J Bartyzel Makiawelizm

background image

:áDG]H.OXEX

'RNXPHQW\

+LVWRULD.OXEX

$UW\NXá\

3UR)LGH5HJHHW/HJH

(QF\NORSHGLD3ROLW\NL

1HNURORJLXPSUDZLF\Z;;,

ZLHNX

/LVW\.UyOHZVNLH

/HNWXU\

)RUXP

,QQHVWURQ\

.RQWDNW

.RQWDNW]5HGDNFM3UR

)LGH5HJHHW/HJH





-DN]RVWDü

F]áRQNLHP.OXEX"



6XEVNU\SFMD



7ZyMDGUHVHPDLO



6XEVNU\EXM

3ROHFDP\





0$.,$:(/,=0



-DFHN%DUW\]HO




0$.,$:(/,=0 ZáPDFKLDYHOOLVPR RZ]QDF]HQLXFLVá\PP\OSROLW\F]QD1LFFROR
0DFKLDYHOOHJRRUD]SRNUHZQ\FKPXOXEQDZL]XMF\FKGRQLHJRDXWRUyZ]D]Z\F]DM
QD]\ZDMF\FKVLHELHOXEQD]\ZDQ\FK?SROLW\F]Q\PLUHDOLVWDPL?NWyUHMLVWRWMHVW
SRMPRZDQLHSROLW\NLSU]H]SU\]PDWVNXWHF]QRFLUR]XPLDQHMMDNRNRQLHF]QRü
QHFHVVLWD QLHRG]RZQDGOD]DFKRZDQLDSDVWZDRUD]NLHURZDQLHVL UDFMVWDQXSU]\
]DáR*HQLXQLHXFKURQQRFLVWRVRZDQLDURGNyZPRUDOQLHQDJDQQ\FKRZ]QDF]HQLX
SRWRF]Q\PV\QRQLPSROLW\F]QHMQLHPRUDOQRFLKLSRNU\]MLLZLDURáRPVWZDZJ
VáRZQLNRZHMGHILQLFML/DURXVVHCD?SRVW SRZDQLHQLHORMDOQHLSHUILGQH? FRQGXLW
GpOR\DOHHWSHUILGH 

0\OSROLW\F]QD0DFKLDYHOOHJR

0DFKLDYHOOLE\áSLHUZV]\PZKLVWRULLP\OLFLHOHPNWyU\QDGDáQRZRF]HVQ\ LG]L
RELHJRZ\ VHQVSRM FLX?UHSXEOLND?NWyUHGRWGE\áRQD]ZURG]DMRZ
R]QDF]DMFSDVWZRSUDZRU]GQHE GFH?U]HF]ZVSyOQ? UHVSXEOLFD EH]
Z]JO GXQDIRUP XVWURMRZRGWG]DVWDáRVL QD]ZJDWXQNRZR]QDF]DMF
Z\áF]QLHQLHPRQDUFKLF]Q\W\SXVWURMXRWHM]PLDQLHSU]HVG]LáRQMX*ZSLHUZV]\P
]GDQLXUR]G]LDáX,.VL FLDVWZLHUG]DMF:V]HONLHSDVWZDZV]HONLHU]G\NWyUHPLDá\
OXEPDMZáDG] QDGOXG(PLE\ZDMUHSXEOLNDPLDOERNVL VWZDPL?-HGQRF]HQLHZ
W\PVDP\PUR]G]LDOH0DFKLDYHOOLZSURZDG]LáLQQH]QDF]FHUR]Uy*QLHQLHSRPL G]\
?NVL VWZDPLG]LHG]LF]Q\PL?DNVL VWZDPL?QRZ\PL?XMDZQLDRQRD]DUD]HPJRG]L
SR]RUQVSU]HF]QRüSRJOGyZDXWRUDDQW\WUDG\FMRQDOLVW\F]Q\LDQW\OHJLW\PLVW\F]Q\
VW\OMHJRP\OHQLDGOD0DFKLDYHOOHJRMHVWU]HF]RERM WQSUDZRZLWRüZáDG]\
]DUyZQRZVHQVLHOHJLW\PL]PXSRFKRG]HQLD G]LHG]LF]HQLDZJXVWDORQ\FK]DVDGVXNFHVML
OXERE\F]DMX MDNOHJLW\PL]PXFHOX RGQRV]HQLDZáDG]\GR%RJDL-HJRSUDZD =
SU]HNRQD0DFKLDYHOOLE\áUHSXEOLNDQLQHPQDZHWGRü MDNQD?]LPQHJRUHDOLVW ? 
HJ]DOWRZDQ\PQLHSU]HV]NDG]DáRPXWRMHGQDNZL]DüVZRLFKQDG]LHLSROLW\F]Q\FK]
?NVL VWZHP?RUD]DGUHVRZDüLFKGR?NVL FLD?ZáDQLHG]L NLRERM WQRFLQDNZHVWL 
WUDG\FMLLSUDZRZLWRFL0DFKLDYHOOLQLHSLV]HGOD?NVL FLD?XRVDELDMFHJRPRQDUFKLF]Q
IRUP ZáDG]\OHF]GOD?NVL FLDQRZHJR? LOSULQFLSHQXRYR NWyU\ZáDG]\QLH
RG]LHG]LF]\áOHF]SR]\VNDáM?REF\POXEZáDVQ\PRU *HPSU]H]V]F] FLHOXERVRELVW
G]LHOQRü? WDP*H F]\OLG\NWDWRUDSRMDZLDMFHJRVL ?]QLNG?:áDFLZLHW\WXáWHJR
G]LHáD ,OSULQFLSH QLHSRZLQLHQE\üWáXPDF]RQ\MDNR.VL* OHF]:áDGFDDMHV]F]H
OHSLHM5]G]F\SRQLHZD*MHVWDGHNZDWQ\GODND*GHMVSHUVRQLILNRZDQHMZáDG]\EH]
Z]JO GXQDMHMW\WXáFKDUDNWHULF]DVWUZDQLD:U]GDFK?NVL FLDQRZHJR?XSDWU\ZDá
0DFKLDYHOOLQDG]LHLQDUHDOL]DFM MHJRSDWULRW\F]QHJRFHOX]MHGQRF]HQLD:áRFKL
Z\S G]HQLD],WDOLLQDMH(G(FyZ 1LHPFyZ)UDQFX]yZ+LV]SDQyZ ]DUHSXEOLNDE\áD
GODQLHJRLGHDOQ\PVWDQHPGRFHORZ\PLQQ\PLVáRZ\SU\QF\SDWWZRU]\DUHSXEOLND
XWUZDOD3RJOG0DFKLDYHOOHJRL*?UHSXEOLNLV  EDUG]LHMWUZDáHRGPRQDUFKLLL
GáX*HMGRSLVXMHLPV]F] FLH? 5R]ZD*DQLDQDGSLHUZV]\PG]LHVL FLRNVL JLHPKLVWRULL
5]\PX/LZLXV]DNV,,,U E\á]UHV]WZMHJRF]DVDFKHZHQHPHQWHPQDZHWMH*HOL
UHSXEOLNDQL]P0DFKLDYHOOHJRXJLáVL SU]HGQDND]DPLSROLW\F]QHMNRQLHF]QRFLWRZ
ND*G\PUD]LHE\áRQ]GHF\GRZDQ\PSU]HFLZQLNLHPQLHRGSRZLHG]LDOQHMDXWRNUDFML
?ZáDGFDERZLHPNWyUHPXZV]\VWNRZROQRSRVW SXMHMDNV]DOHQLHF? WDP*H, 

7UDG\F\MQDE\áDQDWRPLDVW0DFKLDYHOOHJRNODV\ILNDFMDJDWXQNRZDXVWURMyZ
Z\Uy*QLDMFDIRUP\U]GXPRQDUFKLF]Q SULQFLSDWR DU\VWRNUDW\F]Q RWWRPDWR L
GHPRNUDW\F]Q SRSRODUH E\áRQMHGQDNZLDGRP*HXVWURMHGREUHáDWZRZ\URGQLHM]

6WURQD]

.RQVHUZDW\]PSO.OXE=DFKRZDZF]R0RQDUFKLVW\F]Q\3URILGH5HJHHW/HJH



KWWSZZZNRQVHUZDW\]PSOHQF\NORSHGLDSKS"LG 

background image







SRZRGXSRGRELHVWZDGRIRUP]á\FKE GF\FKLFKRGSRZLHGQLNDPLGODWHJR]DZ\MFLH
]V\WXDFML]DSHZQLDMFHXVWURMRZLWUZDáRüDSDVWZXSRNyMVSRáHF]Q\X]QDZDá?U]G
PLHV]DQ\? UHSXEEOLFDPLVWD ]SUHIHUHQFMGODUHSXEOLNL?RSW\PDWyZ?F]\OLWDNLHM
MDNLVWQLDáDZMHJRURG]LQQHM)ORUHQFML

6ZRMSRGVWDZRZLQWHQFM 0DFKLDYHOOLZ\UD]LáGRELWQLHZ;9UR]G]LDOH.VL FLDZ
NWyU\PSU]HFKRG]LGRUR]ZD*DQLDNZHVWLLVSRVREXZMDNLZáDGFDSRZLQLHQRGQRVLüVL 
GRSRGGDQ\FKLSU]\MDFLyá?PRLP]DPLDUHPMHVWSLVDüU]HF]\X*\WHF]QHGODWHJRNWR
MHUR]XPLHSU]HWRRZLHOHEDUG]LHMZáDFLZ\PZ\GDMHPLVL Lü]DSUDZGU]HF]\ZLVW
]GDU]H YHULWDHIIHWWXDOHGHOODFRVD QL*]DMHMZ\REUD*HQLHP LPDJLQD]LRQHGLHVVD 
:LHOXZ\REUD*DáRVRELHWDNLHUHSXEOLNLLNVL VWZDMDNLFKZU]HF]\ZLVWRFLDQLVL QLH
ZLG]LDQLVL QLH]QDZV]DNVSRVyEZMDNLVL *\MHMHVWWDNUy*Q\RGWHJRZMDNLVL 
*\üSRZLQQR*HWHQNWRFKFHSRVW SRZDüWDNMDNVL SRZLQQRSRVW SRZDüDQLHWDN
MDNVL SRVW SXMHJRWXMHUDF]HMVZRMNO VN QL*]DSHZQLDSDQRZDQLH6WGF]áRZLHN
NWyU\ZND*G\PVZ\PSRVW SNX]GHF\GRZDQ\MHVWSU]HVWU]HJDü]DVDGGREUDPXVL
QLHXFKURQQLH]JLQüZUyGW\OXNWyU]\QLHVGREU\PL?:\QLNDMFH]WHJRVWZLHUG]HQLD
VPXWQHNRQVHNZHQFMHF]HNDMFH?EH]EURQQ\FKSURURNyZ? MDN6DYRQDURO VWDQRZL
WH*Z\MDQLHQLH]DJDGNRZ\FKVáyZGHG\NDFML.VL FLDGOD:DZU]\FD0HG\FHXV]D
?7HJRG]LHáDQLHXEUDáHPLQLH]DSHáQLáHPJyUQ\PLZ\UD*HQLDPLDQLV]XPQ\PLL
NZLHFLVW\PLVáRZDPLDQL*DGQLQQSRQ WOXER]GRE]HZQ WU]QMDNLPLSLVDU]H
]Z\F]DMQLH]GRELVZHXWZRU\ERFKFLDáHPE\QLF]\P]JRáDQLHE\áRXSL NV]RQHLE\
Z\áF]QLHSUDZG]LZRüWUHFLWXG]LH*ZDJDSU]HGPLRWXF]\QLá\MHPLá\P?

(VHQFM PVWDQRZL]DOHFHQLDW\F]FHVSRVREX]GRE\FLDLXWU]\PDQLDZáDG]\Z\áR*RQH
ZUR]G]LDáDFK;9;;,.VL FLDQDOH*GRQLFKSU]HVWURJDE\QLHVLOLüVL QDKRMQRüD
IDZRUDPLV]DIRZDüRVWUR*QLHLSRPDáX SRFRDSRFR UDGDE\U]G]LüZ]EXG]DMF
VWUDFKF]\QLF]DUD]HPZUD*HQLHáDJRGQRFLLSRER*QRFLX]QDQLH*HOHSLHML*E\
SRGGDQLEDOLVL ZáDGF\QL*HOLJROHNFHZD*\OL]SRZRGXMHJRGREURFL DF]]DUD]HP
GREU]HMHVWXQLNDüSU]\QDMPQLHMZ]EXG]DQLDQLHQDZLFLMHOLQLHPR*QDSR]\VNDü
PLáRFL NRQFHSFMDGZyFKNRQLHF]QLHX]XSHáQLDMF\FKVL VSRVREyZZDONLGUDSLH*QHJR
?OZD?LSRGVW SQHJR?OLVD?JG\*WU]HED?E\üOLVHPE\ZLHG]LHüFRVLGáDLOZHPE\
SRVWUDFKEXG]LüXZLONyZ? WDP*H;9,,, ]DOHFHQLHE\ZUD]LHNRQLHF]QRFL
XFLHNQL FLDVL GRZLDURáRPVWZDSRVW SRZDüWDNE\PyFREDUF]\üZLQZURJD
GRSXV]F]HQLHVWRVRZDQLDWHUURUXSURSXEOLFRERQRDOHZJUDQLFDFKUR]VGNX
U]HF]\ZLVWHMSRWU]HE\LVNDOL]DJUR*HQLDMDNQDMPQLHMV]\PNRV]WHPLZPR*OLZLH
QDMNUyWV]\PF]DVLHFHORZRüZ\QDMG\ZDQLD]DZF]DVX?NR]áDRILDUQHJR?GODHJ]HNXFML
SRVXQL üQLHSRSXODUQ\FKEG(GOD]DWDUFLDQLHSRZRG]HSRGV\FDQLHZ]DMHPQHM
QLHQDZLFLX]DQWDJRQL]RZDQ\FKZURJyZDSUREDWDGODXFLHNDQLDVL GR?]ER*QHJR
RNUXFLHVWZD?LX*\ZDQLD]DZV]H?UHOLJLLMDNRSR]RUX? WDP*H;;, 

-DNR*H?JPLQOLF]\VL W\ONR]SR]RUDPL?SROLW\NDZLQQDE\üGREU]HLVXJHVW\ZQLH
RGHJUDQ\PVSHNWDNOHP?3RZLQLHQSU]HWRNVL* EDUG]RQDGW\PF]XZDü  E\
WHPXNWRJRZLG]LLVá\V]\Z\GDZDáVL FDá\PLáRVLHUG]LHPFDá\ZLHUQRFLFDá\
OXG]NRFLFDá\SUDZRFLFDá\UHOLJLMQRFL6]F]HJyOQLHSRWU]HEQHMHVWDE\VL 
]GDZDáR*HVL PDW RVWDWQLZáDFLZRü? WDP*H;9,,, 5]HF]\ZLVWHSRVLDGDQLHFQyW
SU]\QRVLNVL FLXUDF]HMV]NRG QDWRPLDVWZUD*HQLH*HMHSRVLDGDSR*\WHNGODWHJR
PXVLRQE\üELHJá\ZV]WXFHPLVW\ILNDFMLWDNMDNSDSLH*$OHNVDQGHU9, %RUJLD NWyU\
?QLFLQQHJRQLJG\QLHF]\QLáMDNW\ONRRV]XNLZDáOXG]LRQLF]\PWH*LQQ\PQLHP\ODá?
D*DGQ\FKSU]\VLJQLHGRWU]\P\ZDá?PLPRWRRV]XVWZDXGDZDá\PXVL ]DZV]HJG\*
GREU]H]QDáW VWURQ ZLDWD? WDP*H 'ODZáDGF\NRQLHF]QHMHVWXPLHü?XSL NV]Dü
QDWXU ?F]\OL?E\üGREU\PNáDPFLREáXGQLNLHP? WDP*H ZLDGRPLHLV]F]HU]H
ZáDGFDZLQLHQXQLNDü?KDE\W\ONRWDNLFKZDGNWyUHE\SR]EDZLüJRPRJá\
SDQRZDQLD?FRVL ]DW\F]\W\FK?NWyUHPXW\PQLHJUR*?WRZ\VWU]HJDüVL LFK
PXVLW\ONR?RW\OHRLOHMHVWWRPR*OLZHOHF]MHOLWRQLHMHVWPR*OLZHQLHSRWU]HEXMH
]E\WQLRQLHSRNRLüVL QLPL? WDP*H;9 

8RJyOQLHQLHPW\FKV]F]HJyáRZ\FKLSUDNW\F]Q\FKZVND]yZHNMHVWERGDMQDMVá\QQLHMV]H
]GDQLHQDSLVDQHSU]H]0DFKLDYHOOHJRSRFKRG]FH]5R]ZD*DQDGSLHUZV]\P
G]LHVL FLRNVL JLHPKLVWRULL5]\PX/LZLXV]DDXFKRG]FHSRZV]HFKQLH]DQDMEDUG]LHM
NODURZQGHILQLFM UDFMLVWDQX PLPRL*0DFKLDYHOOLQLJG\WHUPLQXWHJRQLHX*\á 
?.LHG\FKRG]LERZLHPRRFDOHQLHRMF]\]Q\QLHZROQRNLHURZDüVL W\PFRVáXV]QHOXE
QLHVáXV]QHOLWRFLZHOXERNUXWQHFKZDOHEQHOXEVURPRWQH1DGZV]\VWNRLQQH]ZD*Dü
QDOH*\ZWHG\QDWRDE\]DSHZQLüMHMSU]HWUZDQLHLXUDWRZDüMHMZROQRü? ,,, 
VNGLQGWDP\O0DFKLDYHOOHJRMHVWUR]ZLQL FLHPUyZQLHVá\QQHMGHZL]\VWDUR*\WQ\FK

6WURQD]

.RQVHUZDW\]PSO.OXE=DFKRZDZF]R0RQDUFKLVW\F]Q\3URILGH5HJHHW/HJH



KWWSZZZNRQVHUZDW\]PSOHQF\NORSHGLDSKS"LG 

background image

5]\PLDQVDOXV5HLSXEOLFDHVXSUHPDOH[HVWR

=DOHFHQLD0DFKLDYHOOHJRQDOH*\UR]SDWU\ZDüSU]\XZ]JO GQLHQLXMHJRDQWURSRORJLF]QHJR
SHV\PL]PXSRGNUHODRQ*HZLDURáRPVWZRV]DOELHUVWZRSRGVW SLVLáDQLHE\á\E\
GREUUHJXá?JG\E\ZV]\VF\OXG]LHE\OLGREU]\? .VL* ;9,,, DOHWDNQLHMHVW
ZLDWZ\SHáQLD?QLNF]HPQ\PRWáRFK?DOXG]LH]QDWXU\VNáRQQLVW\ONRGR]áHJRLMHOL
QDZHW]GDU]DVL *HSRVW SXMGREU]HWRW\ONR]NRQLHF]QRFL7\ONRSUDZDF]\QLOXG]L
GREU\PL7HQNWRU]G]LSDVWZHPPXVL]DWHPZ\FKRG]Lü]]DáR*HQLD*HOXG]LHV(OL
SRGOLOHQLZLVáDELL]HSVXFLLQDZHWU]DGNRSRWUDILE\ü]á\PLZVSRVyEEXG]F\
UHVSHNW3HV\PL]PWHQQLHVNáDQLDMHGQDNGRELHUQHJRIDWDOL]PXOHF]MHVWKHURLF]Q\
0DFKLDYHOOL]DFK FDGRZ\NU]HVDQLD]VLHELHPDNVLPXPHQHUJLLNWyUDMHVWWR*VDPD]FQ
RW YLUWX RE\ZDWHOVNLHMG]LHOQRFL&KRFLD*FHQWUDOQHPLHMVFHFQRW\QDSR]yUQLH
Z\Uy*QLD0DFKLDYHOOHJRRGP\OLFLHOLNODV\F]Q\FKZU]HF]\ZLVWRFLSRM FLHWR]PLHQLDX
QLHJR]DVDGQLF]RVHQVSRQLHZD*Z\áF]RQDMHVW]QLHJRQLH]DOH*QDRGSROLW\NLWUHü
PRUDOQD0DNLDZHOLDVNDYLUWXWRUR]XPSROLW\F]Q\SDQXMF\PLDáRQDGFLHPQ\P
SRVSyOVWZHPRUD]QDJLQDMF\MHJRQDURZ\LIDQDEHULHGRUHDOL]DFMLFHOyZVáX*F\FK
NRQLHF]QRFLRPSROLW\F]Q\PYLUWXWZRU]\QLHRGáF]QSDU ])RUWXQ ORVHP 
ZFKRG]F]QLZDPELZDOHQWQ\SU]\FLJDMFRRGS\FKDMF\]ZL]HNTXDVLPLáRVQ\
)RUWXQDERZLHPMHVWNRELHWNWyU?WU]HEDNRQLHF]QLHELüLGU F]\üDE\MSRVLüL
WDF\NWyU]\WRF]\QL]Z\FL *DMáDWZLHMQL*FLNWyU]\SRVW SXMRJO GQLH? WDP*H
;;9 )RUWXQDSU]\UyZQ\ZDQDMHVWWDN*HGRUZFHMU]HNLNWyUDMHVWJUR(QDOHF]QLH
ZV]HFKPRFQDL]Z\FL *DW\ONRZWHG\NLHG\QLHQDSRW\NDRSRUX]HVWURQ\JRWRZHMM
XMDU]PLüYLUWXMDNZ]QDQ\PSRU]HNDGOHORVVSU]\MD]DWHPPLDá\P]ZáDV]F]D
PáRG\PERFLV?EDUG]LHM]DSDOF]\ZLL]ZL NV]]XFKZDáRFLUR]ND]XM? WDP*H ]
GUXJLHMVWURQ\QDZHWQDMZL NV]\JHQLXV]QLH]GRáDSU]HFLZVWDZLüVL WHQGHQFMRPVZRLFK
F]DVyZ ODTXDOLWDGHLWHPSL PR*HW\ONRZ\NRU]\VWDüXPLHM WQLHVSRVREQRü
RFFDVLRQH NWyURQHQDVWU F]DM

)DGQD]?QLNF]HPQ\FK?UDG0DFKLDYHOOHJRVDPDZVRELHQLHE\áDZJUXQFLHU]HF]\
QRZDLND*G]RVREQDPR*QDRGQDOH(üZPDNV\PDFKUy*Q\FKDXWRUyZVWDUR*\WQ\FK
MDNUyZQLH*ZZ\NáDGDQHMSU]H]VFKRODVW\NyZUHGQLRZLHF]Q\FKHW\FHV\WXDF\MQHM
GRW\F]FHMVWDQXNRQLHF]QRFL]ZDQHJR?NRQLHF]QRFLFHOX?NWyUDNDQRQLVWRPVáX*\áD
]DX]DVDGQLHQLH SDSLHVNLHJR SUDZDG\VSHQVDFMLRGUHJXá\RJyOQHM3RPL G]\ILOR]RIDPL
NODV\F]Q\PLLWHRORJDPLNDWROLFNLPLD0DFKLDYHOOLPLVWQLHMHQDWRPLDVWNDUG\QDOQDUy*QLFD
ZW\P*HGODSLHUZV]\FKRGVW SVWZRRGQRUP\PRUDOQHMXVSUDZLHGOLZLRQHMHVWW\ONRZ
REOLF]XQLHEH]SLHF]HVWZDU]HF]\ZLVWHJRLMX*]DLVWQLDáHJRDV\WXDFMHWRX]DVDGQLDMFH
WUDNWRZDQHV]DZV]HMDNRSU]\SDGNLDQRUPDOQHLQG\ZLGXDOQHLQLHSRZWDU]DOQH
SRGF]DVJG\0DFKLDYHOOLXZD*D*HSRVW SRZDQLHWDNLHMHVWGRSXV]F]DOQHMX*
SUHZHQF\MQLHZVDP\PSU]HZLG\ZDQLXQLHEH]SLHF]HVWZDDV\WXDFMHWHJRURG]DMX
XZD*Dá]DWUZDáHWRWH*]SRVW SRZDQLDZEUHZQRUPLHF]\QLáQRUP  ]DVDG GODDXWRUD
.VL FLDSU]HVWU]HSROLW\NLMHVWREV]DUHPSHUPDQHQWQHJRVWDQXZ\MWNR
ZHJR

&HOMDNLVWDZLDVRELH LZáDG]\ 0DFKLDYHOOLMHVWW\ONRSUDNW\F]Q\XW\OLWDUQ\MDN
SRVW SRZDüE\]GRE\üZáDG] RUD]MHMQLHVWUDFLüMHJRPHWRGDMHVWHPSLU\F]QDL
LQGXNF\MQD DF]LQGXNFMDF] VWRQDJLQDMFDIDNW\GRSRJOGyZ UR]XPLHQLHSROLW\NL
XWR*VDPLDMFHM]ZáDG]W\ONRZVHQVLHSRWHVWDV VLá\SDQRZDQLD 7\PVDP\PP\O
SROLW\F]QDPE\áDU]HF]\ZLFLHQRZRFLZVWRVXQNXGRNODV\F]QHMILOR]RILLSROLW\NL
NWyUDVWDZLDáDS\WDQLHRQLHXW\OLWDUQ\LRELHNW\ZQ\ ]SXQNWXZLG]HQLDVSUDZLHGOLZRFL 
DFKU]HFLMDVNDWDN*HRPHWDIL]\F]Q\FHOSROLW\NLLRGQDMG\ZDáDJRZ]DSURZDG]DQLXL
XWU]\P\ZDQLDáDGX RUGR RUD]SRGWU]\PXMFHMJRMHGQRFL XQLWDV ZSRNRMX3RQLHZD*
ZPUR]XPLHQLHSROLW\NLMHVWWDXWRORJLF]QH SROLW\NDWRZáDG]DDZáDG]DMHVWSRWR
*HE\U]G]Lü ?URGHN? U]G]HQLH ]DPLHQLDVL WXQLHXFKURQQLHZFHOPMHVWSU]HWR
QLHW\OHXSRPQLHQLHPVL RDXWRQRPL SROLW\NLMDNRG]LHG]LQ\ ?V]WXNLU]G]HQLD? 
SRVLDGDMFHMZáDVQHUHJXá\WDNMDNSRVLDGDMHHW\NDF]\HVWHW\ND ERWHMDXWRU]\
NODV\F]QLQLHW\ONR*HQLHSU]HF]\OLOHF]ZáDQLHGRFLHNDOLMHM]DVDG OHF]XVWDQRZLHQLHP
ZRGHUZDQLXRGPHWDIL]\NLLWHRORJLLMHMDXWRWHOLL VDPRFHORZRFL 

0DNLDZHOLDVNDPHWRGDSROLW\F]QHJRSR]QDQLDLG]LDáDQLDQLHSURZDG]LWDN*HGR
VWZRU]HQLDQDXNLSROLW\F]QHMSRQLHZD*]DZVND]yZNDPL0DFKLDYHOOHJRQLHVWRL*DGQD
WHRULDU]HF]\ZLVWRFLQSRSHUDF\MQRü]DOHFHQLDDE\NLHURZDüVL QLHW\PFRF]\QLü
QDOH*\OHF]W\PFROXG]LHF]\QLQDSUDZG  FKHVLID MHVW ]SRZRGXEH]WURVNR
DWHRUHW\F]QHJRSRVáXJLZDQLDVL VáRZDPL?SUDZGD??U]HF]\ZLVWRü?F]\
?Z\REUD*HQLH? QLHW\ONRF]\VWR?WHFKQLF]QD?DOHLRJUDQLF]RQDERVND]XMHQD

6WURQD]

.RQVHUZDW\]PSO.OXE=DFKRZDZF]R0RQDUFKLVW\F]Q\3URILGH5HJHHW/HJH



KWWSZZZNRQVHUZDW\]PSOHQF\NORSHGLDSKS"LG 

background image

VWDW\VW\F]QSU]\SDGNRZRüOXG]NLHJRSRVW SRZDQLDL]RJURPQ\PPDUJLQHVHPEá GX
SR]QDZF]HJRPDNLDZHOLDVND?SUDZGDU]HF]\ZLVW\FK]GDU]H?WRFRQDMZ\*HM
SU]\F]\QRZRVNXWNRZH]ZL]DQLHNRQNUHWQ\FKIDNWyZQLHGDMFHSRGVWDZGRV]HUV]\FK
XRJyOQLHHSLVWHPRORJLF]QLHMHVWRQDEH]ZDUWRFLRZDSRQLHZD*QLH]DVáXJXMHQDPLDQR
SUDZG\WRFRRERZL]XMHW\ONRZNRQWHNFLHFLJOH]PLHQLDMF\FKVL RNROLF]QRFLZP
SUDZGDUR]XPLDQDNODV\F]QLH MDNR]JRGQRüVGX]U]HF]\ZLVWRFL DWDN*HSUDZGD
RQWRORJLF]QD ]JRGQRüE\WXRGZ]RURZDQHJRQD]LHPL]E\WHPZLHF]Q\P QLH
RGJU\ZDM*DGQHMUROL?SUDZG?MHVWWXW\ONRWRFR]DSUDZG XFKRG]L5RV]F]HQLHP
GRRGNU\FLDQLH]QDQHMMDNRE\ZF]HQLHM?SUDZG\RSROLW\FH?MHVWZWSOLZHQLHW\ONRZ
ZLHWOHQLHRU\JLQDOQRFLSRV]F]HJyOQ\FKP\OLF]\]DOHFHDOHWDN*HRJUDQLF]HMHJR
WHRULRSR]QDZF]HJRQRPLQDOL]PXNWyU\ZVNXWHNQHJDFMLLVWQLHQLDXQLZHUVDOLyZ
SRM üRJyOQ\FK VDPVND]DáVL QDQLHPR*QRüSR]QDQLDF]HJRNROZLHNFRZ\NUDF]D
SR]DVIHU GRZLDGF]HQLD]P\VáRZHJR9HULWDHIIHWWXDOHVWDQRZLUyZQLH*NDPXIOD*GOD
]DSR*\F]RQHM ]DSRUHGQLFWZHPV]NRá\SDGHZVNLHM RG$ZHUURHVDNRQFHSFML
?SRGZyMQHMSUDZG\?RGGDQHMZG\VSR]\FM ZáDGF\?SUDZG\GODPDOXF]NLFK?F]\OL
X*\WHF]QHJRSROLW\F]QLHNáDPVWZDL?SUDZG\GODP GUFyZ?NWyUHMXGRVW SQLHQLH
SRVSyOVWZXPRJáRE\RND]DüVL V]NRGOLZHGODSDVWZD

2EDSRZRG\QLHREHFQRüWHOHRORJLLSROLW\NLRUD]EUDNWHRULLU]HF]\ZLVWRFL
VSUDZLDML*PQLHPR*QDQD]ZDüILOR]RILSROLW\NLSU]HGPLRWHPILOR]RILLSROLW\NLMHVW
ERZLHP?F]\QLHQLH?NWyUHJRFHOMHVWPRUDOQ\LSROHJDQDRNUHODQLXSR*GDQHJR
VSRVREX*\FLDRVLJDQHJRG]L NLSROLW\FH]DLQWHUHVRZDQLDPGRW\F]QDWRPLDVW
G]LDáDQLDSRM WHJRMDNR?URELHQLH?JG]LHFHOF]\QQRFLMHVWPRUDOQLHQHXWUDOQ\JG\*
LG]LHWXRSL NQRDOERRX*\WHF]QRüMHVWRQMHG\QLHWHFKQLNSROLW\NLXF]F
GLDJQR]RZDQLDV\WXDFMLPHWRGSRVW SRZDQLDNDONXODFMLVNXWNyZSRGHMPRZDQ\FK
G]LDáDF] VWR]UHV]WRSUREOHPDW\F]QHMSU]\GDWQRFL NWR]áROLZLH]DXZD*\á*H
WUDNWXMFG]LHáD0DFKLDYHOOHJRMDNRLQVWUXNWD*PR*QDZQDMOHSV]\PZ\SDGNXGRMüGR
VWDQRZLVNDSRGSUHIHNWD PMHVW]DWHPDPHWDIL]\F]Q\ERSR]EDZLRQ\
RGQLHVLHQLDGRE\WXSR]DMHJRHPSLU\F]Q\PLSU]HMDZLHQLDPL

-DNRQDLZQ\LXSURV]F]RQ\QDOH*\QDWRPLDVWRNUHOLü]DU]XW?QLHPRUDOQRFL?Z
VWRVXQNXGR0DFKLDYHOOHJR6NGLQGZLDGRPR*HMDNRF]áRZLHNSU\ZDWQ\SURZDG]LáRQ
*\FLHSU]\NáDGQHDMDNRXU] GQLNSDVWZRZ\E\áZU F]Z]RUHPXF]FLZRFLL
VXPLHQQRFL*DHWDQR0RVFDSRGNUHOD*H?SRVLDGDáRQWH*ZZ\VRNLPVWRSQLXFQRW 
NWyUQD]\ZDP\XF]FLZRFL]DZRGRZDNWyUDSROHJDQDSRGDQLXF]\WHOQLNRZLVZHM
P\OLEH]Z]JO GXQDSRZRG]HQLHOXEQLHSRZRG]HQLHNVL*NLEH]Z]JO GXWDN*HQD
NRU]\FLOXEQLHEH]SLHF]HVWZDZ\QLNDMFHVWGGODDXWRUD? +LVWRULDGRNWU\Q
SROLW\F]Q\FKRGVWDUR*\WQRFLGRQDV]\FKF]DVyZ:DUV]DZD>@ 1LHE\áDQL
NDULHURZLF]HPERJG\E\QLPE\áWRSU]\VZRLFK]GROQRFLDFK]DV]HGáE\QDSHZQR
Z\*HMDQLRV]XVWHPERJG\E\QLPE\áWRQLHQDSLVDáE\NVL*NLXF]FHMV]WXNL
ZSURZDG]DQLDZEáGSUDZG]LZLRV]XFLQLHXMDZQLDMVZRLFKWDMHPQLF7\ONRSR]RUQ\P
SDUDGRNVHPMDNR*HGRW\F]\F]áRZLHND?NWyUHJRQD]ZLVNRVWDáRVL V\QRQLPHP
GZXOLFRZRFLLV]DOELHUVWZD?MHVWWH*VSRVWU]H*HQLH*H0DFKLDYHOOL?MDNZL NV]Rü
W\FKNWyU\FKP\ONV]WDáWRZDáDVL QDNVL*NDFKMHVW  LGHDOLVWDMDNZV]\VF\
LGHDOLFLE\ZDQDLZQ\? WDP*H 

$XWRU.VL FLDQLHE\áHW\F]Q\PUHODW\ZLVWQLH]DSU]HF]DáLVWQLHQLXRELHNW\ZQHJRGREUD
L]áDDQLQLHSUyERZDá]DFLHUDüJUDQLF\SRPL G]\QLPLMDNUyZQLH*X]DOH*QLDü
ZDUWRFLRZDQLDF]\QXRG?SXQNWyZZLG]HQLD?UR]PDLW\FKLGHRORJLL?RULHQWDFML?F]\
LQWHUHVyZSDUW\NXODUQ\FKZW\PVHQVLHQLHE\áQDZHW?QRZRF]HVQ\?=EURGQL 
QD]\ZDá]EURGQLSU]HPRFSU]HPRF]GUDG ]GUDGZLDURáRPVWZRZLDURáRPVWZHP
SU]\]QDZDáWRQDZHWMHJRWDNVXURZ\NU\W\NMDN-DFTXHV0DULWDLQGRGDMF*H
0DFKWSROLWLN0DFKLDYHOOHJRQLHSUHWHQGXMHGRWHJRDE\%yJE\áSRMHMVWURQLH 0RUDO
3KLORVRSK\/RQGRQ 'RNáDGQHEDGDQLDZ\ND]Dá\*HWDNLFKVáyZMDN
?GREU\? EXRQR ?]á\? FDWWLYR ?XF]FLZ\? RQHVWR ?QLHOXG]NL? LQXPDQR 
X*\ZD0DFKLDYHOOLGRNáDGQLHZWDNLP]QDF]HQLXZMDNLPX*\ZDQRLFKZM ]\NX
SRWRF]Q\P]DMHJR*\FLDLZMDNLPX*\ZDVL LFKQDGDO7ZLHUG]LáQDWRPLDVW*HZ
G]LDáDQLXSROLW\F]Q\PSRVW SNLWDNLHSU]\QRV]QLHSU]HVWDMFE\üPRUDOQLHXMHPQ\PL
]D]Z\F]DMNRU]\üSRGF]DVJG\ZDUXQNRZDQHVNUXSXáDPLHW\F]Q\PLSRZVWU]\P\ZDQLH
VL RGQLFKQDRJyáSURZDG]LGR]JXE\:EUHZSRPyZLHQLRPQDMEDUG]LHM]DSDOF]\Z\FK
DQW\PLDNLDZHOLVWyZ DOERSRFKZDáRPQLHSURV]RQ\FKDSRORJHWyZ 0DFKLDYHOOLQLJG\QLH
JáRVLáMDNRE\F]\Q\QLHPRUDOQHL]EURGQLF]HQDOH*DáRSRSHáQLDüDW\PEDUG]LHMDE\Z
LFKSRSHáQLDQLX]QDMGRZDüVDG\VW\F]QHXSRGREDQLHSU]HFLZQLH]SXQNWXZLG]HQLDP
?EH]LQWHUHVRZQL?VDG\FLSRNURMX.DOLJXOLF]\7DPHUODQDVQDMJRUV]\PL]PR*OLZ\FK

6WURQD]

.RQVHUZDW\]PSO.OXE=DFKRZDZF]R0RQDUFKLVW\F]Q\3URILGH5HJHHW/HJH



KWWSZZZNRQVHUZDW\]PSOHQF\NORSHGLDSKS"LG 

background image

ZáDGFyZDOERZLHPWHQNWRJXVWXMHZ]EURGQLZ]EXG]DSRZV]HFKQ\ZVWU WZL FZFDOH
QLHMHVWVNXWHF]Q\LQLHE G]LH]GROQ\RFDOLüSDVWZD?']LNDVURJRüLQLHOXG]NRüZ
SRáF]HQLX]QLH]OLF]RQ\PL]EURGQLDPL? .VL* 9,,, W\UDQD6\UDNX]$JDWRNOHVD
SU]\QLRVá\PXZSUDZG]LHVXNFHVDOHRNU\á\MHJRLPL WDNKDE*HQLHZV]HGáRQGR
SDQWHRQXERKDWHUyZOXG]NRFLZSU]HFLZLHVWZLHGR7H]HXV]D5RPXOXVD0RM*HV]DL
&\UXVDNWyU]\ZSUDZG]LHWH*SRSHáQLDOLF]\Q\NUZDZHDOHW\ONRRW\OHRLOHE\áRWR
NRQLHF]QHLNRU]\VWQHGODRE\ZDWHOL1DQHJDW\ZQ\FKSU]\NáDGDFK3L]\VWUDWD'LRQL]MRVD
L&H]DUD0DFKLDYHOOLGRZRG]LWDN*H]JXEQRFLF]\VWHM*G]\ZáDG]\

1LH?VDG\]P?OHF]EH]QDPL WQ\SUDJPDW\]PDOHUyZQLH*FK üPLQLPDOL]DFMLL
?]ZLQL FLD?VSLUDOLMX*]DLVWQLDáHMSU]HPRF\SU]\ZLHFDGRNRQDQHPXSU]H]
0DFKLDYHOOHJRUR]Uy*QLHQLXSRPL G]\?GREU\P?OXE?]á\P?SRVáXJLZDQLHPVL 
RNUXFLHVWZHPNWyUHSROHJDQDW\P*H?GREU]HX*\W\PLPRJQD]\ZDüVL WH MH*HOLR
]áHPZROQRSRZLHG]LHü*HMHVWGREUHP NWyUHSRSHáQLDVL UD]MHGHQ]NRQLHF]QRFLGOD
XEH]SLHF]HQLDVL QLHSRZWDU]DVL LFKSy(QLHMDNWyUHQDGWRSU]\QRV]PR*OLZLH
QDMZL NV]\SR*\WHNSRGGDQ\P?QDWRPLDVW?(OHX*\W\PLVWDNLHNWyUHFKRüE\]
SRF]WNXQLHOLF]QH]F]DVHPPQR*VL ]DPLDVWU]HGQLHü? WDP*H 

5]G\EH]P\OQLHRNUXWQHLSRJDUGOLZLHGHSF]FHXF]XFLDOXG]LZFDOHQLHVGODZáDGF\
EH]SLHF]QHGREUHU]G]HQLHSROHJDSU]HFLH*QDVNXWHF]Q\PZ\WZDU]DQLX
SU]HZLDGF]HQLD*HZáDGFDF]\QLGREU]H'ODWHJR?GREU]HXU]G]RQHSDVWZDLPGU]\
NVL* WDVWDUDOLVL ]DZV]HEDUG]RSLOQLHRWRE\PR*Q\FKQLHSU]\SURZDG]DüGR
UR]SDF]\DGRJDG]DüOXGRZLL]DGRZROLüJRJG\*WRMHVWMHGQR]QDMZD*QLHMV]\FK]DGD
NVL FLD? WDP*H;,; 0LQLPXPWHJRFRXF]\QLüPR*HUR]WURSQ\NVL* DE\QLHE\ü
]QLHQDZLG]RQ\PMHVWSRZFLJQL FLHVL ?RGPLHQLDVZRLFKRE\ZDWHOLLSRGGDQ\FKLRG
LFKQLHZLDVW?DOERZLHP?OXG]LHSU G]HMSXV]F]DMZQLHSDPL üPLHUüRMFDQL*VWUDW 
RMFRZL]Q\? WDP*H;9,, 7HJRURG]DMXUDG\QLHW\ONR*HQLHVQLHPRUDOQHDOHQDZHW
QDWOH]DVWDQHMSUDNW\NLPR*QDMHWUDNWRZDüMDNRSUyE SRGGDQLDZáDGFyZQLHEáDK\P
RJUDQLF]HQLRP-HGQDNZL NV]H]QDF]HQLHQL*GR SUREOHPDW\F]QHMDSULRUL PRUDOQRFL
ZáDGFyZSU]\ZL]\ZDá0DFKLDYHOOLGR]ZL]DQLDU]G]F\FKSU]HSLVDPLSUDZDZF]\P
XSDWU\ZDáOHSV]HM?U NRMPLEH]SLHF]HVWZDGODZV]\VWNLFKLFK
SRGGDQ\FK? 5R]ZD*DQLD, GDMF]DSR]\W\ZQ\Z]yU.UyOHVWZR)UDQFML

-HG\QHF]HJR0DFKLDYHOOLU]HF]\ZLFLHSUDJQLHGRZLHüWRWZLHUG]HQLHL*ZSROLW\FHQLH
GDVL XQLNQüF]\QyZZ*\FLXSU\ZDWQ\PXZD*DQ\FKSRZV]HFKQLH]DQLHHW\F]QHPLPR
WRMHGQDNSROLW\NDRERZL]XMHSRF]XFLHPLDU\LJUDQLF0DFKLDYHOOLWHG\QLHMHVW
?QLHPRUDOQ\?OHF]?DPRUDOQ\?QLHSU]HF]\HW\FHRELHNW\ZQHMW\ONR]DZLHV]D
MHMRERZL]\ZDQLHZG]LHG]LQLHSROLW\NLZLPL Z\PRJyZSROLW\F]QHM?NRQLHF]QRFL?
NWyUD]QDW\ONRMHGQUHJXá ]DVDG NRU]\FLLZ]DMHPQRFL?2Wy*PGU\SDQQLH
PR*HDQLSRZLQLHQGRWU]\P\ZDüZLDU\MH*HOLWDNLHGRWU]\P\ZDQLHSU]\QRVLPXV]NRG L
JG\]QLNQ á\SU]\F]\Q\NWyUHVSRZRGRZDá\MHJRSU]\U]HF]HQLH? .VL* ;9,,, 0GU\
SROLW\NQLHSRZLQLHQZSUDZG]LH?SRU]XFDüGREUHJRJG\PR*QD?OHF]?PXVLXPLHü
F]\QLü]áRJG\WU]HED? WDP*H -H*HOLFHFK\?OLVD?L?OZD?]RVWDQGREU]H
VNRPELQRZDQHWRSROLW\NRF]\PZLDGF]SU]\NáDG\$JHVLODRVD7LPROHRQD
.DPLOOXVDF]\6F\SLRQDPR*HSR]ZROLüVRELHQDSUDZRüáDJRGQRüOLWRü
V]ODFKHWQRüLZLHONRGXV]QRüMHOLMHGQDNRNROLF]QRFLXNáDGDMVL QLHIRUWXQQLHWRQLH
SR]RVWDMHPXQLFLQQHJRMDNQDODGRZDQLH)LOLSD0DFHGRVNLHJR+DQQLEDODF]\
6HZHUXVD

3RGREQLHPQLHMGZX]QDF]Q\QL*WRVL F] VWRZ\ROEU]\PLDMHVWVWRVXQHN0DFKLDYHOOHJR
GRUHOLJLL:W\P]DNUHVLHPQLHSROHJDDQLQDDWHL]PLHRVRELVW\PJG\*]QDSLVDQHJR
URNSU]HGPLHUFLWHVWDPHQWXDXWRUD.VL FLD (VRUWD]LRQHDOODSHQLWHQ]D Z\QLND*H
?SU\ZDWQLH?E\áRQNDWROLNLHP FKRüQLHPDSHZQRFLF]\QLHMHVWWRDSRNU\I DQLQD
SU]HGVWDZLHQLXDOWHUQDW\ZQHJRVSRVREXUR]XPLHQLD?SROLW\NLFKU]HFLMDVNLHM? MDN
SUyERZDOLGRZLHü?PDNLDZHOLFLFKU]HFLMDVF\? OHF]QDUDG\NDOQ\PRGVHSDURZDQLX
SROLW\NLRGUHOLJLLLQWHQFMRQDOQLHLLQFRQFUHWRMHVWWRVHSDUDFMDSROLW\NLRGUHOLJLL
FKU]HFLMDVNLHM NDWROLFNLHM F]HJRZSURVWSRGDQPRW\ZDFMMHVWWR*HQDND]\
PRUDOQHWHMUHOLJLLNROLGXM]HVNXWHF]QRFLSROLW\NL0DFKLDYHOOLZ*DGQ\PPLHMVFXQLH
SRGHMPXMHG\VNXVMLDQL]SUDZGDPLZLDU\JáRV]RQ\PLSU]H].RFLyáDQL]
RERZL]\ZDOQRFLLZDUWRFLFQyWFKU]HFLMDVNLFKZ*\FLXSU\ZDWQ\PW\ONR
XSRUF]\ZLHGRZRG]LLFKQLHSU]\GDWQRFLRE\ZDWHOVNLHM&KU]HFLMDVWZRMHJR]GDQLHP
MHVWVSU]HF]QH]HWRVHPUHSXEOLNDVNLPSRQLHZD*XF]FOXG]LPLáRVLHUG]LDSRNRU\L
FLHUSOLZHJR]QRV]HQLDNU]\ZGF]\QLLFKLVWRWDPLVáDE\PLL]GROQ\PLMHG\QLHGR
]QRV]HQLDFLHUSLH]DPLDVWLFKSU]H]Z\FL *DQLDDF]SRZ\UD*HQLXSU]\SXV]F]HQLD*HWR

6WURQD]

.RQVHUZDW\]PSO.OXE=DFKRZDZF]R0RQDUFKLVW\F]Q\3URILGH5HJHHW/HJH



KWWSZZZNRQVHUZDW\]PSOHQF\NORSHGLDSKS"LG 

background image

]SRZRGXRZ\FKLPPDQHQWQ\FKFHFKUHOLJLLFKU]HFLMDVNLHM?]DNRU]HQLáDVL QDZLHFLH
VáDERüZ\GDMFWHQZLDWQDáXSQLHJRG]LZFyZ?0DFKLDYHOOLDVHNXURZDáVL 
]DVWU]H*HQLHP*H?MHOLZLDWMHVW]QLHZLHFLDá\DQLHERZ\GDMHVL EH]VLOQHQLH
SU]\SLVXMP\]DWRZLQ\QLNRPXLQQHPXMDNW\PNWyU]\UHOLJL QDV]SRM OLQDVSRVyE
SUy*QLDNyZDQLHWDNMDNE\Z\PDJDáRWHJRP VWZR*G\E\ERZLHP]ZUyFLOLRQLXZDJ 
QDWR*HUHOLJLDQDV]DSR]ZDODQDZ\Z\*V]HQLHLREURQ RMF]\]Q\SU]HNRQDOLE\VL *H
QDND]XMHQDPRQDW RMF]\]Q NRFKDüF]FLüLVSRVRELüVL GRMHM
REURQ\? 5R]ZD*DQLD,, -HGQDNSRZRáXMFVL JG]LHLQG]LHM +LVWRULHIORUHQFNLH 
QD]DVá\V]DQSRQRüRG.X(P\0HG\FHXV]DPDNV\P ?QLHGDVL U]G]LüSDVWZHP
RGPDZLDMF2MF]H1DV]?0DFKLDYHOOLVWDZLDáSU]HG?NVL FLHP?QDRVWU]XPLHF]D
SU]HF]F\SRZ\*V]HMDVHNXUDFMLG\OHPDWDOER]EDZLHQLHZáDVQHMGXV]\DOERRFDOHQLH
SDVWZDLND]DáPXZ\ELHUDüWRGUXJLH

7HRUHW\F]QLHGRNRQDQ\ZPUR]G]LDáSROLW\NLRGUHOLJLLFKU]HFLMDVNLHMQLHPXVLDá
SRFLJDü]DVREODLF\]DFMLSDVWZDSRQLHZD*0DFKLDYHOOLE\áZLHOELFLHOHPSRJDVNLHM
UHOLJLLU]\PVNLHMUHSUH]HQWXMFHMZMHJRRF]DFKWHFQRW\RE\ZDWHOVNLHNWyU\FK
EUDNRZDüPLDáRFKU]HFLMDVWZX3UDNW\F]QLHMHGQDNNRQVHNZHQFMMDVNUDZHM
DQDFKURQLF]QRFLWHJR?QHRSRJDQL]PX?0DFKLDYHOOHJRDZL FWDN*HMHJR
DEVWUDNF\MQRFLPXVLDáDE\üODLF\]DFMDSROLW\NL SROLW\F]Q\DWHL]PSUDNW\F]Q\ LODLF\
]PSDVWZRZ\

27RPPDVLQL/DYLWDHJOLVFULWWLGL1LFFROR0DFKLDYHOOLQHOODORURUHOD]LRQHFRO
0DFKLDYHOOLVPR,,,5RPD7RULQR)LUHQ]H)(UFROH/DSROLWLFDGL
0DFKLDYHOOL5RPD)$OGHULVLR0DFKLDYHOOLOC$UWHGHOOR6WDWRQHOOCD]LRQHHQHJOL
VFULWWL7RULQR+)UH\HU0DFKLDYHOOL/HLS]LJ$+*LOEHUW0DFKLDYHOOLCV
?3ULQFH?DQG,WV)RUHUXQQHUV'XUKDP1&5.|QLJ1LFFROR0DFKLDYHOOL=XU
.ULHJVDQDO\VHHLQHU=HLWWHQZHQGH=ULFK$5HQDXGHW0DFKLDYHOOCpWXGH
GCKLVWRLUHGHVGRFWULQHVSROLWLTXHV3DULV/2OVFKNL0DFKLDYHOOLWKH6FLHQWLVW
%HUNHOH\&$/-:DONHU7KH'LVFRXUVHVRI1LFFROR0DFKLDYHOOL,,,/RQGRQ
:/HZLV7KH/LRQDQGWKH)R[/RQGRQ(9RHJHOLQ0DFKLDYHOOLCV
?3ULQFH?%DFNJURXQGDQG)RUPDWLRQ?7KH5HYLHZRI3ROLWLFV?)&KLDSHOOL
6WXGLVXOOLQJXDJJLRGHO0DFKLDYHOOL)LUHQ]H*3UH]]ROLQL0DFKLDYHOOL$QWLFULVWR
5RPD+%XWWHUILHOG7KH6WDWHFUDIWRI0DFKLDYHOOL/RQGRQ*6DVVR
1LFFROR0DFKLDYHOOL6WRULDGHOVXRSHQVLHURSROLWLFR,,,1DSROL%RORJQD>@
/6WUDXVV7KRXJKWVRQ0DFKLDYHOOL*OHQFRH,OOLQRLV&KLFDJR>@-'H
/DPDU UHG 0DFKLDYHOOL&\QLF3DWULRWRU3ROLWLFDO6FLHQWLVW"%RVWRQ*)LVFKHU
1LFFROR0DFKLDYHOOLGLH7ULORJLHGHU0DFKW:HLQKHLP)&KDERG6FULWWLVX
0DFKLDYHOOL7RULQR>@*6DVVR6WXGLVX0DFKLDYHOOL1DSROL*
3UH]]ROLQL7KH&KULVWLDQ5RRWVRI0DFKLDYHOOLCV0RUDO3HVVLPLVP?7KH5HYLHZRI
1DWLRQDO/LWHUDWXUHV?5'H0DWWHL,OSHQVLHURSROLWLFRGL0DFKLDYHOOLHODVXD
IRUWXQDQHOPRQGR)LUHQ]H$%RQDGHR&RUUXSWLRQ&RQIOLFWDQG3RZHULQWKH
:RUNVDQG7LPHVRI1LFFROR0DFKLDYHOOL%HUNHOH\/$3(%RQGDQHOOD
0DFKLDYHOOLDQGWKH$UWRI5HQDLVVDQFH+LVWRU\'HWURLW(*DULQ1DGP\O
0DFKLDYHOOHJR?$UFKLZXP+LVWRULL)LOR]RILLL0\OL6SRáHF]QHM?30DQHQW
1DLVVDQFHVGHODSROLWLTXHPRGHUQH0DFKLDYHOOL+REEHV5RXVVHDX3DULV0
.UyO.áRSRW\]0DFKLDYHOOLPZàDGXWDMRQ\.UDNyZ,%HUOLQ2U\JLQDOQRü
0DFKLDYHOOHJR?/LWHUDWXUDQDZLHFLH?/6WUDXVV7U]\IDOHQRZR*\WQRFL
?5HV3XEOLFD?*%RFN46NLQQHU09LUROL UHG 0DFKLDYHOOLDQG
5HSXEOLFDQLVP&DPEULGJH9'H&DSUDULLV6FULWWLVX0DFKLDYHOOL0HVVLQD
+-'LHVQHU9LUWX)RUWXQDXQGGHV3ULQ]LS+RIIQXQJEHL0DFKLDYHOOL*|WWLQJHQ
(*DULQ0DFKLDYHOOLIUDSROLWLFDHVWRULD7RULQR+&0DQVILHOG0DFKLDYHOOLCV
YLUWXH&KLFDJR/RQGRQ-%DUW\]HO?3U]HVW SQ\?0DNLDZHOGXPDQLD
]JU]\ELDáHJRNRQVHUZDW\VW\?3UR)LGH5HJHHW/HJH?$2ULDQL
1LFFROR0DFKLDYHOOL1DSROL>@09LUROL0DFKLDYHOOL2[IRUG7%0DFDXOD\
0DFKLDYHOOL>@Z2UHZROXFMDFKPDNLDZHOL]PLHLSRVW SLH:\EyUV]NLFyZ.UDNyZ


0DNLDZHOLFL

6SRVyEP\OHQLDRSROLW\FHNWyUHPXLPL GDá0DFKLDYHOOLQLHQDURG]LáVL RF]\ZLFLH
GRSLHURZUD]]QLP0\OL]DG]LZLDMFREOLVNLH)ORUHQWF]\NRZL]DZDUáZVZRLFK']LHMDFK
$UDEyZ3HUVyZL%HUEHUyZZ\ELWQ\KLVWRU\NDUDEVNL,EQ&KDOGXQ  DOH
QLHE\áRQ]SHZQRFL]QDQ\0DFKLDYHOOHPX:VWDUR*\WQRFLSRGREQHSRJOG\ ]QDQH
]DSRUHGQLFWZHPGLDORJyZ3ODWRQD JáRVLOLWDN*HVRILVW\F]QLRSRQHQFL6RNUDWHVD

6WURQD]

.RQVHUZDW\]PSO.OXE=DFKRZDZF]R0RQDUFKLVW\F]Q\3URILGH5HJHHW/HJH



KWWSZZZNRQVHUZDW\]PSOHQF\NORSHGLDSKS"LG 

background image

.DOOLNOHVL7UD]\PDFK%H]SRUHGQLPLSRSU]HGQLNDPL0DFKLDYHOOHJRE\OLQLHNWyU]\
SU]HGVWDZLFLHOHZF]HVQHJRKXPDQL]PXZáRVNLHJRD]ZáDV]F]D*LDQ)UDQFHVFR3RJJL
R%UDFFLROLQL  NWyU\WZLHUG]LáL*ZV]\VWNLHVáDZQHF]\Q\GRNRQDQH
]RVWDá\ZEUHZSUDZXDXLFKSRGVWDZOHJáDSU]HPRF?0DNLDZHOLVWZLHU]F\PZ
2SDWU]QRü?QD]\ZDQ\E\ZDIUDQFXVNLSROLW\NLSDPL WQLNDU]3KLOLSSHGH&RPP\Q
HVYDQGH&O\WH  VáX*F\NUyORZL/XGZLNRZL;,NWyU\PyJáE\VáX*\ü]D
UHDOQ\SLHUZRZ]yUPDNLDZHOLDVNLHJR?NVL FLD?&RPP\QHVWH*RFHQLDáF]\Q\
SROLW\F]QHZJNU\WHULXPVNXWHF]QRFLQLHPQLHMXZD*Dá*HZDUXQNLHPSRZRG]HQLDMHVW
SU]HVWU]HJDQLH]DUD]HPPRUDOQ\FKLSUDNW\F]Q\FK]DVDGWDNLFKMDN]DXIDQLHWURVND
RGREURSXEOLF]QHLSRER*QRü2U\JLQDOQDE\áDMHJRNRQFHSFMDSURZLGHQFMDOLVW\F]QHM
NRUHNW\GOD?PDNLDZHOVNLHM?SROLW\NLSROHJDMFDQDW\P*H2SDWU]QRü%R*DGDMH
ND*GHPX]NVL*WMDNRSU]HFLZZDJ GUXJLHJRNVL FLDNWyU\QDGQLP?F]XZD?W]Q
SU]HV]NDG]DPXZ]UHDOL]RZDQLXQD]E\WDPELWQ\FKSODQyZ

-HGQ\P]SLHUZV]\FKOHF]]DUD]HPXSUDV]F]DMF\FKP\OUHFHSWRUyZ0DFKLDYHOOHJRE\á
MHJRSU]\MDFLHOLZVSyáSUDFRZQLN UyZQLH*MHGHQ]SLHUZV]\FKNU\W\NyZ8WRSLL0RUXVD 
)UDQFHVFR9HWWRULD  NWyU\XWU]\P\ZDáL*NWRFKFHE\üZáDGF
SUDZG]LZ\PQLHPR*HOLF]\üQDWRE\XZD*DQRJR]DF]áRZLHNDUHOLJLMQHJRDMX*
]XSHáQLHQLH]JRGQLH]SU]HNRQDQLDPLDXWRUD.VL FLD*HZU]HF]\ZLVWRFLZV]\VWNLH
UHSXEOLNLLNVL VWZDVW\UDQLDPL

=QDF]QLHZL NV]HMUDQJLP\OLFLHOHP]GDQLHPZLHOXQLHXVW SXMF\P0DFKLDYHOOHPX
E\áIORUHQFNLSDWU\FMXV]G\SORPDWDLZ\ELWQ\KLVWRU\N)UDQFHVFR*XLFFLDUGLQL
 3RGNUHODVL F] VWR*HMHJRUHDOL]PSROLW\F]Q\E\áQDZHWFLOHMV]\QL*
DXWRUD.VL FLD*XLFFLDUGLQLERZLHPQLHSR]ZDODáVRELHQD*DGQHXRJyOQLHQLDLZWSOLZH
V\QWH]\QLHZLHU]\áWH*ZLVWQLHQLHRJyOQ\FKSUDZU]G]F\FKKLVWRUL1DGWR
0DFKLDYHOOLPLPRGHNODURZDQHJRWU]\PDQLDVL MHG\QLH?SUDZG\U]HF]\ZLVWHM
]GDU]H?QLHZ\U]HNDáVL QDWFKQLRQ\FKSURMHNFMLSDWULRW\F]Q\FKPDU]HRZ\S G]HQLX
?EDUEDU]\FyZ?L]MHGQRF]HQLX,WDOLL]D*XLFFLDUGLQLQLHSR]ZDODáVRELHQD*DGQH
SURURFWZD3ROHPL]RZDáWDN*HZSURVW]XZLHOELHQLHPDXWRUD5R]ZD*DQDG/LZLXV]HP
GODVWDUR*\WQHJR5]\PXXZD*DMF*HSU]\ZRá\ZDQLHMDNLFKNROZLHNZ]RUyZ]
SU]HV]áRFLMHVWMDáRZHJG\*QLHPDFLVáHJRSRGRELHVWZDPL G]\RGOHJá\PLIDNWDPL
KLVWRU\F]Q\PLSU]HWRQLHSRGREQDLFKQRUPDW\ZQLH]ZL]Dü

7DNVDPRMDNKLVWRULRJUDILDDQDOLW\F]QDLQG\ZLGXDOLVW\F]QDLSHV\PLVW\F]QDE\áD
DQWURSRORJLDSROLW\F]QD*XLFFLDUGLQLHJR0RWRUHPG]LHMyZMHVWGODMHGQRVWNDZUD]]MHM
]UHJXá\QLHFKZDOHEQ\PLF]\QDPLLQLHEXGXMF\PLQDPL WQRFLDPL=JDG]DáVL RQ
ZSUDZG]LH]DáR*\ü*HOXG]LHV]XNDMGREUDLVSUDZLHGOLZRFLRLOHLFKUR]XPQLHMHVW
]DüPLRQ\SU]H]LQWHUHVZáDVQ\OXEQDMEOL*V]\FKDOERSU]H]REDZ SU]HG]HPVW
V\WXDFMHWDNLHVMHGQDNUHJXá1LHQDOH*\WDN*HSRNáDGDüQDG]LHLQDXV]ODFKHWQLHQLH
F]áRZLHNDSU]H]QDXN ZLHG]DERZLHPQLHSRSUDZLDVáDE\FKPy]JyZDQDZHWPR*HMH
SRSVXüGRUHV]W\/XG]L]QLHSUDZLDWH*GHPRNUDW\F]QDIRUPDU]GX?OXGERZLHPMHVW
]ZLHU] FLHP]ZDULRZDQ\PNWRZ\SRZLDGDVáRZR? OXG? PDQDP\OLRV]DODáH]ZLHU] 
SHáQHZ\VW SNyZLEá GyZEH]]GROQRFLRFHQ\GHOLNDWQRFLF]\MDNLHMNROZLHN
VWDáRFL? F\W]D-0DODUF]\N8(UyGHáZáRVNLHJRUHDOL]PXSROLW\F]QHJR/XEOLQ 

=GDQLHP*XLFFLDUGLQLHJRF]áRZLHNPGU\ZLQLHQFLHUSOLZLHG*\üGRRVLJQL FLDNRU]\FL
ZáDVQHM LOVXRSDUWLFRODUH SU]H]FRUR]XPLDáMHGQDNUHDOQLHRVLJDOQFQRW SROLW\F]Q
VNXSLHQLHZ\VLáNXZV]\VWNLFKSRVLDGDQ\FKVLáXP\VáRZ\FKPRUDOQ\FKLZLWDOQ\FKGOD
UHDOL]DFMLWDNLHMDPELFMLZáDVQHMNWyUHQLHVWRLZVSU]HF]QRFL]GREUHPSDVWZD
&KRFLD*XDXWRUDWHJRSRMDZLDVL F] VWR]DSUDZLRQDF\QL]PHPJRU\F] ?SURFLH%RJD
DE\ZDV]DZV]HSRVWDZLáWDPJG]LHVL ]Z\FL *D? WRMHGQDN]UyZQPRFRGFLVND
VL ZMHJRPDNV\PDFKPRW\ZLGHQW\ILNRZDQHJR]YLUWXKRQRUX?NWyU\MHVW
SáRPLHQQ\PERG(FHPQDMZ\*V]FQRWEH]NWyUHMPDUWZHVLSXVWHSRF]\QDQLD
OXG]NLHLG]L NLNWyUHMF]áRZLHNQLHREDZLDVL QLHEH]SLHF]HVWZLQLHSRSHáQLDQLJG\
U]HF]\JRGQ\FKSRW SLHQLD? F\W]DWDP*H 

?0DNLDZHOLVWSUDNW\NXMF\P? ZJRNUHOHQLD*0RVFL E\á6\F\OLMF]\N6FLSLRQHGL&D
VWUR  NWyU\KLV]SDVNLPZLFHNUyORP6\F\OLL]DOHFDá 7HVRURSROLWLFR,,,,
 QHXWUDOL]RZDQLHDQDUFKLF]Q\FKVNáRQQRFLVZRLFKURGDNyZSU]H]]ZRá\ZDQLH
]JURPDG]HSRVHOVNLFKZ\áF]QLH]LPLZPLHMVFRZRFLDFKWUXGQRGRVW SQ\FKRUD]
SU]H]ZSURZDG]DQLHGRQLFKOXG]LNWyU\FKPR*QDSU]HNXSLüOXE]DVWUDV]\ü=P
Z\ZRG]LVL WH*SRM FLH?ZL WHJRHJRL]PX? VDFURHJRLVPR NWyU\P
V]HUPRZDOLMX*SURPRWRU]\SDWULRW\F]QHJR5LVRUJLPHQWDLQDNWyU\ZSURVWSRZRáDáVL 

6WURQD]

.RQVHUZDW\]PSO.OXE=DFKRZDZF]R0RQDUFKLVW\F]Q\3URILGH5HJHHW/HJH



KWWSZZZNRQVHUZDW\]PSOHQF\NORSHGLDSKS"LG 

background image

SUHPLHU$QWRQLR6DODQGUDX]DVDGQLDMFQLP]áDPDQLH7UyMSU]\PLHU]D]$XVWUR
: JUDPLL1LHPFDPLDSU]\VWSLHQLHSU]HFLZNRQLPGRZRMQ\SRVWURQLH(QWHQW\

1DMVáDZQLHMV]\PL?PDNLDZHOLVWDPLSUDNW\NXMF\PL?E\OLMHGQDNEH]ZWSLHQLDGZDM
Vá\QQLIUDQFXVF\SROLW\F\SHUVRQLILNXMF\SRM FLHUDLVRQGCpWDWNVL* NDUG\QDá
$UPDQG-HDQGX3OHVVLVGH5LFKHOLHX  QDNWyUHJRQRFQ\PVWROLNX
OH*Dá\]DZV]HRERNVLHELHEUHZLDU]L.VL* RUD]ELVNXSUHQHJDWL]GUDG]DMF\
ZV]\VWNLFKSDQXMF\FKOHF]QLJG\LQWHUHV)UDQFML&KDUOHV0DXULFHGH7DOOH\UDQG
3pULJRUGNVL* %HQHZHQWX  

:EOL*V]\FKQDPF]DVDFKV]F]HJyOQHPLHMVFHQDOH*\SU]\]QDüVRFMRORJRPSROLW\NL
?UHDOLVWRPSROLW\F]Q\P?NWyU\FKLFKDGPLUDWRU DQW\NRPXQLVW\F]Q\HNVWURFNLVWD 
-DPHV%XUQKDP  QD]\ZD?PDNLDZHOLDQDPLREURFDPLZROQRFL?
0LDQHPW\PRNUHOHQL]RVWDOLDXWRU]\REDUG]RUy*Q\FKSU]HNRQDQLDFKSROLW\F]Q\FKOHF]
ZSRGREQ\FKáRGQ\DQDOLW\F]Q\LGRFLHNDMF\XNU\W\FKVSU *\QG]LDáDQLDSROLW\F]QHJR
VSRVyEP\OF\RSROLW\FHIUDQFXVNLDQDUFKRV\QG\NDOLVWDSURSDJDWRU?VWUDMNX
JHQHUDOQHJR?LDQDOLW\N?PLWXSROLW\F]QHJR?*HRUJHV6RUHO  ZáRVNL
OLEHUDáNRQVHUZDW\ZQ\WHRUHW\N?NODV\SROLW\F]QHM?LRGNU\ZFD?IRUPXá\SROLW\F]QHM?
MDNRPHWRG\OHJLW\PL]DFMLZáDG]\*DHWDQR0RVFD  UyZQLH*:áRFKL
NRQVHUZDW\ZQ\OHVHIHU\VWDWHRUHW\N?NU*HQLDHOLW?9LOIUHGR)HGHULFR'DPDVRPDUNL]
3DUHWR  QLHPLHFNLVRFMDOGHPRNUDWDDSy(QLHMQDWXUDOL]RZDQ\ZH
:áRV]HFKIDV]\VWDDXWRU?*HOD]QHJRSUDZDROLJDUFKLL?5REHUW R 0LFKHOV 
 QLHNWyU]\]DOLF]DMMHV]F]HGRWHJRJURQDUDG\NDOQHJRGHPRNUDW LDQW\IDV]\VW 
*XLGD'RUVD  

,FKZ\ELWQ\PNRQW\QXDWRUHPMHVWUyZQLH*IUDQFXVNLVRFMRORJSROLW\NL-XOLHQ)UHXQG
XU SRGNUHODMF\L*SROLW\NDQLHMHVW?NUyOHVWZHPGREU\FKFK FL? OHUR\DXPH
GHVERQVVHQWLPHQWV DOHWH*QLH?]U F]QRFLLSU]HELHJáRFL? GHOCKDELOLWpHWGHOD
UXVH OHF]QDSHZQRG]LHG]LQVLá\DNW\ZQRFLNWyUD?UHDOL]XMHVL SU]H]VLá ?
FKRFLD*MHVW?Z]DVDG]LHXIXQGRZDQDQDSUDZLH?RUD]?E\üPR*H?SUDZG
/CHVVHQFHGXSROLWLTXH3DULV MDNRREURFD?FQRW\SROLW\NL?DSU]HFLZQLN
DQW\SROLW\F]QHJRPRUDOL]DWRUVWZD)UHXQGRZLDGF]DL*QLHZLHU]\?ZPRUDOQSROLW\N 
SRQLHZD*SROLW\NDPXVLE\üZSLHUZV]\PU] G]LHSROLW\F]QDDQLHPRUDOQD:LHU] 
QDWRPLDVWZPRUDOQRüSROLW\NLNWyUDSROHJDQDXU]HF]\ZLVWQLDQLXZáDFLZHJRFHOX
SROLW\NLRFKURQ\RE\ZDWHOLLEH]SLHF]HVWZDSDVWZD&]áRZLHNSROLW\F]Q\MHVWPRUDOQ\
QLHG]L NLVZHPXSURJUDPRZLDOHSU]H]VSRVyEZMDNLUHDOL]XMHFHOH
SROLW\F]QH? WDP*H 

8RJyOQLDMFGRUREHN?PDNLDZLHOLDQ?%XUQKDPVIRUPXáRZDá]DVDGGHILQLXMF\FKP
MDNRRGU EQWUDG\FM P\OHQLDSROLW\F]QHJRNWyUDEURQLMHJR]GDQLHP?SROLW\F]QHM
SUDZG\SU]HGP\OHQLHP*\F]HQLRZ\P??R0R*OLZDMHVWRELHNW\ZQDQDXNDSROLW\NLL
QDXNDRVSRáHF]HVWZLHSRUyZQ\ZDOQDZVZ\FKPHWRGDFKGRLQQ\FKQDXN
HPSLU\F]Q\FK  %\áDE\WRQDXNDQHXWUDOQDZRGQLHVLHQLXGRMDNLHJRNROZLHN
SUDNW\F]QHJRFHOXSROLW\F]QHJRWR]QDF]\  MHMWZLHUG]HQLDE\á\E\ZHU\ILNRZDQH
SRSU]H]IDNW\GRVW SQHND*GHPXREVHUZDWRURZL  LQLH]DOH*DáDE\RQDRGDNFHSWDFML
MDNLHJR  LGHDáXHW\F]QHJR  R*áyZQ\PSU]HGPLRWHP]DLQWHUHVRZDQLDQDXNLR
SROLW\FHMHVWZDONDRZáDG] SU]HELHJDMFDZVSRVyEMDZQ\L]DNDPXIORZDQ\  R
3UDZD*\FLDSROLW\F]QHJRQLHPRJ]RVWDüRGNU\WHZZ\QLNXDQDOL]\NWyUDELHU]HVáRZDL
ZLHU]HQLDZ\SRZLHG]LDQHOXEVSLVDQH]JRGQLH]LFKOLWHUDOQ\PEU]PLHQLHP6áRZD  
PXV]E\üVNRQIURQWRZDQH]FDá\PNRPSOHNVHPIDNWyZVSRáHF]Q\FKWDNDE\PR*QD
E\áRSRMüLFKUHDOQH]QDF]HQLHSROLW\F]QHLKLVWRU\F]QH  R5DFMRQDOQHLORJLF]QH
G]LDáDQLDJUDMVWRVXQNRZRQLHZLHONURO ZSURFHVDFKSROLW\F]Q\FKLVSRáHF]Q\FK  
UHJXá VSRáHF]QVWDQRZLG]LDáDQLDQLHORJLF]QHZ\ZRáDQHQLHRF]HNLZDQ]PLDQ
V\WXDFMLSRZRGRZDQHLQVW\QNWHPLPSXOVHPF]\LQWHUHVHP  R1DMLVWRWQLHMV]\P
GOD]UR]XPLHQLDSURFHVyZVSRáHF]Q\FKSRG]LDáHPMHVWSRG]LDáQDNODV U]G]FL
U]G]RQQDHOLW LQLHHOLW   R1DXNDRSROLW\FHLKLVWRULLWRSU]HGHZV]\VWNLP
VWXGLXPHOLW\ZáDG]\MHMNRPSR]\FMLVWUXNWXU\RUD]URG]DMyZ]ZL]NyZ]DFKRG]F\FK
SRPL G]\HOLWLQLHHOLW  R=DVDGQLF]\PSU]HGPLRWHP]DLQWHUHVRZDQLDZV]\VWNLFK
HOLWF]\NODVU]G]F\FKMHVWXWU]\PDQLHZáDG]\LSU]\ZLOHMyZ  R5]G\HOLW\
RSLHUDMVL QDVLOHLRV]XVWZLH  VLáDPR*HE\üSU]H]GáX*V]\F]DVVNU\ZDQDDOER
VáX*\ü]DVWUDV]DNRV]XVWZR]DQLHPXVLSRFLJDü]DVREZLDGRPHJRSRVáXJLZDQLD
VL SRGVW SHP  R&DáDVWUXNWXUDVSRáHF]QDMHVWLQWHJURZDQDLXWU]\P\ZDQDSU]H]
IRUPXá SROLW\F]QPDMF]D]Z\F]DM]ZL]HN]]DVDGQLF]RDNFHSWRZDQUHOLJL
LGHRORJLF]\PLWHP  R2GF]DVXGRF]DVXU]G\HOLW\ZVWRSQLXPQLHMV]\POXE

6WURQD]

.RQVHUZDW\]PSO.OXE=DFKRZDZF]R0RQDUFKLVW\F]Q\3URILGH5HJHHW/HJH



KWWSZZZNRQVHUZDW\]PSOHQF\NORSHGLDSKS"LG 

background image

ZL NV]\P]DVSRNDMDMSRWU]HE\QLHHOLW\  R:Z\SDGNXND*GHMHOLW\Z\VW SXM
]DZV]HGZLHSU]HFLZVWDZQHWHQGHQFMHD   DU\VWRNUDW\F]QD]DSRPRFNWyUHMGDQD
HOLWDSUDJQLH]DFKRZDüZáDGF]SR]\FM VZ\FKF]áRQNyZLQDVW SFyZ  E   
GHPRNUDW\F]QD]DSRPRFNWyUHMXVLáXMVIRUVRZDü]ZDUWHV]HUHJLHOLW\OXG]LH]
]HZQWU]  R1DGáX*V]PHW GUXJD]Z\*HMZ\PLHQLRQ\FKWHQGHQFML]DZV]H
ELHU]HJyU =WHJRZ\QLND*HQLHPDSHUPDQHQWQ\FKVWUXNWXUVSRáHF]Q\FKWDNMDNQLH
MHVWPR*OLZDMDNDVWDW\F]QDXWRSLD:DONDVSRáHF]QDF]\NODVRZD]DZV]HWUZDD
KLVWRULDMHVWMHMUHMHVWUHP  R2NUHVRZRZ\VW SXMJZDáWRZQH]PLDQ\ZVNáDG]LHL
VWUXNWXU]HHOLWWRMHVWUHZROXFMHVSRáHF]QH  ? 7U]\QDFLH]DVDGPDNLDZHOL]PX
?1RZH3DVWZR? 

(/XERZVNL0DFKLDYHOOLL*XLFFLDUGLQLGZDSRUWUHW\G]LHMRZH?5XFK
/LWHUDFNL? /ZyZ &*LDUGLQD/DYLWDHOCRSHUDSROLWLFDGL6FLSLRQHGL&DVWUR
3DOHUPR*/HDQWL1LFFROR0DFKLDYHOOLH)UDQFHVFR*XLFFLDUGLQLGXUDQWHODFULVL
GHOODOLEHUWDLWDOLDQD3DOHUPR.:\ND-HU]\6RUHO:DUV]DZD9/XFLDQL
)UDQFHVFR*XLFFLDUGLQLDQG+LV(XURSHDQ5HSXWDWLRQ1HZ<RUN-%XUQKDP7KH
0DFKLDYHOOLDQV'HIHQGHUVRI)UHHGRP1HZ<RUN:DVKLQJWRQ'&>@9'H
&DSUDULLV)UDQFHVFR*XLFFLDUGLQLGHOODSROLWLFDDOODVWRULD%DUL-0DODUF]\N8
(UyGHáZáRVNLHJRUHDOL]PXSROLW\F]QHJR0DFKLDYHOOLL*XLFFLDUGLQL/XEOLQ)
*LOEHUW0DFKLDYHOOLDQG*XLFFLDUGLQL3ROLWLFVDQG+LVWRU\LQWKH6L[WHHQWK&HQWXU\
)ORUHQFH3ULQFHWRQ-+0HLVHO UHG 3DUHWRDQG0RVFD1HZ<RUN-
.XGUQD0DFKLDYHOOLD*XLFFLDUGLQL%UQR*6ROD2UJDQL]]D]LRQH3DUWLWR&ODVVH
SROLWLFDH/HJJH)HUUHDGHOOC2OLJDUFKLDLQ5REHUWR0LFKHOV*HQRYD)*LOEHUW
UHG )UDQFHVFR*XLFFLDUGLQL)LUHQ]H06pQHOODUW0DFKLDYpOLVPHHW
UDLVRQGCeWDW;,,H;9,,,HVLHFOH3DULV7*DEL3DUHWR?1RZH3DVWZR?
7*DEL5REHUW0LFKHOVDOER*HOD]QHSUDZDROLJDUFKLL?1RZH3DVWZR?


6SyURPDNLDZHOL]P

:FDáHMKLVWRULLQRZR*\WQHMWUXGQRE\áRE\ZVND]DüP\OLFLHODSROLW\F]QHJRNWyU\E\
EXG]LáJRU WV]HRG0DFKLDYHOOHJRLWDNGáXJRQLHVáDEQFHHPRFMHRUD]VNUDMQLH
SU]HFLZVWDZQHRFHQ\RGQD]\ZDQLDMHJRG]LHáD?SRGU F]QLNLHPGOD
JDQJVWHUyZ? %HUWUDQG5XVVHOO SRHQWX]MDVW\F]QSRFKZDá L*?QLF]\PRU]HáXQRVLVL 
QDGWáXPHPKLVWRU\NyZLGHL? 93DUHWR %H]Z]JO GXQD]DMPRZDQHVWDQRZLVNRND*G\
MHGQDN]JRG]LVL ]NRQVWDWDFMDXWRUDQDMEDUG]LHMZQLNOLZHMKLVWRULLLGHLUDFMLVWDQXZ
P\OLHXURSHMVNLHM)ULHGULFKD0HLQHFNHJRL*?GRNWU\QD0DFKLDYHOOHJRE\áD
PLHF]HPZUD*RQ\PZSROLW\F]Q\RUJDQL]P]DFKRGQLHMKXPDQLVW\NL?LQDGDOMHVW?QLH
JRMFVL UDQ? 'LH,GHHGHU6WDDWVUlVRQLQGHUQHXHUHQ*HVFKLFKWH0QFKHQ%HUOLQ
 .RQWURZHUVMHZRNyá0DFKLDYHOOHJRGRW\F]]DUyZQRMHJRP\OLSU]HZRGQLHML
LQWHQFMLMDNRVRE\LG]LDáDOQRFLZJXVWDOHNRPSHWHQWQHJRZWHMPLHU]HKLVWRU\NDLGHL
6LU,VDLDKD%HUOLQDW\ONRGRVIRUPXáRZDQRFRQDMPQLHMNRPSOHWQ\FK
LQWHUSUHWDFML0DFKLDYHOOHJRLQDSLVDQRRNNRPHQWDU]\GRQLHJR

,QWHUSUHWDWRU]\0DFKLDYHOOHJRQLHPRJSRJRG]LüVL QDZHWZWDNSRGVWDZRZHMNZHVWLL
MDNWRF]\E\áRQ]LPQ\PDQDOLW\NLHPQLH]DDQJD*RZDQ\PDQLHW\F]QLHDQLSROLW\F]QLH
DMHG\QLH?WHFKQLNLHPZáDG]\?EDGDMF\PPHWRGQLHRPDOSR]\W\ZLVW\F]QSUDZD
?VWDW\NLSROLW\F]QHM?F]\WH*SU]HFLZQLHF]áRZLHNLHPQDPL WQ\PZUD*OLZ\PL
?URPDQW\NLHP?&KRFLD*GRSLHUZV]HJRVWDQRZLVNDVNáDQLDVL ERGDMZL NV]Rü
NRPHQWDWRUyZZW\P(UQVW&DVVLUHU$XJXVWLQ5HQDXGHW/HRQDUGR2OVFKNL.HLWK
+DQFRFNF]\.DUO6FKPLGWRMHGQDNQLHEUDNXMHSRZD*Q\FKLQWHUSUHWDWRUyZ
GRVWU]HJDMF\FKZQLPQDPL WQRFLWDNVLOQH*HD*SU]HNUDF]DMFHJUDQLFHUHDOL]PX
)HGHULFR&KDERG ?ZLHONSDVM ? 5XGROIR5LGROIL RUD]ZL]MRQHUVWZR 9LWWRULRGH
&DSUDULLV 

1LHPDWH**DGQHJRNODURZQHJR]ZL]NXSRPL G]\SRW SLHQLHPDSRORJLF]\
RVWDWHF]QLHVWDQRZLVNLHPSRUHGQLPDZLDWRSRJOGHPLGHRORJLILOR]RILF]\HW\N
MHJRNRPHQWDWRUyZ.D*GH]W\FKVWDQRZLVNE\ZDáRLMHVWZ\UD*DQH]DUyZQRSU]H]
NDWROLNyZMDNLSURWHVWDQWyZDWHLVWyZLDJQRVW\NyZNRQVHUZDW\VWyZLOLEHUDáyZ
DEVROXW\VWyZLGHPRNUDWyZPRQDUFKLVWyZLUHSXEOLNDQyZQDFMRQDOLVWyZL
NRVPRSROLWyZIDV]\VWyZLNRPXQLVWyZHWF7UDJLNRPLF]Q\PHSL]RGHPVSRUXR
0DFKLDYHOOHJRE\áR Z;9,L;9,,Z ]áF]HQLHP]?MH]XLW\]PHP?PLPRL*WRZáDQLH
]7RZDU]\VWZD-H]XVRZHJRUHNUXWRZDOLVL QDMEDUG]LHM]DFL FLDQW\PDNLDZHOLFL


6WURQD]

.RQVHUZDW\]PSO.OXE=DFKRZDZF]R0RQDUFKLVW\F]Q\3URILGH5HJHHW/HJH



KWWSZZZNRQVHUZDW\]PSOHQF\NORSHGLDSKS"LG 

background image

3DSLH*  3DZHá,9SROHFLáZFLJQüG]LHáD0DFKLDYHOOHJRQD,QGH[MX*
FRSRWZLHUG]Lá6REyU7U\GHQFNLOHF]SDSLH*  6\NVWXV9QLH
UR]VWDZDáVL ]HJ]HPSODU]HP.VL FLDL]URELá]QLHJRZ\FLJQDMFHOQLHMV]\FKMHJR
]GDQLHPP\OLGRVW SQ\G]LZ%LEOLRWHFH:DW\NDVNLHM

*ZDáWRZQ\DWDNQD0DFKLDYHOOHJRSU]\SXFLOLZGRELHNRQWUUHIRUPDFMLSLVDU]HNRFLHOQL
RVWDWQL SU]HGVFKL]PDQJOLNDVN DQJLHOVNLNDUG\QDá6LU5HJLQDOG3ROH 
 MX*JáRVLáL*WUDNWDWR.VL FLXQDSLVDQ\E\á?UDF]HMSD]XUHPGLDEáDQL*U N
F]áRZLHNDLJG\E\ZáDGFDE\áV]DWDQHPZOXG]NLPFLHOHLSRVLDGDáV\QDNWyUHPX
]HFKFLDáE\SU]HND]DüVZRMHNUyOHVWZRQLHPyJáE\PXSROHFLüOHSV]\FKZVND]yZHNZ
U]G]HQLXQL*]HEUDQHZSRZ\*V]HMSUDF\? F\W]D-0DODUF]\NG]F\W ,QVSLURZDQ\
SU]H]SDSLH*D,QQRFHQWHJR,;R7KRPDV%R]LXV&2U  GDáUyZQLH
EH]Z]JO GQUHIXWDFM SRJOGyZDXWRUD.VL FLD]DSUH]HQWRZDQHJRMDNR?F]áRZLHN
QDWFKQL W\SU]H]V]DWDQDGRZ\VWSLHQLDSU]HFLZNR&KU\VWXVRZLLZLHU]HFKU]HFLMDVNLHM
RUD]UDG\NDOQHJR]QLV]F]HQLDZV]HONLFKSRZLQQRFLZ\Sá\ZDMF\FK]QDWXUDOQHM
FQRW\? $GYHUVXV1LFRODXP0DFKLDYHOOXP, 3RGREQLHZ\SRZLDGDáVL  ]QDQ\]
SROVNLHMKLVWRULLQLHIRUWXQQ\G\SORPDWDNWyU\RGZLyGá6WHIDQD%DWRUHJRRG
NRQW\QXRZDQLDZRMQ\],ZDQHP*UR(Q\PZ]áXGQHMQDG]LHLQDXQL ]SUDZRVáDZLHP R
$QWRQLR3RVVHYLQR6,  QLHRGPDZLDMF0DFKLDYHOOHPXWDOHQWXDQL
E\VWURFLXP\VáXWZLHUG]LáMHGQDN*HGDUyZW\FK)ORUHQWF]\NX*\ZDá?Z]áHMZU F]
V]DWDVNLHMVSUDZLHLE\áF]áRZLHNLHPNWyUHPXREFRND]DáDVL ZV]HONDSRER*QRü
 LVWRWNWyUHMREFHVZV]HONLHXF]XFLDOXG]NLHD]ZáDV]F]DKXPDQL]PF]\OLWRü:
VSUDZDFKZLDU\E\áRQFDáNRZLW\PDWHLVWZG]LHG]LQLH]DSROLW\NLPR*QDJRMHG\QLH
SRUyZQDü]Z\]QDZFDPL0DKRPHWD? ,XGLFLXPGH1XDHPLOLWLV*DOOL-RDQQLV%RGLQL
3KLOLSSL0RUQDHL1LFRODL0DFKLDYHOOLTXLEXVGDPVFULSVLVTXRUXP&DWDORJXPLQQHUVD
SDJLQDLQGLFDELW 3RVVHYLQR]DNZHVWLRQRZDáMHGQDNQLHW\ONRPRUDOQRüOHF]L
UHDOL]PSROLW\F]Q\0DFKLDYHOOHJRSU]HNRQXMF*H?NWRNROZLHN]HFKFLDáE\GDüZLDU 
MHJRZ\ZRGRPPXVLDáE\UyZQLH*]JRG]LüVL ]W\P*HZQLHGáXJLPF]DVLHUR]V\SLHVL L
UXQLHND*GHQDMVLOQLHMV]HQDZHWNVL VWZRU]HF]SRVSROLWDNUyOHVWZRF]\
FHVDUVWZR? WDP*H :DUWRüGRZRGRZDQW\PDNLDZHOVNLFKGLDWU\E3RVVHYLQDSRGZD*D
GRZLHG]LRQ\MX*SU]H]+HUPDQD&RQULQJDIDNWL*ZáRVNLMH]XLWDQLHF]\WDá
RU\JLQDOQ\FKSLVP)ORUHQWF]\NDDVZRMNU\W\N IRUPXáRZDáQDSRGVWDZLH(UyGHá
SRUHGQLFKJáyZQLHSDPIOHWXIUDQFXVNLHJRNDOZLQLVW\ VLF ,QQRFHQWD*HQWLOOHWD
 'LVFRXUVFRQWUH0DFKLDYHO  

=DUyZQR*HQWLOOHWLLQQLKXJHQRFF\?PRQDUFKRPDFKRZLH? ?NUyOREyMF\? NWyU]\
SHUVRQLILNDFM PZLG]LHOLZ?SRGVW SQHM:áRV]FH?NUyORZHM.DWDU]\QLH0HG\FHMVNLHMD
MHJRNXOPLQDFM Z1RF\Z%DUWáRPLHMD SU]HPLOF]DMFDQDORJLF]QHU]H]LHGRNRQ\ZDQH
SU]H]SURWHVWDQWyZQDNDWROLNDFK MDNSURWHVWDQFLDQJLHOVF\EDUG]RVNZDSOLZLH
XWR*VDPLOLP]?DQW\FKU\VWRZ\P?NDWROLF\]PHP?SDSLVWyZ?V]F]HJyOQLHQRQ\P
LQVWUXPHQWHPVNLHURZDQHMSU]HFLZNR?1LHU]GQLF\%DELORVNLHM? WM5]\PRZL 
SURSDJDQG\RND]DáDVL GUDPDWXUJLDHO*ELHWDVNDZ$QJOLLZNWyUHMZSURVWURLVL RG
SRVWDFLGHPRQLF]Q\FKNDUG\QDáyZL]DNRQQLNyZQLHUR]VWDMF\FKVL ]HV]W\OHWHPL
WUXFL]QRUD]F]HUSLF\FKQDWFKQLHQLH]0DFKLDYHOOHJRDNDWROLFNLH:áRFK\VWDQRZL
DUFKHW\SSRV SQHMNUDLQ\]áDLFLHPQRFL:)\G]LHPDOWDVNLP  ZRMXMFHJR
DQW\SDSLVW\ LSUDZGRSRGREQLHDWHLVW\ &KULVWRSKHUD0DUORZHCD  
0DNLDZHOSRMDZLDVL QDZHW Z3URORJX ZHZáDVQHMRVRELHLFKHáSLVL *H?FLNWyU]\
Z\VW SXMSU]HFLZNRPRLPWUDNWDWRPF]\WDMPQLH]]DSDáHPLZWHQVSRVyERVLJDM
WURQ3LRWURZ\?LQVWUXPHQWDOQHZ\NRU]\VWDQLHNU\W\NLPGRZDONL]NDWROLF\]PHP
SLVDU]WHQáF]\áMHGQDN]HVáDERVNU\ZDQIDVF\QDFMVDP\PPZMHJRQDMEDUG]LHM
VWHUHRW\SRZ\PXM FLXMDNR?Z\]ZROHQLD?]NU SXMF\FKVLOQMHGQRVWN QRUP
PRUDOQ\FK:\PRZQ\PZ\MWNLHPQDW\PWOHE\á SUDZGRSRGREQLHNU\SWRNDWROLFNL
?UHNX]DQW? :LOOLDP6KDNHVSHDUHNWyUHJRZ\REUD*HQLHRPE\áRZSUDZG]LH
UyZQLH*]JRGQH]SRWRF]Q\PVWHUHRW\SHP0DFKLDYHOOHJRMDNR?HUXG\W\]EURGQL? OH
GRFWHXUGHODVFpOpUDWHVVH DOHRFHQDEH]Z]JO GQLHXMHPQDLZGXFKXRSLQLL
NDWROLFNLFKDQW\PDNLDZHOLVWyZVSRUyGERJDWHMJDOHULL?0DNLDZHOyZ?V]HNVSLURZVNLFK
PLQ.ODXGLXV]Z+DPOHFLH-DJRZ2WHOOX(GPXQG*RQHU\ODL5HJDQDZ.UyOX/LU]H
/DG\0DNEHWZ0DNEHFLH EH]SRUHGQLPRGQLHVLHQLHPGRSRVWDFLDXWRUD.VL FLD
Z\Uy*QLDVL 5\V]DUG,,, MHV]F]HMDNRNVL* *ORXFHVWHUZ+HQU\NX9, NWyU\
?PRUGRZDá]HPLHFKHPQDXVWDFK?PQLHPDMFRVRELH*HPyJáE\?E\ü
QDXF]\FLHOHPSU]HVW SQHJR0DNLDZHOD?

3RJOGDQW\PDNLDZHOLVWyZZáRVNLFKLKLV]SDVNLFK DQWLPDTXLDYpOLFRV MDN3HGURGH5L
EDGHQH\UD6, 3ULQFHSVFKULVWLDQXPDGYHUVXV0DFKLDYHOOXP F]\&ODXGLR&O

6WURQD]

.RQVHUZDW\]PSO.OXE=DFKRZDZF]R0RQDUFKLVW\F]Q\3URILGH5HJHHW/HJH



KWWSZZZNRQVHUZDW\]PSOHQF\NORSHGLDSKS"LG 

background image

HPHQWH (O0DFKLDYHOOLVPRGHJROODGR RIXQGDPHQWDOQ\PDQW\FKU\VWLDQL]PLH
0DFKLDYHOOHJRSRGWU]\P\ZDOLZ;;Z+LUDP+D\GQLZáRVNLNRQVHUZDW\VWDUHZROXF\MQ\
*LXVHSSH3UH]]ROLQL 0DFKLDYHOOL$QWLFULVWR 3RJOGZSURVWSU]HFLZQ\R
V]F]HU\PNDWROLF\]PLH0DFKLDYHOOHJRQLH]QDOD]áMX*ZSUDZG]LH Z\MZV]\)HOLFHJR
$OGHULVLD REURFyZWDNGRELWQ\FKMDNZVSyáSUDFRZQLNNDUG5LFKHOLHXLDXWRU$SRORJLH
GH0DFKLDYHOOLNDQRQLN/RXLV0DFKRQQLHPQLHMRVWUR*QLHSU]\FK\ODOLVL QDGDOGR
QLHJRZ;;Z*LXVHSSH7RIIDQLQ5XGROIR5LGROILL/HVOLH-:DONHU

2GPLHQQHLRGNDWROLFNLFKLRGSURWHVWDQFNLFKDQW\PDNLDZHOLVWyZSRGHMFLH]QDOD]áR
Z\UD]ZG]LHáDFKNDWROLFNLFKWDNZáRVNLFK *%RWHUR/=XFFROR/6HWWDOD MDN
KLV]SDVNLFK )&HULRO$GH%DUULHQWRV%)HLMRR WDF\W\VWyZWMDXWRUyZ
LQVSLUXMF\FKVL ZL]MKLVWRULLQLHUHSXEOLNDQLQD/LZLXV]DOHF]FH]DU\VW\7DF\WD
WDF\W\FLQLHUH]\JQXMF]NU\W\NLVSU]HF]Q\FK]HW\NFKU]HFLMDVNSLHUZLDVWNyZP
SRWUDNWRZDOLJRMHGQDNMDNRSXQNWZ\MFLDSR?RF]\V]F]HQLX]SOHZ?GR
Z\SUDFRZDQLDQRZHMQDXNLR?SUDZG]LZHM?UDFMLVWDQX LOUDJLRQHGLVWDWRYHUR
YHUGDGHUDUD]yQGH(VWDGR L?NVL FLXFKU]HFLMDVNLP? LOSULQFLSHFULVWLDQR NWyUHJR
YLUWXZLQQDE\ü]DUyZQRSU]H]RUQDUR]ZDJD SUXGHQ]D MDNSRER*QRüLNWyU\ZLQLHQ
GEDüRSRVLDGDQLHGRUDGFyZPRJF\FKZ\GDüZLDU\JRGQRSLQL FRGR]JRGQRFL
]DPLHU]RQHJRG]LDáDQLD]PRUDOQRFLNDWROLFN

-HGHQ]?WDF\W\VWyZ?7UDLDQR%RFFDOLQL  RUD]SURWHVWDQW$OEHULFR*
HQWLOL  ]DSRF]WNRZDOLWDN*HWHQGHQFM GRRGF]\W\ZDQLD0DFKLDYHOOHJR
?QDRSDN?F]\OLWUDNWRZDQLD.VL FLDMDNRGREU]H]DNDPXIORZDQHMVDW\U\LSDPIOHWX
RVWU]HJDMFHJROXGSU]HGW\UDQLNVL*WRUD]SRXF]DMFHJRMDNVL SU]HGQLEURQLü
0\OW UR]ZLQ OLV]HU]HM]ZROHQQLF\GHPRNUDFML%HQHG\NWGH6SLQR]D  
L-HDQ-DFTXHV5RXVVHDX  ZJNWyUHJR?0DNLDZHO  XGDMF*H
QDXF]DNUyOyZGDáZLHONQDXN QDURGRP.VL*   MHVWNVL*N
UHSXEOLNDQyZ? 8PRZDVSRáHF]QD,,, ZW\PVDP\PGXFKXUHZROXF\MQ\GHPRNUDWD
URPDQW\F]Q\(GJDU4XLQHW  QD]\ZDá.VL FLD?0DUV\OLDQN;9,
ZLHNX?7UDIQUHSOLN W\PPLVW\ILNDFMRPGDáZVSyáF]HQLH%URQLVáDZàDJRZVNL
]DXZD*DMF*HZLHP\MX*L*OXGSRWUDILPRUGRZDüLRV]XNLZDüQLHJRU]HMQL*NVL* WDD
?SRGZ]JO GHPKLSRNU\]MLNVL* WDZSRUyZQDQLX]SDUWLDPLUHSUH]HQWXMF\PLOXG
PXV]Z\GDZDüVL QLHXGROQ\PLGHELXWDQWDPL? :VWURQ 0RQWHVNLXV]DF]\
0DFKLDYHOOHJR"Z/LEHUDOQDNRQWUUHZROXFMD:DUV]DZD 

3RF]ZV]\RGQHRVWRLND-XVWXVD/LSVLXVD  SRSXODUQ\E\áSRJOG
XSDWUXMF\Z0DFKLDYHOOLPZSLHUZV]\PU] G]LH*DUOLZHJRZáRVNLHJRSDWULRW NWyU\
ZV]\VWNRSRGSRU]GNRZ\ZDáG*HQLXGRXZROQLHQLD?ZL WHM?ZáRVNLHM]LHPLRG
GHSF]F\FKMQDMH(G(FyZ:\]QDZFDPLWHJRSRJOGXDZMHJRNRQVHNZHQFMLWH]\L*
WH]\)ORUHQWF]\NDQDOH*\RJOGDü LRVG]Dü MHG\QLHZNRQWHNFLHJHRJUDILF]QR
KLVWRU\F]Q\PE\OLPLQZ;9,,,ZGUDPDWXUJ9LWWRULR$OILHULLKLVWRULR]RI-RKDQQ
*+HUGHUZ;,;*:)+HJHODQJLHOVNLZLJ7KRPDV%0DFDXOD\L
)UDQFHVFR'H6DQFWLVDZ;;2UHVWHV7RPPDVLQL

6]F]\WHPPLVW\ILNDFMLLSU]HZURWQHMKLSRNU\]MLE\áRFLHNDMF\PRUDOQ\PREXU]HQLHPL
KXPDQLWDU\]PHP$QW\0DNLDZHOQDSLVDQ\SU]H]NUyOD3UXV)U\GHU\ND
,,NWyUHJRFDáDG]LDáDOQRüSROLW\F]QDXRVDELDSRM FLHPZMHJRRELHJRZ\PVHQVLHZ
W\PZ\SDGNXUDFM QDOH*\SU]\]QDü9ROWDLUHCRZLNWyU\VWZLHUG]LáL*SLV]F$QW\
0DNLDZHOD)U\GHU\NQDSOXáZVZyMXOXELRQ\WRUW*HE\QLNWLQQ\QLHPyJáJRMHü
-DZQ\PHQWX]MDVW0DFKLDYHOOHJRE\áQDWRPLDVWFHVDU])UDQFX]yZ1DSROHRQ,
NWyU\XZD*Dá*HMHVWWRMHG\Q\SLVDU]SROLW\F]Q\JRGQ\F]\WDQLDDSR]RVWDOLWR
EDQLRSLVDU]H

7UXGQRWUDNWRZDüMDNRDUJXPHQWSU]HFLZNRPSRGREQ\HQWX]MD]PRND]\ZDQ\SU]H]
ZRG]DIDV]\]PX%HQLWD0XVVROLQLHJR NWyU\QDSLVDáQDZHWSU]HGPRZ GR
NROHMQHJRZ\GDQLD.VL FLDQD]\ZDMFJR?YDGHPHFXPGODP *yZVWDQX? MHOLQLH
]DXZD*\üMHGQRF]HQLH*HWDNLVDPVWRVXQHNPLDá]PDUá\ZZL ]LHQLX]DU]GyZ'XFH
Z\ELWQ\ZáRVNLNRPXQLVWD$QWRQLR*UDPVFL]WW\ONRUy*QLFSUDNW\F]Q*HMHJR
?QRZRF]HVQ\NVL* ? LOSULQFLSHPRGHUQR ZFLHODáVL QLHZSDVWZRIDV]\VWRZVNLH
OHF]ZSDUWL NRPXQLVW\F]QMDNR?NROHNW\ZQHJRLQWHOHNWXDOLVW ?5yZQLH*.0DUNV
QD]\ZDá+LVWRULHIORUHQFNLHDUF\G]LHáHP)(QJHOVZLG]LDáZ0DFKLDYHOOLP
?JLJDQWD?DGRZyG]WZR$UPLL&]HUZRQHM]DOHFDáRND*GHPXRILFHURZL]DSR]QDQLH
VL ]WUDNWDWHP0DFKLDYHOOHJRRV]WXFHZRMHQQHMDOHMX*VWDQRZLVNRXU] GRZHM
?QDXNL?VRZLHFNLHMZREHFP\OLDXWRUD.VL FLDE\áRSU]H]FDáKLVWRUL =665

6WURQD]

.RQVHUZDW\]PSO.OXE=DFKRZDZF]R0RQDUFKLVW\F]Q\3URILGH5HJHHW/HJH



KWWSZZZNRQVHUZDW\]PSOHQF\NORSHGLDSKS"LG 

background image

QDFHFKRZDQHFRQDMPQLHMUH]HUZRVáDZLRQ\SURNXUDWRUVWDOLQRZVNL$QGULHM
:\V]\QVNLMJU]PLDáQDZHWREXU]HQLHPZPRZLHRVNDU*\FLHOVNLHMSU]HFLZNRDXWRURZL
ZVW SXGRURV\MVNLHJRSU]HNáDGX.VL FLD.DPLHQLHZRZLNWyU\PLDáZ\UD]LüSRJOG*H
?QLHPDOGLDOHNW\F]QH?XFKZ\FHQLHPHFKDQL]PyZZáDG]\ZROQHRGPHWDIL]\F]Q\FKL
WHRORJLF]Q\FKIDQWD]MLF]\QL0DFKLDYHOOHJRJRGQ\PSUHNXUVRUHP0DUNVD(QJHOVD
/HQLQDL6WDOLQD$QDORJLF]QLHZWSOLZ\PZVSDUFLHGODDQW\PDNLDZHOLVWyZPR*HE\ü
ZURJRü ]Z\UD(QLHUDVLVWRZVNLPSRGWHNVWHP RND]\ZDQD)ORUHQWF]\NRZLSU]H]
F]RáRZHJRLGHRORJDKLWOHURZVNLHJRQD]L]PX$OIUHGD5RVHQEHUJDNWyU\SLVDá*H
?V\VWHP0DNLDZHOD?QDOH*\GRWUDG\FML?HWUXVNLHJR]EDVWDUG\]RZDQHJRDQW\NX?L
?QLHPyJáE\VL ]URG]LüZGXV]\QRUG\FNLHM? 'HU0\WKXVGHV;;-DKUKXQGHUWV%HUOLQ
 

:L FHMGRP\OHQLDGDMUHIOHNVMHJHQ&KDUOHVDGH*DXOOHCDNWyU\UR]ZD*DMF
VSODWDQLHVL ?NU WHMGURJLSROLW\ND?]?SURVWGURJ*RáQLHU]D?RZLDGF]D*HZ
G]LDáDQLXSROLW\ND?FHOQLHMHVWVSUDZFQRW\DGRVNRQDáRüHZDQJHOLF]QDQLHSURZDG]L
GRLPSHULXP&]áRZLHNF]\QX]DWHPQLHPR*HVSHáQLüVL EH]SRND(QHJR]DVREX XQH
IRUWHGRVH HJRL]PXWZDUGRFLLSRGVW SX? /HILOGHOCpSpH3DULV 

/LEHUDá%HQHGHWWR&URFHSU]\SLVXMFDXWRURZL.VL FLD?VXURZLGRMPXMF
ZLDGRPRüPRUDOQ? XQCDXVWHUDHGRORURVDFRVFLHQ]DPRUDOH ZLG]LDáZQLP
XGU F]RQHJRGRVWU]HJDQ\PLLRSLV\ZDQ\PL]EURGQLDPLKXPDQLVW RUD]EROHMFHJRQDG
OXG]NLPLSU]\ZDUDPLPRUDOLVW NWyU\?RGF]DVXGRF]DVXRGF]XZDPRUDOQ\
QLHVPDN? (OHPHQWLGLSROLWLFD%DUL MHGQRF]HQLH&URFHXZD*Dá?Z\]ZROHQLH
SROLW\NLRGHW\NLLUHOLJLL?]D?V]F]\WRZHRVLJQL FLH?0DFKLDYHOOHJRNWyU\WRSRJOG
UR]ZLQá(ULF:&RFKUDQHWZLHUG]FL*?0DFKLDYHOOLQLHQHJRZDáVáXV]QRFL
PRUDOQRFLFKU]HFLMDVNLHMLQLHXVLáRZDáQLNRPXZPDZLDü*H]EURGQLDSRG\NWRZDQD
SROLW\F]QNRQLHF]QRFLSU]HVWDMHE\ü]EURGQL3RSURVWXRGNU\á  *HQDV]D
PRUDOQRüQLHPD]DVWRVRZDQLDZG]LHG]LQLHSROLW\NLRUD]*HND*GHG]LDáDQLHSROLW\F]QH
RSDUWHQD]DáR*HQLX*HPDRQDWDNLH]DVWRVRZDQLHPXVLGRSURZDG]LüGRNDWDVWURI\
-HJRSRGEXGRZDQDIDNWDPLRELHNW\ZQDDQDOL]DZVSyáF]HVQ\FKPXSROLW\F]Q\FK
VWRVXQNyZQLHMHVWSU]HMDZHPF\QL]PXDQLPRUDOQHMRERM WQRFLDOHZHZQ WU]QHM
XGU NL? 0DFKLDYHOOL?-RXUQDORI0RGHUQ+LVWRU\? 

7ZLHUG]HQLDWHSRGZD*DSU]HNRQXMFR,VDLDK%HUOLQGRZRG]F\*H)ORUHQWF]\NGRNRQDá
LQQHJRZDUWRFLXMFHJRSRG]LDáXDOHZREU ELHHW\NLSU]HFLZVWDZLDMFPRUDOQRFL
FKU]HFLMDVNLHMPRUDOQRüZLDWDSRJDVNLHJRNWyUHM?QDF]HOQHZDUWRFLVWDQRZL
P VWZRZLJRUG]LHOQRüZREHFSU]HFLZQRFLORVXRVLJQL FLDZ*\FLXSXEOLF]Q\PáDG
G\VF\SOLQDV]F] FLHVLáDVSUDZLHGOLZRüDQDGHZV]\VWNRGRFKRG]HQLHQDOH*Q\FK
SUDZRUD]ZLHG]DLVLáDSRWU]HEQHGRLFK]DSHZQLHQLD? 2U\JLQDOQRü0DFKLDYHOOHJR
?/LWHUDWXUDQDZLHFLH? %HUOLQRGU]XFLáWDN*HWZLHUG]HQLHW\FKDXWRUyZ
NWyU]\SUyEXMUDWRZDüZL]HUXQHN0DFKLDYHOOHJRSHV\PLVW\F]QHJRFKU]HFLMDQLQDL*
MHJRUH]\JQDFMD]PRUDOQHJRLGHDáXFKU]HFLMDVNLHJRZSROLW\FHE\áDQDVW SVWZHP
NRQVWDWDFML*HWRLGHDá\]E\WZ\VRNLHZVWRVXQNXGRPR*OLZRFLMHGQRVWHNJG\*
?VSUDZDPDVL RGZURWQLH0DFKLDYHOOLMHVWSU]HZLDGF]RQ\*HZáDQLHFHFK\
XFKRG]FH]DSRGVWDZRZHZZLHFLHQDXNLFKU]HFLMDVNLHMQLH]DOH*QLHRGLFKZDUWRFL
VDPHMZVRELHVWDQRZLQLHSU]H]Z\FL *DOQHSU]HV]NRG\GR]EXGRZDQLDWDNLHJRW\SX
VSRáHF]HVWZDMDNLHFKFLDáE\ZLG]LHüZVZ\PNUDMX? WDP*H 0DFKLDYHOOL?Z\U]HND
VL ]DWHPHW\NLFKU]HFLMDVNLHMDOH]DVW SXMHMLQQ\PV\VWHPHPZDUWRFLLQQ\P
SRU]GNLHPPRUDOQ\P:\U]HNDVL MHMZLPL ZLDWD3HU\NOHVDL6F\SLRQDDQDZHW
NVL FLD9DOHQWLQR  ,QQ\PLVáRZ\MHVWWRNRQIOLNWGZyFKPRUDOQRFLFKU]HFLMDVNLHML
SRJDVNLHM  QLH]DGZyFKDXWRQRPLF]Q\FKG]LHG]LQSROLW\NLLHW\NL? WDP*H 

1LHPRUDOLVW OHF]HVWHW NWyU\XFLHNDRGUHDOQHJRZLDWDVSOXJDZLRQHMSU]H]
EDUEDU]\FyZ,WDOLLZIDQWDVW\F]Q\LGHDOQ\ZLDWZ\PDU]RQHMZLHONRFLZLG]LZ
0DFKLDYHOOLP5HQp.|QLJSRJOGWDNLMHVWSHV\PLVW\F]QZHUVMNRQFHSFML
?UHQHVDQV\]PX?JáRV]RQHJRSU]H]DXWRUDNODV\F]QHMSUDF\.XOWXUD2GURG]HQLDZH
:áRV]HFK  -DFRED%XUFNKDUGWDNWyU\ZFDáHMP\OLSROLW\F]QHM
KXPDQL]PXZLG]LDáNRQFHSFM SDVWZDMDNRG]LHáDV]WXNLWZRU]RQHJRSU]H]SROLW\NyZ
DUW\VWyZWUDNWXMF\FKLQQ\FKOXG]LWDNMDNU]H(ELDU]NV]WDáWXMHPDUPXUOXEJOLQ =
WHRUL%XUFNKDUGWD]JDG]DOLVL LUR]ZLMDOLMPLQ)ULHGULFK0HLQHFNH&DUO-)ULHGULFKL
&KDUOHV6LQJOHWRQ

0\OLFLHOHNRQVHUZDW\ZQL]UHJXá\PDMGRPVWRVXQHNNU\W\F]Q\Z\MZV]\
NRQVHUZDW\ZQ\FK?GHF\]MRQLVWyZ? &DUO6FKPLWW$UPLQ0RKOHU ZZ\SDGNX

6WURQD]

.RQVHUZDW\]PSO.OXE=DFKRZDZF]R0RQDUFKLVW\F]Q\3URILGH5HJHHW/HJH



KWWSZZZNRQVHUZDW\]PSOHQF\NORSHGLDSKS"LG 

background image

NRQVHUZDW\VWyZNDWROLFNLFKSRZRGHPWHMNU\W\NLMHVWSU]HGHZV]\VWNLPGRNRQDQDSU]H]
0DFKLDYHOOHJRVHNXODU\]DFMDSROLW\NLXWRPLVWyZF] VWRWH*SRMDZLDVL VWDUV]D
DUJXPHQWDFMDRQLHPRUDOQRFLPLGRWNOLZ\PRNDOHF]HQLXSU]H]HLQWHOHNWX
SUDNW\F]QHJRF]áRZLHND -DFTXHV0DULWDLQR0LHF]\VáDZ$.USLHF23 ,QQL
MDNZ\ZRG]F\VL ]WUDG\FML%XUNHCRZVNLHMHPSLU\VWDLHZROXFMRQLVWD0LFKDHO2DNH
VKRWWNU\W\NXM0DFKLDYHOOHJRMDNRZVSyáWZyUF QRZR*\WQHJRUDFMRQDOL]PX
SROLW\F]QHJRQLHVáDZQHMSDPL FLDXWRUDSLHUZV]HJRZG]LHMDFK?EU\NX??FLJDZNL?
GOD?.VL FLDQXZRULV]D?NWyU\]DVWSLáNVL FLDWUDG\F\MQHJRRWU]\PXMFHJRRGVZRLFK
SU]RGNyZPGURFLRZLSUDNW\F]QZLHG] RV]WXFHU]G]HQLD

6]F]HJyOQLHRVWUNU\W\N 0DFKLDYHOOHJRMDNRSLHUZV]HJR]SROLW\F]Q\FKKHUH]MDUFKyZ
QRZR*\WQRFLSU]HSURZDG]LáREURFDWUDG\FMLNODV\F]QHM/HR6WUDXVVQD]\ZDMF\
)ORUHQWF]\ND?SROLW\F]Q\PSRUQRJUDIHP? DF]WHQSXQNWNU\W\NLMHVWPRUDOQLH
GZX]QDF]Q\ERDXWRUQLH]DSU]HF]DSUDZG]LZRFLMHJRWZLHUG]HW\ONRZ\U]XFD
?QLHGRVWDWHNKLSRNU\]ML? RUD]QLKLOLVWNWyU\?FDáNRZLFLHUR]HUZDá]ZL]HNPL G]\
SROLW\NDSUDZHPSU]\URG]RQ\POXESUDZHPQDWXU\WR]QDF]\]HVSUDZLHGOLZRFL
UR]XPLDQMDNRFRQLH]DOH*QHJRRGOXG]NLFKSRVWDQRZLH? 7U]\IDOHQRZR*\WQRFL
?5HV3XEOLFD? ]GDQLHP6WUDXVVD0DFKLDYHOOLMHVWWDN*HZ\QDOD]FVSU\WQHJR
DSRNXSQHJRSURFHGHUXXGDZDQLDGRNRQ\ZDQLDU]HNRPRQLHEH]SLHF]Q\FKRGNU\üGDMH
RQ?SLHUZV]\SU]\NáDGZLGRZLVNDNWyUHRGWGZ]QDZLDVL ZND*G\PQLHPDOSRNROHQLX
:\JOGDQDWR*HQLHXVWUDV]RQ\P\OLFLHORGVáRQLáJá EL SU]HGNWyUNODV\F\]LFK
V]ODFKHWQSURVWRWFRIDOLVL WUZR*OLZLH? WDP*H -HGQDNUyZQLH*QLHSU]HMHGQDQ\
6WUDXVVQD]\ZDZLQQ\PPLHMVFX0DFKLDYHOOHJR?RGNU\ZF]QDF]QLHZL NV]\PRG
VDPHJR.U]\V]WRID.ROXPED? 3UDZRQDWXUDOQHZZLHWOHKLVWRULL:DUV]DZD 

:3ROVFH0DFKLDYHOOLE\áGREU]H]QDQ\LNRPHQWRZDQ\MX*Z;9,ZZyMWZLOHVNL]
F]DVyZSDQRZDQLD=\JPXQWD,,$XJXVWD$XJXVWXV5RWXQGXV $XJXVW\Q0LHOHFNL 
Z5R]PRZLH3RODND]/LWZLQHPSRZRá\ZDáVL QD)ORUHQWF]\NDEURQLFZ\*V]RFLWURQX
G]LHG]LF]QHJRGR0DFKLDYHOOHJRRGZRá\ZDáVL WDN*HLQQ\]ZROHQQLN?F]\VWHJR?
PRQDUFKL]PXLG]LDáDF]NRQWUUHIRUPDFMLNVLG].U]\V]WRI:DUV]HZLFNL 
 ?3ROVNLPDNLDZHOL]P?QDMSHáQLHMUHSUH]HQWXMMHGQDNGZDMZLHOF\URPDQW\F\
?F\QLNZROQRFL?NWyU\].VL FLHPQLHUR]VWDZDáVL SRQRüQLJG\0DXU\F\0RFKQD
FNLRUD]]ZáDV]F]DMDNRDXWRU.RQUDGD:DOOHQURGD$GDP0LFNLHZLF]1D
ZVSRPQLHQLH]DVáXJXMHWH*]XSHáQLHG]L]DSRPQLDQ\;,;ZLHF]Q\WáXPDF]
0DFKLDYHOOHJR$QWRQL6R]DVNL

0-RO\'LDORJXHDX[HQIHUVHQWUH0DFKLDYHOHW0RQWHVTXLHX%UX[HOOHV
0DFKMDZHOSROVNL%HQGOLNRQ)U\GHU\N,,3UXVNL$QWL0DFKLDYHOO>@/ZyZ
+'HPELVNL0DFKLDYHOOLDF]DV\ZVSyáF]HVQH:DUV]DZD-0DULWDLQ7KH
(QGRI0DFKLDYHOOLDQLVP?7KH5HYLHZRI3ROLWLFV?QU%/HQRGRUVNL?3ROVNL
0DNLDZHO?Z6WXGLD]G]LHMyZNXOWXU\SROVNLHM:DUV]DZD)5DDE7KH(QJOLVK
)DFHRI0DFKLDYHOOL/RQGRQ7RURQWR>@)0HLQHFNH0DFKLDYHOOLVP7KH
'RFWULQHRI5DLVRQGC(WDWDQG,WV3ODFHLQ0RGHUQ+LVWRU\/RQGRQ1HZ-HUVH\
>@$*UDPVFL1RZRF]HVQ\NVL* Z3LVPDZ\EUDQHW,:DUV]DZD5
'H0DWWHL'DOSUHPDFKLDYHOOLVPRDOOCDQWLPDFKLDYHOOLVPRHXURSHRGHO&LQTXHFHQWR
)LUHQ]H-0DODUF]\NLLQ1LFFROR0DFKLDYHOOL3DUDGRNV\ORVyZGRNWU\Q\
:DUV]DZD-*$3RFRFN7KH0DFKLDYHOOLDQ0RPHQW)ORUHQWLQH3ROLWLFDO7KHRU\
DQGWKH$WODQWLF5HSXEOLFDQ7UDGLWLRQ3ULQFHWRQ5%ULOOHW'H*DXOOHHW
0DFKLDYHOOL/\RQ&%LUHOH\7KH&RXQWHU5HIRUPDWLRQ3ULQFH$QWL
0DFKLDYHOOLDQLVPRU&DWKROLF6WDWHFUDIWLQ(DUO\0RGHUQ(XURSH8QLYHUVLW\RI1RUWK
&DUROLQD3UHVV5$URQ0DFKLDYHOHWOHVW\UDQQLHVPRGHUQHV3DULV

:VWHF]

.OXE=DFKRZDZF]R0RQDUFKLVW\F]Q\_XO:LWZLFNLHJRP:DUV]DZD_N]P#NRQVHUZDW\]PSO

6WURQD]

.RQVHUZDW\]PSO.OXE=DFKRZDZF]R0RQDUFKLVW\F]Q\3URILGH5HJHHW/HJH



KWWSZZZNRQVHUZDW\]PSOHQF\NORSHGLDSKS"LG 


Wyszukiwarka

Podobne podstrony:
Jacek Bartyzel Makiawelizm
Makiawelizm, Interesujące, PSYCHOLOGIA, PSYCHOLOGIA (materiały)
makiawel biznes plan, Socjologia
Bartyzel o karze śmierci, ciekawe teksty
Portret makiawelicznego władcy w dramacie Hamlet – postać Klaudiusza
MAKIAWELIZM, Technik Administracji, SOCJOL I PSYCH SPOŁECZNA, Socjologia i Psychologia Społeczna, Ps
Berger 07, DYGRESJA: MAKIAWELIZM SOCJOLOGICZNY l ETYKA
J Bartyzel Proba teoretyzacji Nieznany
Bartyzel Rojalizm francuski wczoraj i dziś
Makiawelizm
Charakterystyka osobowosci makiawelistycznej1, Psychologia, ■ Różne opracowania
Judaizującym frondystom pod rozwagę - prof. Bartyzel
Makiawelizm i Ingracjacja, ^v^ UCZELNIA ^v^, ^v^ Pedagogika, promocja zdrowia z arteterapią i socjot
Peter L. Berger - ZAPROSZENIE DO SOCJOLOGII, 7. ZAPROSZENIE DO SOCJOLOGII - 7 DYGRESJA - MAKIAWELIZM
5 Bartyzel Ojkofobia
makiawelizm i ingracjacja
Makiawelizm, Interesujące, PSYCHOLOGIA, PSYCHOLOGIA (materiały)
Jacek Bartyzel Na skrzyżowaniu cywilizacji
Co to jest Liberalizm Abp Marcel Levebre, prof Jacek Bartyzel

więcej podobnych podstron