1
Secured short-term
financing
Tomasz Słoński, PhD
2
Pledging of accounts
receivable
• Pledging of accounts receivable, or
putting accounts receivable into a
security loan, is characterized by the
fact that the lender not only has a
claim against the receivables but also
has recourse to the borrower.
• Therefore, the risk of default on the
pledged accounts remains with the
borrower.
3
Procedure of pledging
accounts receivables
• It is initiated by a legally binding agreement
between the seller of the goods and the
financing institution
• Agreement sets forth in detail the
procedures to be followed and the legal
obligations of both parties.
• The seller periodically takes a batch of
invoices to the financing institution.
• The lender reviews the invoices and makes
the credit appraisals of the buyers (invoices
of companies that do not meet the credit
standards are not accepted for pledging
4
Risk in pledging of accounts
receivable
• The financial institution seeks to protect
itself in every phase of the operation:
1. The selection of sound invoices is one
way the lender safeguard itself.
2. If the buyer of the goods does not pay
the lender still has recourse against the
seller
3. The loan will be generally the less than
100% of the pledged receivables
5
Factoring accounts
receivable
• Involves the purchase of accounts
receivable by the lender, generally without
recourse to the borrower
• The buyer of the goods is typically notified
of the transfer and is asked to make
payment directly to the financial institution.
• Since the factoring firm assumes the risk of
default of bad debts, it must make a credit
check (it provides not only the money, but
also a credit department for the borrower)
6
Procedures for factoring
accounts receivables
• Again, an agreement between the seller
and the factor specifies legal obligations
and procedural arrangements
• When the seller receives an order from
the buyer a credit approval slip is sent
to factor for a credit check.
• After approval, shipment is made and
the buyer is notified to make payment
directly to the buyer company.
• If the factor does not approve the sale,
the seller generally refuses to fill the
order; if the sale is made anyway, the
factor will not buy the account.
7
The factor performs three
functions
1. Credit checking
2. Lending
3. Risk bearing
• However, the seller may use a
combination of these functions
by changing provisions in the
factoring agreement.
8
Factoring process
• Factoring is normally a continuous process
instead of the single cycle just described.
• Once the routine has been established,
continuous circular flow of goods and funds
take place between the seller, the buyer, and
the factor.
• If the factoring agreement is in force, funds
from this source are spontaneous in the
sense that the increase in sales will
automatically generate additional credit
9
Cost of receivables financing
• Both accounts receivables pledging and
factoring are convenient and advantageous,
but they can be costly.
• The credit-checking and risk-bearing fee is 1
to 3 % of the amount invoices accepted, and
it may be even more if buyers are poor
credit risk
• The cost of money is reflected in the interest
rate (usually 2 to 3% above the prime rate)
charged on the unpaid balance of the funds
advanced by the factor.
10
Advantages of receivables
financing
1.
The flexibility of this source of
financing
2.
Receivables may be use as a security
for loans that would not otherwise be
granted
3.
The factoring might provide the
services of a credit department that
might otherwise be available at a
higher cost
11
Disadvantages of receivables
financing
1.
When invoices are numerous and
relatively small in zloty amount,
the administrative cost involved
might be excessive
2.
Since receivables represent the
firm’s most liquid non-cash assets,
some trade creditors may refuse
on sell on credit to the firm that
pledges or factors its receivables
12
Garden Comfort sales 15 sets of furniture per day. The
sale price is 1450 PLN per set. DSO is 40 days.
Variable costs are 55% of sales. The cost of receivables
collection is 20 thousands PLN. The after tax cost of
capital involved in receivables is 7%.
The bank proposition is to buy 50% of invoices. For 40
days credit the bank counts 1,2% provision. The
collection cost will decrease by 5 thousands PLN. The
effective income tax rate is 20%.
a) Is bank proposition attractive?
b) What is maximum growth rate of sales according to
Cash Conversion Cycle, if current CCC is 65 days and
gross profit margin in one conversion cycle was 20%,
and after the change it will be 18,2%.
Factoring analysis
13
14
Note!
1. In this analysis the usage of capital coming from
reduced receivables is skipped (CCC is 20 days
shorter).
2. The effective rate, instead of nominal rate, should
be used. The effective cost is equal to
([(1+0,012)^9]-1)*(7 830 000/2/9)=11,3% and hence
11,3%*435 000 =49155
ad. b) Current maximum rate of sales growth
=(360/65)*20%=5,5*20%=111%
Maximum rate of sales growth after the change
=(360/45)*18,2%=8*18,2%=145,6%
Those growth rates are adequate rates only if all
benefits are invested in NWC.