>2+
È
+Y0UNOJ-7VYZJOL(.
7VYZJOL [OL 7VYZJOL JYLZ[ *HYYLYH ;HYNH
)V_Z[LY ;PW[YVUPJ HUK ;LX\PWTLU[ HYL YLNPZÌ
[LYLK [YHKLTHYRZ HUK [OL KP Z[P UJ[P ]L ZOHWLZ VM
7VYZJOLH\[VTVIPSLZHYL[YHKLTHYRZVM
+Y0UNOJ-7VYZJOL(.
(SSYPNO[ZYLZLY]LK
7YPU[LKPU.LYTHU`
F"§mF:
>L^V\SKSPRL[V[OHUR`V\MVY`V\YW\YJOHZLVM
H7VYZJOL:WVY[ZJHY
1\KNPUN I` [OL JHY `V\ OH]L JOVZLU `V\ HYL H
TV[VYPZ[ VM H ZWLJPHS IYLLK HUK `V\ HYL WYVIÌ
HIS`UVUV]PJL^OLUP[JVTLZ[VH\[VTVIPSLZ
9LTLTILY OV^L]LY HZ ^P[O HU` ]LOPJSL `V\
ZOV\SK[HRL[PTL[VMHTPSPHYPaL`V\YZLSM^P[O`V\Y
7VYZJOL HUK P[Z WLYMVYTHUJL JOHYHJ[LYPZ[PJZ (SÌ
^H`ZKYP]L^P[OPU`V\YV^U\UPX\LJHWHIPSP[PLZHZ
H KYP]LY HUK `V\Y SL]LS VM L_WLYPLUJL ^P[O `V\Y
7VYZJOL ,UZ\YL [OH[ HU`VUL LSZL KYP]PUN `V\Y
7VYZJOLKVLZ[OLZHTL;VWYL]LU[VYTPUPTPaL
PUQ\Y` HS^H`Z \ZL `V\Y ZHML[` ILS[Z 5L]LY JVUÌ
Z\TL HSJVOVS VY KY\NZ ILMVYL VY K\YPUN [OL
VWLYH[PVUVM`V\Y]LOPJSL
;OPZ 6^ULYqZ 4HU\HS JVU[HPUZ H OVZ[ VM \ZLM\S
PUMVYTH[PVU 7SLHZL [HRL [OL [PTL [V YLHK [OPZ
THU\HS ILMVYL `V\ KYP]L `V\Y UL^ 7VYZJOL
)LJVTL MHTPSPHY ^P[O [OL VWLYH[PVU VM `V\Y
7VYZJOL JHY MVY TH_PT\T ZHML[` HUK VWLYH[PUN
WSLHZ\YL;OLIL[[LY`V\RUV^`V\Y7VYZJOL[OL
TVYL WSLHZ\YL `V\ ^PSS L_WLYPLUJL KYP]PUN `V\Y
UL^JHY
(S^H`Z RLLW `V\Y 6^ULYqZ 4HU\HS PU [OL JHY
HUK NP]L P[ [V [OL UL^ V^ULY PM `V\ L]LY ZLSS
`V\Y7VYZJOL
( ZLWHYH[L 4HPU[LUHUJL )VVRSL[ L_WSHPUZ
OV^ `V\ JHU RLLW `V\Y 7VYZJOL PU [VW KYP]PUN
JVUKP[PVUI`OH]PUNP[ZLY]PJLKYLN\SHYS`
( ZLWHYH[L >HYYHU[` HUK *\Z[VTLY 0UMVYÍ
TH[PVU )VVRSL[ JVU[HPUZ KL[HPSLK PUMVYTH[PVU
HIV\[[OL^HYYHU[PLZJV]LYPUN`V\Y7VYZJOL
-VY<:VUS`!
0M`V\ILSPL]L[OH[`V\Y]LOPJSLOHZHMH\S[^OPJO
JV\SKJH\ZLHJYHZOPUQ\Y`VYKLH[O`V\ZOV\SK
PTTLKPH[LS` PUMVYT [OL 5H[PVUHS /PNO^H` ;YHMMPJ
:HML[` (KTPUPZ[YH[PVU 5/;:( PU HKKP[PVU [V
UV[PM`PUN 7VYZJOL *HYZ 5VY[O (TLYPJH 0UJ
7VYZJOL*HYZ5(
0M 5/;:( YLJLP]LZ ZPTPSHY JVTWSHPU[Z P[ TH`
VWLUHUPU]LZ[PNH[PVUHUKPMP[MPUKZ[OH[HZHML[`
WYVISLT L_PZ[Z PU H NYV\W VM ]LOPJSLZ P[ TH`
VYKLY H YLJHSS HUK YLTLK` JHTWHPNU /V^L]LY
5/;:( JHUUV[ ILJVTL PU]VS]LK PU PUKP]PK\HS
WYVISLTZ IL[^LLU `V\ HUK `V\Y KLHSLY VY
7VYZJOL*HYZ5(
;VJVU[HJ[5/;:(`V\TH`LP[OLYJHSS[OL(\[V
:HML[` /V[SPUL [VSSÌMYLL H[ ÌÌÌ
VYÌPU>HZOPUN[VU+*HYLHVY^YP[L
[V! 5/;:( <: +LWHY[TLU[ VM ;YHUZWVY[H[PVU
>HZOPUN[VU +* @V\ JHU HSZV VI[HPU
V[OLY PUMVYTH[PVU HIV\[ TV[VY ]LOPJSL ZHML[`
MYVT[OL/V[SPUL
@V\Y JHY OHZ [OV\ZHUKZ VM WHY[Z HUK JVTWVÌ
ULU[Z ^OPJO OH]L ILLU KLZPNULK HUK THU\MHJÌ
[\YLK PU HJJVYKHUJL ^P[O 7VYZJOLqZ OPNO Z[HUKÌ
HYKZVMLUNPULLYPUNX\HSP[`HUKZHML[`
(U`HS[LYH[PVUVM[OL]LOPJSLTH`ULNH[LVY
PU[LYMLYL ^P[O [OVZL ZHML[` MLH[\YLZ I\PS[
PU[V[OL]LOPJSL
@V\Y 7VYZJOL PZ PU[LUKLK [V IL \ZLK PU H ZHML
THUULYVIL`PUN[OLSVJHSSH^ZHUKPU[OLSPNO[VM
KYP]PUN JVUKP[PVUZ MHJLK I` `V\ HUK PU HJJVYKÌ
HUJL ^P[O [OL PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ WYV]PKLK PU [OPZ
6^ULYqZ4HU\HS
+V UV[ TPZ\ZL `V\Y 7VYZJOL I` PNUVYPUN
[OVZL SH^Z HUK KYP]PUN JVUKP[PVUZ VY I`
PNUVYPUN[OLPUZ[Y\J[PVUZPU[OPZTHU\HS
(U` HS[LYH[PVU VYTPZ\ZLVM[OL]LOPJSLJHU
SLHK [V HJJPKLU[Z HUK ZL]LYL VY MH[HS WLYÍ
ZVUHSPUQ\YPLZ
9LN\SHYS` JOLJR `V\Y ]LOPJSL MVY ZPNUZ VM
KHTHNL
+HTHNLK VY TPZZPUN HLYVK`UHTPJ JVTWVÍ
ULU[Z Z\JO HZ ZWVPSLYZ VY \UKLYZPKL WHULSZ
HMMLJ[ [OL KYP]PUN ILOH]PVY HUK [OLYLMVYL
T\Z[ILYLWSHJLKPTTLKPH[LS`
¢
@V\Y JHY TH` OH]L HSS VY ZVTL VM [OL JVTWVÌ
ULU[ZKLZJYPILKPU[OPZTHU\HS
:OV\SK `V\ OH]L KPMMPJ\S[` \UKLYZ[HUKPUN HU` VM
[OL L_WSHUH[PVUZ VM MLH[\YLZ VY LX\PWTLU[
PUZ[HSSLKPU`V\Y]LOPJSLJVU[HJ[`V\YH\[OVYPaLK
7VYZJOL KLHSLY /L:OL ^PSS IL NSHK [V HZZPZ[
`V\ (SZV JOLJR ^P[O `V\Y KLHSLY VU V[OLY H]HPSÌ
HISLVW[PVUZVYLX\PWTLU[
;OYV\NOV\[ [OPZ IVVRSL[ SLM[ PZ KLZPNUH[LK HZ
[OL KYP]LYqZ ZPKL VM [OL ]LOPJSL HUKYPNO[HZ[OL
WHZZLUNLYqZZPKLVM[OL]LOPJSL
;L_[ PSS\Z[YH[PVUZ HUK ZWLJPMPJH[PVUZ PU [OPZ THÌ
U\HS HYL IHZLK VU [OL PUMVYTH[PVU H]HPSHISL H[
[OL[PTLVMWYPU[PUN
0[ OHZ HS^H`Z ILLU 7VYZJOLqZ WVSPJ` [V JVU[PU\Ì
V\ZS` PTWYV]L P[Z WYVK\J[Z 7VYZJOL [OLYLMVYL
YLZLY]LZ [OL YPNO[ [V THRL JOHUNLZ PU KLZPNU
HUK ZWLJPMPJH[PVU HUK [V THRL HKKP[PVUZ VY
PTWYV]LTLU[Z PU P[Z WYVK\J[ ^P[OV\[ PUJ\YYPUN
HU` VISPNH[PVU [V PUZ[HSS [OLT VU WYVK\J[Z
WYL]PV\ZS`THU\MHJ[\YLK
>L^PZO`V\THU`TPSLZVMZHMLHUKWSLHZ\YHISL
KYP]PUNPU`V\Y7VYZJOL
0TWVY[HU[
-VY `V\Y V^U WYV[LJ[PVU HUK SVUNLY ZLY]PJL SPML
VM `V\Y JHY WSLHZL OLLK HSS VWLYH[PUN
PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ HUK ZWLJPHS ^HYUPUNZ ;OLZL ZWLJPHS
^HYUPUNZ \ZL [OL ZHML[` HSLY[ Z`TIVS MVSSV^LK
I` [OL ^VYKZ +HUNLY >HYUPUN HUK *H\[PVU
;OLZL ZWLJPHS ^HYUPUNZ JVU[HPU PTWVY[HU[ TLZÌ
ZHNLZYLNHYKPUN`V\YZHML[`HUKVY[OLWV[LU[PHS
MVY KHTHNL [V `V\Y 7VYZJOL 0NUVYPUN [OLT
JV\SKYLZ\S[PUZLYPV\ZTLJOHUPJHSMHPS\YLVYL]LU
WO`ZPJHSPUQ\Y`
+V UV[ HS[LY `V\Y 7VYZJOL (U` HS[LYH[PVU JV\SK
JYLH[L KHUNLYV\Z JVUKP[PVUZ VY KLMLH[ ZHML[`
LUNPULLYPUNMLH[\YLZI\PS[PU[V`V\YJHY
+V UV[ TPZ\ZL `V\Y 7VYZJOL <ZL P[ ZHMLS` HUK
JVUZPZ[LU[S` ^P[O [OL SH^ HJJVYKPUN [V [OL KYP]Ì
PUN JVUKP[PVUZ HUK [OL PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ PU [OPZ THÌ
U\HS
(S[LYH[PVU VY TPZ\ZL VM `V\Y 7VYZJOL JV\SK
JH\ZLHJJPKLU[ZHUKZL]LYLVYMH[HSWLYZVUHS
PUQ\YPLZ
pFpp§mF
0U *HUHKH [OPZ THU\HS PZ HSZV H]HPSHISL PU
-YLUJO;VVI[HPUHJVW`JVU[HJ[`V\YKLHSLYVY
^YP[L[V!
pF"¤¨zpzaF"aF
(\ *HUHKH VU WL\[ ZL WYVJ\YLY \U L_LTWSHPYL
KL JL 4HU\LS LU MYHU¶HPZ H\WY·Z K\ JVUJLZZPVÌ
UHPYLV\K\!
7VYZJOL*HYZ*HUHKH3[K
(\[VTVIPSLZ7VYZJOL*HUHKH3;,,
6YIP[VY+YP]L
)\PSKPUN:\P[L
4PZZPZZH\NH6U[HYPV
*HUHKH3>@
;LSLWOVULU\TILYMVYJ\Z[VTLYHZZPZ[HUJL!
ÌÌ769:*/,6W[PVU
¤Fd¤"da©
@V\YLUNPULPZKLZPNULK[VWYV]PKLVW[PT\TWLYMVYTHUJLHUKM\LSLJVUVT`\ZPUN
\USLHKLKWYLTP\TM\LS^P[OHUVJ[HULYH[PUNVM 965 *3*VY(20
7VYZJOL[OLYLMVYLYLJVTTLUKZ[OL\ZLVM[OLZLM\LSZPU`V\Y]LOPJSL
7VYZJOLHSZVYLJVNUPaLZ[OH[[OLZLM\LSZTH`UV[HS^H`ZILH]HPSHISL)LHZZ\YLK[OH[`V\Y]LOPJSL^PSSVWLYH[L
WYVWLYS`VU\USLHKLKWYLTP\TM\LSZ^P[OVJ[HULU\TILYZVMH[SLHZ[ 965 *3*VY(20
ZPUJL[OLLUNPULqZs,SLJ[YVUPJ6R[HUL¹RUVJRJVU[YVSr^PSSHKHW[[OLPNUP[PVU[PTPUNPMULJLZZHY`
¤Fd4pm"amamV"d4p^pd"m=F^F
:VTLHYLHZVM[OL<:YLX\PYLV_`NLUH[LKM\LSZK\YPUNJLY[HPUWVY[PVUZVM[OL`LHY
6_`NLUH[LKM\LSZHYLM\LSZ^OPJOJVU[HPUHSJVOVSZZ\JOHZTL[OHUVSVYL[OHUVSVYL[OLYZ\JOHZ4;),
<UKLYUVYTHSJVUKP[PVUZ[OLHTV\U[VM[OLZLJVTWV\UKZPU[OLM\LS^PSSUV[HMMLJ[KYP]LHIPSP[`
@V\TH`\ZLV_`NLUH[LKM\LSZPU`V\Y7VYZJOLWYV]PKLK[OLVJ[HULYLX\PYLTLU[ZMVY`V\Y]LOPJSLHYLTL[
>LYLJVTTLUKOV^L]LY[VJOHUNL[VHKPMMLYLU[M\LSVYZ[H[PVUPMHU`VM[OLMVSSV^PUNWYVISLTZVJJ\Y^P[O`V\Y]LOPJSL!
u+L[LYPVYH[PVUVMKYP]LHIPSP[`HUKWLYMVYTHUJL
u:\IZ[HU[PHSS`YLK\JLKM\LSLJVUVT`
u=HWVYSVJRHUKUVUÌZ[HY[WYVISLTZLZWLJPHSS`H[OPNOHS[P[\KLVYH[OPNO[LTWLYH[\YL
u,UNPULTHSM\UJ[PVUVYZ[HSSPUN
¤Fd4pm"amamV
:VTL5VY[O(TLYPJHUM\LSZJVU[HPUHUVJ[HULLUOHUJPUNHKKP[P]LJHSSLKTL[O`SJ`JSVWLU[HKPLU`STHUNHULZL[YPJHYIVU`S44;
0MZ\JOM\LSZHYL\ZLK`V\YLTPZZPVUJVU[YVSZ`Z[LTWLYMVYTHUJLTH`ILULNH[P]LS`HMMLJ[LK
;OLJOLJRLUNPUL^HYUPUNSPNO[ZVU`V\YPUZ[Y\TLU[WHULSTH`[\YUVU
0M[OPZVJJ\YZ7VYZJOLYLJVTTLUKZ`V\Z[VW\ZPUNM\LSZJVU[HPUPUN44;
T
aFF¤FOppd=aF
¤hhFaF"m=mp§aF
-YVU[
WZPIHYV]LYWYLZZ\YL
9LHY
WZPIHYV]LYWYLZZ\YL
pdd"za*dFz"F§^FFd
=LOPJSLZ^P[OV\[7VYZJOL*LYHTPJ*VTWVZP[L)YHRL!
-YVU[HUKYLHY
WZPIHYV]LYWYLZZ\YL
=LOPJSLZ^P[O7VYZJOL*LYHTPJ*VTWVZP[L)YHRL!
-YVU[HUKYLHY
WZPIHYV]LYWYLZZ\YL
;OLZL[PYLWYLZZ\YLZHYL]HSPKVUS`MVY7VYZJOLHWWYV]LK[PYLZ
-VYYLWSHJLTLU[[PYLZP[PZPTWLYH[P]L[OH[`V\JVUZ\S[[OL;LJOUPJHS+H[HHUK;PYLZ>OLLSZ
ZLJ[PVUZVM[OPZTHU\HSHUKMVSSV^[OLYLJVTTLUKH[PVUZJVU[HPULK[OLYLPU
Q
p4^F"m=^Fm¦apmhFm
m¦apmhFm"dV¤a=FdamF
>L KL]LSVW HUK WYVK\JL L_JS\ZP]L ZWVY[Z JHYZ
^P[OHK]HUJLKLU]PYVUTLU[HSHUKZHML[`[LJOUVSÌ
VN`HUKHNYLH[HIPSP[`[VMHZJPUH[L
6\YLU]PYVUTLU[HSWVSPJ`PZIHZLKVU[OL
MVSSV^PUNWYPUJPWSLZ!
;OL TH_PT\T WVZZPISL \ZL VM LU]PYVUTLU[HS
HUK ZHML[` [LJOUVSVN` [OH[ PZ LJVUVTPJHSS`
Q\Z[PMPHISL
,JVUVTPJHS\ZHNLVMLULYN`HUKYLZV\YJLZ
0U]VS]LTLU[VMV\YI\ZPULZZWHY[ULYZHUKJVUÌ
[YHJ[VYZ PU V\Y LMMVY[Z [V WYV[LJ[ [OL LU]PYVUÌ
TLU[
6WLUKPHSVN\L^P[OHSSZVJPHSNYV\WZ
*HSPMVYUPH7YVWVZP[PVU>HYUPUN
>HYUPUN
,UNPUL L_OH\Z[ ZVTL VM P[Z JVUZ[P[\LU[Z HUK
JLY[HPU ]LOPJSL JVTWVULU[Z JVU[HPU VY LTP[
JOLTPJHSZ RUV^U [V [OL :[H[L VM *HSPMVYUPH [V
JH\ZL JHUJLY HUK IPY[O KLMLJ[Z VY V[OLY YLWYVÌ
K\J[P]LOHYT
0U HKKP[PVU JLY[HPU MS\PKZ JVU[HPULK PU ]LOPJSLZ
HUKJLY[HPUWYVK\J[ZVMJVTWVULU[^LHYJVU[HPU
VYLTP[JOLTPJHSZRUV^U[V[OL:[H[LVM*HSPMVYÌ
UPH [V JH\ZL JHUJLY HUK IPY[O KLMLJ[Z VY V[OLY
YLWYVK\J[P]LOHYT
p=¤4apm
;OL THU\MHJ[\YL VM 7VYZJOL ]LOPJSLZ PU H MHJÌ
[VY`HKQHJLU[[VHYLZPKLU[PHSHYLHYLX\PYLZTVYL
[OHU TLYL JVTWSPHUJL ^P[O HSS SH^Z HUK YLN\SHÌ
[PVUZ
>OL[OLYPUWYVK\J[PVUVYYLWHPY7VYZJOLHS^H`Z
YLSPLZVULU]PYVUTLU[HSS`MYPLUKS`[LJOUVSVN`
(UL_HTWSLVM[OPZPZ[OL^H[LYÌIHZLKWHPU[\ZLK
PUV\YWHPU[PUNPUZ[HSSH[PVU
>H[LYÌIHZL WHPU[Z HUK UL^ WHPU[PUNTL[OVKZYLÌ
K\JLZVS]LU[LTPZZPVUZI`WLYJLU[
(UK[OL^H[LY\ZLKPU[OLWHPU[PUNPUZ[HSSH[PVUPZ
YLÌJPYJ\SH[LK >HZ[L ^H[LY SLH]LZ [OL 7VYZJOL
MHJ[VY`VUS`HM[LYILPUNHWWYVWYPH[LS`[YLH[LK
( ^HZ[LÌTHUHNLTLU[ Z`Z[LT OHZ ILLU PU[YVÌ
K\JLK[VYLK\JL[OLHTV\U[VM^HZ[L^OPSLZPTÌ
\S[HULV\ZS`PUJYLHZPUN[OLYLJ`JSPUNYH[L
m¦apmhFm"dd©OaFm=d©¦F^a4dF
4VKLYU LU]PYVUTLU[HS [LJOUVSVN` LUZ\YLZ JVTÌ
WSPHUJL ^P[O HSS LTPZZPVU SH^Z HWWSPJHISL ^VYSKÌ
^PKL
;OLZLOH]L[OLMVSSV^PUNHK]HU[HNLZ!
9HWPK VWLYH[PVUHS YLHKPULZZ VM [OL JH[HS`[PJ
JVU]LY[LYZ LUZ\YLZ SV^ LTPZZPVUZ L]LU PU
ZOVY[Ì[YPWVWLYH[PVU
9LSPHISLVWLYH[PVUHUKNVVKLTPZZPVUJVU[YVS
V]LYHSVUN\ZLM\SSPML
7SLHZLUV[L[OLJOHW[LYs-\LS,JVUVT`r
F4©4damVJOp"p4^F:^aa
¦a¤"dd©"m"4"=Fha4¤Fapm
4VYL [OHU [^VÌ[OPYKZ VM HSS 7VYZJOLZ L]LY I\PS[
HYLZ[PSSY\UUPUN
1\Z[PUJHZLYLJ`JSPUNPZL]LYULJLZZHY`
^L[HRL[OLMVSSV^PUNWYLJH\[PVUHY`
TLHZ\YLZ!
0KLU[PMPJH[PVUVMHSSTH[LYPHSZ
<ZLVMYLJ`JSHISLTH[LYPHSZ
9L\ZHISLJVTWVULU[ZKLZPNULKMVYZPTWSL
YLTV]HS
;OLZL YLHZVUZ YLZ\S[ PU H M\Y[OLY PUJYLHZL PU
[OL YLJ`JSPUN YH[L ^OPJO PZ J\YYLU[S` WLY
JLU[
haapm4pmpda*¤adam
0UUV]H[P]L LUNPUL [LJOUVSVN` JVTIPULZ OPNO LUÌ
NPUL WLYMVYTHUJL HUK LU]PYVUTLU[HS JVTWH[PÌ
IPSP[`
;OLLUNPULKPHNUVZPZZ`Z[LTLSLJ[YVUPJHSS`TVUPÌ
[VYZ[OLJVTWVULU[ZHUKZ`Z[LTZ[OH[HMMLJ[L_Ì
OH\Z[NHZLZ
;OPZJVU[PU\V\ZTVUP[VYPUNHUKMH\S[Z[VYHNLLUÌ
HISLZ Z^PM[ YLSPHISL KPHNUVZPZ HUK MH\S[ KL[LJÌ
[PVU
(U` MH\S[ TLZZHNLZ HYL PUKPJH[LK [V [OL KYP]LY
I` [OL s*OLJR ,UNPULr ^HYUPUN SPNO[ HUK [OL VUÌ
IVHYKJVTW\[LY
zF"apmpO4phh¤ma4"apm
©Fh"m=F¤azhFm§^adF
=a¦amV
>HYUPUN
;OLYL PZ H KHUNLY VM HU HJJPKLU[ PM `V\
VWLYH[L VY ZL[ [OL VUÍIVHYK JVTW\[LY
YHKPV UH]PNH[PVU Z`Z[LT [LSLWOVUL VY
V[OLYLX\PWTLU[^OLUKYP]PUN
;OPZJV\SKKPZ[YHJ[`V\MYVT[OL[YHMMPJHUK
JH\ZL`V\[VSVZLJVU[YVSVM[OL]LOPJSL
6WLYH[L[OLLX\PWTLU[^OPSLKYP]PUNVUS`PM[OL
[YHMMPJZP[\H[PVUHSSV^Z`V\[VKVZVZHMLS`
*HYY` V\[ HU` JVTWSPJH[LK VWLYH[PUN VY
ZL[[PUN WYVJLK\YLZ VUS` ^P[O [OL ]LOPJSL
Z[H[PVUHY`
p"*dF ¤Fdpm"amF
+HUNLY
7VY[HISL M\LS JVU[HPULYZ M\SS VY WHY[PHSS`
LTW[` TH` SLHR JH\ZPUN HU L_WSVZPVU VY
YLZ\S[PUMPYLPUJHZLVMHUHJJPKLU[
5L]LY JHYY` HKKP[PVUHS M\LS PU WVY[HISL JVUÌ
[HPULYZPU`V\Y]LOPJSL
mVamF¨^"¤
+HUNLY
,UNPULL_OH\Z[PZKHUNLYV\ZPMPUOHSLK
,UNPUL L_OH\Z[ M\TLZ OH]L THU` JVTWVÍ
ULU[Z ^OPJO `V\ JHU ZTLSS ;OL` HSZV JVUÍ
[HPU JHYIVU TVUV_PKL *6 ^OPJO PZ H JVÍ
SVYSLZZHUKVKVYSLZZNHZ
*HYIVU TVUV_PKL JHU JH\ZL \UJVUZJPV\ZÍ
ULZZHUKL]LUKLH[OPMPUOHSLK
5L]LY Z[HY[ VY SL[ [OL LUNPUL Y\U PU HU LUÌ
JSVZLK\U]LU[PSH[LKHYLH
0[ PZ UV[ YLJVTTLUKLK [V ZP[ PU `V\Y JHY MVY
WYVSVUNLKWLYPVKZ^P[O[OLLUNPULVUHUK[OL
JHYUV[TV]PUN
p4^FF"ha4phzpaF
"cF|}
;OL OPNOÌWLYMVYTHUJL IYHRL Z`Z[LT PZ KLZPNULK
MVYVW[PTHSIYHRPUNLMMLJ[H[HSSZWLLKZHUK[LTÌ
WLYH[\YLZ
*LY[HPUZWLLKZIYHRPUNMVYJLZHUKHTIPLU[JVUÌ
KP[PVUZZ\JOHZ[LTWLYH[\YLHUKO\TPKP[`[OLYLÌ
MVYLTPNO[JH\ZLIYHRLUVPZLZ
>LHY VU [OL KPMMLYLU[ JVTWVULU[Z HUK IYHRPUN
Z`Z[LT Z\JO HZ IYHRL WHKZ VY IYHRL KPZJZ
KLWLUKZ[VHNYLH[L_[LU[VU[OLPUKP]PK\HSKYP]Ì
PUNZ[`SLHUK[OLJVUKP[PVUZVM\ZLHUK[OLYLMVYL
JHUUV[ IL L_WYLZZLK PU HJ[\HS TPSLZ VU [OL
YVHK
;OL]HS\LZJVTT\UPJH[LKI`7VYZJOLHYLIHZLK
VU UVYTHS VWLYH[PVU HKHW[LK [V [YHMMPJ >LHY
PUJYLHZLZ JVUZPKLYHIS` ^OLU [OL ]LOPJSL PZ
KYP]LU VU YHJL [YHJRZ VY [OYV\NO HU HNNYLZZP]L
KYP]PUNZ[`SL
7SLHZL JVUZ\S[ `V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY
HIV\[ [OL J\YYLU[ N\PKLSPULZ PU LMMLJ[ ILMVYL
Z\JO\ZLVM`V\Y]LOPJSL
G
pmpd:m¤hFm
ssJs¢
^aOamV F"
s¢QJs¢
"amFm"m4F:""F
sJsQG
"4a4"daz:hFVFm4©F¦a4F
sQnJ¢¬¢
F^a4dF=FmaOa4"apm:F4^ma4"d""
¢¬J¢sQ
m=F¨
¢sJ¢¢¬
n
s¬
pmpd:m¤hFm
)LMVYLKYP]PUNVMM
)YLHRPUOPU[Z
2L`Z[OLM[WYV[LJ[PVU u
0TTVIPSPaLYZLJ\YP[`^OLLSIVS[Z
+VVYZKVVY^PUKV^Z
*LU[YHSSVJRPUN u
(SHYTZ`Z[LTPUMYHYLKWHZZLUNLY
JVTWHY[TLU[TVUP[VYPUN
7V^LY^PUKV^Z
4PYYVYZPUZPKLHUKKVVY
9LHY^PUKV^KLMVNNLY
KVVYTPYYVYOLH[PUN
:LH[Zu
:[LLYPUN^OLLSHKQ\Z[TLU[
:HML[`ILS[Zu
*OPSKYLZ[YHPU[Z`Z[LTZ u
(PYIHNZ`Z[LT
7HYRPUNHPKZ
9L[YHJ[HISLYLHYZWVPSLY
*S\[JOWHYRPUNIYHRLIYHRLZu
():IYHRLZ`Z[LT
7:47VYZJOLZ[HIPSP[`THUHNLTLU[
-V\YÌ^OLLSKYP]L
+HZOIVHYKJVU[YVSZHUKPUZ[Y\TLU[Zu
0NUP[PVUZ[HY[LYZ^P[JO
:[HY[PUNHUKZ[VWWPUN[OLLUNPUL
0UZ[Y\TLU[WHULS u
6UÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY u
,TLYNLUJ`MSHZOLYZ^P[JO
3PNO[Z^P[JO
H\[VTH[PJOLHKSPNO[ILHTHKQ\Z[TLU[
;\YUZPNUHSZ
OLHKSPNO[KPTTLYMSHZOLYSL]LY
>PUKZOPLSK^PWLY^HZOLYSL]LY
YHPUZLUZVY
(\[VTH[PJZWLLKJVU[YVS
(\[VTH[PJHPYJVUKP[PVULY u
*LU[YHSHUKZPKL]LU[Z
(ZO[YH`JPNHYL[[LSPNO[LY
9LHY^PWLYZ\U]PZVYZ
0U[LYPVYSPNO[Z
:[VYHNLPU[OLWHZZLUNLYJVTWHY[TLU[
*+VYJHZZL[[LOVSKLY
-YVU[HUKYLHYSPKZ
3\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[
;Y\URLU[YHWTLU[
7*47VYZJOLJVTT\UPJH[PVUTHUHNLTLU[
*\WOVSKLY
*HY[LSLWOVULHUKHM[LYTHYRLKHSHYTZ
*HYH\KPVVWLYH[PVU[PWZ
9VVM[YHUZWVY[Z`Z[LT
3PM[PUNZSPKPUNYVVM u
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
ss
F"p4^F§mF
( SV[ OHZ NVUL PU[V [OL THU\MHJ[\YL VM `V\Y
7VYZJOL PUJS\KPUN HK]HUJLK LUNPULLYPUN YPNPK
X\HSP[`JVU[YVSHUKKLTHUKPUNPUZWLJ[PVUZ
;OLZL LUNPULLYPUN HUK ZHML[` MLH[\YLZ ^PSS IL
LUOHUJLKI``V\
^F"OF=a¦F
^OVRUV^ZOPZJHYHUKHSSJVU[YVSZ
^OVTHPU[HPUZ[OL]LOPJSLWYVWLYS`
^OV\ZLZKYP]PUNZRPSSZ^PZLS`HUKHS^H`ZKYP]LZ
^P[OPU OLYOPZ V^U JHWHIPSP[PLZ HUK [OL SL]LS VM
MHTPSPHYP[`^P[O[OL]LOPJSL
@V\ ^PSS MPUK OLSWM\S OPU[Z PU [OPZ THU\HS VU OV^
[V WLYMVYT TVZ[ VM [OL JOLJRZ SPZ[LK VU [OL
MVSSV^PUNWHNLZ
0M PU KV\I[ OH]L [OLZL JOLJRZ WLYMVYTLK I`
`V\YH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
FOpF=a¦amVpOO
^F4c^FOpddp§amVaFhOa
;\YU [OL LUNPUL VMM ILMVYL `V\ H[[LTW[ HU`
JOLJRZVYYLWHPYZVU[OL]LOPJSL
)LZ\YL[OL[PYLZHYLPUMSH[LKJVYYLJ[S`
*OLJR[PYLZMVYKHTHNLHUK[PYL^LHY
:LL [OH[ ^OLLS IVS[Z HYL WYVWLYS` [PNO[LULK
HUKUV[SVVZLVYTPZZPUN
*OLJRLUNPULVPSSL]LSHKKPMULJLZZHY`
4HRL P[ H OHIP[ [V OH]L LUNPUL VPS JOLJRLK
^P[OL]LY`M\LSMPSSPUN
*OLJR HSS MS\PK SL]LSZ Z\JO HZ ^PUKZOPLSK
^HZOLYHUKIYHRLMS\PKSL]LSZ
)L Z\YL [OL ]LOPJSL IH[[LY` PZ ^LSS JOHYNLK
HUKJYHURZ[OLLUNPULWYVWLYS`
*OLJR HSS KVVYZ HUK SPKZ MVY WYVWLY VWLYH[PVU
HUKSH[JO[OLTWYVWLYS`
*OLJR HUK PM ULJLZZHY` YLWSHJL ^VYU VY
JYHJRLK^PWLYISHKLZ
:LL [OH[ HSS ^PUKV^Z HYL JSLHY HUK \UVIÌ
Z[Y\J[LK
*OLJR HPY PU[HRL ZSV[Z HUK HYLH IL[^LLU S\NÌ
NHNLJVTWHY[TLU[SPKHUK^PUKZOPLSKHYLMYLL
VM ZUV^ HUK PJL ZV [OL OLH[LY HUK [OL ^PUKÌ
ZOPLSK^PWLYZ^VYRWYVWLYS`
0M H JOP SK ^P SS IL YP KP UN P U [OL ]LOP JSL JOLJR
JOPSK ZLH[JOPSK ZLH[ YLZ[YHPU[ Z`Z[LT [V LUÌ
Z\YL[OH[YLZ[YHPU[ZHYLWYVWLYS`HKQ\Z[LK
*OLJR HSS L_[LYPVY HUK PU[LYPVY SPNO[Z MVY VWLYÌ
H[PVUHUK[OH[[OLSLUZLZHYLJSLHU
*OLJR [OL OLHKSP NO[Z MVY WYVWLY HP T HUK P M
ULJLZZHY`OH]L[OLTHKQ\Z[LK
*OLJR\UKLY[OL]LOPJSLMVYSLHRZ
)LZ\YLHSSS\NNHNLPZZ[V^LKZLJ\YLS`
hFVFm4©F¤azhFm
0[ PZ NVVK WYHJ[PJL [V JHYY` LTLYNLUJ` LX\PWÌ
TLU[PU`V\Y]LOPJSL
:VTLVM[OLP[LTZ`V\ZOV\SKOH]LHYL!
^PUKV^ ZJYHWLY ZUV^ IY\ZO JVU[HPULY VY IHN
VM ZHUK VY ZHS[ LTLYNLUJ` SPNO[ ZTHSS ZOV]LS
MPYZ[ÌHPKRP[L[J
s¢
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
m^F=a¦FF"
*OLJRVWLYH[PVUVM[OLOVYU
7VZP[PVU ZLH[ MVY LHZ` YLHJO VM MVV[ WLKHSZ
HUKJVU[YVSZ
;VYLK\JL[OLWVZZPIPSP[`VMPUQ\Y`MYVT[OLHPYÌ
IHN KLWSV`TLU[ `V\ ZOV\SK HS^H`Z ZP[ IHJR
HZMHYMYVT[OLZ[LLYPUN^OLLSHZPZWYHJ[PJHS
^OPSLZ[PSSTHPU[HPUPUNM\SS]LOPJSLJVU[YVS
(KQ\Z[ [OL PUZPKL HUK V\[ZPKL YLHY ]PL^ TPYÌ
YVYZ
)\JRSL`V\YZHML[`ILS[Z
*OLJR VWLYH[PVU VM [OL MVV[ HUK WHYRPUN
IYHRL
*OLJR HSS ^HYUPUN HUK PUKPJH[VY SPNO[Z ^P[O
PNUP[PVUVUHUKLUNPULUV[Y\UUPUN
:[HY[ LUNPUL HUK JOLJR HSS ^HYUPUN KPZWSH`Z
MVY^HYUPUNZ`TIVSZ
5L]LYSLH]LHUPKSPUNJHY\UH[[LUKLK
3VJR KVVYZ MYVT PUZPKL LZWLJPHSS` ^P[O JOPSKÌ
YLU PU [OL JHY [V WYL]LU[ PUHK]LY[LU[ VWLUPUN
VMKVVYZMYVTPUZPKLVYV\[ZPKL
+YP]L^P[OKVVYZSVJRLK
m^Fp"=
5L]LY KYP]L HM[LY `V\ OH]L JVUZ\TLK HSJVOVS
VYKY\NZ
(S^H`ZOH]L`V\YZHML[`ILS[MHZ[LULK
(S^H`ZKYP]LKLMLUZP]LS`
,_WLJ[[OL\UL_WLJ[LK
<ZL ZPNUHSZ [V PUKPJH[L [\YUZ HUK SHUL
JOHUNLZ
;\YU VU OLHKSPNO[Z H[ K\ZR VY ^OLU [OL KYP]Ì
PUNJVUKP[PVUZ^HYYHU[P[
(S^H`Z RLLW H ZHML KPZ[HUJL MYVT [OL]LOPJSL
PUMYVU[VM`V\KLWLUKPUNVU[YHMMPJYVHKHUK
^LH[OLYJVUKP[PVUZ
9LK\JL ZWLLK H[ UPNO[ HUK K\YPUN PUJSLTLU[
^LH[OLY
+YP]PUN PU ^L[ ^LH[OLY YLX\PYLZ JH\[PVU HUK
YLK\JLK ZWLLKZ WHY[PJ\SHYS` VU YVHKZ ^P[O
Z[HUKPUN ^H[LY HZ [OL OHUKSPUN JOHYHJÌ
[LYPZ[PJZ VM [OL ]LOPJSL TH` IL PTWHPYLK K\L
[VO`KYVWSHUPUNVM[OL[PYLZ
(S^H`Z VIZLY]L ZWLLK SPTP[Z HUK VIL` YVHK
ZPNUZHUK[YHMMPJSH^Z
>OLU [PYLK NL[ ^LSS VMM [OL YVHK Z[VW HUK
[HRLHYLZ[;\YU[OLLUNPULVMM+VUV[ZP[PU
[OL]LOPJSL^P[OLUNPULPKSPUN
:LL^HYUPUNZVUs,UNPUL,_OH\Z[r
>OLU WHYRLK HS^H`Z ZL[ [OL WHYRPUN IYHRL
4V]L[OL;PW[YVUPJZLSLJ[VYSL]LY[Vs7rVY[OL
NLHYZOPM[SL]LY[VYL]LYZLVYMPYZ[NLHY
6U OPSSZ HSZV [\YU [OL MYVU[ ^OLLSZ [V^HYK [OL
J\YI
>OLU LTLYNLUJ` YLWHPYZ ILJVTL ULJLZZHY`
TV]L [OL ]LOPJSL ^LSS VMM [OL YVHK ;\YU VU
[OL LTLYNLUJ` MSHZOLY HUK \ZL V[OLY^HYUPUN
KL]PJLZ [V HSLY[ V[OLY TV[VYPZ[Z +V UV[ WHYR
VYVWLYH[L[OL]LOPJSLPUHYLHZ^OLYL[OLOV[
L_OH\Z[Z`Z[LTTH`JVTLPUJVU[HJ[^P[OKY`
NYHZZIY\ZOM\LSZWPSSVYV[OLYMSHTTHISLTHÌ
[LYPHS
4HRLP[HOHIP[[VOH]L[OLLUNPULVPSJOLJRLK
^P[OL]LY`M\LSMPSSPUN
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
s
F"cmamOp^FOa
¢¬¬¬hadF|¬¬¬cadphFF}
;OLMVSSV^PUN[PWZ^PSSILOLSWM\SPUVI[HPUPUNVW[PÌ
T\TWLYMVYTHUJLMYVT`V\YUL^7VYZJOL
+LZWP[L [OL TVZ[ TVKLYU OPNOÌWYLJPZPVU THU\Ì
MHJ[\YPUN TL[OVKZ P[ JHUUV[ IL JVTWSL[LS`
H]VPKLK [OH[ [OL TV]PUN WHY[Z OH]L [V ^LHY PU
^P[OLHJOV[OLY;OPZ^LHYPUNÌPUVJJ\YZTHPUS`PU
[OLMPYZ[TPSLZRT
^FFOpF9
7YLMLYHIS`[HRLSVUNLY[YPWZ
(]VPK MYLX\LU[ JVSK Z[HY[Z ^P[O ZOVY[ÌKPZ[HUJL
KYP]PUN^OLUL]LYWVZZPISL
(]VPKM\SS[OYV[[SLZ[HY[ZHUKHIY\W[Z[VWZ
+V UV[ L_JLLK TH_PT\T LUNPUL ZWLLK VM
YWTYL]VS\[PVUZWLYTPU\[L
+VUV[Y\UHJVSKLUNPULH[OPNOYWTLP[OLYPU
5L\[YHSVYPUNLHY
+V UV[ SL[ [OL LUNPUL SHIVY LZWLJPHSS` ^OLU
KYP]PUN \WOPSS :OPM[ [V [OL UL_[ SV^LY NLHY PU
[PTL\ZL[OLTVZ[MH]VYHISLYWTYHUNL
5L]LY S\N [OL LUNPUL PU OPNO NLHY H[ SV^
ZWLLKZ;OPZY\SLHWWSPLZH[HSS[PTLZUV[Q\Z[
K\YPUN[OLIYLHRÌPUWLYPVK
+V UV[ WHY[PJPWH[L PU TV[VY YHJPUN L]LU[Z
ZWVY[Z KYP]PUN ZJOVVSZ L[J K\YPUN [OL MPYZ[
TPSLZRT
;OLYL TH` IL H ZSPNO[ Z[PMMULZZ PU [OL Z[LLYPUN
NLHYÌZOPM[PUNVYV[OLYJVU[YVSZK\YPUN[OLIYLHRÌPU
WLYPVK^OPJO^PSSNYHK\HSS`KPZHWWLHY
F"cam*"cFz"=
5L^ IYHRL WHKZ HUK IYHRL KPZJZ OH]L [V IL
rIYVRLU PUs HUK [OLYLMVYL VUS` H[[HPU VW[PTHS
MYPJ[PVU ^OLU [OL JHY OHZ JV]LYLK ZL]LYHS O\UÌ
KYLKTPSLZVYRT
;OL ZSPNO[S` YLK\JLK IYHRPUN HIPSP[` T\Z[ IL
JVTWLUZH[LK MVY I` WYLZZPUN [OL IYHRL WLKHS
OHYKLY ;OPZ HSZV HWWSPLZ ^OLUL]LY [OL IYHRL
WHKZHUKIYHRLKPZJZHYLYLWSHJLK
F§aF
5L^ [PYLZ KV UV[ OH]L TH_PT\T [YHJ[PVU ;OL`
[LUK[VILZSPWWLY`
)YLHR PU UL^ [PYLZ I` KYP]PUN H[ TVKLYH[L
ZWLLKZK\YPUN[OLMPYZ[[VTPSLZ
[V RT 3VUNLY IYHRPUN KPZ[HUJLZ T\Z[
ILHU[PJPWH[LK
mVamFpad4pm¤hzapm
+\YPUN [OL IYLHRÌPU WLYPVK VPS JVUZ\TW[PVU TH`
ILOPNOLY[OHUUVYTHS
(Z HS^H`Z [OL YH[L VM VPS JVUZ\TW[PVU KLWLUKZ
VU [OL X\HSP[` HUK ]PZJVZP[` VM VPS [OL ZWLLK H[
^OPJO [OL LUNPUL PZ VWLYH[LK [OL JSPTH[L HUK
YVHK JVUKP[PVUZ HZ ^LSS HZ [OL HTV\U[ VM KPS\Ì
[PVUHUKV_PKH[PVUVM[OLS\IYPJHU[
4HRLHOHIP[VMJOLJRPUNLUNPULVPS^P[OL]LY`
M\LSMPSSPUNHKKPMULJLZZHY`
sT
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
0UULYKVVYOHUKSL
+VVYTPYYVYJVU[YVS
3PNO[Z^P[JO
0NUP[PVUZ[HY[LYZ^P[JO^P[OZ[LLYPUNSVJR
;\YUZPNUHSOLHKSPNO[KPTTLY
MSHZOLYSL]LY
;VNNSLZ^P[JOLZMVY;PW[YVUPJ
,TLYNLUJ`MSHZOLYZ^P [JO
/VYU
.SV]LJVTWHY[TLU[
7HYRPUNIYHRL
+PHNUVZ[PJZVJRL[
6WLYH[PUNSL]LYMVYVUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY
3\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[SPKYLSLHZL
:LH[HKQ\Z[TLU[
:[LLYPUNÌ^OLLSHKQ\Z[TLU[
,UNPULJVTWHY[TLU[SPKYLSLHZL
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
sQ
F¦Fam¦aF4"^FOM
(U\USVJRLKJHY^P[O[OLRL`PU[OLPNUP[PVUSVJR
PU]P[LZJHY[OLM[
( Z[LLYP UN ^OLLS SVJR HUK H NVUN HSHYT HYL
Z[HUKHYKLX\PWTLU[PU`V\Y7VYZJOL
;OL NVUN HSHYT ^PSS ZV\UK PM `V\ VWLU [OL
KYP]LYqZ KVVY ^OPSL [OL RL` PZ Z[PSS PU [OL PNUP[PVU
SVJR 0[ PZ `V\Y YLTPUKLY [V W\SS [OL RL` V\[ VM
[OLPNUP[PVUSVJRHUK[VSVJR[OLKVVYZ
>HYUPUN
(U` \UJVU[YVSSLK TV]LTLU[ VM [OL ]LOPJSL
TH` YLZ\S[ PU ZLYPV\Z WLYZVUHS PUQ\Y` HUK
WYVWLY[`KHTHNL
5L]LY SLH]L `V\Y ]LOPJSL \UH[[LUKLK ^P[O
[OL RL` PU [OL PNUP[PVU SVJR LZWLJPHSS` PM
JOPSKYLU HUKVY WL[Z HYL SLM[ \UH[[LUKLK PU
[OL ]LOPJSL ;OL` JHU VWLYH[L WV^LY ^PUÍ
KV^Z HUK V[OLY JVU[YVSZ 0M [OL LUNPUL PZ
SLM[ Y\UUPUN [OL` TH` HJJPKLU[HSS` LUNHNL
[OLZOPM[SL]LY
(S^H`ZYLTV]L[OLPNUP[PVURL`
(S^H`ZZL[[OLWHYRPUNIYHRL
3VJR [OL KVVYZ ^P[O [OL RL` VY ^P[O [OL
YLTV[LJVU[YVS
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMHZLYPV\ZHJJPKLU[
;OL Z[LLYPUN JVS\TU ^PSS SVJR ^OLU `V\
YLTV]L[OLRL`^OPSL`V\HYLKYP]PUNVYHZ
[OL JHY PZ YVSSPUN [V H Z[VW @V\ ^PSS UV[ IL
HISL[VZ[LLY[OLJHY
5L]LY YLTV]L [OL RL` MYVT [OL Z[LLYP UN SVJR
^OPSL`V\HYLKYP]PUN
;V WYV[LJ[ `V\Y ]LOPJSL HUK `V\Y WVZÍ
ZLZZPVUZMYVT[OLM[`V\ZOV\SKHS^H`ZWYVÍ
JLLKHZMVSSV^Z^OLUSLH]PUN`V\Y]LOPJSL!
*SVZL^PUKV^Z
*SVZLSPM[PUNZSPKPUNYVVM
9LTV]LPNUP[PVURL`
,UNHNLZ[LLYPUNSVJR
3VJRZ[VYHNL[YH`IL[^LLU[OLMYVU[ZLH[Z
HUKNSV]LJVTWHY[TLU[
9LTV]L ]HS\HISLZ LN JHY KVJ\TLU[Z YHKP V
JVU[YVS TVK\SL [LSLWOVUL OV\ZL RL`Z MYVT
[OLJHY
3VJRKVVYZ
s
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
F©
7SLHZL UV[L JOHW[LYZ s*LU[YHS 3VJRPUN HUK
(SHYT:`Z[LTr
;^V THP U RL`Z HUK VUL ZWHYL RL` HYL Z\WWSP LK
^P[O`V\Y7VYZJOL
;OLZL RL`Z VWLYH[L HSS [OL SVJRZ VU `V\Y ]LÌ
OPJSL
)L JHYLM\S ^P[O `V\Y JHY RL`Z! KV UV[ WHY[
^P[O [OLT L_JLW[ \UKLY L_JLW[PVUHS JPYJ\TÌ
Z[HUJLZ
;VH]VPKIH[[LY`Y\UÌKV^UHS^H`ZYLTV]L[OL
PNUP[PVURL`MYVT[OLPNUP[PVUSVJR
Fzd"4FhFmcF©
9LWSHJLTLU[ JHY RL`Z JHU IL VI[HPULK VUS`
MYVT `V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY HUK [OPZ
JHUZVTL[PTLZIL]LY`[PTLÌJVUZ\TPUN
@V\ZOV\SK[OLYLMVYLHS^H`ZRLLW[OLZWHYLRL`
VU`V\YWLYZVU
2LLW P[ PU H ZHML WSHJL LN ^HSSL[ I\[ \UKLY
UVJPYJ\TZ[HUJLZPUVYVU[OL]LOPJSL
;OL RL` JVKLZ VM UL^ RL`Z OH]L [V IL
sYLWVY[LKr [V [OL JHY JVU[YVS \UP[ I` `V\Y H\[OÌ
VYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
;OLRL`NYPWVM[OLZWHYLRL`JHUILL_JOHUNLK
MVYHTHPUÌRL`NYPW
+PZHISPUNRL`JVKLZ
0M H RL` PZ SVZ[ [OL RL` JVKLZ JHU IL KPZHISLK
I`HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
(SS [OL YLTHPUPUN JHY RL`Z HYL YLX\PYLK MVY [OPZ
W\YWVZL
+PZHISPUN [OL JVKL LUZ\YLZ [OH[ [OL JHY JHU IL
Z[HY[LKVUS`\ZPUNH\[OVYPaLKRL`Z
5V[L
7SLHZL UV[L [OH[ [OL V[OLYSVJRZJHUZ[PSSILVWÌ
LULK^P[O[OLKPZHISLKRL`
hhp*ada«F
;OLYL PZ H [YHUZWVUKLY HU LSLJ[YVUPJ JVTWVÌ
ULU[PU[OLRL`NYPWJVU[HPUPUNHZ[VYLKJVKL
>OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ Z^P[JOLK VU [OL PNUP[PVU
SVJRJOLJRZ[OLJVKL
;OL PTTVIPSPaLY JHU IL KLHJ[P]H[LK HUK [OL LUÌ
NPUL Z[HY[LK VUS` \ZPUN HU H\[OVYPaLK PNUP[PVU
RL`
5V[L
0M [OL PNUP[PVU PZ SLM[ VU MVY TVYL [OHU [^V
TPU\[LZ ^P[OV\[ Z[HY[PUN [OLLUNPUL[OLPTTVIPÌ
SPaLYPZYLHJ[P]H[LK
0M [OPZ OHWWLUZ [OL PNUP[PVU RL` T\Z[ IL
[\YULKIHJR[V[OLsrWVZP[PVUILMVYL[OLLUÌ
NPULJHUILZ[HY[LK
;OL PTTVIPSPaLY PZ H\[VTH[PJHSS` HJ[P]H[LK ^OLU
[OLPNUP[PVURL`PZ^P[OKYH^U
F4¤a©^FFdpd
0M^OLLSZOH]L[VILYLTV]LKK\YPUNH^VYRZOVW
]PZP[ KV UV[ MVYNL[ [V OHUK V]LY [OL ZVJRL[ MVY
[OLZLJ\YP[`^OLLSIVS[ZHSVUN^P[O[OLJHYRL`
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
s
(Í4HPURL`
Í*LU[YHSSVJRPUNI\[[VU
Í3\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[SPKI\[[VU
Í3PNO[ÍLTP[[PUNKPVKL
)Í:WHYLRL`
F©§a^"=apFhpFpmpd
zF"amV4Fm"ddp4camV:"d"h©Fh
"m=F"hFhp©
7YLZZI\[[VU
7SLHZL VIZLY]L [OL HWWYVWYPH[L JOHW[LYZ VM [OPZ
4HU\HS
<USVJRPUNS\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[SPK
7YLZZI\[[VUMVYHWWYV_[^VZLJVUKZ
0M [OL ]LOPJSL ^HZ SVJRLK ILMVYL [OL S\NNHNL
JVTWHY[TLU[ PZ VWLULK P[ PZ \USVJRLK ZPT\S[HÌ
ULV\ZS`^P[O[OLS\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[
0U ]LOPJSLZ ^P[O ZLH[ TLTVY` [OL Z[VYLK ZLH[
HUKKVVYTPYYVYWVZP[PVUZHYLH\[VTH[PJHSS`ZL[
;OL]LOPJSL^PSSILSVJRLKHNHPUHWWYV_ZLJÌ
VUKZHM[LY[OLS\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[PZJSVZLKPM
UVULVM[OLKVVYZ^HZVWLULK
5V[L
@V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY JHU WYVNYHT
M\Y[OLY[`WLZVMS\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[\USVJRPUN
;`WL
;OLYLSVJRPUN[PTLVM[OLKVVYZJHUILHKQ\Z[LK
[VZ\P[`V\YPUKP]PK\HSYLX\PYLTLU[Z!
ÌZLJVUKZ
;`WL
;OL KVVYZ Z[H` SVJRLK ^OLU [OL S\NNHNL JVTÌ
WHY[TLU[PZ\USVJRLK
^FFhpF_4pmpd"m=*©O¤m4apm
§a4^FpOO"OFQ="©
0M[OL]LOPJSLPZUV[Z[HY[LKVY\USVJRLK^P[O[OL
YLTV[LJVU[YVS^P[OPUMP]LKH`Z[OLYLTV[LJVUÌ
[YVS Z[HUKI` M\UJ[PVU PZ Z^P[JOLK VMM [V WYL]LU[
KPZJOHYNPUNVM[OL]LOPJSLIH[[LY`
0U[OPZJHZL\USVJR[OLKYP]LYqZKVVY^P[O[OL
RL`H[[OLKVVYSVJR
3LH]L[OLKVVYJSVZLKPUVYKLY[VWYL]LU[[OL
HSHYTZ`Z[LTMYVTILPUN[YPNNLYLK
7YLZZI\[[VUVU[OLYLTV[LJVU[YVS
;OLYLTV[LJVU[YVSPZUV^HJ[P]H[LKHNHPU
sG
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
pp
mdp4camV:dp4camV
<USVJRVYSVJR[OLKVVYSVJRZ^P[O[OLYLTV[L
JVU[YVS VY I` \ZPUN [OL RL` PU [OL KYP]LYqZ
KVVY
0M [OL KVVY ^PUKV^Z HYL JSVZLK [OL` ^PSS IL
H\[VTH[PJHSS` VWLULK I` H ML^ TPSSPTL[LYZ ^OLU
[OL KVVYZ HYL VWLULK HUK ^OLU [OL KVVYZ HYL
JSVZLK [OL` ^PSS IL JSVZLK HNHPU ;OPZ THRLZ P[
LHZPLY[VVWLUHUKJSVZL[OLKVVYZHUKWYV[LJ[Z
[OLZLHSZ
;OLYLMVYL `V\ ZOV\SK W\SS [OL KVVY OHUKSL
ZSV^S` ZV [OH[ [OL KVVY ^PUKV^ JHU IL SV^LYLK
ILMVYL[OLKVVYPZVWLULK
zFmamV¤mdp4cF==ppOphp¤a=F
:SV^S`W\SSKVVYOHUKSL(
zFmamV¤mdp4cF==ppOphama=F
:SV^S`W\SSKVVYOHUKSL)
zFmamVdp4cF==ppOphama=F
:SV^S`W\SSKVVYOHUKSL)[^PJL
(SZVYLMLY[V[OLJOHW[LYr3VJRPUNJVUKP[PVUZs
ppp"VF"©
(S^H`ZRLLW[OLKVVYZ[VYHNL[YH`*JSVZLKZV
[OH[ [OL ZPKL HPYIHN PZ UV[ VIZ[Y\J[LK PU [OL
L]LU[VMHUHJJPKLU[
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
sn
Fm"dp4camV
<:(! -**0+3?792@"
-**0+3?7=04
*HUHKH!;_-7"
9_-7(
;OPZKL]PJLJVTWSPLZ^P[O!
7HY[VM[OL-**9\SLZ
9::ÌVM0UK\Z[Y`*HUHKH
6WLYH[PVUVM[OPZKL]PJLPZZ\IQLJ[[V[OLMVSSV^Ì
PUN[^VJVUKP[PVUZ!
0[TH`UV[JH\ZLOHYTM\SPU[LYMLYLUJLHUK
P[ T\Z[ HJJLW[ HU` PU[LYMLYLUJL YLJLP]LK
PUJS\KPUN PU[LYMLYLUJL [OH[ TH` JH\ZL \UÌ
KLZPYLKVWLYH[PVU
5V[L
;OL THU\MHJ[\YLY PZ UV[ YLZWVUZPISL MVY HU`
YHKPVVY;=PU[LYMLYLUJLJH\ZLKI`\UH\[OVYPaLK
TVKPMPJH[PVUZ[V[OPZLX\PWTLU[
:\JOTVKPMPJH[PVUJV\SK]VPK[OL\ZLYqZH\[OVYP[`
[VVWLYH[L[OLLX\PWTLU[
:LL [OL JOHW[LY VU s3VHK Z^P[JOÌVMMr s7V^LY
^PUKV^ZrHUKs3PM[PUNZSPKPUNYVVMr
)V[O JHY KVVYZ HUK [OL MPSSLY MSHW JHU IL JLUÌ
[YHSS` \USVJRLK VY SVJRLK ^P[O [OL YLTV[L JVUÌ
[YVS
0M[OLKYP]LYqZKVVYPZUV[JVTWSL[LS`JSVZLK[OL
]LOPJSLJHUUV[ILSVJRLK
( ZOVY[ ZPNUHS MYVT [OL HSHYT OVYU ^PSS KYH^
`V\Y H[[LU[PVU [V [OL MHJ[ [OH[ [OL MVSSV^PUN
JVTWVULU[Z HYL UV[ JVTWSL[LS` JSVZLK ^OLU
`V\[Y`[VSVJR[OL]LOPJSL!
7HZZLUNLYqZKVVY
3\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[SPK
,UNPULJVTWHY[TLU[SPK
:[VYHNL[YH`
.SV]LJVTWHY[TLU[
5V[L
<USVJRPUN [OL ]LOPJSL I` \ZPUN [OL RL` PU [OL
KVVYSVJRHUKVWLUPUN[OLKVVYTH`HJ[P]H[L[OL
HSHYTZ`Z[LT^P[OPUZLJVUKZ
¤ph"a4Fdp4camV
0M [OL JHY PZ \USVJRLK I` YLTV[L JVU[YVS HUK
UVUL VM [OL JHY KVVYZ PZ VWLULK ^P[OPU HWWYV_
ZLJVUKZH\[VTH[PJYLSVJRPUN[HRLZWSHJL
;OPZYLSVJRPUN[PTLJHUILHKHW[LK[V`V\YPUKPÌ
]PK\HS YLX\PYLTLU[Z Ì ZLJVUKZ I` HU
H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
p4camV4pm=aapm
3VJRJHYVUJL
;OL KVVYZ JHUUV[ IL VWLULK MYVT [OL V\[Ì
ZPKL
(SHYT Z`Z[LT HUK PUMYHYLK WHZZLUNLY JVTÌ
WHY[TLU[TVUP[VYPUNHYLZ^P[JOLKVU
0MHWLYZVUVYHUPTHSYLTHPUZPU[OL
]LOPJSL!
8\PJRS`SVJRJHY[^PJL
;OL KVVYZ JHUUV[ IL VWLULK MYVT [OL V\[Ì
ZPKL
;OLPUMYHYLKWHZZLUNLYJVTWHY[TLU[TVUP[VYÌ
PUNPZZ^P[JOLKVMM
<USVJRPUN[OLKVVY^P[O[OLPUULYKVVY
OHUKSL
(U` WLYZVU YLTHPUPUN PU [OL SVJRLK JHY JHU
VWLU[OLKVVY^P[O[OLPUULYKVVYOHUKSL!
7\SS PUULY KVVY OHUKSL VUJL [V \USVJR KVVY
SVJR
7\SSPUULYKVVYOHUKSLHNHPU[VVWLUKVVY
5V[L
0UMVYT HU` WLYZVU YLTHPUPUN PU [OL JHY [OH[ [OL
HSHYTZ`Z[LT^PSSIL[YPNNLYLKPM[OLKVVYPZVWÌ
LULK
¢¬
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
hFVFm4©pzF"apmJpzFmamV
<USVJR [OL KYP]LYqZ KVVY ^P[O [OL RL` H[ [OL
KVVYSVJR
6WLU [OL KVVY HUK Z^P [JO [OL P NUP [P VU VU
^P[OPU ZLJVUKZ PU VYKLY [V WYL]LU[ [OL
HSHYTZ`Z[LTMYVTILPUN[YPNNLYLK
hFVFm4©pzF"apmJ4dpamV
8\PJRS` [\YU [OL RL` PU [OL KYP]LYqZ KVVY SVJR
[V [OL SVJR WVZP[PVU [OYLL [PTLZ P U Z\JÌ
JLZZPVU
0M [OLYL PZ H KLMLJ[ PU [OL JLU[YHS SVJRPUN Z`ZÌ
[LT HSS M\UJ[PVUPUN LSLTLU[Z VM [OL JLU[YHS
SVJRPUNZ`Z[LT^PSSILSVJRLK
;OLHSHYTZ`Z[LTPZZ^P[JOLKVU
;OLPUMYHYLKWHZZLUNLYJVTWHY[TLU[TVUP[VYÌ
PUNZ`Z[LTPZZ^P[JOLKVMM
;OL MH\S[ ZOV\SK IL YLTLKPLK PTTLKPH[LS` H[ HU
H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
m=a4"apm*©FhFVFm4©Od"^F"m=
"d"h^pm
0M [OL YLTV[L JVU[YVS PZ \ZLK MVY \USVJRPUN VY
SVJRPUN H YLZWVUZL PZ WYV]PKLK I` [OL LTLYÌ
NLUJ`MSHZOLY!
<USVJRPUNuZPUNSLMSHZO
3VJRPUNuKV\ISLMSHZO
3VJRPUN[^PJLuJVU[PU\V\ZPSS\TPUH[PVUMVYHWÌ
WYV_ZLJVUKZHUKZOVY[HSHYTÌOVYUZPNUHS
Fm"ddp4camV§a4^
;OLJLU[YHSSVJRPUNZ^P[JOVU[OLKHZOIVHYKSL[Z
`V\SVJRHUK\USVJRIV[OKVVYZLSLJ[YPJHSS`
5V[L
0M [OL KVVYZ HYL SVJRLK ^P[O [OL RL` VY YLTV[L
JVU[YVS[OL`JHUUV[ILVWLULKI`WYLZZPUN[OL
JLU[YHSSVJRPUNZ^P[JO
3VJRPUN
7YLZZ[OLYVJRLYÌZ^P[JOZ`TIVS
0UKPJH[VYSPNO[SPNO[Z\WPMPNUP[PVUPZVU
<USVJRPUN
7YLZZ[OLYVJRLYÌZ^P[JOPUKPJH[VYSPNO[
0UKPJH[VYSPNO[NVLZV\[
0M[OLKVVYZ^LYLSVJRLK^P[O[OLJLU[YHSSVJRPUN
Z^P[JO [OL` JHU IL VWLULK I` W\SSPUN [OL PUULY
KVVYOHUKSL!
7\SS PUULY KVVY OHUKSL VUJL [V \USVJR KVVY
SVJR
7\SSPUULYKVVYOHUKSLHNHPU[VVWLUKVVY
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
¢s
¤ph"a4=ppdp4camV
@V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY JHU WYVNYHT
KP]LYZL [`WLZ VM H\[VTH[PJ KVVY SVJRPUN PU [OL
JVU[YVS\UP[VM[OLJLU[YHSSVJRPUNZ`Z[LT!
;`WL
+VVYZ SVJR H\[VTH[PJHSS` ^OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ
Z^P[JOLKVU
;`WL
+VVYZSVJRH\[VTH[PJHSS`^OLUHZWLLKVMÌ
RTOÌTWOPZL_JLLKLK
;`WL
+VVYZ SVJR H\[VTH[PJHSS` ^OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ
Z^P[JOLK VU 0M KVVYZ HYL VWLULK ^P[O [OL LUÌ
NPULY\UUPUN[OL`SVJRHNHPUH\[VTH[PJHSS`^OLU
H ZWLLK VM Ì RTO Ì TWO PZ L_Ì
JLLKLK
;`WL
;OLKVVYZKVUV[SVJRH\[VTH[PJHSS`
5V[L
(\[VTH[PJHSS`SVJRLKKVVYZJHUIL\USVJRLK^P[O
[OL JLU[YHS SVJRPUN I\[[VU VY VWLULK I` W\SSPUN
VU[OLPUZPKLKVVYOHUKSL[^PJL
>HYUPUN
0U HU LTLYNLUJ` ZP[\H[PVU ^OLYL `V\ ULLK
[V L_P[ [OL JHY [OYV\NO HU H\[VTH[PJHSS`
SVJRLK KVVY YLTLTILY [OL MVSSV^PUN WYVÍ
JLK\YL[VVWLU[OLKVVY
<USVJR[OLKVVYZI`WYLZZPUN[OLJLU[YHSSVJRÌ
PUNI\[[VUVY
W\SS [OL PUZPKL KVVY OHUKSL[^PJL[VVWLU[OL
KVVY
"¤dam=a4"apm
(KV\ISLOVYUZPNUHSK\YPUNSVJRPUNPUKPJH[LZH
KLMLJ[PU[OLJLU[YHSSVJRPUNVYHSHYTZ`Z[LT
/H]L [OL KLMLJ[ YLTLKPLK H[ HU H\[OVYPaLK
7VYZJOLKLHSLY
¦Fdp"=zpF4apm
0M [OL JLU[YHS SVJRP UN Z`Z[LT P Z VWLYH[LK TVYL
[OHU[LU[PTLZ^P[OPUHTPU\[LM\Y[OLYVWLYH[PVU
PZISVJRLKMVYZLJVUKZ
(Í3PNO[ÍLTP[[PUNKPVKLMVYHSHYTZ`Z[LT
)Í:LUZVYTVK\SLMVYPUMYHYLKWHZZLUNLYJVTWHY[TLU[
TVUP[VYPUNZ`Z[LT
d"h©Fh:
mO"F="FmVFphz"hFm
pmapamV
;OL HSHYT Z`Z[LT HUK PUMYHYLK WHZZLUNLY JVTÌ
WHY[TLU[ TVUP[VYPUN Z`Z[LT HYL Z^P[JOLK VU
^OLU [OL KVVYZ HYL SVJRLK ^P[O [OL RL` VY
YLTV[LJVU[YVS
:LL[OLJOHW[LYVUs*LU[YHSSVJRPUNr
¢¢
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
<USVJRPUN [OL ]LOPJSL I` \ZPUN [OL RL` PU
[OL KVVY SVJR HUK VWLUPUN [OL KVVY TH`
HJ[P]H[L [OL HSHYT Z`Z[LT ^P[OPU ZLJÍ
VUKZ
¤m4apmam=a4"apm
0M [OL HSHYT Z`Z[LT PZ HJ[P]H[LK SPNO[ÌLTP[[PUN
KPVKL(VU[OLKHZOIVHYKMSHZOLZ
0MHM[LYSVJRPUN[OLSPNO[ÌLTP[[PUNKPVKLKVLZUV[
MSHZO VY HM[LY [LU ZLJVUKZ P[ LTP[Z KV\ISL
MSHZOLZ[OLUUV[HSSHSHYTJVU[HJ[ZHYLJSVZLK
(KKP[PVUHSS`HIYPLMOVYUZPNUHSZV\UKZ
>OLU[OLKVVYZHYL\USVJRLK[OLHSHYTZ`Z[LT
HUKPUMYHYLKWHZZLUNLYJVTWHY[TLU[TVUP[VYPUN
Z`Z[LT HYL Z^P[JOLK VMM HUK [OL SPNO[ÌLTP[[PUN
KPVKLNVLZVMM
^Fm^F"d"ha"hF=:^FOpddp§amV
"F""FhpmapF=
+VVYZ
3\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[SPK
,UNPULJVTWHY[TLU[SPK
9HKPV
.SV]LJVTWHY[TLU[
:[VYHNL[YH`IL[^LLU[OLMYVU[ZLH[Z
7HZZLUNLYJVTWHY[TLU[
0MVULVM[OLZLHSHYTJVU[HJ[ZPZPU[LYY\W[LK[OL
HSHYTOVYUZV\UKZMVYHWWYV_PTH[LS`TPU\[LZ
(KKP[PVUHSS` [OL LTLYNLUJ` MSHZOLY HUK [OLWHZÌ
ZLUNLY JVTWHY[TLU[ SPNO[ MSHZO MVY HWWYV_PÌ
TH[LS`MP]LTPU\[LZ
>OLU [OL HSHYT PZ [YPNNLYLK [OL SPNO[ÌLTP[[PUN
KPVKLJOHUNLZV]LY[VKV\ISLMSHZOLZ
0UVYKLYUV[[VSPTP[[OLHJ[PVUYHUNLVM[OLPUMYHÌ
YLKWHZZLUNLYJVTWHY[TLU[TVUP[VYPUNZ`Z[LT!
4V]LZ\U]PZVYZ[VVULVM[OLMPUHSWVZP[PVUZ
+VUV[MVSK[OLMYVU[ZLH[IHJRYLZ[ZMVY^HYK
F"4a¦"amV^FamO"F=z"FmVF
4phz"hFmhpmapamV©FhOp
pmFdp4camVzp4F
0M H WLYZVUVYHUPTHSYLTHPUZPU[OLJHY^OPSLP[
PZ SVJRLK [OL PUMYHYLK WHZZLUNLY JVTWHY[TLU[
TVUP[VYPUNZ`Z[LTT\Z[ILZ^P[JOLKVMM
8\PJRS`SVJRJHY[^PJL
;OL KVVYZ HYL SVJRLK I\[ JHU IL VWLULK
MYVT[OLPUZPKL!
7\SS PUULY KVVY OHUKSL VUJL [V \USVJR KVVY
SVJR
7\SSPUULYKVVYOHUKSLHNHPU[VVWLUKVVY
5V[L
0UMVYT HU` WLYZVU YLTHPUPUN PU [OL JHY [OH[ [OL
HSHYTZ`Z[LT^PSSIL[YPNNLYLKPM[OLKVVYPZVWÌ
LULK
"¤dam=a4"apm
(KV\ISLOVYUZPNUHSK\YPUNSVJRPUNPUKPJH[LZH
KLMLJ[PU[OLJLU[YHSSVJRPUNVYHSHYTZ`Z[LT
/H]L [OL KLMLJ[ YLTLKPLK H[ HU H\[OVYPaLK
7VYZJOLKLHSLY
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
¢
p§Fam=p§
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMHUHJJPKLU[
+V UV[ W\[ HU`[OPUN VU VY ULHY [OL ^PUKV^Z
[OH[TH`PU[LYMLYL^P[O[OLKYP]LYqZ]PZPVU
9PZRVMPUQ\Y`^OLU[OLKVVY^PUKV^ZJSVZL
;OPZ HWWSPLZ LZWLJPHSS` PM [OL ^PUKV^Z HYL
JSVZLK ^P[O [OL JVTMVY[ M\UJ[PVU ILJH\ZL
^P[O[OPZM\UJ[PVU[OL^PUKV^NVLZ\WH\[VÍ
TH[PJHSS`
4HRL Z\YL UVIVK` JHU IL PUQ\YLK ^OLU [OL
^PUKV^ZJSVZL
9LTV]L [OL PNUP[PVU RL` [V ZO\[ VMM WV^LY [V
[OL ^PUKV^ Z^P[JOLZ ^OLU [OL ]LOPJSL PZ UV[
H[[LUKLKI`HYLZWVUZPISLWLYZVU
F"=amFOppzF"apmpOzp§F
§am=p§
>P[OLUNPULY\UUPUNVY
PUPNUP[PVURL`WVZP[PVUVY
^P[O KVVY JSVZLK HUK PNUP[PVU RL` ^P[OKYH^U!
VUS`\U[PSMPYZ[VWLUPUNVM[OLKVVY
zFmamV§am=p§
6WLUPUN^P[O[OLYVJRLYZ^P[JO
PU[OLJLU[LYJVUZVSL
7YLZZ YVJRLY Z^P[JO ( \U[PS [OL ^PUKV^ OHZ
YLHJOLK[OLKLZPYLKWVZP[PVU
6ULÍ[V\JOVWLYH[PVU!
7YLZZYVJRLYZ^P[JO(IYPLMS`
>PUKV^TV]LZ[VP[ZMPUHSWVZP[PVU
7YLZZHNHPU[VZ[VW[OL^PUKV^PU[OLKLZPYLK
WVZP[PVU
*VTMVY[M\UJ[PVU^OLU\USVJRPUN
[OL]LOPJSL
<USVJRJHY^P[O[OLYLTV[LJVU[YVS
/VSK JHY RL` PU KVVY SVJR PU [OL \USVJRPUN KPÌ
YLJ[PVU \U[PS [OL ^PUKV^Z OH]L YLHJOLK [OL
KLZPYLKWVZP[PVU
¢T
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
dpamV§am=p§
*SVZPUN^P[O[OLYVJRLYZ^P[JO
PU[OLJLU[LYJVUZVSL
7YLZZ YVJRLY Z^P[JO ( \U[PS [OL ^PUKV^ OHZ
YLHJOLK[OLKLZPYLKWVZP[PVU
6ULÍ[V\JOVWLYH[PVU!
7YLZZYVJRLYZ^P[JO(IYPLMS`
>PUKV^TV]LZ[VP[ZMPUHSWVZP[PVU
7YLZZHNHPU[VZ[VW[OL^PUKV^PU[OLKLZPYLK
WVZP[PVU
*VTMVY[M\UJ[PVU^OLUSVJRPUN[OL]LOPJSL
H[[OLKVVYSVJR
/VSKJHYRL`PUKVVYSVJRPU[OLSVJRPUNKPYLJÌ
[PVU \U[PS [OL ^PUKV^Z OH]L YLHJOLK [OL
KLZPYLKWVZP[PVU
ma_4¤^amVzpF4apm
0MHZPKL^PUKV^PZISVJRLKK\YPUNJSVZPUNP[^PSS
Z[VWHUKVWLUHNHPUI`HIV\[HUPUJO
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMZL]LYLWLYZVUHSPUQ\YPLZ
0M [OL YVJRLY Z^P[JO PZ WYLZZLK HNHPU ^P[OPU
ZLJVUKZ VM [OL ^PUKV^ ILPUN ISVJRLK
[OL ^PUKV^ ^PSS JSVZL ^P[O P[Z M\SS JSVZPUN
MVYJL(U[PÍJY\ZOPUNWYV[LJ[PVUPZKPZHISLK
6UJL[OLHU[PÌJY\ZOPUNWYV[LJ[PVUHJ[Z[VZ[VW
[OL^PUKV^HUKVWLUZP[ZSPNO[S`KVUV[WYLZZ
[OL YVJRLY Z^P[JO HNHPU ^P[OPU ZLJVUKZ
^P[OV\[JOLJRPUN[VTHRLZ\YL[OH[UV[OPUNPZ
ISVJRPUN[OLWH[OVM[OL^PUKV^
;OL^PUKV^^PSSJSVZL^P[OM\SSJSVZPUNMVYJL
6ULÌ[V\JO VWLYH[PVU PZ KPZHISLK MVY ZLJVUKZ
HM[LYISVJRHNLVMHZPKL^PUKV^
¤ph"a4§am=p§dp§FamV
:LL[OLJOHW[LYVUs+VVYZr
^F"m=*©O¤m4apmpO^Fzp§F
§am=p§§a4^FpOO"OF§p^p¤
>OLU [OL JHY PZ \USVJRLK [OL WV^LY ^PUKV^Z
JHU UV SVUNLY IL VWLYH[LK HM[LY [^V OV\YZ [V
ZH]L[OLJHYIH[[LY`
:^P[JO VU [OL PNUP[PVU VY Z[HY[ [OL LUNPUL [V
YLHJ[P]H[L[OLWV^LY^PUKV^Z
pamVFm=zpaapmpO^F§am=p§
0M [OL IH[[LY` PZ KPZJVUULJ[LK HUK YLJVUULJ[LK
[OL ^PUKV^Z ^PSS UV[ IL YHPZLK H\[VTH[PJHSS`
^OLU[OLKVVYPZJSVZLK
*SVZL [OL ^PUKV^Z ^P[O [OL YVJRLY Z^P[JO
VUJL
7YLZZ MYVU[ OHSM VM YVJRLY Z^P[JO HNHPU [V
Z[VYL [OL LUK WVZP[PVU VM [OL ^PUKV^Z PU [OL
JVU[YVS\UP[
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
¢Q
(Í:LSLJ[VYZ^P[JOKYP]LYqZWHZZLUNLYqZZPKL
)Í4PYYVYHKQ\Z[TLU[
F"aF§ap
)LMVYLKYP]PUN[OL]LOPJSLHKQ\Z[[OLV\[ZPKLHUK
PUZPKLTPYYVYZ
0[ PZ PTWVY[HU[ MVY ZHML KYP]PUN [OH[ `V\ OH]L
NVVK]PZPVU[V[OLYLHY
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMHUHJJPKLU[
+V UV[ W\[ HU`[OPUN VU VY ULHY [OL ^PUKV^Z
VY [OL TPYYVYZ [OH[ TH` PU[LYMLYL ^P[O [OL
KYP]LYqZ]PZPVU
pphap
;OL TPYYVY OV\ZPUN PZ OPUNLK HUK JHU IL MVSKLK
MSH[ HNHPUZ[ [OL JHY [V WYL]LU[ KHTHNL PU [OL
[PNO[WHYRPUNHYLHZ
(KQ\Z[PUN
:LSLJ[ KYP]LYqZ ZPKL VY WHZZLUNLYqZ ZPKL ^P[O
YVJRLYZ^P[JO(
4V]L[OLKVVYTPYYVYNSHZZLZPU[OLHWWYVWYPÌ
H[LKPYLJ[PVU\ZPUN[OLJVU[YVSZ^P[JO)
0M[OLLSLJ[YPJHSHKQ\Z[TLU[MHJPSP[`MHPSZ
(KQ\Z[TPYYVYI`WYLZZPUNVU[OLTPYYVYMHJL
(\[VTH[PJHSS`Z^P]LSSPUNKV^UTPYYVYNSHZZ
VU[OLWHZZLUNLYqZZPKL
:LL [OL JOHW[LY VU r7HYRPUN HPKZs HUK s:LH[
TLTVY`r
(Í:LUZVY
)Í:^P[JOMVYH\[VTH[PJHU[PÍNSHYLVWLYH[PVU
*Í3PNO[ÍLTP[[PUNKPVKL
¤ph"a4ma_ d"FmFap
ap"m=a¦Fppap
:LUZVYZ VU [OL MYVU[ HUK YLHY ZPKLZ VM [OL PU[LÌ
YPVYTPYYVYTLHZ\YL[OLPUJPKLU[SPNO[
;OL TPYYVYZ H\[VTH[PJHSS` JOHUNL [V HU[PÌNSHYL
WVZP[PVU VY YL]LY[ [V [OLPY UVYTHS Z[H[L KLWLUKÌ
PUNVU[OLSPNO[PU[LUZP[`
>OLU YL]LYZL NLHY PZ ZLSLJ[LK H\[VTH[PJ HU[PÌ
NSHYLVWLYH[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVMM
¢
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
5V[L
;OL PUJPKLU[ SPNO[ PU [OL HYLH VM [OL ZLUZVYZ
T\Z[ UV[ IL YLZ[YPJ[LK LN I` Z[PJRLYZ VU [OL
^PUKZJYLLU
:^P[JOPUNVMM[OLH\[VTH[PJHU[PÍNSHYL
VWLYH[PVU
7YLZZZ^P[JO)
3PNO[ÌLTP[[PUNKPVKL*NVLZV\[
:^P[JOPUNVU[OLH\[VTH[PJHU[PÍNSHYL
VWLYH[PVU
7YLZZZ^P[JO)
3PNO[ÌLTP[[PUNKPVKL*SPNO[Z\W
>HYUPUN
9PZR VM PUQ\Y` ,SLJ[YVS`[L MS\PK JHU LTLYNL
MYVTHIYVRLUTPYYVYNSHZZ
;OPZMS\PKPYYP[H[LZ[OLZRPUHUKL`LZ
0M [OL LSLJ[YVS`[L MS\PK ZOV\SK JVTL PU[V JVUÌ
[HJ[^P[O[OLL`LZVYZRPUPTTLKPH[LS`YPUZLP[
VMM^P[OJSLHU^H[LY
:LLHKVJ[VYPMULJLZZHY`
9PZR VM KHTHNL [V [OL WHPU[^VYR HUK WSHZÍ
[PJ WHY[Z ,SLJ[YVS`[L MS\PK JHU IL YLTV]LK
VUS`^OPSLP[PZZ[PSS^L[
*SLHU[OLHMMLJ[LKWHY[Z^P[O^H[LY
F"am=p§FOpVVF:
ppapF"amV
;OL TPYYVY OLH[LY PZ YLHK` MVY VWLYH[PVU ^OLU
[OLPNUP[PVUPZVU
:^P[JOPUNVU
7YLZZ[OLYVJRLYÌZ^P[JOZ`TIVS
0UKPJH[VYSPNO[PZSP[
(M[LY HIV\[ TPU\[LZ [OL OLH[LY Z^P[JOLZ VMM
H\[VTH[PJHSS`
;OLOLH[LYJHUILZ^P[JOLKIHJRVUHNHPUI`H
M\Y[OLYWYLZZVU[OLZ^P[JO
:^P[JOPUNVMM
7YLZZ[OLPUKPJH[VYSPNO[PU[OLYVJRLYZ^P[JO
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
¢
F"=b¤hFm
>HYUPUN
:HML[` ILS[Z VUS` VMMLY WYV[LJ[PVU ^OLU [OL
IHJRYLZ[ PZ \WYPNO[ HUK [OL ILS[Z HYL
WYVWLYS`WVZP[PVULKVU[OLIVK`
0TWYVWLYS` WVZP[PVULK ZHML[` ILS[Z JHU
JH\ZL ZLYPV\Z WLYZVUHS PUQ\Y` PU HU HJJPÍ
KLU[
+VUV[VWLYH[L[OLJHY^P[O[OLKYP]LYVYWHZÌ
ZLUNLY IHJRYLZ[Z L_JLZZP]LS` YLJSPULK ZLL
s:LH[WVZP[PVUr
;OLZLH[TH`TV]L\UL_WLJ[LKS`PM`V\H[Í
[LTW[ [V HKQ\Z[ ^OPSL KYP]PUN ;OPZ JV\SK
JH\ZLZ\KKLUSVZZVMJVU[YVSVYWLYZVUHSPUÍ
Q\Y`
+VUV[HKQ\Z[ZLH[Z^OPSL[OL]LOPJSLPZPUTVÌ
[PVU
;OL IHJRYLZ[ SVJRZ T\Z[ IL LUNHNLK H[ HSS
[PTLZ^OPSL[OL]LOPJSLPZPUTV[PVU
F"zpaapm
( JVYYLJ[ ZP[[PUN WVZP[PVU PZ PTWVY[HU[ MVY ZHML
HUKMH[PN\LÌMYLLKYP]PUN
>L YLJVTTLUK [OL MVSSV^PUN WYVJLK\YL MVY
HKQ\Z[PUN [OL KYP]LYqZ ZLH[ [V Z\P[ PUKP]PK\HS
YLX\PYLTLU[Z!
(KQ\Z[ [OL ZLH[ OLPNO[ [V NP]L `V\YZLSM
LUV\NO OLHKYVVT HUK H NVVK V]LY]PL^ VM
[OL]LOPJSL
(KQ\Z[ [OL ZLH[ \U[PS ^P[O [OL HJJLSLYH[VY
WLKHSM\SS`KLWYLZZLK`V\YSLNPZZ[YHPNO[I\[
`V\Y LU[PYL MVV[ Z[PSS YLZ[Z VU [OL HJJLSLYH[VY
WLKHS
.YPW[OL[VWOHSMVM[OLZ[LLYPUN^OLLS
:L[ [OL IHJRYLZ[ HUNSL HUK Z[LLYPUNÌ^OLLS
WVZP[PVU ZV [OH[ `V\Y HYTZ HYL HSTVZ[
V\[Z[YL[JOLK /V^L]LY `V\Y ZOV\SKLYZ T\Z[
Z[PSSYLZ[VU[OLIHJRYLZ[
0M ULJLZZHY` JVYYLJ[ [OL ZLH[ MVYLÌHUKÌHM[
HKQ\Z[TLU[
dF4a4"dd©"=b¤"*dFF"
7YLZZ [OL Z^P[JO PU [OL KPYLJ[PVU PUKPJH[LK I`
[OL HYYV^Z \U[PS [OL KLZPYLK ZLH[ WVZP[PVU PZ
YLHJOLK
(Í:LH[OLPNO[HKQ\Z[TLU[
)Í-VYLÍHUKÍHM[HKQ\Z[TLU[
*Í:LH[HUNSLHKQ\Z[TLU[
+Í)HJRYLZ[HUNSLHKQ\Z[TLU[
¢G
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
,Í3\TIHYZ\WWVY[
WLS]PZHUKZWPUHSJVS\TUZ\WWVY[
;VWLYTP[HYLSH_LKZP[[PUNWVZ[\YL[OLIHJRYLZ[
J\Y]H[\YL PZ Z[LWSLZZS` HKQ\Z[HISL PU ]LY[PJHS HUK
OVYPaVU[HS KPYLJ[PVUZ MVY PUKP]PK\HS WLS]PZ HUK
ZWPUHSJVS\TUZ\WWVY[
7YLZZ [OL Z^P[JO PU [OL KPYLJ[PVU PUKPJH[LK I`
[OL HYYV^Z \U[PS [OL KLZPYLK IHJRYLZ[ J\Y]HÌ
[\YLPZYLHJOLK
F"*"4cF
-VSKPUNMVY^HYK
7\SS\WSL]LY-PU[OLZPKLWHY[VM[OLIHJRYLZ[
HUKMVSK[OLIHJRYLZ[MVY^HYK
-VSKPUNIHJR
;PS[ IHJR HUK LUNHNL [OL IHJRYLZ[ ZV [OH[ P[
JHUUV[[PWMVY^HYK^OLU[OLJHYPZIYHRLK
zpF"(
(Í:LH[OLPNO[HKQ\Z[TLU[
9HPZLSVJRPUNSL]LY
:L[ [OL KLZPYLK ZLH[ OLPNO[ I` ZOPM[PUN `V\Y
IVK`^LPNO[
9LSLHZL[OLSL]LY
)Í-VYLHUKHM[
9HPZLSVJRPUNSL]LY
4V]L ZLH[ [V KLZPYLK WVZP[PVU HUK YLSLHZL
SL]LY
,UZ\YL[OH[[OLZLH[LUNHNLZJVYYLJ[S`
*Í)HJRYLZ[HUNSL
6WLYH[L Z^P[JO \U[PS [OL KLZPYLK IHJRYLZ[
HUNSLPZYLHJOLK
F"*"4cF
-VSKPUNMVY^HYK
7\SS \W SL]LY + PU [OL ZPKL WHY[ VM [OL IHJRÌ
YLZ[HUKMVSK[OLIHJRYLZ[MVY^HYK
-VSKPUNIHJR
;PS[ IHJR HUK LUNHNL [OL IHJRYLZ[ ZV [OH[ P[
JHUUV[[PWMVY^HYK^OLU[OLJHYPZIYHRLK
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
¢n
F"Fhp©
0UKP]PK\HS ZLH[ HUK KVVY TPYYVY ZL[[PUNZ JHU IL
Z[VYLKHUKYLJHSSLKMVY[OLKYP]LYqZWVZP[PVU
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMJY\ZOPUN
+\L [V YPZR VM JY\ZOPUN MYVT \UJVU[YVSSLK YLÌ
JHSSPUN [OL TLTVY` VM H ZLH[ ZL[[PUN KV UV[
SLH]LJOPSKYLUPU[OLJHY\UH[[LUKLK
zF"apm§a^zFpm*¤pms:¢
:[VYPUNZLH[WVZP[PVU
:^P[JOPNUP[PVUVU
:L[ [OL KLZPYLK ZLH[ HUK KVVYÌTPYYVY WVZP[Ì
PVUZ
0M`V\^PZOMVY[OLWHZZLUNLYqZTPYYVY[VZ^PÌ
]LS KV^U HZ H WHYRPUN HPK ^OLU YL]LYZPUN
YL]LYZL NLHY T\Z[ IL LUNHNLK ^OLU [OL
ZLH[WVZP[PVUPZZ[VYLK
2LLW TLTVY`I\[[VU4KLWYLZZLKHUKHKKPÌ
[PVUHSS`WYLZZVULVM[OLWLYZVUI\[[VUZVY
;OLPUKP]PK\HSZL[[PUNPZUV^Z[VYLK\UKLY[OL
KLZPYLKWLYZVUI\[[VU
9LJHSSPUNZLH[WVZP[PVU
:^P[JO[OLPNUP[PVUVUVY
VWLU[OLKYP]LYqZKVVY
7YLZZ WLYZVU I\[[VU \U[PS [OL ZLH[ OHZ
YLHJOLKP[ZMPUHSWVZP[PVU
;OL TPYYVY ZL[[PUN ^PSS IL JVTWSL[LK L]LU PM
[OLWLYZVUI\[[VUPZUV[RLW[KLWYLZZLK
5V[L
(\[VTH[PJ ZLH[ HKQ\Z[TLU[ JHU IL PU[LYY\W[LK
PTTLKPH[LS`I`YLSLHZPUN[OLI\[[VU
¬
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
zF"amV§a^^FFhpF4pmpdpO
^F¦F^a4dFcF©
,HJO YLTV[L JVU[YVS \W [V MV\Y JHU IL
HZZPNULK HU PUKP]PK\HS ZLH[ HUK KVVY TPYYVY
WVZP[PVU
;OL Z[VYLK ZLH[ HUK KVVY TPYYVY WVZP[PVU PZ ZL[
H\[VTH[PJHSS`^OLU[OL]LOPJSLPZ\USVJRLK\ZPUN
[OLJVYYLZWVUKPUNYLTV[LJVU[YVS
,HJORL`PZPKLU[PMPLK^P[OHKPMMLYLU[JVSV\Y
:[VYPUNZLH[WVZP[PVU
:^P[JO[OLPNUP[PVUVU^P[O[OLKLZPYLK]LOPJSL
RL`
:L[ [OL KLZPYLK ZLH[ HUK KVVYÌTPYYVY WVZP[Ì
PVUZ
0M`V\^PZOMVY[OLWHZZLUNLYqZTPYYVY[VZ^PÌ
]LS KV^U HZ H WHYRPUN HPK ^OLU YL]LYZPUN
YL]LYZL NLHY T\Z[ IL LUNHNLK ^OLU [OL
ZLH[WVZP[PVUPZZ[VYLK
2LLW TLTVY`I\[[VU4KLWYLZZLKHUKHKKPÌ
[PVUHSS` WYLZZ [OL I\[[VU ILZPKL [OL
TLTVY`I\[[VU
;OL PUKP]PK\HS ZL[[PUN PZ UV^ HZZPNULK [V[OPZ
YLTV[LJVU[YVSHUK[V[OL I\[[VU
9LJHSSPUNZLH[WVZP[PVU
<USVJR [OL SVJRLK ]LOPJSL VY S\NNHNL JVTÌ
WHY[TLU[^P[O[OLYLTV[LJVU[YVS
;OLZ[VYLKZLH[WVZP[PVUPZZL[H\[VTH[PJHSS`
;OL ZLH[ WVZP[PVU HZZPNULK [V H YLTV[L JVU[YVS
JHUHSZVILYLJHSSLK^P[O[OL I\[[VUPM[OL
JVYYLZWVUKPUN RL` ^HZ \ZLK [V \USVJR [OL ]LÌ
OPJSLVY[VZ^P[JOVU[OLPNUP[PVU
0M UV ZLH[ WVZP[PVU ^HZ HZZPNULK [V H YLTV[L
JVU[YVS[OL I\[[VU^PSSUV[^VYR
5V[L
(\[VTH[PJ ZLH[ HKQ\Z[TLU[ JHU IL PU[LYY\W[LK
PTTLKPH[LS` I` WYLZZPUN [OL JLU[YHS SVJRPUN I\[Ì
[VUVYHU`TLTVY`VYZLH[HKQ\Z[TLU[I\[[VU
*SLHYPUN[OLZ[VYLKZLH[WVZP[PVU
:^P[JO[OLPNUP[PVUVU^P[O[OLKLZPYLK]LOPJSL
RL`
:PT\S[HULV\ZS`WYLZZHUKOVSK[OL I\[Ì
[VU HUK WLYZVU I\[[VU MVY H[ SLHZ[ ZLJÌ
VUKZ
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
s
(Í:LH[OLH[PUNSLM[
)Í:LH[OLH[PUNYPNO[
F"F=F"
;OL ZLH[ OLH[PUN ^P[O [^V OLH[PUN Z[HNLZ PZ
YLHK`MVYVWLYH[PVU^OLU[OLPNUP[PVUPZVU
§a4^amVpm
/PNOOLH[PUNWV^LY
7YLZZ[OLYVJRLYÌZ^P[JOZ`TIVS
0UKPJH[VYSPNO[NSV^ZYLK
3V^OLH[PUNWV^LY
7YLZZ[OLYVJRLYÌZ^P[JOZ`TIVSHNHPU
0UKPJH[VYSPNO[NSV^ZVYHUNL
;OLOLH[PUNWV^LYJOHUNLZ^OLUL]LY[OLYVJRLY
Z^P[JOPZVWLYH[LK
§a4^amVpOO
7YLZZ[OLPUKPJH[VYSPNO[PU[OLYVJRLYZ^P[JO
¢
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
F"F""4cF
,_[YH Z[VYHNL ZWHJL PZ NHPULK I` MVSKPUN [OL
YLHYZLH[IHJRYLZ[MVY^HYK
-VSKPUNIHJRYLZ[MVY^HYK
7\SS SL]LY ( MVY^HYK HUK MVSK [OL IHJRYLZ[
KV^U
-VSKPUNIHJRYLZ[IHJR
;PS[[OLIHJRYLZ[IHJR\U[PSP[JSPJRZPU[VWSHJL
>OLUKVPUN[OPZWH`H[[LU[PVU[V[OLZLH[ILS[
N\PKLMPN\YL
FFamV^FFd=b¤hFm
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMHJJPKLU[
;OL Z[LLYPUN ^OLLS TH` TV]L M\Y[OLY [OHU
KLZPYLK PM `V\ H[[LTW[ [V HKQ\Z[ P[ ^OPSL
KYP]PUN
@V\TH`SVZLJVU[YVSVM[OL]LOPJSL
+VUV[HKQ\Z[[OLZ[LLYPUN^OLLS^OPSLKYP]PUN
pmVa¤=am"d"=b¤hFm
7\ZOSVJRPUNSL]LYKV^U^HYKZ
(KQ\Z[ Z[LLYPUN ^OLLS [V MP[ [OL JOVZLU IHJRÌ
YLZ[ HUNSL HUK ZLH[ WVZP[PVU I` TV]PUN [OL
Z[LLYPUN^OLLSSVUNP[\KPUHSS`
:^P]LSSVJRPUNSL]LYIHJR\U[PS`V\MLLSP[
LUNHNL
0MULJLZZHY`TV]LZ[LLYPUN^OLLSZSPNO[S`SVUÌ
NP[\KPUHSS`[VLUZ\YLLUNHNLTLU[
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
"OF©Fd
>HYUPUN
(S^H`Z THRL Z\YL `V\Y HUK `V\Y WHZZLUÍ
NLYZq ZHML[` ILS[Z HYL WYVWLYS` MHZ[LULK
^OPSL[OL]LOPJSLPZPUTV[PVU
-HPS\YL [V MVSSV^ ZHML[` ILS[ ^HYUPUNZ TH`
YLZ\S[PUZLYPV\ZWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`
-VY`V\YHUK`V\YWHZZLUNLYZqWYV[LJ[PVU\ZL
ZHML[`ILS[ZH[HSS[PTLZ^OPSL[OL]LOPJSLPZPU
TV[PVU
<ZLHWWYVWYPH[LJOPSKYLZ[YHPU[Z`Z[LTZMVYHSS
ZTHSSJOPSKYLU
7YVWLY^LHYPUNVMZHML[`ILS[Z
:HML[` ILS[Z T\Z[ IL WVZP[PVULK VU [OL IVK`
HZ [V YLZ[YHPU [OL \WWLY IVK` HUK SHW MYVT
ZSPKPUN MVY^HYK 0TWYVWLYS` WVZP[PVULK ZHML[`
ILS[Z JHU JH\ZL ZLYPV\Z WLYZVUHS PUQ\Y` PU
JHZLVMHUHJJPKLU[
;OL ZOV\SKLY ILS[ ZOV\SK HS^H`Z YLZ[ VU `V\Y
\WWLY IVK` ;OL ZOV\SKLY ILS[ ZOV\SK UL]LY
IL^VYUILOPUK`V\YIHJRVY\UKLY`V\YHYT
-VY TH_PT\T LMMLJ[P]LULZZ [OL SHW ILS[
ZOV\SKIL^VYUSV^HJYVZZ[OLOPWZ
7YLNUHU[ ^VTLU ZOV\SK WVZP[PVU [OL ILS[ HZ
SV^ HZ WVZZPISL HJYVZZ [OL WLS]PZ 4HRL Z\YL
P[PZUV[WYLZZPUNHNHPUZ[[OLHIKVTLU
)LS[ZZOV\SKUV[IL^VYU[^PZ[LK
+VUV[^LHYILS[ZV]LYYPNPKVYIYLHRHISLVIÌ
QLJ[Z PU VY VU `V\Y JSV[OPUN Z\JO HZ L`L
NSHZZLZWLUZRL`ZL[JHZ[OLZLTH`JH\ZL
PUQ\Y`
:L]LYHSSH`LYZVMOLH]`JSV[OPUNTH`PU[LYMLYL
^P[OWYVWLYWVZP[PVUPUNVMILS[Z
)LS[Z T\Z[ UV[ Y\I HNHPUZ[ ZOHYW VIQLJ[Z VY
KHTHNLTH`VJJ\Y[V[OLILS[
;^V VJJ\WHU[Z ZOV\SK UL]LY ZOHYL [OL ZHTL
ILS[H[[OLZHTL[PTL
*HYLHUKTHPU[LUHUJL
2LLWILS[I\JRSLZMYLLVMHU`VIZ[Y\J[PVU[OH[
TH`WYL]LU[HZLJ\YLSVJRPUN
)LS[Z [OH[ OH]L ILLU Z\IQLJ[LK [V L_JLZZP]L
Z[YL[JO MVYJLZ PU HU HJJPKLU[ T\Z[ IL PUÌ
ZWLJ[LKVYYLWSHJLK[VLUZ\YL[OLPYJVU[PU\LK
LMMLJ[P]LULZZPUYLZ[YHPUPUN`V\
;OL ZHTL HWWSPLZ [V ILS[ [LUZPVULY Z`Z[LTZ
^OPJOOH]LILLU[YPNNLYLK
0U HKKP[PVU [OL HUJOVY WVPU[Z VM [OL ILS[Z
ZOV\SKILJOLJRLK
0MZHML[`ILS[ZKVUV[^VYRWYVWLYS`ZLL`V\Y
H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLYPTTLKPH[LS`
0M [OL ILS[Z ZOV^ KHTHNL [V ^LIIPUN IPUKÌ
PUNZI\JRSLZVYYL[YHJ[VYZ[OL`ZOV\SKILYLÌ
WSHJLK[VLUZ\YLZHMLVWLYH[PVU
+VUV[TVKPM`VYKPZHZZLTISL[OLZHML[`ILS[Z
PU`V\Y]LOPJSL
;OL ILS[Z T\Z[ IL RLW[ JSLHU VY [OL YL[YHJÌ
[VYZ TH` UV[ ^VYR WYVWLYS` ZLL HSZV s*HY
JHYLPUZ[Y\J[PVUZr
5L]LYISLHJOVYK`LZHML[`ILS[Z
+V UV[ HSSV^ ZHML[` ILS[Z [V YL[YHJ[ \U[PS [OL`
HYL JVTWSL[LS` KY` HM[LY JSLHUPUN VY [OPZ TH`
JH\ZLKHTHNL[V[OLILS[
FdFmapmF
+LWLUKPUN VU [OL MVYJL VM H JVSSPZPVU MHZ[LULK
MYVU[ZLH[ILS[ZHYL[PNO[LULKPUHUHJJPKLU[
;OLILS[[LUZPVULYZHYL[YPNNLYLKPU!
-YVU[HUKYLHYPTWHJ[Z
;OLILS[[LUZPVULYZHYLUV[[YPNNLYLKPU!
:PKLPTWHJ[Z
=LOPJSLV]LY[\YUPUN
5V[L
;OLILS[[LUZPVULYZ`Z[LTJHUIL[YPNNLYLKVUS`
VUJL"[OLZ`Z[LTT\Z[ILYLWSHJLKHM[LY^HYK
>VYR TH` IL WLYMVYTLK VU [OL ILS[Ì[LUZPVULY
Z`Z[LTVUS`I`HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
:TVRL PZ YLSLHZLK ^OLU [OLILS[[LUZPVULYZHYL
[YPNNLYLK ;OPZ KVLZ UV[ PUKPJH[L H MPYL PU [OL
]LOPJSL
T
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
"OF©Fd"mamV©Fh
(U H\KPVÍ]PZ\HS ^HYUPUN Z`Z[LT PZ PU[LYJVUÌ
ULJ[LK^P[O[OLKYP]LYqZZHML[`ILS[
,]LY` [PTL [OL PNUP[PVU PZ [\YULK VU [OL NVUN
^PSS ZV\UK MVY HIV\[ ZLJVUKZ [V YLTPUK [OL
KYP]LYHUKWHZZLUNLY[VI\JRSL\W
;OL ZHML[` ILS[ ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[
WHULSHUKVUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY^PSSNVVMMHZZVVU
HZ[OLKYP]LYOHZI\JRSLK\W
mFa"FFdF"4p
;OL JVTIPUH[PVU SHWZOV\SKLY ILS[ ^P[O PULY[PH
YLLS SVJRPUN TLJOHUPZT HKQ\Z[Z H\[VTH[PJHSS` [V
`V\YZPaLHUKTV]LTLU[ZHZSVUNHZ[OLW\SSVU
[OLILS[PZZSV^
9HWPKKLJLSLYH[PVUK\YPUNOHYKIYHRPUNVYHJVSSPÌ
ZPVU SVJRZ [OL ILS[ ;OL ILS[ ^PSS HSZV SVJR ^OLU
`V\ KYP]L \W VY KV^U H Z[LLW OPSS VY PU H ZOHYW
J\Y]LV[OLY^PZL[OLZOV\SKLYILS[^PSSUV[PUOPIP[
`V\Y\WWLYIVK`TV]LTLU[
(ZZ\TLHJVTMVY[HISLZP[[PUNWVZP[PVU
;OL ZOV\SKLY ILS[ ZOV\SK HS^H`Z YLZ[ VU `V\Y
\WWLY IVK` ;OL ZOV\SKLY ILS[ ZOV\SK UL]LY
IL^VYUILOPUK`V\YIHJRVY\UKLY`V\YHYT
;V MHZ[LU NYHZW ILS[ HUK W\SS [OL ILS[ PU H
JVU[PU\V\Z ZSV^ TV[PVU HJYVZZ `V\Y JOLZ[
HUKSHW
0UZLY[ILS[[VUN\LPU[VI\JRSLVUPUIVHYKZPKL
VMZLH[7\ZOKV^U\U[PSP[ZLJ\YLS`SVJRZ^P[O
HUH\KPISLJSPJR7\SS[OLILS[[VJOLJR
7\SS ZOV\SKLY ZLJ[PVU [V THRL Z\YL ILS[ MP[Z
ZU\NS`HJYVZZ[OLWLS]PZ
)LS[Z ZOV\SK MP[ ZU\NS` HJYVZZ [OL WLS]PZ HUK
JOLZ[4HRLZ\YL[OLYLPZUVZSHJRPU[OLILS[
;V \UMHZ[LU ILS[ W\ZO PU YLSLHZL I\[[VU
HYYV^ VU I\JRSL )LS[ [VUN\L ^PSS ZWYPUN V\[
VMI\JRSL
;V YLSLHZL H SH[JOLK ILS[ SLHU IHJR [V [HRL
[OLIVK`WYLZZ\YLVMM[OLILS[
;V Z[VYL SHWZOV\SKLY ILS[ HSSV^ [OL ILS[ [V
YL[YHJ[ HZ `V\ N\PKL [OL SH[JO [V P[Z Z[V^LK
WVZP[PVU
7SLHZL UV[L JOHW[LY s(\[VTH[PJ SVJRPUN YL[YHJÌ
[VYr
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
Q
"OF©*Fd^FaV^"=b¤hFm
(KQ\Z[ [OL OLPNO[ VM [OL ZHML[` ILS[ ZV [OH[ P[
Y\UZ HJYVZZ [OL TPKKSL VM [OL ZOV\SKLY UV[
HNHPUZ[[OLULJR
(KQ\Z[PUNILS[OLPNO[
<WuW\ZOILS[KLMSLJ[VY
+V^U u WYLZZ I\[[VU HYYV^ HUK TV]L ILS[
KLMSLJ[VY
¤ph"a4dp4camVF"4p
;OL ZHML[` ILS[Z MVY [OL WHZZLUNLY HUK YLHY
ZLH[ZHYLLX\PWWLK^P[OHUH\[VTH[PJSVJRPUNYLÌ
[YHJ[VYMVYZLJ\YPUN[OLJOPSKYLZ[YHPU[Z`Z[LT
>OLU HJ[P]H[LK [OPZ YL[YHJ[VY HSSV^Z `V\ [V ZLÌ
J\YLS` MHZ[LU [OL JOPSK YLZ[YHPU[ Z`Z[LT PU WSHJL
ZV[OH[PUHK]LY[LU[TV]LTLU[Z^PSSUV[VJJ\Y
(J[P]H[PUN[OLH\[VTH[PJSVJRPUNYL[YHJ[VY
7\SS[OLZHML[`ILS[YL[YHJ[VYJVTWSL[LS`V\[
([ [OPZ WVPU[ [OL SVJRPUN TLJOHUPZT PZ HJ[PÌ
]H[LK
0UZLY[ [OL ZHML[` ILS[ [VUN\L PU[V [OL I\JRSL
HUKTHRLJLY[HPU[OH[P[PZWYVWLYS`SH[JOLK
(SSV^[OLZHML[`ILS[[VYL[YHJ[\U[PSP[PZ[PNO[
VU [OL JOPSK YLZ[YHPU[ Z`Z[LT @V\ TH` M\YÌ
[OLY [PNO[LU [OL ILS[ I` W\SSPUN VU P[ [V HSSV^
TVYLVMP[[VYL[YHJ[
9LSLHZPUN[OLZHML[`ILS[
<UI\JRSL[OLZHML[`ILS[SH[JO
;OLU THRL JLY[HPU [OH[ [OL ILS[ OHZ M\SS` YLÌ
[YHJ[LK
([[OPZWVPU[[OLH\[VTH[PJSVJRPUNMLH[\YL^PSS
ILKPZLUNHNLK
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
^ad=F"amm4^p"VF
7SLHZL UV[L JOHW[LY s(\[VTH[PJ SVJRPUN YL[YHJÌ
[VYr
0M `V\Y JOPSK YLZ[YHPU[ ZLH[ VY ZLH[Z YLX\PYL [OL
\ZL VM H [L[OLY Z[YHW `V\ ^PSS ^HU[ [V \ZL [OL
HUJOVY WVPU[Z WYV]PKLK ILOPUK [OL YLHY ZLH[
IHJRYLZ[Z\UKLY[OLJHYWL[
;V LUZ\YL WYVWLY PUZ[HSSH[PVU ZLL `V\Y H\[OÌ
VYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
;OL [L[OLY Z[YHW JHU IL TV]LK [V [OL V[OLYHUÌ
JOVYWVPU[PMYLX\PYLK
>HYUPUN
*OPSK YLZ[YHPU[ HUJOVYHNLZ HYL KLZPNULK [V
^P[OZ[HUKVUS`[OVZLSVHKZPTWVZLKI`JVYÍ
YLJ[S` MP[[LK JOPSK YLZ[YHPU[Z <UKLY UV JPYÍ
J\TZ[HUJLZ HYL [OL` [V IL \ZLK MVY HK\S[Z
ZHML[` ILS[Z VY OHYULZZLZ :\JO \ZL JV\SK
YLZ\S[PUZLYPV\ZWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`VYKLH[O
+VUV[TPZ\ZL[OLJOPSKYLZ[YHPU[HUJOVYHNLZ
;OL` HYL UV[ KLZPNULK [V ^P[OZ[HUK SVHKZ PTÌ
WVZLKI`HK\S[Z
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
^ad=F"am©Fh
7VYZJOL YLJVTTLUKZ [OH[ HSS PUMHU[Z HUK JOPSKÌ
YLUILYLZ[YHPULKPUJOPSKYLZ[YHPU[Z`Z[LTZH[HSS
[PTLZ ^OPSL [OL ]LOPJSL PZ PU TV[PVU PU HJJVYKÌ
HUJL^P[OHWWSPJHISLSH^Z
;OL \ZL VM PUMHU[ VY JOPSK YLZ[YHPU[Z PZ YLX\PYLK
I` SH^ PU HSS Z[H[LZ HUK [OL *HUHKPHU WYV]Ì
PUJLZ
;OL JOPSK YLZ[YHPU[ Z`Z[LT ZOV\SK IL VUL [OH[
JVTWSPLZ ^P[O <: -LKLYHS*HUHKPHU 4V[VY =LÌ
OPJSL :HML[` :[HUKHYKZ HUK ZOV\SK IL ZLÌ
J\YLK I` H SHW ILS[ VY SHW ILS[ WVY[PVU VM H SHWÌ
ZOV\SKLYILS[
( Z[H[LTLU[ I` [OL ZLH[ THU\MHJ[\YLY VM JVTÌ
WSPHUJL ^P[O [OPZ Z[HUKHYK JHU IL MV\UK VU [OL
PUZ[Y\J[PVU SHILS VU [OL YLZ[YHPU[ HUK PU [OL PUÌ
Z[Y\J[PVUTHU\HSWYV]PKLK^P[O[OLYLZ[YHPU[
+HUNLY
9PZR VM ZLYPV\Z WLYZVUHS PUQ\Y` VY KLH[O [V
[OLJOPSK
-VSSV^HSSJOPSKYLZ[YHPU[PUZ[Y\J[PVUZHUK^HYUÌ
PUNZPU[OPZTHU\HS
>OLU\ZPUNHUPUMHU[VYJOPSKYLZ[YHPU[Z`Z[LT
IL Z\YL [V MVSSV^ HSS THU\MHJ[\YLYqZ PUZ[Y\JÌ
[PVUZVUPUZ[HSSH[PVUHUK\ZL
0UMHU[Z HUK ZTHSS JOPSKYLU ZOV\SK UL]LY IL
OLSK VU [OL SHW UVY ZOV\SK [OL` ZOHYL H
ZHML[`ILS[^P[OHUV[OLYVJJ\WHU[^OPSL[OL]LÌ
OPJSLPZPUTV[PVU
*OPSKYLU [VV IPN MVY JOPSK YLZ[YHPU[ Z`Z[LTZ
ZOV\SK \ZL YLN\SHY ZHML[` ILS[Z ( ZOV\SKLY
ILS[ JHU IL \ZLK WYV]PKPUN P[ KVLZ UV[ JYVZZ
[OLMHJLVY[OLULJRVM[OLJOPSK
-VY TH_PT\T ZHML[` HUK WYV[LJ[PVU ^L YLJÌ
VTTLUK [OH[ ZTHSS JOPSKYLU [YH]LS PU [OL YLHY
ZLH[Z
;OL HPYIHN KLHJ[P]H[PVU KL]PJL PUZ[HSSH[PVU
YLX\PYLZ ZWLJPHS WYVNYHTTPUN H]HPSHISL
VUS`MYVT`V\YH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
@V\YH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY^PSSILNSHK
[V HK]PZL `V\ HIV\[ [OL PUZ[HSSH[PVU WVZZPÍ
IPSP[` MVY H 7VYZJOL JOPSK YLZ[YHPU[ Z`Z[LT
^OPJO HSSV^Z KLHJ[P]H[PVU VM [OL WHZÍ
ZLUNLYqZHPYIHNZ
+HUNLY
;OL \ZL VM H JOPSK YLZ[YHPU[ Z`Z[LT PU [OL
WHZZLUNLY ZLH[ ^P[OV\[ HPYIHN KLHJ[P]H[PVU
JHU YLZ\S[ PU ZLYPV\Z WLYZVUHS PUQ\Y` VY
KLH[O [V [OL JOPSK MYVT HU HPYIHN KLWSV`Í
TLU[
;V YLK\JL YPZR VM PUQ\Y` MYVT HU PUMSH[PUN
HPYIHN PU HU HJJPKLU[ 7VYZJOL Z[YVUNS`
YLJVTTLUKZ!
+VUV[\ZLHJOPSKYLZ[YHPU[Z`Z[LTPU[OLWHZÌ
ZLUNLYZLH[\USLZZ[OLWHZZLUNLYHPYIHNZHYL
KLHJ[P]H[LK
G
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
9LHY^HYKMHJPUNJOPSKYLZ[YHPU[Z`Z[LT!
<ZLVUS`PU[OLWHZZLUNLYZLH[
<ZL PU WHZZLUNLY ZLH[ VUS` ^P[O [OL 7VYZJOL
JOPSKYLZ[YHPU[Z`Z[LT^P[OHPYIHNKLHJ[P]H[PVU
JHWHIPSP[`
>OLU\ZPUN[OL7VYZJOLJOPSKYLZ[YHPU[Z`Z[LT
`V\ T\Z[ LUZ\YL [OH[ [OL WHZZLUNLY HPYIHNZ
HYLKLHJ[P]H[LK
-VY^HYKMHJPUNJOPSKYLZ[YHPU[Z`Z[LT!
>OLUL]LYWVZZPISL\ZLPU[OLYLHYZLH[
0M `V\ T\Z[ WSHJL H MVY^HYK MHJPUN JOPSK
YLZ[YHPU[ Z`Z[LT PU [OL WHZZLUNLY ZLH[
[OL WHZZLUNLY HPYIHNZ T\Z[ IL KLHJ[PÍ
]H[LK
,_HTWSL!9LHY^HYKMHJPUNJOPSKYLZ[YHPU[Z`Z[LT
0U VYKLY [V KLHJ[P]H[L [OL WHZZLUNLYqZ HPYÍ
IHNZ [OL ILS[ [VUN\L VM [OL JOPSKqZ ZLH[
T\Z[ HS^H`Z IL PUZLY[LK PU [OL I\JRSL s(r
PUMYVU[VM[OLWHZZLUNLYZLH[
>OLU[OLPNUP[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVUKLHJ[P]H[PVUVM
[OL HPYIHNZ PZ PUKPJH[LK I` [OL HPYIHN ^HYUPUN
SPNO[MSHZOPUNMVYZLJVUKZ
+HUNLY
0M [OL SPNO[ KVLZ UV[ MSHZO [OL HPYIHNZ HYL
UV[ KLHJ[P]H[LK HUK H JOPSK YLZ[YHPU[ Z`ZÍ
[LTT\Z[UV[ILPUZ[HSSLK
/H]L [OL MH\S[ YLTLKPLK PTTLKPH[LS` I` HU
H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
n
a*"V©Fh
;OL(PYIHNZPUJVTIPUH[PVU^P[O[OLZHML[`ILS[Z
THRLZ \W H ZHML[` Z`Z[LT ^OPJO VMMLYZ [OL
KYP]LY HUK [OL WHZZLUNLY [OL NYLH[LZ[ RUV^U
WYV[LJ[PVUMYVTPUQ\YPLZPUJHZLVMHJJPKLU[
,]LU PM `V\Y ]LOPJSL PZ LX\PWWLK ^P[O HPYIHNZ
[OL ZHML[` ILS[Z T\Z[ IL ^VYU H[ HSS [PTLZ
ILJH\ZL [OL MYVU[ HPYIHN Z`Z[LT PZ VUS` HJ[\Ì
H[LKI`MYVU[HSJVSSPZPVUZ^P[OHUPTWHJ[VMZ\MMPÌ
JPLU[ZL]LYP[`
:LLMPN\YLMVYYHUNLZVMLMMLJ[P]LULZZ
)LSV^ [OL HJ[\H[PVU [OYLZOVSK VM [OL HPYIHNZ`ZÌ
[LTHUKK\YPUN[`WLZVMJVSSPZPVUZ^OPJOKVUV[
JH\ZL [OL HJ[\H[PVU VM [OL Z`Z[LT [OL ZHML[`
ILS[ZWYV]PKL[OLWYPTHY`WYV[LJ[PVU[V[OLVJJ\Ì
WHU[Z^OLUJVYYLJ[S`^VYU
;OLYLMVYL HSS WLYZVUZ ^P[OPU [OL ]LOPJSL
T\Z[ HS^H`Z ^LHY ZHML[` ILS[Z PU THU`
Z[H[LZ Z[H[L SH^ YLX\PYLZ [OL \ZL VM ZHML[`
ILS[Z:LLHSZV[OLJOHW[LYs:HML[`)LS[Zr
;OLMYVU[HPYIHNZHYLSVJH[LKILOPUK[OLWHKKLK
Z[LLYPUN^OLLSWHULSVU[OLKYP]LYqZZPKLHUKVU
[OLWHZZLUNLYqZZPKLPU[OLKHZOIVHYK
;OL ZPKL HPYIHNZ 76:07 Ì 7VYZJOL :PKL 0TWHJ[
7YV[LJ[PVU :`Z[LT HYL PUZ[HSSLK PU [OL KVVYZ
\UKLY[OLKVVY[YPTWHULS
¤m4apm
;OL MYVU[ HPYIHNZ HYL [YPNNLYLK K\YPUN H MYVU[HS
JVSSPZPVUVMZ\MMPJPLU[MVYJL
0U [OL L]LU[ VM H ZPKL PTWHJ[ VM JVYYLZWVUKPUN
MVYJL[OLZPKLHPYIHNVU[OLPTWHJ[ZPKLPZ[YPNÌ
NLYLK
;OL PUMSH[PVU WYVJLZZ NLULYH[LZ [OL HTV\U[ VM
NHZYLX\PYLK[VMPSS[OLHPYIHNZH[[OLULJLZZHY`
WYLZZ\YLPUMYHJ[PVUZVMHZLJVUK
(PYIHNZ WYV[LJ[ [OL MHJL HUK\WWLYIVK`^OPSZ[
ZPT\S[HULV\ZS`KHTWPUN[OLTV[PVUVM[OLKYP]LY
HUK WHZZLUNLY PU [OL PTWHJ[ KPYLJ[PVU PU [OL
L]LU[VMHMYVU[HSPTWHJ[VYZPKLPTWHJ[
+HUNLY
;V WYV]PKL VW[PTHS VJJ\WHU[ WYV[LJ[PVU
HPYIHNZT\Z[PUMSH[LH[]LY`OPNOZWLLK
0M `V\ HYL UV[ ^LHYPUN `V\Y ZHML[` ILS[ VY
HYL [VV JSVZL [V [OL HPYIHN ^OLU P[Z KLÍ
WSV`LK PUMSH[PUN HPYIHNZ JHU YLZ\S[ PU
ZLYPV\ZPUQ\Y`VYKLH[O
4HRL Z\YL [OLYL HYL UV WLVWSL HUPTHSZ VY
VIQLJ[Z IL[^LLU [OL KYP]LY VY WHZZLUNLY HUK
[OLHYLHPU[V^OPJO[OLHPYIHNPUMSH[LZ
:P[ IHJR HZ MHY MYVT [OL KHZOIVHYK VY Z[LLYÌ
PUN^OLLSHZPZWYHJ[PJHS^OPSLZ[PSSTHPU[HPUPUN
M\SS]LOPJSLJVU[YVS
+VUV[SLHUHNHPUZ[[OLPUZPKLVM[OLKVVYZ
(S^H`Z OVSK [OL Z[LLYPUN ^OLLS I` [OL V\[LY
YPT
5L]LYYLZ[`V\YOHUKZVU[OLHPYIHNWHULS
5L]LY [YHUZWVY[ OLH]` VIQLJ[Z VU VY PU MYVU[
VM[OLWHZZLUNLYZLH[
(S^H`ZRLLW[OLSPKVM[OLKVVYZ[VYHNLJVTÌ
WHY[TLU[ JSVZLK 6IQLJ[Z T\Z[ UV[ WYV[Y\KL
V\[VM[OLKVVYZ[VYHNLJVTWHY[TLU[
.P]L `V\Y WHZZLUNLY HSS VM [OL PUMVYTH[PVU PU
[OPZJOHW[LY
5V JOHUNLZ T\Z[ IL THKL [V [OL ^PYPUN VY
JVTWVULU[ZVM[OLHPYIHNZ`Z[LT
T¬
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
+V UV[ HKK HU` HKKP[PVUHS JV]LYPUNZ VY
Z[PJRLYZ [V [OL Z[LLYPUN ^OLLS VY PU [OL HYLH
VM [OL WHZZLUNLY HPYIHN HUK ZPKL HPYIHNZ
+VPUNZVTH`HK]LYZLS`HMMLJ[[OLM\UJ[PVUPUN
VM [OL HPYIHN Z`Z[LT VY JH\ZL OHYT [V [OL
VJJ\WHU[ZPM[OLHPYIHNZ`Z[LTZOV\SKKLWSV`
+V UV[ \UKLY[HRL HU` ^PYPUN MVY LSLJ[YPJHS HJÌ
JLZZVY`LX\PWTLU[PU[OL]PJPUP[`VM[OLHPYIHN
^PYPUN OHYULZZLZ +VPUN ZV TH` KPZHISL [OL
HPYIHNZ`Z[LTVYJH\ZLPUMSH[PVU
0M[OL^HYUPUNSPNO[JVTLZVU[OLHPYIHNZ`ZÌ
[LT ZOV\SK IL YLWHPYLK PTTLKPH[LS` I` `V\Y
H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
5V[L
(PYIHN JVTWVULU[Z LN Z[LLYPUN ^OLLS KVVY
[YPT TH` IL KPZHZZLTISLK VUS` I` HU H\[OÌ
VYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
>OLUKPZWVZPUNVMH\ZLKHPYIHN\UP[V\YZHML[`
PUZ[Y\J[PVUZT\Z[ILMVSSV^LK;OLZLPUZ[Y\J[PVUZ
JHU IL VI[HPULK H[ HU` H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL
KLHSLY
"mamVdaV^
;OL JLU[YHS [YPNNLYPUN \UP[ TVUP[VYZ [OL VWLYÌ
H[PVUHS YLHKPULZZ VM [OL HPYIHN Z`Z[LT HUK [OL
^HYUPUNSPNO[
(U` THSM\UJ[PVUZ [OH[ TH` VJJ\Y ^PSS IL PUKPÌ
JH[LK I` [OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[
WHULSHUKVUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY
0U [OL MVSSV^PUN JHZLZ `V\ ZOV\SK PTTLÍ
KPH[LS` JVUZ\S[ HU H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL
KLHSLY PU VYKLY [V HZZ\YL [OL HPYIHN Z`ZÍ
[LTPZM\UJ[PVUPUNWYVWLYS`!
0SS\TPUH[PVU VM [OL HPYIHN ^HYUPUN SPNO[ K\YPUN
[YH]LS VY YLWLH[LK PSS\TPUH[PVU SVUNLY [OHU
ZLJVUKZHM[LY[OLPNUP[PVUJPYJ\P[PZ[\YULKVU
0SS\TPUH[PVU MHPSZ [V SPNO[ \W K\YPUN PNUP[PVU JPYÌ
J\P[HJ[P]H[PVU
0M [OL HPYIHNZ VU [OL WHZZLUNLYqZ ZPKL HYL
Z^P[JOLK VMM I` [OL JOPSK YLZ[YHPU[ Z`Z[LT VY
PM HU PUZ[HSSLK JOPSK YLZ[YHPU[ Z`Z[LT PZ KL[LJ[LK
^OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ Z^P[JOLK VU [OL ^HYUPUN
SPNO[MSHZOLZMVYZLJVUKZ^OLU[OLPNUP[PVUPZ
VU
+HUNLY
0M [OL SPNO[ KVLZ UV[ MSHZO [OL HPYIHNZ HYL
UV[ KLHJ[P]H[LK HUK H JOPSK YLZ[YHPU[ Z`ZÍ
[LTT\Z[UV[ILPUZ[HSSLK
/H]L [OL MH\S[ YLTLKPLK PTTLKPH[LS` I` HU
H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
a*"Vh"amFm"m4F
0UVYKLY[VLUZ\YLSVUNÌ[LYTM\UJ[PVUPUN[OLHPYÌ
IHNZ`Z[LTT\Z[ILPUZWLJ[LKI`HUH\[OVYPaLK
7VYZJOLKLHSLYHM[LYHUK`LHYZMYVT[OL
KH[L VM THU\MHJ[\YL ZOV^U VU [OL ZHML[` JVTÌ
WSPHUJLZ[PJRLYHUKL]LY``LHYZ[OLYLHM[LY
0TWVY[HU[PUMVYTH[PVU
0M `V\ ZLSS `V\Y 7VYZJOL UV[PM` [OL W\YJOHZLY
[OH[ [OL ]LOPJSL PZ LX\PWWLK ^P[O HPYIHNZ HUK
YLMLY [OLT [V [OL JOHW[LY s(PYIHN :`Z[LTZr PU
[OLV^ULYqZTHU\HSZHML[`HUKKPZWVZHSY\SLZ
-\Y[OLYPUMVYTH[PVUVU[OLHPYIHNZ`Z[LTJHUIL
MV\UK VU Z[PJRLYZ H[ [OL Z\U ]PZVYZ HZ ^LSS HZ
VUHSSHPYIHNJVTWVULU[Z
-VYZWLJPHSYLJVTTLUKH[PVUZVU[OL\ZLVMJOPSK
YLZ[YHPU[Z WSLHZL YLMLY [V [OL JOHW[LY VU s*OPSK
9LZ[YHPU[:`Z[LTZr
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
Ts
"camVa=
"camV"a"m|"caFm}
>OLU [OL KYP]LY IHJRZ \W [OL WHYRPUNHZZPZ[HU[
Z`Z[LT PUKPJH[LZ [OL KPZ[HUJL IL[^LLU [OL JHY
HUK HU VIZ[HJSL ILOPUK P[ I` TLHUZ VM ZPNUHS
[VULZ
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMHJJPKLU[
+LZWP[L \ZL VM [OL WHYRPUN HZZPZ[HU[ Z`ZÍ
[LT[OLKYP]LYPZZ[PSSYLZWVUZPISLMVY[HRPUN
K\L JHYL HUK HZZLZZPUN VIZ[HJSLZ ^OLU
IHJRPUN\W
4HRL Z\YL [OH[ UV WLYZVUZ HUPTHSZ VY VIÌ
Z[HJSLZHYL^P[OPU[OLTHUVL\]YPUNHYLH
;OLWHYRPUNHZZPZ[HU[Z`Z[LTPZHJ[P]H[LKH\[VTH[Ì
PJHSS` ^OLU YL]LYZL NLHY PZ ZLSLJ[LK HUK [OL PNUPÌ
[PVUPZVU
5V[L
)L H^HYL [OH[ [OL WHYRPUN HZZPZ[HU[ Z`Z[LT PZ
UV[ Z^P[JOLK VU PM[OLJHYYVSSZIHJR^HYK^P[OV\[
YL]LYZLNLHYILPUNLUNHNLK
<S[YHZV\UKZLUZVYZ
:LUZVYZ
-V\Y \S[YHZV\UK ZLUZVYZ PU [OL YLHY I\TWLY
TLHZ\YL[OLKPZ[HUJL[V[OLJSVZLZ[VIZ[HJSL
9HUNLTPKKSLZLUZVYZHYV\UKPUJT
9HUNLV\[LYZLUZVYZHYV\UKPUJT
6IZ[HJSLZJHUUV[ILKL[LJ[LKPU[OLsISPUKrZLUÌ
ZVYHYLHLNULHY[OLNYV\UK
5V[L
;OL ZLUZVYZ T\Z[ HS^H`Z IL RLW[ MYLL VM K\Z[
PJL HUK ZUV^ PU VYKLY [V LUZ\YL [OH[ [OL` HYL
M\SS`M\UJ[PVUHS
*H\[PVU
;VH]VPKKHTHNPUN[OLZLUZVYZ!
4HPU[HPUZ\MMPJPLU[KPZ[HUJL^OLUJSLHUPUN^P[O
Z[LHTÌQL[\UP[Z
:PNUHS[VULZM\UJ[PVU
>OLU YL]LYZL NLHY PZ ZLSLJ[LK [OL WHYRPUN HZÌ
ZPZ[HU[JVUMPYTZ[OH[P[PZZ^P[JOLKVUI`PZZ\PUN
HZOVY[ZPNUHS[VUL
(KL[LJ[LKVIZ[HJSLPZZPNUHSSLKI`HUPU[LYTP[Í
[LU[ [VUL ;OL PU[LY]HSZ KLJYLHZL HZ [OL VIÌ
Z[HJSLPZHWWYVHJOLK
( JVU[PU\V\Z [VUL ZV\UKZ ^OLU [OL KPZ[HUJL
ILJVTLZ SLZZ [OHU VUL MVV[ ;OPZ JVU[PU\V\Z
[VUL JHU Z[VW PM [OL VIZ[HJSL PZ HWWYVHJOLK
JSVZLY[OHUVULMVV[
;OL YHKPV ]VS\TL ZOV\SK UV[ IL ZV SV\K HZ
[VKYV^UV\[[OLZPNUHS[VULZ
T¢
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
3PTP[ZVM\S[YHZVUPJTLHZ\YLTLU[
;OLWHYRPUNHZZPZ[HU[Z`Z[LTJHUUV[KL[LJ[!
ZV\UKÌHIZVYIPUN VIZ[HJSLZ LN WV^KLY
ZUV^
ZV\UKÌYLMSLJ[PUN VIZ[HJSLZ LN NSHZZ Z\YÌ
MHJLZMSH[WHPU[LKZ\YMHJLZ
HUK]LY`[OPUVIZ[HJSLZ
6[OLY \S[YHZV\UK ZV\YJLZ LN WUL\TH[PJ
IYHRLZ VM V[OLY ]LOPJSLZ QHJROHTTLYZ JHU
PU[LYMLYL^P[OKL[LJ[PVUVMVIZ[HJSLZ
-H\S[PUKPJH[PVU
;OLWHYRPUNHZZPZ[HU[Z`Z[LTPUKPJH[LZHMH\S[PU
[^V^H`Z!
(M[LY YL]LYZL NLHY OHZ ILLU ZLSLJ[LK [OL
ZOVY[ ZPNUHS [VUL PZ MVSSV^LK I` H JVU[PU\V\Z
[VULVM[OLZHTLWP[JO!
;OPZ PUKPJH[LZ [OH[ ZLUZVYZ HYL ZVPSLK VY
JV]LYLK^P[OPJL
(M[LY YL]LYZL NLHY OHZ ILLU ZLSLJ[LK [OL
ZOVY[ ZPNUHS [VUL PZ MVSSV^LK I` H JVU[PU\V\Z
[VUL^P[OHT\JOSV^LYWP[JO!
;OPZ PUKPJH[LZ H NLULYHS Z`Z[LT MH\S[ 7SLHZL
OH]L [OL MH\S[ YLTLKPLK H[ HU H\[OVYPaLK
7VYZJOLKLHSLY
(Í*VU[YVSZ^P[JOMVYKVVYTPYYVYHKQ\Z[TLU[
§a¦FddamV=p§mhapVd"pm^F
z"FmVFa=F
6U ]LOPJSLZ ^P[O ZLH[ TLTVY` `V\ JHU HJ[P]H[L
HUHKKP[PVUHSWHYRPUNHPK
(J[P]H[PUNZLLs:LH[4LTVY`r
>OLU YL]LYZL NLHY PZ LUNHNLK [OL TPYYVY
NSHZZ VU [OL WHZZLUNLYqZ ZPKL Z^P]LSZ KV^U
ZSPNO[S`[VZOV^[OLJ\YIHYLH
;OL TPYYVY NSHZZ YL[\YUZ [V P[Z PUP[PHS WVZP[PVU
^OLU[OLJHYPZZOPM[LKV\[VMYL]LYZLNLHY
4V]PUNTPYYVYNSHZZ[VP[ZPUP[PHSWVZP[PVU
^P[OYL]LYZLNLHYLUNHNLK
)YPLMS`TV]LJVU[YVSZ^P[JO(PUHU`KPYLJ[PVU
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
T
F"4"*dFF"zpadF
;OLYLHYZWVPSLYYLK\JLZHPYYLZPZ[HUJLHUKWHYÌ
[PJ\SHYS`H[OPNOZWLLKZYLK\JLZYLHYH_SLSPM[
¤ph"a44pmpd
;OL YLHY ZWVPSLY H\[VTH[PJHSS` L_[LUKZ H[ HWÌ
WYV_PTH[LS` TWO RTO HUK YL[YHJ[Z H[
HWWYV_PTH[LS`TWORTO
"mamVdaV^
;OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[ PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[ WHULS SPNO[Z
MVYHSHTWJOLJR^OLUPNUP[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVU
;OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[ WHULS HUK
VUÌIVHYK JVTW\[LY NV VU PM [OL YLHY ZWVPSLY
KVLZ UV[ L_[LUK H[ TVYL [OHU TWO
RTOVYPM[OLLUKWVZP[PVUPZUV[YLHJOLK
0M[OLH\[VTH[PJJVU[YVSMHPSZ!
,_[LUK [OL YLHY ZWVPSLY THU\HSS` I` WYLZZPUN
[OLZWVPSLYYVJRLYZ^P[JO
+HUNLY
9PZRVMHUHJJPKLU[
;OLZWVPSLYHMMLJ[ZTV]LTLU[VMHPYHYV\UK
[OL]LOPJSLHUKPZ\ZLK[VTHPU[HPUHLYVK`Í
UHTPJZ[HIPSP[`HZ]LOPJSLZWLLKZPUJYLHZL
0M[OLZWVPSLYKVLZUV[L_[LUKH\[VTH[PJHSS`
K\L[VTLJOHUPJHSTHSM\UJ[PVUKYP]PUNZ[HÍ
IPSP[` ^PSS IL HK]LYZLS` HMMLJ[LK I` PUÍ
JYLHZLK YLHY H_SL SPM[ ^OPJO JV\SK SLHK [V
SVZZVMJVU[YVS
(KHW[ `V\Y KYP]PUN Z[`SL HUK YLK\JL ZWLLK [V
[OLJOHUNLKHLYVK`UHTPJJVUKP[PVUZ
/H]L [OL MH\S[ YLTLKPLK H[ HU H\[OVYPaLK
7VYZJOLKLHSLY
+VUV[L_JLLK[OLWVZ[LKSLNHSZWLLKSPTP[
TT
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
"m¤"d4pmpd
>OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ VU [OL ZWVPSLY JHU IL L_Ì
[LUKLK HUK YL[YHJ[LK THU\HSS` \ZPUN [OL YVJRLY
Z^P[JO
>HYUPUN
:LYPV\Z PUQ\YPLZ TH` VJJ\Y MYVT JY\ZOPUN
HUKWPUJOPUNH[HSSTV]PUNWHY[ZPU[OLHYLH
VM[OLYL[YHJ[HISLZWVPSLY
,UZ\YL[OH[UVVULJHUILPUQ\YLKHUKUVVIÌ
QLJ[Z JHU IL QHTTLK I` [OL L_[LUZPVU VY YLÌ
[YHJ[PVUVM[OLYLHYZWVPSLY
,_[LUZPVU
7YLZZSLM[OHSMVMYVJRLYZ^P[JOIYPLMS`
;OLZWVPSLYL_[LUKZ[VP[ZMPUHSWVZP[PVU
9L[YHJ[PVU
7YLZZHUKOVSKYPNO[OHSMVMYVJRLYZ^P[JO\U[PS
[OLYLHYZWVPSLYOHZYLHJOLKP[ZMPUHSWVZP[PVU
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
TQ
d¤4^F="d
;OL JS\[JO WLKHS T\Z[ IL KLWYLZZLK M\SS`
ILMVYL[OLZ[HY[LY^PSSLUNHNL
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMHUHJJPKLU[
(S^H`Z JOLJR [OL TV]LTLU[ VM [OL JS\[JO
WLKHS ILMVYL KYP]PUN HUK THRL Z\YL [OH[ P[ PZ
UV[ VIZ[Y\J[LK I` H MSVVY TH[ VY HU` V[OLY
VIQLJ[
:LJ\YL[OLMSVVYTH[[VWYL]LU[P[MYVTZSPKPUN
PU[V WVZP[PVUZ [OH[ JV\SK PU[LYMLYL ^P[O [OL
ZHMLVWLYH[PVUVM`V\Y]LOPJSL
@V\Y 7VYZJOL KLHSLY ^PSS IL NSHK [V VMMLY `V\
MSVVY TH[Z VM [OL JVYYLJ[ ZPaL PUJS\KPUN H ZLÌ
J\YPUNWVZZPIPSP[`
;V H]VPK KHTHNL [V [OL JS\[JO HUK [YHUZÍ
TPZZPVU!
(S^H`Z KLWYLZZ [OL JS\[JO WLKHS M\SS` ^OLU
JOHUNPUNNLHYZ
+VUV[OVSK[OLJHYVUHZ[LLWNYHKL^P[O[OL
JS\[JOWLKHSWHY[PHSS`KLWYLZZLK
:OV\SK [OL MYLL [YH]LS VM [OL JS\[JO WLKHS Z\KÌ
KLUS` ILJVTL IPNNLY P[ JV\SK TLHU H THSM\UJÌ
[PVU VM [OL JS\[JO :LL `V\Y 7VYZJOL KLHSLY MVY
JVYYLJ[PVU
"camV"cF
7HYRPUN IYHRL MVYJL PZ TLJOHUPJHSS` [YHUZMLYYLK
[V[OLYLHY^OLLSZI`TLHUZVMJHISLZ
<ZL [OL WHYRPUN IYHRL VUS` HM[LY [OL ]LOPJSL
OHZJVTL[VHM\SSZ[VW
FamV^Fz"camV*"cF
7\SS[OLSL]LYHSS[OL^H`\WZLLHYYV^
>P[O [OL PNUP[PVU VU [OL WHYRPUN IYHRL ^HYUÌ
PUNSPNO[ZPU[OLPUZ[Y\TLU[WHULSHUKVUÌIVHYK
JVTW\[LY ^PSS JVTL VU PM [OL SL]LY PZ L]LU
ZSPNO[S` YHPZLK ( MPYT W\SS \W^HYK PZ YLX\PYLK
[VWYVWLYS`LUNHNL[OLWHYRPUNIYHRL
0M [OL IYHRL PZ UV[ M\SS` ZL[ [OL ]LOPJSL TH`
YVSS^P[OV\[JVU[YVS
4V]L [OL ZLSLJ[VY SL]LY [V s7r ;PW[YVUPJ VY
TV]L [OL NLHYZOPM[ SL]LY [V YL]LYZL VY MPYZ[
NLHY4HU\HS[YHUZTPZZPVU
)LMVYLL_P[PUN[OL]LOPJSLTHRLZ\YL[OH[[OL
WHYRPUN IYHRL PZ M\SS` ZL[ HUK [OL ]LOPJSL PZ
UV[TV]PUNH[HSS
FdF"amV^Fz"camV*"cF
7\SS [OL SL]LY ZSPNO[S` \W HZ `V\ KLWYLZZ [OL
YLSLHZL I\[[VU ( HUK [OLU W\ZO [OL SL]LY HSS
[OL^H`KV^U
T
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
"camV*"cF§"mamVdaV^
"camV*"cF§"mamVdaV^
"m"="
;OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z ^PSS NV V\[ HM[LY [OL WHYRPUN
IYHRLPZM\SS`YLSLHZLK
;OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z HYL UV[ HU PUKPJH[VY [OH[ [OL
WHYRPUN IYHRL PZ M\SS` ZL[" P[ PZ VUS` PU[LUKLK [V
IL H ^HYUPUN [V YLSLHZL [OL WHYRPUN IYHRL ILÌ
MVYLKYP]PUN[OLJHY
*H\[PVU
( WHY[PHSS` LUNHNLK IYHRL ^PSS V]LYOLH[[OL
YLHYIYHRLZYLK\JL[OLPYLMMLJ[P]LULZZHUK
JH\ZLL_JLZZP]L^LHY
9LSLHZL[OLWHYRPUNIYHRLM\SS`
>OLUWHYRPUN`V\YJHYHS^H`ZZL[[OLWHYRPUN
IYHRLI`W\SSPUNHSS[OL^H`\WVU[OLSL]LY
4V]L [OL ZLSLJ[VY SL]LY [V s7r ;PW[YVUPJ VY
TV]L [OL NLHYZOPM[ SL]LY [V YL]LYZL VY MPYZ[
NLHY4HU\HS[YHUZTPZZPVU
6UOPSSZHSZV[\YU[OLMYVU[^OLLSZ[V^HYKZ[OL
J\YI
"cF
4HRLP[HOHIP[[VJOLJR[OLVWLYH[PVUVM`V\Y
IYHRLZILMVYLKYP]PUN
2LLWPUTPUK[OH[[OLIYHRPUNKPZ[HUJLPUJYLHZLZ
]LY` YHWPKS` HZ[OLZWLLKPUJYLHZLZ([TWO
VY RTO MVY L_HTWSL P[ PZ UV[ [^PJL I\[
MV\Y[PTLZSVUNLY[OHUTWOVYRTO;PYL
[YHJ[PVUPZHSZVSLZZLMMLJ[P]L^OLU[OLYVHKZHYL
^L[VYZSPWWLY`
;OLYLMVYL HS^H`Z THPU[HPU H ZHML KPZ[HUJL
MYVT[OLJHYPUMYVU[VM`V\
5V[L
,]LU [OV\NO [OL IYHRL KPZJZ JVUZPZ[ VM HSSV`LK
NYL`JHZ[PYVU[OL`^PSS\UH]VPKHIS`Z[HY[[VJVYÌ
YVKL PM `V\Y JHY PZ WHYRLK MVY HU L_[LUKLK
WLYPVK ;OL IYHRLZ ^PSS [LUK [V sY\Ir HZ [OL YLÌ
Z\S[
;OL UH[\YL L_[LU[ HUK LMMLJ[Z VM JVYYVZPVU KLÌ
WLUK VU [OL HTV\U[ VM [PTL [OL ]LOPJSL ^HZ
WHYRLK^OL[OLYNYHU\SHYVYSPX\PKYVHKZHS[^HZ
ZWYLHK HUK ^OL[OLY NYLHZLÌKPZZVS]PUN HNLU[Z
^LYL\ZLKPUJHY^HZOLZ
0M[OLIYHRPUNJVTMVY[PZUV[PJLHIS`PTWHPYLK^L
YLJVTTLUK OH]PUN [OL IYHRL Z`Z[LT JOLJRLK
I`L_WLY[ZH[HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
"cF©FhO¤m4apm
@V\Y7VYZJOLPZLX\PWWLK^P[OHWV^LYHZZPZ[LK
O`KYH\SPJ K\HS JPYJ\P[ IYHRL Z`Z[LT ^P[O KPZJ
IYHRLZH[[OLMYVU[HUKYLHY
)V[O JPYJ\P[Z M\UJ[PVU PUKLWLUKLU[S` 6UL IYHRL
JPYJ\P[VWLYH[LZ[OLMYVU[HUK[OLV[OLYVWLYH[LZ
[OLYLHY
0M VUL IYHRL JPYJ\P[ OHZ MHPSLK [OL V[OLY ^PSSZ[PSS
VWLYH[L /V^L]LY `V\ ^PSS UV[PJL HU PUJYLHZLK
WLKHS[YH]LS^OLU`V\HWWS`[OLIYHRLZ
-HPS\YL VM VUL IYHRL JPYJ\P[ ^PSS JH\ZL [OL Z[VWÌ
WPUNKPZ[HUJL[VPUJYLHZL
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMHUHJJPKLU[
0U [OL \USPRLS` L]LU[ VM O`KYH\SPJ MHPS\YL VM
VULIYHRLJPYJ\P[!
7\ZO [OL IYHRL WLKHS KV^U MPYTS` HUK OVSK P[
PU[OH[WVZP[PVU
(TLJOHUPJHSSPURHNLHJ[P]H[LZ[OLZLJVUKJPYÌ
J\P[ HUK `V\ ^PSS IL HISL [V IYPUN [OL ]LOPJSL
[VHZ[VW
(M[LY IYPUNPUN `V\Y ]LOPJSL [V H JVTWSL[L
Z[VW H]VPK KYP]PUN [OL ]LOPJSL HUK PUZ[LHK
OH]L P[ [V^LK [V [OL ULHYLZ[ H\[OVYPaLK
7VYZJOLKLHSLYMVYYLWHPY
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
T
"cF§"mamVdaV^
"cF§"mamVdaV^"m"="
0M [OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[ WHULS HUK
VUÌIVHYK JVTW\[LY NV VU ^OPSL KYP]PUN [OL
IYHRLMS\PKSL]LSTH`IL[VVSV^VYPM[OLIYHRL
WLKHS[YH]LSOHZPUJYLHZLKVULVM[OL[^VIYHRL
JPYJ\P[ZTH`OH]LMHPSLK
( NYLH[LY IYHRPUN WYLZZ\YL ^PSS IL YLX\PYLK
Z[VWWPUN KPZ[HUJLZ ^PSS IL SVUNLY HUK [OL IYHRÌ
PUNILOH]PVY^PSSJOHUNLWHY[PJ\SHYS`PUJ\Y]LZ
>P[O JVYYLJ[S` HKQ\Z[LK IYHRLZ HUK H JVYYLJ[S`
^VYRPUN IYHRL Z`Z[LT [OL WLKHS [YH]LS [V [OL
WVPU[VMIYHRLHJ[\H[PVUZOV\SKILÌPU[V
Ì PUVY[VTT
>OLUL]LY [OL IYHRL WLKHS [YH]LS L_JLLKZ [OPZ
KPZ[HUJLOH]L[OLIYHRLZ`Z[LTJOLJRLK
"cFzF="d
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMHUHJJPKLU[
(U` VIZ[Y\J[PVU VM [OL IYHRL WLKHS JV\SK
PUJYLHZL[OLZ[VWWPUNKPZ[HUJL
(S^H`Z JOLJR [OL TV]LTLU[ VM [OL IYHRL
WLKHS ILMVYL KYP]PUN HUK THRL Z\YL [OH[ P[ PZ
UV[ VIZ[Y\J[LK I` H MSVVY TH[ VY HU` V[OLY
VIQLJ[
:LJ\YL[OLMSVVYTH[[VWYL]LU[P[MYVTZSPKPUN
PU[V WVZP[PVUZ [OH[ JV\SK PU[LYMLYL ^P[O [OL
ZHMLVWLYH[PVUVM`V\Y]LOPJSL
@V\Y 7VYZJOL KLHSLY ^PSS IL NSHK [V VMMLY `V\
MSVVY TH[Z VM [OL JVYYLJ[ ZPaL PUJS\KPUN H ZLÌ
J\YPUNWVZZPIPSP[`
5V[L
0U JHZL VUL VM [OL [^V IYHRL JPYJ\P[Z MHPSZ PUÌ
JYLHZLK WLKHS [YH]LS PZ YLX\PYLK [V IYPUN `V\Y
]LOPJSL[VHM\SSZ[VW
>HYUPUN
;V H]VPK V]LYOLH[PUN HUK WYLTH[\YL ^LHY
VM[OLIYHRLZ!
)LMVYL KLZJLUKPUN H Z[LLW NYHKL YLK\JL
ZWLLK HUK ZOPM[ [OL [YHUZTPZZPVU PU[V H SV^LY
NLHYVYKYP]PUNWVZP[PVU[VJVU[YVSZWLLK
+V UV[ sYPKL [OL IYHRLZr I` YLZ[PUN `V\Y MVV[
VU [OL WLKHS ^OLU UV[ PU[LUKPUN [V HWWS`
IYHRLWYLZZ\YL
+V UV[ OVSK [OL WLKHS KV^U [VV SVUN VY [VV
VM[LU
;OPZ JV\SK JH\ZL [OL IYHRLZ [V NL[ OV[ HUK
UV[M\UJ[PVUWYVWLYS`
TG
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
"cF*ppF
;OL IYHRL IVVZ[LY HZZPZ[Z IYHRPUN VUS`
^OLU[OLLUNPULPZY\UUPUN
>OLU [OL JHY PZ TV]PUN ^OPSL [OL LUNPUL PZ UV[
Y\UUPUN VY PM [OL IYHRL IVVZ[LY PZ KLMLJ[P]L
TVYLWYLZZ\YLVU[OLIYHRLWLKHSPZYLX\PYLK[V
IYPUN[OLJHY[VHZ[VW
4VPZ[\YLVYYVHKZHS[VUIYHRLZHMMLJ[ZIYHRPUN
>OLU [OL ]LOPJSL PZ KYP]LU VU ZHS[LK YVHKZ MVY
L_[LUKLKWLYPVKZ[OLIYHRLZZOV\SKIL^HZOLK
KV^U [OVYV\NOS` HIV\[ L]LY` ^LLRZ (U H\[VÌ
TH[PJ JHY^HZO MHJPSP[` JHUUV[ KV [OPZ QVI
WYVWLYS`
)YHRLZ ^PSS KY` HM[LY H ML^ JH\[PV\Z IYHRL HWWSPÌ
JH[PVUZ
>HYUPUN
+YP]PUN[OYV\NO^H[LYTH`YLK\JL[YHJ[PVU
4VPZ[\YL VU IYHRLZ MYVT YVHK ^H[LY JHY
^HZO VY JVH[PUN VM YVHK ZHS[ TH` HMMLJ[
IYHRPUNLMMPJPLUJ`
*H\[PV\ZS` HWWS` IYHRLZ [V [LZ[ IYHRLZ HM[LY
ILPUNL_WVZLK
"cF§F"
@V\Y JHY OHZ L_JLSSLU[ IYHRLZ I\[ [OL` HYL Z[PSS
Z\IQLJ[ [V ^LHY ;OL YH[L H[ ^OPJO [OL` ^LHY
KLWLUKZVUOV^[OLIYHRLZHYL\ZLK
/H]L[OLIYHRLZ`Z[LTPUZWLJ[LKH[[OLPU[LYÌ
]HSZ YLJVTTLUKLK PU `V\Y 4HPU[LUHUJL
)VVRSL[
"mamVdaV^
"mamVdaV^"m"="
0M[OLSPNO[ZPU[OLPUZ[Y\TLU[WHULSHUKVUÌIVHYK
JVTW\[LYZ[H`VU^OLU[OLLUNPULPZY\UUPUNVY
JVTLVU^OPSLKYP]PUN[OLIYHRLWHKZHYL^VYU
L_JLZZP]LS`
+VUV[JVU[PU\L[VVWLYH[L[OL]LOPJSL
/H]L `V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY PUZWLJ[
VYYLWSHJL[OLIYHRLWHKZ
"cFz"=
>LHY VU [OL IYHRL WHKZ HUK IYHRL KPZJZ
KLWLUKZ [V H NYLH[ L_[LU[ VU [OL KYP]PUN Z[`SL
HUK [OL JVUKP[PVUZ VM \ZL HUK [OLYLMVYL JHUUV[
ILL_WYLZZLKPUHJ[\HSTPSLZVU[OLYVHK
;OL OPNOÌWLYMVYTHUJL IYHRL Z`Z[LT PZ KLZPNULK
MVY VW[PTHS IYHRPUN LMMLJ[ H[ HSS ZWLLKZ HUK
[LTWLYH[\YLZ
*LY[HPUZWLLKZIYHRPUNMVYJLZHUKHTIPLU[JVUÌ
KP[PVUZZ\JOHZ[LTWLYH[\YLHUKO\TPKP[`[OLYLÌ
MVYLTPNO[JH\ZLIYHRLUVPZLZ
5L^IYHRLWHKZVYSPUPUNZ
5L^ IYHRL WHKZ HUK IYHRL KPZJZ OH]L [V IL
rIYVRLU PUs HUK [OLYLMVYL VUS` H[[HPU VW[PTHS
MYPJ[PVU ^OLU [OL JHY OHZ JV]LYLK ZL]LYHS O\UÌ
KYLKTPSLZVYRT
;OL ZSPNO[S` YLK\JLK IYHRPUN HIPSP[` T\Z[ IL
JVTWLUZH[LK MVY I` WYLZZPUN [OL IYHRL WLKHS
OHYKLY ;OPZ HSZV HWWSPLZ ^OLUL]LY [OL IYHRL
WHKZHUKIYHRLKPZJZHYLYLWSHJLK
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
Tn
"cF©Fh
|madp4c"cF©Fh}
;OL():Z`Z[LTYLWYLZLU[ZHTHQVYJVU[YPI\[PVU
[V [OL LUOHUJLTLU[ VM HJ[P]L ZHML[` PU `V\Y ]LÌ
OPJSL ;OPZ Z`Z[LT WYL]LU[Z [OL ^OLLSZ MYVT
SVJRPUN PU H WHUPJ Z[VW VU HSTVZ[ HSS YVHK Z\YÌ
MHJLZ
>P[O[OL():Z`Z[LTPU`V\Y]LOPJSL[OL
MVSSV^PUNHYLHZHYLLUOHUJLK!
:[LLYPUN ]LOPJSL YLTHPUZ Z[LLYHISL \UKLY HSS
IYHRPUNMVYJLZ^OLU():PZLUNHNLK
.VVK KPYLJ[PVUHS JVU[YVS UV Z^LY]PUN JH\ZLK
I`SVJRPUNVM^OLLSZ\UKLYIYHRPUNJVUKP[PVUZ
:OVY[LYZ[VWWPUNKPZ[HUJLZ[VWWPUNKPZ[HUJLZ
HYL \Z\HSS` YLK\JLK ILJH\ZL JVU[YVSSLK IYHRPUN
PZTH_PTPaLK
7YL]LU[PVU VM ^OLLS SVJR \W UV IYHRLÌÌ
PUK\JLK ZSPKPUN HUK [O\Z UV SVJHSPaLK [PYL ^LHY
MYVTLTLYNLUJ`IYHRPUN
;OLJY\JPHSHK]HU[HNLVM[OL():Z`Z[LTV]LYH
JVU]LU[PVUHS IYHRL Z`Z[LT PZ PU [OL HYLH VM
THPU[HPUPUN KPYLJ[PVUHS JVU[YVS HUK THUL\]LYHÌ
IPSP[` VM [OL JHY PU LTLYNLUJ` ZP[\H[PVUZ K\YPUN
UVYTHSKYP]PUNPUJS\KPUNWHUPJIYHRPUNPU[\YUZ
>HYUPUN
;OL PUJYLHZLK JVU[YVS [OH[ PZ WYV]PKLK
ZOV\SKUV[PUK\JL`V\[V[HRLNYLH[LYYPZRZ
^P[O `V\Y ZHML[` ;OL SPTP[Z KPJ[H[LK I` [OL
SH^Z VM WO`ZPJZ JHUUV[ IL V]LYJVTL L]LU
^P[O():
;OL YPZR VM HJJPKLU[Z K\L [V PUHWWYVWYPH[L
ZWLLKJHUUV[ILYLK\JLKL]LUI`[OL():
;OL KYP]LY ILHYZ [OL YLZWVUZPIPSP[` MVY HSS
KYP]PUNTHUL\]LYZ
(KHW[`V\YKYP]PUNZ[`SL[V[OLWYL]HPSPUNYVHK
HUK^LH[OLYJVUKP[PVUZ
6IL`HSS[YHMMPJSH^Z
6[OLY ]LOPJSLZ UV[ LX\PWWLK ^P[O [OL ():
Z`Z[LT TH` UV[ IL HISL [V THPU[HPU JVUÍ
[YVS LZWLJPHSS` VU ^L[ VY WVVY YVHK Z\YÍ
MHJLZ HUK [O\Z TH` IL TVYL SPRLS` [V PTÍ
WHJ[`V\MYVTILOPUK
;V TPUPTPaL [OH[ YPZR \ZL `V\Y (): Z`Z[LT
[V PUJYLHZL `V\Y HIPSP[` [V THUL\]LY [V H]VPK
KHUNLYV\ZZP[\H[PVUZHUKUV[TLYLS`[V[Y`[V
Z[VWPU[OLZOVY[LZ[KPZ[HUJLWVZZPISL
Q¬
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
zF"apmpO^F©Fh
(^OLLSZWLLKZLUZVYPZTV\U[LK[VLHJOVM[OL
MV\Y ^OLLSZ 0M ^OLLS SVJRÌ\W VM LP[OLY VM [OL
MYVU[^OLLSZVY[OLYLHY^OLLSZPZZLUZLKK\YPUN
IYHRPUN[OLIYHRLWYLZZ\YLPZHKQ\Z[LKH\[VTH[Ì
PJHSS` \U[PS [OL ^OLLS UV SVUNLY ZSPWZ ;OL IYHRL
WYLZZ\YL PZ YLN\SH[LK MVY LHJO MYVU[ ^OLLS PUKPÌ
]PK\HSS` HUK MVY IV[O VM [OL YLHY ^OLLSZ
[VNL[OLY
6UHYVHKZ\YMHJL^OPJOPZZSPWWLY`VUVUS`VUL
ZPKL[OLYLHY^OLLS^OPJOPZIYHRPUNVU[OLZSPWÌ
WLY` Z\YMHJL KL[LYTPULZ [OL IYHRL WYLZZ\YL
^OPJO^PSSILHWWSPLKLX\HSS`[VIV[OYLHY^OLLSZ
;OPZ LUZ\YLZ [OH[ KPYLJ[PVUHS Z[HIPSP[` PZ THPUÌ
[HPULK /V^L]LY PM IYHRPUN MVYJLZ HWWYVHJO [OL
^OLLSSVJRÌ\WWVPU[MVYHSS^OLLSZWHUPJIYHRPUN
[OL():Z`Z[LT^PSSPU[LY]LUL[VWYV]PKLHYHWPK
Y`[OTPJIYHRPUN
;OLWYVWLYVWLYH[PVUVM():PZWLYJLP]LKI`[OL
KYP]LY HZ H W\SZH[PUN IYHRL WLKHS PU JVUQ\UJ[PVU
^P[OH\KPISLUVPZLHUKWLYOHWZZVTL]PIYH[PVU
0M `V\ L_WLYPLUJL [OLZL ZLUZH[PVUZ ^OPSL KYP]Ì
PUN VY H YVHK Z\YMHJL ^P[O X\LZ[PVUHISL [YHJÌ
[PVUYLK\JL]LOPJSLZWLLKHWWYVWYPH[LMVY[OL
WYL]HPSPUNYVHKJVUKP[PVUZ
;OLM\UJ[PVUHSYLHKPULZZVMHSS[OLTHPULSLJ[YPJHS
JVTWVULU[Z VM [OL (): PZ JOLJRLK I` HU LSLJÌ
[YVUPJ TVUP[VYPUN Z`Z[LT IV[O ILMVYL HUK ^OPSL
`V\KYP]L
"mamVdaV^
"mamVdaV^"m"="
>OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ Z^P[JOLK VU [OL ():^HYUÌ
PUN SPNO[ ^PSS SPNO[ \W ^OPSL [OL Z`Z[LT PZ LSLJÌ
[YVUPJHSS` PU[LYYVNH[LK HUK NVLZ V\[ ^OLU [OL
LUNPUL PZ Z[HY[LK PM [OL JOLJR PZ UV[ `L[ JVTÌ
WSL[L
0M[OL():^HYUPUNSHTWMHPSZ[VNVV\[[OPZPUKPÌ
JH[LZ [OH[ (): OHZ ILLU KLHJ[P]H[LK K\L [V H
MH\S[0M[OL^HYUPUNSPNO[ZPU[OLPUZ[Y\TLU[WHULS
HUK VUÌIVHYK JVTW\[LY SPNO[ \W ^OPSL `V\ HYL
KYP]PUN [OPZ PUKPJH[LZ [OH[ H MH\S[ OHZ VJJ\YYLK
0U IV[O JHZLZ UVYTHS IYHRPUN HZ PU ]LOPJSLZ
^P[OV\[():PZZ[PSSYL[HPULK
;OL (): Z`Z[LT ZOV\SK OV^L]LY IL L_HTPULK
H[ HU H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY PTTLKPH[LS` [V
WYL]LU[[OLVJJ\YYLUJLVMM\Y[OLYMH\S[Z
0M [OL (): Z`Z[LT ILJVTLZ PUVWLYH[P]L [HRL
`V\Y ]LOPJSL [V `V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL
KLHSLYPTTLKPH[LS`
>HYUPUN
;OLJVU[YVS\UP[VM[OL():IYHRLZ`Z[LTPZ
ZL[ MVY Z[HUKHYK [PYL ZPaL 0M UVUÍZ[HUKHYK
[PYLZHYLPUZ[HSSLK[OLJVU[YVS\UP[TH`TPZÍ
PU[LYWYL[ [OL ZWLLK VM [OL ]LOPJSL ILJH\ZL
VM[OL]HYPHU[KH[HP[YLJLP]LZMYVT[OLZLUÍ
ZVYZVU[OLH_SLZ
<ZL VUS` [PYL THRLZ HUK [`WLZ [LZ[LK I`
7VYZJOL
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
Qs
p4^F"*ada©"m"VFhFm
|}
7:4 PZ HU HJ[P]L JVU[YVS Z`Z[LT MVY Z[HIPSPaPUN
[OL]LOPJSLK\YPUNL_[YLTLKYP]PUNTHUL\]LYZ
>HYUPUN
;OL PUJYLHZLK JVU[YVS [OH[ PZ WYV]PKLK
ZOV\SKUV[PUK\JL`V\[V[HRLNYLH[LYYPZRZ
^P[O `V\Y ZHML[` ;OL SPTP[Z KPJ[H[LK I` [OL
SH^Z VM WO`ZPJZ JHUUV[ IL V]LYJVTL L]LU
^P[O7:4
;OL YPZR VM HJJPKLU[Z K\L [V PUHWWYVWYPH[L
ZWLLKJHUUV[ILYLK\JLKL]LUI`7:4
;OL KYP]LY ILHYZ [OL YLZWVUZPIPSP[` MVY HSS
KYP]PUNTHUL\]LYZ
(KHW[`V\YKYP]PUNZ[`SL[V[OLWYL]HPSPUNYVHK
HUK^LH[OLYJVUKP[PVUZ
6IL`HSS[YHMMPJSH^Z
=¦"m"VFpO
:\WLYPVY [YHJ[PVU HUK SHULÌOVSKPUN HIPSP[` PU HSS
KYP]PUN ZP[\H[PVUZ u L]LU VU YVHK Z\YMHJLZ
^P[O]HY`PUNMYPJ[PVU
7:4 HJ[P]LS` Z[HIPSPaLZ [OL ]LOPJSL K\YPUN K`Ì
UHTPJKYP]PUNTHUVL\]YLZLNYHWPKZ[LLYPUN
TV]LTLU[Z K\YPUN SHUL JOHUNLZ VY VU HS[LYÌ
UH[PUNJ\Y]LZ
0TWYV]LK IYHRPUN Z[HIPSP[` PU J\Y]LZ HUK VU
KPMMLYLU[VY]HY`PUNYVHKZ\YMHJLZ
F"=amFOppzF"apm
;OL 7:4 PZ LUNHNLK H\[VTH[PJHSS` L]LY` [PTL
`V\Z[HY[[OLLUNPUL
¤m4apm
:LUZVYZ H[ [OL ^OLLSZ IYHRLZ Z[LLYPUN Z`Z[LT
HUKLUNPULJVU[PU\V\ZS`TLHZ\YL!
+YP]PUNZWLLK
+PYLJ[PVUVM[YH]LS
3H[LYHSHJJLSLYH[PVU
9H[LVM[\YUHIV\[[OL]LOPJSLqZ]LY[PJHSH_PZ
;OL 7:4 \ZLZ [OLZL ]HS\LZ [V KL[LYTPUL [OL
KPYLJ[PVUVM[YH]LSKLZPYLKI`[OLKYP]LY
7:4 PU[LY]LULZ HUK JVYYLJ[Z [OL JV\YZL PM [OL
]LOPJSLqZ HJ[\HS KPYLJ[PVU KL]PH[LZ MYVT [OL
KLZPYLK JV\YZL Z[LLYPUNÌ^OLLS WVZP[PVU 0[
IYHRLZ PUKP]PK\HS ^OLLSZ HZ ULLKLK 0M ULJLZZÌ
HY` [OL 7:4 HKKP[PVUHSS` PUMS\LUJLZ [OL LUNPUL
WV^LYVY[OLNLHYÌJOHUNPUNJOHYHJ[LYPZ[PJVM[OL
;PW[YVUPJPUVYKLY[VZ[HIPSPaL[OL]LOPJSL
;OL L]LU[Z ILSV^PUMVYT[OLKYP]LYVM7:4JVUÌ
[YVSVWLYH[PVUZHUK^HYUOPT[VHKHW[OPZKYP]PUN
Z[`SL[V[OLYVHKJVUKP[PVUZ!
;OL PUMVYTH[PVU SPNO[ PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[ WHULS
SPNO[Z\W
/`KYH\SPJUVPZLZJHUILOLHYK
;OL ]LOPJSL KLJLSLYH[LZ HUK Z[LLYPUNÌ^OLLS
MVYJLZ HYL HS[LYLK HZ [OL 7:4 JVU[YVSZ [OL
IYHRLZ
9LK\JLKLUNPULWV^LY
;OL IYHRL WLKHS W\SZH[LZ HUK P[Z WVZP[PVU PZ
JOHUNLKK\YPUNIYHRPUN
/V^L]LYP[PZWVZZPISLH[HU`[PTL[VHJOPL]L
M\SS]LOPJSLKLJLSLYH[PVUI`PUJYLHZPUN[OLMVV[
WYLZZ\YLZSPNO[S`VU[OLIYHRLWLKHS
Q¢
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
§a4^amVpOO
7YLZZ [OL r7:4 6--s SVNV VM [OL YVJRLY
Z^P[JO
7:4PZZ^P[JOLKVMMHM[LYHIYPLMKLSH`
>P[O 7:4 Z^P[JOLK VMM [OL 7:4 6-- ^HYUPUN
SPNO[ PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[ WHULS HUK [OL YVJRLY
Z^P[JOPUKPJH[VYSPNO[HYLSP[
+\YPUN IYHRPUN [OL ]LOPJSL PZ Z[HIPSPaLK L]LU
^OLU7:4PZZ^P[JOLKVMM
6ULÍZPKLKZWPUUPUNVM[OL^OLLSZPZWYL]LU[LK
L]LU^P[O7:4Z^P[JOLKVMM
7:4 ZOV\SK HS^H`Z IL Z^P[JOLK VU K\YPUN
rUVYTHSsKYP]PUN
/V^L]LY P[ JHU IL VM HK]HU[HNL [V Z^P[JO VMM
7:4[LTWVYHYPS`PUL_JLW[PVUHSZP[\H[PVUZ!
6UHSVVZLZ\YMHJLVYPUKLLWZUV^
>OLUrYVJRPUN[OL]LOPJSLMYLLs
>OLU\ZPUNZUV^JOHPUZ
;PW[YVUPJ ]LOPJSLZ! >OLU [OL 7:4 PZ Z^P[JOLK
VMM[OLZSPWTVUP[VYPUNM\UJ[PVUVM[OL;PW[YVUPJPZ
HSZVKLHJ[P]H[LK
§a4^amV*"4cpm
7YLZZ [OL PUKPJH[VY SPNO[ PU [OL YVJRLY Z^P[JO
7:4PZZ^P[JOLKVUHM[LYHIYPLMKLSH`
mOph"apmdaV^
;OL 7:4 PUMVYTH[PVU SPNO[ PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[
WHULSSPNO[Z\WMVYHSHTWJOLJR^OLU[OLPNÌ
UP[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVU
;OL SPNO[ PUKPJH[LZ 7:4 PU[LY]LU[PVU L]LU
^OLU7:4PZZ^P[JOLKVMMIYHRLYLN\SH[PVUPU
[OLL]LU[VMVULÌZPKLK^OLLSZWPU
"mamVdaV^
;OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[ PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[ WHULS
SPNO[Z\WPUJVTIPUH[PVU^P[O[OLPUKPJH[VYSPNO[
PU [OL YVJRLY Z^P[JO MVY H SHTW JOLJR ^OLU
[OLPNUP[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVU
0U JVTIPUH[PVU ^P[O [OL PUKPJH[VY SPNO[ PU [OL
YVJRLY Z^P[JO [OL SPNO[ PUKPJH[LZ [OH[ 7:4 PZ
Z^P[JOLKVMM
;OL SPNO[Z PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[ WHULS HUK PU [OL
VUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LYPUKPJH[LHKLMLJ[
7:4PZV\[VMVYKLY
;OL MH\S[ ZOV\SK IL YLTLKPLK PTTLKPH[LS` H[
HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
p§amV
9LMLY[V[OLJOHW[LYr;V^PUNs
"m=*"cFF
/HUKIYHRL [LZ[Z VU [OL YVSSLY [LZ[ Z[HUK T\Z[
ILWLYMVYTLKVUS`^P[O[OLPNUP[PVUZ^P[JOLKVMM
9LMLY[V[OLJOHW[LYr-V\YÌ^OLLSKYP]Ls
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
Q
p¤_^FFda¦F
>P[O [OL MV\YÌ^OLLS KYP]L VM [OL ;\YIV [OL
LUNPUL WV^LY PZ ]HYPHIS` KPZ[YPI\[LK [V [OL MYVU[
HUKYLHY^OLLSZ
7V^LY KPZ[YPI\[PVU HUK ^OLLS ZWLLK JVTWLUZHÌ
[PVUIL[^LLU[OLMYVU[HUKYLHYH_SLZPZYLHSPZLK
^P[OH]PZJV\ZT\S[PWSLÌKPZJJS\[JO
+PZ[YPI\[PVU VM [OL LUNPUL WV^LY PZ KLWLUKLU[
\WVU [OL ^OLLS ZWLLK KPMMLYLUJL IL[^LLU [OL
[^VH_SLZ
;OL ]PZJV\Z T\S[PWSLÌKPZJ JS\[JO HS^H`Z KLSP]LYZ
Z\MMPJPLU[ KYP]L WV^LY [V [OL MYVU[ ^OLLSZ
HWWYV_ [V [VLUZ\YLVW[PT\T[YHJ[PVU
L]LUVUHWVVYYVHKZ\YMHJL
0U JVTIPUH[PVU ^P[O [OL 7VYZJOL :[HIPSP[` 4HUÌ
HNLTLU[ 7:4 MV\YÌ^OLLS KYP]L LUZ\YLZ VW[PÌ
T\TOHUKSPUNHUKPUJYLHZLKKYP]PUNZ[HIPSP[`
>HYUPUN
;OL PUJYLHZLK JVU[YVS [OH[ PZ WYV]PKLK
ZOV\SKUV[PUK\JL`V\[V[HRLNYLH[LYYPZRZ
^P[O `V\Y ZHML[` ;OL SPTP[Z KPJ[H[LK I` [OL
SH^Z VM WO`ZPJZ JHUUV[ IL V]LYJVTL L]LU
^P[OMV\YÍ^OLLSKYP]L
;OL YPZR VM HJJPKLU[Z K\L [V PUHWWYVWYPH[L
ZWLLK JHUUV[ IL YLK\JLK L]LU I` MV\YÍ
^OLLSKYP]L
;OL KYP]LY ILHYZ [OL YLZWVUZPIPSP[` MVY HSS
KYP]PUNTHUL\]LYZ
(KHW[`V\YKYP]PUNZ[`SL[V[OLWYL]HPSPUNYVHK
HUK^LH[OLYJVUKP[PVUZ
6IL`HSS[YHMMPJSH^Z
©m"hphFFFamVzp4F=¤F
:VTL <: Z[H[LZ HUK *HUHKPHU WYV]PUJLZ JVUÌ
K\J[ LTPZZPVUZ PUZWLJ[PVUTHPU[LUHUJL [LZ[PUN
PU]VS]PUN[OL\ZLVM[^VÌ^OLLSK`UHTVTL[LY
( [^VÌ^OLLSLK K`UHTVTL[LY PZ H [YLHKTPSS [`WL
KL]PJL \WVU ^OPJO H ZPUNSL H_SL VM [OL JHY [OL
KYP]PUN H_SL VM [OL ]LOPJSL YV[H[LZ [V ZPT\SH[L
]LOPJSL VWLYH[PVU VU [OL YVHK ^OPSL [OL ]LOPJSL
YLTHPUZZ[H[PVUHY`
@V\Y ;\YIV OHZ H M\SSÌ[PTL MV\YÌ^OLLS KYP]L
Z`Z[LT ^OPJO JHUUV[ IL KPZHISLK :L]LYL KHTÌ
HNL [V [OL WV^LY[YHPU JHU YLZ\S[ PM [LZ[LK VU H
[^VÌ^OLLSK`UHTVTL[LY
>HYUPUN
;V H]VPK ZL]LYL WV^LY[YHPU KHTHNL HUK H
WVZZPISL \UL_WLJ[LK TV]LTLU[ VM [OL ]LÍ
OPJSL
@V\Y ;\YIV]LOPJSLT\Z[UL]LYIL[LZ[LK
VUH[^VÌ^OLLSK`UHTVTL[LY
(K]PZL[OLLTPZZPVUZ[H[PVUVM[OPZ^HYUPUNILÌ
MVYL[LZ[PUN[OL]LOPJSL
7V^LYTLHZ\YLTLU[
7V^LYTLHZ\YLTLU[ZVUK`UHTVTL[LYZHYLUV[
HWWYV]LKI`7VYZJOL
QT
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
"cFF
)YHRL [LZ[Z T\Z[ IL WLYMVYTLK VUS` VU WSH[LÌ
[`WL[LZ[Z[HUKZVYYVSSLY[LZ[Z[HUKZ
;OLMVSSV^PUNSPTP[]HS\LZT\Z[UV[ILL_JLLKLK
VUYVSSLY[LZ[Z[HUKZ!
;LZ[PUNZWLLKTWORTO
;LZ[K\YH[PVUZLJVUKZ
"m=*"cFF
/HUKIYHRL [LZ[Z VU [OL YVSSLY [LZ[ Z[HUK T\Z[
ILWLYMVYTLKVUS`^P[O[OLPNUP[PVUZ^P[JOLKVMM
"d"m4amV§^FFdpm^F¦F^a4dF
+\YPUNMPUPZOIHSHUJPUNVM[OL^OLLSZ[OL]LOPJSL
T\Z[ IL OVPZ[LK HUK [OL ^OLLSZ HISL [V YV[H[L
MYLLS`
p§amV
9LMLY[V[OLJOHW[LYr;V^PUNs
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
Q
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
zF"apm:m¤hFm
:PKL]LU[
0NUP[PVUZ[HY[LYZ^P[JO^P[OZ[LLYPUNSVJR
:WHJLMVYOHUKZÌMYLLTPJYVWOVUL
MVY[LSLWOVUL
;\YUZPNUHSZ
OLHKSPNO[KPTTLYMSHZOLYSL]LY
0UZ[Y\TLU[WHULS
/VYU
>PUKZOPLSK^PWLY^HZOLYSL]LY
,TLYNLUJ`MSHZOLYZ^P[JO
9VJRLYZ^P[JOLZMVY
7VYZJOL:[HIPSP[`4HUHNLTLU[7:4
YLHYZWVPSLY
MVV[^LSSSPNO[
9LHKPULZZKPZWSH`MVYHSHYTZ`Z[LT
*LU[YHS]LU[
*\WOVSKLY
*VU[YVSWHULSMVYOLH[PUN]LU[PSH[PVU
HPYJVUKP[PVUPUN
9VJRLYZ^P[JOLZMVYJLU[YHSSVJRPUN
YLHY^PUKV^HUKKVVYTPYYVYOLH[PUN
YLHY^PUKV^^PWLY
:WLHRLY
3PNO[Z^P[JO
;VNNSLZ^P[JOLZMVY;PW[YVUPJ
6WLYH[PUNSL]LYMVYVUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY
3VJRPUNSL]LYMVYZ[LLYPUNÌ^OLLSHKQ\Z[TLU[
6WLYH[PUNSL]LYMVYH\[VTH[PJZWLLKJVU[YVS
>PWLPU[LY]HSJVU[YVS
YHPUÌZLUZVYZLUZP[P]P[`JVU[YVS
9VJRLYZ^P[JOLZMVYZLH[OLH[PUN
9HKPV
*PNHYL[[LSPNO[LY
.SV]LJVTWHY[TLU[
0U[LYPVY[LTWLYH[\YLZLUZVY
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
Q
Vmaapm"F§a4^§a^
"ma_^FOFFamVp4c
-VY`V\YZHML[`MHZ[LUZHML[`ILS[Z
:LLHSZV[OLJOHW[LYVUs0TTVIPSPaLYr
FOpF"amV^FFmVamF
(WWS`[OLOHUKIYHRL
4HU\HS[YHUZTPZZPVU!
4V]L[OLNLHYZOPM[SL]LYPU[VUL\[YHS
;OLJS\[JOWLKHST\Z[ILKLWYLZZLKM\SS`
ILMVYL[OLZ[HY[LY^PSSLUNHNL
;PW[YVUPJ!
4V]L[OLZLSLJ[VYSL]LY[Vs7rVYs5r
§a4^zpaapm¬
;OL PNUP[PVU RL` JHU IL ^P[OKYH^U PU [OPZ WVZPÌ
[PVUVUS`
;PW[YVUPJTVKLSZ!
;OLPNUP[PVURL`JHUIL^P[OKYH^UVUS`^OLU[OL
ZLSLJ[VYSL]LYPZPU[OLs7rWVZP[PVU
;OL Z[LLYPUN PZ SVJRLK ^OLU [OL RL` PZ ^P[OÌ
KYH^U
,UNHNL[OLZ[LLYPUNSVJRI`TV]PUN[OLZ[LLYÌ
PUN^OLLS[V[OLSLM[VYYPNO[
;\YU[OLZ[LLYPUN^OLLS[V[OLSVJRPUNWVZP[PVU
ILMVYL `V\ Z^P[JO VMM [OL LUNPUL ZV [OH[ `V\
KVUq[ OH]L [V L_LY[ `V\YZLSM ^OLU SVJRPUN VY
\USVJRPUN[OLZ[LLYPUN
QG
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
§a4^zpaapms
0NUP[PVUPZVU
(SSLSLJ[YPJHSLX\PWTLU[JHUILZ^P[JOLKVU
;OL^HYUPUNSPNO[ZSPNO[\WMVYHSHTWJOLJR
7SLHZL UV[L [OL KLZJYPW[PVU VM [OL PUKP]PK\HS
^HYUPUNSPNO[Z
>OLU[\YUPUN[OLRL`[VWVZP[PVUYLSPL]L[OL
Z[LLYPUNSVJR^P[OHZSPNO[Z[LLYPUNTV]LTLU[
5V[L
;V JVUZLY]L IH[[LY` WV^LY H[ SV^ YWT [YHMMPJ
QHTZ [V^U KYP]PUN L[J Z^P[JO VMM HSS LSLJ[YPJHS
JVUZ\TLYZ ^OPJO HYL UV[ ULLKLK H[ [OH[ TVÌ
TLU[
§a4^zpaapm¢
:[HY[PUN[OLLUNPUL
;\YU[OLRL`MYVTWVZP[PVU[VWVZP[PVU
;OL JS\[JO WLKHS T\Z[ IL KLWYLZZLK M\SS`
ILMVYL[OLZ[HY[LY^PSSLUNHNL
;OL MPYZ[ VWLYH[PVU VM [OL Z[HY[LY PZ LUKLK H\[VÌ
TH[PJHSS`^OLU[OLLUNPULZ[HY[Z
0M [OL LUNPUL KVLZ UV[ Z[HY[ Z\IZLX\LU[ Z[HY[LY
VWLYH[PVUZ^PSSUV[ILLUKLKH\[VTH[PJHSS`
0M [OL LUNPUL KVLZ UV[ Z[HY[ H[ [OL MPYZ[ [PTL VY
Z[HSSZ H[ HU` [PTL [OL RL` T\Z[ IL YL[\YULK [V
WVZP[PVU
>OLU [OL LUNPUL PZ Y\UUPUN [OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z
ZOV\SK NV VMM 0M H SPNO[ KVLZ UV[ NV VMM [HRL
HWWYVWYPH[LHJ[PVUHZPUKPJH[LKPU[OPZTHU\HS
§a4^amVFmVamFpOO
;\YU [OL PNUP[PVU RL` MYVT WVZP[PVU [V WVZPÌ
[PVU
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMHUHJJPKLU[
;OL Z[LLYPUN ^OLLS ^PSS SVJR HUK ^PSS JH\ZL
SVZZVMZ[LLYPUN
5L]LY YLTV]L RL` MYVT [OL PNUP[PVU SVJR VY
[\YU[OLRL`VMM^OPSL[OL]LOPJSLPZTV]PUN
;VH]VPKIH[[LY`Y\UÌKV^UHS^H`ZYLTV]L[OL
PNUP[PVURL`MYVT[OLPNUP[PVUSVJR
:LLHSZV[OLJOHW[LYVUs)H[[LY`r
;\YU[OLZ[LLYPUN^OLLS\U[PS[OLZ[LLYPUNSVJR
PZLUNHNLK
5V[L
6U ]LOPJSLZ ^P[O ;PW[YVUPJ P[ PZ VUS` WVZZPISL [V
YLTV]L[OLPNUP[PVURL`PM[OLZLSLJ[VYSL]LYPZPU
WVZP[PVUs7r
pmV
0M`V\SLH]L[OLRL`PU[OLPNUP[PVUZ[LLYPUNSVJR
H NVUN ^PSS ZV\UK ^OLU [OL KYP]LYqZ KVVY PZ
VWLULK;OPZPZHYLTPUKLY[VYLTV]L[OLRL`
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
Qn
"amVp4F=¤F
:LLHSZV[OLJOHW[LYVUs0TTVIPSPaLYr
>HYUPUN
:LYPV\Z PUQ\Y` TH` YLZ\S[ PM `V\ HYL PUÍ
]VS]LKPUHJVSSPZPVU^P[OV\[OH]PUNMHZ[LULK
[OLZHML[`ILS[Z
-HZ[LUZHML[`ILS[ZILMVYLKYP]PUNH^H`
FOpF"amV^FFmVamF
(WWS`[OLOHUKIYHRL
4HU\HS[YHUZTPZZPVU!
4V]L[OLNLHYZOPM[SL]LYPU[VUL\[YHS
;OLJS\[JOWLKHST\Z[ILKLWYLZZLKM\SS`
ILMVYL[OLZ[HY[LY^PSSLUNHNL
;PW[YVUPJ!
4V]L[OLZLSLJ[VYSL]LY[Vs7rVYs5r
;LTWLYH[\YL ZLUZVYZ VU [OL LUNPUL H\[VTH[Ì
PJHSS` WYV]PKL [OL JVYYLJ[ M\LSHPY TP_[\YL YLÌ
X\PYLKMVYZ[HY[PUN
;OLYLMVYL P[ PZ UV[ ULJLZZHY` [VKLWYLZZ[OL
HJJLSLYH[VY WLKHS ^OPSL Z[HY[PUN H JVSK VY H
^HYTLUNPUL
(ZZVVUHZ[OLLUNPULZ[HY[ZYLSLHZL[OLPNUPÌ
[PVURL`
;OL MPYZ[ VWLYH[PVU VM [OL Z[HY[LY PZ LUKLK H\[VÌ
TH[PJHSS`^OLU[OLLUNPULZ[HY[Z
0M [OL LUNPUL KVLZ UV[ Z[HY[ Z\IZLX\LU[ Z[HY[LY
VWLYH[PVUZ^PSSUV[ILLUKLKH\[VTH[PJHSS`
0M [OL LUNPUL MHPSZ [V Z[HY[ HM[LY VY ZLJÌ
VUKZVMJYHURPUN!
>HP[ HIV\[ ZLJVUKZ ILMVYL LUNHNPUN [OL
Z[HY[LYHNHPU
+VUV[SL[[OLLUNPULPKSL[V^HYT\W
>OLU Z[HY[PUN [OL LUNPUL IL YLHK` [V KYP]L
PTTLKPH[LS`
+YP]L ]LOPJSL H[ TVKLYH[L ZWLLKZ HUK H]VPK
LUNPUL ZWLLKZ HIV]L YWT K\YPUN [OL
MPYZ[TPU\[LZ
+HUNLY
,UNPUL L_OH\Z[ M\TLZ OH]L THU` JVTWVÍ
ULU[Z ^OPJO `V\ JHU ZTLSS ;OL` HSZV JVUÍ
[HPU JHYIVU TVUV_PKL *6 ^OPJO PZ H JVÍ
SVYSLZZHUKVKVYSLZZNHZ
*HYIVU TVUV_PKL JHU JH\ZL \UJVUZJPV\ZÍ
ULZZHUKL]LUKLH[OPMPUOHSLK
5L]LY Z[HY[ VY SL[ [OL LUNPUL Y\U PU HU LUÌ
JSVZLK\U]LU[PSH[LKHYLH
0[ PZ UV[ YLJVTTLUKLK [V ZP[ PU `V\Y JHY MVY
WYVSVUNLKWLYPVKZ^P[O[OLLUNPULVUHUK[OL
JHYUV[TV]PUN
(U \UH[[LUKLK ]LOPJSL ^P[O H Y\UUPUN LUÍ
NPULPZWV[LU[PHSS`OHaHYKV\Z
0M^HYUPUNSPNO[ZZOV\SKJVTLVU[VPUKPJH[L
PTWYVWLY VWLYH[PVU [OL` ^V\SK NV \UUVÍ
[PJLK
5L]LYSLH]L[OLLUNPULPKSPUN\UH[[LUKLK
+HUNLYVMMPYL
+V UV[ WHYR VY VWLYH[L [OL ]LOPJSL PU HYLHZ
^OLYL [OL OV[ L_OH\Z[ Z`Z[LT TH` JVTL PU
JVU[HJ[ ^P[O KY` NYHZZ IY\ZO M\LS ZWPSS VY
V[OLYMSHTTHISLTH[LYPHS
0M`V\YJHYJH[JOLZVUMPYLMVYHU`YLHZVUJHSS
[OLMPYLKLWHY[TLU[
+V UV[ LUKHUNLY `V\Y SPML I` H[[LTW[PUN [V
W\[V\[[OLMPYL
¬
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
pzzamVFmVamF
;\YURL`IHJR[VWVZP[PVU
+V UV[ Z[VW LUNPUL PTTLKPH[LS` HM[LY OHYK VY
L_[LUKLKKYP]PUN
2LLW LUNPUL Y\UUPUN H[ PUJYLHZLK PKSL MVY
HIV\[ [^V TPU\[LZ [V WYL]LU[ L_JLZZP]L OLH[
I\PSKÌ\WILMVYL[\YUPUNVMMLUNPUL
;VH]VPKIH[[LY`Y\UÌKV^UHS^H`ZYLTV]L[OL
PNUP[PVURL`MYVT[OLPNUP[PVUSVJR
4HRL Z\YL [OH[ ^OLU `V\ SLH]L [OL JHY L]LU
IYPLMS``V\OH]L^P[OKYH^U[OLPNUP[PVURL`
,UNHNL[OLZ[LLYPUNSVJRI`TV]PUN[OLZ[LLYÌ
PUN^OLLS[V[OLSLM[VYYPNO[
;\YU[OLZ[LLYPUN^OLLS[V[OLSVJRPUNWVZP[PVU
ILMVYL `V\ Z^P[JO VMM [OL LUNPUL ZV [OH[ `V\
KVUq[ OH]L [V L_LY[ `V\YZLSM ^OLU SVJRPUN VY
\USVJRPUN[OLZ[LLYPUN
>HYUPUN
/V[ LUNPUL JVTWHY[TLU[ JVTWVULU[Z JHU
I\YUZRPUVUJVU[HJ[
)LMVYL^VYRPUNVUHU`WHY[PU[OLLUNPULJVTÌ
WHY[TLU[ [\YU [OL LUNPUL VMM HUK SL[ P[ JVVS
KV^UZ\MMPJPLU[S`
mVamF_4phz"hFm*dp§F:
"=a"pO"m
;OL YHKPH[VYZ HUK YHKPH[VY MHUZ HYL PU [OL MYVU[
VM[OLJHY
;OL LUNPULÌJVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY PZ TV\U[LK VU
[OLLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[SPK
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMPUQ\Y`
;OL LUNPULÍJVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY HS^H`Z
Y\UZ^OLU[OLPNUP[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVU(M[LY
[OLPNUP[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVMM[OLLUNPULJVTÍ
WHY[TLU[ HUK JVVSHU[ [LTWLYH[\YLZ HYL
TVUP[VYLKMVYHWWYV_TPU\[LZ
+\YPUN [OPZ WLYPVK HUK KLWLUKPUN VU [LTÍ
WLYH[\YL [OL LUNPULÍJVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY
HUK YHKPH[VY MHUZ TH` JVU[PU\L [V Y\U VY
Z[HY[[VY\U
*HYY` V\[ ^VYR PU [OLZL HYLHZ VUS` ^P[O [OL
LUNPULVMMHUKL_LYJPZLL_[YLTLJH\[PVU
¤ph"a4V""VF=pp
;OL PNUP[PVU Z`Z[LT PU `V\Y 7VYZJOL TH` PU[LYÌ
MLYL ^P[O `V\Y LSLJ[YVUPJHSS` VWLYH[LK NHYHNL
KVVY
;VJOLJR[OPZKYP]L`V\Y7VYZJOLJSVZL[V[OL
NHYHNL KVVY 4HRL Z\YL UV[ [V PU[LYMLYL ^P[O
[OLVWLYH[PUNYHUNLVM[OLKVVY
9\U[OLLUNPULH[KPMMLYLU[ZWLLKZ
0M [OL NHYHNL KVVY VWLUZ VY JSVZLZ ^P[OV\[ `V\
VWLYH[PUN[OLNHYHNLKVVY\UP[PU`V\YJHYJVUÌ
[HJ[ [OL KLHSLY ^OV PUZ[HSSLK [OL H\[VTH[PJ NHYÌ
HNL KVVY [V OH]L [OL MYLX\LUJ` HUKVY JVKPUN
VM[OLNHYHNLKVVYZPNUHSJOHUNLKVYTVKPMPLK
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
s
¢
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
m¤hFm"mFdp=Fd
0UMVYTH[PVU HIV\[ PUKP]PK\HS PUKPJH[VYZ PZ
NP]LUVU[OLZWLJPMPLKWHNLZ
=VS[TL[LY
:WLLKVTL[LY^P[OHUHSVN\LKPZWSH`
:WLLKVTL[LY^P[OKPNP[HSKPZWSH`
(\[VTH[PJZWLLKJVU[YVSPUKPJH[VYSPNO[
;HJOVTL[LY
;\YUZPNUHSPUKPJH[VYSPNO[SLM[
/PNOILHTPUKPJH[VYSPNO[
6UÌIVHYKJVTW\[LYu
;\YUZPNUHSPUKPJH[VYSPNO[YPNO[
3PNO[ZLUZVYMVYPUZ[Y\TLU[PSS\TPUH[PVU
*SVJR
;PW[YVUPJPUKPJH[VY
*VVSPUNZ`Z[LT
;LTWLYH[\YLNH\NL^HYUPUNSPNO[
-\LS
3L]LSNH\NL^HYUPUNSPNO[
,UNPULVPSWYLZZ\YLNH\NL
"mamVdaV^am=a4"pdaV^
( >HZOLYMS\PKSL]LS^HYUPUNSPNO[
) *OLJRLUNPUL^HYUPUNSPNO[
* 7VYZJOL:[HIPSP[`4HUHNLTLU[7:4
0UMVYTH[PVUSPNO[
+ 7VYZJOL:[HIPSP[`4HUHNLTLU[7:4
>HYUPUNSPNO[
, ():^HYUPUNSPNO[
- )YHRLMS\PKSL]LS
)YHRLKPZ[YPI\[PVU^HYUPUNSPNO[
. 7HYRPUNIYHRL^HYUPUNSPNO[
/ )YHRLWHK^LHY^HYUPUNSPNO[
0 ,UNPULVPSWYLZZ\YL^HYUPUNSPNO[
2 )H[[LY`^HYUPUNSPNO[
3 :HML[`ILS[^HYUPUNSPNO[
4 (PYIHN^HYUPUNSPNO[
5 9L[YHJ[HISLYLHYZWVPSLY^HYUPUNSPNO[
6 3\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[SPK
LUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[SPK^HYUPUNSPNO[
>OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ Z^P[JOLK VU [OL ^HYUÍ
PUNSPNO[ZSPNO[\WMVYHSHTWJOLJR
5V[L
>HYUPUNZ[OH[OH]LILLUNP]LUHYLZ[VYLKPU[OL
HWWYVWYPH[L JVU[YVS \UP[ TLTVY` HUK JHU IL
YLHKV\[H[HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
;OPZPUMVYTH[PVUJHUOLSW[V^HYU`V\HIV\[ZP[\Ì
H[PVUZ ^OPJO TH` IL OHaHYKV\Z [V `V\ VY `V\Y
JHY
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
T
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
m¤hFm"mFd"m"="p=Fd
0UMVYTH[PVU HIV\[ PUKP]PK\HS PUKPJH[VYZ PZ
NP]LUVU[OLZWLJPMPLKWHNLZ
=VS[TL[LY
:WLLKVTL[LY^P[OHUHSVN\LKPZWSH`
:WLLKVTL[LY^P[OKPNP[HSKPZWSH`
(\[VTH[PJZWLLKJVU[YVSPUKPJH[VYSPNO[
;HJOVTL[LY
;\YUZPNUHSPUKPJH[VYSPNO[SLM[
/PNOILHTPUKPJH[VYSPNO[
6UÌIVHYKJVTW\[LYu
;\YUZPNUHSPUKPJH[VYSPNO[YPNO[
3PNO[ZLUZVYMVYPUZ[Y\TLU[PSS\TPUH[PVU
*SVJR
;PW[YVUPJPUKPJH[VY
*VVSPUNZ`Z[LT
;LTWLYH[\YLNH\NL^HYUPUNSPNO[
-\LS
3L]LSNH\NL^HYUPUNSPNO[
,UNPULVPSWYLZZ\YLNH\NL
"mamVdaV^am=a4"pdaV^
( >HZOLYMS\PKSL]LS^HYUPUNSPNO[
) *OLJRLUNPUL^HYUPUNSPNO[
* 7VYZJOL:[HIPSP[`4HUHNLTLU[7:4
0UMVYTH[PVUSPNO[
+ 7VYZJOL:[HIPSP[`4HUHNLTLU[7:4
>HYUPUNSPNO[
, ():^HYUPUNSPNO[
- )YHRLMS\PKSL]LS
)YHRLKPZ[YPI\[PVU^HYUPUNSPNO[
. 7HYRPUNIYHRL^HYUPUNSPNO[
/ )YHRLWHK^LHY^HYUPUNSPNO[
0 ,UNPULVPSWYLZZ\YL^HYUPUNSPNO[
2 )H[[LY`^HYUPUNSPNO[
3 :HML[`ILS[^HYUPUNSPNO[
4 (PYIHN^HYUPUNSPNO[
5 9L[YHJ[HISLYLHYZWVPSLY^HYUPUNSPNO[
6 3\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[SPK
LUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[SPK^HYUPUNSPNO[
>OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ Z^P[JOLK VU [OL ^HYUÍ
PUNSPNO[ZSPNO[\WMVYHSHTWJOLJR
5V[L
>HYUPUNZ[OH[OH]LILLUNP]LUHYLZ[VYLKPU[OL
HWWYVWYPH[L JVU[YVS \UP[ TLTVY` HUK JHU IL
YLHKV\[H[HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
;OPZPUMVYTH[PVUJHUOLSW[V^HYU`V\HIV\[ZP[\Ì
H[PVUZ ^OPJO TH` IL OHaHYKV\Z [V `V\ VY `V\Y
JHY
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
Q
pdhFF
0UKPJH[LZ[OLIH[[LY`]VS[HNL
5VYTHSYHUNL![V]VS[Z
;OL ]VS[HNL TH` KYVW JVUZPKLYHIS` ^OLU [OL
]LOPJSLPZILPUNZ[HY[LK
0M [OL NH\NL PZ JVU[PU\HSS` ILSV^ ]VS[Z
^OLU[OLLUNPULPZY\UUPUN!
/H]L[OLIH[[LY`JOHYNPUNZ`Z[LTJOLJRLKH[
HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
"F©
"mamVdaV^
;OL^HYUPUNSPNO[PU[OLPUZ[Y\TLU[WHULSJVTLZ
VU^OLUPNUP[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVUHUKT\Z[NVVMM
^OLULUNPULPZY\UUPUN
0M[OL^HYUPUNSPNO[ZPU[OLPUZ[Y\TLU[WHULS
HUK VUÍIVHYK JVTW\[LY JVTL VU ^OPSL [OL
LUNPULPZY\UUPUNVY^OPSLKYP]PUN!
:[VW[OLJHYPUHZHMLWSHJLHUKZ[VW[OLLUÌ
NPUL
7VZZPISLJH\ZLZ
+LMLJ[PU[OLIH[[LY`JOHYNPUNZ`Z[LT
)YVRLUKYP]LILS[
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMHUHJJPKLU[HUKYPZRVMLUNPULKHTÍ
HNL
( IYVRLU KYP]L ILS[ TLHUZ [OLYL PZ UV
WV^LY HZZPZ[HUJL [V [OL Z[LLYPUN TVYL LMÍ
MVY[ PZ YLX\PYLK [V Z[LLY HUK JVVSHU[ W\TW
M\UJ[PVU^PSSZ[VW
+VUV[JVU[PU\LKYP]PUN
/H]L [OL MH\S[ YLTLKPLK H[ [OL ULHYLZ[ H\[OÌ
VYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
(Í(KQ\Z[TLU[I\[[VUMVYPUZ[Y\TLU[PSS\TPUH[PVUHUK
[YPWJV\U[LY
¤ph"a4zFF=pmpd
m=a4"pdaV^
0UKPJH[LZH\[VTH[PJZWLLKJVU[YVSYLHKPULZZ
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
m¤hFmdd¤ham"apm
;OL PSS\TPUH[PVU PZ H\[VTH[PJHSS` HKQ\Z[LK [V [OL
HTIPLU[ IYPNO[ULZZ I` [OL SPNO[ ZLUZVY PU [OL
[HJOVTL[LY
0UHKKP[PVU^OLU[OLJHYSPNO[ZHYLZ^P[JOLKVU
[OLPUZ[Y\TLU[HUKZ^P[JOZ`TIVSIYPNO[ULZZJHU
ILTHU\HSS`HKQ\Z[LK
>HYUPUN
9PZR VM HU HJJPKLU[ WLYZVUHS PUQ\Y` HUK
SVZZVMJVU[YVS
+V UV[ YLHJO [OYV\NO [OL Z[LLYPUNÌ^OLLS
ZWVRLZ^OPSLKYP]PUN
ahhamVam¤hFmadd¤ham"apm
;\YU HKQ\Z[TLU[ I\[[VU ( PU [OL HWWYVWYPH[L
KPYLJ[PVU HUK OVSK P[ \U[PS [OL KLZPYLK IYPNO[Ì
ULZZOHZILLUYLHJOLK
;OLJOVZLUSL]LSVMIYPNO[ULZZPZPUKPJH[LKI`
H IHY KPZWSH` PU [OL KPZWSH` MPLSK VM [OL
VUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY
az=phFF
>HYUPUN
9PZR VM HU HJJPKLU[ WLYZVUHS PUQ\Y` HUK
SVZZVMJVU[YVS
+V UV[ YLHJO [OYV\NO [OL Z[LLYPUNÌ^OLLS
ZWVRLZ^OPSLKYP]PUN
FFamVp«Fp
7YLZZ HKQ\Z[TLU[ I\[[VU ( MVY HWWYV_PTH[LS`
VULZLJVUKVY
9LZL[ [OL KPZ[HUJL PU [OL s:,;r TLU\ VM [OL
VUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY
9LMLY[V[OLJOHW[LYs6UÌIVHYKJVTW\[LYr
(M[LYL_JLLKPUNTPSLZVY RPSVTL[LYZ
[OLJV\U[LYYL[\YUZ[Vsr
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
(Í(KQ\Z[TLU[I\[[VUMVYJOHUNLÍV]LYIL[^LLU
RPSVTL[LYZTPSLZ
zFF=phFF
;OL KPNP[HS ZWLLKVTL[LY PZ PU[LNYH[LK PU [OL
WVPU[LYPUZ[Y\TLU[
;OLPUKPJH[PVUJOHUNLZMYVTTWO[VRTO^OLU
[OL\UP[ZHYLJOHUNLKMYVTTPSLZ[VRPSVTL[YLZ
^"mVamVp¦F*F§FFm
adFadphFF
@V\JHU\ZLHKQ\Z[TLU[I\[[VU([VJOHUNL[OL
\UP[Z VM [OL KPZ[HUJL HUK ZWLLK KPZWSH`Z PU [OL
VUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LYHUKKPNP[HS[HJOVTL[LY
>HYUPUN
9PZR VM HU HJJPKLU[ WLYZVUHS PUQ\Y` HUK
SVZZVMJVU[YVS
+V UV[ YLHJO [OYV\NO [OL Z[LLYPUNÌ^OLLS
ZWVRLZ^OPSLKYP]PUN
§a4^amV*F§FFm¤ma
>P[O[OLPNUP[PVUVUOVSKHKQ\Z[TLU[I\[[VU(
[\YULK[V[OLSLM[MVYHWWYV_ZLJVUKZ
5V[L
;OL \UP[Z VM [OL KPZ[HUJL HUK ZWLLK KPZWSH`Z
JHU HSZV IL JOHUNLK PU [OL s:,;r TLU\ VM [OL
VUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY
G
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
"4^phFF
;OL [HJOVTL[LY ZOV^Z [OL LUNPUL ZWLLK PU YL]Ì
VS\[PVUZWLYTPU\[LYWT
;OLILNPUUPUNVM[OLYLKTHYRZH[[OLYPNO[LUK
VM [OL ZJHSL PUKPJH[LZ [OL TH_PT\T WLYTPZZPISL
LUNPULYWT
( ZWLLK SPTP[LY WYL]LU[Z [OL LUNPUL MYVT ILPUN
V]LYYL]]LK K\YPUN HJJLSLYH[PVU )LMVYL YLHJOPUN
[OPZ HYLH [OL UL_[ OPNOLY NLHY ZOV\SK IL ZLÌ
SLJ[LK
:OPM[ [V [OL UL_[ SV^LY NLHY ^OLU [OL LUNPUL
YWTKYVWZILSV^YWT
*H\[PVU
;VH]VPKZL]LYLLUNPULKHTHNL
(S^H`Z VIZLY]L [OL LUNPUL YWT ILMVYL KV^UÌ
ZOPM[PUN [V H SV^LY NLHY ZV `V\ KV UV[ L_Ì
JLLK[OLTH_PT\TLUNPULYWT
¤maVm"dm=a4"paV^
-SHZOLZPUZ`UJOYVUPZT^P[O[OL[\YUZPNUHSZ
3LM[HYYV^uSLM[[\YUZPNUHSZ
9PNO[HYYV^uYPNO[[\YUZPNUHSZ
0M [OL MYLX\LUJ` VM [OL KPZWSH` ILJVTLZ UVÌ
[PJLHIS` MHZ[LY JOLJR [OL VWLYH[PVU VM [OL
[\YUZPNUHSZ
aV^F"h
m=a4"pdaV^
3PNO[Z ^OLU OPNO ILHT VY OLHKSPNO[ MSHZOLY PZ
Z^P[JOLKVU
;OL PUKPJH[VY SPNO[ NVLZ V\[ ^OLU [OL OPNO
ILHTZHYLZ^P[JOLKVMM
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
n
ppdamV©Fh
FhzF"¤FV"¤VF
PNUP[PVUVU
<:(!+PZWSH`PU-
*HUHKH!+PZWSH`PU*
7VPU[LY[V[OLSLM[uLUNPULJVSK
(]VPK OPNO LUNPUL ZWLLKZ HUK OLH]` LUNPUL
SVHKPUN
7VPU[LYPU[OLTPKKSLuUVYTHSVWLYH[PUN[LTÌ
WLYH[\YL
;OL WVPU[LY TH` TV]L \W [V [OL YLKHYLH^OLU
LUNPULPZOLH]PS`SVHKLKHUKV\[ZPKL[LTWLYH[\YL
PZ OPNO I\[ ZOV\SK YL[\YU [V sUVYTHSr ^OLU LUÌ
NPULSVHKPZYLK\JLK
"mamVdaV^
0M [OL JVVSHU[ [LTWLYH[\YL PZ [VV OPNO [OL
^HYUPUNSPNO[JVTLZVU
(KKP[PVUHSS` H ^HYUPUN PZ KPZWSH`LK PU [OL VUÌ
IVHYKJVTW\[LY
7\SSVMM[OLYVHK[\YUVMM[OLLUNPULHUKHSSV^
[VJVVS
*OLJR YHKPH[VY HUK HPY WHZZHNLZ PU MYVU[ LUK
VMJHYMVYVIZ[Y\J[PVUZ
*OLJRJVVSHU[SL]LS
0MULJLZZHY`HKKJVVSHU[HUKOH]LMH\S[YLTLÌ
KPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
-VSSV^ [OL ^HYUPUNZ HUK PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ PU
[OLs*VVSHU[SL]LSrJOHW[LY
5V[L
;VWYL]LU[L_JLZZP]L[LTWLYH[\YLZ[OLJVVSPUNÌ
HPY WHZZHNLZ T\Z[ UV[ IL YLZ[YPJ[LK I` JV]LYÌ
PUNZLNMPSTZsZ[VULN\HYKZs
0M[OLJVVSHU[SL]LSPZ[VVSV^[OL^HYUPUNSPNO[
MSHZOLZ
(KKP[PVUHSS` H ^HYUPUN PZ KPZWSH`LK PU [OL VUÌ
IVHYKJVTW\[LY
:^P[JOLUNPULVMMHUKHSSV^[VJVVS
(KKJVVSHU[
/H]L [OL JH\ZL VM [OL MH\S[ YLTLKPLK H[ HU
H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
-VSSV^ [OL ^HYUPUNZ HUK PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ PU
[OLs*VVSHU[SL]LSrJOHW[LY
*H\[PVU
9PZRVMLUNPULKHTHNL
0M [OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z JVTL VU L]LU [OV\NO
JVVSHU[ SL]LS PZ JVYYLJ[ KV UV[ JVU[PU\L KYP]Ì
PUN
/H]L [OL MH\S[ YLTLKPLK H[ [OL ULHYLZ[
H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
¬
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
mVamF4phz"hFm*dp§FO"m
0UHKKP[PVU[OPZ^HYUPUNSPNO[MSHZOLZ[VPUKPJH[L
H MH\S[ PU [OL LUNPUL JVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY
MHU
/H]L [OL JH\ZL VM [OL MH\S[ YLTLKPLK H[ HU
H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
azpma4
m=a4"pOpFdF4pdF¦Fzpaapm"m=
FdF4F=VF"
>OLU [OL LUNPUL PZ Y\UUPUN [OL ZLSLJ[VY SL]LY
WVZP[PVUHUKLUNHNLKNLHYHYLPUKPJH[LK
0M[OLZLSLJ[VYSL]LYPZIL[^LLU[^VWVZPÍ
[PVUZ!
;OL ZLSLJ[VY SL]LY WVZP[PVU PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[
JS\Z[LYMSHZOLZHUK
[OL ^HYUPUN rZLSLJ[VY SL]LY UV[ LUNHNLKs
HWWLHYZ VU [OL KPZWSH` VM [OL VUÌIVHYK
JVTW\[LY
,UNHNL[OLZLSLJ[VYSL]LYJVYYLJ[S`
0M[OLYLPZHMH\S[PU[OL[YHUZTPZZPVU!
[ONLHYMSHZOLZVU[OLKPZWSH`
;OL ^HYUPUN r;PW[YVUPJ LTLYNLUJ` Y\Us
HWWLHYZPU[OLVUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY
(SZVYLMLY[Vr,TLYNLUJ`WYVNYHTs
;V YLTLK` [OL MH\S[ WSLHZL JVUZ\S[ HU H\[OÌ
VYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLYPTTLKPH[LS`
-VSSV^[OLPUZ[Y\J[PVUZPU[OLJOHW[LYr;PW[YVUPJs
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
s
¤Fd
F¦FdV"¤VF
>OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ VU [OL M\LS SL]LS PZ KPZÌ
WSH`LK
-VY[HURJHWHJP[`ZLLs*HWHJP[PLZrJOHW[LY
0M[OL]LOPJSLqZPUJSPUH[PVUJOHUNLZLNNVPUN\W
VY KV^UOPSS TPUVY KL]PH[PVUZ PU [OL PUKPJH[PVU
TH`VJJ\Y
5V[L
0M [OL [HUR PZ ULHY LTW[` HUK `V\ [VW \W ^P[O
VUS`HZTHSSX\HU[P[`VMM\LS[OPZJHUUV[ILYLNÌ
PZ[LYLKI`[OLSL]LSNH\NLHUKJHSJ\SH[PVUVM[OL
YHUNLYLTHPUPUNPZPTWVZZPISL
"mamVdaV^
>OLU [OL LUNPUL PZ Y\UUPUN [OL ^HYUPUN
SPNO[ VM [OL SL]LS NH\NL SPNO[Z \W PM SLZZ [OHU
HWWYV_<:NHSSVUZSP[YLZVMM\LSYLTHPUZ
PU [OL [HUR VY [OL YHUNL VU YLTHPUPUN M\LS MHSSZ
ILSV^HWWYV_TPSLZRT
(KKP[PVUHSS` H ^HYUPUN PZ KPZWSH`LK PU [OL VUÌ
IVHYKJVTW\[LY
-PSS\WH[[OLUL_[VWWVY[\UP[`
*H\[PVU
;V WYL]LU[ KHTHNL[V[OLLTPZZPVUJVU[YVS
Z`Z[LTHUKLUNPUL
5L]LYKYP]L[OL[HURJVTWSL[LS`V\[VMM\LS
(]VPKOPNOJVYULYPUNZWLLKZHM[LY[OL^HYUPUN
SPNO[ZOH]LJVTLVU
-VSSV^ [OL PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ PU [OL s,TPZZPVU *VUÌ
[YVS:`Z[LTrJOHW[LY
0M [OL SL]LS NH\NL ^HYUPUN SPNO[ MSHZOLZ
[OLYLOHZILLUHZ`Z[LTMH\S[
(KKP[PVUHSS` H ^HYUPUN PZ KPZWSH`LK PU [OL VUÌ
IVHYKJVTW\[LY
;OLYL^PSS[OLUILUVYLZLY]L^HYUPUN
;V YLTLK` [OL MH\S[ NV [V HU H\[OVYPaLK
7VYZJOLKLHSLY
¢
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
(Í(KQ\Z[TLU[I\[[VUMVYJSVJR
)Í*SVJR
dp4c
;OL JSVJR PZ ISHURLK V\[ HWWYV_PTH[LS` MV\Y
TPU\[LZHM[LY[OLPNUP[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVMMVY^OLU
[OLJHYPZSVJRLK
FamV^FahF
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMHUHJJPKLU[HUKSVZZVMJVU[YVS
+V UV[ YLHJO [OYV\NO [OL Z[LLYPUNÌ^OLLS
ZWVRLZ^OPSLKYP]PUN
:L[[PUNOV\YZ
7YLZZHKQ\Z[TLU[I\[[VU(MVYHIV\[VULZLJÌ
VUK
/V\YKPZWSH`MSHZOLZ
;\YUI\[[VUPU[OLHWWYVWYPH[LKPYLJ[PVU!
[VYPNO[uPUJYLHZLOV\YZMPN\YL
[VSLM[uKLJYLHZLOV\YZMPN\YL
(KQ\Z[TLU[PUOV\YZu[\YUI\[[VUIYPLMS`
-HZ[HKQ\Z[TLU[KPZWSH`J`JSLZu
[\YUHUKOVSKI\[[VU
:L[[PUNTPU\[LZ
7YLZZHKQ\Z[TLU[I\[[VUHNHPU
4PU\[LZKPZWSH`MSHZOLZ
:L[I`YV[H[PUNHZPUOV\YZTVKL
3LH]PUNHKQ\Z[TLU[TVKL
(\[VTH[PJHSS`HM[LYVULTPU\[LVY!
7YLZZHKQ\Z[TLU[I\[[VUHNHPU
>OLU HKQ\Z[TLU[ TVKL PZ KLSPILYH[LS` SLM[ I`
WYLZZPUN[OLI\[[VU[OL[PTLILNPUZWYLJPZLS`[V
[OLZLJVUK
5V[L
;OL [PTL TVKL JHU IL JOHUNLK IL[^LLU O
HUKOPU[OLVUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
mVamFadF¤F
"¤VF
>P[O H ^HYTLKÌ\W LUNPUL HUK H[ H ZWLLK VM
YWT [OL LUNPUL VPS WYLZZ\YL ZOV\SK IL
HWWYV_IHYVYOPNOLY
0M [OL VPS WYLZZ\YL KYVWZ HIY\W[S` HUK [OL
^HYUPUN SPNO[Z PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[ WHULS HUK
PU [OL VUÍIVHYK JVTW\[LY JVTL VU ^OPSL
[OLLUNPULPZY\UUPUNVY^OPSLKYP]PUN!
0TTLKPH[LS`Z[VWPUHZ\P[HISLWSHJL
:LLr>HYUPUNSPNO[s
"mamVdaV^
;OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[ PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[ WHULS SPNO[Z
\W^OLUPNUP[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVUHUKT\Z[NVV\[
^OLULUNPULPZY\UUPUN
0M[OL^HYUPUNSPNO[ZPU[OLPUZ[Y\TLU[WHULS
HUK PU [OL VUÍIVHYK JVTW\[LY JVTL VU
^P[O[OLLUNPULY\UUPUNVY^OPSLKYP]PUN!
0TTLKPH[LS`Z[VWPUHZ\P[HISLWSHJL
:^P[JOVMM[OLLUNPUL
*OLJR^OL[OLY[OLYLPZHUVI]PV\ZVPSSLHRVU
VY\UKLY[OLJHY
0MUVVPSSLHRJHUILKL[LJ[LK!
4LHZ\YL[OLVPSSL]LS\ZPUN[OLVUÌIVHYKJVTÌ
W\[LY^P[O[OLLUNPULPKSPUN
9LMLY[V[OLJOHW[LYr6UÌIVHYKJVTW\[LYs
(KKLUNPULVPSPMULJLZZHY`
9LMLY[V[OLJOHW[LYr,UNPULVPSSL]LSs
*H\[PVU
9PZRVMLUNPULKHTHNL
+V UV[ JVU[PU\L KYP]PUN PM [OLYL PZ HU VI]PV\Z
VPSSLHR
+V UV[ JVU[PU\L KYP]PUN PM [OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z
JVTLZVUL]LU[OV\NOVPSSL]LSPZJVYYLJ[
/H]L [OL MH\S[ YLTLKPLK H[ [OL ULHYLZ[
H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
T
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
^F4cmVamF
"mamVaV^
;OL^HYUPUNSPNO[PU[OLPUZ[Y\TLU[WHULSJVTLZ
VU ^OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ MPYZ[ [\YULK VU HUK YLÌ
THPUZ VU IYPLMS` HZ H I\SI JOLJR 0M [OL SPNO[
KVLZ UV[ JVTL VU OH]L [OL I\SI YLWSHJLK
WYVTW[S`
0M [OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[ WHULS HUK
VUÌIVHYK JVTW\[LY JVTL VU HUK YLTHPU VU
^OPSLKYP]PUNP[Z\NNLZ[Z!
H WV[LU[PHS LUNPUL JVU[YVS WYVISLT HUK [OL
ULLKMVYZ`Z[LTZLY]PJLVY
HUPTWYVWLYS`MHZ[LULK[HURJHWVY
YLM\LSSPUN^P[OLUNPULY\UUPUN
(S[OV\NO [OL ]LOPJSL PZ \Z\HSS` KYP]LHISL HUK ^PSS
UV[ YLX\PYL [V^PUN ZLL `V\Y KLHSLY MVY ZLY]PJL
HZZVVUHZWVZZPISL
*H\[PVU
0M [OL *OLJR LUNPUL SPNO[ PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[
WHULSPZMSHZOPUNZL]LYLJH[HS`[PJJVU]LY[LY
KHTHNLHUKWV^LYSVZZ^PSSZVVUVJJ\Y
7YVSVUNLK KYP]PUN ^P[O [OL *OLJR LUNPUL
SPNO[ VU JV\SK JH\ZL KHTHNL [V [OL
LTPZZPVU JVU[YVS Z`Z[LT 0[ HSZV JV\SK HMÍ
MLJ[M\LSLJVUVT`HUKKYP]LHIPSP[`
/H]L [OL MH\S[ YLTLKPLK H[ [OL ULHYLZ[ H\[OÌ
VYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLYPTTLKPH[LS`
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
Q
m_p"=phz¤F|}
azd"©OaFd=
;OLKPZWSH`MPLSKPZILULH[O[OL[HJOVTL[LY
F"=amFOppzF"apm
>P[OPNUP[PVUZ^P[JOLKVU
^P[OLUNPULY\UUPUN
zF"apm:4pmpd
0[ PZ UV[ WVZZPISL [V KLZJYPIL HSS KL[HPSZ VM [OL
VUÌIVHYK JVTW\[LY M\UJ[PVUZ PU [OPZ 6^ULYqZ
4HU\HS
/V^L]LY [OL L_HTWSLZ ^PSS X\PJRS` MHTPSPHYPaL
`V\ ^P[O [OLM\UJ[PVUHSWYPUJPWSLHUKOLSW`V\[V
UH]PNH[L[OYV\NO[OLTLU\Z[Y\J[\YL
@V\ JHU YLZ[VYL [OL MHJ[VY` KLMH\S[ ZL[[PUNZ H[
HU`[PTLI`\ZPUN[OLr:,;sTLU\
zF"amVdF¦F
;OL VUÌIVHYK JVTW\[LY PZ VWLYH[LK ^P[O [OL
SV^LYSLM[SL]LYVU[OLZ[LLYPUNJVS\TU
:LSLJ[PUNM\UJ[PVUZVM[OLVUÍIVHYK
JVTW\[LY
7\ZOSL]LY\WVYKV^U
*VUMPYTPUNZLSLJ[PVU,U[LY
7\ZOSL]LYMVY^HYK
4V]PUNIHJRVULVYZL]LYHSZLSLJ[PVUSL]LSZ
7\SS[OLSL]LYIHJRVUJLVYZL]LYHS[PTLZ
5V[L!
@V\ JHU HS^H`Z YL[\YU [V [OL IHZPJ TLU\ I`
W\SSPUN[OLVWLYH[PUNSL]LYZL]LYHS[PTLZ
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
¤m4apm"m==azd"©zpa*adaaF
(Í:LSLJ[PVUMPLSK
)Í*VU[PU\H[PVUHYYV^Z`TIVS
*Í;VWKPZWSH`
+Í*LU[YHSKPZWSH`
,Í6UÍIVHYKJVTW\[LYKPZWSH`
)HZPJZL[[PUN
;VWKPZWSH`!6KVTL[LY
*LU[YHSKPZWSH`!;YPWVKVTL[LY
@V\ JHU JOHUNL IV[O KPZWSH`Z [V Z\P[ `V\Y
YLX\PYLTLU[ZI`\ZPUN[OLr:,;sTLU\
*HSSPUNVUÍIVHYKJVTW\[LYM\UJ[PVUZPU
KPZWSH`r,s
7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LY\WVYKV^U
ZLSLJ[PVUMPLSK(T\Z[ILZ^P[JOLKVMM
;OL MVSSV^PUN KPZWSH`Z JHU IL JHSSLK Z[LW I`
Z[LW!
u6\[ZPKL[LTWLYH[\YL-
u(]LYHNLZWLLK«TWO
u(]LYHNLJVUZ\TW[PVU«TWN
u9HUNLVUYLTHPUPUNM\LSTP )
u,UNPULIVVZ[WYLZZ\YLIHY
u5H]PNH[PVUPUMVYTH[PVU
PMHJ[P]H[LKPU[OLs:,;rTLU\
*HUHKH]LOPJSLZ!
;OL \UP[Z PU [OL VUÌIVHYK JVTW\[LY HYL KPZÌ
WSH`LKPURPSVTL[LYZSP[LYZHUK*
;OL ]HS\LZ r;YPW VKVTL[LYs r(]LYHNL ZWLLKs
HUKr(]LYHNLJVUZ\TW[PVUsJHUILYLZL[[VaLYV
\ZPUN[OLr)*sTLU\
5V[L
7\SSPUN [OL VWLYH[PUN SL]LY [V [OL YLHY [HRLZ
`V\ KPYLJ[S` MYVT H ]HS\L ^OPJO JHU IL YLZL[ [V
[OLr)*sTLU\
:^P[JOPUNZLSLJ[PVUMPLSKr(sVUVYVMM
7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYKVYIHJR
(YYV^Z`TIVSr)sMVYJVU[PU\H[PVU
(YYV^Z`TIVS¶!
7\ZO VWLYH[PUN SL]LY KV^U PU VYKLY [V JVUÌ
[PU\L[OLTLU\
(YYV^Z`TIVSD!
7\ZO VWLYH[PUN SL]LY \W PU VYKLY [V JVU[PU\L
[OLTLU\
C12
111
A B
C D E
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
4p¤a4§"mamVaVm"dOp
zFF=daha
;OLHJV\Z[PJ^HYUPUNZPNUHSJHUILHJ[P]H[LKMVY
ZWLLKZHIV]LTWORTO
;OL ZPNUHS ZV\UKZ PM [OL WYLZL[ ZWLLK PZ
L_JLLKLK
-VY[OLZPNUHS[VZV\UKHNHPU[OLKYP]PUNZWLLK
T\Z[ MHSS ILSV^ [OL WYLZL[ ZWLLK I` H[ SLHZ[
TWORTO
:^P[JOPUNVUZLSLJ[PVUMPLSKr(s
7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK
:L[[PUN[OLZWLLK
:LSLJ[r3040;s^P[O[OLVWLYH[PUNSL]LY
7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK
6W[PVU!
(JJLW[J\YYLU[ZWLLK
7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK
;OL HJV\Z[PJ ^HYUPUN ZPNUHS PZ HJ[P]H[LK MVY [OL
J\YYLU[ZWLLK
+PZWSH`!
6W[PVU!
7YLZL[ZWLLK
:LSLJ[ r3040; HJ[P]H[LKs ^P[O [OL VWLYH[PUN
SL]LY
UV[HJ[P]H[LK
HJ[P] H[LK
7YLZZ [OL VWLYH[PUN SL]LY MVY^HYK PM [OL rUV[
HJ[P]H[LKsKPZWSH`HWWLHYZ
<ZL [OL VWLYH[PUN SL]LY [V ZLSLJ[ rTWO s VY
rTWOus
7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK\U[PS[OLKLZPYLK
ZWLLKPZYLHJOLK
;OL HJV\Z[PJ ^HYUPUN ZPNUHS PZ HJ[P]H[LK MVY
[OLKLZPYLKZWLLK
:^P[JOPUN[OLHJV\Z[PJ^HYUPUNZPNUHSVMM
:LSLJ[ r3040; HJ[P]H[LKs ^P[O [OL VWLYH[PUN
SL]LY!
7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK
+PZWSH`!
C12
110
C12
113
C12
109
C12
121
C12
120
C12
119
G
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
"mamVhF"VF
:^P[JOPUNVUZLSLJ[PVUMPLSKr(s
7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK
*HSSPUN^HYUPUNTLZZHNLZ
:LSLJ[r*/,*2s^P[O[OLVWLYH[PUNSL]LY
7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK
(U` L_PZ[PUN ^HYUPUN TLZZHNLZ JHU IL JHSSLK
\ZPUN[OLVWLYH[PUNSL]LY
@V\HSZVJHUJHSS^HYUPUNTLZZHNLZ^OPJO^LYL
HJRUV^SLKNLK K\YPUN [OL QV\YUL` VUS` \U[PS [OL
UL_[[PTL[OLPNUP[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVU
7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK
C12
103
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
n
azd"©"m=hF"¤FhFmpO^FFmVamF
paddF¦Fd
*H\[PVU
9PZRVMLUNPULKHTHNL
9LN\SHYS`JOLJR[OLVPSSL]LSILMVYLYLM\LSSPUN
+V UV[ HSSV^ [OL VPS SL]LS [V MHSS ILSV^ [OL
TPUPT\TTHYR
*VUKP[PVUZMVYTLHZ\YPUN[OLVPSSL]LS
,UNPULPKSPUN
,UNPULPZH[VWLYH[PUN[LTWLYH[\YL
=LOPJSLPZSL]LS
=LOPJSLZ[H[PVUHY`
:^P[JOPUNVUZLSLJ[PVUMPLSKr(s
7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK
0UP[PH[PUNVPSSL]LSTLHZ\YLTLU[
:LSLJ[r603s^P[O[OLVWLYH[PUNSL]LY
7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK
7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK
4LHZ\YLTLU[PZZ[HY[LK
;OL ^HP[PUN[PTLMVYVPSSL]LSTLHZ\YLTLU[PZPUÌ
KPJH[LK I` H [PTL KPZWSH` HUK rJ`JSPUNs ZLNÌ
TLU[ZVM[OLVPSSL]LSKPZWSH`
6UJL [OL TLHZ\YLTLU[ OHZ ILLU JVTWSL[LK
`V\JHUYLHKVMM[OLLUNPULVPSSL]LSVU[OLZLNÌ
TLU[KPZWSH`
0M [OL VPS SL]LS OHZ MHSSLU ILSV^ [OL TPU THYR
[OLZLNTLU[ILSV^[OLTPUTHYRMSHZOLZ
;OL KPMMLYLUJL IL[^LLU [OL TPU HUK TH_
THYRZ VU [OL ZLNTLU[ KPZWSH` PZ HWWYV_
SP[YLZX\HY[Z
6UL ZLNTLU[ VM [OL KPZWSH` JVYYLZWVUKZ [V H
X\HU[P[`VMHWWYV_SP[YLX\HY[
;VW \W LUNPUL VPS 9LMLY [V [OL JOHW[LY r,UNPUL
VPSSL]LSs
5L]LYHKKTVYLLUNPULVPS[OHUYLX\PYLK[V
YLHJO[OLTH_THYR
0UMV
;OL r0UMVs M\UJ[PVU HSSV^Z `V\ [V JHSS [OL WYLÌ
YLX\PZP[LZMVYVPSSL]LSTLHZ\YLTLU[
-HPS\YL
(MHPS\YLVM[OLVPSSL]LSKPZWSH`PZPUKPJH[LKI`H
^HYUPUNTLZZHNLPU[OLVUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY
C12
117
C12
116
C12
106
C12
118
G¬
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
azd"©^F4cpaddF¦Fd
;OL JVTW\[LY KPZWSH` r*OLJR VPS SL]LSs PZ HU HKÌ
KP[PVUHSYLTPUKLY[V`V\[VJOLJR[OLVPSSL]LS
;OL KPZWSH` KLWLUKZ VU [OL KPZ[HUJL [YH]LSSLK
HUK [OL VWLYH[PUN JVUKP[PVUZ HUK KVLZ UV[ PUKPÌ
JH[L^OL[OLYVYUV[[OLVPSSL]LSPZJVYYLJ[
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
Gs
"ddamV"m=FFamVpm_*p"=
4phz¤FO¤m4apm
:^P[JOPUNVUZLSLJ[PVUMPLSKr(s
7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK
,_HTWSL!
9LZL[[PUNH]LYHNLJVUZ\TW[PVU
:LSLJ[r)*s^P[O[OLVWLYH[PUNSL]LY
7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK
:LSLJ[r«TWNs^P[O[OLVWLYH[PUNSL]LY
7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK
7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK
;OLH]LYHNLJVUZ\TW[PVUPZYLZL[[V
ruuu«TWNs
C12
115
G¢
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
"a4FamVpOpm_*p"=4phz¤F
:^P[JOPUNVUZLSLJ[PVUMPLSKr(s
7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK
*OHUNPUN[OLIHZPJZL[[PUNVM[OLVUÍIVHYK
JVTW\[LY
:LSLJ[r:,;s^P[O[OLVWLYH[PUNSL]LY
7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK
:LSLJ[ [OL KLZPYLKM\UJ[PVU^P[O[OLVWLYH[PUN
SL]LY!
9LZL[
9LZL[HSS
9LZL[[YPWJV\U[LY
9LZL[H]LYHNLJVUZ\TW[PVU
9LZL[H]LYHNLZWLLK
:WLLKVTL[LYRTTSZ
*OHUNLV]LYIL[^LLURPSVTL[YLZHUKTPSLZ
+PZWSH`
0UKP]PK\HSJVTIPUH[PVUVM\WWLYHUK
JLU[YHSSPULZVM[OLVUÍIVHYKJVTW\[LY
*OHUNPUN[VWKPZWSH`
Ì;V[HSTPSLHNL
Ì;YPWJV\U[LY
Ì(\KPVPUMVYTH[PVUZL[YHKPVZ[H[PVU
Ì6\[ZPKL[LTWLYH[\YL
Ì9HUNLVUYLTHPUPUNM\LS
Ì(]LYHNLZWLLK
Ì(]LYHNLJVUZ\TW[PVU
*OHUNPUNJLU[YHSKPZWSH`
Ì;V[HSTPSLHNL
Ì;YPWJV\U[LY
Ì6\[ZPKL[LTWLYH[\YL
Ì9HUNLVUYLTHPUPUNM\LS
Ì(]LYHNLZWLLK
Ì(]LYHNLJVUZ\TW[PVU
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
G
5H]PNH[PVU
0U[LNYH[LKPU[OLVUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY
UH]PNH[PVU PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ JHU IL YLJHSSLK PU [OL
VUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LYKPZWSH`
-VYHSS[\YUZ
UH]PNH[PVU PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ HYL KPZWSH`LK VUS`
WYPVY[VKPYLJ[PVUJOHUNLZ
)HZPJZL[[PUN
9LZ[VYL [OL IHZPJ ZL[[PUN VM [OL VUÌIVHYK
JVTW\[LY
3HUN\HNL
:LSLJ[SHUN\HNL]LYZPVU
*VUZ\TW[PVU
:LSLJ[\UP[MVYM\LSJVUZ\TW[PVU!
SRTTSZNHS<:(TWN<2RTS
;LTWLYH[\YL
:LSLJ[\UP[MVY[LTWLYH[\YL!
*-
OTVKL
:LSLJ[[PTLTVKL!
O ZTHSS ZX\HYLZ VU [OL SLM[ ZPKL VM [OL [PTL
KPZWSH`MVY(474
O
m_*p"=4phz¤F=azd"©
:^P[JOPUNVUZLSLJ[PVUMPLSKr(s
7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK
:^P[JOPUNVUÍIVHYKJVTW\[LYKPZWSH`VMM
:LSLJ[r6--s^P[O[OLVWLYH[PUNSL]LY
7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYK
+PZWSH`PZZ^P[JOLKVMM
:^P[JOPUNVUÍIVHYKJVTW\[LYKPZWSH`VU
HNHPU
7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYPUHU`KPYLJ[PVU
GT
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
FmF"damOph"apmFV"=amV^F
pm_*p"=4phz¤FO¤m4apm
9HUNLVUYLTHPUPUNM\LS
;OL YHUNL VU YLTHPUPUN M\LS PZ JVU[PU\V\ZS`
YLJVTW\[LK ^OPSL KYP]PUN IHZLK VU M\LS SL]LS
J\YYLU[JVUZ\TW[PVUHUKH]LYHNLJVUZ\TW[PVU
;OL TVYL [OL M\LS SL]LS MHSSZ [OL TVYL ZWVU[HÌ
ULV\ZS` [OL KPZWSH` YLHJ[Z -VY [OPZ YLHZVU
YHUNL VU YLTHPUPUN M\LS PZ UV[ KPZWSH`LK PM SLZZ
[OHURPSVTL[YLZ TPSLZ
0M [OL ]LOPJSLqZ PUJSPUH[PVU JOHUNLZ ^OPSL KYP]PUN
VY YLM\LSSPUN PUJVYYLJ[ YHUNL PUMVYTH[PVU TH`
[LTWVYHYPS`ILNP]LU
5V[L
0M [OL [HUR PZ ULHYS` LTW[` HUK `V\ HKK VUS` H
ZTHSS X\HU[P[` VM M\LS [OPZ JHUUV[ IL \ZLK [V
JHSJ\SH[L[OLYHUNLVUYLTHPUPUNM\LS
(]LYHNLJVUZ\TW[PVUHUKH]LYHNLZWLLK
;OL KPZWSH`LK ]HS\LZ HYL IHZLK VU [OL KPZ[HUJL
[YH]LSSLKZPUJL[OLSHZ[YLZL[[VraLYVs
@V\JHUZL[[OLZ[HY[PUN[PTLMVYHTLHZ\YLTLU[
ILMVYLVYK\YPUN[OL[YPW
:^P[JOPUN [OL PNUP[PVU VMM KVLZ UV[ YLZL[ [OL
TLHZ\YLTLU[Z =HS\LZ JHU [O\Z IL JVSSLJ[LK
V]LYSVUNWLYPVKZ
+PZJVUULJ[PUN [OL JHY IH[[LY` JSLHYZ [OLZL
TLTVYPLZ
6\[ZPKL[LTWLYH[\YL
;OL V\[ZPKL [LTWLYH[\YL KPZWSH` KVLZ UV[ PUKPÌ
JH[LPMPJLPZVU[OLYVHK
,]LU PM H [LTWLYH[\YL HIV]L - * PZ KPZÌ
WSH`LK PJL TH` Z[PSS MVYT VU [OL YVHK MVY PUÌ
Z[HUJL VU IYPKNLZ VY ^OLU [OL YVHK WHZZLZ
[OYV\NOHOLH]PS`ZOHKLKHYLH
mVamF*ppzF¤F
(Z[OLLUNPULPZLX\PWWLK^P[OHIVVZ[WYLZZ\YL
JVU[YVSMLH[\YL[OLIVVZ[WYLZZ\YLPZ]HYPHISL
;OL IVVZ[ WYLZZ\YL KLWLUKZ VU [OL HTIPLU[
WYLZZ\YL HUK VU [OL VJ[HUL YH[PUN VM [OL M\LS
\ZLK
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
GQ
"mamVam^Fm¤hFm"mFd"m=am^Fm_p"=phz¤F
0MH^HYUPUNTLZZHNLHWWLHYZHS^H`ZYLMLY[V[OLJVYYLZWVUKPUNJOHW[LYZPU[OL6^ULYqZ4HU\HS
>HYUPUNTLZZHNLZHYLPZZ\LKVUS`PMHSSTLHZ\YLTLU[WYLJVUKP[PVUZHYLTL[;OLYLMVYLJOLJRHSSMS\PKSL]LSZYLN\SHYS`u
PUWHY[PJ\SHYHS^H`ZJOLJR[OLLUNPULVPSSL]LSILMVYLYLM\LSSPUN
0UZ[Y\TLU[
WHULS
6UÍIVHYK
JVTW\[LY
;L_[KPZWSH`PU
VUÍIVHYKJVTW\[LY
4LHUPUNTLHZ\YL
:LH[ILS[
+YP]LYHUKWHZZLUNLYZT\Z[MHZ[LU[OLPY
ZHML[`ILS[Z
<:(
*HUHKH
/HUKIYHRL
/HUKIYHRLUV[YLSLHZLK
0NUP[PVURL`
UV[YLTV]LK
3PNO[ZVU
-YVU[YLHY
SPKUV[
JSVZLK
*SVZLSPKZWYVWLYS`
9LMPSS
^HZOLYMS\PK
;YPWJV\U[LY
YLZL[
;YPWVKVTL[LYPZYLZL[[V
G
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
0UZ[Y\TLU[
WHULS
6UÍIVHYK
JVTW\[LY
;L_[KPZWSH`PU
VUÍIVHYKJVTW\[LY
4LHUPUNTLHZ\YL
<UP[Z
HYLJOHUNLK
;OL\UP[ZRPSVTL[LYZTPSLZMVYZWLLKHUK
KPZ[HUJL^LYLJOHUNLK
3040;
*HUUV[IL
HJJLW[LK^P[O
]LOPJSLZ[VWWLK
*\YYLU[ZWLLKJHUILHJJLW[LKMVY[OL
HJV\Z[PJ^HYUPUNZPNUHSVUS`PM[OL]LOPJSLPZ
PUTV[PVU
<:(
*HUHKH
3040;
L_JLLKLK
:LSLJ[LKZWLLKSPTP[MVY[OLHJV\Z[PJ^HYUPUN
ZPNUHSOHZILLUL_JLLKLK
(KQ\Z[`V\YZWLLKPMULJLZZHY`
-\LSSL]LSNH\NL
^HYUPUNSPNO[
*VUZPKLYYHUNLVU
YLTHPUPUNM\LS
9LM\LSH[[OLUL_[VWWVY[\UP[`
,UNPULVPS
WYLZZ\YL
[VVSV^
:[VWPTTLKPH[LS`H[HZ\P[HISLWSHJL
TLHZ\YLVPSSL]LS^P[O[OLVUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY
HUKPMULJLZZHY`HKKLUNPULVPS
;LTWLYH[\YL
NH\NL^HYUPUN
SPNO[
,UNPUL
[LTWLYH[\YL
[VVOPNO
:^P[JOLUNPULVMMHUKSL[P[JVVS
*OLJRJVVSHU[SL]LSHUKPMULJLZZHY`
HKKJVVSHU[
;LTWLYH[\YL
NH\NL^HYUPUN
SPNO[MSHZOLZ
*OLJR
JVVSHU[SL]LS
:^P[JOLUNPULVMMHUKSL[P[JVVS
*OLJRJVVSHU[SL]LSHUKPMULJLZZHY`
HKKJVVSHU[
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
G
0UZ[Y\TLU[
WHULS
6UÍIVHYK
JVTW\[LY
;L_[KPZWSH`PU
VUÍIVHYKJVTW\[LY
4LHUPUNTLHZ\YL
*OLJR,UNPUL
9LMLY[VJOHW[LYs*OLJRLUNPUL^HYUPUNSPNO[r
/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK
7VYZJOLKLHSLY
;LTWLYH[\YL
NH\NL^HYUPUN
SPNO[MSHZOLZ
-HPS\YLVM
LUNPULÌ
JVTWHY[TLU[
ISV^LY
/H]LMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOL
KLHSLY
>HYUPUN
IH[[LY`
NLULYH[VY
:[VWPUHZHMLWSHJLHUKZ^P[JO[OLLUNPUL
VMM+VUV[JVU[PU\LKYP]PUN
/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK
7VYZJOLKLHSLY
-HPS\YLPUKPJH[VY
6PSWYLZZ\YLPUKPJH[VYPZMH\S[`
/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK
7VYZJOLKLHSLY
-HPS\YL
VPSSL]LS
PUKPJH[VY
/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK
7VYZJOLKLHSLY
-HPS\YLPUKPJH[VY
*VVSHU[[LTWLYH[\YLNH\NLPZMH\S[`
/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK
7VYZJOLKLHSLY
-HPS\YLPUKPJH[VY
;OLJVVSHU[[LTWLYH[\YLNH\NL[HJOVÌ
TL[LYVYJY\PZLJVU[YVSL[JJV\SKILMH\S[`
/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK
7VYZJOLKLHSLY
GG
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
0UZ[Y\TLU[
WHULS
6UÍIVHYK
JVTW\[LY
;L_[KPZWSH`PU
VUÍIVHYKJVTW\[LY
4LHUPUNTLHZ\YL
<:(
*HUHKH
:LY]PJL
^LHYVU
IYHRLWHKZ
/H]L[OLIYHRLWHKZYLWSHJLKH[HU
H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY^P[OV\[KLSH`
<:(
*HUHKH
>HYUPUN
IYHRL
MS\PKSL]LS
:[VWPTTLKPH[LS`PUHZ\P[HISLWSHJL
+VUV[JVU[PU\LKYP]PUN/H]L[OLMH\S[
YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
<:(
*HUHKH
>HYUPUN
IYHRL
KPZ[YPI\[PVU
:[VWPTTLKPH[LS`PUHZ\P[HISLWSHJL
+VUV[JVU[PU\LKYP]PUN/H]L[OLMH\S[
YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
<:(
*HUHKH
():MHPS\YL
/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK
7VYZJOLKLHSLY
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
Gn
0UZ[Y\TLU[
WHULS
6UÍIVHYK
JVTW\[LY
;L_[KPZWSH`PU
VUÍIVHYKJVTW\[LY
4LHUPUNTLHZ\YL
-HPS\YLPUKPJH[VY
;OLZWLLKVTL[LY():VY7:4^HYUPUNSPNO[Z
HUKZ`Z[LTZL[JJV\SKILMH\S[`
/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK
7VYZJOLKLHSLY
7:4MHPS\YL
/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK
7VYZJOLKLHSLY
(PYIHNMHPS\YL
/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK
7VYZJOLKLHSLY
-HPS\YL
ZWVPSLY
JVU[YVS
+YP]PUNZ[HIPSP[`PZPTWHPYLK
(KQ\Z[`V\YKYP]PUNZ[`SL
/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK
7VYZJOLKLHSLY
:LSLJ[VYSL]LY
WVZP[PVUPUKPJH[VY
MSHZOLZ
:LSLJ[VY
SL]LY
UV[LUNHNLK
:LSLJ[VYSL]LYJV\SKILIL[^LLU[^V
WVZP[PVUZ
,UNHNL[OLZLSLJ[VYSL]LYJVYYLJ[S`
:LSLJ[VYSL]LY
WVZP[PVUPUKPJH[VY
MSHZOLZ
;PW[YVUPJ
LTLYNLUJ`Y\U
/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK
7VYZJOLKLHSLY
-HPS\YLPUKPJH[VY
;OLKPZWSH`ZVMZL]LYHSZ`Z[LTZTPNO[OH]L
MHPSLK
/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK
7VYZJOLKLHSLY
-HPS\YLVMM\LS
SL]LSPUKPJH[VY
.V[V
^VYRZOVW
/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK
7VYZJOLKLHSLY
n¬
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
0UZ[Y\TLU[
WHULS
6UÍIVHYK
JVTW\[LY
;L_[KPZWSH`PU
VUÍIVHYKJVTW\[LY
4LHUPUNTLHZ\YL
-HPS\YLV\[ZPKL
[LTWLYH[\YL
PUKPJH[VY
/H]L[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK
7VYZJOLKLHSLY
4cmp§dF=VamV§"mamVhF"VF
>HYUPUNTLZZHNLZJHUILLYHZLK
MYVT[OLVUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LYKPZWSH`
7\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYVMVUÌIVHYK
JVTW\[LYMVY^HYK
@V\JHUYLJHSSLYHZLK^HYUPUNTLZZHNLZ
PU[OLr*/,*2sTLU\
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
ns
n¢
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
hFVFm4© d"^F§a4^
6WLYH[PVUHS YLHKPULZZ VM [OL LTLYNLUJ` MSHZOLY
KVLZ UV[ KLWLUK VU [OL PNUP[PVU SVJR HUK [\YU
ZPNUHSSL]LYWVZP[PVU
0M `V\Y JHY PZ KPZHISLK VY WHYRLK \UKLY LTLYÌ
NLUJ` JVUKP[PVUZ Z^P[JO VU [OL LTLYNLUJ`
MSHZOLYPU[OLKHZOIVHYKHYYV^
(SS [\YU ZPNUHSZ HUK [OL PUKPJH[VY SPNO[ PU [OL
Z^P[JOMSHZO^P[O[OLZHTLMYLX\LUJ`
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMHUHJJPKLU[
>OLUL]LY Z[HSSLK VY Z[VWWLK MVY LTLYNLUJ`
YLWHPYZ TV]L [OL JHY ^LSS VMM [OL YVHK
:^P[JO VU [OL LTLYNLUJ` MSHZOLY HUK THYR
[OL JHY ^P[O YVHK MSHYLZ VY V[OLY ^HYUPUN KLÌ
]PJLZ
+VUV[YLTHPUPU[OLJHY:VTLVULHWWYVHJOÌ
PUNMYVT[OLYLHYTH`UV[YLHSPaL`V\Y]LOPJSL
PZZ[VWWLKHUKJH\ZLHJVSSPZPVU
+HUNLYVMMPYL
+V UV[ WHYR VY VWLYH[L [OL ]LOPJSL PU HYLHZ
^OLYL [OL OV[ L_OH\Z[ Z`Z[LT TH` JVTL PU
JVU[HJ[ ^P[O KY` NYHZZ IY\ZO M\LS ZWPSS VY
V[OLYMSHTTHISLTH[LYPHS
/V[ LUNPUL JVTWHY[TLU[ JVTWVULU[Z JHU
I\YUZRPUVUJVU[HJ[
)LMVYL^VYRPUNVUHU`WHY[PU[OLLUNPULJVTÌ
WHY[TLU[ [\YU [OL LUNPUL VMM HUK SL[ P[ JVVS
KV^UZ\MMPJPLU[S`
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
n
aV^§a4^
3PNO[ZZ^P[JOLKVMM
7HYRPUN SPNO[Z ZPKL THYRLY SPNO[Z
SPJLUZL WSH[L SPNO[ PUZ[Y\TLU[ PSS\TPUHÌ
[PVU
3V^ILHTOPNOILHT
6US`^P[OPNUP[PVUVU
-VNSPNO[ZPUHKKP[PVU[V
WHYRPUNSPNO[ZVYSV^ILHT!
7\SSZ^P[JO[VMPYZ[JSPJR
0UKPJH[VYSPNO[VU
;OL MVN SPNO[Z ^PSS NV V\[ H\[VTH[PJHSS`
^OLU[OLOPNOILHTZHYLZ^P[JOLKVU
9LHYMVNSPNO[PUHKKP[PVU[V
[OLMVNSPNO[Z!
7\SSZ^P[JO[VZLJVUKJSPJR
0UKPJH[VYSPNO[VU
7HYRPUNSPNO[YPNO[SLM[
6US`^OLUPNUP[PVURL`PZ^P[OKYH^U!
7\SSZ^P[JOV\[ZSPNO[S`PUWVZP[PVUsr
HUK[\YU[V
uWHYRPUNÌSPNO[WVZP[PVUSLM[
uWHYRPUNÌSPNO[WVZP[PVUYPNO[
7HYRPUNSPNO[ZHUKZPKLTHYRLYSPNO[Z
HYLSP[VU[OLZLSLJ[LKZPKL
0M [OL PNUP[PVU RL` PZ ^P[OKYH^U HUK [OL KVVY PZ
VWLULK ^OPSL [OL SPNO[Z UV[ [OL WHYRPUN SPNO[
SLM[YPNO[HYLVUHNVUN^HYUZVMWVZZPISLIH[Ì
[LY`KPZJOHYNL
0U ZVTL JV\U[YPLZ KPMMLYLUJLZ HYL WVZZPISL
K\L[VWYV]PZPVUZVMSH^
¤ph"a4F"=daV^F"h
=b¤hFm
>OLU[OLPNUP[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVU[OLSL]LSVM[OL
OLHKSPNO[ILHTH\[VTH[PJHSS`JOHUNLZPUHJJVYKÌ
HUJL^P[O[OL]LOPJSLSVHK
;OL SL]LS VM [OL OLHKSPNO[ ILHT PZ H\[VTH[PJHSS`
RLW[JVUZ[HU[K\YPUNHJJLSLYH[PVUHUKIYHRPUN
*OLJRPUNVWLYH[PVU
:^P[JO[OLSV^ILHTVU
:^P[JOPNUP[PVUVU
;OL SPNO[ ILHT MPYZ[ KPWZ HSS [OL ^H` KV^U
HUKPZ[OLUHKHW[LK[V[OL]LOPJSLSVHK
0[ [OPZ [LZ[ P[LT PZ UV[ TL[ [OL OLHKSPNO[
ILHT HKQ\Z[TLU[ T\Z[ IL JOLJRLK I` HU
H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
●
nT
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
¤maVm"d
F"=daV^ahhF d"^FF¦F
;\YUZPNUHSZSV^ILHTHUKOPNOILHTHYLYLHK`
MVYVWLYH[PVU^OLU[OLPNUP[PVUPZVU
u ;\YUZPNUHSSLM[
u ;\YUZPNUHSYPNO[
u /PNOILHT
u /LHKSPNO[MSHZOLY
3L]LYPUJLU[LYWVZP[PVUu3V^ILHT
>OLU OPNO ILHT HUK OLHKSPNO[ MSHZOLY HYL ZLÌ
SLJ[LK[OLIS\LPUKPJH[VYSPNO[PU[OL[HJOVTL[LY
PZSP[
;OL [\YU ZPNUHS SL]LY [\YUZ VMM H\[VTH[PJHSS`
^OLU [OL Z[LLYPUN ^OLLS PZ Z[YHPNO[LULK V\[
HM[LYJVTWSL[PUNH[\YU
"mF4^"mVF
;V PUKPJH[L `V\Y PU[LU[PVU ^OLU JOHUNPUN
SHULZ VU [OL MYLL^H` ZSPNO[S` SPM[ VY KLWYLZZ
[OLSL]LY[V[OLYLZPZ[HUJLWVPU[
;OLSL]LY^PSSYL[\YU[V[OL6--WVZP[PVU^OLU
YLSLHZLK
0M [OL MYLX\LUJ` VM [OL KPZWSH` ILJVTLZ UVÌ
[PJLHISL MHZ[LY JOLJR [OL VWLYH[PVU VM [OL
[\YUZPNUHSI\SIZ
F"=daV^Od"^F
>P[OPNUP[PVUVUVYVMM
;V MSHZO [OL OLHKSPNO[Z [V VUJVTTPUN TV[VYÌ
PZ[ZZSPNO[S`W\SS[OLSL]LY[V^HYK[OLZ[LLYPUN
^OLLSHUK[OLUYLSLHZLP[
;OL IS\L PUKPJH[VY SPNO[ PU [OL [HJOVTL[LY ^PSS
NVVUVMMHZ`V\W\SSYLSLHZL[OLSL]LY
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
nQ
am=^aFd=azF"^FF¦F
*H\[PVU
+HUNLYVMPUQ\Y`^OLU[OL^PUKZOPLSK^PWLYZ
VWLYH[L\UPU[LU[PVUHSS`
9PZRVMKHTHNL[V[OL^PUKZOPLSKHUK^PWLY
Z`Z[LT
(]VPK Y\UUPUN [OL ^PWLY ISHKLZ V]LY H KY`
^PUKZOPLSK [V WYL]LU[ ZJYH[JOPUN [OL NSHZZ
:WYH`^HZOLYMS\PKVU[OL^PUKZOPLSKMPYZ[
(ZJYH[JOLK^PUKZOPLSK^PSSYLK\JL]PZPIPSP[`
(S^H`ZSVVZLU^PWLYISHKLZMYVTMYVaLUNSHZZ
ILMVYLVWLYH[PUN^PWLYZ[VWYL]LU[KHTHNL[V
[OL^PWLYTV[VYVYISHKLZ
(S^H`Z Z^P[JO VMM ^PUKZOPLSK ^PWLYZ PU JHY
^HZO [V WYL]LU[ [OLT ^PWPUN \UPU[LU[PVUHSS`
PU[LYTP[[LU[VYZLUZVYVWLYH[PVU
(S^H`Z Z^P[JO VMM ^PUKZOPLSK ^PWLYZ ILMVYL
JSLHUPUN [OL ^PUKZOPLSK [V H]VPK \UPU[LU[PVUHS
VWLYH[PVUPU[LYTP[[LU[VYZLUZVYVWLYH[PVU
+V UV[ VWLYH[L [OL OLHKSPNO[ ^HZOLY PU JHY
^HZOLZ
+V UV[ VWLYH[L OLHKSPNO[ ^HZOLY ^OLU P[ PZ
MYVaLU
u >PUKZOPLSK^PWLYZVMM
u >PUKZOPLSK^PWLYZZSV^
u >PUKZOPLSK^PWLYZMHZ[
u 0U[LYTP[[LU[VWLYH[PVU
u >PUKZOPLSK^HZOLYZ`Z[LT!
:WYH`Z^OPSL[OLSL]LYPZW\SSLK[V^HYKZ[OL
Z[LLYPUN^OLLSPU[OLMPYZ[WVZP[PVU
>OLU [OL SL]LY PZ YLSLHZLK H ML^ KY`PUN
^PWLZHYLL_LJ\[LK
u >PUKZOPLSK^PWLYZHUK^HZOLYZ`Z[LT!
:WYH`Z HUK ^PWLZ ^OPSL [OL SL]LY PZ W\SSLK
[V^HYKZ [OL Z[LLYPUN ^OLLS PU [OL ZLJVUK
WVZP[PVU
u /LHKSPNO[^HZOLY!
:WYH`ZVUS`^OPSLSV^ILHTVYOPNOILHTPZ
Z^P[JOLKVU
;OL ZWYH` K\YH[PVU PZ SPTP[LK 0M OLH]PS`
ZVPSLKYLWLH[^HZO
7LYZPZ[LU[ KPY[ LN PUZLJ[ YLTHPUZ ZOV\SK
ILYLN\SHYS`YLTV]LK
:LL[OLJOHW[LYVUs*HY*HYL0UZ[Y\J[PVUZr
5V[L
;OL ^PUKZOPLSK ^HZOLY UVaaSLZ HYL OLH[LK
^OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ VU HZ H WYLJH\[PVU HNHPUZ[
MYLLaPUN
n
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
azFamF¦"d4pmpd
0U^PUKZOPLSK^PWLYPU[LYTP[[LU[TVKL[OL^PWL
PU[LY]HSZ JHU IL PUMPUP[LS` HKQ\Z[LK UV[ PU ]LÌ
OPJSLZ^P[OHYHPUZLUZVY
:OVY[LUPUN^PWLPU[LY]HSZ
;\YU[O\TI^OLLS(JSVJR^PZL
3LUN[OLUPUN^PWLPU[LY]HSZ
;\YU[O\TI^OLLS(JV\U[LYÌJSVJR^PZL
"amFmp
0U]LOPJSLZ^P[OHYHPUZLUZVY[OLHTV\U[VMYHPU
VY ZUV^ ^OPJO OHZ ZL[[SLK VU [OL ^PUKZOPLSK PZ
TLHZ\YLK ;OL ^PWLY ZWLLK PZ JVU[YVSSLK
HJJVYKPUNS` IL[^LLU PU[LYTP[[LU[ HUK JVU[PU\V\Z
VWLYH[PVU^PWLYZWLLKHUK
:^P[JOPUNYHPUZLUZVYVU
4V]L^PWLYSL]LYPUWVZP[PVU
:^P[JOPUNYHPUZLUZVYVMM
4V]L^PWLYSL]LYPUWVZP[PVU
5V[L
;OL YHPU ZLUZVY YLTHPUZ Z^P[JOLK VMM PM [OL
^PWLYSL]LYPZHSYLHK`PUWVZP[PVU^OLU[OLPNUPÌ
[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVU
;VZ^P[JO[OLYHPUZLUZVYVU!
4V]L^PWLYSL]LY[VWVZP[PVUHUK[OLUIHJR
[VWVZP[PVUVY
6WLYH[L^PUKZOPLSK^HZOLYZ`Z[LTVY
*OHUNL [OL ZLUZP[P]P[` VM [OL YHPU ZLUZVY ^P[O
[OL[O\TI^OLLS
:^P[JOÌVU PZ JVUMPYTLK I`VUL^PWLVM[OL^PUKÌ
ZOPLSK
*OHUNPUN[OLZLUZP[P]P[`VM[OLYHPU
ZLUZVY
:LUZP[P]P[`JHUILZL[^P[O[OL[O\TI^OLLS(PU
Z[HNLZ
;\YU [O\TI ^OLLS ( JV\U[LYÌJSVJR^PZL Ì SV^
ZLUZP[P]P[`
;\YU [O\TI ^OLLS ( JSVJR^PZL Ì OPNO ZLUZP[P]Ì
P[`
;OL ZL[[PUN PZ JVUMPYTLK I` VUL ^PWL VM [OL
^PUKZOPLSK
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
n
(Í(\[VTH[PJZWLLKJVU[YVSYLHKPULZZVMMVU
Í/VSKHUKZ[VYLHJJLSLYH[L
Í+LJLSLYH[LYLZ\TL
Í0U[LYY\W[
¤ph"a4zFF=pmpd
;OL H\[VTH[PJ ZWLLK JVU[YVS THPU[HPUZ HU`
ZLSLJ[LKZWLLKIL[^LLUTWOHUKTWO
RTO HUK RTO ^P[OV\[ `V\ OH]PUN [V
\ZL[OLHJJLSLYH[VY
;OL H\[VTH[PJ ZWLLK JVU[YVS PZ VWLYH[LK ^P[O
[OLSL]LYVU[OLZ[LLYPUN^OLLS
>HYUPUN
(JVUZ[HU[ZWLLKTH`UV[ILZHMLPUOLH]`
[YHMMPJVYVU^PUKPUNVYZSPWWLY`YVHKZ
>P[O [OL ZWLLK JVU[YVS Z`Z[LT LUNHNLK
[OL LUNPUL ZWLLK ^PSS UV[ YL[\YU [V PKSL
^OLU YLTV]PUN [OL MVV[ MYVT [OL HJJLSLYHÍ
[VYWLKHS
+VUV[\ZL[OLZWLLKJVU[YVS^OLUP[TH`IL
\UZHML[VRLLW[OLJHYH[HJVUZ[HU[ZWLLK
6IZLY]LHSSSVJHSHUKUH[PVUHSZWLLKSPTP[Z
§a4^"¤ph"a4zFF=4pmpd
F"=amFpm
7YLZZ I\[[VU ( VU [OL H\[VTH[PJ ZWLLK JVUÌ
[YVSSL]LY
;OPZNYLLUPUKPJH[VYSPNO[PU[OL
ZWLLKVTL[LYUV^PUKPJH[LZYLHKPULZZ
pd="m=pFzFF=
)YPUN [OL JHY [V [OL KLZPYLK ZWLLK ^P[O [OL
HJJLSLYH[VY
;OLUW\ZOVWLYH[PUNSL]LYMVY^HYKIYPLMS`
44FdF"amV|FVpp¦F"cF}
0UJYLHZLZWLLKHZ\Z\HS^P[O[OLHJJLSLYH[VY
>OLU[OLHJJLSLYH[VYPZYLSLHZLK[OLWYL]PV\ZS`
ZH]LK]HS\LPZHNHPUZL[
(\[VTH[PJ ZWLLK JVU[YVS VWLYH[PVU PZ H\[VTH[Ì
PJHSS` PU[LYY\W[LK OV^L]LY PM [OL ZWLLK PZ PUÌ
JYLHZLKI`TVYL[OHUHIV\[TWORTO
MVYSVUNLY[OHUZLJVUKZVY!
7YLZZ VWLYH[PUN SL]LY MVY^HYK \U[PS [OL
KLZPYLKZWLLKPZYLHJOLK
;OL ZWLLK YLHJOLK PZ THPU[HPULK HUK Z[VYLK
^OLU[OLSL]LYPZYLSLHZLK
:WLLKJHUILJVYYLJ[LKPUZ[LWZVMRTOHWÌ
WYV_ TWO I` IYPLMS` W\ZOPUN [OL SL]LY MVYÌ
^HYKVYKV^U\W[V[PTLZ
nG
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
F4FdF"amV
7YLZZVWLYH[PUNSL]LYKV^U\U[PS[OLKLZPYLK
ZWLLKPZYLHJOLK
;OL ZWLLK YLHJOLK PZ THPU[HPULK HUK Z[VYLK
^OLU[OLSL]LYPZYLSLHZLK
:WLLKJHUILJVYYLJ[LKPUZ[LWZVMRTOHWÌ
WYV_ TWO I` IYPLMS` W\ZOPUN [OL SL]LY MVYÌ
^HYKVYKV^U\W[V[PTLZ
mF¤zamV"¤ph"a4zFF=4pmpd
pzF"apm
7\SS VWLYH[PUN SL]LY IYPLMS` [V^HYKZ [OL Z[LLYÌ
PUN^OLLSVY!
6WLYH[LIYHRLVYJS\[JOWLKHSVY
^P[O ;PW[YVUPJ [YHUZTPZZPVU ZLSLJ[ WVZP[PVU
s5r:LLHSZV[OLJOHW[LYVUs;PW[YVUPJr
;OL ZWLLK KYP]LU ILMVYL [OL PU[LYY\W[PVU YLÌ
THPUZZ[VYLKPU[OLTLTVY`
(\[VTH[PJ ZWLLK JVU[YVS VWLYH[PVU PZ PU[LYÍ
Y\W[LKH\[VTH[PJHSS`!
0M [OL ZL[ ZWLLK PZ L_JLLKLK I` TVYL [OHU
TWO RTO MVY SVUNLY [OHU ZLJÌ
VUKZ
PM [OL HJ[\HS ZWLLK MHSSZ [V TWO RTO
ILSV^[OLZL[]LOPJSLZWLLKMVYSVUNLY[OHU
ZLJVUKZ\W^HYKZSVWLZ
F¤hamV^FpF=zFF=
7YLZZVWLYH[PUNSL]LYIYPLMS`KV^U
;OLZ[VYLKZWLLKZOV\SKVUS`ILJHSSLK\W^OLU
[YHMMPJ JVUKP[PVUZ HUK [OL YVHK Z\YMHJL ZV WLYÌ
TP[
§a4^amV"¤ph"a4zFF=4pmpd
F"=amFpOO
7YLZZ I\[[VU ( VU [OL H\[VTH[PJ ZWLLK JVUÌ
[YVSSL]LY
;OLNYLLUYLHKPULZZSPNO[PU[OLZWLLKVTL[LY
NVLZVMM
>OLU [OL ]LOPJSL PZ WHYRLK HUK [OL PNUP[PVU
Z^P[JOLKVMM[OLTLTVY`PZJSLHYLK
0TWVY[HU[UV[L
6U \W^HYK VY KV^U^HYK ZSVWLZ [OL ZL[ ZWLLK
JHUUV[ HS^H`Z IL THPU[HPULK I` [OL H\[VTH[PJ
ZWLLKJVU[YVS
;V VI[HPU Z\MMPJPLU[ LUNPUL IYHRPUN VY H IL[[LY
LUNPULÌZWLLK YHUNL [OLYLMVYL `V\ OH]L [V ZLÌ
SLJ[HSV^LYNLHY
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
nn
¤ph"a4apm=aapmamV
;OL HPYÌJVUKP[PVUPUN Z`Z[LT JVU[YVSZ [OL WYLZLÌ
SLJ[LK PU[LYPVY [LTWLYH[\YL JVTWSL[LS` H\[VTH[Ì
PJHSS`
0M ULJLZZHY` [OL H\[VTH[PJ Z`Z[LT JHU IL THÌ
U\HSS`VWLYH[LK
3LM[KPZWSH`WHULSu
;LTWLYH[\YLHUKHJ[P]LM\UJ[PVUZ
9PNO[KPZWSH`WHULSu
)SV^LYZWLLKHUKHJ[P]LM\UJ[PVUZ
¤ph"a4pzF"apm
7YLZZsH\[VrI\[[VU
(PY X\HU[P[` HUK KPZ[YPI\[PVU HYL H\[VTH[PJHSS`
JVU[YVSSLKHUK]HYPH[PVUZHYLJVTWLUZH[LK
(SSH\[VTH[PJZL[[PUNM\UJ[PVUZJHUILPUKP]PK\HSS`
JOHUNLK
;OPZZL[[PUNPZYL[HPULK\U[PS[OLHWWYVWYPH[LM\UJÌ
[PVUI\[[VUPZWYLZZLKHNHPUVY[OLsH\[VrI\[[VU
PZWYLZZLK
JFhzF"¤FFamV
7YLZZ[OLHWWYVWYPH[LI\[[VU
;V Z\P[ WLYZVUHS JVTMVY[ [OL PU[LYPVY [LTWLYHÌ
[\YL JHU IL ZLSLJ[LK IL[^LLU - HUK -
*HUK *
9LJVTTLUKH[PVU!-*
0M[OLKPZWSH`s36rVYs/0rHWWLHYZ[OLZ`Z[LTPZ
VWLYH[PUNH[TH_PT\TJVVSPUNVYOLH[PUNWV^LY
5V[L
0M [OL WYLZLSLJ[LK [LTWLYH[\YL PZ JOHUNLK [OL
ISV^LYZWLLKJHUPUJYLHZLH\[VTH[PJHSS`PUH\[VÌ
TH[PJVWLYH[PVU
;OL KLZPYLK [LTWLYH[\YL PZ YLHJOLK TVYL
X\PJRS`[OPZ^H`
s¬¬
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
FOpamV^F§am=^aFd=
7YLZZI\[[VU
>PUKZOPLSK PZ KLTPZ[LK VY KLMYVZ[LK HZ
X\PJRS`HZWVZZPISL
(PYMSV^Z[V[OL^PUKZOPLSKVUS`
§a4^amV4phzFpOp
"a_4pm=aapmamV©FhpmppOO
>OLUL]LY
V\[ZPKL
[LTWLYH[\YLZ
L_JLLK
-* [OL HPYÌJVUKP[PVUPUN JVTWYLZZVY PZ HSÌ
^H`ZZ^P[JOLKVUPUH\[VTH[PJVWLYH[PVU
;OL JVTWYLZZVY JHU IL Z^P[JOLK VMM [V ZH]L
M\LSI\[JVU[YVSJVTMVY[PZ[OLUSPTP[LK
7YLZZI\[[VU
;OL JVTWYLZZVY PZ Z^P[JOLK VMM [OL Z`TIVS
PU[OLSLM[ÌOHUKKPZWSH`NVLZV\[
0M [OL PU[LYPVY [LTWLYH[\YL PZ [VV OPNO Z^P[JO
JVTWYLZZVYIHJRVUVYWYLZZsH\[VsÌI\[[VU
;V KY` PUJVTPUN HPY PU KHTW ^LH[OLY KV UV[
Z^P[JOVMM[OLHPYÌJVUKP[PVUPUNJVTWYLZZVY
;OPZWYL]LU[ZTPZ[PUNVM^PUKV^Z
J=b¤amV*dp§FzFF=
7YLZZ[OLHWWYVWYPH[LI\[[VU
7YLZL[ ISV^LY ZWLLK PZ PUJYLHZLK VY KLÌ
JYLHZLK HUK r4HU\HSs HWWLHYZ PU [OL YPNO[Ì
OHUKKPZWSH`MPLSK
;OLZWLLKZ[HNLZHYLPUKPJH[LKI`H
IHYKPZWSH`
0M [OL TPU\Z I\[[VU PZ WYLZZLK H[ [OL SV^LZ[
ISV^LY Z[HNL [OL ISV^LY HUK H\[VTH[PJ JVU[YVS
HYLZ^P[JOLKVMM
s6--rPZKPZWSH`LKPU[OLSLM[ÌOHUKKPZWSH`
7YLZZPUNVU[OLWS\ZI\[[VUVY[OLsH\[VrI\[[VU
Z^P[JOLZ[OLISV^LYHUKH\[VTH[PJJVU[YVSIHJR
VUHNHPU
a4¤d"amV_"aFamV
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMHJJPKLU[K\L[VOHTWLYLK]PZPVU
0U JPYJ\SH[PUNÍHPY ZL[[PUN [OL ^PUKV^Z JHU
TPZ[\W
6US` ZLSLJ[ JPYJ\SH[PUNÌHPY ZL[[PUN MVY ZOVY[
WLYPVKZ
0M ^PUKV^Z TPZ[ \W [\YU VMM [OL JPYJ\SH[PUNÌHPY
ZL[[PUN I` WYLZZPUN [OL JPYJ\SH[PUNÌHPY I\[[VU
IYPLMS` HUK ZLSLJ[ [OL M\UJ[PVU s+LMYVZ[ ^PUKÌ
ZOPLSKr
:^P[JOPUNJPYJ\SH[PUNÍHPYZL[[PUN
VUVYVMM
7YLZZI\[[VU
;OL V\[ZPKLÌHPY Z\WWS` PZ PU[LYY\W[LK HUK VUS`
[OLPUZPKLHPYPZJPYJ\SH[LK
6]LYHWWYV_-*
0M [OL HPYÌJVUKP[PVUPUN JVTWYLZZVY ^HZ VMM P[
Z^P[JOLZVUH\[VTH[PJHSS`;OLK\YH[PVUVMJPYJ\Ì
SH[PUNÌHPYTVKLPZUV[SPTP[LK
)LSV^HWWYV_-*
;OL HPYÌJVUKP[PVUPUN JVTWYLZZVY PZ Z^P[JOLK VMM
*PYJ\SH[PUNÌHPY TVKL PZ H\[VTH[PJHSS` LUKLK HM[LY
HWWYV_TPU\[LZ
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
s¬s
a=aa*¤apmpOpp§Fdd
7YLZZI\[[VU
;OLHPYMSV^Z[V[OLMVV[^LSS
a=aa*¤apmp^F
4Fm"d"m=a=F¦Fm
7YLZZI\[[VU
;OLHPYMSV^ZMYVT[OLJLU[YHSHUKZPKL]LU[Z
=LU[ZT\Z[ILVWLU
a=aa*¤apmp
§am=^aFd=
7YLZZI\[[VU
;OLHPYMSV^Z[V[OL^PUKZOPLSK
FmF"dam¤4apmOp
"a_4pm=aapmamV4phzFp
*HU Z^P[JO VMM IYPLMS` PM LUNPUL PZ \UKLY HU
L_[YLTLSVHK[VLUZ\YLZ\MMPJPLU[LUNPULJVVSÌ
PUN
:^P[JOLZ VMM H\[VTH[PJHSS` H[ [LTWLYH[\YLZ
ILSV^ -* HUK JHUUV[ IL Z^P[JOLK VU
L]LUTHU\HSS`
6WLYH[LZ TVZ[ LMMLJ[P]LS` ^P[O ^PUKV^Z
JSVZLK
0M[OLJHYOHZILLUPU[OLZ\UMVYHSVUN[PTL
OV^L]LY P[ PZ H NVVK PKLH [V ]LU[PSH[L [OL PUÌ
[LYPVYIYPLMS`^P[OKVVY^PUKV^ZVWLU
+LWLUKPUNVU[OLV\[ZPKL[LTWLYH[\YLHUKO\Ì
TPKP[` JVUKLUZH[PVU JHU KYPW MYVT [OL L]HWÌ
VYH[VYHUKMVYTHWVVS\UKLY[OLJHY
;OPZPZUVYTHSHUKUV[HZPNUVMSLHRHNL
0M\UJVVSLKHPYMSV^ZV\[^OLU[OLSV^LZ[[LTÌ
WLYH[\YL OHZ ILLU ZL[ Z^P[JO VMM [OL HPYÌJVUÌ
KP[PVUPUN JVTWYLZZVY HUK JVUZ\S[ ^P[O HU
H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
s¢
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
(Í*VU[PU\V\ZVWLUPUNHUKJSVZPUN
)Í:L[[PUN]LU[KPYLJ[PVU
Fm"d"m=a=FFm
zFmamV¦Fm
9V[H[LRU\YSLK^OLLS\W^HYK
dpamV¦Fm
9V[H[LRU\YSLK^OLLSKV^U^HYK
^"mVamV"aOdp§=aF4apm
4V]L [OL ]HULZ [V THRL [OL HPY MSV^ PU [OL
KLZPYLKKPYLJ[PVU
6\[ZPKL HPY VY JVUKP[PVULK HPY JHU IL KLSP]LYLK
MYVT HSS ]LU[Z KLWLUKPUN VU [OL HPYÌKPZ[YPI\[PVU
ZL[[PUNVU[OLVWLYH[PUNWHULS
F^_"aam"cF
;VLUZ\YLWYVWLYHPYPU[HRL!
2LLW [OL MYLZOÌHPY PUSL[ IL[^LLU [OL S\NNHNL
JVTWHY[TLU[ SPK HUK [OL ^PUKZOPLSK MYLL
MYVTZUV^PJLHUKSLH]LZ
●
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
s¬
^"©
zFmamV
7YLZZHZO[YH`SPKIYPLMS`
hz©amV
6WLU HZO[YH` HUK JHYLM\SS` W\SS V\[ HZOPUZLY[
I`[OLSPK
>HYUPUN
+HUNLYVMMPYL
5L]LY \ZL HZO[YH` MVY ^HZ[L WHWLY KPZWVZHS
HZP[JV\SKWVZLHMPYLOHaHYK
aV"FFaV^F
>HYUPUN
+HUNLYVMMPYLHUKI\YUPUN
;OL JPNHYL[[L SPNO[LY PZ YLHK` MVY \ZL YLÍ
NHYKSLZZVM[OLPNUP[PVUSVJRWVZP[PVU
5L]LYSLH]L\UZ\WLY]PZLKJOPSKYLUPU[OLJHY
5L]LY [V\JO [OL OLH[PUN LSLTLU[ VY ZPKLZ VM
[OLSPNO[LY
/VSK[OLSPNO[LYI`[OLRUVIVUS`
F"amVdaV^F
7\ZOPURUVIVM[OLJPNHYL[[LSPNO[LY
>OLU YLHK` MVY \ZL [OL SPNO[LY ^PSS ZUHW
IHJR
zF"amV"==aapm"d"zzda"m4F
>P[O [OL JPNHYL[[L SPNO[LY YLTV]LK [OL ZVJRL[
TH` IL \ZLK MVY ZTHSS LSLJ[YPJHS HWWSPHUJLZ
Z\JOHZHZOH]LYVYOHUK]HJ\\TJSLHULY
4H_PT\TYH[PUN!>H[[
+VUV[VWLYH[LLSLJ[YPJHSHWWSPHUJLZMVYTVYL
[OHUTPU\[LZ^OLULUNPULPZVMMIH[[LY`^PSS
V[OLY^PZLKPZJOHYNL
+VUV[KHTHNL[OLZVJRL[I`[Y`PUN[VPUZLY[
WS\NZVM[OL^YVUNKLZPNU
s¬T
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
F"azF
*H\[PVU
9PZR VM KHTHNL [V [OL YLHY ^PUKV^ HUK
^PWLYISHKL
6US` ^PWL [OL YLHY ^PUKV^ ^OLU Z\MMPJPLU[S`
^L[V[OLY^PZLP[JV\SKILZJYH[JOLK
-YLLMYVaLU^PWLYISHKLZILMVYLZL[[PUNVMM
:^P[JOPUNVU
;V\JO [OL Z`TIVS VU [OL YVJRLY Z^P[JO Ì [OL
YLHY^PWLY^PWLZ[^PJL
¤map
:^PUN [OL Z\U ]PZVYZ KV^U [V WYL]LU[ NSHYL
MYVT[OLMYVU[
;VWYL]LU[NSHYLMYVT[OLZPKL\UJSPW[OLZ\U
]PZVYMYVT[OLPUULYIYHJRL[HUKZ^P]LSYV\UK
ZV[OH[P[PZPUMYVU[VM[OLKVVY^PUKV^
"ma©hap
;OL]HUP[`TPYYVYVU[OLYLHYVM[OLZ\U]PZVYPZ
JV]LYLKI`HSPK
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMPUQ\Y`
2LLW[OLSPKJSVZLK^OPSLKYP]PUN
0U [OL JHZL VM HU PSS\TPUH[LK ]HUP[` TPYYVY [OL
SPNO[PZZ^P[JOLKVU^OLU[OLSPKPZVWLULK
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
s¬Q
(*Í:^P[JOMVYYLHKPUNSPNO[VUKYP]LYqZ
WHZZLUNLYqZZPKL
)Í0U[LYPVYSPNO[Z^P[JO
+Í6YPLU[H[PVUSPNO[Z^P[JO
,Í6YPLU[H[PVUSPNO[
mFapdaV^
7SLHZLVIZLY]L[OLJOHW[LYr3VHKZ^P[JOÌVMMs
5V[L
:^P[JO VMM [OL H\[VTH[PJ HU[PÌNSHYL VWLYH[PVU
VM [OL TPYYVYZ ILMVYL `V\ Z^P[JO VU [OL PU[LÌ
YPVYSPNO[
6[OLY^PZL [OL TPYYVYZ TPNO[ HJJPKLU[HSS` NV
PU[VHU[PÌNSHYLVWLYH[PVU
mFapdaV^:F"=amVdaV^
:^P[JOPUNVMM
7YLZZSLM[OHSMVMZ^P[JO
:^P[JOPUN[VJVU[PU\V\ZPSS\TPUH[PVU
7YLZZYPNO[OHSMVMZ^P[JO
:^P[JOPUNVUHUKVMMH\[VTH[PJHSS`
4V]LSPNO[SLUZ[VJLU[LYWVZP[PVU
;OLPU[LYPVYSPNO[PZZ^P[JOLKVU^OLUHKVVY
PZ \USVJRLK VY VWLULK VY ^OLU [OL PNUP[PVU
RL`PZ^P[OKYH^UMYVT[OLPNUP[PVUSVJR
;OLPU[LYPVYSPNO[PZZ^P[JOLKVMM^P[OHKLSH`
VM HWWYV_ ZLJVUKZ HM[LY [OL KVVY PZ
JSVZLK
;OL PU[LYPVY SPNO[ NVLZ V\[ PTTLKPH[LS` HZ
ZVVUHZ[OLPNUP[PVURL`PZPUZLY[LKPU[OLPNUPÌ
[PVUSVJRVY[OL]LOPJSLPZSVJRLK
aFm"apmdaV^
3PNO[ÌLTP[[PUN KPVKLZ PU [OL KVVYZ HUK PU [OL
IYHJRL[VM[OLPU[LYPVYTPYYVYPTWYV]L`V\YVYPLUÌ
[H[PVUPUZPKL[OL]LOPJSL^OLUP[PZKHYR
;OL SPNO[ÌLTP[[PUN KPVKLZ HYL Z^P[JOLK VU ^OLU
[OL ]LOPJSL PZ \USVJRLK HUK Z^P[JOLK VMM HNHPU
^OLU[OL]LOPJSLPZSVJRLK
3PNO[ÍLTP[[PUNKPVKLPU[OLIYHJRL[VM[OL
PU[LYPVYTPYYVY
*OHUNPUN [OL IYPNO[ULZZ VM [OL SPNO[ÌLTP[[PUN
KPVKL!
7YLZZZ^P[JO+
;OLIYPNO[ULZZJOHUNLZ
s¬
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
pp§FddaV^
;OLSPNO[ZHYLZ^P[JOLKVUH\[VTH[PJHSS`^OLUH
KVVY PZ VWLULK HUK NV V\[ ^P[O H KLSH` VM
HWWYV_ZLJVUKZHM[LY[OLKVVYPZJSVZLK
:^P[JOPUN[VJVU[PU\V\ZPSS\TPUH[PVU
7YLZZ [OL YVJRLYÌZ^P[JO Z`TIVS PU [OL JLU[LY
JVUZVSL
0UKPJH[VYSPNO[JVTLZVU
;OL SPNO[ IL[^LLU [OL Z\U ]PZVYZ HUK [OL KVVY
N\HYK SPNO[Z HYL Z^P[JOLK VU HKKP[PVUHSS` ;OL
SPNO[Z HYL H\[VTH[PJHSS` Z^P[JOLK VMM HM[LY
HWWYV_ TPU\[LZPUVYKLY[VZH]L[OL]LOPJSL
IH[[LY`
;OLSPNO[ZJHUILZ^P[JOLKIHJRVUI`WYLZZPUN
[OLYVJRLYZ^P[JOHNHPU
:^P[JOPUNSPNO[ZVMM
7YLZZ[OLPUKPJH[VYSPNO[PU[OLYVJRLYZ^P[JO
a¨F=F"zpadF
*H\[PVU
9PZRVMKHTHNL[VYLHYZWVPSLY
7SLHZLJVUZ\S[[OLVWLYH[VYILMVYL\ZPUNH\[VÌ
TH[PJJHY^HZOLZ
+VUV[W\ZO[OL]LOPJSLI`[OLZWVPSLY
pmzpadF
*H\[PVU
9PZR VM KHTHNL K\L [V YLK\JLK NYV\UK
JSLHYHUJL ;OL JHY TH` OH]L NYV\UK JVUÍ
[HJ[
+YP]L ZSV^S` HUK JHYLM\SS` VU Z[LLW \WOPSS HUK
KV^UOPSSZSVWLZLNT\S[PÌZ[VYL`JHYWHYRZ
(]VPKZ[LLWYHTWZ
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
s¬
p"VFam^F"FmVF
phz"hFm
>HYUPUN
<UZLJ\YLK S\NNHNL HUK OLH]` VIQLJ[Z TH`
JVTL SVVZL K\YPUN IYHRPUN YHWPK KPYLJÍ
[PVUHSJOHUNLZVYPUHUHJJPKLU[HUKJH\ZL
ZLYPV\ZWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`VYKLH[O
+V UV[ [YHUZWVY[ HU` OLH]` VIQLJ[Z PU [OL
Z[VYHNL[YH`Z
+VUV[JHYY`\UZLJ\YLKS\NNHNLVYVIQLJ[ZPU
[OLWHZZLUNLYJVTWHY[TLU[
==aapm"dp"VFzpa*adaaF
0U[OLKVVYWHULS
PU[OLKVVYZPSSVU[OLWHZZLUNLYZPKL
PU[OLJLU[LYJVUZVSL
ILOPUK[OLYLHYZLH[IHJRYLZ[Z
L_[LUZPVU VM Z[VYHNL ZWHJL I` MVSKPUN [OL
YLHYZLH[IHJRZMVY^HYK
JSV[OLZOVVRVUIHJRVMMYVU[ZLH[Z
WVJRL[VUIHJRVMMYVU[ZLH[ZVUS`VUZWVY[Z
ZLH[Z
dp¦F4phz"hFm
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMPUQ\Y`I`[OLNSV]LJVTWHY[TLU[SPK
PUJHZLVMHUHJJPKLU[
2LLW [OL NSV]L JVTWHY[TLU[ JSVZLK ^OPSL
KYP]PUN
6WLUPUN
7\SS[OLJH[JOHUKVWLU[OLSPK
3VJRPUN
3VJR[OLJH[JO[VZLJ\YL[OLJVU[LU[ZHNHPUZ[
\UH\[OVYPaLKHJJLZZ
s¬G
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
p"VF"©*F§FFm^FF"
6WLUPUN
7YLZZ[OLSVJRPUNRUVIHUKSPM[[OLSPK
;OLYL PZ H JVPU OVSKLY PU [OL MVY^HYK WHY[ VM
[OLZ[VYHNL[YH`
3VJRPUN
3VJR[OLJVTWHY[TLU[[VZLJ\YL[OLJVU[LU[Z
HNHPUZ[\UH\[OVYPaLKHJJLZZ
p"FFpd=F
6JJ\WPLK KYH^LYZ HYL PUKPJH[LK I` H YLK ^PUÌ
KV^
6WLUPUNKYH^LYZ
7\ZO [OL I\[[VU VM [OL KYH^LY `V\ ^PZO [V
VWLU
*SVZPUNKYH^LYZ
-VSK[OL*+KYH^LY\WHUKJSVZL\U[PSP[JSPJRZ
ZO\[
*SVZL[OLJHZZL[[LKYH^LY\U[PSP[JSPJRZZO\[
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
s¬n
(Í6WLUPUNS\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[SPK
)Í6WLUPUNLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[SPK
¤VV"VFphz"hFma="m=
mVamFphz"hFma=
mdp4camV
>P[O [OL KYP]LYqZ KVVY VWLU VWLYH[L [OL
HWWYVWYPH[L W\SSÌI\[[VU UL_[ [V [OL KYP]LYqZ
ZLH[
;OLS\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[VYLUNPULJVTWHY[Ì
TLU[ PZ PSS\TPUH[LK ^OLU [OL YLZWLJ[P]L SPK PZ
VWLU
(SZVYLMLY[V[OLJOHW[LYr3VHKZ^P[JOÌVMMs
;OL S\NNHNL JVTWHY[TLU[ SPK JHU HSZV IL
VWLULK^P[O[OLYHKPVYLTV[LJVU[YVS
9LMLY[V[OLJOHW[LYr2L`Zs
0TWVY[HU[UV[L
0M [OL ]LOPJSL IH[[LY` PZ KPZJOHYNLK [OL SPKZ JHU
IL VWLULK VUS` I` JVUULJ[PUN HU L_[LYUHS LSLJÌ
[YPJHSWV^LYZV\YJL
7SLHZL VIZLY]L [OL JOHW[LY r,SLJ[YPJHS Z`Z[LTs
VY[OLKLZJYPW[PVUPUZPKL[OLM\ZLIV_JV]LY
"mamVdaV^
;OL^HYUPUNSPNO[ZPU[OLPUZ[Y\TLU[WHULSHUKPU
[OL VUÌIVHYK JVTW\[LY JVTL VU PM [OL SPKZ HYL
UV[JVTWSL[LS`JSVZLK
-\SS`JSVZL[OLSPK
ss¬
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
zFmamVd¤VV"VF4phz"hFmda=
*H\[PVU
9PZR VM KHTHNL [V S\NNHNL JVTWHY[TLU[
SPKVY^PUKZOPLSK^PWLYZ
4HRL Z\YL [OH[ [OL ^PUKZOPLSK ^PWLYZ HYL UV[
MVSKLK V\[ MVY^HYKZ ^OLU VWLUPUN [OL S\NÌ
NHNLJVTWHY[TLU[SPK
9HPZL SPK ZSPNO[S` HUK \USH[JO [OL ZHML[` JH[JO
^P[O[OLSL]LYHYYV^
dpamVd¤VV"VF4phz"hFmda="m=
FmVamF4phz"hFmda=
3V^LYSPKHUKSL[P[MHSSPU[V[OLSVJR0MULJLZZÌ
HY`W\ZO[OLSPK^P[O[OLWHSTVM`V\YOHUKPU
[OLHYLHVM[OLSVJR
*OLJR [OH[ [OL SPK OHZ JVYYLJ[S` LUNHNLK PU
[OLSVJR
>HYUPUN
9PZR VM SVZZ VM JVU[YVS VY HU HJJPKLU[ YLÍ
Z\S[PUNPUZLYPV\ZWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`
:OV\SK `V\ UV[PJL H[ HU` [PTL ^OPSL KYP]PUN
[OH[ VUL VM [OL SPKZ PZ UV[ ZLJ\YLK WYVWLYS`
WSLHZL Z[VW PTTLKPH[LS` PU H Z\P[HISL WSHJL
HUKJSVZLP[
;OLMYVU[SPKTH`MS`\WPTWHPYPUN]PZPVU
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
sss
¤VV"VF4phz"hFm
Fhp¦amVd¤VV"VF4phz"hFmOdpp
:PT\S[HULV\ZS` W\SS [OL S\NNHNL JVTWHY[TLU[
MSVVYMVY^HYKHUK\WH[[OLMPUNLYOVSL
mFamVd¤VV"VF4phz"hFmOdpp
0UZLY[ S\NNHNL JVTWHY[TLU[ MSVVY PU [OL YLHY
N\PKLHUKWYLZZP[KV^U
u =LOPJSLPKLU[PMPJH[PVUU\TILY=05
u )H[[LY`
u *VTWHJ[KPZJJOHUNLY
u 1HJR
u ;VVSRP[
u *VTWYLZZVYMVYJVSSHWZPISLZWHYL^OLLS
u :WHJLMVYMPYZ[HPKRP[
u -S\PKYLZLY]VPYMVYJSLHUPUN^PUKV^Z
HUKOLHKSPNO[Z
u )YHRLÌMS\PKYLZLY]VPY
u /LHKSPNO[HKQ\Z[TLU[HUKSVJRPUN
\UKLY[OLJHYWL[
u 7HPU[KH[H
\UKLY[OLJHYWL[
u :WHJLMVY^HYUPUN[YPHUNSL
ss¢
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
3\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[
¤mcm"zhFm
+LWLUKPUN VU [OL WYVK\J[PVU KH[L `V\Y ]LOPJSL
PZ LX\PWWLK ^P[O HU PU[LYUHS [Y\UR YLSLHZL TLJOÌ
HUPZT
( WLYZVU [YHWWLK PU [OL S\NNHNL JVTWHY[TLU[
JHU YLSLHZL [OL SPK MYVT [OL PUZPKL \ZPUN \UÌ
SVJRPUNOHUKSL(
;OL OHUKSL ( PZ MS\VYLZJLU[ HUK NSV^Z PU [OL
KHYR
"mamVdaV^
;OL^HYUPUNSPNO[ZPU[OLPUZ[Y\TLU[WHULSHUKPU
[OL VUÌIVHYK JVTW\[LY SPNO[ \W ^OLU \USVJRPUN
OHUKSL(PZVWLYH[LK
:[VW [OL ]LOPJSL PTTLKPH[LS` ^OLU [OL ^HYUÌ
PUNSPNO[ZSPNO[\W
*OLJR[OLS\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[
*SVZL[OLSPK
-\UJ[PVU^P[O]LOPJSLZ[H[PVUHY`
0M [OL S\NNHNL JVTWHY[TLU[ SPK PZ \USVJRLK ^P[O
\USVJRPUN OHUKSL ( [OL SPK JHU IL VWLULK MYVT
[OLPUZPKLPTTLKPH[LS`
-\UJ[PVU^P[O]LOPJSLPUTV[PVU
0M [OL S\NNHNL JVTWHY[TLU[ SPK PZ \USVJRLK ^P[O
\USVJRPUN OHUKSL ( ^OLU H ZWLLK VM RTO
TWO PZ L_JLLKLK [OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z PU [OL
PUZ[Y\TLU[ WHULS HUK PU [OL VUÌIVHYK JVTW\[LY
SPNO[\W
([ [OL ZHTL [PTL [OL SPK PZ \USVJRLK HUK [OL
SH[JO Z[YPRLY WVWZ PU[V [OL JH[JOÌOVVR WVZP[PVU
;OLSPKSVJRPZM\SS`YLSLHZLKHZZVVUHZ[OLJHY
ZSV^Z [V SLZZ [OHU TWO RTO HUK [OL
[YHWWLKWLYZVUJHUVWLU[OLSPKPTTLKPH[LS`
+HUNLY
9PZRVMHJJPKLU[
0M[OL^HYUPUNSPNO[ZPU[OLPUZ[Y\TLU[WHULS
HUK PU [OL VUÍIVHYK JVTW\[LY SPNO[ \W
^OLU [OL ]LOPJSL PZ PU TV[PVU [OL SPK TH`
PTWHJ[ PU MYVU[ VM [OL ^PUKZOPLSK HUK JHU
[LHYVMM
@V\JHUSVZLJVU[YVSVM[OL]LOPJSL
:[VW [OL ]LOPJSL PTTLKPH[LS` ^OLU [OL ^HYUÌ
PUNSPNO[ZSPNO[\W
*OLJR[OLS\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[
*SVZL[OLSPK
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
ss
5V[L
;OL SPK JHUUV[ IL VWLULK MYVT [OL PUZPKL PM [OL
IH[[LY`PZKPZJVUULJ[LKVYLTW[`
:HML[` YLHZVUZ [OLYLMVYL YLX\PYL [OH[ `V\
\UZJYL^ [OL SH[JO Z[YPRLY VM [OL SPK SVJR PM
`V\WSHU[VW\[[OL]LOPJSLV\[VMVWLYH[PVU
MVYHUL_[LUKLKWLYPVK
7SLHZLJVUZ\S[`V\YH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
;OL` ^PSS HK]PZL `V\ HIV\[ [OL ULJLZZHY` TLHZÌ
\YLZ
5V[L
>OLU SVHKPUN [OL S\NNHNL JVTWHY[TLU[
THRLZ\YL[OH[P[LTZVMS\NNHNLVYV[OLYVIÌ
QLJ[ZJHUUV[ILJVTLJH\NO[VUOHUKSL(
;OPZJV\SKJH\ZL[OLS\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[[V
VWLU\UPU[LU[PVUHSS`
p4^Fphh¤ma4"apm
"m"VFhFm|}
9LMLY [V [OL ZLWHYH[L VWLYH[PUN PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ
ILMVYLW\[[PUN[OL7*4PU[VVWLYH[PVU
>OLU W\[ PU[V VWLYH[PVU MVY [OL MPYZ[ [PTL H
KPZ[HUJL VM HWWYV_ TPSLZ RT T\Z[ IL
KYP]LU PU VYKLY MVY [OL UH]PNH[PVU Z`Z[LT [V
JVTWSL[L[OLWYVJLZZVMMPULJHSPIYH[PVU
;OL ZHTL HWWSPLZ ^OLU [OL [PYLZ HYL JOHUNLK
LNZ\TTLYZUV^[PYLZVYUL^[PYLZMP[[LK
-\SSSVJH[PVUHJJ\YHJ`PZUV[`L[HJOPL]LKK\YPUN
[OLMPULÌJHSPIYH[PVUWYVJLZZ
0M [OL ]LOPJSL OHZ ILLU [YHUZWVY[LK LN MLYY`
JHY [YHPU [OL Z`Z[LT TH` [HRL H ML^ TPU\[LZ
HM[LYILPUNZ^P[JOLKVUILMVYLP[KL[LYTPULZ[OL
J\YYLU[SVJH[PVU
:LYPV\Z [PYL ZSPW LN ZWPUUPUN ^OLLSZ VU ZUV^
TH`YLZ\S[PU[LTWVYHYPS`PUHJJ\YH[LUH]PNH[PVU
>OLU[OLIH[[LY`OHZILLUKPZJVUULJ[LKP[TH`
[HRL \W [V TPU\[LZ ILMVYL [OL UH]PNH[PVU
Z`Z[LTILJVTLZVWLYH[PVUHSHNHPU
ssT
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
¤z^pd=F
|^pd=FOp=amc4"m"m=4¤z}
2LLW[OLJ\WOVSKLYJSVZLK^OPSLKYP]PUN
>HYUPUN
9PZR VM ZJHSKPUN VY KHTHNL K\L [V ZWPSSPUN
KYPURZ
6US`\ZLJVU[HPULYZ^OPJOMP[
5L]LYW\[V]LYM\SSJVU[HPULYZPU[OLJ\WOVSKLY
5L]LY\ZLOV[KYPURZ
¨Fm=amV4¤z^pd=F
7YLZZ[OLJ\WOVSKLYZ`TIVS
;OL J\WOVSKLY JHU IL W\SSLK V\[ [V HJJVTTVÌ
KH[LHZLJVUKJVU[HPULY
¤ddamV4¤z^pd=Fp¤
.YHZWJ\WOVSKLYH[[OLOHUKSLYLJLZZHUKW\SS
P[V\[
dpamV4¤z^pd=F
7\ZOJ\WOVSKLYKYH^LYPU
*SVZLHUKLUNHNL[OLJ\WOVSKLY
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
ssQ
"FdFz^pmF"m=
OFh"cFd"h
0TWVY[HU[SLNHSHUKZHML[`PUMVYTH[PVU
YLNHYKPUN[OL\ZLVMJLSS\SHY[LSLWOVULZ
:VTL Z[H[LZ TH` WYVOPIP[ [OL \ZL VM JLSS\SHY
[LSLWOVULZ ^OPSL KYP]PUN H ]LOPJSL *OLJR [OL
SH^Z HUK YLN\SH[PVUZ VU [OL \ZL VM JLSS\SHY [LSLÌ
WOVULZPU[OLHYLHZ^OLYL`V\KYP]L
+HUNLY
9PZRVMHUHJJPKLU[
:L]LYL WLYZVUHS PUQ\Y` VY KLH[O JHU YLZ\S[
PU[OLL]LU[VMHUHJJPKLU[
3VVRPUN H^H` MYVT [OL YVHK VY [\YUPUN
`V\Y H[[LU[PVU H^H` MYVT `V\Y KYP]PUN JHU
JH\ZL HU HJJPKLU[ HUK ZLYPV\Z VY MH[HS PUÍ
Q\Y`
>OLU \ZPUN `V\Y JLSS\SHY [LSLWOVUL `V\ ZOV\SK
HS^H`Z!
.P]LM\SSH[[LU[PVU[V`V\YKYP]PUNÌW\SSVMM[OL
YVHK HUK WHYR ILMVYL THRPUN VY HUZ^LYPUN H
JHSSPM[YHMMPJJVUKP[PVUZZVYLX\PYL"HUK
2LLW IV[O OHUKZ VU [OL Z[LLYPUN ^OLLS Ì \ZL
OHUKZÌMYLLVWLYH[PVUPMH]HPSHISLÌW\SSVMM[OL
YVHK HUK WHYR ILMVYL \ZPUN H OHUKÌOLSK [LSLÌ
WOVUL
0[PZLZZLU[PHS[VVIZLY]L[OLPUZ[Y\J[PVUZVM
[OL [LSLWOVUL THU\MHJ[\YLY ILMVYL W\[[PUN
[OL[LSLWOVULPU[VVWLYH[PVU
(U` WVY[HISL [LSLWOVUL VY YHKPV [YHUZTP[[LY
^OPJO PZ \ZLK PU H 7VYZJOL T\Z[ IL WYVWLYS`
PUZ[HSSLK PU HJJVYKHUJL ^P[O [OL [LJOUPJHS YLÌ
X\PYLTLU[ZVM7VYZJOL
;OL [YHUZTPZZPVU WV^LY T\Z[ UV[ L_JLLK
>
;OL KL]PJLZ T\Z[ WVZZLZZ H [`WL HWWYV]HS MVY
`V\Y]LOPJSLHUKOH]LHUrLsZ`TIVS
0M `V\ ZOV\SK YLX\PYL LX\PWTLU[ ^P[O [YHUZÌ
TPZZPVUWV^LY]HS\LZNYLH[LY[OHU>WSLHZL
JVUZ\S[ `V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY MVY [OPZ
W\YWVZL/LPZMHTPSPHY^P[O[OL[LJOUPJHSYLX\PYLÌ
TLU[ZMVYPUZ[HSSPUNKL]PJLZVM[OPZRPUK
;OL HU[LUUHZ MVY HSS YHKPVZ HUK [LSLWOVULZ ^P[O
H [YHUZTP[[PUN HU[LUUH T\Z[ IL L_[LYUHSS`
TV\U[LK
;OLPTWYVWLYPUZ[HSSH[PVUVMYHKPVZVY[LSLWOVULZ
VY \ZL VM H YHKPV VY [LSLWOVUL ^P[O H [YHUZTP[Ì
[PUN HU[LUUH PUZPKL [OL JHY TH` JH\ZL [OL
^HYUPUNSPNO[Z[VJVTLVU
0TWYVWLYPUZ[HSSH[PVUVMZ\JOLX\PWTLU[JHUJYLÌ
H[L H KPZJOHYNLK IH[[LY` VY L_JLZZP]L J\YYLU[
KYH^MYVTHKKLKLX\PWTLU[
0M HM[LYTHYRL[ Z`Z[LTZ HYL PUZ[HSSLK I` UVUÌ
KLHSLYZOPW [LJOUPJPHUZ VY V\[ZPKL [OL ZLSSPUN
KLHSLYWYVISLTZTH`YLZ\S[0UZ[HSSH[PVUVMHM[LYÌ
THYRL[LX\PWTLU[PZUV[JV]LYLK\UKLY[OL5L^
*HY>HYYHU[`
*VUZ\S[`V\YH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLYHIV\[
[OL PUZ[HSSH[PVU VM UVU 7VYZJOL HWWYV]LK
LX\PWTLU[
9LJLW[PVUX\HSP[`
;OL YLJLW[PVU X\HSP[` VM `V\Y JHY [LSLWOVUL ^PSS
JOHUNL JVUZ[HU[S` ^OLU `V\ HYL KYP]PUN 0U[LYÌ
MLYLUJL JH\ZLK I` I\PSKPUNZ SHUKZJHWL HUK
^LH[OLY PZ \UH]VPKHISL 0[ TH` ILJVTL WHY[PJ\Ì
SHYS` KPMMPJ\S[ [V OLHY ^OLU \ZPUN [OL OHUKZÌMYLL
M\UJ[PVU K\L [V L_[LYUHS UVPZL Z\JO HZ LUNPUL
HUK^PUKUVPZL
ss
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
"¤=apzF"apmaz
-VY YHKPV VWLYH[PVU ZLL `V\Y YHKPV THU\HS
^OPJO PZ PUJS\KLK ^P[O `V\Y VUÍIVHYK
SP[LYH[\YL
(SZVZLL[OLJOHW[LYVUs3VHKZ^P[JOÌVMMr
F4Fzapm
( ]LOPJSL PZ UV[ HU PKLHS WSHJL [V SPZ[LU [V H
YHKPV
)LJH\ZL[OL]LOPJSLTV]LZYLJLW[PVUJVUKP[PVUZ
HYLJVUZ[HU[S`JOHUNPUN
)\PSKPUNZ[LYYHPUZPNUHSKPZ[HUJLHUKUVPZLMYVT
V[OLY ]LOPJSLZ HYL HSS ^VYRPUN HNHPUZ[ NVVK YLÌ
JLW[PVU
:VTL JVUKP[PVUZ VM -4 TH` HWWLHY [V IL WYVIÌ
SLTZ^OLU[OL`HYLUV[
;OLMVSSV^PUNJOHYHJ[LYPZ[PJZHYLJVTWSL[LS`UVYÌ
THSMVYHNP]LUYLJLW[PVUHYLHHUK[OL`KVUV[
PUKPJH[LHU`WYVISLT^P[O[OLYHKPVP[ZLSM
5V[L
,SLJ[YVUPJ HJJLZZVYPLZ ZOV\SK VUS` IL PUZ[HSSLK
I``V\YH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
,X\PWTLU[ ^OPJO OHZ UV[ ILLU [LZ[LK HUK HWÌ
WYV]LKI`7VYZJOLTH`PTWHPYYHKPVYLJLW[PVU
-HKPUNHUKKYPM[PUN
-4 YHUNL PZ SPTP[LK [V HIV\[ TPSLZ RT
L_JLW[MVYZVTLOPNOWV^LYZ[H[PVUZ
0MH]LOPJSLPZTV]PUNH^H`MYVT[OLKLZPYLKZ[HÌ
[PVUqZ [YHUZTP[[LY [OL ZPNUHS ^PSS [LUK [V MHKL
HUKVY KYPM[ ;OPZ JVUKP[PVU PZ TVYL WYL]HSLU[
^P[O -4 [OHU (4 HUK PZ VM[LU HJJVTWHUPLK I`
KPZ[VY[PVU
-HKPUNHUKKYPM[PUNJHUILTPUPTPaLK[VHJLY[HPU
KLNYLL I` JHYLM\S H[[LU[PVU [V MPUL [\UPUN VY ZLÌ
SLJ[PVUVMHZ[YVUNLYZPNUHS
:[H[PJHUKMS\[[LYPUN
>OLU [OL SPULÌVMÌZPNO[ SPUR IL[^LLU H [YHUZTP[[LY
HUK ]LOPJSL PZ ISVJRLK I` SHYNL I\PSKPUNZ VY
TV\U[HPUZ [OL YHKPV ZV\UK TH` IL HJJVTWHÌ
UPLK^P[OZ[H[PJVYMS\[[LYPUNILJH\ZLVM[OLJOHYÌ
HJ[LYPZ[PJVM-4
0U H ZPTPSHY LMMLJ[ H MS\[[LYPUN UVPZL PZ ZVTLÌ
[PTLZOLHYK^OLUKYP]PUNHSVUNH[YLLÌSPULKYVHK
;OPZ Z[H[PJ HUK MS\[[LYPUN JHU IL YLK\JLK I` HKÌ
Q\Z[PUN [OL [VUL JVU[YVS MVY NYLH[LY IHZZ YLÌ
ZWVUZL\U[PS[OLKPZ[\YIHUJLOHZWHZZLK
4\S[PWH[O
)LJH\ZL VM [OL YLMSLJ[PUN JOHYHJ[LYPZ[PJZ VM -4
KPYLJ[ HUK YLMSLJ[LK ZPNUHSZ TH` YLHJO [OL HUÌ
[LUUH H[ [OL ZHTL [PTL T\S[PWH[O HUK JHUJLS
LHJOV[OLYV\[
(Z H ]LOPJSL TV]LZ [OYV\NO [OLZL LSLJ[YVUPJ
KLHK ZWV[Z [OL SPZ[LULY TH` OLHY H TVTLU[HY`
MS\[[LYVYSVZZVMYLJLW[PVU
:[H[PVUZ^HWWPUN
>OLU [^V -4 Z[H[PVUZ HYL JSVZL [V LHJO V[OLY
HUK HU LSLJ[YVUPJ KLHK ZWV[ Z\JO HZ Z[H[PJ VY
T\S[PWH[O HYLH PU[LYY\W[Z [OL VYPNPUHS ZPNUHS
ZVTL[PTLZ [OL Z[YVUNLY ZLJVUK ZPNUHS ^PSS IL
ZLSLJ[LK H\[VTH[PJHSS` \U[PS [OL VYPNPUHS VUL YLÌ
[\YUZ
;OPZZ^HWWPUNJHUHSZVVJJ\YHZ`V\KYP]LH^H`
MYVT [OL ZLSLJ[LK Z[H[PVU HUK HWWYVHJO HUV[OLY
Z[H[PVUVMHZ[YVUNLYZPNUHS
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
ss
"FF"zFzd"©F
*H\[PVU
;V H]VPK KHTHNL [V JHZZL[[L [HWL WSH`LY
HUK[HWLZ
<ZL VUS` JHZZL[[L [HWLZ VM NVVK X\HSP[` OH]Ì
PUNUVKHTHNL
(]VPK \ZPUN [HWLZ ^P[O H [V[HS WSH`PUN [PTL
SVUNLY[OHU TPU\[LZ
3VUNLY [HWLZ HYL UV[ YLJVTTLUKLK ILJH\ZL
VM[OL[OPUULYJYVZZZLJ[PVUVM[OL[HWL
)LZ\YL[OH[[OL[HWLPZUV[ZSHJRHUK[OH[[OL
SHILS PZ MPYTS` ZLJ\YLK VU [OL ZOLSS ILMVYL PUÌ
ZLY[PUN[OLJHZZL[[LPU[V[OLWSH`LY
/H]L [OL [HWL MPYTS` ^V\UK HYV\UK [OL [HWL
I` [\YUPUN [OL O\I ^P[O H WLUJPS VY ZPTPSHY
P[LTZ )L JHYLM\S UV[ [V [V\JO [OL L_WVZLK
[HWLZ\YMHJL
>OLUUV[PU\ZL[HRL[OLJHZZL[[LV\[VM[OL
WSH`LY W\[ P[ IHJR PU[V P[Z JHZL HUK Z[VYL P[
H^H`MYVTK\Z[THNUL[ZHUKKPYLJ[Z\USPNO[
3LH]PUN [OL JHZZL[[L [HWL VU [OL KHZOIVHYK
PU[OLZ\UJHUKHTHNL[OL[HWL
2LLW [OL WSH`IHJR OLHK JHWZ[HU HUK WPUJO
YVSSLYJSLHU
9LTV]L[HWLJVH[PUNYLZPK\LHJJ\T\SH[LKVU
[OL OLHK JHWZ[HU HUK WPUJO YVSSLY VUJL VY
[^PJLHTVU[O
(JSLHUPUN[HWL^OPJOJHUKV[OPZZOV\SKIL
H]HPSHISLPUH\KPVZ[VYLZ
+VUV[VPSHU`WHY[VM[OL[HWLWSH`LYHUKKV
UV[ PUZLY[ HU` VIQLJ[ V[OLY [OHU H JHZZL[[L
[HWLPU[V[OLZSV[
phz"4=a4zd"©F
*H\[PVU
;V H]VPK KHTHNL [V JVTWHJ[ KPZJ WSH`LY
HUKKPZJZ
<ZL VUS` JVTWHJ[ KPZJZ SHILSLK HZ ZOV^U
OH]PUNUVKPY[KHTHNLVY^HYWHNL
5L]LY H[[LTW[ [V KPZHZZLTISL VY VPS HU` WHY[
VM[OLWSH`LY\UP[
+VUV[PUZLY[HU`VIQLJ[V[OLY[OHUHKPZJPU[V
[OLZSV[
9LTLTILY [OLYL HYL UV \ZLYÌZLY]PJLHISL
WHY[ZPUZPKL[OLJVTWHJ[KPZJWSH`LY
+V UV[ HSSV^ [OL KPZJ [V Z\Z[HPU HU` MPUNLYÌ
WYPU[Z ZJYHWLZ VY Z[PJRLYZ VU [OL Z\YMHJLZ
;OPZTH`JH\ZLWVVYZV\UKX\HSP[`
/VSK[OLKPZJVUS`VU[OLLKNLVYJLU[LYOVSL
>OLU UV[ PU \ZL [HRL [OL KPZJ V\[ VM [OL
WSH`LY W\[ [OL KPZJ IHJR PU[V P[Z JHZL HUK
Z[VYL P[ H^H` MYVT K\Z[ OLH[ KHTW HUK KPÌ
YLJ[Z\USPNO[
3LH]PUN[OLKPZJVU[OLKHZOIVHYKPU[OLZ\U
JHUKHTHNL[OLKPZJ
0M[OLKPZJNL[ZKPY[`JSLHU[OLKPZJI`^PWPUN
[OLZ\YMHJLZMYVT[OLJLU[LY[V[OLV\[ZPKLPU
HYHKPHSKPYLJ[PVU^P[OHZVM[JSV[O
+V UV[ \ZL H JVU]LU[PVUHS YLJVYK JSLHULY VY
HU[PÌZ[H[PJYLJVYKWYLZLY]H[P]L
+PZJJSLHULYZHYLH]HPSHISLPUH\KPVZ[VYLZ
ssG
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
ppO"mzp©Fh
-VSSV^ [OL ZLWHYH[L PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ MVY MP[[PUN
[OL9VVM;YHUZWVY[:`Z[LT
-P[[PUN JVTTLYJPHSS` H]HPSHISL S\NNHNL YHJRZ PZ
UV[WVZZPISL
;OL 7VYZJOL 9VVM ;YHUZWVY[ :`Z[LT HSSV^Z
[OL[YHUZWVY[VM]HYPV\ZZWVY[ZHUKOVII`LX\PWÌ
TLU[
@V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY ^PSS IL WSLHZLK
[V PUMVYT `V\ HIV\[ [OL THU` \ZLZ VM [OL 9VVM
;YHUZWVY[:`Z[LT
>HYUPUN
9PZR VM HU HJJPKLU[ SVZZ VM JVU[YVS HUK
KHTHNL[V[OL]LOPJSL
*VTWSL[LS` YLTV]L [OL 9VVM ;YHUZWVY[ :`ZÌ
[LTILMVYL\ZPUNHUH\[VTH[PJJHY^HZO
-P[[OLZPKLZ\WWVY[LSLTLU[ZVM[OLIHZPJJHYÌ
YPLY VUS` PU JVUQ\UJ[PVU ^P[O [OL [YHUZ]LYZL
Z\WWVY[PUNWPWLZ
;OL WLYTPZZPISL \ZLHISL SVHK VM SIZ
RN [OL WLYTPZZPISL [V[HS ]LOPJSL ^LPNO[ HUK
[OL WLYTPZZPISL H_SL SVHKZ T\Z[ UV[ IL L_Ì
JLLKLK
:LL[OLJOHW[LYVUs>LPNO[Zr
0[LTZ VM S\NNHNL T\Z[ UV[ WYVQLJ[ Z\IZ[HUÌ
[PHSS`IL`VUK[OLZPKLVM[OLSVHKHYLH
+PZ[YPI\[L SVHK L]LUS` ^P[O OLH]` P[LTZ HZ
SV^HZWVZZPISL
,]LY` P[LT T\Z[ IL MP_LK HUK ZLJ\YLK [V [OL
IHZPJ JHYYPLY ^P[O H YVWL VY SHZOPUN Z[YHW KV
UV[\ZLLSHZ[PJY\IILY[LUZPVULYZ
)LMVYL L]LY` QV\YUL` HUK H[ YLN\SHY PU[LY]HSZ
K\YPUN SVUN [YPWZ JOLJR [OH[ 9VVM ;YHUZWVY[
:`Z[LTHUKSVHKHYLZLJ\YL
9L[PNO[LUPMULJLZZHY`HUKZLJ\YLHKKP[PVUHSS`
I`SVJRPUN
0U[OLSVHKLKZ[H[LHKQ\Z[TH_PT\TZWLLK[V
[OL UH[\YL ZPaL HUK ^LPNO[ VM [OL SVHK ILPUN
JHYYPLK
0U UV JHZL OV^L]LY ZOV\SK `V\ KYP]L H[
TVYL[OHU TWORTO
>P[O [OL IHZPJ JHYYPLY PUZ[HSSLK HUK UV SVHK
KVUV[L_JLLKHTH_PT\TZWLLKVMTWO
RTO ZPUJL KYP]PUN Z[HIPSP[` ^PSS IL HKÌ
]LYZLS`HMMLJ[LK
(KHW[ `V\Y KYP]PUN Z[`SL HUK ZWLLK [V [OL
JOHUNLKJVUKP[PVUZ
5L]LY[OLSLZZ 7VYZJOL YLJVTTLUKZ [OH[ `V\
KVUV[L_JLLK[OLWVZ[LKZWLLKSPTP[
+YP]PUN IYHRPUN HUK Z[LLYPUN ILOH]PVY VM [OL
]LOPJSL JOHUNL K\L [V [OL OPNOLY JLU[LY VM
NYH]P[`HUK[OLNYLH[LY^PUKÌYLZPZ[HU[HYLH
@V\ ZOV\SK HKHW[ `V\Y KYP]PUN Z[`SL HWWYVWYPÌ
H[LS`
5V[L
:PUJL M\LS JVUZ\TW[PVU HUK UVPZL HYLPUJYLHZLK
^P[O [OL 9VVM ;YHUZWVY[ :`Z[LT PUZ[HSSLK P[
ZOV\SKUV[YLTHPUVU[OLJHYPMP[PZUV[PU\ZL
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
ssn
aOamVda=amVppO
>HYUPUN
9PZR VM PUQ\Y` ^OLU VWLYH[PUN VY H\[VÍ
TH[PJHSS`JSVZPUN[OLSPM[PUNZSPKPUNYVVM
;HRL JHYL [V LUZ\YL [OH[ UVIVK` JHU IL PUÌ
Q\YLK^OLU[OLSPM[PUNZSPKPUNYVVMPZVWLYH[LK
;OPZHWWSPLZLZWLJPHSS`PM[OLYVVMJSVZLZH\[VÌ
TH[PJHSS`
(S^H`Z YLTV]L [OL PNUP[PVU RL` ^OLU SLH]PUN
[OL]LOPJSL
<UPUMVYTLK WLYZVUZ LN JOPSKYLU JV\SK PUÌ
Q\YL[OLTZLS]LZI`VWLYH[PUN[OLSPM[PUNZSPKPUN
YVVM
0U JHZL VM KHUNLY YLSLHZL [OL I\[[VU VY JHY
RL`PTTLKPH[LS`HUKVWLYH[L[OLSPM[PUNZSPKPUN
YVVMPU[OLVWWVZP[LKPYLJ[PVU
F"=amFOppzF"apm
>OLUPNUP[PVUPZVULUNPULVUVYVMMVY
^OLU KVVY PZ JSVZLK HUK PNUP[PVU RL` PZ
YLTV]LK I\[ VUS` \U[PS [OL KVVY PZ MPYZ[ VWÌ
LULK
_zFmamV^FdaOamVda=amVppO
7YLZZ IHJR VM YVJRLY Z^P[JO \U[PS SPM[PUNZSPKÌ
PUNYVVMYLHJOLZ[OLKLZPYLKWVZP[PVU
6ULÍ[V\JOVWLYH[PVU
;V\JO IHJR VM YVJRLY Z^P[JO Ì SPM[PUNZSPKPUN
YVVMVWLUZM\SS`[VP[ZLUKWVZP[PVU
:[VWP[PUHU`WVZP[PVUI`[V\JOPUNHU`I\[[VU
5V[L
;OL SPM[PUNZSPKPUNYVVMVWLUZ\U[PSP[YLHJOLZ[OL
ILZ[ WVZP[PVU PU [LYTZ VM ^PUK UVPZL 0[ JHU IL
VWLULK M\SS` OV^L]LY PM `V\ WYLZZ [OL YVJRLY
Z^P[JOHNHPU
s¢¬
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
_dpamV^FdaOamVda=amVppO
7YLZZ MYVU[ VM YVJRLY Z^P[JO \U[PS SPM[PUNZSPKÌ
PUNYVVMYLHJOLZ[OLKLZPYLKWVZP[PVU
6ULÍ[V\JOVWLYH[PVU
;V\JO MYVU[ VM YVJRLY Z^P[JO Ì SPM[PUNZSPKPUN
YVVMJSVZLZM\SS`[VP[ZLUKWVZP[PVU
:[VWP[PUHU`WVZP[PVUI`[V\JOPUNHU`I\[[VU
*SVZPUN[OLSPM[PUNZSPKPUNYVVMH\[VTH[Í
PJHSS`^OLU[OL]LOPJSLPZSVJRLK
/VSK [OL JHY RL` PU [OL KVVY SVJR PU SVJRPUN
WVZP[PVU \U[PS [OL SPM[PUNZSPKPUN YVVM YLHJOLZ
[OLKLZPYLKWVZP[PVU
_aOamV^FdaOamVda=amVppO
7YLZZ JLU[LY VM YVJRLY Z^P[JO \U[PS SPM[Ì
PUNZSPKPUNYVVMYLHJOLZ[OLKLZPYLKWVZP[PVU
6ULÍ[V\JOVWLYH[PVU
;V\JO JLU[LY VM YVJRLY Z^P[JO Ì SPM[PUNZSPKPUN
YVVMVWLUZM\SS`[VP[ZLUKWVZP[PVU
:[VWP[PUHU`WVZP[PVUI`[V\JOPUNHU`I\[[VU
_p§FamV^FdaOamVda=amVppO
7YLZZ MYVU[ VM YVJRLY Z^P[JO \U[PS SPM[PUNZSPKÌ
PUNYVVMYLHJOLZ[OLKLZPYLKWVZP[PVU
^F"m=*©O¤m4apmpO^FppO=a¦F
§a4^FpOO"OF§p^p¤
0M [OL ]LOPJSL PZ \USVJRLK [OL SPM[PUNZSPKPUN YVVM
JHU UV SVUNLY IL VWLYH[LK HM[LY [^V OV\YZ
WYL]LU[PVUVMIH[[LY`KPZJOHYNPUN
;OLWV^LYZ\WWS`PZZ^P[JOLKIHJRVU^OLU[OL
PNUP[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVUVY[OLLUNPULZ[HY[LK
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
s¢s
hFVFm4©pzF"apm
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMZLYPV\ZWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`HUKKHTHNL
[V [OLSPM[PUNZSPKPUNYVVMK\YPUNLTLYNLUJ`
VWLYH[PVU
+\YPUNHUKHM[LYLTLYNLUJ`VWLYH[PVU[OLSPM[Ì
PUNZSPKPUN YVVM TH` UV SVUNLY IL VWLYH[LK
^P[O[OLYVJRLYZ^P[JO
)LMVYL \ZPUN LTLYNLUJ` VWLYH[PVU WSLHZL
JOLJR ^OL[OLY KLMLJ[P]L M\ZLZ HYL [OL JH\ZL VM
[OLTHSM\UJ[PVU
:LLJOHW[LYVUr,SLJ[YPJHSZ`Z[LTs
*SVZPUN[OLSPM[PUNZSPKPUNYVVM
<ZPUN `V\Y MPUNLY UHPSVYHZJYL^KYP]LYJHYLÌ
M\SS` \UJSPW [OL [^V JV]LYZ ( VM [OL PUMYHYLK
WHZZLUNLYJVTWHY[TLU[TVUP[VYPUNZ`Z[LT
<UZJYL^[OL[^VZJYL^Z)
-VSKKV^U[OLJV]LYVM[OLSPM[PUNZSPKPUNYVVM
KYP]L
9LTV]L[OL(SSLURL`HYYV^MYVTP[ZOVSKLY
0UZLY[[OL(SSLURL`PU[OLKYP]LH_SL
s¢¢
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
7YLZZ [OL (SSLU RL` PU[V [OL KYP]L H_SL RLLW
P[ WYLZZLK HUK [\YU P[ JSVJR^PZL \U[PS [OL SPM[Ì
PUNZSPKPUNYVVMPZJSVZLK
>P[OKYH^[OL(SSLURL`
*SVZL[OLJV]LYHUKMHZ[LU[OLZJYL^Z
7SLHZL OH]L [OL MH\S[ YLTLKPLK H[ HU H\[OÌ
VYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
s¢
s¢T
*VU[YVSZ0UZ[Y\TLU[Z
^aOamV F"
.LHYZOPM[PUN
;PW[YVUPJ: u
:OPM[PUN.LHY
s¢Q
F"^aOamV
;OL WVZP[PVUZ VM [OL NLHYZ HYL ZOV^U VU [OL
NLHYZOPM[SL]LY
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMHUHJJPKLU[
(S^H`Z JOLJR [OL TV]LTLU[ VM [OL JS\[JO
WLKHS ILMVYL KYP]PUN HUK THRL Z\YL [OH[ P[ PZ
UV[ VIZ[Y\J[LK I` H MSVVY TH[ VY HU` V[OLY
VIQLJ[
:LJ\YL[OLMSVVYTH[[VWYL]LU[P[MYVTZSPKPUN
PU[V WVZP[PVUZ [OH[ JV\SK PU[LYMLYL ^P[O [OL
ZHMLVWLYH[PVUVM`V\Y]LOPJSL
@V\Y7VYZJOLKLHSLYJHUVMMLY`V\MSVVYTH[Z
VM[OLJVYYLJ[ZPaLPUJS\KPUNHZLJ\YPUNWVZZPÌ
IPSP[`
;V H]VPK KHTHNL [V [OL JS\[JO HUK [YHUZÍ
TPZZPVU!
(S^H`Z KLWYLZZ [OL JS\[JO WLKHS M\SS` ^OLU
JOHUNPUNNLHYZ
4HRL Z\YL [OH[ [OL NLHYZOPM[ SL]LY PZ JVTÌ
WSL[LS`LUNHNLK
6US`ZOPM[PU[VYL]LYZL^OLU[OLJHYOHZJVTL
[VHJVTWSL[LZ[VW
F¦FF
+LWYLZZ [OLJS\[JOWLKHSMVYZL]LYHSZLJVUKZ
ILMVYLZOPM[PUNPU[VYL]LYZL
6US`[OLUTV]L[OLNLHYZOPM[SL]LY[V[OLSLM[
V]LYJVTPUN [OL ZWYPUN [LUZPVU HUK [OLU [V
[OLMYVU[
)V[O IHJRÌ\W SPNO[Z JVTL VU ^OLU [OL [YHUZÌ
TPZZPVUPZW\[PU[VYL]LYZL^P[OPNUP[PVUVU
FhaF=FmVamFzFF=
*OHUNL PU[V H OPNOLY NLHY ILMVYL [OL ULLKSL
YLHJOLZ [OL YLK THYR VU [OL [HJOVTL[LY VY
LHZLVMM[OLHJJLSLYH[VY
0M [OL YLK aVUL PZ YLHJOLK K\YPUN HJJLSLYH[PVU
M\LSMLLKPZPU[LYY\W[LK
*H\[PVU
;VH]VPKZL]LYLLUNPULKHTHNL
(S^H`Z VIZLY]L [OL LUNPUL YWT ILMVYL KV^UÌ
ZOPM[PUN [V H SV^LY NLHY ZV `V\ KV UV[ L_Ì
JLLK[OLTH_PT\TLUNPULYWT
s¢
:OPM[PUN.LHY
azpma4
;OL 7VYZJOL ;PW[YVUPJ PZ H MP]LÌZWLLK [YHUZÌ
TPZZPVU ^P[O HU r(\[VTH[PJs HUK r4HU\HSs ZLSLJÌ
[PVUTVKL
0U H\[VTH[PJ ZLSLJ[PVU TVKL ZLSLJ[VY SL]LY
WVZP[PVU+NLHYÌJOHUNPUNPZH\[VTH[PJ
@V\ JHU JOHUNL [LTWVYHYPS` MYVT H\[VTH[PJ [V
THU\HS TVKL \ZPUN [OL [VNNSL Z^P[JOLZ VU [OL
Z[LLYPUN^OLLS
0U THU\HS ZLSLJ[PVU TVKL ZLSLJ[VY SL]LY
WVZP[PVU4 `V\ JOHUNL NLHY \ ZPUN [OL [VNNSL
Z^P[JOLZVU[OLZ[LLYPUN^OLLS
@V\ JHU JOHUNL IL[^LLU ZLSLJ[VYSL]LYWVZP[PVU
+HUK4HZ`V\^PZO^OPSLKYP]PUN
5V[L
;HRLJHYLUV[[VVWLYH[L[OL[VNNSLZ^P[JOLZVU
[OL Z[LLYPUN ^OLLS PUHK]LY[LU[S` PU LP[OLY H\[VÌ
TH[PJ VY THU\HS TVKL [OLYLI` [YPNNLYPUN \UÌ
KLZPYLKNLHYJOHUNLZ
p4camV*¤pm
;V WYL]LU[ \UPU[LUKLK NLHY ZOPM[Z [OL SVJRPUN
I\[[VU PU [OL ZLSLJ[VY SL]LY HYYV^ T\Z[ IL
WYLZZLK[VJOHUNL[VWVZP[PVU9VY7
F©dp4czpaapm
;OPZ WVZP[PVU HSSV^Z [OL PNUP[PVU RL` [V IL
YLTV]LK VUS` HM[LY [OL NLHYZOPM[ ZLSLJ[VY SL]LY
I\[[VU PZ KLWYLZZLK HUK TV]LK [V WVZP[PVU s7r
;OPZLUZ\YLZ[OH[[OLKYP]LYLUNHNLZ[OLWHYRPUN
SVJR ILMVYL SLH]PUN [OL ]LOPJSL HUK [\YUZ [OL
PNUP[PVURL`[VWVZP[PVUs6r[OLU[OLPNUP[PVURL`
JHUILYLTV]LKMYVT[OLPNUP[PVUZ^P[JO
^aOdp4c|FdF4pdF¦Fdp4c}
;OL ZOPM[SVJR Z`Z[LT PZ HUV[OLY MLH[\YL [V WYLÌ
]LU[PUHK]LY[LU[TV]LTLU[VM[OL]LOPJSL
0NUP[PVUZ^P[JOWVZP[PVU
;OLZLSLJ[VYSL]LYSVJRPUNI\[[VUPZSVJRLK
0NUP[PVUZ^P[JOWVZP[PVU
>P[O [OL ]LOPJSL Z[H[PVUHY` [OL ZLSLJ[VY SL]LY
JHUUV[ IL TV]LK MYVT [OL 7 VY 5 WVZP[PVUZ
\USLZZ[OLIYHRLWLKHSPZKLWYLZZLK
"amV^FFmVamF
;OLLUNPULJHUILZ[HY[LKVUS`PUZLSLJ[VYSL]LY
WVZP[PVU7VY5
a¦amVpOO
:LSLJ[ [OL KLZPYLK KYP]L WVZP[PVU + 4 VY 9
MVY KYP]PUN VMM VUS` ^OLU [OL LUNPUL PZ PKSPUN
HUK^OPSLKLWYLZZPUN[OLIYHRLWLKHS
:PUJL [OL JHY JYLLWZ ^OLU PU NLHY KV UV[
YLSLHZL[OLIYHRL\U[PS`V\^HU[[VKYP]LVMM
(M[LYZLSLJ[PUNHNLHYKVUV[HJJLSLYH[L\U[PS
`V\JHUMLLS[OH[[OLNLHYOHZILLUZLSLJ[LK
:OPM[PUN.LHY
s¢
m=a4"pOpFdF4pdF¦Fzpaapm"m=
FmV"VF=VF"
>OLU [OL LUNPUL PZ Y\UUPUN [OL ZLSLJ[VY SL]LY
WVZP[PVUHUKLUNHNLKNLHYHYLPUKPJH[LK
0M[OLZLSLJ[VYSL]LYPZIL[^LLU[^V
WVZP[PVUZ!
;OL ZLSLJ[VY SL]LY WVZP[PVU PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[
JS\Z[LYMSHZOLZHUK
[OL ^HYUPUN rZLSLJ[VY SL]LY UV[ LUNHNLKs
HWWLHYZ VU [OL KPZWSH` VM [OL VUÌIVHYK JVTÌ
W\[LY
,UNHNL[OLZLSLJ[VYSL]LYJVYYLJ[S`
0M[OLYLPZHMH\S[PU[OL[YHUZTPZZPVU!
[ONLHYMSHZOLZVU[OLKPZWSH`
;OL ^HYUPUN r;PW[YVUPJ LTLYNLUJ` Y\Us
HWWLHYZPU[OLVUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY
(SZVYLMLY[Vr,TLYNLUJ`WYVNYHTs
;V YLTLK` [OL MH\S[ WSLHZL JVUZ\S[ HU H\[OÌ
VYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLYPTTLKPH[LS`
s¢G
:OPM[PUN.LHY
FdF4pF¦Fpaapm
J"camVdp4c
0U ZLSLJ[VY SL]LY WVZP[PVU 7 [OL KYP]LU ^OLLSZ
HYLTLJOHUPJHSS`SVJRLK
:LSLJ[VUS`^OLUJHYOHZILLUZ[VWWLK
,UNHNL WHYRPUN SVJR HM[LY HWWS`PUN [OL OHUKÌ
IYHRL HUK YLSLHZL P[ ILMVYL YLSLHZPUN [OL
OHUKIYHRL
;OL PNUP[PVU RL` JHU IL ^P[OKYH^U VUS` PU
ZLSLJ[VYSL]LYWVZP[PVU7
JF¦FF
:LSLJ[ VUS` ^OLU JHY OHZ ILLU Z[VWWLK HUK
[OLIYHRLPZHWWSPLK
JF¤"d
:LSLJ[VY SL]LY WVZP[PVU 5 T\Z[ IL ZLSLJ[LK MVY
[V^PUNVYPUJHY^HZOLZMVYL_HTWSL
:LSLJ[ [OL KLZPYLK WVZP[PVU MVYTV]PUNVMM+
4 VY 9 VUS` ^OLU [OL LUNPUL PZ PKSPUN HUK
^OPSLKLWYLZZPUN[OLIYHRLWLKHS
:LSLJ[WVZP[PVU5^OPSLKYP]PUNVUS`PM[OLJHY
PZ[OYLH[LUPUN[VZRPKPUZSPWWLY`JVUKP[PVUZ
6[OLY^PZL5ZOV\SKUV[ILZLSLJ[LK^OPSLKYP]Ì
PUN
J¤ph"a4FdF4apmhp=F
:LSLJ[ WVZP[PVU + MVY rUVYTHSs KYP]PUN ;OL
NLHYZ HYL ZOPM[LK H\[VTH[PJHSS` HJJVYKPUN [V
[OLHJJLSLYH[VYWVZP[PVUHUKZWLLK
+LWLUKPUN VU [OL ^H` [OL ]LOPJSL PZ KYP]LU HUK
VU[OLYLZPZ[HUJLLN\WOPSS[OLNLHYÌJOHUNPUN
WVPU[Z HYL ZOPM[LK [V^HYKZ OPNOLY VY SV^LY LUÌ
NPULÌZWLLKYHUNLZ
;OL HJJLSLYH[VY WVZP[PVU KYP]PUN ZWLLK LUNPUL
ZWLLK SVUNP[\KPUHS HUK SH[LYHS HJJLSLYH[PVU HUK
[OL YVHK WYVMPSL HSS OH]L HU PUMS\LUJL VU [OL
NLHYÌJOHUNPUNJOHYHJ[LYPZ[PJ
<U^HU[LK \W^HYK ZOPM[Z LN ILMVYL ILUKZ HYL
WYL]LU[LK I` Z^PM[S` YLSLHZPUN [OL HJJLSLYH[VY
WLKHS
+LWLUKPUN VU SH[LYHS HJJLSLYH[PVU \W^HYK ZOPM[Z
VU ILUKZ HYL UV[ THKL \U[PS [OL LUNPULÌZWLLK
SPTP[PZYLHJOLK
<UKLYIYHRPUNHUKKLWLUKPUNVU[OLHTV\U[VM
KLJLSLYH[PVU[OL;PW[YVUPJZOPM[ZKV^ULHYSPLY
-VY Z\IZLX\LU[ JVYULYPUN [OL YPNO[ NLHY PZ LUÌ
NHNLK ^OLU WYLZZ\YL PZ HWWSPLK [V [OL IYHRLZ
ILMVYL[OLILUK
;OL ILUK PZ [HRLU PU [OL YPNO[ NLHY HUK ^OLU
`V\HJJLSLYH[LV\[VM[OLILUK`V\KVUV[OH]L
[VZOPM[KV^U
+YP]PUNVMM
0U UK NLHY [OL ]LOPJSL KYP]LZ VMM ^P[O [OL
[OYV[[SLVUS`ZSPNO[S`VWLU
+YP]L VMM PU Z[ NLHY ^P[O [OL [OYV[[SL VWLU
^PKLYVY^OLU[OLLUNPULPZJVSK
:OPM[PUN.LHY
s¢n
:OPM[PUNNLHYVU[OLZ[LLYPUN^OLLS
>P[O [OL [VNNSL Z^P[JOLZ VU [OL Z[LLYPUN ^OLLS
`V\ JHU JOHUNL [LTWVYHYPS` MYVT H\[VTH[PJ
ZLSLJ[PVUTVKL+[VTHU\HSTVKL4
(K]HU[HNLZ!
:OPM[PUN KV^U ILMVYL ILUKZ HUK VU LU[LYPUN
I\PS[Ì\WHYLHZ
:OPM[PUN KV^U VU KV^U^HYK ZSVWLZ LUNPUL
IYHRPUN
:OPM[PUNKV^UMVYIYPLMZW\Y[ZVMHJJLSLYH[PVU
:LSLJ[PUNZ[NLHYMVYTV]PUNVMM
;OLTHU\HSZLSLJ[PVUTVKLYLTHPUZLUNHNLK!
MVYJVYULYPUNKLWLUKPUNVU[OLSH[LYHS
HJJLSLYH[PVUHUKV]LYY\UUPUN
^OLU[OL]LOPJSLPZZ[H[PVUHY`
LNH[HQ\UJ[PVU
;OLZ`Z[LTSLH]LZTHU\HSZLSLJ[PVUTVKL!
H\[VTH[PJHSS`HM[LYHWWYV_ZLJVUKZ
\USLZZJVYULYPUNVYV]LYY\UUPUN
PM`V\KLWYLZZ[OLHJJLSLYH[VY[VRPJRKV^U
HM[LYTV]PUNVMM
;LTWVYHY`JOHUNLÍKV^U
*VUKP[PVUZ!
:WLLKPZOPNOLY[OHUHWWYV_TWORTO
+LWYLZZHJJLSLYH[VYX\PJRS`
;OL;PW[YVUPJJOHUNLZ[LTWVYHYPS`[V[OLZWVYÌ
[PLZ[ NLHYÌJOHUNPUN THW PL [V [OL OPNOLZ[
WVZZPISL NLHYÌJOHUNPUN WVPU[Z *VYYLZWVUKÌ
PUNS` [OL [YHUZTPZZPVU ZOPM[Z KV^U PTTLKPÌ
H[LS`I`VULVY[^VNLHYZ
,UKPUN[OLM\UJ[PVU!
9LSLHZL [OL HJJLSLYH[VY THYRLKS` I` HWWYV_
2PJRKV^U
;OLRPJRKV^UM\UJ[PVUPZHJ[P]LPUZLSLJ[VYSL]LY
WVZP[PVU + L]LU PM `V\ [LTWVYHYPS` JOHUNL [V
THU\HS TVKL 4 \ ZPUN [OL [VNNSL Z^P[JOLZ VU
[OLZ[LLYPUN^OLLS
-VY VW[PT\T HJJLSLYH[PVU LN ^OLU V]LY[HRÌ
PUNKLWYLZZ[OLHJJLSLYH[VYWLKHSIL`VUK[OL
M\SSÌ[OYV[[SLWVPU[RPJRKV^U
;OL [YHUZTPZZPVU ZOPM[Z KV^U KLWLUKPUN VU [OL
ZWLLKVM[YH]LSHUKLUNPULZWLLK
<W^HYK ZOPM[Z VJJ\Y H[ [OL OPNOLZ[ WVZZPISL
LUNPULZWLLKZ
;OLZL NLHYÌJOHUNPUN ZWLLKZ YLTHPU HJ[P]L \U[PS
[OL HJJLSLYH[VY PZ YLSLHZLK [V HWWYV_ VM
[OL^PKLVWLU[OYV[[SLWVZP[PVU
s¬
:OPM[PUN.LHY
_"m¤"dFdF4apmp=F
;OL J\YYLU[S` ZLSLJ[LK NLHY PZ YL[HPULK PM `V\
JOHUNLMYVT+[V4
0M`V\ZOPM[MYVT4[V+[OLNLHYÌJOHUNPUNTHW
Z\P[HISLMVY`V\YJ\YYLU[KYP]PUNZ[`SLPZZLSLJ[LK
HUK[OLHWWYVWYPH[LNLHYPZZLSLJ[LK
>HYUPUN
;OL RPJRKV^U M\UJ[PVU PZ UV[ HJ[P]L PU
THU\HSZLSLJ[PVUTVKLr4s
;OLYLMVYL ZOPM[ KV^U THU\HSS` ^OLU HJJLSLYHÌ
[PUNLN[VV]LY[HRL
;^V[VNNSLZ^P[JOLZPU[OL\WWLYZ[LLYPUNÌ^OLLS
ZWVRLZ SL[ `V\ JVTMVY[HIS` HUK YLSPHIS` ZLSLJ[
[OLMP]LMVY^HYKNLHYZ
:OPM[PUN\W
7YLZZ\WWLYWHY[VMH[VNNSLZ^P[JO
:OPM[PUNKV^U
7YLZZSV^LYWHY[uVMH[VNNSLZ^P[JO
+LWLUKPUN VU KYP]PUN ZWLLK HUK LUNPUL ZWLLK
`V\JHUZOPM[\WVYKV^UH[HU`[PTL
.LHYJOHUNLZ^OPJO^V\SKL_JLLK[OL\WWLYVY
SV^LYLUNPULÌZWLLKSPTP[HYLUV[L_LJ\[LKI`[OL
JVU[YVSSLY
@V\JHUZOPM[KV^U[^VNLHYZH[VUJLI`X\PJRS`
WYLZZPUN[OL[VNNSLZ^P[JOLZ[^PJL
0M [OL LUNPULÌZWLLK SPTP[ PZ YLHJOLK HU H\[VÌ
TH[PJ \W^HYK ZOPM[ PZ WLYMVYTLK VY Q\Z[ ILMVYL
PKSPUNZWLLKPZYLHJOLKHKV^U^HYKZOPM[PZWLYÌ
MVYTLK
:LSLJ[ HU HWWYVWYPH[LS` SV^ NLHY VU \W^HYK
HUKKV^U^HYKZSVWLZ
;OPZ^PSSLUZ\YLVW[PT\T\ZLVMLUNPULWV^LY
HUKLUNPULIYHRPUN
0M THU\HS TVKL MHPSZ [OL JVU[YVS LSLJ[YVUPJZ
Z^P[JO [V H\[VTH[PJ TVKL 0U [OPZ L]LU[ [OL
PUZ[Y\TLU[JS\Z[LY^PSSKPZWSH`ZLSLJ[VYSL]LYWVZPÌ
[PVU+
;V YLTLK` [OL MH\S[ WSLHZL JVUZ\S[ HU H\[OÌ
VYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
:OPM[PUN.LHY
ss
dazhpmapamV
>OLU [OL ZWLLKZ VM YV[H[PVU VM [OL MYVU[ HUK
YLHYH_SLZKPMMLYI`TVYL[OHU[OLTH_PT\TWLYÌ
TPZZPISL ]HS\L PU[LNYH[LK ZSPW TVUP[VYPUN ZOPM[Z
\W[V[OLUL_[NLHY
;OPZPUJYLHZLZKYP]PUNZ[HIPSP[`VUHZSPWWLY`Z\YÌ
MHJL
5V[L
:SPW TVUP[VYPUN PZ HSZV KLHJ[P]H[LK ^OLU
7VYZJOL:[HIPSP[`4HUHNLTLU[7:4PZZ^P[JOLK
VMM
pzzamV
-VY H IYPLM Z[VW LN H[ H [YHMMPJ SPNO[ SLH]L
[OL ZLSLJ[VY SL]LY PU KYP]L WVZP[PVU HUK OVSK
[OL]LOPJSL^P[O[OLIYHRLWLKHS
-VY H SVUNLY Z[VW ^P[O [OL LUNPUL Y\UUPUN
ZLSLJ[WVZP[PVU5UL\[YHS
+V UV[ OVSK [OL JHY VU H ZSVWL \ZPUN [OL
HJJLSLYH[VY<ZL[OLIYHRLWLKHSVY[OLOHUKÌ
IYHRLPUZ[LHK
)LMVYL SLH]PUN [OL ]LOPJSL HS^H`Z HWWS` [OL
OHUKIYHRL HUK TV]L [OL ZLSLJ[VY SL]LY [V
WVZP[PVU7
"camV
.VLHZ`VU[OLHJJLSLYH[VY
>OLU WHYRPUN VY THUVL\]LYPUN PU H ZTHSS
ZWHJL JVU[YVS [OL ZWLLK I` JHYLM\S \ZL VM
[OLMVV[IYHRL
a¦amVam§amF
0U^PU[LY`YVHKJVUKP[PVUZP[PZHK]PZHISL[V[HRL
Z[LLWPUJSPULZPUTHU\HSTVKL;OPZWYL]LU[Z[OL
VJJ\YYLUJL VM NLHY JOHUNLZ [OH[ JV\SK JH\ZL
^OLLSZWPU
p§_"amV:p§amV
9LMLY[V[OLJOHW[LYr;V^PUNs
hFVFm4©zpV"h
([YHUZTPZZPVUMH\S[PZPUKPJH[LKI`[OLMVSSV^PUN
Z`TW[VTZ!
[ONLHYMSHZOLZVU[OLKPZWSH`VM[OLPUZ[Y\Ì
TLU[JS\Z[LY
;OL ^HYUPUN r;PW[YVUPJ LTLYNLUJ` Y\Us
HWWLHYZPU[OLVUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LY
;OL[YHUZTPZZPVUUVSVUNLYZOPM[Z
>HYUPUN
9L]LYZLNLHYSVJRTVUP[VYPUNPZKPZHISLKPU
[OLLTLYNLUJ`Y\UUPUNWYVNYHT
+HTHNL [V [OL ]LOPJSL TH` YLZ\S[ HZ ^LSS
HZ SVZZ VM JVU[YVS PM [OL ]LOPJSL PZ TV]PUN
MVY^HYK MHZ[ LUV\NO [V JH\ZL YLHY ^OLLS
SVJR\W
+VUV[ZOPM[PU[V9^OPSL[OL]LOPJSLPZTV]PUN
MVY^HYK
7YVJLLK HZ MVSSV^Z PU [OL L]LU[ VM H [YHUZÌ
TPZZPVUMH\S[!
:[VWPUHZHMLWSHJL
4V]LZLSLJ[VYSL]LY[VWVZP[PVU7Z^P[JO[OL
PNUP[PVUVMMHUK^HP[MVYZLJVUKZ
:[HY[[OLLUNPUL
UK NLHY PU ZLSLJ[VY WVZP[PVU + HUK YL]LYZL
NLHY9HYLUV^H]HPSHISLHUK^PSSHSSV^`V\[V
YLHJO[OLULHYLZ[H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
;V YLTLK` [OL MH\S[ WSLHZL JVUZ\S[ HU H\[OÌ
VYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLYPTTLKPH[LS`
s¢
:OPM[PUN.LHY
"amFm"m4F:""F
*H\[PVUZ
*VVSHU[SL]LS
,UNPULVPS u
,UNPULVPSSL]LS
,UNPULVPSYLJVTTLUKH[PVU
)YHRLÌMS\PKSL]LS
-\LSLJVUVT`VWLYH[PUN`V\YJHY
PUV[OLYJV\U[YPLZ
-\LSMPSSLYMSHWM\LS[HUR
-\LSYLJVTTLUKH[PVUZ
7VY[HISLM\LSJVU[HPULYZ
,TPZZPVUJVU[YVSZ`Z[LT
-\LSL]HWVYH[PVUJVU[YVS
>HZOLYMS\PK
7V^LYZ[LLYPUNMS\PKSL]LS
(PYMPS[LYWHY[PJSLMPS[LY
H\[VTH[PJ[YHUZTPZZPVUMS\PK
THU\HS[YHUZTPZZPVUVPS
7V^LYTLHZ\YLTLU[Z
>PWLYISHKLZ
*HYJHYL u
4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL
s
¨F4aF¨FhF"¤apm§^Fm
pcamVpm©p¤F^a4dF
>HYUPUN
0NUVYPUN [OL MVSSV^PUN PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ TH`
JH\ZLZLYPV\ZWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`
;OLLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[VMHU`TV[VY]LOPJSL
PZHWV[LU[PHSS`OHaHYKV\ZHYLH0M`V\HYLUV[
M\SS`MHTPSPHY^P[OWYVWLYYLWHPYWYVJLK\YLZKV
UV[H[[LTW[[OLHKQ\Z[TLU[ZKLZJYPILKVU[OL
MVSSV^PUNWHNLZ
;OPZJH\[PVUHWWSPLZ[V[OLLU[PYL]LOPJSL
6US` ^VYR VU `V\Y ]LOPJSL V\[KVVYZ VY PU H
^LSS]LU[PSH[LKHYLH
,UZ\YL [OH[ [OLYL HYL UV VWLU MSHTLZ PU [OL
HYLH VM `V\Y ]LOPJSL H[ HU` [PTL ^OLU M\LS
M\TLZ TPNO[ IL WYLZLU[ )L LZWLJPHSS` JH\Ì
[PV\Z VM Z\JO KL]PJLZ Z\JO HZ OV[ ^H[LY
OLH[LYZ^OPJOPNUP[LHMSHTLPU[LYTP[[LU[S`
)LMVYL^VYRPUNVUHU`WHY[PU[OLLUNPULJVTÌ
WHY[TLU[ [\YU [OL LUNPUL VMM HUK SL[ P[ JVVS
KV^U Z\MMPJPLU[S` /V[ LUNPUL JVTWHY[TLU[
JVTWVULU[ZJHUI\YUZRPUVUJVU[HJ[
)L HSLY[ HUK JH\[PV\Z HYV\UK LUNPUL H[ HSS
[PTLZ^OPSL[OLLUNPULPZY\UUPUN
0M ^VYR OHZ [V IL WLYMVYTLK ^P[O [OL LUNPUL
Y\UUPUN HS^H`Z ZL[ [OL WHYRPUN IYHRL HUK
THRL Z\YL [OL ZOPM[ SL]LY PZ PU UL\[YHS VY [OL
ZLSLJ[VYSL]LYPZPUWVZP[PVUs7rVYs5r
0U WHY[PJ\SHY IL ]LY` JHYLM\S [V LUZ\YL [OH[
P[LTZ VM JSV[OPUN [PLZ ZOPY[ ZSLL]LZ L[J
QL^LSY` SVUN OHPY OHUK VY MPUNLYZ JHUUV[ NL[
JH\NO[ PU [OL LUNPULÌJVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY
MHUILS[ZVYV[OLYTV]PUNWHY[Z
;OLYHKPH[VYHUKYHKPH[VYMHUZHYLPU[OLMYVU[
VM[OLJHY
;OL LUNPULÌJVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY PZ TV\U[LK
VU[OLLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[SPK
;OL LUNPULÌJVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY HS^H`Z Y\UZ
^OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ Z^P[JOLK VU (M[LY [OL
PNUP[PVU PZ Z^P[JOLK VMM [OL LUNPUL JVTWHY[Ì
TLU[HUKJVVSHU[[LTWLYH[\YLZHYLTVUP[VYLK
MVYHWWYV_TPU\[LZ
+\YPUN [OPZ WLYPVK HUK KLWLUKPUN VU [LTÌ
WLYH[\YL [OL LUNPULÌJVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY HUK
YHKPH[VY MHUZ TH` JVU[PU\L [V Y\U VY Z[HY[ [V
Y\U
*HYY` V\[ ^VYR PU [OLZL HYLHZ VUS` ^P[O [OL
LUNPULVMMHUKL_LYJPZLL_[YLTLJH\[PVU
@V\Y 7VYZJOL PZ LX\PWWLK ^P[O HU LSLJ[YVUPJ
PNUP[PVU Z`Z[LT >OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ VU OPNO
]VS[HNL PZ WYLZLU[ PU HSS ^PYLZ JVUULJ[LK ^P[O
[OL PNUP[PVU Z`Z[LT" [OLYLMVYL L_LYJPZL L_Ì
[YLTL JH\[PVU ^OLU ^VYRPUN VU HU` WHY[ VM
[OL LUNPUL ^OPSL [OL PNUP[PVU PZ VU VY [OL LUÌ
NPULPZY\UUPUN
(S^H`Z Z\WWVY[ `V\Y JHY ^P[O ZHML[` Z[HUKZ PM
P[ PZ ULJLZZHY` [V ^VYR \UKLY [OL JHY ;OL
QHJRZ\WWSPLK^P[O[OLJHYPZUV[HKLX\H[LMVY
[OPZW\YWVZL
>OLU ^VYRPUN \UKLY [OL JHY ^P[OV\[ ZHML[`
Z[HUKZ I\[ ^P[O [OL ^OLLSZ VU [OL NYV\UK
THRL Z\YL [OL JHY PZ VU SL]LS NYV\UK [OL
^OLLSZ HYL ISVJRLK HUK [OH[ [OL LUNPUL JHUÌ
UV[ILZ[HY[LK
9LTV]L[OLPNUP[PVURL`
+VUV[ZTVRLVYHSSV^HUVWLUMSHTLHYV\UK
[OLIH[[LY`VYM\LS
2LLWHMPYLL_[PUN\PZOLYPUJSVZLYLHJO
0UJVTWSL[L VY PTWYVWLY ZLY]PJPUN TH` JH\ZL
WYVISLTZ PU [OL VWLYH[PVU VM [OL JHY 0M PU
KV\I[ HIV\[ HU` ZLY]PJPUN OH]L P[ KVUL I`
`V\YH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
0TWYVWLY THPU[LUHUJL K\YPUN [OL ^HYYHU[`
WLYPVK TH` HMMLJ[ `V\Y 7VYZJOL ^HYYHU[`
JV]LYHNL
:\WWSPLZ VM MS\PKZ LN LUNPUL VPS IYHRL MS\PK
VYJVVSHU[HYLOHaHYKV\Z[V`V\YOLHS[O
2LLW [OLZL MS\PKZ V\[ VM JOPSKYLUqZ YLHJO HUK
KPZWVZL VM [OLT PU HJJVYKHUJL ^P[O [OL HWÌ
WYVWYPH[LYLN\SH[PVUZ
:VTL JV\U[YPLZ YLX\PYL HKKP[PVUHS [VVSZ HUK
ZWLJPHSZWHYLWHY[Z[VILJHYYPLK
7SLHZLTHRLLUX\PYPLZILMVYLKYP]PUNHIYVHK
sT
4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL
ppd"mF¦Fd
-VSSV^[OLPUZ[Y\J[PVUZPU[OLs*H\[PVUZrJOHW[LY
;OLJVVSPUNZ`Z[LTPZMPSSLKH[[OLMHJ[VY`^P[OH
WLYTHULU[JVVSHU[
0[ WYV]PKLZ `LHYÌYV\UK WYV[LJ[PVU MYVT JVYYVZPVU
HUK MYLLaPUN KV^U [V u-u* 5VYKPJ
JV\U[YPLZu-u*
6US`\ZLHU[PMYLLaLH\[OVYPaLKI`7VYZJOL
^F4camV4ppd"mdF¦Fd
;OLL_WHUZPVU[HUR^P[OP[ZMPSSLYVYPMPJLPZPU[OL
LUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[
*OLJR [OL JVVSHU[ SL]LS YLN\SHYS` [OYV\NO [OL
[YHUZWHYLU[L_WHUZPVU[HUR
>OLU[OLLUNPULPZJVSKHUK[OLJHYPZSL]LS[OL
MS\PKSL]LST\Z[SPLIL[^LLU[OLs4PUrHUKs4H_r
THYRPUNZ
pzzamVpOO4ppd"m
>HYUPUN
+HUNLY VM ZLYPV\Z WLYZVUHS PUQ\Y` MYVT
ZJHSKPUN *VVSHU[ PZ OHaHYKV\Z [V `V\Y
OLHS[OHUKTH`ILMH[HSPMZ^HSSV^LK
+V UV[ VWLU [OL JHW VM [OL L_WHUZPVU [HUR
^OPSL[OLLUNPULPZOV[
(SSV^[OLLUNPUL[VJVVSKV^UILMVYLVWLUPUN
[OL JHW HUK WYV[LJ[ `V\Y OHUKZ HYTZ HUK
MHJLMYVTHU`WVZZPISLLZJHWLVMOV[JVVSHU[
2LLWJVVSHU[V\[VMJOPSKYLUqZYLHJO
(SZVRLLWJVVSHU[H^H`MYVT`V\YWL[Z
;OL`JHUILH[[YHJ[LK[VP[ZOV\SK[OLYLILH
ZWPSS VY [V \ZLK JVVSHU[ SLM[ PU HU VWLU JVUÌ
[HPULY *VVSHU[ JHU IL KLHKS` [V WL[Z PM JVUÌ
Z\TLK
:^P[JOLUNPULVMMHUKSL[P[JVVS
:LL[OLJOHW[LYVU[OLs*VVSPUNZ`Z[LTr
*V]LY [OL L_WHUZPVU [HUR JHW ^P[O H [OPJR
YHN
6WLUJHWZSV^S`HUKJHYLM\SS`HUKHSSV^V]LYÌ
WYLZZ\YL[VLZJHWL
;OLU\UZJYL^JHWJVTWSL[LS`
6US`HKKHTP_[\YLVMHU[PMYLLaLHUK^H[LYPU
LX\HS WHY[Z HUK KV UV[ L_JLLK [OL s4H_r
THYR
(U[PMYLLaLPUJVVSHU[!
NP]LZWYV[LJ[PVUKV^U[Vu-u*
NP]LZWYV[LJ[PVUKV^U[Vu-u*
:JYL^JHWMPYTS`VU
0M PU HU LTLYNLUJ` W\YL ^H[LY OHZ ILLU HKKLK
[OLTP_YH[PVT\Z[ILJVYYLJ[LKH[HUH\[OVYPaLK
7VYZJOLKLHSLY
4HYRLK SVZZ VM JVVSHU[ PUKPJH[LZ SLHRHNL PU [OL
JVVSPUNZ`Z[LT
;OL JH\ZL ZOV\SK PTTLKPH[LS` IL YLTLKPLK H[
HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL
sQ
mVamF_4phz"hFm*dp§F:
"=a"pO"m
;OL YHKPH[VYZ HUK YHKPH[VY MHUZ HYL PU [OL MYVU[
VM[OLJHY
;OL LUNPULÌJVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY PZ TV\U[LK VU
[OLLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[SPK
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMPUQ\Y`
;OL LUNPULÍJVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY HS^H`Z
Y\UZ^OLU[OLPNUP[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVU(M[LY
[OLPNUP[PVUPZZ^P[JOLKVMM[OLLUNPULJVTÍ
WHY[TLU[ HUK JVVSHU[ [LTWLYH[\YLZ HYL
TVUP[VYLKMVYHWWYV_TPU\[LZ
+\YPUN [OPZ WLYPVK HUK KLWLUKPUN VU [LTÍ
WLYH[\YL [OL LUNPULÍJVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY
HUK YHKPH[VY MHUZ TH` JVU[PU\L [V Y\U VY
Z[HY[[VY\U
*HYY` V\[ ^VYR PU [OLZL HYLHZ VUS` ^P[O [OL
LUNPULVMMHUKL_LYJPZLL_[YLTLJH\[PVU
mVamFad
,UNPULVPSJVUZ\TW[PVU
0[PZUVYTHSMVY`V\YLUNPUL[VJVUZ\TLVPS
;OL YH[L VM VPS JVUZ\TW[PVU KLWLUKZ VU [OL
X\HSP[` HUK ]PZJVZP[` VM VPS [OL ZWLLK H[ ^OPJO
[OL LUNPUL PZ VWLYH[LK [OL JSPTH[L YVHK JVUKPÌ
[PVUZHZ^LSSHZ[OLHTV\U[VMKPS\[PVUHUKV_PKHÌ
[PVUVM[OLS\IYPJHU[
0M [OL ]LOPJSL PZ \ZLK MVY YLWLH[LK ZOVY[ [YPWZ
HUK JVUZ\TLZ H UVYTHS HTV\U[ VM VPS [OL LUÌ
NPULVPSTLHZ\YLTLU[TH`UV[ZOV^HU`KYVWPU
[OL VPS SL]LS H[ HSS L]LU HM[LY TPSLZ
RTVYTVYL;OPZPZILJH\ZL[OLVPSPZNYHK\HSS`
ILJVTPUNKPS\[LK^P[OM\LSVYTVPZ[\YLTHRPUNP[
HWWLHY[OH[[OLVPSSL]LSOHZUV[JOHUNLK
;OL KPS\[PUN PUNYLKPLU[Z L]HWVYH[L V\[ ^OLU [OL
]LOPJSL PZ KYP]LU H[ OPNO ZWLLKZ HZ VU HU L_Ì
WYLZZ^H` THRPUN P[ [OLU HWWLHY [OH[ VPS PZ L_Ì
JLZZP]LS`JVUZ\TLKHM[LYKYP]PUNH[OPNOZWLLKZ
0M [OL JVUKP[PVUZ `V\ KYP]L `V\Y ]LOPJSL PU HYL
K\Z[` O\TPK VY OV[ [OL MYLX\LUJ` VM [OL VPS
JOHUNLPU[LY]HSZZOV\SKILNYLH[LY
0M [OL ]LOPJSL PZ KYP]LU H[ H OPNO YH[L VM ZWLLK
JSPTH[PJ JVUKP[PVUZ HYL ^HYT HUK [OL SVHK PZ
OPNO[OLVPSZOV\SKILJOLJRLKTVYLMYLX\LU[S`
HZ KYP]PUN JVUKP[PVUZ ^PSS KL[LYTPUL [OL YH[L VM
VPSJVUZ\TW[PVU
;OL LUNPUL PU `V\Y ]LOPJSL KLWLUKZ VU VPS [V
S\IYPJH[LHUKJVVSHSSVMP[ZTV]PUNWHY[Z
;OLYLMVYL [OL LUNPUL VPS ZOV\SK IL JOLJRLK
YLN\SHYS`HUKRLW[H[[OLYLX\PYLKSL]LS
4HRL P[ H OHIP[ [V OH]L [OL LUNPUL VPS SL]LS
JOLJRLK^P[OL]LY`M\LSMPSSPUN
;OL VPS WYLZZ\YL ^HYUPUN SPNO[ PZ UV[ HU VPS
SL]LSPUKPJH[VY
;OL VPS WYLZZ\YL ^HYUPUN SPNO[ PUKPJH[LZ
ZLYPV\Z LUNPUL KHTHNL TH` IL VJJ\YPUN
^OLUSP[PMLUNPULYWTPZHIV]LPKSLZWLLK
s
4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL
mVamFadF¦Fd
9LN\SHYS` JOLJR [OL VPS SL]LS \ZPUN [OL VUÌ
IVHYKJVTW\[LYLHJO[PTLILMVYLYLM\LSSPUN
9LMLY[V[OLJOHW[LYr6UÌIVHYKJVTW\[LYs
;OL KPMMLYLUJL IL[^LLU [OL TPU HUK TH_
THYRZ VU [OL ZLNTLU[ KPZWSH` VM [OL VUÌ IVHYK
JVTW\[LYPZHWWYV_SP[LYZX\HY[Z
6UL ZLNTLU[ VM [OL KPZWSH` JVYYLZWVUKZ [V H
X\HU[P[`VMHWWYV_SP[LYX\HY[
pzzamVpOOFmVamFpad
>HYUPUN
9PZR VM I\YUPUN MYVT OV[ WHY[Z PU LUNPUL
JVTWHY[TLU[ 9PZR VM PUQ\Y` I` YV[H[PUN
WHY[Z ;OL LUNPUL JVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY VU
[OL LUNPUL JVTWHY[TLU[ SPK JHU Z[HY[ \W
L]LU^P[O[OLLUNPULVMM
,_LYJPZL L_[YLTL JH\[PVU ^OLU ^VYRPUN VU
[OLLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[
-VSSV^ [OL PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ PU [OL JOHW[LY r5V[LZ
VUTHPU[LUHUJLs
;VWVMMLUNPULVPSVUS`^P[O[OLLUNPULVMM
,UNPUL VPS PZ OHaHYKV\Z [V `V\Y OLHS[O HUK
TH`ILMH[HSPMZ^HSSV^LK
2LLWLUNPULVPSV\[VMJOPSKYLUqZYLHJO
<ZLK LUNPUL VPS JVU[HPUZ JOLTPJHSZ [OH[
OH]LJH\ZLKJHUJLYPUSHIVYH[VY`HUPTHSZ
(S^H`Z WYV[LJ[ `V\Y ZRPU I` ^HZOPUN [OVYÌ
V\NOS`^P[OZVHWHUK^H[LY
;OL VUÌIVHYK JVTW\[LY PUKPJH[LZ OV^ T\JO
VPST\Z[ILHKKLK
:^P[JOVMM[OLLUNPUL
<UZJYL^JHWVM[OLVPSMPSSLYVWLUPUN
(KK H[ TVZ[ OHSM H SP[LY VM LUNPUL VPS H[ H
[PTL
4LHZ\YLVPSSL]LSHNHPU
(KKTVYLLUNPULVPSPMULJLZZHY`
5L]LYHKKTVYLLUNPULVPS[OHUYLX\PYLK
[VYLHJO[OLTH_THYR
*SVZLJHWVM[OLVPSMPSSLYVWLUPUN
4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL
s
mVamFadF4phhFm="apm
9LJVTTLUKLKVPS]PZJVZP[`YHUNLZKLWLUKLU[VUHTIPLU[[LTWLYH[\YLZ!
(TIPLU[[LTWLYH[\YLZ
:(,=PZJVZP[`9HUNL
ZLHZVUHS
LUNPULVPSZ
NLULYHSS`OPNOLY[OHU
>Ì
-*
>Ì
>Ì
NLULYHSS`SV^LY[OHU
>Ì
-*
>Ì
<ZLVUS`LUNPULVPSZSHILSSLKHZ(70:/VY:1HUK]PZJVZP[`NYHKLZVM:(,>Í>ÍVYOPNOLY
7YLMLYHIS``V\ZOV\SK\ZLZ`U[OL[PJVYZLTPZ`U[OL[PJLUNPULVPSZ
0MPUKV\I[HZR`V\YH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLYMVY7VYZJOL[LZ[LKHUKHWWYV]LKHSSÍZLHZVUVPSZ
sG
4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL
ad4^"mVF
;OL LUNPUL VPS OHZ [V IL JOHUNLK H[ [OL PU[LYÌ
]HSZSPZ[LKPU`V\Y4HPU[LUHUJL:JOLK\SL
:LLs*HWHJP[PLZr
>L YLJVTTLUK [OH[ `V\ OH]L [OL LUNPUL VPS
JOHUNLK H[ `V\Y 7VYZJOL KLHSLY ^OV OHZ [OL
YLX\PYLKVPSZHUK[OLULJLZZHY`MPSSPUNLX\PWTLU[
0M `V\ Z\ZWLJ[ HU VPS SLHR PU [OL LUNPUL OH]L
`V\YKLHSLYJOLJRP[V\[PTTLKPH[LS`
(SS J\YYLU[ LUNPUL VPSZ HYL JVTWH[PISL ^P[O LHJO
V[OLY PL ^OLU THRPUN HU VPS JOHUNL P[ PZ UV[
ULJLZZHY`[VMS\ZO[OLLUNPULPM`V\^PZO[V\ZL
HKPMMLYLU[IYHUKVYNYHKLVMVPS
:PUJL OV^L]LY LHJO IYHUK VM VPS OHZ H ZWLJPHS
JVTWVZP[PVU `V\ ZOV\SK PM WVZZPISL \ZL [OL
ZHTL VPS IYHUK PM P[ ILJVTLZ ULJLZZHY` [V [VW
VMMIL[^LLUVPSJOHUNLZ
7VYZJOL LUNPULZ OH]L SVUNPU[LY]HSZIL[^LLUVPS
JOHUNLZ @V\ JHU THRL ILZ[ \ZL VM [OLZL SVUN
VPS JOHUNL PU[LY]HSZ I` \ZPUN T\S[PNYHKL VPSZ
ZPUJL [OLZL HYL SHYNLS` PUKLWLUKLU[ VM ZLHZVUHS
MS\J[\H[PVUZPU[LTWLYH[\YL
0M `V\Y ]LOPJSL PZ \ZLK MYLX\LU[S` PU Z[VWÌHUKÌNV
[YHMMPJPUJVSK^LH[OLY[OLLUNPUL^PSSUV[HS^H`Z
ILWYVWLYS`^HYTLK\W
*VUKLUZH[PVUMYVTWYVK\J[ZVMJVTI\Z[PVUTH`
HJJ\T\SH[LPU[OLVPS0U[OPZJHZLP[PZHK]PZHISL
[V JOHUNL [OL VPS TVYL MYLX\LU[S` ZV [OH[ `V\Y
LUNPUL VUJL HNHPU OHZ LMMPJPLU[ LUNPUL
VPS
mVamFpadzFOph"m4F4d"
,UNPULVPSPZUV[VUS`HS\IYPJHU[I\[HSZVZLY]LZ
[V RLLW [OL LUNPUL JSLHU [V UL\[YHSPaL [OL KPY[
^OPJO WLUL[YH[LZ PU[V [OL LUNPUL [OYV\NO JVTÌ
I\Z[PVUHUK[VWYV[LJ[[OLLUNPULHNHPUZ[JVYYVÌ
ZPVU
;V WLYMVYT [OLZL M\UJ[PVUZ [OL VPS PZ WYV]PKLK
^P[O HKKP[P]LZ ^OPJO OH]L ILLU ZWLJPHSS` KLÌ
]LSVWLKMVY[OLZLM\UJ[PVUZ
;OL LMMPJPLUJ` VM HU VPS PZ L_WYLZZLK MVY
L_HTWSL I` [OL (70 03:(* VY (*,( JSHZZPMPJHÌ
[PVUZ
<ZL VUS` LUNPUL VPSZ ^P[O [OL JSHZZPMPJH[PVU (70
:/VY:1VY03:(*.-VY(*,((,\YVWL
a4pa©
3PRL HSS SPX\PKZ LUNPUL VPS PZ ]PZJV\Z ^OLU JVSK
HUK [OPUÌIVKPLK ^OLU ^HYT ;OL ]PZJVZP[` VM HU
VPS PZ L_WYLZZLK I` P[Z :(, JSHZZ -VY JVSK ]PZÌ
JVZP[` TLHZ\YLK H[ [LTWLYH[\YLZ ILSV^
-* [OL :(, JSHZZ PZ NP]LU HZ H U\TILY
HUK[OLSL[[LYs>rHZPU^PU[LYMVYOV[]PZJVZP[`
TLHZ\YLK H[ -* [OL :(, JSHZZ PZ
NP]LUVUS`HZHU\TILY
;OL ]PZJVZP[` VM HU VPS PZ [OLYLMVYL HS^H`Z [OL
ZHTL PM P[ OHZ [OL ZHTL U\TILY VM HU :(,
JSHZZ
,N! ( >Ì VPS HUK H >Ì VPS OH]L [OL
ZHTL]PZJVZP[`^OLUJVSKILSV^*"^OLUOV[
H[ -* [OL VPS ^P[O [OL U\TILY PZ
[OPUULY[OHU[OLVPS^P[O[OLU\TILY
6PSZ ^P[O [^V ]PZJVZP[PLZ HYL JHSSLK T\S[PNYHKL
VPSZ" VPSZ ^P[O VUS` VUL ]PZJVZP[` HYL [LYTLK
ZPUNSLÌNYHKLVPSZ
:PUNSLÌNYHKLVPSZJHUUV[IL\ZLKPU`V\YLUNPUL
;OL ]PZJVZP[` VM [OL LUNPUL VPS MVY `V\Y 7VYZJOL
OHZ[VILJOVZLUHJJVYKPUN[V[OLHTIPLU[[LTÌ
WLYH[\YLNP]LUPU[OLLUNPULVPSYLJVTTLUKH[PVU
[HISL
4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL
sn
"cF d¤a=F¦Fd
-VSSV^[OLPUZ[Y\J[PVUZPU[OLs*H\[PVUZrJOHW[LY
<ZL VUS` UL^ \U\ZLK 6YPNPUHS 7VYZJOL
IYHRLMS\PK
>HYUPUN
)YHRLMS\PKPZOHaHYKV\Z[V`V\YOLHS[OHUK
TH`ILMH[HSPMZ^HSSV^LK
)YHRLMS\PKHSZVH[[HJRZWHPU[^VYR
2LLWIYHRLMS\PKV\[VMJOPSKYLUqZYLHJO
;HRL JHYL ^OPSL [VWWPUN VMMIYHRLMS\PKUV[[V
ZVPS[OLS\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[VYP[LTZVMS\NÌ
NHNL
^F4camV^F*"cFOd¤a=dF¦Fd
;OLYLZLY]VPYMVY[OLO`KYH\SPJIYHRPUNZ`Z[LTPZ
PU[OLS\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[
*OLJR [OL IYHRLÌMS\PK SL]LS YLN\SHYS` H[ [OL
[YHUZWHYLU[YLZLY]VPY
;OL MS\PK SL]LS ZOV\SK HS^H`Z SPL IL[^LLU [OL
s4PUrHUKs4H_rTHYRZ
( ZSPNO[ KLJYLHZL PU [OL MS\PK SL]LS K\L [V ^LHY
HUK H\[VTH[PJ YLHKQ\Z[TLU[ VM [OL KPZJ IYHRLZ
PZUVYTHS
0M OV^L]LY [OL MS\PK SL]LS MHSSZ THYRLKS` VY
ILSV^ [OL s4PUr THYR [OL IYHRPUN Z`Z[LT TH`
OH]LKL]LSVWLKHSLHR
/H]L[OLIYHRPUNZ`Z[LTJOLJRLKPTTLKPH[LS`
H[HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
^"mVamV^F*"cFOd¤a=
)YHRL MS\PK HIZVYIZ TVPZ[\YL MYVT [OL HPY V]LY
[PTL;OPZHJJ\T\SH[PVUVM^H[LYSV^LYZ[OLIVPSÌ
PUN WVPU[ HUK \UKLY JLY[HPU VWLYH[PUN JVUÌ
KP[PVUZJHUHMMLJ[[OLIYHRPUNHJ[PVU
;OLYLMVYL OH]L [OL IYHRL MS\PK JOHUNLK PU HJÌ
JVYKHUJL^P[O[OLJOHUNLPU[LY]HSZZ[H[LKPU[OL
IYVJO\YLs4HPU[LUHUJLr
"mamVdaV^
"mamVdaV^"m"="
;OL IYHRLÌMS\PK ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[
WHULSHUKVUÌIVHYKJVTW\[LYPUKPJH[L!
IYHRLÌMS\PKSL]LS[VVSV^
PUJVUQ\UJ[PVU^P[OSHYNLWLKHS[YH]LS
HIYHRPUNÌJPYJ\P[MHPS\YL
0M[OL^HYUPUNSPNO[ZZOV\SKSPNO[\W^OPSL
KYP]PUN!
:[VWPTTLKPH[LS`PUHZ\P[HISLWSHJL
+VUV[JVU[PU\LKYP]PUN
7SLHZL OH]L [OL MH\S[ YLTLKPLK H[ `V\Y ULHYÌ
LZ[H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
sT¬
4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL
¤Fd4pmph©
-\LS LJVUVT` ^PSS ]HY` KLWLUKPUN VU
^OLYL ^OLU HUK OV^ `V\ KYP]L VW[PVUHS
LX\PWTLU[PUZ[HSSLKHUK[OLNLULYHSJVUKPÍ
[PVUVM`V\YJHY
( JHY [\ULK [V ZWLJPMPJH[PVUZ HUK JVYYLJ[S`
THPU[HPULK^PSSOLSW`V\[VHJOPL]LVW[PTHS
M\LSLJVUVT`
/H]L`V\Y]LOPJSL[\ULK[VZWLJPMPJH[PVUZ
(PYJSLHULYZOV\SKILKPY[MYLL[VHSSV^WYVWLY
LUNPULsIYLH[OPUNr
)H[[LY`ZOV\SKILM\SS`JOHYNLK
>OLLSZZOV\SKILWYVWLYS`HSPNULK
;PYLZZOV\SKILPUMSH[LKH[JVYYLJ[WYLZZ\YL
(S^H`ZTVUP[VY`V\YM\LSJVUZ\TW[PVU
+YP]L ZTVV[OS` H]VPK HIY\W[ JOHUNLZ PU
ZWLLKHZT\JOHZWVZZPISL
(]VPKQHJRYHIIP[Z[HY[ZHUKZ\KKLUZ[VWZ
+V UV[ KYP]L SVUNLY [OHU ULJLZZHY` PU [OL
SV^LY NLHYZ :OPM[PUN PU[V H OPNOLY NLHY LHYS`
^P[OV\[S\NNPUN[OLLUNPUL^PSSOLSWZH]LM\LS
7YVSVUNLK s^HYT \Wr PKSPUN ^HZ[LZ NHZ:[HY[
[OL]LOPJSLQ\Z[ILMVYL`V\HYLYLHK`[VKYP]L
(JJLSLYH[LZSV^S`HUKZTVV[OS`
:^P[JO VMM [OL LUNPUL PM Z[H[PVUHY` MVY SVUNLY
WLYPVKZ
(U`HKKP[PVUHS^LPNO[JHYYPLKPU[OL]LOPJSLYLÌ
K\JLZ M\LS LJVUVT` (S^H`Z RLLW JHYNV [V H
TPUPT\THUKYLTV]LHSS\UULJLZZHY`P[LTZ
6YNHUPaL`V\Y[YPWZ[V[HRLPUZL]LYHSLYYHUKZ
PUVUL[YPW
(SS LSLJ[YPJHS HJJLZZVYPLZ JVU[YPI\[L [V PUÌ
JYLHZLKM\LSJVUZ\TW[PVU
6US` Z^P[JO VU [OL HPY JVUKP[PVUPUN ^OLU
ULJLZZHY`
+V UV[ KYP]L ^P[O [OL 9VVM ;YHUZWVY[ :`Z[LT
TV\U[LK\USLZZ`V\ULLKP[
;OL,7(LZ[PTH[LKTWNPZ[VIL\ZLKMVY
JVTWHYPZVU W\YWVZLZ HJ[\HS TPSLHNL TH`
IL KPMMLYLU[ MYVT [OL LZ[PTH[LK TWNKLÍ
WLUKPUN VU `V\Y KYP]PUN ZWLLK ^LH[OLY
JVUKP[PVUZ HUK [YPW SLUN[O @V\Y HJ[\HS
OPNO^H` TPSLHNL ^PSS WYVIHIS` IL SLZZ [OHU
[OLLZ[PTH[LKTWN
7SLHZL VIZLY]L HSS SVJHS HUK UH[PVUHS ZWLLK
SPTP[Z
zF"amV p¤p4^Famp^F
p¤maF
.V]LYUTLU[YLN\SH[PVUZPU[OL<UP[LK:[H[LZHUK
*HUHKH YLX\PYL [OH[ H\[VTVIPSLZ TLL[ ZWLJPMPJ
LTPZZPVU YLN\SH[PVUZ HUK ZHML[` Z[HUKHYKZ
;OLYLMVYL JHYZ I\PS[ MVY [OL <: HUK *HUHKH
KPMMLYMYVT]LOPJSLZZVSKPUV[OLYJV\U[YPLZ
0M`V\WSHU[V[HRL`V\Y7VYZJOLV\[ZPKL[OLJVUÌ
[PULU[HS SPTP[Z VM [OL <UP[LK :[H[LZ VY *HUHKH
[OLYLPZ[OLWVZZPIPSP[`[OH[
\USLHKLKM\LSTH`UV[ILH]HPSHISL"
\USLHKLK M\LS TH` OH]L H JVUZPKLYHIS` SV^LY
VJ[HUL YH[PUN ,_JLZZP]L LUNPUL RUVJR HUK
ZLYPV\Z KHTHNL [V IV[O LUNPUL HUK JH[HS`[PJ
JVU]LY[LYZJV\SKYLZ\S["
ZLY]PJL TH` IL PUHKLX\H[L K\L [V SHJR VM
WYVWLY ZLY]PJL MHJPSP[PLZ [VVSZ VY KPHNUVZ[PJ
LX\PWTLU["
YLWSHJLTLU[ WHY[Z TH` UV[ IL H]HPSHISL VY
]LY`KPMMPJ\S[[VNL[
7VYZJOL JHUUV[ IL YLZWVUZPISL MVY [OL
TLJOHUPJHS KHTHNL [OH[ JV\SK YLZ\S[ ILÍ
JH\ZL VM PUHKLX\H[L M\LS ZLY]PJL VY WHY[Z
H]HPSHIPSP[`
0M`V\W\YJOHZLK`V\Y7VYZJOLHIYVHKHUK^HU[
[VIYPUNP[IHJROVTLILZ\YL[VMPUKV\[HIV\[
ZOPWWPUN HUK MVY^HYKPUN YLX\PYLTLU[Z HZ ^LSS
HZJ\YYLU[PTWVY[HUKJ\Z[VTZYLN\SH[PVUZ
4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL
sTs
¤Fd
>HYUPUN
-\LS PZ OPNOS` MSHTTHISL HUK OHYTM\S [V
OLHS[O
-PYL VWLU MSHTL HUK ZTVRPUN HYL WYVOPIP[LK
^OLUOHUKSPUNM\LS
(]VPKJVU[HJ[^P[OZRPUVYJSV[OPUN
+VUV[PUOHSLM\LS]HWVYZ
;V WYL]LU[ KHTHNL[V[OLLTPZZPVUJVU[YVS
Z`Z[LTHUKLUNPUL!
5L]LYKYP]L[OL[HURJVTWSL[LS`V\[VMM\LS
(]VPKOPNOJVYULYPUNZWLLKZHM[LY[OL^HYUPUN
SPNO[ZOH]LJVTLVU
-VSSV^ [OL PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ PU [OL s-\LS ,JVUVT`r
s,TPZZPVU *VU[YVS :`Z[LTr HUK s-\LS SL]LS
NH\NLrJOHW[LYZ
zFmamV^FOaddFOd"z
;OL MPSSLY VWLUPUN PZ \UKLY [OL MPSSLY MSHW PU [OL
MYVU[YPNO[MLUKLY
>P[O [OL ]LOPJSL \USVJRLK WYLZZ VU [OL MYVU[
WHY[VM[OLMPSSLYMSHWHYYV^[VVWLU[OLMSHW
;OL MPSSLY MSHW PZ JLU[YHSS` SVJRLK HSVUN ^P[O [OL
V[OLYSVJRZ
0M[OLYLPZHKLMLJ[PU[OLH\[VTH[PJ\USVJRÍ
PUNZ`Z[LT!
6WLU[OLWHZZLUNLYKVVY
7\SS [OL YPUN PU [OL YPNO[ÌOHUK KVVY HWLY[\YL
HYYV^
sT¢
4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL
FO¤FddamV
-\LS[HURJHWHJP[`PZSPZ[LK\UKLYs*HWHJP[PLZr
7VYZJOL KVLZ UV[ YLJVTTLUK [OL \ZL VM M\LS
HKKP[P]LZ
0TWVY[HU[! :[VW [OL LUNPUL HUK Z^P[JO VMM
[OLPNUP[PVU
:SV^S`\UZJYL^[OL[HURJHW
/HUN[OL[HURJHWVU[OLWSHZ[PJZ[YHWVM[OL
MPSSLYMSHW
0UZLY[M\LSÌOVZLUVaaSLM\SS`PU[V[OLMPSSLYULJR
^P[O[OLOHUKSLVM[OLM\LSÌOVZLUVaaSLMHJPUN
KV^U
+V UV[ HKK M\Y[OLY M\LS VUJL [OL JVYYLJ[S`
VWLYH[LK H\[VTH[PJ M\LSÌOVZL UVaaSL OHZ
Z^P[JOLKVMM
-\LS JV\SK ZWYH` VY JV\SK Y\U V]LY PU ^HYT
[LTWLYH[\YLZ
9LWSHJL [OL [HUR JHW PTTLKPH[LS` HM[LY
YLM\LSSPUNHUK[\YUP[\U[PS`V\OLHYP[HUKMLLS
P[LUNHNL
0M `V\ SVZL [OL [HUR JHW `V\ T\Z[ YLWSHJL
P[ VUS` ^P[O HU VYPNPUHS WHY[ [V YLK\JL [OL
WVZZPIPSP[` VM H MPYL PU [OL L]LU[ VM H JVSSPÍ
ZPVU
*OLJRLUNPUL^HYUPUNSPNO[
0M [OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[ WHULS HUK
VUÌIVHYK JVTW\[LY JVTL VU HUK YLTHPU VU
^OPSLKYP]PUNP[Z\NNLZ[Z!
HUPTWYVWLYS`MHZ[LULK[HURJHWVY
YLM\LSSPUN^P[OLUNPULY\UUPUN
¤FdF4phhFm="apm
@V\Y 7VYZJOL PZ LX\PWWLK ^P[O JH[HS`[PJ JVU]LYÌ
[LYZHUKT\Z[\ZL<53,(+,+-<,3653@
@V\YLUNPULPZKLZPNULK[VWYV]PKLVW[PT\TWLYÌ
MVYTHUJLHUKM\LSLJVUVT`\ZPUN\USLHKLKWYLÌ
TP\T M\LS ^P[O HU VJ[HUL YH[PUN VM 965
*3*VY(20 7VYZJOL [OLYLMVYL YLJVTÌ
TLUKZ[OL\ZLVM[OLZLM\LSZPU`V\Y]LOPJSL
7VYZJOL HSZV YLJVNUPaLZ [OH[ [OLZL M\LSZ TH`
UV[ HS^H`Z IL H]HPSHISL )L HZZ\YLK [OH[ `V\Y
]LOPJSL ^PSS VWLYH[L WYVWLYS` VU \USLHKLK WYLÌ
TP\T M\LSZ ^P[O VJ[HUL U\TILYZ VM H[ SLHZ[
965 *3* VY (20 ZPUJL [OL LUNPULqZ
s,SLJ[YVUPJ 6R[HUL¹ RUVJR JVU[YVSr ^PSS HKHW[
[OLPNUP[PVU[PTPUNPMULJLZZHY`
;OL \ZL VM \USLHKLK M\LS VUS` PZ JYP[PJHSS`
PTWVY[HU[[V[OLSPMLVM[OLJH[HS`[PJJVU]LYÍ
[LYZ +LWVZP[Z MYVT SLHKLK M\LSZ ^PSS Y\PU
[OL JVU]LY[LYZ HUK THRL P[ PULMMLJ[P]L HZ
HULTPZZPVUJVU[YVSKL]PJL
*HYZ ^P[O JH[HS`[PJ JVU]LY[LYZ OH]L H ZTHSSLY
M\LS [HUR VWLUPUN HUK NHZ Z[H[PVU W\TWZ OH]L
ZTHSSLY UVaaSLZ ;OPZ ^PSS WYL]LU[ HJJPKLU[HS
W\TWPUN VM SLHKLK M\LS PU[V JHYZ ^P[O JH[HS`[PJ
JVU]LY[LYZ
4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL
sT
<USLHKLK M\LSZ TH` UV[ IL H]HPSHISLV\[ZPKL[OL
JVU[PULU[HS<:HUK*HUHKH;OLYLMVYL^LYLJÌ
VTTLUK `V\ KV UV[ [HRL `V\Y JHY [V HYLHZ VY
JV\U[YPLZ ^OLYL \USLHKLK M\LS TH` UV[ IL H]HPSÌ
HISL
4"mF"amV
6J[HUL YH[PUN PUKPJH[LZ H M\LSqZ HIPSP[` [V YLZPZ[
KL[VUH[PVU;OLYLMVYLI\`PUN[OLJVYYLJ[VJ[HUL
NHZPZPTWVY[HU[[VWYL]LU[LUNPULsKHTHNLr
;OL965VJ[HULYH[PUNPZIHZLKVU[OLYLZLHYJO
TL[OVK ;OL *3* <: *VZ[ VM 3P]PUN *V\UJPS
VJ[HUL YH[PUN VY (20 HU[PRUVJR PUKL_ VJ[HUL
YH[PUN \Z\HSS` KPZWSH`LK VU <: M\LS W\TWZ PZ
JHSJ\SH[LK HZ YLZLHYJO VJ[HUL U\TILY WS\Z
TV[VYVJ[HULU\TILYKP]PKLKI`[OH[PZ^YP[Ì
[LUHZ!
965465 VY 94
;OL *3* VY (20 VJ[HUL YH[PUN PZ \Z\HSS` SV^LY
[OHU[OL965YH[PUN!
-VYL_HTWSL! 965LX\HSZ *3*VY(20
¤Fd4pm"amamV"d4p^pd"m=F^F
:VTL HYLHZ VM [OL <: YLX\PYL V_`NLUH[LK
M\LSZ K\YPUN JLY[HPUWVY[PVUZVM[OL`LHY6_`NLÌ
UH[LK M\LSZ HYL M\LSZ ^OPJO JVU[HPU HSJVOVSZ
Z\JO HZ TL[OHUVS VY L[OHUVS VY L[OLY Z\JO HZ
4;),
<UKLY UVYTHS JVUKP[PVUZ [OL HTV\U[ VM [OLZL
JVTWV\UKZPU[OLM\LS^PSSUV[HMMLJ[KYP]LHIPSP[`
@V\ TH` \ZL V_`NLUH[LK M\LSZ PU `V\Y 7VYZJOL
WYV]PKLK [OL VJ[HUL YLX\PYLTLU[Z MVY `V\Y ]LÌ
OPJSL HYL TL[ >L YLJVTTLUK OV^L]LY [V
JOHUNL[VHKPMMLYLU[M\LSVYZ[H[PVUPMHU`VM[OL
MVSSV^PUNWYVISLTZVJJ\Y^P[O`V\Y]LOPJSL!
+L[LYPVYH[PVUVMKYP]LHIPSP[`HUKWLYMVYTHUJL
:\IZ[HU[PHSS`YLK\JLKM\LSLJVUVT`
=HWVY SVJR HUK UVUÌZ[HY[ WYVISLTZ LZWLJPHSS`
H[OPNOHS[P[\KLVYH[OPNO[LTWLYH[\YL
,UNPULTHSM\UJ[PVUVYZ[HSSPUN
¤Fd4pm"amamV
:VTL 5VY[O (TLYPJHU M\LSZ JVU[HPU HU VJ[HUL
LUOHUJPUN HKKP[P]L JHSSLK TL[O`SJ`JSVWLU[HKPLU`S
THUNHULZL[YPJHYIVU`S44;
0M Z\JO M\LSZ HYL \ZLK `V\Y LTPZZPVU JVU[YVS
Z`Z[LTWLYMVYTHUJLTH`ILULNH[P]LS`HMMLJ[LK
;OL JOLJR LUNPUL ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z VU `V\Y PUZ[Y\Ì
TLU[WHULSTH`[\YUVU
0M [OPZ VJJ\YZ 7VYZJOL YLJVTTLUKZ `V\ Z[VW
\ZPUNM\LSZJVU[HPUPUN44;
p"*dF ¤Fdpm"amF
+HUNLY
7VY[HISL M\LS JVU[HPULYZ M\SS VY WHY[PHSS`
LTW[` TH` SLHR JH\ZPUN HU L_WSVZPVU VY
YLZ\S[PUMPYLPUJHZLVMHUHJJPKLU[
5L]LY JHYY` HKKP[PVUHS M\LS PU WVY[HISL JVUÌ
[HPULYZPU`V\Y]LOPJSL
sTT
4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL
haapmpmpd©Fh
m^FamFFpO4dF"m"a
7VSS\[PVUVMV\YLU]PYVUTLU[OHZILJVTLHWYVIÌ
SLT[OH[PZVMPUJYLHZPUNJVUJLYU[VHSSVM\Z>L
\YNL`V\[VQVPU\ZPUV\YLMMVY[ZMVYJSLHULYHPY
PU JVU[YVSSPUN [OL WVSS\[HU[Z LTP[[LK MYVT [OL
H\[VTVIPSL
7VYZJOLOHZKL]LSVWLKHULTPZZPVUJVU[YVSZ`ZÌ
[LT [OH[ JVU[YVSZ VY YLK\JLZ [OVZLWHY[ZVM[OL
LTPZZPVU [OH[ JHU IL OHYTM\S [V V\Y LU]PYVUÌ
TLU[@V\Y7VYZJOLPZLX\PWWLK^P[OZ\JOHZ`ZÌ
[LT
7VYZJOL ^HYYHU[Z [OL ,TPZZPVU *VU[YVS :`Z[LT
PU `V\Y UL^ JHY \UKLY [OL [LYTZ HUK JVUKP[PVUZ
ZL[MVY[OPU[OL>HYYHU[`)VVRSL[
@V\ HZ [OL V^ULY VM [OL ]LOPJSL OH]L [OL
YLZWVUZPIPSP[` [V WYV]PKL YLN\SHY THPU[LUHUJL
ZLY]PJL MVY [OL ]LOPJSL HUK [V RLLW H YLJVYK VM
HSS THPU[LUHUJL ^VYR WLYMVYTLK ;V MHJPSP[H[L
YLJVYK RLLWPUN OH]L [OL ZLY]PJL WLYMVYTLK I`
H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLYZ ;OL` OH]L 7VYZJOL
[YHPULK [LJOUPJPHUZ HUK ZWLJPHS [VVSZ [V WYV]PKL
MHZ[HUKLMMPJPLU[ZLY]PJL
;VHZZ\YLLMMPJPLU[VWLYH[PVUVM[OL
,TPZZPVU*VU[YVS:`Z[LT!
/H]L `V\Y ]LOPJSL THPU[HPULK WYVWLYS` HUK PU
HJJVYKHUJL ^P[O [OL YLJVTTLUKH[PVUZ KLÌ
ZJYPILKPU`V\Y4HPU[LUHUJL)VVRSL[
3HJR VM WYVWLY THPU[LUHUJL HZ ^LSS HZ PTÌ
WYVWLY\ZLVM[OL]LOPJSL^PSSPTWHPY[OLM\UJÌ
[PVUVM[OLLTPZZPVUJVU[YVSZ`Z[LTHUKJV\SK
SLHK[VKHTHNL
+VUV[HS[LYVYYLTV]LHU`JVTWVULU[VM[OL
LTPZZPVUJVU[YVSZ`Z[LT
+V UV[ HS[LY VY YLTV]L HU` KL]PJL Z\JO HZ
OLH[ ZOPLSKZ Z^P[JOLZ PNUP[PVU ^PYLZ ]HS]LZ
L[J^OPJOHYLKLZPNULK[VWYV[LJ[`V\Y]LOPÌ
JSLqZLTPZZPVUJVU[YVSZ`Z[LT
0UHKKP[PVU[VZLYPV\ZLUNPULKHTHNL[OPZJHU
YLZ\S[ PU H MPYL PM L_JLZZ YH^ M\LS YLHJOLZ [OL
L_OH\Z[Z`Z[LT
+VUV[JVU[PU\L[VVWLYH[L`V\Y]LOPJSLPM`V\
KL[LJ[ LUNPUL TPZMPYL VY V[OLY \U\Z\HS VWLYHÌ
[PUNJVUKP[PVUZ
"camV
>HYUPUN
+HUNLYVMMPYL
+V UV[ WHYR VY VWLYH[L [OL ]LOPJSL PU HYLHZ
^OLYL [OL OV[ L_OH\Z[ Z`Z[LT TH` JVTL PU
JVU[HJ[ ^P[O KY` NYHZZ IY\ZO M\LS ZWPSS VY
V[OLYMSHTTHISLTH[LYPHS
0M`V\YJHYJH[JOLZVUMPYLMVYHU`YLHZVUJHSS
[OLMPYLKLWHY[TLU[
+V UV[ LUKHUNLY `V\Y SPML I` H[[LTW[PUN [V
W\[V\[[OLMPYL
m=F4p"amV
>HYUPUN
+HUNLY VM MPYL HUK ZLYPV\Z WLYZVUHS PUÍ
Q\YPLZ
+V UV[ HWWS` HKKP[PVUHS \UKLYJVH[PUN VY Y\Z[Ì
WYVVMPUN VU VY ULHY [OL L_OH\Z[ THUPMVSK L_Ì
OH\Z[ WPWLZ JH[HS`[PJ JVU]LY[LYZ VY OLH[
ZOPLSKZ+\YPUNKYP]PUN[OLZ\IZ[HUJL\ZLKMVY
\UKLYJVH[PUNJV\SKV]LYOLH[HUKPNUP[L
4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL
sTQ
p§haapmpmpdpc
>OLU HU H\[VTVIPSL LUNPUL PZ Y\UUPUN P[ \ZLZ
LULYN` NLULYH[LK [OYV\NO [OL JVTI\Z[PVU VM H
TP_[\YLVMHPYHUKM\LS+LWLUKPUNVU^OL[OLYH
JHY PZ KYP]LU MHZ[ VY ZSV^S` VY ^OL[OLY [OL LUÌ
NPUL PZ JVSK VY OV[ ZVTL VM [OL M\LS O`KYVJHYÌ
IVUZ TH` UV[ IL I\YULK JVTWSL[LS` I\[ TH`
IL KPZJOHYNLK PU[V [OL LUNPUL JYHURJHZL VY L_Ì
OH\Z[Z`Z[LT(KKP[VUHSO`KYVJHYIVUZTH`LU[LY
[OLH[TVZWOLYL[OYV\NOL]HWVYH[PVUVMM\LSMYVT
[OLM\LS[HUR;OLZLO`KYVJHYIVUZ/*^OLUYLÌ
SLHZLKPU[V[OLHPYJVU[YPI\[L[V\UKLZPYHISLWVSÌ
S\[PVU
0UHKKP[PVUJHYIVUTVUV_PKL*6HUKV_PKLZVM
UP[YVNLU 56_ JVU[YPI\[L [V LUNPUL LTPZZPVUZ
;OL` [VV HYL MVYTLK K\YPUN [OL JVTI\Z[PVU
WYVJLZZ HUK KPZJOHYNLK PU[V [OL L_OH\Z[ Z`ZÌ
[LT
;V YLK\JL [OLZL WVSS\[HU[Z `V\Y 7VYZJOL PZ
LX\PWWLK^P[OHWYLJPZLS`JHSPIYH[LKM\LSPUQLJ[PVU
Z`Z[LT [V HZZ\YL H MPULS` IHSHUJLK HPYM\LS TP_Ì
[\YL\UKLYHSSVWLYH[PUNJVUKP[PVUZ
¨©VFmFmp
;OLV_`NLUZLUZVYPUZ[HSSLKPU[OLL_OH\Z[WPWL
JVU[PU\V\ZS` ZLUZLZ [OL V_`NLU JVU[LU[ VM [OL
L_OH\Z[ HUK ZPNUHSZ [OL PUMVYTH[PVU [V HU LSLJÌ
[YVUPJ JVU[YVS \UP[ ;OL JVU[YVS \UP[ JVYYLJ[Z [OL
HPYM\LS YH[PV ZV [OL LUNPUL HS^H`Z YLJLP]LZ HU
HJJ\YH[LS`TL[LYLKHPYM\LSTP_[\YL
"mc4"F¦Fmad"apm
;OYV\NO JYHURJHZL ]LU[PSH[PVU \UKLZPYHISL
LTPZZPVUZ MYVT [OL LUNPUL JYHURJHZL HYL UV[
WLYTP[[LK [V YLHJO [OL V\[ZPKL H[TVZWOLYL
;OLZL LTPZZPVUZ HYL YLJPYJ\SH[LK MYVT [OL
JYHURJHZL [V [OL HPY PU[HRL Z`Z[LT -YVT OLYL
[OL LTPZZPVUZ TP_ ^P[O [OL PU[HRL HPY HUK HYL
SH[LYI\YULKPU[OLLUNPUL
""d©a44pm¦FF
;OL JH[HS`[PJ JVU]LY[LYZ HYL LMMPJPLU[ sJSLHUÌ\Wr
KL]PJLZ I\PS[ PU[V [OL L_OH\Z[ Z`Z[LT VM [OL ]LÌ
OPJSL ;OL JH[HS`[PJ JVU]LY[LYZ I\YU [OL \UKLZPYÌ
HISL WVSS\[HU[Z PU [OL L_OH\Z[ NHZ ILMVYL P[ PZ
YLSLHZLKPU[V[OLH[TVZWOLYL
;OL L_JS\ZP]L \ZL VM \USLHKLK M\LS PZ JYP[PÍ
JHSS` PTWVY[HU[ MVY [OL SPML VM [OL JH[HS`[PJ
JVU]LY[LYZ ;OLYLMVYL VUS` \USLHKLK M\LS
T\Z[IL\ZLK
;OLJH[HS`[PJJVU]LY[LYZ^PSSILKHTHNLK
I`!
W\ZOVY[V^Z[HY[PUN[OL]LOPJSL
TPZMPYPUNVM[OLLUNPUL
[\YUPUN VMM [OL PNUP[PVU ^OPSL [OL ]LOPJSL PZ
TV]PUNVY
KYP]PUN\U[PS[OLM\LS[HURPZJVTWSL[LS`LTW[`
I`V[OLY\U\Z\HSVWLYH[PUNJVUKP[PVUZ
+VUV[JVU[PU\L[VVWLYH[L`V\Y]LOPJSL\UKLY
[OLZL JVUKP[PVUZ ZPUJL YH^ M\LS TPNO[ YLHJO
[OL JH[HS`[PJ JVU]LY[LYZ ;OPZ JV\SK YLZ\S[ PU
V]LYOLH[PUN VM [OL JVU]LY[LYZ -LKLYHS SH^
WYVOPIP[Z\ZLVMSLHKLKM\LSPU[OPZJHY
sT
4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL
¤Fd¦"zp"apmpmpd
¤Fd"mc¦FmamV
;OL L]HWVYH[PVU JOHTILY HUK [OL JHYIVU JHUPZÌ
[LY WYL]LU[ M\LS MYVT LZJHWPUN [V [OL H[TVZÌ
WOLYL H[ L_[YLTL OPNO V\[ZPKL [LTWLYH[\YLZ
^OLU KYP]PUN HIY\W[S` HYV\UK J\Y]LZ HUK ^OLU
[OL JHY PZ WHYRLK H[ HU PUJSPUL VY PU HU` V[OLY
UVUSL]LSWVZP[PVU
"zp4pmpd©Fh"m=p"VF
>OLU[OLM\LS[HURPZMPSSLK]HWVYZHYLJVSSLJ[LK
PU [OL L]HWVYH[PVU JOHTILY I` H ]LU[ SPUL SLHKÌ
PUN[OL]HWVYZ[V[OLJHYIVUJHUPZ[LY^OLYL[OL`
HYLZ[VYLKHZSVUNHZ[OLLUNPULKVLZUV[Y\U
¤VF©Fh
>OLU[OLLUNPULPZY\UUPUN[OLM\LS]HWVYZMYVT
[OLJHUPZ[LY^PSSILTP_LK^P[OMYLZOHPYMYVT[OL
HTIPLU[ HPY VM [OL JHUPZ[LY ;OPZ TP_[\YL ^PSS IL
KPYLJ[LK [V [OL PU[HRL HPY OV\ZPUN I` [OL [HUR
]LU[ SPUL TP_LK ^P[O [OL PU[HRL HPY HUK I\YULK
K\YPUNUVYTHSJVTI\Z[PVU
"^F d¤a=
;OL YLZLY]VPY ^P[O H IS\L ZJYL^ JHW PZ PU [OL
S\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[[V[OLYLHYSLM[
*HWHJP[`!HWWYV_PTH[LS` X\HY[ZSP[LYZ
*SLHU^H[LYPZNLULYHSS`UV[LUV\NO[VJSLHU[OL
^PUKZOPLSKHUKOLHKSPNO[Z
0[PZHK]HU[HNLV\Z[VHKKH^PU[LYJSLHULYNP]PUN
HU[PMYLLaL WYV[LJ[PVU VY H Z\P[HISL Z\TTLY
JSLHULYKLWLUKPUNVU[OLZLHZVU-VSSV^[OLPUÌ
Z[Y\J[PVUZMVY[OLTP_PUNYH[PV
+V UV[ \ZL LUNPUL JVVSHU[ HU[PÌMYLLaL VY HU`
V[OLY ZVS\[PVU [OH[ JHU KHTHNL [OL JHYqZ
WHPU[PU[OL^HZOLYYLZLY]VPY
7SLHZL UV[L HSS [OL PUMVYTH[PVU VU [OL JVUÌ
[HPULYVM[OLJSLHUPUNHNLU[
"mamVdaV^
;OL ^HYUPUN SPNO[Z PU [OL PUZ[Y\TLU[ WHULS HUK
VUÌIVHYK JVTW\[LY SPNO[ ^OLU HWWYV_PTH[LS`
SP[LYPZSLM[PU[OLYLZLY]VPY
4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL
sT
p§FFFamV"m=d¤4^
7V^LYZ[LLYPUNHUKJS\[JOHJ[\H[PVUHYLHZZPZ[LK
I`O`KYH\SPJH\_PSPHY`MVYJLZ
;OLO`KYH\SPJMS\PKYLZLY]VPYPZSVJH[LKPU[OLLUÌ
NPULJVTWHY[TLU[
5V[L
;OL MSV^ UVPZL OLHYK H[ M\SS Z[LLYPUN SVJR PZ KLÌ
ZPNUÌYLSH[LK HUK KVLZ UV[ PUKPJH[L H KLMLJ[ PU
[OLZ[LLYPUNZ`Z[LT
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMHJJPKLU[
>OLU [OL LUNPUL PZ Z[VWWLK LN ^OLU VU
[V^ VY [OL O`KYH\SPJ Z`Z[LT MHPSZ [OLYL PZ
UV HZZPZ[HUJL MVY Z[LLYPUN VYMVYJS\[JOHJÍ
[\H[PVU
;OLYLMVYL Z\IZ[HU[PHSS` TVYL MVYJL ^PSS
OH]L [V IL L_LY[LK PU VYKLY [V Z[LLY VY [V
HJ[\H[L[OLJS\[JO
,_LYJPZLNYLH[JHYL^OLUILPUN[V^LK
/H]L [OLMH\S[YLTLKPLKH[`V\YULHYLZ[H\[OÌ
VYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
^F4camV^©="¤da4Od¤a=
-VSSV^[OLPUZ[Y\J[PVUZPU[OLs*H\[PVUZrJOHW[LY
6US`\ZLO`KYH\SPJMS\PKH\[OVYPaLKI`7VYZJOL
:WLJPMPJH[PVU!ZLLJOHW[LYVUs*HWHJP[PLZr
*OLJR [OL MS\PK SL]LS ^P[O [OL LUNPUL Z[VWWLK
HUKJVSKHWWYV_PTH[LS`-
:[HY[ [OL LUNPUL HUK SL[ P[ PKSL MVY HWWYV_
ZLJVUKZ
:^P[JOVMM[OLLUNPUL
6WLU[OLLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[SPK
6WLU[OLYLZLY]VPYJHW
>PWLTLHZ\YPUNYVK
*SVZL JHW HUK YLVWLU ;OL MS\PK SL]LS ZOV\SK
SPLPU[OLHYLHILSV^[OLs*VSKrTHYRPUN
(KKO`KYH\SPJMS\PKPMULJLZZHY`
*SVZLJHWJHYLM\SS`
*SVZLLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[SPK
5V[PJLHISL SVZZ VM MS\PK PUKPJH[LZ SLHRHNL PU [OL
Z`Z[LT
;OL JH\ZL ZOV\SK IL YLTLKPLK PTTLKPH[LS` H[
HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
sTG
4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL
a adF
( KPY[` HPY MPS[LY UV[ VUS` YLK\JLZ LUNPUL WLYMVYÌ
THUJLI\[JHUSLHK[VWYLTH[\YLLUNPUL^LHY
9LN\SHY MPS[LY YLWSHJLTLU[ PZ WHY[ VM [OL YV\[PUL
THPU[LUHUJLZLY]PJL
0U K\Z[` JVUKP[PVUZ JOLJR [OL MPS[LY LSLTLU[
TVYLMYLX\LU[S`HUKYLWSHJLPMULJLZZHY`
"a4dF adF
;OL MYLZO HPY WHZZPUN [OYV\NO [OL WHY[PJSL MPS[LY
PU[V [OL WHZZLUNLY JVTWHY[TLU[ PZ]PY[\HSS`MYLL
VMK\Z[HUKWVSSLU
0M[OLV\[ZPKLHPYPZWVSS\[LKI`L_OH\Z[M\TLZ
WYLZZ[OLJPYJ\SH[PUNÌHPYI\[[VU
( KPY[` MPS[LY JHU IL [OL JH\ZL VM YLK\JLK HPY
MSV^!
/H]L MPS[LY YLWSHJLK I` `V\Y H\[OVYPaLK
7VYZJOLKLHSLY
9LN\SHY MPS[LY YLWSHJLTLU[ PZ WHY[ VM [OL YV\[PUL
THPU[LUHUJLZLY]PJL
¤ph"a4"mhaapm d¤a=
;OL [VYX\L JVU]LY[LY HUK [OL [YHUZTPZZPVU HYL
S\IYPJH[LK ^P[O (\[VTH[PJ ;YHUZTPZZPVU -S\PK
(;- ;OL MPUHS KYP]L YLX\PYLZ [YHUZTPZZPVU VPS
:LLs*HWHJP[PLZr
+V UV[ [V^ [OL JHY VY Y\U [OL LUNPUL ^P[OV\[
(;- PU [OL [YHUZTPZZPVU ;OL H\[VTH[PJ [YHUZÌ
TPZZPVU TH` IL KHTHNLK I` L]LU H [PU` ZWLJR
VM KPY[ VUS` H JSLHU M\UULS VY ZWV\[ T\Z[ IL
\ZLK^OLUHKKPUN(;-
;OL(;-HUK[YHUZTPZZPVUVPSOHZ[VILJOLJRLK
HUKJOHUNLKH[[OLPU[LY]HSZSPZ[LKPU`V\Y4HPUÌ
[LUHUJL:JOLK\SL
>LYLJVTTLUK[OH[`V\OH]L[OL(;-HUK[YHUZÌ
TPZZPVUVPSJOHUNLKH[`V\Y7VYZJOLKLHSLY^OV
OHZ [OL YLX\PYLK S\IYPJHU[Z HUK [OL ULJLZZHY`
MPSSPUNLX\PWTLU[
0M `V\ Z\ZWLJ[ HU VPS SLHR PU [OL [YHUZTPZZPVU
OH]L `V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY JOLJR P[
V\[PTTLKPH[LS`
"m¤"d"mhaapmad
;OL [YHUZTPZZPVU VPS OHZ [V IL JOLJRLK HUK
JOHUNLK H[ [OL PU[LY]HSZ SPZ[LK PU `V\Y 4HPU[LUÌ
HUJL:JOLK\SL:LLs*HWHJP[PLZr
>L YLJVTTLUK [OH[ `V\ OH]L [OL [YHUZTPZZPVU
VPSJOHUNLKH[`V\Y7VYZJOLKLHSLY^OVOHZ[OL
YLX\PYLK S\IYPJHU[Z HUK [OL ULJLZZHY` MPSSPUN
LX\PWTLU[
0M `V\ Z\ZWLJ[ HU VPS SLHR PU [OL [YHUZTPZZPVU
OH]L `V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY JOLJR P[
V\[PTTLKPH[LS`
p§FF"¤FhFm
7V^LYTLHZ\YLTLU[ZVUK`UHTVTL[LYZHYLUV[
HWWYV]LKI`7VYZJOL
4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL
sTn
(Í7HZZLUNLYqZZPKL
)Í+YP]LYqZZPKL
azFd"=F
>OLU^PWLYWLYMVYTHUJLKL[LYPVYH[LZYLWSHJL
[OL^PWLYZ
-VSSV^[OLPUZ[Y\J[PVUZPU[OLs*HY*HYLrJOHWÌ
[LY
*H\[PVU
9PZR VM KHTHNL PM [OL ^PWLY HYT HJJPKLUÍ
[HSS`MHSSZIHJRVU[V[OL^PUKV^
(S^H`Z OVSK [OL ^PWLY HYT ZLJ\YLS` ^OLU YLÌ
WSHJPUN[OL^PWLYISHKL
9PZR VM KHTHNL PM ^PWLY ISHKLZ [OH[ HYL
MYVaLUPUWSHJLHYLSVVZLULKPTWYVWLYS`
;OH^[OL^PWLYISHKLZILMVYLSVVZLUPUN[OLT
7\SSV\[PNUP[PVURL`
-VSK^PWLYHYTH^H`MYVT[OL^PUKV^
7YLZZ[VNL[OLY[OLWSHZ[PJZWYPUNVM[OL^PWLY
ISHKLYPNO[HYYV^
7\SS^PWLYISHKLV\[VM^PWLYHYT
0UZLY[ UL^ ^PWLY ISHKL HUK LUZ\YL P[ LUÌ
NHNLZ
,UZ\YL [OH[ [OL UL^ ^PWLY ISHKL NVLZ PU[V
[OLZHTLWVZP[PVUKPYLJ[PVUVMZWVPSLYPU[OL
^PWLYHYTHUKLUNHNLZ
*HYLM\SS` MVSK ^PWLY HYT IHJR VU [V [OL ^PUÌ
KV^
sQ¬
4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL
""Fm¤4apm
-VSSV^ [OL PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ PU [OL s*H\[PVUZr
JOHW[LY
9LN\SHYHUKJVYYLJ[JHYLOLSWZ[VTHPU[HPU
[OL]HS\LVM`V\YJHYHUKPZHSZVHWYLJVUÍ
KP[PVUMVY[OL5L^=LOPJSL>HYYHU[`HUK[OL
(U[P*VYYVZPVU>HYYHU[`
@V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY OHZ ZWLÍ
JPHSS`KL]LSVWLKJHYÍJHYLWYVK\J[ZMYVT[OL
7VYZJOL WYVNYHT H]HPSHISL LP[OLY ZPUNS` VY
HZ JVTWSL[L JHYÍJHYL ZL[Z ;OL` ^PSS IL
WSLHZLK [V OLSW `V\ ZLSLJ[ Z\P[HISL WYVÍ
K\J[Z
>OL[OLY`V\\ZL7VYZJOLWYVK\J[ZVYV[OLY
JVTTLYJPHSS`H]HPSHISLJSLHUPUNHNLU[ZMPYZ[
THRLZ\YLVM[OLPYJVYYLJ[HWWSPJH[PVU
( 7VYZJOL [OH[ PZ ^LSSÌJHYLK MVY JHU SVVR SPRL
UL^ MVY `LHYZ 0[ HSS KLWLUKZ VU [OL HTV\U[ VM
JHYL[OLV^ULYPZ^PSSPUN[VNP]L[OLJHY
>HYUPUN
9PZR VM ZLYPV\Z WLYZVUHS PUQ\Y` VY KHTHNL
[V[OL]LOPJSLVYWYVWLY[`
*SLHUPUN HNLU[Z TH` ILOHaHYKV\Z[V`V\Y
OLHS[O
4VZ[ JOLTPJHS JSLHULYZ HYL JVUJLU[YH[LZ
^OPJO YLX\PYL KPS\[PVU /PNO JVUJLU[YH[PVUZ
TPNO[ JH\ZL WYVISLTZ YHUNPUN MYVT PYYP[HÍ
[PVU [V ZLYPV\Z PUQ\Y` HZ ^LSS HZ KHTHNL [V
`V\Y]LOPJSL
2LLWJSLHUPUNHNLU[ZV\[VMYLHJOMYVTJOPSKÌ
YLU
6IZLY]LHSSJH\[PVUSHILSZ
(S^H`Z YLHK KPYLJ[PVUZ VU [OL JVU[HPULY ILÌ
MVYL \ZPUN HU` WYVK\J[ ;OLZL KPYLJ[PVUZTH`
JVU[HPU PUMVYTH[PVU ULJLZZHY` [V H]VPK WLYÌ
ZVUHSPUQ\Y`
+VUV[\ZLM\LSRLYVZLULUHWO[OHUHPSWVSPZO
YLTV]LYVYV[OLY]VSH[PSLJSLHUPUNMS\PKZ;OL`
TH` IL [V_PJ MSHTTHISL VY OHaHYKV\Z PU
V[OLY^H`Z6US`\ZLZWV[YLTV]PUNMS\PKZPUH
^LSS]LU[LKHYLH
+V UV[ JSLHU [OL \UKLYZPKL VM JOHZZPZ MLUÌ
KLYZ ^OLLS JV]LYZ L[J ^P[OV\[ WYV[LJ[PUN
`V\Y OHUKZ HUK HYTZ HZ `V\ TH` J\[ `V\YÌ
ZLSMVUZOHYWÌLKNLKTL[HSWHY[Z
4VPZ[\YL HUK YVHK ZHS[ VU IYHRLZ TH` HMMLJ[
IYHRPUNLMMPJPLUJ`
;LZ[[OLIYHRLZHM[LYLHJO]LOPJSL^HZOPUN
4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL
sQs
"^amV
;OL ILZ[ TL[OVK VM WYV[LJ[PUN `V\Y JHY MYVT
[OL KHTHNPUN LMMLJ[Z VM [OL LU]PYVUTLU[ PZ MYLÌ
X\LU[ ^HZOPUN HUK [OL HWWSPJH[PVU VM H WYLZLY]Ì
H[P]L ;OL \UKLYZPKL VM `V\Y ]LOPJSL ZOV\SK HSZV
IL^HZOLK[OVYV\NOS`H[[OLSH[LZ[^OLUZHS[PZ
UVSVUNLYZWYLHKVU[OLYVHKZ
;OL SVUNLY ZHS[ YVHK K\Z[ HUK PUK\Z[YPHS K\Z[
KLHKPUZLJ[ZIPYKKYVWWPUNZVYZ\IZ[HUJLZMYVT
[YLLZYLZPUWVSSLUHYLHSSV^LK[VYLTHPUVU[OL
IVK`^VYR [OL TVYL ZLYPV\Z PZ [OLPY OHYTM\S LMÌ
MLJ[
5L^JHYZZOV\SKIL^HZOLKJHYLM\SS`^P[OWSLU[`
VM JSLHY ^H[LY [V WYV[LJ[ [OL UL^ WHPU[ ^VYR
+HYR WHPU[ MPUPZOLZ ZOV^ \W [OL ZTHSSLZ[ VM Z\YÌ
MHJLKHTHNLLNZJYH[JOLZTVYLYLHKPS`[OHU
SPNO[LYJVSVYZ
+HYR JVSVYZ HYL HSZV TVYL Z\ZJLW[PISL [V
ZJYH[JOPUN ILJH\ZL VM [OL JVTWVZP[PVU VM [OLPY
WPNTLU[Z HUK YLX\PYL WHY[PJ\SHYS` JHYLM\S WHPU[
JHYL
+V UV[ ^HZO `V\Y JHY PU IYPNO[ Z\USPNO[ VY
^OPSL[OLIVK`^VYRPZZ[PSSOV[
>OLU ^HZOPUN I` OHUK \ZL HI\UKHU[ ^H[LY
H ZVM[ ZWVUNL VY ^HZO IY\ZO HUK 7VYZJOL
JHYZOHTWVV
)LNPU I` ZWYH`PUN [OL IVK` [OVYV\NOS` ^P[O
^H[LY[VYPUZLH^H`SVVZLKPY[
(M[LY ^HZOPUN YPUZL [OL JHY ^P[O WSLU[` VM
^H[LYHUK[OLUKY`^P[OHJOHTVPZSLH[OLY
+V UV[ \ZL [OL ZHTL JOHTVPZ SLH[OLY MVY
KY`PUN HZ `V\ \ZL MVY JSLHUPUN [OL ^PUKZOPLSK
HUK^PUKV^Z
>HYUPUN
4VPZ[\YL^OPJONL[ZVU[V[OLIYHRLZK\YPUN
HJHY^HZOJHUYLK\JLIYHRPUNLMMPJPLUJ`VY
THRL [OL IYHRLZ W\SS \UL]LUS` ^OPJO JV\SK
PUJYLHZL [OL KHUNLY VM HU HJJPKLU[ JH\ZPUN
ZLYPV\ZWLYZVUHSPUQ\YPLZVYKLH[O
(S^H`Z HWWS` [OL IYHRLZ H ML^ [PTLZ HM[LY
^HZOPUN [OL JHY [V [LZ[ IYHRPUN LMMPJPLUJ` HUK
KY`[OLIYHRLKPZJZ
>OLU KVPUN [OPZ [HRL JHYL UV[ [V OHTWLY
V[OLYYVHK\ZLYZILOPUK`V\[YHMMPJJVUKP[PVUZ
WLYTP[[PUN
(\[VTH[PJJHY^HZOLZ
6W[PVUHS HKKÌVU WHY[Z VY WHY[Z ^OPJO WYVQLJ[
IL`VUK [OL JVU[V\YZ VM [OL ]LOPJSL TH` IL
KHTHNLK I` KLZPNU MLH[\YLZ LN IY\ZOLZ VM
H\[VTH[PJJHY^HZOLZ
;OLMVSSV^PUNWHY[ZHYLWHY[PJ\SHYS`Z\ZJLWÍ
[PISL[VKHTHNL!
>PUKZOPLSK ^PWLYZ HS^H`Z Z^P[JO [OLT VMM [V
WYL]LU[[OLT^PWPUN\UPU[LU[PVUHSS`PUPU[LYTP[Ì
[LU[VYZLUZVYVWLYH[PVU
,_[LYUHS[LSLWOVULHU[LUUHZHS^H`Z\UZJYL^
9VVM ;YHUZWVY[ :`Z[LT HS^H`Z YLTV]L JVTÌ
WSL[LS`
-P_LKYLHYZWVPSLYVYL_[LUKLKYLHYZWVPSLYKV
UV[ ^HZO [OL ]LOPJSL ^P[O P[Z YLHY ZWVPSLY L_Ì
[LUKLK
>OLLSZ [OL ^PKLY [OL YPT HUK [OL SV^LY [OL
[PYLOLPNO[[OLNYLH[LY[OLYPZRVMKHTHNL
/PNOÌNSVZZ ^OLLSZ [V WYL]LU[ [OLZLMYVTNL[Ì
[PUN ZJYH[JOLK KV UV[ JSLHU ^P[O [OL ^OLLSÌ
JSLHUPUNIY\ZOLZVM[OLJHY^HZO
7SLHZLJVUZ\S[[OLVWLYH[VYILMVYL\ZPUNH\[VÌ
TH[PJJHY^HZOLZ
>HZO HUK KY` I` OHUK HSS WVPU[Z UV[ YLHJOLK
I`HJHY^HZOZ\JOHZKVVYHUKSPKZLHTZVY
KVVYZPSSZ
5V[L
(\[VTH[PJ JHY ^HZOLZ ZWYH` ^H[LY H[ VKK
HUNSLZ HUK OPNO WYLZZ\YLZ ^OPJO HYL UV[ ZLLU
PU UVYTHS KYP]PUN ;OLYLMVYL ^H[LY JHU ZVTLÌ
[PTLZ MPUK P[Z ^H` PU[V [OL WHZZLUNLYZ JVTWHY[Ì
TLU[K\YPUNVYZOVY[S`HM[LY[OLJHY^HZO
sQ¢
4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL
ppdp4c
;V WYL]LU[ [OL KVVY SVJRZ MYVT MYLLaPUN K\YÌ
PUN[OLJVSKZLHZVU[OLSVJRJ`SPUKLYZZOV\SK
ILJV]LYLKK\YPUNH^HZO
:OV\SK [OL SVJRZ MYLLaL \ZL HU VYKPUHY` KLÌ
PJLY 0U THU` JHZLZ H ^LSS ^HYTLK RL` JHU
OLSW
5L]LY\ZLL_JLZZP]LMVYJL
"am
5L]LY Y\I H K\Z[` JHY ^P[O H KY` JSV[O ZPUJL
K\Z[WHY[PJSLZHYLHIYHZP]LHUKJV\SKK\SSHUK
KHTHNL[OLZ\YMHJLMPUPZO
;OL WHPU[^VYR VM `V\Y JHY PZ L_WVZLK [V HSS
[`WLZ VM TLJOHUPJHS HUK JOLTPJHS JVUKP[PVUZ
WHY[PJ\SHYS`JSPTH[PJVULZZ\JOHZIYPNO[Z\USPNO[
YHPU MYVZ[ HUK ZUV^ <S[YH]PVSL[ SPNO[ YHWPK
JOHUNLZ PU [LTWLYH[\YL YHPU ZUV^ PUK\Z[YPHS
K\Z[HUKJOLTPJHSKLWVZP[ZJVUZ[HU[S`H[[HJR[OL
WHPU[ ^OPJO PZ VUS` HISL [V ^P[OZ[HUK Z\JOL_WVÌ
Z\YL PU [OL SVUN [LYT PM P[ PZ NP]LU YLN\SHY JHYL
HUKH[[LU[PVU
+V UV[ HWWS` ZPSPJVUL WVSPZOLZ [V [OL ^PUKÌ
ZOPLSKHUK^PUKV^Z
+V UV[ [YLH[ TH[[ÌWHPU[LK JVTWVULU[Z ^P[O
WYLZLY]H[P]LZVYWVSPZOLZHZ[OPZ^PSSZWVPS[OL
TH[[LLMMLJ[
7YLZLY]H[PVU
;OLWHPU[Z\YMHJLILJVTLZK\SSV]LY[PTLK\L[V
^LH[OLYPUN0[PZ[OLYLMVYLULJLZZHY`[VWYLZLY]L
[OLWHPU[YLN\SHYS`
;OPZ RLLWZ [OL WHPU[ ZOPU` HUK LSHZ[PJ +PY[ PZ
WYL]LU[LK MYVT HKOLYPUN [V [OL WHPU[ Z\YMHJL
HUKPUK\Z[YPHSK\Z[PZWYL]LU[LKMYVTWLUL[YH[PUN
[OLWHPU[
7YV]PKLK P[ PZ ^HZOLK HUK [YLH[LK ^P[O WYLZLY]Ì
H[P]L YLN\SHYS` [OL IYHUK UL^ MPUPZO VM `V\Y JHY
^PSSILYL[HPULKMVY`LHYZ[VJVTL
(WWS`[OL7VYZJOLWHPU[WYLZLY]H[P]LHM[LY[OL
JHY ^HZO HUK WVSPZO P[ KY` [V VI[HPU H IYPNO[
MPUPZOVYZPTWS`HKKHSPX\PKWYLZLY]H[P]LYLN\Ì
SHYS`[V[OLMPUHSYPUZL^H[LY
7VSPZOPUN
+V UV[ YLZVY[ [V \ZPUN 7VYZJOL WVSPZO \U[PS P[
ILJVTLZ L]PKLU[ [OH[ [OL UVYTHS WYLZLY]H[P]LZ
UVSVUNLYWYVK\JL[OLKLZPYLKMPUPZO
:WV[ZHUKZ[HPUZ
9LTV]L[HYZ[HPUZNYLHZLVPSZWV[ZHUKKLHK
PUZLJ[Z HZ ZVVU HZ WVZZPISL ^P[O 0UZLJ[
9LTV]LY ;OL` JHU JH\ZL KPZJVSVYH[PVU PM
HSSV^LK[VYLTHPUVU[OLWHPU[^VYR
>HZO [OL HMMLJ[LK HYLH PTTLKPH[LS` HM[LY
[YLH[PUNP[
4PUVYWHPU[KHTHNL
/H]LTPUVYWHPU[KHTHNLZ\JOHZZJYH[JOLZ
ZJVYLZ VY JOPWZ JH\ZLK I` MS`PUN Z[VULZ YLÌ
WHPYLK PTTLKPH[LS` I` `V\Y H\[OVYPaLK
7VYZJOLKLHSLYILMVYLJVYYVZPVUZL[ZPU
/V^L]LY PM [OLYL HYL HSYLHK` [YHJLZ VM JVYYVÌ
ZPVU [OL` T\Z[ MPYZ[ IL YLTV]LK JHYLM\SS` HUK
[OVYV\NOS` *VH[ [OL HYLH ^P[O H Y\Z[ÌWYVVMPUN
WYPTLY HUK MPUPZO VMM ^P[O H [VW JVH[ ;OL WHPU[
JVKL HUK JVSVY U\TILY HYL MV\UK VU [OL ]LOPÌ
JSLqZWHPU[KH[HWSH[L
4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL
sQ
mVamF4phz"hFm
;OLLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[HUK[OLZ\YMHJLVM[OL
LUNPUL HYL [YLH[LK ^P[O H JVYYVZPVUÌPUOPIP[VY H[
[OLMHJ[VY`
0MKLNYLHZPUNZVS]LU[ZHYL\ZLK[VJSLHU[OLLUÌ
NPUL JVTWHY[TLU[ VY [OL LUNPUL PZ ^HZOLK
KV^U [OL WYVJLZZ HSTVZ[ PU]HYPHIS` YLTV]LZ
[OL JVYYVZPVUÌPUOPIP[PUN JVH[PUN 0[ PZ [OLU HIZVÌ
S\[LS` ULJLZZHY` [V OH]L H K\YHISL WYLZLY]H[P]L
HWWSPLK [V HSS Z\YMHJLZ IVK` ZLHTZ QVPU[Z HUK
HZZLTISPLZPU[OLLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[;OPZHSZV
HWWSPLZ ^OLU JVYYVZPVUÌPUOPIP[VY WHY[Z HYL YLÌ
WSHJLK
,MMLJ[P]LJVYYVZPVUÌWYVVMPUNPZWHY[PJ\SHYS`PTWVY[Ì
HU[ K\YPUN [OL JVSK ^LH[OLY ZLHZVU 0M `V\Y JHY
PZKYP]LUMYLX\LU[S`PUHYLHZ^OLYLZHS[OHZILLU
ZWYLHKVU[OLYVHKZ[OL^OVSLLUNPULJVTWHY[Ì
TLU[ ZOV\SK IL JSLHULK [OVYV\NOS` HM[LY [OL
^PU[LY [V WYL]LU[ ZHS[ MYVT JH\ZPUN HU` SHZ[PUN
KHTHNL ( M\SS \UKLYÌIVK` ^HZO ZOV\SK HSZV IL
WLYMVYTLKH[[OLZHTL[PTL
*H\[PVU
9PZRVMKHTHNL[V[OLNLULYH[VY
+V UV[ WVPU[ [OL JSLHUPUN QL[ KPYLJ[S` H[ [OL
NLULYH[VYVYJV]LY[OLNLULYH[VY
am=p§
;OL YVHK K\Z[ ^OPJO ZL[[SLZ VU [OL ^PUKZOPLSK
HUK ^PUKV^Z JVU[HPUZ WHY[PJSLZ VM [PYL Y\IILY
HUK VPS YLZPK\L ;OL PU[LYPVY [YPT HUK \WOVSZ[LY`
YLSLHZL WHY[PJSLZ WHY[PJ\SHYS` PU Z[YVUN Z\USPNO[
^OPJO JVSSLJ[ VU [OL PUZPKLZ VM [OL ^PUKV^Z
;OLZL KLWVZP[Z HYL H\NTLU[LK I` PTW\YP[PLZ PU
[OLHPY^OPJOLU[LYZ[OLJHY[OYV\NO[OLMYLZOHPY
]LU[Z
*SLHU HSS ^PUKV^Z YLN\SHYS` PUZPKL HUK V\[Ì
ZPKL^P[O7VYZJOL^PUKV^JSLHULY
0M`V\\ZLHJOHTVPZSLH[OLYMVY[OL^PUKV^Z
KVUV[\ZLP[MVYWHPU[^VYRHZP[^PSSV[OLY^PZL
WPJR \W H JLY[HPU HTV\U[ VM WYLZLY]H[P]L VY
WVSPZOHUKJV\SKZTLHY[OL^PUKV^ZHUK[O\Z
PTWHPY]PZPVU
9LTV]LKLHKPUZLJ[Z^P[O[OL7VYZJOLPUZLJ[
YLTV]LY
azF*d"=F
>PWLY ISHKLZ [OH[ HYL PU WLYMLR[ JVUKP[PVU HYL
]P[HSMVYHJSLHY]PL^
9LWSHJL [OL ^PWLY ISHKLZ [^PJL WLY `LHY ILÌ
MVYL HUK HM[LY [OL JVSK ZLHZVU VY ^OLUL]LY
^PWLYWLYMVYTHUJLKL[LYPVYH[LZ
7LYPVKPJHSS` JSLHU [OL ^PWLYISHKLZ^P[O7VYZJOL
^PUKV^ JSLHULY LZWLJPHSS` HM[LY [OL ]LOPJSL OHZ
ILLU^HZOLKPUHJHY^HZO
0M [OL` HYL ]LY` KPY[` LN ^P[O PUZLJ[ YLTHPUZ
[OL`JHUILJSLHULK^P[OHZWVUNLVYJSV[O
m=F4p"amV
;OL \UKLYZPKL VM `V\Y JHY PZ K\YHIS` WYV[LJ[LK
HNHPUZ[JOLTPJHSHUKTLJOHUPJHSPUMS\LUJLZ
(ZP[PZUV[WVZZPISL[VL_JS\KL[OLYPZRVMKHTÌ
HNL[V[OPZWYV[LJ[P]LJVH[PUNPUKH`[VKH`KYP]Ì
PUN P[ PZ HK]PZHISL [V OH]L [OL \UKLYZPKL VM [OL
JHYPUZWLJ[LKH[JLY[HPUPU[LY]HSZÌWYLMLYHIS`ILÌ
MVYL[OLZ[HY[VM^PU[LYHUKHNHPUPUZWYPUNÌHUK
[OL\UKLYJVH[PUNYLZ[VYLKHZULJLZZHY`
@V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY PZ MHTPSPHY ^P[O
[OL IVK`ZLHS [YLH[TLU[ WYVJLK\YLZ HUK OHZ [OL
ULJLZZHY` LX\PWTLU[ MVY HWWS`PUN MHJ[VY` HWÌ
WYV]LK TH[LYPHSZ >L YLJVTTLUK [OH[ `V\ LUÌ
[Y\Z[[OLT^P[OZ\JO^VYRHUKPUZWLJ[PVUZ
<USPRL JVU]LU[PVUHS ZWYH` VPSZ \UKLYJVH[PUN HUK
Y\Z[ÌWYVVMPUN JVTWV\UKZ IHZLK VU IP[\TLU VY
^H_ KV UV[ H[[HJR [OL ZV\UKÌWYVVMPUN TH[LYPHSZ
HWWSPLKH[[OLMHJ[VY`
sQT
4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL
>HYUPUN
+HUNLY VM MPYL HUK ZLYPV\Z WLYZVUHS PUÍ
Q\YPLZ
+V UV[ HWWS` HKKP[PVUHS \UKLYJVH[PUN VY Y\Z[Ì
WYVVMPUN VU VY ULHY [OL L_OH\Z[ THUPMVSK L_Ì
OH\Z[ WPWLZ JH[HS`[PJ JVU]LY[LYZ VY OLH[
ZOPLSKZ+\YPUNKYP]PUN[OLZ\IZ[HUJL\ZLKMVY
\UKLYJVH[PUNJV\SKV]LYOLH[HUKPNUP[L
)LMVYL HWWS`PUN MYLZO \UKLYZLHS JHYLM\SS`
YLTV]L KLWVZP[Z VY KPY[ HUK NYLHZL 6UJL P[
OHZ KYPLK [OL UL^ \UKLYJVH[PUN JVTWV\UK
MVYTZ H [V\NO WYV[LJ[P]L JVH[PUN ^OPJO WYVÌ
]PKLZLMMPJPLU[Y\Z[ÌWYVVMPUNVM[OLMSVVYWHULSZ
HUKJVTWVULU[Z
(S^H`Z HWWS` H MYLZO JVH[PUN VM Z\P[HISL WYLÌ
ZLY]H[P]L [V \UWYV[LJ[LK HYLHZ HM[LY JSLHUPUN
[OL \UKLYZPKL VM [OL IVK` [OL [YHUZTPZZPVU
[OL LUNPUL VY JHYY`PUN V\[ YLWHPYZ [V \UKLYÌ
IVK`LUNPULVY[YHUZTPZZPVUJVTWVULU[Z
,MMLJ[P]L Y\Z[ÌWYVVMPUN PZ WHY[PJ\SHYS` PTWVY[HU[
K\YPUN [OL JVSK ^LH[OLY ZLHZVU 0M `V\Y JHY PZ
KYP]LU MYLX\LU[S` PU HYLHZ ^OLYL ZHS[ OHZ ILLU
ZWYLHKVU[OLYVHKZ[OL^OVSLLUNPULJVTWHY[Ì
TLU[ ZOV\SK IL JSLHULK [OVYV\NOS` HM[LY [OL
^PU[LY [V WYL]LU[ ZHS[ MYVT JH\ZPUN HU` SHZ[PUN
KHTHNL ( M\SS \UKLYÌIVK` ^HZO ZOV\SK HSZV IL
WLYMVYTLKH[[OLZHTL[PTL
pp:ppO:da="m=§am=p§F"d
>HZO KPY[ LN HIYHZPVU K\Z[ YVHK ZHS[Z
MYVT HSS ZLHSZ YLN\SHYS` \ZPUN ^HYT ZVHW`
^H[LY +V UV[ \ZL HU` JOLTPJHS JSLHUPUN
HNLU[ZVYZVS]LU[Z
>OLU [OLYL PZ H MYVZ[ OHaHYK [OL V\[LY KVVY
ZLHSZ HUK [OL MYVU[ HUK YLHY SPK ZLHSZ JHU IL
WYV[LJ[LK HNHPUZ[ MYLLaPUN PU[V WSHJL I` H Z\P[Ì
HISLJHYLWYVK\J[
0UVYKLY[VWYL]LU[KHTHNL[V[OLHU[PÍMYPJÍ
[PVU JVH[PUN [OL PUULY KVVY ZLHSZ T\Z[ UV[
IL[YLH[LK^P[OJHYLWYVK\J[Z
F"=daV^:daV^:amFap"m=F¨Fap
zd"a4z"
<ZLVUS`JSLHU^H[LYHUKHSP[[SLKPZO^HZOPUN
KL[LYNLU[ [V JSLHU SPNO[ SLUZLZ WSHZ[PJ OLHKÌ
SPNO[SLUZLZWSHZ[PJWHY[ZHUKZ\YMHJLZ
+VUV[JSLHU^OLUKY`
<ZL H ZVM[ ZWVUNL VY H ZVM[ SPU[ÌMYLL JSV[O
.LU[S` ^PWL [OL Z\YMHJL ^P[OV\[ HWWS`PUN [VV
T\JOWYLZZ\YL
;OL 7VYZJOL PUZPKL ^PUKV^ JSLHULY PZ HSZV
Z\P[HISL MVY JSLHUPUN WSHZ[PJ Z\YMHJLZ -VSSV^
[OLJSLHUPUNPUZ[Y\J[PVUZVU[OLJVU[HPULY
5L]LY \ZL V[OLY JOLTPJHS JSLHULYZ VY
ZVS]LU[Z
9PUZLJSLHULKZ\YMHJLZ^P[OJSLHY^H[LY
4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL
sQQ
aV^"ddp©§^FFd
(SZVYLMLY[Vs*HY^HZOLZr
7P[[PUN TH` VJJ\Y PM TL[HSSPJ WHY[PJSLZ ^OPJO
JH\ZLJVU[HJ[JVYYVZPVULNIYHZZVYJVWWLYPU
IYHRL K\Z[ HYL HSSV^LK [V YLTHPU VU [OL HS\Ì
TPU\TMVY[VVSVUN
0MWVZZPISL^HZO[OL^OLLSZ^P[OHZWVUNLVY
^HZO IY\ZO HIV\[ L]LY` [^V ^LLRZ 0U HYLHZ
^OLYLZHS[PZZWYLHKVU^PU[LYYVHKZVY[OLYL
PZHSV[VMHPYIVYULPUK\Z[YPHSK\Z[P[PZILZ[[V
JSLHU[OL^OLLSZ^LLRS`
;OL 7VYZJOL 3PNO[ (SSV` >OLLS *SLHULY
WOÍ]HS\L JHU IL \ZLK MVY [OPZ W\YÍ
WVZL
0M [OL WOÍ]HS\L VM [OL KL[LYNLU[ PZ PUJVYÍ
YLJ[[OLWYV[LJ[P]LJVH[PUNVU[OL^OLLSZ
^PSSILKLZ[YV`LK
7VSPZOLZ ^OPJO KPZZVS]L V_PKLZ Z\JO HZ
[OVZL MYLX\LU[S` \ZLK MVY V[OLY TL[HSZ VY
HIYHZP]L [VVSZ VY HNLU[Z HYL \UZ\P[HISL ILÍ
JH\ZL [OL` IYLHR KV^U [OL V_PKL MPST VM
[OLWYV[LJ[P]LJVH[PUNHUK^PSSJH\ZLKPZJVÍ
SVYH[PVUVM[OL^OLLS
,]LY` [OYLL TVU[OZ HM[LY JSLHUPUN JVH[ [OL
^OLLSZ ^P[O H JHY ^H_ VY UVUÌ JVYYVZP]L
NYLHZL]HZLSPUL
<ZPUNHJSLHUJSV[O[OVYV\NOS`Y\I[OLNYLHZL
PU[V[OLZ\YMHJL
F"^F
*OHYHJ[LYPZ[PJZHUKZWLJPHSMLH[\YLZ
;OL UH[\YHS Z\YMHJL THYRPUNZ VM SLH[OLY LN
JYLHZLZOLHSLKZJHYZPUZLJ[Z[PUNTHYRZZ[Y\JÌ
[\YHS KPMMLYLUJLZ HUK ZSPNO[ ]HYPH[PVUZ PU ZOHKL
HUK NYHPU HKK [V [OL H[[YHJ[P]LULZZ VM [OL UH[\Ì
YHSSLH[OLYWYVK\J[
(ZWLJPHSTLU[PVUT\Z[ILTHKLOLYLVMUH[\YHS
SLH[OLY
-VY UH[\YHS SLH[OLY JHYLM\SS` ZLSLJ[LK OPKLZ VM
[OL OPNOLZ[ X\HSP[` HYL \ZLK 0[ PZ UV[ JV]LYLK
JVTWSL[LS`^P[OK`LVUWYVK\J[PVU
r5H[\YLqZ ZPNUH[\YLs PZ[OLYLMVYLLHZPS`YLJVNUPZÌ
HISL
;OPZ MPUL TH[LYPHS PZ KPZ[PUN\PZOLK I` HU V\[Ì
Z[HUKPUN ZLH[PUN JVTMVY[ ZWLJPHS Z\WWSLULZZ
HUKH[`WPJHSWH[PUH
3LH[OLYJHYLHUK[YLH[TLU[
*SLHU HSS [`WLZ VM SLH[OLY YLN\SHYS` [V YLTV]L
MPUL K\Z[ \ZPUN H ZVM[ KHTW ^OP[L ^VVSSLU
JSV[O VY H JVTTLYJPHSS` H]HPSHISL TPJYVMPIYL
JSV[O
9LTV]L OLH]` JVU[HTPUH[PVU ^P[O 7VYZJOL
SLH[OLYJSLHULY
7SLHZL HS^H`Z MVSSV^ [OL PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ MVY \ZL
NP]LUVU[OLJVU[HPULYZ
*H\Z[PJ JSLHULYZ HUK OHYK JSLHUPUN VIQLJ[Z
T\Z[UV[IL\ZLK
7LYMVYH[LK SLH[OLY T\Z[ \UKLY UV JPYJ\TÍ
Z[HUJLZNL[^L[VUP[ZYL]LYZLZPKL
6UJL JSLHULK SLH[OLY WHY[PJ\SHYS` [OL OLH]PS`
Z[YLZZLK SLH[OLY ZLH[Z T\Z[ IL [YLH[LK VUS`
^P[O7VYZJOLSLH[OLYJHYLSPX\PK
sQ
4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL
"*a4:¤z^pdF©:4"zF"m=
Odpp_h"
<ZL VUS` H ]HJ\\T JSLHULY VY H TLKP\T Z[PMM
IY\ZO
9LTV]L Z[HPUZ HUK ZWV[Z ^P[O 7VYZJOL Z[HPU
YLTV]LY
;OL 7VYZJOL YHUNL VM HJJLZZVYPLZ PUJS\KLZ
MSVVYÌTH[Z[VWYV[LJ[[OLJHYWL[ZPUZ\TTLYHUK
^PU[LY
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMHUHJJPKLU[
(S^H`ZJOLJR[OLTV]LTLU[VM[OLWLKHSZILÌ
MVYL KYP]PUN HUK THRL Z\YL [OH[ [OL` HYL UV[
VIZ[Y\J[LKI`HMSVVYTH[VYHU`V[OLYVIQLJ[
:LJ\YL[OLMSVVYTH[[VWYL]LU[P[MYVTZSPKPUN
PU[V WVZP[PVUZ [OH[ JV\SK PU[LYMLYL ^P[O [OL
ZHML VWLYH[PVU VM `V\Y ]LOPJSL Ì KV UV[ SPL
[OLTSVVZLS`PU[OL]LOPJSL
@V\Y 7VYZJOL KLHSLY ^PSS IL NSHK [V VMMLY `V\
MSVVY TH[Z VM [OL JVYYLJ[ ZPaL PUJS\KPUN H ZLÌ
J\YPUNWVZZPIPSP[`
d4"m""
+V UV[ \ZL H SLH[OLY JHYL WYVK\J[ [V JSLHU
(SJHU[HYH
-VY YLN\SHY JHYL P[ PZ Z\MMPJPLU[ [V JSLHU [OL
JV]LY^P[OHZVM[IY\ZO
*SLHUPUN^OLUSPNO[S`ZVPSLK
>L[ H ZVM[ JSV[O ^P[O ^H[LY VY HUL\[YHSZVHW
ZVS\[PVUHUK^PWLVMM[OLKPY[
*SLHUPUN^OLUOLH]PS`ZVPSLK
>L[ H ZVM[ JSV[O ^P[O S\RL^HYT ^H[LY VY
[OPUULK ^OP[L ZWPYP[ HUK KHI [OL KPY[ MYVT [OL
V\[ZPKLPU
"OF©*Fd
0M P[ ILJVTLZ ULJLZZHY` [V JSLHU [OL ILS[Z `V\
JHU\ZLHU`TPSK^HZOPUNHNLU[
(SSV^ [OL ILS[Z [V KY` WYPVY [V YL[YHJ[PUN I\[
H]VPKKPYLJ[Z\USPNO[
6US`\ZLZ\P[HISLJSLHULYZ
0M\UZ\P[HISLJSLHULYZHYL\ZLKVYHU`H[[LTW[PZ
THKL [V K`L VY ISLHJO [OL ILS[Z [OL ^LIIPUN
TH` IL ^LHRLULK HUK [O\Z JVUZ[P[\[L H ZHML[`
YPZR
4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL
sQ
pamV©p¤p4^F
0M `V\ PU[LUK [V Z[VYL `V\Y 7VYZJOL MVY H WYVÌ
SVUNLK WLYPVK WSLHZL JVUZ\S[ `V\Y H\[OVYPaLK
7VYZJOL KLHSLY ;OL Z[HMM ^PSS IL NSHK [V HK]PZL
`V\ VU [OL TVZ[ Z\P[HISL HUK ULJLZZHY`
TL[OVKZ
*SLHU `V\Y ]LOPJSL [OVYV\NOS` PUZPKL HUK V\[Ì
ZPKL
*SLHU[OLLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[
;OL \UKLY JHYYPHNL HUK JOHZZPZ JVTWVULU[Z
ZOV\SKILMYLLVMKPY[HUKZHS[KLWVZP[Z
-PSS\W[OLM\LS[HUR
*OHUNL [OL VPS HUK VPS MPS[LY HUK Y\U [OL LUÌ
NPULMVYZL]LYHSTPU\[LZ
0UJYLHZL[OL[PYLWYLZZ\YL[VWZPIHY
0[ PZ UV[ YLJVTTLUKLK [V SPM[ [OL ]LOPJSL K\L
[V[OLWVZZPIPSP[`VMJVYYVZPVUVUZOVJRHIZVYÌ
ILYWPZ[VUZOHM[Z
;OL]LOPJSLZOV\SKILTV]LKZSPNO[S`HWWYV_PÌ
TH[LS` L]LY` MV\Y ^LLRZ [V WYL]LU[ MSH[ ZWV[
VU[OL[PYLZ
*SPTH[LJVU[YVS
;OL HPY JVUKP[PVUPUN Z`Z[LT ZOV\SK IL PU NVVK
^VYRPUNJVUKP[PVUHUKM\SS`JOHYNLK
>PUKZOPLSK/LHKSPNO[^HZOLY
*OLJR HUK JVYYLJ[ HU[PMYLLaLJSLHUPUN ZVS\Ì
[PVUSL]LSHZULJLZZHY`
,SLJ[YPJHSZ`Z[LT
9LTV]L [OL IH[[LY` MYVT [OL ]LOPJSL HUK
Z[VYL P[ PU H JVVS KY` WSHJL UV[ VU H JLTLU[
MSVVY
>OLU [OL IH[[LY` PZ KPZJVUULJ[LK [OL
HSHYTZ`Z[LTPZKLHJ[P]H[LK
9LJOHYNL [OL IH[[LY` L]LY` TVU[OZ 0M [OL
IH[[LY` YLTHPUZ PU [OL ]LOPJSL ^P[O [OL JHISLZ
JVUULJ[LK P[ PZ ULJLZZHY` [V JOLJR YLTV]L
HUKYLJOHYNL[OLIH[[LY`L]LY`Ì^LLRZ
+VUV[MHZ[JOHYNL[OLIH[[LY`
-VSSV^ [OL PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ PU [OL s)H[[LY`r JOHWÌ
[LY
=LOPJSLPU[LYPVY
;OL PU[LYPVY T\Z[ IL KY` LZWLJPHSS` PU [OL HYLH
VM [OL MSVVY JHYWL[Z ;OL \ZL VM KY`PUN HNLU[Z
:PSPJHÌ.LS PZ YLJVTTLUKLK PU ]LOPJSLZ ^P[O
SLH[OLY PU[LYPVY HUK PU HYLHZ ^P[O OPNO O\TPKP[`
;OL YLJVTTLUKLK HTV\U[ PZ MHIYPJ IHNZ VM
SIZ NYHTZ LHJO WSHJLK VU [OL MSVVY
JHYWL[Z
>PUKV^Z KVVYZ SPKZ HUK YVVM T\Z[ IL JSVZLK
;OLHPYMSHWZZOV\SKILVWLULK
sQG
4HPU[LUHUJL*HY*HYL
"4a4"daz:hFVFm4©F¦a4F
*H\[PVUZ
;PYLZ^OLLSZ u
1HJR[VVSZ
3PM[PUN[OL]LOPJSL
:WHYL^OLLS
>OLLSIVS[Z
*OHUNPUN^OLLSZ u
,SLJ[YPJHSZ`Z[LTM\ZLZYLSH`Z u
)H[[LY` u
,TLYNLUJ`Z[HY[PUN
^P[OQ\TWLYJHISLZ
3PNO[ZYLWSHJPUNI\SIZ u
(KQ\Z[PUNOLHKSPNO[Z
;V^PUN
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
sQn
¨F4aF¨FhF"¤apm§^Fm
pcamVpm©p¤F^a4dF
>HYUPUN
0NUVYPUN [OL MVSSV^PUN PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ TH`
JH\ZLZLYPV\ZWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`
;OLLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[VMHU`TV[VY]LOPJSL
PZHWV[LU[PHSS`OHaHYKV\ZHYLH0M`V\HYLUV[
M\SS`MHTPSPHY^P[OWYVWLYYLWHPYWYVJLK\YLZKV
UV[H[[LTW[[OLHKQ\Z[TLU[ZKLZJYPILKVU[OL
MVSSV^PUNWHNLZ
;OPZJH\[PVUHWWSPLZ[V[OLLU[PYL]LOPJSL
6US` ^VYR VU `V\Y ]LOPJSL V\[KVVYZ VY PU H
^LSS]LU[PSH[LKHYLH
,UZ\YL [OH[ [OLYL HYL UV VWLU MSHTLZ PU [OL
HYLH VM `V\Y ]LOPJSL H[ HU` [PTL ^OLU M\LS
M\TLZ TPNO[ IL WYLZLU[ )L LZWLJPHSS` JH\Ì
[PV\Z VM Z\JO KL]PJLZ Z\JO HZ OV[ ^H[LY
OLH[LYZ^OPJOPNUP[LHMSHTLPU[LYTP[[LU[S`
)LMVYL^VYRPUNVUHU`WHY[PU[OLLUNPULJVTÌ
WHY[TLU[ [\YU [OL LUNPUL VMM HUK SL[ P[ JVVS
KV^U Z\MMPJPLU[S` /V[ LUNPUL JVTWHY[TLU[
JVTWVULU[ZJHUI\YUZRPUVUJVU[HJ[
)L HSLY[ HUK JH\[PV\Z HYV\UK LUNPUL H[ HSS
[PTLZ^OPSL[OLLUNPULPZY\UUPUN
0M ^VYR OHZ [V IL WLYMVYTLK ^P[O [OL LUNPUL
Y\UUPUN HS^H`Z ZL[ [OL WHYRPUN IYHRL HUK
THRL Z\YL [OL ZOPM[ SL]LY PZ PU UL\[YHS VY [OL
ZLSLJ[VYSL]LYPZPUWVZP[PVUs7rVYs5r
0U WHY[PJ\SHY IL ]LY` JHYLM\S [V LUZ\YL [OH[
P[LTZ VM JSV[OPUN [PLZ ZOPY[ ZSLL]LZ L[J
QL^LSY` SVUN OHPY OHUK VY MPUNLYZ JHUUV[ NL[
JH\NO[ PU [OL LUNPULÌJVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY
MHUILS[ZVYV[OLYTV]PUNWHY[Z
;OLYHKPH[VYHUKYHKPH[VYMHUZHYLPU[OLMYVU[
VM[OLJHY
;OL LUNPULÌJVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY PZ TV\U[LK
VU[OLLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[SPK
;OL LUNPULÌJVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY HS^H`Z Y\UZ
^OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ Z^P[JOLK VU (M[LY [OL
PNUP[PVU PZ Z^P[JOLK VMM [OL LUNPUL JVTWHY[Ì
TLU[HUKJVVSHU[[LTWLYH[\YLZHYLTVUP[VYLK
MVYHWWYV_TPU\[LZ
+\YPUN [OPZ WLYPVK HUK KLWLUKPUN VU [LTÌ
WLYH[\YL [OL LUNPULÌJVTWHY[TLU[ ISV^LY HUK
YHKPH[VY MHUZ TH` JVU[PU\L [V Y\U VY Z[HY[ [V
Y\U
*HYY` V\[ ^VYR PU [OLZL HYLHZ VUS` ^P[O [OL
LUNPULVMMHUKL_LYJPZLL_[YLTLJH\[PVU
@V\Y 7VYZJOL PZ LX\PWWLK ^P[O HU LSLJ[YVUPJ
PNUP[PVU Z`Z[LT >OLU [OL PNUP[PVU PZ VU OPNO
]VS[HNL PZ WYLZLU[ PU HSS ^PYLZ JVUULJ[LK ^P[O
[OL PNUP[PVU Z`Z[LT" [OLYLMVYL L_LYJPZL L_Ì
[YLTL JH\[PVU ^OLU ^VYRPUN VU HU` WHY[ VM
[OL LUNPUL ^OPSL [OL PNUP[PVU PZ VU VY [OL LUÌ
NPULPZY\UUPUN
(S^H`Z Z\WWVY[ `V\Y JHY ^P[O ZHML[` Z[HUKZ PM
P[ PZ ULJLZZHY` [V ^VYR \UKLY [OL JHY ;OL
QHJRZ\WWSPLK^P[O[OLJHYPZUV[HKLX\H[LMVY
[OPZW\YWVZL
>OLU ^VYRPUN \UKLY [OL JHY ^P[OV\[ ZHML[`
Z[HUKZ I\[ ^P[O [OL ^OLLSZ VU [OL NYV\UK
THRL Z\YL [OL JHY PZ VU SL]LS NYV\UK [OL
^OLLSZ HYL ISVJRLK HUK [OH[ [OL LUNPUL JHUÌ
UV[ILZ[HY[LK
9LTV]L[OLPNUP[PVURL`
+VUV[ZTVRLVYHSSV^HUVWLUMSHTLHYV\UK
[OLIH[[LY`VYM\LS
2LLWHMPYLL_[PUN\PZOLYPUJSVZLYLHJO
0UJVTWSL[L VY PTWYVWLY ZLY]PJPUN TH` JH\ZL
WYVISLTZ PU [OL VWLYH[PVU VM [OL JHY 0M PU
KV\I[ HIV\[ HU` ZLY]PJPUN OH]L P[ KVUL I`
`V\YH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
0TWYVWLY THPU[LUHUJL K\YPUN [OL ^HYYHU[`
WLYPVK TH` HMMLJ[ `V\Y 7VYZJOL ^HYYHU[`
JV]LYHNL
:\WWSPLZ VM MS\PKZ LN LUNPUL VPS IYHRL MS\PK
VYJVVSHU[HYLOHaHYKV\Z[V`V\YOLHS[O
2LLW [OLZL MS\PKZ V\[ VM JOPSKYLUqZ YLHJO HUK
KPZWVZL VM [OLT PU HJJVYKHUJL ^P[O [OL HWÌ
WYVWYPH[LYLN\SH[PVUZ
:VTL JV\U[YPLZ YLX\PYL HKKP[PVUHS [VVSZ HUK
ZWLJPHSZWHYLWHY[Z[VILJHYYPLK
7SLHZLTHRLLUX\PYPLZILMVYLKYP]PUNHIYVHK
s¬
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
aF^FFd
;OL VYPNPUHS LX\PWTLU[ [PYLZ HUK ^OLLS YPTZ VU
`V\Y 7VYZJOL JVTWS` ^P[O HSS HWWSPJHISL -LKLYHS
4V[VY=LOPJSL:HML[`:[HUKHYKZ
-VY`V\YZHML[`YLTLTILY[OLMVSSV^PUN!
>OLLSYPTZHUK^OLLSIVS[ZHYLTH[JOLK[VMP[
`V\Y7VYZJOL
0M `V\ PU[LUK [V \ZL V[OLY [OHU VYPNPUHS LX\PWÌ
TLU[ ^OLLSZ IL Z\YL [OH[ [OL` JVUMVYT [V
7VYZJOLZWLJPMPJH[PVUZMVY`V\YTVKLS
6US` [PYLZ ^P[O [OL ZHTL THRL HUK ^P[O [OL
ZHTL ZWLJPMPJH[PVU JVKL LN s5r s5r
JHUILTV\U[LK
;OL\ZLVM^OLLSYPTZHUK^OLLSIVS[Z[OH[KV
UV[ TLL[ ZWLJPMPJH[PVUZ VM [OLVYPNPUHSMHJ[VY`
PUZ[HSSLK LX\PWTLU[ ^PSS HMMLJ[ [OL ZHML VWLYÌ
H[PVUVM`V\Y]LOPJSL
)LMVYL `V\ WSHU VU L_JOHUNPUN ^OLLSZ VY
ZUV^ [PYLZ HSYLHK` TV\U[LK VU [OL ^OLLS
YPTZ JVUZ\S[ `V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY
@V\Y KLHSLY OHZ [OL [LJOUPJHS PUMVYTH[PVU
ULJLZZHY`[VHK]PZL`V\^OPJO^OLLSYPTZHUK
^OLLS IVS[Z HYL JVTWH[PISL ^P[O [OL VYPNPUHS
MHJ[VY`PUZ[HSSH[PVUZ
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMSVZZVMJVU[YVSHUKZLYPV\ZWLYZVUHS
PUQ\Y`
0M ^OPSL KYP]PUN `V\Y ]LOPJSL L_WLYPLUJLZ H
Z\KKLU ]PIYH[PVU VY YPKL KPZ[\YIHUJL HUKVY
`V\ Z\ZWLJ[ [OH[ WVZZPISL KHTHNL [V `V\Y
[PYLZ VY ]LOPJSL OHZ VJJ\YYLK `V\ ZOV\SK PTÌ
TLKPH[LS` YLK\JL `V\Y ZWLLK ^P[OV\[ L_Ì
JLZZP]L\ZLVM[OLIYHRLZ
:[VW [OL ]LOPJSL HZ ZVVU HZ WVZZPISL HUK PUÌ
ZWLJ[[OL[PYLZ
0M`V\JHUUV[KL[LYTPUL[OLJH\ZLMVY[OLKPZÌ
[\YIHUJL OH]L `V\Y ]LOPJSL [V^LK [V [OL
ULHYLZ[ 7VYZJOL VY [PYL KLHSLY [V OH]L `V\Y
]LOPJSLVY[PYLZPUZWLJ[LK
*VU[PU\PUN [V VWLYH[L [OL ]LOPJSL ^P[OV\[ JVYÌ
YLJ[PVU JV\SK YLZ\S[ PU H SVZZ VM JVU[YVS HUK
ZLYPV\ZWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
ss
maOphaF¤"da© "=amV
8\HSP[`NYHKLZJHUILMV\UK^OLYLHWWSPJHISLVU
[OL [PYL ZPKL^HSS IL[^LLU [YLHK ZOV\SKLY HUK
TH_PT\TZLJ[PVU^PK[O
,_HTWSL
(SSWHZZLUNLYJHY[PYLZT\Z[JVUMVYT[V-LKLYHS
:HML[`9LX\PYLTLU[ZPUHKKP[PVU[V[OLZLNYHKLZ
;YLHK^LHY
;OL [YLHK^LHY NYHKL PZ H JVTWHYH[P]L YH[PUN
IHZLK VU [OL ^LHY YH[L VM [OL [PYL ^OLU [LZ[LK
\UKLYJVU[YVSSLKJVUKP[PVUZVUHZWLJPMPJNV]LYUÌ
TLU[[LZ[JV\YZL
-VYL_HTWSLH[PYLNYHKLK^V\SK^LHYVUL
HUK H OHSM Ì [PTLZ HZ ^LSS VU [OL NV]LYUÌ
TLU[JV\YZLHZH[PYLNYHKLK
;OL YLSH[P]L WLYMVYTHUJL VM [PYLZ KLWLUKZ \WVU
[OL HJ[\HS JVUKP[PVUZ VM [OLPY \ZL OV^L]LY HUK
TH` KLWHY[ ZPNUPMPJHU[S` MYVT [OL UVYT K\L [V
]HYPH[PVUZPUKYP]PUNOHIP[ZZLY]PJLWYHJ[PJLZHUK
KPMMLYLUJLZPUYVHKJOHYHJ[LYPZ[PJZHUKJSPTH[L
;YHJ[PVU((()*
;OL[YHJ[PVUNYHKLZMYVTOPNOLZ[[VSV^LZ[HYL
(( ( ) HUK * HUK [OL` YLWYLZLU[ [OL [PYLqZ
HIPSP[` [V Z[VW VU ^L[ WH]LTLU[ HZ TLHZ\YLK
\UKLY JVU[YVSSLK JVUKP[PVUZ VU ZWLJPMPLK NV]LYUÌ
TLU[[LZ[Z\YMHJLZVMHZWOHS[HUKJVUJYL[L
( [PYL THYRLK * TH` OH]L WVVY [YHJ[PVU WLYMVYÌ
THUJL
>HYUPUN
;OL [YHJ[PVU NYHKL HZZPNULK [V [OPZ PZ IHZLKVU
IYHRPUN Z[YHPNO[ÌHOLHK [YHJ[PVU [LZ[Z HUK KVLZ
UV[ PUJS\KL JVYULYPUN [\YULK [YHJ[PVU HJJLSLYHÌ
[PVU O`KYVWSHUPUN VY WLHR [YHJ[PVU JOHYHJÌ
[LYPZ[PJZ
s¢
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
;LTWLYH[\YL()*
;OL [LTWLYH[\YL NYHKLZ HYL ( [OL OPNOLZ[ )
HUK * YLWYLZLU[PUN [OL [PYLqZ YLZPZ[HUJL [V [OL
NLULYH[PVU VM OLH[ HUK P[Z HIPSP[` [V KPZZPWH[L
OLH[^OLU[LZ[LK\UKLYJVU[YVSSLKJVUKP[PVUZVU
HZWLJPMPLKPUKVVYSHIVYH[VY`[LZ[^OLLS
:\Z[HPULK OPNO [LTWLYH[\YLZ JHU JH\ZL [OL THÌ
[LYPHS VM [OL [PYL [V KLNLULYH[L HUK YLK\JL [PYL
SPMLHUKL_JLZZP]L[LTWLYH[\YLJHUSLHK[VZ\KÌ
KLU[PYLMHPS\YL
;OL NYHKL * JVYYLZWVUKZ [V H SL]LS VM WLYMVYÌ
THUJL ^OPJO HSS WHZZLUNLY JHY [PYLZ T\Z[ TLL[
\UKLY[OL-LKLYHS4V[VY=LOPJSL:HML[`:[HUKHYK
5V
.YHKLZ ) HUK ( YLWYLZLU[ OPNOLY SL]LSZ VM WLYÌ
MVYTHUJL VU [OL SHIVYH[VY` [LZ[ ^OLLS [OHU [OL
TPUPT\TYLX\PYLKI`SH^
>HYUPUN
;OL [LTWLYH[\YL NYHKL MVY [OPZ [PYL PZ LZ[HIÌ
SPZOLK MVY H [PYL [OH[ PZ WYVWLYS` PUMSH[LK HUK UV[
V]LYSVHKLK
,_JLZZP]L ZWLLK \UKLYPUMSH[PVU VY L_JLZZP]L
SVHKPUNLP[OLYZLWHYH[LS`VYPUJVTIPUH[PVUJHU
JH\ZLOLH[I\PSK\WHUKWVZZPISL[PYLMHPS\YL
aFzF¤F
>HYUPUN
0UJVYYLJ[ [PYL WYLZZ\YL JH\ZLZ PUJYLHZLK
[PYL ^LHY HUK HK]LYZLS` HMMLJ[Z YVHK OHUKÍ
SPUN
(S^H`Z \ZL HU HJJ\YH[L [PYL WYLZZ\YL NH\NL
^OLUJOLJRPUNPUMSH[PVUWYLZZ\YLZ
+V UV[ L_JLLK [OL TH_PT\T [PYL WYLZZ\YL
SPZ[LKVU[OL[PYLZPKL^HSS(SZVYLMLY[Vs;LJOÌ
UPJHSKH[Hs
*VSK [PYL PUMSH[PVU WYLZZ\YL TLHUZ! HSS [PYLZ
T\Z[ IL JVSK HTIPLU[ [LTWLYH[\YLTH_PT\T
- * ^OLU HKQ\Z[PUN [OL PUMSH[PVU
WYLZZ\YL
(]VPK Z\USPNO[ Z[YPRPUN [OL [PYLZ ILMVYL
TLHZ\YPUN JVSK WYLZZ\YLZ ZPUJL [OL WYLZZÌ
\YLZ^V\SKYPZLMYVT[LTWLYH[\YLPUMS\LUJL
=HS]L JHWZ WYV[LJ[ [OL ]HS]L MYVT K\Z[ HUK
KPY[HUK[O\ZMYVTSLHRHNL
(S^H`ZZJYL^JHWZ[PNO[S`KV^U
9LWSHJLTPZZPUNJHWZPTTLKPH[LS`
-VY ZHML[` YLHZVUZ KVUq[ \ZL [PYL PUMSH[PUN
IV[[SLZ
aF"4apm
>HYUPUN
>OLU KYP]PUN VU ^L[ VY ZS\ZO` YVHKZ H
^LKNL VM ^H[LY TH` I\PSK \W IL[^LLU [OL
[PYLZ HUK [OL YVHK ;OPZ WOLUVTLUVU PZ
RUV^UHZsO`KYVWSHULrHUKTH`JH\ZLWHYÍ
[PHS VY JVTWSL[L SVZZ VM [YHJ[PVU ]LOPJSL
JVU[YVSVYZ[VWWPUNHIPSP[`
9LK\JLZWLLKVU^L[Z\YMHJL[VWYL]LU[[OPZ
aFdaOF
;PYL SPML KLWLUKZ VU ]HYPV\Z MHJ[VYZ PL YVHK
Z\YMHJLZ [YHMMPJ HUK ^LH[OLY JVUKP[PVUZ KYP]PUN
OHIP[Z[`WLVM[PYLZHUK[PYLJHYL
0UZWLJ[ `V\Y [PYLZ MVY ^LHY HUK KHTHNL ILÌ
MVYL KYP]PUN VMM 0M `V\ UV[PJL \UL]LU VY Z\IÌ
Z[HU[PHS^LHY^OLLSZTPNO[ULLKHSPNUTLU[VY
[PYLZZOV\SKILIHSHUJLKVYYLWSHJLK
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
s
aF§F"
;OL VYPNPUHS LX\PWTLU[ [PYLZ VU `V\Y 7VYZJOL
OH]L I\PS[ÌPU [PYL ^LHY PUKPJH[VYZ ;OL` HYL
TVSKLK PU[V [OL IV[[VT VM [OL [YLHK NYVV]LZ
HUK^PSSHWWLHYHZHWWYV_PTH[LS`PUTT
IHUKZ ^OLU [OL [PYL [YLHK KLW[O PZ KV^U [V
VMHUPUTT
>OLU [OL PUKPJH[VYZ HWWLHY PU [^V VY TVYL HKÌ
QHJLU[ NYVV]LZ P[ PZ [PTL [V YLWSHJL [OL [PYLZ
>L YLJVTTLUK OV^L]LY [OH[ `V\ KV UV[ SL[
[OL[PYLZ^LHYKV^U[V[OPZL_[LU[
>VYU[PYLZJHUUV[NYPW[OLYVHKZ\YMHJLWYVWLYS`
HUKHYLL]LUSLZZLMMLJ[P]LVU^L[YVHKZ
0U [OL <UP[LK :[H[LZZ[H[LSH^ZTH`NV]LYU[OL
TPUPT\T [YLHK KLW[O WLYTPZZPISL -VSSV^ HSS
Z\JOSH^Z
>HYUPUN
+YP]PUN VU ^VYU [PYLZ JHU YLZ\S[ PU SVZZ VM
JVU[YVS VM [OL ]LOPJSL HUK JV\SK JH\ZL
ZL]LYLWLYZVUHSPUQ\YPLZ
+V UV[ KYP]L ^P[O ^VYU [PYLZ VY [PYLZ ZOV^PUN
J\[Z VY IY\PZLZ HZ [OL` TH` SLHK [V Z\KKLU
KLMSH[PVU HUK SVZZ VM JVU[YVS ^OPJO JV\SK
JH\ZLZL]LYLWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`
:WLJPHSPaLK OPNO WLYMVYTHUJL [PYLZ VU OPNO
WLYMVYTHUJL ZWVY[Z JHYZ L_OPIP[ TVYL ^LHY
[OHU [OVZL VU H MHTPS` ZLKHU VY L]LU H OPNO
WLYMVYTHUJLZLKHU
;OLYLMVYL P[ PZ PTWVY[HU[ [V JOLJR `V\Y [PYL
WYLZZ\YL HUK JVUKP[PVU H[ SLHZ[ L]LY` [^V
^LLRZ
0M `V\ UV[PJL [OH[ [PYLZ HYL ^LHYPUN \UL]LUS`
JVUZ\S[`V\Y7VYZJOLKLHSLY
<UL]LU ^LHY TH` UV[ HS^H`Z IL K\L [V PTÌ
WYVWLY ^OLLS HSPNUTLU[ 0[ JHU IL [OL YLZ\S[ VM
PUKP]PK\HS KYP]PUN OHIP[Z Z\JO HZ JVYULYPUN H[
OPNO ZWLLKZ 0M [OL [PYL WYLZZ\YL PZUV[JOLJRLK
HUK HKQ\Z[LK YLN\SHYS` HIUVYTHS [PYL ^LHY JHU
HSZVVJJ\Y
aF4"F
(]VPKKHTHNPUN[PYLZHUK^OLLSYPTZ
0M `V\ T\Z[ KYP]L V]LY H J\YI VY V[OLY VIÌ
Z[HJSLKYP]LZSV^S`HUKH[HUVI[\ZLHUNSL
*OLJR [PYLZ MVY \UL]LU ^LHY HUK KHTHNL ILÌ
MVYLKYP]PUNVMM
9LTV]LPTILKKLKTH[LYPHS
9LWSHJL^VYUVYKHTHNLK[PYLZPTTLKPH[LS`
2LLW VPS M\LS IYHRL MS\PK L[J H^H` MYVT
[PYLZ
9LWSHJLTPZZPUN]HS]LZ[LTJHWZ
2LLW[PYLZPUMSH[LKJVYYLJ[S`
sT
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
aF="h"VF:z¤m4¤F
*OLJR[PYLZMVYPTILKKLKTH[LYPHSJ\[ZW\UJÌ
[\YLZ JYHJRZ HUK I\SNLZ ZPKL ^HSS ILMVYL
KYP]PUNVMM
0U JHZL VM [PYL KHTHNL ^OLYL P[ PZ \UJLY[HPU
^OL[OLY [OLYL PZ H IYLHR PU [OL WS` ^P[O HSS P[Z
JVUZLX\LUJLZ VY [PYL KHTHNL JH\ZLK I` [OLYÌ
THS VY TLJOHUPJHS V]LYSVHKPUN K\L [V SVZZ VM
WYLZZ\YL VYHU`V[OLYWYPVYKHTHNL^LYLJVTÌ
TLUK [OH[ [OL [PYL IL YLWSHJLK MVY ZHML[` YLHÌ
ZVUZ
0M VUL MH\S[` [PYL PZ YLWSHJLK P[ ZOV\SK IL UV[LK
[OH[ [OL KPMMLYLUJL PU [YLHK KLW[O VU VUL H_SL
T\Z[UV[L_JLLK
/HUKSPUNPUJVUZPZ[LUJPLZTH`YLZ\S[
7LYMVYTH]PZ\HSPUZWLJ[PVUPMULJLZZHY`
aFFzd"4FhFm
0M PU KV\I[ JVU[HJ[ `V\Y 7VYZJOL KLHSLY VY
7VYZJOL0TWVY[LYVM`V\YJV\U[Y`
<ZL VUS` [PYL THRLZ HUK [`WLZ [LZ[LK I`
7VYZJOL
0M `V\ KV UV[ \ZL H 7VYZJOL YLJVTTLUKLK
YLWSHJLTLU[ [PYL THR L Z\YL [OH[ `V\ W\YÍ
JOHZL `V\Y UL^ [PYLZ MYVT H YLW\[HISL [PYL
KLHSLYHUK[OH[[OLKLHSLYJVTWSPLZ^P[OHSS
THU\MHJ[\YLYZ^HYUPUNZMVY[OVZL[PYLZ
6US`[PYLZ^P[O[OLZHTLTHRLHUK^P[O[OL
ZHTLZWLJPMPJH[PVUJVKLLNs5rs5r
JHUILTV\U[LK
)LMVYLTV\U[PUNUL^[PYLZJOLJR^P[O`V\Y
7VYZJOL KLHSLY HIV\[ [OL J\YYLU[ YLSLHZL
Z[H[\Z
<ZL [PYLZ ^P[O sA9r X\HSP[` Z[HUKHYKZ ;OLYL
HYL J\YYLU[S` UV Z[HUKHYKZ JVUJLYUPUN [PYL
Z[YLUN[OH[ZWLLKZHIV]LTWORTO
;PYLZZOV\SKILYLWSHJLKUVSLZZ[OHUVUVULH_SLH[
[OL[PTL
6US`[PYLZVM[OLZHTLTHRLHUK[`WLT\Z[IL\ZLK
4P_LK[PYLZHYLUV[WLYTPZZPISL
0UP[PHSS` UL^ [PYLZ KV UV[ OH]L [OLPY M\SS [YHJ[PVU
@V\ ZOV\SK [OLYLMVYL KYP]L H[ TVKLYH[L ZWLLKZ
K\YPUN[OLMPYZ[ÌTPSLZÌRT
0MUL^[PYLZHYLPUZ[HSSLKVUS`VUVULH_SLHUVÌ
[PJLHISL JOHUNL PU OHUKSPUN VJJ\YZ K\L [V [OL
KPMMLYLU[[YLHKKLW[OVM[OLV[OLY[PYLZ
;OPZ OHWWLUZ LZWLJPHSS` PM VUS` YLHY [PYLZ HYL YLÌ
WSHJLK /V^L]LY [OPZ JVUKP[PVU KPZHWWLHYZ HZ
[OLUL^[PYLZHYLIYVRLUPU
7SLHZLHKQ\Z[`V\YKYP]PUNZ[`SLHJJVYKPUNS`
0UZ[HSSH[PVU VM UL^ [PYLZ ZOV\SK VUS` IL KVUL I`
HX\HSPMPLK[PYL[LJOUPJPHU
=HS]LZ
9\IILY ]HS]L Z[LTZ T\Z[ IL YLWSHJLK L]LY`
[PTLH[PYLPZYLWSHJLK
-VYZ[LLS]HS]LZ[OLPUZ[HSSH[PVUHUKYLWSHJLTLU[
PUZ[Y\J[PVUZT\Z[ILVIZLY]LK
<ZLVUS`NLU\PUL7VYZJOLZ[LLS]HS]LZ
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
sQ
"camV"^F4¤*
>HYUPUN
/HYK PTWHJ[Z HNHPUZ[ J\YIZ VY [YHMMPJ
PZSHUKZHYLKHUNLYV\ZHUKTH`JH\ZLOPKÍ
KLU [PYL KHTHNL ^OPJO PZ UV[ UV[PJLHISL
\U[PSSH[LY:\JOKHTHNLJHUYLZ\S[PUHJJPÍ
KLU[Z H[ OPNO ZWLLKZ JH\ZPUN ZL]LYL WLYÍ
ZVUHSPUQ\Y`
+LWLUKPUNVU[OLMVYJLVMPTWHJ[[OLLKNL
VM[OLYPTJHUHSZVILKHTHNLK
0M `V\ HYL PU KV\I[ OH]L [OL ^OLLS JOLJRLK
I` HU L_WLY[ WHY[PJ\SHYS` PM `V\ Z\ZWLJ[ KHTÌ
HNLVU[OLPUZPKL
0M `V\ T\Z[ KYP]L V]LY H J\YI VY V[OLY VIÌ
Z[HJSL KYP]L ZSV^S` HUK H[ HU VI[\ZL HUNSL
,_LYJPZLJHYL^OLUWHYRPUNHSVUNJ\YIZ
^FFd"daVmhFm:§^FFd*"d"m4amV
(SZVYLMLY[Vs-V\YÌ>OLLSKYP]Lr
(ZHWYLJH\[PVUOH]L^OLLSZ^P[OZ\TTLY[PYLZ
IHSHUJLK PU [OL ZWYPUN HUK [OVZL ^P[O T\KHUK
ZUV^[PYLZILMVYL^PU[LY
<UIHSHUJLK ^OLLSZ TH` HMMLJ[ JHY OHUKSPUN HUK
[PYLSPML
6US` [OL ZWLJPMPLK ^LPNO[Z TH` IL \ZLK MVY
^OLLSIHSHUJPUN
:LSMÌHKOLZP]L ^LPNO[Z T\Z[ UV[ JVTL PU[V JVUÌ
[HJ[^P[OJSLHUPUNHNLU[ZZPUJL[OL`JV\SKKYVW
VMM
( ^OLLS ZOV\SK HS^H`Z IL IHSHUJLK HM[LY H [PYL
YLWHPY
<UL]LU[YLHK^LHYPUKPJH[LZ^OLLSPTIHSHUJL0U
[OPZ L]LU[ [OL ]LOPJSL ZOV\SK IL JOLJRLK H[ HU
H\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
>HYUPUN
0M K\YPUN H QV\YUL` \UL]LU Y\UUPUN VY ]PÍ
IYH[PVUZ VJJ\Y [OH[ JV\SK IL JH\ZLK I`
KHTHNL[V[PYLZVY[OLJHY[OLZWLLKT\Z[
IL YLK\JLK PTTLKPH[LS` I\[ ^P[OV\[ IYHRÍ
PUNZOHYWS`
0M `V\JVU[PU\L`V\Y[YPW^P[OV\[OH]PUN[OL
JH\ZLVM[OLMH\S[YLTLKPLK`V\TPNO[SVZL
JVU[YVS VM `V\Y ]LOPJSL ^OPJO JV\SK JH\ZL
ZL]LYLWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`
:[VW[OL]LOPJSLHUKJOLJR[OL[PYLZ
0M UV JH\ZL MVY [OL MH\S[ JHU IL MV\UK KYP]L
JHYLM\SS` [V [OL ULHYLZ[ H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL
KLHSLY
s
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
Fhp¦amV"m=pamVaF
(M[LY JOHUNPUN HKQ\Z[ [PYL WYLZZ\YL HUK
[VYX\L ^OLLS IVS[Z KPHNVUHSS` [V M[SI
5T
:LLs*OHUNPUN^OLLSZr
;PYLZT\Z[HS^H`ZYLTHPUVU[OLZHTLZPKL
VM[OL]LOPJSL
>OLU^OLLSZHYLYLTV]LK[OLKPYLJ[PVUVMYV[HÌ
[PVU HUK WVZP[PVU VM LHJO ^OLLS ZOV\SK IL
THYRLK
,_HTWSL
-9MYVU[YPNO[-399HUK93
>OLLSZT\Z[HS^H`ZILMP[[LKPUHJJVYKHUJL^P[O
[OLPYTHYRPUN
;OL WYLJLW[PVU [OH[ [PYL K\YHIPSP[` HUK WLYMVYÌ
THUJL HYL PTT\UL [V [OL LMMLJ[Z VMZ[VYHNLHUK
HNLPZ\UMV\UKLK
*OLTPJHSHKKP[P]LZ^OPJOTHRL[OLY\IILYLSHZ[PJ
SVZL [OLPY LMMLJ[P]LULZZ PU[OLJV\YZLVM[PTLHUK
[OLY\IILYILJVTLZIYP[[SLHUKJYHJRZ
;OLYLMVYL [OL [PYLZ LZWLJPHSS` [OL ZWHYL
[PYLZOV\SKILPUZWLJ[LKMYVT[PTL[V[PTL
5V[L
<UKLY UV JPYJ\TZ[HUJLZ ZOV\SK [PYLZ VSKLY [OHU
`LHYZIL\ZLKVU`V\Y7VYZJOL
;OL HNL VM [OL [PYL JHU IL VI[HPULK MYVT [OL
s+6;r JVKL U\TILY 0M MVY L_HTWSL [OL SHZ[
MV\Y U\TILYZ YLHK [OLU [OL [PYL ^HZ WYVÌ
K\JLKPU[OL[O^LLRVM
:[VYL[PYLZPUHJVVSHUKKY`WSHJL
mp§aF
-VY H IL[[LY NYPW VU ZUV^ HUK PJL \ZL YHKPHS 4:
[PYLZ^P[OZ[\KZ
*OLJR ^P[O `V\Y SVJHS 4V[VY =LOPJSL )\YLH\ MVY
WVZZPISLYLZ[YPJ[PVUZ
>HYUPUN
9PZR VM SVZZ VM JVU[YVS HUK KHTHNL [V [OL
]LOPJSLHZ^LSSHZZL]LYLWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`
;OL Z[HUKHYK [PYLZ WYVMPSL HUK Y\IILY TP_Í
[\YL HYL VW[PTPaLK MVY ^L[ HUK KY` KYP]PUN
JVUKP[PVUZHUKTH`UV[WYV]LMH]VYHISLMVY
ZUV^JVUKP[PVUZ
;OLYLMVYL PUZ[HSS 4: [PYLZ ILMVYL KYP]PUN PU
Z\JOJVUKP[PVUZ
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
s
)LMVYL TV\U[PUN ZUV^ [PYLZ JVUZ\S[ ^P[O
`V\Y 7VYZJOL KLHSLY /L OHZ [OL [LJOUPJHS
PUMVYTH[PVU ULJLZZHY` [V HK]PZL `V\ VU
^OLLSHUK[PYLJVTWH[PIPSP[`
:UV^[PYLZZOV\SKOH]L[OLZHTLSVHKJHWHJP[`HZ
VYPNPUHSLX\PWTLU[[PYLZHUKZOV\SKILTV\U[LKVU
HSSMV\Y^OLLSZ
:UV^[PYLZ^P[OZ[\KZZOV\SKILY\UH[TVKLYH[L
ZWLLKZ^OLUUL^PUVYKLY[VNP]L[OLZ[\KZ[PTL
[VZL[[SL
>HYUPUN
;PYLZ ^P[O IHKS` ^VYU [YLHKZ HUK Z[\KZ HYL
]LY` KHUNLYV\Z HUK JV\SK JH\ZL HJJPKLU[Z
YLZ\S[PUNPUZL]LYLWLYZVUHSPUQ\YPLZ
4HRLZ\YL[OL`HYLYLWSHJLKPTTLKPH[LS`
+V UV[ KYP]L H ]LOPJSL LX\PWWLK ^P[O ZUV^ [PYLZ
H[WYVSVUNLKOPNOZWLLK
:UV^[PYLZKVUV[OH]L[OLZHTLKLNYLLVM[YHJÌ
[PVUVUKY`^L[VYZUV^MYLLYVHKZHZHUVYTHS
[PYL
-\Y[OLYTVYL ZUV^ [PYLZ ^LHY YHWPKS` \UKLY
[OLZLJVUKP[PVUZ
:UV^[PYLZKVUV[M\SMPSS[OLPYW\YWVZLPM[OL[YLHK
KLW[OPZSLZZ[OHUPUTT
*VTWS` ^P[O HSS Z[H[L HUK SVJHS SH^Z
NV]LYUPUN ZUV^ [PYL HUK [YLHK KLW[O
YLX\PYLTLU[Z
mp§4^"am
*H\[PVU
9PZR VM KHTHNL [V IVK` H_SL VY IYHRL
JVTWVULU[Z
-P[ ZUV^ JOHPUZ VUS` [V [OL YLHY ^OLLSZ HUK
VUS`^P[O[OL[PYLYPTJVTIPUH[PVUSPZ[LKPU[OL
;LJOUPJHS+H[H
;V LUZ\YL HKLX\H[L JSLHYHUJL IL[^LLU JOHPU
HUK IVK` 7VYZJOLYLJVTTLUKZVUS`[OL\ZL
VM MPULÌSPUR JOHPUZ Z\JO HZ [OVZL HWWYV]LK I`
7VYZJOL
-VSSV^ PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ PZZ\LK I` [OL Z\WWSPLY VM
[OLJOHPUZ
+PMMLYLU[ Z[H[LZ HUK JV\U[YPLZ OH]L ]HY`PUN Z[H[\Ì
[VY` YLX\PYLTLU[Z YLNHYKPUN TH_PT\T ZWLLK
*OLJR ^P[O SVJHS H\[OVYP[PLZ MVY WVZZPISL YLZ[YPJÌ
[PVUZ
9LTV]LJOHPUZHZZVVUHZ[OLYVHKZHYLMYLL
VMPJLHUKZUV^
aF=FaVm"apm
+\L [V UL^ ZWLLK HUK SVHK YH[PUNZ MVY YHKPHS
[PYLZUL^KLZPNUH[PVUZOH]LJVTLPU[VMVYJLMVY
ZUV^[PYLZMVY`V\Y7VYZJOL
;OLKLZPNUH[PVU[VIL\ZLKMVYA9[PYLZPZLN
A9 A $ JVKL SL[[LY MVY YHKPHS [PYLZ
MVYZWLLKZHIV]LTWORTO
sG
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
"4c:ppd
>HYUPUN
;OLQHJRT\Z[IL\ZLKVUS`[VYHPZL[OLJHY
MVY^OLLSJOHUNPUN
;OL QHJR T\Z[ UL]LY IL \ZLK HZ H Z\WWVY[
[V ^VYR \UKLYULH[O [OL ]LOPJSL 0M [OL QHJR
PZHJJPKLU[HSS`KPZSVKNLK`V\VYI`Z[HUKLYZ
JV\SKZ\MMLYZL]LYLWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`
5L]LY QHJR \W V[OLY ]LOPJSLZ VY V[OLY SVHKZ
^P[O[OLQHJR
(S^H`ZWSHJL[OLJHYVUZ[HISLZ\WWVY[ZPM`V\
OH]L[V^VYR\UKLYP[
>OLU ^VYRPUN \UKLY [OL ]LOPJSL HS^H`Z \ZL
ZHML[` Z[HUKZ ZWLJPMPJHSS` KLZPNULK MVY [OPZ
W\YWVZL
:LLJOHW[LYs*OHUNPUN>OLLSZr
;OLQHJR[VVSZJVTWYLZZVYHUKWYLZZ\YL[LZ[LY
HYLSVJH[LKPU[OLZWHYL^OLLS
aOamV^FF^a4dF§a^"aOamV
d"Ophp ""VFaO
;OL JHY T\Z[ IL YHPZLK VUS` H[ [OL PSS\Z[YH[LK
QHJRPUNWVPU[Z:LLJOHW[LYs*OHUNPUN>OLLSZr
3PM[PUN H[ HU` V[OLY WSHJL TH` KHTHNL [OL
]LOPJSLVYTH`YLZ\S[PUWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`
*H\[PVU
9PZR VM ZLYPV\Z KHTHNL [V [OL LUNPUL VY
[OL]LOPJSL
5L]LY SPM[ [OL ]LOPJSL I` [OL LUNPUL [YHUZÌ
TPZZPVUVYH_SLZ
+VUq[ KHTHNL HU` ZLUZP[P]L JVTWVULU[Z PU
[OL]PJPUP[`VM[OLQHJRPUNWVPU[Z
d"OphdaO
)LMVYL [OL JHY PZ KYP]LU VU [V H SPM[PUN WSH[MVYT
P[ T\Z[ IL LUZ\YLK [OH[ [OLYL PZ LUV\NO ZWHJL
IL[^LLU[OLSPM[PUNWSH[MVYTHUK[OL]LOPJSL
""VFdaO
(NHYHNLSPM[T\Z[IL\ZLKVUS`H[[OLPSS\Z[YH[LK
QHJRPUNWVPU[Z
1HJRPUN H[ HU` V[OLY WSHJL TH` KHTHNL [OL
]LOPJSLVYTH`YLZ\S[PUWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
sn
z"F^FFd
;OLZWHYL^OLLSPZZLJ\YLKPU[OLS\NNHNLJVTÌ
WHY[TLU[^P[OH^PUNU\[(
;OLYL PZ H WSHZ[PJ ZOLL[ PU [OL [VVS WVJRL[ [V
Z[VYL[OLKHTHNLK^OLLS
=LOPJSLZ^P[O7VYZJOL*LYHTPJ
*VTWVZP[L)YHRL
)LMVYL PUMSH[PUN [OL ZWHYL ^OLLS VWLU [OL
SH[JOVU[OLSHZOPUNZ[YHWZHUKYLTV]LILS[Z
@V\Y]LOPJSLPZLX\PWWLK^P[OHJVSSHWZPISLZWHYL
^OLLS [OH[ T\Z[ IL PUMSH[LK ^P[O [OL LSLJ[YPJHS
JVTWYLZZVY^OLUULLKLK
;PYLWYLZZ\YL
=LOPJSLZ ^P[OV\[ 7VYZJOL *LYHTPJ *VTWVZP[L
)YHRL!WZPIHY
=LOPJSLZ ^P[O 7VYZJOL *LYHTPJ *VTWVZP[L
)YHRL!WZPIHY
0TWVY[HU[UV[L
-VSSV^HSS^HYUPUNZHUKPUZ[Y\J[PVUZMV\UKPU[OPZ
THU\HSMVYJOHUNPUNH^OLLS
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMHUHJJPKLU[
-VY ZHML[` YLHZVUZ [OL MVSSV^PUN PUZ[Y\JÍ
[PVUZ MVY [OL \ZL VM [OL ZWHYL ^OLLS T\Z[
ILMVSSV^LKL_HJ[S`
*OLJR [OL [PYL MPSSPUN WYLZZ\YL PTTLKPH[LS`
HM[LYMP[[PUN[OLZWHYL^OLLS
;OL ZWHYL ^OLLS T\Z[ IL \ZLK VUS` V]LY
ZOVY[KPZ[HUJLZPUJHZLZVMLTLYNLUJ`
(M[LY YLWHPY VY YLWSHJLTLU[ YLÌTV\U[ [OL
YVHK^OLLSHUK[PYLHZZVVUHZWVZZPISL
(]VPK YHWPK HJJLSLYH[PVU OHYK IYHRPUN HUK
OPNO JVYULYPUN ZWLLKZ [V WYL]LU[ SVZZ VM ]LÌ
OPJSLJVU[YVS
;OL TH_PT\T WLYTP[[LK ZWLLK PZ TWO
RTOHUKT\Z[UV[ILL_JLLKLKILJH\ZL
VM HS[LYLK KYP]PUN JOHYHJ[LYPZ[PJZ HUK MVY YLHÌ
ZVUZVM^LHY
;OL[YLHKKLW[OVM[OLZWHYL^OLLSPZZ\IQLJ[
[V[OLZHTLSH^ZHZ[OLVYPNPUHS[PYLZ
;OL ]LOPJSL T\Z[ IL MP[[LK ^P[O VUS` VUL
ZWHYL^OLLS
+VUV[\ZLHZWHYL^OLLSMYVTV[OLY]LOPJSLZ
VU`V\YJHY
3PRL^PZL [OL ZWHYL ^OLLS MYVT `V\Y ]LOPJSL
T\Z[UV[IL\ZLKVUV[OLYJHYZ
;V H]VPK KHTHNL KV UV[ \ZL H\[VTH[PJ JHY
^HZOLZ^OLU[OLZWHYL^OLLSPZPUZ[HSSLK
s¬
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
z"4FamV
>HYUPUN
9PZR VM HJJPKLU[ 0M PUJVYYLJ[S` MP[[LK [OL
ZWHYL ^OLLS TH` JVTL VMM ^OPSL KYP]PUN
^OPJOJV\SKYLZ\S[PUZLYPV\ZWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`
VYKLH[O
TTZWHJLYYPUNZVUYLHYH_SL!
0MTTZWHJLYYPUNZHYLMP[[LK[V[OL^OLLS
O\IZ [OL HWWYVWYPH[L ZWHJLY YPUN T\Z[ IL
YLTV]LKILMVYL[OLZWHYL^OLLSPZMP[[LK
;V TV\U[ [OL ZWHYL ^OLLS \ZL [OL ^OLLS
IVS[Z ^OPJO ^LYL \ZLK [V MHZ[LU [OL ZWHJLY
YPUN
^FFdpd
>HYUPUN
9PZRVM^OLLSIVS[IYLHRHNLHUK^OLLSZLWÍ
HYH[PVU YLZ\S[PUN PU ZL]LYL WLYZVUHS PUQ\Y`
VYKLH[O
-VSSV^HSSPUZ[Y\J[PVUZJVUJLYUPUN^OLLSIVS[Z
(S^H`ZJSLHU[OL^OLLSIVS[ZILMVYLMP[[PUN
(WWS` H [OPU JVH[ VM 6W[PTVS` ;( HS\TPUP\T
WHZ[L VU [OL [OYLHK HUK IL[^LLU [OL IVS[
OLHKHUKTV]HISLZWOLYPJHSJHWYPUNHYYV^Z
;OL ILHYPUN Z\YMHJL VM [OL ZWOLYPJHSJHW
MHJPUN[OL^OLLST\Z[UV[ILNYLHZLK
9LWSHJLKHTHNLK^OLLSIVS[Z
6US` \ZL [OL 6YPNPUHS 7VYZJOL ^OLLS IVS[Z
ZWLJPHSS`KLZPNULKMVY[OPZ]LOPJSL[`WL
5V[L
6U ]LOPJSLZ ^P[O TT ZWHJLY YPUNZ VU [OL
YLHYH_SL[OL^OLLSZHYLZLJ\YLK^P[OU\[Z
aV^FmamVp¤F
;PNO[LUPUN[VYX\LVM^OLLSIVS[ZHUK^OLLSU\[Z!
5T
^FFdF4¤amVpd
;OL ^YLUJO ZVJRL[ MVY [OL ^OLLS ZLJ\YPUN IVS[Z
PZPU[OL[VVSWVJRL[
;VSVVZLUVY[PNO[LU[OL^OLLSIVS[^P[OHU[PÌ[OLM[
WYV[LJ[PVUH^YLUJOZVJRL[^P[O[OLHWWYVWYPH[L
JVKPUN T\Z[ IL \ZLK IL[^LLU [OL ^OLLS IVS[
HUK[OL^OLLSÌIVS[ZWHUULY
>OLU WVZP[PVUPUN [OL ^YLUJO ZVJRL[ LUZ\YL
[OH[ P[ LUNHNLZ M\SS` PU [OL [LL[O VM [OL ^OLLS
IVS[
0M [OL ^OLLSZ OH]L [V IL YLTV]LK H[ [OL ^VYRÌ
ZOVW WSLHZL KV UV[ MVYNL[ [V OHUK V]LY [OL
^YLUJO ZVJRL[ MVY [OL ^OLLS ZLJ\YPUN IVS[Z
HSVUN^P[O[OLJHYRL`
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
ss
^"mVamV^FFd
>HYUPUN
-HPS\YL [V MVSSV^ [OLZL PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ TH` YLÍ
Z\S[PUZLYPV\ZWLYZVUHSPUQ\YPLZ[V`V\VY[V
I`Z[HUKLYZ
)LMVYLJOHUNPUN[OL^OLLS
0M `V\ OH]L H MSH[ [PYL TV]L H ZHML KPZ[HUJL
VMM [OL YVHK ;\YU [OL LTLYNLUJ` MSHZOLY VU
HUK \ZL V[OLY ^HYUPUN KL]PJLZ [V HSLY[ V[OLY
TV[VYPZ[Z
+VUV[WHYR`V\Y]LOPJSL^OLYLP[TH`JVU[HJ[
KY` NYHZZ IY\ZO VY V[OLY MSHTTHISL THÌ
[LYPHSZ ;OL OV[ WHY[Z VM [OL L_OH\Z[ Z`Z[LT
JV\SK ZL[ Z\JO TH[LYPHSZ VU MPYL [OLYLI`
JH\ZPUN IV[O WYVWLY[` KHTHNL HUK ZL]LYL VY
MH[HSWO`ZPJHSPUQ\Y`
7HZZLUNLYZ T\Z[ UV[ YLTHPU PU [OL ]LOPJSL
^OLUP[PZQHJRLK\W
)LMVYL `V\ JOHUNL H ^OLLS IL Z\YL [OL
NYV\UK PZ SL]LS HUK MPYT 0M ULJLZZHY` \ZL H
IVHYK \UKLY [OL QHJR [V LUZ\YL [OH[ [OL QHJR
KVLZUV[ZPURPU[V[OLNYV\UK
:L[ [OL WHYRPUN IYHRL HUK ISVJR [OL ^OLLSZ
VWWVZP[L [OL MSH[ [PYL VU [OL V[OLY ZPKL VM [OL
]LOPJSL
>OPSLVWLYH[PUN[OLQHJR
;OL QHJR PZ VUS` [V IL \ZLK MVY JOHUNPUN H
^OLLS +V UV[ \ZL P[ HZ H Z\WWVY[ [V ^VYR
\UKLY[OLJHY
;OL JHY T\Z[ IL QHJRLK \W VUS` H[ [OL PSS\ZÌ
[YH[LKQHJRPUNWVPU[Z
3PM[PUNH[HU`V[OLYWSHJLTH`KHTHNL[OL]LÌ
OPJSLVYTH`YLZ\S[PUWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`
5L]LY QHJR [OL JHY \W I` [OL IVK` VY [OL
I\TWLYZ
-VY ZHML[` YLHZVUZ KV UV[ \ZL [PYL PUMSH[PUN
IV[[SLZ
+V UV[ \ZL JVTTLYJPHSS` H]HPSHISL ZLHSHU[
IV[[SLZ
s¢
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
F¤Fm4FpOpzF"apm
>HYUPUN
;OLQHJRT\Z[IL\ZLKVUS`[VYHPZL[OLJHY
MVY^OLLSJOHUNPUN
;OL QHJR T\Z[ UL]LY IL \ZLK HZ H Z\WWVY[
[V ^VYR \UKLYULH[O [OL ]LOPJSL 0M [OL QHJR
PZHJJPKLU[HSS`KPZSVKNLK`V\VYI`Z[HUKLYZ
JV\SKZ\MMLYZL]LYLWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`
5L]LY QHJR \W V[OLY ]LOPJSLZ VY V[OLY SVHKZ
^P[O[OLQHJR
(S^H`ZWSHJL[OLJHYVUZ[HISLZ\WWVY[ZPM`V\
OH]L[V^VYR\UKLYP[
>OLU ^VYRPUN \UKLY [OL ]LOPJSL HS^H`Z \ZL
ZHML[` Z[HUKZ ZWLJPMPJHSS` KLZPNULK MVY [OPZ
W\YWVZL
7SLHZL \ZL H Z\P[HISL RULL YLZ[ [V WYV[LJ[ `V\Y
JSV[OPUNHNHPUZ[ZVPSPUN
1HJRPUNWVPU[MVYMYVU[^OLLSJOHUNL
:SPNO[S` SVVZLU [OL ^OLLS IVS[Z VM [OL ^OLLS
[VILJOHUNLK
:L[\WQHJRVUS`H[[OLWVPU[ZWYV]PKLK
;OL QHJR MVV[ T\Z[ IL PU JVU[HJ[ V]LY P[Z
^OVSLHYLH
<ZLHZ\P[HISLZ\WWVY[PMULJLZZHY`
/VSK QHJR Z[PSS HUK ^PUK P[ \W \U[PS P[Z OLHK
LU[LYZ[OLQHJRPUNWVPU[VU[OLJHY
6US` QHJR JHY \W \U[PS [OL ^OLLS [V IL
JOHUNLKPZJVTWSL[LS`VMM[OLNYV\UK
1HJRPUNWVPU[MVYYLHY^OLLSJOHUNL
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
s
:JYL^PUHZZLTIS`HPKMVY]LOPJSLZ^P[OV\[7VYZJOL
*LYHTPJ*VTWVZP[L)YHRL
9LTV]L VY ^OLLS IVS[Z ZLL YLZWLJ[P]L
PSS\Z[YH[PVU 9LTV]L HZZLTIS` HPKZ MYVT [VVS
RP[HUKZJYL^PUPUZ[LHKVM[OL^OLLSIVS[Z
9LTV]L[OLYLTHPUPUN^OLLSIVS[Z
*H\[PVU
9PZRVMKHTHNL[VIYHRLKPZJZ
,UZ\YL[OH[[OLHZZLTIS`HPKZHYLZJYL^LKPU
^OLUJOHUNPUNH^OLLS
:JYL^PU[^VHZZLTIS`HPKZMVY]LOPJSLZ^P[O7VYZJOL
*LYHTPJ*VTWVZP[L)YHRL
=LOPJSLZ ^P[O 7VYZJOL *LYHTPJ *VTWVÍ
ZP[L)YHRL
6WLU SH[JOLZ VU [OL SHZOPUN Z[YHWZ VM [OL
ZWHYL^OLLSHUKYLTV]LILS[Z
4V\U[ [OL JVSSHWZPISL ZWHYL ^OLLS VU [OL
]LOPJSLILMVYLPUMSH[PUNP[
7SLHZLUV[LJOHW[LYs>OLLSIVS[Zr
0UZLY[ MV\Y ^OLLS IVS[Z HUK [PNO[LU I` OHUK
9LTV]L HZZLTIS` HPKZ ZJYL^ PU YLTHPUPUN
IVS[
0UP[PHSS` [PNO[LU ZJYL^Z PU KPHNVUHSS` VWWVZP[L
ZLX\LUJLZV[OH[[OL^OLLSPZJLU[LYLK
:JYL^ MPSSLY OVZL VM [OL JVTWYLZZVY VU[V
[OL[PYL]HS]L
0UZLY[ WS\N VM [OL JVTWYLZZVY PU[V [OL JPNHÌ
YL[[LSPNO[LY
;OLYLX\PYLKMPSSPUNWYLZZ\YL^PSSILYLHJOLK
HM[LYHML^TPU\[LZ
9LX\PYLKMPSSPUNWYLZZ\YL!
=LOPJSLZ ^P[OV\[ 7VYZJOL *LYHTPJ *VTWVÌ
ZP[L)YHRLWZPIHY
=LOPJSLZ ^P[O 7VYZJOL *LYHTPJ *VTWVZP[L
)YHRLWZPIHY
<UZJYL^MPSSLYOVZLVM[OLJVTWYLZZVY
0M[OLWYLZZ\YLPZ[VVOPNOYLSLHZLZVTLHPY
I`WYLZZPUN[OL]HS]LPUZLY[
9LJOLJR[OLMPSSPUNWYLZZ\YL
3V^LYJHYHUKYLTV]LQHJR
;PNO[LU ^OLLS IVS[Z PU KPHNVUHSS` VWWVZP[L
ZLX\LUJL
0TWVY[HU[UV[L
0TTLKPH[LS` HM[LY JOHUNPUN H ^OLLS HKQ\Z[ [OL
[PYL MPSSPUN WYLZZ\YL YLMLY [V 7HNL HUK \ZL H
[VYX\L ^YLUJO [V JOLJR [OL WYLZJYPILK [PNO[LÌ
UPUN[VYX\LVM[OL^OLLSIVS[Z5T
sT
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
(M[LY\ZPUN[OLJVSSHWZPISLZWHYL^OLLS
9LSLHZLHPYI`\UZJYL^PUN[OL]HS]LPUZLY[
;OL [PYL ^PSS YL]LY[ [V P[Z VYPNPUHS ZOHWL VUS`
HM[LY ZL]LYHS OV\YZ 6US` [OLU JHU P[ IL
Z[V^LK PU [OL ZWHYL ^OLLS YLJLZZ PU [OL
S\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[
=LOPJSLZ ^P[O 7VYZJOL *LYHTPJ *VTWVZP[L
)YHRL
;OLZWHYL^OLLSJHUUV[ILZ[V^LKPU[OLZWHYL
^OLLSYLJLZZ^P[OV\[H[[HJOLKSHZOPUNZ[YHWZ
(M[LY YLSLHZPUN [OL HPY H[[HJO [OL SHZOPUN
Z[YHWZVU[OLVWWVZP[LZPKLZ
;VKV[OPZW\SS[OLZ[YHWZ[OYV\NO[OLYPTHUK
WSHJLHYV\UK[OL[PYLZ
7VZP[PVU [OL Z[YHWZ ZV [OH[ [OL Z[YHW SH[JOLZ
HYLPU[OLPUULYZPKLVM[OLYPT
*SVZLZ[YHWSH[JOLZHUKW\SS[OLZ[YHWZ[H\[
:[V^[OLJVSSHZWPISLZWHYL^OLLSPU[OLZWHYL
^OLLS YLJLZZ ZV [OH[ [OL SHZOPUN Z[YHWZ HYL
SVJH[LKH[[OLMYVU[HUKYLHYZLLPSS\Z[YH[PVU
Fz"a
;OL JVSSHWZPISL ZWHYL ^OLLS T\Z[ IL YLWHPYLK
VUS` I` [OL THU\MHJ[\YLY 7SLHZL JVUZ\S[ `V\Y
H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY PM [OL JVSSHWZPISL
ZWHYL^OLLSPZKLMLJ[P]L
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
sQ
dF4a4"d©Fh
0UVYKLY[VH]VPKKHTHNLHUKMH\S[ZPULSLJ[YPJHS
VY LSLJ[YVUPJ Z`Z[LTZ LSLJ[YPJHS HJJLZZVYPLZ
ZOV\SK IL PUZ[HSSLK H[ `V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL
KLHSLY
6US`\ZLHJJLZZVYPLZH\[OVYPaLKI`7VYZJOL
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMZOVY[JPYJ\P[HUKMPYL
9LWSHJPUN M\ZLZ VY YLSH`Z ^P[O [OL LUNPUL
Y\UUPUNVY[OLPNUP[PVUVUJV\SKJH\ZLLSLJÍ
[YPJHSZOVJR
+PZJVUULJ[LK [OL IH[[LY` K\YPUN HSS ^VYR VU
[OLLSLJ[YPJHSZ`Z[LT:LLJOHW[LYs)H[[LY`r
Fd"©
+LMLJ[P]L YLSH`Z ZOV\SK IL JOHUNLK VUS` I` HU
H\[OVYPaLK^VYRZOVW
"=ap4p=F
;OL [OLM[ÌWYV[LJ[PVU JVKL VM [OL YHKPV T\Z[ IL
LU[LYLKHNHPUPM[OLIH[[LY`^HZKPZJVUULJ[LK
d"h©Fh:4Fm"ddp4camV
;OL Z[H[\Z VM [OL JLU[YHS SVJRPUN HUK HSHYT
Z`Z[LT PZ UV[ JOHUNLK I` KPZJVUULJ[PUN [OL
IH[[LY`
>OLU[OLIH[[LY`PZKPZJVUULJ[LK[OLHSHYTZ`ZÌ
[LTJLHZLZ[VM\UJ[PVU
¦Fdp"=zpF4apm
0M [OL JLU[YHS SVJRPUN Z`Z[LT PZ VWLYH[LK TVYL
[OHU[LU[PTLZ^P[OPUHTPU\[LM\Y[OLYVWLYH[PVU
PZISVJRLKMVYZLJVUKZ
p"=§a4^_pOO"OF§p^p¤
pOa¦F="©
0M [OL PNUP[PVU RL` PZ YLTV]LK SVHKZ ^OPJO HYL
Z^P[JOLK VU VY PU Z[HUKI`LNWV^LY^PUKV^Z
S\NNHNL JVTWHY[TLU[ SPNO[PUN PU[LYPVY SPNO[
YHKPV HYL H\[VTH[PJHSS` Z^P[JOLK VMM HM[LY HWÌ
WYV_PTH[LS`OV\YZ
0M[OL]LOPJSLPZUV[Z[HY[LKVY\USVJRLK^P[O[OL
YLTV[L JVU[YVS ^P[OPU KH`Z [OL YLTV[L JVUÌ
[YVS Z[HUKI` M\UJ[PVU PZ Z^P[JOLK VMM [V WYL]LU[
KPZJOHYNPUNVM[OL]LOPJSLIH[[LY`
0U[OPZJHZL\USVJR[OLKYP]LYqZKVVY^P[O[OL
RL`H[[OLKVVYSVJR
3LH]L[OLKVVYJSVZLKPUVYKLY[VWYL]LU[[OL
HSHYTZ`Z[LTMYVTILPUN[YPNNLYLK
7YLZZI\[[VUVU[OLYLTV[LJVU[YVS
;OLYLTV[LJVU[YVSPZUV^HJ[P]H[LKHNHPU
s
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
(Í+PHNUVZ[PJZVJRL[
Fzd"4amVO¤F
0U VYKLY [V WYL]LU[ KHTHNL [V JHISLZ HUK JVUÌ
Z\TLYZPU[OLLSLJ[YPJHSZ`Z[LTK\L[VZOVY[JPYÌ
J\P[Z HUK V]LYSVHKZ [OL PUKP]PK\HS JPYJ\P[Z HYL
WYV[LJ[LKI`M\ZLZ
;OLM\ZLIV_PZH[SV^LYSLM[PU[OLKYP]LYqZMVV[Ì
^LSSHUKPZWYV[LJ[LK^P[OHWSHZ[PJJV]LY
)Í7SHZ[PJNYPWWLY
*Í:WHYLM\ZLZ
)LMVYLYLWSHJPUNHM\ZLZ^P[JOVMMHSSLSLJ[YPÌ
JHSJVUZ\TLYZHUKYLTV]L[OLPNUP[PVURL`
;VVWLUW\SS[OLJV]LYVMMH[[OLMPUNLYOVSL
HYYV^
;OL M\ZL WSHU HUK PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ MVY LTLYÍ
NLUJ` \USVJRPUN VM [OL S\NNHNL JVTÍ
WHY[TLU[SPKHUKLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[SPK
JHUILMV\UKVU[OLPUZPKLVM[OLJV]LY
;V JOLJR VY YLWSHJL H M\ZL YLTV]L P[ MYVT
[OLZWYPUNJSPW\ZPUN[OLWSHZ[PJNYPWWLY)
(ISV^UM\ZLPUKPJH[LZHUV]LYSVHKPU[OLJPYÌ
J\P[HUKJHUILPKLU[PMPLKI`[OLTLS[LKTL[HS
Z[YPW
9LWSHJLVUS`^P[OM\ZLZVM[OLZHTLYH[PUN
:WHYL M\ZLZ * HYL PU [OL SV^LZ[ ZLJ[PVU VM
[OLM\ZLIV_
0TWVY[HU[UV[L
0MHM\ZLISV^ZYLWLH[LKS`WSLHZLPTTLKPH[LS`
JVUZ\S[HUH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLYZV[OH[
[OL ZOVY[ JPYJ\P[ JHU IL SVJH[LK HUK JVYÌ
YLJ[LK
5L]LY [Y` [V sYLWHPYr M\ZLZ! `V\ TH` JH\ZL
ZLYPV\Z KHTHNL [V V[OLY WHY[Z VM [OL LSLJ[YPÌ
JHSZ`Z[LT
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
s
hFVFm4©¤mdp4camVpO^Fd¤VV"VF
4phz"hFmda="m=FmVamF
4phz"hFmda=
0M [OL IH[[LY` PZ KPZJOHYNLK [OL SPKZ JHU IL
VWLULKVUS`^P[O[OLHPKVMHKVUVYIH[[LY`
<USVJRPUNSPKZ
<ZL[OLRL`[V\USVJR[OL]LOPJSLH[[OLKVVY
SVJR
3LH]L[OLRL`PU[OLKVVYSVJR
9LTV]LWSHZ[PJJV]LYV]LY[OLM\ZLIV_
7\SSV\[WVZP[P]L[LYTPUHS(PU[OLM\ZLIV_
<ZL H Q\TWLY JHISL [V JVUULJ[ [OL WVZP[P]L
[LYTPUHS VM [OL KVUVY IH[[LY` ^P[O WVZP[P]L
[LYTPUHS(PU[OLM\ZLIV_
5V[L
0M [OL ]LOPJSL ^HZ SVJRLK [OL HSHYT OVYU ^PSS
ZV\UK^OLU[OLULNH[P]LJHISLPZJVUULJ[LK
<ZL [OLZLJVUKQ\TWLYJHISL[VJVUULJ[[OL
ULNH[P]L [LYTPUHS VM [OL KVUVY IH[[LY` ^P[O
SH[JOZ[YPRLY)
:^P[JO [OL HSHYT Z`Z[LT VMM I` SVJRPUN HUK
\USVJRPUNH[[OLKVVYSVJR
<USVJR [OL LUNPUL JVTWHY[TLU[ SPK VY S\NÌ
NHNLJVTWHY[TLU[SPK^P[O[OLZ^P[JO
+PZJVUULJ[ [OL ULNH[P]L JHISL MPYZ[ [OLU [OL
WVZP[P]LJHISL
7\ZO WVZP[P]L [LYTPUHS ( PU[V [OL M\ZL IV_
HUKW\ZOVU[OLWSHZ[PJM\ZLIV_JV]LY
5V[L
;OLLUNPULJHUUV[ILZ[HY[LK^P[O[OPZTL[OVK
7SLHZLVIZLY]L[OLJOHW[LYr,TLYNLUJ`:[HY[PUN
^P[O1\TWLY*HISLZsMVY[OPZW\YWVZL
sG
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
"F©
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMZOVY[JPYJ\P[HUKMPYL
6IZLY]LHSS^HYUPUNUV[LZVU[OLIH[[LY`
+PZJVUULJ[ [OL IH[[LY` K\YPUN HSS ^VYR VU [OL
LSLJ[YPJHSZ`Z[LT
+VUV[SH`[VVSZVYV[OLYTL[HSVIQLJ[ZVU[OL
IH[[LY` HZ [OL` JV\SK JH\ZL H ZOVY[ JPYJ\P[
HJYVZZ[OLIH[[LY`[LYTPUHS
/`KYVNLU NHZ NLULYH[LK I` [OL IH[[LY`
JV\SK JH\ZL HU L_WSVZPVU YLZ\S[PUN PU
ZL]LYLWLYZVUHSPUQ\YPLZ
+V UV[ L_WVZL [OL IH[[LY` [V HU VWLU MSHTL
LSLJ[YPJHSZWHYRVYHSP[JPNHYL[[L
9PZR VM ZL]LYL WLYZVUHS PUQ\Y` HUK KHTHNL
[V[OLMHIYPJTL[HSVYWHPU[
>LHYL`LWYV[J[PVU
+V UV[ HSSV^ IH[[LY` HJPK [V JVTL PU JVU[HJ[
^P[O `V\Y ZRPU L`LZ MHIYPJ VY WHPU[LK Z\YÌ
MHJLZ
0M`V\NL[LSLJ[YVS`[L^OPJOPZHUHJPKPU`V\Y
L`LZ VY VU `V\Y ZRPU PTTLKPH[LS` YPUZL ^P[O
JVSK^H[LYMVYZL]LYHSTPU\[LZHUKJHSSHKVJÌ
[VY
:WPSSLK LSLJ[YVS`[L T\Z[ IL YPUZLK VMM H[ VUJL
^P[O H ZVS\[PVU VM IHRPUN ZVKH HUK ^H[LY [V
UL\[YHSPaL[OLHJPK
)H[[LY` WVZ[Z [LYTPUHSZ HUK YLSH[LK HJJLZÍ
ZVYPLZ JVU[HPU SLHK HUK SLHK JVTWV\UKZ
JOLTPJHSZ RUV^U [V [OL :[H[L VM *HSPMVYUPH
[VJH\ZLJHUJLYHUKYLWYVK\J[P]LOHYT
(S^H`Z WYV[LJ[ `V\Y ZRPU I` ^HZOPUN [OVYÌ
V\NOS`^P[OZVHWHUK^H[LY
^"VF"F
(^LSSJOHYNLKIH[[LY`^PSSUV[VUS`WYL]LU[Z[HY[Ì
PUNWYVISLTZI\[^PSSHSZVSHZ[SVUNLY
0UVYKLY[VH]VPKKPZJOHYNPUN[OLIH[[LY`
\UPU[LU[PVUHSS`!
*\Y[HPS \UULJLZZHY` WV^LY JVUZ\TW[PVU WHYÌ
[PJ\SHYS` PU JP[` [YHMMPJ VY ^OLU [YH]LSSPUN ZOVY[
KPZ[HUJLZVUS`
(S^H`Z YLTV]L [OL PNUP[PVU RL` ^OLU SLH]PUN
[OLJHY
(]VPK \ZPUN [OL 7VYZJOL *VTT\UPJH[PVU
4HUHNLTLU[ Z`Z[LT ^OLU [OL LUNPUL PZ UV[
Y\UUPUN
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
sn
"F©4"F
,UZ\YL[OH[IH[[LY`PZZLJ\YLS`TV\U[LK
2LLW [LYTPUHSZ HUK JVUULJ[PVUZ JSLHU HUK
WYVWLYS`[PNO[LULK
*VYYVZPVU JHU IL WYL]LU[LK I` JVH[PUN [OL
[LYTPUHSZHUKJVUULJ[PVUZ^P[OWL[YVSL\TQLSS`
VYZPSPJVULZWYH`
,UZ\YL [OH[ ]LU[ JHWZ HYL ZLJ\YLS` [PNO[LULK
[VWYL]LU[ZWPSSHNL
*OLJRPUN[OLLSLJ[YVS`[LMS\PKSL]LS
.LULYHSS` [OL LSLJ[YVS`[LSL]LST\Z[ILJOLJRLK
TVYL VM[LU PU Z\TTLY [OHU PU [OL ^PU[LY HUK
TVYLVM[LU^OLUKYP]PUNSVUNKPZ[HUJLZ
>OLUHKKPUN^H[LY\ZLVUS`JSLHU]LZZLSZ
0U UV JHZL TH` HSJVOVS LN ^PUKV^ JSLHULY
YLZPK\LZILWLYTP[[LK[VLU[LY[OLIH[[LY`
<UZJYL^HUKVWLU[OLMPSSLY]LU[JHWZVMLHJO
JLSS
>P[O [OL JHY OVYPaVU[HS [OL MS\PK SL]LS ZOV\SK
TLL[[OLPUKPJH[VYTHYRPULHJOJLSS
0MULJLZZHY`[VW\W^P[OKPZ[PSSLK^H[LY
+VUV[\ZLHJPK
6US`MPSS\W[V[OLTHYRV[OLY^PZL[OLLSLJ[YVÌ
S`[L ^PSS V]LYMSV^ ^OLU [OL IH[[LY` PZ ILPUN
JOHYNLKHUKJH\ZLKHTHNL
)H[[LY`JOHYNPUN
(\[VTV[P]L IH[[LYPLZ SVVZL [OLPY LMMPJPLUJ` ^OLU
UV[PU\ZL
;OL JOHYNL H]HPSHISL PU `V\Y IH[[LY` JHU IL
TLHZ\YLK^P[OHIH[[LY`O`KYVTL[LY
>L YLJVTTLUK [OH[ [OL IH[[LY` ]VS[HNL IL
[LZ[LK I` `V\Y 7VYZJOL KLHSLY ^OV OHZ [OL HWÌ
WYVWYPH[LLX\PWTLU[
0M [OL JHY PZ UV[ KYP]LU MVY WYVSVUNLK WLYPVKZ
[OL IH[[LY` T\Z[ IL JOHYNLK H[ SLHZ[ L]LY`
^LLRZ
( KPZJOHYNLK IH[[LY` HSSV^Z YHWPK MVYTH[PVU VM
Z\SMH[LZ SLHKPUN [V WYLTH[\YL KL[LYPVYH[PVU VM
[OLWSH[LZ
sG¬
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
>HYUPUN
/`KYVNLU NHZ NLULYH[LK I` [OL IH[[LY`
JV\SK JH\ZL HU L_WSVZPVU YLZ\S[PUN PU
ZL]LYLWLYZVUHSPUQ\YPLZ
*OHYNLIH[[LY`PUH^LSS]LU[PSH[LKHYLH
5L]LYJOHYNLHMYVaLUIH[[LY`0[TH`L_WSVKL
ILJH\ZL VM NHZ [YHWWLK PU [OL PJL (SSV^ H
MYVaLUIH[[LY`[V[OH^V\[MPYZ[
0M`V\NL[LSLJ[YVS`[L^OPJOPZHUHJPKPU`V\Y
L`LZ VY VU `V\Y ZRPU PTTLKPH[LS` YPUZL ^P[O
JVSK^H[LYMVYZL]LYHSTPU\[LZHUKJHSSHKVJÌ
[VY
:SV^IH[[LY`JOHYNPUN
7H` H[[LU[PVU [V HSS ^HYUPUNZ HUK MVSSV^ PUÌ
Z[Y\J[PVUZ [OH[ JVTL ^P[O `V\Y IH[[LY`
JOHYNLY
>OLUJOHYNPUNLUZ\YLHKLX\H[L]LU[PSH[PVU
9LTV]LIH[[LY`ZLLs9LTV]PUNIH[[LY`r
(SS]LU[JHWZZOV\SKILVWLU
;OLMS\PKSL]LSZOV\SKTLL[[OLPUKPJH[VYTHYR
PULHJOJLSS
,UZ\YL[OH[JOHYNLYPZZ^P[JOLKVMMuKHUNLY
VMZOVY[JPYJ\P[
*VUULJ[JOHYNLYJHISLZ
*OHYNLYJHISLZT\Z[ILJVUULJ[LK
76:0;0=,[V76:0;0=,HUK
5,.(;0=,u[V5,.(;0=,u
:^P[JOVUJOHYNLY
5VYTHSS` H IH[[LY` ZOV\SK IL JOHYNLK H[ UV
TVYL [OHU WLYJLU[ VM P[Z YH[LK JHWHJP[`
9H[LK JHWHJP[` VM [OL IH[[LY` PU `V\Y ]LOPJSL
PZSPZ[LKVU[OLIH[[LY`OV\ZPUN
(M[LY JOHYNPUN [\YU VMM JOHYNLY HUK KPZJVUÌ
ULJ[JOHYNLYJHISLZ
;PNO[LU [OL ]LU[ JHWZ HUK YLPUZ[HSS IH[[LY`
ZLLs0UZ[HSSPUNIH[[LY`r
amFpzF"apm
+\YPUN[OL^PU[LYTVU[OZIH[[LY`JHWHJP[`[LUKZ
[VKLJYLHZLHZ[LTWLYH[\YLZKYVW
(KKP[PVUHSS` TVYL WV^LY PZ JVUZ\TLK ^OPSL
Z[HY[PUNHUK[OLOLHKSPNO[ZOLH[LYYLHY^PUKV^
KLMVNNLYL[JHYL\ZLKTVYLMYLX\LU[S`
3L[`V\Y7VYZJOLKLHSLY[LZ[[OLIH[[LY`qZJHÌ
WHJP[`ILMVYL^PU[LYZL[ZPU
Fzd"4amV*"F©
;OL ZLY]PJL SPML VM [OL IH[[LY` PZ Z\IQLJ[ [V UVYÌ
THS ^LHY" P[ KLWLUKZ NYHL[S` VU JHYL JSPTH[PJ
JVUKP[PVUZ HUK KYP]PUN JVUKP[PVUZ KPZ[HUJLZ
SVHKZ
6US`\ZLHUVYPNPUHS7VYZJOLIH[[LY`^P[O[OL
JVYYLJ[WHY[U\TILYHZHYLWSHJLTLU[
7SLHZL VIZLY]L [OL KPZWVZHS PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ MVY
IH[[LYPLZ
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
sGs
Fhp¦amV^F*"F©
;OLYLX\PZP[L[VVSPZPU[OL[VVSRP[
;OL IH[[LY` PZ SVJH[LK PU [OL S\NNHNL JVTWHY[Ì
TLU[\UKLYHISHJRWSHZ[PJSPK
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMKHTHNL[VHS[LYUH[VYHUKLSLJ[YVUPJ
JVU[YVS\UP[Z
+V UV[ KPZJVUULJ[ [OL IH[[LY` ^OPSL [OL LUÌ
NPULPZY\UUPUN
;OPZHSZVHWWSPLZ[VJHYZLX\PWWLK^P[OHIH[Ì
[LY`THPUZ^P[JO
5L]LY KYP]L [OL JHY ^P[O H KPZJVUULJ[LK IH[Ì
[LY`
9PZRVMJH\Z[PJI\YUZMYVTLZJHWPUNHJPK
2LLW]LU[JHWZVU[VH]VPKZWPSSHNL
+V UV[ [PS[ [OL IH[[LY` ^OLU YLTV]PUN HUK PUÌ
Z[HSSPUNP[
:^P[JOVMMLUNPULHUKHSSLSLJ[YPJHSSVHKZ
6WLU[\YUÌSVJRZ(
9LTV]LWSHZ[PJSPK
7\SSVMMJLU[YHS]LU[OVZL)
0TWVY[HU[!KPZJVUULJ[[OLULNH[P]LuNYV\UK
^PYL MPYZ[ HUK [OLU [OL WVZP[P]L JHISL u
KHUNLYVMZOVY[JPYJ\P[
<UZJYL^MHZ[LUPUNZJYL^*
9LTV]LIH[[LY`
m"ddamV^F*"F©
7\[IH[[LY`PU
:JYL^PUMHZ[LUPUNZJYL^*
0TWVY[HU[! JVUULJ[ [OL WVZP[P]L JHISL
MPYZ[HUK[OLU[OLULNH[P]LuNYV\UK^PYLu
KHUNLYVMZOVY[JPYJ\P[
7\ZOVUJLU[YHS]LU[OVZL)
-P[WSHZ[PJSPK3VJR[\YUÌSVJRZ(
,U[LY[OLYHKPVJVKLHNHPU
sG¢
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
Fzd"4amV^FFhpF_4pmpd*"F©
( ^LHR IH[[LY` TH` IL YLJVNUPaLK I` [OL
JSLHYS`YLK\JLKHJ[PVUYHUNLVM[OLYLTV[LJVUÌ
[YVS VY ^OLU [OL SPNO[ÍLTP[[PUN KPVKL PU [OL
RL`NYPWUVSVUNLYMSHZOLZ^OLU[OLYLTV[LJVUÌ
[YVSPZVWLYH[LK
<ZPUN`V\YMPUNLYUHPSVYHZTHSSZJYL^KYP]LY
JHYLM\SS`SPM[VMM[OLJV]LYVM[OLRL`NYPW
9LWSHJLIH[[LY`VIZLY]LWVSHYP[`
(ZWHYLIH[[LY`3P[OP\T*9]VS[ZPZ
H]HPSHISLH[`V\YH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY
9LWSHJLJV]LYHUKWYLZZ[VNL[OLYMPYTS`
5V[L
(U` KPZWVZHS YLN\SH[PVUZ MVY IH[[LYPLZ T\Z[ IL
VIZLY]LK
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
sG
hFVFm4©"amV§a^ ¤hzF
"*dF
:LL [OL JOHW[LY s)H[[LY`r HUK s,TLYNLUJ` \UÌ
SVJRPUNVM[OLSPKZr
0M [OL IH[[LY` PZ KPZJOHYNLK LN PU ^PU[LY VY
HM[LY [OL JHY OHZ ILLU WHYRLK MVY H SVUN [PTL
[OLIH[[LY`VMHUV[OLYJHYJHUIL\ZLKMVYZ[HY[Ì
PUN^P[O[OLOLSWVMQ\TWLYJHISLZ
4HRL Z\YL [OL ]VS[HNL VM IV[O IH[[LYPLZ PZ [OL
ZHTL
;OL JHWHJP[` (TWLYL OV\YZ (O VM [OL IVVZ[LY
IH[[LY` T\Z[ UV[ IL Z\IZ[HU[PHSS` SLZZ [OHU [OH[
VM[OLKPZJOHYNLKIH[[LY`
;OL KPZJOHYNLK IH[[LY` T\Z[ IL JVYYLJ[S` JVUÌ
ULJ[LK[V[OL]LOPJSLqZLSLJ[YPJHSZ`Z[LT
5V[L
+VUV[[Y`[VZ[HY[[OLJHYI`W\ZOPUNVY[V^Ì
PUN +HTHNL [V [OL JH[HS`[PJ JVU]LY[LYZ HUK
V[OLYJVTWVULU[ZVM[OLJHYTH`YLZ\S[
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMKHTHNLHUKZLYPV\ZWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`
K\L[VZOVY[JPYJ\P[
<ZL VUS`Q\TWLYJHISLZVMHKLX\H[LKPHTL[LY
JYVZZÌZLJ[PVU HUK MP[[LK ^P[O JVTWSL[LS` PUZ\Ì
SH[LKHSSPNH[VYJSPWZ
-VSSV^ HSS ^HYUPUNZ HUK PUZ[Y\J[PVUZ VM [OL
Q\TWLYJHISLTHU\MHJ[\YLY
>OLU JVUULJ[PUN Q\TWLY JHISLZ THRL Z\YL
[OH[ [OL` JHUUV[ NL[ JH\NO[ PU HU` TV]PUN
WHY[ZPU[OLLUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[
;OL Q\TWLY JHISLZ T\Z[ IL SVUN LUV\NO ZV
[OH[ULP[OLY]LOPJSLZUVYJHISLZ[V\JOHUV[OLY
;OL ]LOPJSLZ T\Z[ UV[ IL PU JVU[HJ[ V[OLYÌ
^PZL J\YYLU[ TPNO[ MSV^ HZ ZVVU HZ [OL WVZPÌ
[P]L[LYTPUHSZHYLJVUULJ[LK
;OLJHISLJSHTWZT\Z[UV[ILHSSV^LK[VJVUÌ
[HJ[ LHJO V[OLY ^OLU VUL LUK VM [OL Q\TWLY
JHISLZHYLJVUULJ[LK[VHIH[[LY`
,UZ\YL [OH[ [VVSZ VY JVUK\J[P]L QL^LSSLY`
YPUNZJOHPUZ^H[JOZ[YHWZKVUV[JVTLPU[V
JVU[HJ[^P[OSP]LWHY[ZVM[OL]LOPJSL
0TWYVWLY OVVRÌ\W VM Q\TWLY JHISLZ JHU Y\PU
[OLHS[LYUH[VY
+HUNLYVMJH\Z[PJI\YUZ
+VUV[SLHUV]LY[OLIH[[LY`
+HUNLYVMNHZL_WSVZPVU
0TWYVWLY\ZLVMIVVZ[LYIH[[LY`[VZ[HY[H]LÌ
OPJSL TH` JH\ZL HU L_WSVZPVU YLZ\S[PUN PU
ZL]LYLWLYZVUHSPUQ\YPLZ
2LLW ZV\YJLZ VM PNUP[PVU H^H` MYVT [OL IH[Ì
[LY` LN VWLU MSHTL I\YUPUN JPNHYL[[LZ VY
ZWHYRPUN K\L [V JHISL JVU[HJ[ VY ^LSKPUN
^VYR
( KPZJOHYNLK IH[[LY` JHU MYLLaL L]LU H[
-u*
)LMVYL JVUULJ[PUN Q\TWLY JHISLZ H MYVaLU
IH[[LY`T\Z[IL[OH^LKV\[
sGT
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
$ 7VZP[P]L[LYTPUHSMVYQ\TWZ[HY[PUN
u $ .YV\UKPUNWVPU[MVYQ\TWZ[HY[PUN
*VUULJ[Q\TWLYJHISLZPU[OLMVSSV^PUNZLÍ
X\LUJL!
*OLJR LSLJ[YVS`[L SL]LS VM LHJO JLSS 0M
ULJLZZHY` MPSS ^P[O KPZ[PSSLK ^H[LY [V Q\Z[
HIV]LWSH[LZ
6U H ]LOPJSL ^P[O H KPZJOHYNLK IH[[LY`! [\YU
VMMHSSJVUZ\TLYZHUKHJJLZZVYPLZTV]L[OL
NLHY ZOPM[ SL]LY PU[V [OL UL\[YHS WVZP[PVU HUK
ZL[[OLWHYRPUNIYHRL
6WLU [OL JHW VM [OL WVZP[P]L [LYTPUHS MVY
Q\TWZ[HY[PUN
([[HJO[OLWVZP[P]LJHISLMPYZ[[V[OLWVZP[P]L
[LYTPUHSMVYQ\TWZ[HY[PUN
[OLU [V [OL WVZP[P]L [LYTPUHS VM [OL IVVZ[LY
IH[[LY`
*VUULJ[ [OL ULNH[P]L JHISL MPYZ[ [V [OL ULÌ
NH[P]L[LYTPUHSVM[OLIVVZ[LYIH[[LY`
[OLU [V [OL NYV\UKPUN WVPU[ MVY Q\TW Z[HY[PUN
u
9\U[OLLUNPULVM[OLIVVZ[LYJHYH[HOPNOLY
ZWLLK
:[HY[[OLLUNPUL
(U H[[LTW[LK Z[HY[ \ZPUN Q\TWLY JHISLZ
ZOV\SK UV[ SHZ[ TVYL [OHU ZLJVUKZ ;OLU
HSSV^H^HP[PUNWLYPVKVMH[SLHZ[VULTPU\[L
>P[O[OLLUNPULY\UUPUNKPZJVUULJ[IV[OQ\TÌ
WLYJHISLZPUYL]LYZLVYKLY
*SVZL[OLSPKVM[OLQ\TWZ[HY[IV_
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
sGQ
aV^:Fzd"4amV¤d*
>HYUPUN
9PZRVMZOVY[JPYJ\P[
(S^H`ZZ^P[JOVMM[OLYLSL]HU[JVUZ\TLY^OLU
JOHUNPUNI\SIZ
9PZR VM PUQ\Y` ;OL OLHKSPNO[Z HYL \UKLY
OPNO]VS[HNL^OLUPUZ[HSSLK
)L JHYLM\S K\YPUN HSS ^VYR PU [OL HYLH VM [OL
OLHKSPNO[Z
9PZR VM KHTHNL )\SIZ VM H OPNOLY ^H[[HNL
JHUKHTHNL[OLSHTWOV\ZPUN
6US` [OL I\SIZ ZOV^U PU [OL JOHY[ TH` IL
\ZLK
5L^ I\SIZ T\Z[ IL JSLHU HUK MYLL MYVT
NYLHZL;OLYLMVYLUL]LY[V\JOI\SIZ^P[O
`V\YIHYLOHUKZ
<ZL H JSV[O VY ZVM[ WHWLY ^OPSL YLWSHJPUN
I\SIZ
-VY YLHZVUZ VM [YHMMPJ ZHML[` ^L YLJVTTLUK
[OH[`V\HS^H`ZJHYY`ZWHYLI\SIZZV[OH[`V\
JHU OH]L H JVYYLJ[S` PSS\TPUH[LK JHY H[ HSS
[PTLZ
0U JLY[HPU JV\U[YPLZ [OL JHYY`PUN VM ZWHYL
I\SIZPZTHUKH[VY`
*H\[PVU!
9PZR VM KHTHNL [V OLHKSPNO[Z K\L [V L_Í
JLZZP]L[LTWLYH[\YLZHUKHIYHZPVU
([[HJO UV JV]LYPUNZ LN MPSTZ sZ[VUL
N\HYKZsPU[OLHYLHVM[OLOLHKSPNO[Z
<ZL ZVHW` ^H[LY VUS` [V JSLHU SPNO[ SLUZLZ
HUKWSHZ[PJOLHKSPNO[SLUZLZ
0U UV JHZL TH` JOLTPJHS JSLHULYZ VY V[OLY
]VSH[PSLJSLHUPUNMS\PKZIL\ZLK
;V WYL]LU[ ZJYH[JOLZ KV UV[ Y\I ^P[O H KY`
VY TLYLS` TVPZ[ JSV[O [PZZ\L VY PUZLJ[
ZWVUNLZ
sG
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
)\SI*OHY[
:VJRL[
7HYRPUNSPNO[MYVU[
)(? :
3V^ILHT
/PNOILHTNHZÌKPZJOHYNLSHTW
7OPSPWZ+:
(KKP[PVUHSOPNOILHT
OLHKSPNO[MSHZOLY
7.1 Ì
-VNSPNO[Z
72:
;\YUZPNUHSSPNO[
)(<:
9LHYMVNSPNO[YL]LYZPUNSPNO[
)(:
)YHRL[HPSSPNO[
)(@K
;HPSSPNO[
)(:
:PKLTHYRLYSPNO[
YLHKPUNSPNO[KVVYN\HYK
J\YISPNO[
>_ +
9HPZLKIYHRLSPNO[
>_ +
3PJLUZLWSH[LSPNO[
:=
3\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[LUNPUL
JVTWHY[TLU[SPNO[PU[LYPVYSPNO[
:=
;`WLYH[PUN
/>
>
/>
/>
7@>
7>
7>
9>
>>
>>
*>
2>
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
sG
F"=daV^
Fhp¦"d
<UZJYL^WSHZ[PJU\[(
+L[HJOZPKLJHYWL[PUN
9LTV]L Y\IILY WS\N ) MYVT [OL \USVJRPUN
VWLUPUN
7SHJL ZVJRL[ ^YLUJO MYVT [VVS RP[ VU [OL
\USVJRPUNZWPUKSL
;OL OHUKSL VM [OL ^YLUJO ZOV\SK WVPU[
OVYPaVU[HSS`[V[OLYLHY
;\YU ZVJRL[ ^YLUJO HWWYV_ ( HUK
SLH]LPUWVZP[PVU
;OL OLHKSPNO[ PZ UV^ \USVJRLK HUK JHU IL
W\SSLKMVY^HYKV\[VM[OL^PUN
;\YU ZVJRL[ ^YLUJO IHJR \U[PS P[ PZ WVPU[PUN
]LY[PJHSS`KV^U^HYK)
sGG
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
m"ddamV
0UZLY[OLHKSPNO[PU[VN\PKLYHPSZHUKW\ZOM\SS`
PU[V[OL^PUN
7\ZO OLHKSPNO[ [V [OL YLHY HUK H[ [OL ZHTL
[PTL [\YU [OL ZVJRL[ ^YLUJO \U[PS P[ WVPU[Z
OVYPaVU[HSS`[V[OLYLHY*
;OLOLHKSPNO[SVJRPUNKL]PJLT\Z[WLYJLW[PIS`
HUKH\KPIS`LUNHNL
*OLJR OLHKSPNO[ MVY H MPYT ZLH[PUN LN I`
W\SSPUNP[PU[OLHYLHVM[OLMVNSPNO[
0UZLY[ Y\IILY WS\N PU[V [OL \USVJRPUN VWLUPUN
HUKZLJ\YL[OLJHYWL[PUN
*OLJR[OLM\UJ[PVUVMHSSSPNO[Z
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
sGn
p§*F"h:^aV^*F"h"m="==aapm"d
^aV^*F"h
6WLUPUN[OLSPKVM[OLOLHKSPNO[OV\ZPUN
<UZJYL^[OL[^VZJYL^Z(
7YLZZIV[OYLSLHZL[HIZ)HUKYLTV]LSPK
*OHUNPUNI\SIMVYSV^ILHTHUKOPNOILHT
;\YU WS\N JV\U[LYÌJSVJR^PZL IH`VUL[ SVJR
HUKW\SSP[VMM
;\YU JSHTWPUN YPUN JV\U[LYÌJSVJR^PZL IH`VUL[
SVJRHUKW\SSP[VMM
9LWSHJLKLMLJ[P]LI\SI
>OLUKVPUNZVLUZ\YLI\SIPZZLH[LKWYVWLYS`
9LHZZLTISLPUYL]LYZLVYKLY
5V[L
0U VYKLY [V WYL]LU[ PTWHPYTLU[ VM [OL OLHKSPNO[
ILHT HKQ\Z[TLU[ M\UJ[PVU [OL JHISL * VM [OL
WS\NT\Z[HS^H`ZWVPU[[V[OLV\[ZPKLVM[OL]LÌ
OPJSL
sn¬
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
*OHUNPUNI\SIMVYHKKP[PVUHSOPNOILHT
;\YUI\SIOVSKLY
;\YUP[JV\U[LYÌJSVJR^PZLVU[OLSLM[OLHKSPNO[
HUKJSVJR^PZLVU[OLYPNO[OLHKSPNO[
;HRL I\SI OVSKLY V\[ VM [OL OLHKSPNO[ OV\ZÌ
PUN
7\SSIV[OWS\NYLSLHZL[HIZHWHY[
7\SSWS\NV\[VM[OLI\SIOVSKLY
9LWSHJL[OLKLMLJ[P]LI\SI^P[OI\SIOVSKLY
9LHZZLTISLPUYL]LYZLVYKLY
*SVZPUNSPKVMOLHKSPNO[OV\ZPUN
0UZLY[ YL[HPUPUN S\NZ VM SPK PU[V [OL IV[[VT VM
[OL OLHKSPNO[ OV\ZPUN HUK JSVZL SPK \U[PS P[
WLYJLW[PIS`LUNHNLZ
:JYL^PUIV[OZJYL^Z
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
sns
^"mVamV*¤d*Opz"camVdaV^
;\YU JHW PU [OL OLHKSPNO[ OV\ZPUN JV\U[LYÌ
JSVJR^PZLHUKYLTV]L[OLJHW
;\YUI\SIOVSKLY
;\YUP[JV\U[LYÌJSVJR^PZLVU[OLSLM[OLHKSPNO[
HUKJSVJR^PZLVU[OLYPNO[OLHKSPNO[
;HRL I\SI OVSKLY V\[ VM [OL OLHKSPNO[ OV\ZÌ
PUN
;\YU KLMLJ[P]L I\SI JV\U[LYÌJSVJR^PZL IH`Ì
VUL[SVJRHUKYLWSHJLP[
9LHZZLTISLPUYL]LYZLVYKLY
^"mVamV*¤d*Op¤maVm"ddaV^
;\YU I\SI OVSKLY PU [OL OLHKSPNO[ OV\ZPUN
JV\U[LYÌJSVJR^PZLHUKW\SSP[V\[
;\YU KLMLJ[P]L I\SI JV\U[LYÌJSVJR^PZL IH`Ì
VUL[SVJRHUKYLWSHJLP[
9LHZZLTISLPUYL]LYZLVYKLY
sn¢
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
^"mVamV*¤d*OpOpVdaV^
;\YU JHW PU [OL OLHKSPNO[ OV\ZPUN JV\U[LYÌ
JSVJR^PZLHUKYLTV]L[OLJHW
7YLZZ [OL YL[HPUPUN JSPW KV^U ^P[O H ZJYL^Ì
KYP]LYHUKW\ZOP[[V[OLSLM[
7P]V[[OLYL[HPUPUNJSPWIHJR
7\SSI\SI^P[OJHISLV\[VM[OLOLHKSPNO[OV\ZÌ
PUN
+PZJVUULJ[ WS\N JVUULJ[PVU HUK YLWSHJL [OL
KLMLJ[P]LI\SI
9LHZZLTISLPUYL]LYZLVYKLY
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
sn
^"mVamV¤d*am^Fa=F
"cFaV^
9LTV]L JHW PU [OL ^OLLS OV\ZPUN SPULY ^P[O
[OLZJYL^KYP]LY
0UZLY[ ZJYL^KYP]LY PU[V [OL VWLUPUN PU [OL
^OLLSOV\ZPUNSPULYH[YPNO[HUNSLZ[V[OLZPKL
THYRLYSPNO[OV\ZPUN
)` WYLZZPUN ^P[O [OL ZJYL^KYP]LY KPZLUNHNL
[OL ZLJ\YPUN ZWYPUN VM [OL ZPKL THYRLY SPNO[
OV\ZPUN
9LTV]L ZPKL THYRLY SPNO[ HUK \UKV I\SI
OVSKLYIH`VUL[SVJR
9LTV]L I\SI MYVT [OL OVSKLY HUK YLWSHJL
0UZLY[OVSKLY
0UZLY[[OLSPNO[[HIZHYYV^(PU[V[OL^PUNH[
[OLMYVU[
,UNHNLZLJ\YPUNZWYPUNHYYV^)PU[OL^PUN
7YLZZJHWPU[V[OL^OLLSOV\ZPUNSPULY
*OLJRVWLYH[PVUVM[OLSPNO[
snT
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
;HPSSPNO[SLM[
"adaV^
^"mVamV*¤d*
6WLULUNPULJVTWHY[TLU[SPK
<UZJYL^ MHZ[LUPUN ZJYL^Z ( ^P[O H ZJYL^Ì
KYP]LYHUKW\SS[HPSSPNO[IHJRHUKV\[
(Í9L]LYZPUNSPNO[
)Í;\YUZPNUHSSPNO[
*Í;HPSSPNO[IYHRLSPNO[
+Í;HPSSPNO[
,Í9LHYMVNSPNO[
-Í:PKLTHYRLYSPNO[
;\YU I\SI OVSKLY PU [OL [HPS SPNO[ OV\ZPUN
JV\U[LYÌJSVJR^PZLHUKW\SSP[V\[
;\YU KLMLJ[P]L I\SI JV\U[LYÌJSVJR^PZL IH`Ì
VUL[SVJRHUKYLWSHJLP[
0UZLY[I\SIOVSKLYHUK[\YUP[JSVJR^PZL
0UZLY[[HPSSPNO[PU[OL^PUN
,UZ\YL [OH[ SVJH[PUN S\N HYYV^ PZ JVYYLJ[S`
WVZP[PVULK
:SPNO[S`ZJYL^PUIV[OMHZ[LUPUNZJYL^ZVM[OL
[HPSSPNO[
(SPNU [OL [HPS SPNO[ ^P[O [OL ]LOPJSL JVU[V\YZ
HUK[PNO[LU[OLZJYL^Z
*OLJRVWLYH[PVUVM[OLSPNO[
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
snQ
a4FmFd"FaV^
^"mVamV*¤d*
<UKVIV[OZJYL^ZHYYV^ZHUKYLTV]LSPNO[
7\ZOY\IILYJV]LYPUNIHJRYLTV]LKLMLJ[P]L
I\SI MYVT IL[^LLU [OL JVU[HJ[ ZWYPUNZ HUK
YLWSHJL
9LHZZLTISLPUYL]LYZLVYKLY
*OLJRVWLYH[PVUVM[OLSPNO[
¤VV"VFphz"hFmaV^:
mVamFphz"hFmaV^:
pp§FddaV^
^"mVamV*¤d*
>P[O H ZJYL^KYP]LY HYYV^ JHYLM\SS` WYLZZ
SPNO[V\[VM[OLJ\[V\[PU[OLSPUPUN
9LTV]L KLMLJ[P]L I\SI MYVT IL[^LLU [OL
JVU[HJ[ZWYPUNZHUKYLWSHJL
0UZLY[ [OL SPNO[ PU[V [OL J\[V\[ MPYZ[ MYVT VUL
ZPKL[OLUMYVT[OLV[OLY*OLJRVWLYH[PVU
pp ¤"=¤*aV^
^"mVamV*¤d*
>P[OHZJYL^KYP]LYHYYV^JHYLM\SS`W\ZOV\[
[OLSPNO[
7\SSI\SIOVSKLYV\[VMSPNO[OV\ZPUN
9LTV]LKLMLJ[P]LI\SIHUKYLWSHJL
0UZ[HSSI\SIOVSKLYHUKPUZLY[SPNO[
sn
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
mFapaV^:F"=amVaV^
^"mVamV*¤d*
*HYLM\SS` W\SS SPNO[ OV\ZPUN V\[ VM [OL SPUPUN
HYYV^
9LHKPUNSPNO[!
;\YU [OL OVSKLY ( VM [OL KLMLJ[P]L I\SI
JV\U[LYÌJSVJR^PZLHUKYLTV]L
9LTV]LI\SIHUKYLWSHJL
0U[LYPVYSPNO[!
*HYLM\SS` \UJSPW [OL SPNO[ SLUZ VU [OL Z^P[JO
ZPKLHYYV^ZHUK[OLUKL[HJOP[
9LTV]L KLMLJ[P]L I\SI MYVT IL[^LLU [OL
JVU[HJ[ZWYPUNZHUKYLWSHJL
*SPWSPNO[SLUZIHJRPU
0UZLY[ SPNO[ OV\ZPUN PU[V [OL SPUPUN YLHY LUK
MPYZ[
7YLZZ MYVU[ VM OV\ZPUN \W HUK JSPJR PU[V
WSHJL
*OLJRVWLYH[PVUVMSPNO[Z
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
sn
"aF="cFaV^
^"mVamV*¤d*
3L]LY V\[ YPNO[ÌOHUK JVYULY ZLNTLU[ VM [OL
SLUZ^P[O[OLZJYL^KYP]LYISHKLHYYV^
;\YU SVJR VM SPNO[ OV\ZPUN JV\U[LYÌJSVJR^PZL
I`HWWYV_ HUKYLTV]LSPNO[
+PZLUNHNL HSS ZLJ\YPUN [HIZ VM [OL SHTW
IYHJRL[HYYV^
9LTV]L SHTW IYHJRL[ [HRL V\[ KLMLJ[P]L
I\SIHUKYLWSHJL
9LHZZLTISLPUYL]LYZLVYKLY
*OLJRVWLYH[PVUVM[OLSPNO[
snG
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
*LU[LYVM[OLOLHKSHTWSLUZ
=b¤amVF"=daV^
:LLJH\[PVUVUs9LWSHJPUN)\SIZr
(KQ\Z[TLU[
;OL HKQ\Z[TLU[ PZ THKL ^P[O [OL ]LOPJSL YLHK`
[VKYP]LHUK[OLM\LS[HURJVTWSL[LS`MPSSLK
;OLKYP]LYqZZLH[T\Z[ILSVHKLKI`HWLYZVUVY
HSIZRN^LPNO[HUK[OL[PYLWYLZZ\YLZ
T\Z[TLL[[OLWYLZJYPILK]HS\LZ
(M[LYILPUNSVHKLK[OLJHYT\Z[ILYVSSLKHML^
TL[LYZZV[OH[[OLZ\ZWLUZPVUJHUZL[[SL
-VYJOLJRPUN[OLOLHKSPNO[HKQ\Z[TLU[[OL]LY[PÌ
JHS WVZP[PVU VM [OL J\[VMM VM [OL SV^ILHT ZLL
MPN OHZ [V IL WYVQLJ[LK VU H ]LY[PJHS ZJYLLU
^HSSPUKPZ[HUJLVMTMYVT[OLMYVU[SLUZVM
[OLOLHKSHTW
;OL JVYYLJ[ WVZP[PVU VM [OL J\[VMM PZ JT H[
T ILSV^HOVYPaVU[HSSPUL_ JT MYVT
NYV\UK[V[OLJLU[LYVM[OLOLHKSHTWSLUZ
+PZ[HUJL
=PZ\HS HPT ZOHSS IL WLYMVYTLK H[ UV[ SLZZ [OHU
T [OPZ ]HS\L PZ HYV\UKLKKV^UJVU]LYZPVU
MYVT [OL ÌMVV[ KPZ[HUJL [`WPJHS VM MPLSK HPT
\ZPUN H ZJYLLU ;OL T KPZ[HUJL PZ
TLHZ\YLKMYVT[OLOLHKSHTWSLUZ[V[OL]PL^PUN
ZJYLLU
-SVVY
;OL Z\YMHJL \WVU ^OPJO [OL ]LOPJSL YLZ[Z PZ MSH[
HUKHWWYV_PTH[LS`SL]LS
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
snn
:JYLLU
;OL ZJYLLU \WVU ^OPJO OLHKSHTW ILHTZ HYL
WYVQLJ[LK PZ WLYWLUKPJ\SHY [V [OL MSVVY HUK [OL
]LOPJSLqZ SVUNP[\KPUHS H_PZ MSH[ \UPMVYTS` SPNO[ PU
JVSVY \UVIZ[Y\J[LK HUK ^PKL HUK OPNO LUV\NO
[V HJJVTTVKH[L [OL ]LOPJSL ILHT WH[[LYUZ [V
ILHPTLK
;OLZJYLLUZOV\SKIL^PKLLUV\NO[VWYV]PKLH[
SLHZ[ T VM ZWHJL V\[IVHYK VM [OL ]LOPJSLqZ
OLHKSHTWZWHJPUN
(KQ\Z[TLU[ZJYL^Z
+L[HJO ZPKL JHYWL[PUN PU S\NNHNL JVTWHY[Ì
TLU[
;OLYLMVYL\UZJYL^WSHZ[PJU\[(
6WLU[OLJV]LYVM[OLHWWYVWYPH[LHKQ\Z[TLU[
ZJYL^
;OLZL[[PUNPZHKQ\Z[LKI`[\YUPUN[OLOL_HNVU
ZVJRL[ZJYL^ZYPNO[VYSLM[HZHWWYVWYPH[L
)Í/LHKSPNO[]LY[PJHSHKQ\Z[TLU[
*Í-VNSPNO[OLPNO[HKQ\Z[TLU[
=LY[PJHSHKQ\Z[TLU[ZJYL^)
[\YUJSVJR^PZL$ILHTTV]LZKV^U
[\YUJV\U[LYÌJSVJR^PZL$ILHTTV]LZ\W
5V[L
+VUV[HS[LY[OLSH[LYHSHKQ\Z[TLU[
-VNSPNO[HKQ\Z[TLU[
;OL MVN SPNO[ HKQ\Z[TLU[ * ZOV\SK VUS` IL KVUL
H[ H ZWLJPHSPZ[ ^VYRZOVW ^P[O HU VW[PJHS HKQ\Z[Ì
TLU[\UP[
¢¬¬
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
p§amV
*LY[HPU Z[H[L Z[H[\[LZ HUK SVJHS VYKPUHUJLZ WYVÌ
OPIP[ [V^PUN ^P[O H JOHPU YVWL VY L]LU H [V^
IHY
0U HKKP[PVU KHTHNL [V `V\Y ]LOPJSL TH` YLZ\S[
MYVTPTWYVWLYWYVJLK\YLZ
*VUZ\S[ `V\Y H\[OVYPaLK 7VYZJOL KLHSLY MVY KLÌ
[HPSZ
F^a4dFp§amV
-SH[ ILK [V^PUN PZ [OL WYLMLYYLK [`WL VM [V^PUN
[VIL\ZLKVU7VYZJOL]LOPJSLZ
<UKLYJLY[HPUJPYJ\TZ[HUJLZ^OLLSSPM[ZTH`IL
\ZLK^OLU[OL]LOPJSL^PSSUV[YVSS
;OL ]LOPJSL T\Z[ IL [V^LK ^P[O HSS MV\Y
^OLLSZVMM[OLNYV\UKV[OLY^PZLKHTHNL[V
[OL]LOPJSLTH`YLZ\S[
p§amVF©F
;OL[V^PUNL`LPZJVU[HPULKPU[OL[VVSRP[
*H\[PVU
9PZRVMKHTHNL[V[OL]LOPJSL
<ZL[OL[V^PUNL`LVUS`MVYHULTLYNLUJ`[V
YLTV]L [OL ]LOPJSL VMM [OL YVHK ;OL [V^PUN
L`LPZ[VIL\ZLKVUS`[VW\SS[OL]LOPJSLVU[V
[OL MSH[ ILK [YHJ[VY VY [V^PUN HWHYH[\Z PM [OL
]LOPJSL^PSSYVSSMYLLS`<UKLYUVJPYJ\TZ[HUJLZ
PZ [OL ]LOPJSL [V IL ZLJ\YLK \ZPUN [OL [V^PUN
L`L
5L]LY \ZL [OL [V^PUN L`L [V [V^ [OPZ VY HU`
V[OLY]LOPJSL
-YVU[TV\U[PUN
*HYLM\SS` YLTV]L [OL WSHZ[PJ JHW ILZPKL [OL
SPJLUZLWSH[L^P[OHZJYL^KYP]LY
:JYL^[OL[V^PUNL`LPU[V[OLOVSL
9LHYTV\U[PUN
9LTV]LSPJLUZLWSH[L
*HYLM\SS`YLTV]L[OLWSHZ[PJJHWIL[^LLU[OL
I\TWLYZ^P[OHZJYL^KYP]LY
:JYL^[OL[V^PUNL`LPU[V[OLOVSL
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
¢¬s
¤ddamV¦F^a4dFpmpOd"*F=
7VZP[PVU ^VVKLU YHTWZ H[ [OL IHZL VM [OL
MSH[ILK[VYLK\JL[OLHUNSLVM[OLW\SS
9LLS PU [OL OVPZ[ JHISL HUK JOLJR [OL \UKLYÌ
ZPKLVM[OL]LOPJSLMVYHU`PU[LYMLYLUJL
aFamV=p§m¦F^a4dFpmOd"*F=
*HYLM\SS` MLLK [V^PUN Z[YHWZ [OYV\NO [OL
VWLUPUNPU[OLYLHY^OLLSZ
4HRLZ\YLTL[HSWHY[ZVMZ[YHWZKVUV[KHTÌ
HNLYPT
4HRLZ\YL[OLZ[YHWPZMSH[V]LY[OLYPTILHK
4HRL Z\YL IYHRL IHJRPUN WSH[L PZ UV[ KHTÌ
HNLK
:LJ\YLZ[YHWZ[VYLHYVMMSH[ILK
9LLSPUOVPZ[JHISLVUS`MHYLUV\NO[V[LUZPVU
[PLÌKV^UZ[YHWZ
*HYLM\SS` MLLK [V^PUN Z[YHWZ [OYV\NO [OL
VWLUPUNPU[OLMYVU[^OLLSZ
4HRLZ\YLTL[HSWHY[ZVMZ[YHWZKVUV[KHTÌ
HNLYPT
4HRLZ\YL[OLZ[YHWPZMSH[V]LY[OLYPTILHK
4HRL Z\YL IYHRL IHJRPUN WSH[L PZ UV[ KHTÌ
HNLK
:LJ\YLZ[YHWZ[VMYVU[VMMSH[ILK
9LSLHZL [LUZPVU VU OVPZ[ JHISL I\[ KV UV[
KPZJVUULJ[
<ZLOVPZ[JHISLHZHZHML[`JHISL
¢¬¢
7YHJ[PJHS;PWZ,TLYNLUJ`:LY]PJL
F^a4dF=FmaOa4"apm:F4^ma4"d""
=LOPJSL0KLU[PMPJH[PVU;LJOUPJHS+H[H
¢¬
F^a4dF=FmaOa4"apm
>OLU VYKLYPUN ZWHYL WHY[Z VY THRPUN PUÍ
X\PYPLZ WSLHZL HS^H`Z X\V[L [OL ]LOPJSL
PKLU[PMPJH[PVUU\TILY
F^a4dFa=FmaOa4"apmd"*Fd
=LOPJSL PKLU[PMPJH[PVU SHILS PZ H[[HJOLK [V [OL
PUULY ZPKL VM [OL S\NNHNL JVTWHY[TLU[ OVVK
ILSV^ [OL OVVK SVJR 0[ JVU[HPUZ HSS PTWVY[HU[
KH[HHIV\[`V\YJHY
;OPZSHILSJVU[HPUZ[OLMVSSV^PUNPUMVYTH[PVU!
=LOPJSL0KLU[PMPJH[PVU5V
;`WL;`WLKLZJYPW[PVU
,UNPULJVKL;YHUZTPZZPVUJVKL
7HPU[5V0U[LYPVY
6W[PVUHSLX\PWTLU[
( K\WSPJH[L VM [OPZ SHILS PZ PU `V\Y 4HPU[LUHUJL
)VVRSL[
5V[L
;OPZ KH[H IHUR JHUUV[ IL YLÌVYKLYLK PM P[ PZ SVZ[
VYKHTHNLK
F^a4dFa=FmaOa4"apmm¤h*F
0U HJJVYKHUJL ^P[O -LKLYHS :HML[` 9LN\SH[PVUZ
[OL ]LOPJSL PKLU[PMPJH[PVU U\TILY VM `V\Y JHY PZ
SVJH[LK H[ [OL IV[[VT SLM[ VM [OL ^PUKZOPLSK
MYHTLHUKJHUILZLLUMYVT[OLV\[ZPKL
;OL ]LOPJSL PKLU[PMPJH[PVU U\TILY PZ HSZV PU [OL
S\NNHNL JVTWHY[TLU[ VU [OL YPNO[ UL_[ [V [OL
IH[[LY`HYYV^
¢¬T
=LOPJSL0KLU[PMPJH[PVU;LJOUPJHS+H[H
"OF©4phzda"m4Fa4cF
;OLZHML[`JVTWSPHUJLZ[PJRLYPZ`V\YHZZ\YHUJL
[OH[ `V\Y UL^ 7VYZJOL JVTWSPLZ ^P[O HSS HWWSPJÌ
HISL -LKLYHS 4V[VY =LOPJSL :HML[` :[HUKHYKZ
^OPJO^LYLPULMMLJ[H[[OL[PTL[OL]LOPJSL^HZ
THU\MHJ[\YLK
;OL Z[PJRLY HSZV ZOV^Z [OL TVU[O HUK `LHY VM
WYVK\J[PVU HUK [OL ]LOPJSL PKLU[PMPJH[PVU U\TILY
VM `V\Y JHY WLYMVYH[PVUZ HZ ^LSS HZ [OL .YVZZ
=LOPJSL >LPNO[ 9H[PUN HUK [OL .YVZZ (_SL
>LPNO[9H[PUN
"am=""
;OL WHPU[ KH[H WSH[L PZ H[[HJOLK [V [OL SLM[ ZPKL
^HSS \UKLY [OL JHYWL[ PU [OL S\NNHNL JVTWHY[Ì
TLU[
mVamFm¤h*F
;OLLUNPULU\TILYPZZ[HTWLKVU[OL\UKLYZPKL
VM[OLJYHURJHZL
=LOPJSL0KLU[PMPJH[PVU;LJOUPJHS+H[H
¢¬Q
F4^ma4"d""
mVamF=""
;`WL
4
4 ,
OPNOÌWV^LY]LYZPVU
/VYPaVU[HSS`VWWVZLKLUNPULSPX\PKJVVSLK
5\TILYVMJ`SPUKLYZ
)VYL
PUTT
:[YVRL
PUTT
*\IPJJHWHJP[`
J\PUJT
*VTWYLZZPVUYH[PV
!
5L[ÌOVYZLWV^LY:(,1
OW R>
OWR>
H[JYHURZOHM[ZWLLK
YWT
YWT
5L[[VYX\L:(,1
M[SI5T
M[SI5T
H[JYHURZOHM[ZWLLK
ÌYWT
ÌYWT
(S[LYUH[VY
>
-PYPUNVYKLY
ÌÌÌÌÌ
,UNPULJVU[YVS
:[H[PVUHY`OPNOÌ]VS[HNLKPZ[YPI\[PVUZLX\LU[PHSPUQLJ[PVU
J`SPUKLYÌZLSLJ[P]LRUVJRÌJVU[YVSZ[LYLVV_`NLUZLUZVYJSVZLKÌSVVWJVU[YVSKPHNUVZ[PJZ`Z[LT
V]LYOLHKJHTZOHM[Z7VYZJOL=HYPV*HT7S\ZO`KYH\SPJ]HS]LJSLHYHUJLJVTWLUZH[PVU
¢¬
;LJOUPJHS+H[H
"mhaapm
.LHYYH[PVZ
4HU\HS[YHUZTPZZPVU
;PW[YVUPJ:
Z[NLHY
!
!
UKNLHY
!
!
YKNLHY
!
!
[ONLHY
!
!
[ONLHY
!
!
[ONLHY
!
9L]LYZL
!
!
!
-PUHSKYP]LYH[PV
!
!
a¦amVFOph"m4F
([+05LTW[`^LPNO[HUKOHSMSVHK^P[OV\[WLYMVYTHUJLÌPUOPIP[PUNL_[YHLX\PWTLU[
4HU\HS[YHUZTPZZPVU
;PW[YVUPJ:
4H_PT\TZWLLK
TWORTO
TWO RTO
OPNOÌWV^LY]LYZPVU
TWORTO
TWORTO
(JJLSLYH[PVUuRTOTWO
ZLJVUKZ
ZLJVUKZ
OPNOÌWV^LY]LYZPVU
ZLJVUKZ
ZLJVUKZ
;LJOUPJHS+H[H
¢¬
aF:ah:"4c
;PYL
9PT
9PTVMMZL[
;YHJR
:\TTLY[PYLZ
MYVU[
A9
1_/
TT
PUTT
YLHY
A9
1_/
TT
PUTT
VY
YLHY
A9
1_/
TTVUS`^P[OTTZWHJLYYPUN
PUTT
:UV^[PYLZ
MYVU[
9/4:
1_/
TT
PUTT
YLHY
9 /4:
1_/
TT
PUTT
;OLSVHKJHWHJP[`JVLMMPJPLU[LNsrHUKTH_PT\TZWLLKJVKLSL[[LYLNs/rHYLTPUPT\TYLX\PYLTLU[Z
;PYLHUKYPTZPaLZ
,_[LUZP]L[LZ[ZHYLWLYMVYTLKILMVYLZWLJPMPJ[PYLZHUK^OLLSZHYLHWWYV]LKI`7VYZJOL
@V\Y7VYZJOLKLHSLYOHZPUMVYTH[PVUHIV\[HWWYV]LK[PYLZHUK^OLLSZHUKPZOHWW`[VHZZPZ[`V\
0MHM[LYTHYRL[[PYLZHUKVY^OLLSZHYLPUZ[HSSLK^OPJOHYLUV[HWWYV]LKI`7VYZJOL[OL]LOPJSLqZYVHKHIPSP[`HUKOHUKSPUN
JOHYHJ[LYPZ[PJZTPNO[ILPTWHPYLK:PUJL7VYZJOLOHZUVKH[HVUZ\JOJVTIPUH[PVUZ7VYZJOLJHUUV[Z[HUKILOPUK
[OLZHML[`VYK\YHIPSP[`VM[OLZLHM[LYTHYRL[JVTIPUH[PVUZ
:UV^JOHPUZ
*HUILTV\U[LKVUS`VU[OLYLHY^OLLSZ"TH_PT\TZWLLKTWORTO
<ZLVUS`7VYZJOLH\[OVYPaLKMPULÌSPURJYVZZÌ[`WLVYLKNLJOHPUZ
:UV^JOHPUJSLHYHUJLJHUILN\HYHU[LLKVUS`VU[OL[PYLYPTJVTIPUH[PVUTHYRLK
:WHYL^OLLS
=LOPJSLZ^P[OV\[7VYZJOL*LYHTPJ*VTWVZP[L)YHRL!;Ì 7JVSSHWZPISL[PYLVU1_YPT
=LOPJSLZ^P[O7VYZJOL*LYHTPJ*VTWVZP[L)YHRL!Ì 7JVSSHWZPISL[PYLVU1_YPT
4H_PT\TZWLLKTWORTO(S^H`ZJVTWS`^P[O[OLPUZ[Y\J[PVUZPU[OLJOHW[LYs:WHYL^OLLSr
¢¬G
;LJOUPJHS+H[H
>HYUPUN
0UZ[HSSH[PVUVMZPaLZUV[H\[OVYPaLKI`
7VYZJOLTH`OH]LHKHUNLYV\ZLMMLJ[VU
[OLKYP]PUNZ[HIPSP[`HUKJV\SKYLZ\S[PU
ZL]LYLWLYZVUHSPUQ\Y`VYKLH[O
)LMVYL TV\U[PUN UL^ [PYLZ JOLJR ^P[O `V\Y
7VYZJOL KLHSLY HIV\[ [OL J\YYLU[ YLSLHZL
Z[H[\Z
aFF¤FOp4pd=aF
¤hhFaF"m=mp§aF
-YVU[
WZPIHYV]LYWYLZZ\YL
9LHY
WZPIHYV]LYWYLZZ\YL
pdd"za*dFz"F§^FFdpm¦F^a4dF§a^p¤p4^FF"ha4phzpaF"cF
-YVU[HUKYLHY
WZPIHYV]LYWYLZZ\YL
pdd"za*dFz"F§^FFdpm¦F^a4dF§a^p4^FF"ha4phzpaF"cF
-YVU[HUKYLHY
WZPIHYV]LYWYLZZ\YL
;OLZL[PYLWYLZZ\YLZHWWS`VUS`[V[OL[PYLTHRLZHUK[`WLZHWWYV]LKI`7VYZJOL
(S^H`ZVIZLY]LPUZ[Y\J[PVUZPU[OLJOHW[LYs;PYLZHUK;PYL*HYLr
;LJOUPJHS+H[H
¢¬n
"z"4aaF
<ZLVUS`MS\PKZHUKM\LSZH\[OVYPaLKI`7VYZJOL@V\YH\[OVYPaLK7VYZJOLKLHSLY^PSSNSHKS`HK]PZL`V\
@V\Y7VYZJOLOHZILLUKLZPNULKZV[OH[P[PZUV[ULJLZZHY`[VTP_HU`HKKP[P]LZ^P[OVPSZVYM\LSZ
,UNPUL
6PSJOHUNLX\HU[P[`^P[OV\[VPSMPS[LYHWWYV_X\HY[ZSP[LYZ
6PSJOHUNLX\HU[P[`^P[OVPSMPS[LYHWWYV_X\HY[ZSP[LYZ
(SZVYLMLY[V[OLZLJ[PVUs,UNPUL6PSZr
*VVSHU[
HWWYV_<:NHSSVUZSP[LYZ
4HU\HS[YHUZTPZZPVU
HUKKPMMLYLU[PHS
HWWYV_X\HY[ZSP[LYZ
;PW[YVUPJ:
HWWYV_ X\HY[Z SP[LYZ
+PMMLYLU[PHS^P[O;PW[YVUPJ:
HWWYV_X\HY[ZSP[LYZ
-\LS[HURYLMPSS]VS\TL
HWWYV_<:NHSSVUZSP[LYZ
-\LSX\HSP[`
@V\YLUNPULPZKLZPNULK[VWYV]PKLVW[PT\TWLYMVYTHUJLHUKM\LSLJVUVT`\ZPUN
\USLHKLKWYLTP\TM\LS^P[OHUVJ[HULYH[PUNVM 965 *3*VY(20
7VYZJOL[OLYLMVYLYLJVTTLUKZ[OL\ZLVM[OLZLM\LSZPU`V\Y]LOPJSL
7VYZJOLHSZVYLJVNUPaLZ[OH[[OLZLM\LSZTH`UV[HS^H`ZILH]HPSHISL)LHZZ\YLK[OH[`V\Y]LOPJSL
^PSSVWLYH[LWYVWLYS`VU\USLHKLKWYLTP\TM\LSZ^P[OVJ[HULU\TILYZVMH[SLHZ[ 965 *3*VY(20
ZPUJL[OLLUNPULqZs,SLJ[YVUPJ6R[HUL¹RUVJRJVU[YVSr^PSSHKHW[[OLPNUP[PVU[PTPUNPMULJLZZHY`
7V^LYZ[LLYPUN
HWWYV_X\HY[ZSP[LYZO`KYH\SPJMS\PK7LU[VZPU*/-:
·
)YHRLMS\PK
HWWYV_X\HY[ZSP[LYZ"\ZLVUS`6YPNPUHS7VYZJOLIYHRLMS\PK
>PUKZOPLSK^HZOLY
HWWYV_ X\HY[ZSP[LYZ^P[OOLHKSPNO[^HZOLY
¢s¬
;LJOUPJHS+H[H
FaV^
4HU\HS[YHUZTPZZPVU
;PW[YVUPJ:
,TW[`^LPNO[KLWLUKPUNVULX\PWTLU[
SIZRN
SIZRN
4H_PT\TNYVZZ^LPNO[
SIZRN
SIZ RN
4H_PT\TH_SLSVHKMYVU[
SIZRN
SIZRN
4H_PT\TH_SLSVHKYLHY
SIZRN
SIZRN
4H_PT\T\ZLM\SSVHK9VVM;YHUZWVY[:`Z[LT
SIZRN
SIZRN
;OLTH_PT\TNYVZZ^LPNO[T\Z[UV[ILL_JLLKLK
5V[L!0MHKKP[PVUHSHJJLZZVYPLZHYLPUZ[HSSLK[OL\ZLM\SSVHK^PSSILJVYYLZWVUKPUNS`SLZZ
<ZLVUS`6YPNPUHS7VYZJOL9VVM;YHUZWVY[:`Z[LT
ahFmapm
3LUN[O
PUTT
>PK[O
PUTT
/LPNO[
PU TT
>OLLSIHZL
PUTT
.YV\UKJSLHYHUJL
PUTT
;\YUPUNJPYJSL
M[T
;LJOUPJHS+H[H
¢ss
a"V"h
mVamF=a"V"h"O¤ddzp§F
(JJLSLYH[PVUKPHNYHT
=HS\LZOH]LILLUKL[LYTPULKH[+05LTW[`
^LPNO[HUK^P[OH SVHK^P[OV\[HKKP[PVUHS
LX\PWTLU[
;YHUZTPZZPVUKPHNYHT
;OL[YHUZTPZZPVUKPHNYHTPZIHZLKVUZ[HUKHYK
]HS\LZVU[OLIHZPZVMHTLHULMMLJ[P]LZJY\I
YHKP\Z
*OHUNLZVM[OLZJY\IYHKP\Z[OL[PYL
[VSLYHUJL^LHYHUK[LHYKL]PH[PUNJV\U[Y`
LX\PWTLU[HUK[PYLZSPWOH]LUV[ILLU[HRLU
PU[VHJJV\U[
,UN
PUL
WV^LY
;
VY
X\
L
,UNPULZWLLK
¢s¢
;LJOUPJHS+H[H
44FdF"apm=a"V"h
4HU\HS[YHUZTPZZPVU
;PTL
:
WLLK
;LJOUPJHS+H[H
¢s
"mhaapm=a"V"h
4HU\HS[YHUZTPZZPVU
:WLLK
,
UN
PU
L
ZWLLK
¢sT
;LJOUPJHS+H[H
"mhaapm=a"V"h
;PW[YVUPJ
:WLLK
,UN
PUL
ZWLLK
;LJOUPJHS+H[H
¢sQ
m=F¨
():HU[PSVJRIYHRLZ`Z[LT
(JV\Z[PJ^HYUPUNZPNUHS
(PYIHNZ`Z[LTZ
u:^P[JOPUNVMMWHZZLUNLYHPYIHN u
(PYKPZ[YPI\[PVU u
(PYMPS[LY
(PYJVUKP[PVUPUNZ`Z[LT u
(SHYTZ`Z[LT
(SJHU[HYH
(U[PMYLLaL
(U[PSVJRIYHRLZ`Z[LT
(ZO[YH`
(\KPVVWLYH[PVU u
(\[VÌI\[[VUHPYJVUKP[PVUPUNZ`Z[LT
(\[VTH[PJ
u(U[PÌNSHYLTPYYVYZ
u+VVYSVJRPUN
u/LHKSPNO[HKQ\Z[TLU[
u3VJRPUNYL[YHJ[VY
u:WLLKJVU[YVS
(]LYHNLJVUZ\TW[PVU
(]LYHNLZWLLK
)HJRYLZ[
u(KQ\Z[TLU[u
)H[[LY` u
u>HYUPUNSPNO[
)LMVYLKYP]PUNVMM
)SV^LYHKQ\Z[TLU[u
)VVZ[WYLZZ\YLLUNPUL
)YHRLZu
u-S\PK
u-S\PK^HYUPUNSPNO[
u3PNO[Z
u7HKZ
u9VSSLYIYHRL[LZ[LY
)YLHRPUOPU[Z
)\SIZ
u*OHY[
u9LWSHJPUNu
*HUOVSKLY
*HWHJP[PLZV]LY]PL^
*HYJHYL u
*HY[LSLWOVUL
*HY^HZOLZ
*HZZL[[L[HWL
u7SH`LY
u/VSKLY
*H[HS`[PJJVU]LY[LYZ
*H\[PVUZ
*LU[YHSSVJRPUN u
*OHUNPUN^OLLSZ u
*OLJRLUNPUL^HYUPUNSPNO[
*OPSKYLZ[YHPU[
u(UJOVYHNLZ
u:`Z[LTu
u:^P[JOPUNVMMWHZZLUNLYHPYIHNu
*PNHYL[[LSPNO[LY
*PYJ\SH[PUNHPYI\[[VU
*SVJR
*SV[OLZOVVR
*S\[JOWLKHS
*VSSHWZPISLZWHYL^OLLS u
*VTWHJ[KPZJ
u*OHUNLY
u/VSKLY
u7SH`LY
*VTWYLZZVYMVYJVSSHWZPISLZWHYL^OLLS
*VVSHU[
u3L]LS
u;LTWLYH[\YLNH\NL
u>HYUPUNSPNO[
*VVSPUNZ`Z[LT
*Y\PZLJVU[YVS
*\WOVSKLY
*\YISPNO[
+HZOIVHYK
+LMYVZ[PUN^PUKV^Zu
+PHNUVZ[PJZVJRL[
+PHNYHTZu
+PTLUZPVUZ
¢s
0UKL_
+VVY
u.\HYK
u/HUKSLZ
u3VJRZ
u>PUKV^Z
+VVYTPYYVY
u/LH[PUN
+YP]PUNOPU[Z u
+YP]PUNWLYMVYTHUJL
+`UHTVTL[LY[LZ[PUN
,SLJ[YPJHSZ`Z[LT u
,TLYNLUJ`MSHZOLY
,TLYNLUJ`VWLYH[PVU
u*LU[YHSSVJRPUN
u3PKZ
u3PM[PUNZSPKPUNYVVM
u;HURMSHW
,TLYNLUJ`WYVNYHT;PW[YVUPJ
,TLYNLUJ`ZLY]PJL u
,TLYNLUJ`Z[HY[PUN
^P[OQ\TWLYJHISLZ
,TPZZPVUJVU[YVSZ`Z[LTu
,UNPULJVTWHY[TLU[
u)SV^LY
u3PK
u3PNO[
,UNPUL
u)VVZ[WYLZZ\YL
u*OLJRPUNVPSSL]LS
u,_OH\Z[
u5\TILY
u6PSJVUZ\TW[PVU
u6PSSL]LS
u6PSSL]LSNH\NL
u6PSWYLZZ\YLNH\NL
u6PSWYLZZ\YL^HYUPUNSPNO[
u6PSZ u
u:[HY[PUNu
u:WLLKZ
u:^P[JOPUNVMM u
-VNSPNO[Z
-VV[IYHRLu
-VV[^LSSSPNO[Z
-V\YÌ^OLLSKYP]L
-YVU[OVVK
-\LS u
u*VU[HPULYZ
u,JVUVT`
u,]HWVYH[PVUJVU[YVS
u3L]LS^HYUPUNSPNO[
u3L]LSNH\NL
u9LJVTTLUKH[PVU
u;HUR
-\ZLZ
.HYHNLKVVYH\[VTH[PJ
.HYHNLSPM[
.LHYJOHUNPUN u
.SV]LJVTWHY[TLU[
.VUN
/LHKSPNO[Z u
u(KQ\Z[PUN
u*SLHUPUNZ`Z[LT
/LH[LKYLHY^PUKV^/HYK[VW
/LH[PUN u
/PNOILHT
u0UKPJH[VYSPNO[
u3L]LY
/VVKZ
/VYU
0KLU[PMPJH[PVUU\TILY
0NUP[PVUSVJR
0TTVIPSPaLY
0UKPJH[VYSPNO[Z u
0UMYHYLKWHZZLUNLY
JVTWHY[TLU[TVUP[VYPUN
0UZ[Y\TLU[WHULS u
0UZ[Y\TLU[Z u
u3PNO[Z
0U[LYPVYTPYYVY
0U[LYPVYSPNO[
0U[LYTP[[LU[VWLYH[PVUZ^P[JO
1HJR
1\TWLYJHISLZ
0UKL_
¢s
2L`SVJR
2L`Z u
3LH[OLYJHYL
3PJLUZLWSH[LSPNO[
3PKLTLYNLUJ`VWLYH[PVU
3PM[PUNZSPKPUNYVVM u
3PNO[
u-SHZOLY
u3V^ILHT
u:^P[JO
3VHKZ^P[JOÌVMM
3VJRPUN u
u*VUKP[PVUZ
3\NNHNLJVTWHY[TLU[ u
3\NNHNLJHYYPLY
4HPU[LUHUJL u
4HRLÌ\WTPYYVY
4H_PT\TWLYTP[[LKLUNPULZWLLKZ
4PYYVYZ
5V[LZVU
u*HYJHYL u
u4HPU[LUHUJL
5\TILYWSH[LSPNO[
6J[HULYH[PUN
6KVTL[LY
6PS u
u*VUZ\TW[PVU
u3L]LSJOLJRZ
u3L]LSNH\NL
u7YLZZ\YLNH\NL
u7YLZZ\YL^HYUPUNSPNO[
6UÌIVHYKJVTW\[LYu
u)HZPJZL[[PUN
u3HUN\HNLZLSLJ[PVU
6UÌIVHYKSP[LYH[\YL
6YPLU[H[PVUSPNO[
6\[ZPKLÌ[LTWLYH[\YLKPZWSH`
7HPU[
u*HYL u
u+H[H
7HYRPUN
u(PKZ
u(ZZPZ[HU[
u)YHRL
u3PNO[
7HY[PJSLMPS[LY
7HZZLUNLYHPYIHNZ^P[JOPUNVMM u
7HZZLUNLYJVTWHY[TLU[
TVUP[VYPUNPUMYHYLK
7SH[MVYTSPM[
7SHZ[PJWHY[ZJHYLVM
7VYZJOLJLYHTPJJVTWVZP[LIYHRL
7VYZJOLJVTT\UPJH[PVUTHUHNLTLU[
7VYZJOLZ[HIPSP[`THUHNLTLU[
7V^LYTLHZ\YLTLU[
7V^LYZ[LLYPUNMS\PKSL]LS
7V^LY^PUKV^Z
7YHJ[PJHS[PWZ u
9HKPH[VYMHU
9HKPVYLJLW[PVU
9HPUZLUZVY
9HUNLVUYLTHPUPUNM\LS
9LHYMVNSPNO[
9LHYOVVK
9LHYZLH[IHJRYLZ[
9LHYZWVPSLY
9LHY]PL^TPYYVYZ
9LHY^PUKV^KLMVNNLY
9LHY^PWLY
9LSH`Z
9LTV[LJVU[YVS
9LWSHJPUNI\SIZ u
9LWSHJPUN^PWLYISHKLZ
9LWSHJLTLU[RL`
9L[YHJ[HISLZWVPSLYYLHY
9VVM
u3PM[PUNZSPKPUNu
u;YHUZWVY[Z`Z[LT
9\UUPUNPU
¢sG
0UKL_
:HML[`ILS[Z u
:HML[`JVTWSPHUJLZ[PJRLY
:LHSZJHYLVM
:LH[ u
u(KQ\Z[TLU[ u
u/LH[PUN
u4LTVY`
:LSLJ[VYSL]LYWVZP[PVUPUKPJH[VY
:OPM[SVJR
:PKLTHYRLYSPNO[
:SPKPUNYVVM u
:UV^JOHPUZ
:WHYLRL`
:WHYL^OLLS u
:WLLK
u*VU[YVS
u.VUN
:WLLKVTL[LY
:WVPSLYYL[YHJ[HISL
:[HY[PUNHUKZ[VWWPUN[OLLUNPUL u
:[LLYPUN^OLLS
u(KQ\Z[TLU[
u3VJR
u;VNNSLZ^P[JOLZ u
:[VYHNLVW[PVUZ
:[VYHNL[YH`
:[VYPUN`V\Y7VYZJOL
:\U]PZVYZ
;HJOVTL[LY
;HPSSPNO[
;HUR
u=LU[PSH[PVUZ`Z[LT
;LJOUPJHSKH[H u
;LSLWOVUL
;LTWLYH[\YLZL[[PUN u
;OLM[WYV[LJ[PVU
;PW[YVUPJ u
;PYLZ u
u7YLZZ\YL
u7YLZZ\YLJVTWYLZZVY
;PYLZHUK[PYLJHYLu
;VVSRP[
;V^PUN
;YHJR
;YHUZTPZZPVU u
u-S\PK
;YPWJV\U[LY
;Y\URLU[YHWTLU[
;\YUZPNUHSZ
<UKLYJVH[PUN
=HS]LZ
=HUP[`TPYYVY
=LOPJSL
u*HYL u
u+H[H
u0KLU[PMPJH[PVUSHILS
u0KLU[PMPJH[PVUU\TILY
u>HZOPUN u
=LU[PSH[PVU u
=LU[Z u
=VS[TL[LY
0UKL_
¢sn
>HYUPUNSHTWZ u
>HYUPUNTLZZHNLZ u
>HZOLYMS\PK
>HZOPUN u
>LPNO[Z
>OLLS
u*OHUNPUN u
u)VS[Z
>OLLSZ u
>PUKV^Z
u>HZOLYUVaaSLZ
u>HZOLYZ`Z[LT
>PUKZOPLSK^PWLY^HZOLYSL]LY
>PUKZOPLSK^PWLYZ
u9LWSHJPUN
>PWLY
u)SHKLZ
u0U[LY]HS
>PU[LYVWLYH[PVU!
u)H[[LY`
u*VVSHU[
u,UNPULVPS u
u1\TWLYJHISLZ
u3VJRZ
u:LHSZ
u:UV^JOHPUZ
u;PYLZ u
u>HZOLYMS\PK
u>PWLYISHKLZ
¢¢¬
0UKL_