVZLJHWVM[OLVPSMPSSLYVWLUPUN

4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL

s•

background image

mVamF˜ad˜F4phhFm="›apm

9LJVTTLUKLKVPS]PZJVZP[`YHUNLZKLWLUKLU[VUHTIPLU[[LTWLYH[\YLZ!

(TIPLU[[LTWLYH[\YLZ

:(,=PZJVZP[`9HUNL

ZLHZVUHS

LUNPULVPSZ

NLULYHSS`OPNOLY[OHU

 >Ì

•-•*

 >Ì 

 >Ì

NLULYHSS`SV^LY[OHU

 >Ì

•-•*

 >Ì 

<ZLVUS`LUNPULVPSZSHILSSLKHZ(70:/VY:1HUK]PZJVZP[`NYHKLZVM:(,>Í>ÍVYOPNOLY
7YLMLYHIS``V\ZOV\SK\ZLZ`U[OL[PJVYZLTPZ`U[OL[PJLUNPULVPSZ

0MPUKV\I[HZR`V\YH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLYMVY7VYZJOL[LZ[LKHUKHWWYV]LKHSSÍZLHZVUVPSZ

sG˜˜

4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL

background image

ad˜4^"mVF

;OL LUNPUL VPS OHZ [V IL JOHUNLK H[ [OL PU[LYÌ

]HSZSPZ[LKPU`V\Y4HPU[LUHUJL:JOLK\SL

:LLs*HWHJP[PLZr

>L YLJVTTLUK [OH[ `V\ OH]L [OL LUNPUL VPS

JOHUNLK H[ `V\Y 7VYZJOL KLHSLY ^OV OHZ [OL

YLX\PYLKVPSZHUK[OLULJLZZHY`MPSSPUNLX\PWTLU[

0M `V\ Z\ZWLJ[ HU VPS SLHR PU [OL LUNPUL OH]L

`V\YKLHSLYJOLJRP[V\[PTTLKPH[LS`

(SS J\YYLU[ LUNPUL VPSZ HYL JVTWH[PISL ^P[O LHJO

V[OLY PL ^OLU THRPUN HU VPS JOHUNL P[ PZ UV[

ULJLZZHY`[VMS\ZO[OLLUNPULPM`V\^PZO[V\ZL

HKPMMLYLU[IYHUKVYNYHKLVMVPS

:PUJL OV^L]LY LHJO IYHUK VM VPS OHZ H ZWLJPHS

JVTWVZP[PVU `V\ ZOV\SK PM WVZZPISL \ZL [OL

ZHTL VPS IYHUK PM P[ ILJVTLZ ULJLZZHY` [V [VW

VMMIL[^LLUVPSJOHUNLZ

7VYZJOL LUNPULZ OH]L SVUNPU[LY]HSZIL[^LLUVPS

JOHUNLZ @V\ JHU THRL ILZ[ \ZL VM [OLZL SVUN

VPS JOHUNL PU[LY]HSZ I` \ZPUN T\S[PNYHKL VPSZ

ZPUJL [OLZL HYL SHYNLS` PUKLWLUKLU[ VM ZLHZVUHS

MS\J[\H[PVUZPU[LTWLYH[\YL

0M `V\Y ]LOPJSL PZ \ZLK MYLX\LU[S` PU Z[VWÌHUKÌNV

[YHMMPJPUJVSK^LH[OLY[OLLUNPUL^PSSUV[HS^H`Z

ILWYVWLYS`^HYTLK\W

*VUKLUZH[PVUMYVTWYVK\J[ZVMJVTI\Z[PVUTH`

HJJ\T\SH[LPU[OLVPS0U[OPZJHZLP[PZHK]PZHISL

[V JOHUNL [OL VPS TVYL MYLX\LU[S` ZV [OH[ `V\Y

LUNPUL VUJL HNHPU OHZ   LMMPJPLU[ LUNPUL

VPS

mVamF˜pad˜zFOph"m4F˜4d"’’

,UNPULVPSPZUV[VUS`HS\IYPJHU[I\[HSZVZLY]LZ

[V RLLW [OL LUNPUL JSLHU [V UL\[YHSPaL [OL KPY[

^OPJO WLUL[YH[LZ PU[V [OL LUNPUL [OYV\NO JVTÌ

I\Z[PVUHUK[VWYV[LJ[[OLLUNPULHNHPUZ[JVYYVÌ

ZPVU

;V WLYMVYT [OLZL M\UJ[PVUZ [OL VPS PZ WYV]PKLK

^P[O HKKP[P]LZ ^OPJO OH]L ILLU ZWLJPHSS` KLÌ

]LSVWLKMVY[OLZLM\UJ[PVUZ

;OL LMMPJPLUJ` VM HU VPS PZ L_WYLZZLK MVY

L_HTWSL I` [OL (70 03:(* VY (*,( JSHZZPMPJHÌ

[PVUZ

<ZL VUS` LUNPUL VPSZ ^P[O [OL JSHZZPMPJH[PVU (70

:/VY:1VY03:(*.-VY(*,((,\YVWL

a’4p’a›©

3PRL HSS SPX\PKZ LUNPUL VPS PZ ]PZJV\Z ^OLU JVSK

HUK [OPUÌIVKPLK ^OLU ^HYT ;OL ]PZJVZP[` VM HU

VPS PZ L_WYLZZLK I` P[Z :(, JSHZZ -VY JVSK ]PZÌ

JVZP[` TLHZ\YLK H[ [LTWLYH[\YLZ ILSV^

•-•* [OL :(, JSHZZ PZ NP]LU HZ H U\TILY

HUK[OLSL[[LYs>rHZPU^PU[LYMVYOV[]PZJVZP[`

TLHZ\YLK H[ •-•* [OL :(, JSHZZ PZ

NP]LUVUS`HZHU\TILY

;OL ]PZJVZP[` VM HU VPS PZ [OLYLMVYL HS^H`Z [OL

ZHTL PM P[ OHZ [OL ZHTL U\TILY VM HU :(,

JSHZZ

,N! (  >Ì VPS HUK H  >Ì VPS OH]L [OL

ZHTL]PZJVZP[`^OLUJVSKILSV^•*"^OLUOV[

H[ •-•* [OL VPS ^P[O [OL U\TILY  PZ

[OPUULY[OHU[OLVPS^P[O[OLU\TILY

6PSZ ^P[O [^V ]PZJVZP[PLZ HYL JHSSLK T\S[PNYHKL

VPSZ" VPSZ ^P[O VUS` VUL ]PZJVZP[` HYL [LYTLK

ZPUNSLÌNYHKLVPSZ

:PUNSLÌNYHKLVPSZJHUUV[IL\ZLKPU`V\YLUNPUL

;OL ]PZJVZP[` VM [OL LUNPUL VPS MVY `V\Y 7VYZJOL

OHZ[VILJOVZLUHJJVYKPUN[V[OLHTIPLU[[LTÌ

WLYH[\YLNP]LUPU[OLLUNPULVPSYLJVTTLUKH[PVU

[HISL

4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL

sn

background image

"cF˜ d¤a=˜F¦Fd

-VSSV^[OLPUZ[Y\J[PVUZPU[OLs*H\[PVUZrJOHW[LY

<ZL VUS` UL^ \U\ZLK 6YPNPUHS 7VYZJOL

IYHRLMS\PK

>HYUPUN

)YHRLMS\PKPZOHaHYKV\Z[V`V\YOLHS[OHUK

TH`ILMH[HSPMZ^HSSV^LK

)YHRLMS\PKHSZVH[[HJRZWHPU[^VYR

2LLWIYHRLMS\PKV\[VMJOPSKYLUqZYLHJO

;HRL JHYL ^OPSL [VWWPUN VMMIYHRLMS\PKUV[[V

ZVPS[OLS\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[VYP[LTZVMS\NÌ

NHNL

^F4camV˜›^F˜*"cF˜Od¤a=˜dF¦Fd

;OLYLZLY]VPYMVY[OLO`KYH\SPJIYHRPUNZ`Z[LTPZ

PU[OLS\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[

*OLJR [OL IYHRLÌMS\PK SL]LS YLN\SHYS` H[ [OL

[YHUZWHYLU[YLZLY]VPY

;OL MS\PK SL]LS ZOV\SK HS^H`Z SPL IL[^LLU [OL

s4PUrHUKs4H_rTHYRZ

( ZSPNO[ KLJYLHZL PU [OL MS\PK SL]LS K\L [V ^LHY

HUK H\[VTH[PJ YLHKQ\Z[TLU[ VM [OL KPZJ IYHRLZ

PZUVYTHS

0M OV^L]LY [OL MS\PK SL]LS MHSSZ THYRLKS` VY

ILSV^ [OL s4PUr THYR [OL IYHRPUN Z`Z[LT TH`

OH]LKL]LSVWLKHSLHR

/H]L[OLIYHRPUNZ`Z[LTJOLJRLKPTTLKPH[LS`

H[HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

^"mVamV˜›^F˜*"cF˜Od¤a=

)YHRL MS\PK HIZVYIZ TVPZ[\YL MYVT [OL HPY V]LY

[PTL;OPZHJJ\T\SH[PVUVM^H[LYSV^LYZ[OLIVPSÌ

PUN WVPU[ HUK \UKLY JLY[HPU VWLYH[PUN JVUÌ

KP[PVUZJHUHMMLJ[[OLIYHRPUNHJ[PVU

;OLYLMVYL OH]L [OL IYHRL MS\PK JOHUNLK PU HJÌ

JVYKHUJL^P[O[OLJOHUNLPU[LY]HSZZ[H[LKPU[OL

IYVJO\YLs4HPU[LUHUJLr

˜˜˜˜˜"mamV˜daV^›˜

˜˜˜˜˜"mamV˜daV^›˜"m"="

;OL IYHRLÌMS\PK ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[

WHULSHUKVUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LYPUKPJH[L!



IYHRLÌMS\PKSL]LS[VVSV^



PUJVUQ\UJ[PVU^P[OSHYNLWLKHS[YH]LS

HIYHRPUNÌJPYJ\P[MHPS\YL

0M[OL^HYUPUNSPNO[ZZOV\SKSPNO[\W^OPSL

KYP]PUN!

:[VWPTTLKPH[LS`PUHZ\P[HISLWSHJL

+VUV[JVU[PU\LKYP]PUN

7SLHZL OH]L [OL MH\S[ YLTLKPLK H[ `V\Y ULHYÌ

LZ[H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

sT¬˜˜

4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL

background image

¤Fd˜4pmph©

-\LS LJVUVT` ^PSS ]HY` KLWLUKPUN VU

^OLYL ^OLU HUK OV^ `V\ KYP]L VW[PVUHS

LX\PWTLU[PUZ[HSSLKHUK[OLNLULYHSJVUKPÍ

[PVUVM`V\YJHY

( JHY [\ULK [V ZWLJPMPJH[PVUZ HUK JVYYLJ[S`

THPU[HPULK^PSSOLSW`V\[VHJOPL]LVW[PTHS

M\LSLJVUVT`

/H]L`V\Y]LOPJSL[\ULK[VZWLJPMPJH[PVUZ

(PYJSLHULYZOV\SKILKPY[MYLL[VHSSV^WYVWLY

LUNPULsIYLH[OPUNr

)H[[LY`ZOV\SKILM\SS`JOHYNLK

>OLLSZZOV\SKILWYVWLYS`HSPNULK

;PYLZZOV\SKILPUMSH[LKH[JVYYLJ[WYLZZ\YL

(S^H`ZTVUP[VY`V\YM\LSJVUZ\TW[PVU

+YP]L ZTVV[OS` H]VPK HIY\W[ JOHUNLZ PU

ZWLLKHZT\JOHZWVZZPISL

(]VPKQHJRYHIIP[Z[HY[ZHUKZ\KKLUZ[VWZ

+V UV[ KYP]L SVUNLY [OHU ULJLZZHY` PU [OL

SV^LY NLHYZ :OPM[PUN PU[V H OPNOLY NLHY LHYS`

^P[OV\[S\NNPUN[OLLUNPUL^PSSOLSWZH]LM\LS

7YVSVUNLK s^HYT \Wr PKSPUN ^HZ[LZ NHZ:[HY[

[OL]LOPJSLQ\Z[ILMVYL`V\HYLYLHK`[VKYP]L

(JJLSLYH[LZSV^S`HUKZTVV[OS`

:^P[JO VMM [OL LUNPUL PM Z[H[PVUHY` MVY SVUNLY

WLYPVKZ

(U`HKKP[PVUHS^LPNO[JHYYPLKPU[OL]LOPJSLYLÌ

K\JLZ M\LS LJVUVT` (S^H`Z RLLW JHYNV [V H

TPUPT\THUKYLTV]LHSS\UULJLZZHY`P[LTZ

6YNHUPaL`V\Y[YPWZ[V[HRLPUZL]LYHSLYYHUKZ

PUVUL[YPW

(SS LSLJ[YPJHS HJJLZZVYPLZ JVU[YPI\[L [V PUÌ

JYLHZLKM\LSJVUZ\TW[PVU

6US` Z^P[JO VU [OL HPY JVUKP[PVUPUN ^OLU

ULJLZZHY`

+V UV[ KYP]L ^P[O [OL 9VVM ;YHUZWVY[ :`Z[LT

TV\U[LK\USLZZ`V\ULLKP[

;OL,7(LZ[PTH[LKTWNPZ[VIL\ZLKMVY

JVTWHYPZVU W\YWVZLZ HJ[\HS TPSLHNL TH`

IL KPMMLYLU[ MYVT [OL LZ[PTH[LK TWNKLÍ

WLUKPUN VU `V\Y KYP]PUN ZWLLK ^LH[OLY

JVUKP[PVUZ HUK [YPW SLUN[O @V\Y HJ[\HS

OPNO^H` TPSLHNL ^PSS WYVIHIS` IL SLZZ [OHU

[OLLZ[PTH[LKTWN

7SLHZL VIZLY]L HSS SVJHS HUK UH[PVUHS ZWLLK

SPTP[Z

zF"›amV˜ p¤˜p’4^F˜am˜p›^F

p¤m›aF’

.V]LYUTLU[YLN\SH[PVUZPU[OL<UP[LK:[H[LZHUK

*HUHKH YLX\PYL [OH[ H\[VTVIPSLZ TLL[ ZWLJPMPJ

LTPZZPVU YLN\SH[PVUZ HUK ZHML[` Z[HUKHYKZ

;OLYLMVYL JHYZ I\PS[ MVY [OL <: HUK *HUHKH

KPMMLYMYVT]LOPJSLZZVSKPUV[OLYJV\U[YPLZ

0M`V\WSHU[V[HRL`V\Y7VYZJOLV\[ZPKL[OLJVUÌ

[PULU[HS SPTP[Z VM [OL <UP[LK :[H[LZ VY *HUHKH

[OLYLPZ[OLWVZZPIPSP[`[OH[



\USLHKLKM\LSTH`UV[ILH]HPSHISL"



\USLHKLK M\LS TH` OH]L H JVUZPKLYHIS` SV^LY

VJ[HUL YH[PUN ,_JLZZP]L LUNPUL RUVJR HUK

ZLYPV\Z KHTHNL [V IV[O LUNPUL HUK JH[HS`[PJ

JVU]LY[LYZJV\SKYLZ\S["



ZLY]PJL TH` IL PUHKLX\H[L K\L [V SHJR VM

WYVWLY ZLY]PJL MHJPSP[PLZ [VVSZ VY KPHNUVZ[PJ

LX\PWTLU["



YLWSHJLTLU[ WHY[Z TH` UV[ IL H]HPSHISL VY

]LY`KPMMPJ\S[[VNL[

7VYZJOL JHUUV[ IL YLZWVUZPISL MVY [OL

TLJOHUPJHS KHTHNL [OH[ JV\SK YLZ\S[ ILÍ

JH\ZL VM PUHKLX\H[L M\LS ZLY]PJL VY WHY[Z

H]HPSHIPSP[`

0M`V\W\YJOHZLK`V\Y7VYZJOLHIYVHKHUK^HU[

[VIYPUNP[IHJROVTLILZ\YL[VMPUKV\[HIV\[

ZOPWWPUN HUK MVY^HYKPUN YLX\PYLTLU[Z HZ ^LSS

HZJ\YYLU[PTWVY[HUKJ\Z[VTZYLN\SH[PVUZ

4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL

sTs

background image

¤Fd

>HYUPUN

-\LS PZ OPNOS` MSHTTHISL HUK OHYTM\S [V

OLHS[O

-PYL VWLU MSHTL HUK ZTVRPUN HYL WYVOPIP[LK

^OLUOHUKSPUNM\LS

(]VPKJVU[HJ[^P[OZRPUVYJSV[OPUN

+VUV[PUOHSLM\LS]HWVYZ

;V WYL]LU[ KHTHNL[V[OLLTPZZPVUJVU[YVS

Z`Z[LTHUKLUNPUL!

5L]LYKYP]L[OL[HURJVTWSL[LS`V\[VMM\LS

(]VPKOPNOJVYULYPUNZWLLKZHM[LY[OL^HYUPUN

SPNO[ZOH]LJVTLVU

-VSSV^ [OL PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ PU [OL s-\LS ,JVUVT`r

s,TPZZPVU *VU[YVS :`Z[LTr HUK s-\LS SL]LS

NH\NLrJOHW[LYZ

zFmamV˜›^F˜OaddF˜Od"z

;OL MPSSLY VWLUPUN PZ \UKLY [OL MPSSLY MSHW PU [OL

MYVU[YPNO[MLUKLY

>P[O [OL ]LOPJSL \USVJRLK WYLZZ VU [OL MYVU[

WHY[VM[OLMPSSLYMSHWHYYV^[VVWLU[OLMSHW

;OL MPSSLY MSHW PZ JLU[YHSS` SVJRLK HSVUN ^P[O [OL

V[OLYSVJRZ

0M[OLYLPZHKLMLJ[PU[OLH\[VTH[PJ\USVJRÍ

PUNZ`Z[LT!

6WLU[OLWHZZLUNLYKVVY

7\SS [OL YPUN PU [OL YPNO[ÌOHUK KVVY HWLY[\YL

HYYV^

sT¢˜˜

4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL

background image

FO¤FddamV

-\LS[HURJHWHJP[`PZSPZ[LK\UKLYs*HWHJP[PLZr

7VYZJOL KVLZ UV[ YLJVTTLUK [OL \ZL VM M\LS

HKKP[P]LZ

 0TWVY[HU[! :[VW [OL LUNPUL HUK Z^P[JO VMM

[OLPNUP[PVU

 :SV^S`\UZJYL^[OL[HURJHW

/HUN[OL[HURJHWVU[OLWSHZ[PJZ[YHWVM[OL

MPSSLYMSHW

 0UZLY[M\LSÌOVZLUVaaSLM\SS`PU[V[OLMPSSLYULJR

^P[O[OLOHUKSLVM[OLM\LSÌOVZLUVaaSLMHJPUN

KV^U

 +V UV[ HKK M\Y[OLY M\LS VUJL [OL JVYYLJ[S`

VWLYH[LK H\[VTH[PJ M\LSÌOVZL UVaaSL OHZ

Z^P[JOLKVMM

-\LS JV\SK ZWYH` VY JV\SK Y\U V]LY PU ^HYT

[LTWLYH[\YLZ

 9LWSHJL [OL [HUR JHW PTTLKPH[LS` HM[LY

YLM\LSSPUNHUK[\YUP[\U[PS`V\OLHYP[HUKMLLS

P[LUNHNL

0M `V\ SVZL [OL [HUR JHW `V\ T\Z[ YLWSHJL

P[ VUS` ^P[O HU VYPNPUHS WHY[ [V YLK\JL [OL

WVZZPIPSP[` VM H MPYL PU [OL L]LU[ VM H JVSSPÍ

ZPVU

*OLJRLUNPUL^HYUPUNSPNO[
0M [OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[ WHULS HUK

VUÌIVHYK JVTW\[LY JVTL VU HUK YLTHPU VU

^OPSLKYP]PUNP[Z\NNLZ[Z!



HUPTWYVWLYS`MHZ[LULK[HURJHWVY



YLM\LSSPUN^P[OLUNPULY\UUPUN

¤Fd˜F4phhFm="›apm’

@V\Y 7VYZJOL PZ LX\PWWLK ^P[O JH[HS`[PJ JVU]LYÌ

[LYZHUKT\Z[\ZL<53,(+,+-<,3653@

@V\YLUNPULPZKLZPNULK[VWYV]PKLVW[PT\TWLYÌ

MVYTHUJLHUKM\LSLJVUVT`\ZPUN\USLHKLKWYLÌ

TP\T M\LS ^P[O HU VJ[HUL YH[PUN VM  965

 *3*VY(20 7VYZJOL [OLYLMVYL YLJVTÌ

TLUKZ[OL\ZLVM[OLZLM\LSZPU`V\Y]LOPJSL

7VYZJOL HSZV YLJVNUPaLZ [OH[ [OLZL M\LSZ TH`

UV[ HS^H`Z IL H]HPSHISL )L HZZ\YLK [OH[ `V\Y

]LOPJSL ^PSS VWLYH[L WYVWLYS` VU \USLHKLK WYLÌ

TP\T M\LSZ ^P[O VJ[HUL U\TILYZ VM H[ SLHZ[

 965   *3* VY (20 ZPUJL [OL LUNPULqZ

s,SLJ[YVUPJ 6R[HUL¹ RUVJR JVU[YVSr ^PSS HKHW[

[OLPNUP[PVU[PTPUNPMULJLZZHY`

;OL \ZL VM \USLHKLK M\LS VUS` PZ JYP[PJHSS`

PTWVY[HU[[V[OLSPMLVM[OLJH[HS`[PJJVU]LYÍ

[LYZ +LWVZP[Z MYVT SLHKLK M\LSZ ^PSS Y\PU

[OL JVU]LY[LYZ HUK THRL P[ PULMMLJ[P]L HZ

HULTPZZPVUJVU[YVSKL]PJL

*HYZ ^P[O JH[HS`[PJ JVU]LY[LYZ OH]L H ZTHSSLY

M\LS [HUR VWLUPUN HUK NHZ Z[H[PVU W\TWZ OH]L

ZTHSSLY UVaaSLZ ;OPZ ^PSS WYL]LU[ HJJPKLU[HS

W\TWPUN VM SLHKLK M\LS PU[V JHYZ ^P[O JH[HS`[PJ

JVU]LY[LYZ

4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL

sT

background image

<USLHKLK M\LSZ TH` UV[ IL H]HPSHISLV\[ZPKL[OL

JVU[PULU[HS<:HUK*HUHKH;OLYLMVYL^LYLJÌ

VTTLUK `V\ KV UV[ [HRL `V\Y JHY [V HYLHZ VY

JV\U[YPLZ ^OLYL \USLHKLK M\LS TH` UV[ IL H]HPSÌ

HISL

4›"mF˜"›amV’

6J[HUL YH[PUN PUKPJH[LZ H M\LSqZ HIPSP[` [V YLZPZ[

KL[VUH[PVU;OLYLMVYLI\`PUN[OLJVYYLJ[VJ[HUL

NHZPZPTWVY[HU[[VWYL]LU[LUNPULsKHTHNLr

;OL965VJ[HULYH[PUNPZIHZLKVU[OLYLZLHYJO

TL[OVK ;OL *3* <: *VZ[ VM 3P]PUN *V\UJPS

VJ[HUL YH[PUN VY (20 HU[PRUVJR PUKL_ VJ[HUL

YH[PUN \Z\HSS` KPZWSH`LK VU <: M\LS W\TWZ PZ

JHSJ\SH[LK HZ YLZLHYJO VJ[HUL U\TILY WS\Z

TV[VYVJ[HULU\TILYKP]PKLKI`[OH[PZ^YP[Ì

[LUHZ!

965465    VY    94

            

;OL *3* VY (20 VJ[HUL YH[PUN PZ \Z\HSS` SV^LY

[OHU[OL965YH[PUN!

-VYL_HTWSL! 965LX\HSZ *3*VY(20

¤Fd’˜4pm›"amamV˜"d4p^pd˜"m=˜F›^F

:VTL HYLHZ VM [OL <: YLX\PYL V_`NLUH[LK

M\LSZ K\YPUN JLY[HPUWVY[PVUZVM[OL`LHY6_`NLÌ

UH[LK M\LSZ HYL M\LSZ ^OPJO JVU[HPU HSJVOVSZ

Z\JO HZ TL[OHUVS VY L[OHUVS VY L[OLY Z\JO HZ

4;),

<UKLY UVYTHS JVUKP[PVUZ [OL HTV\U[ VM [OLZL

JVTWV\UKZPU[OLM\LS^PSSUV[HMMLJ[KYP]LHIPSP[`

@V\ TH` \ZL V_`NLUH[LK M\LSZ PU `V\Y 7VYZJOL

WYV]PKLK [OL VJ[HUL YLX\PYLTLU[Z MVY `V\Y ]LÌ

OPJSL HYL TL[ >L YLJVTTLUK OV^L]LY [V

JOHUNL[VHKPMMLYLU[M\LSVYZ[H[PVUPMHU`VM[OL

MVSSV^PUNWYVISLTZVJJ\Y^P[O`V\Y]LOPJSL!



+L[LYPVYH[PVUVMKYP]LHIPSP[`HUKWLYMVYTHUJL



:\IZ[HU[PHSS`YLK\JLKM\LSLJVUVT`



=HWVY SVJR HUK UVUÌZ[HY[ WYVISLTZ LZWLJPHSS`

H[OPNOHS[P[\KLVYH[OPNO[LTWLYH[\YL



,UNPULTHSM\UJ[PVUVYZ[HSSPUN

¤Fd’˜4pm›"amamV˜

:VTL 5VY[O (TLYPJHU M\LSZ JVU[HPU HU VJ[HUL

LUOHUJPUN HKKP[P]L JHSSLK TL[O`SJ`JSVWLU[HKPLU`S

THUNHULZL[YPJHYIVU`S44;

0M Z\JO M\LSZ HYL \ZLK `V\Y LTPZZPVU JVU[YVS

Z`Z[LTWLYMVYTHUJLTH`ILULNH[P]LS`HMMLJ[LK

;OL JOLJR LUNPUL ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z VU `V\Y PUZ[Y\Ì

TLU[WHULSTH`[\YUVU

0M [OPZ VJJ\YZ 7VYZJOL YLJVTTLUKZ `V\ Z[VW

\ZPUNM\LSZJVU[HPUPUN44;

p›"*dF˜ ¤Fd˜pm›"amF’

+HUNLY

7VY[HISL M\LS JVU[HPULYZ M\SS VY WHY[PHSS`

LTW[` TH` SLHR JH\ZPUN HU L_WSVZPVU VY

YLZ\S[PUMPYLPUJHZLVMHUHJJPKLU[

5L]LY JHYY` HKKP[PVUHS M\LS PU WVY[HISL JVUÌ

[HPULYZPU`V\Y]LOPJSL

sTT˜˜

4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL

background image

ha’’apm˜pm›pd˜©’›Fh

m˜›^F˜am›FF’›˜pO˜4dF"m˜"a

7VSS\[PVUVMV\YLU]PYVUTLU[OHZILJVTLHWYVIÌ

SLT[OH[PZVMPUJYLHZPUNJVUJLYU[VHSSVM\Z>L

\YNL`V\[VQVPU\ZPUV\YLMMVY[ZMVYJSLHULYHPY

PU JVU[YVSSPUN [OL WVSS\[HU[Z LTP[[LK MYVT [OL

H\[VTVIPSL

7VYZJOLOHZKL]LSVWLKHULTPZZPVUJVU[YVSZ`ZÌ

[LT [OH[ JVU[YVSZ VY YLK\JLZ [OVZLWHY[ZVM[OL

LTPZZPVU [OH[ JHU IL OHYTM\S [V V\Y LU]PYVUÌ

TLU[@V\Y7VYZJOLPZLX\PWWLK^P[OZ\JOHZ`ZÌ

[LT

7VYZJOL ^HYYHU[Z [OL ,TPZZPVU *VU[YVS :`Z[LT

PU `V\Y UL^ JHY \UKLY [OL [LYTZ HUK JVUKP[PVUZ

ZL[MVY[OPU[OL>HYYHU[`)VVRSL[

@V\ HZ [OL V^ULY VM [OL ]LOPJSL OH]L [OL

YLZWVUZPIPSP[` [V WYV]PKL YLN\SHY THPU[LUHUJL

ZLY]PJL MVY [OL ]LOPJSL HUK [V RLLW H YLJVYK VM

HSS THPU[LUHUJL ^VYR WLYMVYTLK ;V MHJPSP[H[L

YLJVYK RLLWPUN OH]L [OL ZLY]PJL WLYMVYTLK I`

H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLYZ ;OL` OH]L 7VYZJOL

[YHPULK [LJOUPJPHUZ HUK ZWLJPHS [VVSZ [V WYV]PKL

MHZ[HUKLMMPJPLU[ZLY]PJL

;VHZZ\YLLMMPJPLU[VWLYH[PVUVM[OL

,TPZZPVU*VU[YVS:`Z[LT!

/H]L `V\Y ]LOPJSL THPU[HPULK WYVWLYS` HUK PU

HJJVYKHUJL ^P[O [OL YLJVTTLUKH[PVUZ KLÌ

ZJYPILKPU`V\Y4HPU[LUHUJL)VVRSL[

3HJR VM WYVWLY THPU[LUHUJL HZ ^LSS HZ PTÌ

WYVWLY\ZLVM[OL]LOPJSL^PSSPTWHPY[OLM\UJÌ

[PVUVM[OLLTPZZPVUJVU[YVSZ`Z[LTHUKJV\SK

SLHK[VKHTHNL

+VUV[HS[LYVYYLTV]LHU`JVTWVULU[VM[OL

LTPZZPVUJVU[YVSZ`Z[LT

+V UV[ HS[LY VY YLTV]L HU` KL]PJL Z\JO HZ

OLH[ ZOPLSKZ Z^P[JOLZ PNUP[PVU ^PYLZ ]HS]LZ

L[J^OPJOHYLKLZPNULK[VWYV[LJ[`V\Y]LOPÌ

JSLqZLTPZZPVUJVU[YVSZ`Z[LT

0UHKKP[PVU[VZLYPV\ZLUNPULKHTHNL[OPZJHU

YLZ\S[ PU H MPYL PM L_JLZZ YH^ M\LS YLHJOLZ [OL

L_OH\Z[Z`Z[LT

+VUV[JVU[PU\L[VVWLYH[L`V\Y]LOPJSLPM`V\

KL[LJ[ LUNPUL TPZMPYL VY V[OLY \U\Z\HS VWLYHÌ

[PUNJVUKP[PVUZ

"camV

>HYUPUN

+HUNLYVMMPYL

+V UV[ WHYR VY VWLYH[L [OL ]LOPJSL PU HYLHZ

^OLYL [OL OV[ L_OH\Z[ Z`Z[LT TH` JVTL PU

JVU[HJ[ ^P[O KY` NYHZZ IY\ZO M\LS ZWPSS VY

V[OLYMSHTTHISLTH[LYPHS

0M`V\YJHYJH[JOLZVUMPYLMVYHU`YLHZVUJHSS

[OLMPYLKLWHY[TLU[

+V UV[ LUKHUNLY `V\Y SPML I` H[[LTW[PUN [V

W\[V\[[OLMPYL

m=F4p"›amV

>HYUPUN

+HUNLY VM MPYL HUK ZLYPV\Z WLYZVUHS PUÍ

Q\YPLZ

+V UV[ HWWS` HKKP[PVUHS \UKLYJVH[PUN VY Y\Z[Ì

WYVVMPUN VU VY ULHY [OL L_OH\Z[ THUPMVSK L_Ì

OH\Z[ WPWLZ JH[HS`[PJ JVU]LY[LYZ VY OLH[

ZOPLSKZ+\YPUNKYP]PUN[OLZ\IZ[HUJL\ZLKMVY

\UKLYJVH[PUNJV\SKV]LYOLH[HUKPNUP[L

4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL

sTQ

background image

p§˜ha’’apm˜pm›pd˜pc’

>OLU HU H\[VTVIPSL LUNPUL PZ Y\UUPUN P[ \ZLZ

LULYN` NLULYH[LK [OYV\NO [OL JVTI\Z[PVU VM H

TP_[\YLVMHPYHUKM\LS+LWLUKPUNVU^OL[OLYH

JHY PZ KYP]LU MHZ[ VY ZSV^S` VY ^OL[OLY [OL LUÌ

NPUL PZ JVSK VY OV[ ZVTL VM [OL M\LS O`KYVJHYÌ

IVUZ TH` UV[ IL I\YULK JVTWSL[LS` I\[ TH`

IL KPZJOHYNLK PU[V [OL LUNPUL JYHURJHZL VY L_Ì

OH\Z[Z`Z[LT(KKP[VUHSO`KYVJHYIVUZTH`LU[LY

[OLH[TVZWOLYL[OYV\NOL]HWVYH[PVUVMM\LSMYVT

[OLM\LS[HUR;OLZLO`KYVJHYIVUZ/*^OLUYLÌ

SLHZLKPU[V[OLHPYJVU[YPI\[L[V\UKLZPYHISLWVSÌ

S\[PVU

0UHKKP[PVUJHYIVUTVUV_PKL*6HUKV_PKLZVM

UP[YVNLU 56_ JVU[YPI\[L [V LUNPUL LTPZZPVUZ

;OL` [VV HYL MVYTLK K\YPUN [OL JVTI\Z[PVU

WYVJLZZ HUK KPZJOHYNLK PU[V [OL L_OH\Z[ Z`ZÌ

[LT

;V YLK\JL [OLZL WVSS\[HU[Z `V\Y 7VYZJOL PZ

LX\PWWLK^P[OHWYLJPZLS`JHSPIYH[LKM\LSPUQLJ[PVU

Z`Z[LT [V HZZ\YL H MPULS` IHSHUJLK HPYM\LS TP_Ì

[\YL\UKLYHSSVWLYH[PUNJVUKP[PVUZ

¨©VFm˜’Fm’p

;OLV_`NLUZLUZVYPUZ[HSSLKPU[OLL_OH\Z[WPWL

JVU[PU\V\ZS` ZLUZLZ [OL V_`NLU JVU[LU[ VM [OL

L_OH\Z[ HUK ZPNUHSZ [OL PUMVYTH[PVU [V HU LSLJÌ

[YVUPJ JVU[YVS \UP[ ;OL JVU[YVS \UP[ JVYYLJ[Z [OL

HPYM\LS YH[PV ZV [OL LUNPUL HS^H`Z YLJLP]LZ HU

HJJ\YH[LS`TL[LYLKHPYM\LSTP_[\YL

"mc4"’F˜¦Fm›ad"›apm

;OYV\NO JYHURJHZL ]LU[PSH[PVU \UKLZPYHISL

LTPZZPVUZ MYVT [OL LUNPUL JYHURJHZL HYL UV[

WLYTP[[LK [V YLHJO [OL V\[ZPKL H[TVZWOLYL

;OLZL LTPZZPVUZ HYL YLJPYJ\SH[LK MYVT [OL

JYHURJHZL [V [OL HPY PU[HRL Z`Z[LT -YVT OLYL

[OL LTPZZPVUZ TP_ ^P[O [OL PU[HRL HPY HUK HYL

SH[LYI\YULKPU[OLLUNPUL

"›"d©›a4˜4pm¦F›F’

;OL JH[HS`[PJ JVU]LY[LYZ HYL LMMPJPLU[ sJSLHUÌ\Wr

KL]PJLZ I\PS[ PU[V [OL L_OH\Z[ Z`Z[LT VM [OL ]LÌ

OPJSL ;OL JH[HS`[PJ JVU]LY[LYZ I\YU [OL \UKLZPYÌ

HISL WVSS\[HU[Z PU [OL L_OH\Z[ NHZ ILMVYL P[ PZ

YLSLHZLKPU[V[OLH[TVZWOLYL

;OL L_JS\ZP]L \ZL VM \USLHKLK M\LS PZ JYP[PÍ

JHSS` PTWVY[HU[ MVY [OL SPML VM [OL JH[HS`[PJ

JVU]LY[LYZ ;OLYLMVYL VUS` \USLHKLK M\LS

T\Z[IL\ZLK

;OLJH[HS`[PJJVU]LY[LYZ^PSSILKHTHNLK

I`!



W\ZOVY[V^Z[HY[PUN[OL]LOPJSL



TPZMPYPUNVM[OLLUNPUL



[\YUPUN VMM [OL PNUP[PVU ^OPSL [OL ]LOPJSL PZ

TV]PUNVY



KYP]PUN\U[PS[OLM\LS[HURPZJVTWSL[LS`LTW[`



I`V[OLY\U\Z\HSVWLYH[PUNJVUKP[PVUZ

+VUV[JVU[PU\L[VVWLYH[L`V\Y]LOPJSL\UKLY

[OLZL JVUKP[PVUZ ZPUJL YH^ M\LS TPNO[ YLHJO

[OL JH[HS`[PJ JVU]LY[LYZ ;OPZ JV\SK YLZ\S[ PU

V]LYOLH[PUN VM [OL JVU]LY[LYZ -LKLYHS SH^

WYVOPIP[Z\ZLVMSLHKLKM\LSPU[OPZJHY

sT–˜˜

4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL

background image

¤Fd˜¦"zp"›apm˜pm›pd

¤Fd˜›"mc˜¦Fm›amV

;OL L]HWVYH[PVU JOHTILY HUK [OL JHYIVU JHUPZÌ

[LY WYL]LU[ M\LS MYVT LZJHWPUN [V [OL H[TVZÌ

WOLYL H[ L_[YLTL OPNO V\[ZPKL [LTWLYH[\YLZ

^OLU KYP]PUN HIY\W[S` HYV\UK J\Y]LZ HUK ^OLU

[OL JHY PZ WHYRLK H[ HU PUJSPUL VY PU HU` V[OLY

UVUSL]LSWVZP[PVU

"zp˜4pm›pd˜’©’›Fh˜"m=˜’›p"VF

>OLU[OLM\LS[HURPZMPSSLK]HWVYZHYLJVSSLJ[LK

PU [OL L]HWVYH[PVU JOHTILY I` H ]LU[ SPUL SLHKÌ

PUN[OL]HWVYZ[V[OLJHYIVUJHUPZ[LY^OLYL[OL`

HYLZ[VYLKHZSVUNHZ[OLLUNPULKVLZUV[Y\U

¤VF˜’©’›Fh

>OLU[OLLUNPULPZY\UUPUN[OLM\LS]HWVYZMYVT

[OLJHUPZ[LY^PSSILTP_LK^P[OMYLZOHPYMYVT[OL

HTIPLU[ HPY VM [OL JHUPZ[LY ;OPZ TP_[\YL ^PSS IL

KPYLJ[LK [V [OL PU[HRL HPY OV\ZPUN I` [OL [HUR

]LU[ SPUL TP_LK ^P[O [OL PU[HRL HPY HUK I\YULK

K\YPUNUVYTHSJVTI\Z[PVU

"’^F˜ d¤a=

;OL YLZLY]VPY ^P[O H IS\L ZJYL^ JHW PZ PU [OL

S\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[[V[OLYLHYSLM[

*HWHJP[`!HWWYV_PTH[LS` X\HY[ZSP[LYZ

*SLHU^H[LYPZNLULYHSS`UV[LUV\NO[VJSLHU[OL

^PUKZOPLSKHUKOLHKSPNO[Z

0[PZHK]HU[HNLV\Z[VHKKH^PU[LYJSLHULYNP]PUN

HU[PMYLLaL WYV[LJ[PVU VY H Z\P[HISL Z\TTLY

JSLHULYKLWLUKPUNVU[OLZLHZVU-VSSV^[OLPUÌ

Z[Y\J[PVUZMVY[OLTP_PUNYH[PV

+V UV[ \ZL LUNPUL JVVSHU[ HU[PÌMYLLaL VY HU`

V[OLY ZVS\[PVU [OH[ JHU KHTHNL [OL JHYqZ

WHPU[PU[OL^HZOLYYLZLY]VPY

7SLHZL UV[L HSS [OL PUMVYTH[PVU VU [OL JVUÌ

[HPULYVM[OLJSLHUPUNHNLU[

"mamV˜daV^›

;OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[ WHULS HUK

VUÌIVHYK JVTW\[LY SPNO[ ^OLU HWWYV_PTH[LS`

SP[LYPZSLM[PU[OLYLZLY]VPY

4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL

sT•

background image

p§F˜›FFamV˜"m=˜d¤›4^

7V^LYZ[LLYPUNHUKJS\[JOHJ[\H[PVUHYLHZZPZ[LK

I`O`KYH\SPJH\_PSPHY`MVYJLZ

;OLO`KYH\SPJMS\PKYLZLY]VPYPZSVJH[LKPU[OLLUÌ

NPULJVTWHY[TLU[

5V[L
;OL MSV^ UVPZL OLHYK H[ M\SS Z[LLYPUN SVJR PZ KLÌ

ZPNUÌYLSH[LK HUK KVLZ UV[ PUKPJH[L H KLMLJ[ PU

[OLZ[LLYPUNZ`Z[LT

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMHJJPKLU[

>OLU [OL LUNPUL PZ Z[VWWLK LN ^OLU VU

[V^ VY [OL O`KYH\SPJ Z`Z[LT MHPSZ [OLYL PZ

UV HZZPZ[HUJL MVY Z[LLYPUN VYMVYJS\[JOHJÍ

[\H[PVU

;OLYLMVYL Z\IZ[HU[PHSS` TVYL MVYJL ^PSS

OH]L [V IL L_LY[LK PU VYKLY [V Z[LLY VY [V

HJ[\H[L[OLJS\[JO

,_LYJPZLNYLH[JHYL^OLUILPUN[V^LK

/H]L [OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[`V\YULHYLZ[H\[OÌ

VYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

^F4camV˜^©="¤da4˜Od¤a=

-VSSV^[OLPUZ[Y\J[PVUZPU[OLs*H\[PVUZrJOHW[LY

6US`\ZLO`KYH\SPJMS\PKH\[OVYPaLKI`7VYZJOL

:WLJPMPJH[PVU!ZLLJOHW[LYVUs*HWHJP[PLZr

*OLJR [OL MS\PK SL]LS ^P[O [OL LUNPUL Z[VWWLK

HUKJVSKHWWYV_PTH[LS`‰-‰

 :[HY[ [OL LUNPUL HUK SL[ P[ PKSL MVY HWWYV_

ZLJVUKZ

:^P[JOVMM[OLLUNPUL

 6WLU[OLLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[SPK

 6WLU[OLYLZLY]VPYJHW

 >PWLTLHZ\YPUNYVK

*SVZL JHW HUK YLVWLU ;OL MS\PK SL]LS ZOV\SK

SPLPU[OLHYLHILSV^[OLs*VSKrTHYRPUN

(KKO`KYH\SPJMS\PKPMULJLZZHY`

 *SVZLJHWJHYLM\SS`

*SVZLLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[SPK

5V[PJLHISL SVZZ VM MS\PK PUKPJH[LZ SLHRHNL PU [OL

Z`Z[LT

;OL JH\ZL ZOV\SK IL YLTLKPLK PTTLKPH[LS` H[

HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

sTG˜˜

4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL

background image

a˜ ad›F

( KPY[` HPY MPS[LY UV[ VUS` YLK\JLZ LUNPUL WLYMVYÌ

THUJLI\[JHUSLHK[VWYLTH[\YLLUNPUL^LHY

9LN\SHY MPS[LY YLWSHJLTLU[ PZ WHY[ VM [OL YV\[PUL

THPU[LUHUJLZLY]PJL

0U K\Z[` JVUKP[PVUZ JOLJR [OL MPS[LY LSLTLU[

TVYLMYLX\LU[S`HUKYLWSHJLPMULJLZZHY`

"›a4dF˜ ad›F

;OL MYLZO HPY WHZZPUN [OYV\NO [OL WHY[PJSL MPS[LY

PU[V [OL WHZZLUNLY JVTWHY[TLU[ PZ]PY[\HSS`MYLL

VMK\Z[HUKWVSSLU

0M[OLV\[ZPKLHPYPZWVSS\[LKI`L_OH\Z[M\TLZ

WYLZZ[OLJPYJ\SH[PUNÌHPYI\[[VU

( KPY[` MPS[LY JHU IL [OL JH\ZL VM YLK\JLK HPY

MSV^!

/H]L MPS[LY YLWSHJLK I` `V\Y H\[OVYPaLK

7VYZJOLKLHSLY

9LN\SHY MPS[LY YLWSHJLTLU[ PZ WHY[ VM [OL YV\[PUL

THPU[LUHUJLZLY]PJL

¤›ph"›a4˜"m’ha’’apm˜ d¤a=˜

;OL [VYX\L JVU]LY[LY HUK [OL [YHUZTPZZPVU HYL

S\IYPJH[LK ^P[O (\[VTH[PJ ;YHUZTPZZPVU -S\PK

(;- ;OL MPUHS KYP]L YLX\PYLZ [YHUZTPZZPVU VPS

:LLs*HWHJP[PLZr

+V UV[ [V^ [OL JHY VY Y\U [OL LUNPUL ^P[OV\[

(;- PU [OL [YHUZTPZZPVU ;OL H\[VTH[PJ [YHUZÌ

TPZZPVU TH` IL KHTHNLK I` L]LU H [PU` ZWLJR

VM KPY[ VUS` H JSLHU M\UULS VY ZWV\[ T\Z[ IL

\ZLK^OLUHKKPUN(;-

;OL(;-HUK[YHUZTPZZPVUVPSOHZ[VILJOLJRLK

HUKJOHUNLKH[[OLPU[LY]HSZSPZ[LKPU`V\Y4HPUÌ

[LUHUJL:JOLK\SL

>LYLJVTTLUK[OH[`V\OH]L[OL(;-HUK[YHUZÌ

TPZZPVUVPSJOHUNLKH[`V\Y7VYZJOLKLHSLY^OV

OHZ [OL YLX\PYLK S\IYPJHU[Z HUK [OL ULJLZZHY`

MPSSPUNLX\PWTLU[

0M `V\ Z\ZWLJ[ HU VPS SLHR PU [OL [YHUZTPZZPVU

OH]L `V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY JOLJR P[

V\[PTTLKPH[LS`

"m¤"d˜"m’ha’’apm˜ad

;OL [YHUZTPZZPVU VPS OHZ [V IL JOLJRLK HUK

JOHUNLK H[ [OL PU[LY]HSZ SPZ[LK PU `V\Y 4HPU[LUÌ

HUJL:JOLK\SL:LLs*HWHJP[PLZr

>L YLJVTTLUK [OH[ `V\ OH]L [OL [YHUZTPZZPVU

VPSJOHUNLKH[`V\Y7VYZJOLKLHSLY^OVOHZ[OL

YLX\PYLK S\IYPJHU[Z HUK [OL ULJLZZHY` MPSSPUN

LX\PWTLU[

0M `V\ Z\ZWLJ[ HU VPS SLHR PU [OL [YHUZTPZZPVU

OH]L `V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY JOLJR P[

V\[PTTLKPH[LS`

p§F˜F"’¤FhFm›’

7V^LYTLHZ\YLTLU[ZVUK`UHTVTL[LYZHYLUV[

HWWYV]LKI`7VYZJOL

4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL

sTn

background image

(Í7HZZLUNLYqZZPKL

)Í+YP]LYqZZPKL

azF˜d"=F’

>OLU^PWLYWLYMVYTHUJLKL[LYPVYH[LZYLWSHJL

[OL^PWLYZ

-VSSV^[OLPUZ[Y\J[PVUZPU[OLs*HY*HYLrJOHWÌ

[LY

*H\[PVU

9PZR VM KHTHNL PM [OL ^PWLY HYT HJJPKLUÍ

[HSS`MHSSZIHJRVU[V[OL^PUKV^

(S^H`Z OVSK [OL ^PWLY HYT ZLJ\YLS` ^OLU YLÌ

WSHJPUN[OL^PWLYISHKL

9PZR VM KHTHNL PM ^PWLY ISHKLZ [OH[ HYL

MYVaLUPUWSHJLHYLSVVZLULKPTWYVWLYS`

;OH^[OL^PWLYISHKLZILMVYLSVVZLUPUN[OLT

 7\SSV\[PNUP[PVURL`

-VSK^PWLYHYTH^H`MYVT[OL^PUKV^

 7YLZZ[VNL[OLY[OLWSHZ[PJZWYPUNVM[OL^PWLY

ISHKLYPNO[HYYV^

7\SS^PWLYISHKLV\[VM^PWLYHYT

 0UZLY[ UL^ ^PWLY ISHKL HUK LUZ\YL P[ LUÌ

NHNLZ

,UZ\YL [OH[ [OL UL^ ^PWLY ISHKL NVLZ PU[V

[OLZHTLWVZP[PVUKPYLJ[PVUVMZWVPSLYPU[OL

^PWLYHYTHUKLUNHNLZ

 *HYLM\SS` MVSK ^PWLY HYT IHJR VU [V [OL ^PUÌ

KV^

sQ¬˜˜

4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL

background image

"˜"F˜ m’›¤4›apm’

-VSSV^ [OL PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ PU [OL s*H\[PVUZr

JOHW[LY

9LN\SHYHUKJVYYLJ[JHYLOLSWZ[VTHPU[HPU

[OL]HS\LVM`V\YJHYHUKPZHSZVHWYLJVUÍ

KP[PVUMVY[OL5L^=LOPJSL>HYYHU[`HUK[OL

(U[P*VYYVZPVU>HYYHU[`

@V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY OHZ ZWLÍ

JPHSS`KL]LSVWLKJHYÍJHYLWYVK\J[ZMYVT[OL

7VYZJOL WYVNYHT H]HPSHISL LP[OLY ZPUNS` VY

HZ JVTWSL[L JHYÍJHYL ZL[Z ;OL` ^PSS IL

WSLHZLK [V OLSW `V\ ZLSLJ[ Z\P[HISL WYVÍ

K\J[Z

>OL[OLY`V\\ZL7VYZJOLWYVK\J[ZVYV[OLY

JVTTLYJPHSS`H]HPSHISLJSLHUPUNHNLU[ZMPYZ[

THRLZ\YLVM[OLPYJVYYLJ[HWWSPJH[PVU

( 7VYZJOL [OH[ PZ ^LSSÌJHYLK MVY JHU SVVR SPRL

UL^ MVY `LHYZ 0[ HSS KLWLUKZ VU [OL HTV\U[ VM

JHYL[OLV^ULYPZ^PSSPUN[VNP]L[OLJHY

>HYUPUN

9PZR VM ZLYPV\Z WLYZVUHS PUQ\Y` VY KHTHNL

[V[OL]LOPJSLVYWYVWLY[`

*SLHUPUN HNLU[Z TH` ILOHaHYKV\Z[V`V\Y

OLHS[O

4VZ[ JOLTPJHS JSLHULYZ HYL JVUJLU[YH[LZ

^OPJO YLX\PYL KPS\[PVU /PNO JVUJLU[YH[PVUZ

TPNO[ JH\ZL WYVISLTZ YHUNPUN MYVT PYYP[HÍ

[PVU [V ZLYPV\Z PUQ\Y` HZ ^LSS HZ KHTHNL [V

`V\Y]LOPJSL

2LLWJSLHUPUNHNLU[ZV\[VMYLHJOMYVTJOPSKÌ

YLU

6IZLY]LHSSJH\[PVUSHILSZ

(S^H`Z YLHK KPYLJ[PVUZ VU [OL JVU[HPULY ILÌ

MVYL \ZPUN HU` WYVK\J[ ;OLZL KPYLJ[PVUZTH`

JVU[HPU PUMVYTH[PVU ULJLZZHY` [V H]VPK WLYÌ

ZVUHSPUQ\Y`

+VUV[\ZLM\LSRLYVZLULUHWO[OHUHPSWVSPZO

YLTV]LYVYV[OLY]VSH[PSLJSLHUPUNMS\PKZ;OL`

TH` IL [V_PJ MSHTTHISL VY OHaHYKV\Z PU

V[OLY^H`Z6US`\ZLZWV[YLTV]PUNMS\PKZPUH

^LSS]LU[LKHYLH

+V UV[ JSLHU [OL \UKLYZPKL VM JOHZZPZ MLUÌ

KLYZ ^OLLS JV]LYZ L[J ^P[OV\[ WYV[LJ[PUN

`V\Y OHUKZ HUK HYTZ HZ `V\ TH` J\[ `V\YÌ

ZLSMVUZOHYWÌLKNLKTL[HSWHY[Z

4VPZ[\YL HUK YVHK ZHS[ VU IYHRLZ TH` HMMLJ[

IYHRPUNLMMPJPLUJ`

;LZ[[OLIYHRLZHM[LYLHJO]LOPJSL^HZOPUN

4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL

sQs

background image

"’^amV

;OL ILZ[ TL[OVK VM WYV[LJ[PUN `V\Y JHY MYVT

[OL KHTHNPUN LMMLJ[Z VM [OL LU]PYVUTLU[ PZ MYLÌ

X\LU[ ^HZOPUN HUK [OL HWWSPJH[PVU VM H WYLZLY]Ì

H[P]L ;OL \UKLYZPKL VM `V\Y ]LOPJSL ZOV\SK HSZV

IL^HZOLK[OVYV\NOS`H[[OLSH[LZ[^OLUZHS[PZ

UVSVUNLYZWYLHKVU[OLYVHKZ

;OL SVUNLY ZHS[ YVHK K\Z[ HUK PUK\Z[YPHS K\Z[

KLHKPUZLJ[ZIPYKKYVWWPUNZVYZ\IZ[HUJLZMYVT

[YLLZYLZPUWVSSLUHYLHSSV^LK[VYLTHPUVU[OL

IVK`^VYR [OL TVYL ZLYPV\Z PZ [OLPY OHYTM\S LMÌ

MLJ[

5L^JHYZZOV\SKIL^HZOLKJHYLM\SS`^P[OWSLU[`

VM JSLHY ^H[LY [V WYV[LJ[ [OL UL^ WHPU[ ^VYR

+HYR WHPU[ MPUPZOLZ ZOV^ \W [OL ZTHSSLZ[ VM Z\YÌ

MHJLKHTHNLLNZJYH[JOLZTVYLYLHKPS`[OHU

SPNO[LYJVSVYZ

+HYR JVSVYZ HYL HSZV TVYL Z\ZJLW[PISL [V

ZJYH[JOPUN ILJH\ZL VM [OL JVTWVZP[PVU VM [OLPY

WPNTLU[Z HUK YLX\PYL WHY[PJ\SHYS` JHYLM\S WHPU[

JHYL

+V UV[ ^HZO `V\Y JHY PU IYPNO[ Z\USPNO[ VY

^OPSL[OLIVK`^VYRPZZ[PSSOV[

>OLU ^HZOPUN I` OHUK \ZL HI\UKHU[ ^H[LY

H ZVM[ ZWVUNL VY ^HZO IY\ZO HUK 7VYZJOL

JHYZOHTWVV

)LNPU I` ZWYH`PUN [OL IVK` [OVYV\NOS` ^P[O

^H[LY[VYPUZLH^H`SVVZLKPY[

(M[LY ^HZOPUN YPUZL [OL JHY ^P[O WSLU[` VM

^H[LYHUK[OLUKY`^P[OHJOHTVPZSLH[OLY

+V UV[ \ZL [OL ZHTL JOHTVPZ SLH[OLY MVY

KY`PUN HZ `V\ \ZL MVY JSLHUPUN [OL ^PUKZOPLSK

HUK^PUKV^Z

>HYUPUN

4VPZ[\YL^OPJONL[ZVU[V[OLIYHRLZK\YPUN

HJHY^HZOJHUYLK\JLIYHRPUNLMMPJPLUJ`VY

THRL [OL IYHRLZ W\SS \UL]LUS` ^OPJO JV\SK

PUJYLHZL [OL KHUNLY VM HU HJJPKLU[ JH\ZPUN

ZLYPV\ZWLYZVUHSPUQ\YPLZVYKLH[O

(S^H`Z HWWS` [OL IYHRLZ H ML^ [PTLZ HM[LY

^HZOPUN [OL JHY [V [LZ[ IYHRPUN LMMPJPLUJ` HUK

KY`[OLIYHRLKPZJZ

>OLU KVPUN [OPZ [HRL JHYL UV[ [V OHTWLY

V[OLYYVHK\ZLYZILOPUK`V\[YHMMPJJVUKP[PVUZ

WLYTP[[PUN

(\[VTH[PJJHY^HZOLZ
6W[PVUHS HKKÌVU WHY[Z VY WHY[Z ^OPJO WYVQLJ[

IL`VUK [OL JVU[V\YZ VM [OL ]LOPJSL TH` IL

KHTHNLK I` KLZPNU MLH[\YLZ LN IY\ZOLZ VM

H\[VTH[PJJHY^HZOLZ

;OLMVSSV^PUNWHY[ZHYLWHY[PJ\SHYS`Z\ZJLWÍ

[PISL[VKHTHNL!



>PUKZOPLSK ^PWLYZ HS^H`Z Z^P[JO [OLT VMM [V

WYL]LU[[OLT^PWPUN\UPU[LU[PVUHSS`PUPU[LYTP[Ì

[LU[VYZLUZVYVWLYH[PVU



,_[LYUHS[LSLWOVULHU[LUUHZHS^H`Z\UZJYL^



9VVM ;YHUZWVY[ :`Z[LT HS^H`Z YLTV]L JVTÌ

WSL[LS`



-P_LKYLHYZWVPSLYVYL_[LUKLKYLHYZWVPSLYKV

UV[ ^HZO [OL ]LOPJSL ^P[O P[Z YLHY ZWVPSLY L_Ì

[LUKLK



>OLLSZ [OL ^PKLY [OL YPT HUK [OL SV^LY [OL

[PYLOLPNO[[OLNYLH[LY[OLYPZRVMKHTHNL



/PNOÌNSVZZ ^OLLSZ [V WYL]LU[ [OLZLMYVTNL[Ì

[PUN ZJYH[JOLK KV UV[ JSLHU ^P[O [OL ^OLLSÌ

JSLHUPUNIY\ZOLZVM[OLJHY^HZO

7SLHZLJVUZ\S[[OLVWLYH[VYILMVYL\ZPUNH\[VÌ

TH[PJJHY^HZOLZ

>HZO HUK KY` I` OHUK HSS WVPU[Z UV[ YLHJOLK

I`HJHY^HZOZ\JOHZKVVYHUKSPKZLHTZVY

KVVYZPSSZ

5V[L
(\[VTH[PJ JHY ^HZOLZ ZWYH` ^H[LY H[ VKK

HUNSLZ HUK OPNO WYLZZ\YLZ ^OPJO HYL UV[ ZLLU

PU UVYTHS KYP]PUN ;OLYLMVYL ^H[LY JHU ZVTLÌ

[PTLZ MPUK P[Z ^H` PU[V [OL WHZZLUNLYZ JVTWHY[Ì

TLU[K\YPUNVYZOVY[S`HM[LY[OLJHY^HZO

sQ¢˜˜

4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL

background image

pp˜dp4c’

;V WYL]LU[ [OL KVVY SVJRZ MYVT MYLLaPUN K\YÌ

PUN[OLJVSKZLHZVU[OLSVJRJ`SPUKLYZZOV\SK

ILJV]LYLKK\YPUNH^HZO

:OV\SK [OL SVJRZ MYLLaL \ZL HU VYKPUHY` KLÌ

PJLY 0U THU` JHZLZ H ^LSS ^HYTLK RL` JHU

OLSW

5L]LY\ZLL_JLZZP]LMVYJL

"am›

5L]LY Y\I H K\Z[` JHY ^P[O H KY` JSV[O ZPUJL

K\Z[WHY[PJSLZHYLHIYHZP]LHUKJV\SKK\SSHUK

KHTHNL[OLZ\YMHJLMPUPZO

;OL WHPU[^VYR VM `V\Y JHY PZ L_WVZLK [V HSS

[`WLZ VM TLJOHUPJHS HUK JOLTPJHS JVUKP[PVUZ

WHY[PJ\SHYS`JSPTH[PJVULZZ\JOHZIYPNO[Z\USPNO[

YHPU MYVZ[ HUK ZUV^ <S[YH]PVSL[ SPNO[ YHWPK

JOHUNLZ PU [LTWLYH[\YL YHPU ZUV^ PUK\Z[YPHS

K\Z[HUKJOLTPJHSKLWVZP[ZJVUZ[HU[S`H[[HJR[OL

WHPU[ ^OPJO PZ VUS` HISL [V ^P[OZ[HUK Z\JOL_WVÌ

Z\YL PU [OL SVUN [LYT PM P[ PZ NP]LU YLN\SHY JHYL

HUKH[[LU[PVU

+V UV[ HWWS` ZPSPJVUL WVSPZOLZ [V [OL ^PUKÌ

ZOPLSKHUK^PUKV^Z

+V UV[ [YLH[ TH[[ÌWHPU[LK JVTWVULU[Z ^P[O

WYLZLY]H[P]LZVYWVSPZOLZHZ[OPZ^PSSZWVPS[OL

TH[[LLMMLJ[

7YLZLY]H[PVU
;OLWHPU[Z\YMHJLILJVTLZK\SSV]LY[PTLK\L[V

^LH[OLYPUN0[PZ[OLYLMVYLULJLZZHY`[VWYLZLY]L

[OLWHPU[YLN\SHYS`

;OPZ RLLWZ [OL WHPU[ ZOPU` HUK LSHZ[PJ +PY[ PZ

WYL]LU[LK MYVT HKOLYPUN [V [OL WHPU[ Z\YMHJL

HUKPUK\Z[YPHSK\Z[PZWYL]LU[LKMYVTWLUL[YH[PUN

[OLWHPU[

7YV]PKLK P[ PZ ^HZOLK HUK [YLH[LK ^P[O WYLZLY]Ì

H[P]L YLN\SHYS` [OL IYHUK UL^ MPUPZO VM `V\Y JHY

^PSSILYL[HPULKMVY`LHYZ[VJVTL

(WWS`[OL7VYZJOLWHPU[WYLZLY]H[P]LHM[LY[OL

JHY ^HZO HUK WVSPZO P[ KY` [V VI[HPU H IYPNO[

MPUPZOVYZPTWS`HKKHSPX\PKWYLZLY]H[P]LYLN\Ì

SHYS`[V[OLMPUHSYPUZL^H[LY

7VSPZOPUN
+V UV[ YLZVY[ [V \ZPUN 7VYZJOL WVSPZO \U[PS P[

ILJVTLZ L]PKLU[ [OH[ [OL UVYTHS WYLZLY]H[P]LZ

UVSVUNLYWYVK\JL[OLKLZPYLKMPUPZO

:WV[ZHUKZ[HPUZ

9LTV]L[HYZ[HPUZNYLHZLVPSZWV[ZHUKKLHK

PUZLJ[Z HZ ZVVU HZ WVZZPISL ^P[O 0UZLJ[

9LTV]LY ;OL` JHU JH\ZL KPZJVSVYH[PVU PM

HSSV^LK[VYLTHPUVU[OLWHPU[^VYR

>HZO [OL HMMLJ[LK HYLH PTTLKPH[LS` HM[LY

[YLH[PUNP[

4PUVYWHPU[KHTHNL

/H]LTPUVYWHPU[KHTHNLZ\JOHZZJYH[JOLZ

ZJVYLZ VY JOPWZ JH\ZLK I` MS`PUN Z[VULZ YLÌ

WHPYLK PTTLKPH[LS` I` `V\Y H\[OVYPaLK

7VYZJOLKLHSLYILMVYLJVYYVZPVUZL[ZPU

/V^L]LY PM [OLYL HYL HSYLHK` [YHJLZ VM JVYYVÌ

ZPVU [OL` T\Z[ MPYZ[ IL YLTV]LK JHYLM\SS` HUK

[OVYV\NOS` *VH[ [OL HYLH ^P[O H Y\Z[ÌWYVVMPUN

WYPTLY HUK MPUPZO VMM ^P[O H [VW JVH[ ;OL WHPU[

JVKL HUK JVSVY U\TILY HYL MV\UK VU [OL ]LOPÌ

JSLqZWHPU[KH[HWSH[L

4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL

sQ

background image

mVamF˜4phz"›hFm›

;OLLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[HUK[OLZ\YMHJLVM[OL

LUNPUL HYL [YLH[LK ^P[O H JVYYVZPVUÌPUOPIP[VY H[

[OLMHJ[VY`

0MKLNYLHZPUNZVS]LU[ZHYL\ZLK[VJSLHU[OLLUÌ

NPUL JVTWHY[TLU[ VY [OL LUNPUL PZ ^HZOLK

KV^U [OL WYVJLZZ HSTVZ[ PU]HYPHIS` YLTV]LZ

[OL JVYYVZPVUÌPUOPIP[PUN JVH[PUN 0[ PZ [OLU HIZVÌ

S\[LS` ULJLZZHY` [V OH]L H K\YHISL WYLZLY]H[P]L

HWWSPLK [V HSS Z\YMHJLZ IVK` ZLHTZ QVPU[Z HUK

HZZLTISPLZPU[OLLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[;OPZHSZV

HWWSPLZ ^OLU JVYYVZPVUÌPUOPIP[VY WHY[Z HYL YLÌ

WSHJLK

,MMLJ[P]LJVYYVZPVUÌWYVVMPUNPZWHY[PJ\SHYS`PTWVY[Ì

HU[ K\YPUN [OL JVSK ^LH[OLY ZLHZVU 0M `V\Y JHY

PZKYP]LUMYLX\LU[S`PUHYLHZ^OLYLZHS[OHZILLU

ZWYLHKVU[OLYVHKZ[OL^OVSLLUNPULJVTWHY[Ì

TLU[ ZOV\SK IL JSLHULK [OVYV\NOS` HM[LY [OL

^PU[LY [V WYL]LU[ ZHS[ MYVT JH\ZPUN HU` SHZ[PUN

KHTHNL ( M\SS \UKLYÌIVK` ^HZO ZOV\SK HSZV IL

WLYMVYTLKH[[OLZHTL[PTL

*H\[PVU

9PZRVMKHTHNL[V[OLNLULYH[VY

+V UV[ WVPU[ [OL JSLHUPUN QL[ KPYLJ[S` H[ [OL

NLULYH[VYVYJV]LY[OLNLULYH[VY

am=p§’

;OL YVHK K\Z[ ^OPJO ZL[[SLZ VU [OL ^PUKZOPLSK

HUK ^PUKV^Z JVU[HPUZ WHY[PJSLZ VM [PYL Y\IILY

HUK VPS YLZPK\L ;OL PU[LYPVY [YPT HUK \WOVSZ[LY`

YLSLHZL WHY[PJSLZ WHY[PJ\SHYS` PU Z[YVUN Z\USPNO[

^OPJO JVSSLJ[ VU [OL PUZPKLZ VM [OL ^PUKV^Z

;OLZL KLWVZP[Z HYL H\NTLU[LK I` PTW\YP[PLZ PU

[OLHPY^OPJOLU[LYZ[OLJHY[OYV\NO[OLMYLZOHPY

]LU[Z

*SLHU HSS ^PUKV^Z YLN\SHYS` PUZPKL HUK V\[Ì

ZPKL^P[O7VYZJOL^PUKV^JSLHULY

0M`V\\ZLHJOHTVPZSLH[OLYMVY[OL^PUKV^Z

KVUV[\ZLP[MVYWHPU[^VYRHZP[^PSSV[OLY^PZL

WPJR \W H JLY[HPU HTV\U[ VM WYLZLY]H[P]L VY

WVSPZOHUKJV\SKZTLHY[OL^PUKV^ZHUK[O\Z

PTWHPY]PZPVU

9LTV]LKLHKPUZLJ[Z^P[O[OL7VYZJOLPUZLJ[

YLTV]LY

azF˜*d"=F’

>PWLY ISHKLZ [OH[ HYL PU WLYMLR[ JVUKP[PVU HYL

]P[HSMVYHJSLHY]PL^

9LWSHJL [OL ^PWLY ISHKLZ [^PJL WLY `LHY ILÌ

MVYL HUK HM[LY [OL JVSK ZLHZVU VY ^OLUL]LY

^PWLYWLYMVYTHUJLKL[LYPVYH[LZ

7LYPVKPJHSS` JSLHU [OL ^PWLYISHKLZ^P[O7VYZJOL

^PUKV^ JSLHULY LZWLJPHSS` HM[LY [OL ]LOPJSL OHZ

ILLU^HZOLKPUHJHY^HZO

0M [OL` HYL ]LY` KPY[` LN ^P[O PUZLJ[ YLTHPUZ

[OL`JHUILJSLHULK^P[OHZWVUNLVYJSV[O

m=F4p"›amV

;OL \UKLYZPKL VM `V\Y JHY PZ K\YHIS` WYV[LJ[LK

HNHPUZ[JOLTPJHSHUKTLJOHUPJHSPUMS\LUJLZ

(ZP[PZUV[WVZZPISL[VL_JS\KL[OLYPZRVMKHTÌ

HNL[V[OPZWYV[LJ[P]LJVH[PUNPUKH`[VKH`KYP]Ì

PUN P[ PZ HK]PZHISL [V OH]L [OL \UKLYZPKL VM [OL

JHYPUZWLJ[LKH[JLY[HPUPU[LY]HSZÌWYLMLYHIS`ILÌ

MVYL[OLZ[HY[VM^PU[LYHUKHNHPUPUZWYPUNÌHUK

[OL\UKLYJVH[PUNYLZ[VYLKHZULJLZZHY`

@V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY PZ MHTPSPHY ^P[O

[OL IVK`ZLHS [YLH[TLU[ WYVJLK\YLZ HUK OHZ [OL

ULJLZZHY` LX\PWTLU[ MVY HWWS`PUN MHJ[VY` HWÌ

WYV]LK TH[LYPHSZ >L YLJVTTLUK [OH[ `V\ LUÌ

[Y\Z[[OLT^P[OZ\JO^VYRHUKPUZWLJ[PVUZ

<USPRL JVU]LU[PVUHS ZWYH` VPSZ \UKLYJVH[PUN HUK

Y\Z[ÌWYVVMPUN JVTWV\UKZ IHZLK VU IP[\TLU VY

^H_ KV UV[ H[[HJR [OL ZV\UKÌWYVVMPUN TH[LYPHSZ

HWWSPLKH[[OLMHJ[VY`

sQT˜˜

4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL

background image

>HYUPUN

+HUNLY VM MPYL HUK ZLYPV\Z WLYZVUHS PUÍ

Q\YPLZ

+V UV[ HWWS` HKKP[PVUHS \UKLYJVH[PUN VY Y\Z[Ì

WYVVMPUN VU VY ULHY [OL L_OH\Z[ THUPMVSK L_Ì

OH\Z[ WPWLZ JH[HS`[PJ JVU]LY[LYZ VY OLH[

ZOPLSKZ+\YPUNKYP]PUN[OLZ\IZ[HUJL\ZLKMVY

\UKLYJVH[PUNJV\SKV]LYOLH[HUKPNUP[L

)LMVYL HWWS`PUN MYLZO \UKLYZLHS JHYLM\SS`

YLTV]L KLWVZP[Z VY KPY[ HUK NYLHZL 6UJL P[

OHZ KYPLK [OL UL^ \UKLYJVH[PUN JVTWV\UK

MVYTZ H [V\NO WYV[LJ[P]L JVH[PUN ^OPJO WYVÌ

]PKLZLMMPJPLU[Y\Z[ÌWYVVMPUNVM[OLMSVVYWHULSZ

HUKJVTWVULU[Z

(S^H`Z HWWS` H MYLZO JVH[PUN VM Z\P[HISL WYLÌ

ZLY]H[P]L [V \UWYV[LJ[LK HYLHZ HM[LY JSLHUPUN

[OL \UKLYZPKL VM [OL IVK` [OL [YHUZTPZZPVU

[OL LUNPUL VY JHYY`PUN V\[ YLWHPYZ [V \UKLYÌ

IVK`LUNPULVY[YHUZTPZZPVUJVTWVULU[Z

,MMLJ[P]L Y\Z[ÌWYVVMPUN PZ WHY[PJ\SHYS` PTWVY[HU[

K\YPUN [OL JVSK ^LH[OLY ZLHZVU 0M `V\Y JHY PZ

KYP]LU MYLX\LU[S` PU HYLHZ ^OLYL ZHS[ OHZ ILLU

ZWYLHKVU[OLYVHKZ[OL^OVSLLUNPULJVTWHY[Ì

TLU[ ZOV\SK IL JSLHULK [OVYV\NOS` HM[LY [OL

^PU[LY [V WYL]LU[ ZHS[ MYVT JH\ZPUN HU` SHZ[PUN

KHTHNL ( M\SS \UKLYÌIVK` ^HZO ZOV\SK HSZV IL

WLYMVYTLKH[[OLZHTL[PTL

pp:˜ppO:˜da=˜"m=˜§am=p§˜’F"d’

>HZO KPY[ LN HIYHZPVU K\Z[ YVHK ZHS[Z

MYVT HSS ZLHSZ YLN\SHYS` \ZPUN ^HYT ZVHW`

^H[LY +V UV[ \ZL HU` JOLTPJHS JSLHUPUN

HNLU[ZVYZVS]LU[Z

>OLU [OLYL PZ H MYVZ[ OHaHYK [OL V\[LY KVVY

ZLHSZ HUK [OL MYVU[ HUK YLHY SPK ZLHSZ JHU IL

WYV[LJ[LK HNHPUZ[ MYLLaPUN PU[V WSHJL I` H Z\P[Ì

HISLJHYLWYVK\J[

0UVYKLY[VWYL]LU[KHTHNL[V[OLHU[PÍMYPJÍ

[PVU JVH[PUN [OL PUULY KVVY ZLHSZ T\Z[ UV[

IL[YLH[LK^P[OJHYLWYVK\J[Z

F"=daV^›’:˜daV^›’:˜am›Fap˜"m=˜F¨›Fap

zd"’›a4˜z"›’

<ZLVUS`JSLHU^H[LYHUKHSP[[SLKPZO^HZOPUN

KL[LYNLU[ [V JSLHU SPNO[ SLUZLZ WSHZ[PJ OLHKÌ

SPNO[SLUZLZWSHZ[PJWHY[ZHUKZ\YMHJLZ

+VUV[JSLHU^OLUKY`

<ZL H ZVM[ ZWVUNL VY H ZVM[ SPU[ÌMYLL JSV[O

.LU[S` ^PWL [OL Z\YMHJL ^P[OV\[ HWWS`PUN [VV

T\JOWYLZZ\YL

;OL 7VYZJOL PUZPKL ^PUKV^ JSLHULY PZ HSZV

Z\P[HISL MVY JSLHUPUN WSHZ[PJ Z\YMHJLZ -VSSV^

[OLJSLHUPUNPUZ[Y\J[PVUZVU[OLJVU[HPULY

5L]LY \ZL V[OLY JOLTPJHS JSLHULYZ VY

ZVS]LU[Z

9PUZLJSLHULKZ\YMHJLZ^P[OJSLHY^H[LY

4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL

sQQ

background image

aV^›˜"ddp©˜§^FFd’

(SZVYLMLY[Vs*HY^HZOLZr

7P[[PUN TH` VJJ\Y PM TL[HSSPJ WHY[PJSLZ ^OPJO

JH\ZLJVU[HJ[JVYYVZPVULNIYHZZVYJVWWLYPU

IYHRL K\Z[ HYL HSSV^LK [V YLTHPU VU [OL HS\Ì

TPU\TMVY[VVSVUN

0MWVZZPISL^HZO[OL^OLLSZ^P[OHZWVUNLVY

^HZO IY\ZO HIV\[ L]LY` [^V ^LLRZ 0U HYLHZ

^OLYLZHS[PZZWYLHKVU^PU[LYYVHKZVY[OLYL

PZHSV[VMHPYIVYULPUK\Z[YPHSK\Z[P[PZILZ[[V

JSLHU[OL^OLLSZ^LLRS`

;OL 7VYZJOL 3PNO[ (SSV` >OLLS *SLHULY

WOÍ]HS\L  JHU IL \ZLK MVY [OPZ W\YÍ

WVZL

0M [OL WOÍ]HS\L VM [OL KL[LYNLU[ PZ PUJVYÍ

YLJ[[OLWYV[LJ[P]LJVH[PUNVU[OL^OLLSZ

^PSSILKLZ[YV`LK

7VSPZOLZ ^OPJO KPZZVS]L V_PKLZ Z\JO HZ

[OVZL MYLX\LU[S` \ZLK MVY V[OLY TL[HSZ VY

HIYHZP]L [VVSZ VY HNLU[Z HYL \UZ\P[HISL ILÍ

JH\ZL [OL` IYLHR KV^U [OL V_PKL MPST VM

[OLWYV[LJ[P]LJVH[PUNHUK^PSSJH\ZLKPZJVÍ

SVYH[PVUVM[OL^OLLS

,]LY` [OYLL TVU[OZ HM[LY JSLHUPUN JVH[ [OL

^OLLSZ ^P[O H JHY ^H_ VY UVUÌ JVYYVZP]L

NYLHZL]HZLSPUL

<ZPUNHJSLHUJSV[O[OVYV\NOS`Y\I[OLNYLHZL

PU[V[OLZ\YMHJL

F"›^F

*OHYHJ[LYPZ[PJZHUKZWLJPHSMLH[\YLZ
;OL UH[\YHS Z\YMHJL THYRPUNZ VM SLH[OLY LN

JYLHZLZOLHSLKZJHYZPUZLJ[Z[PUNTHYRZZ[Y\JÌ

[\YHS KPMMLYLUJLZ HUK ZSPNO[ ]HYPH[PVUZ PU ZOHKL

HUK NYHPU HKK [V [OL H[[YHJ[P]LULZZ VM [OL UH[\Ì

YHSSLH[OLYWYVK\J[

(ZWLJPHSTLU[PVUT\Z[ILTHKLOLYLVMUH[\YHS

SLH[OLY

-VY UH[\YHS SLH[OLY JHYLM\SS` ZLSLJ[LK OPKLZ VM

[OL OPNOLZ[ X\HSP[` HYL \ZLK 0[ PZ UV[ JV]LYLK

JVTWSL[LS`^P[OK`LVUWYVK\J[PVU

r5H[\YLqZ ZPNUH[\YLs PZ[OLYLMVYLLHZPS`YLJVNUPZÌ

HISL

;OPZ MPUL TH[LYPHS PZ KPZ[PUN\PZOLK I` HU V\[Ì

Z[HUKPUN ZLH[PUN JVTMVY[ ZWLJPHS Z\WWSLULZZ

HUKH[`WPJHSWH[PUH

3LH[OLYJHYLHUK[YLH[TLU[

*SLHU HSS [`WLZ VM SLH[OLY YLN\SHYS` [V YLTV]L

MPUL K\Z[ \ZPUN H ZVM[ KHTW ^OP[L ^VVSSLU

JSV[O VY H JVTTLYJPHSS` H]HPSHISL TPJYVMPIYL

JSV[O

9LTV]L OLH]` JVU[HTPUH[PVU ^P[O 7VYZJOL

SLH[OLYJSLHULY

7SLHZL HS^H`Z MVSSV^ [OL PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ MVY \ZL

NP]LUVU[OLJVU[HPULYZ

*H\Z[PJ JSLHULYZ HUK OHYK JSLHUPUN VIQLJ[Z

T\Z[UV[IL\ZLK

7LYMVYH[LK SLH[OLY T\Z[ \UKLY UV JPYJ\TÍ

Z[HUJLZNL[^L[VUP[ZYL]LYZLZPKL

6UJL JSLHULK SLH[OLY WHY[PJ\SHYS` [OL OLH]PS`

Z[YLZZLK SLH[OLY ZLH[Z T\Z[ IL [YLH[LK VUS`

^P[O7VYZJOLSLH[OLYJHYLSPX\PK

sQ–˜˜

4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL

background image

"*a4:˜¤z^pd’›F©:˜4"zF›’˜"m=

Odpp_h"›’

<ZL VUS` H ]HJ\\T JSLHULY VY H TLKP\T Z[PMM

IY\ZO

9LTV]L Z[HPUZ HUK ZWV[Z ^P[O 7VYZJOL Z[HPU

YLTV]LY

;OL 7VYZJOL YHUNL VM HJJLZZVYPLZ PUJS\KLZ

MSVVYÌTH[Z[VWYV[LJ[[OLJHYWL[ZPUZ\TTLYHUK

^PU[LY

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMHUHJJPKLU[

(S^H`ZJOLJR[OLTV]LTLU[VM[OLWLKHSZILÌ

MVYL KYP]PUN HUK THRL Z\YL [OH[ [OL` HYL UV[

VIZ[Y\J[LKI`HMSVVYTH[VYHU`V[OLYVIQLJ[

:LJ\YL[OLMSVVYTH[[VWYL]LU[P[MYVTZSPKPUN

PU[V WVZP[PVUZ [OH[ JV\SK PU[LYMLYL ^P[O [OL

ZHML VWLYH[PVU VM `V\Y ]LOPJSL Ì KV UV[ SPL

[OLTSVVZLS`PU[OL]LOPJSL

@V\Y 7VYZJOL KLHSLY ^PSS IL NSHK [V VMMLY `V\

MSVVY TH[Z VM [OL JVYYLJ[ ZPaL PUJS\KPUN H ZLÌ

J\YPUNWVZZPIPSP[`

d4"m›""

+V UV[ \ZL H SLH[OLY JHYL WYVK\J[ [V JSLHU

(SJHU[HYH

-VY YLN\SHY JHYL P[ PZ Z\MMPJPLU[ [V JSLHU [OL

JV]LY^P[OHZVM[IY\ZO

*SLHUPUN^OLUSPNO[S`ZVPSLK

>L[ H ZVM[ JSV[O ^P[O ^H[LY VY HUL\[YHSZVHW

ZVS\[PVUHUK^PWLVMM[OLKPY[

*SLHUPUN^OLUOLH]PS`ZVPSLK

>L[ H ZVM[ JSV[O ^P[O S\RL^HYT ^H[LY VY

[OPUULK ^OP[L ZWPYP[ HUK KHI [OL KPY[ MYVT [OL

V\[ZPKLPU

"OF›©˜*Fd›’

0M P[ ILJVTLZ ULJLZZHY` [V JSLHU [OL ILS[Z `V\

JHU\ZLHU`TPSK^HZOPUNHNLU[

(SSV^ [OL ILS[Z [V KY` WYPVY [V YL[YHJ[PUN I\[

H]VPKKPYLJ[Z\USPNO[

6US`\ZLZ\P[HISLJSLHULYZ

0M\UZ\P[HISLJSLHULYZHYL\ZLKVYHU`H[[LTW[PZ

THKL [V K`L VY ISLHJO [OL ILS[Z [OL ^LIIPUN

TH` IL ^LHRLULK HUK [O\Z JVUZ[P[\[L H ZHML[`

YPZR

4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL

sQ•

background image

›pamV˜©p¤˜p’4^F

0M `V\ PU[LUK [V Z[VYL `V\Y 7VYZJOL MVY H WYVÌ

SVUNLK WLYPVK WSLHZL JVUZ\S[ `V\Y H\[OVYPaLK

7VYZJOL KLHSLY ;OL Z[HMM ^PSS IL NSHK [V HK]PZL

`V\ VU [OL TVZ[ Z\P[HISL HUK ULJLZZHY`

TL[OVKZ

*SLHU `V\Y ]LOPJSL [OVYV\NOS` PUZPKL HUK V\[Ì

ZPKL

*SLHU[OLLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[

;OL \UKLY JHYYPHNL HUK JOHZZPZ JVTWVULU[Z

ZOV\SKILMYLLVMKPY[HUKZHS[KLWVZP[Z

-PSS\W[OLM\LS[HUR

*OHUNL [OL VPS HUK VPS MPS[LY HUK Y\U [OL LUÌ

NPULMVYZL]LYHSTPU\[LZ

0UJYLHZL[OL[PYLWYLZZ\YL[VWZPIHY

0[ PZ UV[ YLJVTTLUKLK [V SPM[ [OL ]LOPJSL K\L

[V[OLWVZZPIPSP[`VMJVYYVZPVUVUZOVJRHIZVYÌ

ILYWPZ[VUZOHM[Z

;OL]LOPJSLZOV\SKILTV]LKZSPNO[S`HWWYV_PÌ

TH[LS` L]LY` MV\Y ^LLRZ [V WYL]LU[ MSH[ ZWV[

VU[OL[PYLZ

*SPTH[LJVU[YVS
;OL HPY JVUKP[PVUPUN Z`Z[LT ZOV\SK IL PU NVVK

^VYRPUNJVUKP[PVUHUKM\SS`JOHYNLK

>PUKZOPLSK/LHKSPNO[^HZOLY

*OLJR HUK JVYYLJ[ HU[PMYLLaLJSLHUPUN ZVS\Ì

[PVUSL]LSHZULJLZZHY`

,SLJ[YPJHSZ`Z[LT

9LTV]L [OL IH[[LY` MYVT [OL ]LOPJSL HUK

Z[VYL P[ PU H JVVS KY` WSHJL UV[ VU H JLTLU[

MSVVY

>OLU [OL IH[[LY` PZ KPZJVUULJ[LK [OL

HSHYTZ`Z[LTPZKLHJ[P]H[LK

9LJOHYNL [OL IH[[LY` L]LY`  TVU[OZ 0M [OL

IH[[LY` YLTHPUZ PU [OL ]LOPJSL ^P[O [OL JHISLZ

JVUULJ[LK P[ PZ ULJLZZHY` [V JOLJR YLTV]L

HUKYLJOHYNL[OLIH[[LY`L]LY`Ì^LLRZ

+VUV[MHZ[JOHYNL[OLIH[[LY`

-VSSV^ [OL PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ PU [OL s)H[[LY`r JOHWÌ

[LY

=LOPJSLPU[LYPVY
;OL PU[LYPVY T\Z[ IL KY` LZWLJPHSS` PU [OL HYLH

VM [OL MSVVY JHYWL[Z ;OL \ZL VM KY`PUN HNLU[Z

:PSPJHÌ.LS PZ YLJVTTLUKLK PU ]LOPJSLZ ^P[O

SLH[OLY PU[LYPVY HUK PU HYLHZ ^P[O OPNO O\TPKP[`

;OL YLJVTTLUKLK HTV\U[ PZ  MHIYPJ IHNZ VM

 SIZ  NYHTZ LHJO WSHJLK VU [OL MSVVY

JHYWL[Z

>PUKV^Z KVVYZ SPKZ HUK YVVM T\Z[ IL JSVZLK

;OLHPYMSHWZZOV\SKILVWLULK

sQG˜˜

4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL

background image

"4›a4"d˜az’:˜hFVFm4©˜F¦a4F

*H\[PVUZ  

;PYLZ^OLLSZ  u

1HJR[VVSZ 

3PM[PUN[OL]LOPJSL 

:WHYL^OLLS

>OLLSIVS[Z 

*OHUNPUN^OLLSZ u

,SLJ[YPJHSZ`Z[LTM\ZLZYLSH`Z u

)H[[LY`   u

,TLYNLUJ`Z[HY[PUN

^P[OQ\TWLYJHISLZ  

3PNO[ZYLWSHJPUNI\SIZ  u 

(KQ\Z[PUNOLHKSPNO[Z   

;V^PUN  

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

sQn

background image

¨F4a’F˜¨›FhF˜"¤›apm˜§^Fm

pcamV˜pm˜©p¤˜F^a4dF

>HYUPUN

0NUVYPUN [OL MVSSV^PUN PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ TH`

JH\ZLZLYPV\ZWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`

;OLLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[VMHU`TV[VY]LOPJSL

PZHWV[LU[PHSS`OHaHYKV\ZHYLH0M`V\HYLUV[

M\SS`MHTPSPHY^P[OWYVWLYYLWHPYWYVJLK\YLZKV

UV[H[[LTW[[OLHKQ\Z[TLU[ZKLZJYPILKVU[OL

MVSSV^PUNWHNLZ

;OPZJH\[PVUHWWSPLZ[V[OLLU[PYL]LOPJSL

6US` ^VYR VU `V\Y ]LOPJSL V\[KVVYZ VY PU H

^LSS]LU[PSH[LKHYLH

,UZ\YL [OH[ [OLYL HYL UV VWLU MSHTLZ PU [OL

HYLH VM `V\Y ]LOPJSL H[ HU` [PTL ^OLU M\LS

M\TLZ TPNO[ IL WYLZLU[ )L LZWLJPHSS` JH\Ì

[PV\Z VM Z\JO KL]PJLZ Z\JO HZ OV[ ^H[LY

OLH[LYZ^OPJOPNUP[LHMSHTLPU[LYTP[[LU[S`

)LMVYL^VYRPUNVUHU`WHY[PU[OLLUNPULJVTÌ

WHY[TLU[ [\YU [OL LUNPUL VMM HUK SL[ P[ JVVS

KV^U Z\MMPJPLU[S` /V[ LUNPUL JVTWHY[TLU[

JVTWVULU[ZJHUI\YUZRPUVUJVU[HJ[

)L HSLY[ HUK JH\[PV\Z HYV\UK LUNPUL H[ HSS

[PTLZ^OPSL[OLLUNPULPZY\UUPUN

0M ^VYR OHZ [V IL WLYMVYTLK ^P[O [OL LUNPUL

Y\UUPUN HS^H`Z ZL[ [OL WHYRPUN IYHRL HUK

THRL Z\YL [OL ZOPM[ SL]LY PZ PU UL\[YHS VY [OL

ZLSLJ[VYSL]LYPZPUWVZP[PVUs7rVYs5r

0U WHY[PJ\SHY IL ]LY` JHYLM\S [V LUZ\YL [OH[

P[LTZ VM JSV[OPUN [PLZ ZOPY[ ZSLL]LZ L[J

QL^LSY` SVUN OHPY OHUK VY MPUNLYZ JHUUV[ NL[

JH\NO[ PU [OL LUNPULÌJVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY

MHUILS[ZVYV[OLYTV]PUNWHY[Z

;OLYHKPH[VYHUKYHKPH[VYMHUZHYLPU[OLMYVU[

VM[OLJHY

;OL LUNPULÌJVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY PZ TV\U[LK

VU[OLLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[SPK

;OL LUNPULÌJVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY HS^H`Z Y\UZ

^OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ Z^P[JOLK VU (M[LY [OL

PNUP[PVU PZ Z^P[JOLK VMM [OL LUNPUL JVTWHY[Ì

TLU[HUKJVVSHU[[LTWLYH[\YLZHYLTVUP[VYLK

MVYHWWYV_TPU\[LZ

+\YPUN [OPZ WLYPVK HUK KLWLUKPUN VU [LTÌ

WLYH[\YL [OL LUNPULÌJVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY HUK

YHKPH[VY MHUZ TH` JVU[PU\L [V Y\U VY Z[HY[ [V

Y\U

*HYY` V\[ ^VYR PU [OLZL HYLHZ VUS` ^P[O [OL

LUNPULVMMHUKL_LYJPZLL_[YLTLJH\[PVU

@V\Y 7VYZJOL PZ LX\PWWLK ^P[O HU LSLJ[YVUPJ

PNUP[PVU Z`Z[LT >OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ VU OPNO

]VS[HNL PZ WYLZLU[ PU HSS ^PYLZ JVUULJ[LK ^P[O

[OL PNUP[PVU Z`Z[LT" [OLYLMVYL L_LYJPZL L_Ì

[YLTL JH\[PVU ^OLU ^VYRPUN VU HU` WHY[ VM

[OL LUNPUL ^OPSL [OL PNUP[PVU PZ VU VY [OL LUÌ

NPULPZY\UUPUN

(S^H`Z Z\WWVY[ `V\Y JHY ^P[O ZHML[` Z[HUKZ PM

P[ PZ ULJLZZHY` [V ^VYR \UKLY [OL JHY ;OL

QHJRZ\WWSPLK^P[O[OLJHYPZUV[HKLX\H[LMVY

[OPZW\YWVZL

>OLU ^VYRPUN \UKLY [OL JHY ^P[OV\[ ZHML[`

Z[HUKZ I\[ ^P[O [OL ^OLLSZ VU [OL NYV\UK

THRL Z\YL [OL JHY PZ VU SL]LS NYV\UK [OL

^OLLSZ HYL ISVJRLK HUK [OH[ [OL LUNPUL JHUÌ

UV[ILZ[HY[LK

9LTV]L[OLPNUP[PVURL`

+VUV[ZTVRLVYHSSV^HUVWLUMSHTLHYV\UK

[OLIH[[LY`VYM\LS

2LLWHMPYLL_[PUN\PZOLYPUJSVZLYLHJO

0UJVTWSL[L VY PTWYVWLY ZLY]PJPUN TH` JH\ZL

WYVISLTZ PU [OL VWLYH[PVU VM [OL JHY 0M PU

KV\I[ HIV\[ HU` ZLY]PJPUN OH]L P[ KVUL I`

`V\YH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

0TWYVWLY THPU[LUHUJL K\YPUN [OL ^HYYHU[`

WLYPVK TH` HMMLJ[ `V\Y 7VYZJOL ^HYYHU[`

JV]LYHNL

:\WWSPLZ VM MS\PKZ LN LUNPUL VPS IYHRL MS\PK

VYJVVSHU[HYLOHaHYKV\Z[V`V\YOLHS[O

2LLW [OLZL MS\PKZ V\[ VM JOPSKYLUqZ YLHJO HUK

KPZWVZL VM [OLT PU HJJVYKHUJL ^P[O [OL HWÌ

WYVWYPH[LYLN\SH[PVUZ

:VTL JV\U[YPLZ YLX\PYL HKKP[PVUHS [VVSZ HUK

ZWLJPHSZWHYLWHY[Z[VILJHYYPLK

7SLHZLTHRLLUX\PYPLZILMVYLKYP]PUNHIYVHK

s–¬˜˜

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

background image

aF’—^FFd’

;OL VYPNPUHS LX\PWTLU[ [PYLZ HUK ^OLLS YPTZ VU

`V\Y 7VYZJOL JVTWS` ^P[O HSS HWWSPJHISL -LKLYHS

4V[VY=LOPJSL:HML[`:[HUKHYKZ

-VY`V\YZHML[`YLTLTILY[OLMVSSV^PUN!



>OLLSYPTZHUK^OLLSIVS[ZHYLTH[JOLK[VMP[

`V\Y7VYZJOL



0M `V\ PU[LUK [V \ZL V[OLY [OHU VYPNPUHS LX\PWÌ

TLU[ ^OLLSZ IL Z\YL [OH[ [OL` JVUMVYT [V

7VYZJOLZWLJPMPJH[PVUZMVY`V\YTVKLS

6US` [PYLZ ^P[O [OL ZHTL THRL HUK ^P[O [OL

ZHTL ZWLJPMPJH[PVU JVKL LN s5r s5r

JHUILTV\U[LK



;OL\ZLVM^OLLSYPTZHUK^OLLSIVS[Z[OH[KV

UV[ TLL[ ZWLJPMPJH[PVUZ VM [OLVYPNPUHSMHJ[VY`

PUZ[HSSLK LX\PWTLU[ ^PSS HMMLJ[ [OL ZHML VWLYÌ

H[PVUVM`V\Y]LOPJSL



)LMVYL `V\ WSHU VU L_JOHUNPUN ^OLLSZ VY

ZUV^ [PYLZ HSYLHK` TV\U[LK VU [OL ^OLLS

YPTZ JVUZ\S[ `V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY

@V\Y KLHSLY OHZ [OL [LJOUPJHS PUMVYTH[PVU

ULJLZZHY`[VHK]PZL`V\^OPJO^OLLSYPTZHUK

^OLLS IVS[Z HYL JVTWH[PISL ^P[O [OL VYPNPUHS

MHJ[VY`PUZ[HSSH[PVUZ

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMSVZZVMJVU[YVSHUKZLYPV\ZWLYZVUHS

PUQ\Y`

0M ^OPSL KYP]PUN `V\Y ]LOPJSL L_WLYPLUJLZ H

Z\KKLU ]PIYH[PVU VY YPKL KPZ[\YIHUJL HUKVY

`V\ Z\ZWLJ[ [OH[ WVZZPISL KHTHNL [V `V\Y

[PYLZ VY ]LOPJSL OHZ VJJ\YYLK `V\ ZOV\SK PTÌ

TLKPH[LS` YLK\JL `V\Y ZWLLK ^P[OV\[ L_Ì

JLZZP]L\ZLVM[OLIYHRLZ

:[VW [OL ]LOPJSL HZ ZVVU HZ WVZZPISL HUK PUÌ

ZWLJ[[OL[PYLZ

0M`V\JHUUV[KL[LYTPUL[OLJH\ZLMVY[OLKPZÌ

[\YIHUJL OH]L `V\Y ]LOPJSL [V^LK [V [OL

ULHYLZ[ 7VYZJOL VY [PYL KLHSLY [V OH]L `V\Y

]LOPJSLVY[PYLZPUZWLJ[LK

*VU[PU\PUN [V VWLYH[L [OL ]LOPJSL ^P[OV\[ JVYÌ

YLJ[PVU JV\SK YLZ\S[ PU H SVZZ VM JVU[YVS HUK

ZLYPV\ZWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

s–s

background image

maOph˜aF˜¤"da›©˜ "=amV

8\HSP[`NYHKLZJHUILMV\UK^OLYLHWWSPJHISLVU

[OL [PYL ZPKL^HSS IL[^LLU [YLHK ZOV\SKLY HUK

TH_PT\TZLJ[PVU^PK[O

,_HTWSL

(SSWHZZLUNLYJHY[PYLZT\Z[JVUMVYT[V-LKLYHS

:HML[`9LX\PYLTLU[ZPUHKKP[PVU[V[OLZLNYHKLZ

;YLHK^LHY
;OL [YLHK^LHY NYHKL PZ H JVTWHYH[P]L YH[PUN

IHZLK VU [OL ^LHY YH[L VM [OL [PYL ^OLU [LZ[LK

\UKLYJVU[YVSSLKJVUKP[PVUZVUHZWLJPMPJNV]LYUÌ

TLU[[LZ[JV\YZL

-VYL_HTWSLH[PYLNYHKLK^V\SK^LHYVUL

HUK H OHSM Ì [PTLZ HZ ^LSS VU [OL NV]LYUÌ

TLU[JV\YZLHZH[PYLNYHKLK

;OL YLSH[P]L WLYMVYTHUJL VM [PYLZ KLWLUKZ \WVU

[OL HJ[\HS JVUKP[PVUZ VM [OLPY \ZL OV^L]LY HUK

TH` KLWHY[ ZPNUPMPJHU[S` MYVT [OL UVYT K\L [V

]HYPH[PVUZPUKYP]PUNOHIP[ZZLY]PJLWYHJ[PJLZHUK

KPMMLYLUJLZPUYVHKJOHYHJ[LYPZ[PJZHUKJSPTH[L

;YHJ[PVU((()*
;OL[YHJ[PVUNYHKLZMYVTOPNOLZ[[VSV^LZ[HYL

(( ( ) HUK * HUK [OL` YLWYLZLU[ [OL [PYLqZ

HIPSP[` [V Z[VW VU ^L[ WH]LTLU[ HZ TLHZ\YLK

\UKLY JVU[YVSSLK JVUKP[PVUZ VU ZWLJPMPLK NV]LYUÌ

TLU[[LZ[Z\YMHJLZVMHZWOHS[HUKJVUJYL[L

( [PYL THYRLK * TH` OH]L WVVY [YHJ[PVU WLYMVYÌ

THUJL

>HYUPUN

;OL [YHJ[PVU NYHKL HZZPNULK [V [OPZ PZ IHZLKVU

IYHRPUN Z[YHPNO[ÌHOLHK [YHJ[PVU [LZ[Z HUK KVLZ

UV[ PUJS\KL JVYULYPUN [\YULK [YHJ[PVU HJJLSLYHÌ

[PVU O`KYVWSHUPUN VY WLHR [YHJ[PVU JOHYHJÌ

[LYPZ[PJZ

s–¢˜˜

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

background image

;LTWLYH[\YL()*
;OL [LTWLYH[\YL NYHKLZ HYL ( [OL OPNOLZ[ )

HUK * YLWYLZLU[PUN [OL [PYLqZ YLZPZ[HUJL [V [OL

NLULYH[PVU VM OLH[ HUK P[Z HIPSP[` [V KPZZPWH[L

OLH[^OLU[LZ[LK\UKLYJVU[YVSSLKJVUKP[PVUZVU

HZWLJPMPLKPUKVVYSHIVYH[VY`[LZ[^OLLS

:\Z[HPULK OPNO [LTWLYH[\YLZ JHU JH\ZL [OL THÌ

[LYPHS VM [OL [PYL [V KLNLULYH[L HUK YLK\JL [PYL

SPMLHUKL_JLZZP]L[LTWLYH[\YLJHUSLHK[VZ\KÌ

KLU[PYLMHPS\YL

;OL NYHKL * JVYYLZWVUKZ [V H SL]LS VM WLYMVYÌ

THUJL ^OPJO HSS WHZZLUNLY JHY [PYLZ T\Z[ TLL[

\UKLY[OL-LKLYHS4V[VY=LOPJSL:HML[`:[HUKHYK

5V 

.YHKLZ ) HUK ( YLWYLZLU[ OPNOLY SL]LSZ VM WLYÌ

MVYTHUJL VU [OL SHIVYH[VY` [LZ[ ^OLLS [OHU [OL

TPUPT\TYLX\PYLKI`SH^

>HYUPUN

;OL [LTWLYH[\YL NYHKL MVY [OPZ [PYL PZ LZ[HIÌ

SPZOLK MVY H [PYL [OH[ PZ WYVWLYS` PUMSH[LK HUK UV[

V]LYSVHKLK

,_JLZZP]L ZWLLK \UKLYPUMSH[PVU VY L_JLZZP]L

SVHKPUNLP[OLYZLWHYH[LS`VYPUJVTIPUH[PVUJHU

JH\ZLOLH[I\PSK\WHUKWVZZPISL[PYLMHPS\YL

aF˜zF’’¤F’

>HYUPUN

0UJVYYLJ[ [PYL WYLZZ\YL JH\ZLZ PUJYLHZLK

[PYL ^LHY HUK HK]LYZLS` HMMLJ[Z YVHK OHUKÍ

SPUN

(S^H`Z \ZL HU HJJ\YH[L [PYL WYLZZ\YL NH\NL

^OLUJOLJRPUNPUMSH[PVUWYLZZ\YLZ

+V UV[ L_JLLK [OL TH_PT\T [PYL WYLZZ\YL

SPZ[LKVU[OL[PYLZPKL^HSS(SZVYLMLY[Vs;LJOÌ

UPJHSKH[Hs

*VSK [PYL PUMSH[PVU WYLZZ\YL TLHUZ! HSS [PYLZ

T\Z[ IL JVSK HTIPLU[ [LTWLYH[\YLTH_PT\T

•- •* ^OLU HKQ\Z[PUN [OL PUMSH[PVU

WYLZZ\YL

(]VPK Z\USPNO[ Z[YPRPUN [OL [PYLZ ILMVYL

TLHZ\YPUN JVSK WYLZZ\YLZ ZPUJL [OL WYLZZÌ

\YLZ^V\SKYPZLMYVT[LTWLYH[\YLPUMS\LUJL

=HS]L JHWZ WYV[LJ[ [OL ]HS]L MYVT K\Z[ HUK

KPY[HUK[O\ZMYVTSLHRHNL

(S^H`ZZJYL^JHWZ[PNO[S`KV^U

9LWSHJLTPZZPUNJHWZPTTLKPH[LS`

-VY ZHML[` YLHZVUZ KVUq[ \ZL [PYL PUMSH[PUN

IV[[SLZ

aF˜›"4›apm

>HYUPUN

>OLU KYP]PUN VU ^L[ VY ZS\ZO` YVHKZ H

^LKNL VM ^H[LY TH` I\PSK \W IL[^LLU [OL

[PYLZ HUK [OL YVHK ;OPZ WOLUVTLUVU PZ

RUV^UHZsO`KYVWSHULrHUKTH`JH\ZLWHYÍ

[PHS VY JVTWSL[L SVZZ VM [YHJ[PVU ]LOPJSL

JVU[YVSVYZ[VWWPUNHIPSP[`

9LK\JLZWLLKVU^L[Z\YMHJL[VWYL]LU[[OPZ

aF˜daOF

;PYL SPML KLWLUKZ VU ]HYPV\Z MHJ[VYZ PL YVHK

Z\YMHJLZ [YHMMPJ HUK ^LH[OLY JVUKP[PVUZ KYP]PUN

OHIP[Z[`WLVM[PYLZHUK[PYLJHYL

0UZWLJ[ `V\Y [PYLZ MVY ^LHY HUK KHTHNL ILÌ

MVYL KYP]PUN VMM 0M `V\ UV[PJL \UL]LU VY Z\IÌ

Z[HU[PHS^LHY^OLLSZTPNO[ULLKHSPNUTLU[VY

[PYLZZOV\SKILIHSHUJLKVYYLWSHJLK

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

s–

background image

aF˜§F"

;OL VYPNPUHS LX\PWTLU[ [PYLZ VU `V\Y 7VYZJOL

OH]L I\PS[ÌPU [PYL ^LHY PUKPJH[VYZ ;OL` HYL

TVSKLK PU[V [OL IV[[VT VM [OL [YLHK NYVV]LZ

HUK^PSSHWWLHYHZHWWYV_PTH[LS`PUTT

IHUKZ ^OLU [OL [PYL [YLHK KLW[O PZ KV^U [V

VMHUPUTT

>OLU [OL PUKPJH[VYZ HWWLHY PU [^V VY TVYL HKÌ

QHJLU[ NYVV]LZ P[ PZ [PTL [V YLWSHJL [OL [PYLZ

>L YLJVTTLUK OV^L]LY [OH[ `V\ KV UV[ SL[

[OL[PYLZ^LHYKV^U[V[OPZL_[LU[

>VYU[PYLZJHUUV[NYPW[OLYVHKZ\YMHJLWYVWLYS`

HUKHYLL]LUSLZZLMMLJ[P]LVU^L[YVHKZ

0U [OL <UP[LK :[H[LZZ[H[LSH^ZTH`NV]LYU[OL

TPUPT\T [YLHK KLW[O WLYTPZZPISL -VSSV^ HSS

Z\JOSH^Z

>HYUPUN

+YP]PUN VU ^VYU [PYLZ JHU YLZ\S[ PU SVZZ VM

JVU[YVS VM [OL ]LOPJSL HUK JV\SK JH\ZL

ZL]LYLWLYZVUHSPUQ\YPLZ

+V UV[ KYP]L ^P[O ^VYU [PYLZ VY [PYLZ ZOV^PUN

J\[Z VY IY\PZLZ HZ [OL` TH` SLHK [V Z\KKLU

KLMSH[PVU HUK SVZZ VM JVU[YVS ^OPJO JV\SK

JH\ZLZL]LYLWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`

:WLJPHSPaLK OPNO WLYMVYTHUJL [PYLZ VU OPNO

WLYMVYTHUJL ZWVY[Z JHYZ L_OPIP[ TVYL ^LHY

[OHU [OVZL VU H MHTPS` ZLKHU VY L]LU H OPNO

WLYMVYTHUJLZLKHU

;OLYLMVYL P[ PZ PTWVY[HU[ [V JOLJR `V\Y [PYL

WYLZZ\YL HUK JVUKP[PVU H[ SLHZ[ L]LY` [^V

^LLRZ

0M `V\ UV[PJL [OH[ [PYLZ HYL ^LHYPUN \UL]LUS`

JVUZ\S[`V\Y7VYZJOLKLHSLY

<UL]LU ^LHY TH` UV[ HS^H`Z IL K\L [V PTÌ

WYVWLY ^OLLS HSPNUTLU[ 0[ JHU IL [OL YLZ\S[ VM

PUKP]PK\HS KYP]PUN OHIP[Z Z\JO HZ JVYULYPUN H[

OPNO ZWLLKZ 0M [OL [PYL WYLZZ\YL PZUV[JOLJRLK

HUK HKQ\Z[LK YLN\SHYS` HIUVYTHS [PYL ^LHY JHU

HSZVVJJ\Y

aF˜4"F

(]VPKKHTHNPUN[PYLZHUK^OLLSYPTZ

0M `V\ T\Z[ KYP]L V]LY H J\YI VY V[OLY VIÌ

Z[HJSLKYP]LZSV^S`HUKH[HUVI[\ZLHUNSL

*OLJR [PYLZ MVY \UL]LU ^LHY HUK KHTHNL ILÌ

MVYLKYP]PUNVMM

9LTV]LPTILKKLKTH[LYPHS

9LWSHJL^VYUVYKHTHNLK[PYLZPTTLKPH[LS`

2LLW VPS M\LS IYHRL MS\PK L[J H^H` MYVT

[PYLZ

9LWSHJLTPZZPUN]HS]LZ[LTJHWZ

2LLW[PYLZPUMSH[LKJVYYLJ[S`

s–T˜˜

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

background image

aF˜="h"VF:˜z¤m4›¤F

*OLJR[PYLZMVYPTILKKLKTH[LYPHSJ\[ZW\UJÌ

[\YLZ JYHJRZ HUK I\SNLZ ZPKL ^HSS ILMVYL

KYP]PUNVMM

0U JHZL VM [PYL KHTHNL ^OLYL P[ PZ \UJLY[HPU

^OL[OLY [OLYL PZ H IYLHR PU [OL WS` ^P[O HSS P[Z

JVUZLX\LUJLZ VY [PYL KHTHNL JH\ZLK I` [OLYÌ

THS VY TLJOHUPJHS V]LYSVHKPUN K\L [V SVZZ VM

WYLZZ\YL VYHU`V[OLYWYPVYKHTHNL^LYLJVTÌ

TLUK [OH[ [OL [PYL IL YLWSHJLK MVY ZHML[` YLHÌ

ZVUZ

0M VUL MH\S[` [PYL PZ YLWSHJLK P[ ZOV\SK IL UV[LK

[OH[ [OL KPMMLYLUJL PU [YLHK KLW[O VU VUL H_SL

T\Z[UV[L_JLLK 

/HUKSPUNPUJVUZPZ[LUJPLZTH`YLZ\S[

7LYMVYTH]PZ\HSPUZWLJ[PVUPMULJLZZHY`

aF˜Fzd"4FhFm›’

0M PU KV\I[ JVU[HJ[ `V\Y 7VYZJOL KLHSLY VY

7VYZJOL0TWVY[LYVM`V\YJV\U[Y`

<ZL VUS` [PYL THRLZ HUK [`WLZ [LZ[LK I`

7VYZJOL

0M `V\ KV UV[ \ZL H 7VYZJOL YLJVTTLUKLK

YLWSHJLTLU[ [PYL THR L Z\YL [OH[ `V\ W\YÍ

JOHZL `V\Y UL^ [PYLZ MYVT H YLW\[HISL [PYL

KLHSLYHUK[OH[[OLKLHSLYJVTWSPLZ^P[OHSS

THU\MHJ[\YLYZ^HYUPUNZMVY[OVZL[PYLZ

6US`[PYLZ^P[O[OLZHTLTHRLHUK^P[O[OL

ZHTLZWLJPMPJH[PVUJVKLLNs5rs5r

JHUILTV\U[LK

)LMVYLTV\U[PUNUL^[PYLZJOLJR^P[O`V\Y

7VYZJOL KLHSLY HIV\[ [OL J\YYLU[ YLSLHZL

Z[H[\Z

<ZL [PYLZ ^P[O sA9r X\HSP[` Z[HUKHYKZ ;OLYL

HYL J\YYLU[S` UV Z[HUKHYKZ JVUJLYUPUN [PYL

Z[YLUN[OH[ZWLLKZHIV]LTWORTO

;PYLZZOV\SKILYLWSHJLKUVSLZZ[OHUVUVULH_SLH[

[OL[PTL

6US`[PYLZVM[OLZHTLTHRLHUK[`WLT\Z[IL\ZLK

4P_LK[PYLZHYLUV[WLYTPZZPISL

0UP[PHSS` UL^ [PYLZ KV UV[ OH]L [OLPY M\SS [YHJ[PVU

@V\ ZOV\SK [OLYLMVYL KYP]L H[ TVKLYH[L ZWLLKZ

K\YPUN[OLMPYZ[ÌTPSLZÌRT

0MUL^[PYLZHYLPUZ[HSSLKVUS`VUVULH_SLHUVÌ

[PJLHISL JOHUNL PU OHUKSPUN VJJ\YZ K\L [V [OL

KPMMLYLU[[YLHKKLW[OVM[OLV[OLY[PYLZ

;OPZ OHWWLUZ LZWLJPHSS` PM VUS` YLHY [PYLZ HYL YLÌ

WSHJLK /V^L]LY [OPZ JVUKP[PVU KPZHWWLHYZ HZ

[OLUL^[PYLZHYLIYVRLUPU

7SLHZLHKQ\Z[`V\YKYP]PUNZ[`SLHJJVYKPUNS`

0UZ[HSSH[PVU VM UL^ [PYLZ ZOV\SK VUS` IL KVUL I`

HX\HSPMPLK[PYL[LJOUPJPHU

=HS]LZ
9\IILY ]HS]L Z[LTZ T\Z[ IL YLWSHJLK L]LY`

[PTLH[PYLPZYLWSHJLK

-VYZ[LLS]HS]LZ[OLPUZ[HSSH[PVUHUKYLWSHJLTLU[

PUZ[Y\J[PVUZT\Z[ILVIZLY]LK

<ZLVUS`NLU\PUL7VYZJOLZ[LLS]HS]LZ

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

s–Q

background image

"camV˜"›˜›^F˜4¤*

>HYUPUN

/HYK PTWHJ[Z HNHPUZ[ J\YIZ VY [YHMMPJ

PZSHUKZHYLKHUNLYV\ZHUKTH`JH\ZLOPKÍ

KLU [PYL KHTHNL ^OPJO PZ UV[ UV[PJLHISL

\U[PSSH[LY:\JOKHTHNLJHUYLZ\S[PUHJJPÍ

KLU[Z H[ OPNO ZWLLKZ JH\ZPUN ZL]LYL WLYÍ

ZVUHSPUQ\Y`

+LWLUKPUNVU[OLMVYJLVMPTWHJ[[OLLKNL

VM[OLYPTJHUHSZVILKHTHNLK

0M `V\ HYL PU KV\I[ OH]L [OL ^OLLS JOLJRLK

I` HU L_WLY[ WHY[PJ\SHYS` PM `V\ Z\ZWLJ[ KHTÌ

HNLVU[OLPUZPKL

0M `V\ T\Z[ KYP]L V]LY H J\YI VY V[OLY VIÌ

Z[HJSL KYP]L ZSV^S` HUK H[ HU VI[\ZL HUNSL

,_LYJPZLJHYL^OLUWHYRPUNHSVUNJ\YIZ

^FFd˜"daVmhFm›:˜§^FFd˜*"d"m4amV

(SZVYLMLY[Vs-V\YÌ>OLLSKYP]Lr

(ZHWYLJH\[PVUOH]L^OLLSZ^P[OZ\TTLY[PYLZ

IHSHUJLK PU [OL ZWYPUN HUK [OVZL ^P[O T\KHUK

ZUV^[PYLZILMVYL^PU[LY

<UIHSHUJLK ^OLLSZ TH` HMMLJ[ JHY OHUKSPUN HUK

[PYLSPML

6US` [OL ZWLJPMPLK ^LPNO[Z TH` IL \ZLK MVY

^OLLSIHSHUJPUN

:LSMÌHKOLZP]L ^LPNO[Z T\Z[ UV[ JVTL PU[V JVUÌ

[HJ[^P[OJSLHUPUNHNLU[ZZPUJL[OL`JV\SKKYVW

VMM

( ^OLLS ZOV\SK HS^H`Z IL IHSHUJLK HM[LY H [PYL

YLWHPY

<UL]LU[YLHK^LHYPUKPJH[LZ^OLLSPTIHSHUJL0U

[OPZ L]LU[ [OL ]LOPJSL ZOV\SK IL JOLJRLK H[ HU

H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

>HYUPUN

0M K\YPUN H QV\YUL` \UL]LU Y\UUPUN VY ]PÍ

IYH[PVUZ VJJ\Y [OH[ JV\SK IL JH\ZLK I`

KHTHNL[V[PYLZVY[OLJHY[OLZWLLKT\Z[

IL YLK\JLK PTTLKPH[LS` I\[ ^P[OV\[ IYHRÍ

PUNZOHYWS`

0M `V\JVU[PU\L`V\Y[YPW^P[OV\[OH]PUN[OL

JH\ZLVM[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLK`V\TPNO[SVZL

JVU[YVS VM `V\Y ]LOPJSL ^OPJO JV\SK JH\ZL

ZL]LYLWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`

:[VW[OL]LOPJSLHUKJOLJR[OL[PYLZ

0M UV JH\ZL MVY [OL MH\S[ JHU IL MV\UK KYP]L

JHYLM\SS` [V [OL ULHYLZ[ H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL

KLHSLY

s––˜˜

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

background image

Fhp¦amV˜"m=˜’›pamV˜›aF’

(M[LY JOHUNPUN HKQ\Z[ [PYL WYLZZ\YL HUK

[VYX\L ^OLLS IVS[Z KPHNVUHSS` [V  M[SI 

5T

:LLs*OHUNPUN^OLLSZr

;PYLZT\Z[HS^H`ZYLTHPUVU[OLZHTLZPKL

VM[OL]LOPJSL

>OLU^OLLSZHYLYLTV]LK[OLKPYLJ[PVUVMYV[HÌ

[PVU HUK WVZP[PVU VM LHJO ^OLLS ZOV\SK IL

THYRLK

,_HTWSL
-9MYVU[YPNO[-399HUK93

>OLLSZT\Z[HS^H`ZILMP[[LKPUHJJVYKHUJL^P[O

[OLPYTHYRPUN

;OL WYLJLW[PVU [OH[ [PYL K\YHIPSP[` HUK WLYMVYÌ

THUJL HYL PTT\UL [V [OL LMMLJ[Z VMZ[VYHNLHUK

HNLPZ\UMV\UKLK

*OLTPJHSHKKP[P]LZ^OPJOTHRL[OLY\IILYLSHZ[PJ

SVZL [OLPY LMMLJ[P]LULZZ PU[OLJV\YZLVM[PTLHUK

[OLY\IILYILJVTLZIYP[[SLHUKJYHJRZ

;OLYLMVYL [OL [PYLZ LZWLJPHSS` [OL ZWHYL

[PYLZOV\SKILPUZWLJ[LKMYVT[PTL[V[PTL

5V[L
<UKLY UV JPYJ\TZ[HUJLZ ZOV\SK [PYLZ VSKLY [OHU

`LHYZIL\ZLKVU`V\Y7VYZJOL

;OL HNL VM [OL [PYL JHU IL VI[HPULK MYVT [OL

s+6;r JVKL U\TILY 0M MVY L_HTWSL [OL SHZ[

MV\Y U\TILYZ YLHK  [OLU [OL [PYL ^HZ WYVÌ

K\JLKPU[OL[O^LLRVM

:[VYL[PYLZPUHJVVSHUKKY`WSHJL

mp§˜›aF’

-VY H IL[[LY NYPW VU ZUV^ HUK PJL \ZL YHKPHS 4:

[PYLZ^P[OZ[\KZ

*OLJR ^P[O `V\Y SVJHS 4V[VY =LOPJSL )\YLH\ MVY

WVZZPISLYLZ[YPJ[PVUZ

>HYUPUN

9PZR VM SVZZ VM JVU[YVS HUK KHTHNL [V [OL

]LOPJSLHZ^LSSHZZL]LYLWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`

;OL Z[HUKHYK [PYLZ WYVMPSL HUK Y\IILY TP_Í

[\YL HYL VW[PTPaLK MVY ^L[ HUK KY` KYP]PUN

JVUKP[PVUZHUKTH`UV[WYV]LMH]VYHISLMVY

ZUV^JVUKP[PVUZ

;OLYLMVYL PUZ[HSS 4: [PYLZ ILMVYL KYP]PUN PU

Z\JOJVUKP[PVUZ

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

s–•

background image

)LMVYL TV\U[PUN ZUV^ [PYLZ JVUZ\S[ ^P[O

`V\Y 7VYZJOL KLHSLY /L OHZ [OL [LJOUPJHS

PUMVYTH[PVU ULJLZZHY` [V HK]PZL `V\ VU

^OLLSHUK[PYLJVTWH[PIPSP[`

:UV^[PYLZZOV\SKOH]L[OLZHTLSVHKJHWHJP[`HZ

VYPNPUHSLX\PWTLU[[PYLZHUKZOV\SKILTV\U[LKVU

HSSMV\Y^OLLSZ

:UV^[PYLZ^P[OZ[\KZZOV\SKILY\UH[TVKLYH[L

ZWLLKZ^OLUUL^PUVYKLY[VNP]L[OLZ[\KZ[PTL

[VZL[[SL

>HYUPUN

;PYLZ ^P[O IHKS` ^VYU [YLHKZ HUK Z[\KZ HYL

]LY` KHUNLYV\Z HUK JV\SK JH\ZL HJJPKLU[Z

YLZ\S[PUNPUZL]LYLWLYZVUHSPUQ\YPLZ

4HRLZ\YL[OL`HYLYLWSHJLKPTTLKPH[LS`

+V UV[ KYP]L H ]LOPJSL LX\PWWLK ^P[O ZUV^ [PYLZ

H[WYVSVUNLKOPNOZWLLK

:UV^[PYLZKVUV[OH]L[OLZHTLKLNYLLVM[YHJÌ

[PVUVUKY`^L[VYZUV^MYLLYVHKZHZHUVYTHS

[PYL

-\Y[OLYTVYL ZUV^ [PYLZ ^LHY YHWPKS` \UKLY

[OLZLJVUKP[PVUZ

:UV^[PYLZKVUV[M\SMPSS[OLPYW\YWVZLPM[OL[YLHK

KLW[OPZSLZZ[OHUPUTT

*VTWS` ^P[O HSS Z[H[L HUK SVJHS SH^Z

NV]LYUPUN ZUV^ [PYL HUK [YLHK KLW[O

YLX\PYLTLU[Z

mp§˜4^"am’

*H\[PVU

9PZR VM KHTHNL [V IVK` H_SL VY IYHRL

JVTWVULU[Z

-P[ ZUV^ JOHPUZ VUS` [V [OL YLHY ^OLLSZ HUK

VUS`^P[O[OL[PYLYPTJVTIPUH[PVUSPZ[LKPU[OL

;LJOUPJHS+H[H

;V LUZ\YL HKLX\H[L JSLHYHUJL IL[^LLU JOHPU

HUK IVK` 7VYZJOLYLJVTTLUKZVUS`[OL\ZL

VM MPULÌSPUR JOHPUZ Z\JO HZ [OVZL HWWYV]LK I`

7VYZJOL

-VSSV^ PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ PZZ\LK I` [OL Z\WWSPLY VM

[OLJOHPUZ

+PMMLYLU[ Z[H[LZ HUK JV\U[YPLZ OH]L ]HY`PUN Z[H[\Ì

[VY` YLX\PYLTLU[Z YLNHYKPUN TH_PT\T ZWLLK

*OLJR ^P[O SVJHS H\[OVYP[PLZ MVY WVZZPISL YLZ[YPJÌ

[PVUZ

9LTV]LJOHPUZHZZVVUHZ[OLYVHKZHYLMYLL

VMPJLHUKZUV^

aF˜=F’aVm"›apm’

+\L [V UL^ ZWLLK HUK SVHK YH[PUNZ MVY YHKPHS

[PYLZUL^KLZPNUH[PVUZOH]LJVTLPU[VMVYJLMVY

ZUV^[PYLZMVY`V\Y7VYZJOL

;OLKLZPNUH[PVU[VIL\ZLKMVYA9[PYLZPZLN

 A9  A $ JVKL SL[[LY MVY YHKPHS [PYLZ

MVYZWLLKZHIV]LTWORTO

s–G˜˜

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

background image

"4c:˜ppd’

>HYUPUN

;OLQHJRT\Z[IL\ZLKVUS`[VYHPZL[OLJHY

MVY^OLLSJOHUNPUN

;OL QHJR T\Z[ UL]LY IL \ZLK HZ H Z\WWVY[

[V ^VYR \UKLYULH[O [OL ]LOPJSL 0M [OL QHJR

PZHJJPKLU[HSS`KPZSVKNLK`V\VYI`Z[HUKLYZ

JV\SKZ\MMLYZL]LYLWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`

5L]LY QHJR \W V[OLY ]LOPJSLZ VY V[OLY SVHKZ

^P[O[OLQHJR

(S^H`ZWSHJL[OLJHYVUZ[HISLZ\WWVY[ZPM`V\

OH]L[V^VYR\UKLYP[

>OLU ^VYRPUN \UKLY [OL ]LOPJSL HS^H`Z \ZL

ZHML[` Z[HUKZ ZWLJPMPJHSS` KLZPNULK MVY [OPZ

W\YWVZL

:LLJOHW[LYs*OHUNPUN>OLLSZr

;OLQHJR[VVSZJVTWYLZZVYHUKWYLZZ\YL[LZ[LY

HYLSVJH[LKPU[OLZWHYL^OLLS

aO›amV˜›^F˜F^a4dF˜§a›^˜"˜aO›amV

d"›Oph˜p˜ ""VF˜aO›

;OL JHY T\Z[ IL YHPZLK VUS` H[ [OL PSS\Z[YH[LK

QHJRPUNWVPU[Z:LLJOHW[LYs*OHUNPUN>OLLSZr

3PM[PUN H[ HU` V[OLY WSHJL TH` KHTHNL [OL

]LOPJSLVYTH`YLZ\S[PUWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`

*H\[PVU

9PZR VM ZLYPV\Z KHTHNL [V [OL LUNPUL VY

[OL]LOPJSL

5L]LY SPM[ [OL ]LOPJSL I` [OL LUNPUL [YHUZÌ

TPZZPVUVYH_SLZ

+VUq[ KHTHNL HU` ZLUZP[P]L JVTWVULU[Z PU

[OL]PJPUP[`VM[OLQHJRPUNWVPU[Z

d"›Oph˜daO›

)LMVYL [OL JHY PZ KYP]LU VU [V H SPM[PUN WSH[MVYT

P[ T\Z[ IL LUZ\YLK [OH[ [OLYL PZ LUV\NO ZWHJL

IL[^LLU[OLSPM[PUNWSH[MVYTHUK[OL]LOPJSL

""VF˜daO›˜

(NHYHNLSPM[T\Z[IL\ZLKVUS`H[[OLPSS\Z[YH[LK

QHJRPUNWVPU[Z

1HJRPUN H[ HU` V[OLY WSHJL TH` KHTHNL [OL

]LOPJSLVYTH`YLZ\S[PUWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

s–n

background image

z"F˜^FFd

;OLZWHYL^OLLSPZZLJ\YLKPU[OLS\NNHNLJVTÌ

WHY[TLU[^P[OH^PUNU\[(

;OLYL PZ H WSHZ[PJ ZOLL[ PU [OL [VVS WVJRL[ [V

Z[VYL[OLKHTHNLK^OLLS

=LOPJSLZ^P[O7VYZJOL*LYHTPJ

*VTWVZP[L)YHRL

)LMVYL PUMSH[PUN [OL ZWHYL ^OLLS VWLU [OL

SH[JOVU[OLSHZOPUNZ[YHWZHUKYLTV]LILS[Z

@V\Y]LOPJSLPZLX\PWWLK^P[OHJVSSHWZPISLZWHYL

^OLLS [OH[ T\Z[ IL PUMSH[LK ^P[O [OL LSLJ[YPJHS

JVTWYLZZVY^OLUULLKLK

;PYLWYLZZ\YL
=LOPJSLZ ^P[OV\[ 7VYZJOL *LYHTPJ *VTWVZP[L

)YHRL!WZPIHY

=LOPJSLZ ^P[O 7VYZJOL *LYHTPJ *VTWVZP[L

)YHRL!WZPIHY

0TWVY[HU[UV[L
-VSSV^HSS^HYUPUNZHUKPUZ[Y\J[PVUZMV\UKPU[OPZ

THU\HSMVYJOHUNPUNH^OLLS

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMHUHJJPKLU[

-VY ZHML[` YLHZVUZ [OL MVSSV^PUN PUZ[Y\JÍ

[PVUZ MVY [OL \ZL VM [OL ZWHYL ^OLLS T\Z[

ILMVSSV^LKL_HJ[S`

*OLJR [OL [PYL MPSSPUN WYLZZ\YL PTTLKPH[LS`

HM[LYMP[[PUN[OLZWHYL^OLLS

;OL ZWHYL ^OLLS T\Z[ IL \ZLK VUS` V]LY

ZOVY[KPZ[HUJLZPUJHZLZVMLTLYNLUJ`

(M[LY YLWHPY VY YLWSHJLTLU[ YLÌTV\U[ [OL

YVHK^OLLSHUK[PYLHZZVVUHZWVZZPISL

(]VPK YHWPK HJJLSLYH[PVU OHYK IYHRPUN HUK

OPNO JVYULYPUN ZWLLKZ [V WYL]LU[ SVZZ VM ]LÌ

OPJSLJVU[YVS

;OL TH_PT\T WLYTP[[LK ZWLLK PZ  TWO

RTOHUKT\Z[UV[ILL_JLLKLKILJH\ZL

VM HS[LYLK KYP]PUN JOHYHJ[LYPZ[PJZ HUK MVY YLHÌ

ZVUZVM^LHY

;OL[YLHKKLW[OVM[OLZWHYL^OLLSPZZ\IQLJ[

[V[OLZHTLSH^ZHZ[OLVYPNPUHS[PYLZ

;OL ]LOPJSL T\Z[ IL MP[[LK ^P[O VUS` VUL

ZWHYL^OLLS

+VUV[\ZLHZWHYL^OLLSMYVTV[OLY]LOPJSLZ

VU`V\YJHY

3PRL^PZL [OL ZWHYL ^OLLS MYVT `V\Y ]LOPJSL

T\Z[UV[IL\ZLKVUV[OLYJHYZ

;V H]VPK KHTHNL KV UV[ \ZL H\[VTH[PJ JHY

^HZOLZ^OLU[OLZWHYL^OLLSPZPUZ[HSSLK

s•¬˜˜

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

background image

z"4F˜amV’

>HYUPUN

9PZR VM HJJPKLU[ 0M PUJVYYLJ[S` MP[[LK [OL

ZWHYL ^OLLS TH` JVTL VMM ^OPSL KYP]PUN

^OPJOJV\SKYLZ\S[PUZLYPV\ZWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`

VYKLH[O

TTZWHJLYYPUNZVUYLHYH_SL!

0MTTZWHJLYYPUNZHYLMP[[LK[V[OL^OLLS

O\IZ [OL HWWYVWYPH[L ZWHJLY YPUN T\Z[ IL

YLTV]LKILMVYL[OLZWHYL^OLLSPZMP[[LK

;V TV\U[ [OL ZWHYL ^OLLS \ZL [OL ^OLLS

IVS[Z ^OPJO ^LYL \ZLK [V MHZ[LU [OL ZWHJLY

YPUN

^FFd˜pd›’

>HYUPUN

9PZRVM^OLLSIVS[IYLHRHNLHUK^OLLSZLWÍ

HYH[PVU YLZ\S[PUN PU ZL]LYL WLYZVUHS PUQ\Y`

VYKLH[O

-VSSV^HSSPUZ[Y\J[PVUZJVUJLYUPUN^OLLSIVS[Z

(S^H`ZJSLHU[OL^OLLSIVS[ZILMVYLMP[[PUN

(WWS` H [OPU JVH[ VM 6W[PTVS` ;( HS\TPUP\T

WHZ[L VU [OL [OYLHK HUK IL[^LLU [OL IVS[

OLHKHUKTV]HISLZWOLYPJHSJHWYPUNHYYV^Z

;OL ILHYPUN Z\YMHJL VM [OL ZWOLYPJHSJHW

MHJPUN[OL^OLLST\Z[UV[ILNYLHZLK

9LWSHJLKHTHNLK^OLLSIVS[Z

6US` \ZL [OL 6YPNPUHS 7VYZJOL ^OLLS IVS[Z

ZWLJPHSS`KLZPNULKMVY[OPZ]LOPJSL[`WL

5V[L
6U ]LOPJSLZ ^P[O  TT ZWHJLY YPUNZ VU [OL

YLHYH_SL[OL^OLLSZHYLZLJ\YLK^P[OU\[Z

aV^›FmamV˜›p„¤F

;PNO[LUPUN[VYX\LVM^OLLSIVS[ZHUK^OLLSU\[Z!

5T

^FFd˜F4¤amV˜pd›’

;OL ^YLUJO ZVJRL[ MVY [OL ^OLLS ZLJ\YPUN IVS[Z

PZPU[OL[VVSWVJRL[

;VSVVZLUVY[PNO[LU[OL^OLLSIVS[^P[OHU[PÌ[OLM[

WYV[LJ[PVUH^YLUJOZVJRL[^P[O[OLHWWYVWYPH[L

JVKPUN T\Z[ IL \ZLK IL[^LLU [OL ^OLLS IVS[

HUK[OL^OLLSÌIVS[ZWHUULY

>OLU WVZP[PVUPUN [OL ^YLUJO ZVJRL[ LUZ\YL

[OH[ P[ LUNHNLZ M\SS` PU [OL [LL[O VM [OL ^OLLS

IVS[

0M [OL ^OLLSZ OH]L [V IL YLTV]LK H[ [OL ^VYRÌ

ZOVW WSLHZL KV UV[ MVYNL[ [V OHUK V]LY [OL

^YLUJO ZVJRL[ MVY [OL ^OLLS ZLJ\YPUN IVS[Z

HSVUN^P[O[OLJHYRL`

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

s•s

background image

^"mVamV˜^FFd’

>HYUPUN

-HPS\YL [V MVSSV^ [OLZL PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ TH` YLÍ

Z\S[PUZLYPV\ZWLYZVUHSPUQ\YPLZ[V`V\VY[V

I`Z[HUKLYZ

)LMVYLJOHUNPUN[OL^OLLS

0M `V\ OH]L H MSH[ [PYL TV]L H ZHML KPZ[HUJL

VMM [OL YVHK ;\YU [OL LTLYNLUJ` MSHZOLY VU

HUK \ZL V[OLY ^HYUPUN KL]PJLZ [V HSLY[ V[OLY

TV[VYPZ[Z

+VUV[WHYR`V\Y]LOPJSL^OLYLP[TH`JVU[HJ[

KY` NYHZZ IY\ZO VY V[OLY MSHTTHISL THÌ

[LYPHSZ ;OL OV[ WHY[Z VM [OL L_OH\Z[ Z`Z[LT

JV\SK ZL[ Z\JO TH[LYPHSZ VU MPYL [OLYLI`

JH\ZPUN IV[O WYVWLY[` KHTHNL HUK ZL]LYL VY

MH[HSWO`ZPJHSPUQ\Y`

7HZZLUNLYZ T\Z[ UV[ YLTHPU PU [OL ]LOPJSL

^OLUP[PZQHJRLK\W

)LMVYL `V\ JOHUNL H ^OLLS IL Z\YL [OL

NYV\UK PZ SL]LS HUK MPYT 0M ULJLZZHY` \ZL H

IVHYK \UKLY [OL QHJR [V LUZ\YL [OH[ [OL QHJR

KVLZUV[ZPURPU[V[OLNYV\UK

:L[ [OL WHYRPUN IYHRL HUK ISVJR [OL ^OLLSZ

VWWVZP[L [OL MSH[ [PYL VU [OL V[OLY ZPKL VM [OL

]LOPJSL

>OPSLVWLYH[PUN[OLQHJR

;OL QHJR PZ VUS` [V IL \ZLK MVY JOHUNPUN H

^OLLS +V UV[ \ZL P[ HZ H Z\WWVY[ [V ^VYR

\UKLY[OLJHY

;OL JHY T\Z[ IL QHJRLK \W VUS` H[ [OL PSS\ZÌ

[YH[LKQHJRPUNWVPU[Z

3PM[PUNH[HU`V[OLYWSHJLTH`KHTHNL[OL]LÌ

OPJSLVYTH`YLZ\S[PUWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`

5L]LY QHJR [OL JHY \W I` [OL IVK` VY [OL

I\TWLYZ

-VY ZHML[` YLHZVUZ KV UV[ \ZL [PYL PUMSH[PUN

IV[[SLZ

+V UV[ \ZL JVTTLYJPHSS` H]HPSHISL ZLHSHU[

IV[[SLZ

s•¢˜˜

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

background image

F„¤Fm4F˜pO˜pzF"›apm

>HYUPUN

;OLQHJRT\Z[IL\ZLKVUS`[VYHPZL[OLJHY

MVY^OLLSJOHUNPUN

;OL QHJR T\Z[ UL]LY IL \ZLK HZ H Z\WWVY[

[V ^VYR \UKLYULH[O [OL ]LOPJSL 0M [OL QHJR

PZHJJPKLU[HSS`KPZSVKNLK`V\VYI`Z[HUKLYZ

JV\SKZ\MMLYZL]LYLWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`

5L]LY QHJR \W V[OLY ]LOPJSLZ VY V[OLY SVHKZ

^P[O[OLQHJR

(S^H`ZWSHJL[OLJHYVUZ[HISLZ\WWVY[ZPM`V\

OH]L[V^VYR\UKLYP[

>OLU ^VYRPUN \UKLY [OL ]LOPJSL HS^H`Z \ZL

ZHML[` Z[HUKZ ZWLJPMPJHSS` KLZPNULK MVY [OPZ

W\YWVZL

7SLHZL \ZL H Z\P[HISL RULL YLZ[ [V WYV[LJ[ `V\Y

JSV[OPUNHNHPUZ[ZVPSPUN

1HJRPUNWVPU[MVYMYVU[^OLLSJOHUNL

 :SPNO[S` SVVZLU [OL ^OLLS IVS[Z VM [OL ^OLLS

[VILJOHUNLK

 :L[\WQHJRVUS`H[[OLWVPU[ZWYV]PKLK

;OL QHJR MVV[ T\Z[ IL PU JVU[HJ[ V]LY P[Z

^OVSLHYLH

<ZLHZ\P[HISLZ\WWVY[PMULJLZZHY`

 /VSK QHJR Z[PSS HUK ^PUK P[ \W \U[PS P[Z OLHK

LU[LYZ[OLQHJRPUNWVPU[VU[OLJHY

6US` QHJR JHY \W \U[PS [OL ^OLLS [V IL

JOHUNLKPZJVTWSL[LS`VMM[OLNYV\UK

1HJRPUNWVPU[MVYYLHY^OLLSJOHUNL

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

s•

background image

:JYL^PUHZZLTIS`HPKMVY]LOPJSLZ^P[OV\[7VYZJOL

*LYHTPJ*VTWVZP[L)YHRL

 9LTV]L  VY  ^OLLS IVS[Z ZLL YLZWLJ[P]L

PSS\Z[YH[PVU 9LTV]L HZZLTIS` HPKZ MYVT [VVS

RP[HUKZJYL^PUPUZ[LHKVM[OL^OLLSIVS[Z

9LTV]L[OLYLTHPUPUN^OLLSIVS[Z

*H\[PVU

9PZRVMKHTHNL[VIYHRLKPZJZ

,UZ\YL[OH[[OLHZZLTIS`HPKZHYLZJYL^LKPU

^OLUJOHUNPUNH^OLLS

:JYL^PU[^VHZZLTIS`HPKZMVY]LOPJSLZ^P[O7VYZJOL

*LYHTPJ*VTWVZP[L)YHRL

 =LOPJSLZ ^P[O 7VYZJOL *LYHTPJ *VTWVÍ

ZP[L)YHRL

6WLU SH[JOLZ VU [OL SHZOPUN Z[YHWZ VM [OL

ZWHYL^OLLSHUKYLTV]LILS[Z

 4V\U[ [OL JVSSHWZPISL ZWHYL ^OLLS VU [OL

]LOPJSLILMVYLPUMSH[PUNP[

 7SLHZLUV[LJOHW[LYs>OLLSIVS[Zr

0UZLY[ MV\Y ^OLLS IVS[Z HUK [PNO[LU I` OHUK

9LTV]L HZZLTIS` HPKZ ZJYL^ PU YLTHPUPUN

IVS[

0UP[PHSS` [PNO[LU ZJYL^Z PU KPHNVUHSS` VWWVZP[L

ZLX\LUJLZV[OH[[OL^OLLSPZJLU[LYLK

  :JYL^ MPSSLY OVZL VM [OL JVTWYLZZVY VU[V

[OL[PYL]HS]L

  0UZLY[ WS\N VM [OL JVTWYLZZVY PU[V [OL JPNHÌ

YL[[LSPNO[LY

;OLYLX\PYLKMPSSPUNWYLZZ\YL^PSSILYLHJOLK

HM[LYHML^TPU\[LZ

9LX\PYLKMPSSPUNWYLZZ\YL!

=LOPJSLZ ^P[OV\[ 7VYZJOL *LYHTPJ *VTWVÌ

ZP[L)YHRLWZPIHY

=LOPJSLZ ^P[O 7VYZJOL *LYHTPJ *VTWVZP[L

)YHRLWZPIHY

 <UZJYL^MPSSLYOVZLVM[OLJVTWYLZZVY

0M[OLWYLZZ\YLPZ[VVOPNOYLSLHZLZVTLHPY

I`WYLZZPUN[OL]HS]LPUZLY[

9LJOLJR[OLMPSSPUNWYLZZ\YL

 3V^LYJHYHUKYLTV]LQHJR

 ;PNO[LU ^OLLS IVS[Z PU KPHNVUHSS` VWWVZP[L

ZLX\LUJL

0TWVY[HU[UV[L
0TTLKPH[LS` HM[LY JOHUNPUN H ^OLLS HKQ\Z[ [OL

[PYL MPSSPUN WYLZZ\YL YLMLY [V 7HNL  HUK \ZL H

[VYX\L ^YLUJO [V JOLJR [OL WYLZJYPILK [PNO[LÌ

UPUN[VYX\LVM[OL^OLLSIVS[Z5T

s•T˜˜

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

background image

(M[LY\ZPUN[OLJVSSHWZPISLZWHYL^OLLS

9LSLHZLHPYI`\UZJYL^PUN[OL]HS]LPUZLY[

;OL [PYL ^PSS YL]LY[ [V P[Z VYPNPUHS ZOHWL VUS`

HM[LY ZL]LYHS OV\YZ 6US` [OLU JHU P[ IL

Z[V^LK PU [OL ZWHYL ^OLLS YLJLZZ PU [OL

S\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[

=LOPJSLZ ^P[O 7VYZJOL *LYHTPJ *VTWVZP[L

)YHRL

;OLZWHYL^OLLSJHUUV[ILZ[V^LKPU[OLZWHYL

^OLLSYLJLZZ^P[OV\[H[[HJOLKSHZOPUNZ[YHWZ

(M[LY YLSLHZPUN [OL HPY H[[HJO [OL SHZOPUN

Z[YHWZVU[OLVWWVZP[LZPKLZ

;VKV[OPZW\SS[OLZ[YHWZ[OYV\NO[OLYPTHUK

WSHJLHYV\UK[OL[PYLZ

7VZP[PVU [OL Z[YHWZ ZV [OH[ [OL Z[YHW SH[JOLZ

HYLPU[OLPUULYZPKLVM[OLYPT

*SVZLZ[YHWSH[JOLZHUKW\SS[OLZ[YHWZ[H\[

:[V^[OLJVSSHZWPISLZWHYL^OLLSPU[OLZWHYL

^OLLS YLJLZZ ZV [OH[ [OL SHZOPUN Z[YHWZ HYL

SVJH[LKH[[OLMYVU[HUKYLHYZLLPSS\Z[YH[PVU

Fz"a

;OL JVSSHWZPISL ZWHYL ^OLLS T\Z[ IL YLWHPYLK

VUS` I` [OL THU\MHJ[\YLY 7SLHZL JVUZ\S[ `V\Y

H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY PM [OL JVSSHWZPISL

ZWHYL^OLLSPZKLMLJ[P]L

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

s•Q

background image

dF4›a4"d˜©’›Fh

0UVYKLY[VH]VPKKHTHNLHUKMH\S[ZPULSLJ[YPJHS

VY LSLJ[YVUPJ Z`Z[LTZ LSLJ[YPJHS HJJLZZVYPLZ

ZOV\SK IL PUZ[HSSLK H[ `V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL

KLHSLY

6US`\ZLHJJLZZVYPLZH\[OVYPaLKI`7VYZJOL

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMZOVY[JPYJ\P[HUKMPYL

9LWSHJPUN M\ZLZ VY YLSH`Z ^P[O [OL LUNPUL

Y\UUPUNVY[OLPNUP[PVUVUJV\SKJH\ZLLSLJÍ

[YPJHSZOVJR

+PZJVUULJ[LK [OL IH[[LY` K\YPUN HSS ^VYR VU

[OLLSLJ[YPJHSZ`Z[LT:LLJOHW[LYs)H[[LY`r

Fd"©’

+LMLJ[P]L YLSH`Z ZOV\SK IL JOHUNLK VUS` I` HU

H\[OVYPaLK^VYRZOVW

"=ap˜4p=F

;OL [OLM[ÌWYV[LJ[PVU JVKL VM [OL YHKPV T\Z[ IL

LU[LYLKHNHPUPM[OLIH[[LY`^HZKPZJVUULJ[LK

d"h˜’©’›Fh:˜4Fm›"d˜dp4camV

;OL Z[H[\Z VM [OL JLU[YHS SVJRPUN HUK HSHYT

Z`Z[LT PZ UV[ JOHUNLK I` KPZJVUULJ[PUN [OL

IH[[LY`

>OLU[OLIH[[LY`PZKPZJVUULJ[LK[OLHSHYTZ`ZÌ

[LTJLHZLZ[VM\UJ[PVU

¦Fdp"=˜zp›F4›apm

0M [OL JLU[YHS SVJRPUN Z`Z[LT PZ VWLYH[LK TVYL

[OHU[LU[PTLZ^P[OPUHTPU\[LM\Y[OLYVWLYH[PVU

PZISVJRLKMVYZLJVUKZ

p"=˜’§a›4^_pOO˜"O›F˜›§p˜^p¤’

p˜Oa¦F˜="©’

0M [OL PNUP[PVU RL` PZ YLTV]LK SVHKZ ^OPJO HYL

Z^P[JOLK VU VY PU Z[HUKI`LNWV^LY^PUKV^Z

S\NNHNL JVTWHY[TLU[ SPNO[PUN PU[LYPVY SPNO[

YHKPV HYL H\[VTH[PJHSS` Z^P[JOLK VMM HM[LY HWÌ

WYV_PTH[LS`OV\YZ

0M[OL]LOPJSLPZUV[Z[HY[LKVY\USVJRLK^P[O[OL

YLTV[L JVU[YVS ^P[OPU  KH`Z [OL YLTV[L JVUÌ

[YVS Z[HUKI` M\UJ[PVU PZ Z^P[JOLK VMM [V WYL]LU[

KPZJOHYNPUNVM[OL]LOPJSLIH[[LY`

 0U[OPZJHZL\USVJR[OLKYP]LYqZKVVY^P[O[OL

RL`H[[OLKVVYSVJR

3LH]L[OLKVVYJSVZLKPUVYKLY[VWYL]LU[[OL

HSHYTZ`Z[LTMYVTILPUN[YPNNLYLK

 7YLZZI\[[VUVU[OLYLTV[LJVU[YVS

;OLYLTV[LJVU[YVSPZUV^HJ[P]H[LKHNHPU

s•–˜˜

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

background image

(Í+PHNUVZ[PJZVJRL[

Fzd"4amV˜O¤’F’

0U VYKLY [V WYL]LU[ KHTHNL [V JHISLZ HUK JVUÌ

Z\TLYZPU[OLLSLJ[YPJHSZ`Z[LTK\L[VZOVY[JPYÌ

J\P[Z HUK V]LYSVHKZ [OL PUKP]PK\HS JPYJ\P[Z HYL

WYV[LJ[LKI`M\ZLZ

;OLM\ZLIV_PZH[SV^LYSLM[PU[OLKYP]LYqZMVV[Ì

^LSSHUKPZWYV[LJ[LK^P[OHWSHZ[PJJV]LY

)Í7SHZ[PJNYPWWLY

*Í:WHYLM\ZLZ

 )LMVYLYLWSHJPUNHM\ZLZ^P[JOVMMHSSLSLJ[YPÌ

JHSJVUZ\TLYZHUKYLTV]L[OLPNUP[PVURL`

 ;VVWLUW\SS[OLJV]LYVMMH[[OLMPUNLYOVSL

HYYV^

;OL M\ZL WSHU HUK PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ MVY LTLYÍ

NLUJ` \USVJRPUN VM [OL S\NNHNL JVTÍ

WHY[TLU[SPKHUKLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[SPK

JHUILMV\UKVU[OLPUZPKLVM[OLJV]LY

 ;V JOLJR VY YLWSHJL H M\ZL YLTV]L P[ MYVT

[OLZWYPUNJSPW\ZPUN[OLWSHZ[PJNYPWWLY)

(ISV^UM\ZLPUKPJH[LZHUV]LYSVHKPU[OLJPYÌ

J\P[HUKJHUILPKLU[PMPLKI`[OLTLS[LKTL[HS

Z[YPW

 9LWSHJLVUS`^P[OM\ZLZVM[OLZHTLYH[PUN

:WHYL M\ZLZ * HYL PU [OL SV^LZ[ ZLJ[PVU VM

[OLM\ZLIV_

0TWVY[HU[UV[L

0MHM\ZLISV^ZYLWLH[LKS`WSLHZLPTTLKPH[LS`

JVUZ\S[HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLYZV[OH[

[OL ZOVY[ JPYJ\P[ JHU IL SVJH[LK HUK JVYÌ

YLJ[LK

5L]LY [Y` [V sYLWHPYr M\ZLZ! `V\ TH` JH\ZL

ZLYPV\Z KHTHNL [V V[OLY WHY[Z VM [OL LSLJ[YPÌ

JHSZ`Z[LT

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

s••

background image

hFVFm4©˜¤mdp4camV˜pO˜›^F˜d¤VV"VF

4phz"›hFm›˜da=˜"m=˜FmVamF

4phz"›hFm›˜da=

0M [OL IH[[LY` PZ KPZJOHYNLK [OL SPKZ JHU IL

VWLULKVUS`^P[O[OLHPKVMHKVUVYIH[[LY`

<USVJRPUNSPKZ
 <ZL[OLRL`[V\USVJR[OL]LOPJSLH[[OLKVVY

SVJR

3LH]L[OLRL`PU[OLKVVYSVJR

 9LTV]LWSHZ[PJJV]LYV]LY[OLM\ZLIV_

 7\SSV\[WVZP[P]L[LYTPUHS(PU[OLM\ZLIV_

 <ZL H Q\TWLY JHISL [V JVUULJ[ [OL WVZP[P]L

[LYTPUHS VM [OL KVUVY IH[[LY` ^P[O WVZP[P]L

[LYTPUHS(PU[OLM\ZLIV_

5V[L
0M [OL ]LOPJSL ^HZ SVJRLK [OL HSHYT OVYU ^PSS

ZV\UK^OLU[OLULNH[P]LJHISLPZJVUULJ[LK

 <ZL [OLZLJVUKQ\TWLYJHISL[VJVUULJ[[OL

ULNH[P]L [LYTPUHS VM [OL KVUVY IH[[LY` ^P[O

SH[JOZ[YPRLY)

 :^P[JO [OL HSHYT Z`Z[LT VMM I` SVJRPUN HUK

\USVJRPUNH[[OLKVVYSVJR

 <USVJR [OL LUNPUL JVTWHY[TLU[ SPK VY S\NÌ

NHNLJVTWHY[TLU[SPK^P[O[OLZ^P[JO

 +PZJVUULJ[ [OL ULNH[P]L JHISL MPYZ[ [OLU [OL

WVZP[P]LJHISL

 7\ZO WVZP[P]L [LYTPUHS ( PU[V [OL M\ZL IV_

HUKW\ZOVU[OLWSHZ[PJM\ZLIV_JV]LY

5V[L
;OLLUNPULJHUUV[ILZ[HY[LK^P[O[OPZTL[OVK

7SLHZLVIZLY]L[OLJOHW[LYr,TLYNLUJ`:[HY[PUN

^P[O1\TWLY*HISLZsMVY[OPZW\YWVZL

s•G˜˜

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

background image

"››F©

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMZOVY[JPYJ\P[HUKMPYL

6IZLY]LHSS^HYUPUNUV[LZVU[OLIH[[LY`

+PZJVUULJ[ [OL IH[[LY` K\YPUN HSS ^VYR VU [OL

LSLJ[YPJHSZ`Z[LT

+VUV[SH`[VVSZVYV[OLYTL[HSVIQLJ[ZVU[OL

IH[[LY` HZ [OL` JV\SK JH\ZL H ZOVY[ JPYJ\P[

HJYVZZ[OLIH[[LY`[LYTPUHS

/`KYVNLU NHZ NLULYH[LK I` [OL IH[[LY`

JV\SK JH\ZL HU L_WSVZPVU YLZ\S[PUN PU

ZL]LYLWLYZVUHSPUQ\YPLZ

+V UV[ L_WVZL [OL IH[[LY` [V HU VWLU MSHTL

LSLJ[YPJHSZWHYRVYHSP[JPNHYL[[L

9PZR VM ZL]LYL WLYZVUHS PUQ\Y` HUK KHTHNL

[V[OLMHIYPJTL[HSVYWHPU[

>LHYL`LWYV[J[PVU

+V UV[ HSSV^ IH[[LY` HJPK [V JVTL PU JVU[HJ[

^P[O `V\Y ZRPU L`LZ MHIYPJ VY WHPU[LK Z\YÌ

MHJLZ

0M`V\NL[LSLJ[YVS`[L^OPJOPZHUHJPKPU`V\Y

L`LZ VY VU `V\Y ZRPU PTTLKPH[LS` YPUZL ^P[O

JVSK^H[LYMVYZL]LYHSTPU\[LZHUKJHSSHKVJÌ

[VY

:WPSSLK LSLJ[YVS`[L T\Z[ IL YPUZLK VMM H[ VUJL

^P[O H ZVS\[PVU VM IHRPUN ZVKH HUK ^H[LY [V

UL\[YHSPaL[OLHJPK

)H[[LY` WVZ[Z [LYTPUHSZ HUK YLSH[LK HJJLZÍ

ZVYPLZ JVU[HPU SLHK HUK SLHK JVTWV\UKZ

JOLTPJHSZ RUV^U [V [OL :[H[L VM *HSPMVYUPH

[VJH\ZLJHUJLYHUKYLWYVK\J[P]LOHYT

(S^H`Z WYV[LJ[ `V\Y ZRPU I` ^HZOPUN [OVYÌ

V\NOS`^P[OZVHWHUK^H[LY

^"VF˜’›"›F

(^LSSJOHYNLKIH[[LY`^PSSUV[VUS`WYL]LU[Z[HY[Ì

PUNWYVISLTZI\[^PSSHSZVSHZ[SVUNLY

0UVYKLY[VH]VPKKPZJOHYNPUN[OLIH[[LY`

\UPU[LU[PVUHSS`!

*\Y[HPS \UULJLZZHY` WV^LY JVUZ\TW[PVU WHYÌ

[PJ\SHYS` PU JP[` [YHMMPJ VY ^OLU [YH]LSSPUN ZOVY[

KPZ[HUJLZVUS`

(S^H`Z YLTV]L [OL PNUP[PVU RL` ^OLU SLH]PUN

[OLJHY

(]VPK \ZPUN [OL 7VYZJOL *VTT\UPJH[PVU

4HUHNLTLU[ Z`Z[LT ^OLU [OL LUNPUL PZ UV[

Y\UUPUN

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

s•n

background image

"››F©˜4"F

,UZ\YL[OH[IH[[LY`PZZLJ\YLS`TV\U[LK

2LLW [LYTPUHSZ HUK JVUULJ[PVUZ JSLHU HUK

WYVWLYS`[PNO[LULK

*VYYVZPVU JHU IL WYL]LU[LK I` JVH[PUN [OL

[LYTPUHSZHUKJVUULJ[PVUZ^P[OWL[YVSL\TQLSS`

VYZPSPJVULZWYH`

,UZ\YL [OH[ ]LU[ JHWZ HYL ZLJ\YLS` [PNO[LULK

[VWYL]LU[ZWPSSHNL

*OLJRPUN[OLLSLJ[YVS`[LMS\PKSL]LS
.LULYHSS` [OL LSLJ[YVS`[LSL]LST\Z[ILJOLJRLK

TVYL VM[LU PU Z\TTLY [OHU PU [OL ^PU[LY HUK

TVYLVM[LU^OLUKYP]PUNSVUNKPZ[HUJLZ

>OLUHKKPUN^H[LY\ZLVUS`JSLHU]LZZLSZ

0U UV JHZL TH` HSJVOVS LN ^PUKV^ JSLHULY

YLZPK\LZILWLYTP[[LK[VLU[LY[OLIH[[LY`

<UZJYL^HUKVWLU[OLMPSSLY]LU[JHWZVMLHJO

JLSS

>P[O [OL JHY OVYPaVU[HS [OL MS\PK SL]LS ZOV\SK

TLL[[OLPUKPJH[VYTHYRPULHJOJLSS

0MULJLZZHY`[VW\W^P[OKPZ[PSSLK^H[LY

+VUV[\ZLHJPK

6US`MPSS\W[V[OLTHYRV[OLY^PZL[OLLSLJ[YVÌ

S`[L ^PSS V]LYMSV^ ^OLU [OL IH[[LY` PZ ILPUN

JOHYNLKHUKJH\ZLKHTHNL

)H[[LY`JOHYNPUN
(\[VTV[P]L IH[[LYPLZ SVVZL [OLPY LMMPJPLUJ` ^OLU

UV[PU\ZL

;OL JOHYNL H]HPSHISL PU `V\Y IH[[LY` JHU IL

TLHZ\YLK^P[OHIH[[LY`O`KYVTL[LY

>L YLJVTTLUK [OH[ [OL IH[[LY` ]VS[HNL IL

[LZ[LK I` `V\Y 7VYZJOL KLHSLY ^OV OHZ [OL HWÌ

WYVWYPH[LLX\PWTLU[

0M [OL JHY PZ UV[ KYP]LU MVY WYVSVUNLK WLYPVKZ

[OL IH[[LY` T\Z[ IL JOHYNLK H[ SLHZ[ L]LY` 

^LLRZ

( KPZJOHYNLK IH[[LY` HSSV^Z YHWPK MVYTH[PVU VM

Z\SMH[LZ SLHKPUN [V WYLTH[\YL KL[LYPVYH[PVU VM

[OLWSH[LZ

sG¬˜˜

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

background image

>HYUPUN

/`KYVNLU NHZ NLULYH[LK I` [OL IH[[LY`

JV\SK JH\ZL HU L_WSVZPVU YLZ\S[PUN PU

ZL]LYLWLYZVUHSPUQ\YPLZ

*OHYNLIH[[LY`PUH^LSS]LU[PSH[LKHYLH

5L]LYJOHYNLHMYVaLUIH[[LY`0[TH`L_WSVKL

ILJH\ZL VM NHZ [YHWWLK PU [OL PJL (SSV^ H

MYVaLUIH[[LY`[V[OH^V\[MPYZ[

0M`V\NL[LSLJ[YVS`[L^OPJOPZHUHJPKPU`V\Y

L`LZ VY VU `V\Y ZRPU PTTLKPH[LS` YPUZL ^P[O

JVSK^H[LYMVYZL]LYHSTPU\[LZHUKJHSSHKVJÌ

[VY

:SV^IH[[LY`JOHYNPUN
 7H` H[[LU[PVU [V HSS ^HYUPUNZ HUK MVSSV^ PUÌ

Z[Y\J[PVUZ [OH[ JVTL ^P[O `V\Y IH[[LY`

JOHYNLY

 >OLUJOHYNPUNLUZ\YLHKLX\H[L]LU[PSH[PVU

 9LTV]LIH[[LY`ZLLs9LTV]PUNIH[[LY`r

 (SS]LU[JHWZZOV\SKILVWLU

;OLMS\PKSL]LSZOV\SKTLL[[OLPUKPJH[VYTHYR

PULHJOJLSS

 ,UZ\YL[OH[JOHYNLYPZZ^P[JOLKVMMuKHUNLY

VMZOVY[JPYJ\P[

 *VUULJ[JOHYNLYJHISLZ

*OHYNLYJHISLZT\Z[ILJVUULJ[LK

76:0;0=,[V76:0;0=,HUK

5,.(;0=,u[V5,.(;0=,u

 :^P[JOVUJOHYNLY

5VYTHSS` H IH[[LY` ZOV\SK IL JOHYNLK H[ UV

TVYL [OHU  WLYJLU[ VM P[Z YH[LK JHWHJP[`

9H[LK JHWHJP[` VM [OL IH[[LY` PU `V\Y ]LOPJSL

PZSPZ[LKVU[OLIH[[LY`OV\ZPUN

 (M[LY JOHYNPUN [\YU VMM JOHYNLY HUK KPZJVUÌ

ULJ[JOHYNLYJHISLZ

 ;PNO[LU [OL ]LU[ JHWZ HUK YLPUZ[HSS IH[[LY`

ZLLs0UZ[HSSPUNIH[[LY`r

am›F˜pzF"›apm

+\YPUN[OL^PU[LYTVU[OZIH[[LY`JHWHJP[`[LUKZ

[VKLJYLHZLHZ[LTWLYH[\YLZKYVW

(KKP[PVUHSS` TVYL WV^LY PZ JVUZ\TLK ^OPSL

Z[HY[PUNHUK[OLOLHKSPNO[ZOLH[LYYLHY^PUKV^

KLMVNNLYL[JHYL\ZLKTVYLMYLX\LU[S`

3L[`V\Y7VYZJOLKLHSLY[LZ[[OLIH[[LY`qZJHÌ

WHJP[`ILMVYL^PU[LYZL[ZPU

Fzd"4amV˜*"››F©

;OL ZLY]PJL SPML VM [OL IH[[LY` PZ Z\IQLJ[ [V UVYÌ

THS ^LHY" P[ KLWLUKZ NYHL[S` VU JHYL JSPTH[PJ

JVUKP[PVUZ HUK KYP]PUN JVUKP[PVUZ KPZ[HUJLZ

SVHKZ

6US`\ZLHUVYPNPUHS7VYZJOLIH[[LY`^P[O[OL

JVYYLJ[WHY[U\TILYHZHYLWSHJLTLU[

7SLHZL VIZLY]L [OL KPZWVZHS PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ MVY

IH[[LYPLZ

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

sGs

background image

Fhp¦amV˜›^F˜*"››F©

;OLYLX\PZP[L[VVSPZPU[OL[VVSRP[

;OL IH[[LY` PZ SVJH[LK PU [OL S\NNHNL JVTWHY[Ì

TLU[\UKLYHISHJRWSHZ[PJSPK

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMKHTHNL[VHS[LYUH[VYHUKLSLJ[YVUPJ

JVU[YVS\UP[Z

+V UV[ KPZJVUULJ[ [OL IH[[LY` ^OPSL [OL LUÌ

NPULPZY\UUPUN

;OPZHSZVHWWSPLZ[VJHYZLX\PWWLK^P[OHIH[Ì

[LY`THPUZ^P[JO

5L]LY KYP]L [OL JHY ^P[O H KPZJVUULJ[LK IH[Ì

[LY`

9PZRVMJH\Z[PJI\YUZMYVTLZJHWPUNHJPK

2LLW]LU[JHWZVU[VH]VPKZWPSSHNL

+V UV[ [PS[ [OL IH[[LY` ^OLU YLTV]PUN HUK PUÌ

Z[HSSPUNP[

 :^P[JOVMMLUNPULHUKHSSLSLJ[YPJHSSVHKZ

 6WLU[\YUÌSVJRZ(

9LTV]LWSHZ[PJSPK

 7\SSVMMJLU[YHS]LU[OVZL)

 0TWVY[HU[!KPZJVUULJ[[OLULNH[P]LuNYV\UK

^PYL MPYZ[ HUK [OLU [OL WVZP[P]L  JHISL u

KHUNLYVMZOVY[JPYJ\P[

 <UZJYL^MHZ[LUPUNZJYL^*

 9LTV]LIH[[LY`

m’›"ddamV˜›^F˜*"››F©

 7\[IH[[LY`PU

 :JYL^PUMHZ[LUPUNZJYL^*

 0TWVY[HU[! JVUULJ[ [OL WVZP[P]L  JHISL

MPYZ[HUK[OLU[OLULNH[P]LuNYV\UK^PYLu

KHUNLYVMZOVY[JPYJ\P[

 7\ZOVUJLU[YHS]LU[OVZL)

 -P[WSHZ[PJSPK3VJR[\YUÌSVJRZ(

 ,U[LY[OLYHKPVJVKLHNHPU

sG¢˜˜

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

background image

Fzd"4amV˜›^F˜Fhp›F_4pm›pd˜*"››F©

( ^LHR IH[[LY` TH` IL YLJVNUPaLK I` [OL

JSLHYS`YLK\JLKHJ[PVUYHUNLVM[OLYLTV[LJVUÌ

[YVS VY ^OLU [OL SPNO[ÍLTP[[PUN KPVKL  PU [OL

RL`NYPWUVSVUNLYMSHZOLZ^OLU[OLYLTV[LJVUÌ

[YVSPZVWLYH[LK

 <ZPUN`V\YMPUNLYUHPSVYHZTHSSZJYL^KYP]LY

JHYLM\SS`SPM[VMM[OLJV]LYVM[OLRL`NYPW

 9LWSHJLIH[[LY`VIZLY]LWVSHYP[`

(ZWHYLIH[[LY`3P[OP\T*9]VS[ZPZ

H]HPSHISLH[`V\YH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY

 9LWSHJLJV]LYHUKWYLZZ[VNL[OLYMPYTS`

5V[L
(U` KPZWVZHS YLN\SH[PVUZ MVY IH[[LYPLZ T\Z[ IL

VIZLY]LK

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

sG

background image

hFVFm4©˜›"›amV˜§a›^˜ ¤hzF

"*dF’

:LL [OL JOHW[LY s)H[[LY`r HUK s,TLYNLUJ` \UÌ

SVJRPUNVM[OLSPKZr

0M [OL IH[[LY` PZ KPZJOHYNLK LN PU ^PU[LY VY

HM[LY [OL JHY OHZ ILLU WHYRLK MVY H SVUN [PTL

[OLIH[[LY`VMHUV[OLYJHYJHUIL\ZLKMVYZ[HY[Ì

PUN^P[O[OLOLSWVMQ\TWLYJHISLZ

4HRL Z\YL [OL ]VS[HNL VM IV[O IH[[LYPLZ PZ [OL

ZHTL

;OL JHWHJP[` (TWLYL OV\YZ (O VM [OL IVVZ[LY

IH[[LY` T\Z[ UV[ IL Z\IZ[HU[PHSS` SLZZ [OHU [OH[

VM[OLKPZJOHYNLKIH[[LY`

;OL KPZJOHYNLK IH[[LY` T\Z[ IL JVYYLJ[S` JVUÌ

ULJ[LK[V[OL]LOPJSLqZLSLJ[YPJHSZ`Z[LT

5V[L

+VUV[[Y`[VZ[HY[[OLJHYI`W\ZOPUNVY[V^Ì

PUN +HTHNL [V [OL JH[HS`[PJ JVU]LY[LYZ HUK

V[OLYJVTWVULU[ZVM[OLJHYTH`YLZ\S[

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMKHTHNLHUKZLYPV\ZWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`

K\L[VZOVY[JPYJ\P[

<ZL VUS`Q\TWLYJHISLZVMHKLX\H[LKPHTL[LY

JYVZZÌZLJ[PVU HUK MP[[LK ^P[O JVTWSL[LS` PUZ\Ì

SH[LKHSSPNH[VYJSPWZ

-VSSV^ HSS ^HYUPUNZ HUK PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ VM [OL

Q\TWLYJHISLTHU\MHJ[\YLY

>OLU JVUULJ[PUN Q\TWLY JHISLZ THRL Z\YL

[OH[ [OL` JHUUV[ NL[ JH\NO[ PU HU` TV]PUN

WHY[ZPU[OLLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[

;OL Q\TWLY JHISLZ T\Z[ IL SVUN LUV\NO ZV

[OH[ULP[OLY]LOPJSLZUVYJHISLZ[V\JOHUV[OLY

;OL ]LOPJSLZ T\Z[ UV[ IL PU JVU[HJ[ V[OLYÌ

^PZL J\YYLU[ TPNO[ MSV^ HZ ZVVU HZ [OL WVZPÌ

[P]L[LYTPUHSZHYLJVUULJ[LK

;OLJHISLJSHTWZT\Z[UV[ILHSSV^LK[VJVUÌ

[HJ[ LHJO V[OLY ^OLU VUL LUK VM [OL Q\TWLY

JHISLZHYLJVUULJ[LK[VHIH[[LY`

,UZ\YL [OH[ [VVSZ VY JVUK\J[P]L QL^LSSLY`

YPUNZJOHPUZ^H[JOZ[YHWZKVUV[JVTLPU[V

JVU[HJ[^P[OSP]LWHY[ZVM[OL]LOPJSL

0TWYVWLY OVVRÌ\W VM Q\TWLY JHISLZ JHU Y\PU

[OLHS[LYUH[VY

+HUNLYVMJH\Z[PJI\YUZ

+VUV[SLHUV]LY[OLIH[[LY`

+HUNLYVMNHZL_WSVZPVU

0TWYVWLY\ZLVMIVVZ[LYIH[[LY`[VZ[HY[H]LÌ

OPJSL TH` JH\ZL HU L_WSVZPVU YLZ\S[PUN PU

ZL]LYLWLYZVUHSPUQ\YPLZ

2LLW ZV\YJLZ VM PNUP[PVU H^H` MYVT [OL IH[Ì

[LY` LN VWLU MSHTL I\YUPUN JPNHYL[[LZ VY

ZWHYRPUN K\L [V JHISL JVU[HJ[ VY ^LSKPUN

^VYR

( KPZJOHYNLK IH[[LY` JHU MYLLaL L]LU H[

‰-u‰*

)LMVYL JVUULJ[PUN Q\TWLY JHISLZ H MYVaLU

IH[[LY`T\Z[IL[OH^LKV\[

sGT˜˜

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

background image

 $ 7VZP[P]L[LYTPUHSMVYQ\TWZ[HY[PUN

u $ .YV\UKPUNWVPU[MVYQ\TWZ[HY[PUN

*VUULJ[Q\TWLYJHISLZPU[OLMVSSV^PUNZLÍ

X\LUJL!
 *OLJR LSLJ[YVS`[L SL]LS VM LHJO JLSS 0M

ULJLZZHY` MPSS ^P[O KPZ[PSSLK ^H[LY [V Q\Z[

HIV]LWSH[LZ

 6U H ]LOPJSL ^P[O H KPZJOHYNLK IH[[LY`! [\YU

VMMHSSJVUZ\TLYZHUKHJJLZZVYPLZTV]L[OL

NLHY ZOPM[ SL]LY PU[V [OL UL\[YHS WVZP[PVU HUK

ZL[[OLWHYRPUNIYHRL

 6WLU [OL JHW VM [OL WVZP[P]L [LYTPUHS MVY

Q\TWZ[HY[PUN

 ([[HJO[OLWVZP[P]LJHISLMPYZ[[V[OLWVZP[P]L

[LYTPUHSMVYQ\TWZ[HY[PUN

[OLU [V [OL WVZP[P]L [LYTPUHS VM [OL IVVZ[LY

IH[[LY`

 *VUULJ[ [OL ULNH[P]L JHISL MPYZ[ [V [OL ULÌ

NH[P]L[LYTPUHSVM[OLIVVZ[LYIH[[LY`

[OLU [V [OL NYV\UKPUN WVPU[ MVY Q\TW Z[HY[PUN

u

 9\U[OLLUNPULVM[OLIVVZ[LYJHYH[HOPNOLY

ZWLLK

 :[HY[[OLLUNPUL

(U H[[LTW[LK Z[HY[ \ZPUN Q\TWLY JHISLZ

ZOV\SK UV[ SHZ[ TVYL [OHU  ZLJVUKZ ;OLU

HSSV^H^HP[PUNWLYPVKVMH[SLHZ[VULTPU\[L

 >P[O[OLLUNPULY\UUPUNKPZJVUULJ[IV[OQ\TÌ

WLYJHISLZPUYL]LYZLVYKLY

*SVZL[OLSPKVM[OLQ\TWZ[HY[IV_

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

sGQ

background image

aV^›’:˜Fzd"4amV˜¤d*’

>HYUPUN

9PZRVMZOVY[JPYJ\P[

(S^H`ZZ^P[JOVMM[OLYLSL]HU[JVUZ\TLY^OLU

JOHUNPUNI\SIZ

9PZR VM PUQ\Y` ;OL OLHKSPNO[Z HYL \UKLY

OPNO]VS[HNL^OLUPUZ[HSSLK

)L JHYLM\S K\YPUN HSS ^VYR PU [OL HYLH VM [OL

OLHKSPNO[Z

9PZR VM KHTHNL )\SIZ VM H OPNOLY ^H[[HNL

JHUKHTHNL[OLSHTWOV\ZPUN

6US` [OL I\SIZ ZOV^U PU [OL JOHY[ TH` IL

\ZLK

5L^ I\SIZ T\Z[ IL JSLHU HUK MYLL MYVT

NYLHZL;OLYLMVYLUL]LY[V\JOI\SIZ^P[O

`V\YIHYLOHUKZ

<ZL H JSV[O VY ZVM[ WHWLY ^OPSL YLWSHJPUN

I\SIZ

-VY YLHZVUZ VM [YHMMPJ ZHML[` ^L YLJVTTLUK

[OH[`V\HS^H`ZJHYY`ZWHYLI\SIZZV[OH[`V\

JHU OH]L H JVYYLJ[S` PSS\TPUH[LK JHY H[ HSS

[PTLZ

0U JLY[HPU JV\U[YPLZ [OL JHYY`PUN VM ZWHYL

I\SIZPZTHUKH[VY`

*H\[PVU!

9PZR VM KHTHNL [V OLHKSPNO[Z K\L [V L_Í

JLZZP]L[LTWLYH[\YLZHUKHIYHZPVU

([[HJO UV JV]LYPUNZ LN MPSTZ sZ[VUL

N\HYKZsPU[OLHYLHVM[OLOLHKSPNO[Z

<ZL ZVHW` ^H[LY VUS` [V JSLHU SPNO[ SLUZLZ

HUKWSHZ[PJOLHKSPNO[SLUZLZ

0U UV JHZL TH` JOLTPJHS JSLHULYZ VY V[OLY

]VSH[PSLJSLHUPUNMS\PKZIL\ZLK

;V WYL]LU[ ZJYH[JOLZ KV UV[ Y\I ^P[O H KY`

VY TLYLS` TVPZ[ JSV[O [PZZ\L VY PUZLJ[

ZWVUNLZ

sG–˜˜

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

background image

)\SI*OHY[

:VJRL[

7HYRPUNSPNO[MYVU[

)(? :

3V^ILHT

/PNOILHTNHZÌKPZJOHYNLSHTW

7OPSPWZ+:

(KKP[PVUHSOPNOILHT

OLHKSPNO[MSHZOLY

7.1 Ì

-VNSPNO[Z

72:

;\YUZPNUHSSPNO[

)(<:

9LHYMVNSPNO[YL]LYZPUNSPNO[

)(:

)YHRL[HPSSPNO[

)(@K

;HPSSPNO[

)(:

:PKLTHYRLYSPNO[

YLHKPUNSPNO[KVVYN\HYK

J\YISPNO[

>_ +

9HPZLKIYHRLSPNO[

>_ +

3PJLUZLWSH[LSPNO[

:=

3\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[LUNPUL

JVTWHY[TLU[SPNO[PU[LYPVYSPNO[

:=

;`WLYH[PUN

/>

>

/>

/>

7@>

7>

7>

9>

>>

>>

*>

2>

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

sG•

background image

F"=daV^›’

Fhp¦"d

 <UZJYL^WSHZ[PJU\[(

+L[HJOZPKLJHYWL[PUN

 9LTV]L Y\IILY WS\N ) MYVT [OL \USVJRPUN

VWLUPUN

 7SHJL ZVJRL[ ^YLUJO MYVT [VVS RP[ VU [OL

\USVJRPUNZWPUKSL

;OL OHUKSL VM [OL ^YLUJO ZOV\SK WVPU[

OVYPaVU[HSS`[V[OLYLHY

 ;\YU ZVJRL[ ^YLUJO HWWYV_ ‰ ( HUK

SLH]LPUWVZP[PVU

;OL OLHKSPNO[ PZ UV^ \USVJRLK HUK JHU IL

W\SSLKMVY^HYKV\[VM[OL^PUN

 ;\YU ZVJRL[ ^YLUJO IHJR \U[PS P[ PZ WVPU[PUN

]LY[PJHSS`KV^U^HYK)

sGG˜˜

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

background image

m’›"ddamV

 0UZLY[OLHKSPNO[PU[VN\PKLYHPSZHUKW\ZOM\SS`

PU[V[OL^PUN

 7\ZO OLHKSPNO[ [V [OL YLHY HUK H[ [OL ZHTL

[PTL [\YU [OL ZVJRL[ ^YLUJO \U[PS P[ WVPU[Z

OVYPaVU[HSS`[V[OLYLHY*

;OLOLHKSPNO[SVJRPUNKL]PJLT\Z[WLYJLW[PIS`

HUKH\KPIS`LUNHNL

 *OLJR OLHKSPNO[ MVY H MPYT ZLH[PUN LN I`

W\SSPUNP[PU[OLHYLHVM[OLMVNSPNO[

 0UZLY[ Y\IILY WS\N PU[V [OL \USVJRPUN VWLUPUN

HUKZLJ\YL[OLJHYWL[PUN

*OLJR[OLM\UJ[PVUVMHSSSPNO[Z

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

sGn

background image

p§˜*F"h:˜^aV^˜*F"h˜"m=˜"==a›apm"d

^aV^˜*F"h

6WLUPUN[OLSPKVM[OLOLHKSPNO[OV\ZPUN
 <UZJYL^[OL[^VZJYL^Z(

 7YLZZIV[OYLSLHZL[HIZ)HUKYLTV]LSPK

*OHUNPUNI\SIMVYSV^ILHTHUKOPNOILHT
 ;\YU WS\N JV\U[LYÌJSVJR^PZL IH`VUL[ SVJR

HUKW\SSP[VMM

 ;\YU JSHTWPUN YPUN JV\U[LYÌJSVJR^PZL IH`VUL[

SVJRHUKW\SSP[VMM

 9LWSHJLKLMLJ[P]LI\SI

>OLUKVPUNZVLUZ\YLI\SIPZZLH[LKWYVWLYS`

 9LHZZLTISLPUYL]LYZLVYKLY

5V[L

0U VYKLY [V WYL]LU[ PTWHPYTLU[ VM [OL OLHKSPNO[

ILHT HKQ\Z[TLU[ M\UJ[PVU [OL JHISL * VM [OL

WS\NT\Z[HS^H`ZWVPU[[V[OLV\[ZPKLVM[OL]LÌ

OPJSL

sn¬˜˜

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

background image

*OHUNPUNI\SIMVYHKKP[PVUHSOPNOILHT
 ;\YUI\SIOVSKLY

;\YUP[JV\U[LYÌJSVJR^PZLVU[OLSLM[OLHKSPNO[

HUKJSVJR^PZLVU[OLYPNO[OLHKSPNO[

;HRL I\SI OVSKLY V\[ VM [OL OLHKSPNO[ OV\ZÌ

PUN

 7\SSIV[OWS\NYLSLHZL[HIZHWHY[

7\SSWS\NV\[VM[OLI\SIOVSKLY

 9LWSHJL[OLKLMLJ[P]LI\SI^P[OI\SIOVSKLY

 9LHZZLTISLPUYL]LYZLVYKLY

*SVZPUNSPKVMOLHKSPNO[OV\ZPUN
 0UZLY[ YL[HPUPUN S\NZ VM SPK PU[V [OL IV[[VT VM

[OL OLHKSPNO[ OV\ZPUN HUK JSVZL SPK \U[PS P[

WLYJLW[PIS`LUNHNLZ

 :JYL^PUIV[OZJYL^Z

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

sns

background image

^"mVamV˜*¤d*˜Op˜z"camV˜daV^›

 ;\YU JHW PU [OL OLHKSPNO[ OV\ZPUN JV\U[LYÌ

JSVJR^PZLHUKYLTV]L[OLJHW

 ;\YUI\SIOVSKLY

;\YUP[JV\U[LYÌJSVJR^PZLVU[OLSLM[OLHKSPNO[

HUKJSVJR^PZLVU[OLYPNO[OLHKSPNO[

;HRL I\SI OVSKLY V\[ VM [OL OLHKSPNO[ OV\ZÌ

PUN

 ;\YU KLMLJ[P]L I\SI JV\U[LYÌJSVJR^PZL IH`Ì

VUL[SVJRHUKYLWSHJLP[

 9LHZZLTISLPUYL]LYZLVYKLY

^"mVamV˜*¤d*˜Op˜›¤m˜’aVm"d˜daV^›

 ;\YU I\SI OVSKLY PU [OL OLHKSPNO[ OV\ZPUN

JV\U[LYÌJSVJR^PZLHUKW\SSP[V\[

 ;\YU KLMLJ[P]L I\SI JV\U[LYÌJSVJR^PZL IH`Ì

VUL[SVJRHUKYLWSHJLP[

 9LHZZLTISLPUYL]LYZLVYKLY

sn¢˜˜

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

background image

^"mVamV˜*¤d*˜Op˜OpV˜daV^›

 ;\YU JHW PU [OL OLHKSPNO[ OV\ZPUN JV\U[LYÌ

JSVJR^PZLHUKYLTV]L[OLJHW

 7YLZZ [OL YL[HPUPUN JSPW KV^U ^P[O H ZJYL^Ì

KYP]LYHUKW\ZOP[[V[OLSLM[

 7P]V[[OLYL[HPUPUNJSPWIHJR

 7\SSI\SI^P[OJHISLV\[VM[OLOLHKSPNO[OV\ZÌ

PUN

 +PZJVUULJ[ WS\N JVUULJ[PVU HUK YLWSHJL [OL

KLMLJ[P]LI\SI

 9LHZZLTISLPUYL]LYZLVYKLY

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

sn

background image

^"mVamV˜¤d*˜am˜›^F˜a=F

"cF˜aV^›

 9LTV]L JHW PU [OL ^OLLS OV\ZPUN SPULY ^P[O

[OLZJYL^KYP]LY

 0UZLY[ ZJYL^KYP]LY PU[V [OL VWLUPUN PU [OL

^OLLSOV\ZPUNSPULYH[YPNO[HUNSLZ[V[OLZPKL

THYRLYSPNO[OV\ZPUN

)` WYLZZPUN ^P[O [OL ZJYL^KYP]LY KPZLUNHNL

[OL ZLJ\YPUN ZWYPUN VM [OL ZPKL THYRLY SPNO[

OV\ZPUN

 9LTV]L ZPKL THYRLY SPNO[ HUK \UKV I\SI

OVSKLYIH`VUL[SVJR

 9LTV]L I\SI MYVT [OL OVSKLY HUK YLWSHJL

0UZLY[OVSKLY

 0UZLY[[OLSPNO[[HIZHYYV^(PU[V[OL^PUNH[

[OLMYVU[

,UNHNLZLJ\YPUNZWYPUNHYYV^)PU[OL^PUN

 7YLZZJHWPU[V[OL^OLLSOV\ZPUNSPULY

*OLJRVWLYH[PVUVM[OLSPNO[

snT˜˜

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

background image

;HPSSPNO[SLM[

"ad˜aV^›

^"mVamV˜*¤d*

 6WLULUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[SPK

 <UZJYL^ MHZ[LUPUN ZJYL^Z ( ^P[O H ZJYL^Ì

KYP]LYHUKW\SS[HPSSPNO[IHJRHUKV\[

(Í9L]LYZPUNSPNO[

)Í;\YUZPNUHSSPNO[

*Í;HPSSPNO[IYHRLSPNO[

+Í;HPSSPNO[

,Í9LHYMVNSPNO[

-Í:PKLTHYRLYSPNO[

 ;\YU I\SI OVSKLY PU [OL [HPS SPNO[ OV\ZPUN

JV\U[LYÌJSVJR^PZLHUKW\SSP[V\[

 ;\YU KLMLJ[P]L I\SI JV\U[LYÌJSVJR^PZL IH`Ì

VUL[SVJRHUKYLWSHJLP[

 0UZLY[I\SIOVSKLYHUK[\YUP[JSVJR^PZL

 0UZLY[[HPSSPNO[PU[OL^PUN

,UZ\YL [OH[ SVJH[PUN S\N HYYV^ PZ JVYYLJ[S`

WVZP[PVULK

 :SPNO[S`ZJYL^PUIV[OMHZ[LUPUNZJYL^ZVM[OL

[HPSSPNO[

(SPNU [OL [HPS SPNO[ ^P[O [OL ]LOPJSL JVU[V\YZ

HUK[PNO[LU[OLZJYL^Z

 *OLJRVWLYH[PVUVM[OLSPNO[

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

snQ

background image

a4Fm’F˜d"›F˜aV^›’

^"mVamV˜*¤d*

 <UKVIV[OZJYL^ZHYYV^ZHUKYLTV]LSPNO[

 7\ZOY\IILYJV]LYPUNIHJRYLTV]LKLMLJ[P]L

I\SI MYVT IL[^LLU [OL JVU[HJ[ ZWYPUNZ HUK

YLWSHJL

 9LHZZLTISLPUYL]LYZLVYKLY

*OLJRVWLYH[PVUVM[OLSPNO[

¤VV"VF˜phz"›hFm›˜aV^›:

mVamF˜phz"›hFm›˜aV^›:

pp›§Fdd˜aV^›’

^"mVamV˜*¤d*

 >P[O H ZJYL^KYP]LY HYYV^ JHYLM\SS` WYLZZ

SPNO[V\[VM[OLJ\[V\[PU[OLSPUPUN

 9LTV]L KLMLJ[P]L I\SI MYVT IL[^LLU [OL

JVU[HJ[ZWYPUNZHUKYLWSHJL

 0UZLY[ [OL SPNO[ PU[V [OL J\[V\[ MPYZ[ MYVT VUL

ZPKL[OLUMYVT[OLV[OLY*OLJRVWLYH[PVU

pp˜ ¤"=—¤*˜aV^›

^"mVamV˜*¤d*

 >P[OHZJYL^KYP]LYHYYV^JHYLM\SS`W\ZOV\[

[OLSPNO[

 7\SSI\SIOVSKLYV\[VMSPNO[OV\ZPUN

9LTV]LKLMLJ[P]LI\SIHUKYLWSHJL

 0UZ[HSSI\SIOVSKLYHUKPUZLY[SPNO[

sn–˜˜

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

background image

m›Fap˜aV^›:˜F"=amV˜aV^›’

^"mVamV˜*¤d*

 *HYLM\SS` W\SS SPNO[ OV\ZPUN V\[ VM [OL SPUPUN

HYYV^

 9LHKPUNSPNO[!

;\YU [OL OVSKLY ( VM [OL KLMLJ[P]L I\SI

JV\U[LYÌJSVJR^PZLHUKYLTV]L

9LTV]LI\SIHUKYLWSHJL

 0U[LYPVYSPNO[!

*HYLM\SS` \UJSPW [OL SPNO[ SLUZ VU [OL Z^P[JO

ZPKLHYYV^ZHUK[OLUKL[HJOP[

9LTV]L KLMLJ[P]L I\SI MYVT IL[^LLU [OL

JVU[HJ[ZWYPUNZHUKYLWSHJL

*SPWSPNO[SLUZIHJRPU

 0UZLY[ SPNO[ OV\ZPUN PU[V [OL SPUPUN YLHY LUK

MPYZ[

7YLZZ MYVU[ VM OV\ZPUN \W HUK JSPJR PU[V

WSHJL

*OLJRVWLYH[PVUVMSPNO[Z

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

sn•

background image

"a’F=˜"cF˜aV^›’

^"mVamV˜*¤d*

 3L]LY V\[ YPNO[ÌOHUK JVYULY ZLNTLU[ VM [OL

SLUZ^P[O[OLZJYL^KYP]LYISHKLHYYV^

 ;\YU SVJR VM SPNO[ OV\ZPUN JV\U[LYÌJSVJR^PZL

I`HWWYV_ ‰HUKYLTV]LSPNO[

 +PZLUNHNL HSS  ZLJ\YPUN [HIZ VM [OL SHTW

IYHJRL[HYYV^

9LTV]L SHTW IYHJRL[ [HRL V\[ KLMLJ[P]L

I\SIHUKYLWSHJL

 9LHZZLTISLPUYL]LYZLVYKLY

*OLJRVWLYH[PVUVM[OLSPNO[

snG˜˜

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

background image

*LU[LYVM[OLOLHKSHTWSLUZ

=b¤’›amV˜ F"=daV^›’

:LLJH\[PVUVUs9LWSHJPUN)\SIZr

(KQ\Z[TLU[
;OL HKQ\Z[TLU[ PZ THKL ^P[O [OL ]LOPJSL YLHK`

[VKYP]LHUK[OLM\LS[HURJVTWSL[LS`MPSSLK

;OLKYP]LYqZZLH[T\Z[ILSVHKLKI`HWLYZVUVY

HSIZRN^LPNO[HUK[OL[PYLWYLZZ\YLZ

T\Z[TLL[[OLWYLZJYPILK]HS\LZ

(M[LYILPUNSVHKLK[OLJHYT\Z[ILYVSSLKHML^

TL[LYZZV[OH[[OLZ\ZWLUZPVUJHUZL[[SL

-VYJOLJRPUN[OLOLHKSPNO[HKQ\Z[TLU[[OL]LY[PÌ

JHS WVZP[PVU VM [OL J\[VMM VM [OL SV^ILHT ZLL

MPN OHZ [V IL WYVQLJ[LK VU H ]LY[PJHS ZJYLLU

^HSSPUKPZ[HUJLVMTMYVT[OLMYVU[SLUZVM

[OLOLHKSHTW

;OL JVYYLJ[ WVZP[PVU VM [OL J\[VMM PZ  JT H[

 T ‰ ILSV^HOVYPaVU[HSSPUL_ JT MYVT

NYV\UK[V[OLJLU[LYVM[OLOLHKSHTWSLUZ

+PZ[HUJL
=PZ\HS HPT ZOHSS IL WLYMVYTLK H[ UV[ SLZZ [OHU

 T [OPZ ]HS\L PZ HYV\UKLKKV^UJVU]LYZPVU

MYVT [OL ÌMVV[ KPZ[HUJL [`WPJHS VM MPLSK HPT

\ZPUN H ZJYLLU ;OL  T KPZ[HUJL PZ

TLHZ\YLKMYVT[OLOLHKSHTWSLUZ[V[OL]PL^PUN

ZJYLLU

-SVVY
;OL Z\YMHJL \WVU ^OPJO [OL ]LOPJSL YLZ[Z PZ MSH[

HUKHWWYV_PTH[LS`SL]LS

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

snn

background image

:JYLLU
;OL ZJYLLU \WVU ^OPJO OLHKSHTW ILHTZ HYL

WYVQLJ[LK PZ WLYWLUKPJ\SHY [V [OL MSVVY HUK [OL

]LOPJSLqZ SVUNP[\KPUHS H_PZ MSH[ \UPMVYTS` SPNO[ PU

JVSVY \UVIZ[Y\J[LK HUK ^PKL HUK OPNO LUV\NO

[V HJJVTTVKH[L [OL ]LOPJSL ILHT WH[[LYUZ [V

ILHPTLK

;OLZJYLLUZOV\SKIL^PKLLUV\NO[VWYV]PKLH[

SLHZ[  T VM ZWHJL V\[IVHYK VM [OL ]LOPJSLqZ

OLHKSHTWZWHJPUN

(KQ\Z[TLU[ZJYL^Z

+L[HJO ZPKL JHYWL[PUN PU S\NNHNL JVTWHY[Ì

TLU[

;OLYLMVYL\UZJYL^WSHZ[PJU\[(

6WLU[OLJV]LYVM[OLHWWYVWYPH[LHKQ\Z[TLU[

ZJYL^

;OLZL[[PUNPZHKQ\Z[LKI`[\YUPUN[OLOL_HNVU

ZVJRL[ZJYL^ZYPNO[VYSLM[HZHWWYVWYPH[L

)Í/LHKSPNO[]LY[PJHSHKQ\Z[TLU[

*Í-VNSPNO[OLPNO[HKQ\Z[TLU[

=LY[PJHSHKQ\Z[TLU[ZJYL^)

[\YUJSVJR^PZL$ILHTTV]LZKV^U

[\YUJV\U[LYÌJSVJR^PZL$ILHTTV]LZ\W

5V[L

+VUV[HS[LY[OLSH[LYHSHKQ\Z[TLU[

-VNSPNO[HKQ\Z[TLU[
;OL MVN SPNO[ HKQ\Z[TLU[ * ZOV\SK VUS` IL KVUL

H[ H ZWLJPHSPZ[ ^VYRZOVW ^P[O HU VW[PJHS HKQ\Z[Ì

TLU[\UP[

¢¬¬˜˜

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

background image

p§amV

*LY[HPU Z[H[L Z[H[\[LZ HUK SVJHS VYKPUHUJLZ WYVÌ

OPIP[ [V^PUN ^P[O H JOHPU YVWL VY L]LU H [V^

IHY

0U HKKP[PVU KHTHNL [V `V\Y ]LOPJSL TH` YLZ\S[

MYVTPTWYVWLYWYVJLK\YLZ

*VUZ\S[ `V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY MVY KLÌ

[HPSZ

F^a4dF˜›p§amV

-SH[ ILK [V^PUN PZ [OL WYLMLYYLK [`WL VM [V^PUN

[VIL\ZLKVU7VYZJOL]LOPJSLZ

<UKLYJLY[HPUJPYJ\TZ[HUJLZ^OLLSSPM[ZTH`IL

\ZLK^OLU[OL]LOPJSL^PSSUV[YVSS

;OL ]LOPJSL T\Z[ IL [V^LK ^P[O HSS MV\Y

^OLLSZVMM[OLNYV\UKV[OLY^PZLKHTHNL[V

[OL]LOPJSLTH`YLZ\S[

p§amV˜F©F

;OL[V^PUNL`LPZJVU[HPULKPU[OL[VVSRP[

*H\[PVU

9PZRVMKHTHNL[V[OL]LOPJSL

<ZL[OL[V^PUNL`LVUS`MVYHULTLYNLUJ`[V

YLTV]L [OL ]LOPJSL VMM [OL YVHK ;OL [V^PUN

L`LPZ[VIL\ZLKVUS`[VW\SS[OL]LOPJSLVU[V

[OL MSH[ ILK [YHJ[VY VY [V^PUN HWHYH[\Z PM [OL

]LOPJSL^PSSYVSSMYLLS`<UKLYUVJPYJ\TZ[HUJLZ

PZ [OL ]LOPJSL [V IL ZLJ\YLK \ZPUN [OL [V^PUN

L`L

5L]LY \ZL [OL [V^PUN L`L [V [V^ [OPZ VY HU`

V[OLY]LOPJSL

-YVU[TV\U[PUN
 *HYLM\SS` YLTV]L [OL WSHZ[PJ JHW ILZPKL [OL

SPJLUZLWSH[L^P[OHZJYL^KYP]LY

 :JYL^[OL[V^PUNL`LPU[V[OLOVSL

9LHYTV\U[PUN
 9LTV]LSPJLUZLWSH[L

 *HYLM\SS`YLTV]L[OLWSHZ[PJJHWIL[^LLU[OL

I\TWLYZ^P[OHZJYL^KYP]LY

 :JYL^[OL[V^PUNL`LPU[V[OLOVSL

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

¢¬s

background image

¤ddamV˜¦F^a4dF˜pm›p˜Od"›˜*F=

 7VZP[PVU ^VVKLU YHTWZ H[ [OL IHZL VM [OL

MSH[ILK[VYLK\JL[OLHUNSLVM[OLW\SS

 9LLS PU [OL OVPZ[ JHISL HUK JOLJR [OL \UKLYÌ

ZPKLVM[OL]LOPJSLMVYHU`PU[LYMLYLUJL

aFamV˜=p§m˜¦F^a4dF˜pm˜Od"›˜*F=

 *HYLM\SS` MLLK [V^PUN Z[YHWZ [OYV\NO [OL

VWLUPUNPU[OLYLHY^OLLSZ

4HRLZ\YLTL[HSWHY[ZVMZ[YHWZKVUV[KHTÌ

HNLYPT

4HRLZ\YL[OLZ[YHWPZMSH[V]LY[OLYPTILHK

4HRL Z\YL IYHRL IHJRPUN WSH[L PZ UV[ KHTÌ

HNLK

 :LJ\YLZ[YHWZ[VYLHYVMMSH[ILK

 9LLSPUOVPZ[JHISLVUS`MHYLUV\NO[V[LUZPVU

[PLÌKV^UZ[YHWZ

 *HYLM\SS` MLLK [V^PUN Z[YHWZ [OYV\NO [OL

VWLUPUNPU[OLMYVU[^OLLSZ

4HRLZ\YLTL[HSWHY[ZVMZ[YHWZKVUV[KHTÌ

HNLYPT

4HRLZ\YL[OLZ[YHWPZMSH[V]LY[OLYPTILHK

4HRL Z\YL IYHRL IHJRPUN WSH[L PZ UV[ KHTÌ

HNLK

 :LJ\YLZ[YHWZ[VMYVU[VMMSH[ILK

 9LSLHZL [LUZPVU VU OVPZ[ JHISL I\[ KV UV[

KPZJVUULJ[

<ZLOVPZ[JHISLHZHZHML[`JHISL

¢¬¢˜˜

7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL

background image

F^a4dF˜ =Fm›aOa4"›apm:˜F4^ma4"d˜"›"

=LOPJSL0KLU[PMPJH[PVU;LJOUPJHS+H[H

¢¬

background image

F^a4dF˜ =Fm›aOa4"›apm

>OLU VYKLYPUN ZWHYL WHY[Z VY THRPUN PUÍ

X\PYPLZ WSLHZL HS^H`Z X\V[L [OL ]LOPJSL

PKLU[PMPJH[PVUU\TILY

F^a4dF˜a=Fm›aOa4"›apm˜d"*Fd

=LOPJSL PKLU[PMPJH[PVU SHILS PZ H[[HJOLK [V [OL

PUULY ZPKL VM [OL S\NNHNL JVTWHY[TLU[ OVVK

ILSV^ [OL OVVK SVJR 0[ JVU[HPUZ HSS PTWVY[HU[

KH[HHIV\[`V\YJHY

;OPZSHILSJVU[HPUZ[OLMVSSV^PUNPUMVYTH[PVU!

=LOPJSL0KLU[PMPJH[PVU5V

;`WL;`WLKLZJYPW[PVU

,UNPULJVKL;YHUZTPZZPVUJVKL

7HPU[5V0U[LYPVY

6W[PVUHSLX\PWTLU[

( K\WSPJH[L VM [OPZ SHILS PZ PU `V\Y 4HPU[LUHUJL

)VVRSL[

5V[L
;OPZ KH[H IHUR JHUUV[ IL YLÌVYKLYLK PM P[ PZ SVZ[

VYKHTHNLK

F^a4dF˜a=Fm›aOa4"›apm˜m¤h*F

0U HJJVYKHUJL ^P[O -LKLYHS :HML[` 9LN\SH[PVUZ

[OL ]LOPJSL PKLU[PMPJH[PVU U\TILY VM `V\Y JHY PZ

SVJH[LK H[ [OL IV[[VT SLM[ VM [OL ^PUKZOPLSK

MYHTLHUKJHUILZLLUMYVT[OLV\[ZPKL

;OL ]LOPJSL PKLU[PMPJH[PVU U\TILY PZ HSZV PU [OL

S\NNHNL JVTWHY[TLU[ VU [OL YPNO[ UL_[ [V [OL

IH[[LY`HYYV^

¢¬T˜˜

=LOPJSL0KLU[PMPJH[PVU;LJOUPJHS+H[H

background image

"OF›©˜4phzda"m4F˜’›a4cF

;OLZHML[`JVTWSPHUJLZ[PJRLYPZ`V\YHZZ\YHUJL

[OH[ `V\Y UL^ 7VYZJOL JVTWSPLZ ^P[O HSS HWWSPJÌ

HISL -LKLYHS 4V[VY =LOPJSL :HML[` :[HUKHYKZ

^OPJO^LYLPULMMLJ[H[[OL[PTL[OL]LOPJSL^HZ

THU\MHJ[\YLK

;OL Z[PJRLY HSZV ZOV^Z [OL TVU[O HUK `LHY VM

WYVK\J[PVU HUK [OL ]LOPJSL PKLU[PMPJH[PVU U\TILY

VM `V\Y JHY WLYMVYH[PVUZ HZ ^LSS HZ [OL .YVZZ

=LOPJSL >LPNO[ 9H[PUN HUK [OL .YVZZ (_SL

>LPNO[9H[PUN

"am›˜="›"

;OL WHPU[ KH[H WSH[L PZ H[[HJOLK [V [OL SLM[ ZPKL

^HSS \UKLY [OL JHYWL[ PU [OL S\NNHNL JVTWHY[Ì

TLU[

mVamF˜m¤h*F

;OLLUNPULU\TILYPZZ[HTWLKVU[OL\UKLYZPKL

VM[OLJYHURJHZL

=LOPJSL0KLU[PMPJH[PVU;LJOUPJHS+H[H

¢¬Q

background image

F4^ma4"d˜"›"

mVamF˜="›"

;`WL

4 

4 ,

OPNOÌWV^LY]LYZPVU

/VYPaVU[HSS`VWWVZLKLUNPULSPX\PKJVVSLK

5\TILYVMJ`SPUKLYZ



)VYL

 PUTT

:[YVRL

PUTT

*\IPJJHWHJP[`

 J\PUJT





*VTWYLZZPVUYH[PV

!

5L[ÌOVYZLWV^LY:(,1

OW R>

OWR>

H[JYHURZOHM[ZWLLK

YWT

YWT

5L[[VYX\L:(,1

M[SI5T

M[SI5T

H[JYHURZOHM[ZWLLK

ÌYWT

ÌYWT

(S[LYUH[VY

>

-PYPUNVYKLY

ÌÌÌÌÌ

,UNPULJVU[YVS

:[H[PVUHY`OPNOÌ]VS[HNLKPZ[YPI\[PVUZLX\LU[PHSPUQLJ[PVU

J`SPUKLYÌZLSLJ[P]LRUVJRÌJVU[YVSZ[LYLVV_`NLUZLUZVYJSVZLKÌSVVWJVU[YVSKPHNUVZ[PJZ`Z[LT

V]LYOLHKJHTZOHM[Z7VYZJOL=HYPV*HT7S\ZO`KYH\SPJ]HS]LJSLHYHUJLJVTWLUZH[PVU

¢¬–˜˜

;LJOUPJHS+H[H

background image

"m’ha’’apm

.LHYYH[PVZ

4HU\HS[YHUZTPZZPVU

;PW[YVUPJ:

Z[NLHY

!

 !

UKNLHY

!

 !

YKNLHY

!

!

NLHY

!

!

[ONLHY

 !

!

[ONLHY

!

9L]LYZL

!

 !

!

-PUHSKYP]LYH[PV

!

 !

a¦amV˜FOph"m4F

([+05LTW[`^LPNO[HUKOHSMSVHK^P[OV\[WLYMVYTHUJLÌPUOPIP[PUNL_[YHLX\PWTLU[

4HU\HS[YHUZTPZZPVU

;PW[YVUPJ:

4H_PT\TZWLLK

 TWORTO

TWO RTO

OPNOÌWV^LY]LYZPVU

 TWORTO

TWORTO

(JJLSLYH[PVUuRTOTWO

ZLJVUKZ

 ZLJVUKZ

OPNOÌWV^LY]LYZPVU

ZLJVUKZ

ZLJVUKZ

;LJOUPJHS+H[H

¢¬•

background image

aF’:˜ah’:˜"4c’

 ;PYL

9PT

9PTVMMZL[

;YHJR

:\TTLY[PYLZ

MYVU[

 A9

1_/

TT

 PUTT

YLHY

  A9

1_/

TT

PUTT

VY

YLHY

  A9

1_/

TTVUS`^P[OTTZWHJLYYPUN

PUTT

:UV^[PYLZ

MYVU[

 9/4:

1_/

TT

 PUTT

YLHY

9 /4:

1_/

TT

PUTT

;OLSVHKJHWHJP[`JVLMMPJPLU[LNsrHUKTH_PT\TZWLLKJVKLSL[[LYLNs/rHYLTPUPT\TYLX\PYLTLU[Z

;PYLHUKYPTZPaLZ

,_[LUZP]L[LZ[ZHYLWLYMVYTLKILMVYLZWLJPMPJ[PYLZHUK^OLLSZHYLHWWYV]LKI`7VYZJOL

@V\Y7VYZJOLKLHSLYOHZPUMVYTH[PVUHIV\[HWWYV]LK[PYLZHUK^OLLSZHUKPZOHWW`[VHZZPZ[`V\

0MHM[LYTHYRL[[PYLZHUKVY^OLLSZHYLPUZ[HSSLK^OPJOHYLUV[HWWYV]LKI`7VYZJOL[OL]LOPJSLqZYVHKHIPSP[`HUKOHUKSPUN

JOHYHJ[LYPZ[PJZTPNO[ILPTWHPYLK:PUJL7VYZJOLOHZUVKH[HVUZ\JOJVTIPUH[PVUZ7VYZJOLJHUUV[Z[HUKILOPUK

[OLZHML[`VYK\YHIPSP[`VM[OLZLHM[LYTHYRL[JVTIPUH[PVUZ

:UV^JOHPUZ

*HUILTV\U[LKVUS`VU[OLYLHY^OLLSZ"TH_PT\TZWLLKTWORTO

<ZLVUS`7VYZJOLH\[OVYPaLKMPULÌSPURJYVZZÌ[`WLVYLKNLJOHPUZ

:UV^JOHPUJSLHYHUJLJHUILN\HYHU[LLKVUS`VU[OL[PYLYPTJVTIPUH[PVUTHYRLK

:WHYL^OLLS

=LOPJSLZ^P[OV\[7VYZJOL*LYHTPJ*VTWVZP[L)YHRL!;Ì 7JVSSHWZPISL[PYLVU1_YPT

=LOPJSLZ^P[O7VYZJOL*LYHTPJ*VTWVZP[L)YHRL!Ì 7JVSSHWZPISL[PYLVU1_YPT

4H_PT\TZWLLKTWORTO(S^H`ZJVTWS`^P[O[OLPUZ[Y\J[PVUZPU[OLJOHW[LYs:WHYL^OLLSr

¢¬G˜˜

;LJOUPJHS+H[H

background image

>HYUPUN

0UZ[HSSH[PVUVMZPaLZUV[H\[OVYPaLKI`

7VYZJOLTH`OH]LHKHUNLYV\ZLMMLJ[VU

[OLKYP]PUNZ[HIPSP[`HUKJV\SKYLZ\S[PU

ZL]LYLWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`VYKLH[O

)LMVYL TV\U[PUN UL^ [PYLZ JOLJR ^P[O `V\Y

7VYZJOL KLHSLY HIV\[ [OL J\YYLU[ YLSLHZL

Z[H[\Z

aF˜F’’¤F’˜Op˜4pd=˜›aF’

¤hhF˜›aF’˜"m=˜’mp§˜›aF’

-YVU[

WZPIHYV]LYWYLZZ\YL

9LHY

WZPIHYV]LYWYLZZ\YL

pdd"z’a*dF˜’z"F˜§^FFd˜pm˜¦F^a4dF’˜§a›^p¤›˜p’4^F˜F"ha4˜phzp’a›F˜"cF

-YVU[HUKYLHY

WZPIHYV]LYWYLZZ\YL

pdd"z’a*dF˜’z"F˜§^FFd˜pm˜¦F^a4dF’˜§a›^˜p’4^F˜F"ha4˜phzp’a›F˜"cF

-YVU[HUKYLHY

WZPIHYV]LYWYLZZ\YL

;OLZL[PYLWYLZZ\YLZHWWS`VUS`[V[OL[PYLTHRLZHUK[`WLZHWWYV]LKI`7VYZJOL

(S^H`ZVIZLY]LPUZ[Y\J[PVUZPU[OLJOHW[LYs;PYLZHUK;PYL*HYLr

;LJOUPJHS+H[H

¢¬n

background image

"z"4a›aF’

<ZLVUS`MS\PKZHUKM\LSZH\[OVYPaLKI`7VYZJOL@V\YH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY^PSSNSHKS`HK]PZL`V\

@V\Y7VYZJOLOHZILLUKLZPNULKZV[OH[P[PZUV[ULJLZZHY`[VTP_HU`HKKP[P]LZ^P[OVPSZVYM\LSZ

,UNPUL

6PSJOHUNLX\HU[P[`^P[OV\[VPSMPS[LYHWWYV_X\HY[ZSP[LYZ

6PSJOHUNLX\HU[P[`^P[OVPSMPS[LYHWWYV_X\HY[ZSP[LYZ

(SZVYLMLY[V[OLZLJ[PVUs,UNPUL6PSZr

*VVSHU[

HWWYV_<:NHSSVUZSP[LYZ

4HU\HS[YHUZTPZZPVU

HUKKPMMLYLU[PHS

HWWYV_X\HY[ZSP[LYZ

;PW[YVUPJ:

HWWYV_ X\HY[Z SP[LYZ

+PMMLYLU[PHS^P[O;PW[YVUPJ:

HWWYV_X\HY[ZSP[LYZ

-\LS[HURYLMPSS]VS\TL

HWWYV_<:NHSSVUZSP[LYZ

-\LSX\HSP[`

@V\YLUNPULPZKLZPNULK[VWYV]PKLVW[PT\TWLYMVYTHUJLHUKM\LSLJVUVT`\ZPUN

\USLHKLKWYLTP\TM\LS^P[OHUVJ[HULYH[PUNVM 965 *3*VY(20

7VYZJOL[OLYLMVYLYLJVTTLUKZ[OL\ZLVM[OLZLM\LSZPU`V\Y]LOPJSL

7VYZJOLHSZVYLJVNUPaLZ[OH[[OLZLM\LSZTH`UV[HS^H`ZILH]HPSHISL)LHZZ\YLK[OH[`V\Y]LOPJSL

^PSSVWLYH[LWYVWLYS`VU\USLHKLKWYLTP\TM\LSZ^P[OVJ[HULU\TILYZVMH[SLHZ[ 965 *3*VY(20

ZPUJL[OLLUNPULqZs,SLJ[YVUPJ6R[HUL¹RUVJRJVU[YVSr^PSSHKHW[[OLPNUP[PVU[PTPUNPMULJLZZHY`

7V^LYZ[LLYPUN

HWWYV_X\HY[ZSP[LYZO`KYH\SPJMS\PK7LU[VZPU*/-:

·

)YHRLMS\PK

HWWYV_X\HY[ZSP[LYZ"\ZLVUS`6YPNPUHS7VYZJOLIYHRLMS\PK

>PUKZOPLSK^HZOLY

HWWYV_ X\HY[ZSP[LYZ^P[OOLHKSPNO[^HZOLY

¢s¬˜˜

;LJOUPJHS+H[H

background image

FaV^›’

4HU\HS[YHUZTPZZPVU

;PW[YVUPJ:

,TW[`^LPNO[KLWLUKPUNVULX\PWTLU[

  SIZRN

 SIZRN

4H_PT\TNYVZZ^LPNO[

SIZRN

SIZ RN

4H_PT\TH_SLSVHKMYVU[

SIZRN

SIZRN

4H_PT\TH_SLSVHKYLHY

SIZRN

SIZRN

4H_PT\T\ZLM\SSVHK9VVM;YHUZWVY[:`Z[LT

SIZRN

SIZRN



;OLTH_PT\TNYVZZ^LPNO[T\Z[UV[ILL_JLLKLK

5V[L!0MHKKP[PVUHSHJJLZZVYPLZHYLPUZ[HSSLK[OL\ZLM\SSVHK^PSSILJVYYLZWVUKPUNS`SLZZ

 <ZLVUS`6YPNPUHS7VYZJOL9VVM;YHUZWVY[:`Z[LT

ahFm’apm’

3LUN[O

PUTT

>PK[O

PUTT

/LPNO[

PU TT

>OLLSIHZL

PUTT

.YV\UKJSLHYHUJL

PUTT

;\YUPUNJPYJSL

M[T

;LJOUPJHS+H[H

¢ss

background image

a"V"h’

˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜mVamF˜=a"V"h˜"›˜O¤dd˜zp§F˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜

(JJLSLYH[PVUKPHNYHT
=HS\LZOH]LILLUKL[LYTPULKH[+05LTW[`

^LPNO[HUK^P[OH SVHK^P[OV\[HKKP[PVUHS

LX\PWTLU[

;YHUZTPZZPVUKPHNYHT
;OL[YHUZTPZZPVUKPHNYHTPZIHZLKVUZ[HUKHYK

]HS\LZVU[OLIHZPZVMHTLHULMMLJ[P]LZJY\I

YHKP\Z

*OHUNLZVM[OLZJY\IYHKP\Z[OL[PYL

[VSLYHUJL^LHYHUK[LHYKL]PH[PUNJV\U[Y`

LX\PWTLU[HUK[PYLZSPWOH]LUV[ILLU[HRLU

PU[VHJJV\U[

,UN

PUL

WV^LY

;

VY

X\

L

,UNPULZWLLK

¢s¢˜˜

;LJOUPJHS+H[H

background image

˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ ˜ 44FdF"›apm˜=a"V"h˜

4HU\HS[YHUZTPZZPVU

;PTL

:

WLLK

;LJOUPJHS+H[H

¢s

background image

˜˜"m’ha’’apm˜=a"V"h˜

4HU\HS[YHUZTPZZPVU

:WLLK

,

UN

PU

L

ZWLLK

¢sT˜˜

;LJOUPJHS+H[H

background image

˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜˜"m’ha’’apm˜=a"V"h˜

;PW[YVUPJ

:WLLK



,UN

PUL

ZWLLK

;LJOUPJHS+H[H

¢sQ

background image

m=F¨



():HU[PSVJRIYHRLZ`Z[LT  

(JV\Z[PJ^HYUPUNZPNUHS  

(PYIHNZ`Z[LTZ 

u:^P[JOPUNVMMWHZZLUNLYHPYIHN u

(PYKPZ[YPI\[PVU u

(PYMPS[LY  

(PYJVUKP[PVUPUNZ`Z[LT  u

(SHYTZ`Z[LT 

(SJHU[HYH  

(U[PMYLLaL  

(U[PSVJRIYHRLZ`Z[LT  

(ZO[YH` 

(\KPVVWLYH[PVU u

(\[VÌI\[[VUHPYJVUKP[PVUPUNZ`Z[LT 

(\[VTH[PJ

u(U[PÌNSHYLTPYYVYZ  

u+VVYSVJRPUN  

u/LHKSPNO[HKQ\Z[TLU[ 

u3VJRPUNYL[YHJ[VY  

u:WLLKJVU[YVS   

(]LYHNLJVUZ\TW[PVU 

(]LYHNLZWLLK 



)HJRYLZ[

u(KQ\Z[TLU[u

)H[[LY` u

u>HYUPUNSPNO[  

)LMVYLKYP]PUNVMM 

)SV^LYHKQ\Z[TLU[u

)VVZ[WYLZZ\YLLUNPUL 

)YHRLZu

u-S\PK 

u-S\PK^HYUPUNSPNO[ 

u3PNO[Z   

u7HKZ

u9VSSLYIYHRL[LZ[LY

)YLHRPUOPU[Z 

)\SIZ

u*OHY[  

u9LWSHJPUNu 



*HUOVSKLY  

*HWHJP[PLZV]LY]PL^ 

*HYJHYL u

*HY[LSLWOVUL  

*HY^HZOLZ 

*HZZL[[L[HWL

u7SH`LY  

u/VSKLY 

*H[HS`[PJJVU]LY[LYZ 

*H\[PVUZ 

*LU[YHSSVJRPUN u

*OHUNPUN^OLLSZ  u

*OLJRLUNPUL^HYUPUNSPNO[

*OPSKYLZ[YHPU[

u(UJOVYHNLZ 

u:`Z[LTu

u:^P[JOPUNVMMWHZZLUNLYHPYIHNu

*PNHYL[[LSPNO[LY

*PYJ\SH[PUNHPYI\[[VU

*SVJR 

*SV[OLZOVVR 

*S\[JOWLKHS 

*VSSHWZPISLZWHYL^OLLS u

*VTWHJ[KPZJ

u*OHUNLY 

u/VSKLY

u7SH`LY 

*VTWYLZZVYMVYJVSSHWZPISLZWHYL^OLLS

*VVSHU[  

u3L]LS 

u;LTWLYH[\YLNH\NL 

u>HYUPUNSPNO[

*VVSPUNZ`Z[LT 

*Y\PZLJVU[YVS  

*\WOVSKLY

*\YISPNO[  



+HZOIVHYK 

+LMYVZ[PUN^PUKV^Zu

+PHNUVZ[PJZVJRL[  

+PHNYHTZu

+PTLUZPVUZ

¢s–˜˜

0UKL_

background image

+VVY 

u.\HYK   

u/HUKSLZ  

u3VJRZ   

u>PUKV^Z  

+VVYTPYYVY

u/LH[PUN 

+YP]PUNOPU[Z u

+YP]PUNWLYMVYTHUJL  

+`UHTVTL[LY[LZ[PUN  



,SLJ[YPJHSZ`Z[LT u

,TLYNLUJ`MSHZOLY  

,TLYNLUJ`VWLYH[PVU

u*LU[YHSSVJRPUN  

u3PKZ 

u3PM[PUNZSPKPUNYVVM  

u;HURMSHW  

,TLYNLUJ`WYVNYHT;PW[YVUPJ 

,TLYNLUJ`ZLY]PJL  u

,TLYNLUJ`Z[HY[PUN

^P[OQ\TWLYJHISLZ  

,TPZZPVUJVU[YVSZ`Z[LTu

,UNPULJVTWHY[TLU[

u)SV^LY  

u3PK

u3PNO[  

,UNPUL

u)VVZ[WYLZZ\YL  

u*OLJRPUNVPSSL]LS  

u,_OH\Z[  

u5\TILY  

u6PSJVUZ\TW[PVU

u6PSSL]LS 

u6PSSL]LSNH\NL

u6PSWYLZZ\YLNH\NL 

u6PSWYLZZ\YL^HYUPUNSPNO[

u6PSZ u 

u:[HY[PUNu

u:WLLKZ 

u:^P[JOPUNVMM u

-VNSPNO[Z   

-VV[IYHRLu

-VV[^LSSSPNO[Z  

-V\YÌ^OLLSKYP]L 

-YVU[OVVK  

-\LS  u

u*VU[HPULYZ

u,JVUVT`

u,]HWVYH[PVUJVU[YVS

u3L]LS^HYUPUNSPNO[ 

u3L]LSNH\NL 

u9LJVTTLUKH[PVU 

u;HUR  

-\ZLZ

.HYHNLKVVYH\[VTH[PJ 

.HYHNLSPM[ 

.LHYJOHUNPUN u

.SV]LJVTWHY[TLU[ 

.VUN   

/LHKSPNO[Z   u 

u(KQ\Z[PUN   

u*SLHUPUNZ`Z[LT 

/LH[LKYLHY^PUKV^/HYK[VW  

/LH[PUN u

/PNOILHT

u0UKPJH[VYSPNO[ 

u3L]LY  

/VVKZ  

/VYU 

0KLU[PMPJH[PVUU\TILY  

0NUP[PVUSVJR  

0TTVIPSPaLY  

0UKPJH[VYSPNO[Z  u

0UMYHYLKWHZZLUNLY

JVTWHY[TLU[TVUP[VYPUN  

0UZ[Y\TLU[WHULS  u

0UZ[Y\TLU[Z u 

u3PNO[Z  

0U[LYPVYTPYYVY  

0U[LYPVYSPNO[   

0U[LYTP[[LU[VWLYH[PVUZ^P[JO 

1HJR  

1\TWLYJHISLZ  

0UKL_

¢s•

background image



2L`SVJR  

2L`Z u



3LH[OLYJHYL 

3PJLUZLWSH[LSPNO[  

3PKLTLYNLUJ`VWLYH[PVU 

3PM[PUNZSPKPUNYVVM u

3PNO[

u-SHZOLY     

u3V^ILHT   

u:^P[JO   

3VHKZ^P[JOÌVMM  

3VJRPUN   u

u*VUKP[PVUZ  

3\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[ u 

3\NNHNLJHYYPLY   



4HPU[LUHUJL  u

4HRLÌ\WTPYYVY  

4H_PT\TWLYTP[[LKLUNPULZWLLKZ 

4PYYVYZ  



5V[LZVU

u*HYJHYL u

u4HPU[LUHUJL  

5\TILYWSH[LSPNO[   



6J[HULYH[PUN 

6KVTL[LY  

6PS u 

u*VUZ\TW[PVU 

u3L]LSJOLJRZ

u3L]LSNH\NL 

u7YLZZ\YLNH\NL 

u7YLZZ\YL^HYUPUNSPNO[  

6UÌIVHYKJVTW\[LYu 

u)HZPJZL[[PUN 

u3HUN\HNLZLSLJ[PVU 

6UÌIVHYKSP[LYH[\YL 

6YPLU[H[PVUSPNO[  

6\[ZPKLÌ[LTWLYH[\YLKPZWSH`  



7HPU[

u*HYL u

u+H[H  

7HYRPUN

u(PKZ

u(ZZPZ[HU[

u)YHRL

u3PNO[    

7HY[PJSLMPS[LY 

7HZZLUNLYHPYIHNZ^P[JOPUNVMM u

7HZZLUNLYJVTWHY[TLU[

TVUP[VYPUNPUMYHYLK 

7SH[MVYTSPM[  

7SHZ[PJWHY[ZJHYLVM  

7VYZJOLJLYHTPJJVTWVZP[LIYHRL  

7VYZJOLJVTT\UPJH[PVUTHUHNLTLU[ 

7VYZJOLZ[HIPSP[`THUHNLTLU[  

7V^LYTLHZ\YLTLU[  

7V^LYZ[LLYPUNMS\PKSL]LS  

7V^LY^PUKV^Z  

7YHJ[PJHS[PWZ  u



9HKPH[VYMHU 

9HKPVYLJLW[PVU 

9HPUZLUZVY  

9HUNLVUYLTHPUPUNM\LS

9LHYMVNSPNO[   

9LHYOVVK  

9LHYZLH[IHJRYLZ[ 

9LHYZWVPSLY 

9LHY]PL^TPYYVYZ  

9LHY^PUKV^KLMVNNLY 

9LHY^PWLY

9LSH`Z 

9LTV[LJVU[YVS

9LWSHJPUNI\SIZ u 

9LWSHJPUN^PWLYISHKLZ 

9LWSHJLTLU[RL` 

9L[YHJ[HISLZWVPSLYYLHY 

9VVM

u3PM[PUNZSPKPUNu

u;YHUZWVY[Z`Z[LT  

9\UUPUNPU 

¢sG˜˜

0UKL_

background image



:HML[`ILS[Z u 

:HML[`JVTWSPHUJLZ[PJRLY 

:LHSZJHYLVM  

:LH[  u

u(KQ\Z[TLU[ u

u/LH[PUN 

u4LTVY`  

:LSLJ[VYSL]LYWVZP[PVUPUKPJH[VY  

:OPM[SVJR  

:PKLTHYRLYSPNO[   

:SPKPUNYVVM  u

:UV^JOHPUZ  

:WHYLRL`  

:WHYL^OLLS u

:WLLK

u*VU[YVS  

u.VUN  

:WLLKVTL[LY  

:WVPSLYYL[YHJ[HISL 

:[HY[PUNHUKZ[VWWPUN[OLLUNPUL u

:[LLYPUN^OLLS

u(KQ\Z[TLU[ 

u3VJR 

u;VNNSLZ^P[JOLZ  u

:[VYHNLVW[PVUZ  

:[VYHNL[YH`  

:[VYPUN`V\Y7VYZJOL 

:\U]PZVYZ  



;HJOVTL[LY

;HPSSPNO[  

;HUR  

u=LU[PSH[PVUZ`Z[LT

;LJOUPJHSKH[H u

;LSLWOVUL 

;LTWLYH[\YLZL[[PUN u

;OLM[WYV[LJ[PVU

;PW[YVUPJ u

;PYLZ  u

u7YLZZ\YL  

u7YLZZ\YLJVTWYLZZVY 

;PYLZHUK[PYLJHYLu

;VVSRP[ 

;V^PUN

;YHJR 

;YHUZTPZZPVU u

u-S\PK 

;YPWJV\U[LY 

;Y\URLU[YHWTLU[ 

;\YUZPNUHSZ      



<UKLYJVH[PUN 



=HS]LZ  

=HUP[`TPYYVY 

=LOPJSL

u*HYL u

u+H[H  

u0KLU[PMPJH[PVUSHILS  

u0KLU[PMPJH[PVUU\TILY  

u>HZOPUN u

=LU[PSH[PVU u

=LU[Z u

=VS[TL[LY 

0UKL_

¢sn

background image



>HYUPUNSHTWZ  u 

>HYUPUNTLZZHNLZ u 

>HZOLYMS\PK 

>HZOPUN  u

>LPNO[Z  

>OLLS

u*OHUNPUN   u

u)VS[Z  

>OLLSZ u

>PUKV^Z 

u>HZOLYUVaaSLZ 

u>HZOLYZ`Z[LT  

>PUKZOPLSK^PWLY^HZOLYSL]LY  

>PUKZOPLSK^PWLYZ 

u9LWSHJPUN 

>PWLY

u)SHKLZ 

u0U[LY]HS  

>PU[LYVWLYH[PVU!

u)H[[LY`  

u*VVSHU[ 

u,UNPULVPS  u

u1\TWLYJHISLZ  

u3VJRZ  

u:LHSZ 

u:UV^JOHPUZ  

u;PYLZ u

u>HZOLYMS\PK 

u>PWLYISHKLZ 

¢¢¬˜˜

0UKL_


Wyszukiwarka

Podobne podstrony:
Porsche 911 Turbo instrukcja obslugi ENG by mobopx
Peugeot 406 D8 instrukcja obslugi PL by mobopx
Fiat Panda 100HP instrukcja obslugi PL by mobopx
Peugeot 306 instrukcja obslugi PL by mobopx
Peugeot 406 D9 instrukcja obslugi PL by mobopx
Mercedes E W210 1995 2002 instrukcja obslugi PL by mobopx
Jeep Cherokee 2003 instrukcja obslugi PL by mobopx
Audi A3 S3 8L instrukcja obslugi PL by mobopx
Citroen C5 instrukcja obslugi PL by mobopx
Peugeot 407 instrukcja obslugi PL by mobopx
Peugeot 306 2002 instrukcja obslugi PL by mobopx
Daewo Matiz instrukcja obslugi PL by mobopx
Nissan Micra instrukcja obslugi PL by mobopx
Mazda Premacy 1998 2002 instrukcja obslugi PL by mobopx
Peugeot 405 instrukcja obslugi PL by mobopx
Mazda 3 2004 instrukcja obslugi PL by mobopx
Fiat Panda 4x4 instrukcja obslugi PL by mobopx
Audi A4 S4 B5 instrukcja obslugi PL by mobopx
Peugeot 406 D9 instrukcja obslugi PL by mobopx

więcej podobnych podstron