&\FHURQ3LHUZV]DPRZDSU]HFLZNR.DW\OLQLH
IUDJP
.LHG\ ZUHV]FLH SU]HVWDQLHV] .DW\OLQR QDGX*\ZDü QDV]HM FLHUSOLZRFL" -DN GáXJR
MHV]F]H EG]LHV] GUZLá ]QDV V]DOHF]H" 'RNG SDQRV]\ü VL EG]LH WD QLHRNLHá]QDQD
]XFKZDáRü"&]\DQLQRFQDVWUD*QD3DODW\QLHDQLZDUW\QDPLHFLHDQLSU]HUD*HQLHOXGXDQL
]JURPDG]HQLHQDMOHSV]\FK RE\ZDWHOL DQL WR ZDURZQH PLHMVFH SRVLHG]H VHQDWX DQL WZDU]H
LZ]URNW\FKOXG]L*DGQHJRQDWRELHQLHZ\ZDUá\ZUD*HQLD"1LHUR]XPLHV]*HWZRMHSODQ\
RGNU\WR QLH ZLG]LV] *H ]FKZLO XZLDGRPLHQLD RW\P FDáHJR VHQDWX SRNU]\*RZDQ\ ]RVWDá
WZyM VSLVHN" &R RVWDWQLHM FR SRSU]HGQLHM QRF\ URELáH JG]LH E\áH NRJR ]ZRá\ZDáH MDNL
SODQSRZ]LáH±NWR]QDVP\OLV]WHJRQLHZLH"&R]DF]DV\FR]DRE\F]DMH:LHRW\P
VHQDWNRQVXOWRZLG]LDWHQ±*\MH)\MH"%DWR*QDZHWGRVHQDWXSU]\FKRG]LELHU]HXG]LDá
ZSXEOLF]Q\FK QDUDGDFK Z\SDWUXMH LND*GHJR ]QDV Z]URNLHP QD U]H( SU]H]QDF]D $P\
OXG]LH RGZD*QL XZD*DP\ *H GRV\ü URELP\ GOD U]HF]\SRVSROLWHM NLHG\ XQLNDP\ MHJR
ZFLHNáRFL LFLRVyZ 1D PLHUü FL .DW\OLQR QDOH*DáR ]UR]ND]X NRQVXOD MX* GDZQR
SRSURZDG]LüQDWZRMJáRZ±FLJQüW]JXENWyUQDPZV]\VWNLPRGGDZQDJRWXMHV]
3U]HFLH*3XEOLXV]6F\SLRQP*]HZV]HFKPLDUJRGQ\V]DFXQNXMDNRQDMZ\*V]\NDSáDQD
ZLF F]áRZLHN SU\ZDWQ\ ]DELá 7\EHULXV]D *UDNFKD ]D VDP SUyE ]DFKZLDQLD XVWURMHP
U]HF]\SRVSROLWHM DP\ NRQVXORZLH PDP\ FLHUSLHü .DW\OLQ NWyU\ RJQLHP LPLHF]HP
FKFH]QLV]F]\üZLDWFDá\"%RSRPLMDPMX*WDNGDZQHVSUDZ\MDNWR*H*DMXV]6HUZLOLXV]
$KDODZáDVQUN]JáDG]LáG*FHJRGRSU]HZURWX6SXULXV]D0HOLXV]D%\áDE\áDQLHJG\
ZW\P SDVWZLH RGZDJD NWyUD OXG]LRP P*QHJR VHUFD ND]DáD RVWU]HMV]\PL URGNDPL
XQLHV]NRGOLZLDü QLHEH]SLHF]QHJR RE\ZDWHOD QL* QDMJUR(QLHMV]HJR ZURJD 0DP\ .DW\OLQR
VNLHURZDQ SU]HFLZ WRELH XFKZDá VHQDWX VWDQRZF] LVXURZ 5]HF]\SRVSROLWHM QLH EUDN
UR]ZDJLDQL]QDF]HQLDWHJRVWDQX1DVSRZLDGDPRWZDUFLHQDVNRQVXOyZ]DEUDNáR
3U]\SLV\
:U6F\SLRQ1D]\NDSU]HFLQDMFZDKDQLDNRQVXOD3XEOLXV]D0XFMXV]D6FHZROL
ZH]ZDáGRWHJR]DEyMVWZDVáRZDPLÄ.WRFKFHUDWRZDüU]HF]SRVSROLWQLHFKUXV]D]DPQ´
3RQW\ILNDWQLHE\áXU]GHPPDJLVWUDWXU
&\FHURQ VWRVXQNRZR áDJRGQLH RFHQLD WX UHIRUPDWRUVNLH ]DPLHU]HQLD *UDNFKyZ
SRQLHZD*SU]HFLZVWDZLDMHDQDUFKLVW\F]Q\PSODQRP.DW\OLQ\
6HUZLOLXV] $KDOD ± PDJLVWHU HTXLWXP ZZRMVNX G\NWDWRUD /XFMXV]D .ZLQFMXV]D
&\QF\QQDWD 6SXULXV] 0HOLXV] HNZLWD FLJQá QD VLHELH SRGHMU]HQLD RFKü ]DJDUQLFLD
ZáDG]\SRQLHZD*ZRNUHVLHGUR*\]Q\RPLHOLáVLVSU]HGDZDü]ER*HSRQL*HMFHQXVWDORQ\FK
RGPyZLZV]\VWDZLHQLDVLQDZH]ZDQLHG\NWDWRUD]JLQá]UNL$KDOLZU
IUDJP
6NRURGRWHJRGRV]áR.DW\OLQRNRF]FR]DF]áXVWSZUHV]FLH]PLDVWD%UDP\VWRM
RWZRUHPUXV]DM=DGáXJRMX*REy]0DQOLXV]RZ\GRSRPLQDVLRVZHJRZRG]D=DELHU]]H
VRE ZV]\VWNLFK VZRLFK OXG]L DSU]\QDMPQLHM ]DELHU] LFK MDN QDMZLFHM 2F]\ü PLDVWR
8ZROQLV] PQLH RG QLHPDáHM WURVNL ± E\OHE\ PXU PQLH RG FLHELH RGG]LHOLá ) QDPL GáX*HM
SU]HE\ZDüQLHPR*HV]1LH]QLRVWHJRQLHFLHUSLQLHSR]ZRO:LHONZG]LF]QRüZLQQL
MHVWHP\ ERJRP QLHPLHUWHOQ\P DSU]HGH ZV]\VWNLP VDPHPX -RZLV]RZL 6WDWRURZL
QDMGDZQLHMV]HPX RSLHNXQRZL WHJR PLDVWD *H MX* W\OH UD]\ XQLNQOLP\ WDN RK\GQHM WDN
VWUDV]QHMWDNEOLVNLHM]DJáDG\U]HF]\SRVSROLWHM1DMZ\*V]HGREURU]HF]\SRVSROLWHMQLHPR*H
E\üXVWDZLF]QLH]DJUR*RQH]SRZRGXMHGQHJRF]áRZLHND-DNGáXJR.DW\OLQRQDVWDZDáHQD
PQLH JG\ E\áHP Z\]QDF]RQ\P NRQVXOHP QLH XFLHNDáHP VL GR RFKURQ\ SDVWZRZHM
LEURQLáHPVLVWRVXMFZáDVQHURGNLRVWUR*QRFL1DRVWDWQLFKNRPLFMDFKNRQVXODUQ\FK
NLHG\FKFLDáHQD3ROX0DUVRZ\P]JáDG]Lü]DUyZQRPQLHNRQVXODMDNVZRLFKU\ZDOLG]LNL
VSUDZQHMSRPRF\SU]\MDFLyáXNUyFLáHPWZRMH]EURGQLF]H]DSG\QLHZV]F]\QDMFSU]\W\P
*DGQHJR ]DPLHV]DQLD ,OHNURü ZUHV]FLH QD PQLH JRG]LáH VDP VWDZLDáHP FL F]RáD FKRü
ZLHG]LDáHP*HPRMDPLHUüSRFLJQáDE\]DVRERJURPQLHV]F]FLDGODSDVWZD7HUD]MX*
RWZDUFLHJRG]LV]ZFDáU]HF]SRVSROLWZLW\QLHERJyZQLHPLHUWHOQ\FKGRP\ZPLDVWDFK
*\FLHZV]\VWNLFKRE\ZDWHOL,WDOLFDáZLHG]LHV]GR]JXE\L]QLV]F]HQLD3RQLHZD*ZLFQLH
PLHP MHV]F]H WHJR XF]\QLü FR MHVW PRLP SLHUZV]\P RERZL]NLHP LFR MHVW ]JRGQH
]FKDUDNWHUHPWHJRXU]GXL]Z\F]DMDPLQDV]\FKSU]RGNyZRELRUVSRVyEPQLHMVXURZ\DOH
MHOLFKRG]LRRFDOHQLHQDVZV]\VWNLFK±EDUG]LHMVNXWHF]Q\%RMHOLND*FLVWUDFLüUHV]WD
EDQG\VSLVNRZFyZSR]RVWDQLHZNUDMX$OHMHOLW\VLZ\PNQLHV]MDNMX*RGGDZQDFLUDG]
Z\JDUQLHV]]PLDVWDVSRUOLF]EVZRLFKNDPUDWyZ±WUR]NáDGDMFSDVWZR]JQLOL]Q,Fy*
.DW\OLQR" &]\ ZDKDV] VL QD PyM UR]ND] WHJR GRNRQDü FR MX* VDP GREURZROQLH ]DF]á"
.RQVXOND*HZURJRZLRSXFLüPLDVWR3\WDV]PQLHF]\PDV]LüQDZ\JQDQLH1LHND*FL
WHJRDOHMHOLPQLHS\WDV]R]GDQLH±GRUDG]DP
3U]\SLV\
6WDWRU±GRVáRZQLH]DWU]\PXMF\VFZRMVNRZXFLHF]FHSU]\GRPHNWHQUR]XPLDQ\
MHVW WDN*H LQDF]HM ÄEyJ G]LNL NWyUHPX V W RL PLDVWR LSDVWZR´ :J SRGDQLD SLHUZV]
ZLW\QL]EXGRZDá-RZLV]RZL6WDWRURZL5RPXOXVZF]DVLHZDON]6DELQDPL
:F]DVLHZ\ERUXNRQVXOyZQDU
IUDJP
2MFRZLH ]JURPDG]HQL FKFLDáE\P WHUD] XVSUDZLHGOLZLü VL LREURQLü SU]HG SHZQ\P
]DU]XWHP MDNLP SRQLHNG VáXV]QLH PRJáDE\ PQLH REDUF]\ü RMF]\]QD SLOQLH ZLF SURV]
Z\VáXFKDMFLH WHJR FR SRZLHP LQLHFK WH VáRZD JáERNR ]DSDGQ ZZDV]H XP\Vá\ LVHUFD
*G\E\ RMF]\]QD NWyUD PL MHVW VWRNURü GUR*V]D QDG *\FLH JG\E\ FDáD ,WDOLD FDáD
U]HF]SRVSROLWD WDN VL GR PQLH RGH]ZDáD Ä&R URELV] 0DUNX 7XOOLXV]X" &]áRZLHNRZL
NWyUHJRX]QDáH]DZURJDZNWyU\PZLG]LV]SU]\ZyGFSU]\V]áHMUHEHOLLNWyUHJRUR]ND]yZ
MDN ZLHV] RF]HNXM ZRER]LH QLHSU]\MDFLyá NWyU\ MHVW RUJDQL]DWRUHP LJáRZ ]EURGQLF]HJR
VSLVNX NWyU\ EXQWXMH QLHZROQLNyZ L]UXMQRZDQ\FK RE\ZDWHOL ± WDNLHPX F]áRZLHNRZL W\
SR]ZROLV]VSRNRMQLHRGHMüDE\PyZLRQR*H]DPLDVWZ\GDOLüJR]PLDVWDVDPJRGR5]\PX
ZSXFLáH"1LHND*HV]JR]DNXüZNDMGDQ\SRZOHFQDVWUDFHQLHSRGGDü]DNDUQDMVUR*V]\P
PF]DUQLRP" &R FL MHV]F]H ZVWU]\PXMH" &]\*E\ RE\F]DM SU]RGNyZ" 7R* ZQDV]\P
SDVWZLH EDUG]R F]VWR QDZHW OXG]LH SU\ZDWQL NDUDOL PLHUFL QLHEH]SLHF]Q\FK RE\ZDWHOL
&]\ PR*H XVWDZ\ NWyU\PL REZDURZDQR JDUGáRZH VSUDZ\ RE\ZDWHOL U]\PVNLFK" 7R*
OXG]LH NWyU]\ VSU]HQLHZLHU]\OL VL U]HF]\SRVSROLWHM QLJG\ QLH ]DFKRZ\ZDOL ZW\P PLHFLH
SUDZRE\ZDWHOVNLFK&]\ERLV]VLQLHQDZLFLSRWRPQ\FK"=DLVWHSLNQLHRGZG]LF]DV]VL
QDURGRZLU]\PVNLHPXNWyU\FLHELHF]áRZLHNDRRVRELVW\PUR]JáRVLHQLHSRSDUW\P]DVáXJDPL
SU]RGNyZWDNV]\ENRZ\QLyVáGRQDMZ\*V]HMJRGQRFLSRZV]\VWNLFKVWRSQLDFKXU]GQLF]HM
NDULHU\±MHOL]REDZ\SU]HGQLHQDZLFLF]\MDNLPQLHEH]SLHF]HVWZHPOHNFHZD*\V]*\FLH
ZVSyáRE\ZDWHOL$MHOLFKRG]LRVWUDFKSU]HGQLHQDZLFLWRQLHSRZLQLHQHVLREDZLDü*H
FLEDUG]LHM]QLHQDZLG]]DVXURZRüLRGZDJQL*]DJQXQRüLQLNF]HPQRü&]\VG]LV]
*HNLHG\ZRMQDVSXVWRV]\,WDOLNLHG\SOGURZDüEGPLDVWDLSRGSDODüGRP\±QLHVSáRQLHV]
LW\ZRJQLXSRZV]HFKQHMQLHQDZLFL"´
1D WHQ F]FLJRGQ\ JáRV U]HF]\SRVSROLWHM LQD ]DU]XW\ OXG]L NWyU]\ P\O SRGREQLH
ZSDUX VáRZDFK RGSRZLHP 2MFRZLH ]JURPDG]HQL JG\E\P X]QDá *H QLF LQQHJR PL QLH
SR]RVWDMH MDN .DW\OLQ PLHUFL XNDUDü DQL JRG]LQ\ GáX*HM QLH SR]ZROLáE\P *\ü WHPX
EDQG\FLH %R MHOL SU]HODQD NUHZ ZLHONLFK OXG]L LQDMVáDZQLHMV]\FK RE\ZDWHOL 6DWXUQLQD
*UDNFKyZ )ODNNXVD LZLHOX LQQ\FK ZLFKU]\FLHOL QLH W\ONR QLH VSODPLáD DOH SU]HFLZQLH
QDZHWLP]DV]F]\WSU]\QLRVáDWR]DSHZQHLMDQLHPLDáHPSRZRGXVLREDZLDü*HVWUDFHQLH
WHJRPRUGHUF\ZVSyáRE\ZDWHOLFLJQLHQDPQLHZSU]\V]áRFLMDNQLHQDZLü$FKRüE\PL
RQDMDNQDMEDUG]LHMPLDáD]DJUD*Dü]DZV]HE\áHP]GDQLD*HQLHQDZLFLZ\QLNDMFHM]PRLFK
]DOHWQLHSRZLQLHQHPVRELHSRF]\W\ZDü]DKDEDOH]DFKOXE$WROLVZUyGQDVLWDF\
NWyU]\ QLH ZLG] FR QDP JUR]L DOER ZLG]F WR ± XNU\ZDM /XG]LH NWyU]\ VZ\PL
QLH]GHF\GRZDQ\PLJáRVDPLSRGV\FDOLQDG]LHMH.DW\OLQ\LSU]H]VZyMEUDNF]XMQRFLXPRFQLOL
URG]F\VLVSLVHN*G\E\PZ\VWSLáSU]HFLZ.DW\OLQLH]FDáVXURZRFLSUDZDZLHOXOXG]L
RSLHUDMFVLQDLFKSRZDG]HQLHW\ONR]H]áHMZROLDOHZSURVW]QLHZLDGRPRFLPRJáRE\PL
]DU]XFLüRNUXFLHVWZRLGHVSRW\]P7HUD]ZLHP*HMHOL.DW\OLQDWDNMDN]DPLHU]DXGDVL
GRRER]X0DQOLXV]DQLNWQLHEG]LHQDW\OH]DOHSLRQ\E\QLHZLG]LDá*H]RVWDá]DZL]DQ\
VSLVHN QLNW WDN QLHJRG]LZ\ *HE\ WHJR QLH SU]\]QDá $OH ZLHP UyZQLH* *H SU]H] VWUDFHQLH
WHJR MHGQHJR F]áRZLHND PR*QD WR U]HF]\SRVSROLWHM JUR*FH QLHV]F]FLH QD NUyWNR
SRZVWU]\PDüQLHPR*QDJRRGQLHMQD]DZV]H RGZUyFLü 1DWRPLDVW MHOL VDP VL Z\QLHVLH
LVZRLFK ]H VRE ]DELHU]H LMHV]F]H SU]\JDUQLH WDP UHV]W SRFLJDQ\FK ]HZV]G
Z\NROHMHFyZ ZWHG\ QLH W\ONR EG]LHP\ PRJOL SU]HFLü WHQ ZH]EUDQ\ ZU]yG ZFLHOH
U]HF]\SRVSROLWHMDOHWDN*HXVXQüNRU]HLQDVLHQLHZV]HONLHJR]áD
'DZQR MX* ERZLHP ]JURPDG]HQL RMFRZLH REUDFDP\ VL ZUyG QLHEH]SLHF]HVWZ
L]DVDG]HN WHJR VSU]\VL*HQLD QLH ZLHP W\ONR GODF]HJR WH ZV]\VWNLH ]EURGQLH GDZQR
WáXPLRQDZFLHNáRüL]XFKZDOVWZRWHUD]ZáDQLHGRMU]Dá\L]DPRMHJRNRQVXODWXZ\EXFKá\
-HOL ]WHM FDáHM ]JUDL áRWUyZ MHJR MHGQHJR W\ONR VSU]WQLHP\ WR PR*H EG]LH VL QDP
Z\GDZDáR *H QD MDNL F]DV XZROQLOLP\ VL RG WURVN LREDZ QLHEH]SLHF]HVWZR MHGQDN
SR]RVWDQLHW\OH*HJáERNRXWDMRQHZRUJDQL]PLHU]HF]\SRVSROLWHM-DNFL*NRFKRU]\PLRWDQL
JRUF]NLGUHV]F]DPLSRZ\SLFLX]LPQHMZRG\F]XMVL]UD]XOHSLHMDSRWHPJZDáWRZQLHLP
VLSRJDUV]DLMHV]F]HFL*V]DLFKQLHPRFSRZDOD±WDNLFKRUHMU]HF]\SRVSROLWHMXNDUDQLHWHJR
MHGQHJRF]áRZLHNDSU]\QLHVLHXOJDOH]DFKRZDQLHSU]\*\FLXSR]RVWDá\FKW\PJZDáWRZQLHM
]DV]NRG]L 1LHFKDM ZLF OXG]LH ]VXPLHQLD Z\]XFL XVWSL QLHFK VL RG SDWULRWyZ RGVXQ L
ZMHGQ\PPLHMVFX]JURPDG]QLHFKLFKQDUHV]FLHFRFLJOHSRZWDU]DPPXU\PLDVWDRGQDV
RGG]LHO1LHFKSU]HVWDQZGRPXNRQVXODF]\KDüQDMHJR*\FLHWáRF]\üVLZRNyáWU\EXQDáX
PLHMVNLHJR SUHWRUD ]EURQL ZUNX REOHJDü NXUL SU]\JRWRZ\ZDü *DJZLH
LSRFKRGQLH GR SRGSDOHQLD PLDVWD 1LHFK ND*G\ PD QDUHV]FLH Z\SLVDQH QD F]ROH FR P\OL
RU]HF]\SRVSROLWHM2ELHFXMZDPRMFRZLH]JURPDG]HQL*HP\NRQVXORZLHZ\ND*HP\WDN
JRUOLZRü Z\ ± WDN VWDQRZF]Rü U\FHU]H U]\PVF\ ± WDNLH PVWZR ZV]\VF\ XF]FLZL
RE\ZDWHOH ± WDN MHGQRP\OQRü *H SR XVXQLFLX VL .DW\OLQ\ ZV]\VWNLH MHJR ]DP\Vá\
]RVWDQ QD ZDV]\FK RF]DFK RGNU\WH Z\MDQLRQH SRNU]\*RZDQH LXNDUDQH 3RG W ZUy*E
.DW\OLQRGODGREUDFDáHMU]HF]\SRVSROLWHMDQDZáDVQ]JXELQLHV]F]FLHQD]JXEVZRLFK
ZVSyOQLNyZ ZPRUGHUVWZDFK L]EURGQLDFK ± UXV]DM QD ZRMQ SU]HNOW LQLHVSUDZLHGOLZ
-RZLV]X W\ NWyUHPX 5RPXOXV ]ER*HJR QDND]X UD]HP ]W\P PLDVWHP ]EXGRZDá ZLW\QL
NWyUHJR VáXV]QLH QD]\ZDP\ 2SLHNXQHP WHJR PLDVWD LSDVWZD QLH SR]ZyO WHPX
F]áRZLHNRZLLMHJRWRZDU]\V]RPWDUJQüVLQDWZRMHLLQQ\FKERJyZRáWDU]HQDGRP\LPXU\
PLDVWD QD *\FLH LPLHQLH *DGQHJR ]RE\ZDWHOL LVSUDZ DE\ ZURJRZLH XF]FLZ\FK OXG]L
QLHSU]\MDFLHOH RMF]\]Q\ áXSLH*F\ QNDMF\ ,WDOL L]ZL]DQL ]H VRE Z]áHP ]EURGQL
LZVSyOQRWZ\VWSNX]D*\FLDLSRPLHUFLZLHF]QNDUSRQLHOL
3U]\SLV\
2E\ZDWHORZL U]\PVNLHPX VND]DQHPX SU]H] XU]GQLNyZ QD ZL]LHQLH OXE NDU
PLHUFLSU]\VáXJLZDáRSUDZRRGZRáDQLDVLGROXGXOH[GHSURYRFDWLRQH
1DOH*Dá\ GR QLHJR VSUDZ\ F\ZLOQH WU\EXQDá MHJR ± GUHZQLDQ\ SRGHVW QD NWyU\P
VWDáR NU]HVáR XU]GQLND VHOOD FXUXOLV ± ]QDMGRZDá VL RERN ZLW\QL .DVWRUD 2EOHJDQLH
WU\EXQDáXSU]H]VSLVNRZFyZPLDáRQDFHOXVWHUURU\]RZDQLHVG]LHJR
&XULD+RVWLOLD±]Z\NáHPLHMVFHSRVLHG]HVHQDWX
-RZLV] NWyUHJR RU]Há ZVND]Dá QD 5RPXOXVD MDNR SU]\V]áHJR ]DáR*\FLHOD PLDVWD
X]QDQ\]RVWDá]DUD]HP]DRSLHNXQD5]\PXLRWU]\PDáVZRMZLW\QL