cluster two
Case Studies
Early Childhood:
“Fire Safety”
Elementary School:
“Project Night”
Middle School:
“Frogs”
High School:
“The Substitute”
Module 6:
The Brain and Development
Outline and Learning Goals 102 The Relevance of Brain Research 103 Physiology of the Brain
105 Applications for the Classroom 111 Summary 115 Key Concepts 115 Case Studies: Re
flect
and Evaluate 116
boh7850x_CL2.p092-101.indd 92
boh7850x_CL2.p092-101.indd 92
10/9/08 8:30:09 AM
10/9/08 8:30:09 AM
C L U S T E R
the developing
learner
EARLY CHILDHOOD
MIDDLE SCHOOL
HIGH SCHOOL
ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
Module 7:
Cognitive Development
Outline and Learning Goals 118 Constructivist Theories of Cognitive
Development 119 Issues in Cognitive Development:
Piaget and Vygotsky 125 Applications: Principles for Effective
Teaching 128 Summary 130 Key Concepts 130 Case Studies: Re
flect and Evaluate 131
Module 8:
Language Development
Outline and Learning Goals 133 Understanding Language
Acquisition 134 Development of Language Skills 136 Applications: Encouraging Language
Development in the Classroom 144 Summary 147 Key Concepts 147 Case Studies: Re
flect
and Evaluate 148
2
boh7850x_CL2.p092-101.indd 93
boh7850x_CL2.p092-101.indd 93
10/9/08 8:30:26 AM
10/9/08 8:30:26 AM
94
Prepare:
As you read the case, make notes:
1.
WHO
are the primary participants in the case?
Describe them.
2.
WHAT
is taking place?
3.
WHERE
is the case taking place? Is the environment
a factor?
4.
WHEN
is the case taking place? Is the timing a factor?
I
t
’s Fire Safety Week at Rolling Hills Preschool, a half-day preschool in the small suburban town of
Westview. Mrs. Grace Palmer, the head teacher for nearly 20 years, is supervising Angela Hodan, a
student teacher from a university in a neighboring city. Angela begins today
’s activities by explaining
emergency situations for dialing 9-1-1 and having children practice how to dial 9-1-1 on pretend phones.
She also has the children recite basic safety information, such as their
first and last names, address,
phone number, and parents
’ names. The children trace the digits of their phone numbers on giant
flash-cards that Angela prepared to help them recite their phone numbers, and then they color and
decorate them.
“I’m going to pick pink first,” says Michala. “I’m trying to stay in the lines.”
“I like purple best,” says her best friend, Brianna. “You know, my
dad
’s a firefighter. He’s coming to visit our school tomorrow.”
As Angela listens to the chatter and observes the coloring, she
feels satis
fied that things seem to be going smoothly.
On Tuesday morning, the preschool classroom is buzzing with
excitement because the children are expecting a visit from the
Westview Volunteer Fire Department. After snack time, Angela
announces,
“Boys and girls, please find a spot on the carpet. We’re
going to read a story about
fire safety while we wait for the firefighters
to arrive.
”
Brianna and her best friend, Michala, rush to sit on the letter M
on the alphabet rug, the coveted spot opposite the teacher. The girls
begin pushing and shoving as each tries to occupy the letter M
space.
“I was here first!” Michala shouts.
“No you weren’t!” Brianna responds.
“Well, M is for Michala, so I can sit here!” Michala yells, almost in tears.
Angela asks the girls to apologize to each other and suggests
that they sit on two different letters today, F for
firefighter, and D for
dragon, the main character in the story they are about to read.
Brianna and Michala are happy that they can sit next to each other,
because no one has chosen to sit on the E. Angela eagerly
announces,
“I need all of you to put on your listening ears for our
story.
” Once the children have settled down, Angela sits in a tiny
chair at the center of the carpet and begins to read No Dragons for
Tea: Fire Safety for Kids, a rhyming book about a dragon who starts
a
fire at a girls’ tea party. As Angela finishes the story, distant sirens
grow louder and louder.
“The firefighters are here!” some of the
children shriek, wriggling with excitement. Angela leads them outside
for a tour of the
fire truck.
Back inside, the children take their seats while
firefighters Dan
and Tracy, in full gear, demonstrate what to do and what not to do in
a
fire situation. “If you hear a smoke alarm when you’re in bed,
should you hide under your covers?
” Dan asks.
“Oooh! Oooh! I know,” says Brenden. “You don’t hide in your
bed. The dragon in our story hided under a rug when he started a
fire. That was bad.”
“Right, that’s not safe. You never hide in the house if there’s a
fire. You get out!” replies Tracy. The firefighters continue to
demonstrate safety tips, such as feeling a door for heat before
opening it, crawling low under smoke, and stop-drop-and-roll, with
each child practicing in turn. When the
firefighters leave, everyone
receives a shiny, red
fire hat as
1
Early Childhood
2
Fire Safety
boh7850x_CL2.p092-101.indd 94
boh7850x_CL2.p092-101.indd 94
10/9/08 8:30:30 AM
10/9/08 8:30:30 AM
a reward for learning the safety rules. The children eagerly line up to go outside. They can
’t wait to play firefighters on
the playground!
In the last half-hour of preschool, Angela reviews what they learned from the
firefighters. “Who can tell me what
we do if our clothes catch
fire?” Several children happily drop to the floor and begin rolling around. “Okay, I see you
remember stop-drop-and-roll. Now, what number do we call in a
fire emergency?” Angela asks.
“9-1-1!!” they all shout.
“And where do we call 9-1-1?” she asks. The children look confused. “Where did the mommy in the story call
9-1-1? From her house?
” asks Angela.
Raising her hand, Dominique answers,
“She ran to her neighbor’s house.”
“That’s right. She went to a safe place to make the phone call,” Angela responds. “We need to give our address
when we call 9-1-1 so the
firefighters know where the fire is. Aakshi, can you tell me where you live?”
“Two-two . . . uhhm . . .” Aakshi pauses.
“2249 Hunter’s . . .” Angela hints.
“2249 Hunter’s Ridge Road,” Aakshi replies. The children all have a turn at recalling their addresses and phone
numbers.
After the children leave, Grace and Angela discuss how the
fire safety lessons are going. Grace listens as
Angela describes what she thinks was effective and what wasn
’t working. Together they identify what needs to be
changed and come up with some modi
fications of the lessons for the rest of the week. They agree to meet at the end
of each day to evaluate the children
’s learning and Angela’s teaching.
Assess
EARLY CHILDHOOD
MIDDLE SCHOOL
HIGH SCHOOL
ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
1. Would you consider Rolling Hills Preschool a stimulating environment for four-year-olds? Why or why not?
3
2. In your opinion, are the lessons that Angela prepared appropriate for preschool children? Why or why not?
3. Based on your knowledge of preschool-age children, describe their language skills. Can you
find examples of
preschool language skills in the case?
boh7850x_CL2.p092-101.indd 95
boh7850x_CL2.p092-101.indd 95
10/9/08 8:30:34 AM
10/9/08 8:30:34 AM
96
Prepare:
As you read the case, make notes:
1.
WHO
are the primary participants in the case? Describe them.
2.
WHAT
is taking place?
3.
WHERE
is the case taking place? Is the environment a factor?
4.
WHEN
is the case taking place? Is the timing a factor?
A
I
n March, students in Mr. Carlos Morales
’s fifth-grade class begin a project-based unit in social studies. They
choose a topic for their project based on any of the social studies units they have completed during the school year.
Carlos has provided them with a long list of topics from
five areas: Native Americans, explorers, colonial America,
forming a government, and the westward movement. The students begin by conducting research in the school
’s
media center with the help of Linda Porter, the library media specialist, who taught them to
find information on their
topics using encyclopedias and Internet searches. Carlos knows that his students need to develop and practice these
important research skills.
After students have compiled and read information they collected on their chosen topics, Carlos forms
“research
evaluation teams
” to help students learn to identify important information and evaluate their sources. In research
teams, each student has an opportunity to explain to the others what information they think they should include in
their projects and why it is important. To help team members evaluate the presenter
’s ideas, Carlos gives them
question starters:
Project Night
Elementary School
n
“Can you make your point clearer?”
n
“An even better idea is . . . .”
n
“I’d like to know more about . . . .”
Carlos likes using this procedure. It helps improve the quality of the projects by giving students practice at
evaluating their own and others
’ thinking. The question starters also have been especially helpful for the bilingual
students who are not as
fluent in English. Carlos monitors students’ progress in the research teams and assists when
needed. Research teams continue for several weeks, until everyone has had a turn to present his or her project
resources.
Students then meet individually with Carlos to pick a project design. They have many choices, including:
n
writing a skit,
n
writing a poem,
n
creating a painting or sculpture,
n
developing storybooks,
n
developing a board game,
n
writing songs to illustrate an era, and
n
writing a newspaper article or a letter from the perspective of a historical
figure.
Carlos thinks that the range of options will allow right-brained and left-brained students alike to use their
strengths. He has arranged some time each week for students to work on their projects at school, and he has
provided as many supplies as possible to sup-
boh7850x_CL2.p092-101.indd 96
boh7850x_CL2.p092-101.indd 96
10/9/08 8:30:39 AM
10/9/08 8:30:39 AM
B
C
port their projects (paints, clay, wardrobe items). Because his students
come from diverse socioeconomic backgrounds, he wants every child
to have an equal opportunity for success.
Project Night has
finally arrived, and it’s as much fun for Carlos as
it is for his students. It
’s a wonderful opportunity for students to show
off their class projects to students in other grades, teachers, and
parents. Carlos enjoys viewing the projects of students in other
grades, conversing with his students
’ parents, and beaming over the
success of all his students. As Project Night winds down, Carlos
announces to his students,
“Class, I want to congratulate you all on
your hard work and achievement. Give yourselves a pat on the back.
”
Parents and children clap enthusiastically.
“Make sure you enjoy some
refreshments
— you’ve earned it. Thanks everyone, and have a good
evening.
”
Later that evening, Carlos reviews the project self-evaluations students turned in before they left.
“I liked that we got to choose a project. So I picked something that interested me.”—Ahmad
“My favorite subject is art. So I liked this project because I got to
make something to show what I learned. I was happy I didn
’t have
to take a test. I always do bad on multiple choice. Thanks, Mr.
Morales.
”—Isaac (student with a learning disability)
“Working in the research teams was fun and helped me think
more about what I wanted to do for a project. Doing projects is
better than tests. I don
’t like memorizing a lot of facts.”—Leah
“I learned a lot. The research was hard and it took a long time to
read. But I had fun in the media center and in the research teams.
It would be more fun to do group projects.
”—Sonia (a
Spanish-English bilingual student)
Carlos is surprised that many students made comments like Sonia
’s
about wanting to work in groups. He is also disturbed that not much
self-re
flection is evident in the self-evaluations. But, as always, his
students
’ comments give him much food for thought about how to
improve the project unit next year.
1. Was Carlos correct in assuming that students are right-brained
or left-brained? Is your response opinion, speculation, or based on
some source, such as a course, a textbook, or a news report?
2. In your opinion, is the lack of re
flection in the students’
self-evaluations typical of
fifth graders? Why or why not?
3. Based on the students
’ comments, are their language skills typical of fifth graders? Why or why not?
Assess
EARLY CHILDHOOD
MIDDLE
SCHOOL
HIGH SCHOOL
ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
boh7850x_CL2.p092-101.indd 97
boh7850x_CL2.p092-101.indd 97
10/9/08 8:30:43 AM
10/9/08 8:30:43 AM
98
Prepare:
As you read the case, make notes:
1.
WHO
are the primary participants in the case?
Describe them.
2.
WHAT
is taking place?
3.
WHERE
is the case taking place? Is the environment
a factor?
4.
WHEN
is the case taking place? Is the timing a factor?
A
s the second-period bell rings Monday morning at Exeter Middle School, eighth-grade students begin
filing into their science labs. This morning in Ms. Morgan Thesdale’s biology lab, students will be
dissecting frogs. Dissection is a new addition to the district
’s curriculum, and Morgan, who taught
tenth-grade biology for three years, is eager to try dissection with middle school students. She
’s sure the
students will enjoy the hands-on format.
After students take their seats, Morgan brie
fly covers laboratory
procedures, han dling and storing the frogs, and the lab
’s
objectives. She reminds students that one objective is to
compare the frog
’s body systems to those of humans
and discuss the similarities and differences between frogs and
humans. She then divides students into six groups of three. Students
will take different roles: cutting and probing, drawing the frog
’s
body systems, and taking lab notes on their discussions.
During
the lab, Morgan walks around the room to monitor the
groups and join in their discussions.
Alanna, Yumi, and Keon have already made their
first incision,
have sketched the diagram of their dissection, and are discussing
what they saw as Yumi took notes. Morgan stops to compliment their
progress. Then she walks toward Haley, Kyla, and Erin, who are not
as far along.
“Kyla, like I heard Robert asked you out. Is that true?”
Haley asks as Erin tries to draw the frog diagram and listen at the
same time.
“Yeah, but my parents won’t let me go out on a date yet. So
we
’re going bowling this weekend like with a bunch of us. You wanna
. . .
” Kyla says, as Morgan interrupts.
“Ladies, I’m not sure how this relates to biology. Keep your
conversations on the frog, please,
” Morgan warns.
Morgan notices that Jay, Tyler, and Vincent are also talking. But
they insist that they are already
finished. However, when Morgan
asks them questions about the frog
’s digestive organs, it is clear that
they have not done much discussing at all. Jay, who is outgoing and
a natural-born leader, did the cutting, while Vincent sketched and
Tyler took notes. Tyler, who was born with fetal alcohol syndrome
and has a language delay, receives special education
accommodations such as extended time tests and notetakers.
Morgan is perturbed at the boys for assigning Tyler to a note-taking
role, for speeding through the lab assignment without any discussion
or collaboration, and for not taking Tyler under their wing. Morgan
finishes making her way around the room and tries to initiate and
support students
’ discussions in the rest of the groups—she realizes
that the students need a lot more assistance with the comparing and
contrasting than she originally thought.
On Friday, students take a lab exam. They rotate through
several stations set up in the classroom showing frogs at different
stages of dissection. Students identify organs, indicated by tags, by
filling in the diagrams on their exam sheets.
The following Friday, after the class
finishes the unit on body
systems, students take a written exam that includes questions about
some of the same items from the lab exam, as well as
multiple-choice and essay questions.
On Monday Morgan hands back the lab and the written exams.
“Class, the good news is that everyone did pretty well on the lab
exam. However, I
’m very disappointed in the results of the written
exam. Many of you did
fine on the lab questions and multiple-choice
Middle School
Frogs
boh7850x_CL2.p092-101.indd 98
boh7850x_CL2.p092-101.indd 98
10/9/08 8:30:49 AM
10/9/08 8:30:49 AM
B
+
EARLY CHILDHOOD
MIDDLE
SCHOOL
HIGH SCHOOL
ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
questions. But I was disappointed by many of your essay responses. I
expected to see a lot more explanation to show me that you were
thinking, but I saw a lot of regurgitation of facts.
”
“But Morgan, I studied a lot,” says Keon. “I can even show you my flashcards.”
“Yeah, Morgan, some of us studied together. We quizzed each
other on the de
finitions in the notes and the textbook,” Haley chimes
in, as Erin, Kyla, and others nod.
Vincent raises his hand and comments,
“Your test questions are
tricky. I mean . . . the multiple-choice questions are not exactly like the
de
finitions in the book.”
“I’m not sure I even understood some of the questions!” Alanna
adds.
“I mean, you know, what does exemplify mean, anyway, and I
don
’t know how to even compare the former with the latter.”
Morgan and the students continue to discuss study techniques.
She is glad she took the time to discuss this important issue. But she
knows inside that in order to get students to learn material in a
meaningful way, she has to make changes in her teaching as well.
Assess
1. In your opinion, what role
—if any—should knowledge of
adolescent brain development play in teacher planning of curricula
and teaching methods?
2. Should Morgan have the same expectations for teaching biology
in middle school and in high school? Why or why not?
3. How would you describe the language skills of the middle school students in this case?
%
boh7850x_CL2.p092-101.indd 99
boh7850x_CL2.p092-101.indd 99
10/9/08 8:30:53 AM
10/9/08 8:30:53 AM
100
Prepare:
As you read the case, make notes:
1.
WHO
are the primary participants in the case?
Describe them.
2.
WHAT
is taking place?
3.
WHERE
is the case taking place? Is the environment
a factor?
4.
WHEN
is the case taking place? Is the timing a factor?
A
s the
fi
rst-period bell rings Monday morning, a hush falls over Mr. Reddy
’s British literature class
as a young man in his 20s walks through the classroom door. A new substitute teacher! Mr. Reddy was to
return to work after a recent surgery, but due to complications he would be on medical leave for the
remainder of the semester. Mr. Jake Matthews has been hired as a long-term substitute.
“Good morning
class. I
’m Mr. Matthews. I’ll be taking over Mr. Reddy’s classes while he’s on medical leave. I understand
you
’re reading A Tale of Two Cities, one of my favorite novels,” he says. Mr. Matthews, a newly certified
secondary education teacher, exudes con
fidence and energy. The students definitely are not used to
someone so young and vibrant.
Mr. Reddy is predictable and
—well, boring. He assigns his junior
class chapters of the book to read, they come to class, and he
lectures for most of the 50-minute class about the progression of the
plot or about Dickens
’s life while he was writing the novel. The
students take notes and study for exams on the books they are
reading.
But this morning Mr. Matthews stands in front of the class,
leaning against the teach-er
’s desk. The students all look at Mr.
Matthews and then at each other, not sure what to expect. They are
eager for a change of pace from Mr. Reddy
’s usual routine.
“Where did you leave off?” Mr. Matthews asks the
class. Maya raises her hand sheepishly.
“The Jackal . . . page 89. That’s where we are,” she says.
“Great. Let’s start by recapping where we are in the novel. Who
wants to start off? You, sir, in the yellow shirt next to the window,
what
’s your name?”
“Dylan,” the boy says.
“Dylan, what’s been happening in the plot?” asks Mr. Matthews.
Dylan looks back at Mr. Matthews with a blank stare. He hasn
’t kept
up with the reading and has fallen asleep in class several times.
Dylan comes from a single-parent home and his mother works the
late shift. Recently, he has been hanging out late at night with older
adolescents, some of whom have dropped out of school. Rumor has
it that he has started drinking and smoking. So he easily falls asleep
at 8:00 A.M., especially when Mr. Reddy drones on.
“Who can help him out?” Mr. Matthews asks.
“We’re not sure,” says Collin, the outgoing junior class vice
president.
“Mr. Reddy doesn’t really ask us any questions. We just
listen to him and take notes.
”
“Hmmm,” Mr. Matthews replies pensively. “Well, we’re not going
to do that. I know this is a challenging story with some archaic
language. But the only way to understand it is to jump into it with two
feet and enjoy it. Let
’s start by discussing the historical backdrop for
the novel.
” Mr. Matthews is a history buff and is eager to begin by
telling the students about the late 1700s in London.
“Excuse me, Mr. Matthews. Should we be taking notes? I mean .
. . will this be on the test?
” asks Felicia. Felicia has always been
extremely anxious about taking tests and doing well.
“Don’t worry about any tests for now. What’s more important
right now is that you listen and get a feel for the setting,
” replies Mr.
Matthews.
High School
The Substitute
boh7850x_CL2.p092-101.indd 100
boh7850x_CL2.p092-101.indd 100
10/9/08 8:31:00 AM
10/9/08 8:31:00 AM
EARLY CHILDHOOD
MIDDLE
SCHOOL
HIGH SCHOOL
ELEMENTARY SCHOOL
The students sit on the edge of their seats, hanging onto Mr.
Matthews
’s every word. He has a way of lecturing that is more like
camp
fire storytelling. Even Dylan is staying awake.
As the bell rings for next period, Mr. Matthews announces,
“Be
sure you
finish reading the next chapter for tomorrow. I have a special
activity planned.
”
The next day, as students take their seats, wondering what Mr.
Matthews has in store for them, he begins passing out booklets. Is this
a quiz? they wonder.
“Okay, everyone, these are scripts I prepared for today’s class,”
Mr. Matthews announces.
“Don’t worry. You will all get a turn acting in
a skit before we
’ve finished the novel. For today, I’d like some
volunteers. Who wants to be
first?”
Jody, Mason, and Demeri raise their hands. Demeri, a bilingual
student who recently transferred to this school, for the
first time feels
comfortable participating. Because the school does not have a
separate bilingual program, Demeri was placed in British literature
without any bilingual supports, even though his English reading skills
are two grade levels below those of his peers.
“Great! An eager bunch!” Mr. Matthews says. “Now, the rest of
you can follow along in your scripts.
” The students begin the skit as
the rest of the class watches attentively. Mr. Matthews can tell they
are enjoying themselves.
After the skit, Mr. Matthews arranges students in groups of four
and hands out a sheet of guided questions, including these:
n
Place yourself in the scene of the novel you acted out today.
n
How do you feel
—what are your thoughts, your reactions?
n
How do you think the characters felt?
n
What do you think will happen next? Why?
Mr. Matthews instructs,
“I want you to first answer the questions
by yourselves. Write down your responses in your notebooks. These
won
’t be collected. They’re only for your reference. Once each
member of your group is done, discuss your points of view in your
groups for about 15 minutes. You may take notes if you want.
” The
students immediately begin writing. Soon the room is
filled with noise.
1. Imagine that you are a new high school teacher like Mr.
Matthews. What might you want to know about the brain and its
development in adolescence? Think of some speci
fic questions
you might have.
2. In your opinion, is British literature developmentally appropriate
for juniors in high school? What about freshmen?
3. What aspects of language development should a high school teacher be
concerned about?
Assess
boh7850x_CL2.p092-101.indd 101
boh7850x_CL2.p092-101.indd 101
10/9/08 8:31:03 AM
10/9/08 8:31:03 AM