Divided Ireland

by Taro Fruhwirth, 5HBa
Mag. Schaludek-Paletschek

CORRECTED VERSION

Divided Ireland (Corrected Version) 18.02.1997

Taro Fruhwirth, 5HBa

page 2 of 2

TABLE OF CONTENTS

The Beginning of the Conflict ................................................ 3

The Home Rule Controversy .................................................. 4

The Republic of Ireland .......................................................... 4

The Civil Rights of the Irish in Northern Ireland.................... 5

The Irish Economy.................................................................. 5

Constitutional Controversies................................................... 6

The Anglo-Irish Agreement .................................................... 6

Divided Ireland (Corrected Version) 18.02.1997

Taro Fruhwirth, 5HBa

page 3 of 3

DIVIDED IRELAND

by Taro Fruhwirth, 5HBa

My speech is about the history of the Irish and English people and the conflict concerning the

area called Northern Ireland.

THE BEGINNING OF THE CONFLICT

The first time mankind arrived on the island of Ireland was about 200 years before Christ. In

the year 432, St. Patrick came to Ireland, initiating a “Golden Age“ of cultural and spiritual

development.

But in the year 1169, this era came to an end and a time of pain and agony began. This was the

year when the Anglo-Normans, who were the forefathers of the English nation, started to

invade Ireland and finally controlled most of the country. This was the origin of the national-

based conflict. England tried to conquer the whole land and to extinguish the Irish nation, but

it never achieved that target. This caused very much hatred and hostility against England in

the minds of the Irish people.

But what made peace between the two countries nearly impossible was the conflict between

the cultures and religions. This was also the reason why a fusion with England became so

inconceivable. The planned reformation of the Irish population was not just unsuccessful, but

it also created a big gulf between the Catholic Ireland and the Protestant England.

When two chieftains of Ulster, which is the northern part of Ireland, were defeated and

departed from England they started a plantation of Protestant settlers in the North of Ireland.

This land is now a part of the United Kingdom, called Northern Ireland.

Divided Ireland (Corrected Version) 18.02.1997

Taro Fruhwirth, 5HBa

page 4 of 4

THE HOME RULE CONTROVERSY

In the year 1800, the United Kingdom was created, consisting of Great Britain and Ireland.

This led to a never-ending movement to repeal the union between the two isles.

The Great Famine in 1846 changed the political scenery. It confirmed Irish fears about the

incapacity of the British administration in handling Irish needs. But also many English

politicians saw that the situation needed to be changed.

This was the beginning of the idea of Home Rule. In 1886, the Liberal Prime Minister

Gladstone introduced the first Home Rule bill. This bill gave certain powers to a Dublin

parliament. But the first, and later also the second, Home Rule bill were rejected. The first

Home Rule bill was rejected in the House of Commons, the second in the House of Lords.

The third and last attempt to establish Home Rule was prevented by the illegal Ulster

Volunteer Force until the First World War broke out. The UVF is still active in Northern

Ireland.

THE REPUBLIC OF IRELAND

After the First World War, a radical republican party called Sinn Féin (“Ourselves alone“ in

Gaelic) won the general election, but instead of taking their seats, they established an

alternative parliament. A year later, in the year 1919, the War of Independence began. On the

side of the Irish people, the Irish Republican Army was founded to fight the British troops.

The war ended in 1921 with a treaty that partitioned the isle. 6 counties of Ulster remained

with the United Kingdom, the rest of the 26 counties formed the Republic of Ireland in 1922.

But this solution satisfied neither of the two sides, it was only seen as a temporary measure.

The partition was based on the religious distribution of the population.

Except for the following rumours between pro and anti-Treaty forces that lasted a year, the

Republic of Ireland stayed mainly peaceful until today. But in Northern Ireland the conflict

between Irish and English people held on and has not ended yet. An armed police force called

the Royal Ulster Constabulary and the British army were sent to Ireland to establish peace and

order. But instead of this, they were fighting a war against the IRA, which is still going on

now.

Divided Ireland (Corrected Version) 18.02.1997

Taro Fruhwirth, 5HBa

page 5 of 5

THE CIVIL RIGHTS OF THE IRISH IN NORTHERN IRELAND

In the beginning of the existence of Northern Ireland, the Irish and Catholic population of this

area was not very happy with the new state. They voted mainly for Nationalist politicians. But

the British and Protestant population was about two-thirds of the whole state. So the Unionists

that received the majority of the vote from the Protestant population were the ruling party.

Many Unionists felt that the Catholic disloyalty to the new state justified discrimination

against them. The electoral system with its principle of winner-take-all played a large part in

the discrimination against the Catholics.

Rising living standards that came with the years made people on both sides more tolerant to

each other. This resulted in the forming of the Northern Ireland Civil Rights Association in

1967. This Association demanded an electoral reform and fair housing allocation. Many

marches were held for these changes and the demands were met a year later. But the marches

were often attacked by extremist Protestants.

THE IRISH ECONOMY

1920 - 1929 : The partition from the highly industrial Northern Ireland resulted in a high

degree of agricultural industry. Therefore the living standard was very low and

many people emigrated. But eventually the beginning of rural electrification

was a major success.

1930 - 1959 : In this period Ireland was not able to increase its industrial efforts because of

another war with Britain just economic and because of Ireland’s isolation in the

Second World War. In the 1950’s, the emigration rate was at its highest point

ever and the population was declining.

1960 - 1979 : In this time the economy recovered and Ireland was rapidly industrialising. The

consequences were rising living standards and population levels.

1980 - 1989 : This period brought recession back to Ireland and the emigration of people

started again.

Divided Ireland (Corrected Version) 18.02.1997

Taro Fruhwirth, 5HBa

page 6 of 6

CONSTITUTIONAL CONTROVERSIES

Eamon De Valera was one of the most important persons in the history of the Republic of

Ireland. He founded a new party, called Fianna Fáil, that is today one of the largest parties in

Ireland. He created a new constitution in 1937 and made a Republic out of Ireland, though this

was not officially recognised by Britain until 1949. His constitution is still in force today. But

a number of articles have caused considerable controversy.

Article 2. ( Territory )

The national territory consists of the whole

island of Ireland, its islands and the

territorial seas.

This article is still in force. It is seen by many

people as encouraging violence against British

administration in Northern Ireland.

Article 41. ( Family Rights )

3.2. No law shall be enacted providing for the

grant of a dissolution of marriage.

This article is also still in force. There was a

referendum in 1986 to remove the prohibition

of divorce. But this referendum has failed.

THE ANGLO-IRISH AGREEMENT

In 1985, Garret Fitzgerald and Margaret Thatcher signed an important agreement between the

United Kingdom and the Republic of Ireland.

In this agreement the British Government “recognises the need to acknowledge the rights of

the two major traditions“. These traditions are the tradition of the unionists, who want to unify

Ireland with Great Britain, and the tradition of “those who aspire to a sovereign united Ireland

achieved by peaceful means and through agreement.“

Divided Ireland (Corrected Version) 18.02.1997

Taro Fruhwirth, 5HBa

page 7 of 7

The British Government also committed itself to abandon discrimination and intolerance.

Special notice should be given to the next sentence that is written in the agreement.

“If a majority of the people of Northern Ireland give their consent to Irish unity, the British

Government commit themselves to introduce and support in the Westminster parliament,

legislation to give effect to this.“

Added to this, the British Government agrees to establish an Intergovernmental Conference

concerned with Northern Ireland and with relations between the two parts of the island. And

this conference imposes both governments to make efforts to resolve any differences in the

interests of promoting peace and stability.

The first meeting of this conference discussed the policies of the RUC and the British armed

forces.

The purpose of this agreement is that the nationalists should change their opinion about the

structure of government, the security forces and the judicial system in Northern Ireland.

Finally I would like to tell you (to end with) the last sentence of a Fine Gael party leaflet about

the Anglo-Irish Agreement.

“Of course it is always easier to do nothing, in the hope of avoiding blame for anything that

may go wrong, but such an attitude would be totally irresponsible in the face of the tragedy of

Northern Ireland.“

TABLE OF CONTENTS

The Beginning of the Conflict
The Home Rule Controversy
The Republic of Ireland
The Civil Rights of the Irish in Northern Ireland
The Irish Economy
Constitutional Controversies
The Anglo-Irish Agreement

VOCABULARY

agony Schmerz,

Leid

to aspire

streben

bill Gesetzesentwurf
controversy Streitfrage
electoral system

Wahlsystem

to extinct

ausrotten

hatred Hass
hostility Feindschaft
partition Teilung
party Partei
to plant

hier: ansiedeln

Divided Ireland (Corrected Version) 18.02.1997

Taro Fruhwirth, 5HBa

page 9 of 9

Divided Ireland (Corrected Version) 18.02.1997

Taro Fruhwirth, 5HBa

page 10 of 10

200 B.C. Celtic speaking people arrive in Ireland
432

St. Patrick comes to Ireland

1169

The Anglo-Normans invade Ireland

(Origin of English-Irish conflict)

1536

English start Reformation in Ireland

(Origin of religious conflict)

1607

Protestant settlers are planted in Ulster

(Origin of Ulster conflict)

1846

The Great Famine

1886

First Home Rule bill is rejected

1893

Second Home Rule bill is rejected

1912

UVF formed to resist Third Home Rule

1918

Sinn Féin party wins general election

1919 War

of

Independence

1921

End of the war

1937

Republic of Ireland is founded

1967

N.I. Civil Rights Association is founded

Divided Ireland (Corrected Version) 18.02.1997

Taro Fruhwirth, 5HBa

page 11 of 11

“DIVIDED

IRELAND“

12.12.1996

by Taro Fruhwirth, 5HBa

TABLE OF CONTENTS

The Beginning of the Conflict
The Home Rule Controversy
The Republic of Ireland
The Civil Rights of the Irish in Northern Ireland
The Irish Economy
Constitutional Controversies
The Anglo-Irish Agreement

TIME TABLE

200 B.C.

Celtic speaking people arrive in Ireland

432

St. Patrick comes to Ireland

1169

The Anglo-Normans invade Ireland

(Origin of English-Irish conflict)

1536

English start Reformation in Ireland

(Origin of religious conflict)

1607

Protestant settlers are planted in Ulster

(Origin of Ulster conflict)

1846

The Great Famine

1886

First Home Rule bill is rejected

1893

Second Home Rule bill is rejected

1912

UVF formed to resist Third Home Rule

1918

Sinn Féin party wins general election

1919

War of Independence

1921

End of the war

1937

Republic of Ireland is founded

1967

N.I. Civil Rights Association is founded

VOCABULARY

agony Schmerz,

Leid

to aspire

streben

bill Gesetzesentwurf
controversy Streitfrage
electoral system

Wahlsystem

to extinct

ausrotten

hatred Hass
hostility Feindschaft
partition Teilung
party Partei
to plant

hier: ansiedeln