3RVW SRZDQLHZ]HVSROHSR]DSDOHQLXURJyZ
SU]HGQLFKUG]HQLD
0DQDJHPHQWRISRVWSROLRV\QGURPH
*XGQL7KRUVWHLQVVRQ0'
0D\R&OLQLF3URFHHGLQJV
2NUHOHQLD Ä]HVSyá SR ]DSDOHQLX
URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD ]HVSyá SR
SU]HE\FLXFKRURE\+HLQHJR0HGLQD
DQJ SRVWSROLR V\QGURPH SR UD]
SLHUZV]\ ]DF] OL X*\ZDü FKRU]\
NWyU]\ SU]HE\OL Z SU]HV]áRFL RVWUH
]DSDOHQLH URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD
&KFLHOL Z WHQ VSRVyE ]ZUyFLü XZDJ
URGRZLVND
PHG\F]QHJR
QD
Z\VW SXMFH X QLFK REMDZ\ L VSRZR
GRZDü SRGM FLH EDGD QDG LFK SRFKR
G]HQLHP
2GWHJRF]DVXZLHG]DOHNDU]\
LVDP\FKFKRU\FKQDWHPDW]HVSRáXSR
]DSDOHQLX URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD
XOHJáD ]QDF]QHPX SRV]HU]HQLX 0LPR
WRF] üOHNDU]\QLHXZD*DWHJR]HVSRáX
]DSUREOHPPHG\F]Q\LWRZV\WXDFML
JG\
FKRU]\
NWyU]\
SU]HE\OL
ZLUXVRZH ]DSDOHQLH URJyZ SU]HGQLFK
UG]HQLDRF]HNXM Z\MDQLHQLDVNGELRU
VL X QLFK QRZH REMDZ\ L MDNL PDM
]ZL]HN ] SU]HE\W QLHJG\ FKRURE
: W\P DUW\NXOH SU]HGVWDZLRQR
DNWXDOQ\VWDQZLHG]\QDWHPDW]HVSRáX
SR]DSDOHQLXURJyZSU]HGQLFKUG]HQLD
RUD] PHWRG OHF]HQLD 3LPLHQQLFWZR
'RGDWHN ]DZLHUD OLVW QDMQRZV]\FK
SXEOLNDFML
3LHUZV]H GRQLHVLHQLH ]DZLHUDMFH
RSLV WHJR ]HVSRáX RSXEOLNRZDQH Z
PHG\F]Q\P F]DVRSLPLH IUDQFXVNLP
SRFKRG]L ] URNX =DZLHUDáR
RQR KLSRWH] WáXPDF]F Z MDNL VSR
VyEGRFKRG]LGR]DEXU]H
3RMHG\QF]H
GRQLHVLHQLDQDWHQWHPDWSRMDZLDá\VL
Z SLPLHQQLFWZLH PHG\F]Q\P GR
ZF]HVQ\FK ODW W\FK ;; Z
SU]\S UHG 1LHNWyUH ] QLFK ]ZáDV]
F]D ZVND]XMFH QD ]ZL]HN ]HVSRáX SR
]DSDOHQLX URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD ]H
VWZDUGQLHQLHP ERF]Q\P ]DQLNRZ\P
]EXG]Lá\ ZLHOH REDZ X RVyE NWyUH
SU]HE\á\ FKRURE +HLQHJR L 0HGLQD
=QDF]F\ SRVW S Z SRV]HU]HQLX ZLH
G]\QDWHPDWWHJR]HVSRáXGRNRQDáVL
Z ODWDFK W\FK 6WDáR VL WDN Z Z\
QLNX SHW\FML ]áR*RQHM SU]H] FKRU\FK ]
]HVSRáHP SR ]DSDOHQLX URJyZ SU]HG
QLFKUG]HQLDGR1DWLRQDO,QVWLWXWHRI
+HDOWK
L SRGM W\FK Z MHM QDVW SVWZLH
SU]H] 'DODNDVD
+DOVWHDGD
RUD] LFK
ZVSyáSUDFRZQLNyZ EDGD D WDN*H
]RUJDQL]RZDQLD NRQIHUHQFML Z 3DOP
6SULQJV 2VWDWQLR GR MHV]F]H OHSV]HJR
]UR]XPLHQLD WHJR ]HVSRáX SU]\F]\QLá\
VL PL G]\QDURGRZH NRQIHUHQFMH
1DWRPLDVW NUDMRZH L UHJLRQDOQH NRQIH
UHQFMH 6HYHQWK ,QWHUQDWLRQDO 3RVW
3ROLR DQG ,QGHSHQGHQW /LYLQJ &RQ
IHUHQFH 6W /RXLV 0LVVRXUL Z PDMX
SRPRJá\ FKRU\P L SUDFRZQL
NRP PHG\F]Q\P SR]QDü SU]\F]\Q\ L
]DVDG\ SRVW SRZDQLD Z ]HVSROH SR
]DSDOHQLX URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD
&KRU\P ] W\P ]HVSRáHP SU]\VáXJXM
REHFQLH ZLDGF]HQLD GOD QLHSHáQR
VSUDZQ\FK SU]\]QDZDQH ] IXQGXV]X
XEH]SLHF]HQLRZHJR Z 86$ SU]\S
UHG
2675(=$3$/(1,(52*Ï:
35=('1,&+5'=(1,$
/HWQLH HSLGHPLH RVWUHJR ]DSDOHQLD
LVWRW\ V]DUHM UG]HQLD V]HU]\á\ VL Z
XSU]HP\VáRZLRQ\FK NUDMDFK ]D
FKRGQLFK Z ODWDFK W\FK L W\FK
=DSU]HVWDQR Z\MD]GyZ QD XUORS\
PLHMVFRZRFL GRWNQL WH HSLGHPL SX
VWRV]Dá\ ]D QLHNWyUH URG]LQ\ QLH ]JáD
V]Dá\ SU]\SDGNyZ ]DFKRURZD ZUyG
QDMEOL*V]\FK
2SUDFRZDQLH SU]H] 6DOND
VNXWHF]QHM V]F]HSLRQNL D QDVW SQLH
SRZV]HFKQH ]DVWRVRZDQLH GRXVWQHM
DWHQXRZDQHM V]F]HSLRQNL SU]\F]\QLáR VL
GR ]OLNZLGRZDQLD FKRURE\ +HLQHJR L
0HGLQD Z RE\GZX $PHU\NDFK 2VWDWQL
SU]\SDGHN SRUD*HQLD VSRZRGRZDQHJR
ZLUXVHP RVWUHJR ]DSDOHQLD URJyZ
SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD RSLVDQR Z 3HUX ZH
ZU]HQLX URNX
3RPLPR *H RVWUH
]DSDOHQLH URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD
Z\VW SXMH
HQGHPLF]QLH
W\ONR
Z
QLHNWyU\FK F] FLDFK ZLDWD QDGDO
SRGHMPRZDQH V SUyE\ ]OLNZLGRZDQLD
FKRURE\ SROHJDMFH QD RUJDQL]RZDQLX
QDURGRZ\FK GQL V]F]HSLH
&HOHP
ZLDWRZHM 2UJDQL]DFML =GURZLD MHVW
FDáNRZLWH ]OLNZLGRZDQLH WHM FKRURE\ QD
ZLHFLHGRURNX
3U]\F]\Q ]DND*HQLD V WU]\ W\S\
ZLUXVD RVWUHJR ]DSDOHQLD URJyZ SU]HGQLFK
UG]HQLD HQWHURZLUXV\ O L
=DND*HQLH V]HU]\ VL SU]H] NRQWDNW ]
]DND*RQ\PL Z\G]LHOLQDPL ] SU]HZRGX
SRNDUPRZHJR OXE GUyJ RGGHFKRZ\FK
:LUXV SU]HGRVWDMH VL QDMSLHUZ GR
SU]HZRGX SRNDUPRZHJR D VWDPWG GR
NUZL 'URJD QD MDNLHM ZLUXV Z GUXMH GR
RURGNRZHJR XNáDGX QHUZRZHJR GáXJR
QLH E\áD ]QDQD 1DMQRZV]H EDGDQLD
Z\ND]Dá\ *H UHFHSWRU\ GOD ZLUXVD V
XPLHMVFRZLRQH JáyZQLH Z REU ELH Sá\WNL
PRWRU\F]QHM 6WDPWG SU]H] QHUZ\
QHXURQyZ
UXFKRZ\FK
ZLUXV
SU]HPLHV]F]D VL GR RURGNRZHJR
XNáDGX QHUZRZHJR JG]LH QLV]F]\ OXE
XV]NDG]D NRPyUNL QHUZRZH JáyZQLH
QHXURQ\ UXFKRZH %DGDF]H V FRUD]
EDUG]LHM ZLDGRPL IDNWX *H ]PLDQ\ Z
RURGNRZ\P XNáDG]LH QHUZRZ\P QLH
GRW\F] W\ONRQHX
: \ E U D Q H
5(+$%,/,7$&-$
0HG\F]QD
7RP1U
URQyZ UXFKRZ\FK DOH V R ZLHOH EDUG]LHM
UR]OHJáH
=HVWDZLHQLH
:LQGHEDQN L ZVS
O
SRGNUHODOL
V]F]HJyOQH ]QDF]HQLH ]QDMRPRFL NU\WHULyZ
GLDJQRVW\F]Q\FK RVWUHJR ]DSDOHQLD URJyZ
SU]HGQLFK
UG]HQLD
GOD
ZáDFLZHM
NZDOLILNDFML FKRU\FK GR EDGD QDG
]HVSRáHP SR ]DSDOHQLX URJyZ SU]HGQLFK
UG]HQLD .U\WHULD WH REHMPXM SR]D
RVáDELHQLHP L SRUD*HQLHP Z\ZLDG
ZVND]XMF\QDFKRURE +HLQHJRL 0HGLQD
REHMPXMF\ JRUF]N V]W\ZQRü NDUNX OXE
JU]ELHWX D WDN*H OHXNRF\WR] PO
RUD]]ZL NV]HQLHVW *HQLDELDáNDZSá\QLH
Py]JRZRUG]HQLRZ\P
&KRU\
MHVW
RGSRZLHGQLP NDQG\GDWHP GR EDGD MHOL
VSHáQLDFRQDMPQLHMWU]\]W\FKNU\WHULyZ
:\Uy*QLD VL WU]\ SRVWDFLH RVWUHJR
]DSDOHQLD URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD
SRURQQ QDMáDJRGQLHMV] QLHSRUD*HQQ
RUD]
SRUD*HQQ
QDMFL *V]
1LHUR]VWU]\JQL WD SR]RVWDMH NZHVWLD F]\
]HVSyá SR ]DSDOHQLX URJyZ SU]HGQLFK
UG]HQLD PR*H Z\VWSLü X FKRU\FK X
NWyU\FK GRV]áR GR SRVWDFL SRURQQHM OXE
QLHSRUD*HQQHM
.D*GHJR
URNX
GR
SHáQRREMDZRZHM
SRUD*HQQHM
SRVWDFL
FKRURE\ +HLQHJR L 0HGLQD GRFKRG]L X
NLONRUJD G]LHFL NWyU\P SRGDQR GRXVWQ
DWHQXRZDQ
V]F]HSLRQN
5RG]DM
V]F]HSLRQNL ] ]DELW\FK F]\ DWHXRZDQ\FK
ZLUXVyZMDNL
QDOH*\ VWRVRZDü RNUHODM &HQWHUV IRU
'LVHDVH &RQWURO DQG 3UHYHQWLRQ
O
1LH ZLDGRPR F]\ SR SU]HE\W\P
RVWU\P ]DSDOHQLX URJyZ SU]HGQLFK
UG]HQLD PR*H GRMü GR ]QDF]FHM SR
SUDZ\ :\GDMH VL ]H ]DOH*\ WR JáyZ
QLH RG OLF]E\ XV]NRG]RQ\FK QHXUR
QyZ
UXFKRZ\FK
@
-HOL F] FLRZHPX
OXE FDáNRZLWHPX XV]NRG]HQLX XOHJQLH
QLH ZL FHM QL* QHXURQyZ
UXFKRZ\FK WRXFKRUHJRLVWQLHMH V]DQVD
QDÄFDáNRZLW SRSUDZ F]\QQR
FLRZ 3RZUyW F]\QQRFL NWyU\ MHVW
SURFHVHP FLJá\P UR]SRF]\QD VL MX*
SR GZyFK PLHVLFDFK 3U]\F]\Q ]H
VSRáX SR ]DSDOHQLX URJyZ SU]HGQLFK
UG]HQLD MHVW ]DEXU]HQLH UyZQRZDJL
SRPL G]\ RG]\VNLZDQLHP VSUDZQRFL D
GRNRQXMF VL SU]HEXGRZ
=(63Ïà322675<0
=$3$/(1,852*Ï:
35=('1,&+5'=(1,$
3DWRJHQH]D ]HVSRáX SR ]DSDOHQLX UR
JyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD QDMSHáQLHM
SU]HGVWDZLRQD SU]H] 'DODNDVD
SR
OHJD QD ]DFKZLDQLX UyZQRZDJL SR
PL G]\ SU]HZOHNá\PL SURFHVDPL RG
QHUZLDQLD L UHLQHUZDFML 'RFKRG]L GR
WHJR Z PRPHQFLH JG\ ]DFKRZDQH
QHXURQ UXFKRZH PH V MX* Z VWDQLH
Z\SXV]F]Dü QRZ\FK ]DNRF]H :WHG\
RGQHUZLDQLH ]DF]\QD SU]HZD*Dü QDG
UHLQHUZDFM U\FLQ\ O L SDWU]
3DWRJHQH]D 3RF]WNRZH REMDZ\ WR
]P F]HQLH RVáDELHQLH EyO QLH
WROHUDQFMD ]LPQD ]DQLN PL QL RUD]
QRZH WUXGQRFL Z SRGHMPRZDQLX FR
G]LHQQ\FK F]\QQRFL 2EMDZ\ WH E\á\
SU]HGPLRWHP F]WHUHFK GX*\FK ED
GD
7DEHOD &] VWRü SR
V]F]HJyOQ\FK REMDZyZ E\áD QDVW SX
MFD ]P F]HQLH Z\VW SRZDáR X
FKRU\FK RVáDELHQLH PL QL REM
W\FK XSU]HGQLR SURFHVHP FKRURER
Z\P X RUD] ZF]HQLHM
QLH]DM W\FK
X EyOH
PL QLRZH
: \ E U D Q H
=HVWDZLHQLH
80,(-6&2:,(1,(=0,$13$72/2*,&=1<&+:2%5 %,(
252'.2:(*28.à$'81(5:2:(*2
5G]H NU JRZ\
1HXURQ\UXFKRZHURJyZSU]HGQLFKV]F]HJyOQLHRGFLQND
O G(ZLRZHJRLV]\MQHJR
1HXURQ\URJyZSRUHGQLFKSRUHGQLRERF]Q\FKLW\OQ\FK=ZRMHNRU]HQL
JU]ELHWRZ\FK
1HXURQ\NRURZH
3U]HGURGNRZDNRUDUXFKRZD3RGZ]JyU]H
:]JyU]H
0y*G*HN
-GUDVNOHSLHQLDPy*G*NXLUREDN
3LH Py]JX
-GURGZX]QDF]QH
-GUDQHUZXWZDU]RZHJRSRGM ]\NRZHJRSU]HGVLRQNRZHJRLWUyMG]LHOQHJR
7ZyUVLDWNRZDW\ ZUG]HQLXPRFLHLUyGPy]JRZLX
5\FLQD
3RGVXPRZDQLHSU]HELHJXNOLQLF]QHJR]HVSRáXSR]DSDOHQLXURJyZSU]HGQLFKUG]HQLDRG
RVWUHJRSRUD*HQLDSRSU]H]F] FLRZ SRSUDZ RNUHVVWDELOL]DFMLREMDZyZGRZ\VWSLHQLD
QRZ\FKREMDZyZRVáDELHQLD=DFKRG]FHQDVLHELHSRODZRNUHVLHVWDELOL]DFMLL
Z\VW SRZDQLD]HVSRáXSR]DSDOHQLXURJyZSU]HGQLFKUG]HQLDZVND]XM QDXWU]\P\ZDQLH
VL VXENOLQLF]QHMQLHVWDELOQRFLMHGQRVWHNUXFKRZ\FKSRPLPRVWDELOQRFLREUD]X
NOLQLF]QHJR'R]HVSRáXSR]DSDOHQLXURJyZSU]HGQLFKUG]HQLDGRFKRG]LZWHG\JG\
QHXURQ\ZRNUHVLHÄVWDELOL]DFMLQLHV MX* ZVWDQLHSRGWU]\P\ZDüDNW\ZQRFLZV]\VWNLFK
G\VWDáQ\FK]DNRF]H DNVRQDOQ\FKZHGáXJ'DODNDVD
:\EUDQH
%H]REMDZRZ\RNUHVSR]DSDOHQLXURJyZSU]HGQLFKUG]HQLD
Z\NOXF]HQLH LQQ\FK VFKRU]H NWyUH
PRJ
E\ü SU]\F]\Q
REMDZyZ
Z\PLHQLRQ\FK
Z
SXQNFLH
'LDJQRVW\ND Uy*QLFRZD REHMPXMH
VFKRU]HQLD NWyUH PRJ E\ü SU]\F]\Q
]P F]HQLD L RVáDELHQLD VWZDUGQLHQLH
UR]VLDQH QHXURSDWLH VWZDUGQLHQLH
ERF]QH ]DQLNRZH LQQH FKRURE\ UR
JyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD QLHGRNUZL
VWRü PLDVWHQL SU]HZOHNáH ]DND*HQLD
QLHGRF]\QQRü WDUF]\F\ NRODJHQR]\
GHSUHVM L G]LDáDQLD QLHSR*GDQH
OHNyZ : UD]LH Z\VWSLHQLD GROH
JOLZRFL EyORZ\FK QDOH*\ WDN*H Z\
NOXF]\ü ]DSDOHQLH NRFL L VWDZyZ ]D
SDOHQLH NDOHWHN PD]LRZ\FK ]DSDOHQLH
FL JLHQ EyOH PL QLRZH UHXPDW\F]QH
EyOH ZLHORPL QLRZH ILEURPLDOJL
QHXURSDWLH RUD] ]DSDOHQLH ZLHOR
PL QLRZH =HVSyá SR ]DSDOHQLX UR
JyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD Z\VW SXMH QDM
F] FLHM SR RNRáR ODWDFK RG Z\VW
SLHQLD FKRURE\ +HLQHJR L 0HGLQD
GODWHJR FKRU]\ F] VWR V MX* ZWHG\
ZVWDUV]\PZLHNXLOHF] VL ]SRZRGX
LQQ\FK ]DEXU]H PRJF\FK XWUXGQLDü
UR]SR]QDQLH
5\FLQD
3RGVXPRZDQLH]MDZLVN]DFKRG]F\FKXFKRU\FK]]HVSRáHPSR]DSDOHQLXURJyZ
SU]HGQLFKUG]HQLDRGEH]REMDZRZHJRRNUHVXSRSU]HE\WHMFKRURELH+HLQHJRL0HGLQDD*
GRUR]ZRMXREMDZyZ]HVSRáX%H]REMDZRZ\RNUHVSRSU]HE\WHMFKRURELHFKDUDNWHU\]XMH
VL
$áDJRGQ\PVWDQHP]DSDOQ\PQHXURQyZUXFKRZ\FKUG]HQLDNU JRZHJR
%Z]PR*RQ\PÄNLHáNRZDQLHPG\VWDOQ\FKDNVRQyZSURZDG]F\PGRVNXWHF]QHM
UHLQHUZDFML
&]ZL NV]HQLHPMHGQRVWHNUXFKRZ\FK]PDNURHOHNWURPLRJUDILF]Q\PLSRWHQFMDáDPLR
GX*HMDPSOLWXG]LH
'KLVWRFKHPLF]Q\PJUXSRZDQLHPVL EDUG]RJUXE\FKZáyNLHQ3RQDGWRUyZQRF]HQLH]
UHLQHUZDFM ]DFKRG]LSURFHVRGQHUZLDQLDE GF\SU]\F]\Q ]PLHQQRFLRGVW SX
SRPL G]\NROHMQ\PLSRWHQFMDáDPLF]\QQRFLRZ\PLMHGQRVWNLUXFKRZHM1DZáyNQDFK
PL QLRZ\FKNWyUH]DFKRZXM SUDZLGáRZ ZLHONRüVWZLHUG]DVL F]VWHF]NLDGKH]\MQH
GODNRPyUHNQHUZRZ\FK1&$0'$
(
GR]HVSRáXSR]DSDOHQLXURJyZSU]HGQLFK
UG]HQLDGRFKRG]LJG\]DFKRZDQHQHXURQ\UXFKRZHQLHV ZVWDQLHXWU]\PDüZV]\VWNLFK
G\VWDOQ\FK]DNRF]H LRGQHUZLDQLH]DF]\QDSU]HZD*DüQDGUHLQHUZDFM:HIHNFLHF] ü
NRFyZHNQHUZRZ\FK]DQLND%-DWR]NROHLSURZDG]LGR]DQLNXSRV]F]HJyOQ\FKZáyNLHQ
PL QLRZ\FKXZLGDF]QLDMF\FKVL ZPDWHULDOH]ELRSVMLMDNRPDáHNDQFLDVWHZáyNQD'
L
]PQLHMV]HQLDUR]PLDUyZMHGQRVWNLUXFKRZHMSU]HMDZLDMFHJRVL VSDGNLHPDPSOLWXG\
PDNURHOHNWURPLRJUDILF]QHM&:LHOH]SRGOHJDMF\FKSU]HZOHNá\PSURFHVRP
RGQHUZLDQLDLUHLQHUZDFMLF] VWRKLSHUWURILF]Q\FKZáyNLHQPL QLRZ\FK]SRZRGX
]DEXU]H PHWDEROL]PX WOHQRZHJRZ\JOGDSREDUZLHQLXKLVWRFKHPLF]Q\PMDN
ÄZ\JU\]LRQHSU]H]PROH'=PLDQ\WHRGSRZLDGDM ]DEXU]HQLRPPHWDEROL]PX
WOHQRZHJRXZLGDF]QLDMF\PVL ZVSHNWURVNRSLLUH]RQDQVXPDJQHW\F]QHJRZHGáXJ
'DODNDVD
%DGDQLHNOLQLF]QH
3RQLHZD* UR]SR]QDQLH ]HVSRáX SR
]DSDOHQLX URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD
VWDZLD VL SU]H] Z\NOXF]HQLH LQQ\FK
FKRUyE SRGVWDZRZH ]QDF]HQLH PD
V]F]HJyáRZ\ Z\ZLDG L GRNáDGQH ED
GDQLH IL]\NDOQH -HOL RVWU\ HSL]RG
FKRURE\ Z\VWSLá Z RNUHVLH QLHPR
ZO F\P QDOH*\ ]HEUDü Z\ZLDG GRW\
F]F\ *\ZLHQLD L SU]HELHJX SRURGX
&] üFKRU\FK]]HVSRáHPSR]DSDOHQLX
URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD QLH MHVW
ZLDGRPD SU]HE\WHM FKRURE\ 0R*H
WR Z\QLNDü ] IDNWX *H GDQ\ SU]\SD
GHNE\áRGRVREQLRQ\LQLHSRVWDZLRQR
SUDZLGáRZHJR UR]SR]QDQLD DOER WH*
URG]LQD ]DWDLáD ]DFKRURZDQLH Z
F]DVLH HSLGHPLL =Z\NOH WUXGQR MHVW
RGQDOH(ü GRNXPHQWDFM ] RNUHVX
RVWUHJR ]DND*HQLD PR*H RQD E\ü MHG
QDNSRPRFQD/HNDU]SRZLQLHQ]ZUyFLü
XZDJ QD WR F]\ LQQL F]áRQNRZLH
URG]LQ\ WDN*H ]DFKRURZDOL F]\ FKRU\
Z RVWU\P RNUHVLH FKRURE\ E\á OHF]RQ\
ZGRPXF]\ZV]SLWDOXRUD]F]\]RVWDá
SRGGDQ\ UHKDELOLWDFML :D*QH MHVW
]ZUyFHQLH XZDJL QD VWRSLH SRZURWX
F]\QQRFL X*\ZDQLH DSDUDWyZ RUWR
SHG\F]Q\FKFKRG]LNDZy]NDLQZD
]QDQLD]HVSRáXSR]DSDOHQLXURJyZ
SU]HGQLFKUG]HQLD
Z\ZLDG RUD] Z\QLNL EDGDQLD IL]\
NDOQHJR L HOHNWURPLRJUDILF]QHJR
(0* RGSRZLDGDMFH SU]HE\WHM
FKRURELH+HLQHJRL0HGLQD
Z\QLN EDGDQLD (0* ZVND]XMF\ QD
FKRURE URJyZSU]HGQLFKUG]HQLD
Z\ZLDG ZVND]XMF\ QD SRSUDZ
QHXURORJLF]Q ] RNUHVHP XVWDELOL]R
ZDQLDREMDZyZ
VWRSQLRZ\ OXE RVWU\ SRF]WHN RVáD
ELHQLD L P F]OLZRFL EyOyZ PL
QLRZ\FK L VWDZRZ\FK ]PQLHMV]HQLD
Z\WU]\PDáRFL L XSROHG]HQLD F]\Q
QRFL
X DWURILD PL QL X
QRZH ]DEXU]HQLD FKRGX X
QRZH WUXGQRFL Z F]DVLH ZFKRG]HQLD
SR VFKRGDFK X L Z F]DVLH
XELHUDQLD VL X FKRU\FK
1DOH*\ ]DXZD*\ü *H QRZH WUXGQRFL
Z Z\NRQ\ZDQLX FRG]LHQQ\FK F]\Q
QRFL GRW\F] Z ]QDF]QLH ZL NV]\P
VWRSQLX NRF]\Q GROQ\FK QL* JyU
Q\FK
5R]SR]QDQLH VWDZLD VL SU]H] Z\
NOXF]HQLH LQQ\FK FKRUyE SRQLHZD*
QLH PD VZRLVWHJR EDGDQLD NWyUH SR
]ZROLáRE\ Z\NU\ü ]HVSyá SR ]DSDOHQLX
URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD +DOVWHDG
]HVWDZLáQDVW SXMFHNU\WHULDUR]SR
: \ E U D Q H
3UDZLGáRZR
2VWUH]DSDOHQLHURJyZSU]HGQLFKUG]HQLD
ZHM 3y(QH ]PLDQ\ Z SU]HELHJX ]H
VSRáX SR ]DSDOHQLX URJyZ SU]HGQLFK
UG]HQLD QLH PDM VZRLVWHJRFKDUDNWHUX
:\QLNDM RQH ] Z\VW SRZDQLD
WU]HFK URG]DMyZ MHGQRVWHN UXFKR
Z\FK SUDZLGáRZ\FK QLH]PLHQLR
Q\FK Z Z\QLNX FKRURE\ RUD] VWDELO
Q\FK L QLHVWDELOQ\FK SRQRZQLH XQHU
ZLRQ\FK MHGQRVWHN :\VW SXMFH ]PLDQ\
RG]ZLHUFLHGODM
UDF]HM XV]NRG]HQLH
FDáHM MHGQRVWNL UXFKRZHM QL* L]RORZDQH
]DEXU]HQLD SU]HZRGQLFWZD QHUZR
ZRPL QLRZHJR
:\QLNL ELRSVML PL QLD EDGD Sá\QX
UG]HQLRZHJR RUD] EDGD LPPXQR
ORJLF]Q\FK L ZLUXVRORJLF]Q\FK QLH V
VZRLVWH GOD ]HVSRáX SR ]DSDOHQLX UR
JyZSU]HGQLFKUG]HQLD
'X*H ]QDF]HQLH PD RFHQD VWDQX
SV\FKLF]QHJR FKRUHJR L XZDUXQNR
ZD VSRáHF]Q\FK %UXQR L ZVS
Z\
ND]DOL *H SU]H*\FLD FKRUHJR Z F]DVLH
RVWUHJR ]DSDOHQLD URJyZ SU]HGQLFK
UG]HQLD RUD] Z RNUHVLH ]GURZLHQLD L
VWDELOL]DFML REMDZyZ PDM FLVá\
]ZL]HN ] REMDZDPL NOLQLF]Q\PL RUD]
F]\QQLNDPL L ]MDZLVNDPL SV\FKRVSR
áHF]Q\PL 2EVHUZDFMH WH Z\GDM VL
ZVND]\ZDü *H FKRU]\ WDF\ Z\ND]XM
SHZQH V]F]HJyOQH FHFK\ FKDUDNWHUX D
WDN*H VNáRQQRü GR GHSUHVML QLHSR
NRMX ]DEXU]H NRQFHQWUDFML SDPL FL L
ORJLF]QHJR UR]XPRZDQLD RNUHODQH
MDNRXE\WNLXZDJL
&KRU]\ ] ]HVSRáHP SR ]DSDOHQLX
URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD Z FKDUDNWHU\
VW\F]Q\ VSRVyE RSLVXM VZRMH REMDZ\ L
UHDJXM QD EDGDQLH 2WDF]DM VL WDN*H
VZRLVW\PL ÄEORNDGDPL,FK ]DFKRZDQLH
MHVW QD VZyM VSRVyE SRGREQH GR
]DFKRZDQLD FKRU\FK ] SU]HZOHNá\P
]HVSRáHP
EyORZ\P
3URZDG]F\
WHUDSL PXVL SDPL WDü R SV\FKROR
JLF]Q\FK L VSRáHF]Q\FK F] VWR EROHV
Q\FK GRZLDGF]HQLDFK FKRUHJR XQLH
PR*OLZLDMF\FK PX QLHMHGQRNURWQLH
]DFKRZDQLH GREUHJR VDPRSRF]XFLD
1DOH*\ VL JDü SR]D ÄEORNDG\ XVWD
ZLRQH SU]H] FKRUHJR ER LQDF]HM RG
QLHVLH RQ ZUD*HQLH *H MHJR SUREOHP\
PDM UDF]HMSV\FKRORJLF]Q\FKDUDNWHUD
QLH Z\QLNDM ] ]HVSRáX SR ]DSDOHQLX
URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD &] VWR ]GDU]D
VL *H FKRU\FKNWyU]\ SU]HE\OLRVWUH
]DSDOHQLH URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD
SRGGDMH VL Uy*Q\P ]DELHJRP IL
]MRWHUDSHXW\F]Q\P FKLUXUJLF]Q\P
RUD] LQQ\P QLHVSUDZG]RQ\P PHWR
GRP OHF]HQLD1LHSU]\QRV] RQH
5\ü
=PLDQ\ZQHXURQDFKZSU]HELHJXRVWUHJR]DSDOHQLDURJyZSU]HGQLFKUG]HQLDLZ
]HVSROHSR]DSDOHQLXURJyZSU]HGQLFKUG]HQLD:VWDELOQ\PRNUHVLHSRSU]HE\W\P
RVWU\P]DSDOHQLXURJyZSU]HGQLFKUG]HQLDFLJáDSU]HEXGRZDMHGQRVWNLUXFKRZHM
]DFKRG]LZZ\QLNXVNXWHF]QHMUHLQHUZDFMLQRZRRGQHUZLDQ\FKZáyNLHQ:H
ZF]HVQHM ID]LH]DQLNXPL QLSRRVWU\P]DSDOHQLXURJyZSU]HGQLFKUG]HQLDREHFQH
V W\ONRQLHZLHONLHUR]SURV]RQHQLHSUDZLGáRZHZáyNQDFLHPQHZLDGF]FHR
XV]NRG]HQLXG\VWDOQ\FK]DNRF]H=PLDQ\WHZL*VL ]QRZ\PRVáDELHQLHP
PL QL:PLDU MDNSRVW SXMH]DQLNPL QLZ]HVSROHSR]DSDOHQLXURJyZSU]HGQLFK
UG]HQLDRGQHUZLHQLXXOHJDFRUD]ZL FHMZáyNLHQ$WURILF]QHZáyNQDPRJ
Z\VW SRZDüZPDá\FKJUXSDFKUHSUH]HQWRZDQ\FKQDU\FLQLHSU]H]GZDVVLDGXMFH
FLHPQHZáyNQD.URSNLRGSRZLDGDM VNXSLHQLRPPDWHULDáXMGURZHJRSR]RVWDá\P
SRRVWU\PHSL]RG]LHFKRURE\+HLQHJRL0HGLQDZHGáXJ'DODNDVD
OLG]NLHJR RUD] NRU]\VWDQLH ] LQQ\FK
SRPRF\ D WDN*H QD WR F]\ ]RVWDá\ RQH
Sy(QLHM RGVWDZLRQH SU]H] FKRUHJR
&KRU]\ SRGDM F] VWR *H URG]LFH OXE
SUDFRZQLF\ PHG\F]QL ]DOHFLOL LP ]D
SU]HVWDü NRU]\VWDQLD ] W\FK DSDUDWyZ
PLPR ]QDF]QHJR XSROHG]HQLD VSUDZ
QRFL $QDOL]XMF LQIRUPDFMH ] Z\ZLDGX
OHNDU] SRZLQLHQ XVWDOLü NLHG\ QDVWSLá
SRF]WHN VWDELOL]DFML REMDZyZ RNUHOLü
PDNV\PDOQ\
GOD
FKRUHJR
]DNUHV
VSUDZQRFL
SRGVXPRZDü
RNUHV
VWDELOL]DFML RUD] XVWDOLü F]\ GR ]D
RVWU]HQLD PRJáR GRMü Z Z\QLNX ]D
G]LDáDQLD F]\QQLND ]ZL]DQHJR ]H
]PLDQ F]\QQRFL ]DZRGRZ\FK ERG(FyZ
SV\FKLF]Q\FK L VSRáHF]Q\FK OXE LQQ\FK
VFKRU]H
.RQLHF]QH
MHVW
GRNáDGQH
EDGDQLH IL]\NDOQH XNáDGX QHUZRZHJR L
PL QLRZRV]NLHOHWRZHJR %DGDQLH PR*H
XMDZQLü Uy*QH WRZDU]\V]FH ]DEXU]HQLD
QS XE\WNL F]XFLD VSDVW\F]QRü RUD]
FKRURE\VWDZyZ
%UDNMHVWVZRLVW\FKWHVWyZODERUDWR
U\MQ\FK
NWyUH
SR]ZROLá\E\
UR]SR]QDü ]HVSyá SR ]DSDOHQLX
URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD %DGDQLD
ODERUDWRU\MQH V MHGQDN NRQLHF]QH
DE\Z\NOXF]\üLQQH
VFKRU]HQLD 1DOH*\ R]QDF]\ü PRUIR
ORJL 2% VW *HQLD HOHNWUROLWyZ JOLNH
PL RUD] SU]HSURZDG]Lü EDGDQLD
F]\QQRFL ZWURE\ QHUHN L WDUF]\F\
6WZLHUG]RQR *H ]ZL NV]HQLH DNW\Z
QRFL NLQD]\ NUHDW\QRZHM X FKRUHJR ]
]HVSRáHP SR ]DSDOHQLX URJyZ SU]HG
QLFK UG]HQLD ]DOH*\ RG DNW\ZQRFL
FKRUHJR EH]SRUHGQLR SU]HG EDGD
QLHP
%DGDQLD HOHNWURPLRJUDILF]QH L
SU]HZRGQLFWZD QHUZRZHJR PDM QD
FHOX Z\ND]DQLH QDVW SVWZ RVWUHJR
RNUHVX FKRURE\ +HLQHJR L 0HGLQD
RNUHOHQLH UR]OHJáRFL ]PLDQ RUD] QD
VLOHQLD RGQHUZLHQLD D WDN*H Z\NOX
F]HQLHPLDVWHQLLLQHXURSDWLL:\Uy*QLD
VL SL üVWDGLyZHOHNWURIL]MRORJLF]Q\FK
FKRURE\ RVWUH ]DSDOHQLH LVWRW\ V]DUHM
SLHUZV]\ PLHVLF ZF]HVQD SRSUDZD
PLHVL F\ Sy(QD SRSUDZD
VWDELOL]DFMD F]\QQRFLRZD RUD]
Sy(QH ]PLDQ\ Z RNUHVLH F]\QQRFLR
ZHM VWDELOL]DFML
:UD] ] UR]ZRMHP
Sy(Q\FK ]PLDQ SRMDZLDM VL GU*HQLD
S F]NRZH PL QL GRGDWQLH IDOH L
GU*HQLD ZáyNLHQNRZH 'RFKRG]L WH*
GR ]ZL NV]HQLD DPSOLWXG\ L F]DVX
WUZDQLDSRWHQFMDáXMHGQRVWNLUXFKR
RVWDWHF]QLH SRSUDZ\ PLPR SRF]WNR
Z\FK GX*\FK RF]HNLZD &KRU]\
F] VWR SRGDM *H RGUDG]DQR LP X*\
ZDQLD SRPRF\ GR FKRG]HQLD QDWR
PLDVW ]DOHFDQR SRGHMPRZDQLH ÄKHUR
LF]Q\FK Z\VLáNyZ SU]\ SRUXV]DQLX
VL -HVWWRSU]HMDZQDVWDZLHQLDURG]LQ\
SU]\MDFLyá L SUDFRZQLNyZ RSLHNL
]GURZRWQHM XZD*DMF\FK WDNLH SRVW
SRZDQLH ]D ZáDFLZ\ VSRVyE PRW\
ZRZDQLD FKRUHJR 3UDFRZQLF\ RSLHNL
]GURZRWQHM L VDPL FKRU]\ FRUD] OHSLHM
UR]XPLHM *H ZVSyáF]HVQD ILOR]RILD
UHKDELOLWDFML SROHJD UDF]HM QD Z\NR
U]\VW\ZDQLX GRVW SQ\FK FKRUHPX
F]\QQRFL EH] QDGPLHUQHM DNW\ZQRFL
:\VW SXMFH X FKRU\FK SR ]DSDOHQLX
URJyZSU]HGQLFKUG]HQLDREMDZ\V F] VWR
LQWHUSUHWRZDQH MDNR Z\QLN SUREOHPyZ
SV\FKRORJLF]Q\FKE GF\FKRGEL
FLHP RSLVDQ\FK SRZ\*HM XZDUXQNR
ZD Z\QLNDMF\FK ] G*HQLD GR GRVWR
VRZDQLD VL GR ÄQRUPDOQHJR ZLDWD
/HNDU]D QLH SRZLQQD G]LZLü SU]HVDGD
Z RSLV\ZDQLX REMDZyZ DJUDZRZDQLH L
OHNFHZD*F\ VWRVXQHN GR EDGDQLD IL]\
NDOQHJR =DZV]H QDOH*\ SDPL WDü *H V
WR UDF]HM ÄHOHPHQW\ WáD SV\FKRORJLF]QHJR
L VSRáHF]QHJR D QLH SU]\F]\Q\ ]HVSRáX
FKRURERZHJR
: UD]LH QDUDVWDMF\FK ]DEXU]H
F]\QQRFL XNáDGX NU*HQLD L RGGHFKR
ZHJR OXE WUXGQRFL Z SRá\NDQLX NR
QLHF]QH MHVW Z\NRQDQLH RGSRZLHG
QLFK EDGD GLDJQRVW\F]Q\FK : SU]\
SDGNX MHOL QD SLHUZV]\ SODQ Z\VXZDM
VL WUXGQRFL SR]QDZF]H OXE ]DEX
U]HQLD SDPL FL ZVND]DQH MHVW EDGDQLH
QHXURSV\FKRORJLF]QH &KRU]\ ] ]H
VSRáHPSR]DSDOHQLXURJyZSU]HG
QLFKUG]HQLDV ]Z\NOHZZLHNXNWyU\
SUHG\VSRQXMH GR VFKRU]H XNáDGX
NU*HQLD GODWHJR WH* NRQLHF]QH MHVW
]DZV]H SU]HSURZDG]HQLH GRNáDGQHJR
EDGDQLD NDUGLRORJLF]QHJR áF]QLH ]
R]QDF]HQLHP OLSLGRJUDPX &] VW\P
SUREOHPHP MHVW NRQIOLNW SRPL G]\
ZVND]DQLDPL GR LQWHQV\ZQHM UHKDELOL
WDFML NDUGLRORJLF]QHM D NRQLHF]QRFL
RJUDQLF]DQLD ]P F]HQLD L MHJR QLHNR
U]\VWQ\FKVNXWNyZ
7KH 1DWLRQDO 5HKDELOLWDWLRQ +RVSL
WDO/LPE&ODVVLILFDWLRQ
=HVWDZLHQLH
L Z\QLNDMFD ] QLHM NODV\ILNDFMD RG
QRV]FD VL GR PL QL 5\FLQD V
SRPRFQH Z GLDJQRVW\FH SURZDG]HQLX
EDGD QDXNRZ\FKLOHF]HQLXFKRU\FK]
]HVSRáHP SR ]DSDOHQLX URJyZ
SU]HGQLFKUG]HQLD
3DWRJHQH]D
3DWRJHQH]D ]HVSRáX SR ]DSDOHQLX UR
JyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD MHVW QDGDO ]D
JDGQLHQLHP NRQWURZHUV\MQ\P 3DQXMH
SU]HNRQDQLH *H PHFKDQL]P RGSR
ZLHG]LDOQ\ ]D MHJR Z\VWSLHQLH SROHJD
QD ]DFKZLDQLX UyZQRZDJL SRPL G]\
FLJá\PL SURFHVDPL RGQHUZLDQLD L
UHLQHUZDFML : HIHNFLH ]DFKRZDQH
QHXURQ\ UXFKRZH QLH V MX* ]GROQH GR
Z\WZDU]DQLD QRZ\FK ]DNRF]H L ]MD
ZLVNR RGQHUZLDQLD ]DF]\QD SU]HZD*Dü
QDG UHLQHUZDFM
U\FLQ\ O L
:WSOLZRFL GRW\F] XG]LDáX Z UR]
ZRMX]HVSRáXSR]DSDOHQLXURJyZ
:<:,$''27<&= &<2675(*2
(3,=2'8&+252%<
:<:,$''27<&= &<
12:<&+'2/(*/,:2 &,
(0*
./$6$:*1$7,21$/
5(+$%,/,7$7,21+263,7$/
5\FLQD
.ODV\ILNDFMDVWDQXPL QLZ]HVSROHSR]DSDOHQLXURJyZSU]HGQLFKUG]H QLDZJ1DWLRQDO5HKDELOLWDWLRQ+RVSLWDO&535 FKRURED URJyZSU]HGQLFKUG]HQLDDQJ
$+&' DQWHULRUKRUQFHOLGVHDVH(0* HOHNWURPLRJUDP3&-5 SRWHQFMDá\F]\QQR FLRZHMHGQRVWNLUXFKRZHMDQJ 08$3 PRWRUXQLWDFWLRQSRWHQWLDOVZHGáXJ
*DZQH D
=HVWDZLHQLH
./$6<),.$&-$
1$7,21$/5(+$%,/,7$7,21+263,7$/326732/,2
/,0%&/$66,),&$7,21
.ODVDO
EUDNNOLQLF]Q\FKREMDZyZRVWUHJR]DSDOHQLD
URJyZ
SU]HGQLFKUG]HQLD
.ODVD,,VXENOLQLF]Q\SU]HELHJFKRURE\
.ODVD,,,NOLQLF]QLHVWDELOQDFKRURED
.ODVD,9NOLQLF]QLHQLHVWDELOQDFKRURED
.ODVD9FL *NDFKRURED]]DQLNDPL
1DSRGVWDZLH+DOVWHDGDLZVS
SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD ZLUXVD RVWUHJR ]D
SDOHQLD SU]HGQLFK URJyZ UG]HQLD L
]QDF]HQLD ]MDZLVN LPPXQRORJLF]
Q\FK
=HVSyO WHQ MHVW Z\QLNLHP
XRJyOQLRQHJR VFKRU]HQLD QHXURQyZ
=PLDQ\ GHVWUXNF\MQH GRW\F] QHXUR
QyZ R Uy*QHM ORNDOL]DFML L F]\QQRFL
=HVWDZLHQLH 8V]NRG]HQLH QHXUR
QyZ WDN*H Z\ND]XMH Uy*QH QDVLOHQLH
5\FLQD 2EVHUZXMH VL D SUDZL
GáRZH QHXURQ\ RGOHJáH RG XV]NRG]R
Q\FK NRPyUHN ESUDZLGáRZHQHXURQ\
]QDMGXMFHVL ZSREOL*XXV]NRG]RQ\FK
NRPyUHN
L
GODWHJR
SRGGDQH
ÄG]LDáDQLX VWUHVX F ÄQDSUDZLRQH
QHXURQ\ SRGOHJDMFH SU]HZOHNáHPX
ÄG]LDáDQLX VWUHVX OXE REM WH XPLDU
NRZDQLH QDVLORQ\P SURFHVHP FKRUR
ERZ\P NWyUH SU]HWUZDá\ MDNR PDáH
QHXURQ\ L ZUHV]FLH G QHXURQ\ QLHFDá
NRZLFLH QDSUDZLRQH L ]EOL]QRZDFLD
áH
: EDGDQLX (0* SRMHG\QF]HJR
ZáyNQD REVHUZXMH VL ]ZL NV]HQLH
]PLHQQRFL RGVW SX SRPL G]\ NROHM
Q\PL SRWHQFMDáDPL F]\QQRFLRZ\PL
MHGQRVWNL UXFKRZHM RUD] ]MDZLVNR EOR
NRZDQLD 1D ZáyNQDFK VWZLHUG]D VL
F]VWHF]NL DGKH]\MQH GOD NRPyUHN
QHUZRZ\FK
5\FLQD 8SROHG]HQLH
F]\QQRFL]áF]DQHUZRZR PL
QLRZHJRRUD]RNV\GDF\MQHMIRVIRU\OD
FMLMHVWSU]HGPLRWHPG\VNXVML,VWQLHM
MHGQDNGRZRG\QD]DEXU]HQLDPHFKD
QL]PyZRGSRZLHG]LDOQ\FK]DZ\WZD
U]DQLHHQHUJLLZPL QLDFK
2EVHU
ZXMHVL WDN*H]X*\ZDQLHVL ]DNR
F]H DNVRQDOQ\FK3R]DW\PL]MDZL
VNDPLQDOH*\WDN*HSDPL WDüRQRU
PDOQ\PSURFHVLHVWDU]HQLDVL LZ\VW
SXMFHMSRZ\*HMWHJRURNX*\FLD
XWUDFLHQHXURQyZ=DEXU]HQLDUHJXODFML
LPPXQRORJLF]QHMVWZLHUG]DQRZ
REU ELHUG]HQLDNU JRZHJRPL QL
RUD]ZOLPIRF\WDFK5HDNFMDQD51$
ZLUXVDRVWUHJR]DSDOHQLDURJyZ
SU]HGQLFKUG]HQLDNU JRZHJRSU]HMDZLD
VL V\QWH] SU]HFLZFLDáNODV\,J*L,J0
SU]HFLZNRWHPXZLUXVRZL7DN*HZ
VXURZLFVWZLHUG]DVL SRGZ\*V]HQLH
SU]HFLZFLDá,J0VZRLVW\FKGODZLUXVD
=QDF]HQLHW\FK]MDZLVNZSDWRJHQH]LH
]HVSRáXSR]DSDOHQLXURJyZA
SU]HGQLFKUG]HQLDQLHMHVWMDVQH
3RPLPR *H QLH]QDQH V F]\QQLNL
U\]\NDUR]ZRMX]HVSRáXSR]DSDOHQLXUR
JyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD Z\QLNL EDGD
SU]HPDZLDM ]D LVWQLHQLHP NLONX F]\QQL
NyZ WRZDU]\V]F\FK
'R REMDZyZ
GRFKRG]L QDMSLHUZ Z REU ELH QDMVáDE
V]HMNRF]\Q\ZF]HQLHMXFKRU\FK]
FL *NLP SRUD*HQLHP L ZF]HVQ\PL ]DEX
U]HQLDPL RGG\FKDQLD SRFKRG]HQLD
RSXV]NRZHJR:F]HQLHMV]HZ\VWSLHQLH
REMDZyZREVHUZXMHVL WDN*HXFKRU\FK
X NWyU\FK RVWUH ]DSDOHQLH URJyZ
SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD NU JRZHJR Z\VWSLáR
ZVWDUV]\PZLHNX
3LHUZV]HREMDZ\]HVSRáXSR]DSDOHQLX
URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD Z\VW SXM
UHGQLR SR ODWDFK RG RVWUHJR
HSL]RGX FKRURE\ 2SLV\ZDQR Z\
VWSLHQLD REMDZyZ ]HVSRáX SR
ODWDFK 3UDZGRSRGREQLH X ND*GHJR
FKRUHJR NWyU\ SU]HE\á FKRURE +H
LQHJR L 0HGLQD GRV]áRE\ NLHG\ GR
]HVSRáX SR ]DSDOHQLX URJyZ SU]HG
QLFK UG]HQLD
2EMDZ\ SRVW SXM SR
ZROL ² Z\QLNL QDMQRZV]\FK EDGD Z\
ND]Dá\VWRSQLRZHQDUDVWDQLHRVáDELHQLD
PL QL
,P EDUG]LHM QDVLORQH V
]HMFLRZHREMDZ\FKRURE\+HLQHJRL
0HGLQD W\P ZL NV]D MHVW SRGDWQRü
FKRUHJR QD Z\VWSLHQLH ]HVSRáX ]H
Z]JO GX QD ]QDF]QLH PQLHMV] UH]HUZ
QHXURQyZ '\VNXVMH QDG SRVW SHP
FKRURE\ SURZDG]RQH SU]H] VDP\FK
FKRU\FK XMDZQLDM ]H ZV]\VF\ FKRU]\
REDZLDM VL V\WXDFML JG\ GRMG]LH GR
WDNLHJR QDVLOHQLD GROHJOLZRFL MDN Z
RVWUHMID]LHFKRURE\-HVWWR]UR
: \ E U D Q H
]XPLDáH JG\* GOD FKRU\FK ] FL *NLPL
]HMFLRZ\PL ]DEXU]HQLDPL SRVW S
FKRURE\ R]QDF]D SU]HMFLH ]H VWDQX
QLH]DOH*QRFL Z Z\NRQ\ZDQLX FR
G]LHQQ\FK F]\QQRFL GR VWDQX FDáNR
ZLWHJRX]DOH*QLHQLDRGRSLHNXQD
&] VWRü ]HVSRáX SR ]DSDOHQLX UR
JyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD X FKRU\FK
NWyU]\ SU]HE\OL FKRURE +HLQHJR L
0HGLQD ZDKD VL RG GR
2FHQLD VL ]H ]HVSyá WHQZ\VW SXMH
X FKRU\FK X NWyU\FK GRV]áR
GRSRUD*HQQHMSRVWDFLRVWUHJR]DSDOHQLD
URJyZSU]HGQLFKUG]HQLD8FKRU\FKX
NWyU\FK ]PLDQ\ UH]\GXDOQH V
PLQLPDOQH REMDZ\ ]HVSRáX V WDN*H
QLH]QDF]QH 1DWRPLDVW X FKRU\FK ]
EDUG]R PDá UH]HUZ QHXURQDOQ F]
VWRü ]HVSRáX MHVW GX*D ]ZáDV]F]DSR
ODWDFK RG RVWUHJR HSL]RGX
6]DFXQNL FR GRFKRURERZRFL]PLHQLá\
VL RG SLHUZV]\FK EDGD REHFQLH
RFHQLDVL M QDRNPLQZ86$
2EMDZ\
=P F]HQLH
=P F]HQLH Z\VW SXMH X FKR
U\FK ] ]HVSRáHP SR ]DSDOHQLX URJyZ
SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD 6NXWHF]QRü SODFH
ER Z OHF]HQLX FKRU\FK VNDU*F\FK VL
QD QDVLORQH ]P F]HQLH SRGREQLH MDN
Z OHF]HQLX EyOX Z\QRVL RN
:\Uy*QLD VL GZD URG]DMH ]P F]HQLD
RURGNRZH L REZRGRZH 2EMDZ\ WR
ZDU]\V]FH RURGNRZHPX ]P F]HQLX
SROHJDM QD WUXGQRFLDFK Z NRQFHQ
WUDFML L ]DSDPL W\ZDQLX RUD] VHQQRFL
,VWQLHMH ZLHOH WHRULL QD WHPDW SDWRJH
QH]\ WHJR REMDZX =ZUDFD VL XZDJ
QD ]QDF]HQLH SU]HZOHNáHJR EyOX RVR
ERZRFL W\SX $ GHSUHVML ]DEXU]H
F] FL DNW\ZXMFHM WZRUX VLDWNRZDWH
JR ]DEXU]H VQX RUD] XSROHG]HQLD
F]\QQRFL RGGHFKRZHM
3RQLHZD*
]D MHJR Z\VWSLHQLH RGSRZLDGD
SUDZGRSRGREQLH ZL FHM F]\QQLNyZ
GODWHJR QDOH*\ FKRUHJR EDUG]R GR
NáDGQH]EDGDü
2EMDZ\ REZRGRZHJR ]P F]HQLD WR
]PQLHMV]HQLH Z\WU]\PDáRFL L P F]OL
ZRü PL QL 0R*OLZH SU]\F]\Q\ WR
Z\F]HUSDQLH PHWDEROLF]QH SRZL N
V]RQHM MHGQRVWNL UXFKRZHM ]DEXU]HQLD
SU]HZRG]HQLD Z ]áF]X QHUZRZR
PL PRZ\P L SUDZGRSRGREQLH PLR
SDWLD]Z\F]HUSDQLD
:\QLNLEDGD
QLD (0* ZVND]XMFH QD GHIHNW]áF]D
QHUZRZRPL PRZHJR WR VWRSQLRZ\
]DQLN SREXG]H REVHUZRZDQ\ Z F]DVLH
SRZWDU]DQHM VW\PXODFML RUD] ]ZL NV]HQLH
]PLHQQRFL RGVW SyZ SRPL G]\
NROHMQ\PL F]\QQRFLRZ\PL SRWHQFMD
áDPL MHGQRVWNL UXFKRZHM 1DOH*\ SD
PL WDü ]H ]DEXU]HQLD WH QLH PDM VZR
LVWHJR FKDUDNWHUX JG\* REVHUZXMH VL
MH WDN*H Z PLDVWHQLL VWZDUGQLHQLX ]D
PNRZ\P ERF]Q\P RUD] Z SU]HELHJX
SRZLNáD RVWUHJR ]DSDOHQLD URJyZ
SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD EH] REMDZyZ ]H
VSRáX SR ]DSDOHQLX URJyZ SU]HGQLFK
UG]HQLD
1DMZL NV]H ]QDF]HQLH Z OHF]HQLX
]P F]HQLD PD HGXNDFMD FKRUHJR 3R
ZLQQDVL RQDZL]Dü]ZáDFLZ RFHQ
DNW\ZQRFL FKRUHJR
-HOL FKRU\ QLH
MHVW Z VWDQLH SU]HVWU]HJDü SRG
VWDZRZ\FK ]DVDG SRVW SRZDQLD PDM
F\FK RJUDQLF]\ü ]P F]HQLH WM RV]F]
G]DQLD HQHUJLL L RGSRZLHGQLHJR UHJX
ORZDQLD WHPSD Z\NRQ\ZDQ\FK F]\Q
QRFL LQQHPHWRG\QLHE G VNXWHF]QH
&] VWR FKRU\ *\MH ]JRGQLH ] ]DVDG
ÄQLH SRGGDZDQLD VL .RQLHF]QH V
ZWHG\ OLF]QH ZL]\W\ X OHNDU]D L LQQ\FK
SUDFRZQLNyZ RSLHNL ]GURZRWQHM DE\
SU]HNRQDü JR R SRWU]HELH ]PLDQ\
DNW\ZQRFL 7DND SRVWDZLD PR*H
E\üWDN*HSU]\F]\Q QLHVWRVRZDQLDVL
FKRUHJR
GR
WU\EX
ZL]\W
NRQWUROQ\FK
&DVKPDQ L 7URMDQ
EDGDOL VNX
WHF]QRü EURPNX SLU\GRVW\JPLQ\
0HVWLQRQ Z OHF]HQLX ]P F]HQLD Z
SU]HELHJX ]HVSRáX SR ]DSDOHQLX
URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD :\QLNL
ZVND]XM ]H QDVLOHQLH RJyOQHJR ]P
F]HQLD ]PQLHMV]\áR VL Z Z\QLNX OH
F]HQLD RXFKRU\FK8
FKRU\FK REVHUZRZDQR ]PQLHMV]HQLH
P F]OLZRVFL PL QL L ]ZL NV]HQLH
DNW\ZQRFL 8 RVyE NWyUH ]DUHDJR
ZDá\ QD OHF]HQLH Z SU]HFLZLHVWZLH
GRQLHZ\ND]XMF\FKNRU]\VWQHMUHDNFML
VWZLHUG]RQR ]PQLHMV]HQLH ]PLHQQRFL
RGVW SX
SRPL G]\
NROHMQ\PL
SRWHQFMDáDPL F]\QQRFLRZ\PL Z ED
GDQLX (0* SRMHG\QF]\FK ZáyNLHQ
:\GDMH VL ]H VNXWHF]QRü OHF]HQLD
E\áD QDMZL NV]D X FKRU\FK ] QDMEDU
G]LHM QDVLORQ\P ]P F]HQLHP 7\ONR
QLHZLHON SRSUDZ REVHUZRZDQRZ
]DNUHVLHVLá\L]RNLQHW\F]QHM:LQQ\P
EDGDQLX PDMF\P QD FHOX RFHQ
VNXWHF]QRFL SLU\GRVW\JPLQ\ ]QDF]FHM
SRSUDZLHXOHJáDVLáDVWDW\F]QDLG\±
:\EUDQH
QDPLF]QD RUD] WDNLH F]\QQRFL MDN
XELHUDQLH VL L FKRG]HQLH
3LU\GR
VW\JPLQ VWRVXMH VL SRF]WNRZR Z
GDZFH PJ G]LHQQLH D QDVW SQLH
GDZN QDOH*\ VWRSQLRZR ]ZL NV]Dü D*
GR PJ WU]\ UD]\ G]LHQQLH ']LDáD
QLD XERF]QH V F] VWH
L SROHJDM QD
Z\VW SRZDQLX QDVLORQ\FK GU*H PL
QLRZ\FK QXGQRFL OX(Q\FK VWROFyZ
F] VW\FK PLNFML EyOyZ JáRZ\ RUD]
UXPLHQLD WZDU]\ 3U]HFLZZVND]DQLD
GR VWRVRZDQLD LQKLELWRUyZ FKROLQH
VWHUD]\ REHMPXM ]DEXU]HQLD U\WPX
VHUFD VNXUF] RVNU]HOL DVWPD RVNU]HOR
ZD VWDQ\ ]ZL NV]HQLD Z\G]LHOP\ Z
RVNU]HODFK RUD] ]DEXU]HQLD GUR*QRFL
GUyJPRF]RZ\FKLMHOLW
'UXJLP OHNLHP VWRVRZDQ\P Z FHOX
]PQLHMV]HQLD ]P F]HQLD MHVW FKORUR
ZRGRUHN DPDQWDG\Q\ 6WRVXMH VL JR
JáyZQLH DE\ ]ZL NV]\ü SREXG]HQLH
FKRUHJR 'R WHM SRU\ PH Z\ND]DQR
MHGQDN DE\ X FKRU\FK ] ]HVSRáHP SR
]DSDOHQLX URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD
PLDá RQ ZL NV] VNXWHF]QRü QL* SOD
FHER
-DN MX* WR ZF]HQLHM SRGNUHODQR
WDN*H LQQH F]\QQLNL PRJ VL SU]\F]\
QLDü GR QDVLOHQLD ]P F]HQLD QS EyO
RVáDELHQLH PL QL GHSUHVMD RUD] VWRVR
ZDQHOHNL:RVWDWQLPRNUHVLH]QDF]QLH
Z]URVáR ]DLQWHUHVRZDQLH URGNDPL
DQDEROLF]Q\PL L SREXG]DMF\PL
SURFHV\ QDSUDZF]H Z NRPyUNDFK
-HGQ\P ] QLFK MHVW VXURZLF]\ LQVXOL
QRSRGREQ\F]\QQLN Z]URVWX ,:VW SQH
EDGDQLDZVND]\ZDá\QDREQL*HQLHMHJR
VW *HQLD X FKRU\FK ] ]HVSRáHP SR
]DSDOHQLX URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD
MHGQDN QDMQRZV]H EDGDQLD QLH SR
WZLHUG]Lá\ W\FK REVHUZDFML
6WG QLH
PD X]DVDGQLHQLD GOD MHJR VWRVRZDQLD
Z W\FK SU]\SDGNDFK ,QQH UR]ZD*DQH
F]\QQLNL WHUDSHXW\F]QH MHGQDN R QLH
VSUDZG]RQHM VNXWHF]QRFL Z ]HVSROH
SR ]DSDOHQLX URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]H
QLD WR GHSUHQ\O GHK\GURHSLDQGURVWH
URQ U] VNRZ\ F]\QQLN QHXURWURSRZ\
DFHW\OR/NDUQLW\QDRUD]/NDUQLWYQD
:\ND]DQR ]H NUyWNLH GU]HPNL PDM
NRU]\VWQH G]LDáDQLH Z SU]\SDGNX ]P
F]HQLD Z SU]HELHJX ]HVSRáX SR ]DSD
OHQLXURJyZSU]HGQLFKUG]HQLD
2VáDELHQLHPL VQL
'UXJLP REMDZHP QDMF] FLHM Z\PLH
QLDQ\PSU]H]FKRU\FK]]HVSRáHPSR
: \E U D Q H
]DSDOHQLX URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD
MHVWRVáDELHQLHPL QL1DRVáDELHQLH
Z REU ELH ZF]HQLHM ]DM W\FKPL QL
VNDU*\VL DZSRSU]HGQLR
]GURZ\FK PL QLDFK FKR
U\FK
:LQGHEDN L ZVS
QLH VWZLHU
G]LOLDE\RVáDELHQLXXOHJDá\PL QLH
ZF]HQLHM QLH REM WH SURFHVHPFKRUR
ERZ\P8ZD*DM RQL]HFKRU\QLHE\á
SRSURVWXZLDGRP\E\üPR*HQLH
SRZLHG]LDQR PX WHJRZ F]DVLH RVWUH
JR HSL]RGX FKRURE\ ]H ]PLDQ\
GRW\F]
WDN*H
W\FK
PL QL
2EVHUZDFMH
WH
]QDOD]á\
SRWZLHUG]HQLH
Z
Z\QLNDFK
V]F]HJyáRZ\FK ZVW SQ\FK EDGD VLá\
PL QLRZHMZF]DVLHRVWUHJRHSL]RGX
FKRURE\+HLQHJRL0HGLQDRUD]SR
UyZQD ]REMDZDPLDNWXDOQLHZ\VW
SXMFHJR RVáDELHQLD PL QL :\MDQLH
QLHW\FKNZHVWLLMHVWV]F]HJyOQLHLVWRW
QHGODFKRUHJRJG\* PR*HRQRGQLHü
ZUD*HQLH]HRVáDELHQLHZLDGF]\R
SRVW SLHFKRURE\=DQLNLZ]DNUHVLH
QRZ\FK JUXS PL QL REVHUZXMH VL
Z SU]\SDGNyZ
2SLV\ZDQR
WDN*H VNXUF]H PL QLRZH L GU*HQLD
S F]NRZH
/HF]HQLH RVáDELHQLD PL QL REHMPXMH
üZLF]HQLD MHOL QLH V SU]HFLZZVND
]DQH
áDJRG]HQLH WRZDU]\V]F\FK
GROHJOLZRFL EyORZ\FK OHF]HQLH QHX
URSDWLL ]XFLVNXRUD]XSU]HG]HQLH R
VNXWNDFK IRUVRZDQLD PL QL ,QQH
SU]\F]\Q\ RVáDELHQLD NWyUH QDOH*\
UR]ZD*\ü WR ]ZL NV]HQLH FL *DUX FLD
áD SURFHV VWDU]HQLD
RUD] SU]HE\WH
RVWDWQLR FKRURE\ ]ZL]DQH ] XQLHUX
FKRPLHQLHP FKRUHJR SR]RVWDZDQLH
Záy*NXSU]H]RNUHVW\JRGQLSURZD
G]LGR]PQLHMV]HQLDVLá\PL QLRZHMR
6LáDPL QLRZDRFHQLDQDMDNR
SUDZLGáRZD Z F]DVLH EDGDQLD IL]\NDO
QHJR PR*H E\ü REQL*RQD QDZHW R
&\EH[ MHOL GRNRQD VL RELHN
W\ZQHJR SRPLDUX VLá\ L]RNLQHW\F]
QHM
3U]\F]\Q RVáDELHQLD WRZDU]\
V]FHJR QDGPLHUQHPX X*\ZDQLX PL
QLPR*HEYü]P F]HQLHPHWDEROLF]QH
OXE DQDWRPLF]QH XV]NRG]HQLH GR NWy
UHJR GRV]áR ZZ\QLNXQLHGDZQHMP
F]FHM DNW\ZQRFL OXE SU]HWUHQRZD
QLD
'RQLHVLHQLD QD WHPDW üZLF]H
Z]PDFQLDMF\FK V VSU]HF]QH :\GDMH
VL MHGQDN ]H SRGVWDZRZH ]QDF]HQLH
PD LQWHQV\ZQRü Z\VLáNX ûZLF]HQLD
VLáRZH GOD FKRU\FK ] ]HVSRáHP SR ]D
SDOHQLX URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD QLH
PRJ E\üPHF]FH&KRU\SRZLQLHQ
Z\NRQ\ZDü MH FR GUXJL G]LH QDOH*\
WDN MH GRELHUDü DE\ FKRU\ PH RFHQLDá
LFK MDNR EDUG]R FL *NLH &KRU]\ PRJ
XWU]\P\ZDü FL *DU\ QDMZ\*HM SU]H]
VHNXQG 3RPL G]\ SRV]F]HJyOQ\PL
F]\QQRFLDPL PXVL E\ü ]DFKRZDQD
VHNXQGRZD D SRPL G]\ SRV]F]H
JyOQ\PL üZLF]HQLDPL PLQXWRZD
SU]HUZD &KRU\ SRZLQLHQ Z\NRQ\
ZDü PH ZL FHM QL* VHULH SR
SRZWyU]HüZLF]HQLD
a
:\QLNLüZLF]H VLáRZ\FKE\á\]PLHQQH
L ]DOH*Dá\ RG SURJUDPX üZLF]H
2EVHUZRZDQR ]ZL NV]HQLH R
VLá\ L]RNLQHW\F]QHM L R V\QWD]\
F\WU\QLDQRZHM EUDN VSDGNX VLá\ Z
RNUHVLH PLHVL F\ ]ZL NV]HQLH R
PDNVPDOQHJR PRPHQWX REUR
WRZHJR UHGQLH ]ZL NV]HQLH ]DNUHVX
UXFKyZ Z RFHQLDQ\FK SáDV]F]\]
QDFK RUHGQLRLZUHV]FLHRZH
]ZL NV]HQLHVLá\L]RPHWU\F]QHM
%DGDQR WDN*H ZSá\Z SUHGQLVRQX QD
VLá PL QLRZ 3U]HVáDQN X]DVDGQLD
MF VWRVRZDQLH SUHGQLVRQX E\áD KL
SRWH]D ZVND]XMFD QD LPPXQRORJLF]QH
WáR ]HVSRáX SR ]DSDOHQLX URJyZ
SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD
: Z\QLNX
PLHVL F]QHJR OHF]HQLD VWZLHUG]RQR
X FKRU\FK W\ONR QLHZLHONLH NUyWNR
WUZDáH]ZL NV]HQLHVLá\PL QLRZHM
6W\PXODFMD HOHNWU\F]QD PD QD FHOX
Z]PRFQLHQLH RVáDELRQ\FK L XDNW\Z
QLHQLH QLHX*\ZDQ\FK PL QL
=QDMGXMH
RQD WDN*H ]DVWRVRZDQLH Z ]PQLHM
V]HQLX WRZDU]\V]F\FK GROHJOLZRFL
EyORZ\FK P LQ Z PL QLRZRSRZL
]LRZ\P ]HVSROH EyORZY P L ILEURPLDO
JLL 6W\PXODFMD HOHNWU\F]QD XáDWZLD UR]
SRF] FLH SURJUDPX üZLF]H Z]PDF
QLDMF\FK L ]ZL NV]D X*\ZDQLH PL QL
G]L NL ]PQLHMV]HQLX GROHJOLZRFL Ey
ORZ\FK : SU]\SDGNX üZLF]H ] ]D
VWRVRZDQLHP VW\PXODFML HOHNWU\F]QHM
RERZL]XMH WD VDPD ]DVDGD MDN SU]\
UHJXODUQ\FK üZLF]HQLDFK QDOH*\ XQL
NDü]P F]HQLDZZ\QLNXVW\PXODFML
1LH]Z\NOH LVWRWQH MHVW X]\VNDQLH
UyZQRZDJL SRPL G]\ LQWHQV\ZQRFL
üZLF]H D G*HQLHP GR XQLNDQLD ZL N
V]HJR ]P F]HQLD 'ODWHJR WH] SUR
JUDP üZLF]H PXVL E\ü UHDOLVW\F]Q\
L SRZLQLHQ GRW\F]\ü FLOH RNUHORQHM
JUXS\ PL QL NWyUHM F]\QQRü PD XOHF
XVSUDZQLHQLX &KRU]\ SRGGDZDQL
SURJUDPRP üZLF]H XZ]JO GQLDM
F\P WH ]DVDG\ QLH V QDUD*HQL QD
ZL NV]H ]P F]HQLH VWZLHUG]D VL QD
WRPLDVW X QLFK ]ZL NV]HQLH VLá\ L RJUD
QLF]HQLHGROHJOLZRFLEyORZ\FK
%yO
'ROHJOLZRFL EyORZH WR WU]HFL SRG
Z]JO GHP F] VWRFL REMDZ ]HVSRáX SR
]DSDOHQLX URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD 8
FKRU\FK Z\VW SXMH EyO PL QL
D X GROHJOLZRFL ]H VWURQ\
VWDZyZ
%yO REZRGRZ\ OXE PL QLRZ\
PLDOJLD MHVW SRVWU]HJDQ\ MDNR Já ERNL
0R*H RQ E\ü ]DUyZQR SU]HMDZHP
EH]F]\QQRFL PL QLD MDN L MHJR
SU]HFL*HQLD MDN WR MX* ZF]HQLHM
Z\MDQLRQR
DOER
WH]
]DEXU]H
F]\QQRFL PL QLD SROHJDMF\FK QD
Z\VW SRZDQLX EROHVQ\FK NXUF]yZ
:
]HVSROH SR ]DSDOHQLX URJyZ SU]HGQLFK
UG]HQLD
EyO
MHVW
SUDZGRSRGREQLH
HOHPHQWHP ]HVSRáX PL QLRZRSR
ZL ]LRZHJR OXE ILEURPLDOJLL 2VWDWQLH
EDGDQLD Z\ND]Dá\ ]H ILEURPLDOJLD MHVW
EDUG]RF] VWDXW\FKFKRU\FK
/HF]HQLH EyOX QDOH*\ SURZDG]Lü
UyZQRF]HQLH]OHF]HQLHPLQQ\FKREMDZyZ
PLQ
]P F]HQLD
L
]PQLHMV]RQHM
Z\GROQRFL Z\VLáNRZHM /HF]HQLH EyOX
]DOH*\ RG MHJR FKDUDNWHUX : EyODFK
PL QLRZRSRZL ]LRZ\FK
QDOH*\
UR]ZD*\ü ]DVWRVRZDQLH OHNyZ SU]H
FLZGUHSUHV\MQ\FK OXE ] JUXS SRNUHZQ\FK
%yOH PL QLRZH OHF]\ VL FLHSáHP
VWRVRZDQ\P
SRZLHU]FKRZQLH
OXE
Já ERNR
VW\PXODFM
HOHNWU\F]Q
Z\VRNRQDSL FLRZH
SREXG]HQLD
JDO
ZDQLF]QH OXE VW\PXODFMH Z SXQNWDFK
VSXVWRZ\FK RUD] üZLF]HQLDPL UR]FL
JRZ\PL
:VND]DQ\ PR*H E\ü WDN*H
ELRIHHGEDFN L üZLF]HQLD UHODNVDF\MQH
PL QL ,VWRWQD MHVW RFHQD ELRPHFKDQLNL
XWU]\PDQLD SRVWDZ\ L UXFKX FDáHJR FLDáD
3DFMHQWD QDOH*\ SRLQVWUXRZDü Z MDNL
VSRVyEPR*H]áDJRG]LüOXEXQLNQüEyOX
Z F]DVLH Z\NRQ\ZDQLD FRG]LHQQ\FK
F]\QQRFL SUDF GRPRZ\FK L HZHQWXDOQLH
SUDF\]DZRGRZHM
%yOH VWDZRZH WDN*H QDOH*\ OHF]\ü
FLHSáHP $FHWDPLQRIHQ OXE LQQH QLH
VWHURLGRZH OHNL SU]HFLZ]DSDOQH PRJ
SU]\QLHü ]QDF]QH ]áDJRG]HQLH EyOX
6NXWHF]QH V WH] Z\EUDQH üZLF]HQLD
PDMFH QD FHOX Z]PRFQLHQLH PL QL Z
RWRF]HQLX ]PLHQLRQHJR ]DSDOQLH VWDZX
$E\ ]áDJRG]Lü REMDZ\ L ]DSRELHF
QDGX*\ZDQLX VWDZX NRQLHF]QH E\ZD
]DVWRVRZDQLHDSDUDWyZRUWRSHG\F]Q\FK
1DOH*\ XQLNDü QDUNRW\F]Q\FK OHNyZ
SU]HFLZEyORZ\FK MHGQDN MHOL ]DZLRG
LQQHPHWRG\OHF]HQLDPRJ VL RQHRND]Dü
QLH]E GQH
=PQLHMV]HQLH
Z\GROQRFLZ\VLáNRZHM
LRW\áRü
&KRU]\ ] QDVLODMF\P VL ]P F]HQLHP
EyOHP L RVáDELHQLHPVWDM VL FRUD]
PQLHM DNW\ZQL L SU]\ELHUDM QD ZD
G]H
= GUXJLHM VWURQ\ REMDZ\ WH
PRJ VL QDVLODü ] SRZRGX LQWHQV\Z
QHJR SU]\ELHUDQLD QD ZDG]H 6WZLHU
G]RQR ]H FKRU]\ ] ]HVSRáHP SR ]DSD
OHQLX URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD Z
86$ PDM ZL NV]\ FL *DU FLDáD QL*
FKRU]\ Z 6]ZHFML
2FHQLD VL ]H
QDGZDJ PD RN FKRU\FK 3R]R
VWDZDQLH Z áy*NX GRSURZDG]D GR
]PQLHMV]HQLD VSUDZQRFL XNáDGX NU
*HQLD 'ODWHJR QDOH*\ SDPL WDü ]H
SU]HGáX*DMFHVL OH*HQLHZáy*NX]
SRZRGX EyOX OXE LQQ\FK SU]\F]\Q
PHG\F]Q\FK PR*H E\ü SRF]WNLHP
Eá GQHJR NRáD 2SLVDQR ZLHOH Uy*
Q\FK ]HVWDZyZ üZLF]H E GF\FK
PRG\ILNDFM NODV\F]Q\FK LQWHQV\Z
Q\FK SURJUDPyZ UHKDELOLWDFML NU*H
QLRZHM
,QWHQV\ZQRü W\FK
SURJUDPyZ SRZLQQD E\ü WDN GREUD
QDDE\QLHVSRZRGRZDüZ]URVWXDNFML
VHUFD SRZ\*HM PDNV\PDOQHM
F] VWRFL D SRV]F]HJyOQH üZLF]HQLD
SRZLQQ\ WUZDü PLQXW SU]HUZD
PLHG]\QLPL O PLQXW DFDáDVHVMD
PLQXW ,QQL EDGDF]H ]DOHFDM
PQLHM LQWHQV\ZQH SURJUDP\ üZLF]H
WDN DE\ FKRU]\ SRVWU]HJDOL Z\VLáHN
MDNR PQLHM P F]F\ L DE\ QLH GRFKR
G]LáR GR GROHJOLZRFL EyORZ\FK ûZL
F]HQLDSROHJDM QDMH(G]LH QDF\NORHU
JRPHWU]H PDUV]X QD ELH*QL SU]\ VXE
PDNV\PDOQ\P SR]LRPLH Z\VLáNX
üZLF]HQLDFK ]ZL NV]DMF\FK ]DNUHV
UXFKyZ Z]PDFQLDMF\FK L UR]FLJDM
F\FK
:H ZV]\VWNLFK EDGDQLDFK RE
VHUZRZDQR NRU]\VWQH RGG]LDá\ZDQLH
üZLF]H VWZLHUG]RQR ]ZL NV]HQLH
]GROQRFL GR SUDF\ R ]ZL NV]H
QLH PHWDEROL]PX WOHQRZHJR R
]PQLHMV]HQLH NRV]WX HQHUJHW\F]QHJR
FKRG]HQLD ]ZL NV]HQLH F]DVX FKRG]H
QLD L SRSUDZ Z\GROQRFL UXFKRZHM
: QLHNWyU\FK EDGDQLDFK QLH REVHU
ZRZDQR MHGQDN NRU]\VWQ\FK ]PLDQ
SROHJDMF\FK QD Z\WUHQRZDQLX XNáDGX
NU*HQLD L RGGHFKRZHJR &KRU\FK
QDOH*\ ZáF]Dü GR SURJUDPyZ
]PQLHMV]DQLD FL *DUX FLDáD JG\* SR
SUDZLDM RQH Z\QLNL OHF]HQLD WRZD
U]\V]F\FK VFKRU]H WDNLFK MDN FX
NU]\FD KLSHUOLSLGHPLD QDGFLQLHQLH L
LQQHFKRURE\XNáDGXNU*HQLD
=DEXU]HQLDFKRGX
1D QRZH ]DEXU]HQLD FKRGX VNDU*\ VL
D QD QRZH WUXGQRFL ZH
ZFKRG]HQLX SR VFKRGDFK
FKRU\FK ] ]HVSRáHP SR ]DSDOHQLX UR
JyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD =DEXU]HQLD
FKRGX Z\VW SXM F] VWR X FKRU\FK
NWyU]\ ZF]HQLHM VWRVRZDOL Z F]DVLH
FKRG]HQLD Uy*QHJR URG]DMX SRPRFH
QS ODVN NXOH OXE DSDUDW\ RUWRSH
G\F]QH D Sy(QLHM MH SRU]XFLOL 3U]\
F]\Q ]DEXU]H FKRGX MHVW SRVW SXMFH
RVáDELHQLH EyO ]DSDOHQLH NRFL L
VWDZyZ RUD] QLHVWDELOQRü VWDZyZ
Z\QLNDMFD ] RVáDELHQLD PL QL SU]H
FL*HQLD ZL ]DGHá L QLHSUDZLGáRZHJR
XVWDZLHQLD VWDZX 3RPLPR ]H RF]\
ZLVW\P UR]ZL]DQLHP MHVW SRQRZQH
Z\NRU]\VWDQLH W\FK SRPRF\ Z F]DVLH
FKRG]HQLD SU]HNRQDQLH RW\PFKRUHJR
MHVW F] VWR EDUG]R WUXGQH D QDZHW
QLHPR*OLZH ] SRZRGX XWUZDORQHM IL
OR]RILL ÄPH SRGGDZDQLD VL 1DMF]
FLHM ]DOHFD VL VDPRG]LHOQH NUyWNLH
VSDFHU\ EH] GDOV]HJR SU]HFL*DQLD
FKRU\FK VWDZyZ ]ZáDV]F]D NRODQR
Z\FK 1DOH*\ SDPL WDü]HSRVáXJLZDQLH
VL NXODPLOXEODVN PR*HZSU]\SDGNX
EDUG]R GX*HJR REFL*HQLD GR
SURZDG]Lü X FKRUHJR GR V]\ENLHJR
SU]HFL*HQLD EDUNyZ 1DMF] FLHM VSR
W\NDQ\P ]DEXU]HQLHP VWDELOL]DFML VWD
ZX NRODQRZHJR Z\PDJDMF\P ]D
RSDWU]HQLD RUWRSHG\F]QHJR MHVW MHJR
Z\JL FLH GR W\áX Z SR]\FML VWRMFHM
JHQX UHFULYDWXP FR FKURQL FKRUHJR
SU]HG XSDGNLHP ]DJUD*DMF\P ] SR
ZRGX RVáDELHQLD PL QLD F]ZRURJáR
ZHJR XGD 3UREOHPX WHJR PR*QD
XQLNQü ]DRSDWUXMF VWDZ NRODQRZ\
Z VZRERGQ\ PHFKDQL]P ]DZLDVRZ\
] RJUDQLF]HQLHP ]DSRELHJDMF\P Z\
JL FLX GR W\áX DOH XPR*OLZLDMF\P
XVWDELOL]RZDQLH Z\SURVWRZDQHJR NR
ODQD : REU ELH VWDZX VNRNRZHJR
GRFKRG]LQDMF] FLHMGRQLHVWDELOQRFLL
RSDGDQLD VWRS\ OXE SL W\ : WDNLFK
SU]\SDGNDFK VWRVXMH VL SODVW\NRZ\
DSDUDW]DNáDGDQ\QDVWDZVNRNRZ\L
VWRS ] ]DZLDVHP QD Z\VRNRFL VWDZX
VNRNRZHJR XPR*OLZLDMF\P JU]ELHWRZH
]JL FLH VWRS\ D ]DUD]HP X]\VNDQLH
EDUG]LHM Sá\QQHJR UXFKX Z F]DVLH
FKRGX $SDUDW WDNL RJUDQLF]D SRGH
V]ZRZH ]JL FLH VWRS\ L SU]H] WR ]DSR
ELHJDMHM RSDGDQLX
3U]HG]DOHFHQLHPVWRVRZDQLDODVNL
OXENXáQDOH*\RFHQLüF]\QQRüREU
: \EUDQH
F]\ EDUNRZHM -HOL W\ONR Z\VWSL
FHFK\ RVáDELHQLD PL QL OXEEyOHVWD
ZRZHQDOH*\RJUDQLF]\üG\VWDQVFKR
G]HQLD 8FKURQL WR FKRUHJR SU]HG
XSROHG]HQLHP LQQ\FK F]\QQRFL UH
DOL]RZDQ\FK]XG]LDáHPEDUNyZPLQ
SU]HQRV]HQLD SU]HGPLRWyZ LLQQ\FK
FRG]LHQQ\FK F]\QQRFL *\FLRZ\FK
]DSHZQLDMF\FK QLH]DOH*QRü -HOL
GRMG]LHGRWDN]QDF]QHJRRVáDELHQLD
EDUNyZ]HLFKGDOV]HZ\NRU]\VW\ZD
QLHGRFKRG]HQLDJUR]LRJUDQLF]HQLHP
W\FK F]\QQRFL QDOH*\ ]DOHFLü SRUX
V]DQLH VL QD HOHNWU\F]Q\P Zy]NX
LQZDOLG]NLP
=Z\NOH QDMWUXGQLHMV]H GR SU]\M FLD
GODFKRUHJRMHVW]DOHFHQLHSRUXV]DQLD
VL QD Zy]NX LQZDOLG]NLP -HGQDN
XFKRU\FK]PLQLPDOQ UH]HUZ QHXUR
QDOQ SRRVWU\PHSL]RG]LH]DSDOHQLD
URJyZSU]HGQLFKUG]HQLDLW\ONRQLH
]QDF]Q Sy(QLHMV] SRSUDZ MHJRVWR
VRZDQLH MHVW]Z\NOH NRQLHF]QH1LHMHG
QRNURWQLH DE\ Z MDN QDMZL NV]\P
VWRSQLX RJUDQLF]\ü ]X*\FLH HQHUJLL
SU]H] FKRUHJR ]P F]HQLH Z\ZRá\ZD
QHFKRG]HQLHPL]DFKRZDüVSUDZQRü
EDUNyZ GOD LQQ\FK SRGVWDZRZ\FK
F]\QQRFL*\FLRZ\FKQLH]E GQ\MHVW
SRMD]GVDPRELH*Q\QSHOHNWU\F]Q\
VNXWHU
$NW\ZQRFLGQLDFRG]LHQQHJR
1D QRZH WUXGQRFL Z Z\NRQ\ZDQLX
FRG]LHQQ\FK F]\QQRFL *\FLRZ\FK
WDNLFK MDN QS XELHUDQLH VL VNDU*\ VL
FKRU\FK ] ]HVSRáHP SR ]DSD
OHQLX URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD
1DM
F] FLHM WUXGQRFL WH Z\QLNDM ] RVáD
ELHQLD Z REU ELH EDUNyZ L WRZDU]\
V]FHJR EyOX &KRU]\ VNDU* VL WDN*H
QD ]DEXU]HQLD F]\QQRFL VWDZX áRNFLR
ZHJR QDGJDUVWND L U NL 6WDELOQRü
EDUNX MHVW XZDUXQNRZDQD F]\QQRFL
PL QL L ZL ]DGHá =QDF]QH RVáDELHQLH
PR*H E\ü SU]\F]\Q EyOX ] SRFLJD
QLD 3RPRFQH PR*H E\ü ]DVWRVRZDQLH
S WOL ELHJQF\FK GRNRáD UDPLHQLD L
REU F]\ EDUNRZHM 1LHMHGQRNURWQLH
FKRU]\ NWyU]\ Z\NRQXM U NDPL Uy*
QH F]\QQRFL QS SUDFXM QD NRPSX
WHU]H OXE JUDM QD IRUWHSLDQLH V]\ENR
VL P F] ] SRZRGX RVáDELHQLD EDU
NyZ : WDNLFK V\WXDFMDFK QLHRFHQLR
QD PR*H E\ü SU]HQRQD SRGSyUND
SRG SU]HGUDPL 5RG]DM V]\Q\
RUWH]D VWDW\F]QD OXE G\QDPLF]QD
MDN
: \EUDQH
QDOH*\ ]DVWRVRZDü Z SU]\SDGNX ]DEX
U]H F]\QQRFLQDGJDUVWNDLU NL]DOH
*\RGF]\QQRFLPL QLLVWDZyZ
3UREOHP\QHXURSV\FKRORJLF]QH
8FKRU\FK]]HVSRáHPSR]DSDOHQLX
URJyZSU]HGQLFKUG]HQLDRSLV\ZDQR
QDVLORQH REMDZ\ VWUHVX HPRFMRQDOQH
JR XF]XFLHQLHSRNRMXRUD]WUXGQRFL
Z ]DV\SLDQLX VSRZRGRZDQH JRQLWZ
P\OL 3R]D SU]\JQ ELHQLHP VWZLHU
G]DVL XQLFKFHFK\RVRERZRFLW\SX
$ RUD] QDGZUD*OLZRü QD NU\W\N
:FL* QLHZLDGRPRF]\RVWUH]DSDOH
QLH URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD PD
ZSá\ZQDIXQNFMHSR]QDZF]HLQD
VWUyMF]\SU]\F]\Q P F]OLZRFLMHVW
GHSUHVMDRUD]F]\FKRU]\VNDU* VL QD
EyO DE\ Z]EXG]Lü ]DLQWHUHVRZDQLH
RWRF]HQLD
:LQGHEDQN LZVS
PHVWZLHUG]LOLX
SURZDG]RQ\FK SU]H] VLHELH FKRU\FK
FHFK GHSUHVML =NROHL 7DWH LZVS
]D
REVHUZRZDOL ]H X GHSUHV\MQ\FK FKR
U\FK ] ]HVSRáHP SR ]DSDOHQLX URJyZ
SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD VWZLHUG]D VL EDU
G]LHM QDVLORQH GROHJOLZRFL EyORZH
L JRUV]\ RJyOQ\ VWDQ ]GURZLD :\ND
]XM RQL WDN*H PQLHM VNXWHF]QH PHFKD
QL]P\UDG]HQLDVRELH]SUREOHPDPL
RUD] PQLHMV]H SRF]XFLH ]DGRZROHQLD
.RELHW\ VNDU* VL QD ZL FHM GROHJOL
ZRFL VRPDW\F]Q\FK QDWRPLDVW P *
F]\(QL PDM WHQGHQFM GR L]RORZDQLD
VL %DGDQLD WH QLH Z\ND]Dá\ MHGQDN
]H RVáDELHQLH PDXW\FKFKRU\FKSRG
áR*H SV\FKRSDWRORJLF]QH
: EDGD
QLDFK SU]HSURZDG]RQ\FK SU]H] %UXQR
L)QFND
FKRU]\E\OLEDUG]LHMZUD*OLZL
QDNU\W\N LQLHSRZRG]HQLDJRU]HMWH]
SU]HVWU]HJDOL ]DOHFH FR GR OHF]HQLD
.ROHMQH EDGDQLH SU]HSURZDG]RQH
SU]H]W\FKEDGDF]\Z\ND]DáR]HVWUHV
HPRFMRQDOQ\ E\á X W\FK FKRU\FK SU]\
F]\Q ]P F]HQLD FKRU\FK VNDU
*\áRVL QDQLHSRNyMDPLDáR
SUREOHP\]]DV\SLDQLHP:\QLNDVWG
]HFKRU]\]]HVSRáHPSR]DSDOHQLXUR
JyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD Z\ND]XM VLO
QLHM Z\UD*RQH REMDZ\ VWUHVX L QLHSR
NRMXQLHREVHUZXMHVL MHGQDN]ZL]NX
SRPL G]\ ]MDZLVNDPL SV\FKRSDWR
ORJLF]Q\PL D XSROHG]HQLHP IL]\F]
Q\P %DGDQLD IXQNFML SR]QDZF]\FK
SURZDG]RQH SU]H] )UHLGHQEHUJD L
ZVS
M
QLH Z\ND]Dá\ X W\FK FKRU\FK
*DGQ\FK]DEXU]H1DWRPLDVW%UXQR
L ZVS
6
X FKRU\FK VWZLHUG]LOL ]D
EXU]HQLD NRQFHQWUDFML SDPL FL L OR
JLF]QHJR P\OHQLD VSRZRGRZDQH
ÄGHILF\WHP XZDJL -HOL REMDZ\ QHX
URSV\FKRORJLF]QH SURZDG] GR ]DEX
U]H DNW\ZQRFL FKRUHJR QDOH*\ VNLH
URZDü JR GR SV\FKLDWU\ OXE SV\FKROR
JD 1DOH*\ UR]ZD*\ü ]DVWRVRZDQLH
OHNyZ ]PQLHMV]DMF\FK ]DEXU]HQLD
VQX XF]XFLH QLHSRNRMX L SU]\JQ ELH
QLD RUD] ]DVWRVRZDQLH GRUDG]WZD SV\
FKRORJLF]QHJR Z UDPDFK WHUDSLL NR
JQLW\ZQHM : SU]\SDGNX ]DEXU]H
*\FLD URG]LQQHJR OXE LQQ\FK VSRáHF]
Q\FK F]\QQLNyZ VWUHVRZ\FK GX*H
]QDF]HQLH PD SRPRF SUDFRZQLNyZ
RSLHNLVSRáHF]QHM
=DEXU]HQLDRGG\FKDQLD
FKRU\FK ] ]HVSRáHP SR ]DSDOH
QLX URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD VNDU*\
VL QD QRZH ]DEXU]HQLD RGG\FKDQLD
3R ODWDFK RG RVWUHJR HSL]RGX
FKRURE\ ]DEXU]HQLD RGG\FKDQLD Z\
VW SXM SRQRZQLH D* X FKR
U\FK 6]F]HJyOQLH V QD QLH QDUD*HQL
FKRU]\ ] XWU]\PXMF\P VL RVáDELH
QLHP PL QL RGGHFKRZ\FK ,FK Z\
VWSLHQLX PR*H WDN*H VSU]\MDü UR]H
GPD VNU]\ZLHQLH NU JRVáXSD L ]DEX
U]HQLD ]HVWURQ\XNáDGXNU*HQLD8
FKRU\FKXNWyU\FKSRMDZLáDVL Sy(QD
QLHZ\GROQRü RGGHFKRZD Z\PD
JDMFD V]WXF]QHM ZHQW\ODFML VWZLHUG]D
VL QDMF] FLHM RVáDELHQLH PL QL
]PQLHMV]HQLH REM WRFL SáXF PDNV\
PDOQHJR FLQLHQLD ZGHFKRZHJR L Z\
GHFKRZHJR
RUD]
RJUDQLF]HQLH
SU]HSá\ZX
SRZLHWU]D
7DNLH
]DEXU]HQLD F]\QQRFL RGGHFKRZHM
SURZDG]
GR
SU]HZOHNáHM
DOH
QLHZLHONLHM QLHGRGP\ ]PQLHMV]HQLD
SRGDWQRFL SáXF ]ZL NV]HQLD QDSL FLD
FLDQ\ NODWNL SLHUVLRZHM SU]HZOHNáHJR
]PQLHMV]HQLD
ZHQW\ODFML
S FKHU]\NRZHM KDPRZDQLD NDV]OX L
SU]HSá\ZX
Z\GHFKRZHJR
RUD]
RF]\V]F]DQLD GUyJ RGGHFKRZ\FK ]
Z\G]LHOP\ : SU]\SDGNX SRZLNáD
RGGHFKRZ\FK EDUG]R LVWRWQH MHVW LFK
ZF]HVQH UR]SR]QDQLH JG\* SR]ZDOD
WR ]DSRELHF GDOV]\P RJyOQ\P ]DEX
U]HQLRP Z\QLNDMFP ] XSROHG]HQLD
F]\QQRFL SáXF = WHJR SRZRGX GLD
JQRVW\N OHF]HQLH L NRQWURO WDNLHJR
FKRUHJR SRZLQLHQ SURZDG]Lü SXOPR
QRORJ :F]HVQH QLHLQZD]\MQH OHF]HQLH
SROHJDQDZHQW\ODFML]]DVWRVRZDQLHP
SU]HU\ZDQHJR GRGDWQLHJR FLQLHQLD RUD]
]DELHJDFK ZVSRPDJDMF\FK NDV]HO SU]\
UyZQRF]HVQ\P PRQLWRURZDQLX FLQLHQLD
SDUFMDOQHJR JD]yZ Z NUZL W WQLF]HM
]ZáDV]F]D Z QRF\ Z FHOX Z\NU\FLD
HZHQWXDOQHM KLSRNVHPQ
&KRU\FK ]
]DEXU]HQLDPL RGG\FKDQLD QDOH*\ WDN*H
VNLHURZDü GR IL]MRWHUDSHXW\ Z FHOX QDXNL
NRQWURORZDQHJR NDV]OX üZLF]H PDMF\FK
QD FHOX UR]FLJQL FLH SU]\NXUF]RQ\FK
GRGDWNRZ\FK
PL QL
RGGHFKRZ\FK
SU]\MPRZDQLD RGSRZLHGQLHM SR]\FML FLDáD
XWU]\P\ZDQLD RGSRZLHGQLHM Z\GROQRFL
IL]\F]QHM L UR]OX(QLDQLD PL QL -H*HOL GR
]DEXU]H
SU]\F]\QLD
VL
ERF]QH
VNU]\ZLHQLH NU JRVáXSD SRPRFQH PR*H
E\ü ]DVWRVRZDQLH DSDUDWX RUWRSHG\F]QHJR
SDWU] G\VNXVMD SRQL*HM D MHOL FKRU\
SRUXV]D VL QD Zy]NX RUWH]\ GR VLHG]HQLD
:UD]LHRW\áRFLQDOH*\FKRUHJRVNLHURZDüGR
VSHFMDOLVW\RG*\ZLHQLD
=DEXU]HQLDSRá\NDQLD
3RQRZQH ]DEXU]HQLD SRá\NDQLD Z\VW SXM X
FKRU\FK ]DUyZQR ] RSXV]NRZ\P MDN L
QLHRSXV]NRZ\P ]HVSRáHP SR ]DSDOHQLX
URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD
6RQLHV L
'DODNDV
VWZLHUG]LOL ]H GURJD GRXVWQD
]Z\NOH QLH MHVW X W\FK FKRU\FK ]DEXU]RQD D
SU]\SDGNL ]DFKá\QL FLD ]GDU]DM VL QLH]Z\NOH
U]DGNR =DFKá\QL FLH ]ZáDV]F]D X
FKRUHJR ] QDUDVWDMF\PL ]DEXU]HQLDPL
RGGHFKRZ\PL MHVW GOD QLHJR GX*\ P
]DJUR*HQLHP = EDGD 6RQLHVD L 'DODNDVD
Z\QLND ]H SU]\MPRZDQLH SRNDUPyZ PR*H
E\ü XWUXGQLRQH ] SRZRGX ]DEXU]H
F]\QQRFL M ]\ND L SRF]WNRZHM ID]\
SRá\NDQLD RUD] Z UD]LH ]DWU]\P\ZDQLD
SRNDUPX Z XVWDFK 6WZLHUG]D VL ZWHG\
QLHSUDZLGáRZH XQLHVLHQLH NRFL JQ\NRZHM =D
EXU]HQLD Z ID]LH JDUGáRZHM SROHJDM
QDWRPLDVW QD MHGQRVWURQQ\P SU]H
FKRG]HQLX N VD SRNDUPRZHJR JUR
PDG]HQLXVL SRNDUPXZRNROLF\FKU]VWNL
SLHUFLHQLRZDWHM RUD] ]DWU]\P\ZDQLX SRNDUPX
Z JDUGOH 7UXGQRFL Z ID]LH SU]Há\NRZHM
Z\QLNDM ] ]DU]XFDQLD WUHFL *RáGNRZHM L
RSy(QLRQHM UXFKRPRFL GROQHM F] FL SU]Há\
NX ,QWHUHVXMFH MHVW ]H EDGDQLD SRá\NDQLD
RND]Dá\ VL EDUG]LHM F]Xá\ P WHVWHP
SRJDUV]DQLD VL F]\QQRFL UXFKRZHM QL*
EDGDQLDPL QLV]NLHOHWRZ\FK
8FKRU\FKXNWyU\FKZ\VW SRZDá\
ZF]HQLHMOXESRMDZLá\VL QRZH]DEX
U]HQLD SRá\NDQLD QDOH*\ SU]HSURZD
G]Lü RGSRZLHGQLH EDGDQLD GLDJQR
VW\F]QH /HF]HQLH SROHJDQD QDXFH
ZáDFLZHJR SU]\JRWRZ\ZDQLD SRNDU
PyZ SU]\MPRZDQLD RGSRZLHGQLHM
SR]\FMLSU]\MHG]HQLXLXVSUDZQLHQLD
SRV]F]HJyOQ\FKID]SRá\NDQLD
=DEXU]HQLDF]\QQRFLXNáDGX
ZHJHWDW\ZQHJR
1LHWROHUDQFM ]LPQD SRGDMH
FKRU\FK ] ]HVSRáHP SR ]DSDOHQLX UR
JyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD
3RGáR*H
WHJR REMDZX QLH MHVW MDVQH DOH PD
SUDZGRSRGREQLH REZRGRZ\ FKDUDN
WHU -HGQ ] PR*OLZ\FK SU]\F]\Q MHVW
]DQLN PL QL L Z HIHNFLH ]PQLHMV]HQLH
Z\WZDU]DQLD FLHSáD &] VWR Z SU]\
SDGNX QDVLORQ\FK ]DQLNyZ PL QLR
Z\FK XNáDG QDF]\QLRZ\ Z FKRUHM
NRF]\QLH QLH MHVW ZáDFLZLH UR]ZLQL
W\D NU*HQLH NUZLQLHZSHáQLZ\GRO
QH0R*HWRE\üSU]\F]\Q Eá GQHJR
UR]SR]QDQLD ]PLDQ PLD*G*\FRZ\FK
Z QDF]\QLDFK REZRGRZ\FK = SRZR
GX RVáDELHQLD NWyUH SR]EDZLD NR
F]\Q G]LDáDQLD SRPS\ PL QLRZHM
PR*H Z QLHM GRFKRG]Lü GR ]DVWRMX
: SU]\SDGNX QLHWROHUDQFML ]LPQD
]Z\NOH Z\VWDUF]\ ]DáR*HQLH MHV]F]H
MHGQHM ZDUVWZ\ RG]LH*\ &KRU]\ ] ]H
VSRáHP SR ]DSDOHQLX URJyZ SU]HG
QLFK UG]HQLD ]Z\NOH ]DNáDGDM QD QRF
FLHSáHVNDUSHW\
%RF]QH VNU]\ZLHQLHNU JRVáXSDL
RVáDELHQLHPL QLEU]XFKD
2VáDELHQLH PL QL WXáRZLD ] ]DM FLHP
SURVWRZQLNyZ JU]ELHWX L PL QL EU]X
FKD PR*H GRSURZDG]Lü Z ID]LH ]GUR
ZLHQLD SR RVWU\P HSL]RG]LH ]DSDOHQLD
URJyZSU]HGQLFKUG]HQLDGRUR]ZRMX
SRUD*HQQHJR ERF]QHJR VNU]\ZLHQLD
NU JRVáXSD 1D V]F] FLH VWDQ WHQ MHVW
]Z\NOH LQWHQV\ZQLH OHF]RQ\ 0LPR
WR XFKRU\FKPR*HGRFKRG]LüGRSR
Já ELDQLD VL VNROLR]\ Z PLDU QDVLOD
QLD VL RVáDELHQLD PL QL %RF]QH
VNU]\ZLHQLH NU JRVáXSD PR*H SU]\
F]\QLDü VL GR Z\VWSLHQLD ]DEXU]H
]H VWURQ\ XNáDGX NU*HQLD L RGGHFKR
ZHJR -HOL FKRU\ PR*H FKRG]Lü Z
SU]\SDGNXRVáDELHQLDPL QLEU]XFKD
VWRVXMH VL DSDUDW VWDELOL]XMF\ ZVSR
PDJDMF\ PL QLH EU]XFKD $E\ X]\
VNDü ZL NV] VWDELOL]DFM FKRU\ SRZL
QLHQ X*\ZDü ODVNL OXE FKRG]Lü R NX
ODFK &KRU\ ] SRVW SXMF\P SRUD*HQ
Q\P ERF]Q\P VNU]\ZLHQLHP NU JR
VáXSD Z\PDJD EDGDQLD SU]H] FKLUXUJD
VSHFMDOL]XMFHJR VL Z ]DELHJDFK NRU\
JXMF\FK L UR]ZD*HQLD PR*OLZRFL Z\
NRQDQLD XV]W\ZQLHQLD -HOL VNROLR]D
QLH SRVW SXMH L QLH ]DEXU]D LQQ\FK
IXQNFML VWRVXMH VL W\ONR ]DRSDWU]HQLH
RUWRSHG\F]QH 8 FKRU\FK SRUXV]DM
F\FK VL QD Zy]NX LQZDOLG]NLP RER
ZL]XM WH VDPH ]DVDG\ 3RQDGWR X
W\FK FKRU\FK Z FHOX SRSUDZ\ SR]\FML
FLDáD Z Zy]NX VWRVXMH VL MHV]F]H
GRGDWNRZ RUWH] SU]H]QDF]RQ GOD
SR]\FMLVLHG]FHM
&KRUHJR ] ]HVSRáHP SR ]DSDOHQLX
URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD ]H VNROLR]D
OXE RVáDELHQLHP PL QL EU]XFKD QDOH*\
VNLHURZDü GR IL]MRWHUDSHXW\ Z FHOX
QDXNL ]DVDG PHFKDQLNL FLDáD L XWU]\
P\ZDQLD NU JRVáXSD Z RGSRZLHGQLHM
SR]\FML RGSRZLHGQLHM SLHO JQDFML
EH]SLHF]QHJR L ZáDFLZHJR EH] IRUVR
ZDQLD SRUXV]DQLD VL Z W\P ]PLDQ
SR]\FML XáR*HQLD FLDáD Z áy*NX SU]H
PLHV]F]DQLD VL L FKRGX .RQLHF]QH
PRJ RND]Dü VL üZLF]HQLD Z]PDFQLD
MFHUR]FLJDMFHLRGGHFKRZH
%H]VHQQRü
%UXQR L ZVS
VWZLHUG]LOL *H
FKRU\FK ] ]HVSRáHP SR ]DSDOHQLX UR
JyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD NWyU]\ VNDU*
VL QD]P F]HQLHF] VWRPDWUXGQRFL
] ]DV\SLDQLHP ] SRZRGX ÄJRQLWZ\
P\OL =MDZLVNR WR PR*H Z\QLNDü ]H
VWUHVX L QLHSRNRMX 8 FKRU\FK W\FK
VWZLHUG]D VL WDN*H LQQH ]DEXU]HQLD
FR SRGNUHODQR MX* ZF]HQLHM áF]
QLH ] ILEURPLDOJL 7RZDU]\V]\ LP
F] VWR EH]VHQQRü OXE ]DEXU]HQLD VQX
%H]VHQQRü PR*H E\ü VSRZRGRZDQD
SU]HZOHNá\PL EyODPL QD FR WDN*H MX*
ZVND]\ZDQR
8FKRU\FK]]HVSRáHPSR]DSDOHQLX
URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD ] RSXV]NR
Z\PRVáDELHQLHPPL QL]DEXU]HQLDPL
RGGHFKRZ\PL OXE RW\áRFL PR*H
Z\VW SRZDü ]HVSyá EH]GHFKX VHQQH
JR
.ROHMQ SU]\F]\Q EH]VHQQRFL
E\ZDGHSUHVMD'ODWHJRWH*FKRU\FK]
EH]VHQQRFL QDOH*\ NLHURZDü GR
RURGNyZ
]DMPXMF\FKVL ]DEXU]H
: \EUDQH
QLDPLVQXZFHOXGRNáDGQHJR]EDGD
QLDLZ\]QDF]HQLDZáDFLZHJRSRVW
SRZDQLD1DOH*\LPWDN*H]DSHZQLü
RSLHN LQQ\FKVSHFMDOLVWyZSXOPRQR
ORJDSV\FKLDWU\LGLHWHW\ND
32'6802:$1,(
:LHG]D QD WHPDW RVWUHJR ]DSDOHQLD
URJyZSU]HGQLFKUG]HQLDL]HVSRáXSR
]DSDOHQLX URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD
XOHJáD ]QDF]QHPX SRV]HU]HQLX Z F]D
VLHRVWDWQLFKSL WQDVWXODW6]DFXMHVL
*HZ86$*\MHPLQRVyENWyUH
SU]HE\á\ FKRURE +HLQHJR L 0HGLQD
0LPR*HZFKZLOLREHFQHMLVWQLHMH
V]DQVD QD ]XSHáQH ]OLNZLGRZDQLH WHM
FKRURE\ FLJOH ]GDU]DM VL QRZH
SU]\SDGNL D ]H Z]JO GX QD ]ZL NV]D
MFH VL ]DLQWHUHVRZDQLH SRGUy*DPL
ND*G RVRE QDOH*\ SRGGDü V]F]HSLH
QLX&LJOHMHV]F]HQLHPDRSW\PDOQHM
PHWRG\ V]F]HSLH .D*GHJRURNX Z
Z\QLNX ]DVWRVRZDQLD DWHQXRZDQHM
V]F]HSLRQNL GRFKRG]L GR NLONX ]DFKR
URZD QD RVWUH ]DSDOHQLH URJyZ SU]HG
QLFK UG]HQLD =HVSyá SR ]DSDOHQLX
URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD MHVW SUDZ
GRSRGREQLH VSRZRGRZDQ\ ]DEXU]H
QLHP UyZQRZDJL SRPL G]\ SURFHVD
PL RGQHUZLDQLD L UHLQHUZDFML ]DFKR
G]F\PL Z QDVW SVWZLH XRJyOQLRQHM
FKRURE\ NRPyUHN QHUZRZ\FK =D
FKRZDQH QHXURQ\ UXFKRZH QLH PRJ
QDGDO Z\WZDU]Dü QRZ\FK ]DNRF]H
L ZWHG\ RGQHUZLDQLH ]DF]\QD SU]HZD
*Dü QDG UHLQHUZDFM 'RNáDGQD UROD
ZLUXVD RVWUHJR ]DSDOHQLD URJyZ SU]HG
QLFK L ]MDZLVN LPPXQRORJLF]Q\FK
Z ]HVSROH SR ]DSDOHQLX URJyZ SU]HG
QLFK UG]HQLD QLH MHVW RNUHORQD =H
VSyá SR]DSDOHQLXURJyZSU]HGQLFK
UG]HQLD SROHJD QD Z\VW SRZDQLX WD
NLFK REMDZyZ MDN ]P F]HQLH QLH
VWZLHUG]DQH ZF]HQLHM RVáDELHQLH PL
QLRUD]GROHJOLZRFLEyORZH:MHJR
SU]HELHJX F] VWR GRFKRG]L GR ]PQLHM
V]HQLD Z\GROQRFL Z\VLáNRZHM RW\áR
FL ]DEXU]H FKRGX WUXGQRFL Z Z\
NRQ\ZDQLX FRG]LHQQ\FK F]\QQRFL
*\FLRZ\FK SRMDZLHQLD VL SUREOHPyZ
QHXURSV\FKRORJLF]Q\FK RGGHFKR
Z\FK WUXGQRFL Z SRá\NDQLX UR]UH
JXORZDQLD ZHJHWDW\ZQHJR ERF]QHJR
VNU]\ZLHQLD NU JRVáXSD L EH]VHQQRFL
'ODWHJR WH* FKRU\FK ] WHM JUXS\ QDOH
*\ SRGGDü GRNáDGQHPX EDGDQLX D
F] VWRWDN*HSU]HSURZDG]LüXQLFK
:\EUDQH
EDGDQLD ODERUDWRU\MQH /LF]QH ZWyUQH
OXE ZVSyáG]LDáDMFH VWDQ\ FKRURERZH
PRJ PLHü ]QDF]F\ ZSá\Z QD Z\VW
SLHQLH OXE QDVLOHQLH REMDZyZ ]HVSRáX
SR ]DSDOHQLX URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]H
QLD 1LH PD *DGQHJR VZRLVWHJR EDGD
QLD SR]ZDODMFHJR UR]SR]QDü WHQ ]H
VSyá 3RVW SRZDQLH Z\PDJD ZVSyá
G]LDáDQLD IL]MRWHUDSHXWyZ SV\FKLD
WUyZ SXOPRQRORJyZ RUWRSHGyZ
NDUGLRORJyZ DQJLRORJyZ VSHFMDOL
VWyZ PHG\F\Q\ SUDF\ ORJRSHGyZ
SUDFRZQLNyZ RSLHNL VSRáHF]QHM GLH
WHW\NyZ L VSHFMDOLVWyZ SU]\JRWRZXM
F\FK RUWH]\ (GXNDFMD FKRU\FK SURZD
G]RQD SU]H] SRV]F]HJyOQ\FK VSHFMDOL
VWyZ PR*H PLHü FKDUDNWHU LQG\ZLGX
DOQ\ :\ND]DQR MHGQDN ]H LVWRWQ\ MHVW
WDN*H XG]LDá Z SURJUDPDFK HGXNDF\M
Q\FK SURZDG]RQ\FK SU]H] JUXS\
ZVSDUFLD -HGQ ] PHWRG G]LDáDQLD WD
NLFK JUXS V RGZLHG]LQ\ X QRZ\FK
FKRU\FK PDMFH QD FHOX XáDWZLHQLH LP
SU]HVWU]HJDQLD ]DOHFH OHNDUVNLFK :L
]\W\ LQQ\FK FKRU\FK ] ]HVSRáHP SR
]DSDOHQLX URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD
VáX* WDN*H SU]HND]DQLX QRZ\P FKR
U\P V]HUV]\FK GRZLDGF]H RG RVyE
NWyUH SU]HE\á\ RVWUH ]DSDOHQLH URJyZ
SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD L VWDUDá\ VL SRSUD
ZLüMDNRüVZRMHJR*\FLD
.RPHQWDU]
&KRURED+HLQHJR0HGLQDZ\VW SXMFDHSLGHPLF]QLHGRSRWRZ\QDV]HJRZLHNXG]L NLSRVW SRZLPHG\F\Q\RUD]
SURZDG]RQHM UHKDELOLWDFML SR]RVWDZLáD SU]\ *\FLX ZLHOX FKRU\FK NWyU]\ QLH W\ONR SU]H*\OL MHM RVWU\ RNUHV OHF]
X]\VNDOLWDN]QDF]Q VSUDZQRüUXFKRZ*HPR*QDPyZLüRLFKZ\OHF]HQLX
-X* ZODWDFKV]HüG]LHVLW\FK;;ZLHNX6KDUUDUGRSXEOLNRZDáGDQH*H]DFKRZDQLHZURJDFKSU]HGQLFKUG]HQLD
NRPyUHN UXFKRZ\FK ]DRSDWUXMF\FK PL VLH Z\VWDUF]D GR X]\VNDQLD VLá\ Z VNDOL /RYHWWD D W\FK
NRPyUHNSR]ZDODQDRFHQ NOLQLF]Q VLá\MDNRSUDZLGáRZSRPLPRXSU]HGQLHJRQLHGRZáDGX
: RVWDWQLFK ODWDFK PR*QD ]QDOH(ü ZLHOH GRQLHVLH *H ZUyG W\FK SDFMHQWyZ SRMDZLá\ VL QRZH REMDZ\
FKDUDNWHU\]XMFH VL SU]HZOHNá\P ]P F]HQLHP RUD] OLF]Q\PL GROHJOLZRFLDPL ]H VWURQ\ XNáDGX PL QLRZR
V]NLHOHWRZHJR SRVW SXMFH RVáDELHQLH L ]DQLN PL QL QLH W\ONR GRWNQL W\FK XSU]HGQLR W\P VFKRU]HQLHP OHF]
WDN*H PL QL RGOHJá\FK RUD] EyOH L ]PQLHMV]HQLH Z\GROQRFL IL]\F]QHM D WDN*H V]HUHJLHP ]DEXU]H
QHXURSV\FKRORJLF]Q\FK NWyUH QD]ZDQR Ä]HVSRáHP SR ]DSDOHQLX URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD 1LH ZLDGRPR F]\
LVWQLHMH ]ZL]HN WHJR]HVSRáX]H]QDQ\PLRSLV\ZDQ\PZNODV\F]Q\PSLPLHQQLFWZLHQHXURORJLF]Q\P]HVSRáHP
ÄSROLRP\HOLWLVFKURQLFDDQWHULRUJG\* FKRU]\]W\P]HVSRáHPQLH]DZV]HSRGDM ZZ\ZLDG]LHSU]HE\WHSROLR
(WLRSDWRJHQH]D ]HVSRáX SR ]DSDOHQLX URJyZ SU]HGQLFK UG]HQLD MHVW QDGDO QLHMDVQD 6]HUHJ EDGD ]ZáDV]F]D
HOHNWURIL]MRORJLF]Q\FK ZVND]XMH QD GHVWDELOL]DFM MHGQRVWNL UXFKRZHM NWyUD Z SURFHVLH UHLQHUZDFML SR
SU]HE\W\PRVWU\PSROLR]ZL NV]\áD]QDF]QLHVZRM SUDZLGáRZ ZLHONRü
3RQDGWR SURFHV\ VWDU]HQLD VL ] XE\WNLHP MHGQRVWHN PRWRU\F]Q\FK RN URF]QLH RUD] SU]HFL*HQLH
SR]RVWDá\FKPRWRQHXURQyZPRJ SURZDG]LüGRQDUDVWDMFHMQLHVWDELOQRFLIXQNFMRQDOQHMMHGQRVWNLUXFKRZHM
$XWRU SUH]HQWRZDQHM SUDF\ SRGNUHOD *H Z\*HM Z\PLHQLRQH SURFHV\ GRW\F] WDN*H PL QL QLH REM W\FK
ZF]HQLHM SURFHVHP FKRURERZ\P OHF] PR*H WR Z\QLNDü ] EUDNX GRVWDWHF]QHM ZLHG]\ FKRU\FK NWyU]\ Z
G]LHFLVWZLHSU]HE\OLFKRURE +HLQHJR0HGLQD1DOH*\SRGNUHOLü*HEDUG]RLQWHQV\ZQ\Z\VLáHNIL]\F]Q\PR*H
SU]\VSLHV]\üGHNRPSHQVDFM LSRJá ELDüRGQHUZLHQLHW\FKPL QL
3RVW SRZDQLHUHKDELOLWDF\MQHZW\P]HVSROHWRSU]HGHZV]\VWNLPáDJRG]HQLHWRZDU]\V]F\FKGROHJOLZRFLRUD]
WUXGQRFLZDNW\ZQRFL*\FLDFRG]LHQQHJRL]PQLHMV]HQLH]DOH*QRFLVSRáHF]QHMW\FKSDFMHQWyZ
:WyUQH L ZVSyáLVWQLHMFH VWDQ\ FKRURERZH NWyUH SRMDZLDM VL ZUD] ] ZLHNLHP W\FK FKRU\FK Z\PDJDM
ZVSyáSUDF\IL]MRWHUDSHXW\ ] OLF]Q\PLVSHFMDOLVWDPL JG\* QDGU] GQ\PFHOHP UHKDELOLWDFML MHVWSRSUDZDMDNRFL
*\FLDW\FKFKRU\FK
SURIGUKDEPHG-DQ&]HUQLFNL
=DNáDG5HKDELOLWDFML0HG\F]QHM:$0