.2602/2*,$ ±
3UDZR+XEEOH¶D
35$:2+8%%/(¶$
-X*ZURNX906OLSKHURGNU\á*HOLQLHZLGPRZHSUDZLHZV]\VWNLFKJDODNW\N]DZ\MWNLHP
NLONXQDMEOL*V]\FKSU]HVXQLWHVZUy*Q\PVWRSQLXZVWURQGáXJRIDORZ²NXF]HUZLHQL-HGQDN
GRSLHUR Z URNX ( +XEEOH EDGDMF VNUXSXODWQLH ZLGPD JDODNW\N R ]QDQ\FK MX* ZyZF]DV
RGOHJáRFLDFK Z\]QDF]RQ\FK Uy*Q\PL PHWRGDPL VWZLHUG]Lá LVWQLHQLH OLQLRZHM NRUHODFML SRPLG]\
SU]HVXQLFLHPNXF]HUZLHQLOLQLLZLGPRZ\FKDRGOHJáRFLGRJDODNW\NL,QWHUSUHWXMFWRSU]HVXQLFLH
ZLGPD MDNR HIHNW 'RSSOHUD Z\VXQá PLDá KLSRWH] *H :V]HFKZLDW MDNR FDáRü HNVSDQGXMH L
ZV]\VWNLHRGOHJáRFLZQLPURVQ]F]DVHPDSUGNRüZ]DMHPQHJRRGGDODQLDVLVSHáQLD]DOH*QRü
V
(
D
¸
JG]LHD ²RGOHJáRüGRJDODNW\NL]D ( ²ZVSyáF]\QQLNSURSRUFMRQDOQRFLQD]ZDQ\Sy(QLHMVWDá
+XEEOH¶D-DN]REDF]\P\SRQL*HMRNUHOHQLHÄVWDáD´QLH MHVW Z RJyOQRFL WUDIQH JG\* ZLHONRü WD
]PLHQLDVLZNRVPRORJLF]QHMVNDOLF]DVX/HSLHMMHVWZLFX*\ZDüQD]Z\²SDUDPHWU+XEEOH¶D]D
GODZDUWRFLWHJRSDUDPHWUXZREHFQ\PF]DVLH
T
ZSURZDG]RQRR]QDF]HQLH
(
LGODQLHJRWHUPLQ
ÄVWDáD´MHVWMX*ZSHáQLDGHNZDWQ\:LHORNURWQLHZHU\ILNRZDQRREVHUZDF\MQLHZDUWRüVWDáHM+XEEOH¶D
(
L SRPLDU\ WH ZFL* V SRZWDU]DQH 1D LFK SRGVWDZLH SU]\MPXMH VL REHFQLH ZDUWRü
(
o
NPV0SF2]QDF]DWR*H]ND*G\PPHJDSDUVHNLHPRGOHJáRFLSUGNRüRGGDODQLDVL
RELHNWXRGGRZROQLHZ\EUDQHJRSXQNWXSRF]WNRZHJRQDUDVWDRRNNPV3RQLHZD*Z\VWSXMFHZ
MHGQRVWNDFK VWDáHM +XEEOH¶D NLORPHWU\ RUD] PHJDSDUVHNL PR*QD Z\UD]Lü Z PHWUDFK ZLF SR
XSURV]F]HQLXSU]H]PHWU\SRGVWDZRZMHGQRVWNGODZLHONRFL ( MHVW
;S =
F]\OLRGZURWQRüF]DVX
&]DVWHQF]\OL
(
MHVWFRGRU]GXZLHONRFLSRUyZQ\ZDOQ\]ZLHNLHP:V]HFKZLDWD
2GNU\FLH +XEEOH¶D VWDáR VL LQVSLUDFM GR SRV]XNLZDQLD WDNLFK PRGHOL NRVPRORJLF]Q\FK NWyUH
]DZLHUDá\E\ Z VRELH PR*OLZRü HNVSDQVML 2PDZLDQH RQH EG Z UR]G]LDOH Ä.RVPRORJLF]QH
UR]ZL]DQLDUyZQD(LQVWHLQD´
)XQNFMRQRZDQLH SUDZD +XEEOH¶D PR*HP\ ]DGHPRQVWURZDü JUDILF]QLH QD SU]\NáDG]LH PRGHOX
:V]HFKZLDWD R JHRPHWULL W\SX VIHU\F]QHJR 1LHFK QDV] WUyMZ\PLDURZ SU]HVWU]H UHSUH]HQWXMH
GZXZ\PLDURZD SRZLHU]FKQLD VIHU\ QD NWyUHM Z\ELHUDP\ GZD SXQNW\ ² QS JDODNW\NL L
3URPLHWHMVIHU\LMHMURGHNQLHQDOH*MX*GRQDV]HMSRZLHU]FKQL²VSR]DQLDZLFMDNE\SR]D
W\PPRGHORZ\PZV]HFKZLDWHP2]QDF]DP\VRELHSU]H]
2 T
SURPLHVIHU\ZFKZLOL T]DSU]H]
2 T
T
%
SURPLH SR SHZQ\P F]DVLH
T
%
3RGREQLH RGOHJáRFL SRPLG]\ Z\EUDQ\PL SXQNWDPL
R]QDF]\P\RGSRZLHGQLRSU]H]D RUD]
D a
-DNZLGDüSXQNW\V\PEROL]XMFHJDODNW\NLRGGDOLá\VLRG
VLHELHQLHQDVNXWHNUXFKyZZáDVQ\FKSRSRZLHU]FKQLOHF]QDVNXWHNHNVSDQVMLVDPHMVIHU\
0R*HP\ZLFQDSLVDüSURVWSURSRUFM
D
D
2 T
2 T
T
a
%
6WG
2 T
T
D
D
2 T
%
a
¸
.2602/2*,$ ±
3UDZR+XEEOH¶D
5W
5W
''
W
G G¶
=PLDQDRGOHJáRFLSRPLG]\SXQNWDPLLEG]LH
2 T
T
2 T
D
D
D
D
2 T
%
a
%
¸
']LHOFVWURQDPLSU]H]SU]\URVWF]DVX T
%
GRVWDQLHP\SUGNRüRGGDODQLDVL
D
2 T
T
2 T
V
D
T
2 T
T
%
%
¸
%
¸ %
5R]SR]QDMHP\ Z W\P Z\UD*HQLX ]QDQ\ LORUD] Uy*QLFRZ\ Z JUDQLF\ SRFKRGQ 0R*HP\ ]URELü
ZLFSRGVWDZLHQLH
D2
2
(
( T
2 DT
2
SRNWyU\PIRUPXáDX]\VNXMHSRVWDüSUDZD+XEEOH¶D
V
(
D
¸
:LG]LP\ZLFMDZQLH*HSDUDPHWU
+XEEOH¶D ( MHVW]PLHQQ\ZF]DVLHDWHPSRWHM]PLDQ\]DOH*\RGW\SXPRGHOXNRVPRORJLF]QHJR:
UR]G]LDOHRUR]ZL]DQLDFKNRVPRORJLF]Q\FKSRND*HP\*HQSGODPRGHOXRJHRPHWULLHXNOLGHVRZHM
]DOH*QRü
( T
MHVW
( T
T
3RPLDU\+XEEOH¶D]ODWGRW\F]\á\JDODNW\NRRGOHJáRFLDFKNLONDG]LHVLWOXEQLHZLHOHSRQDG
PLOLRQyZ SDUVHNyZ : WHM V\WXDFML Z]JOGQLH GREU\P SU]\EOL*HQLHP E\áR VWRVRZDQLH
QLHUHODW\ZLVW\F]QHJRZ]RUX'RSSOHUDQDSU]HVXQLFLHNXF]HUZLHQL
V
Z
C
M
M
%
*G\Sy(QLHMRGNU\WREDUG]LHMRGOHJáHJDODNW\NLRUD]NZD]DU\REDUG]RGX*\FKSU]HVXQLFLDFKZLGP
NRQLHF]Q\PVWDáRVLVWRVRZDQLHUHODW\ZLVW\F]QHJRZ]RUX'RSSOHUD
V
C
Z
V
C
M
M
%
-DN ZLGDü ] QLHJR JG\
Z
l d
WR
V
C
l
2EHFQLH QDMGDOV]H L ]DUD]HP QDMVWDUV]H
]DREVHUZRZDQH JDODNW\NL L NZD]DU\ PDM SU]HVXQLFLD NX F]HUZLHQL
Z
=D QDMVWDUV]\
REVHUZRZDQ\RELHNWZH:V]HFKZLHFLHPR*QDX]QDüUHOLNWRZHSURPLHQLRZDQLHWáDNWyUHZFKZLOL
WHUPRG\QDPLF]QHJRRGHUZDQLDVLRGPDWHULLPLDáRWHPSHUDWXUNLONXW\VLF\.HOYLQyZREHFQLH]D
.2602/2*,$ ±
3UDZR+XEEOH¶D
PD
4
. 2GSRZLDGDMFH WHM ]PLDQLH WHPSHUDWXU\ SU]HVXQLFLH NX F]HUZLHQL WHUPLF]QHJR
ZLGPDWHJRSURPLHQLRZDQLDGDMHZDUWRü
Z
U]GX
3UREOHPRGOHJáRFLSU]\GX*\FKZDUWRFLDFK
Z
3UDZR+XEEOH¶DZIRUPLHPR*HVáX*\üGRZ\]QDF]DQLDRGOHJáRFLGRJDODNW\NLNZD]DUyZ3U]\
QLH]E\WGX*\FKZDUWRFLDFKSU]HVXQLFLDNXF]HUZLHQL
Z
GREU\PSU]\EOL*HQLHPMHVWVWRVRZDQLH
ZDUWRFL
(
-HGQDNMDNWRMX*VWZLHUG]LOLP\SDUDPHWU+XEEOH¶D]PLHQLDVLZF]DVLH1LHPR*HP\
ZLFX*\ZDüZDUWRFL
(
GODEDUG]RRGOHJá\FKRELHNWyZU]GXPLOLDUGyZODWZLHWOQ\FKJG\*SU]HG
PLOLDUGDPLODWZDUWRüSDUDPHWUX+XEEOH¶DE\áDLVWRWQLHUy*QDRGG]LVLHMV]HM-HGQRF]HQLHZFKZLOL
HPLVMLREVHUZRZDQHJRG]LZLDWáDWDNLHMJDODNW\NLE\áDRQD]QDF]QLHEOL*HMQDVQL*MHVWZWHMFKZLOL
JG\*ZV]\VWNLHRGOHJáRFLZH:V]HFKZLHFLHE\á\ZyZF]DVPQLHMV]HZLDWáRELHJáRRGJDODNW\NLGR
QDVDZW\PF]DVLH:V]HFKZLDWUR]V]HU]DáVLLWR]H]PLHQQZF]DVLHSUGNRFL3RZVWDMHZLF
SUREOHP²FRZW\PNRQWHNFLH]QDF]\ÄRGOHJáRüGRJDODNW\NL´Z\]QDF]DQD]SUDZD+XEEOH¶D&]\
FKRG]LRRGOHJáRüZFKZLOLHPLVMLZLGRF]QHJRG]LZLDWáDWHMJDODNW\NLF]\WH*RRGOHJáRüGRQLHMZ
FKZLOLREHFQHM
=DJDGQLHQLHWR]RVWDáRUR]ZL]DQHZODWDFKSU]H]0DWWLJD3U]\WRF]\P\WXNRFRZ\UH]XOWDW
WHJRUR]ZL]DQLD2EHFQDRGOHJáRüGRJDODNW\NL
D
]REVHUZRZDQZDUWRFLSRF]HUZLHQLHQLD²
Z
Z\UD*DVL
;
=
C
Z
Z
D
(
Z
8 ¸
8
¸
8 ¸
¸
8
JG]LH
C
S
S
8
F]\OL VWRVXQHN UHGQLHM JVWRFL PDWHULL ZH :V]HFKZLHFLH GR W]Z JVWRFL NU\W\F]QHM
FKDUDNWHU\]XMFHM:V]HFKZLDWRJHRPHWULLHXNOLGHVRZHM]
K
1DWRPLDVW RGOHJáRü
D
GR WHJR VDPHJR RELHNWX Z FKZLOL Z\HPLWRZDQLD REVHUZRZDQHJR G]L
ZLDWáDZ\UD*DVLZ]RUHP
D
D
Z
:V]F]HJyOQRFLGODHXNOLGHVRZHJRPRGHOX:V]HFKZLDWDJG\
8
IRUPXáDXSUDV]F]D
VLGRSRVWDFL
C
D
(
Z
¯
¡
°
¢
±
:LGDü]QLHM*HZJUDQLF\
Z
C
D
(
ld
¶¶ ¶¶
l
-HVW WR ZáDQLH RGOHJáRü GR KRU\]RQWX NRVPRORJLF]QHJR 3RQLHZD* GOD PRGHOX HXNOLGHVRZHJR
RWU]\PDOLP\ ]DOH*QRü
T
( T
ZLF SRGVWDZLDMF GR REHFQ FKZLO
T
T
GRVWDQLHP\
D
CT
MDNRZVSyáF]HVQRGOHJáRüGRKRU\]RQWX
'ODPDá\FKZDUWRFL
Z
PR*HP\UR]ZLQüZV]HUHJZ]JOGHP
Z
C
C
D
Z
(
Z
(
¯
x
¸
¡
°
¢
±
!
.2602/2*,$ ±
3UDZR+XEEOH¶D
2WU]\PXMHP\ZyZF]DV
V
D (
C
Z
C
C
V
C
M
M
%
¸
F]\OL]QDQHOLQLRZHSUDZR+XEEOHZSRVWDFL
3U]\NáDGRZRGODMHGQHM]JDODNW\N UHNRUG]LVWHN REVHUZRZDQD ZDUWRü
Z
'OD QLHM SU]\
8
RUD]
ÅKMS-PC
ÅS
(
q
F]\OL
(
POG ODW GRVWDQLHP\
D
POGODWZLHWOQ\FK]D
D
D
POGODWZLHWOQ\FK
SURI-HU]\6LNRUVNL
,QVW\WXW)L]\NL7HRUHW\F]QHML$VWURIL]\NL
8QLZHUV\WHW*GDVNL
HPDLOIL]MNV#LIWLDXQLYJGDSO