Kutyłowski M, Logika w3s

"!#%$'&(*)

+-,'./1032456587:9%;=<?>A@CBD@FEHG8IKJFL<NMPORQS

TVUWXY1Z\[]U Y^X_àbZ?c[]XU

deSgf]hgfiQ?<kj8O=Il;=G%Q?mAnoS"<kp%Sgf]QqIlrNMsG%tuJMwv?jqJ6m\x MySgj8>z<k;={|v}IKJ6mufi{|v~m\xFv;lv?QqIlfu; Q?<kj8O=Il;=G%Q?mAnoSSj8%G%Q?mJNnojJm\x*@uI\vj%Fv?;=<MJ{98;RuJQ%Lzv%f]{nofuO=IH8fuFj%Sgmon=vV9%;=<kk;Rv?{rMMFv?jqJ{-no

uJQG9%;R<k?;lv?{<NMvj%Sv^m\x%<%]S<|>z<k;={v?hj8f/O=IKMPSgf];=%]fuj%Sfm]JFv?jqJm]S:]jFvQ?rNMnofuO=I9%;R<k?;lv?{f]{

v~j%Sfimu<|hgSmuuJF\@

fu%j%SmAnofwSgj%%G%QmuJNnoj%f<?Qv]Gn=ORSgC{v?m\xFvj%Su{f]{ j%SfuOlv?{<NMPSgm]SgfORQG8IRf]m]ujqJ6{¡]nofu¢RhgS6m\x%<%uS<G%9%;=<kOR

m]uf]j%Sgf¡SG%¢RmuS¢=hfuj%Sgf <k98SO=G£;=<kuMwv?t¤vjJm\x£<kp%Sgf]QqIlrNMi@¦¥v;R%u<9 <k{v?kv}n=M§<?9 fu;R<NMvj%SG¨jFvI\vQSgm\x

<kp%Sgf]QqI\vm\x*@3©ª;=uJQ%Lzv?8f]{ nofuO=IILG%{v?mu]fuj%Sf9%;R<k?;lv?{«G:Cnof]8j%f]k<no]uJQ}v/jFv¬Sgj%jqJ^m]<¬{|v«{SgfonoO=m]f#M

m]]v?ORSgf«Q<k{9%Sghv?mAnoSzl@

• ©;RJQFLv?*ªMJ;lv?tuf]j%Svi9b<k9%;RvNMPj8Sf®;R<kuO=IlvNMPSg<kjqJ{Sj%vNMPSv?ORv?{S

;RG%%j8<%<kQ%Lzv%j%Sgf:<k9%SgOlv?±®n=v?QSf²MJ;Rv?t]fuj%SvOR MJ;lv?tuf]j%Sv?{S:9b<k9%;RvNMPj8Sf:;=<k]OoI\v¤MPSg<

¯°

jqJ{S3jFv¤MPSv?Olv?{S^@³´v9 fMPj%<j%Sgf²ORj%Sg{S3Ilv?QSfMJ6;Rv?t]fuj%Sv8MµQqIlrk;oJ6m\x¦j%v 9%;=uJQ%Lzv?

hgSmu]pFv¶j%vNMPSv?O=rM·<?IKMPSgf];Rv}n=?mJ6m\x¸nofuO=I:Sgj%jFvDj%St hSgm]upFv¶jFv¤MPSv?ORrNM·¤v{«JQ}v}n=?muJm\x*@³´v 9bfuMPj%<~Ilfuti9%Sfu;=MPO=uJ{¹jFv?9b<?IlQ}v?jqJ{ºjFv¤MPSv?ORfu{º9b<hgfuMCfonO=IR;R<kj%Sgfij%Sgf®{<ktufHpqJ6±®jFv¤MPSv?O

¤v{«JQ}v}n=?muJ?@

fFj%Sgmon=v²vhk<?;=JIl{Sgm]]j%v8w{<ktujFv|9%;=rkpb<Mwv?±®<kQ;RfuORhgS±®Ilf]OoI¤kn=v?QS"9 <NMPSgj%j%j%<|9%;Rufono¢=±«MJq

;lvt]f]j8SfCpqJ¢R{®J£]v?QqMvhS»FQ?<NMwv?hgSªnof/n=v?Q<MJ;Rv?t]fuj%Sf¡9 <?9%;lv¤MPj%Sgf¡;R<kuO=I\v¤MPSg<kjqJ{SPjFv

MPSv?Olv?{S^@©<k{«J¢Rhnof]%jFvQ¡n=v?Qu%fuFj8S<NMwv?±:I\v?QSªIlfuO=I~%hv¡¼MJ;lv?tuf]½¦²9b<k9%;Rv¤MPj%Sf²;R<k

O=Ilv¤MPS<kjqJ{SªjFv¤MPSv?ORv?{S¿¾\@³vV9 fMPj%<j%Sf#nofuO=IiIl<¡¤vFv?j%Sgf~Il;=JMPSv?hgj%f?@²À?f]¢=hSIRf]O=I®<kQ}v?tuf ORSg/O=Q?<k{9%hgSQ<NMv?jqJ?Án=v?Q¡9%;=]fuQ?<kjFv±~Sj%j%:<kOR<kpb¬tuf¬IlfuO=IRGnof¬I\vQn=v?QVIR;R]fupFvqÂ£j%v²9 fMPj%<

pb]%uSfHIl<j%SgfuMJk<%j%f@

fFj%Sgmon=v²Sgj%%G%QmuJNnojFv8PMJ;lv?tuf]j%Sv²I\vQSgf/{<ktujFv²<k9%SgOlv±¬9b<k9%;Ruf]«9 <kQ}v?]v?j%SgfÃ]Ä}Å²Æ²Ç]È]ÉbÄ

ÃNÊiËÌ1ÍwÇ}Î=È]ÏqÐ@CÑH98SOI\vQS{v~9b<kO=Ilv?±?

Q}v?t]6J¦jFv?9%SgO~pbf]¡jFv¤MPSvORrNMnofuO=Id¶]©ªÛ´³ÜÝ¼ÝMJ;lv?tuf]j%Sgf¡V9 <}

ÒqÓFÔ]Ó

ÓDÕÖ

Òq×8Ø

Ö6Ù¬Ó*Ú

9%;lv¤MPj%Sgf«;=<k]OoI\v¤MPSg<kjqJ6{S"jFv¤MPSv?Olv?{SÞ¾l

Uß

Z\[

nofu¢RhgSjFv?9%SgO

ÖÁÕ

ÓáàFÚ

A nofuO=IPdD¤©ªÛ´³âIR< {A} (A) [A] Ilfut«OR~dD¤©ªÛ³

Uß

Z\[

nofu¢RhgSjFv?9%SgO=J

ÖÁÕ

Ó¸ã*Ú

A <k;Rv? B OldD¤©ªÛ³«Il< AB ^Q?<?j%Q}vIlfujFv?mon=v A <k;Rv? B

m]uJhgS"jFv?9%SgOP9 <NMPO=IlvLÝJ:9 <¤v9%SORv?j%SgG<kpb<kQ|ORSgf]p%Sgf

A <k;Rv? B 3IRf]nof]OoIdD¤©ªÛ³

Ñ#9%Sgf];lvn=?m|O=SjFv9 <NMJt]O=uJm\xä¤v?ORv?Fv?m\x¸{<ktujFv upFv?Fv±?tuf|MJ;lvt]f]j8Sf

[()as{c}] nof]O=I

dD¤©ªÛ´³®@%dDJQ}v?]v?j%SgfiIRf]k<>^v?QqIlG¡9b<khgf]qv~jFvOR9%;Rv¤MP%]fuj%SG'

@PjFv?9%SgOP9%G%O=IKJ/nofuO=IPdD¤©ªÛ´³-z¤v?ORv?Fv9 <m]]IlQ<Mwv

S<k9bf];Rv?monoS

() nofuO=IPd¶]©ªÛ´³

as nof]OoIdD¤©ªÛ³-^¤vOlv?Fv9b<6mu¤IRQ?<NMv

S<k9bf];Rv?monoS

()as nof]OoIdD¤©ªÛ³

c nof]OoIdD¤©ªÛ³§z¤v?ORv?Fv~9b<6mu¤IRQ?<NMv

<k;Rv?H<k9bf];Rv?monoS

{c} nof]OoIdD¤©ªÛ³

S<k9bf];Rv?monoS

()as{c} nof]OoIdD¤©ªÛ³

S<k9bf];Rv?monoS

[()as{c}] nof]OoIPd¶]©3Û³

• ©;RJQFLv?*ªMJ;lv?tuf]j%Svhg<kkSgm]uj%f²^hg<kkSgQv~9%Sgf];oMPORuf]k<|;R]u%G

Q}v?t]%vu{Sfuj%jFv~hG8p¡Mwv?;oIl<k¢=±®hg<kkSgm]ujFv¡^j89*@ª¤v?9%SgOlvjFvn=v?QMyíF<k;=IR;lv}

ÒqÓFÔ]Ó

ÓDÕÖ

Òq×8Ø

Ö6Ù¬Ó*Ú

j%Sgf?P@

Ûîï@g@ðíñ#ò8ï@»"nofuO=IPMJ;lv?tuf]j%Sgf]{óhg<kkSgm]]jqJ{¡

Ůß

Z\[

nofu¢RhgSFjFv?9%SgO

ÖÁÕ

ÓàFÚ

A nof]O=IMJ;Rv?t]fuj%Sfu{ôh<?kSmu]jqJ{¡IR< (A) Ilf]tnofuO=IªMJ;lv?tuf]j%Sgf]{ôhg<kkSgm]

jqJ{

Uß

Z\[

nofu¢RhgSbj%v?9%SgO=J

ÖÁÕ

Ó¦ã*Ú

A <k;lv B ORiMJ;lvt]f]j8Sv?{SÁhg<kkSgm]]jqJ{S1Il< A ∧ B A ∨ B A ⇒ B

A ⇔ B ¬A Ilfut«OR~MJ;Rv?t]fuj%Sv{S"hg<kkSgm]ujJ{S^@

• ©;RJQFLv?*ªMJ;lv?tuf]j%Sv|v;=JIl{fuIKJmu]j%f

Q}v?t]%v]{Sgf]j%jFvhgG%p¸hgSgm]]p%väzMµ¤v9%SO=Sf@@g@»Dnof]OoI¬MJ;lv?tuf]j%Sgf]{õv?;=JIo

ÒqÓFÔ]Ó

ÓDÕÖ

Òq×8Ø

Ö6Ù¬Ó*Ú

{fuIKJm]ujqJ6{¡

Uß

Z\[

nofu¢RhgSj%v?9%SgO

ÖÁÕ

ÓàFÚ

A nof]OoI´MJ;Rv?t]fuj%Sfu{·v?;=JIl{fIKJ6mu]jqJ{¡'Il< (A) Ilf]tnof]OoIPMJ6;Rv?t]fuj%Sgf]{

v?;oJIR{fuIKJm]ujJ{¡

Uß

Z\[

nofu¢RhgS3j%v?9%SgO=J

ÖÁÕ

Ó¦ã*Ú

A <k;lv? B OlVMJ;lv?tuf]j%Sv?{SCv?;=JIl{fIKJ6mu]jqJ{S1IR< A + B A · B

A − B A/B −A IRf]tiOl~MJ;lv?tuf]j%Sv?{Sv?;=JIR{fIKJm]]jqJ{S1@

îMwv?qv6Ilv%fu%j%SmAn=v%<k9%G%O=]mu¤v]p%G8%<NMv?j8Sf:MJ;lvt]f]j8Sv9b<kO=Ilv?m]S^2/2/2@À?fuk<]jFvm]]fuj%Sgf j%Sgf3nofuO=In=vORj%fzm]JMJ;Rv?t¤v/<kj8<

(2/2)/2 = 1 6muuJIlfut 2/(2/2) = 2)@ªE¬L<?9 <?IªMJj%SgQ}v/Ílfuk<%

t]fij%Sgfnof]OoIªn=vORj%fHM£n=vQSO=9 <?ORrkpORQ<kj%O=IR;RG%<NMwv?j%<²Ilv?QSfHMJ;lvt]f]j8Sf@

• ©;RJQFLv?*/MJ;lvt]f]j8Sv;=f]kG8hv?;=j%fO=Il<?OR<NMvj%f:9%;=uJSjqIRf]hgSkfujqIljqJ{öMJORuG%QSgMwv?j%SgG¦M÷IlfuQ¢=m]Sgf?@

x%<%]S6<#p%G%8<Mwv?j%SgfMP]<?;Rm]rNMávj%SgfwIKJhQ<#MJOR]G8QS»Mwv?j%Sgf´<kQ;=f]¢Rhg<kj%fAn>z;Rv?uJ?@dJ;lv?tuf]j%SvI\v?QSgf G%tJMwv?j%f®Ol9%;=]f]®ORuf];=f]²fu8JIl<k;=rNMµ^j89*@ù6S\F<?;lv?#MJORuG%QSgMwv?;=QSSjqIRf];Rj8fuIl<NMCf?@

• ©;RJQFLv?*3<66MP;R<?IRjFv~j%<?I\vmon=v~9 <?hO=Qv6@

nof]OoIIl<¬>z<?;R{v/¤v?98SO=G¡MJ;Rv?t]fu½ v;=JIl{fuIKJmu]jqJm\x*'QqIlr?;lv/j%Sgf#OR98;lv¤MPSv~Q%L<?9 <?IRrNMs9b<k9%;=]fuHp%;lv?Q

nof]8j%<k]j%v?m]uj%<k¢RmuS1®vnof]%j8<6mu]f]¢=j%Sgf¶j%SgfDG8tuJMv¨jFv¤MPSvORrNMi@óÀ?f]OoIG8tuJMvjFv¨Mú;=f]9%;=f]uf]jqI\v?mAnoS

¼K{v?O=uJj%<NMCfonû¾MJ;lvt]f]½¶v?;=JIR{fIKJm]]jqJm\x*@|hv¡hgG%%uSj%Sgf~jFv?Fv}nof~O=S]v¡p%v?;R%u<%pb<:Il;RG8%j%< MP];=<kQ?<NMC<²uSjqIlfu;R9%;=fuIR<Mwv?±®I\v?QSgfiMJ;Rv?t]fuj%Sf@

Q}v?t]%v¡u{Sfuj%jFvVhG8phgSgm]]p%vDMü]v?9%SgORSgf¡@@g@»|nof]OoIHMJ6;Rv?t]fuj%Sgf]{M <6

ÒqÓFÔ]Ó

ÓDÕÖ

Òq×8Ø

Ö6Ù¬Ó*Ú

MP;R<Ilj%fAnj%<I\v?mAnoS9 <khgORQSgfon

Uß

Z\[

nof]¢=hS6jFv?9%SgO=J

ÖÁÕ

Ó*Ú

A <k;Rv? B Ol´MJ;lvt]f]j8Sv?{SFv;=JIl{fuIKJmu]jqJ{S%MJ;Rv?t]fuj%Sfu{üMä<8MP;R<?Io

j%fAnj%<I\v?mAnoS%9 <?hO=QSgfonIl<

AB+ AB· AB− AB/ Ilf]tPORHMJ;Rv?t]fuj%Sv{Sbv?;oJIl{fuIKJm]ujqJ6{S

Ms<68MP;=<?Ilj8fonj8<?I\v?mAnoS*9b<khO=QSfAn@

©;RJ6Q%Lv?*«MJ;Rv?t]fuj%Sf

345 + +2− <k]jFvm]¤v¡Il<Olv?{< m]< (3 + (4 + 5)) − 2@:³´v¡MJQ%Lzv?8]Sgf G8IKMC<k;RJhSg¢R{®J:%<kOoJ±ORQ<k{9%hgSQ<Mwv?j%f#MJ;Rv?t]fuj%SfSb9b<?IRf]{ô];=f]Q<kj%O=IR;RG%<NMwv?hgS¢={«J«nofuk<¬p8G%%<NMw@

IR;lv?Qm]SgfHIlfon;RfuQ?<kj%OoIl;=G%Q?mAnoS9b<kO=IR]9%G}nof]{«J¡uk<%j%Sgf®ijFvO=Ilu9%Gn=?mJ{S";=f]kG Lv?{S19%;=]f]ujFv?QSfu{<k9bf];Rv?monoSj%v?hfutuJ9b<kO=]G%Q}v?±~8MCrm\x¶v?;=kG%{f]jqIRrMi"Q}v?tu8Jv?;=kG%{f]jqInof]OoI

v?hgp <²hSgm]upF8"]{Sgf]j%jF¡v?hgpb<VpFv?;R8]SgfonHO=Q?<k{9%hgSgQ?<NMvjJ{úMJ;lv?tuf]j%Sgf]{M<8MP;R<?IRj%fon´j%<}

I\vmonoS*9b<khgORQSfAn®MyI\vQSg{§MJ9Fv?8QGQ?<k½%muuJ¡O=Si]j%v?QSfu{¹<k9 fu;lv?mAnoSz

<8IKMv;R¤v±®{<ktujFv8¼Ki{vLÝJm\x Qv¤MwvLQrNM;R<kp%S?mim]<?;lv?HMPSg]QORuf¾/hG%p v?jFvhSg]Gn=miMJ;Rv}

t]fuj%Sgf®OoI\v?;Rv}n=?mi9%;=]f]m\x8<6%]?m®<6¡<kkr?hj%fAnp%G8%<NMJ¡%<OR]mu]fukr6LrNMi@

hv98;RuJQ%Lzv%G*Á];=f]Q?<?j%O=IR;RG%Gnofu{«J~n=v?Q:up%G%%<NMwv?j%< 523 + 5 · +2+

23+ jFvi9bfuMPj%<«<k]jFvm]¤v (2 + 3)SOoIl<?IRj%Sgf?9%;=]fu + Oli8Mwv¬v?;=kG%{f]jqIKJ? 3 j%Sgf´{<ktuf´pqJ±

Q?<?½%m]fu{§MJ;lv?tuf]j%Svup%G%%<NMwv?j%fuk<|]v/9 <?{<m¤/<?9 fu;lv?mAnoS1%]vIlfu{

3 OoI\v?j8<MPS"v;RkG%{fujI]%

9b<6%<?p%j%fonw9%;=uJm]J6jqJ

2 nof]OoI´98Sfu;=MPORJ{ýv;RkG%{fujIRf]{ºIRfonw;Rf]hv?mAnoS1@

©<H]v?O=Il98Sfuj%SG

23+ 9%;Ruf] X <?]jFv?mu¤v}n=m]fMJ;lv?tuf]j%SgfP<#]j%v?j%fonp%G%8<MPSgf<?IR;RuJ{«Gnof]{®J 5X5 · +2+@

9b<68<kp%jqJm\xV9%;RJ6muuJj/n=v?Q9 <?9%;Ruf]%j%Sg</MPSg%]Sg{«J?%t]f

¯÷þ

X5· <6%9b<NMPSvFv (X · 5) I^n@ ((2 +

3) · 5)@ª©<|]v?O=Il98Sfuj%SGIlfuk<ORQ%Lzv?8j%SQ}v9%;Ruf] Y <?Il;=uJ{¬Gnofu{«Jb 5Y + 2+@

deSg%]Sg{«J?btuf

5Y + <6%9b<NMPSvFv Z <?]jFv?mu¤v}n=m]f]{«G (5 + ((2 + 3) · 5))@

©<%OoI\v¤MPSvn=?m?ÁjFv?O=]fHMJ;lv?tuf]j%Sgf¬{v~9b<kO=Ilv?±

Z2+@

Ñ#O=IlvIlfum]]j8Sf6jFvOR]fPMJ;lv?tuf]j%Sgf<%9b<NMPSv?%v

Z + 2 = (5 + Y ) + 2 = (5 + ((2 + 3) · 5)) + 2

ÿ'U_X

ß}Ua

ß}àbZ\[¤Y

B v}n=?miMJ6;Rv?t]fuj%Sgf¬ORQ<kj%OoIl;RG8<Mwv?j%f¬Sj%8G%Q?mJnoj8Sf/m\x8m]f]{®J];Rf

ÖÁÒ

ÔØ

Q?<kj8O=Il;=G%<NMv±«M£n=vQS'OR9b<kORrkp9b<MPOoI\vLÝ<%@

• ³SfuQSgf]6J~j%Sgfnof]O=IIl<H{<kt]hgS»MwfIlv?Qn=v?Q«8hv#MJ6Q%LJ6m\xMJ;lv?tuf]½v?;=JIR{fIKJm]]jqJm\x* 2+3+4 j%Sf MPSv?%<k{<%m]uJ®9b<NMPO=I\vL<Cn=v?Q<

(2+3)+4 muuJn=v?Q?< 2+(3+4)@

Ñe

dñÛ

ñ£©ªÛÑH¥ò"ïCB~

Q?<?hfAnoj%<k¢R±MJQ?<kjqJMvj%Sv/<?9 fu;lv?mAnoSF]{Sfuj%j%<k98;R]fum]Sgj%Q?<NMJm\x{|viMP9 LÝJM

j%viMJj%SgQÁx + (y + z)

{<kt]fiFv±®Sgj%jqJVMJj%SgQVj%St

(x + y) + z 9 <k98;R]fuHMJ6OoIlu9%Gn=?muf¬¤v<kQ;lkhgf]j%Sv8@

• dJk<68j%f/pqJFLpqJIlv?QSQORI\vLIH%fFj%SgmonoSSgj%%G%QmuJNnoj%fAnpJ 9b<kuMwv?hvLjFv«nofu%j%<kujFv?mu]j%f~<8IKMC<

;Ruf]j%Sgf®OR9b<kOR<kp8G Q<kj%O=IR;RG%QmonoS"MJ;lv?tuf]j%Sv8@3hvMJ;lvt]f]½v?;=IKJ{fuIKJmu]jqJm\xVnofuO=IPIl<{<ktuhS»Mwf 9b<k9%;Ruf]P¤vO=I\9%Sgf]j%Sgf

A + B 98;R]fu (A + B) zSF9 <%<kp%j8SfM98;RuJ9Fv%QG:Sj8jJm\x:<?9 fu;lv?mAnoSz

]{Sv?j%3OR9b<kOR<?p%G¬%fFj%Sg<NMv?j8Sv´MJ;Rv?t]fu½«bSOoIlj%Sgfon=ORQ<k{9%hSgQ?<NMwv?j%f%fFj%SgmonofCSj%8G%Q?mJnoj8f?

QqIlrk;=f¡nofu%j%<kujFv?mu]j%Sgf¶9b<kuMwv?hv}n=£u;RfuQ?<kj%OoIl;=G%<NMv?±¶p%G%%<NMCDMJ;lv?tuf]j%Sv

Il<á8<kp%;Rf%hv

v?G8IR<k{vIKJm]uj%f]k<´9%;RufuIKMwv?;R]v?j%SvMJ;lvt]f]½b"vnof]%j%<m]uf]¢=j%SfC%<k9%G8OR]mu¤v}n=I\v?Q}Sm\x®>z<k;R{

%<wn=v?QSgfonbnof]OoIlf]¢={«J~98;RuJMJ6mu¤v}nofuj%S^@

v?Q¬]v?uMJmu¤v}nªpqJMwviMno]JQvm\x|9%;=<kk;Rv?{<Mwv?j%Sv

m]u]O=IR<#j%SgfCuFv}nofu{«J®OR<kp8Sf3IKJ6m\x¬j%SG%v?j%ORrNM¦O=9%;lv¤MJ®Sq{<kt]f3pqJ±CIl<P9b<NMw<%f]{

IR;RG%%j8<k¢RmuS

Ms];R<?]G%{Sgf]j%SgG9%;Rv?muJV98;R<kk;Rv?{¬G'@

• hv¸]SghgG%O=IR;R<NMvj%Sv¦p%G8%<NMJ£MJ;lvt]f]½v?;oJIl{fuIKJm]ujqJ6m\xym]]uO=IR<¦9 <kOLG%?Gnof]{®JORSg?Î=È}ÊÍ3Ä?Æ

ÅqÇ}ÉÌ^ÎËqÅ Ã ÍÏ}Î=Ä}ÊF@

v?Olv?%vp8G%%<NMJVI\v?QSgm\x%;=]fM£nof]OoI9%;R<kOoI\v8

<kp%Sgf]QqI:¼KvIl<k{<NMJk¾9%;=]fu%O=IlvNMPSv?{®Jän=vQ?<ä9 <}nof]8Jj%muuJeMwu]fL¬fIKJ6QSgfuIl¨pb]Fm¤¦IKJ6{

<kp%Sgf]QqIRf]{

nof]¢=hSÁMJ;lv?tuf]j%Sgf

U 9 <NMPOoI\vLÝ</´MJ;lvt]f]½ A, B 98;RuJ9b<k{<6mJ<k9 fu;lv?mAnoS xIl< U ;Rf]98;Rf]uf]j6

IlG}nof]{«Jn=v?Q<²%;=]fuMC<V/Q<k;Ruf]j%Sgf]{

x'QqIlr?;=J {|v8MCr6m\x9b<?Il<?{QrNMi9b<?IR<k{Q?<NMPSf¬m]SOl

Q?<?;R]fuj%Sv?{S9b<%%;RufuMy;Rf]98;Rf]uf]jqIlG}n=?muJm\x A <k;Rv? B @

HÄ?ÎÏË\Ã®ÌûÄ}Å

Ê?Î=È}ÊÍwÇgÄbÎ=È]ÏNÅûÄ?Ë ÍÏ}Î=Ä}ÊÉ ^Ä|ÍyÇ?ÍÎlÇ}Ì1É'ÊÃiÉ'Ç}Ì

Ä Ã FÇ\Å

ÊÃ

• Ñ#{v¤MPSv?j%v¨;=f]Q?<?j%O=IR;RG%Qmon=váM98;RuJ9Fv%QG£no]J6QrNMÜ9%;R<k?;lv?{<NMvj%SväjFv?JMváO=S!8Ä?Î" É$#S

nof]OoICnofu%jqJ6{·¬j%v}nAMvt]j%SgfonoO=uJm\xDfuhfu{f]jqIlrNMQ?<k{9%Sghv}Il<k;Rv8@¥CG%%<NMv8Ä?Î"NÊÎNAvj%Sgfnof]OoIMCm¤v?hgf 9%;=<kO=Ilv8@

TVUWXY1Z\[

[&%

c*a

[

_"UqWXY1Z\[

Y1X_`"abZ?c[¤X

Z\[

_10

Ó¦Õ

Ö('

Ó)¶ÖÙ/Ó

Ó+*

ÖFØNÓ

Ó, -/.

Ó32#ÓFÔ54

³´v}nAMJk<%j%SgfonoOR]8;R<kq|9%;RfumuJuJNnoj%fuk< u%fu%j%S<NMwv?j%SvVp%G%%<NMJ98;R<kk;Rv?{rNM M<kQ;Rfu¢Rhg<kjqJ{

no]J6QG9%;=<kk;Rv?{<Mwv?j%SvinofuO=Ij%<?I\vmon=v²¥w³íw@b³Śgfnof]O=IÍl<|%fuFj8SmAn=v²Sj8%G%Q?mJNnojFv²M%<?IKJm\x%mu¤v?O#<?{|v

MPSvjJ{óORfuj%ORSgf?j8Sf«%fuFj8SGnof«ORSg¬<kp8SfuQIRrNMnof]%j%fuk<²;=<68¤v}noG

0^U

YzU0^UX

v9%SOnof]OoIj8Sfum]<

Ó%Ò

Sj8jJ?bv?hf#IR<|8;R<kp%Sv?u%@ª©;RuJQ%Lzv%<NMw<MJ6;Rv?t]fuj%Sv²v?;oJIR{fuIKJm]uj%f¬]v?9%SgOlv?hgSpqJ¢R{®Jn=vQ?<%6789;:=<?>@;<BAC9?87$DCE<?D7(FG><IH

@F;GK9

G?EL@?<?>$>9

67=8B9;:=<?>@?<BAC9?8C7DCE<?D$7FG><NMO6=7=89;:=<C>@;<BAC9C8C7$DCE<CD$7(FG>B< 67=8B9;:=<?>@?<BAC9?8C7DCE<?D$7FG><QPR6=7=89;:=<C>@;<BAC9C8C7$DCE<CD$7(FG>B< S

6789;:=<?>@;<BAC9?87$DCE<?D7(FG><T

9 <NMJt]O=]fAnH%fFj%SgmonoSMJOoI\v?;=m]uJFLÝ<ujFv?±/Q}vIRf]k<?;RSg

"v?pqJ{rm¬<kQ;Rfu¢RhgS±~mu<:;R<}

@F;GK9

G?EL@?<?>$>9

]G%{Sgf]{®J 98;R]fuHMJ6;Rv?t]fuj%Sgf/v?;oJIR{fuIKJm]uj%f?@

©ª;=uJIl<m]J{«J 9 <%<kp%jqJ:>z;Rv?k{f]jqIP%fFj%SgmonoSU ÉÌ^ÎËqÅ Ã ªM

©vORm¤vhG*

D(9D<E<C>$DA

DWH

D9;D<E<?>D

D9;D<E<?>DA

DYX

D9D<E(<?>$D

D(9D<E<C>$DWH

<E=ZD$7

V$V

[9?8(@C9K

<\H^]_<?`$Z8<

@a>

K<Cb@>

D9D<;E<?>$DA

Dc<C>=d

V$V

@feg<?`$Z=8=<

@Ca;>gD$h<?>

D9DB<E<?>$D

V$V

@feg<?`$Z=8=<

@Ca;>gD$h<?>

D9DB<E<?>$DN<

D9D<;E<?>$D

<i<C`$Z=8<

@Ca>ca;eNF9

DN<C>=d

V$V

6h@

<j<?`$Z=8<

@Ca>kdBa

D9;D<E<?>D

V$V

8<?ZB<=9D

D9DB<E<?>$DA

Dkl$>$D@

<?`$Z8<

@a>

eBa?8m[9?8(@d\Hn]mea?8A

Doda

D9D<E(<?>$D

Z=8a=F@d

<C`$Z=8<

@Ca>A

DpT

bBaD(a

9K<

6@Dhg8=<Fa?8$d(A[9?8@9K

<BA

Dqda

D9D<E(<?>$D

9KB<

D9D<E(<?>$D

• fFj%Sgmon=v¡hSgO=IKJSgj%OoIl;RG8Q?monoSª9b<6%v}nof?"t]fhgSOoI\vVSgj%O=IR;RG%QmonoSIl<v?hgp <¡9b<nof]6J6mu]jFvSj8O=Il;=G%Q?mAn=v8v?hpb<

hgSOoI\v¦Sj8O=Il;=G%Q?mAnoSi9 <äQqIlrk;=fon²MJ6OoIlu9%Gnof9 <nofu8Jj%m]]v£Sgj%O=IR;RG%Qmon=v8@÷deSgFv?±#t]fM·IlfujsO=9 <kO=rkp

p%G%8Gnof]{®JVMJÁL?m]uj%Sgf¬hgSOoIKJV}LÝ<kt]<kj8f«HSgj%O=IR;RG%QmonoS^@

• d

%fu%j%SmAnoSªSj%OoIl;=G%Q?mAnoS9 <kO=]mu]f]?rkhj8fMPSgf];=OR]f9b<MPSgj%jqJpqJ±VLvIKMC< ;=<k]9b<k]j%v?j%f~9%;=]f]<kO=<kpqJ

9b<kOLÝG%kGn=?mufiORSg«©v?ORm]v?hgf]{¡@

• ø Sgf]Q}v¤Mv«nofuO=IH{<ktuhS»MC<k¢R±~up%G%%<NMwv?j%Sv¡Sgj%OoIl;RG8Q?monoS9%;RJ9b<k{<muJ

@g@g@

@HE<kj%OoIl;RG8Q?mon=v

K<Cb(@>

<?>d

I\v~<8MC<6LGnofiO=Si%<hSgO=ISgj%O=IR;RG%QmonoS*ªI\vQ²MPSum«<?p%SfH8fuFj%Sgmonof®9%;=]f]98hvIlv}n=vORSg«{<m]j%<%@

• ³´v9b<68O=I\v¤MPSgfw9b<NMJ6tuORufon%fFj%SgmonoS]<kpFvm]uJhgS¢={«J?q%hvm]]fuk<#9b<´<?O=I\v}Ilj%Sgfon"Sgj%OoIl;RG8Q?monoSMCfuMPjFIR;R

@g@@

j%Sgfi{|v~¢=;Rf]8j%SQ}v8@

K<Cb@>

<?>=d

rÄ}Å¬È]Æ²Ç?ÏtsÅqÇ}Í3ÄÐÊusªÉ v Ãw®Äx]ÏÌAÊÉzyÎlÊ{?É Åx]Ï|

TVUWXY1Z\[]UY^X_`"a Z?cq[¤XU_}0

YzUa

_"UqWXY

Xbc"Z;Y^X_àbZ?c[]XYzUz

[]U_X

ZqY

Ó²Ö~

Ø6ÙµÒ

ÖÙ/Ó

ÖÁÒ

ßUa

ß}àbZ\[¤Yn

hv<?p%SfuQqIlrNMó]%fFj%Sg<NMv?jqJm\x

Sgj%%G%QmuJNnoj%Sgf{<kt]j%vDpFv?;=%]<¦Lzv}IKMw<%fu%j%S<NMwv?±

ÔuØ

>zG%j%Qmonof~¤v:9b<k{<m¤²Sgj%%G%QmonoS^@«ÑH?rkhjqJ ORm\x%fu{vIi]%fFj%Sg<NMv?j8Sv:>zG%j%QmonoS

f MI\v?QSO=9 <?ORrkpMJkh?Fv

jFv?OoIl]98Gn=?m]<8

• %hv:<kp%Sgf]QqIRrM¼Av}Il<k{<NMJm\x¾ u %fFj%SgGnof]{®J f (u) := g(u) ?%]Sgf g nof]OoIwn=v?Q}?¢CnoG%t¬<kQ;Rf]¢=h<?jF

>zG%j%Qmon=8

• nofu¢RhgS<kp%Sgf]QqI u nof]OoIúp%G%%<NMwv?jqJ¡Sj8%G%Q?mJNnoj%Sfn=v?Q?< Fi(a, b)8IR<|8fuFj%SgGnofu{«J

f (u) := hi(f (a), f (b))

• 9%;=uJQ%Lzv?'®<?p%hSgm]]v?j%Sgf6Lup <kQ<k¢RmuSMJ6;Rv?t]fuj%Sv v?;oJIl{fuIKJm]uj%f]?<%@²´hvVhgSmu]p¶S]{Sfuj%jqJm\x¸6Lf

pb<kQ?<k¢=±HMJ6j8<kORS}8

f (A + B) %fu%j%SG}nof]{«J~n=v?Q< max[f (A), f (B)] <k;lv? f ((A)) = f (A) + 1@

• 9%;=uJQ%Lzv?'wIuLÝG%{v?m]uf]j%Sgf¬<8MP;R<Ilj%fAnj%<?Ilv?monoS"9b<khgORQSfAnPjFv/¼KMJ6Q%LÝf¾«MJ;lv?tuf]j%Sv:v?;oJIR{fuIKJm]uj%f?f jFvhSgm]upFv?m\x£S]{Sfuj%jqJm\xDnof]OoIS%fujqIKJ6mu]j%<?¢Rm]S8 f (AB+) = (f (A) + f (B)) f (AB·) =

(f (A) · f (B))

Y^X_`"abZ\[¤Y~_10

Y^Ua

_"UqWXY

Xbc"Z;-Y^X_àbZ?c[]XYzU

MJQ%Lzv¤v?ORv?FvSj8%G%Q?mAnoS

ÓFÔuÓ

ÓyÖ(~

Ø6Ù

ÖÙ/Ó

Fv}nof:O=S²;R<kuOR]fu;RJ6±¡%<<kp%Sgf]QqIlrNM]%fFj%Sg<Mwv?jqJm\xáSgj%%G%QmuJNnoj%Sgf?@D]Sg]QSwIRf]{«G¦{<?t]hgSgMCf¬nof]OoI~pFv?;A

%]<LzvIKMCf%<NMw<%]fuj%SgfO=9%;lv¤MP%]v?j%Sgf:ORuf];RfukG¶M#Lv?ORj%<?¢Rm]S^@¡À?fuO=I®Il<~nof]%jFv¡9%;RJ6muuJj¸%hv¡QIRrk;=Jm\x

%fu%j%SmAnof«Sgj%%G8Q?muJNnoj%f«Ol~I\v?Q²9 <ktJIlf]mu]j%f@

• <NMCr6VSgj%%G8Q?muJNnojqJ:IR</ORm\x%fu{vIP9 <?O=Ilu9 <NMwv?j%Sv/ORQ%LzvFv}n=?mJ:ORSg##6Mwrm\xVQ;R<kQrMi@ªñ´pJ²9 <?Qv

¤v±?t]fPM#Lzv?O=j%<k¢=±

w ¤vm\x%<68]SÁ%hviMPO=uJO=IRQSgm\xV<kp%Sgf]QqIRrMe<Il;RJ{|vjJm\x:]v®9b<k{<m¤H<kQ;Rfu¢Rhg<kj%fon

%fFj%SgmonoS"Sj8%G%Q?mJNnoj%fonÁIl<jFv?hgf]tJb

@P9b<kQ}v?¤v?±#M#Lv?ORj8<k¢R±

w %hvQ}v?tu%f]?<|<kp8SfuQIRG¡¼KvIl<?{<NMCf]k<¾

@P9b<kQ}v?¤v?±~tufinofu¢RhgSª<kp%Sgf]QqI¤jFv?MPS

no{®Jk<

α"]<kOoI\vLC]p8G%%<NMvjJ9%;=uJ9b<k{<6mJ<kp%Sgf]QqIRrM

9b<kORSv?Fv}n=muJm\x M#Lv?ORj%<?¢R±

w 8IR< α Ilf]ti{v/M#Lzv?O=j%<k¢=± w @

Mwv?j%fon

∧, ¬ @

@>z<k;={¬G Lv#ORQ%Lzv?%v}n=?m¤v#O=S9b<nofu8Jj%m]ufonu{Sfuj%j%fonhG8pOoI\vLÝfonhg<kkSgm]]j8fonbnof]O=IªORv?{vMáO=<kp%Sgf å

I\/>z<k;={¬G L~p fu®Q<kj%SgG%j%QmonoS^ <QqIlrk;=fon{<NMwv8

@^vinof]¢RhgSk>z<k;={¬G Lv

φ nofuO=I"9b<kO=Ilv?m]S (¬ψ)NIl<Pp%Sgf];Ruf]{®J ψ0 ;RrNMPj%<NMwv?t]j%f ψ vj%Sgfª¤v¤MPSfu;lv}n=m]f

∧MIRf]8J¡9b<kORuG%QSgMwv?jF>z<k;R{«G Lz~;=rMPj8<Mwv?tujF φ nofuO=I (¬ψ0)

zp ®nof]¢RhgS>z<k;R{«G Lzv

φ nofuO=I9 <kOoI\v?muS (α∧β)Il<ªnof]OoI<kjFvP;RrNMPj%<NMwv?t]j%v>z<k;R{«G L<k{

¬¬(α∧β)

¬(¬α ∨ ¬β)@d

<kOoI\vIRj%SfAnw>z<?;R{¬G8hfi¤v{Sgf]j8Sv?{®J

α jFv~;RrNMPj%<NMwv?t]jF α0 %<?;lv? β jFv

β0 %k%uSf α0 S β0 j%Sgfi¤v¤MPSgf];lvn= ∧@

MPSgf]hg<k{Svjâ]p%G8%<NMv?jqJsD98;RuJ9b<k{<6mJe<k9bf];lvmonoS

+ S · ]f

]{Sgf]j%j8fon

x SO=I\vLÝJm\x 8<6Fv}Ilj%Sgm\x 8fuFj%SgGnofi>zG%j%Qmono®j%Sfu{v?hfAn=v?m¤6@C´<MCr{SvL8MvfuIlv?9qJb9b<kQ}v?¤v?hgSg¢R{«JSj%8G%Q?mJnoj8Sft]f~I\vQSgf~MPSfuh<?{Sv?jqJ%fu%j%SG}n=¡>zG%j8Q?monof<VMv;=Il<?¢Rm]Sv?m\xDj%Sf

Gnofu{jqJm\xe%hv¶v?;=kG%{f]jqIlrNM·%<FvIRj%Sm\x'%hvMPSfuh<k{Sv?jG

ORQ%LzvFv}n=?muf]k<¦O=S ]fOoI\vLÝfon

hgG%psu{Sfuj%j%fon

x nof]O=IIl<¨<m]uJMPSgO=IRf?nof]¢=hS f (a) ≥ 0 <k;lv? g(a) ≥ 0Il<¨<m]uJMPSg¢RmuSf (f (a) + g(a)) ≥ 0 <?;lv? (f (a) · g(a)) ≥ 0@

9b<kQ}v?¤v?hgSg¢R{«JSgj%%G%QmuJNnoj%Sgf¬M#Lzv¢Rm]S»MCf¬IKMPSfu;R%uf]j%Sgf?Q;=<kQVSj8%G%Q?mJNnojJ%hv

f S g j%Sgf]{v?hgf

n=?mJ6m\x'

%hv

a < b {|v{«J f (a) ≤ f (b) <?;lv? g(a) ≤ g(b)@<6%v}n=?mOoIl;R<?jFv?{S#%<kOoI\v}nofu{«J

(f (a) + g(a)) ≤ (f (b) + g(b))@

v?Q ORv?{<V{<kt]jFvVu;R<kp%Sg±/%hv:{j%<ktuf]j%Sv8pb<:hSgm]upqJM

IKJm\xj%Sgf];=rNMPj%<k¢RmuSvm\xOl~j%Sgf]Gnofu{j%f?@

•

MJQ%LzvSj%8G%Q?mAn=vjFv¡hSgm]upFv?m\x¦jFvIRG%;lvhjqJm\x¸Fv}nofORSg9 <%m]Sv?kj%?±|9b<D;=<kuMwv?t¤vjJO=m\x%f]{vI

Sgj%%G%QmonoS^¶pb<MPSgf]{

hSgm]upqJ

jFvIRG%;lv?hgj%f{<ktujFv¸]8fuFj%Sg<NMv±Sgj%%G8Q?muJNnoj%Sgf?¶¼KvIl<?{<NMw¾hSgm]upF

jFvIRG%;lvhjF#nof]OoI6F¤v?¢<k9bf];lvmon=/IKMw<?;R]fuj%Sv²j%<NMJm\xhSgm]upjFv}IlG%;Rv?hjqJm\x|nofuO=I´%<k9%SgOlv?j8Sf

+1 9b<

9%;RvNMCfonO=IR;R<kj%Sgf?@

v?Q²MPSg]mihSgm]upFv?{S"jFvIRG%;lv?hgjqJ{S"pqJFLÝJpqJ

0 0 + 1 0 + 1 + 1*@]@u@

• hv?mu]f]?<®O=m\x%f]{vI3Sgj%%G%QmonoS?nofuO=Iª9b<k9%;lv¤MPjqJ8Â

vLÝrkt]{®Jkqt]f98;R]fu9%;R<NMwv?%uShgS¢={«J%<NMCr6Sgj%%G%Qk

muJNnojqJVM#LzvORj%<k¢=m]S

w %v{Sg{<IR<9bfuMPj8f M j%Sgfi{|v~IlfAnwM#Lv?ORj8<k¢RmuS1@

M j%SfP{<ktuf´pqJ±´<?p%SfuQqIlf]{µv}Il<k{<NMJ{pb<«j%vIKJm\x%{Sv?OoIw<Il;RJ{|vhSgpqJ6¢={«J|OR9%;=]fum]]j8<k¢R±

H9%;=]f]98;R<NMv%]<kjqJ{·%<NMw<%f]{¹Sgj%%G8Q?muJNnojqJ{¡@

vIRf]{

¯÷þ

M ]<kOoI\vL'<?Il;=uJ{v?jqJ´{j%SgfonORQ?<?{98hSgQ?<NMwv?jqJ6m\x<kp%Sgf]QqIRrMi69 <NMPSgf]%u{«J U <k;Rv?

V 9%;=uJ9b<k{<6mJ9bfuMPj%fAnH<k9bf];Rv?monoS^@H8JpJ U <k;lv V {SvLJ<kpFv:M#LzvORj%<k¢=± W *Il<¡jFv

{<6mJ%<NMw<%G¸Sgj%%G8Q?muJNnoj%fuk<

M Ilfut²{SvL<kpqJM#LzvORj%<k¢=± w @

vIlfu{

U hG%p V j%Sgf²{v

M#LzvORj%<k¢=m]S

w @

vLrktu{«J?Ft]fHIl<

U j%Sgfi{v~M#Lv?ORj8<k¢RmuS w @

f];lvH9 <kOoIlu9%Gnof]{®JV9b<6%<?p%j%Sgf#

Ů S ]jFvno%Gnof]{®JV9%;=<kO=IRORuJ:<kp%Sgf]QqI U 0 j%Sf{|vn=?muJ|M#Lzv?O=j%<k¢RmuS

w @

I\vQ|FvhfAn3Q?<kjqIKJjG%Gnof]{®JVMj%SfuORQ<k½%m]u<kj%<k¢=±?@Cñhgf#%;=G%kSgfonCO=IR;R<kjqJ|j%SgfCnof]OoIIl<«{<?t]hgSgMCf?Fpb< M u<kO=IlvL<PO=Q?<kj%OoIl;=G%<NMv?j8fwM¸O=Q?<k½%mu]fuj%SfCMPSfuhG«Q;=<kQ}v?m\x¬Sqj8Sfª{<kt]j%vÓRSgªm]<?>zj%?±ªCQ<kj%O=IR;RG%Qmon=

j%Sgf]O=Q?<k½%mu]fuj%Sf«MPSfuhf®;lv?Jk@