6FHQDULXV]]DM üHGXNDF\MQ\FKZJUXSLHV]HFLRODWNyZ
2SUDFRZDáDPJU5HQDWD- GU]HMDN
6]NRáD3RGVWDZRZDZ)DELQDFK
7HPDW]DM FLD
&RZLHPRZL WDFK%R*HJR1DURG]HQLD"ûZLF]HQLD
NODV\ILNDF\MQHLXWUZDODMFH]QDMRPRü]Z\F]DMyZ
ZLWHF]Q\FK
&(/(=$- &,$
5R]ZLMDQLHSDPL FLZ]URNRZHMLVáXFKRZHM
:GUD*DQLHGRDNW\ZQHJRP\OHQLD
.V]WDáFHQLHXPLHM WQRFLSRGHMPRZDQLDGHF\]ML
'RVNRQDOHQLHXPLHM WQRFLOLF]HQLDZ]DNUHVLHGRGDZDQLHQD]ELRUDFK
]DVW SF]\FKV\OZHW\ERPEHN
'RVNRQDOHQLHXPLHM WQRFLUR]SR]QDZDQLDNRORUyZ
2GF]XZDQLHUDGRVQHJRQDVWURMXZLW%R*HJR1DURG]HQLD
2GF]XZDQLHVDW\VIDNFML]Z\NRQDQ\FK]DGD
=$0,(5=21(()(.7<
'=,(&.2
UR]XPLHWUHüSROHFHS\WDNRQNXUVRZ\FK
SRWUDILVNRQFHQWURZDüVL QD]DGDQLX
OLF]\OLF]HEQLNDPLJáyZQ\PL
UR]G]LHOD]ELRU\]HZ]JO GXQDGDQFHFK
SRUyZQDOLF]HEQRü]ELRUyZ
VDPRG]LHOQLHXVWDOLZ\QLNGRGDZDQLDQDSRGVWDZLHPDQLSXORZDQLD
V\OZHWDPLERPEHN
QDNOHLV\OZHW\ERPEHNQDV\OZHW FKRLQNLLGRU\VXMHLQQHR]GRE\
0(72'<35$&<
3UREOHPRZH]DGDQLRZHSUDNW\F]QHJRG]LDáDQLD
3202&(
:LHUV](6]HOEXUJ=DUHPELQ\Ä:H(P\VL ]DU FH´V\OZHW\ERPEHN
GODND*GHJRG]LHFNDF]HUZRQ\FK]LHORQ\FKQLHELHVNLHV\OZHW\
FKRLQHNNOHMHSU]\ERU\GRU\VRZDQLDQDJUDQLH&'LOXVWUDFMH]
QDU\VRZDQRGSRZLHG]LQDS\WDQLDNRQNXUVRZH
(WDS\
]DM FLD
2SLVSURMHNWRZDQHMV\WXDFML
Z\FKG\GDNW
&]\QQRFLQDXF]\FLHOD
5RG]DMHLIRUP\
DNW\ZQRFLG]LHFL
8ZDJL
RUJDQL]DF\MQH
,
=
$
$
1
*
$
)
2
:
$
1
,
(
=DSUDV]DPZDVG]LVLDMGRZLWHF]QHM
]JDG\ZDQNL´&]\ZLHV]ZV]\VWNRR
ZL WDFK%R*HJR1DURG]HQLD"´
3RVáXFKDMFLHWHUD]XZD*QLHNRO G\
1DXF]\FLHONDZSURZDG]DG]LHFLZ
ZLWHF]Q\QDVWUyM=EOL*DMVL ZL WD
%R*HJR1DURG]HQLD.D*G\]QDVOXELWH
ZL WD
6]F]HJyOQLHG]LHFL&KRLQNDSUH]HQW\
.RO G\WRZV]\VWNRVWZDU]D
QLHSRZWDU]DOQ\QDVWUyM']LHFLZLHG]
EDUG]RZLHOHRZL WDFK%R*HJR
1DURG]HQLD$OHF]\ZV]\VWNR"
1DXF]\FLHONDF]\WDS\WDQLDNRQNXUVX
MHGQRG]LHFNRSRXG]LHOHQLXSRSUDZQHM
RGSWZRU]\QDWDEOLF\ÄPDS SDPL FL´
XPLHV]F]DMFQDQLHMRGSRZLHGQL
LOXVWUDFM
3RRVWDWQLPS\WDQLXQDXF]\FLHOND
UHF\WXMHZLHUV]Ä:H(P\VL ]DU FH´L
]DSUDV]DG]LHFLGR]HEUDQLDV\OZHW
ERPEHNUR]áR*RQ\FKQDG\ZDQLH
1DXF]\FLHONDSURVLDE\G]LHFL]HEUDá\
XVWDORQOLF]E ERPEHNF]HUZRQ\FK
]LHORQ\FKLQLHELHVNLH
']LHFLVáXFKDM
NRO G\RGWZDU]DQHM
]Sá\W\&'
']LHFLNWyUH]QDM
RGSRZLHG(QD
S\WDQLHSU]HFKRG]
]DND*G\PUD]HPQD
GUXJVWURQ
G\ZDQX
']LHFLVWDUDMVL
GRNáDGQLHZ\NRQDü
SROHFHQLH
']LHFLVLHG]Z
NU JX
']LHFLVWRM]
MHGQHMVWURQ\
G\ZDQX
,,
%
$
'
$
1
,
(
Ä8ELHUDP\FKRLQN ´
1DXF]\FLHONDSU]HGVWDZLDSUREOHP\GOD
G]LHFL
-DNPR*QDUR]G]LHOLüERPENL"]H
Z]JO GXQDNRORU
,OHMHVWERPEHNND*GHJRNRORUX"
.WyU\FKERPEHNMHVWQDMZL FHM
QDMPQLHM"
&RSRZLHFLHROLF]ELHERPEHN
']LHFL
%DGDMZMDNL
VSRVyEPR*QD
SRVHJUHJRZDü
ERPENL
0DMSRND]Dü
RGSRZLHGQLF\IU
%DGDMF]\]ELRU\
VUyZQROLF]QH
OLF]FERPENL
']LHFLVLHG]Z
NU JXND*GHPD
ERPEHN
F]HUZRQ\FK
]LHORQ\FKL
QLHELHVNLH
F]HUZRQ\FKL]LHORQ\FK"
1DXF]\FLHONDSURVLG]LHFLDE\
VSUyERZDá\XáR*\üERPENLQDFKRLQFH
WDNDE\ND*GDE\áDLQQHJRNRORUX
']LHFLPDQLSXOXM
V\OZHWDPLERPEHN
,,,
3
5
=
(
.
6
=
7
$
à
&
$
1
,
(
$WHUD]Xáy*FLHERPENLZWDNLVSRVyE
MDNMDZDPSRGDPLSRZLHG]FLHLOHMHVW
LFKUD]HP
ERPENDQLHELHVNDLF]HUZRQD
ERPENDF]HUZRQDL]LHORQH
ERPENDQLHELHVNDL]LHORQH
ERPENDF]HUZRQDLQLHELHVNLH
Ä2]GRE\FKRLQNRZH´
:SL FLXSXGHáNDFKPDFLHSRXNáDGDQH
ERPENL'RU\VXMFLHW\OHERPEHNDE\Z
ND*G\PSXGHáNXE\áRLFKSRW\OHVDPR
-HV]F]HUD]ZUDFDP\GRQDV]\FKFKRLQHN
7HUD]VZRMHV\OZHW\ERPEHNSU]\NOHMFLH
QDFKRLQNLLVSUyEXMFLHGRU\VRZDüVZRMH
ZáDVQHR]GRE\
']LHFLSRXáR*HQLX
V\OZHWERPEHN
RGSRZLDGDM
PyZLF
LWR
LWR
LWR
LWR
']LHFLU\VXM
']LHFLXNáDGDM
ERPENLQDFKRLQFHL
R]GDELDMZáDVQ\PL
Z]RUDPL
1DXF]\FLHONDZ
PLDU SRWU]HE\
SRPDJDG]LHFLRP
,9
3
5
(
=
(
1
7
$
&
-
$
1DXF]\FLHONDSURSRQXMHG]LHFLRPDE\
]DSUH]HQWRZDá\HIHNW\VZRMHMSUDF\
:F]DVLHSUH]HQWDFMLG]LHFLZ\SRZLDGDM
VL QDWHPDW]Z\F]DMXXELHUDQLDFKRLQNL
ZLFKGRPDFK
3RSU]\VWURMHQLXVDOLQDXF]\FLHONDSURVL
G]LHFLDE\XSRU]GNRZDá\VZRMH
PLHMVFHSUDF\LXVLDGá\QDG\ZDQLH
']LHFLSUH]HQWXM
VZRMHFKRLQNL
2FHQLDMNWyUDLP
VL QDMEDUG]LHM
SRGRED1DVW SQLH
UD]HP]
QDXF]\FLHON
SU]\VWUDMDMQLPL
VDO
']LHFLSRU]GNXM
VZRMHPLHMVFD
SUDF\RGNáDGDM
SU]\ERU\QD
SyáHF]NL
9
5
(
)
/
(
.
6
-
$
*G\ZV]\VWNLHG]LHFLMX*VLHG]
QDXF]\FLHONDSURVLMHDE\SRGHV]á\GR
GU]HZNDLZ\EUDá\VRELHMHGQERPEN ]
GZyFKNRORUyZ]áRWOXEV]DU
1DXF]\FLHONDZ\MDQLDG]LHFLRP*H
ERPENLR]QDF]DMZDV]HVDPRSRF]XFLH
QDG]LVLHMV]\FK]DM FLDFK
%RPEND]áRWD*HE\OLFLH]DGRZROHQL
]DM FLHLSUDFHZDPVL SRGREDá\
-HOLE\OLFLHVPXWQLOXE]DM FLHLSUDFH
ZDPVL QLHSRGREDá\Z\ELHUDFLH
ERPEN V]DU
']LHFLSRQRZQLHVLDGDMQDG\ZDQLH
3RZLHG]FLHFRZDPVL SRGREDáR
QDMEDUG]LHM"'ODF]HJR"
&RE\áRGODZDVWUXGQH"
-DNF]XOLFLHVL ZUROLZ\JUDQ\FKL
SU]HJUDQ\FK"
1DXF]\FLHONDR]QDMPLD*HG]LVLDMMHVW
Z\MWNRZ\SU]HGZLWHF]Q\G]LHLZ
QDJURG ]DXG]LDáZNRQNXUVLHL
]DEDZDFKZV]\VWNLHG]LHFLRWU]\PDM
NDUWNLZLWHF]QH]DGUHVHPZL WHJR
0LNRáDMD
']LHFLSRGFKRG]
GRGU]HZNDL
Z\ELHUDM
RGSRZLHGQL
ERPEN
6ZRERGQH
Z\SRZLHG]LG]LHFL
3<7$1,$.21.8562:(
&]\SRWUDILV]Z\PLHQLüW\WXáMHGQHM]NRO G"
'ODNRJR]RVWDZLDVL SXVWHQDNU\FLHSU]\ZLJLOLMQ\PVWROH"
.LHG\]D]Z\F]DM]DVLDGDVL GRZLHF]HU]\ZLJLOLMQHM"
&]\ZG]LH:LJLOLLMDGDVL SRWUDZ\PL VQH"
-DNQD]\ZDOLVL WU]HMNUyORZLHNWyU]\SU]\V]OLSRZLWDü-H]XVD"
-DNQD]\ZDVL F]DVNWyU\SRSU]HG]DZL WD%R*HJR1DURG]HQLD"
-DNQD]\ZDVL QDER*HVWZRRGSUDZLDQHRSyáQRF\ZQRFZLJLOLMQ "
&]\POXG]LHWUDG\F\MQLHG]LHOVL SRGF]DVZLHF]HU]\ZLJLOLMQHM"
.LHG\XELHUDVL FKRLQN "
:('0<6, =$5 &(
:H(P\VL ]DU FH
FKáRSF\LG]LHZF]\QNL
]DWDF]\P\UD]HP
GRNRáDFKRLQNL
'RNRáDFKRLQNL
MHVWWXPLHMVFDGRV\ü
0R*HE\LLQQHG]LHFL
WH*]DSURVLü"
3URVLP\SURVLP\
SU]\MG(FLHGRQDVZJRFL
ZWRZHVRáHZL WR
ZWRZL WR5DGRFL
(6=(/%85*=$5(0%,1$
/,7(5$785$
+.UXNÄ:\EyUOLWHUDWXU\GR]DEDZL]DM üZSU]HGV]NROX´:6L3:DUV]DZD
(*UXV]F]\N.ROF]\VND(=LHOLVNDÄ']LHFL FDPDWHPDW\ND´:6L3:DUV]DZD
&]&\UDVNL:)DED)DELVND0RMHODW±SU]HZRGQLNPHWRG\F]Q\
:\G0$&
('8.$&-$
.LHOFH
3\WDQLDNRQNXUVRZH±RSUDFRZDQLHZáDVQH